Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / Acupuncture and Alternative Therapies for Migraine Relief with Dr. Lauren Natbony, MD
Transcript
- 0:00So, you know, one of the things that I find is fascinating about you is you are such a rock
- 0:04star neurologist, but at the same time, you know acupuncture.
- 0:10Tell me about that.
- 0:11Like, how did you even go down that path?
- 0:14What made you want to kind of jump off the mainstream bandwagon and go get this additional
- 0:21training?
- 0:21Just I just wanna hear
- 0:22the whole story.
- 0:24I'm gonna tell you the real story because I actually decided to do acupuncture training to
- 0:28start it a month after I gave birth to my first child.
- 0:31It was like, I have to do it right now.
- 0:32I just can't wait.
- 0:33It has to be done now.
- 0:34So So so funny.
- 0:35Yeah.
- 0:36But it was good because, actually, like, I feel like it was good for for my peace of mind.
- 0:40So, yes.
- 0:41But I always felt that there was more than medication.
- 0:45Right?
- 0:45Like, medication is a tool, but it's only one tool in our toolbox and one that is relied on
- 0:50first line, and it doesn't always have to be.
- 0:53And I've always felt that the whole mind there there's something more.
- 0:57Right?
- 0:57And acupuncture has always been brought up.
- 1:00So I was like, I wanna be trained in it.
- 1:01So yeah.
- 1:01So I went to Harvard for a year, learned medical acupuncture.
- 1:05Also, a lot of that because it was geared towards physicians just taught me a lot about
- 1:10the differences between Western and Eastern medicine and then just a lot about
- 1:13musculoskeletal system and sort of how it all connects.
- 1:16So the way I've utilized it is beyond just giving acupuncture, but it's really
- 1:23understanding the connections in the body meridians
- 1:26Mhmm.
- 1:26And how that that interplay occurs.
- 1:28So that sort of was my interest.
- 1:30How I use it now, like I said, acupuncture practicing it, I feel like time wise, I don't
- 1:35do it as much in in clinic, but I definitely use the skills to be able to help my patients
- 1:40from a more musculoskeletal and whole body perspective.
- 1:44So I'm curious.
- 1:45Who do you think is a good person to go get acupuncture?
- 1:50You're mentioning musculoskeletal.
- 1:52Is it people who have a lot of neck pain or upper back pain?
- 1:55Are are they a better candidate, or or does acupuncture not really work that way?
- 1:59It's not necessarily related, but there's different parts of acupuncture.
- 2:03So looking at the migraine space, if I'm looking at evidence, there is good evidence for
- 2:07acupuncture for episodic migraine in terms of reducing frequency and intensity of attacks.
- 2:13The main issue is you have to do it every week for ten weeks, really, based on trials to see
- 2:19results.
- 2:20And a lot of times people don't stick with it long enough.
- 2:22It is like any other prevention.
- 2:24We need to be on prevention for a period of time for it to work.
- 2:27Yeah.
- 2:28For chronic migraine, there aren't as many trials, but I will say it can be relaxing.
- 2:32Just the relaxation of it alone can be helpful.
- 2:35There's no downside to doing it.
- 2:37So if you're a person who's like, you know what?
- 2:40I wanna sort of try the complementary modalities, it can be helpful.
- 2:44There's no one who it's not going to be helpful for if you're open minded to it and and sort of
- 2:48willing to give it a try as long as you give it that dedicated try, not just a one off, a one
- 2:52time.
- 2:53And if also, if the acupuncturist can do dry needling, so there are some states where
- 2:59acupuncturists who are not MDs or are not MDs or DOs cannot, dry needle.
- 3:04So if though the acupuncturists can, what I like doing is combining dry needling of trigger
- 3:09points with the acupuncture, and that's where the musculoskeletal system comes in more.
- 3:13Because acupuncture, you're looking to align energies that are out of alignment and
- 3:18therefore causing symptoms.
- 3:19Whereas with dry needling, you're looking to break up tight muscle tissue.
- 3:24And they kinda go together, but also can can treat different things.
- 3:28So I like combining them.
- 3:30And I would say then if you have a lot of neck tension, shoulder tension, that would be a good
- 3:34a good candidate for the dry kneeling part.
- 3:37So how does that work?
- 3:39Can they use the acupuncture needle Yep.
- 3:41Yep.
- 3:41To do the like,
- 3:43they wiggle it around.
- 3:44And Yeah.
- 3:45So it's a very specific technique.
- 3:46There's specific very thin needles.
- 3:48But because I I do wet needling and dry needling, so the wet needling is with
- 3:53injectables, it's much more precise to do it with an acupuncture needle.
- 3:57The needles are finer, longer, and can really get the smaller muscle fibers.
- 4:02And the residual pain that is left after because the it's such a smaller caliber is a
- 4:06lot less.
- 4:06If you're breaking up those fibers with a larger caliber well, neater.
- 4:11Wow.
- 4:11Look at my words today.
- 4:12Larger caliber needle, sometimes it could leave more more residual pain.
- 4:16So I feel like there's a lot, I think, of benefit in dry needling, but we as doctors
- 4:21don't learn how to do that with an acupuncture needle.
- 4:23Like, that's never something that's taught unless you are an acupuncturist.
- 4:26Yeah.
- 4:27Gotcha.
- 4:28Okay.
- 4:29K.
- 4:29Now here's the big question that everybody wants to know.
- 4:33How much does acupuncture hurt?
- 4:36So you're asking a person who literally will give myself nerve blocks in the mirror when I
- 4:40have a migraine, so I don't know if that
- 4:42works in death.
- 4:43Good for you.
- 4:43Not much.
- 4:44Don't for me
- 4:45Their needles are so fine.
- 4:47I feel like you can barely feel them half the time.
- 4:51So I would say, is it going to be like I'm falling asleep comfortable the first time?
- 4:56Probably not, but I it's not as painful as migraine.
- 5:00It's it's something that I feel like you kinda have to try to know.
- 5:03But I would say on the pain scale of things, when you're dealing with a pain condition,
- 5:08very, very minor.
- 5:09Okay.
- 5:10Alright.
- 5:11So to summarize, acupuncture once a week for ten weeks has good evidence to support it.
- 5:20It's good for anybody, maybe better for people who have a lot of musculoskeletal issues.
- 5:26It doesn't really hurt that much.
- 5:28You might be able to find somebody who can combine it with dry needling for you and kinda
- 5:33get two two treatments, the benefit of two different types of of treatments in there.
- 5:39Okay.
- 5:39Great.
- 5:40So is that is that, like, your go to complimentary and alternative medicine
- 5:46treatment because you have that training?
- 5:48Like, are you just so persuaded of the the benefits of it that that's what you recommend,
- 5:53or you think that do you think there are other things that are good in other circumstances?
- 5:58So I am a not I'm not a one thing for everyone person.
- 6:02So I think, like like you, I practice precision medicine and making sure that what I am
- 6:08recommending for that person is what's the right thing for that person.
- 6:10So when I talk to someone and they're like, I can't even get to, like, do the things I wanna
- 6:16do because I have no time.
- 6:17I'm not gonna be like, okay.
- 6:18Go to acupuncture and spend another hour hour a week.
- 6:21Or I I also really like mindfulness based stress reduction meditation.
- 6:25There are lot of people who can't who's just not gonna be the right thing for them.
- 6:28I like doing, like, heart math and biofeedback.
- 6:32Mhmm.
- 6:32Again, patient.
- 6:33Or it's something like a wearable device.
- 6:35Is someone gonna wear a wearable device?
- 6:37Is someone going to do subthresholds training for migraine of ex exercise training?
- 6:42Is this someone who I should work on sleep with?
- 6:45It's not a one size fits all.
- 6:47I will say no.
- 6:49The answer to your question is no.
- 6:50I do not recommend acupuncture for everyone, and I feel that maybe as an acupuncturist, I
- 6:55should, but I I I just don't feel that that's it is a one size prescription.
- 7:00Yeah.
- 7:00It's not gonna hurt anyone, but I always go with what do I think is the highest yield for
- 7:04this patient?
- 7:05Start there, and then I could always add on.
- 7:07Because when you throw so many things on to a person that's complementary, I feel like it
- 7:11could be overwhelming.
- 7:12Yeah.
- 7:12Yeah.
- 7:13Exactly.
- 7:14Exactly.
- 7:15And I I agree.
- 7:15I think there are definitely subsets of what is causing the migraines under the surface, so
- 7:22you've really gotta try to drill down on that and go there first because you want somebody to
- 7:29get some big wins early on, start feeling better, then they're able to bring in more
- 7:34tools to help their body fully heal.
- 7:36But if somebody's, like, wiped out, having headaches every single day, migraines, you
- 7:40know, a day or two a week or whatever is going on for like, they can't.
- 7:44You you have
- 7:44to you have to break through a little bit with, like, that low hanging fruit.
- 7:49Exactly.
- 7:50And I think as doctors, sometimes we just pile everything.
- 7:53We're like, do this.
- 7:54Do this.
- 7:54Do this.
- 7:55Do this.
- 7:56Nobody can can do all those things at once.
- 7:58So I have the same approach that you that you are describing.
- 8:01Yeah.
- 8:02So I love HeartMath.
- 8:04I was interested when you said that you are a fan of heart math too.
- 8:08How do you use it in your patients?
- 8:10I have
- 8:10a practitioner who is heart math certified that I will send them to to to do the initial
- 8:15training, but I have had some patients who are actually really good at doing it at home and
- 8:18keeping a log of what they're doing and do find it beneficial through just them doing it
- 8:22themselves?
- 8:23How do you use it?
- 8:24Well, I think it's a great measure of whether or not you have shifted your body out of that
- 8:29fight or flight state into parasympathetic because, of course, in parasympathetic is where
- 8:34you heal.
- 8:35You know, you don't heal when you're stressed out.
- 8:37So I think we all intuitively know that, you know, getting into that calmer state helps our
- 8:42bodies heal.
- 8:43But I I think what people don't always know is how they can create that for themselves
- 8:49because, you know, I'll be honest, I've done this too.
- 8:52You know, we have a stressful day.
- 8:54What's our what's our go to?
- 8:56You know, it might be watching TV.
- 8:58It might be having a drink.
- 9:00It might be eating some junk food.
- 9:02You know, none of those things are gonna yeah.
- 9:04I know.
- 9:04I'm guilty on all counts.
- 9:05On food.
- 9:06Sugar.
- 9:06Yeah.
- 9:07Not pointing fingers here, but I'm just saying, like, it's not our cultural norm to go to
- 9:13something that puts you into parasympathetic.
- 9:15I think there are cultures that have, you know, mindfulness or meditation or community or being
- 9:21outside or, like, any number of things much more than we do in our modern world, but it's
- 9:27just not what we're a culture to do anymore.
- 9:30And so I feel like it's really a learned skill these days.
- 9:33How do you get yourself from stressed to, rested and relaxed and recovered?
- 9:40And HeartMath is just a tool to help you know you're doing it right.
- 9:43That's how I see it.
- 9:44You can see the little wave go way, way up when you're doing the right thing.
- 9:47You know?
- 9:48Like, good.
- 9:48Got it.
- 9:49Okay.
- 9:49That's what I'm supposed to be doing because I think it's really hard to teach somebody how to
- 9:54meditate.
- 9:54Like, you can't tell them what it's supposed to feel like inside their body.
- 9:58You're you've only been in your own body.
- 10:00You know?
- 10:00You don't know what somebody else's experience with what it feels like.
- 10:04All we have is words to try to explain it, and HeartMath just puts an objective measure on it
- 10:09so that
- 10:10Love it.
- 10:10Exactly.
- 10:11Okay.
- 10:11That's it.
- 10:12That's what I'm supposed to be doing.
- 10:13I'm learning.
- 10:14Good.
- 10:14Okay.
- 10:15So I use it too because I realized I don't know how to breathe.
- 10:18Like, you would think that that's a skill.
- 10:21I hold my breath all the time.
- 10:24And, actually, what I want to get myself in I I'm not a good meditator, but into a more
- 10:28parasympathetic state is learning box breathing or the alternate nostril breathing, and that's
- 10:33an easy way for me to say, okay.
- 10:36I just need to focus on breathing, which I can see then when I'm doing things like heart math,
- 10:41bring bring my levels down.
- 10:42So you're right.
- 10:42It is a learning tool to figure out what will work for you in those situations.
- 10:45Yeah.
- 10:46Yeah.
- 10:47Absolutely.
- 10:47It's a good one.
- 10:48I love that one.
- 10:50Oh, and thank you so much for sharing your expertise, with us here.
- 10:54Many, many thanks.
- 10:56Really appreciate you taking the time to come and share.