Latest / Interfaiths / The Incommunicable Limit: Abraham’s Silence and the Paradox of Faith
Transcript
- 0:00So, what if the most profound acts of faith,
- 0:02the ones that truly define belief, are the very
- 0:05ones that can never, ever be explained? Today,
- 0:08we're going to jump into the mind of philosopher
- 0:10Soren Kierkegaard and take a fresh look at one
- 0:13of history's most troubling stories. And in doing
- 0:15so, we might just uncover a powerful truth about
- 0:18the limits of our own words. Okay, let's just
- 0:21get right to the heart of it, the question that
- 0:23kicks this whole thing off. So you've got the
- 0:25story of Abraham, commanded by God to sacrifice
- 0:28his son Isaac. And on that long three -day journey
- 0:31to the mountain, he says nothing. Not a word
- 0:34to his wife, not a word to his son walking right
- 0:37beside him. I mean, why? That's silence. That's
- 0:40the real puzzle here. For ages, right, the debate
- 0:43among scholars has always been about what Abraham
- 0:45must have been thinking. The general idea was
- 0:48that the real problem, the big paradox of faith,
- 0:51had to be some kind of massive contradiction
- 0:53happening inside his head. Yeah, the traditional
- 0:56view is that this is a paradox of knowledge,
- 0:59of belief. I mean, think about it. How could
- 1:01Abraham possibly believe two completely opposite
- 1:04things at the exact same time? Number one, God
- 1:07told me to kill my son. And number two, God promised
- 1:11that this same son would make me the father of
- 1:13nations. It just doesn't compute, right? It feels
- 1:16like a logical impossibility. But what if that
- 1:19whole debate is just a distraction? What if we've
- 1:22been focusing on the wrong thing this entire
- 1:24time? While a really fascinating new analysis
- 1:27by philosopher Alexei Proshashin suggests that's
- 1:30exactly what's been happening. And here's the
- 1:33big shift. The real defining feature of Abraham's
- 1:36faith isn't what he believes. It's what he can't
- 1:39communicate. The paradox isn't happening in his
- 1:42mind. It's happening in his silence. And this
- 1:45is the crucial part. He doesn't just choose to
- 1:47be quiet. He fundamentally, literally cannot
- 1:50explain himself. To really get our heads around
- 1:53this, we need to look at Kierkegaard's big idea
- 1:56about human experience. He called them the three
- 1:59spheres of existence. And, as it turns out, each
- 2:02sphere has its own unique kind of silence. So,
- 2:05you can see here how it all breaks down. We've
- 2:07got the aesthetic, the ethical, and the religious
- 2:09spheres. And just look at how silence evolves.
- 2:11In the aesthetic sphere, silence is a choice.
- 2:14It's a secret you could tell if you wanted to.
- 2:16Move up to the ethical, and silence is a temporary
- 2:19problem that you must eventually explain. But
- 2:21when you hit the religious sphere, the silence
- 2:23becomes absolute. It's something that is fundamentally
- 2:25incommunicable. Let's start with aesthetic silence.
- 2:29The best way to think about this is like holding
- 2:31a winning hand in poker. You're keeping it a
- 2:33secret to create mystery, maybe a little intrigue.
- 2:36You could show your cards at any moment. The
- 2:38power is in the choice to stay silent. Now, when
- 2:41we get to the ethical sphere, the rules totally
- 2:43change. Silence here isn't a strategy. It's more
- 2:47like being a witness on the stand. It's a temporary
- 2:49state because eventually you are required to
- 2:51speak up and justify yourself. Think of a tragic
- 2:54hero like Agamemnon who sacrifices his daughter.
- 2:56It's a horrible choice, but he can and he must
- 2:59explain his reasoning to the community using
- 3:01shared ethical principles. But for Abraham, who
- 3:05Kierkegaard calls the knight of faith, the silence
- 3:08is something else entirely. It's not a choice,
- 3:10and it's not temporary. It's more like a radio
- 3:14that's definitely picking up a signal from a
- 3:16faraway station, but all we can hear on our end
- 3:19is static. The message is real for him, but for
- 3:22the rest of us, it's completely untranslatable.
- 3:25This whole idea of an experience that just can't
- 3:28be translated, well, it has some massive consequences
- 3:31for how we understand what faith even is. I mean,
- 3:35Kierkegaard really drives this home. He says
- 3:37that even if Abraham knew every single language
- 3:39in the world, he still couldn't talk about this.
- 3:42It's not about not having the right words. He's
- 3:45operating in a totally different communicative
- 3:47reality. He's speaking, as Kierkegaard says,
- 3:49in tongues. And here's where that contrast just
- 3:52becomes crystal clear. The tragic hero, Agamemnon,
- 3:56is great because we can understand him. We can
- 3:59debate his choice, sympathize with his dilemma.
- 4:02But the knight of faith, Abraham? He is great
- 4:05for the exact opposite reason. He is great because
- 4:07he is beyond our ethical system. His greatness
- 4:10is found in that singular, private, and totally
- 4:13silent relationship with the divine. So let's
- 4:16be really clear. This inability to communicate
- 4:18isn't a bug, it's a feature. The fact that Abraham's
- 4:21experience can't be put into words is the very
- 4:24sign that it's a genuine, profound religious
- 4:26experience, one that has stepped outside the
- 4:29boundaries of our normal, everyday world. Okay,
- 4:31so this is all some pretty heavy 19th century
- 4:34philosophy. But why does it matter for us today?
- 4:37Well, it might just completely reframe how we
- 4:40think about something as modern as interfaith
- 4:42dialogue. And you know, this isn't just a Kierkegaard
- 4:44thing. You see this idea pop up across so many
- 4:47of the world's religions. In Sufism, you have
- 4:49the concept of fauna, the annihilation of the
- 4:51self and God. In Kabbalah, there's Devakut, this
- 4:54intense cleaving to the divine. In Christianity,
- 4:57there's a whole tradition of prayer that focuses
- 4:58on what can't be said about God. All of these
- 5:01point to core experiences that people insist
- 5:03are ultimately beyond words. This kind of blows
- 5:07up a key assumption in a lot of interfaith work,
- 5:09doesn't it? The idea that if we just talk enough,
- 5:11if we just find the right words, we can explain
- 5:13everything to each other. But what if the most
- 5:16essential, the most vital parts of a person's
- 5:18faith are precisely the parts that can never
- 5:20be explained in a dialogue? So maybe this points
- 5:23to a new kind of approach, you know, one that
- 5:25starts with humility, just acknowledging that
- 5:27our explanations have real limits, one that values
- 5:30shared contemplative silence instead of always
- 5:33needing to talk, and maybe one that focuses more
- 5:35on action, on witnessing how a faith is lived,
- 5:38not just how it's described. And all of this
- 5:41brings us to one final and pretty provocative
- 5:44distinction that this analysis raises. It's a
- 5:47potential clash between two ideals that we all
- 5:50hold in really high regard. Take a look at this
- 5:53difference between how wisdom and faith get passed
- 5:56on. Wisdom, you know, it's like a craft. Think
- 5:58of the ancient Taoist wheelwright. It's hard
- 6:00to explain in words, but an apprentice can learn
- 6:02by doing, by watching, by feeling it out. It
- 6:05can be taught. But Abraham's faith, there's no
- 6:08apprenticeship program for that. It's a path
- 6:10that can't be taught or followed. It's one you
- 6:12have to walk utterly alone. And if we needed
- 6:15one final clue. Kierkegaard himself published
- 6:18this book under a pseudonym, Johannes de Silencio,
- 6:21which literally means John of Silence. It's almost
- 6:25like he was leaving us a little wink, a hint
- 6:27that the most important lesson in the book is
- 6:29the one that could never be written down. And
- 6:32so this leaves us with a really tough final question
- 6:34to think about. If wisdom is something that can
- 6:36be shared and learned by others, but this kind
- 6:38of faith is absolutely singular and cannot be
- 6:41communicated, do we ultimately have to choose
- 6:43one over the other? This whole analysis is based
- 6:46on a really fantastic article by Alexei Prozheshin
- 6:49in the journal Sophia. If you want to go deeper
- 6:52down this rabbit hole, we absolutely recommend
- 6:54you check it out. Thanks for joining us.