Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Securing Your Legacy: Succession Planning for Law Firms with Daniel J. O'Riell
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to securing your legacy, succession planning
- 0:08for law firms. I'm Samantha Seves and I am one
- 0:12of the co -membership chairs of the barrister
- 0:14section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:17And it is my pleasure to introduce today's speaker,
- 0:20Daniel O 'Reilly. Daniel is a founder and managing
- 0:23partner of O 'Reilly and Roach LLP. Based in
- 0:26Los Angeles, he is a business and legal ethics
- 0:29lawyer for California law firms. He counsels
- 0:32and advises firms on strategic business issues,
- 0:35including developing and drafting partnership
- 0:37agreements and other firm organizing documents,
- 0:41developing and documenting compensation systems,
- 0:44attorney promotion systems, succession planning,
- 0:47developing and executing law firm startup planning,
- 0:50and growth planning. We can't wait to see what
- 0:52he has prepared to show us today. Let's get started.
- 0:55Thank you, Sam. Today we're going to consider
- 0:58what I think is one of the most important and
- 1:02also one of the most overlooked aspects of law
- 1:05firm ownership. And by law firm ownership, I
- 1:08mean equity partners, and that is succession
- 1:10planning. What does that mean exactly? It means
- 1:14having a plan for another group of lawyers or
- 1:17another firm or another lawyer. to take over
- 1:22your practice as you step back for whatever reason,
- 1:24and that can be planned or unplanned. Assuming
- 1:28you own the firm or the majority of the firm
- 1:30or a significant stake in a law firm, this is
- 1:33the path for you also to get full value of your
- 1:36ownership interest, or at least to maximize the
- 1:38value to you and your family if you leave. So
- 1:42we think of two types of succession planning.
- 1:44The first is the plan that ensures that your
- 1:47practice continues and your clients are protected.
- 1:50in the event that you're unable to practice law
- 1:53for some period of time, planned or unplanned.
- 1:56The second is the plan that ensures a smooth
- 1:59transition of your law practice and your firm
- 2:02when the time comes for you to step back from
- 2:04practicing law. Maybe you're going to retire,
- 2:07maybe you're going to go write the novel that
- 2:09you've always wanted to write, or maybe you're
- 2:10going to do some other thing besides being a
- 2:12lawyer at a law firm. When that happens, there
- 2:16are things that you can do to ensure that you
- 2:19protect your clients and you transition the firm
- 2:21over to a new regime, but also maximize the value
- 2:26for you and your family that you get from something
- 2:28that you built over a lifetime in a career. Lawyers
- 2:33tend to put off succession planning. They're
- 2:36busy with client matters, and that always comes
- 2:38first. And even with good intentions, law firm
- 2:42planning can take a back seat. That is 100 %
- 2:45normal. So for every busy lawyer who are our
- 2:49clients, it is good intentions. And we try to
- 2:53structure the process so that we can overcome
- 2:56obstacles to planning, which we'll touch on at
- 2:58the end of the talk today. But in the first instance,
- 3:03one of the things that we want to question is,
- 3:05why should you worry about succession planning
- 3:07at all? And there are some very compelling reasons
- 3:11why you should focus on this and plan ahead.
- 3:15Last year, the State Bar of California's Committee
- 3:18on Professional Responsibility and Conduct, that's
- 3:21CoPRAC, issued its formal opinion 2024 -209,
- 3:26that's in the materials. This opinion details
- 3:30a lawyer's duty to engage in succession planning,
- 3:33and the takeaway of it is that the rules require
- 3:37you to assess whether succession planning is
- 3:41required for your firm. And again, we're in category
- 3:44one of succession planning, which is how to protect
- 3:47your clients in the event that you have an unexpected
- 3:50interruption in your practice, and how to ensure
- 3:53that the firm continues its operations. There
- 3:57is no single California rule of professional
- 4:00conduct that explicitly requires a lawyer to
- 4:03adopt a succession plan, but there are multiple
- 4:07rules that would be impossible to meet without
- 4:10a succession plan. In other words, an interruption
- 4:14to your practice without a succession plan almost
- 4:18certainly would lead to a violation of multiple
- 4:20rules. Specifically, Rule 1 .1, the duty of competence.
- 4:26Rule 1 .3, diligence. The duty of loyalty to
- 4:31your clients in making sure their interests are
- 4:33protected. Rule 1 .4, the duty to communicate.
- 4:38Rule 116, the duty to avoid reasonably foreseeable
- 4:42prejudice when terminating a representation.
- 4:47Rule 115, safeguarding funds and property of
- 4:50clients. Rule 5 .1, the duty to supervise others
- 4:53and ensure compliance with the rules. There's
- 4:56a laundry list of rules and it's detailed in
- 4:59this opinion, which is really worth a read because
- 5:02it's not generally considered to be required,
- 5:06but the opinion does illustrate how it would
- 5:08not be possible to really meet the obligations
- 5:11that you have under these rules and the other
- 5:13duties that you have to clients if you don't
- 5:16have the succession plan. And again, the takeaway
- 5:21is to meet these obligations, you have to engage
- 5:23in an assessment of whether a succession plan
- 5:26is required for your practice. Examine whether
- 5:31and what you need to do in advance to meet your
- 5:33obligations under the rules. that might require
- 5:36you to arrange in advance how client matters
- 5:39are handled. That's a baseline. Arrange in advance
- 5:42how client files would be returned. Arrange in
- 5:45advance how funds and property belonging to clients
- 5:48will be returned to them. If you don't have a
- 5:52succession plan, it's very easy to imagine scenarios
- 5:54where your client's interests are unproductive,
- 5:57their rights are prejudiced, and the firm suffers.
- 6:00And when you come back, if it's a temporary unplanned
- 6:02absence, it will really be a mess. So the first
- 6:07answer to the question why worry about succession
- 6:08planning is really the rules require it. And
- 6:11they don't require you to do something specific
- 6:13in terms of what the plan should be, but they
- 6:16absolutely require you to assess whether you
- 6:19can meet these obligations if you had a planned
- 6:21or unplanned absence from your practice. And
- 6:25just in general, it's very good business to put
- 6:30in contingent plans for the protection of your
- 6:33clients in the event that you are not available.
- 6:37But there are other reasons, more practical reasons,
- 6:39that we worry about succession planning, and
- 6:42these have to do with the second category of
- 6:44succession planning, which is if you're a firm
- 6:46owner, a substantial owner of a firm, or an exclusive
- 6:50owner of a firm, getting value for that law firm
- 6:53ownership interest really requires you to plan
- 6:56ahead. And it doesn't happen overnight. It's
- 6:59not very straightforward, but it can be done
- 7:02if you have the right plan and When we say getting
- 7:07full value for your partnership interest What
- 7:09we mean is a smooth transition of your practice
- 7:12to others and you are bought out your interest
- 7:15is purchased or otherwise compensated You move
- 7:19on to other things whether that's retirement
- 7:21or some other thing and if you don't have a plan
- 7:24and you are deciding that you're just going to
- 7:26wind down your firm, you're really giving up
- 7:30a substantial value of something that you have
- 7:33built over many, many years in your career. And
- 7:37this is oddly something that we see lawyers do.
- 7:41People just take a sort of soft landing approach
- 7:44to their firms and their succession plans. Maybe
- 7:47you take fewer clients over the years. Maybe
- 7:50you wind down some of the staff obligations that
- 7:52you have, shrink the operations. But in doing
- 7:56that, you're really giving up a substantial asset.
- 8:00And the value that you have created in the firm
- 8:03is the ongoing revenue. So if you wind that down
- 8:06slowly over time, yes, things will get easier
- 8:09for you in life. And maybe that's the path for
- 8:12you. And if it is, that's OK. But if you want
- 8:15to get full value out of your firms and your
- 8:18interest in the firm, you really do need to have
- 8:21a plan for how you're going to transition out.
- 8:26More to the point, not just protecting your own
- 8:29financial interests, although that's a significant
- 8:31interest. At the firm, you have employees, you
- 8:34have other attorneys, you have colleagues and
- 8:37peers, and protecting them and their futures
- 8:41really requires having a succession plan. in
- 8:45place so that you don't simply one day decide
- 8:49that you're going to wind the practice down and
- 8:51they're left to fend for themselves. In many
- 8:54firms, it's the case that one or two people run
- 8:57the firm and they're the only people who know
- 8:59how to run the firm. So part of what we also
- 9:02think of as a reason to worry about succession
- 9:04planning is really creating a future for the
- 9:07people that work with you, your trusted colleagues,
- 9:10your employees, people who have served you over
- 9:15many years and who will be the future of the
- 9:21firm if it's handled properly, but who will really
- 9:24be left in the lurch if it's not. For many lawyers
- 9:28and staff, sudden interruptions with no plan
- 9:32and succession is an extremely unwelcome development
- 9:36in their own careers that easily can be avoided.
- 9:40Why should you worry about succession planning?
- 9:42Well, one, the rules require you to take a look
- 9:44at this. That's one. Two, if you want to get
- 9:48full value for what you have created, you need
- 9:50to plan ahead. And three, to protect your colleagues,
- 9:54your employees, your peers of the firm, and to
- 9:57continue the legacy of the firm that you've created,
- 10:00you need a plan in place. The good news is it's
- 10:06not really terribly difficult to think through
- 10:09that plan We do this with clients every single
- 10:13day and we encourage our clients to Handle this
- 10:17and think about this as they would any client
- 10:20problem that their clients present which they
- 10:22do all day every day in other words people put
- 10:25lawyers put this off because it has it's it's
- 10:28extremely important, but it's not urgent and
- 10:30everything else on their Desk is urgent and so
- 10:34they solve those client problems first But the
- 10:37reality is you should think of this is just another
- 10:39matter where you bring your best lawyer mind
- 10:41to the problem and think through what these options
- 10:44are. Now, you don't have to think about dying
- 10:47if that's something that makes you uncomfortable.
- 10:50You can think about retiring and going off to
- 10:53do whatever it is that you would rather do instead
- 10:55of practicing law. There's another element of
- 10:59this that we stress, which is when the time comes
- 11:03that it's too late for you to leave is way too
- 11:06late. You don't necessarily know when that time
- 11:10is going to come. And we certainly have lawyers
- 11:14who are fully functional and bright well into
- 11:16their 80s or later. And there are other folks
- 11:20for whom issues arise much sooner than that,
- 11:23but you won't necessarily know. And if you're
- 11:25a lawyer, you need a plan in order to reduce
- 11:28risk. That's what you do for your clients every
- 11:30single day. And this is what we do for our clients
- 11:33who are lawyers. It takes a bit of... prodding
- 11:38to get lawyers to think about their own plans
- 11:41in that way, but we really encourage clients
- 11:45to look at it as with their lawyer brains just
- 11:47as any other problem to solve. What would the
- 11:53goals be of your succession plan? This is where
- 11:55you start to think about what do I actually want
- 11:58to achieve here? We're obviously looking at an
- 12:01exit for the firm. You're going to leave the
- 12:03firm someday. And as I mentioned before, one
- 12:07of the main goals you have if you're a majority
- 12:09interest owner or an exclusive owner of a firm
- 12:11is maximizing the value of what is probably one
- 12:15of your largest assets in your life. That seems
- 12:19intuitive, but again, consider what will happen
- 12:23if you don't have a succession plan. Your family
- 12:26or your spouse will have to deal with, in some
- 12:30fashion, handing over the transition of the firm,
- 12:33the lawyers at the firm will be taken by surprise
- 12:36in the event that you're unexpectedly gone. The
- 12:40staff will be taken by surprise. People may or
- 12:42may not have the qualifications to pick it up
- 12:44and run it. You won't have trained any of them
- 12:47to do that. And it's very unlikely that the firm
- 12:50will survive. Another part of our practice is
- 12:53dissolving firms when a principal lawyer has
- 12:57departed unexpectedly, and that is a mess. And
- 13:00it's easily avoided if you just plan ahead. So
- 13:03set the goals of the succession plan. The one
- 13:06goal if you're a majority owner is to maximize
- 13:09the value to you or other founders or other equity
- 13:12partners of a transition. Another goal that you
- 13:18may have, and this part of the plan that you'll
- 13:20develop, which is creating a lasting legacy for
- 13:23the firm to continue this thing that you've built
- 13:26over the course of your entire career, the practice
- 13:28that you have, for that to be handed off to people
- 13:32who you've trained, and for it to continue, whether
- 13:36it's in your own name or a different name, but
- 13:39the practice continues and the clients are protected.
- 13:42And that is a lawyer legacy. That is a significant
- 13:45interest that lawyers should have when they're
- 13:48thinking through these succession planning goals.
- 13:52The other goals would include creating some type
- 13:56of a tiered or a graduated exit for yourself
- 13:59or your colleagues. If you plan ahead, you can
- 14:03step back slowly in the way that makes sense
- 14:06for you. If you don't plan ahead and something
- 14:11unexpected happens, it'll be an extremely sudden
- 14:15disruption to the practice. So over a period
- 14:18of time, you can create a plan that fits the
- 14:21way in which you want to step back. Maybe you
- 14:24want to be in charge of the firm up to the last
- 14:26day that you're there. Maybe you don't want to
- 14:29be in charge tomorrow, but you still want to
- 14:31be practicing law or being a big brain at the
- 14:35firm and walking around. Maybe you want to do
- 14:37just business development and talking to clients,
- 14:40but not the other aspects of it. You can define
- 14:43that role for yourself at the firm. And you can
- 14:47plot out the timing for that, which is most important
- 14:50in the plan. And one of the goals really should
- 14:54be to think through and to create the specifics
- 14:57around how you want to exit in an orderly way.
- 15:02Another important goal for a succession plan
- 15:04is really to reward the hard work of colleagues
- 15:07by transitioning ownership and control of the
- 15:10firm to them. These are folks who have worked
- 15:13at a firm, made it successful, with you over
- 15:17probably many years. In some instances, it will
- 15:21be the only place they've ever worked. And in
- 15:23some instances, it will be the only professional
- 15:28home that they can imagine. And it's a significant...
- 15:35process for a law firm to bring people up to
- 15:38an ownership level. And that's not just necessarily
- 15:41training them to how to run the firm, but that
- 15:45is a critical part of it because as a founder
- 15:48or an equity partner or somebody who owns a significant
- 15:51part of a firm, you probably are the only one
- 15:53or one of a few people who actually knows how
- 15:56it runs, knows how decisions are made, knows
- 16:00what it made it successful. knows what it should
- 16:03be doing in the future in terms of strategy to
- 16:05keep it successful. So rewarding the hard work
- 16:09of your colleagues is a critically important
- 16:12goal of a succession plan. And again, what we're
- 16:17doing in this process is putting the very huge
- 16:22undefined problem of how do I wind down my practice,
- 16:27my role in the practice, and hand it over to
- 16:29other people. Well, just like anything that you
- 16:32would advise your clients to do, it happens in
- 16:35a logical, orderly way. We first figure out what
- 16:38are the goals we're trying to achieve, and they'll
- 16:40be different for every lawyer. There will be
- 16:44lawyers who say, I don't want to do this if I'm
- 16:49not in charge. There will be lawyers who say,
- 16:52I have a team of people right below me who are
- 16:58excellent, talented, ready to take the next step.
- 17:02It's much more likely that nobody can replace
- 17:05you if you're a founder of the firm and you started
- 17:07the firm and you've been with it for the duration,
- 17:11because that's an identity that if you're not
- 17:13a founder, you're unlikely to ever have. However,
- 17:16you may have... four or five or more people at
- 17:20the next level below you who can do pieces of
- 17:23what you do and may have strengths in those areas
- 17:28and can be trained to fill in the gaps of what
- 17:31they don't know about the specifics of your firm.
- 17:35So you do business development, you manage the
- 17:38firm, you do recruiting, practice development,
- 17:40and all the other functions that a founder or
- 17:43equity partner is called upon to do. And that
- 17:47doesn't happen overnight. It didn't happen overnight
- 17:49for you and it won't for others. But there will
- 17:51be people who have a specific strength in originating
- 17:56new work. There will be people who have a specific
- 17:58strength in managing the firm. There will be
- 18:01people who have a specific strength in practice
- 18:04development, meaning how we become better lawyers
- 18:07in a planned way. And those are all three things
- 18:10that are critically important to the firm's development.
- 18:13If you plan it out correctly, you can identify
- 18:17and plan to develop those lawyers at the next
- 18:20level who can replace those functions for equity
- 18:23partners who are Xing. And that's really what
- 18:27we're talking about in terms of a plan. Now,
- 18:30your goals will definitely diverge from others
- 18:36at the firm. And in that instance, Part of what
- 18:40we're doing by identifying the goals is to see
- 18:43whether there are any tension points where You
- 18:46want to leave tomorrow, but nobody's ready to
- 18:48take over Or you want to stay for a long time,
- 18:52but other people are ready to move up And the
- 18:56process of identifying goals is really also identifying
- 18:59any kind of tensions that we think might emerge
- 19:02Based on what you want to do compared to the
- 19:05reality of your firm actually on the ground Okay,
- 19:12so we've identified some goals. You have identified
- 19:15why you should think about succession planning,
- 19:17and then you've thought through some of the things
- 19:21that will be specific to you, the goals, and
- 19:24put that into a framework for what works and
- 19:28what doesn't in reality at the firm. And starting
- 19:31to think through goals, how achievable they are
- 19:34at your firm is really the process of planning.
- 19:38Based on the goals, What is the right structure
- 19:42for your firm succession plan? This is where
- 19:45most lawyers just blue screen and have a blank
- 19:49stare. And it makes sense that you wouldn't necessarily
- 19:52know about this because it's not something that
- 19:55people talk about very often. It's certainly
- 19:57not something that anybody ever trained you to
- 20:01do. Certainly not in law school or anywhere else.
- 20:04And it's a little bit like a wedding. If you
- 20:06do it correctly, you only have to do it once.
- 20:10So ultimately, what we are talking about is three
- 20:15broad categories. And again, this is probably
- 20:19new to most lawyers, but we're thinking about
- 20:22three ways that you can exit a firm. You're going
- 20:26to sell to another law firm, probably with a
- 20:30recruiter or a law firm broker. Or you are going
- 20:35to sell to an internal group. Lawyer candidates
- 20:39of people that you've worked with and People
- 20:44that you've trained and that you will train to
- 20:46sort of take over Your role as that plan develops
- 20:51that's the second option and a third option is
- 20:56You're gonna merge the practice with another
- 20:58firm joining a larger platform platform Then
- 21:04finally another fourth option and we'll come
- 21:06back to talk through the pros and cons of these
- 21:07is You create a law related business that actually
- 21:12runs firm operations that can be sold including
- 21:15to non -lawyers and Then what remains at the
- 21:18firm is something that only licensed people can
- 21:20do which is actually practice law So let's come
- 21:24back to Some of the pros and cons about these
- 21:28four structures. The first was sell to another
- 21:31law firm potentially with a recruiter or a law
- 21:35firm broker. That can be a high value if you
- 21:39find the right buyer. Let's say you do something
- 21:42in California that an East Coast firm does in
- 21:46the East Coast or elsewhere and wants to have
- 21:49duplicated in California, and many firms want
- 21:52to have a presence in California. For obvious
- 21:54reasons, it's an enormous economy, but also it
- 21:57means coast -to -coast coverage. It means that
- 22:00they're in every major market. And if you find
- 22:04the right buyer, it can be a significant value
- 22:07to you. Now, if you look at these types of opportunities,
- 22:14and you've probably had these opportunities multiple
- 22:16times over the years, to join other firms and
- 22:21the deal is essentially come here and be a lawyer
- 22:24and we'll pay you compensation. But you're not
- 22:26going to get anything out of the actual value
- 22:29that you've created at your firm because that's
- 22:31just going to wind up. And that's what you really
- 22:34want to avoid. You're not looking for a new job.
- 22:38You're essentially looking for somebody who could
- 22:40actually pay you a premium because they want
- 22:43something that complements that you have their
- 22:46business. Client retention in these circumstances
- 22:50can be much more difficult. Clients may not want
- 22:53a larger firm, if that's what happens. They may
- 22:56not want a different firm. The fees of the new
- 22:59firm can be much higher, service can be different
- 23:02or less personal. They viewed you as their personal
- 23:06lawyers and then all of a sudden, you're not
- 23:09the personal lawyer anymore and they don't have
- 23:11a particular reason to feel connected to the
- 23:15firm. The clients chose you and they didn't choose
- 23:23whoever it is that buys you or wherever you go
- 23:25and so that's going to be a client retention
- 23:27issue. So true for lawyers at the firm. They
- 23:32may not want to be at a larger firm if that's
- 23:34what happens or they may not want to be at a
- 23:36new firm and they may want to practice on their
- 23:38own and they may take that opportunity to decide
- 23:42that it's time to try that. These can be a better
- 23:46fit for certain types of practices. In particular,
- 23:50contention fee practices can be easier to transfer
- 23:54over to different firms and it's easier to, say,
- 23:57get paid for the value of those cases because
- 24:00it isn't just the straight hourly work that you
- 24:02get from working as a lawyer on a daily basis.
- 24:05Some practices can be very difficult to transition
- 24:08to new firms. If you have a highly personalized
- 24:11trial practice, That's based on your reputation
- 24:14as a star trial lawyer. It's really unlikely
- 24:16that somebody else is going to step in and be
- 24:19you That doesn't mean it can't be done, but it
- 24:23just means that it's not going to be plug -and
- 24:25-play at some other firm It's also possible that
- 24:29in these circumstances the practice that you
- 24:31have could be a mismatch for the new firm in
- 24:33terms of Expenses what it takes to run the firm
- 24:36how you actually produce the revenue and the
- 24:38overhead that is required the expense load is
- 24:41rarely you know, a match at a different firm.
- 24:44It's probably why you started the firm or worked
- 24:46at the firm in its current form in the first
- 24:49place. And it can be very difficult to find a
- 24:53buyer at the right price. Many firms, as I mentioned,
- 24:56don't value this. They just want to plug you
- 24:58in as an additional equity partner and say, we'll
- 25:01pay you compensation. But if you find the right
- 25:05buyer, that first option of selling to a different
- 25:07firm can be a good option. It provides a home
- 25:12for your lawyers, staff and others, depending.
- 25:16And the clients may be happy with it and it might
- 25:18bring opportunities in the short term. And if
- 25:21the firm is willing to compensate you for what
- 25:22you're bringing, it could be an exit, that makes
- 25:25sense. The second category is selling to internal
- 25:30lawyer candidates at your firm, people that you
- 25:33have trained and worked with over many years.
- 25:36and you would update and train them over a period
- 25:39of time to own and manage the firm if there are
- 25:41things that they just don't know about, which
- 25:43is probable. Selling to internal lawyer candidates
- 25:47is great. It is a great way to maintain the legacy
- 25:51of the firm, the culture of the firm. It's best
- 25:54for other lawyers of the firm because they move
- 25:56up. gives you the opportunity to have a planned
- 25:59departure. It gives the staff continuity, the
- 26:03clients feel comfortable with it if you do it
- 26:05correctly and over time. There are challenges
- 26:09though to this. I mean, one is it's rare to have
- 26:12the right internal candidates who are working
- 26:15for you and have for a long period of time and
- 26:17all of a sudden have to take an entrepreneurial
- 26:19bent and become a sort of a lawyer owner mentality.
- 26:25relatively quickly, and sometimes it can be very
- 26:27difficult to properly identify them. You may
- 26:31have them at your firm, in which case it'll work,
- 26:34and you may not, in which case it won't. And
- 26:37some practices call for the full development
- 26:40of lawyers into kind of lawyer -owners, and by
- 26:44that I mean they're managing client relationships,
- 26:46they're getting client work, they're taking part
- 26:48in firm management, they are taking part in professional
- 26:52development. And some practices don't require
- 26:56that. They just really rely on legal expertise,
- 26:59work as a lawyer, I'll handle all the rest. In
- 27:03the latter example, it's really unlikely that
- 27:05you're gonna be able to turn somebody from a
- 27:07service lawyer into an owner. It's possible,
- 27:10but it'll be a challenge and it will take longer.
- 27:14So identifying suitable candidates can be a challenge
- 27:16and then properly incentivizing them can be a
- 27:18challenge. What are they going to get out of
- 27:20this besides moving up and headaches and a bunch
- 27:23of liabilities? What is the future look like
- 27:26for them? And you have to have a plan where they
- 27:28could see a future that looks way better than
- 27:32what they have. Usually it's after you're gone.
- 27:36And then, of course, you have to train them to
- 27:38do the things that you do, which we've referenced
- 27:40in multiple categories, but it's not to be overlooked.
- 27:44Again, not something that any one person is likely
- 27:46to do to be able to do what you do, but multiple
- 27:50people can do pieces of it, most likely. Candidates
- 27:55are unlikely to have the traits of a founder
- 27:57or an equity partner, somebody who runs their
- 28:00own practice or the firm as a whole, until they
- 28:03do it. And so it requires a thoughtful approach
- 28:06to be able to train them. and recognize that
- 28:11it's not going to be something that's turnkey
- 28:13and very quickly. Things that make a successful
- 28:17attorney, as somebody who's very effective as
- 28:19a lawyer, are not always the traits that make
- 28:22them successful as firm owners or equity partners.
- 28:28Another challenge for internal lawyer candidates,
- 28:30significant challenge, is how are they going
- 28:33to pay for this? So we'll come back to financing
- 28:36a bid in the next category. On the back of the
- 28:40envelope, if you've created a firm that has a
- 28:42significant value, people who are rising equity
- 28:46partner tend to be in their 30s. They have a
- 28:47lot of other obligations. They may have young
- 28:49families, mortgages, other things. They're not
- 28:52going to be handing you millions of dollars overnight.
- 28:55It has to be something that is transitional and
- 28:59probably financed by the firm. We'll come back
- 29:02to the structure and what that looks like in
- 29:03a bit. But financing, selling it to internal
- 29:07candidates can be a challenge. Okay, let's say
- 29:12if that's a problem we'll go to the third category.
- 29:15Merge the practice with another firm, join a
- 29:17larger platform. And this is probably the least
- 29:21likely to work. It has a lower value because
- 29:24you're not even really selling something as in
- 29:28the first category where you expect to get some
- 29:30type of a premium for what you've created. You're
- 29:33just joining another firm. And that alleviates
- 29:36a lot of the headaches of running the firm and
- 29:39owning the firm. and obviously the liabilities,
- 29:41but then you have a boss and it's not that different
- 29:45from just winding down your practice in terms
- 29:47of value that you can expect to receive. It probably
- 29:51puts you as a founder or an equity partner who's
- 29:53been running your own practice for a long period
- 29:55of time in a management structure that does not
- 29:58fit because nobody has told you what to do for
- 30:00a long time and you're not in the mood for it.
- 30:04It can be very beneficial to clients. depending
- 30:07on where you go, and it can be very protective
- 30:09of them. And that is a goal. But it often leaves
- 30:12non -equity partners out of the process. So you're
- 30:15not likely to protect other people at your firm
- 30:17because there may be other people at the new
- 30:20firm who can do what these folks do, and they
- 30:22may need work to do. And if you plug in, that
- 30:27can create significant uncertainty for the people
- 30:29at your firm. And again, it could be a terrible
- 30:33fit for your clients. Maybe they don't want to
- 30:35be at a huge firm. Maybe they don't want to pay
- 30:37different rates. Maybe they don't want to have
- 30:40the person that is designated to take over the
- 30:42practice be in charge of their stuff. Or maybe
- 30:47they have actual conflicts with that firm, which
- 30:49would obviously be something that would have
- 30:51to be vetted. But it's a significant problem
- 30:53that can be pretty tricky to manage. Clients
- 30:56chose you for a reason and they don't really
- 30:58want to have other choices imposed on them. Okay,
- 31:06the fourth category is something that lawyers
- 31:08typically don't really think about. And it is
- 31:12emerging and it takes a little more creativity
- 31:14and can be something that will take some analysis
- 31:19to determine whether it fits well for your practice.
- 31:22But it should be on the table because there is
- 31:25flexibility that comes from this. that can be
- 31:28difficult to get in the other three categories.
- 31:31And it is creating a law -related business that
- 31:35owns firm operations. And when you do that, you
- 31:40can sell that, including to non -lawyers. This
- 31:43obviously is a much better fit for certain types
- 31:45of practices than others. If you have, again,
- 31:50an active trial practice where it's personal
- 31:52to you and you're the star trial lawyer, it's
- 31:55really... relatively unlikely that it's going
- 31:57to be seamless to transfer. And the operations
- 31:59of the firm consist of very specific trial work
- 32:04that varies depending on the case and what is
- 32:06required. And from year to year and from month
- 32:09to month, the different cases that go to trial
- 32:12are vastly different than each other and you
- 32:14can't really plan around it. But for other types
- 32:18of practices where there is a steady stream of
- 32:22revenue, a predictable workflow, a repeatable
- 32:28staff level sort of workload that can be made
- 32:33more efficient, for example. Or if there's a
- 32:36significant marketing operation related to the
- 32:39practice, for example, in high -level PI work,
- 32:42high -volume PI work, that definitely is the
- 32:46type of thing where there's a lot of operation
- 32:49work that's driving value for the firm, which
- 32:52is not something that only a licensed person
- 32:54can do. meaning a lawyer. And if those things
- 32:58that are business functions that are critical
- 33:00to the value of the firm can be split into a
- 33:04different entity, those things are not things
- 33:07that only a lawyer can own. Now, a law firm is.
- 33:11And there are downsides to this and there are
- 33:14opportunities to it. It should be analyzed in
- 33:17the context of your practice and how it would
- 33:20be a fit for your practice. It can be complex,
- 33:26and the transaction is higher cost. You have
- 33:28to have all the documentation about how these
- 33:32two entities will relate to each other. That
- 33:34tends to be a service agreement between the non
- 33:36-law firm and the law firm. It can create management
- 33:41and administration challenges, and it requires
- 33:43significant diligence to ensure the compliance
- 33:46with the legal ethics rules. There are many legal
- 33:50ethics rules that this would touch. and you have
- 33:54to ensure not just in the way that it's set up,
- 33:57but in the way that it's actually managed and
- 33:59administered, that you comply with those rules.
- 34:05Of course, if it's set up, if it's a fit for
- 34:07the practice, and if it's set up and there are
- 34:10significant value in the business operations
- 34:12of the firm, and it's easy to see how the liar
- 34:16functions can be split into something that only
- 34:18licensed persons can do, it can be much easier
- 34:22to sell because non -lawyers can own it. And
- 34:26there are a lot more non -lawyers than lawyers.
- 34:33Again, the four categories are things that should
- 34:36be assessed as part of the plan to think about
- 34:39where does your practice fit in this structure?
- 34:43What options are available to you? What make
- 34:45the most sense? And sometimes it's the right
- 34:48choice to pursue a couple different options and
- 34:50then to see what that looks like in practice.
- 34:55You may think that you have people who can take
- 34:57over, and so you're going to sell to internal
- 34:59candidates, but then you approach those people
- 35:02and discuss it, and it turns out they don't want
- 35:05to do that, or they can't do that, or they have
- 35:07some other plan in mind for themselves. There
- 35:12are very likely one or more of these categories
- 35:15that would be viable for the practice. But this
- 35:17is the process of sort of logically planning
- 35:20through succession planning. Where does your
- 35:22practice fit in the context of these options?
- 35:26And then once we identify that, you're looking
- 35:29into the actual practical realities. I want to
- 35:32sell to internal candidates. Do they want to
- 35:35own this? Do they have the wherewithal to make
- 35:37it work? Because if they can't run it when you're
- 35:40gone, it's not going to make a difference what
- 35:43they agree to do. Another significant element
- 35:49of this which I referenced previously is how
- 35:55will the succession plan be financed? And this
- 35:58is another area that is typically extremely daunting
- 36:03to lawyers who are thinking through these issues
- 36:05because what they're really thinking about is
- 36:10probably an old school regime where a new equity
- 36:15partner, and when you became an equity partner,
- 36:17this may have been what you did. You go to a
- 36:21bank and you get a loan for the amount of buying
- 36:25into the firm. Money goes to the firm to purchase
- 36:31your interest and the equity partners who are
- 36:33selling some of the interest or handing it over
- 36:36Get that and they reduce over time and you buy
- 36:40and step up over time so if you did that and
- 36:45When you became an equity partner, it was your
- 36:48process Many lawyers think that's the only possible
- 36:52process that's out there and in fact, it's just
- 36:55one of several options, but It does still exist.
- 36:59It's much less likely to be a thing because you
- 37:03simply you have fewer banks who are participating
- 37:06in this and you also have a very different reluctant
- 37:10approach for some of the rising equity partners
- 37:13who just don't want to be tied to that level
- 37:17of a specific liability for something that is
- 37:20not as secure as it might have been in like 1983.
- 37:24Clients leave law firm fortunes change and if
- 37:28you're a rising equity partner Taking out a huge
- 37:31loan For that when it could change in the next
- 37:36day is a fairly daunting thing So this does happen
- 37:40and it can be a great option If it's available
- 37:44and if the people who are buying in are open
- 37:47and willing to do it for obvious reasons because
- 37:49it provides cash upfront and the people who are
- 37:54selling and leaving the firm or stepping down
- 37:57their ownership of the firm get that cash and
- 38:00they're ready to roll. It's less likely to be
- 38:05something that would be palatable to rising equity
- 38:07partners in 2025 for the reasons that I just
- 38:10mentioned, that fortunes of law firms are much
- 38:12more variable, partners feel much more mobile.
- 38:16And at the time when this was prevalent, people
- 38:19stated firms, clients stated firms, and it was
- 38:21really unlikely that either of them would leave.
- 38:24Well, now it's likely. And so taking out a hard
- 38:27liability for something that is extremely variable
- 38:30is a tricky concept. A second way that law firm
- 38:36succession plans get financed is contributed
- 38:40capital from new owners. And this is much more
- 38:44similar to self -financing. It's kind of a variation
- 38:49on that theme. But basically, the firm identifies
- 38:52some amount of contributed capital that the new
- 38:55equity partners should contribute. And the founders
- 38:58are departing equity partners over time, again,
- 39:01slowly take that contributed capital and they
- 39:04step down their interests in the firm. These
- 39:09are plans that have to take three to five years
- 39:11at a minimum to exercise because you're not going
- 39:13to go to somebody and say, give me your whole
- 39:16annual distribution as payment for contributing
- 39:19capital and make nothing. What you're going to
- 39:22do is say some percentage of that will be paid
- 39:25to step down my interest as an owner as I exit
- 39:31and step up your interest as a rising equity
- 39:34partner as you enter the ownership ranks or develop
- 39:39more ownership from what you already have. And
- 39:42that's best through a really sort of slow, progressive
- 39:47approach. These are paid out of distributions.
- 39:51So if you would be entitled to get $100 ,000
- 39:54as an equity partner, and you're gonna contribute,
- 39:58you know, 50 over five years, obviously, you
- 40:02give back 10 every year. That's just an example
- 40:05of this way. Now, Contributed capital doesn't
- 40:09have to correspond exactly to a percentage of
- 40:12ownership of the firm. And this touches on what
- 40:15we will always recommend you consult your tax
- 40:18advisors about, which we'll come back to in the
- 40:20next section. But it is not the case that if
- 40:26you sell 1 % of the firm, you have to have it
- 40:28valued and then you have to charge people that
- 40:301%. The value of a law firm is highly subjective.
- 40:35And what it means is really, to be an equity
- 40:38partner, what it means is to have a claim to
- 40:41the profits of the firm in the future, based
- 40:44on what we do, the work we do, or the profits
- 40:47that are generated from the work we do. It doesn't
- 40:50mean that you own 1 % of all the hard assets
- 40:52of the firm, although you technically do, but
- 40:55when you combine all the hard assets of a law
- 40:57firm, you got a bunch of used staplers and computers
- 41:00that are fully depreciated and essentially worthless.
- 41:03or worse that you have to have hauled away in
- 41:06the event of a dissolution. So contributed capital
- 41:10doesn't necessarily correspond exactly to the
- 41:13value of the firm because also it's extremely
- 41:15expensive and it's highly subjective to go out
- 41:18and have a firm valued. Some firms do it and
- 41:21that can work but it's also widely recognized
- 41:27now that what you're really getting as an equity
- 41:30partner, the identity of being an equity partner
- 41:32is that you have ownership and management of
- 41:35a firm, control of its governance, and a right
- 41:37to participate in its profits. That's how you
- 41:39get paid. Which is the other category of how
- 41:43these succession plans get structured, financed,
- 41:47and it's owner financing, which is I have $100
- 41:52,000 in equity in the firm, say, And I've got
- 41:57five people who are going to take over. I'm going
- 41:59to give them equal parts over three to five years,
- 42:02and they're going to pay me for my 100 grand
- 42:04between the five of them over those five years.
- 42:08Obviously, the numbers matter. If it's 100, then
- 42:11five of them at 35 can probably do that over
- 42:15five years. If it's 100 million, it's really
- 42:18unlikely that that's going to happen, no matter
- 42:20how many people are coming in. Owner financing
- 42:25in this instance really means we've identified
- 42:28something that I'm going to take away from the
- 42:30firm as an exiting founder or an equity partner.
- 42:33And the new group is going to come in and they're
- 42:36going to pay me that over time. I'm going to
- 42:39step down my experience at the firm. I'm going
- 42:42to make sure that what I built transfers over
- 42:44to them. And they're going to pay me for it.
- 42:48And that's how you exit with internal candidates.
- 42:53And then, of course, you could have hybrid options
- 42:57that include and are all of these together, which
- 43:01is increasingly common. Sometimes you might have
- 43:04parts of it financed by a bank or litigation
- 43:08finance company. You might have some of it straight
- 43:12ownership financing, and you might have some
- 43:15of it that is just contributed capital that relates
- 43:20to the working capital. of the firm. Okay, we
- 43:24have a question, which is what are the practicalities
- 43:27of the effect of the selling attorney dying,
- 43:30leaving a non -lawyer spouse when the sale consists
- 43:32of future payments or referrals? The rule says
- 43:36you can't share fees with a non -lawyer. That's
- 43:39the concern. Correct. This is a question that
- 43:44comes up a lot. The answer will be very specific
- 43:46to you, but what we're talking about, the general
- 43:49answer will be Your estate would receive payment
- 43:53for your interest in the value of the firm. You
- 43:56wouldn't be just writing a check to share fees
- 44:00with a surviving spouse. And those are two very
- 44:04different things. And so in one instance, in
- 44:08our view, you'd be complying with the rules.
- 44:10You'd simply be having your interest in the firm
- 44:12bought out. Your estate would receive it. according
- 44:17to whatever terms you've defined, say in the
- 44:19partnership agreement or in the succession plan.
- 44:22And the other would be a very weird non -compliant
- 44:26law firm sharing with a non -lawyer who is a
- 44:28surviving spouse. So it just, it doesn't work
- 44:31that way. It doesn't get structured that way,
- 44:32but it's a valid concern. If you have no plan,
- 44:35it is a valid concern. Another question, how
- 44:41is AI likely to impact firm value over time?
- 44:45This is a great question. This is a significant
- 44:49variable that we cannot quantify. We have studied
- 44:52AI, and I know that CoPRAC has issued guidance.
- 44:57And as part of issuing that guidance, you learn
- 45:02a little bit about AI and you know that it is
- 45:05the Wild West. One way that it could impact a
- 45:09firm over time is that if you invest a significant
- 45:11amount of money in an AI process that works,
- 45:14to do something for your firm that you need done.
- 45:19For example, marketing, generating leads, acquiring
- 45:23cases, say, in a PI firm, that is a non -legal
- 45:27function that could be sold as an asset of the
- 45:29firm. But if you rely on AI to do the work, obviously
- 45:36within the confines of the roles, and you don't
- 45:39have many other lawyers, Well, you're not going
- 45:42to have anybody to sell the firm to because robots
- 45:44aren't going to buy it. And it also, it's very
- 45:47unclear what the value proposition would be for
- 45:52your firm if AI can do it. Somebody else could
- 45:54get AI to do it. We don't think of blurs that
- 45:57way. That's not how we think about the future
- 45:59AI impacting it. And that would be obviously
- 46:02a different CLE. But in the short term, the answer
- 46:05is it's likely to significantly affect the value
- 46:09of a firm over time. On the other hand, it's
- 46:12possible that it will just still be human beings
- 46:15making relationships and hiring lawyers that
- 46:17they trust, in which case, how the work gets
- 46:20done, whether with AI or something else, doesn't
- 46:23make that much of a difference in the value,
- 46:25because that trust relationship is where the
- 46:27value is actually stored. Again, though, if you
- 46:31have an AI system that can do something specific
- 46:33for the firm's functions that needs to be done,
- 46:36that could be a significant asset that could
- 46:38be sold, and that in itself could be a non -law
- 46:42firm asset that you can sell to anybody. All
- 46:50right, let's talk about some of the other factors
- 46:53or details related to succession planning that
- 46:55are really important to make this work. A significant
- 46:59one is really thinking through and identifying
- 47:02what is the right continuing role. equity partners
- 47:07or founders if that's your identity at the firm
- 47:10and what's the right timeline for that. It can
- 47:15be really challenging for equity partners to
- 47:18identify the right exit for themselves. We try
- 47:23to help clients do that by looking at many different
- 47:25factors and we encourage them to think about
- 47:27it. Very broadly, but you know, we all as lawyers
- 47:31recognize that we've been doing this in many
- 47:34cases since we were 25 years old you've been
- 47:36in law school some of us since you were 22 and
- 47:40your identity is Being a lawyer and in some way
- 47:45you may not be able to very easily imagine what
- 47:50it's like not to be one and That's really what
- 47:54we're talking about here, which is you're gonna
- 47:56go and you're not going to be a lawyer, but even
- 48:00more important than that, you're not going to
- 48:01be an important person at the firm as much as
- 48:04you once were. This can be a very difficult transition
- 48:08for founders because you built something that
- 48:12you are a significant part of, possibly with
- 48:15other partners or maybe just with yourself. And
- 48:18when you're there, it's an intellectual engagement,
- 48:20but also it is prestigious. You run something
- 48:24and people there work for you. So Addressing
- 48:30that is in many ways beyond the planning of just
- 48:33the lawyer But it's something we encourage our
- 48:35clients to do with our help and then with other
- 48:37resources that they may want to consider Like
- 48:39do you have things to do that will be fulfilling
- 48:42or like some of our clients? Are you going to
- 48:44retire and then after a month? really want to
- 48:47come back or want to undo that and What is the
- 48:51right timeline for you to retire? Do you want
- 48:54to die at your desk at 90? That's not a very
- 48:58realistic goal, but it could be done if you structure
- 49:00it properly And or do you want to go tomorrow?
- 49:06To the golf course and never come back also not
- 49:09a very realistic goal Something in between those
- 49:13two That those vast extremes is probably more
- 49:16realistic. But one of the things that we do encourage
- 49:19clients to think through is What are you gonna
- 49:21do? You've been this for a long period of time
- 49:24and something really specific a successful lawyer
- 49:28and so you need to think about what that's like
- 49:32when you're done. Client and talent retention
- 49:37should also dictate the timing. If you're saying
- 49:40that you want to do this over 20 years and the
- 49:43people that work for you are themselves 60, that's
- 49:47not going to be, you know, a tremendous incentive
- 49:49for them to move up. They may have other goals
- 49:52in mind. We have had instances where people are
- 49:57talking about succession planning and the lawyers
- 50:00they'd like to hand it over to themselves are
- 50:01ready to retire. So client and talent retention
- 50:05is really significant. The client retention depends
- 50:09on how specific it is to you and what it means
- 50:11for you to transition this over time. It can't
- 50:14be done overnight. It doesn't have to take 10
- 50:18years, but it does take time to get clients introduced
- 50:20to new people, to have them comfortable with
- 50:23new people making decisions, to train the new
- 50:26people to handle the clients and get to know
- 50:29what they need in a really specific way, but
- 50:32it shouldn't take forever. Buyers tend to have
- 50:38a much faster timeline than sellers. Sellers
- 50:41who are at the firm usually want the firm transition
- 50:45to take an orderly path and wind them down and
- 50:49buyers are basically like, let's flip the switch
- 50:51and I own this now, I can do whatever I want
- 50:53with it. And then how much training really would
- 50:58be required to make the new buyer successful,
- 51:01whether that's internal candidates or others.
- 51:04Is that gonna take a significant amount of time
- 51:06beyond what you wanna do in your exit? Another
- 51:11category of really important elements of this
- 51:14is what are the tax considerations that you have
- 51:16to think about in the structure of the plan.
- 51:19We're not tax lawyers, but we do frequently recommend
- 51:22that all our clients consult with their tax advisors
- 51:24so that the tax structure that results from the
- 51:32structure that you decide is part of this whole
- 51:33planning process, your goals and how it's set
- 51:37up and other things actually work for you from
- 51:39a tax perspective. And employment advice is also
- 51:44significant too. In some instances where you
- 51:48are downsizing a firm and selling it to somebody.
- 51:53Or if you're in a professional corporation and
- 51:55some people also happen to be employees of the
- 51:57PC. Legal and ethics advice and regulatory advice
- 52:03obviously is going to be significant in the context
- 52:06of the category where you're selling it to a
- 52:08non -law firm. where you're splitting some non
- 52:11-legal assets or assets of the firm operations
- 52:14that are not something that only a licensed person
- 52:17can do, you really need to be mindful of how
- 52:21those rules interact with what you're doing,
- 52:24how it's administered, and what is compliant,
- 52:27because it makes no sense to do that if you're
- 52:29immediately violating significant rules. You
- 52:34know, another significant Factor is how the risk
- 52:39exposure for you as an exiting partner is balanced,
- 52:43how you transition management control, and what
- 52:48those two things do in relation to each other.
- 52:51If you're not in charge of anything anymore,
- 52:53are you still liable for them? What is the ownership
- 52:56and liability percentage as balanced against
- 52:59the management and control function? You typically
- 53:03want them to correspond really closely with each
- 53:05other, meaning the less control you have, the
- 53:08less liability you should have. And so the plan
- 53:10should work that way. It steps you down. It steps
- 53:14other people up on both of those categories,
- 53:17up and down in concert. Another significant category
- 53:24is, well, whether there are founders or equity
- 53:28partners who are at the same stage. Maybe you
- 53:31founded a firm with five other law school roommates
- 53:35and you've had a great run and you have a great
- 53:38practice, it's very unlikely that you're all
- 53:41really willing and ready to able to do a retirement
- 53:44or something as an exit at the same time. Again,
- 53:48some people want to work till 90 and some people
- 53:51are done at 55. And everybody has different financial
- 53:55situations as well that might dictate options
- 53:58that may not be available to all. So are the
- 54:02founders who are in the firm with you going to
- 54:05do the same thing on the same time frame? And
- 54:08if not, are you giving your ownership binges
- 54:11to them? They're going to buy you out? Or is
- 54:13it some combination of new people plus them?
- 54:16And will that work? And when you have equity
- 54:20partners who've been with you for a long period
- 54:22of time, which many law firm owners do, it's
- 54:25important to think about what the timing is vis
- 54:27-a -vis the other colleagues and peers that you
- 54:30have. Assuming that each you know, person can
- 54:35figure out the right transition for them individually,
- 54:41how does that affect what the other people are
- 54:43going to do in terms of timing? And how does
- 54:45the split happen with ownership? Is all the ownership
- 54:51going to go to the other people, in which case
- 54:53you still have a bunch of people who are not
- 54:55owning significant portions of the firm? Or can
- 54:59it be done in some way where everybody steps
- 55:01out just over a different time period? And how
- 55:07will or how can the firm change if the founders
- 55:11or the equity partners who are controlling most
- 55:14of it leave at different times? It's frequently
- 55:18the case that some of the founders or equity
- 55:21partners who run firms split among themselves
- 55:24the functions of managing the firm and generating
- 55:27work and doing other things. If one person in
- 55:30that group leaves, you may need somebody else
- 55:33to step into that role. who is more junior and
- 55:36that can lead to some tricky balancing because
- 55:39some people who have been in charge for a long
- 55:41period of time might now be working with and
- 55:43possibly training people who've never done it
- 55:46and maybe they're not in the mood for that. So
- 55:48the timing between equity partners who are at
- 55:52the same level and may want to exit but on different
- 55:54time frames is a significant thing to think about
- 55:58when you're putting a plan together. And not
- 56:02all these answers are going to be very obvious,
- 56:04and some of them won't be determined. But leading
- 56:08to the next section, what contingency planning
- 56:12should be built into the plan? We've identified
- 56:17in the materials a few different things that
- 56:19do happen, and we have experience with different
- 56:22clients. What if a selling equity partner changes
- 56:25their mind during the plan or after the plan?
- 56:29and they say want to come back and practice law
- 56:32and possibly compete with the buyer, that creates
- 56:35a significant, significant problem. What if a
- 56:38buyer or a new equity partner who's gonna step
- 56:41in and own more changes their mind during the
- 56:45plan? This also creates a significant problem
- 56:48because what if they leave during the plan? They're
- 56:51gonna say buy in over five years time, they start
- 56:54doing that, and then they leave in year three.
- 56:57What do they get back? What do they own? What
- 57:01obligations do they have to the firm? What happens
- 57:03to the founder who's not getting bought out?
- 57:06These are things that really need to be integrated
- 57:08into the plan, and we like to put them into partnership
- 57:10agreements, but they can also be put into other
- 57:13planning documents. Because it does happen, things
- 57:16change, people move, people's goals change, health
- 57:20changes for lawyers, and it's... predictable
- 57:24that sometimes people will start a plan for the
- 57:27transition and not be able to finish it or not
- 57:29want to finish it. So we need to plan ahead for
- 57:31that. What if clients leave during the plan?
- 57:35You got a transition plan where five of us are
- 57:37going to buy you out in over five years time,
- 57:40but the main firm client is gone and the revenue
- 57:43with it. This is where the planning really gets
- 57:46very specific. What happens if the revenue isn't
- 57:49what we expect? We build in certain ratchets
- 57:52so that the payments and the other obligations
- 57:55change. Sometimes that happens because of cash
- 58:00flow, which is temporary, and then payments may
- 58:02be deferred. Sometimes it happens because if
- 58:05a client leaves, there isn't going to be the
- 58:08value that we thought there was going to be.
- 58:10And so what are we paying you for? What if the
- 58:15new equity partners who are buying in and rising
- 58:19cannot successfully own or manage the firm without
- 58:22you if you're an exiting equity partner. This
- 58:26is one of the main risks that you take in structuring
- 58:31these deals as an exit. And we address these
- 58:35really specifically. It's a balance between how
- 58:37much you get paid up front versus how much you
- 58:39get paid over time. And as a person who's leaving,
- 58:43you want to get all the money up front, just
- 58:44walk out. But as a person who's buying in, It's
- 58:48better for you to have this happen over time
- 58:50so that you can ensure that you get the training
- 58:53that you need, that you have the resources while
- 58:55the other person is still involved in the liability
- 58:58and the operations of the firm. And that you
- 59:02also confirm that what you thought was going
- 59:06to happen in terms of the business does happen,
- 59:09meaning clients do transition, revenue is transferable,
- 59:13that you're able to become a principal. you're
- 59:16getting some value for what you're paying and
- 59:20that the other person's actually going to leave.
- 59:24These contingencies are really critical for obvious
- 59:27reasons, but also they can all be addressed if
- 59:30you think through them and think about many different
- 59:34options for creating contingent planning. If
- 59:38something happens in this way, if these expectations
- 59:41aren't met, this is what we're going to do. Because
- 59:45it's a critical part of the planning to obviously
- 59:48think about the contingency that it ain't gonna
- 59:51work the way we thought it was. And if that happens,
- 59:54that's okay. We just think through what should
- 59:57happen instead. Okay, I see that we are just
- 1:00:02about at our hour of time. I'm happy to stay
- 1:00:06on and answer any other questions that anyone
- 1:00:10has. And otherwise, I'll yield back to our host.
- 1:00:17Alrighty then, this concludes today's presentation.
- 1:00:19Thank you so much, Daniel, for your time and
- 1:00:22thank you so much to our guests for joining us
- 1:00:24today. You may be eligible for CLE credit in
- 1:00:27your state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts for
- 1:00:31more information.