Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / In Old Chicago (1938)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And this is how we keep things
- 0:23moving, baby. That's right. I didn't even know
- 0:25we were recording. That's right. And guess what?
- 0:28We're here. We're back. We're talking about...
- 0:30Are all of my thoughts on the Tom Cruise movie
- 0:31recorded? They're all on here. Oh no. Yep. I'm
- 0:35not ready to talk about that until like January.
- 0:37Well... People are going to be real shocked when
- 0:40they learn about you signing up first. I mean,
- 0:44look, I'm just saying that L. Ron Hubbard wasn't
- 0:47completely... I'm not even finished with that.
- 0:50Is that right? L. Ron Hubbard? I cannot take
- 0:53it seriously if there's somebody named L. Rond.
- 0:56Well, first off, I don't mean to do this. His
- 0:59first initial is L. Oh. And then his second name
- 1:02is Ron. So it's L... I'm not defending Elrond
- 1:06Hubbard. I'm just making sure you don't think
- 1:07the man's name is Elrond. No, this actually helps
- 1:09a little bit. Yeah, I thought he was like Isildur
- 1:13cast into the flame. He might still be. He might
- 1:17be. We don't know. I'm just making sure that
- 1:20you know his name is not Elrond Hubbard. I just
- 1:22imagine somebody throwing like a water bottle
- 1:24past his head or something and you see that little
- 1:27whiff of hair like when Elrond the arrow goes
- 1:30past him. Can you imagine that image of Lord
- 1:32of the Rings Fellowship of the Ring but You are
- 1:35Frodo waking up from that dream. And in that
- 1:38white light of Elrond standing over his bed,
- 1:42that's just Tom Cruise. Oh, no. And he's like,
- 1:46hi, how you doing? Nice to meet you. I can't
- 1:49wait to make a movie. Frodo's like, Sam. Have
- 1:51you seen The Good Son? The Good Son. It's one
- 1:54of my favorite Elijah Wood movies. Oh, yeah,
- 1:56yeah. So have you been to Chicago? When I was
- 2:00younger, yeah. I was in middle school. Nope.
- 2:03I was in high school. I went there on a field
- 2:05trip. Oh. Yeah. What kind of field trip were
- 2:07they taking to Chicago? So I was in the marching
- 2:09band in high school, and we marched in the St.
- 2:12Patrick's Day parade. You are not going to believe
- 2:14this. You and I are the yin and yang in this,
- 2:18my friend. Oh. I've also been to Chicago once.
- 2:20It was also because of a marching band. Yeah?
- 2:23But it was the Thanksgiving Day parade. My God.
- 2:25See what I'm saying? Listen, they dyed the river
- 2:28green when I was there. That's cool. What'd they
- 2:30do to the turkeys while you were there? It's
- 2:33against the Geneva Code. We shouldn't be giving
- 2:36that much light. Somebody call Elrond. But here's
- 2:38the thing. I wasn't in the marching band at the
- 2:40time. It was my brother, and I was just a chaperone
- 2:42because I had been in the marching band. And
- 2:44they were like, we need a chaperone. What did
- 2:46you play? When I was in marching band? Yeah.
- 2:49Drumline all four years. And for my first three
- 2:52years, I was the fifth and biggest bass drum,
- 2:54which meant I was at the end or beginning of
- 2:57a lot of runs. And then my final year, I pretty
- 3:02much spent my entire drum audition on my knees
- 3:04begging to my instructors, please let me play
- 3:07the quads, please let me play the quads, the
- 3:08tenors. And they were like, fine, do it. It's
- 3:13his last year anyways, whatever. And they let
- 3:15me play it. And I love tenors. Just because the
- 3:19tenors are like the six drums. So you have four
- 3:22larger drums and then two smaller ones in the
- 3:24middle. And it allows for so much crossover.
- 3:27And thankfully, I didn't have something blocking
- 3:30my view in front of me the whole time, like a
- 3:32bass drum. Now I could see everything. So I loved
- 3:35playing the tenors. Yeah. You marched drill and
- 3:38all of that, too? I did. Honestly, it's so easy
- 3:41for me to think about just going left and right,
- 3:43back and forth, because I'm just on the tip of
- 3:45my toes. It's so funny. So Chicago, you were
- 3:48in the marching band. You played trumpet? Melophone.
- 3:52Melophone? Yeah, which is a marching French horn.
- 3:55yes yeah okay did you play all four years i did
- 3:58not do marching band my senior year so question
- 4:01for you i would feel like if i did it for my
- 4:03first three of four years it's the fourth year
- 4:06come on i'm just gonna round it out i was a rebel
- 4:09in high school it was pretty pretty bad like
- 4:12can i ask you a question yeah how many causes
- 4:14did you have uh none really wow you're not gonna
- 4:18you're not gonna believe who i can compare you
- 4:20to now yeah I got the bullets. No, I was weird
- 4:24in high school. I was like, yeah, it's my senior
- 4:26year. I hate school. I'm not doing anything.
- 4:28I didn't walk at graduation. I didn't get a yearbook.
- 4:32I didn't. What's the other thing you do? I didn't
- 4:34go to prom. You're not missing out a ton. No.
- 4:37Yeah. And, you know, that was almost 20 years
- 4:40ago. Don't do that. Yeah. You don't have to do
- 4:42that. You can leave that alone. Yep. But anyway,
- 4:46yeah, Chicago, man. Did you like Chicago? It
- 4:48was pretty cool. I had a good time. Yeah. I've
- 4:50always said that, like, Chicago, always, since
- 4:53I was born, when we got to visit Chicago, I was
- 4:56like, man, this is what I wanted New York to
- 4:58be. Because, like, New York is great, but it's
- 5:00just so busy, right? Okay, yeah. Like, Chicago,
- 5:03there wasn't a lot going on, but it was so beautiful.
- 5:06So I was, like, walking through downtown and
- 5:08everything, this is what I wanted New York to
- 5:09be. So I always have a lot of fondness for Chicago.
- 5:12We also went in November, so it was very, like,
- 5:15breezy and cold. I loved it. So I've wanted to
- 5:18go back to Chicago for a while. And when I'm
- 5:21back in Chicago. I was thinking Fall Out Boy
- 5:25if I was going to start quoting Chicago. But
- 5:26that's okay. That's just, that's me. Not Joe.
- 5:31But you know where I don't want to be? Where's
- 5:34that, Ryan? In old Chicago. Yeah. Not that much
- 5:37interest in old Chicago. Hey, good news. Doesn't
- 5:39exist anymore. Hey, we don't have to worry about
- 5:41it. But if we need some kind of evidence as to
- 5:44what it was like to be in old Chicago. Look no
- 5:46further than In Old Chicago. Nailed it. In Old
- 5:50Chicago is the movie we're talking about today,
- 5:52and it is our second to last of our 10th ceremony
- 5:57Academy Award Best Picture. Yeah. Very excited.
- 6:01Six nominations surround this one. Hang with
- 6:03me. Writing, original story, this is Niven Bush.
- 6:07Sound recording, this is 20th Century Fox Sound
- 6:10Department. Of course, E .H. Hansen was the sound
- 6:13director, but as you know. We're still giving
- 6:16it to the sound studios. Music for scoring. This
- 6:20was also 20th Century Fox Studios, the music
- 6:23department. But Louis Silvers was the head of
- 6:27the department there. Assistant director was
- 6:29Robert D. Webb. Actress in a supporting role.
- 6:32This was Alice Brady as Molly O 'Leary. She makes
- 6:35her return to the podcast. An outstanding production,
- 6:3820th Century Fox. 20th Century Fox. We don't
- 6:41get a lot of those. No, we will in the future.
- 6:44Yeah. But at the time, this is a little new.
- 6:46It is. So this was directed by Henry King, and
- 6:49it stars Tyrone Power, Alice Faye, Donamiche,
- 6:54which I love saying that name. Donamiche. Donamiche.
- 6:58And that is not who I expected to see on screen
- 7:01when I said Donamiche. No. Yeah, it's some guy
- 7:04named Jack. And he's like, what up? I'm Jack.
- 7:06Alice Brady, as you mentioned. And Andy Devine
- 7:09with, like, what's becoming the most recognizable
- 7:11voice of the century, I guess. I like to think
- 7:15of him as Friar Tuck from the Robin Hood movie.
- 7:19Oh, interesting. Yeah. Yeah, we've seen him in
- 7:21Romeo and Juliet. But the big names here are
- 7:24Tyrone Power and Donna Miche. I'm actually not
- 7:28going to let you get away with mentioning Andy
- 7:29Devine and not saying his character's name. It's
- 7:32Pickle Bixly. Pickle Bixby. Pickle Bixby. Even
- 7:36better. Yeah. Sometimes I think that's funny
- 7:40where they're like, my name's Pickle. And they're
- 7:41like, great. What's your last name? I'm just
- 7:43going to call you Mr. And they're like, Bixby.
- 7:44Okay. Well, either way, this isn't good. Yep.
- 7:48Yeah, you at home might recognize the title,
- 7:52In Old Chicago, by the first two words in that
- 7:56title, in old. We've done this before. We have.
- 7:59But we've also never done this before. Well,
- 8:02we've done states, right? We've talked about
- 8:04in old Arizona. That's right. But we haven't
- 8:06done specific cities. We haven't. So now we're
- 8:09in old Chicago. There's a lot of, you know, when
- 8:12I was typing in earlier on my phone, like in
- 8:14old, a lot of movies were, did you mean this?
- 8:17Did you mean that? Did you mean this? Like there's
- 8:18a lot of this happening in the in old series.
- 8:21It's like the once upon a time in series. Not
- 8:25at. Not yet. Nope. We're very individual. Mexico,
- 8:30America, Hollywood. Hollywood. Once Upon a Time
- 8:34in... The Bronx? New York? Is it the Bronx? It's
- 8:39a Bronx tale. Bronx tale. That might be what
- 8:41I'm thinking of. Yeah. Harlem? Maybe. Once Upon
- 8:44a Time in Harlem? That sounds right. Maybe. But,
- 8:46you know, it got me thinking. Maybe we went with
- 8:49the wrong title. You know? Once Upon a Time at
- 8:51the Oscars. In old Oscars. In old Oscars, right?
- 8:54I think that we need to look into a name change
- 8:56and do in an old, in old Oscar. In old Hollywood.
- 9:00Yeah. That's, yeah. Yeah, that would make sense.
- 9:03I feel like that could be anything. Not anything,
- 9:06but it could be more than what. It'd have to
- 9:08be three words. Yeah. In old Oscar. In old Oscar.
- 9:13I'm a little concerned of the demographic we
- 9:15might pick up on that. Yeah. Yeah, maybe. But
- 9:17yeah, we've, we've, I like these tropes of. titles
- 9:22that we've seen um i think we'll see tons more
- 9:25of them as as time goes on but as far as the
- 9:28content i still think we're continuing to trope
- 9:31in that though you think so a different but i
- 9:33think this is a a full response to san francisco
- 9:37Totally. Yes. For San Francisco, I was talking
- 9:39about In Old Arizona, where the stories are very,
- 9:43very different, and they have only taken that
- 9:45in old trope. So tell us a little bit about In
- 9:49Old Chicago. In Old Chicago sees mostly the O
- 9:53'Leary family. We see the O 'Leary's, both Alice
- 9:58Brady as Molly O 'Leary, leading her family or
- 10:02following her husband and their young children
- 10:04to start anew in Chicago. And after her husband's
- 10:08unfortunate death, because he lives life a quarter
- 10:12mile at a time with horses and wants to beat
- 10:15a train, she decides to keep moving forward.
- 10:18There's no other option but to just keep moving
- 10:19forward and go to Chicago and start her life
- 10:22there. And she starts her life up as a seamstress
- 10:26and not a seamstress, but a laundromat and cleaning
- 10:29all the clothing for the wealthy in Chicago.
- 10:32And this is how she builds her empire, builds
- 10:35her family. And we see Chicago as not run, but
- 10:39I guess potentially ran by the O 'Leary's. How
- 10:44corrupt it can be and how they want to take over
- 10:47and have more power. And how, as a lawyer and
- 10:49a politician, the two brothers, played by Tyrone
- 10:54Power and Don Amiche, how Dion? Dion. Yeah, I
- 11:00think it's Dion. How Dion and Jack can make a
- 11:04difference. And whether they are together or
- 11:08opposed, what does Chicago look like from that?
- 11:10Yeah. And the setting here, not only is it Chicago,
- 11:14of course, but it's like the seedy kind of poverty
- 11:18stricken part of Chicago called The Patch. The
- 11:23Patch. Yeah. Yeah. Well, and it's a little bit
- 11:26of both because we're seeing like Chicago proper
- 11:28and then we're seeing The Patch. And where the
- 11:30O 'Leary's have survived has been the patch.
- 11:34And I think that, not I think, we do see where
- 11:39Jack is trying to make a difference here. And
- 11:43Jack is really trying to be a politician to try
- 11:45and make all of this better and thrive. Whereas
- 11:49we see Dion actually kind of taking a little
- 11:52bit more of a point of pride in the patch and
- 11:56becoming kind of a leader in that community.
- 11:59Yeah. And then he finds some opposition from
- 12:03his brother in this. He does. If at home you're
- 12:06thinking, hey, they mentioned San Francisco.
- 12:09Why? There's so many similarities to San Francisco.
- 12:13And really, you could take Dion and Jack and
- 12:17make a comparison to Clark Gable and Spencer
- 12:22Tracy's character and just the opposition there
- 12:25of kind of not evil, but, you know. Bad versus
- 12:29good. Yes. And you're seeing that a lot in Tyrone
- 12:33Powers and Don Amiche's characters. And then
- 12:36this is another one of those movies where I don't
- 12:39know if you were familiar with this tragedy.
- 12:42I can't say I was. Not enough. Like if you were
- 12:46to say to me the Great Chicago Fire, I'd be like,
- 12:49oh, I know that it is a thing that happened at
- 12:51some point in history. But no specifics. No specifics.
- 12:54Same. So this is one of those where had I not
- 12:56read the synopsis. Or research during San Francisco?
- 13:00I had no idea what this was about. Well, and
- 13:03that's the thing is, much like San Francisco,
- 13:05it's not really about that. No. Right? Like,
- 13:08that's the thing that you can kind of call back
- 13:09to. Like, with Titanic, I think some people might
- 13:12be like, oh, the Jack and Rose movie. But most
- 13:14people are like, yeah, the iceberg. Right. Like,
- 13:16it's the tragedy that surrounds that movie. So,
- 13:19it's similar in that sense. But you're... You're
- 13:23dead on about how with San Francisco, it's not
- 13:25just, oh, it's a disaster movie at times. The
- 13:29characterization is all there. Dion is playing
- 13:33the Clark Gable. No. Yeah, yeah. Oh, that's right.
- 13:36I would say that. The Clark Gable character and
- 13:38then Father Tim Mullins, that aspect or that
- 13:42character is really played more by Jack. Yeah,
- 13:44Don Amice. Don Amice. And we see the kind of
- 13:47like... Not to say that one's right and one's
- 13:49wrong, but we're seeing one saying like, well,
- 13:51this is morally where we should be and this is
- 13:53what we need to do to get to a better place.
- 13:55And then we see the other person who's like,
- 13:57well, no, I'm of this community and we can't
- 13:59see this community being affected just so other
- 14:01people can be living a better life. And on top
- 14:05of that, I don't mean to diminish her performance
- 14:08in this because I do want to talk about her in
- 14:09length, but Alice Brady's character in this is
- 14:12kind of represented in, is it? Tim Mullen's mother.
- 14:18Oh, when, uh, Clark Gable goes to like get her
- 14:21from the mansion and she like sees her mansion.
- 14:23Oh no. It's, um, that's another character. Yeah.
- 14:27It's a different carry. I can't remember a different
- 14:29character, but like that mother of like seeing
- 14:31what, like her house fall to all of this and
- 14:34what her son would have wanted in that. We see
- 14:36a lot of that in Alice Brady here. So with all
- 14:39that said, we can talk and we will talk a lot
- 14:41about, uh, Tyrone power and Donna Miche, but
- 14:44I do want to talk about Alice Brady. Because
- 14:46Alice Brady is kind of leading this movie. She
- 14:49is. And she does go on to win the Academy Award
- 14:54here for Supporting Actress. Right. And I'd say
- 14:57deservedly. Okay. Here's why. Alice Brady is
- 15:00someone that we're no stranger to talking about.
- 15:02It's true. She's popped up a lot in these movies,
- 15:04but never quite like this. Alice Brady has shown
- 15:07up a lot in comedies. You might remember her
- 15:10most from, I feel like, Troy McClure from The
- 15:14Simpsons. You might know me from, and then some
- 15:18insane title. But you might remember Alice Brady
- 15:22from, was it The Gay Divorcee? The Gay Divorcee,
- 15:25yep. She was Ginger Rogers' best friend and aunt?
- 15:30I think she was the aunt, yeah. Edward Everett
- 15:33Horton's love interest. Yes. Very funny in that.
- 15:37Was she in Libel Lady? No, she was in the two
- 15:40Henry Koster films. Oh, 100 Men and a Girl. Yeah.
- 15:45And three smart girls. So we have seen her a
- 15:48lot in comedies. Like, that's it. Yeah. Primarily
- 15:53comedies. That's right. We just talked about
- 15:55her this year with 100 Men and a Girl and how
- 15:57she was playing like the over -the -top aristocrat.
- 16:03The problem is that everybody wants to be a cat.
- 16:08Oh, you're right. That would have been way better.
- 16:11Aristocrat. and the humor that we saw in that
- 16:15character so in this i wasn't sure to expect
- 16:18i was like oh okay maybe she's kind of like the
- 16:20doting like you know mother like causing you
- 16:22know some mischief here and there but she actually
- 16:25does get the chance to be pretty on in the spotlight
- 16:30yeah with this movie and i liked her a lot in
- 16:33this i think watching like what her uh children
- 16:36go on to be and trying to like monitor that household
- 16:39like i i really do like her performance in this
- 16:42but i do think that the majority of the movie
- 16:44is focusing a bit on the characters of dion and
- 16:48jack so she seems a little lost in it at times
- 16:51i think that's ultimately why they put her in
- 16:53the supporting actress category um because it's
- 16:56not really her movie but her performance is very
- 16:58important to those it is when we get to the end
- 17:03of the movie i'll kind of talk about it and i
- 17:06don't think it's a it's a her thing i think it's
- 17:08the movie itself well that's what happens with
- 17:10movies like this in san francisco is san francisco
- 17:13does a pretty good job of like balancing out
- 17:15the disaster versus like the story of it and
- 17:18in this it just feels i think the balance in
- 17:21this is pretty good too It's just one year removed
- 17:25from San Francisco. And like you mentioned, it's
- 17:28not just the structure of the movie mimicking
- 17:31San Francisco, but it's also the story of Jack
- 17:35and Dion. Dion? Dion. My God, I don't know what's
- 17:39happening. And Father Tim Mullins and, forgive
- 17:44me, Clark Gable's character. Right. Blackie.
- 17:46Blackie, that's right. So Father Mullins and
- 17:49Blackie. jack and die on here yeah it's so monitored
- 17:53in that even the idea of running for mayor is
- 17:56like yes right there it feels like a remake yes
- 17:59and you know there were parts of san francisco
- 18:03in in that plot and storyline where i was like
- 18:05i don't know if i'm really interested in this
- 18:07like trying to promote his club and meeting this
- 18:09girl that he loves and and all of this and i
- 18:12i don't want to say i started getting confused
- 18:14at that plot line but i think i just kind of
- 18:16lost interest and in this movie when it first
- 18:19Took off. I mean, first of all, it opens up with,
- 18:22I think, a great sequence where they are traveling
- 18:25to Chicago. And like you said, the father is
- 18:28racing the train. That train racing scene looks
- 18:31phenomenal. Well, channeling in old, right? Yeah.
- 18:36My immediate thought was in that opening scene,
- 18:39matching it to in old Arizona and where we were
- 18:42then. Right. So how far have we come in that?
- 18:45And I would say extremely far. Like the fact
- 18:49that like the camera, this happens in Lost Horizon
- 18:522, but that the camera can start further away
- 18:55with the horse coming towards the camera, but
- 18:58the sound is recorded throughout. Yeah. And it's
- 19:00not just we have one camera and hopefully like
- 19:02we'll pick up something when the horse goes underneath
- 19:04it. Like we have come a very long way and that
- 19:07scene is exhilarating of him like trying to beat
- 19:10the train. Yeah. And incredible stunt work when
- 19:13they do hit the bump in the road or whatever.
- 19:17Yeah. The reins, I don't know, wagon terms, but
- 19:22he gets pulled from the wagon and dragged. They
- 19:25go over a bump, and then that causes the front
- 19:27wheels to kind of like collapse. Yeah. So then
- 19:30he, holding on to the reins, goes with the horses,
- 19:33but the carriage stays behind. Yes. And he's
- 19:36dragged. Can I ask a question? Okay. Was that
- 19:38funny at all to you? No. The way it was shot,
- 19:41I did laugh. Did you? Because it looked kind
- 19:44of like a pratfall, like something Charlie Chaplin
- 19:46would do, where he's going to get up afterwards
- 19:48and just kind of brush himself off. Sure. So
- 19:50it wasn't like, ha ha, he's dead. It was more
- 19:51like, they're going to be like, oh, dad. And
- 19:53he's like, whoa, whoa. Right. But I was like,
- 19:57oh, that's a comedic thing. And then he dies.
- 20:00Yes. So it's not a comedic thing at all. It's
- 20:02not anymore. No. No, but I get you. Sure. Without
- 20:05knowing. Well, I think it's also the camera work
- 20:07of it. Because it's not just that it happened.
- 20:09It's that they capture the wheel collapsing and
- 20:11then him taking off of the reins. And then he's
- 20:13dragged for maybe 10 seconds. Yeah. You see a
- 20:17lot. You see a good bit. It's a great stunt.
- 20:20It is. So whoever that was, I'm not sure if it
- 20:24was the actor, they got dragged. Yeah. There
- 20:26was no dummy in that. That's true. But that's
- 20:30ultimately how he meets his fate is he's able
- 20:32to talk to his sons and talk about how they need
- 20:35to be good to his mother or their mother and
- 20:36like support her before he passes. Yeah. And
- 20:41I think that that opening, like I was more invested
- 20:44in this movie because I was like, okay, we're
- 20:45opening up with kind of like a cold open and
- 20:48it's really intense. And I'm getting to know
- 20:51this family. That kind of all goes out the window
- 20:54and it only serves as an introduction to Alice
- 20:57Brady's character because everybody else is replaced
- 20:59by older versions of themselves. Then when you
- 21:03get to Chicago and you see the lives they're
- 21:05living, I'm like, okay, well, I'm still in the
- 21:08mindset of where I'm enjoying this story more
- 21:11than San Francisco. There is one aspect that
- 21:15we've skipped over that I do really want to get
- 21:17into, and that's where her children, while she's
- 21:20trying to find a place to live or to start their
- 21:23life in Chicago, they try to help through different
- 21:26shenanigans, helping the wealthy get what they
- 21:29need. Specifically, women who are stuck in a
- 21:32carriage are trying to get out, but there's a
- 21:34patch of mud, and they're trying to get beyond
- 21:36it, and the kids help, but accidentally they
- 21:39drop, I think, the mother of the family in the
- 21:42mud. And she's all upset because her clothing's
- 21:45ruined. And her mother's like, hey, I'll make
- 21:47you a deal. Like, I bet I can get that out in
- 21:49like, you know, three in one day. But you owe
- 21:52me like, you know, $20 or whatever. And if not,
- 21:54it's free. Yeah. And that's ultimately how she
- 21:57starts her like laundromat business. But that
- 22:00thing I wanted to talk about. Was while she's
- 22:02washing this dress, you can see, like, as she's
- 22:06washing it more and more, bubbles start showing
- 22:08up on the screen showing the years. Yes, that
- 22:10was fun. Loved that. Yeah. Looked really good.
- 22:13Sometimes, like, that's the thing. Watching these
- 22:15movies from the 30s, I'm often impressed. And
- 22:19I'm trying to think, like, hey, I know we didn't
- 22:20have, like, the visual capability of, like, graphic
- 22:24work that we do now with CG and, like, practical
- 22:27effects. But how do they do some of these things?
- 22:29It has to be animated. It has to be, but it looks
- 22:32so good. It doesn't look out of place. Sometimes
- 22:35the hand -drawn or the animated or stop -motion
- 22:40versus actual filming, you can see the difference
- 22:44so easily. But in this, it blends so extremely
- 22:47well. It looked great. So all the separate years
- 22:49coming up as bubbles before they pop and go past
- 22:52the screen shows the passing of time, and that's
- 22:55where we see the grown version of the children.
- 22:57Yes. There's also a third child named Bob. And
- 23:01Bob is mostly there to be like, hey, I have a
- 23:04wife, and she's the Dutch farm girl who we hired.
- 23:08Oh, yes, who is the catalyst, really, for so
- 23:13many things. That's right, right? Like, she's
- 23:16the cause, in a way, of what happens? I would
- 23:20say no. I would say we'll get there. Well, I
- 23:26would just say this, that maybe we shouldn't
- 23:29be eating more chicken. That's what I'm trying
- 23:30to say. Well, yeah. I think it's the cow. It
- 23:34is the cow, but there was somebody that left
- 23:37the lantern, and I couldn't remember if it was
- 23:40that guy's wife. Wasn't it the mother? Was it
- 23:44Alice Brady? I think it was Alice Brady. Oh,
- 23:45no. And she won for this? Yeah. She caused a
- 23:48tragedy. Oh, no, remember? Because she was like,
- 23:50hey, don't kick your mom. Or, yeah, she's like,
- 23:53stop kicking your mom. You're going to upset
- 23:54her. and nudging i think is what she says oh
- 23:57that's right because the the baby calf was like
- 24:00feeding and would just like throw its head against
- 24:02the mom's udder yeah and then the mom kicks because
- 24:04of it you know let's take a side beat uh what
- 24:11yeah that's it okay perfect yeah let's do that
- 24:14and let's talk about the acting of these cows
- 24:17Cow acting. Cow acting. Yeah. You know, we've
- 24:20had the incredible Skippy the dog, or Asta. Skippy,
- 24:25Asta, Mr. Smith. Yep, that's the one. We have
- 24:28had Swine Time on the show. We love some Swine
- 24:31Time. We love Swine Time. Here on Cow Corner,
- 24:34we're going to discuss the incredible acting
- 24:38abilities of these bovines. We really haven't
- 24:41had a chance to talk about this since, um, oh,
- 24:44Louis Pasteur? Oh, you're right. Yeah, there
- 24:48were some cows there. Yeah, I mean, that's pretty
- 24:51integral to the plot. Yeah, a little bit. Not
- 24:53a ton of acting showcased. It's more like cows
- 24:55in general. Right. We just show a number of cows.
- 24:59They were background cows. I'm very familiar.
- 25:02Yeah, background cows. But now we get the...
- 25:04Cattle call. That's not even funny. That's what
- 25:09it is. Cattle call. You know what? That's what
- 25:16this segment's called. Yeah. Cattle call. Yeah,
- 25:18get out of here with cow corner. It's the cattle
- 25:20call. Can you put in, obviously not now, but
- 25:22can you put in like a bell, maybe like a triangle?
- 25:26Yeah, like the cow bell. Yeah. Add that in here
- 25:29for cattle call. Cattle call. Oh, it's going
- 25:32to be so good. Cattle call. Cattle call. So these
- 25:35cows, right, when we're first introduced to them,
- 25:38the one is being milked. Can we name her? Sure.
- 25:42What's her name? Bessie Love. Oh, no. Yeah, we
- 25:47could do that. Just Bessie. Yeah, the cow is
- 25:50doing its thing. And she kicks. Who is this?
- 25:53Is this Ty? No, this is Bob, the other brother.
- 25:56Yes. Yeah, this is the third brother. And it
- 25:58is a very cute moment where he's talking to his
- 26:01soon -to -be wife. And he's like, hey, let's
- 26:05go be cute together. I don't remember exactly
- 26:08what happens. I think that's exactly what he
- 26:09says. Gretchen is her name. Gretchen. Okay. It's
- 26:12kind of a throwaway scene where Bob. Doesn't
- 26:16really matter as a character. Neither does Gretchen.
- 26:18Not until later, but yeah. The most important
- 26:21element of this is to show that, hey, this cow
- 26:23kicks sometimes. That's it. And there is a moment
- 26:27where the cow does kick Bob into Gretchen so
- 26:31that they embrace and they kiss. And the cow
- 26:34looks back at Bob with the most intense look
- 26:38I've ever seen a cow give. And I laughed so hard.
- 26:42Well, I think this movie should be renamed. I
- 26:45think it shouldn't be in Old Chicago. It should
- 26:47be as the cow moves. Because this is a story
- 26:51about how, I mean, maybe horses and cows, but
- 26:54how cows kind of are the cause of everything.
- 26:57Because Bob and Gretchen don't get together if
- 27:01not for the cow. That's true. The fire does not
- 27:05start in Chicago. All of Chicago doesn't burn
- 27:08down if not for Bessie Love, the cow. You know,
- 27:12I kind of think about this now. The cow didn't
- 27:14make it out, right? Like the cow definitely burned
- 27:17with the fire. Like first. Yes. Yeah. So do we
- 27:21think that like the cow was just angry at everything?
- 27:24It was like, I don't, you guys just get together.
- 27:27I don't care. And that kicks him into her. And
- 27:29then her cow or her cow, her child is nudging
- 27:33her while he's trying, she's trying to feed him.
- 27:35And she's like, you know what? I'm done. Just
- 27:38kicks the fire, the lantern into the hay. He's
- 27:41like, we're done. We're just move on. That is
- 27:43so dark. I'm just saying. To think about. Because
- 27:46this is all, like, this movie is about, like,
- 27:47hey, here's how politics are affected by this
- 27:50family. In reality, the cow is doing everything.
- 27:52Yeah. That's true. That's a big element of this
- 27:55movie. And this is based on real life, historical
- 27:59events, of course. San Francisco. That's what
- 28:01this should be called, is San Francisco. San
- 28:03Francisco. Yes. I thought you just shouted San
- 28:06Francisco. I was like, no. No. It should be San
- 28:09Francisco. An old Chicago. An old Chicago. In
- 28:12old Chicago. In old Chicago. Chocolate milk.
- 28:18Ah, that's my best one yet. In old Chicago. Chicago
- 28:22is good. Yeah. We have to move on from the cow.
- 28:25I just thought the cow was funny. I can't. Towards
- 28:28the end of the movie when the calf does nudge
- 28:31and the cow kicks, that actually happens. And
- 28:33I'm like, how did they get the cow, both of them,
- 28:36to do this? Well, I think unfortunately they
- 28:38were probably just slapping the crap out of the
- 28:41back of the cows. i don't think it was good i
- 28:43don't think they're like all right cow now i
- 28:45think they probably had to provoke it a little
- 28:47bit yeah now i think the the the calf was probably
- 28:51just hungry and they were just like filming okay
- 28:53just he'll probably nudge the cow at some point
- 28:55yeah um yeah it's like a lot of cow talk yeah
- 28:58a lot um thanks for coming to uh what do we call
- 29:00it cattle call yeah uh cattle call and now on
- 29:03to cow beret uh there's a couple of other things
- 29:06that this movie has in common with san francisco
- 29:09San Francisco, not just the disaster aspect and
- 29:12not just the betrayal of two brother -like figures
- 29:15and that's actual brothers, but also there's
- 29:18a cabaret in this. There is. So, and not just,
- 29:22I mean, look, there's a cabaret everywhere at
- 29:23these times, but... not just a cabaret but like
- 29:26the cabaret actress is integral to the plot as
- 29:29well yeah so there's just a lot of this that
- 29:31feels like hey i know i saw san francisco so
- 29:34it's hard to give this movie a lot of the praise
- 29:35that it may sound like we're giving it because
- 29:38it just stemmed with san francisco and again
- 29:40everything is a remake everything is a remake
- 29:43or a mod of another thing But this was a year
- 29:45later. Right. Right. This is so fresh to that,
- 29:48that it's hard not to see this and think that
- 29:51they may have taken some aspects from that story.
- 29:54So I will say that Daryl F. Zanuck did want Gene
- 30:00Harlow and Clark Gable for this movie specifically.
- 30:03I did see that. But Louis B. Mayer, head of MGM
- 30:06at the time, refused to loan them out. So even
- 30:11that is almost kind of like an indictment. Of
- 30:13like, hey, you know who was great in a disaster
- 30:17movie? These two. Let's bring them in. And he
- 30:20couldn't. So he's like, all right, find these
- 30:21people. So it just feels like they're like, yeah,
- 30:23let's make San Francisco again. And that's the
- 30:26funny thing. San Francisco didn't clean up last
- 30:28year at the Oscars. So it's almost like you're
- 30:32just trying to make that movie for the money,
- 30:34which of course you are. But again, that's just
- 30:38an indictment of how you're just trying to make
- 30:39that movie again. Yeah. I do want to point out,
- 30:42too, that... I think that Gene Harlow element
- 30:45of that story, like, yes, he wanted her, but
- 30:48it wasn't that he wouldn't loan her out. She
- 30:50died. Well. Yeah. That changes some things. So
- 30:54probably Cary Grant. Yes. That makes sense. But
- 30:56yeah, Gene Harlow did pass away in June of 1937.
- 30:59And this movie, funny enough, came out in 1938
- 31:02is how it's listed. Yes. Don't know why that
- 31:05is. Yeah, I don't know. It definitely qualified
- 31:06for the 1938 Oscars. having released in 1937,
- 31:10but it didn't. So I don't know how that goes.
- 31:12Yeah, I'm going to assume that it was so early
- 31:17in the year. Yeah, here it is. It premiered January
- 31:206th, 1938. So it must have been so early in the
- 31:24year that they allowed it to pass, which is interesting.
- 31:28Must have been. Yeah. I also just noticed there's
- 31:31a Letterboxd review that I can, it must be your
- 31:34burner account. Best cow acting I've ever seen.
- 31:38But then it says correction second best, and
- 31:40I want to know what they're talking about. Hey,
- 31:41you know what? If we keep watching the Oscars,
- 31:44maybe we'll get to First Cow. First Cow. And
- 31:46maybe that's... You know that movie? It's an
- 31:48A24 movie. I don't know that. We'll get there.
- 31:52Don't worry about it. Sorry, I was hoping I could
- 31:53find what cow he was talking to, but he's not.
- 31:55Or talking about. Talking to would be cool. Talking
- 31:58to the cow. Hey, Alice Faye is that actress that
- 32:02took the Jean Harlow part over. And when you
- 32:06first see her, her outfits are very reminiscent
- 32:08of Jean Harlow's character in, like, She Done
- 32:11Him Wrong. And she kind of has, like, that attitude.
- 32:13She, nothing against Alice Faye, but she's definitely
- 32:16not Jean Harlow. She does a great job here. Her
- 32:19performance is solid. Here's where I ran into
- 32:22my first problem with the movie, though. Let's
- 32:24go. Tyrone Power, very handsome. I think he's
- 32:28very handsome. He has a Kyle MacLachlan smile
- 32:30that I could not get over. To me... Beyond Cary
- 32:33Grant, beyond Gary Cooper, just a handsome guy
- 32:36all around. He discovers Belle Fawcett is Alice
- 32:41Faye's character's name, the burlesque dancer,
- 32:44and immediately falls in love with her. And then
- 32:47he proceeds to spend the next 30 to 40 minutes
- 32:50of the movie being one of the most disgusting
- 32:54men that we've seen portrayed in these movies
- 32:57yet. I think that there is a twist in this movie,
- 33:01and it's not the fire. And the twist comes at
- 33:05the expense of Dion, Tyrone Power, and Belle
- 33:11that you mentioned. And it is where we think
- 33:15that Jack is probably the most sinister person
- 33:19in this, in that he is running for office and
- 33:22he has successfully gotten the power and the
- 33:26role because of a trick that Dion played. And
- 33:29now the patch. Is rumored to be removed. And
- 33:34it's, this is the thing. San Francisco, the earthquake
- 33:38came out of nowhere. Right. In old Chicago, every
- 33:4210 minutes, there's a character who's like, hey,
- 33:44did you know that the patch is a fire liability?
- 33:46Yeah. There's just dry area without rain. One
- 33:50match places a tinderbox. It's made entirely
- 33:53out of pine. Right. Though, like every 10 minutes,
- 33:56they're like, hey, you think there's a fire that
- 33:57could happen here? And you're like, okay, yeah,
- 33:59I see what's going to happen. They're saying,
- 34:02hey, it's a tinderbox. We got to replace it.
- 34:03And Dion takes some umbrage with that. Now, what
- 34:07we see happen is that Dion takes this more seriously
- 34:12than he does his relationship. And his girlfriend
- 34:17at this time, Belle, is upset by that. He shows
- 34:20back up in her place. There's a scene that I
- 34:23think is supposed to be played for laughs, but
- 34:25it's kind of just like haunting. Happens twice.
- 34:27Where he shows up, she doesn't want him there,
- 34:29and he kind of, like, grabs her and forces her
- 34:31to, like, stay still. Mm -hmm. Enough to where
- 34:34her, like, housemaid is like, I'm gonna call
- 34:37the cops. Leaves. Brings the cops. By the time
- 34:40she gets back, Belle has changed her mind. She's
- 34:42like, oh, I actually love you. And then they
- 34:44just start kissing. Yeah. And each time, the
- 34:47cop, like, looks at the housemaid like, ooh,
- 34:49you're bothering me on my day off. Right. Or
- 34:51something. You're wasting my time. Exactly. And...
- 34:54I guess it's supposed to be funny, but it's just
- 34:56more like, hey, let go of her. And granted, it's
- 35:002026 goggles. It's different. But he does this
- 35:04again. And he comes back and says, hey, I'm in
- 35:07it. I'm committed. And if you want to kick me
- 35:08out, kick me out. But I want to marry you. And
- 35:10we need to be together. And I want to do it right
- 35:13now. Let's get married. And they get married.
- 35:16And he goes to tell his brother, which is like
- 35:19a joyous moment. But in reality. He's like, hey,
- 35:22isn't this great? You just married us. That's
- 35:24fantastic. You're our officiant, and I'm so happy
- 35:26that you were able to do it. Now you can't indict
- 35:27me. And he is like maniacally laughing like the
- 35:31Joker while he says this. rightfully so the movie
- 35:36plays this as a tragic twist and it films both
- 35:40jack and bell's reactions more than dion's and
- 35:44i loved that because it showed the heartbreak
- 35:46on both of their sides now with jack it's a little
- 35:49bit more of like a tom and jerry cartoon of like
- 35:51oh i can't believe you do this to me but bell's
- 35:54reaction is the most heartbreaking and it's the
- 35:56one that camera lingers on the most and while
- 35:58this like twist was like very shocking Because
- 36:01it didn't feel like that was in Dion's character
- 36:03to be able to do something like this. Right.
- 36:05You can see him actually going mad when like
- 36:07he announces this, that he can't be indicted
- 36:09now. I thought that was so interesting. But that's
- 36:13the twist you're talking about here, right? I
- 36:15mean, the twist is the like harassment to me.
- 36:19Yes. That is so extreme. Because the moment you
- 36:23talk about where he has her pinned down on the
- 36:25ground, like they've already. Yes. Quote unquote.
- 36:29So like there is at least a familiarity to that
- 36:32conflict. But she's throwing like a vase at him
- 36:35and it's shattering. Yes. No, it's violent. It's
- 36:38when he first goes into her room after he watches
- 36:41her perform and he's like, hi, I'm Jack. I'm
- 36:43in love with you. Let's be together forever.
- 36:47And he is being physical with her in that moment,
- 36:51which is insane. And then it progresses to where
- 36:55he gets kicked out of the club. Um, because he
- 36:58does say, oh, I'm going to donate like a thousand
- 37:00dollars to, to whatever you're raising money
- 37:03for. Uh, and he gets kicked out for just being
- 37:06a menace and he camps out in her stage coach.
- 37:10So when she gets in, he's like, I've already
- 37:13paid the driver to take me to your place. Let's,
- 37:17let's get together. And it's so vile and disgusting.
- 37:21Well, unfortunately, it's perpetuating that stereotype
- 37:25that women overreact. Yeah. So, like, I think
- 37:28everyone watching the movie at that time is believing
- 37:31that stereotype of, like, oh, yeah, you know
- 37:33how women can be. And if you just, like, give
- 37:36them a second, they'll calm down and everything
- 37:37will be okay. And, yeah, I had to wait on her
- 37:40stagecoach because where else would she be? And
- 37:41the audience would be like, ah, it's a good point.
- 37:43Right. Makes sense. It's so outdated. And then
- 37:45it's... The fact that she like falls for Dion
- 37:48at any point is very much the, hey, girl, let's
- 37:54be real. That's Tyrone Powers. Like, what are
- 37:57you doing? Yeah. Just let it happen. It's so
- 37:59gross. It is. And I think also in the story,
- 38:02too, not only is he just like so conventionally
- 38:04beautiful, but also he has so much power. Like
- 38:07he is a known name in the patch. So she's like.
- 38:12okay well how bad could he really be yeah so
- 38:15i agree like watching him do these things it's
- 38:18almost easier to write off but then the real
- 38:19like i think fully formed version of himself
- 38:23is when he reveals this yeah and when he reveals
- 38:26that it's not just and this is what i like about
- 38:28the movie it's not just a reveal to those characters
- 38:31it's a reveal to the audience as well right and
- 38:34i think in a movie that is absolutely showing
- 38:37its hand at every turn hey, this place could
- 38:39be a tinderbox if one match goes off. And a movie
- 38:43that's doing that constantly, that was one thing
- 38:46where you're like, what? Yeah. What do you mean?
- 38:48What a genuine twist. A genuine reveal. And it's
- 38:53not fun or exciting. It's just more like, oh
- 38:55my God, that's terrible. And you really start
- 38:58wanting to root against this character who otherwise,
- 39:01even with his problematic tendencies, you don't
- 39:05think of as a real heel. But now he is like the
- 39:08real villain of this movie. And I thought that
- 39:12was interesting. I think it's kind of undone
- 39:14by the fire. Like when the fire happens, it's
- 39:16more like kumbaya. We got to get together and
- 39:18figure this thing out. The fire's weird in this
- 39:20movie. And it does happen pretty suddenly. So
- 39:23like shortly after this happens between Jack,
- 39:27Dion, and Belle, we then cut to the house where
- 39:31Alice Brady is with Bob and Gretchen. Bob and
- 39:34Gretchen have had a child at this point. And
- 39:37the fire happens because Bessie kicks the lantern
- 39:42into the hay and just erupts from there. Now,
- 39:47I do want to talk about this whole sequence.
- 39:49Similarly from San Francisco, it is extremely
- 39:52well done. A lot of practical nature in this.
- 39:55It cost $150 ,000 not to make this movie, but
- 40:01to stage and burn the set for three days. So
- 40:04just the fire sequences themselves were like
- 40:07$150 ,000. So they knew they had to make it a
- 40:10very big cost, and they did. And that's one thing,
- 40:14just showing the fires themselves and how that
- 40:17comes to be. But the thing that I really thought
- 40:20was well done about this is the only thing missing
- 40:23from San Francisco is the score and the memorable
- 40:27sounds from it. They just kind of let the scene
- 40:30happen itself. Like, you know, the crumbling
- 40:32of towers and buildings, like all of that is
- 40:35the sound. And this, obviously we're hearing
- 40:38the fires, but there's also like this bell chiming
- 40:41that's happening throughout. And at first I thought
- 40:45maybe this was like, okay, there's a fire truck
- 40:47or a carriage or something nearby and that's
- 40:50the bell. But throughout like the 20 minute scenes
- 40:53of the fire, that bell continues and it's haunting.
- 40:57It disturbed me when it was happening. So I loved
- 41:02this. I mentioned that they were nominated for
- 41:05music scoring. And there's obviously music that
- 41:07plays throughout this movie, too. But I just
- 41:09want to kind of give some credit to Louis Silvers
- 41:11and the music department there. Because the fire
- 41:14sequences of the score, or lack thereof, with
- 41:17just the bell ringing, is really, really haunting
- 41:21and dark. I do like that San Francisco... Made
- 41:25the template of. Hey when we get to the disaster.
- 41:28It's serious. People are going to die. You're
- 41:31going to see people like. Immediately mourning
- 41:34people. Or looking for people. And just chaos.
- 41:37And it is going to be haunting. And I like that
- 41:39this movie continues with that trend. That was
- 41:41set before it. I think that the fire itself.
- 41:45Looks fantastic. I love the way it grows. You
- 41:51know. When you first see it you're like. Okay
- 41:53we're at the fire. Yeah, that looks pretty severe,
- 41:56and it gets so bad. It's pretty incredible that
- 42:01they were able to make it look as large and uncontrollable
- 42:05as it appears on film, when obviously they had
- 42:08a pretty good handle on the situation on set.
- 42:12I think this has more chaos than San Francisco,
- 42:15too. There's a big moment where, is it Gretchen
- 42:20that gets swept up in the crowd at one point?
- 42:23uh gretchen and it's gretchen who gets swept
- 42:28up in the crowd with uh alice brady gotcha because
- 42:32they're carrying the baby out yeah it's one of
- 42:34those where where like people become water in
- 42:37a way and and it's like they're being swept downstream
- 42:39with this massive herd of people that are uh
- 42:43just fleeing from the fire and then later there's
- 42:47there's an actual stampede that Kills another
- 42:50one of, like, the rival politicians. He's hanging
- 42:53off the side of a building and lets go and completely
- 42:55gets Mufasa'd. And there's so many different
- 43:02things that happen in this. And I think that
- 43:04San Francisco plays off the tragedy in a very
- 43:08haunting way, but also in a very hopeful way.
- 43:11Yes. That this movie does not do. Well, there's
- 43:15a, in San Francisco, there is a, we have saved
- 43:18the soul of Blackie. Yes. And Father Tim Mullins
- 43:22has done a part in this too. So now all the characters
- 43:24that we have come to love, at least these main
- 43:27three, can move forward and rebuild San Francisco
- 43:30to where we actually see the rebuild of San Francisco.
- 43:33In this, it's much more focused on, I think the
- 43:36last lines of the movie are Alice Brady being
- 43:38like, us O 'Leary's are a crazy tribe or something
- 43:43like that. And we will be, we will. continue
- 43:47to be a tribe. So it's less like Chicago will
- 43:50rise again. It's more like the O 'Leary's are
- 43:52here to stay. So it's more focused on the family
- 43:54than it is like San Francisco in general. And
- 43:57I think San Francisco, the movie, does a better
- 44:00job of completing the story for the characters
- 44:02and the setting. And in this, it's more like,
- 44:05well, Chicago had to burn because those crazy
- 44:07O 'Leary's were at play. Right. But I also think
- 44:10that during the chaos of the fire, there's so
- 44:13much like violence. between people that it really
- 44:18does lack that that uh feeling of hope that san
- 44:21francisco has well even humanity yeah yeah there
- 44:24are people shooting at people during during the
- 44:27sequence um because the the plan of course just
- 44:30like in uh san francisco where they're like oh
- 44:33we're gonna demolish these buildings so that
- 44:36there's not a chain of fires that take place
- 44:38they're gonna do the same thing here they're
- 44:39gonna dynamite these buildings so people are
- 44:42like trying to burn the buildings First? Is that
- 44:45what they're doing? Like, why are they trying
- 44:47to set fire to the building? I didn't understand
- 44:49that. I don't think it's that they're trying
- 44:51to set fire to the building. Well, maybe they
- 44:53stop it. One guy runs up with a torch. Well,
- 44:56okay, maybe they're trying to stop or set the
- 44:58building on fire so when the fire arrives, it
- 45:01can't continue to burn. It's just already burned.
- 45:03Maybe? It's not really clarified. I get that,
- 45:05but, like, how do you stop it from doing what
- 45:08it was going to do originally then? Like, moving
- 45:10on to the next house from there? I don't think
- 45:12he had a plan. Doesn't it seem weird? I'll be
- 45:14honest with you. I was confused. I think he was
- 45:15like, the fire rises. Yeah. They expect one of
- 45:18us in the wreckage, brother. I think he was just
- 45:20kind of like going for it. Yeah, because I think
- 45:21at this point, Jack is trying to prevent them
- 45:24from blowing up this building. Yes. And he gets
- 45:27shot in trying to do so. And ultimately, he meets
- 45:32his demise, one from the bullet and then from
- 45:34the building collapsing on top of him. Well,
- 45:36this is my question. Was it Jack or Dion who
- 45:39died at the end? It was Jack. Okay. Yeah. So
- 45:42Dion makes it through. Yeah. Because I thought
- 45:44at one point Dion was the guy on the gutter who
- 45:46fell and got Mufasa'd. No, that was the other,
- 45:49like, bearded politician that shows up halfway
- 45:53through the movie. He's like, my name's Mufasa.
- 45:56Yeah. Long live the king. Yeah, no, Dion makes
- 46:01it to the end of the movie. And that's what's
- 46:03so strange about this movie, too, is that he's
- 46:05clearly... the problem in this movie he's clearly
- 46:07the villain well him and the cow him and the
- 46:09cow yeah oh god what a dark dark twist but at
- 46:14the end of the movie it's it's him and his wife
- 46:17bell and there's a moment too which is very sad
- 46:21for bell where she's kind of standing there away
- 46:24from everybody and just traumatized by everything
- 46:27going on and alice brady calls her out and she's
- 46:29like what are you doing like Your husband just
- 46:32showed up. He survived all of this and you're
- 46:34just standing there. Why aren't you comforting
- 46:35him? But she doesn't know everything that's happened.
- 46:38Yeah. So she like walks over very hesitantly
- 46:41and she's like, hey, they're Dion. They're there.
- 46:45And it's so sad to think about. And then Alice
- 46:48Brady gives like her final speech was which feels
- 46:51very like shoehorned in. Yep. Of. Okay, we've
- 46:55got to say the thing about hope and everything.
- 46:58While the fires are still burning, it's not like
- 47:00San Francisco where... The soul is intact, so
- 47:04now we can rebuild. Yeah, who is it in that movie?
- 47:07Who has the speech? Who's singing Closer the
- 47:11Unto God? Oh, it's Jean Harlow. Not Jean Harlow.
- 47:14Isn't she singing with the church group? It's
- 47:19the lead actress in that, but it's not Jean Harlow.
- 47:21Jean Harlow, she done him wrong. Jeanette McDonald.
- 47:25Jeanette McDonald. Yes, thank you. Yeah, Jeanette
- 47:27McDonald is singing. You know, and, like, everything
- 47:30is kind of, they say, like, the fires are starting
- 47:33to stop. And she's singing and Blackie finds
- 47:37her. Like, there is closure, not only to the
- 47:40family or the character stories, but, like, the
- 47:42story of the tragedy itself. And in this, it
- 47:45feels like everything is still burning. They
- 47:48are still losing people. And Alice Brady is like,
- 47:52hope. hope is how we persevere yeah yeah like
- 47:55what are you doing well so i want to point out
- 47:59something about that um it almost feels like
- 48:02alice brady was playing okay hang with me like
- 48:06alice brady was playing um molly o 'leary but
- 48:11then tyrone power and um bell faucet's character
- 48:16alice fey the actress it's like that actually
- 48:19happened to them that divorce or like you know
- 48:21hey i actually just only got married to you so
- 48:23i wouldn't be indicted and once they get to that
- 48:25final scene molly o 'leary is looking at those
- 48:28two actors like hey get places get in your places
- 48:31what are you doing i have to give my speech so
- 48:33it just it feels so out of place because she's
- 48:36expecting something of them that isn't going
- 48:38to happen so she can say her line yes that's
- 48:41kind of how she says it is not just like hey
- 48:43why aren't you with my son because my son's the
- 48:45best it's just more like like she's almost like
- 48:47nudging her shoulder she's like in line yeah
- 48:50Now, it falls flat so hard. It does. It doesn't
- 48:53land. It pulls away from Alice Brady's performance
- 48:55for me. And that's kind of what I was saying
- 48:57earlier is that the story itself is the problem
- 49:00here, I think. Yes. Just Dion's personality and
- 49:04the way that he treats Belle in this movie is
- 49:06so hard to watch. And just the lead up to the
- 49:11fire is so heavy handed in the, did you know
- 49:14there could be a fire and it would be really
- 49:16bad? None of this has the same effect. by the
- 49:19final act of the movie that san francisco did
- 49:22and it it takes away not only from alice brady's
- 49:24performance which she did win for and i don't
- 49:27know that she should have just based on the movie
- 49:30itself and i don't think that the fire was as
- 49:34exciting to watch as the earthquake i think because
- 49:38there are so many uh showcases of like the humans
- 49:42being the problem here you know it it did not
- 49:46work for me well i think also with san francisco
- 49:49it's very easy to make the comparison of we're
- 49:52watching uh humanity and like human uh human
- 49:54beings and then we're watching nature and like
- 49:57this is just something that happens there's nothing
- 49:59that's caused it's just nature where like tectonic
- 50:02plates shift and earthquakes will happen and
- 50:05in this it's more well here's the humanity and
- 50:07then this cow knocked over this so now it's just
- 50:11gonna be a fire yeah and you could say it's nature
- 50:13but like it wasn't just started naturally this
- 50:15just happens right like some something caused
- 50:18this and they even do the the foreshadowing where
- 50:21bob gets kicked by the the horse earlier or the
- 50:24cow earlier in the movie and this is why i think
- 50:27it should be called as the cow moose because
- 50:30it's not about humanity and like how we affected
- 50:33things it's how this cow is causing everything
- 50:35to happen that's true good and bad you're right
- 50:37So, as the cow moves. Where did this land for
- 50:40you overall? As the utter... No. I was trying
- 50:43to think of other ways to do this. Utter ways.
- 50:45Utter mother. Utter mommy. Utter mommy. Oh, wow.
- 50:52What a timely reference. It just came out when
- 50:54this was released. Well, there you go. It's already
- 50:56been out. That's fine. Oops. Oh, my God. What
- 51:01did I rate this? Is that what you asked? Yeah,
- 51:02yeah. Like, where did it fall for you? Before
- 51:04I, well, that's a hell of a segue. I didn't mean
- 51:07that. But before we get into the ratings, I do
- 51:10want to point out that the similarities of San
- 51:11Francisco and Old Chicago don't stop there. Because
- 51:15there is an aspect when the fire first starts
- 51:17hitting downtown that we see a fire has, like,
- 51:20you know, there's multiple people trying to evacuate.
- 51:22And there's a person on the third or fourth floor
- 51:25of a building who actually jumps off. into the
- 51:28fire because he believes it's going to be safer
- 51:30on the ground than it is in the building and
- 51:32that's a direct scene from san francisco that
- 51:35we talked about on the episode where it was so
- 51:37dark and like difficult to watch of them realizing
- 51:41they'd be safer on the ground than in the building
- 51:43so they just jump and that was when to me i was
- 51:47like i kind of got out of it the movie kicked
- 51:49me out of it where i was like that's just that
- 51:51is san francisco yeah we've seen it and again
- 51:54movies can be iterations of each other but When
- 51:57you came out a year ago, and it's been a month
- 51:59since you and I talked about San Francisco, of
- 52:02course we're going to see the parallels. Yeah.
- 52:04And not just in tone and not just in subject
- 52:07matter, but in actual scenes. Yeah, like the
- 52:10visuals. The visuals, the setup of the characters.
- 52:13It's all there. Yeah. So that just, to me, that
- 52:16continued to degrade the movie. So ultimately,
- 52:19when we talk about ratings, I did give In Old
- 52:22Chicago the same rating as you. Ooh. The same
- 52:25rating as Bryce, friend of the pod. Two and a
- 52:28half. Two and a half, yeah. Look, The Fire is
- 52:32some of the best work in the movie. Alice Brady,
- 52:35I want to commend her just for seeing the comedic
- 52:38roles that she has done. This is a good dramatic
- 52:40role for her. That is true. I agree with you.
- 52:44I don't think it's like, hey, this was best actress
- 52:46material supporting her otherwise. But it was
- 52:50still good of a dramatic turn for someone that
- 52:53we have seen. thrive in a comedic aspect up to
- 52:58this point. I think that's the thing. It's not
- 53:01best actress material, but it is a best actress
- 53:04performance. It is. Yeah. Yes. But boy, the material
- 53:08just fell so flat for me. And I think there are
- 53:11a lot of things in this movie that are great,
- 53:13like the fire and everything at the end. It all
- 53:16looks great. I liked the... opening scene of
- 53:20this movie and I liked the idea of following
- 53:23the O 'Leary's and all of that especially two
- 53:25brothers at odds yeah yeah I liked a lot of that
- 53:28more than I liked Blackie's character until you're
- 53:32introduced to like just the snake that Dion becomes
- 53:35in this movie not even becomes like he kind of
- 53:39is that from the moment he meets Belle so I don't
- 53:42know there's a lot that I like in both movies
- 53:45but San Francisco is the the supreme Of the two.
- 53:50Completely agreed. Yeah. So how about a double
- 53:53feature? So the double features, I want to lean
- 53:55into the brother aspect, which I think is of
- 53:58everything we talked about, the one that works
- 53:59the best. Fox and the Hound. I'd appreciate if
- 54:03you didn't just pull the rug under my feet like
- 54:05that. By the way, a lot of Fox and the Hound
- 54:07merch at Disney. Did you see that? I did not.
- 54:10Disney Store, Disney Springs specifically had
- 54:12a lot of like Fox and the Hound, like them smiling.
- 54:14And I was like, have they seen the movie? That's
- 54:17not. They don't do that. That's not the vibe
- 54:19that I remember. Taylor was like, oh, that's
- 54:22cute. It was like, watch the movie again. Yeah.
- 54:24So no, my double feature, I want to lean into
- 54:27the brothers. I think that that's, that is a
- 54:30great feature for me. Having brothers or, well,
- 54:33I do have brothers, but also Tim and I, like
- 54:36we love a brother movie and Warriors is a, one
- 54:40of our favorites, Warrior. Joel Edgerton, Tom
- 54:43Brady, Tom Brady, not Tom Brady, Tom Hardy. I'm
- 54:47losing my mind. Brothers at Odds is always a
- 54:50lot of fun to watch. So I wanted to pair this
- 54:52with a movie of Brothers at Odds, and I paired
- 54:54that with someone we've already talked about
- 54:56off -pod today. That's a James Gray movie from
- 54:592007. This is the right way to say that. We Own
- 55:03the Night. We Own the Night is a fantastic movie
- 55:09about two brothers on opposite sides of the law.
- 55:12One who's a criminal, one who's a cop. And in
- 55:15this... it's a very similar thing with one brother
- 55:17in power and as a mayor and the other as running
- 55:21the, um, I guess the ghetto, uh, the patch of
- 55:25the town or of the city. And we on the night
- 55:28is a far superior movie. Um, but especially the
- 55:33James Gray direction. It's so good. Um, walking
- 55:36Phoenix is in it's great movie, a fantastic,
- 55:40uh, driving shot about three fourths, fourths
- 55:43of this movie. Um, but definitely, Channels into
- 55:45the Brothers in Power and Brothers at Odds that
- 55:48I think is the best version of in Old Chicago.
- 55:51Interesting. I've never heard of that movie.
- 55:53It's great. If you can believe it. You should
- 55:54check it out. I will. I will. Good. One day I'll
- 55:57go back and I'll watch all the double feature
- 55:59recommendations that you had. And then I'll watch
- 56:01all the ones that I've had and haven't seen.
- 56:03And then I'll meet you in the cafeteria for our
- 56:07early supper. In the retirement home that we
- 56:10both live in. Yeah. When you have the time to
- 56:12do that. That sounds great. So I went with another
- 56:15disaster movie that I enjoyed quite a bit when
- 56:17I was younger. This is the 1997 Mick Jackson
- 56:20film Volcano. I used to love the title screen
- 56:25for the trailer of this movie that would just
- 56:28show Volcano and then all of the letters would
- 56:31fade but the L and the A in Volcano because it's
- 56:35a volcano in Los Angeles. Excellent. The comparison
- 56:39here is it's a disaster movie. That's pretty
- 56:41much it. Tommy Lee Jones is in this movie. It's
- 56:43been a long time since I've seen it, but I watched
- 56:47it a lot as a kid. And there are like images
- 56:49from it that really stuck with me. I believe
- 56:52there's a fireman rescuing somebody from the
- 56:55subway. And he like steps in lava and throws
- 57:00the person he's carrying like onto the subway
- 57:03thing while he gets engulfed in flames. It's
- 57:06very dramatic, very scary. And there is a moment
- 57:09I will always remember. I thought my dad was
- 57:12like a genius in this moment. But there is like
- 57:16a news crew surrounding a manhole cover. And
- 57:18they're like, somebody's down there and it's
- 57:20pretty bad. And they're getting ready to pull
- 57:23him up. And my dad turned to me and said, it's
- 57:25just a movie. And I was like, what do you mean?
- 57:27And they pulled him out and half of his face
- 57:29was burned. And I was like, I was like, how did
- 57:33you know? And then I learned about. movies dramatic
- 57:37tension yeah and it was it was like we did it
- 57:39we saved him he's like oh no yeah my dad immediate
- 57:42was like this won't end well very funny um really
- 57:46enjoyed that movie i don't know if it holds up
- 57:49but uh look it's about a volcano in la i think
- 57:52it's going to be as good as it needs to be yeah
- 57:53it was fun i'll i'll gladly watch that again
- 57:56yeah i'll check it out again why not but that's
- 58:00in old chicago if you have i saw you enunciate
- 58:04the a yeah If you have any thoughts about this
- 58:07movie or any of the other films we talk about
- 58:09on the podcast, especially for this year, we
- 58:11will be reading those on the ceremony episode
- 58:14in just a few days. Shoot us an email at OUTAOPodcast
- 58:19at gmail .com for all of those thoughts, opinions,
- 58:21questions, and anything else. And if you would
- 58:24like to support the show, check out patreon .com
- 58:27slash OUTAOPodcast for tons of cool bonus material.
- 58:32That's right. And next week. Nope. Next episode
- 58:35will be our final movie episode of the 10th year
- 58:40of the ceremony. And we will be covering a returning
- 58:43director, Frank Capra, with Lost Horizon. Yeah.
- 58:47And you might be saying, hey, I can't wait to
- 58:49see another Frank Capra feel -good movie about
- 58:52two people falling in love and the little hijinks
- 58:56they get into. And we're going to say, strap
- 58:58in. Yeah. Strap in. Also, I do want to promote
- 59:02the ceremony episode. We do have a pretty significant
- 59:06interview coming up here. So stay tuned for that.
- 59:10I'm really, really looking forward to that one.
- 59:12And that's all I got. That's all I got. As always,
- 59:16I'm your host, Kyle. And I am Ryan. And we'll
- 59:19see you at the movies.