Latest / Kentucky Tonight / School Choice and Amendment 2
Transcript
- 0:07[♪♪]
- 0:10GOOD EVENING.
- 0:12WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:13I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:15THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:17OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: SCHOOL CHOICE
- 0:19AND AMENDMENT 2.
- 0:23WE’RE ELECTING A PRESIDENT, PLUS
- 0:24MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND THE
- 0:26GENERAL ASSEMBLY THIS NOVEMBER.
- 0:28BUT SOMETHING ELSE ON THE
- 0:29KENTUCKY BALLOT MIGHT END UP
- 0:31GETTING THE MOST ATTENTION —
- 0:33AMENDMENT 2, THE SO-CALLED
- 0:35SCHOOL CHOICE AMENDMENT.
- 0:36IF PASSED, IT WOULD ALLOW THE
- 0:38KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO
- 0:39OKAY PUBLIC MONEY FOR PRIVATE
- 0:40SCHOOLS.
- 0:42SUPPORTERS SAY THE AMENDMENT
- 0:44WOULD GIVE KENTUCKY PARENTS MORE
- 0:45OPTIONS FOR THEIR CHILDREN’S
- 0:47EDUCATION.
- 0:48CRITICS SAY IT WOULD DIVERT
- 0:49MONEY AWAY FROM PUBLIC SCHOOLS,
- 0:52HURTING MOST KENTUCKY STUDENTS.
- 0:54TV COMMERCIALS, ON BOTH SIDES,
- 0:56ARE ALREADY RUNNING.
- 0:57EXPECT A LOT MORE, BETWEEN NOW
- 1:00AND NOVEMBER FIFTH — AS MILLIONS
- 1:02ARE EXPECTED TO POUR FROM THOSE
- 1:04ADVOCATING ON BOTH SIDES.
- 1:06TO TALK ABOUT ALL THIS, WE’RE
- 1:07JOINED IN OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO
- 1:08BY:
- 1:10RANDY ADAMS, FORMER PRINCIPAL IN
- 1:12THE ANDERSON COUNTY SCHOOL
- 1:12DISTRICT;
- 1:14TOM SHELTON, CHAIR OF THE
- 1:16PROTECT OUR SCHOOLS CAMPAIGN AND
- 1:17FORMER SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT;
- 1:20JIM WATERS, PRESIDENT OF THE
- 1:21BLUEGRASS INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC
- 1:23POLICY SOLUTIONS;
- 1:24AND MATT ROBBINS, FORMER
- 1:26SUPERINTENDENT OF DAVIESS COUNTY
- 1:27PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 1:31WELCOME TO ALL OF OUR GUESTS.
- 1:39SEND AN E-MAIL TO KET.ORG OR USE
- 1:43THE WEB FORM AT KET.ORG/KY
- 1:49TONIGHT OR CALL...
- 1:55AS WE BEGIN OUR DISCUSSION,
- 1:57LET’S TAKE A LOOK AT THE PRECISE
- 1:58WORDING OF AMENDMENT 2, AS IT
- 2:00WILL APPEAR ON THE NOVEMBER
- 2:00BALLOT:
- 2:07QUOTE•.. “IT IS PROPOSED THAT A
- 2:09NEW SECTION BE ADDED TO THE
- 2:11CONSTITUTION OF KENTUCKY TO READ
- 2:12AS FOLLOWS:
- 2:15THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY PROVIDE
- 2:16FINANCIAL SUPPORT FOR THE
- 2:18EDUCATION OF STUDENTS OUTSIDE
- 2:21THE SYSTEM OF COMMON SCHOOLS.
- 2:22THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY
- 2:24EXERCISE THIS AUTHORITY BY LAW,
- 2:26SECTIONS 59, 60, 171, 183, 184,
- 2:27186, AND 189 OF THIS
- 2:31CONSTITUTION NOTWITHSTANDING.”
- 2:32UNQUOTE.
- 2:39>> Renee: Mr. ROBINS IT'S PO
- 2:41IMPORTANT BECAUSE WE'VE TALKED
- 2:42ABOUT THE ISSUE MANY, MANY,
- 2:45TIMES ON THIS PROGRAM BUT GIVE A
- 2:47REFRESHER AND INFORM OTHERS.
- 2:49WHAT DOES IT MEAN BY A SYSTEM OF
- 2:53COMMON SCHOOLS?
- 2:54>> THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION.
- 2:57THE COMMON SCHOOLS ARE WHAT WE
- 2:59DEFINE AS OUR NEIGHBORHOOD
- 3:01PUBLIC SCHOOLS ACROSS ALL OF
- 3:03KENTUCKY FROM PA PADUCAH TO
- 3:06PIKEVILLE.
- 3:07THE COMMON SCHOOLS IT'S GIVEN
- 3:09TATD TERMINOLOGY IN THE
- 3:11CONSTITUTION BECAUSE IT'S DEEMED
- 3:12TO BE PART OF THE COMMON GOOD
- 3:14LIKE FIRE, POLICE AND THE ROADS
- 3:16THAT WE HAVE, EVEN THE NATIONAL
- 3:18GUARD, MILITARY, THOSE THINGS
- 3:20ARE CONSIDERED AND DEEMED TO BE
- 3:22THE COMMON GOOD.
- 3:23AND OUR FRAMERS WHEN THEY
- 3:25DRAFTED THE CONSTITUTION FOR
- 3:27KENTUCKY, BACK IN 1792, WE'RE
- 3:31COGNIZANT OF THE FACT THAT
- 3:32PRIVATE SCHOOLS EXISTED THEN.
- 3:35IN FACT THEY WERE THE
- 3:37PREDOMINANT WAY OF SCHOOLING
- 3:38THAT EXISTED.
- 3:39IN TERMS OF EDUCATING THE VAST
- 3:41MAJORITY OF OUR DEMOCRACY,
- 3:43PUBLIC SCHOOLS WERE CREATED AND
- 3:45THEREFORE AS THEY ADOPTED OUR
- 3:47CONSTITUTION, WE'RE ONE OF THE
- 3:50STRICTEST 16 STRICTEST
- 3:51CONSTITUTIONS IN THE UNION.
- 3:52THAT IS FOR A REASON BECAUSE OUR
- 3:54FRAMERS WERE PROTECTIVE ABOUT
- 3:56OUR SYSTEM THAT WE HAVE CREATED
- 3:58AND WE HAVE ENJOYED FOR THE LAST
- 4:00230 YEARS.
- 4:02>> Renee: IF THIS AMENDMENT IS
- 4:03APPROVED IT STRIKES THAT
- 4:04LANGUAGE FROM ALL OF THOSE
- 4:06SECTIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION, I
- 4:07JUST READ IS THAT CORRECT?
- 4:08>> IT DOES.
- 4:10AND IT'S NORTH WORTHY THERE ARE
- 4:12SEVEN SECTIONS.
- 4:13IT IS NOT JUST A SLIGHT WORD OF
- 4:16CHANGE THERE ARE SEVEN SECTIONS
- 4:18OF THE CONSTITUTION.
- 4:19THIS IS A VERY DRAMATIC CHANGE
- 4:21ON BEHALF OF KENTUCKY
- 4:24POLITICIANS TO PUT THIS INTO THE
- 4:26HANDS OF THE VOTERS.
- 4:27I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD TAKE AT
- 4:29THAT TIME LIGHTLY.
- 4:29HOST OF US HONOR AND RECOGNIZE
- 4:32THOSE WHO HAVE COME BEFORE US,
- 4:34CERTAINLY THE HISTORIANS AND
- 4:36THOSE WHO CREATED AND DRAFTED
- 4:38THIS CONSTITUTION.
- 4:39BECAUSE I THINK THEY DID THAT
- 4:40WITH GREAT INTENT, BECAUSE THIS
- 4:42IS NOT A NEW ISSUE BEFORE THE
- 4:45COMMONWEALTH.
- 4:45IT EXISTED THEN AS IT EXISTS
- 4:47NOW.
- 4:48>> Renee: Mr. WATERS WE WANT
- 4:50TO CLARIFY IF THIS AMENDMENT
- 4:52PASSES DOES IT AUTOMATICALLY
- 4:53MEAN THAT THE KENTUCKY GENERAL
- 4:56ASSEMBLY MUST DO A, B OR C WHEN
- 4:58IT COMES TO SCHOOL CHOICE?
- 5:00DOES IT LAYOUT A PATH, DIRECTIVE
- 5:03OR POLICY THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO
- 5:05ADOPT?
- 5:05>> YOU JUST READ THE GENERAL
- 5:07ASSEMBLY MAY.
- 5:08IT DOESN'T SAY IT MUST PROVIDE
- 5:11OR RECOMMEND ANY POLICY.
- 5:15AMENDMENT 2 DOES NOT SETUP
- 5:17SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM.
- 5:18IT SIMPLY SAYS THAT THE STATE
- 5:20CONSTITUTION CANNOT BE
- 5:21INTERPRETED AS PROHIBITING SUCH
- 5:23PROGRAMS.
- 5:24AND I THINK IT'S UNREASONABLE TO
- 5:26THINK THE FOUND ESH OF OUR
- 5:28COMMONWEALTH THOSE HO RATIFIED
- 5:30THIS CONSTITUTION WAS 1891 THEY
- 5:32WERE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO
- 5:34KEEP PARENTS IN 2024 FROM HAVING
- 5:37OPTIONS THAT WOULD BEST FIT THE
- 5:39NEEDS OF THEIR CHILDREN.
- 5:40THIS IS NOT DRAMATIC.
- 5:42THIS IS SIMPLY CLARIFYING THAT
- 5:44OUR CONSTITUTION DOES NOT
- 5:46PROHIBIT GIVING PARENTS IN
- 5:47KENTUCKY THE SAME KIND OF
- 5:49EDUCATION FREEDOM THAT PARENTS
- 5:50IN MOST OTHER STATES INCLUDING
- 5:52EVERY STATE THAT SURROUNDS US
- 5:54THE SAME OPTIONS AND CHOICES.
- 5:56>> Renee: Mr. SHELTON DO,
- 5:58OBJECT TO THE FACT THIS
- 5:59AMENDMENT IS APPEARING ON THE
- 6:01BALLOT FOR KENTUCKY VOTERS TO
- 6:03DECIDE WHAT IS WRONG WITH
- 6:05LETTING KENTUCKY VOTERS HAVE THE
- 6:07SAY ON WHETHER OR NOT THE
- 6:09GENERAL ASSEMBLY CAN PROCEED
- 6:10WITH CONSIDERING CERTAIN OPTIONS
- 6:12THEY MAY HAVE THOUGHT OF BEFORE?
- 6:13SY.
- 6:14WELL, AS Mr. ROBINS MENTIONED
- 6:16WITH THE SEVEN SECTIONS OF THE
- 6:18CONSTITUTION IT WOULD BE SET
- 6:20ASIDE AND THAT'S ONE OF THE
- 6:22THINGS TO ME THE MOST ALARMING
- 6:24ABOUT THIS ISSUE BEING PUT
- 6:26BEFORE THE PEOPLE, IS OUR
- 6:30LEGISLATORS OUR POLITICIANS IN
- 6:32FRANKFORT ARE SAYING TO THE
- 6:34GENERAL PUBLIC, WE WANT YOU TO
- 6:36ALLOW US TO NOT WITHSTAND OR TO
- 6:40VIOLATE SEVEN SECTIONS OF THE
- 6:42CONSTITUTION THEY ARE KNOWINGLY
- 6:43ASKING MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
- 6:45WITHOUT FULLY DEFINING WHAT THE
- 6:47SEVEN SECTIONS ARE, WHAT THEY
- 6:50MEAN, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT IS
- 6:52MOST ALARMING TO ME IN THOSE
- 6:54SECTIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION IS
- 6:56I WILL HIGHLIGHT IS 183.
- 7:00SECTION 183 IS THE MOST FAMOUS
- 7:03OF THE SECTIONS RELATED TO
- 7:05PUBLIC SCHOOLS BECAUSE IT WAS
- 7:06WHAT WAS USED IN THE ROSE
- 7:08DECISION, FAMOUS ROSE DECISION
- 7:10IN 1990.
- 7:12THAT SAID THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY'S
- 7:14RESPONSIBILITY TO PROVIDE FOR AN
- 7:16EFFICIENT SYSTEM OF COMMON
- 7:17SCHOOLS.
- 7:18THIS WOULD ALLOW THE GENERAL
- 7:20ASSEMBLY TO BASICALLY VIOLATE
- 7:22THAT OR SET ASIDE THEIR
- 7:23RESPONSIBILITY TO OUR COMMON
- 7:25SCHOOLS AND THEREFORE 90% OF OUR
- 7:27STUDENTS IN KENTUCKY.
- 7:28I DON'T REALLY THINK THAT THAT'S
- 7:31SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE DECIDED
- 7:32THROUGH A BALLOT VOTE.
- 7:35THE OTHER THING ABOUT THAT, IS
- 7:37THAT WE HAVE TO LOOK AT THIS
- 7:39ISSUE AND RECOGNIZE THAT ALL
- 7:41SEVEN OF THESE ISSUES THAT THEY
- 7:43ARE TRYING TO SET ASIDE OF THE
- 7:46SECTIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION,
- 7:46ARE THE ONES THAT THEY HAVE LOST
- 7:49ON LITIGATION THAT HAS BEEN
- 7:51BROUGHT WHEN THEY HAVE VIOLATED
- 7:53THE CONSTITUTION BEFORE.
- 7:54SO THEY HAVE ALREADY SHOWN WHAT
- 7:57POLICY MEASURES THEY WANT TO TRY
- 7:59TO PASS, SO THEY DID THAT WITH
- 8:01HOUSE BILL 563, WITH HOUSE BILL
- 8:049, AND WE HAVE SUED EACH TIME.
- 8:07AND THESE ARE THE SECTIONS OF
- 8:08THE CONSTITUTION THAT WERE
- 8:10UPHELD UNANIMOUSLY BY THE
- 8:11SUPREME COURT.
- 8:12>> Renee: AND YOU WERE A PART OF
- 8:13THE COUNSEL FOR BETTER EDUCATION
- 8:15PART OF THE LAWSUITS, RIGHT?
- 8:18>> YES.
- 8:18>> Renee: AND THAT IS TRUE
- 8:19CHARTER SCHOOL LAW WAS PASSED IN
- 8:212017 MOST OF US REMEMBER IT WAS
- 8:24AN ORGANIZATIONAL SESSION AND
- 8:25THERE WERE SIGNIFICANT BILLS
- 8:27PASSED, SEVEN TO 10 I BELIEVE
- 8:29AND THIS WAS PASSED ON A FRIDAY
- 8:31AN EIGHT-HOUR MARATHON SESSION
- 8:33THAT PASSED HOUSE BILL 520.
- 8:35BUT IT HAS NOT BEEN FUNDED
- 8:37SINCE.
- 8:37YOU HAD THE 2021 SESSION 563 AND
- 8:41VETOED BY THE GOVERNOR AND
- 8:44KENTUCKY SUPREME COURT STRUCK
- 8:45THAT DOWN AND HOUSE BILL 9.
- 8:46WHICH PASSED AND ADDED RULES FOR
- 8:49FUNDING KENTUCKY CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 8:51AND INCLUDINGED ENROLLMENT GAPS
- 8:55AND THE JUDGE RULE THAT
- 8:57UNCONSTITUTIONAL.
- 8:57>> IF I CAN ADD QUICKLY HOUSE
- 8:59BILL 9 CHANGED THE ORIGINAL
- 9:02CHARTER SCHOOL LAW.
- 9:04IT WAS WRITTEN IN 2017 WITH THE
- 9:08PARTICIPATION OF OUR PUBLIC
- 9:10EDUCATORS.
- 9:10I ACTUALLY WAS PART OF THE
- 9:11COMMITTEE THAT WORKED WITH THE
- 9:13GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO HELP CRAFT
- 9:14THAT BILL.
- 9:16THAT WAS CHANGED WHEN HOUSE BILL
- 9:179 WAS FILED.
- 9:20THERE WERE PRIVATE CHARTER
- 9:21SCHOOLS THAT WERE ADDED TO THAT
- 9:23LANGUAGE.
- 9:24IN ADDITION TO THAT, THEY TOOK
- 9:25AWAY THE ABILITY FOR ANY
- 9:27DISTRICT OF 7500 STUDENTS OR
- 9:30MORE TO BE ABLE TO DENY A
- 9:32CHARTER SCHOOL IN THEIR
- 9:33DISTRICT.
- 9:34IN ADDITION TO THAT, THEY
- 9:35REQUIRED THE JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 9:37SCHOOLS AND NORTHERN KENTUCKY TO
- 9:39HAVE PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 9:40AND SO AGAIN, WE SUED ON THAT
- 9:42MEASURE AND WON.
- 9:44AND IT WILL SOON GO TO THE
- 9:46SUPREME COURT WHERE WE BELIEVE
- 9:47WE WILL PREVAIL AGAIN.
- 9:50BECAUSE WE DO NOT BELIEVE
- 9:52WHETHER IT IS A PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 9:54OR A PRIVATE CHARTER SCHOOL
- 9:56SHOULD RECEIVE STATE FUNDING.
- 9:58>> Renee: AND MADISON COUNTY IT
- 10:00WAS LAST YEAR WHERE THE SCHOOL
- 10:02BOARD DENIED THE APPLICATION FOR
- 10:04A CHARTER SCHOOL.
- 10:05AND THERE ARE NO CHARTER SCHOOLS
- 10:07OPERATING IN KENTUCKY.
- 10:08Mr. ADAMS I WANT TO COME TO
- 10:10YOU.
- 10:10YOU HAVE BEEN A TRADITIONAL
- 10:12PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATOR AND MANY
- 10:14PEOPLE WILL SAY HE LOOKS
- 10:16FAMILIAR.
- 10:17AND MAYBE I'VE SEEN HIM ON
- 10:18TELEVISION AND YOU ARE FEATURED
- 10:21IN THE AD FOR AMENDMENT NUMBER 2
- 10:23AS A PROPONENT WHICH MANY PEOPLE
- 10:27MAY FIND CURIOUS.
- 10:28WHY AS A PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATOR
- 10:31AT ONE TIME ARE YOU SUPPORTIVE
- 10:34OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TWO
- 10:35ON THE BALLOT THIS YEAR.
- 10:36>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
- 10:38I'VE BEEN IN THE CLASSROOM MORE
- 10:40RECENTLY THAN ANYBODY HERE.
- 10:42I'VE DRIVEN SCHOOL BUSES AND
- 10:44WORKED FROM PRESCHOOL THROUGH
- 10:4612TH GRADE.
- 10:46I HAVE A LOT OF EXPERIENCE.
- 10:49AND I'VE BEEN A PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 10:51SUPPORTER AND I STILL AM.
- 10:53I'M HERE NOT AS AN ENEMY OF
- 10:55PUBLIC SCHOOLS BUT A SUPPORTERS.
- 10:57SOMETIMES YOU SUPPORT BEST
- 10:58WHENEVER YOU CRITIQUE AND SAY WE
- 11:00HAVE TO WORK ON A FEW THINGS.
- 11:02SO FOR ME, I IN SEPTEMBER OF
- 11:042022 I WAS WORKING AS A DIRECTOR
- 11:06OF AN ALTERNATIVE SCHOOL IN
- 11:09ANDERSON COUNTY SCHOOLINGS.
- 11:12KDE CAME OUT WITH GUIDANCE ON
- 11:14STUDENT PRONOUNCES AND ASKED
- 11:18TEACHERS TO USE PRO NOUNS AND
- 11:25HIDE IT FROM BARENTS.
- 11:27MY WIFE AND I FELT TENSION, THE
- 11:30BEHAVIOR WAS GETTING WORSE.
- 11:32TEACHERS SHORTAGES ARE
- 11:33COMPOUNDING AND AMENDMENT 2 IS A
- 11:36WAY OF EMPOWERING PARENTS.
- 11:37I AM NOT ALARMED IF GIVING A
- 11:40PEOPLE A CHOICE ON THE
- 11:41CONSTITUTION WHEN I THINK ABOUT
- 11:43THE COMMON SCHOOLS I THINK ABOUT
- 11:45THE COMMON GOOD.
- 11:45I BELIEVE IN THEM TOO IT'S GOING
- 11:47TO OPEN DOORS FOR PARENTS TO
- 11:49WORK WITH SCHOOLS AND NEW WAYS
- 11:51AND ALSO EMPOWER TEACHERS TO NOT
- 11:53BE FORCED TO VIOLATE THEIR
- 11:55CONSCIENCE AND TO LIE TO
- 11:57PARENTS.
- 11:57WE SHOULD BE SERVING PARENTS NOT
- 11:59LYING TO THEM.
- 11:59AND WHEN I THINK ABOUT ALL OF
- 12:02THE LITIGATION THAT HAS BEEN
- 12:04MENTIONED TONIGHT I AM NOT A
- 12:06LOBBIEST NOT PAID BY ANYBODY TO
- 12:08BE HERE.
- 12:09I AM A FATHER WHO PULLED MY
- 12:11CHILDREN OUT OF PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 12:12AND MOVED THEM INTO PRIVATE.
- 12:14AND I WORK WITH TEACHERS WHO
- 12:16LEFT PUBLIC SCHOOL AND GO WOW I
- 12:18NEVER KNEW TEACHING COULD BE
- 12:20THIS FULFILLING.
- 12:21I'M SO RELIEVED AND I WANT MORE
- 12:24TEACHERS TO HAVE THAT
- 12:24OPPORTUNITY.
- 12:25TONIGHT I'M EXCITED TO BE ABLE
- 12:27TO SPEAK ON THESE ISSUES.
- 12:29>> Renee: AND WE ARE GLAD YOU
- 12:30ARE HERE TO DO SO.
- 12:31A QUESTION THAT COMES TO MIND
- 12:33WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT THAT ISSUE
- 12:35THAT DEALT WITH THE LGBTQ
- 12:37STUDENT POPULATION SOME WOULD
- 12:41SAY AS A CORRELATION DES THAT
- 12:43MEAN A PRIVATE SCHOOL CAN
- 12:45DISCRIMINATE AGAINST A STUDENT
- 12:46WHO IS PART OF THAT POPULATION?
- 12:49BASED ON PERHAPS THEY DON'T
- 12:51SUBSCRIBE TO THOSE BELIEFS
- 12:53BECAUSE THAT GETS AT ONE OF THE
- 12:55CORNERSTONE ARGUMENTS AGAINST
- 12:57THIS TYPE OF AMENDMENT IS THAT
- 12:59PRIVATE SCHOOLS CAN PLAY BY
- 13:01DIFFERENT RULES THEY CAN CHERRY
- 13:02PICK THEIR STUDENTS BASED ON
- 13:05ACADEMIC, DISCIPLINARY
- 13:06BACKGROUNDS OR SPECIAL NEEDS OR
- 13:08HOW THEY IDENTIFY?
- 13:09>> GREAT QUESTION.
- 13:10SO LET'S PUT THAT BACK WHEN I
- 13:12READ THOSE KDE GUIDELINES WE
- 13:16TALK ABOUT DISCRIMINATING
- 13:18AGAINST STUDENTS THEY MENTIONED
- 13:20MICRO AYESESES --
- 13:23AGGRESSIONS.
- 13:23IF WE HAD A STUDENT WHO WAS
- 13:26UNCOMFORTABLE CALLING A STUDENT
- 13:28BY A DIFFERENT PRONOUN OR NAME
- 13:30THEY COULD HAVE GOTTEN IN
- 13:31TROUBLE FROM THEIR PRINCIPAL.
- 13:32THEY COULD HAVE BEEN HELD
- 13:36RESPONSIBLE FOR BREAKING THE
- 13:38SCHOOL RULES.
- 13:38WE TALK ABOUT DISCRIMINATION
- 13:40AGAINST STUDENTS THAT IS ALREADY
- 13:41HAPPENING IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 13:43THE BEAUTIFUL THING ABOUT
- 13:45AMENDMENT 2, AND WE THINK ABOUT
- 13:46THE WORD IS EDUCATIONAL FREEDOM,
- 13:49RENEE IS THAT SCHOOLS CAN OPEN
- 13:51UP AND SERVE DIFFERENT NEEDS.
- 13:53YOU WILL HEAR SO MANY PEOPLE
- 13:54TALK ABOUT THE LGBTQ STUDENTS
- 13:56WHO ARE BEING BULLIED WHO THEIR
- 13:59SELF-WORTH THEY ARE STRUGGLING
- 14:00WITH DEPRESSION IN OUR SCHOOLS
- 14:02THEY WOULD HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
- 14:03TO OPEN UP SCHOOLS TO SERVE
- 14:06THOSE STUDENTS NEEDS.
- 14:07IT'S BEAUTIFUL TO ALLOW TEACHERS
- 14:09TO CREATE SETTINGS AND NICHES
- 14:11FOR STUDENTS TO GET WHAT THEY
- 14:12NEED.
- 14:13RIGHT NOW, I CAN SHARE THE
- 14:15BEHAVIOR DATA TONIGHT THAT SHOW
- 14:17OUR SCHOOLS HAVE BEEN MORE
- 14:19VIOLENT, MORE FILLED CAN
- 14:21DISRUPTIONS AND TEACHERS ARE
- 14:22REALLY STRUGGLING TO STAY IN THE
- 14:24PROFESSION BECAUSE THEY ARE
- 14:25UNHAPPY WITH WHAT'S GOING ON.
- 14:28>> Renee: WELL, BEFORE WE GO
- 14:29FURTHER BECAUSE WE'VE MENTIONED
- 14:31YOU ARE GOING TO SEE A LOT OF
- 14:33ADS ABOUT THIS ISSUE AND THEY
- 14:34ARE AIRING ON BOTH SIDES.
- 14:36AND OUR JUNE LEFFLER CAUGHT UP
- 14:40WITH PROPONENTS AND OPPONENTS
- 14:41THAT ARE PUTTING BOOTS ON THE
- 14:43GROUND.
- 14:44>> THE CAMPAIGN TO PASS
- 14:46AMENDMENT 2 IS REVVED UP AND
- 14:48HITTING THE ROAD.
- 14:49>> WE HAVE A GOAL OF REACHING
- 14:52225,000 PEOPLE JUST AT DOORS.
- 14:53>> THE CONSERVATIVE GROUP
- 14:55AMERICANS FOR PROSPERITY PUSHES
- 14:57SCHOOL CHOICE LAWS ACROSS THE
- 14:58NATION.
- 14:59BUT KENTUCKY POSES A NEW
- 15:02CHALLENGE.
- 15:02>> WELL, OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE NOT
- 15:04HAD TO GO THROUGH A BALLOT
- 15:06INITIATIVE IN ANY OTHER STATE
- 15:08BUT KENTUCKY WHICH IS NOT IDEAL
- 15:10WAY.
- 15:10>> THAT MEANS SELLING THE
- 15:12MESSAGE NOT JUST TO LAWMAKERS
- 15:13BUT ALL THE VOTERS THEY
- 15:15REPRESENT.
- 15:15>> WE KNOW THERE ARE PROBLEMS IN
- 15:18EDUCATION IN OUR STATE.
- 15:19WE KNOW THAT MATH AND READING
- 15:22PROFICIENCY IS NOT WHERE IT
- 15:23SHOULD BE.
- 15:24AND WE KNOW THAT WITH MORE
- 15:27OPTIONS IN EDUCATION THAT A LOT
- 15:29OF THOSE THINGS CAN BE
- 15:31ADDRESSED.
- 15:31>> AFP EXPLAINS THE OPTIONS AT A
- 15:35Q AND A.
- 15:36>> HOW MANY OF READ THE
- 15:38AMENDMENTS?
- 15:39WE HAVE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO
- 15:40HAVE, THAT'S GREAT.
- 15:41>> STATE LAWMAKERS SUPPORTS
- 15:43CHARTER SCHOOLS THE GENERAL
- 15:44ASSEMBLY APPROVED THEM BUT
- 15:46KENTUCKY COURTS HAVE BLOCKED
- 15:47THEM.
- 15:48>> THEY WOULD FALL UNDERNEATH
- 15:50ALL OF THE STANDARDS OF OUR
- 15:52STATE TESTING AND FALL UNDER ALL
- 15:54OF THE KDE GUIDELINES HOWEVER
- 15:57THEY WOULD NOT FALL UNDER ALL OF
- 15:59THE RED TAPE THAT WE HAVE IN OUR
- 16:01PUBLIC SCHOOLS THEY WOULD HAVE
- 16:02MORE FREEDOM.
- 16:03>> AFP STAYS AWAY FROM A MORE
- 16:06CONTROVERSIAL SCHOOL CHOICE
- 16:08MECHANISM.
- 16:09>> I DON'T KNOW WHY IT'S CALLED
- 16:11THE VOUCH ARE AMENDMENT.
- 16:12>> THIS AMENDMENT ALLOWS US TO
- 16:14BEGIN MOVING LEGISLATION FORWARD
- 16:16AND FUNDING STATUTES THAT
- 16:18ALREADY EXIST.
- 16:19IF VOUCHERS ARE GOING TO COME,
- 16:21IT'S GOING TO COME DOWN THE
- 16:23ROAD.
- 16:23>> AN EDUCATION POLICY EXPERT
- 16:26SAYS VOUCHERS ARE A DISASTER.
- 16:27>> OVER THE LAST DECADE VOUCHERS
- 16:30HAVE CAUSED THE WORST ACADEMIC
- 16:34DECLINES ON ANYTHING IN THE
- 16:35RESEARCH COMMUNITY.
- 16:36>> SCHOOL VOUCHERS PROVIDE
- 16:38PUBLIC DOLLARS TO HELP PAY FOR A
- 16:41STUDENT'S PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 16:42TUITION.
- 16:42>> IT'S IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT
- 16:4470% OF VOUCHER USERS IN STATE
- 16:46AFTER STATE WERE ALREADY IN
- 16:48PRIVATE SCHOOL TO BEGIN WITH.
- 16:49BUT FOR THE 25% OR 30% OF KIDS
- 16:52WHO DO TRANSFER FROM PUBLIC TO
- 16:54PRIVATE SCHOOL YOU SEE THE
- 16:56RECORD ACADEMIC DECLINES ON
- 16:58THEIR OUTCOMES.
- 17:00AND THE REASON IS THAT THE
- 17:02SCHOOLS THAT HAVE OPEN SEATS TO
- 17:03TAKE THOSE TRANSFERS, TEND TO BE
- 17:05WHAT I CALL SUBPRIME PROVIDERS.
- 17:08THEY HAVE OPEN SEATS FOR A
- 17:10REASON.
- 17:10>> POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
- 17:12TIED TO RAND PAUL RELEASED THIS
- 17:14AD IN KENTUCKY.
- 17:15>> VOTE YES ON AMENDMENT 2 FOR
- 17:17EDUCATIONAL FREEDOM.
- 17:18>> JOSH COHEN WHO WROTE THE BOOK
- 17:22HOW BILLIONAIRES SOLD SCHOOL
- 17:25VOUCHERS SAYS POLITICAL
- 17:26MESSAGING AROUND PARENTS' CHOICE
- 17:28IS MISLEADING.
- 17:29>> WHEN IT COMES TO THE VOUCHER
- 17:31PLAN IT'S THE SCHOOL CHOICE
- 17:34NOTHING IN THE LEGISLATION IN
- 17:35ANY STATE RIGHT NOW, THAT'S
- 17:37PASSED THE VOUCHER SYSTEM
- 17:39COMPELS THOSE PRIVATE SCHOOLS TO
- 17:41TAKE YOUR KID.
- 17:42YOU ARE STILL ON YOUR OWN AND
- 17:43FIND YOU A SCHOOL TO ALLOW YOU
- 17:46TO USE THE VOUCHER.
- 17:47>> ADVOCATES SAY IT WON'T OPEN
- 17:50THE FLOODGATES.
- 17:51>> WE'RE TRYING TO TALK TO
- 17:53PEOPLE AT EVENTS AND GATHERINGS
- 17:55WHAT THE TYPES OF SCHOOL CHOICE
- 17:57OPTIONS THERE ARE.
- 17:58AND I THINK IT WILL BE IMPORTANT
- 18:00FOR CONSTITUENTS TO TALK TO
- 18:02THEIR LEGISLATORS WHAT THEY WANT
- 18:04TO SEE.
- 18:04>> KENTUCKY'S GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 18:06HAS NOT TOUCHED VOUCHER PER SE.
- 18:08LAWMAKERS DID APPROVE A
- 18:10PRIVATELY FUNDED SCHOLARSHIP
- 18:12SYSTEM THAT OFFERED TAX CREDITS
- 18:13TO DONORS.
- 18:15THE KENTUCKY SUPREME COURT
- 18:16BLOCKED THAT IN 2022.
- 18:20FOR "KENTUCKY TONIGHT" I'M JUNE
- 18:22LEFFLER.
- 18:23>> Renee: THANK YOU FOR THAT.
- 18:24I WANT TO GO TO YOU Mr. WATERS
- 18:26WE HAVE SEVERAL OF THESE AND
- 18:27THIS IS A SUCCINCT WAY OF ASKING
- 18:31THIS WHAT LAWMAKERS HAVE TO TAKE
- 18:33MONEY FROM PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND
- 18:34RAISE TAXES FOR THIS TO WORK?
- 18:37FOR SCHOOL CHOICE TO WORK?
- 18:39>> ASK THAT AGAIN.
- 18:42>> Renee: WON'T LAWMAKERS HAVE
- 18:43TO TAKE MONEY FROM PUBLIC
- 18:45SCHOOLS TO RAISE TAXES TO
- 18:47PROVIDE FOR SCHOOL CHOICE
- 18:49OPTIONS SUCH AS PERHAPS MAYBE
- 18:51SCHOOL VOUCHERS?
- 18:52>> THE DOLLARS ARE FOR WHAT
- 18:55PURPOSE?
- 18:56THE DOLLARS ARE FOR EDUCATING
- 18:57STUDENTS.
- 18:58WE'VE HEARD ABOUT PROTECT OUR
- 19:00SCHOOLS WHAT ABOUT EDUCATE OUR
- 19:02STUDENTS AND WHAT ABOUT SERVE
- 19:03OUR STUDENTS AND MAKING SURE WE
- 19:05CLOSE THESE ACHIEVEMENT GAPS
- 19:07BETWEEN BLACK AND WHITE STUDENTS
- 19:09THAT HAVE GROWN MANY YEARS.
- 19:11THE DOLLARS ARE FOR EDUCATING
- 19:13STUDENTS AND THAT'S WHAT WE
- 19:15DON'T HEAR OPPONENTS MUCH AT ALL
- 19:17ABOUT THE PERFORMANCE THE
- 19:19OUTCOMES OF OUR EDUCATIONAL
- 19:20SYSTEM.
- 19:21IF A STUDENT GETS EDUCATED AT A
- 19:23PUBLIC SCHOOL OR A PUBLIC
- 19:25CHARTER SCHOOL THEY ARE PUBLIC
- 19:27SCHOOLS WITH ALL DUE RESPECT AND
- 19:31PRIVATE SCHOOL IF THEY ARE
- 19:32GETTING EDUCATED THEN THE
- 19:33DOLLARS ARE PROPERLY USED.
- 19:36>> Renee: THE DOLLAR FOLLOWS THE
- 19:39CHILD.
- 19:39>> THEY ARE GETTING EDUCATED AS
- 19:41YOU ALL SAID THE CONSTITUTION
- 19:43REQUIRES THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO
- 19:44PROVIDE FOR AN EFFICIENT,
- 19:46EFFECTIVE SYSTEM OF EDUCATION.
- 19:48SO IF WE'RE SPENDING $24,000
- 19:51LIKE WE ARE IN JEFFERSON COUNTY,
- 19:52AND YET, ONLY A THIRD OF THE
- 19:54STUDENTS ARE PROFICIENT IN MATH
- 19:56AND READING I DON'T THINK MANY
- 19:58KENTUCKIANS WOULD CONSIDER THAT
- 20:00TO BE EFFICIENT.
- 20:01THEREFORE, IF IT'S NOT WORKING,
- 20:03THEN WE HAVE TO SAY WHAT IS IT
- 20:05THAT WE CAN DO THAT WILL HELP
- 20:07CLOSE TOES GAPS AND WHAT WE
- 20:09FOUND IN OTHER STATES FROM
- 20:10FLORIDA TO ARIZONA TO
- 20:12CALIFORNIA, THERE ARE 1220
- 20:15CHARTER SCHOOLS IN CALIFORNIA
- 20:16AND THOSE STATES ARE CLOSING THE
- 20:18GAPS.
- 20:19THE BLACK STUDENTS IN FLORIDA'S
- 20:20CHARTER SCHOOLS ARE
- 20:22OUTPERFORMING THE BLACK STUDENTS
- 20:23IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS IN KEY
- 20:26AREAS OF MATH AND READING.
- 20:28AND TO THE YOUR POINT ABOUT
- 20:32ARIZONA, AND TO THE POINT OF THE
- 20:35EXPERT ON THE FILM THERE THAT
- 20:38TALKED ABOUT VOUCHERS THAT MOST
- 20:39OF THE PEOPLE IN ARE IN PROGRAMS
- 20:42ARE IN PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 20:43THE PROBLEM IS THAT THESE STATES
- 20:47HAVE HAD LONG STANDING SCHOOL
- 20:48CHOICE PROGRAMS.
- 20:49LIKE IN ARIZONA FOR EXAMPLE,
- 20:51THEY'VE HAD PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 20:53CHOICE PROGRAMS FOR A LONGTIME.
- 20:54SO THERE ARE KIDS THAT HAVE BEEN
- 20:56IN THOSE PROGRAMS AND THAT WOULD
- 20:59BENEFIT FROM HAVING AN EXPANSION
- 21:00OF SCHOOL CHOICE THEY ARE
- 21:01ALREADY IN.
- 21:03IT'S NOT THAT THEY WEREN'T IN
- 21:04PUBLIC SCHOOLS THEY TOOK
- 21:05ADVANTAGE OF EARLIER SCHOOL
- 21:07CHOICE PROGRAMS.
- 21:08AND SO THEY ARE NOT COUNTED AS
- 21:10COMING FROM PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 21:11THEY ARE COUNTED AS ALREADY
- 21:13BEING IN PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 21:14>> Renee: SURE.
- 21:15AND PROFESSOR COHEN DID MENTION
- 21:17HOW IT'S NOT SCHOOL CHOICE IT'S
- 21:19THE SCHOOL'S CHOICE IN ORDER TO
- 21:22THEY COULD PICK AND DECIDE WHICH
- 21:23STUDENTS THEY WANTED TO ACCEPT.
- 21:25I WANTED TO GET YOUR RESPONSE TO
- 21:27THAT?
- 21:28>> THE SCHOOL CHOICE LEGISLATION
- 21:30PASSED HERE IN KENTUCKY, LEAVES
- 21:33THAT DECISION UP TO THE PARENTS.
- 21:35HOUSE BILL 563, WOULD HAVE GIVEN
- 21:38PARENTS THE CONTROL OF THOSE
- 21:40DOLLARS AND WHERE THE DOLLARS
- 21:41ARE SPENT.
- 21:43IT WASN'T ANY SCHOOL'S DECISION
- 21:44IT WAS THE PARENTS' DECISION AND
- 21:46THAT IS THE KEY IN SCHOOL CHOICE
- 21:49PROGRAMS IT'S PARENTAL CHOICE
- 21:50THAT IS CREATING THE KAI
- 21:52UNANIMOUS McS IN STATES LIKE
- 21:54FLORIDA.
- 21:55WHERE HALF A MILLION STUDENTS
- 21:56ARE IN PROGRAMS BECAUSE OF
- 21:57SCHOOL CHOICE LEGISLATION, AND
- 22:00THEY ARE IMPROVING THEIR PUBLIC
- 22:02EDUCATION SYSTEM DRAMATICALLY.
- 22:04AND THE MAJOR DIFFERENCE IN
- 22:05FLORIDA AND KENTUCKY IS THEY
- 22:06HAVE MORE OPTIONS FOR PARENTS.
- 22:09>> Renee: MILWAUKEE HAS A
- 22:10COUNTER EXPERIENCE.
- 22:11THEY STARTED VOUCHERS IN CHARTER
- 22:13SCHOOLS 30 YEARS AGO WHEN
- 22:15ACCORDING TO A REPORT FROM THE
- 22:17WISCONSIN POLICY FORUM PUBLICLY
- 22:19FUNDED PRIVATE SCHOOL PROGRAMS
- 22:21AND INDEPENDENTSLY RUN CHARTER
- 22:23SCHOOLS AND 40% OF THE CITY'S
- 22:24STUDENTS AFTER 30 YEARS THERE'S
- 22:27LITTLE EVIDENCE THAT THE AVERAGE
- 22:29MILWAUKEE CHILD RECEIVES A
- 22:30HIGHER EDUCATION THAN THEY DID
- 22:3130 YEARS AGO?
- 22:34>> SO ONE SIZE DOES NOT FIT ALL.
- 22:38AND I THINK WE SHOULD OFFER
- 22:41PARENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO
- 22:42DECIDE.
- 22:43IF A SCHOOL IS NOT EDUCATING
- 22:45THEIR CHILDREN AND THEY DECIDE
- 22:47TO ENROLL THEM SOMEWHERE ELSE
- 22:49WHETHER THAT IS A PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 22:50OR A CHARTER SCHOOL, THAT'S THE
- 22:53GREATEST TYPE OF ACCOUNTABILITY
- 22:55YOU CAN HAVE IS PARENTS MAKING
- 22:57THAT DECISION NOT SOME STUDENT
- 22:59ASSIGNMENT PERSONNEL AT THE
- 23:00CENTRAL OFFICE THEY DON'T KNOW
- 23:02WHAT THAT CHILD NEEDS AS MUCH AS
- 23:04THE PARENT DOES.
- 23:05>> Renee: Mr. ADAMS?
- 23:06>> ECONOMIC POLICY CENTER IN
- 23:08ANOTHER STATE I WANT TO POINT
- 23:10SOMETHING OUT THAT SOMEBODY
- 23:11SHARED WITH ME.
- 23:12EDDIE CAMPBELL IS THE PRESIDENT
- 23:14OF THE KENTUCKY EDUCATION
- 23:16ASSOCIATION.
- 23:17THE RESEARCH THAT PROTECT OUR
- 23:19SCHOOLS KY PUTS OUT CITING ALL
- 23:21OF THE NEGATIVE IMPACTS IT'S
- 23:23COMING FROM THE KENTUCKY CENTER
- 23:25FOR ECONOMIC POLICY.
- 23:26WHAT IS INTERESTING ON THEIR TAX
- 23:28STATEMENTS, EDDIE CAMPBELL IS
- 23:31LISTED AS A DIRECTOR.
- 23:32IS THAT A DIFFERENT EDDIE
- 23:35CAMPBELL?
- 23:36IS THE KEA PRESIDENT A DIRECTOR
- 23:40ON THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR
- 23:42ECONOMIC POLICY.
- 23:44OR ARE THERE ARE TWO EDDIE
- 23:46CAMPBELLS?
- 23:47THE INFORMATION ABOUT PUBLIC
- 23:48SCHOOLS PERFORMING WORSE, I
- 23:50THINK THERE'S THINGS MISLEADING
- 23:52THAT ARE COMING ON THIS MOVEMENT
- 23:54AGAINST AMENDMENT 2.
- 23:55AND YOU ALSO ASKED ABOUT SCHOOLS
- 23:57CAN CHOOSE YOUR CHILD.
- 23:58I WANT TO SHARE THAT HIGHLIGHTS
- 24:00A PROBLEM IN SCHOOLS.
- 24:01SCHOOLS ARE TRYING TO FOCUS ON
- 24:05EVERYTHING AND THEY ARE FOCUSING
- 24:06ON NOTHING WELL.
- 24:08SCHOOLS ARE TRYING TO CATER TO
- 24:10KEEP THEM THERE AND KEEP THE
- 24:12MONEY FLOWING.
- 24:12WHAT HAPPENS IS IF YOU LOOK AT
- 24:14THE KENTUCKY SAFETY REPORT CARD
- 24:16IN KENTUCKY WILL SCHOOLS THERE
- 24:18WERE 7,000 ASSAULTS.
- 24:20THERE WERE 18,000 STUDENTS
- 24:22BULLIED.
- 24:22THIS IS WHAT IS ON THE CAMPUS.
- 24:25DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY STUDENTS
- 24:27WERE SUSPENDED IN THE ENTIRE
- 24:28STATE?
- 24:2930.
- 24:30THERE WERE 30 STUDENTS EXPELLED
- 24:33IN KENTUCKY.
- 24:33THERE WERE 13 31ST DEGREE
- 24:36ASSAULTS.
- 24:37SO I JUST THINK THAT WE HAVE TO
- 24:39THINK ABOUT IF SCHOOLS ARE
- 24:41TALLYING A SCHOOL FOR ALL, KIDS
- 24:43HAVE GOTTEN HURT AND TRAUMATIZED
- 24:45AT SCHOOL BECAUSE WE ARE NOT
- 24:46HAVING THE COURAGE TO MAKE
- 24:48SCHOOLS SAFE AND WE'RE NOT
- 24:49HAVING THE COURAGE TO MAKE SURE
- 24:51THAT KIDS RNTS' BEING HURT BY
- 24:54THEIR PEERS.
- 24:55>> Renee: WHAT WOULD YOU DO WITH
- 24:56THE KIDS WHO ARE THE PERPETRATOR
- 24:58OF THOSE ASSAULTS?
- 25:00WHERE SHOULD THEY GO?
- 25:01>> THEY THE CHARTER SCHOOLS WILL
- 25:03BE A GREAT THING FOR US TO
- 25:05UNLOCK THE DOOR AND LET PUBLIC
- 25:08SCHOOLS THAT TAKE FOLKS THAT
- 25:10COULD TAILOR TO THOSE NEEDS.
- 25:13>> Renee: THAT IS ALTERNATIVE
- 25:16SCHOOLS, CORRECT?
- 25:16>> THAT IS WHAT I DID.
- 25:18SO LET ME EXPLAIN WHAT THAT
- 25:20LOOKS LIKE.
- 25:21OKAY.
- 25:21A LOT OF TIMES THOSE KIDS THAT
- 25:23CAUSED PROBLEMS ARE SENT HOME
- 25:24AND PUT ON A CHROME BOOK.
- 25:26AND THEY SIT ON A CHROME BOOK
- 25:28AND LEARN AT HOME.
- 25:30WHENEVER I WOULD NOTICE KIDS ARE
- 25:32NOT LEARNING AND THIS KID IS
- 25:34FALLING BEHIND MAKE IT EASIER TO
- 25:36GET HIM A DIPLOMA.
- 25:37WE DON'T WANT TO TALK ABOUT
- 25:40THAT, BUT THAT IS GOING ON
- 25:41BEHIND THE SCENES.
- 25:42WE CAN CUT OUT PROGRAMS THAT
- 25:45DON'T WORK, A DISCIPLINARY
- 25:48PROGRAM RESTORATIVE CARE
- 25:50PROGRAMS THAT REPLACED
- 25:52DISCIPLINE AND STRUCTURE.
- 25:53>> Renee: THIS SOUNDS LIKE THIS
- 25:55IS EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE.
- 25:57>> IT'S WREAKED HAVOC IN OUR
- 26:00SCHOOLS.
- 26:00>> THE WHOLE CHILD CONCEPT.
- 26:02>> I THINK THE QUESTION THAT
- 26:03CAME IN IS BASICALLY WHERE DO
- 26:05THE DOLLARS COME FROM?
- 26:07IF I RECALL GOING BACK TO THAT.
- 26:09AND I THINK A CRITICAL QUESTION
- 26:13THERE IS YOU KNOW THERE'S TWO
- 26:15WAYS TO BALANCE A BUDGE BUDGET.
- 26:17IT'S NOT COMPLICATED YOU REDUCE
- 26:19EXPENSES OR INCREASE REVENUE.
- 26:22WHEN WE LOOK ACROSS THE LAND
- 26:23SCAPE AND ARIZONA THAT WAS
- 26:25CITED, WE LOOK AT INDIANA, WE
- 26:27LOOK AT OHIO, WE LOOK AT
- 26:30FLORIDA, FLORIDA'S $4 BILLION
- 26:31NOW INTO IT.
- 26:34AND CANNOT TELL US WITH ANY
- 26:37CERTAINTY BECAUSE FLORIDA WON'T
- 26:39LET ANYONE INTO TO THE STATE
- 26:41THAT PROVIDES AN OBJECTIVE
- 26:42OPINION OUTSIDE OF SOMEONE THAT
- 26:44IS HIRED TO GIVE THAT OPINION.
- 26:49AND I THINK ARIZONA AND OHIO
- 26:52BOTH ADD A BILLION INTO THE
- 26:54COST.
- 26:54NOW WE LOOK AT THE OUTCOMES
- 26:57ACADEMICALLY AGAIN FROM
- 26:59OBJECTIVE, INDEPENDENT EVIDENCE
- 27:01OHIO VOUCHERS ARE NEGATIVE ZERO
- 27:05POINT 5.
- 27:06LUIS LUIS VOUCHERS 0.4.
- 27:09>> Renee: WHAT IS THE NEGATIVE
- 27:11IN TERMS OF ACADEMIC SCORING?
- 27:14>> IN TERMS OF GROWTH IT'S
- 27:16REGRESSION THAT'S OCCURRED BY
- 27:18THE STATE INTRODUCING VOUCHERS.
- 27:21INDIANA 0.15.
- 27:23THE THING ABOUT THIS IS IS THAT
- 27:25WE'RE GOING TO SPEND A LOT OF
- 27:28MONEY, OKAY, IF THE YES VOTERS
- 27:31WIN TO WHAT END THAT WE'RE NOT
- 27:34UNDETERMINABLE IN TERMS OF HOW
- 27:36IT AFFECTS POSITIVELY STUDENT
- 27:38ACHIEVEMENT.
- 27:38I WOULD APPEAL THOSE
- 27:41CONSERVATIVES IS THESE STATES
- 27:42ARE SPENDING OVER A BILLION
- 27:44DOLLARS AND KNTS' TELL YOU?
- 27:47WHERE THE OUTCOME IS.
- 27:48AND THEN THE OTHER POINT I THINK
- 27:49I WANT TO MAKE HERE THAT I
- 27:52CANNOT FIND ANYONE WHO HAS EVER
- 27:54BEEN ABLE TO GIVE ME A COGENT
- 27:57ANSWER TO THIS.
- 27:5875% ON AVERAGE OF VOUCHER
- 28:02RECIPIENTS ACROSS VOUCHER STATES
- 28:03WERE ALREADY STUDENTS OF PRIVATE
- 28:05SCHOOLS.
- 28:06>> Renee: HE SAID THE SAME,
- 28:07Mr. WATERS.
- 28:08HE SAID THAT.
- 28:10>> THOSE --
- 28:12THESE ARE THE SAME STUDENTS WHO
- 28:14YESTERDAY UNFUNDED BY THE
- 28:16GOVERNMENT, OKAY, WERE STUDENTS
- 28:18IN A PRIVATE SCHOOL TOMORROW
- 28:20FUNDED BY THE GOVERNMENT AT A
- 28:22TUNE OF 75%.
- 28:23>> THAT'S BECAUSE MANY OF THE
- 28:25FAMILIES WERE STRUGGLING TO GIVE
- 28:27THEIR CHILDREN A BETTER
- 28:28EDUCATION.
- 28:28AND I THINK IT'S OUR
- 28:30RESPONSIBILITY OUR MORAL
- 28:31RESPONSIBILITY TO HELP FAMILIES
- 28:32WHO DON'T HAVE LARGE INCOMES.
- 28:35>> Renee: WE DON'T KNOW THAT.
- 28:37>> 75%.
- 28:38HOW MUCH CHOICE YOU SEE WHERE
- 28:41I'M GOING WITH THIS HOW MUCH
- 28:43CHOICE DO PEOPLE HAVE WHEN THREE
- 28:46OUT OF FOUR WERE STUDENTS IN A
- 28:47PRIVATE SCHOOL THAT LEAVES 25%
- 28:50FOR EVERYBODY ELSE TO GO FOR.
- 28:51>> AND NOT TO MENTION THE FACT
- 28:54THAT THESE OTHER STATES TRYING
- 28:56TO SAY THAT KENTUCKY SHOULD DO
- 28:58THIS BECAUSE SOME OTHER STATE
- 28:59DID IT THAT REMINDS ME WHEN I
- 29:02MOM USED TO SAY IF EVERYBODY
- 29:04ELSE IS JUMPING OFF A CLIFF DOES
- 29:05THAT MEAN YOU NEED TO DO SO AS
- 29:07WELL?
- 29:08THAT HAS NO RATIONAL LOGIC
- 29:10BECAUSE OTHER STATES ARE DOING
- 29:11IT WE SHOULD DO IT.
- 29:13AS MATT POINTED OUT THEY DON'T
- 29:15HAVE POSITIVE RESULTS.
- 29:16THE OTHER THING IS KENTUCKY IS
- 29:18NOT A GOOD FIT FOR THIS.
- 29:19IT IS NOT A GOOD MATCH.
- 29:21IF YOU LOOK AT WHERE THE PRIVATE
- 29:23SCHOOLS ARE, THERE ARE IN THREE
- 29:27COUNTIES HAVE 52% OF THE PRIVATE
- 29:30SCHOOLS IN THE STATE.
- 29:32JEFFERSON COUNTY HAS 33% OF THEM
- 29:34ALONE IN JEFFERSON COUNTY.
- 29:36THAT 80% OF KENTUCKY'S PRIVATE
- 29:38SCHOOLS ARE LOCATED IN JUST
- 29:41EIGHT ZIP CODES OF OUR STATE.
- 29:44MOST COUNTIES MOST SCHOOL
- 29:47DISTRICTS DO NOT HAVE A PRIVATE
- 29:48SCHOOL FOR THEIR CHILD TO
- 29:49CHOOSE.
- 29:49THERE IS NO CHOICE AVAILABLE FOR
- 29:51THEM.
- 29:52AND SO WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN IS
- 29:54RURAL COMMUNITIES BECAUSE OF THE
- 29:55WAY OUR FUNDING FORMULA WORKS
- 29:57ARE GOING TO BE SENDING MONEY TO
- 29:59THE WEALTHIER COUNTIES AND TO
- 30:01THE TRIANGLE AS WE KNOW IT IN
- 30:03OUR STATE AND THAT'S WHERE THE
- 30:05PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE AND WHERE
- 30:06THE MONEY WILL GO.
- 30:07ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S MOST
- 30:09IRRITATING TO ME THAT I HEAR
- 30:11ABOUT JEFFERSON COUNTY OVER AND
- 30:12OVER AGAIN, IS HOW MUCH MONEY
- 30:14IT'S COSTING IN JEFFERSON
- 30:16COUNTY.
- 30:16WE DON'T SEEM TO REALIZE IS THAT
- 30:19WITH KENTUCKY SCHOOL FUNDING
- 30:21FORMULA, JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 30:23TAXPAYERS THEMSELVES FUND 80% OF
- 30:25THE COST OF EDUCATION IN THEIR
- 30:27OWN COMMUNITY.
- 30:28THE STATE ONLY PROVIDES 20% OF
- 30:31THAT COST.
- 30:32THAT'S THE WAY OUR FUNDING
- 30:34FORMULA WORKS.
- 30:35WHEN YOU HAVE A LARGE, STRONG,
- 30:37TAX BASE THE LOCAL TAXPAYERS
- 30:39BEAR THE BRUNT NOT THE STATE.
- 30:41SO WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IN THE CASE
- 30:43OF FUNDING FOR A VOUCHER IN
- 30:46JEFFERSON COUNTY MOST LIKELY AT
- 30:48MOST IT COULD BE THE SAME AMOUNT
- 30:50THAT THE STATE CONTRIBUTES TO A
- 30:52PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENT WHICH IS
- 30:54$2400 IN JEFFERSON COUNTY.
- 30:56>> Renee: THAT IS A QUESTION IS
- 30:57HOW MUCH WHEN STATES THAT HAVE
- 30:59VOUCHERS, THE AVERAGE VOUCHER IS
- 31:02$7,000.
- 31:03DO THE PRIVATE INSTITUTIONS DO
- 31:05THEY KEEP THE TUITION AT SUCH A
- 31:08RATE WHERE SOMEONE OF A LOWER
- 31:10SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS CAN AFFORD
- 31:12TO STILL GO THERE?
- 31:13OR DO THEY HAVE TO PONY UP
- 31:16ANOTHER FIVE, SEVEN, 10, 15,000
- 31:19DOLLARS TO TRY TO GET INTO A
- 31:20SCHOOL ALLEGEDLY DESIGNED FOR
- 31:22CHILDREN LIKE THEIR CHILD?
- 31:24>> WE'RE FINDING ACROSS THE
- 31:25COUNTRY THAT SCHOOLS OF CHOICE
- 31:27ARE WORKING WITH PARENTS TO FIND
- 31:29A WAY TO EDUCATE STUDENTS
- 31:31BECAUSE THEIR GOAL IS TO EDUCATE
- 31:33STUDENTS NOT FUND A SYSTEM NOT
- 31:34PROP UP A SYSTEM IT'S TO EDUCATE
- 31:36THE STUDENTS.
- 31:37WHATEVER THAT TAKES.
- 31:38THAT'S WHY WE SEE SUCCESSFUL
- 31:40CHARTER SCHOOLS AND PRIVATE
- 31:42SCHOOLS EDUCATING KIDS AT HALF
- 31:44THE COST OR LESS THAN IN OUR
- 31:46PUBLIC SYSTEM.
- 31:47WE HAVE INCREASED FUNDING IN
- 31:49KENTUCKY PER PUPIL FUNDING BY
- 31:52122%.
- 31:52WE ARE NOW SPENDING MORE THAN
- 31:55$20,000 PER PUPIL WHEN YOU TAKE
- 31:57ALL THE REVENUE SOURCES TOGETHER
- 32:00THAT IS STATE, LOCAL AND FEDERAL
- 32:03THE POINT IS THEY ARE ALL FOR
- 32:04EDUCATING STUDENTS.
- 32:05SO I WONDER ABOUT THE TAXPAYERS
- 32:07IN JEFFERSON COUNTY IF THEY ARE
- 32:09HAPPY WITH THE OUTCOMES AND
- 32:10HAPPY WITH THE RETURN ON
- 32:12INVESTMENT.
- 32:12AND THE OTHER THING IS I JUST
- 32:14HEAR WHAT THE OTHER SIDE'S
- 32:16AGAINST WE'RE AGAINST OFFERING
- 32:18PARENTS CHOICE.
- 32:19WE'RE AGAINST EXPANDING
- 32:20OPPORTUNITY.
- 32:21WE'RE AGAINST SCHOOL CHOICE AND
- 32:23YET WE'RE FOR OFFERING PARENTS
- 32:25MORE OPPORTUNITIES.
- 32:26THIS IS NOT AN EITHER OR OPTION
- 32:29TO FIT THEIR NARRATIVE IT HAS TO
- 32:31BE EITHER OR.
- 32:32OURS IS AS RANDY SAID BOTH AND
- 32:35THAT WE FIND IN STATES LIKE
- 32:37FLORIDA AND THE DATA COMES FROM
- 32:39CREDIBLE SOURCES.
- 32:39THANK YOU I APPRECIATE THE
- 32:41CONCERN ABOUT SOURCES.
- 32:42BUT IT COMES FROM THEIR
- 32:43DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION.
- 32:46THAT SHOWS THE MORE CHOICES
- 32:47FLORIDA'S PARENTS HAVE HAD THE
- 32:49BETTER THE PUBLIC EDUCATION HAS
- 32:51PERFORMED.
- 32:51A RISING TIDE LIFTS ALL BOATS.
- 32:54WE JUST RELEASED AN ANALYSIS OF
- 32:56TEACHER PAY.
- 32:57TEACHERS ARE BENEFITING ACROSS
- 32:59THE COUNTRY FROM SCHOOL CHOICE
- 33:00THEY ARE HAVING MORE OPTIONS
- 33:02WHERE THEY WANT TO TEACH.
- 33:03IF THEY WANT TO TEACH IN A SAFER
- 33:05SCHOOL THEY HAVE THAT OPTION AND
- 33:07SEEING INCREASES IN THEIR PAY
- 33:08ACROSS THE BOARD, PUBLIC,
- 33:10CHARTER AND PRIVATE.
- 33:12>> THERE'S TWO INCORRECT
- 33:14STATEMENTS JUST MADE THERE.
- 33:15WE HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH SCHOOL
- 33:18CHOICE.
- 33:18CHOICE ALREADY EXISTS.
- 33:20THIS DOES NOT CREATE ANY CHOICE
- 33:21THAT WASN'T ALREADY THERE.
- 33:23WHAT IT DOES IT TAKES PUBLIC
- 33:25DOLLARS TO PAY FOR THAT CHOICE.
- 33:27IT IS A MEANS OF PRIVATIZATION.
- 33:30THIS IS A MEANS OF TAKING MONEY
- 33:32THAT IS SET ASIDE FOR THE PUBLIC
- 33:34COMMON GOOD FOR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 33:36AND TAKING IT AND SENDING IT TO
- 33:39UNACCOUNTABLE PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 33:40THAT'S THE FIRST THING.
- 33:41AND WE DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH
- 33:43SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 33:44SCHOOL CHOICE WHEN WE FIRST
- 33:46STARTED HAS BEEN THERE FOR
- 33:48HUNDREDS OF YEARS THE AND WILL
- 33:50CONTINUE TO BE.
- 33:52WE'RE --
- 33:52WE DON'T OPPOSE SCHOOL CHOICE WE
- 33:55OPPOSE TAKING PUBLIC DOLLARS AND
- 33:57SENDING THEM TO UNACCOUNTABLE
- 33:58PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 34:00THE SECOND THING IS THE FACT
- 34:01YOUR NUMBERS ABOUT THE SPENDING
- 34:02ARE COMPLETELY INACCURATE AND
- 34:04FALSE BECAUSE YOU ARE INCLUDING
- 34:07IN THAT AUNT IS PUTTING IN TO
- 34:14FUND THE UNFUNDED PENSION
- 34:16SYSTEM.
- 34:16>> ISN'T THAT TO HELP TEACHERS?
- 34:19DIDN'T THEY BENEFIT FROM THAT
- 34:21SYSTEM?
- 34:21>> THEY ARE PAYING BACK THE
- 34:24LIABILITY NOT FUNDED IN THE
- 34:25PAST.
- 34:26NOT PART OF ANNUAL SPEND SNOOK
- 34:29YOUR FIRST POINT WE ARE NOT
- 34:30OPPOSED TO CHOICE.
- 34:31THIS IS REALLY A FORM OF ELITISM
- 34:35I'VE BEEN SURPRISED AT IN
- 34:37KENTUCKY BECAUSE OUR GOVERNOR
- 34:38SAID, HEY, YOU KNOW WE'RE NOT
- 34:40OPPOSED TO CHOICE YOU HAVE
- 34:42SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 34:43YEAH, BE DO HAVE SCHOOL CHOICE
- 34:46AND I AGREE IF YOU ARE A WEALTHY
- 34:48FAMILY IN KENTUCKY YOU HAVE
- 34:49CHOICE.
- 34:50YOU CAN WRITE A CHECK TO A
- 34:52PRIVATE SCHOOL TO COVER THE
- 34:54TUITION YOU AND UP AND MOVE TO A
- 34:56BETTER PERFORMING PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 34:58DISTRICT AND THAT IS THE THING
- 34:59WE DON'T HEAR AN ACKNOWLEDGMENT
- 35:02THERE ARE FAILING SCHOOLS IN OUR
- 35:03STATE.
- 35:04WE'VE GOT MORE THAN HALF OF OUR
- 35:06STUDENTS ARE FAILING TO REACH
- 35:08PROFICIENCY AND WE HAVE NOT
- 35:09HEARD MUCH ABOUT THAT.
- 35:10BUT, YEAH WE DO HAVE CHOICE.
- 35:12BUT IF YOU DON'T HAVE A LARGE
- 35:13INCOME OR YOU DON'T HAVE THE
- 35:15MEANS TO DO THAT YOU DON'T HAVE
- 35:17THOSE OPTIONS.
- 35:18AND WE'RE SAYING BY DENYING
- 35:20CHOICE IS SAYING THAT WE THINK
- 35:22THAT UNLESS PARENTS HAVE THE
- 35:23MONEY THAT THEY SHOULDN'T HAVE
- 35:25THE BEST OPPORTUNITY FOR THEIR
- 35:27CHILDREN AND WE DISAGREE WITH
- 35:28THAT.
- 35:29>> THAT MONEY IN OUR SCHOOLS IS
- 35:30THAT I LOOKED AT KDE MONEY IN A
- 35:34TEACH AREA CLASSROOM.
- 35:35I BELIEVE PARENTS HAVE BEEN SO
- 35:37SHUTOUT BY OUR SCHOOLS.
- 35:40WE SAW PARENTS SHOW UP TO A
- 35:42MEETING AND THEY WERE IGNORED
- 35:44CONCERNED ABOUT A GUIDANCE
- 35:46COUNSELOR HAVING INAPPROPRIATE
- 35:48CONVERSATIONS WITH A STUDENT AND
- 35:49THE SCHOOL BOARD DID NOTHING.
- 35:51PARENTS ARE TIRED OF BEING
- 35:52MISLED AND IT'S NOT THE
- 35:57TEACHERS' FAULT.
- 35:58ARE WE FAMILIAR WITH THE IMPACT
- 36:00STUDY IN KENTUCKY USED TO BE
- 36:02CALLED THE TALE SURVEY WHEN
- 36:04TEACHERS VOICE THEIR OPINIONS
- 36:05ABOUT THE SCHOOL CLIMATE AND
- 36:07CULTURE.
- 36:08DO YOU KNOW THAT 94% OF PUBLIC
- 36:11SCHOOLTEACHERS SAID THEY HAD TO
- 36:12SPEND MONEY OUT OF THEIR POCKETS
- 36:14FOR SUPPLIES.
- 36:16I WANT TO MENTION THIS.
- 36:17I WENT TO THE KENTUCKY
- 36:19DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION'S
- 36:20WEBSITE AND LOOKING AT PER PUPIL
- 36:22SPENDING AND TEACHER SALARY YOU
- 36:24KNOW HOW MUCH MONEY IS DPLING TO
- 36:26MOST TEACHERS IF YOU HAD TO
- 36:28AVERAGE CLASS SIZE OF 25, 12% OF
- 36:31THE BUDGET.
- 36:31WHERE IS THE OTHER 88% GOING?
- 36:34WHEN WE TALK ABOUT BUDGETS LET'S
- 36:36TALK ABOUT SPENDING THE MONEY
- 36:37WISELY THAT WE ALREADY HAVE.
- 36:39IT'S GOING AWAY FROM THE
- 36:40CLASSROOM AND I WANT TO POINT
- 36:42OUT OF COURSE YOU HAVE BUS
- 36:44DRIVERS AND LUNCH STAFF, AND YOU
- 36:46NEED CURRICULUM AND RESOURCES.
- 36:47HERE'S THE PROBLEM.
- 36:49THERE'S TWO THINGS THAT TEAR
- 36:51THAT ARGUMENT APART.
- 36:53SINCE 2000 TEACHERS AND STUDENT
- 36:57POPULATIONS HAVE GROWN AT THE
- 36:58SAME RATE, ADMINISTRATIVE JOBS
- 37:00HAVE GROWN 37% AND CENTRAL
- 37:02OFFICE STAFF 88%.
- 37:04THE MONEY IS FLOWING AWAY FROM
- 37:05THE CLASSROOM AND FURTHER FROM
- 37:06OUR KIDS.
- 37:07I SUPPORT TEACHERS RAISES BUT
- 37:10THE MONEY'S THERE IT'S BEEN
- 37:12FLOWED WAY FROM THE CLASSROOM
- 37:13AND AWAY FROM WHAT TEACHERS
- 37:15NEED.
- 37:15WE DON'T NEED 94% OF TEACHERS
- 37:18SPENDING MONEY OUT OF THEIR OWN
- 37:20POCKET.
- 37:21WE NEED TO PUT THE MONEY BACK
- 37:22WHERE IT BELONGS.
- 37:24>> Renee: Mr. ROBINS.
- 37:25>> I HEAR WHERE YOU ARE COMING
- 37:27FROM BUT THAT IS CATEGORICALLY
- 37:30WRONG IN 2008 WHEN YOU LOOK AT
- 37:33THE AMOUNT OF FUNDING PER PUPIL
- 37:35IN THE STATE OF KENTUCKY, VERSUS
- 37:392024, WHEN WE STARTED THE
- 37:41GENERAL ASSEMBLY SESSION WE WERE
- 37:42BACK 1200 PER STUDENT.
- 37:45ACROSS KENTUCKY.
- 37:46AND THAT'S BASED ON INFLATION.
- 37:49>> IS THAT THE SEEK FUNDING.
- 37:51>> THAT IS JUST ONE PART.
- 37:54THAT IS JUST ONE REF FEW STREAM
- 37:55FOR STUDENTS.
- 37:56>> IT IS PRIMARY.
- 37:58>> YOU HAVE LOCAL PROPERTY TAX
- 38:00DOLLARS AND FEDERAL DOLLARS.
- 38:02>> THE PRIMARY STATE.
- 38:04>> SPENDING INCREASED.
- 38:05>> THE PRIMARY STATE VEHICLE PER
- 38:07PUPIL.
- 38:08LET ME FINISH HERE.
- 38:10SO THE CONCEPT HERE IS THAT
- 38:12THERE'S NOT ENOUGH MONEY FLOWING
- 38:14TO THE CLASSROOM.
- 38:15WELL, WHEN WE HAVE FRANKFORT
- 38:17POLITICIANS WHO HAVE BEEN DARE
- 38:20LCTS IN TERMS OF MAKING SURE THE
- 38:23AMOUNT PER PUPIL IS SOMEWHAT
- 38:26APPROXIMATING DPLATION AREA
- 38:27INCREASES OVER TIME YOU SEE IT'S
- 38:29NOT EASY TO FIGURE OUT WHY THE
- 38:31TEACHER DOESN'T HAVE ENOUGH
- 38:32MONEY AT THE CLASSROOM LEVEL
- 38:34WHEN WE ARE BEHIND A THOUSAND
- 38:36DOLLARS NOW.
- 38:38>> NEW JOBS ADDED.
- 38:41>> IF I HAVE ONE PERSON AND
- 38:44INCREASE IT BY TWO, WHAT
- 38:46PERCENTAGE INCREASE?
- 38:47>> 50%.
- 38:48>> AND 30%?
- 38:49>> I SEE YOUR POINT.
- 38:51>> STOP.
- 38:52STOP.
- 38:54BECAUSE THAT --
- 38:56>> Renee: ONE AT A TIME.
- 38:57>> ALL I HAVE TO DO IS ADD ONE
- 38:59ADMINISTRATOR AND THAT IS A 50%
- 39:01INCREASE.
- 39:02I SAW THAT GRAPH AND IT IS SO
- 39:04FLAWED IN TERMS OF WHAT IT'S
- 39:06TRYING TO DEPICT VERSUS IF I HAD
- 39:0930 TEACHERS AND ADD ONE.
- 39:12>> Renee: QUESTIONS THAT VIEWERS
- 39:12ARE SENDING IN.
- 39:13Mr. ADAMS YOU JOE BIDENNED
- 39:15AMENDMENT 2, LGBTQ KIDS COULD BE
- 39:18SENT TO THEIR OWN SCHOOLS AND
- 39:20MAKE THEM MORE COMFORTABLE.
- 39:22THIS SOUNDS READING FROM THE
- 39:24READERS THE VIEWERS' QUESTION
- 39:26LIKE SEG GATION.
- 39:28CAN YOU EXPLAIN HOW THIS IS NOT
- 39:30SEGREGATION BY ANOTHER NAME?
- 39:31>> FIRST POINT, THE 94% OF
- 39:34TEACHERS SPENDING MONEY OUT OF
- 39:36THEIR POCKETS THAT IS NOT
- 39:39CATEGORICALLY LONG.
- 39:40THE LGBTQ ISSUES THAT IS A CRAZY
- 39:43EXAGGERATION OF WHAT I SAID THAT
- 39:44IS THE ISSUE IN OUR SCHOOLS WE
- 39:46HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT RELATING
- 39:48TO THE COMMON VALUES OF
- 39:49KENTUCKY.
- 39:50PARENTS DON'T WANT THEIR KIDS
- 39:52GOING TO SCHOOL AND BEING
- 39:54SEXUALIZED BY PORNOGRAPHIC BOOKS
- 39:56IT IS A CRAZY IDEA TO MENTION I
- 39:58WAS HINTING AT THAT.
- 39:59I WAS IN EDUCATION IN A
- 40:01CLASSROOM AS A PRINCIPAL FOR
- 40:02OVER A DECADE.
- 40:03I DID NOT HAVE ONE COMPLAINT
- 40:06AGAINST ME FOR DISRESPECTING A
- 40:07STUDENT.
- 40:08I KNEW THAT EVERY STUDENT THAT
- 40:10WALKED IN MY SCHOOL WHETHER THEY
- 40:12SHARED THE SAME BELIEFS I WAS
- 40:14GOING TO BE RESPECTFUL TOWARDS
- 40:15AND I SAW SO MANY TEACHERS DOING
- 40:18A GREAT JOB WHO DISAGREED WITH
- 40:20ME BUT THEY DID THE SAME THING.
- 40:22BUT THE PROBLEM IS OUR KEA THEY
- 40:25DON'T HAVE THE COURAGE TO
- 40:26ADVOCATE FOR SCHOOLS TO STOP
- 40:28PUSHING THE IDEAS.
- 40:29THERE IS A GROUP CALLED BETTER
- 40:31SCHOOLS KENTUCKY THAT IS FLOWING
- 40:32A LOT OF MONEY AGAINST AMENDMENT
- 40:342.
- 40:35I WILL CHALLENGE TEACHERS AND
- 40:36PARENTS TO LOOK AT THEIR
- 40:38WEBSITE.
- 40:39BETTER SCHOOLS KENTUCKY LOOK IT
- 40:40UP.
- 40:40THERE IS NOT A SINGLE IDEA ON
- 40:42THE WEBSITE TO MAKE KENTUCKY
- 40:44SCHOOLS BETTER.
- 40:44IT HAS A LIST OF TWO CANDIDATES.
- 40:47INSTEAD OF GETTING DISTRACTED BY
- 40:49THE ISSUES AND TRYING TO PAINT
- 40:50ME AS A HORRIBLE PERSON LET ME
- 40:53SAY WHAT IF I WERE YOUR CHILD'S
- 40:55PRINCIPAL AND YOU DISAGREED WITH
- 40:57ME, WOULDN'T YOU WANT SCHOOL
- 40:59CHOICE THEN?
- 41:00WHAT IF I WERE THE COMMISSIONER
- 41:01OF EDUCATION OR THE NEXT
- 41:02GOVERNOR APPOINTED ME.
- 41:04TEACHERS AND PARENTS NEED TO
- 41:05VOTE YES ON 2.
- 41:07RIGHT NOW VOTING NO MIGHT SEEM
- 41:09RIGHT BUT FIVE OR SIX YEARS DOWN
- 41:11THE ROAD THEY MIGHT REGRET
- 41:13GIVING THEMSELVES THE RIGHT TO
- 41:14CHANNEL THE FUNDING.
- 41:16I'M OKAY IF PEOPLE DISLIKE
- 41:18BECAUSE THEY WANT TO
- 41:20AUTOMATICALLY, CALL ME NAMES.
- 41:21BUT I AM STANDING UP SO PARENTS
- 41:24DON'T HAVE TO SEND THEIR KIDS TO
- 41:26SCHOOL AND BE LIED TO WHAT IS
- 41:28GOING ON I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR
- 41:34WHEN SENATE BILL 150 ARE ON THE
- 41:36BOOKS.
- 41:37THE ISSUES TEACHERS ARE TALKING
- 41:39ABOUT ON THE IMPACT SURVEY THE
- 41:41GROUPS ARE NOT TRYING TO ADDRESS
- 41:42THE BEHAVIOR, THE DISRESPECT AND
- 41:44THE TEACHER SHORTAGE THEY ARE
- 41:46CONTRIBUTING TO THE PROBLEM.
- 41:47AND AMENDMENT 2 IS THE SOLUTION.
- 41:49>> Renee: OKAY.
- 41:50FROM LEXINGTON, NEXT QUESTION
- 41:51COULD VOUCHERS BE USED FOR
- 41:53RELIGIOUS SCHOOL EDUCATION?
- 41:57WHAT ABOUT SCHOOLS THAT MIGHT
- 41:59DISCRIMINATE AGAINST REGULARS
- 42:07RELIGIONS OF KIDS.
- 42:08>> THOSE DECISIONS WOULD BE MADE
- 42:10BY THE LEGISLATURE IF AMENDMENT
- 42:122 PASSES.
- 42:13LET ME POINT OUT WE ALREADY HAVE
- 42:16FUNDING THAT HIGHER EDUCATION
- 42:18STUDENTS STUDENTS IN HIGHER
- 42:19EDUCATION USE FOR ALL KINDS OF
- 42:21SCHOOLS.
- 42:21THE GI BILL, THE PELL GRANT WE
- 42:24HAVE PUBLIC DOLLARS USED ALREADY
- 42:27FOR RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS.
- 42:29IT'S NOT THE GOVERNMENT GIVING
- 42:30MONEY TO THE SCHOOLS, IT'S THE
- 42:33INDIVIDUAL OR IN THIS CASE, WITH
- 42:35SCHOOL CHOICE IT WOULD BE THE
- 42:36PARENTS MAKING THAT DECISION.
- 42:38AND THE U.S. SUPREME COURT MADE
- 42:40A DIG DISTINCT --
- 42:42BIG DISTINCTION BETWEEN SCHOOLS
- 42:45GIVING MONEY GOVERNMENT GIVING
- 42:47MONEY TO SCHOOLS VERSUS PARENTS
- 42:49DECIDING OR INDIVIDUALS
- 42:50DECIDING.
- 42:51WE ALREADY HAVE THAT AND I WANT
- 42:52TO ADD I DISAGREE THAT
- 42:55LEGISLATORS HAVE BEEN DEREK LICK
- 42:58IN THEIR DUTY.
- 43:00>> Renee: FOR FUNDING HE WAS
- 43:01SAYING.
- 43:01>> THE PAST COUPLE OF BUDGET
- 43:05SESSIONS THEY'VE GIVEN RECORD
- 43:07AMOUNTS OF INCREASED FUNDING
- 43:10LUMP SUM FUNDING TO LOCAL
- 43:11DISTRICTS AND THEY'VE SAID YOU
- 43:13DO WITH IT WHAT YOU NEED TO DO.
- 43:14IF YOU WANT TO GIVE TEACHERS
- 43:17RAISES HERE.
- 43:17IF YOUR SCHOOL SYSTEM NEEDS A
- 43:19PROGRAM OR NEED A VOCATIONAL
- 43:21PROGRAM OR THEY NEED AN ADVANCED
- 43:24PLACEMENT, USE IT IN THE WAY YOU
- 43:25SEE FIT.
- 43:26TEACHERS WORK FOR THEIR
- 43:28DISTRICTS.
- 43:28THEY DON'T WORK FOR THE STATE.
- 43:30I THINK IT IS A WRONG TO SAY
- 43:34LEGISLATORS HAVE BEEN DERELICT
- 43:36IN FUNDING THEY HAVE INCREASED
- 43:38FUNDING AND THE SEEK FUNDING HAS
- 43:40BEEN STAGNANT.
- 43:41BUT OVERALL FUNDING HAS
- 43:43INCREASED.
- 43:44>> I HAVE TO POINT THAT OUT
- 43:46THERE.
- 43:46SO, YES, I WILL SAY THAT THEY
- 43:48HAVE NOT PUT STRINGS ATTACHED IN
- 43:51TERMS OF PRIOR LEGISLATURES THAT
- 43:54HAVE TIED A PERCENTAGE RAISE
- 43:57THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS HAD TO
- 43:58GIVE.
- 43:59SO I WILL GIVE YOU THAT.
- 44:01BUT RECORD FUNDING?
- 44:03WE'LL NEED TO LOOK AT THE MATH
- 44:04ON THAT.
- 44:06BECAUSE THAT HASN'T HAPPENED.
- 44:08>> IT'S GIVEN ADDITIONAL
- 44:11FUNDING.
- 44:11>> BUT THAT IS NOT RECORD.
- 44:14>> RECORD AMOUNTS IN THE LAST
- 44:16COUPLE OF BUDGETS.
- 44:17>> NO, THEY HAVE NOT.
- 44:19NOT OVER AND ABOVE THE
- 44:21PERCENTAGE OF YEARS.
- 44:22>> IT'S BEEN ADDITIONAL FUNDING.
- 44:24>> I SAY ADDITIONAL FUNDING BUT
- 44:26THAT IS A LONG WAY AWAY FROM
- 44:29RECORD WHICH IS WHAT YOU SAID.
- 44:30>> .
- 44:32>> Renee: LET'S PUT THAT POINT
- 44:33ASIDE.
- 44:33Mr. SHELTON?
- 44:34>> JUST ONE THING ABOUT THAT AND
- 44:36I WANTED TO GET WHAT I DIDN'T
- 44:38FINISH EARLIER.
- 44:38I COULD GIVE DOLL 1 MORE THAN I
- 44:42GAVE LAST YEAR AND IT WOULD BE
- 44:44RECORD FUNDING WE'RE GIVING MORE
- 44:46FUNDING THAN WE'VE EVER GIVEN TO
- 44:48EDUCATION IF YOU GIVE YOU ONE
- 44:51DOLLAR MORE THAT'S RECORD LEVEL
- 44:53FUNDING.
- 44:53THE POINT I WAS GOING TO MAKE
- 44:55EARLIER IS TO MATT'S POINT ABOUT
- 44:58GOING BACK TO 2008, IN 2008, THE
- 45:01GENERAL ASSEMBLY WAS PROVIDING
- 45:0460% OF THE COST OF FUNDING
- 45:07EDUCATION INTO THE SEEK FORMULA.
- 45:09SEEK FORMULA IS NOT JUST STATE
- 45:11FUNDING IT'S STATE AND LOCAL
- 45:13FUNDING IT IS A BLENDED FORMULA.
- 45:15THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY WAS
- 45:17PROVIDING 60%.
- 45:18TODAY THEY PROVIDE 40%.
- 45:20YOU KNOW WHO PACE THE OTHER 20%?
- 45:23LOCAL TAXPAYERS.
- 45:24YOU KNOW WHAT WILL HAPPEN,
- 45:27TAXPAYERS WILL TAKE THE BURDEN
- 45:28HIT BECAUSE SCHOOL DISTRICTS
- 45:29WILL HAVE TO INCREASE THEIR
- 45:31LOCAL TAXES BECAUSE THE GENERAL
- 45:33ASSEMBLY IS NOT FUNDING AT THE
- 45:34LEVEL TO MATCH INFLATION TO
- 45:36MATT'S POINT.
- 45:37SO WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN RURAL
- 45:41DISTRICTS WILL SIT AROUND RURAL
- 45:42IN PARTICULAR WILL SIT AROUND
- 45:43AND SAY OKAY, DO WE CUT PEOPLE
- 45:46OR DO WE CUT PROGRAMS?
- 45:48WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO START
- 45:49TALKING ABOUT WE MAY HAVE TO CUT
- 45:51THE ARTS WE MAY HAVE TO CUT BAND
- 45:54AND EXTRACURRICULAR.
- 45:55WE MAY HAVE TO CUT OUR SPORTS
- 45:59PROGRAMS BECAUSE IF THE STATE IS
- 46:00NOT FUNDING AT THE LEVEL THAT IT
- 46:03SHOULD, AND THE LOCAL TAXPAYERS
- 46:06ARE EXPECTING THAT THEIR TAXES
- 46:08ARE NOT GOING TO INCREASE THE
- 46:09HONE HAS TO COME FROM SOMEWHERE.
- 46:12WE ARE TALKING ABOUT LOCAL
- 46:13SCHOOL DISTRICTS RAISING TAXES
- 46:14OR CUTTING PROGRAMS.
- 46:16>> Renee: Mr. BILLY PARKER
- 46:18FROM SCOTT COUNTY RESEMBLES YOUR
- 46:21REMARKS 98,000 STUDENTS IN
- 46:23KENTUCKY THAT ATTEND PRIVATE
- 46:25SCHOOLS OR HOME SCHOOLED IF THE
- 46:26FUNDING IS GIVEN TO THESE
- 46:29STUDENTS $326 THAT WILL RESULT
- 46:33IN $400 MILLION IN FUNDING THAT
- 46:35WOULD BE REQUIRED.
- 46:36TO THE QUESTION OR THE COMMENT
- 46:39ABOUT RURAL KENTUCKY, VIEWER
- 46:42FROM HARTFORD SAYS Mr. ADAMS
- 46:45FAILS TO MENTION HE IS
- 46:46ADVOCATING FOR REDISTRIBUTING
- 46:48TAX DOLLARS FROM RURAL AREAS
- 46:50THAT DO NOT HAVE AND WILL NOT
- 46:52HAVE PRIVATE SCHOOLS TO SELECT
- 46:53URBAN AREAS.
- 46:54DO YOU WANT TO SET THE RECORD
- 46:56STRAIGHT.
- 46:56>> I LOVE THAT QUESTION.
- 46:57I'M IN ANDERSON COUNTY A RURAL
- 47:00COMMUNITY.
- 47:01WHEN THE SCHOOL SYSTEM WENT
- 47:03AGAINST THE VALUES OF PARENTS WE
- 47:04WENT TO A PRIVATE SCHOOL.
- 47:06THERE WAS ONE THERE.
- 47:08NOW, HERE'S THE THING.
- 47:09LET'S SAY YOU ARE IN A COMMUNITY
- 47:11AND THERE IS NOT A SCHOOL.
- 47:12GUESS WHAT?
- 47:14WITH THIS NEW MECHANISM TEACHERS
- 47:16CAN START A SCHOOL.
- 47:17THE TEACHERS THAT ARE REPORTING
- 47:18ON THE IMPACT SURVEY THEY ARE
- 47:21OVERWHELMED, THEY CAN CREATE A
- 47:23SCHOOL THAT IS BASED ON A
- 47:26SPECIFIC PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION
- 47:27THAT PARENTS THEY WANT AND NEED.
- 47:31WE KEEP TALKING ABOUT BUDGETS
- 47:32AND WHAT IT WILL DO TO THE
- 47:34COMMUNITIES, I THINK THERE IS
- 47:36SOMETHING TO BE SAID.
- 47:37KENTUCKY IS ONE OF TWO STATES
- 47:39WHO HAS HELD OUT AND NOT
- 47:41PROVIDED ANYTHING.
- 47:41WE HAVE TO AT SOME POINT LEARN
- 47:43AND LOOK WHY IS THIS GROWING IN
- 47:45WILD POPULARITY WHY IS PARENT
- 47:48SATISFACTION HIGH IN OTHER
- 47:49STATES IF IT DECIMATES
- 47:51COMMUNITIES.
- 47:51I DON'T UNDERSTAND THE ARGUMENT
- 47:53ONLY KIDS ALREADY IN PRIVATE
- 47:55SCHOOL ARE GOING TO BENEFIT.
- 47:56AND AT THE SAME TIME SCHOOLS
- 47:57WILL SHUT DOWN AND LOSE MONEY.
- 47:59THOSE ARGUMENTS FALL IN ON EACH
- 48:01OTHER.
- 48:02WHICH ONE IS IT?
- 48:04IF THEY ARE STAYING PUT HOW IS
- 48:05THE MONEY GOING TO FLOW AWAY
- 48:07FROM SCHOOLS.
- 48:07OUR MONEY IS BEING MISMANAGED
- 48:10AND ONE LAST THING, AND THIS IS
- 48:13A STORY FROM WDRB FROM MAY 31,
- 48:172018.
- 48:18A NEWS STORY.
- 48:19LET'S TALK ABOUT MONEY
- 48:21MANAGEMENT.
- 48:22JEFFERSON COUNTY SCHOOLS QUIETLY
- 48:23PAYS OUT HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS
- 48:25OF DOLLARS IN SETTLEMENTS TO
- 48:26CHILDREN WHO WERE TORMENTED
- 48:29ATTACKED IN LOUISVILLE SCHOOLS
- 48:31AND TAXPAYERS COVER THE COST.
- 48:32THAT IS A VERY ALARMING STORY.
- 48:35>> Renee: WHICH WE DON'T KNOW
- 48:36THE CRUX OF BECAUSE YOU GAVE A
- 48:40QUICK SUMMATION.
- 48:43>> BUT THE REALITY IS OUR
- 48:44SCHOOLS PAYING OUT HUNDREDS OF
- 48:46THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS AND AS A
- 48:48GAG ORDER WE'LL PAY YOU BECAUSE
- 48:50YOUR CHILD SUFFERED A HORRIBLE
- 48:52EVENT AT SCHOOL AND DON'T TALK
- 48:54ABOUT IT.
- 48:54HOW MANY PARENTS AND SCHOOLS ARE
- 48:57GOING --
- 48:57GIVE US A SAFE SCHOOL WHERE OUR
- 49:00KIDS CAN COME AND LEARN.
- 49:01IT'S LIP SERVICE.
- 49:02AND THEN WHEN SOMETHING HAPPENS
- 49:04WE PAY THEM OFF AND NO
- 49:07ADMINISTRATORS OR TEACHERS THAT
- 49:08CONTRIBUTED TO THE PROBLEM ARE
- 49:09DEALT WITH.
- 49:10IT'S PAID OFF SO THE SCHOOL CAN
- 49:13AVOID ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 49:14>> YOU HAVE TO REMEMBER, THOUGH,
- 49:16PRIVATE SCHOOLS THEY ARE NOT
- 49:17REQUIRED TO HAVE OPEN MEETING OR
- 49:19OPEN RECORDS LIKE PUBLIC
- 49:21SCHOOLS.
- 49:21>> Renee: THEY HAVE TO FOLLOW
- 49:25KED GUIDELINES.
- 49:26>> NOT PRIVATE SCHOOLS DON'T.
- 49:28THEY DON'T HAVE TO HAVE OPEN
- 49:30MEETINGS LIKE BOARD MEETINGS OR
- 49:33COUNCIL MEETINGS THEY DON'T HAVE
- 49:35TO HAVE OPEN RECORDS.
- 49:36THEY DON'T HAVE AUDITS.
- 49:38WHAT I WOULD SAY IS IF WE THINK
- 49:41THAT PRIVATE SCHOOLS SHOULD GET
- 49:43PUBLIC MONEY THEN WHY WOULD THEY
- 49:46THINK THAT THEY COULD CONTINUE
- 49:48TO TEACH WHATEVER THEY WANT TO
- 49:50TEACH, WHATEVER CURRICULUM THEY
- 49:51WANT TO SET ASIDE WHEN WE IN
- 49:54PUBLIC SCHOOLS HAVE TO DO
- 49:56WHATEVER THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
- 49:58OR STATE GOVERNMENT TELLS US TO
- 49:59TEACH INTEREST TOM THAT IS AN
- 50:01IMPORTANT POINT BECAUSE THERE IS
- 50:02AN OLD ADD DAMAGE HE WHO HAS THE
- 50:05PURSE HAS THE POWER.
- 50:07AND I'M STARTING TO HEAR THIS IN
- 50:09OTHER STATES PARTICULARLY WHERE
- 50:10THEY ARE SPENDING OVER A BILLION
- 50:12DOLLARS OF NEW COST ON VOUCHERS
- 50:15AND THEY ARE NOT REALLY FINDING
- 50:17THE INCREASE IN ACADEMIC
- 50:19ACHIEVEMENT.
- 50:20THAT'S OCCURRING THERE.
- 50:22IN FACT MAYBE IT'S DECLINING.
- 50:24SO THERE IS ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 50:25WHERE ARE ALL THE DOLLARS GOING
- 50:27AND FINDING ABSURD EXAMPLES IN
- 50:30TERMS OF WHERE THIS MONEY IS
- 50:32SPENT.
- 50:32I WANT TO GET BACK --
- 50:34>> Renee: STICK ON THE
- 50:35ACCOUNTABILITY ISSUE.
- 50:35Mr. WATERS ANSWER THAT ABOUT
- 50:38THE GUIDELINES THAT THEY HAVE TO
- 50:39ABIDE BY, THE CURRICULUM.
- 50:43>> SO Mr. SHELTON STILL
- 50:46REDUCES TO DESIGNATE THE
- 50:47DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A PUBLIC
- 50:49CHAFORTER SCHOOL AND A PUBLIC
- 50:52CHARTER SCHOOL WOULD BE SUBJECT
- 50:53TO THE OPEN MEETINGS ACT.
- 50:58>> Renee: TO SOME THEY WOULD BE
- 51:01FREE --
- 51:01OWE.
- 51:02>> THAT WOULD BE DETERMINED
- 51:03HOWEVER THE LEGISLATION IS
- 51:05SETUP.
- 51:06THE MAJOR DIFFERENCE IS TWO
- 51:07DIFFERENCES, ONE IS THE CHARTER
- 51:10SCHOOL PRINCIPALS IN CHARGE.
- 51:11HE DOES AHAVE TO CALL THE BRUR
- 51:14CONTRACT AT THE CENTRAL OFFICE
- 51:16TO MAKE DECISIONS WHO TO HIRE OR
- 51:18FIRE.
- 51:19HE IS NOT BEHOLDENNED TO THE
- 51:21UNIONS WHO TO HIRE.
- 51:23THE MORE IMPORTANT THING IS THE
- 51:25DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A PUBLIC
- 51:26CHARTER SCHOOL AND A TRADITIONAL
- 51:27PUBLIC SCHOOL IS PARENTS DECIDE
- 51:30TO ENROLL THEIR CHILDREN IN A
- 51:31CHARTER SCHOOL.
- 51:32THAT IS THE ULTIMATE
- 51:34ACCOUNTABILITY FACTOR.
- 51:35IF YOU SAY THAT PARENTS ARE
- 51:37ENROLLING THEIR CHILDREN AND THE
- 51:38CHILDREN ARE FAILING, YOU ARE
- 51:40ACCUSING PARENTS OF NOT GIVING
- 51:43THEIR CHILDREN THE BEST
- 51:44OPPORTUNITY.
- 51:45WE KNOW THAT CHARTER SCHOOLS ARE
- 51:47CLOSING THE ACHIEVEMENT GAPS AND
- 51:49DOING GREAT THINGS WE ARE NOT
- 51:50HEARING ANYTHING ABOUT SOLUTIONS
- 51:51FROM THE OTHER SIDE.
- 51:52ONE OTHER THING IS, THE
- 51:55BROOKINGS INSTITUTION HAS FOUND
- 51:57THAT SEVEN IN 10 RURAL AMERICAN
- 52:00FAMILIES LIVE WITHIN 10 MILES OF
- 52:02A NONPUBLIC SCHOOL AND THERE'S
- 52:04TWO IN JACKSON COUNTY.
- 52:05I FOUND ONE OF THE MOST RURAL
- 52:07COUNTIES IN OUR STATE THIS IDEA
- 52:09THERE AREN'T OPTIONS AND THIS
- 52:11MONEY WOULD LEAVE THE RURAL
- 52:12COMMUNITY AND GO TO THE GOLDEN
- 52:14TRIANGLE IS NONSENSE AND IT IS A
- 52:16DISTRACTION.
- 52:17WE OUGHT TO BE FUNDING STUDENTS
- 52:19AND NOT PROPPING UP A FAILING
- 52:22SYSTEM.
- 52:22>> Renee: THE TUITION, THOUGH.
- 52:23THE TUITION AT THE PRIVATE
- 52:26INSTITUTIONS DOES IT REMAIN THE
- 52:27SAME?
- 52:28DO THEY ELEVATE BASED ON THE
- 52:30NUMBER OF NEW STUDENTS THEY CAN
- 52:32GET THAT COULD PRICE OUT OF THE
- 52:34MARKET OTHER CHILDREN?
- 52:35DOES THE TUITION STAY THE SAME?
- 52:38>> THEY ARE NOT --
- 52:42IF THEY PRICE THEMSELVES OUT
- 52:44THEY WILL NOT BE THERE.
- 52:46>> Renee: I'M TALKING ABOUT NEW
- 52:48KIDS WHO ARE IN THE PUBLIC
- 52:50SCHOOL SYSTEM IS THE TUITION
- 52:52SUCH A LEVEL THAT THE KIDS CAN
- 52:53TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THAT
- 52:55OPPORTUNITY?
- 52:55>> SO $7,000 VERSUS THE 20,000
- 52:59WE'RE SPENDING IN THE PUBLIC
- 53:01EDUCATION SYSTEM NOT ALL THAT
- 53:02MONEY IS GOING TO FOLLOW THE
- 53:03STUDENT.
- 53:04SOME DOLLARS WILL.
- 53:05BUT NOT ALL OF IT.
- 53:06AND SO THAT MAKES IT POSSIBLE
- 53:08FOR MORE STUDENTS TO
- 53:10PARTICIPATE.
- 53:11>> ONE THING I THINK HAS TO BE
- 53:13POINTED OUT THERE IS ONE WE ARE
- 53:15TALKING ABOUT WHAT A PRIVATE OR
- 53:17PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL, WE DON'T
- 53:19HAVE CHARTER SCHOOLS IN
- 53:21KENTUCKY.
- 53:22THEY DON'T EXIST.
- 53:23>> AND THAT'S BECAUSE YOU ALL
- 53:25HAVE SUED TO STOP IT.
- 53:27>> WE WERE FINE WITH THE LAW
- 53:29WHEN IT WAS PUBLIC CHARTER
- 53:30SCHOOLS.
- 53:31I STATED CLEARLY EARLIER WHEN WE
- 53:33SUED WAS WHEN PRIVATE CHARTER
- 53:35SCHOOLS WERE ADDED TO THE LAW
- 53:36WHEN IT CHANGED.
- 53:40>> HERE'S THE OTHER DIFFERENCE
- 53:41OF CHARTER SCHOOLS THE WAY YOU
- 53:45DELIVER EDUCATION, SOMETIMES
- 53:47GOVERNMENT IS THE BEST AT MAKE
- 53:49SURE KIDS HAVE ACCESS TO THE
- 53:51EDUCATION BUT THEY ARE NOT
- 53:53ALWAYS THE DELIVER FER BEST
- 53:54DRIVERRER OF IT.
- 53:55THE CHARTER SCHOOLS TAKE THE
- 53:57SAME CURRICULUM AND DELIVER IT
- 54:00MORE EFFECTIVELY.
- 54:02>> Renee: WE'LL GET TO THAT.
- 54:03>> MY LAST POINT I CAN MAKE IS
- 54:06THAT THE OTHER POINT STARTED
- 54:08TALKING ABOUT UNIONS.
- 54:09THERE ARE NO TEACHER UNIONS IN
- 54:12KENTUCKY.
- 54:12AND KEA IS NOT A UNION.
- 54:14>> JEFFERSON COUNTY HAS
- 54:17COLLECTIVE BARGAINING.
- 54:18>> WE HAVE THREE DISTRICTS OUT
- 54:21OF 171.
- 54:22>> THREE THAT HAVE COLLECTIVE
- 54:25BARGAINING AGREEMENTS.
- 54:25>> THEY ARE NOT UNIONS BECAUSE
- 54:27THEY CAN'T STRIKE.
- 54:28STRIKING IN KENTUCKY IS ILLEGAL
- 54:30FOR A TEACHER.
- 54:31THERE ARE NO TEACHER UNIONS.
- 54:33TRYING TO USE THE ADD DAMAGE AT
- 54:34THE OTHER STATES DO ABOUT
- 54:36UNIONS.
- 54:37>> OPPOSING AMENDMENT 2 ON THE
- 54:38WEBSITES AND USING TAXPAYER
- 54:40FUNDED RESOURCES.
- 54:41>> THEY HAVE FIRST AMENDMENT
- 54:44RIGHTS.
- 54:44>> HE'S TALKING ABOUT HOW
- 54:46AVAILABLE PRIVATE SCHOOLS ARE.
- 54:48BY THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR THAT
- 54:51WE SPOKE ABOUT EARLIER.
- 54:54>> Renee: ECONOMIC POLICY A
- 54:55PROGRESSIVE LEANING THINK TANK.
- 54:56>> THEY HAVE NO ECONOMIST THERE.
- 54:58>> 63% OF COUNTIES IN KENTUCKY
- 55:01HAVE ZERO PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 55:0463%.
- 55:05SO THEN GOING BACK TO THERE'S
- 55:0980% OF THE PRIVATE SCHOOLS THAT
- 55:11EXIST IN EIGHT ZIP CODES CAN YOU
- 55:13SEE THE WEALTH SHIFT TO THE
- 55:16GOLDEN TRIANGLE, TO LOUISVILLE,
- 55:17LEXINGTON AND NORTHERN KENTUCKY
- 55:20THAT WOULD OCCUR BY THIS POLICY.
- 55:22>> Renee: A QUESTION FROM A
- 55:23VIEWER WHO ASKED HOW WOULD THE
- 55:25PROPOSED AMENDMENT IMPACT HOME
- 55:27SCHOOLS?
- 55:28>> THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT THE
- 55:30LANGUAGE ON IT IS TO EMPOWER THE
- 55:33GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND OUR
- 55:34GOVERNOR WOULD HAVE TO SIGN A
- 55:35PLAN IN THERE.
- 55:37AT THIS POINT NOT AT ALL.
- 55:39I WOULD URGE EVERYBODY TO VOTE
- 55:41YES AND 2 AND WHENEVER A POLICY
- 55:43IS DESIGNED THEN TO WEIGH-IN
- 55:45YOUR VOICE.
- 55:46I KNOW HOME SCHOOL FAMILIES THEY
- 55:48DON'T WANT GOVERNMENT REACHING
- 55:49IN THEIR HOMES AND I UNDERSTAND
- 55:50THAT 100% BECAUSE OF THE
- 55:53INEFFICIENCY.
- 55:53WE TALKED ABOUT THE CONSTITUTION
- 55:54OF KENTUCKY IT SAYS SCHOOLS
- 55:57SHOULD BE EFFICIENT AND WE HAVE
- 55:58TO GET BACK TO THAT.
- 56:00>> Renee: THIS HAS BEEN A
- 56:01RIGOROUS DISCUSSION SO WE'LL
- 56:02PROBABLY HAVE IT AGAIN BEFORE
- 56:04NOVEMBER 5 AND WE WILL BE BACK
- 56:05IN A COUPLE OF WEEKS.
- 56:07THEY ARE ALREADY BOOKED TO BE
- 56:08HERE.
- 56:09NEXT WEEK WE HAVE A SPECIAL ON
- 56:10THE ROADSHOW FROM NORTHERN
- 56:13KENTUCKY AT NORTHERN KENTUCKY
- 56:14UNIVERSITY WHERE WE TALK ABOUT
- 56:15SOME OF THE ISSUES THERE, THE
- 56:17PROGRESS AND THE OPPORTUNITIES
- 56:18AND EACH WEEKNIGHT AT 6:30
- 56:21EASTERN ON KENTUCKY EDITION WE
- 56:22TALK ABOUT ALL THIS STILL TO
- 56:24SHOW YOU WHAT'S HAPPENING ON THE
- 56:25CAMPAIGN TRAIL.
- 56:26WE HOPE YOU WILL JOAN US THEN.
- 56:28UNTIL I SEE YOU AGAIN, TAKE
- 56:31REALLY GREAT CARE.
- 56:32HAVE A GREAT NIGHT.