Latest / A Hamster With a Blunt Penknife - a Doctor Who Commentary podcast / Hamster Book Club - The Plotters by Gareth Roberts (featuring Anthony Carroll)
Transcript
- 0:00Vicky turned for a closer look at the young man.
- 0:03Not long ago he must have been a ravishing beauty.
- 0:07Now he had an incipient beard, and his cheeks and nose were
- 0:10dotted with premature liver spots.
- 0:13His manner was preening and unpleasant, and he took a
- 0:16deliberate and evident pleasure in the King's company.
- 0:21I don't like the look of him. What's his job, then?
- 0:25The doctor looked uncomfortable. Well, I don't think he has an
- 0:32official position. Vicky twigged.
- 0:35But the King's married, isn't he?
- 0:40In a level 2 society that can count for very little.
- 0:43The doctor seemed rather flustered and embarrassed and
- 0:46quickly changed the subject. My point is, you shouldn't
- 0:49expect perfection from the privileged.
- 0:52He caught the King's eye and raised a goblet with a smile
- 0:54that was out of place on his normally stern features.
- 0:57Do as I do, child. He muttered to Vicky.
- 1:00She lifted her own goblet and smiled at the king.
- 1:03Hello down there. The king called.
- 1:07Hello up there. Vicky called back, realizing as
- 1:10she did that she had committed a terrible error.
- 1:13The yard fell suddenly silent. The doctor took a sharp intake
- 1:17of breath. The king fixed Vicky with a
- 1:20penetrating stare, and he seemed to lose all of his silliness
- 1:24after a moment. The Doctor stammered.
- 1:27Ah, your Majesty, I must apologise for my young ward.
- 1:30He is unused to your Exalted. The King waved A forgiving hand.
- 1:36Not at all, not at all. He peered at the Doctor, then
- 1:40turned his gaze again on Vicky. His eyes travelled up and down
- 1:45the length of her body. She had an uncomfortable feeling
- 1:48that he was mentally undressing her.
- 1:50You would be the Doctor of Divinity out of York, he said at
- 1:55length. Yes, your Majesty, this is my
- 1:59ward, Victor, a comely lad, the King said, stretching out each
- 2:04syllable suggestively. Fair of hair, and with such
- 2:08splendidly plump and rosy cheeks.
- 2:11A model of health, and with a lively wist about him.
- 2:14Hello up there. Indeed.
- 2:18The Yard echoed the King's appreciation with an automatic
- 2:21and artificial ripple of laughter.
- 2:24Vicky felt she ought to say something.
- 2:26Thank you, she said. The doctor nudged her in the
- 2:29ribs. Your Majesty, she added quickly.
- 2:33The King lured Victor. You would like to play me at
- 2:36Loggarts tomorrow. Vicky felt the situation is
- 2:40slipping away from her. Well, well, of course I'd love
- 2:42to. I mean, that would be nice, but
- 2:45well, I have to help the Doctor win in his researches.
- 2:48Oh, the doctor said loudly. How devoted the Boyers to me, of
- 2:53course. Yes, I should be glad to place
- 2:56him in your care, Your Majesty. A few hours of playful Loggetts
- 2:59will do him the power of good after our long journey.
- 3:04Indeed, Haberton Loggetts are good for youthful soul.
- 3:09There was another mumble of agreement.
- 3:12In spite of her misgivings, Vicky noticed that Cecil did not
- 3:14join in this time. She recalled the chamberlain's
- 3:17early words of warning. As if on cue, Cecil pushed his
- 3:21chair with a scrape and got to his feet.
- 3:24Your Majesty, He said with an undisguised glass of contempt of
- 3:28Vicky that throws her blood. I would respectfully remind you
- 3:32that your commitments to the state of such that further time
- 3:35away cannot be spared. He blinked rapidly, as if
- 3:39forcing down a wave of anger. We have yet to discuss the
- 3:43speech. You will not raise your voice in
- 3:46this chamber again, Cecil, James said pettishly.
- 3:50Remember, I am king. And who appointed me so?
- 3:55Almighty God, he said sullenly. Did he remember the doctor's
- 3:59earlier words of how Cecil would work to bring James to the
- 4:02English throne and could understand his bitterness?
- 4:05Exactly. And by divine Providence, you
- 4:08are at my side. He struck a fist down at the
- 4:11table. If the Lord wants me to dance, I
- 4:14shall dance. If he directs me to play.
- 4:16Loggets, loggets, I shall play. I listen to him before you do.
- 4:22You presume to exalt yourself about the highest.
- 4:26Cecil took a rolled up scroll from the fold in his robes.
- 4:30I act as I have always done, out of my love for you and this
- 4:34nation. The Catholics of the Catholics,
- 4:37nothing. James said fiercely.
- 4:39Vicky was impressed by his sudden gravity.
- 4:43She cast a sideway glance at the doctor and found him following
- 4:45the exchange keenly, his eyes darting between the two men as
- 4:49if he were following a tennis match.
- 4:52Cecil, my tactics I have made plain, and my successes are
- 4:56palpable. We have peace with the Spanish,
- 4:59peace with the French, peace with the Dutch, and peace in the
- 5:02country. Let there be no return to
- 5:05burning and persecutions. These bring forth only martyrs,
- 5:10and thus further disharmony. Moderation is the key to good
- 5:14politics. You will hear that in my speech
- 5:17on the night of the 5th, which you will have in your hand, and
- 5:20of which you will not alter one word.
- 5:24You hear, Cecil, not a letter. Will I suffer to be altered?
- 5:28There was a long silence. The two men held each other's
- 5:31gaze. Finally Cecil said.
- 5:34And while you played Loggarts, James, what if the papers should
- 5:37be plotting some disruption at this most vital and vulnerable
- 5:41time of our calendar? James rolled his eyes.
- 5:45You are the greatest disruptor, Cecil.
- 5:47I tell you, if anyone Catholic, Puritan, or even one of my
- 5:51closest advisors. He emphasized the warning.
- 5:55Whoever tries to interrupt this Parliament's opening, there'll
- 5:58be fireworks. I should advise such a person to
- 6:02back down and trust in my divine right.
- 6:06Any other course might be regarded as blasphemy.
- 6:09Cecil nodded and sat down. The court returned to its food
- 6:13in embarrassed silence. There was something in the quiet
- 6:16and atmosphere that reminded Vicky of children.
- 6:18After a particularly stern ticking off, she found she was
- 6:22missing democracy for all its contradictions.
- 6:26The doctor was muttering something under his breath.
- 6:28It was an especially irritating habit.
- 6:31She listened closely. Fireworks, he was saying.
- 6:36Fireworks indeed. If only he knew.
- 6:39What are you mumbling about, Doctor?
- 6:41Oh, nothing, my child, nothing. He looked up and she saw that
- 6:45his eyes were wettening with stifled laughter.
- 6:48His face reddened as he forced his reaction down.
- 6:51Oh dear, yes, yes, yes, fireworks.
- 6:57Vicki returned her attention to the meal and tried to ignore a
- 7:00worry that nagged at her like an aching tooth.
- 7:03Was the doctor still holding something back?
- 7:09Right, Anthony? Quick, get up that passage.
- 7:12Right. We're we're underneath
- 7:14Parliament right now. Yeah.
- 7:16Did you bring the stuff? I've got my stuff in my back.
- 7:19Let's go through the passage. Get it out.
- 7:21Get your stuff out now I'll. Get my stuff out in this back
- 7:24passage. I've got some here that'll say
- 7:27it off a tree. Do you know why are we doing
- 7:31this? Again, why are we doing this?
- 7:33As if it was less on the nose when some of this stuff and
- 7:36applause. No, I'm still acting.
- 7:39What are you talking about? I mean, why are we underneath
- 7:41Parliament right now politically?
- 7:44Why are we doing this? Wait, there's, there's, there's
- 7:47a lot of good. I've got reasons.
- 7:49I think these days that, you know, everyone's had enough.
- 7:52I've had enough. I realise.
- 7:56That information means reformation.
- 7:58I've just invited a politician onto my podcast and suggested a
- 8:01very bad thing. Welcome back to a hamster with a
- 8:05no. It's what we call the Hamster
- 8:06Book Club. Hamster big club.
- 8:07Thank you so much. I don't know where we are these
- 8:10days. Anthony, how are you today?
- 8:13Thanks, I will be OK as long as I don't get prescribed after
- 8:15this introduction to the podcast from the government.
- 8:18But it's. Been nice knowing you.
- 8:20All right, OK. I'll see you in 30 years.
- 8:24I think you've got a very impressive stick of dynamite
- 8:26there. You're brandishing.
- 8:30Yes, the little little stick of Brighton rock that will get us
- 8:33through this this book. Stick of Brighton rock, is that
- 8:37it? Oh, bless you.
- 8:40What we're here to talk about today, I mean, we've not dropped
- 8:42any clues at all. Why we are here to talk about
- 8:46the Plotters by David Agnew. David Agnew, much celebrated
- 8:52author. Yes.
- 8:53Well, actually, let's be honest. In the day, Yes, a much
- 8:57celebrated author. Yes.
- 9:00It's just while we're doing politics, you know, In current
- 9:04days, perhaps less so. Yes, perhaps not someone we
- 9:09would want to be seen returning any day soon in this time.
- 9:12Not to put you in the more of an awkward spot than I already
- 9:15have, you know, sort of coming on to you and getting you to
- 9:19perform terrorism in the 1st 5 minutes of this recording.
- 9:21But how did you sort of approach Agnew in the higher science that
- 9:25you recently did on your fabulous podcast?
- 9:28Too broad and too deep. Say we're still rude.
- 9:32Yeah, so when we covered Higher Science by Agnew, I wasn't as
- 9:37smart as you is who had used the pseudonyms.
- 9:40I I just put a cloister bill anytime we forgot to say to not
- 9:45say just the offer or whatever but that's AI think a more
- 9:50professional ways to give actual name in the situation.
- 9:53I'm not professional, Anthony. No, you are more professional
- 9:56than I was by and much more easier than the edit than I was
- 9:59by needing to. Unless it was a quite an issue
- 10:02trying to add cloister bills every 10 seconds.
- 10:04But. I'm going to get this over and
- 10:06done with in 30 seconds. Are you ready?
- 10:09I recently put out an episode on The English Way of Death with
- 10:12the glorious Kieran Powell, where we discussed at length the
- 10:17politically, morally, socially tricky situation of talking
- 10:23about Mr. Agnew's books and came to the conclusion that we will
- 10:26cover them, but we will separate our from artists.
- 10:30How's that? Yeah, that, that does it.
- 10:34A bit tricky in a book where there's plenty of sort of gender
- 10:36bending and yeah. This is this is the thing that
- 10:41keeps occurring in in his books. It's the same when we're doing
- 10:44the highest science, when we're are.
- 10:46They I'm aphrodisiac. Yeah.
- 10:50So like, well, I think so, yeah, that like they, they use
- 10:54masculine gendered terms, but when it comes to that, it's also
- 10:58their mothers and such. So there's like the hybrid mix
- 11:01of different kind of gender terms and it's the same in this
- 11:05because we all it's just it's bizarre sort of cutting thing.
- 11:10My mum was obsessed with people changing sex.
- 11:13Well, can I very quickly, I'm always going to do this.
- 11:20I told you. Is this sort of catch up with
- 11:22you on being too broad and too deep for the small screen and
- 11:27ask you sort of where your journey is So fun.
- 11:29I know you've you've been down the pit and survived.
- 11:33Yeah, we went a bit too broad, a bit too deep down, a bit of of
- 11:37pain. Everyone going this is life.
- 11:44Genuinely, it was a bit of a struggle getting through that
- 11:47one because is a it deserves its reputation.
- 11:53I mean, I think there won't be many who will disagree with
- 11:56that. I think there will be probably
- 11:58only one person who disagrees with that, at least in the
- 12:00comments we got. Did you?
- 12:01Know that it was like, yeah, you know, I sort of started this and
- 12:04it was all right, bloody hell, what's happened?
- 12:06Like Jesus Christ. Or was that you?
- 12:09No, that was you. No, yeah, I was on this podcast,
- 12:12the last episode we talked about Dalek, and I was enjoying it
- 12:14because it was a simple world setting and when it just kept
- 12:18doing that. And like, the big thing about
- 12:22the book is that, you know, it's essentially a plot, like a
- 12:24script from what could have been the season 27.
- 12:29And yeah, well, it could be a really simple Terry Nation style
- 12:34script if it did happen. But it could have happened.
- 12:38But on top of that, the writer decided to try and just have
- 12:42other sort of nepless plots that have no connection to the
- 12:46storyline, had no connection to the doctor and Benny.
- 12:50And at the same time, Ben had to try and cut the novel near the
- 12:54end by 25,000 words and didn't cut these sort of additional
- 13:00things that and bring it down just to what the script was.
- 13:03It tried to do the best of both worlds and end up being the
- 13:06worst. So yeah, it was quite, quite
- 13:10expedient getting through and digging ourselves through that
- 13:13part. Another thing I asked you last
- 13:15time was, you know, whether you're leaving that book lying
- 13:17around with that Lady with the blue tits on the cover.
- 13:19Did she feature a lot in the book?
- 13:21Was she? No.
- 13:22And she's she's she's much more, you know, boisterous as I could
- 13:28say on the cover than she is within the book.
- 13:31Because they're all meant to be some sort of pre Gallif, pre
- 13:35Time Lord Gallifrey and leopards, like leopards that are
- 13:40like, meant to have like arms missing and be all disease and
- 13:44things like this. But you can't, you can't have a,
- 13:46a boisterously bosomed woman on the front cover be all limbs
- 13:52missing and all of that. So they took some liberties, I
- 13:55think, on the car. You know, there's that sort of
- 13:57theory, you know, the the Doctor was there back in the olden days
- 14:01of Gallifrey, you know, in the ancient times with Omega and
- 14:04Raslod and all that. I mean, if these blue women were
- 14:07going around with their boobs out all the time, you've got to
- 14:09wonder why he ever decided to leave.
- 14:11You know, he would have stuck around and got, actually, it's
- 14:13pretty all right around here. Exactly.
- 14:15And you don't need to worry about anything.
- 14:17You've got limbs near limbs nearby if you ever do want to
- 14:19have any any offspring. Anthony, I'm really sorry.
- 14:23I feel like on your own podcast you just talk about intellectual
- 14:26things. Then I'll bring you on ear and
- 14:27it's just all smart. So.
- 14:29Sorry. Well, you.
- 14:30Chose a good book for smart, I think.
- 14:32Let's move. Away from smart and talk about
- 14:34the plotters say, which is as end of the pair smarty as you're
- 14:39going to get in a Doctor Who book.
- 14:41Well, overall, how did you find it?
- 14:44Did you enjoy it? Oh, it was.
- 14:46A breeze and I absolutely enjoyed reading this one,
- 14:49especially from what I just had gone through with the Pet.
- 14:53This was such a quick read because it just flowed better,
- 14:57flowed so naturally. It's very much delivered on what
- 15:02the style of the show of the timer was as well.
- 15:04And I was, I think one of the biggest benefits across these
- 15:09ranges of books that David Agnew does as he can really kind of
- 15:13capture that period of whatever doctor he's he's doing.
- 15:17And yeah, it really works for doing a sort of Season 2 style
- 15:20story. Oddly, I think the only place
- 15:23where he falters is when he tries to write a new adventure
- 15:26when he's trying to do like what's happening now rather than
- 15:30what's what's happened in the past because hi sites, I know
- 15:34you guys had a bit of a mixed reaction to.
- 15:35And then he does two more going ahead, and those aren't
- 15:39considered great successes. And yeah, he's missing
- 15:42Adventures, the three Season 17 ones.
- 15:44And the plotters are held in huge regard.
- 15:47Like one of the joys of the missing adventures, I think one
- 15:52of the things they have to make them more enjoyable than the New
- 15:56Avengers sometimes, is that the New Avengers can push the Doctor
- 16:00aside and the companions aside sometimes in order to tell big,
- 16:04ambitious stories. Whereas Missing Adventures
- 16:07really gets you close to the regulars that they choose and
- 16:11you have a lot of time with them.
- 16:13And this book had a lot of time with the First Doctor, Vicki,
- 16:17Ian and Barbara. I don't think there's really
- 16:19many scenes where one of them doesn't feature.
- 16:22Am I wrong? No, you're right.
- 16:24Because, you know, in that vein, the New Adventures is kind of
- 16:29like the Wild West at that time. They can plot, as it were,
- 16:31whatever journey they want. They can go to any direction of
- 16:34storytelling and to varying degrees they try that.
- 16:40But when it comes to the missing adventures, it's like a sort of
- 16:42like, you know, comfort blanket almost.
- 16:46I'm not an end of dog. She would be.
- 16:47I mean, I mean, like, if if that's going a bit too wild for
- 16:50you, you've got something that you can know and trust from the
- 16:55old show and it's done in that style so that you can rely on it
- 17:00to still be not too, too wild, too broad or too deep.
- 17:04Because it's it's meant to be in the context of the show that you
- 17:08used to watch at the time. So it's a definite way of
- 17:12storytelling. That then means that you need to
- 17:14have the Doctor or the Companions more than it as well.
- 17:17Well, here's a question for you then, because I feel like when
- 17:21the missing Avengers came out, this was the first of this sort
- 17:23of thing that we'd ever done, right?
- 17:25Is is look back to the past and have a nostalgia hit like this
- 17:30beyond maybe some of the comic strips that sort of lean towards
- 17:34the past? A couple of Times Now in 2025,
- 17:37we have had 30-40 years of books, comics, I mean, 100
- 17:45million Big Finish audios. You know, we are in nostalgia
- 17:49City now. No, not city empire.
- 17:51No, let's go bigger universe. We're in nostalgia universe.
- 17:54So do these things still hit in the same way now in the wake of
- 17:58that massive wave? It depends when you're a fan and
- 18:03and who is it actually for in the end?
- 18:05Like at the time in the 90s when these these were being
- 18:08published. Yeah, fans probably more so for
- 18:12like the the Baker ones and the Pearly ones maybe to an extent
- 18:15as well, is where the big hitters would have been for
- 18:18nostalgia and would have been a good time for these.
- 18:20And that's why you've got ones that David Agu did, which people
- 18:24really kind of rave about these days.
- 18:28It's interesting where that that nostalgia is hitting now because
- 18:32it's the folk who are nostalgic, you know, for, for for Hartnell
- 18:37sort of style stories in the day and age of 2025 who are like, my
- 18:42age would probably just be me and Josh Snails and no one.
- 18:45Else I was going to say, it's old fossils like me and very few
- 18:51young pups like you. Yeah.
- 18:52Exactly like there's very like it's not the market that you you
- 18:56see that the styled before. It's it's it's the things that
- 19:00you see with the the echoes in box sets and that, you know, the
- 19:04the attention that the new one with the 9th Doctor and Rose is
- 19:07getting, for example, because that's nostalgic to us.
- 19:11In the same way that's the same amount of time, like 20 odd
- 19:13years from this book getting published for the plotters was
- 19:18the 70s. And so people would have had
- 19:21that nostalgia for those like Tom Baker style books at the
- 19:25time. So yeah, it's it, it has to kind
- 19:30of move with the times to be able to not wobble in the same
- 19:35nostalgia because that same nostalgia isn't what you've
- 19:40been, you know, like that, not just like at the time, but like
- 19:43new generations have came that have liked things that you found
- 19:46too new to broad or whatever. And actually get, I mean, a good
- 19:51example actually was my first virgin new adventure I actually
- 19:56want to think was maybe Bullet Time, the past doctor adventure
- 20:04from David Mckinty. Yeah.
- 20:06Because because I've read it and I was like, what the hell is
- 20:08this? Like, why is he killing or Sarah
- 20:11Jane? Yeah, exactly.
- 20:13But I always think of it as a if as a sort of like nugget in my
- 20:18brain that I feel slightly nostalgic for.
- 20:21Even though, Oh yeah, that book in itself almost was like a
- 20:25twang of nostalgia for something that had only just happened
- 20:28recently in a lot of ways. So it it it changes generally
- 20:32relationally. Like if the pluses came out
- 20:34today, I I don't know who it would be for.
- 20:39Yeah, I mean like. Obviously they didn't choose
- 20:41this one when the 50th anniversary books came out and
- 20:44they republished a lot of Missing and New and a couple of
- 20:49EDA's. But they did publish English Way
- 20:52of Death again, which I actually think was a lot weaker than
- 20:57this. And we'll talk about that as we
- 20:59go in. Yeah.
- 21:01Do you mind? You know, I think there's a
- 21:02YouTube series, you know, in the making.
- 21:05We could call it Carol and Snares, Nostalgia Twinks.
- 21:09What do you think? You 2 can read all the 1st
- 21:13Doctor Mystic adventures and PDAs and review them together.
- 21:18Oh, that would. Be lovely, George.
- 21:19If you I would, I would. I would like that.
- 21:22I don't know. If you're going to disagree, all
- 21:25right, I expect oil to be used. All right.
- 21:27That's all. Sorry.
- 21:32So the Plotters by David Agnew, yes.
- 21:35How? Do you think, how do you think
- 21:39Mr. Agnew captured our regulars then?
- 21:45This is this is the thing that I I might be like hot taking on is
- 21:50is great, like the the characterisations as a whole is,
- 21:54is really nice and and you know, plays to to a tee.
- 21:58A lot of you know, season 2 style characterisation, but it's
- 22:03sometimes gets a bit too smug. Not smug, but a bit to knowing a
- 22:09bit to knowing that this is the show that you like and the
- 22:12character then saying things that you would think, but that's
- 22:18not what they're meant to be saying.
- 22:19It's it's what you would be thinking in response to what
- 22:21their situation is, rather than. Surprising you with their
- 22:24reactions. It's exactly what you would
- 22:27expect, yeah. Like there was an example where
- 22:30I think it was Ian was like there was a situation with Ian
- 22:37and I think he says something like, well, there's no way to
- 22:41deal with like the TARDIS now because of it was it was quite
- 22:45thoughtful wall breaking in the scene.
- 22:48I'm trying to remember what it was now.
- 22:50It was I think it was like, oh, yeah, here it is.
- 22:54Like a familiar sinking sensation way down on them.
- 22:57I hardly think I'm going to faint with surprise this time.
- 23:01And it just felt like like, yeah, there's some of these like
- 23:054th wall breaking things because were they that?
- 23:07Knowing in season 2, I mean, maybe in the Romans.
- 23:13No, even. I don't even.
- 23:14Think in the Romans they were they were that's referential
- 23:17about the the plot points that would happen within the stories
- 23:23because no one was it was still even at that time that was a it
- 23:28was still doing until probably like mid season 4.
- 23:32It was a show that was always experimenting.
- 23:34So it was hard. You'd be impossible to kind of
- 23:36pinpoint contrivances and repeated when it's.
- 23:40That too, you know, like you don't have tropes in your second
- 23:43year or you do. You've got an old pretty
- 23:46quickly. Exactly.
- 23:47So it felt like those sort of points have been like, oh,
- 23:50they're going to do that. Well, not again.
- 23:52It felt a bit for the fans, a bit self referential and a bit
- 23:58too indulgent. I mean, I could.
- 24:00Probably make the argument this is for the fans, but well,
- 24:03sometimes I don't think you give the fans what they want.
- 24:05I think you should surprise the fans.
- 24:07Like one of my big criticisms of the English word death was it
- 24:10captured season 17 to AT to an absolute T Yeah, it could have
- 24:15been broadcast in season 17. There were no surprises.
- 24:19And and and it was a lot of sort of recycled plot points and
- 24:22ideas. And I was like, yes, yeah.
- 24:25So Oh my God, if I want to wallow in the nostalgia of
- 24:27season 17, absolutely perfect. But like, and I would throw some
- 24:33of that criticism at the plotters as well, because you've
- 24:36got like Barbara and Ian in a Tavern, very the reign of
- 24:40terror, you know, the doctor and Vicky sneaking off like a pair
- 24:43of kids to go and meet somebody famous like Nero in the Romans.
- 24:48You know, the discussion about not interfering with history and
- 24:51then interfering with history and then going, Oh, well, you
- 24:54know, I'm sure the timeline will sort itself out and all that.
- 24:58So it's ticking all the boxes, but it's not breaking outside
- 25:02the box. No, it's, it's very much, yeah.
- 25:06Like you see a mismatch of different ideas from from
- 25:10different historicals. Yeah.
- 25:12Like, yeah, like you see with like Vicky dressing up as a boy
- 25:15or even the idea of having Catholic and Protestant
- 25:19discourse in in a courtroom of of, you know, royalty.
- 25:23Like the massacre. It's, you know, that there's
- 25:26ideas and themes that kind of bun are bundled into this in a
- 25:29lot of ways. And King.
- 25:31James, like for all, I think he's astoundingly good in this
- 25:35book. Like so funny and and like we
- 25:38will get on to how funny. Oh.
- 25:40Yes, because it is. Hilarious in places.
- 25:43He's basically Nero, isn't he? A bawdy sort of political hot
- 25:49head. Yeah, he's he's very much.
- 25:53I'm trying to, I've been trying to think what other characters
- 25:55he's been like apart from it, because he does have the comedic
- 25:58elements of, of of Nero. But it's it's been impossible
- 26:03really to to try and ground him in any of our sort of 60s
- 26:05characters because I just kept reading a lot of his lines like
- 26:10Alan coming and. You can't help it like they're.
- 26:15So, so virtually said. And he's, yeah, like undertoning
- 26:21like with like homosexuality throughout.
- 26:23It's, it's very much in that tone that you can read and
- 26:28imagine Alan Cumming to see. Oh, come on.
- 26:30And say you can't throw me a bone like that and then not give
- 26:33me something in the style of Alan Cumming.
- 26:37Well, this is. So Alan, because Alan Cumming,
- 26:38he does end the which things, he's got a very Kelvin side, a
- 26:41very West End Glasgow accent that's very quite, you know,
- 26:46something like from the plane of Mystream Brody or something.
- 26:49But my favorite was it's page 105 for anyone listening, and
- 26:54it's the scene which tries to do the Romans when Vicky's getting
- 26:57chased around by King James. We will say, like the Romans,
- 27:02it's both hilarious and hugely problematic.
- 27:05OK. Oh God, yeah, absolutely.
- 27:07It is absolutely a bit Co tailing at moments, but some of
- 27:13it is. It's just wonderful.
- 27:17Let's see what we've got. Even just looking at it, it's
- 27:22just. Thank you.
- 27:26We'll let you know. A win a winter apple, whereas
- 27:31you, dear Victor, smooth of cheek, are a Peach and springs
- 27:37initial bloom. Won't you stay stay still for me
- 27:40Peach. Remember fair fruits that are
- 27:44eaten in their prime while rot and weather off the vine.
- 27:50And he's just like, I'm afraid I don't fancy being peeled.
- 27:53I was about to propose to after that, you know, Jesus Christ,
- 27:57yes, I mean I kept hearing coming as well.
- 27:59I mean you can't help it, can you?
- 28:01After The weird thing is I've just done the Witch Finders
- 28:03literally 2 weeks ago. So I've read the Witch Finders
- 28:07and I read this. I was like, are they in
- 28:09simpatico? The cabinet is definitely there
- 28:12in both. I think he's he airs on the side
- 28:15of being a bit more serious in the Witch Finders than he does
- 28:18in this, but like after those. First initial scenes in the
- 28:21Witch finders. He is a genuine threat in terms
- 28:25of like his his ideas about things like witch finding which
- 28:30doesn't really happen here. He's very lazy.
- 28:32Fell in a lot of this book I did.
- 28:34Though to the books credit, the plotters that is, I did get more
- 28:38of a sense of his political worth in this.
- 28:41There's several, several scenes where they basically say, no, he
- 28:46came, he brought a lot of stability.
- 28:48He brought people together, united, you know, and that he
- 28:51did a lot of good as well as being a a total Lech around the
- 28:56court. God bless him.
- 28:59I mean, yeah, because on top of him having a lot of court
- 29:03intrigue regarding like, the Protestant Catholics, he's also
- 29:07got the speed demon twink on his lap for a lot of this book.
- 29:11Is it? Hay, you refer to Anthony, he.
- 29:14Yes, yeah, a man of. Many places.
- 29:22I mean, we're all over the place here, but let's just go with it.
- 29:25I mean, hay, right? I absolutely remembered the Hay
- 29:31and the Spaniards were one of the same.
- 29:34Right? But I totally forgotten that a
- 29:36Hay and Sybil the buxom bar wench were one of the same.
- 29:42And I'm in my notes going, oh Sybil was such a great
- 29:45character, so funny. And then when he revealed I felt
- 29:48cheated. I was like, no, I thought she
- 29:50was a real person. I know I genuinely like I was
- 29:54expecting the Spaniard twist to be honest.
- 29:56I think just because it's there wasn't many other characters, it
- 29:59could really kind of point towards Sybil was just like, are
- 30:03we auditioned towards all of that?
- 30:04And I was like, oh, I mean, sure, let's just have a full on
- 30:08again with the the sort of like like gender roles gain being a
- 30:16big mix up within this book as well.
- 30:20It's it's something I wasn't quite expecting to be part of
- 30:23the plot twists within this but and her.
- 30:25Dialogue and today I mean listen to this.
- 30:28I was up with the cock by my through she goes at one point.
- 30:34What what's the one she has as well when she she's she's first
- 30:37meeting Barbara and Ian and kind of they've offered to get some
- 30:43some food and drink from there and Oh yes, that's the so she
- 30:50says to Ian, I don't know why I'm going to give her a Cornish
- 30:53accent. She feels like she should have a
- 30:54Cornish accent or something like that.
- 30:56Do it. Shall I fill you up again, Sir?
- 31:00It will give him the vim to dance.
- 31:01The shaking of the streets right proper tonight.
- 31:05I didn't do. There's more cockney there, but
- 31:07there's like shaking of the of the sheets and all of this sort
- 31:10of stuff that just keeps coming acting.
- 31:14Lessons. You know, you could really tell
- 31:19from my lack of back sense that I can provide, like I can even
- 31:23provide proper Scottish ones like that one that I did for
- 31:26King James, the shape I was. Going to get in touch with them
- 31:29and get you a refund. Don't worry.
- 31:35And as, as we said off my right, there is there is a a good
- 31:40handful as well as the regulars. And we will we'll we'll sort of
- 31:43deal with the regulars or the jokes around them as we go
- 31:47along. But there's, you know, Ian falls
- 31:49in with a pair of Cobblers and that isn't a joke.
- 31:52They genuinely are a pair of Cobblers and obviously simple
- 31:58helps him out as well. Barbara falls in with Guy
- 32:00Fawkes. The doctor is having many an
- 32:05argument with the two historians that are rewriting the King
- 32:09James Bible. Yeah.
- 32:11Otley and Howarden it was. Great.
- 32:16Oh boy. And obviously Vicky is sort of
- 32:19in and out with the King and the Chamberlain.
- 32:22So there's, there's loads happening here, isn't there?
- 32:25Like, I don't think there's any time to get bored.
- 32:28No, and, and the great thing is that is that you can imagine
- 32:30these characters within the context of like a season 2
- 32:33story, like like the Chamberlain, for example, you
- 32:37can imagine I'm huffing around and being a bit out of breath
- 32:39and you can't. The Chamberlain.
- 32:42Did I, oh, do what? That's a good, that is a good
- 32:45point. I should I should have cast
- 32:47them. I did.
- 32:48Know the fellow from the crusade who goes a boy dressed as a
- 32:52girl. What's the world coming to?
- 32:54I just saw him. The the one who's the the
- 32:58Chamberlain within the Crusades, That's the one.
- 33:01Yes, it's another cliche of the era.
- 33:05Well, I was thinking about, you see the guy who's who sells
- 33:10them, who's trying to flog the wires and says the doctor and
- 33:14Vicky have stolen them. Oh yes.
- 33:17Silks, satin, satin. 'S wonderful silks Batman.
- 33:22I was imagining him kind of, you know, being so like out of
- 33:27breath and like, flustered because he's very faster than
- 33:31that. Is he the one that?
- 33:32Says I'll dress up Vicky like a veritable strutting Peacock,
- 33:36that one. That's, that's the Chamberlain
- 33:38within the crusade, I think. Oh yeah.
- 33:40Oh, the dialogue's so great. In that story, isn't it?
- 33:43But he's vaping that as well here, right?
- 33:45The the richness of the dialogue.
- 33:48Oh yeah. I mean, it, it tries to do in in
- 33:51the similar vein of like, yeah, where the crusade tries to to be
- 33:56of that, of that time. There's a lot of that within how
- 34:00in in in particular, like Lord Salisbury and like Cecil and his
- 34:06languages being the more statesman figure the the kind of
- 34:11the the the comedic St. almost to a lot of the sort of folly
- 34:15that happens around in this story because he's there to try
- 34:19and drive his political idea. Why was it King James's last
- 34:23thing after Victor and such? We try.
- 34:26Hard as I might though, I can't imagine this line in the
- 34:29Crusade. I pray for a monarch that can
- 34:32ignore the pulse things of their groin.
- 34:39I mean, this is a Carry On movie, right?
- 34:41Isn't it at? One point, there's a line that
- 34:44says it's, you know, I think it says Carry on performing or
- 34:48something like that. But it's it's always like
- 34:49capitalized in the same way that they would do say in a Carry On
- 34:53movie where they say the title of the of the film with Carry
- 34:56on, whatever. And I was like, that's the Carry
- 34:58On title for this book. Chapter 7 and I don't want you
- 35:01to get excited when I say this. Chapter 7 is called Intrigue
- 35:05down below. I mean, that's a carry on title
- 35:08if ever I've heard one. Exactly.
- 35:11Like there's, there's a lot of of that sort of leadiness
- 35:16throughout the book from us, so many characters.
- 35:19Yeah. And see, I don't really like
- 35:21that sort of thing, you know, I try, not always.
- 35:24You have a straight edge, straight edge, serious drama
- 35:27this is that's what you want to me having.
- 35:29This conversation with you today, so thank you for, you
- 35:32know, guiding me through it exactly.
- 35:34I mean, you don't want scenes where the serious head of state
- 35:38is meant to be having very serious dialogue, but instead
- 35:42you you end up with things such as how now, Ganymede, you can't
- 35:47know if you don't like a thing until you've tried it.
- 35:51Dip a little toe in the water and you know, who knows, you
- 35:55might soon be swimming like a duck.
- 36:02Do you know what? I was taking tips when I was
- 36:03reading this? No, I'll never use that one.
- 36:08Jesus Christ. Yeah.
- 36:10Yes. Wow, yes, that's hell of a I
- 36:13think it's things. You can only get way when you're
- 36:14a monarch rather than trying to use it on the streets like
- 36:18sorry. I mean, I'm sorry to divert you
- 36:19away from the book for a second. What's like the worst, come on,
- 36:22you've ever tried with somebody? Do you know what I was?
- 36:25And I can't believe I'm going to admit this to you on camera.
- 36:28That is, I said to the person, my God, I think it was a coat.
- 36:35I thought I'd heard it in a movie and I thought, I'm just
- 36:37going to try it. I went.
- 36:38That coat looks very becoming on you.
- 36:40Why don't you take it off and put me on and then I'll be
- 36:44coming. Needless to say, we did not go
- 36:50home together. Oh, come on.
- 36:52What's yours? What's your worst?
- 36:55Wolf. One chance.
- 36:58We'll get a chance to do it in a book club episode, you know,
- 37:01true. I'm not a naturally flirtatious
- 37:04person. I've been trying to think of you
- 37:05could have. Fooled me, Jesus Christ.
- 37:10I know with that lustrous readings of King James, maybe
- 37:13that's what I should do. Maybe I'll just I'll go around
- 37:16different clubs and just read different pieces of dialogue
- 37:18from King James. Whatever you do, see what you
- 37:21got to anyone and call. Them a Nubian Prince, all right.
- 37:23Please don't do that, whatever you do.
- 37:27Oh boy. Or.
- 37:28Or, or just dismiss their wee lassie that's sitting beside
- 37:32them so that I could sneak in. Yeah.
- 37:35Get rid of a white Well, it depends actually, with today
- 37:37you're fancying boys or girls, but you can say like you know,
- 37:40you ladies with your innate gossip, please go and gossip
- 37:43over there. I'm talking to this gentleman.
- 37:45Or vice versa. Where was your heart with this
- 37:48book then? Was your heart more with the
- 37:50Doctor and Vicky in the court of King James?
- 37:53Was it with Barbara and Guy Fawkes, you know, in the
- 37:56political machinations, or Ian and the fabulous Cobblers, the
- 38:00two heroes of the book, sort of trying to bring down all the
- 38:05plot and say Barbara? Oh, I was probably there more
- 38:08with like the Doctor and Vicky just because like, yeah, with
- 38:11dialogue like that, whenever King James wasn't in that
- 38:14chapter, I was asking where is King James?
- 38:17I want, I want to know what he's going to be saying next in a lot
- 38:21of this book. But it was also because that's
- 38:24where a lot of the layers of drama was as well, because like
- 38:27the actually the doctor is just a a very big nosy gossip as well
- 38:33and would have joined the wee lassies for the gossip because
- 38:36that's really what the first talk is to like about in a lot
- 38:39of ways for the historical adventures.
- 38:42And it got perfect. Didn't he?
- 38:43That the fact that he is just like, a naughty school kid?
- 38:46Yeah. And it's like, you know, it's
- 38:47all bluster and like, you know, how dare you?
- 38:49And then the second they're away, he's like, OK, let's go.
- 38:53Yeah, exactly. Like he gets away with so much
- 38:56in this and it shows that as much as he's physically the much
- 39:02older doctor, he just uses that as a as a facade.
- 39:05And really it's just such a childish we guy just wanting to
- 39:08get into different places, hear what the gossip is and kind of
- 39:12bluster his way through and seeing that side of the doctor
- 39:16it, it was just really, you can imagine Hartnell loving it
- 39:20because because I watched the Romans last week just to get a
- 39:23flavor. And I think it's genuinely his
- 39:25best performance. He's having the.
- 39:27Best time. He's loving it.
- 39:29He just the small quirks of almost like someone talks about
- 39:33how Trouting is a physical actor in a lot of ways.
- 39:37How no in the Romans is one of the is the best physical comedic
- 39:42performances of the Doctor going from you know, him fighting with
- 39:46the the guy without a talk. Oh, you want?
- 39:49To fight, do you? To all this thing of him kind of
- 39:53fumbling a sword in a sauna, did you ever?
- 39:56Expect to see the 1st doctor in a gay sauna like that.
- 40:01I know it was and I don't. I think that's the first.
- 40:04It's one of the few times we've seen the Doctor half naked in
- 40:08some form, and this heart know that we see at first.
- 40:12Chicken chest. Although didn't you love his
- 40:16lime reading of, you know, when poor Barbara has been, you know,
- 40:20sexually chased around the streets?
- 40:22And he goes, oh, I wanted to chat with Susan Nero, but he
- 40:25seems to be rather busy. And then he just goes.
- 40:28His timing is impeccable. Exactly.
- 40:32And you could see exactly the same happening here, because he
- 40:34has that same lack of care for Vicky when she's getting chased
- 40:39and for her peril of trying to pass as a boy.
- 40:43Doesn't even say. Can't you?
- 40:45Just, you know, lead him on a bit and then maybe we'll get
- 40:47somewhere. Yeah.
- 40:49And he's just like, oh, wow. And it's like, no, what is?
- 40:52Because she would just be rumbled.
- 40:53And. And so it's just that same sort
- 40:56of lack of care he had for Barbara's getting chased around
- 40:59in the Romans that happens here. Just eat it up.
- 41:03Yeah. And I think he would love it.
- 41:06But I, I mean, like, as much as we've said like it falls into a
- 41:10lot of the cliches of the time or what we expect from the time.
- 41:13I do think every line they gave the 1st Doctor in this was just,
- 41:18I mean, imagine Hartnell clutching his lapel saying this.
- 41:21You ready? Gentlemen, Gentlemen, please.
- 41:24There's hardly need for the Oh, I can't even say the word.
- 41:29How'd you say that aprobibrium of over this treacle trifle?
- 41:35I'm very impressed with your progress.
- 41:36Why, if you've reached Jeremiah, there is much 'cause to rejoice.
- 41:41Only another few books to go before the New Testament, and
- 41:44from there it will be pain sailing.
- 41:45Gentlemen, I could just hear him saying it all.
- 41:49Exactly. And I think one of the few
- 41:51things we have sort of top literal toilet humour and Doctor
- 41:55Who as well, where he's asking for a bowl.
- 41:58I was like, yes, excuse me, I have, I have a rather sudden
- 42:03need of a chamber pot. Do you understand?
- 42:05And the God has to go and fetch it and such.
- 42:08And you could just imagine him playing it so well in terms of
- 42:13trying to be that flustered intentionally rather than what
- 42:17is sometimes put on in this book.
- 42:20Because to be honest, there's maybe one too many heart, No
- 42:23fluff written within the book. Yeah.
- 42:26It was, it was all over the missing adventures whenever he
- 42:29turned up that, you know, Chatterton.
- 42:31Chesterton. Yeah.
- 42:33Yeah, which it's fine because it is.
- 42:36It's it's it's a blunt tool to make kids realise, yes, this is
- 42:40meant to be hard over here. But I'm like, he wasn't always
- 42:43like that. He he it may be 1A story at
- 42:46best, like he wouldn't he's not fluffing his lines all the time.
- 42:50It's the one of the things that get someone else sometimes that
- 42:52people think that's always about is a bumbling sexist whatever.
- 42:57When nice he's he's he's he's like a young gossiper at heart
- 43:02in an old man's body and I love it when.
- 43:04People write him clever as well, and he's really smart in this,
- 43:08you know, he's there with an immediate disguise to get in
- 43:10with that mangy old horse. And then he has really
- 43:14intelligent dialogues with the guys that are right in the the
- 43:17King James Bible. He sort of deftly works his way
- 43:20through all the court intrigue that's going on, you know,
- 43:23figures out the, the plot that's happening.
- 43:26I just like, I like the first doctor to be sort of the
- 43:29smartest person in the room whilst acting the fool.
- 43:32And I I got a sense of that here.
- 43:34Yeah, definitely. Like he, he constantly has, it
- 43:38takes him a bit of time to get used to the characters around
- 43:41him. And that's, it's also part of I
- 43:43think the first doctor too, because like, you know, when he,
- 43:46when he first meets the, the, the kind of double actor Otley
- 43:50and Howden who are making the King James Bible and they're
- 43:52asking very particular theological questions.
- 43:56It's like, oh, there's the case on both sides or whatever.
- 43:59And they're just like, one thing we both hate is sending
- 44:02equivocation. And that's exactly what you're
- 44:03doing. And so he he ends up trying to
- 44:06busted his way through, not always succeeding, which is the
- 44:10joy of it as well, because a lot of the time he he he might have
- 44:14one or two successes and it goes to his head and he then kind of
- 44:19falls see him. Puffing out his chest and then
- 44:22the blow comes. He's like, oh, you know, got his
- 44:25fingers on his mouth going all to you, you know?
- 44:28Exactly like all these things and kind of near the end with
- 44:32the exorcism of the tortoise where he's he's trying to put it
- 44:38off for so long to try and just make it look like it's something
- 44:43that King James wanted to have happened.
- 44:45Do you know what right I? Would kill a handful of Doctor
- 44:47Who fans to see William Hartnell, Maureen O'Brien and
- 44:51Jacqueline Hill act out that scene where they're exercising
- 44:54the Sardis? I would have been wonderful
- 44:59someone. 'S got the bell, someone's got
- 45:01the book, and someone's sprinkling holy water, right?
- 45:04Yeah. Vicky's read, Vicky's trying to
- 45:08ring the bell quite badly, Barbara's reading out Latin very
- 45:12badly, and everyone around her who knows Latin is looking
- 45:16unconfused and the Doctor's like just blessing the TARDIS over
- 45:20and over for about. I think it was only for multiple
- 45:22hours like a many events if it was on.
- 45:26TV, you could just keep cutting back to it and they're still
- 45:28going round, you know, like I did.
- 45:31Like though, you know, you said about Howden, Howden and Notley,
- 45:34Is that what they're called? The two scholars, Howden and
- 45:36Notley? Yeah.
- 45:37Yeah. When he realises what they're up
- 45:39to right in that book, that they're doing all the best bits.
- 45:41Listen to this. You mean you're skipping?
- 45:44You're skipping bits, said Vicky.
- 45:47The doctor goes the burning Bush, the Whiting on the walls,
- 45:50Sodom and Gomorrah, all the more colourful sections.
- 45:54And then Howden goes, well, you know, why would you like to be
- 45:57stuck on the big guards week after week?
- 45:59The doctor goes, then you've got to die and leave some other poor
- 46:02soul to finish the boring sections.
- 46:04Yeah, that's exactly what they're doing.
- 46:07Yeah, I mean, and this is the this is the thing about it with
- 46:09the human things like that. The the double as it were with
- 46:14with them with with the two Cobblers and and King James as
- 46:18well. Like there's there's a sort of
- 46:23humour level that things that you wouldn't have saw since the
- 46:26myth makers as well, which I think is a kind of touchstone as
- 46:30well for basically having a lot of that, the humour, but also
- 46:34the themes of the discourse about Catholics and Protestants
- 46:38from Season 3 as well with the massacre.
- 46:40But with the characters of Season 2, it feels like as much
- 46:45as it says on the back of the cover or this is a story set
- 46:47between, you know, the Space Museum and the chase.
- 46:51If they kept their contracts going and they went into Season
- 46:543 and Torch and whales were doing this, this, it feels like
- 46:57a torch and whales era, sort of historical.
- 47:03There's a lot. Of history in it.
- 47:04There's a lot of detail in it. Oh yeah, yeah.
- 47:06As well as the joke. But I say with the humour, it's
- 47:09like Mr. Agnew is probably as witty as Dennis Spooner.
- 47:14I don't think he's as sophisticated as Oh God I've
- 47:19forgotten his name. Who wrote the myth makers?
- 47:22Donald Cotton. Donald Cotton, I'd say he's.
- 47:24Probably somewhere in the middle between the two of them, but
- 47:26that's still a high bar. When it comes to comedy, it is.
- 47:30I guess it's because it's, yeah, I think everyone talks about it
- 47:33being a more something like the myth makers to be more highbrow
- 47:39in terms of your reading and knowledge to get some of the
- 47:42jokes and such. That isn't that with with
- 47:45thinness. It's just the level of constant
- 47:50amounts of humour that's been thrown around and, and, and a
- 47:54lot of this because he's, yeah, he's not like that sort of level
- 47:59of higher intellectual humour. It's it's the same thing you
- 48:01might see in the Shakespeare code when he wrote that when
- 48:04he's when they go there and they're thinking, oh,
- 48:06Shakespeare is going to be all like very high fluting and
- 48:10everyone's just like, shut your. Big fat mouth or whatever it is.
- 48:16You're going to hear beautiful. Shakespearean words hi, noni,
- 48:21noni, or way of recess. Yeah, exactly.
- 48:25So so it has like that sort of level thing about, but it's just
- 48:28like the consistent level of it that you see in something like
- 48:32the Myth Makers perhaps. And yeah, I did.
- 48:35The myth makers for the book club about a year ago.
- 48:39And I really have to work to understand that book.
- 48:43But as a result, it's it's still my number one of all the books
- 48:47I've covered. It's such a clever bit of work.
- 48:50And if you put the time into the jokes, they just keep giving.
- 48:54They're so clever. Whereas the plotters and I
- 48:59can't, I cannot stress enough how deliriously enjoyable I
- 49:02found this book to read. Yeah, but it was a much simpler
- 49:06read. Like I didn't really have to
- 49:07think very hard. Like the jokes were either very
- 49:11obviously spelled out to me or, you know, the history was
- 49:15delivered as a bit of a lecture or exposition.
- 49:18Like you. You don't really have to go
- 49:20digging, no. No.
- 49:22And it's delivered, I dare say that much more accessible way.
- 49:26Even something like the massacre, as well as a lot of
- 49:31the core energy is more serious and things like the massacre.
- 49:33Well, this is the the seriousness of the court drama
- 49:38is under not under undermined, but it is cut through with a
- 49:44sort of, you know, comedic line from King James or some sort of
- 49:50like blush stuff from the doctor or something else that happens
- 49:54that that keeps it going in a different way and makes that
- 49:58sort of plot line kind of more exchangeable to know about.
- 50:01Because I don't know much about this apart from Yep, the
- 50:04gunpowder plot. It's like 16 hundreds that
- 50:08happened. I didn't know much about
- 50:10details. I.
- 50:10Didn't know the sort of the motivations behind it or
- 50:14anything. So I learned a bit here as well.
- 50:15You know, I was sort of writing out.
- 50:17I felt as if I was back at school writing out in my
- 50:19exercise book, you know, because it was in great big chunks.
- 50:22I was going, oh, great. Yeah, Catholics, Protestants,
- 50:24Right. Starting war of Europe.
- 50:25OK, Yeah, yeah. So I was learning, yeah.
- 50:28Exactly and antibodies when I was reading through it and when
- 50:31we were because we for the lessons we were meant to
- 50:35initially record this on the 12th of July and as a Glaswegian
- 50:38where sick together and is rife with Protestants and Catholics
- 50:43and the 12th of July is a big day for one side of the city.
- 50:48I was like of all things and all days to try and talk about
- 50:52you'll be hearing much as outside my flat voice.
- 50:54It goes on and I don't know if there'll be for my.
- 50:57Administration errors then. But it was it was interesting
- 51:02how much of that was helped to be fleshed out in this book,
- 51:05because I I really wasn't really aware as much about the the
- 51:08history of it when it came to that sort of angles within this
- 51:13within this book. But it was it was great to have
- 51:15it definitely an. Element of those Hartnell
- 51:17historicals wasn't it was to teach like that was part of the
- 51:20rebate of the historicals. But I really did like the fact
- 51:24that in season 2 because the historicals in season 1 are so
- 51:28earnest they're great but they're so serious.
- 51:31You know history is a horror to be trapped in and then comes
- 51:34series 2. You know, we're doing sex
- 51:35comedy. It comes series 3, The doctors
- 51:38design and a bloody catapult to send people over a wall like
- 51:42story on history. But that sort of fusion of
- 51:44comedy and education, I think it's pretty potent.
- 51:50Yeah, it's, it's the best way to do it in terms of because I
- 51:52think there's a story from, what's his name, the guy who
- 51:58wrote Farewell Great Macedonia, John Dorney.
- 52:04The guy originally. The guy.
- 52:05Yeah, yeah, the guy who wrote it.
- 52:07I can't remember his name right now.
- 52:09Great. Script though, yeah.
- 52:11But I think he was, he said in some sort of interview about
- 52:13how, you know, essentially why that script wasn't taken was
- 52:17because like folk and the production team have seen, we've
- 52:21had complaints from teachers saying they've been writing
- 52:24history essays of Marco Polo with the doctor in it.
- 52:28And the issue is that it's a fairly straight story, something
- 52:31like Marco Polo, probably great if we saw it, but it's, it's the
- 52:35straightness of the history is there with the straightness of
- 52:39the acting of the of the sci-fi characters.
- 52:42But in some kind of like the Romans, it's very much
- 52:45contrasted with like here's the comedy of, of the of the time as
- 52:49well as comedy. So it's much more contrasting by
- 52:52by showing the contrast of these people with with light
- 52:56heartedness, with jokes and a level of kind of like coverage
- 53:03to make sure you're not doing a pure historical drama production
- 53:07for kids so that kids don't think, Oh yeah, that's Emperor
- 53:10Nero and his, you know, liar player, Doctor Who from the
- 53:15history books. It helps to kind of separate
- 53:19that better version of. History to me, you know the
- 53:24letters they were getting then when they did the response
- 53:27today, you know, they started bringing out the massacre and
- 53:28things like, dear Sir, one of my students went out and massacred
- 53:32a load of Huguenots. Please, can you go back to Ryan
- 53:35comedies please? What about being a Barbara then?
- 53:41They were so sweet. It was genuinely some of the
- 53:45best because it's one part that we were talking earlier about
- 53:49nostalgia and how there's waves of nostalgia and when when it
- 53:56came to Doctor Who being shown on Twitch, what, five years ago
- 54:00or something like that, and the warmth that new fans were
- 54:03feeling about Teen and Barbara 1965 stuff and all of that.
- 54:08Like it felt like a new wave of people got to appreciate their
- 54:12relationship. And it's not something that's
- 54:15seen or fizzles as much on screen.
- 54:18I mean, the Romans again, it's a great example of of their their
- 54:22fondness for each other when they're literally sitting around
- 54:25this big house themselves and the personal moments is really
- 54:31touching and you feel for them when you reunite at the end.
- 54:34That's the exact same feelings that are replicated in this, you
- 54:38know, when they get split away and they're going through the
- 54:42different trials and tribulations and the warmth that
- 54:45you feel of them reuniting. Like I think it says about how
- 54:49Barbara was kind of holding them that bit more closer and such
- 54:54and you you feel for them in such a way that you really would
- 54:58with other kind of non like more platonic companions like as they
- 55:05were technically meant to be, but they really one.
- 55:08I mean, it's it, it was their journey at the start, wasn't it?
- 55:11It was less Doctor Who. It was more Ian and Bob.
- 55:14Yeah, right. And until they left, then
- 55:17obviously it's all about the Doctor at that point.
- 55:19He, he's the hero and it's whoever's hanging about with
- 55:22him. I think they realised that
- 55:25Jackie Hill and William Russell, they were never going to run as
- 55:27a couple, but you can see the chemistry between the two of
- 55:30them. They were always going to go
- 55:32together, right. And I think fans that ship, it's
- 55:37there for the picking. And I can understand why in this
- 55:40book, you know, Gareth, oops, sorry, David Agnew has gone.
- 55:44I'll bleed something in there. Some rude line from King James.
- 55:49You can see. Why?
- 55:50He makes a suggestion that Ian has to pose as Barbara's husband
- 55:56at one point and he sort of looks apologetically at her and
- 55:59she don't mind at all. But this is the thing, like as
- 56:03much as that's just a surface level line for them, for their
- 56:06disguise, the earnestness he has and determination he has to save
- 56:11Barbara throughout this. Like he goes so desperate to the
- 56:14Cobblers to get their help, to try and find her.
- 56:18They treat it as a sort of night's quest for him in a lot
- 56:22of ways when they when they talk about it too.
- 56:24And he has that sort of serious determination, like as much as
- 56:28the lot of comedy for his book. And those Cobblers do provide it
- 56:30too. Like Ian is the most serious
- 56:33character I think in this book because he is.
- 56:36He is so determined to save Barbara.
- 56:39That's his drive and the plot one with.
- 56:42The most heart, like you say, is exactly, yeah, sort of the
- 56:45beating heart of the book. And it's it's, it's where a lot
- 56:48of the beating heart of of the show was at that time as well.
- 56:51So it's great to see that hating the bit to be a bit of the kind
- 56:55of focus for a lot of the book. I mean, you don't.
- 56:59Bring in William Russell from Camelot, you know, and don't
- 57:02make him the hero of the show, no.
- 57:04Exactly. And you could, again, there's
- 57:07scenes that you could just imagine him performing perfectly
- 57:11when it comes to like walking in the cobbler scene, like having a
- 57:16side quest of needing to mop up like the Cobblers yards and
- 57:20stuff. Like he does so much of that
- 57:23sort of stuff that he doesn't need to, but he he's he's there
- 57:27to earn earnest friends to help him on his quest.
- 57:31And yeah, it feels like a true sort of, yeah.
- 57:34Journey of a quest, I mean. Jesus Christ, you know if you
- 57:36was kidnapped by Guy Fawkes I would be as concerned.
- 57:39You know, I would be scooping up manure like you wouldn't believe
- 57:43to try and rescue you from his clutches.
- 57:46He was. He was very horny by the way as
- 57:49well. Who was?
- 57:50Guy. Fawkes, OH.
- 57:52I know he he thought Barbara was a bit of all right, didn't he?
- 57:55Like. Literally as soon as like they
- 57:58so because Guy Fawkes, you know, essentially takes her away
- 58:02because she thinks she knows more of the plot than than you.
- 58:06Were specific, then that sounded like a euphemism.
- 58:09Take the. Chaser away.
- 58:11Well, I mean, he kind of does as well, don't they?
- 58:14Wait. Up in bed together and she goes.
- 58:15Thank God we're fully clothed. Exactly, but the way that he
- 58:20sort of talks about, you know, it's like it's not a thing a man
- 58:23should usually speak of before a lady.
- 58:26But I have known many, many women.
- 58:28The battlefield makes a fellow first for love.
- 58:31And I have taken a full swig from Aphrodite's bottle.
- 58:35None as fair as you. It's like Aphrodite.
- 58:40'S bottle. He's he's suckered from that.
- 58:43I mean, have you seen Jacqueline Hill?
- 58:45That's enough to turn my head. All right.
- 58:48Yeah. Yeah.
- 58:48Yeah. Beauty.
- 58:49Statuesque, I call her just just like a like a Greek goddess.
- 58:55Absolutely. What about Buffon?
- 58:56Obviously there's the. Fighting couple of the 1960s,
- 58:59Izina and Barbara. Oh boy, they are.
- 59:02They are. I did love the Cobblers as well.
- 59:04When the Cobblers then turn round towards the end and go
- 59:08like, yeah, we're going to come. We're going to help you get
- 59:10Barbara back. You need to be reunited with
- 59:12your wife. I was just like, punch him.
- 59:14Yeah, go. No, I love his pair.
- 59:15I love him. I know because because I mean
- 59:19they're the sort of proper in the scene we were talking about,
- 59:23like the Shakespeare code where like they arrive and they think
- 59:26it's all going to be a Shakespearean language and
- 59:28everyone is just like why? And they are the perfect example
- 59:32from the get go because, you know, Ian and Barbara initially
- 59:35wanted to go see a Shakespeare play and they go to a bar which
- 59:39has these two that speak in the most sort of like course way
- 59:45immediately to them. Like there's a bit where they
- 59:53they've just literally introduced each other just to
- 59:58get into the bar and they realise they are a bit more
- 1:00:01uppity, perhaps because they're from the 1960s, got RP accents
- 1:00:04and all of that. And Barbara just asks is anybody
- 1:00:10serving here? The man laughed and nudged his
- 1:00:12companion in the ribs. I and twas the same question
- 1:00:15that came to my mind when I first saw you yourself.
- 1:00:18Good mistress. He chuckled fraughtily.
- 1:00:23Like you've got quite an. Education.
- 1:00:25Read in this book all these lines you've written down.
- 1:00:28I know I've got all the all the pick up lines that I'm sure do
- 1:00:31not try that. One all right.
- 1:00:33I'd be getting everywhere around in 1605 I'm sure, but by.
- 1:00:38The end of this call I should be saying I'll pray that my Co host
- 1:00:42here can ignore the pulse things of his groin for God's sake.
- 1:00:47But but you know, like it's as much as you think at first when
- 1:00:51I was reading those lines, they could they could also have been
- 1:00:54the two that could have kidnapped Barbara and Ian.
- 1:00:57If if they took Guy Fawkes's side in that argument in the
- 1:01:00pub, like you could have seen them equally just as be the bad
- 1:01:04guys that were needing to Ian would have to try and save
- 1:01:08Barbara from it just so happens it falls the other way.
- 1:01:13And the great thing about it, it was just, it didn't just make
- 1:01:18them other sort of like rough guys in a pub who would never
- 1:01:22help anyone. They, they, they go on a loving
- 1:01:24journey and kind of in the end are one of the good double acts
- 1:01:28in the book. I've been.
- 1:01:29Those scenes in the pub, I was getting pangs of the end of the
- 1:01:33Reign of Terror and I was definitely getting pangs of the
- 1:01:36star of the massacre when Stevens in the bar and there's
- 1:01:39some political discussion there. But I was also because Ian sort
- 1:01:44of ends up with like a pair of just like every men.
- 1:01:49Yeah, I was getting sort of pangs of Delos from the Romans,
- 1:01:52where he gets like, a pal that helps him out on his adventure.
- 1:01:55So again, it was just this whole melting pot of stuff from the
- 1:01:58era. Well, no exactly.
- 1:02:01But as much as as I was saying about like the casting that we
- 1:02:07might have for some of these these sort of people, I could I
- 1:02:13could very much imagine like Tony Selby be one of the sort of
- 1:02:17two guys in the pub and giving a sort of glitz style sort of
- 1:02:20performance to it all. So I would have yeah, I would
- 1:02:24have loved that. We'll.
- 1:02:25Help you? All right.
- 1:02:26But only for a few grot seats. All right, great.
- 1:02:30Well, OK, So what about the death of Guy Fawkes?
- 1:02:36Because I'd forgotten that happened.
- 1:02:38I was like, excuse me? Yes, I genuinely was one of the
- 1:02:44few times I've actually had to stop reading a book.
- 1:02:46I can actually almost gasp to reading it thinking how what?
- 1:02:50And I had to try and think how much of this book is like,
- 1:02:53surely they're not going to do some sort of, because everything
- 1:02:57I heard about it was to be a historic book.
- 1:02:59It's not going to do some sort of time travelling Spacey thing.
- 1:03:03They're going to just deal with that.
- 1:03:06And the way it played out, it was it was really nice.
- 1:03:10I could have genuinely imagined the cliffhanger happened at
- 1:03:12Glove, like Guy Fawkes getting killed on the ground and the
- 1:03:18fade to black as the credits start to roll up as maybe Ian
- 1:03:21says off camera that you've killed Guy Fawkes and I'll just
- 1:03:27go up. It'd be a.
- 1:03:29Great cliffhanger it would have. Been it would have been great,
- 1:03:32but I I was genuinely unsure how it was going to land, how to
- 1:03:37could find a way that would slot everything back into history.
- 1:03:40And it was quite a clever bit of writing of making sure that
- 1:03:46there wasn't enough crossover with the plotting freaks as it
- 1:03:50well with Cecil within the court and how much he knew about the
- 1:03:57the plotters and who and how much people knew about the
- 1:04:01plotters and how much people knew about Guy Fawkes and how
- 1:04:03much the king knew about Guy Fawkes to be able to get away
- 1:04:05with someone else in particular, someone who was the king might
- 1:04:09also recognise as Guy Fawkes. I thought I.
- 1:04:13Thought because we'd already introduced the idea of disguises
- 1:04:18and we would go on to introduce a further twist about disguises
- 1:04:23that I was like, OK, someone is going to be mistaken for guy
- 1:04:26source. Like, I wasn't sure who, but I
- 1:04:28thought, well, that's, you know, because that is absolutely going
- 1:04:31to be, you know, a pinpoint in the historical Atlas and that
- 1:04:35isn't going to change. Well, OK, I suppose the time is
- 1:04:39here then for us to finally talk about poor Vicky, or should I
- 1:04:44say Victor. Do as much as I was saying
- 1:04:48earlier is that where my heart was for a lot of like following
- 1:04:53the book defective. Just see some of the more
- 1:04:55company between James and such. Vicky was the weakest regular in
- 1:05:01this book. She's she's much stronger in so
- 1:05:08many other stories in the actual show as as well.
- 1:05:12I feel at least then what she's made out to be.
- 1:05:15I think in fan memory, in particular in fan memory
- 1:05:18probably in the 90s as well, because a lot of this book that
- 1:05:22this points where she's she's so gullible.
- 1:05:25She's so we just. Did with that role, isn't she?
- 1:05:30Because Ian and Barbara are going to be that gullible and
- 1:05:32the Doctor isn't going to be that gullible.
- 1:05:33So it's like, well, it's the kid, obviously.
- 1:05:36Yeah, but there's things like basic sort of things that she's
- 1:05:41she's falling for or, and at one point is, is breaking down in
- 1:05:46front of the doctor because she she's not able to stand up for
- 1:05:51herself or something like this. And I, I just, I don't see Vicky
- 1:05:56like that in a lot of ways. Like she still had her old
- 1:05:59agency and and a lot of her stories, especially when she was
- 1:06:03in Space Museum. When she was like revolution.
- 1:06:06Like, yeah, literally. Yeah, she reads the revolution
- 1:06:08there. Even even in the crusading
- 1:06:11extent where she's she tries to be, she's not as like wrapped up
- 1:06:21in cotton wool like she is in this in a lot of ways, in terms
- 1:06:27of how kind of naivety about things like if you she's, she's
- 1:06:31not as wise to our situations in this.
- 1:06:35And it's a bit of a caricature of her, which is a bit of a
- 1:06:37shame. But sometimes the plot required
- 1:06:41someone to not she is as ways she is.
- 1:06:46Boxed into that slightly problematic role of being, you
- 1:06:51know, the victim of the sex pestery, which it's never really
- 1:06:56a great idea to go down that angle ever.
- 1:06:58But it was a weird trope in early on or vase or in keys of
- 1:07:04Mariners. The the Vikings in with Edith
- 1:07:07in. You know that there's the
- 1:07:09entertainment. Of Romans as well.
- 1:07:10There's there's some pretty, we'll never do that again,
- 1:07:14hopefully stuff that happened there.
- 1:07:17So I don't think he's not right to put it in there because it
- 1:07:20was absolutely a part of the era.
- 1:07:22And I, you know, forgive me. King James's lines are very
- 1:07:27funny. They are outrageous at times.
- 1:07:31Yeah, I mean, I don't know if it was something that it was.
- 1:07:36It was something to help try and make sure that King James was
- 1:07:40still on side in the plot by having him lust over factor I
- 1:07:44guess. Not on the side with the plot,
- 1:07:47but just totally like diverted from the main plot because all
- 1:07:52he can think about is Victor, whereas he's being told, you
- 1:07:54know, you know, there's this whole plot to blow up
- 1:07:56Parliament. It's like, oh, fireworks,
- 1:07:58whatever. Where's Victor?
- 1:07:59You know, where's that young cherubic?
- 1:08:02Yes, exactly. Like there's there's a there's a
- 1:08:04there's a good way for him to to start kind of gloss over some of
- 1:08:11the other facts such as that don't make sense for him about
- 1:08:13the doctor and why he's exactly there, things like that.
- 1:08:20And I guess I make it kind of one of the issues is that I
- 1:08:24would quite like it to have been probably Ian in some way rather
- 1:08:29than, OK, that would be hilarious because he would be
- 1:08:34able to be more wily about the situation, be more kind of, you
- 1:08:39know, aware of in what Vicky kind of, again, kind of plays
- 1:08:43into some of the tropes. And I was kind of jokingly
- 1:08:45referring to he as a sort of demon twinkle and such.
- 1:08:48But King James wrote it just has this thing about how essentially
- 1:08:52he's aged, you know, of being his twink, the court's twink.
- 1:08:56And Victor's meant to be the new one on the scene, but he keeps
- 1:09:02calling him the boy. And it's all about younger men
- 1:09:05that way. And it's a predatory angle in a
- 1:09:07lot of ways that isn't. Me, absolutely.
- 1:09:10The Romans as well, wasn't it? I know she wasn't underage, but
- 1:09:13it's predatory all the same. Yeah, but.
- 1:09:15It's yeah, it's still predatory in that way, but it's it's it
- 1:09:19has that particular language as well, especially when it is in a
- 1:09:22homosexual situation is like this as well.
- 1:09:25That if it was someone like Ian and this dealing with it in the
- 1:09:29same way that, say, Barbara did, where she she ingrained herself
- 1:09:35in that court from being a servant, slave servant, Ian
- 1:09:38could have been a similar sort of role in some way that could
- 1:09:43have also been useful to the plot.
- 1:09:46Unless icky, less icky in a lot of ways because, yeah, just be
- 1:09:51less icky with Vicky, please, when using.
- 1:09:55Well done. Well summarized.
- 1:09:56I mean, one of the things I loved, many things I love about
- 1:10:00the witch finders, one of the things I love was that Ryan had
- 1:10:03no gay panic whatsoever when he realised the King was interested
- 1:10:07in him. He's right.
- 1:10:07Right now I can delay him from going to murdering a load of
- 1:10:10people by flirting out. Rate was he say please show me
- 1:10:14your pricker or whatever he was like.
- 1:10:15Yeah. Oh, really?
- 1:10:18Tell me about your history. So interesting, you know.
- 1:10:21Yeah, there's there's, there's you know, and that's like like
- 1:10:25that's something I probably Ian maybe at first a bit flustered,
- 1:10:30but then would have got into the role quite well to be able to
- 1:10:33kind of use to the advantage in a way that they they keep not
- 1:10:38doing in this because as Becky, she is meant to be this young
- 1:10:42teenager. So it would not be suitable for
- 1:10:44her to actually, they would never.
- 1:10:46Write so far. I think.
- 1:10:48We could say that comfortably this wouldn't, this would never
- 1:10:51get up. You would never have keep going
- 1:10:53after an underage companion like no.
- 1:10:56No, you wouldn't be having that and a big finish anytime soon,
- 1:11:00although we're not. Suggesting as well that Ian, our
- 1:11:04Ian, you know, who's devoted to Barbara, starts doing things
- 1:11:07like Chris Quedge in the New Adventures, going down back
- 1:11:09alleys and giving people such jobs.
- 1:11:11We don't want that, but we want him to start.
- 1:11:13You know, there's a lot of back. Alleys in there.
- 1:11:16So there's plenty of opportunities the night off
- 1:11:19because it's pre 1666 and so there's lots of smaller holes
- 1:11:24that people can, if you can get can get through to expedite
- 1:11:32their journeys. And it's it's a nice part of of
- 1:11:36world building that they do with that.
- 1:11:39So he would have had ample opportunities.
- 1:11:42What did you think of that particular all?
- 1:11:44Right. Don't you tell me you ain't good
- 1:11:45at this all right, because. There was another small hole in
- 1:11:48this as well with the. I'm intrigued with with the
- 1:11:53underground network within the tree.
- 1:11:55So they would go into the the small caves of of labyrinths
- 1:12:00like underground. That bit was a bit hard to
- 1:12:05believe in terms of the plot because how how small were these
- 1:12:11holes to fit people through? How big were the sun?
- 1:12:16There was this underground network.
- 1:12:17It's it was a bit odd in comparison to the regular sort
- 1:12:23of historical stuff, but were you talking about?
- 1:12:25What? What the passages in order to
- 1:12:26get underneath Westminster? Yeah, no.
- 1:12:29It wasn't the ones that they had with that there was the tree
- 1:12:31which kept the under secret underground network that he was
- 1:12:34using. Oh.
- 1:12:36Yes. So he was just way in and out of
- 1:12:38everywhere, wasn't it? Of like, you know, so we could
- 1:12:40be in about 5 place, 5 plots at once.
- 1:12:43Yeah, because. It seems like at one point I
- 1:12:45think they said it was maybe hundreds of years old.
- 1:12:49And the thing was, was like the dog that can have pains.
- 1:12:50This is the sort of secret society that doesn't really
- 1:12:53exist and there's not many of them around, but they seem to
- 1:12:56have built like a very elaborate thing.
- 1:12:59And I'm going to. Suggest you consider them
- 1:13:02narrative passages to squeeze down rather than literal ones.
- 1:13:06OK. Yeah, I'll take it as I'll take
- 1:13:10it as a narrative type passage instead of sort of 1.
- 1:13:16What do you do you have anything else in your notes?
- 1:13:20Any lines you wish to spot, you know to to rejoice about?
- 1:13:24I mean, I've got quite a few, so if you want to bat back and
- 1:13:28forth for a second. Well I'll, I'll let.
- 1:13:32Well, I've got one. I'll kick off with another King
- 1:13:36James one near the beginning. I'll try and get my King James
- 1:13:39one. What is this?
- 1:13:41What's his accent like again? Oh, oh, Matron Prince, I knew.
- 1:13:48I knew it would be a Prince witchcraft.
- 1:13:51The weed, lassie. Yes, more wine.
- 1:13:55We shall return to the well. Oh, to have long noticed this.
- 1:14:05I'm going to quickly look in my book instead, because I just I
- 1:14:07wrote the quite a bit of a frozen slip of a Coke.
- 1:14:11Oh, please, can you read that out now though, please?
- 1:14:13I'll read that. After I read the actual one,
- 1:14:15because it's when King James says more wine, we shall return
- 1:14:22to the Barbary ape and I wrote the Salisbury ape, which as his
- 1:14:27political advisor, hopefully he's not returning to him
- 1:14:32anytime Simon in any apish fashion, but oh what?
- 1:14:34Was the line about Salisbury where we went?
- 1:14:37Thank God he wasn't called Reading or.
- 1:14:41Something Oh yeah, to name a cathedral yeah a fuck Cathedral
- 1:14:44City yeah, I. Did like this the Chamberlain?
- 1:14:46His interest in divinity and theology are much greater than
- 1:14:51his interest in female company. There's there's so many
- 1:14:56references that he makes about how happy he's not to be in his
- 1:15:00his wife's company as as the queen, like throughout is.
- 1:15:04Yeah, it's not very subtle. Oh.
- 1:15:07God, what was the what was the line about the pie?
- 1:15:13Hang on, I've got it here somewhere.
- 1:15:18On a rising scale, if one is a stolen pie from the kitchen and
- 1:15:2210 is revolution in the streets, how awful is it?
- 1:15:26I like that 1/8. I love how he's he's because the
- 1:15:32Chamberlain's trying to be so dramatic about it, but even in
- 1:15:36that scale, he just thinks it's an 8 out of 10 of of how
- 1:15:39dramatic it is, which my. Life rarely goes below 8.
- 1:15:44Absolutely. If I'm honest, you know, if I'm
- 1:15:47at 5, then I'm doing something very wrong.
- 1:15:49Oh, listen to this. This was, this was the ultimate
- 1:15:51plot. You ready?
- 1:15:52When Parliament is a smoking wreck, the war would begin.
- 1:15:55This country will be torn apart with hidden tensions.
- 1:15:58And then begins the reign of darkness for which we have longs
- 1:16:02prepared. The fall of England will crush
- 1:16:04the spirits of Europe. France will fall, then Spain,
- 1:16:07then Germany. Everlasting darkness.
- 1:16:10I mean, I thought that summed it up quite well.
- 1:16:13Exactly. There's, there's been a lot of
- 1:16:19like, yeah, nice, lovely dialogue from, from King James
- 1:16:23and such. But there was there was a lovely
- 1:16:25part of of word play as as well from the first Doctor where
- 1:16:32they're talking about this idea of an exorcism in the first
- 1:16:36instance and the the the Doctor just.
- 1:16:41So I'm just trying to find it there.
- 1:16:45I've had I know it's over the place right now but yes King
- 1:16:51James is just going on about saying oh we need to wipe out
- 1:16:55this devilry within this wooden box and doctors like well I
- 1:16:58could do if the exorcise It's just nice little word plays like
- 1:17:04that. You can imagine this script like
- 1:17:06just ice that line exercise. Yes yeah, he was he would
- 1:17:12positively glow say in that line.
- 1:17:15I did like the. Chamberlain.
- 1:17:16I really like the Chamberlain's line.
- 1:17:17At one point he's so I was like, oh, who is to know truth from
- 1:17:21fiction these days? I thought, yes, very droll, Mr.
- 1:17:24Agnew. Yes, no, yeah.
- 1:17:27I mean, throughout, throughout the book, there's the, yeah,
- 1:17:32there's so much wonderful control lines the Doctor had.
- 1:17:36The nerve to say this. For one moment there, I thought
- 1:17:39this episode, I mean to say this episode of my life was going in
- 1:17:44a different direction. Was that the sort of knowing
- 1:17:46comment that you were talking about?
- 1:17:47Yeah, there was some sort of like 4th wall stuff sometimes
- 1:17:50that went a bit too bit too far. Can I ask you?
- 1:17:56This, though, would you if I sort of, you know, got you
- 1:17:59involved in some devilish plot, Anthony?
- 1:18:02Yeah. And like the Cobblers, if I gave
- 1:18:04you enough money to be able to afford a pie a day, would that
- 1:18:08be enough to get you on board? It'd.
- 1:18:10Be very tempting. That would stay.
- 1:18:13High at that, you know, with loads it's a.
- 1:18:15It's a universal price. I think everyone would sign up
- 1:18:18if you offered anyone at any time period a pie a day.
- 1:18:21I'll take a. Slice, you know, Oh, I've.
- 1:18:26Just seen this item in Page 249 which they're about to go out to
- 1:18:31go to the exercising. However, the only way to kind of
- 1:18:36agree for for them to go off right now is that Vicky has to
- 1:18:42return to be on King James's knee and sit on his knee.
- 1:18:47When they return to court and and James stands up, he says
- 1:18:55steady on. Does a victor have to stamp on
- 1:18:58it too? He looked down sadly at his
- 1:19:01vacant knee. I'm afraid he does, says the
- 1:19:04doctor. I'll need someone to hold my
- 1:19:06prayer book, I suppose. James blew a kiss to the lad.
- 1:19:11Watch yourself and beware of spirits.
- 1:19:15And I won't forget that promise you made.
- 1:19:19Coming fuck off but I'm getting you in the Rollers King times.
- 1:19:23I just, you know, it's, it's, it's genuinely, it never ends.
- 1:19:28It never ceases throughout the book, like this level of of
- 1:19:34horniness that he has for it. I can't.
- 1:19:37Imagine why I enjoyed it this much.
- 1:19:40But but it does help to, like I say, undercut the sort of thing
- 1:19:43of, you know, if you were having this as a serious drama like you
- 1:19:46might have had in some of like say by Marco Polo, you would
- 1:19:50would have had people treating it as a more serious drama and
- 1:19:53taking a lot to serious elements.
- 1:19:54And you still can. You could still take the broad
- 1:19:57history of it but enjoy it as an entertainment piece as well from
- 1:20:00this high camp performance. I do I.
- 1:20:02Mean, I will say again that I do think there are moments where
- 1:20:05it's thoughtful. There are moments where it's
- 1:20:07educational and there's lines like this which are funny lines,
- 1:20:10but it, it says something. All it takes is to be utterly
- 1:20:14unscrupulous to exploit the worst aspects of human nature.
- 1:20:17And I was like, yeah, that's kind of true.
- 1:20:19Just leave your morals at the door and you can exploit
- 1:20:22anybody, you know. So I was like, yeah, there was,
- 1:20:25there was moments where I was thinking, but there was far more
- 1:20:28moments where I was laughing. Yeah, because in amongst that
- 1:20:33you do have. Actually.
- 1:20:34Good characterization and about some of the themes that you see
- 1:20:38because he is the kind of master manipulator and boiling
- 1:20:43sociopathic in terms of his ideas.
- 1:20:46He just wants sort of chaos to reign as his main sort of thing
- 1:20:50and he knows how to manipulate people to be able to.
- 1:20:54He knows what the weaknesses are, especially in this time
- 1:20:56period and the ideas we're talking about on the sort of
- 1:21:00Catholic and Protestant kind of religious arguments that take
- 1:21:07place for this book. Cecil, who is is meant to be the
- 1:21:11main political master manipulator in Westminster in
- 1:21:14this book is outplayed because of his bigotry towards
- 1:21:19Catholics. He just he thinks he can get a
- 1:21:21one off up off them in this plot with the gunpowder he sets the
- 1:21:26fucking. Thing up, didn't he?
- 1:21:27Like, yeah. Well, yeah, it's at the same
- 1:21:30time that he is played against with Hay because he he gets so
- 1:21:35involved within that that he in turn can be be exposed to it.
- 1:21:42And his own bigotry towards their downfall ultimately could
- 1:21:46have brought down him at the same time.
- 1:21:49So it it, it does have that theme of like, as much as he is
- 1:21:53just a mad sort of cultist, like it exposes some of the people
- 1:21:59for their bigotry at the same time.
- 1:22:01And I hate to kind of not fall into into that sort of deep pit.
- 1:22:08What does he know about the doctor to call him the Grand
- 1:22:12Behemoth? Yeah.
- 1:22:14Is this another sort of melon? The other sort, I can only
- 1:22:21guess. Yeah, I don't know, man.
- 1:22:23Who knew you squid during that sort of scene?
- 1:22:26No, don't. Don't do it.
- 1:22:27Don't. Yeah, Well, summarise your
- 1:22:31thought. I mean, we've sort of done that,
- 1:22:33but we've we've quoted a load of witty lines.
- 1:22:37One last thing I want to say before we summarise is I can
- 1:22:39absolutely understand why somebody else who is not me
- 1:22:43would be able to read this and find it highly awkward and
- 1:22:47problematic at times. Certainly the King James and
- 1:22:50Vicky staff and I absolutely respect that.
- 1:22:53But that reading is there because I know people that watch
- 1:22:56the Barbara stuff in the Romans and say, I don't really want to
- 1:22:59watch that. That's like that's that's kind
- 1:23:02of the worst of humanity there. He's basically trying to rape
- 1:23:04that, you know, So I get I get that people might not.
- 1:23:07I think he teeters on the right line of it being fast instead of
- 1:23:12problematic, but it is possible to to to take that line with
- 1:23:17this book and his books in general.
- 1:23:20Anyway, I just wanted to say that, but so the plotters please
- 1:23:25in your best double entendres summarise this book.
- 1:23:29Well, it's, it's, it won't, it won't bet through everyone's
- 1:23:32passage. I would say it's not something I
- 1:23:36think, like you say, everyone would enjoy because it's a nice
- 1:23:41perfect slice of Season 2. And to an extent, some of the
- 1:23:46latter. I saw the quotas, well, kind of
- 1:23:48cobbled in with that. The one thing is that is that
- 1:23:53you can't have this all the time.
- 1:23:56It's why it's nice having this as a very limited thing.
- 1:23:59It's just a little window into an additional story here.
- 1:24:02But if you're doing scores and scores of this all the time, you
- 1:24:08wouldn't have an audience for this.
- 1:24:09No one would find it original. They would be kind of, you know,
- 1:24:14out of steam to have something like this week in, week out when
- 1:24:19it comes to any of the sort of past ranges for anything be a
- 1:24:23book, audio, whatever. But if you want a just pure
- 1:24:28distilled slice of 1965, this really covers a lot of the
- 1:24:33bases. It also covers the historic
- 1:24:37aspects really well. I would say as well.
- 1:24:40There's characters that are well respected in terms of how
- 1:24:46they're portrayed in the same way in the Crusade where Saladin
- 1:24:50is more even handed than you'd expect in a 1960s production.
- 1:24:54So there's there's aspects of understanding more people in
- 1:24:59this historic context quite well.
- 1:25:01And for the most part, in particular, Ian and Barbara and
- 1:25:03the Doctor, the characterization is really strong and to the
- 1:25:08point that you genuinely especially feel that emotion
- 1:25:11with Barbara and Ian near the end of the book.
- 1:25:14And yeah, it's just full of absolute smut.
- 1:25:19It is completely, it is completely an absolute dirty
- 1:25:25fest. Where do you want?
- 1:25:27I was actually, I wonder if you could cast the people because we
- 1:25:32were casting people in this book from people from Doctor Who, but
- 1:25:38you could cast folk from the Carry On films within this as
- 1:25:41well. Like really easily sort of cast
- 1:25:44and wait. Who's the fellow with the
- 1:25:45glasses? Charles Holtry.
- 1:25:46Can he be the Charles Holtry? Can he be the Charles Holtry?
- 1:25:48Can be the Chamberlain Who would?
- 1:25:51Kenneth Williams be. Oh, Kenneth.
- 1:25:55Well, would you want Kenneth Williams to be King James?
- 1:26:01Yes. Hey, come on, sit on my knee.
- 1:26:07In fact, no, maybe I would have. I would have Charles Hotchley.
- 1:26:11No. Yeah, I would have Charles
- 1:26:12Hotchley as the Chamberlain. I was between him and Peter.
- 1:26:15But if he's already the medal in monk in the show, we maybe
- 1:26:20couldn't quite do that. I would have Barbara.
- 1:26:23Windsor play all versions of Hey, All right, the buxom wedge,
- 1:26:28the The young boy and the Spaniards you.
- 1:26:32See the you see the the the bomb.
- 1:26:34The one who? The landlady who runs the bar.
- 1:26:37Hatty, Hatty Jay. Oh no.
- 1:26:41How would we get? What's the name in there?
- 1:26:43Joan Sims. Oh, and what is the thing?
- 1:26:47Actually, there's not a lot of women in this book, no.
- 1:26:49There's well, no. He turns all the women into men.
- 1:26:53He does indeed, actually, apart from the landlady and genuinely
- 1:26:59that I think that's the only woman which is very unbraided
- 1:27:02for some, fortunately. We've already got William
- 1:27:04Hartnell in this. He's from a Carry On movie, so
- 1:27:06that's all right. Yeah, Sid James.
- 1:27:10Who would you put Sid James to be?
- 1:27:15Maybe one of the Cobblers with a really dirty laugh.
- 1:27:19Well. True, well maybe if you add some
- 1:27:21smutty lines to him, maybe sestool because he's got quite a
- 1:27:24meaty role and you can smut him up.
- 1:27:27Who's sort? Of the most heroic of the Carry
- 1:27:29On actors to play Guy Fawkes. Oh, what's that young guy who?
- 1:27:35Oh, with a sort of Beatles cart? I can't.
- 1:27:37Yeah, yeah, I know what you mean.
- 1:27:39Not Kenneth. Connor, Jim.
- 1:27:41Dale, Jim. Dale.
- 1:27:42Jim Dale as Guy Fawkes. OK, Have we done?
- 1:27:45Everybody hang on. I'm trying to figure who else
- 1:27:48even, because it's not many character wise.
- 1:27:52I mean, you could well just let you say with the sort of comedy
- 1:27:55duel of the two cockneys in the bar you could throw in.
- 1:28:02Maybe Bernard Breslaw is one of them.
- 1:28:04I just want to read this again now with all those castings in.
- 1:28:07Mind especially. Barbara Windsor's hi.
- 1:28:12You never thought? Through my plan did you you.
- 1:28:18Should be great. Like, yeah, maybe, maybe.
- 1:28:21Like maybe Teddy Scott is one of the the librarians, Frankie
- 1:28:28Howard perhaps, or Leslie Phillips, someone like that kind
- 1:28:31of camping that up. I'm going.
- 1:28:34To mock up, I'm going to mock up a movie poster for the plotters
- 1:28:37to come out with this all right. With all the plotting I've just
- 1:28:42put terrible Photoshop costumes on.
- 1:28:45Them, yes, I think I think that's the the main legacy we
- 1:28:49can do from this is to have a whole cast of carry on plotting.
- 1:28:54I would say because they did create audios of the Tom Baker,
- 1:28:59David Agnew books, they could easily have done this.
- 1:29:03They could easily have turned this into a great audio, I think
- 1:29:06because the lines are just there, you know, just take them
- 1:29:09from the book. Did he still do some of the
- 1:29:12missing adventure adaptations? The.
- 1:29:14The the novel adaptations they did the one didn't they recently
- 1:29:17golf opera because that was already recorded.
- 1:29:20They just weren't. Selling so they they stopped
- 1:29:22bothering, you know, and they were quite expensive to do.
- 1:29:25I think you've taught me in this conversation.
- 1:29:27I came into this conversation thinking, my God, the regulars
- 1:29:30are great. I've actually come out of this
- 1:29:32conversation thinking the most impressive thing about this is
- 1:29:35the guest characters and what they bring out of the regulars.
- 1:29:39If you're pardon the pub. Yeah, I know what Guy Fawkes are
- 1:29:42trying to bring out a Barbara, but bring out.
- 1:29:46Put in what he's talking about. Yeah, but no, yet.
- 1:29:50Like it's, it's, it's almost not even sometimes the characters.
- 1:29:55It's the idea of what the actor would get out of performing in
- 1:29:59this situation with the characters, especially like
- 1:30:01William Hartnell, like he would have thrived dealing with this
- 1:30:04sort of court intrigue and sort of like melodrama with King
- 1:30:11James, Like he would have thrived with that.
- 1:30:14And the same with the tender scenes that Barbara has with Guy
- 1:30:18Fawkes. You can really see Jacqueline
- 1:30:21Hill could do really well in those parts.
- 1:30:24And Ian being that sort of honest knight on his way to save
- 1:30:28his his his wife. Yeah, unfortunately.
- 1:30:32Sort of halfway through the story, his shirt got torn open
- 1:30:35and we had to look at his chest for the rest of the story.
- 1:30:37It's a shame, but there it is a shame.
- 1:30:40I mean, I'll say any complaints I've got are minimal.
- 1:30:44And because I just, the entertainment value was so high.
- 1:30:47And you know, I've, I've waved through some dirges of Doctor
- 1:30:51Who books doing this book club, and I know you have as well.
- 1:30:55Doing yours? Absolutely.
- 1:30:57And this was a. Breeze, yes.
- 1:31:00It was such a easy read. And that is the thing as well as
- 1:31:03in terms of if you struggle with the styles of some of these
- 1:31:08books, this one really is quite it gets along at a very fair
- 1:31:13pace. There's a lot of dialogue, so
- 1:31:15it's a very easy jumping into scene and picturing these scenes
- 1:31:20without too much of the of the kind of sentences around it to
- 1:31:24help you paint that picture. Because you can paint it through
- 1:31:27how they're talking, how people are interacting quite well,
- 1:31:30especially given the 67. So yeah, it's definitely would
- 1:31:34be something I'd be recommending to any who wants a slice of 60s
- 1:31:38who because we don't get much of them.
- 1:31:42And that's probably the best way to do it because we don't want
- 1:31:44to overmine every. Nostalgia.
- 1:31:47Yeah. Well, if you would care to
- 1:31:51explore Dark and Frightening House with me, with possible
- 1:31:57incestuous overtones. Or at least according to Paul
- 1:31:59Quinn on Target Book Day. Where are we heading next?
- 1:32:04Somewhere quite different from the plotters are here.
- 1:32:07When we're going through the dark colors of passages within
- 1:32:10the house and ghost light, Gabriel Chase ghost light as as
- 1:32:16to give a little tease is maybe one of my favourite stories.
- 1:32:20It's it's my favorite McCoy by a mile.
- 1:32:22Oh. Interesting.
- 1:32:25Have you read the book? No.
- 1:32:27Never read like I say, I think on the Dalek novelization that
- 1:32:31was my first target. I read through fill through so
- 1:32:34I've barely touched the targets I so I am intrigued the
- 1:32:38reputation. Of these, these late Mccoys are
- 1:32:40really high and there's a great Ian Hogg reading.
- 1:32:43If you don't even want to do the work of reading it, you could
- 1:32:45listen to it, right? OK.
- 1:32:47And the last hospital though? My my last question to you then,
- 1:32:51before we go is, you know, should people wish to, you know,
- 1:32:56squeeze down your passage of podcast them, then what narrows
- 1:33:02would they have to manoeuvre? Well, if you want to come to the
- 1:33:06the sorry, I'm so wrong. If you wish to come to the court
- 1:33:12of depravity that is the New Adventures, then you.
- 1:33:18Might see nothing left, you might say nothing yet.
- 1:33:20All right if you think this is as bad as it gets.
- 1:33:23Exactly. Can Caro and Shaw real supreme
- 1:33:25over on the Too Broad and Too Deep podcast, where we have
- 1:33:30thankfully just done the pits. You can join our pain listening
- 1:33:35to that episode or listening to our future episodes, which we
- 1:33:40are going to be doing the seat, which is coming next and
- 1:33:45features Joe. Yeah.
- 1:33:49So yeah, I'm going. To press up a space bitch ace
- 1:33:52just for the episode, just for the return.
- 1:33:54All right, I'll be proud of you. Only episodes.
- 1:33:57Both. My gums.
- 1:34:01You bet. Award.
- 1:34:01Alistair All right. So yes, hopefully that will be a
- 1:34:06tantalizing image for you all listening to, to imagine that as
- 1:34:09you hear Joe and your eardrums talk about deceit with us next
- 1:34:14time, I mean. I can promise you all that
- 1:34:17potentially things will be a little less smutty next time.
- 1:34:21This absolutely. We're on brand for this episode.
- 1:34:25Well, we are heading, you know, into a ghost light, which is
- 1:34:27literate and very smart text. But for now, this has been one
- 1:34:33of the most enjoyable hour and a half broadcast that I've ever
- 1:34:36done. Anthony, thank you very much for
- 1:34:39your time tonight. It's.
- 1:34:41Been a pleasure as it has been for King James and certain
- 1:34:45certain servants. Stuff has been this book as
- 1:34:47well. How do we out this in a
- 1:34:49particularly like, terrifyingly rude way?
- 1:34:54Your place or mine? Neva will go to King James's
- 1:34:59room, that'll be easier. OK, I'll race you to his knee.