Latest / Black Holes and Bubblegum / Do Atoms Ever Really Touch?
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, so here's the playground excuse.
- 0:02Somebody says you bumped into them, and you go, "I didn't actually touch you,
- 0:07because our atoms never touch."
- 0:09Technically my hand was hovering.
- 0:11I really want to know if that holds up, because it sounds like a winning argument.
- 0:15Whoa, wait, that's so cool!
- 0:17So when I poke somebody, I'm not even poking them?
- 0:20I'm just kind of floating near them?
- 0:22Could I say that to a teacher?
- 0:23I want to try it!
- 0:25Oh, I would love to see the teacher's face.
- 0:27The short answer is that the teacher would still send you to the office.
- 0:31But the physics behind the joke is real, and it's stranger than the joke.
- 0:35Let's start with what an atom is.
- 0:37Most of us picture a tiny hard marble.
- 0:40It's actually a super tiny, super heavy, positively charged nucleus in the middle,
- 0:46surrounded by a cloud of negatively charged electrons.
- 0:49A cloud.
- 0:50Like an actual cloud?
- 0:51Sort of.
- 0:52The electron isn't a little dot zooming around.
- 0:55It's described by something called a wavefunction, which tells you the chance of
- 1:00finding it in different places.
- 1:02Here's a picture one physics teacher uses.
- 1:05Imagine the biggest football stadium in America.
- 1:08The nucleus is a pea on the fifty yard line.
- 1:11The electron cloud is a swarm of gnats buzzing through the whole stadium.
- 1:15A pea!
- 1:17In the whole stadium!
- 1:18That's tiny!
- 1:19So is an atom mostly empty space, like everybody says?
- 1:25Because that's what I always heard.
- 1:27Like it's all just air with a pea in it.
- 1:31That's the part people get wrong.
- 1:33Almost all the mass is in the pea, so it's mostly empty in terms of where the weight
- 1:38is.
- 1:39But the electron wavefunction spreads through the whole stadium,
- 1:43so it isn't empty in a meaningful way.
- 1:45It's fuzzy, not hollow.
- 1:47Okay, so fuzzy clouds.
- 1:49Then what happens when my finger gets close to something, like a desk?
- 1:53The outside of your finger is a fuzzy cloud of electrons, and the outside of the
- 1:57desk is too.
- 1:59Electrons all have negative charge, and like charges push away from each other.
- 2:04There's a rule called Coulomb's law that says the closer the charges get,
- 2:09the harder the push gets, and it rises fast.
- 2:12Your nerves feel that push, and your brain says, "desk."
- 2:17Like magnets!
- 2:18When you push two magnets the same way and they won't go together,
- 2:22and you can feel it pushing against your hands.
- 2:24Is it like that?
- 2:26That's a good comparison for the electric push, yes.
- 2:28But here's the twist.
- 2:30Electric push alone isn't enough to explain why stuff is solid.
- 2:34Think about it.
- 2:35An oxygen atom has eight electrons in its cloud, and they all repel each other,
- 2:40yet they stay put in one atom.
- 2:42So why can't the electrons from your finger just rearrange themselves and slip in
- 2:47between the electrons in the desk?
- 2:49Ooh.
- 2:49Because...
- 2:50they don't want to?
- 2:51I don't know.
- 2:51Why not?
- 2:52Because of a rule of nature called the Pauli exclusion principle.
- 2:56Electrons are a kind of particle called fermions, which have what's called half
- 3:02integer spin.
- 3:04And the rule says no two identical fermions can be in the exact same quantum state
- 3:10at the same time.
- 3:12A state means things like energy, the shape of the cloud, and spin.
- 3:18At most, two electrons can share one orbital, and only if they spin in opposite
- 3:24ways.
- 3:25A third one gets the door shut in its face.
- 3:28Like musical chairs!
- 3:30But there are only two chairs per spot, and if you don't have a chair,
- 3:35you have to go sit somewhere way more expensive!
- 3:39That's very close to how the video I read put it.
- 3:42When you squeeze atoms together, electrons run out of the low energy seats and get
- 3:47pushed into higher energy ones, like moving people to more expensive seats.
- 3:51Add up trillions of atoms in your finger and trillions in the desk,
- 3:55and the energy cost shoots up.
- 3:57That shows up as a strong push called exchange repulsion.
- 4:01Physicists don't count it as a brand new force.
- 4:04It's a quantum rule that works together with the electric push.
- 4:08So that's why my hand doesn't go through the desk.
- 4:10It's the electric push plus the rule about chairs.
- 4:14Okay!
- 4:15So my excuse works!
- 4:17We never touch!
- 4:18I'm basically floating a tiny bit above everything, like all the time.
- 4:22Hold on, because this is where the experts disagree.
- 4:26Some explanations say you hover about a nanometer or less above your chair,
- 4:32a billionth of a meter or smaller, held up by those pushes.
- 4:36But a physicist at the University of Illinois who answers questions on a site called
- 4:41Physics Van, writing as Mike W., says that's mixing two pictures.
- 4:46Between ordinary uncharged objects, the overall electric force is actually a weak
- 4:52attraction, called van der Waals attraction.
- 4:56And the Pauli push doesn't start until the electron wavefunctions begin to overlap.
- 5:01Wait, overlap?
- 5:03So they DO touch?
- 5:04The clouds are mixing together a little?
- 5:06That's his point.
- 5:07He says that if touching means your electron wavefunctions overlap,
- 5:11then objects do touch, in the only physical sense possible.
- 5:15The video by Arvin Ash lands in a similar place.
- 5:19He says it's not correct to say atoms never touch, because their electron clouds
- 5:23absolutely interact and can partly overlap.
- 5:26What's true is that under normal conditions, the nuclei, the peas,
- 5:30never touch.
- 5:31Ha.
- 5:32So the excuse is half right.
- 5:34My pea didn't touch your pea, but my cloud touched your cloud.
- 5:38That would not go over well with the recess teacher.
- 5:41What if the peas did touch?
- 5:43What would happen?
- 5:44Would there be an explosion?
- 5:45Nuclei only really get that close in extreme places.
- 5:49In a neutron star, gravity squeezes matter so hard that electrons get captured by
- 5:54nuclei and protons turn into neutrons.
- 5:57In very high energy particle collisions, like at the Large Hadron Collider,
- 6:02nuclei or their pieces can collide.
- 6:04And inside a nucleus, protons and neutrons do touch, held by the strong nuclear
- 6:09force, at distances far smaller than an atom.
- 6:13Not something that happens when you high five.
- 6:15Okay, so what's the honest answer?
- 6:17Do things touch or not?
- 6:18It depends on what you mean by touch.
- 6:20If you mean hard little marbles clacking together, then no,
- 6:25because atoms aren't hard little marbles.
- 6:28If you mean forces and overlapping electron clouds pushing back on your nerve
- 6:33endings, then yes, that is what touch is.
- 6:35Your nerves sense that push, and your brain turns it into the feeling of something
- 6:40solid.
- 6:41So when I hug somebody, it's electron clouds and a rule about chairs!
- 6:46That's the best hug ever.
- 6:48And the playground ruling is this.
- 6:50If you say you didn't touch them, and the clouds were definitely overlapping,
- 6:54then your excuse is just a fib with extra steps.
- 6:57I'd say sorry anyway.
- 6:59And that's the best part of this whole thing.
- 7:02The rule about those chairs is why you don't fall through the floor,
- 7:06why atoms have a size, and why chemistry works at all.
- 7:11Without it, matter wouldn't be stable.
- 7:13So the next time someone pokes you and you feel it, thank the electron clouds.
- 7:19And then maybe say sorry.