Latest / True Crime California / TCC #19 The Speed Freak Killers
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Dark Cast Network. Welcome to the Dark Side of podcasting.
- 0:11Speaker 2: Hi there, I'm Cony Gallagher and I'm Ethan Flick and
- 0:14together we are the husband and wife team Behind and
- 0:17Then They Were Gone, a true crime podcast about unsolved
- 0:21missing persons cases. Each week we take a deep dive
- 0:25into a case that I have researched and written about
- 0:29and that you have never heard of.
- 0:32Speaker 1: Right, and I react naturally and usually leave me with
- 0:36a whole lot of stuff to add it out with the.
- 0:38Speaker 2: Podcast very true, but I do love getting your analysis
- 0:42and a fresh perspective on these crimes that I've been
- 0:45spending so much time learning about. So you can see
- 0:49us on your favorite podcast app every Wednesday when we
- 0:53release a brand new episode.
- 0:56Speaker 1: And find us on the socials at ATTWG.
- 0:59Speaker 2: Pod and you can also visit us on our website
- 1:03and Then They Were Gone dot Com? Could you hold
- 1:06the key to bringing someone Home?
- 1:13Speaker 1: Hey everyone, welcome to True Crime California. I'm your host, Cindy,
- 1:18and I'm glad you're here. Hey, everybody, welcome back to
- 1:31another podcast episode of True Crime California. Thank you all
- 1:35so much for tuning in last week and the week
- 1:37before for the two parter that was the murder of
- 1:40Kristen Smart. I hope you guys all enjoyed that. It's
- 1:43a really horrible case, but it is a little satisfying
- 1:46to cover now that we have a conclusion for it.
- 1:49At the end, it's all high fives and fist pumps
- 1:52and you know, it's a horrible, horrible case, but I'm
- 1:54really glad that it finally was solved. So, you know,
- 2:00silver lining kind of case in that vein. The case
- 2:03this week kind of takes place in the same area,
- 2:06around the same time, so I thought it was kind
- 2:07of a cool idea to cover it this week, so
- 2:10we have sort of back to back cases with some
- 2:13similar themes. This is actually recommended to me by a listener,
- 2:16so thank you so much for that. Hopefully you guys
- 2:20enjoy I think I'm just gonna jump into it, so
- 2:22let's get started. So I'm gonna be covering the case
- 2:26of the speed Freak killers this week, and this case,
- 2:31like I said, it's not super different from the murder
- 2:33of Kristen Smart in quite a few ways. The killings
- 2:36take place in and around Kristen's hometown of Stockton. They
- 2:40are all they all take place when Kristen is growing
- 2:43up in that area. And most notably, this case spans
- 2:48nearly fifteen years. It actually spans longer than that, but
- 2:52basically fifteen years of murders basically, and then an additional
- 3:00you know, quite a few years of being in and
- 3:02out of court. So it has a really long kind
- 3:05of timeline, which is similar to Kristen's timeline. And it's
- 3:09also due too unbelievable police negligents. This case is far
- 3:15worse in a lot of ways, and that so many
- 3:16people died as a result of the police doing nothing,
- 3:19even as more and more young women and girls went
- 3:22missing in the area. And what's more, with this case,
- 3:25it's quite possible there was an intentional cover up with
- 3:28the Sheriff's Department of San Juaquin County, either because the
- 3:32family of one of the killers was well connected, or
- 3:35possibly because the police just didn't want to deal with
- 3:38admitting they once again were absolutely terrible at their jobs.
- 3:41In any case, this will all be discussed as we
- 3:43move through the case. So let's get started. Actually, hold on,
- 3:48hold on. There was something that I wanted to say
- 3:50because I was reading my reviews on Apple Podcasts and
- 3:54somebody called out my recording, saying they can hear like
- 3:58every time I swallow, and yes, I agree, and I
- 4:01hate it. I've been trying to get my recordings to
- 4:04not be so damn crisp. So crisp. What I hear
- 4:09more is like the breath, but the swallowing. If you
- 4:12hear that, I'm really sorry. I'm working really hard to
- 4:14get this all kind of normalized and kind of aligned.
- 4:18I have a little bit of an older computer, so
- 4:19I feel like it's just not gonna do me as
- 4:22good as in a new computer would, so I might
- 4:25not have perfect sound. I appreciate the feedback, but damn
- 4:29three stars. You love my podcast, but three stars because
- 4:32you can hear me swallow, that is harsh, y'all, Maybe
- 4:35consider giving me an extra star, knowing I'm working on it.
- 4:38I'm trying. I'm trying, Okay, anyway, all right, let's get
- 4:42into this case. Like I said, I'm talking about the
- 4:44speed freak killers case, and this refers to two men
- 4:49born in the mid sixties and raised in Linden, California,
- 4:52which is only about twenty miles or sorry, twenty minutes
- 4:56east of Stockton, so kind of in central California. Like
- 5:00the Central Valley of California, and once again very close
- 5:02to where Kristin Smart was born and raised. As noted,
- 5:06much of the story takes place in the mid eighties
- 5:08and nineties, so also aligning sort of with her disappearance,
- 5:11at least in part anyway. The older of these two men,
- 5:14Lauren Hertzog, was born in December nineteen sixty five, while
- 5:18Wesley Wes Shermantine was born in February nineteen sixty six.
- 5:24These two were very close in age clearly, and grew
- 5:26up on the same street directly across from one another,
- 5:29in fact, so their homes like faced each other. This
- 5:32alone would bring kids together, you know, like proximity relationships,
- 5:36when you become friends with people you live near, or
- 5:38go to school with, or work with. I guess that's
- 5:40how we always make friends. But especially when you're young,
- 5:43it's sort of the past path of least resistance because
- 5:45you don't necessarily know what you're going to be into.
- 5:48Until you get a little older, you're not sure what
- 5:51kind of person you're going to be. So when you're younger,
- 5:53it's really easy to make friends with whoever is around.
- 5:56And so these two became very close that being said,
- 5:59even beyond their proximity, were they did share a lot
- 6:03in common. They were both really into hunting, and Wess's father,
- 6:08Wesley Shermantine or Shermantine Senor, was also very into hunting
- 6:13and he would take the boys with him quite often.
- 6:16So this means from a young age the boys were
- 6:18very good with firearms. They were used to dressing animals,
- 6:21so they were not weird about blood, and they were
- 6:25just kind of brought up with violence around them. And
- 6:28I don't I'm not passing any sort of judgment on hunting.
- 6:31I actually think if you are hunting to eat, that's
- 6:34probably the best and most natural way to do it.
- 6:36I'm just saying that from a young age they were
- 6:40used to this kind of thing. Also, I wanted to
- 6:43note that Wesley Senior was a very successful contractor in
- 6:47the area, so the family had a lot of money
- 6:50and this is going to come into play. So before
- 6:52I get more into their family specifically, I kind of
- 6:55wanted to give an idea of Lynden, California and the
- 6:58surrounding area because I believe the demographics of this area
- 7:02play a pretty large role in the outcome of this
- 7:05case and why things went on the way that they did.
- 7:08So just so you guys kind of get an idea,
- 7:11Linden is not even a city. It's not today, and
- 7:13it wasn't then either. It is a census designated area
- 7:18in California. So what that means is it's an unincorporated
- 7:21area with no central government, police department, or any of that.
- 7:25And what's more, it wasn't even a census designated area
- 7:29until nineteen ninety. Well some of this story takes place
- 7:32before then. So Linden is a very very small town.
- 7:36And because they don't have a centralized government, they use
- 7:40the San Joaquin County Sheriff's Department as sort of their
- 7:44police because they're in San Juan or San Joaquin County
- 7:48in California. So again they're using like the broader, you know,
- 7:52the Sheriff's department. They don't have their own police, They
- 7:54don't really have like their own anything. They kind of
- 7:56go to Stockton or the surrounding areas for government services.
- 8:00That all being said, Linden was a really nice little
- 8:03enclave in this area. It was a pretty nice place
- 8:06to live. People enjoyed a mostly quiet life, and it
- 8:09was definitely a richer area than anywhere else around. But
- 8:14there were a few factors to consider that would sort
- 8:16of bring a different element into Linden, especially in the
- 8:18eighties and nineties. Now, first, Linden is surrounded by farmland,
- 8:23individual homes, people who aren't working tech jobs. Let's say
- 8:26it's very very rural, so the area is kind of
- 8:31poor around them. There's not a lot of money. It's
- 8:35very spread out, like I said, very rural. It's not
- 8:38really what people who aren't from California think of when
- 8:40they're talking about California. So while we have some halves,
- 8:44especially in London, the area is a lot of have nots,
- 8:48the working poor, and people without much money. Now, what
- 8:51happens in small towns where people don't have a lot
- 8:53of money but do have a lot of time on
- 8:55their hands is they tend to get into drugs because
- 8:58they're just bored. They don't really see much else to
- 9:01do with their time. And in the eighties and nineties, especially,
- 9:06methamphetamine became a very popular drug in the area because
- 9:10it was cheap and easy to make. Now, meth makes
- 9:13people feel euphoric, which I think is something everybody likes,
- 9:16but especially in these more depressed areas It's likely a
- 9:19very different feeling than day to day life, so people
- 9:22are really into that. And another problem with meth is
- 9:25that it becomes extremely addictive. Not only are you addicted
- 9:28to the feeling, but you're actually physically addicted to the
- 9:32chemicals that you're ingesting into your body when you snort
- 9:36or smoke meth. So when Lauren and Wes, going back
- 9:40to these two were teens, this drug was taking over
- 9:43the area and they were definitely not immune to its
- 9:46draw Now I'm going to go back into their childhoods
- 9:51a little bit, so we've kind of talked about you know,
- 9:54Wes's family had money. Lauren's family was actually pretty middle class.
- 9:57They lived in the same neighborhood, so obviously they weren't poor.
- 10:00But Wes was definitely like a rich kid. We've talked
- 10:03about the demographics of the area. So let's talk about
- 10:06these guys as young kids. Wesley Shermantine Junior was the
- 10:12middle child of three. He had a younger and an
- 10:15older sister. His parents, like I said, Wes, and I
- 10:19think she went by Sue. I think her first name
- 10:21is actually Verna. Those are his parents, and they spoiled
- 10:25the kids in a lot of ways. They would give
- 10:26them dirt bikes, horse riding lessons, all the toys they
- 10:30could want, so the kids monetarily were very very spoiled
- 10:34and given whatever they wanted. But on the other hand,
- 10:37the Shermantine parents were also very abusive. Wes's mother, Sue,
- 10:42was a hardcore alcoholic and would become physically abusive to
- 10:46the children when she was drinking, and especially Wes, probably
- 10:50because he was the only boy. When he would get
- 10:52into trouble, his parents would take guns and shoot at
- 10:56his feet while making him stand still, which is beyond
- 11:01potentially shooting him. It's extremely mentally abusive, so a big
- 11:06problem there. So this was a very confusing and damaging
- 11:10childhood for Wes and his sisters because one moment they're
- 11:13being lavished with expensive presence, and the next moment they're
- 11:16being beaten by that's those same parents, so really not good.
- 11:21In childhood, Wes was always seen as the more aggressive
- 11:24between himself and Lauren. He was confrontational. He was considered
- 11:28a bully m probably because he was trying to assert
- 11:31dominance because he felt so powerless at home, and then
- 11:37Lauren was definitely the more meek of the two at
- 11:39least through high school, and Lauren was also much more
- 11:43of a regular kid, not only in the way he
- 11:46was raised and just being like middle class, but he
- 11:48was also like well liked by his peers, well behaved,
- 11:52and until he really got involved with Wes as they
- 11:54grew up, he was a pretty chill kid. So you
- 11:57kind of get the idea of the dynamic between these
- 11:59two boys as well as how they reviewed when growing up.
- 12:05These two graduate high school in nineteen eighty four, and
- 12:08before even then they are starting to get into some
- 12:12bad shit and escalating their behavior. Now. For instance, when
- 12:16they were in the seventh grade, Lauren had a girlfriend
- 12:19and although they had been together for a few months
- 12:22and he seemed to really like her, at one point,
- 12:24Wes for some reason punched her right in the nose
- 12:28and Lauren did not do anything about it. Another time,
- 12:32they were all hanging out and suddenly Wes tells Lauren
- 12:34basically to rape his girlfriend. Now, again, he's in seventh grade,
- 12:38his girlfriend is in sixth grade. This isn't even something
- 12:42they should be exploring at all at this age, let
- 12:46alone talking about rape and attempting to rape someone. But Lauren,
- 12:52being the meeker of the two does as he's told,
- 12:54and he starts holding his girlfriend down. He gets on
- 12:57top of her, and the whole time she's crying and
- 13:00asking him to stop. As this is happening, Wes is
- 13:04watching and telling this young girl, you know you want it,
- 13:07over and over while she says no, I don't, please stop. Finally,
- 13:12after some time, Lauren stops and does not in fact
- 13:15rape her, but the damage was done and their escalating
- 13:19behavior is set in motion. This girl never spoke to
- 13:23either of them ever again, which is you know, really
- 13:26saying something. Because the town of Linden had less than
- 13:29two thousand people in it, so I'm sure she saw
- 13:31them all the time, which is really damaging. So that's very,
- 13:36very alarming. And what's worse is she didn't tell anybody
- 13:39about this, which I'm not blaming her for. You know,
- 13:42she's young, she's scared, but not telling is something we'll
- 13:46see happen over and over in this case, and it
- 13:48sort of helps set the scene for how things go
- 13:50in small towns with rich and therefore powerful families. So
- 13:56going back to their graduating high school, as soon as
- 13:58they do that, they moved in together into an apartment
- 14:01in Stockton, which again is very close to Linden and
- 14:04the nearest big city, so it makes sense that that's
- 14:06kind of where they would end up. I'm pretty sure
- 14:08Wes had money from his parents, and the two spent
- 14:10most of their time drinking and doing drugs, namely meth.
- 14:14The two also dealt meth to make money and were
- 14:17known in the area as being meth dealers. So this
- 14:21is you know, already they've got this bad reputation and
- 14:25they're not really working. They're just basically being hoodlums. And
- 14:29the two began doing this even in high school, not
- 14:32only selling but using meth, and it got way more
- 14:36out of control once they were out of their parents' homes. Now,
- 14:39as I said, I've kind of talked about methamphetamine. It's
- 14:42this euphoric feeling. It doesn't last very long. What does
- 14:45last a long time is being wide awake from using meth.
- 14:49It speeds you up and you can't really sleep, and
- 14:52users will often be up for days at a time,
- 14:56which is so so bad for your brain. So beyond
- 14:59the high of you know, being high for days and
- 15:02the effects that can have. See, sleep deprivation also causes hallucinations, paranoia,
- 15:08and general confusion. So you mix that with the energy
- 15:11and aggressiveness that comes with using meth, and you've got
- 15:14a very scary combination. So you have these two guys
- 15:17who already are fine with violence, they've already attempted to
- 15:22like rape someone, they obviously have issues with women, with
- 15:25their home lives, and they're using meth regularly. So this
- 15:29is a very very scary situation. And as I said,
- 15:33it's also meth is very addictive, so people will use
- 15:36it literally until they crash out, like pass out from exhaustion,
- 15:40only to wake up and start using again right away.
- 15:44As far as the physical effects of methamphetamine, it's pretty crazy.
- 15:49It includes sometimes severe weight loss because you can't eat
- 15:53because your stomach's in knots, facial acne and scarring, like
- 15:57very very severe like face wounds that just kind of
- 16:00boil up on your face, hair loss, tooth decay. I mean,
- 16:05people lose all of their teeth. The chemicals are very
- 16:08hard on your enamel when you're smoking them or snorting them.
- 16:11It's just it's a really gross drug and unfortunately a
- 16:15lot of people do it in this area of California,
- 16:18and to this day, it's a very big problem, but
- 16:21it definitely started in the eighties. So anyway, these two
- 16:24are high as kites and living on their own with
- 16:26the history of bullying people, assaulting young women, and selling drugs,
- 16:29so we know where this is going right now. These
- 16:33two still went out hunting, and on September first, nineteen
- 16:35eighty four, they were headed home from an area near
- 16:38Lake Tahoe when they saw a car parked on the
- 16:40side of the road with a man sleeping inside. These
- 16:44two decided, okay, this is it. It's time to go
- 16:47from hunting animals to hunting humans. And they're like, this
- 16:50is this is gonna be our first victim. They pulled
- 16:52Shermantine's red truck to the side of the road, got out,
- 16:57and Shermantine pulled out a shotgun. The two then went
- 17:01up to the window a forty one year old father
- 17:03of five, Henry Lee Howell. Henry was a member of
- 17:08the Lummy nation, who were indigenous to Washington State and
- 17:11the surrounding areas. Before Henry, who had pulled over to
- 17:15sleep off some beers, could respond to the knocking, the
- 17:17men shot him through the window, killing him instantly. They
- 17:22then robbed him for about ten dollars cash. His death
- 17:27remained unsolved until two thousand and one, which we'll talk
- 17:30about later. So from nineteen eighty four to two thousand
- 17:34and one, this murder is unsolved, which is crazy. Now
- 17:38two months later, on November twenty seventh, nineteen eighty four,
- 17:41the men were driving again in Shermantine's red pickup truck
- 17:45when they came upon two men in a Pontiac which
- 17:47was pulled over again on the side of the road.
- 17:50These two men, thirty five year old Harold Michael King
- 17:53the Third and another man, thirty one year old Paul
- 17:56Raymond Cavanaugh, were sitting in this car, and to this day,
- 17:59we aren't really sure why. I've read that they were transient.
- 18:02I read that they maybe were doing drugs. I really
- 18:05don't know. It could have been anything, and it's kind
- 18:08of weird that all of the guesses were so negative.
- 18:11But these men were parked on Robert's Island, which is
- 18:14just near Stockton in the River Delta, and it was
- 18:18a popular area for hunting because it's undeveloped, but it's
- 18:22also a good area for illicit activities, so that could
- 18:26be why it was thought maybe they were doing something.
- 18:28They shouldn't have been doing. As a result, it also
- 18:31has a lot of sheriff's presence. There's a lot of
- 18:34police driving around trying to catch people, but you can
- 18:37still get away with a lot, as we'll see anyway,
- 18:40So Herzog and Shermantine, Shermantine, I keep changing it. I
- 18:43don't know what to call him. Anyway, They pull over
- 18:45and attack these men as well, shooting Howard while he
- 18:48was still in the driver's seat of the car, then
- 18:50pulling Raymond out of the car before shooting him point
- 18:53blank in the face. The men's bodies were left at
- 18:57the scene, and a woman driving by noticed Sherman times
- 19:00red truck parked where near the road where the bodies
- 19:03would soon be found. I am tripping over my words today.
- 19:06I'm sorry, guys. I'm not gonna redo it because every
- 19:08time I do, I just make the same mistakes. So
- 19:11bear with me. I'll get through it. She kept driving
- 19:14but didn't stop or even really indicate any interest in
- 19:16the scene, and didn't see the bodies. But even as
- 19:19she passed, she felt creeped out and quickly realized she
- 19:23was being followed by the red truck that she had
- 19:26just seen parked. So she got freaked out, obviously because
- 19:30she already felt like something was weird. It's like an
- 19:33isolated area. So she does something really smart, and she
- 19:36goes and she drives by the nearby jail, and she
- 19:41does this to kind of try to scare this truck off,
- 19:44and it actually worked. She saw the truck kind of
- 19:48veer away and she didn't see it anymore. So she
- 19:50then turns and hurries to go home, but as she's
- 19:54turning onto her street, she again sees this red pickup
- 19:57truck pulling in behind her. So she parks in her driveway,
- 20:02runs into her house, locks the door behind her, and
- 20:06runs upstairs where she hides, but is also looking out
- 20:09her window to see what's gonna happen. Now, to her horror,
- 20:13she sees this red pickup truck pull into her driveway.
- 20:19She's watching terrified from the upstairs window, but nothing really happens.
- 20:24The truck just kind of sits there for a while
- 20:27and then finally drives away. Now, once again, like their
- 20:31victim when they were in junior high, this woman does
- 20:34not call the police while this is happening, and I
- 20:37really wish she had, because police found the two murdered
- 20:40men so quickly after they were killed that their bodies
- 20:43were still warm. So had she called, this case may
- 20:47have ended right here, which would have been really nice. Unfortunately,
- 20:52she was far too scared to do so, and I understand,
- 20:54and again not blaming her, I'm just saying what could
- 20:56have been. But after seeing the murders on the news,
- 20:59and Rea it was likely whoever was in the truck.
- 21:02She did call police, and they took prints of the
- 21:04tire tracks left in her driveway. She later found out
- 21:08that those tracks perfectly matched those left at the scene
- 21:12of the murders. Now, if I was her, I would
- 21:15have moved the next damn day. I don't know if
- 21:17she did, but like they know where she lives. That's
- 21:19fucking scary. So again we have someone who saw something
- 21:22and either didn't report it or waited too long. And
- 21:25again I'm not blaming her, I'm just saying that sucks.
- 21:28But it's also indicative of sort of the vibe of
- 21:31the area. I truly believe that people who lived in
- 21:34this area at the time knew how things went with
- 21:36the cops, and they didn't want to risk their lives
- 21:38when they didn't expect anything to happen, and some of
- 21:42the things that happened in this case later on kind
- 21:44of backed that up. So anyway, the next victims were women,
- 21:48which is a departure from these first crimes, but I
- 21:51believe this is because the men kind of became addicted
- 21:53to killing, much like they were addicted to meth, so
- 21:56they started to sort of plan their murders rather than
- 21:58just let them happen random. So the next confirmed victim,
- 22:02who wasn't tied to the men for many, many years,
- 22:05was nineteen year old Kimberly Ann Billy, who went missing
- 22:08from Stockton on December eleventh, nineteen eighty four, So just
- 22:12about two weeks after this second murder of these two men,
- 22:16they're now kind of changing what they're doing and picking
- 22:19women up intentionally. I don't know a lot about her death,
- 22:23but I do know that these men killed her. Now.
- 22:26The next victim was sixteen year old Joanne Hobson, a bright,
- 22:31bubbly girl who lived with her mother and sister in Stockton.
- 22:35Her mother worked the night shift at the cannery nearby
- 22:38in order to make the most money from her job,
- 22:40so Joanne and her sister were home alone often overnight.
- 22:44Joanne was a very girly girl, very small tiny in fact,
- 22:47she was only four foot eight and weighed only eighty pounds.
- 22:51And on the night she went missing, she told her
- 22:53sister she had a date with a man her sister
- 22:55didn't know, but who was quote tall and blonde. Now
- 22:59for the Rst. Lauren Herzog was both tall and blonde. Now.
- 23:04Joanne put on her makeup and got ready, but as
- 23:07the night progressed, she didn't end up going anywhere. Her
- 23:10sister went back into her room to check on her
- 23:12around eleven PM and found her asleep in bed, but
- 23:15with her window open. So her sister, Michelle, closed the
- 23:18window and went to bed herself, and when her mother,
- 23:21Joan Shelley, came home the next morning, she and Michelle
- 23:24were surprised to find Joanne wasn't in her bed, but
- 23:27her window was back to being open. After a short while,
- 23:31when Joanne still didn't come home, Joan called the police
- 23:34to report her missing. Now, huh, this is kind of
- 23:38proving my point about how it doesn't really make a
- 23:41difference if people call her not. The sheriff told Joan Shelley,
- 23:46even though Joanne was a minor, she still had to
- 23:50wait at least seventy two hours before she could report
- 23:54her missing. They also said, she's probably a runaway. There's
- 23:58nothing we can do. Now. Nowadays there's generally no waiting
- 24:02period to report missing people, especially children, but back then
- 24:06police use this as an excuse to straight up not
- 24:08do their jobs, and when they were forced to take
- 24:11a report by families who refused to be ignored, they
- 24:13simply marked pretty much every missing girl as a runaway,
- 24:16especially girls from this area, and then went on with
- 24:19their day, which which we fucking love. And I also
- 24:22want to point out like, even if she did run away,
- 24:25she's a miner, so the police have a legal duty
- 24:28to find her. But of course they didn't, so that's great. Now,
- 24:33there was one officer who really did care about Joanne's disappearance,
- 24:37and he was already sort of onto her Zog and
- 24:39Sherman Tine, and he told Joan Shelley not to tell
- 24:43anyone but the police that Joanne had been on a
- 24:46date that night. This comes up later, so it ended
- 24:50up being really great advice, and Joan Shelley was really
- 24:53grateful for this officer. So, of course he was later
- 24:56killed in a shootout not much later in fact, leaving
- 25:00Joan on her own to try and find her daughter.
- 25:03The next known victim was twenty four year old Robin
- 25:07arm Trout. Her full name was ROBERTA. J. Arm Trout,
- 25:10but she went by Robin. She was a fiery haired
- 25:13twenty four year old woman with a troubled past, but
- 25:16a heart of gold and a family who loved her dearly.
- 25:19At a fairly young age, Robin had fallen into drugs,
- 25:22namely meth, and had turned to sex work over the
- 25:25years to pay for her habit, which of course leads
- 25:27to a number of bad things, including kind of what
- 25:30happens to her ultimately, which is not to say it's
- 25:33her fault, it's just a very unfortunate situation. Robin obviously
- 25:37had a lot of self destructive behavior, including tattooing bad
- 25:41words into her own abdomen while she was drunk, and
- 25:44you know, her sister Candy confronted her about this because
- 25:47her family really cared about her, and she sort of
- 25:50just shrugged it off like she was ashamed, but she
- 25:53just wanted to act like it wasn't a big deal.
- 25:56Despite her own self hatred, Robin loved children and animals
- 25:59and was a true sweet soul. She had been married
- 26:02at seventeen, then divorced, then married again, but was estranged
- 26:07from her husband at the time of her death. She
- 26:09went missing on the night of September eighth, nineteen eighty five,
- 26:12after two men in a red pickup truck picked her
- 26:15up outside her house to go drinking. The details of
- 26:19her death were not known for many years, even though
- 26:21her body was found shortly after she went missing, lying
- 26:24naked near a creek. Her stomach tattoos were one of
- 26:27the things to help identify her otherwise very decomposed body.
- 26:31She had been stabbed nearly fifteen times and had also
- 26:34been raped and beaten. There were no leads, though Herzog
- 26:38and Shermantine were suspected by those in the area just
- 26:41based on who they were and how they behaved, but
- 26:44basically police didn't really care that much. Only about a
- 26:47month later, yet another sixteen year old girl, Chevelle Chevy Wheeler,
- 26:53went missing from her high school after getting into a
- 26:56red pickup truck. She told her friend she was going
- 26:59to her friend Wess's cabin and told her friend to
- 27:01tell her dad in case she didn't make it back
- 27:03by the end of the school day. Chevy was skipping
- 27:06school and seemed a little nervous about the situation, even
- 27:08though she did skip school here and there. Now here's
- 27:11what is insane about this next part and what makes
- 27:14me so so mad. Chevy had been hanging out with Wes,
- 27:18who was at this time nineteen years old and she
- 27:20was sixteen. They'd been hanging out for a while, and
- 27:22he even met her dad, So the family knows who
- 27:25this guy is, knows he has a red pickup truck,
- 27:28and her friend knows she left with him before fucking disappearing.
- 27:32When the family called the police the next day, they
- 27:35said there was nothing they could do. And not only
- 27:38was there nothing they could do, but there was nothing
- 27:40they could do, not for seventy two hours, but for
- 27:42thirty days. I'm fairly sure that this is a flat
- 27:46out fucking lie, and it's ridiculous that they would do
- 27:49this anyway, because once again, she's a miner and she's missing,
- 27:53and also there's multiple missing women and girls at this time,
- 27:57and the family knows who she was with before she
- 27:59went missing. Her sister confirmed that Shermantine had called the
- 28:03day before, like called her house, and her friend saw
- 28:05her leave school with him, so like, what is going on.
- 28:08Here's where that like connections corruption kind of thing comes
- 28:12into play, because it's pretty blatant, and yet they refuse
- 28:17to do anything. Police did finally interview Wes and even
- 28:21searched his cabin, and when they did, they found blonde
- 28:25hair that matched Chevy's hair, as well as blood that
- 28:28matched her blood type in the cabin. Now, as a reminder,
- 28:32there wasn't DNA back then, but there was blood typing
- 28:34as DNA was sort of starting to become more of
- 28:37a thing, and the blood types did match. Still, police
- 28:41said they didn't have enough evidence, so they did nothing,
- 28:44which really makes me wonder just how rich and connected
- 28:48Wes's senior was, because this is beyond egregious. Now that
- 28:53being said, this possibly led to a prolonged cooling off
- 28:56period for Herzog and Shermantine where they didn't kill anybody
- 29:00else as far as we know, for a while, and
- 29:04there were many many other suspected victims of these monsters,
- 29:07but as far as we know, there was quite a
- 29:11long time before another person was actually killed, although many
- 29:15people were victimized in other ways, which I'm going to
- 29:18talk about now. At some point in all of this
- 29:23Shermantine ended up getting married and even had kids. At
- 29:26one point, he had a babysitter who worked for him regularly,
- 29:30That is until he lured her into his home while
- 29:32nobody else was there and raped her. She went home
- 29:35to her husband and told him what happened, and two
- 29:38days later they reported the rape to the police, who
- 29:40told her she quote waited too long to report it
- 29:43so there was nothing they could do, which is unfucking believable.
- 29:48He also, at one point intentionally rear ended a woman
- 29:51in his red pickup truck, then abducted her when she
- 29:54came out of her car to exchange information. She ended
- 29:58up throwing herself out of his truck while it was
- 30:00going at least eighty five miles per hour, and somehow
- 30:04was mostly unharmed and was able to escape. He also
- 30:08had a quote unquote friend go pay a utility bill
- 30:11for him, but because he was so high on speed,
- 30:13he didn't believe she actually did it, even after she
- 30:16proved it, and he made her strip naked in front
- 30:18of his family, not sure if children were present, to
- 30:21search her body for his money. Lastly, on February fourteenth,
- 30:26nineteen ninety eight, and please notice we've jumped forward about
- 30:30thirteen years. Wes Shermantine called his friend Lisa Pisano to
- 30:35come pick him up from a bar because he was
- 30:37too drunk to drive home. Now, something tells me he
- 30:40wouldn't hesitate to drive drunk, but that was his excuse
- 30:42to get her alone with him. She met him at
- 30:45the bar, picked him up, and immediately he forced his
- 30:48way into the driver's seat of her car, then drove
- 30:51her to a remote area outside of Linden. He then
- 30:55raped and sodomized her, and when he was done, he
- 30:57pulled her out of the car and pushed her head
- 30:59against the ground. He held her there and told her
- 31:02to listen to the heartbeats of the people he killed,
- 31:06and then told her if she told anyone, he would
- 31:09kill her young son. This guy is an absolute monster. Now,
- 31:14Lisa is a badass, and she went ahead and told
- 31:16the police anyway, and Wes actually ended up arrested and
- 31:20went to court for this crime. And I bet you
- 31:22can guess what happened. I bet you can guess why
- 31:24nobody else would report him, why everybody was afraid, because
- 31:28nothing fucking came of this. His defense lawyers, paid for
- 31:31by his rich parents did what all scumbag lawyers did
- 31:35back then and to this day, honestly and made Lisa
- 31:38out to be a promiscuous drug addict, which made her
- 31:40testimony worthless to the now prejudiced jury, and Wes was
- 31:45set free. So despite half the town knowing what he's
- 31:48up to and in him and Herzog being the lead
- 31:51and sole suspects in many cases, he kept getting away
- 31:54with this shit for literally fifteen years. And what's so
- 31:57frustrating and also lends credibility to the idea that the
- 32:00police were in his parents' pocket, was the fact that
- 32:03his parents knew, at least to some degree about what
- 32:06he was up to. Now, when the two men went
- 32:09missing way back when and were found murdered in their car,
- 32:12you know, Wes knew. Wes and Lauren knew that that
- 32:16woman had seen them. They followed her home all that shit.
- 32:19Wes then went to his mom the next day and
- 32:21told her, oh, we drove by and saw some dead bodies.
- 32:24We didn't do anything. We didn't call the police, but
- 32:26we saw them. So he's starting to like spin a
- 32:28story to make himself seem innocent in case the cops
- 32:32come knocking and that's just the first indication, But it
- 32:36turns out that he didn't really need to do that
- 32:38because his parents would have covered for him anyway. His
- 32:41parents actually had a girl working for them for a while,
- 32:43I think, cleaning their house, who witnessed his parents literally
- 32:47burning his clothing so that they could deny he lived
- 32:50with them when police came looking for him after yet
- 32:52another woman went missing. So I'm pretty sure they knew
- 32:56and just didn't care. They just were going to cover
- 32:59for their son no matter what. As far as Lauren
- 33:02Herzog goes, his parents were, as far as I can tell,
- 33:05completely unaware of what was going on, and his name
- 33:07came up far less than Wes's and never really on
- 33:10its own, And as we remember, at least when they
- 33:13were younger, Lauren was considered sort of the weaker of
- 33:15the two. However, even though I haven't been talking about
- 33:19him that much. Later witness statements said this sort of
- 33:22changed like their dynamic as time went on, and not
- 33:25so much that Wes wasn't the leader, but that Lauren
- 33:28himself became very mean and violent, very aggressive, and just
- 33:31completely different than how he had been raised. There was
- 33:34another victim who came forward and actually said that she
- 33:38had been drugged, held captive, and raped by Shermantine while
- 33:41Herzog watched one night, but they let her go because
- 33:45she pretended not to remember anything the following morning. So
- 33:48now we have an instance way back when of Shermantine
- 33:51watching Hertzog, and now we have a more recent instance
- 33:54of Hertzog watching Shermantine. So these dudes are definitely doing
- 33:58a lot of the shit together, and it's very, very scary.
- 34:02And I'm sort of bringing up Lauren's role here because
- 34:05of course he's a part of this, but also his
- 34:07involvement is what brings us to our last known victim,
- 34:12which also I want to note this victim would not
- 34:14have been murdered if Lisa Pizzano had been believed, which
- 34:17is even more frustrating because she reported him for rape,
- 34:21but she wasn't believed, and so these two were allowed
- 34:24to continue on their spree. Now, as I mentioned, West,
- 34:28Shermantine is married, and at this point so is Lauren Hertzog,
- 34:33and both with kids know less, which is fucking terrible.
- 34:35They're both in their early thirties and prior to getting married, Lauren,
- 34:38who was kind of the more conventionally attractive. Of the
- 34:41two dated around a bit, not a ton, but definitely
- 34:44dated women here and there. Now. One of the women
- 34:47that he ended up dating for a while was named
- 34:49Kim vander Heyden, and she was the daughter of a
- 34:52man who owned a few bars in Linden and the
- 34:54surrounding area. Lauren and Wes would frequent the bar in
- 34:58Linden called the Linden Inn to hang out with Kim
- 35:01and later just because it was a place where they
- 35:03knew people, including Kim's younger sister, Cindy. Cindy vander Heyden
- 35:08was twenty five years old at the time that she
- 35:10was murdered and worked at the bar from time to
- 35:13time and also hung out there when she wasn't working,
- 35:15because you know, when you're in your twenties, you hang
- 35:17out at bars. And also, I don't think there's a
- 35:19lot to do in the area. I've kind of mentioned
- 35:21this a few times. So Cindy was really cool. She
- 35:25was super energetic, she was really pretty. People called her
- 35:28Tigger because she was so bouncy and fun. Now Tigger
- 35:32from Winnie the Pooh the Disney I don't know if
- 35:35it's Disney anyway, I think it predates Disney, but anyway,
- 35:37Tigger from Winnie the Pooh, and she even wore a
- 35:41little bracelet that had Tigger on it, which very sadly,
- 35:44she was wearing the day that she went missing. So
- 35:47let's kind of talk about what happens to Cindy, and
- 35:49this is going to sort of bring us home a
- 35:51little bit here. So on the night of November fourteenth,
- 35:54nineteen ninety eight, Cindy was hanging out at the bar,
- 35:57the Linden Inn, and Lauren and West were also there
- 36:00on this night. They seem to be chatting Cyndia up
- 36:03quite a bit, despite you know, both of them being married,
- 36:06and I think we know why, but I don't think
- 36:08she knew why. But at the end of the night,
- 36:10she apparently did drive her own car home. Her friend
- 36:14even followed her to make sure she got home okay,
- 36:16which is a very high quality friend thing to do. Unfortunately, though,
- 36:20it didn't make a difference in the end, because after
- 36:23her friend left, it's not exactly clear what happened, but
- 36:27we believe that she left of her own volition. Just
- 36:30so you know, her parents remember hearing her car pull in,
- 36:33but nine other could recall if they heard her actually
- 36:36coming through the front door, because they kind of just
- 36:37went back to sleep. They're like, oh, she's home, went
- 36:40back to bed. Now, Cydya had just moved back in
- 36:42with them so she could pursue her dream of acting,
- 36:45so she'd only been back in the area for a
- 36:47short time. In any case, her parents hear her car
- 36:50pull up, they go back to sleep, and the next
- 36:52morning they wake up and they realize that Sydney's not there.
- 36:56They look out front and they see that her car
- 36:58is already gone, and they're like, huh, we wonder where
- 37:00she went. It wasn't until later, when she still hadn't
- 37:03come home, that her dad got scared and went looking
- 37:05for her. Pretty quickly, he found her abandoned car by
- 37:09the local city cemetery full of her things. So it
- 37:12was that like she had brought her id, she'd brought
- 37:15her wallet and then got out of her car and
- 37:17left all of those things inside. Now, of course, the
- 37:20police didn't take this seriously at first, so her parents
- 37:23put together searches of their own, which is great because
- 37:25they had money similar to Wes's family, which allowed them
- 37:28to hire a helicopter and search for her in the
- 37:31woods and do other things that, like a lot of
- 37:32people in the area, weren't able to do when their
- 37:35family members went missing. Within a few days, police knew
- 37:39that the last people seen talking to her were Wes
- 37:43and Lauren, and they had a long list of possible
- 37:46victims similar to Cindy, spanning over fifteen years. So these
- 37:49two became top suspects, but again, not a lot to
- 37:53go on. However, finally the cops are actually starting to
- 37:57like take this seriously and look for ways to bring
- 38:00in and very luckily they caught a break when just
- 38:04a few months later, Wes Shermantine defaulted on his car
- 38:08loan and his car was repossessed. Now I want to
- 38:11say this wasn't his red truck at this point he
- 38:12had got a different car, but either way, he still
- 38:15transported and probably killed victims in his car, So this
- 38:20was a great find. Once in custody of the dealership,
- 38:24police were able to search this car and they found bloodstains.
- 38:28They found bloodstains on the passenger headrest and in the trunk,
- 38:31and at this point DNA had come into play like
- 38:34it was a thing. So because the police knew these
- 38:36two assholes never did anything without the other one there,
- 38:39they decided to not bring Wesley Shermantine in for an interview,
- 38:43even though it was his car where they found the evidence,
- 38:45but instead they wanted to focus on Lauren Hertzog. They
- 38:49did this because, like everybody else, they saw him as
- 38:52the weaker of the pair and expected they would get
- 38:54more information out of him than they would Wess and
- 38:57damn if they weren't right. Waved his right to a
- 39:00lawyer and sang like a fucking canary. He told police
- 39:04that not only did West Shermantine kill Cindy Vanderhyden, but
- 39:07they also killed Chevy Wheeler and Howard King and Paul Cavanaugh.
- 39:12He also told police about their first victim, Henry Howell,
- 39:15but of course blamed every single murder on Wes, and
- 39:19also said that Wes killed Robin Armtrout and I believe
- 39:23in that instance. He tried to, at least at first,
- 39:26say that he wasn't even present for that, although it
- 39:28later came out that he definitely was.
- 39:31Speaker 2: So.
- 39:31Speaker 1: Lauren was a bit flippant about most of the murders,
- 39:34but seemed very upset by the murder of Cindy, maybe
- 39:37because he'd previously dated her sister, or maybe because it
- 39:41was fresher in his mind. But either way, he seemed
- 39:44like sick to his stomach over the murder, and especially
- 39:47when he was going into the details, which unfortunately he
- 39:50did do. According to Lauren, Cindy had met them of
- 39:54her own volition, drove her own car to the cemetery
- 39:57in Clemente, California, which was right by her house, so
- 40:00they could snort some speed and hang out for a
- 40:02little while. They did, in fact, according to Lauren, snort
- 40:06the speed and pretty immediately after Wes began assaulting Cindy.
- 40:11They first got her into his car, then drove her
- 40:13deep into the woods, where Wes then raped her while
- 40:16she begged Lauren to help her, he of course did nothing.
- 40:21When Wes was done, he cut Cindy's throat, and unfortunately,
- 40:25it took a while for her to die, and while
- 40:27she was dying, she was asking them to help her,
- 40:30praying and fighting to get Wes off from on top
- 40:34of her so that she could try to escape. Just
- 40:36before she died, Wes told her to quote, just let
- 40:39it come natural, fucking haunting shit. After Cindy was dead,
- 40:46the men dumped her body and went on their way,
- 40:49or maybe what I should say is that Shermantine dumped
- 40:53her body, because when Lauren was giving up all of
- 40:56this information, he still did not divulge the location of
- 40:59her body, nor any others that we know of. And
- 41:02to be clear, none of the victim's bodies besides Robbin's,
- 41:05had been found at the time these men were arrested
- 41:08and tried for these murders, which is crazy and part
- 41:11of me wonders if Lauren really didn't know where the
- 41:14bodies were, or maybe he was just saying that he
- 41:17didn't as a way of proving his innocence kind of thing,
- 41:20because he was trying to blame it all on Wes.
- 41:24In any case, he was interrogated for seventeen hours and
- 41:27gave up all of the above information during that time. Now,
- 41:30as a note, this was like February nineteen ninety nine.
- 41:34He had actually been interviewed back in November nineteen ninety eight,
- 41:37but this was before Wes's car was repolled, and once
- 41:40Lauren sort of you know, realized they were caught, he
- 41:43turned on Wes immediately. His lifelong best friend didn't mean
- 41:47shit to him the moment he saw jail in front
- 41:50of him. Now, Wes was also interrogated about a month
- 41:54later in March of nineteen ninety nine, but they waited
- 41:56until after the DNA in his car tested positive as
- 42:01being Cindy vander Heyden's blood. So at first he's saying like, well,
- 42:05I don't know whose blood that is, because thinking back
- 42:07to when he killed Chevy Wheeler, you know, they were like, well,
- 42:10we know there's blood in your cabin, but we can't
- 42:12prove who's it is. So this dude didn't realize how
- 42:15far DNA technology had come, and once he sort of
- 42:18had to explain to him how it worked, he went
- 42:21from I don't know if that's her blood to I
- 42:23don't know how it got there. Basically, it's not mine, officer.
- 42:27So pretty fucking stupid. Now, even though he was given
- 42:32the opportunity, he didn't blame Lauren right away. First, he
- 42:37tried to use him as sort of like an alibi.
- 42:39But as time went on, he started saying, oh, yeah,
- 42:41he's threatened me before, he's pulled a gun on me.
- 42:45But right is he's about to get to the point
- 42:47in his interview where he just straight up blames Lauren
- 42:50instead he lawyers up. Now. Regardless, both men were arrested
- 42:56and like I said, using DNA from Sherman Tine's car,
- 43:00tried for five I think five murders in total. Now,
- 43:04the funny thing is that Lauren actually thought that if
- 43:06he blamed Wes, he would be able to walk free,
- 43:09which is absolutely insane considering he admitted to being present
- 43:12for multiple murders over multiple years. I watched some of
- 43:17his interviews, like I think I mentioned, and he's really
- 43:19animated and angry, keep saying he's gonna choose his family
- 43:23over Wes. But like, I just don't understand why he
- 43:27thought that that would happen for him, very very fucking weird. Now,
- 43:32during the trial, multiple women came forward about Wes raping
- 43:36them or otherwise abusing them, but not a lot about Lauren,
- 43:39which does lend credibility to the idea that maybe he
- 43:42wasn't quite as involved. But still, come on, come on,
- 43:47all that said, when all was sudden done, what I'm
- 43:52saying is sorry, guys making fun of my storytelling there.
- 43:54But anyway, all that said, both men were convicted of
- 43:58well they were both convicted I think of four murders
- 44:01with the murders of Cindy vander Heyden Howell Cavanaugh, Robin Armtrout,
- 44:07and King. Lauren was found guilty on one of those,
- 44:11for only manslaughter, but either way he was sentenced to
- 44:13seventy eight years in prison, while Shermantine was given the
- 44:17death penalty. Now, normally this would be the end of
- 44:20the story, but this story has a fun little end
- 44:24to it, and I don't want to say fun, but
- 44:25just interesting, little little footnote. I guess I shouldn't really
- 44:31call it a footnote because it's like a ps that
- 44:33turns into its own two page letter. But basically, after
- 44:38they were convicted, Lauren fought his convictions, and believe it
- 44:44or not, he fucking won. He had I think four
- 44:50of the convictions overturned in two thousand and four, after
- 44:54he'd spent only about four years in prison. Now he
- 44:57was found guilty of a lesser charge on the fifth,
- 45:00or would have been, but he ended up taking a
- 45:03plea deal to avoid more jail time and he was
- 45:06given I think twelve years as a result. Between the
- 45:09jail time he'd already done and his good behavior, he
- 45:12was released on parole in twenty ten. If you can
- 45:16believe it, this man who took part in who knows
- 45:20how many murders, but at least five, plus multiple rapes
- 45:24and other attempted murders and horrible things. He got twelve
- 45:27years and was released. Now, this was much to the
- 45:31anger of the victims' families and the local communities, and
- 45:34as a result, none of the nearby cities would take
- 45:37him at none of them would allow him to rehab
- 45:39there because you have to go to like a halfway house.
- 45:42Nobody would accept him. So what the prison did was
- 45:45they put him in a trailer on their property just
- 45:49outside of the prison, where he basically lived alone with
- 45:52no friends, definitely not his family, and was just sort
- 45:56of doing his parole and biding time. So it definitely
- 46:01wasn't a good life, but he was on the outside.
- 46:05And I gotta tell you this did not sit well
- 46:07with Leslie Shermantine, who at this point had been pretty
- 46:10tight lipped about things beyond trying to say that it
- 46:12was all Lauren's fault, and the anger that good old
- 46:15Weshre felt caused him to decide to do something kind
- 46:20of crazy but ultimately very good for all of the victims.
- 46:23He came forward and he spilled the beans on where
- 46:27all of the victims were buried. So he starts doing
- 46:31this in twenty ten by sending letters to one of
- 46:34his sisters, and in these letters he's drawing maps giving
- 46:38the locations of various victims' bodies. Now, the first set
- 46:42of maps showed victims' bodies that were buried near an
- 46:45abandoned well in Lynden, California. Police went to the owner
- 46:50of the well and he said, no, no, no, that
- 46:51well has been filled in long before those murders took place.
- 46:54So police took this dude at his word and didn't
- 46:56dig up shit and just went along their merry way.
- 46:59Sound familiar, Chris and smart anybody. Two years later, Shermantine
- 47:04continued kind of expressing interest in telling where the bodies were,
- 47:09and a bounty hunter came forward and said to him,
- 47:12I'll give you thirty five thousand dollars if you draw
- 47:15up those maps and send them to me and we
- 47:17get some bodies. So once again Shermantine sends the maps out,
- 47:22this time to this bounty hunter, and police this time
- 47:26decide to dig up the well. Now, before they did,
- 47:30this bounty hunter Leonard Padilla, who called himself Leonard Padilla,
- 47:34which I think is so funny, reached out to Lauren
- 47:37Hertzog and told him what was going on. Now, I
- 47:41think he was probably telling Lauren in an attempt to
- 47:43get him to kind of give up the information first,
- 47:47or corroborate it, or do something to kind of save
- 47:49his ass. But I think Lauren was a bit more
- 47:52involved in these murders than we even realized, because as
- 47:56a result of learning this information, this motherfucker hung himself
- 47:59out in his little trailer on his little property on
- 48:02the prison grounds and died like the loser sack of
- 48:05shit that he was. Now after Shermantine sent these maps
- 48:09to the bounty hunter, police finally did go back and
- 48:12dig up that well that the owner had claimed had
- 48:14been filled in, and wouldn't you know it, they found
- 48:16literally thousands of brone fragments, as well as beer cans,
- 48:21a woman's ring, purses, and clothing that belonged to some
- 48:24of the victims. There were three bodies found at this site.
- 48:27The first was nineteen year old Kimberly and Billy, the
- 48:31second was sixteen year old Joanne Hobson, whose mother Joan
- 48:35had been searching for her since the day she went missing,
- 48:38and the third was a still unidentified female who had
- 48:44been pregnant at the time, so there was actually a
- 48:46fourth baby body there, a little fetus as well. From here,
- 48:52Shermantine wrote more letters to the bounty hunter, who then
- 48:55had police dig up two other sites where his family
- 48:58owned land in Calaveras County near where they lived. So
- 49:01this site was kind of directly tied to West Shermantine,
- 49:05whereas the other one was dubbed Herdzog's Boneyard, which I
- 49:08think was just like a media thing. In this second
- 49:11dig site, police found Cindy vander Heyden's body or pieces
- 49:17of it, and not even that many pieces of it
- 49:19because they decided to dig this area up with a
- 49:22giant back ho which definitely pulverized many of the bones
- 49:26and made it difficult for the recovery teams to recover
- 49:30the bodies. In another well in the same area, they
- 49:33found the remains of sixteen year old Chevy Wheeler, and
- 49:36finally her family was able to lay her to rest.
- 49:39Remember the runaway that the police couldn't do anything about
- 49:41for thirty days. I forgot to mention, Oh no, I didn't.
- 49:45I told you guys about the fetus and the woman,
- 49:48and that's about it. Sherman Tine was led out once
- 49:51or twice to help quote unquote find bones, but it
- 49:54seems he's just lying to get out of prison for
- 49:56the day at this point, as nothing else has really
- 49:57been found. That being said is to believe that at
- 50:00a minimum they had killed nineteen people, but maybe as
- 50:04many as seventy or more, though unfortunately will likely never know. Now.
- 50:10One thing I wanted to do to sort of close
- 50:12the loop on the horrific job done by the police
- 50:13and potential corruption that I'd mentioned was sort of say
- 50:17that as soon as the bodies were found, the family
- 50:20started coming forward and being like, Hey, this is really
- 50:23blatant the way you guys are handling this. You're clearly
- 50:25doing this on purpose to cover something up. And what
- 50:28the family is alleged starting in twenty twelve, was that
- 50:31the recovery efforts were done so poorly in an attempt
- 50:35to actually destroy the bone evidence so that they couldn't
- 50:39tell whose bodies were in the ground. Because prior to this,
- 50:43police had either accidentally or intentionally lost multiple cases relating
- 50:50to missing girls and women in the area that were
- 50:53likely victims of Hertzog and Shermantine. So whether or not
- 50:58this was an intentional cover up. It all sort of
- 51:00leads back to, like, why wasn't any of this being
- 51:03taken seriously at the time, What the hell is going on?
- 51:06In fact, one of the families, I think, the vander Heyden's,
- 51:09because they had money to do so, sued the city
- 51:12or the police department or the sheriff's department, I should say,
- 51:15And I do believe that they won because when they
- 51:18received their daughter, it was like they said, they got
- 51:21three arms, they got the bones for three arms. So
- 51:26somebody else's child is being sent in part to them,
- 51:29and they're not even getting their full child because they
- 51:31did such a shitty job on the recovery. I don't know.
- 51:35So anyway, this is a really terrible case. It's hard
- 51:38for me to do serial killers. I don't know. You
- 51:40guys might see that I don't do quite as many.
- 51:43Maybe I'm sure I'll mix them in, but I feel
- 51:45like it doesn't give you quite enough time to really
- 51:47focus on each individual murder, which I think is an
- 51:49important thing to do when you're talking about victims, to
- 51:52have the time to talk about the victims, to talk
- 51:54about the impacts of their deaths. But Hopefully you all
- 51:57enjoy this. Thanks everybody again for listening. I'm gonna finish
- 52:01this kind of cut it short. I've been having a
- 52:03hell of a time recording. I think I just need
- 52:05a new computer, so hopefully the sound is okay. Thanks
- 52:08everybody for listening. Please like, rate, review, share with your
- 52:11friends and family. I'll be back next week with another
- 52:14California case, and until then, stay safe.