Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Gothard's God: Reflections on the Amazon Documentary "Shiny Happy People"
Transcript
- 0:04The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting faith,
- 0:15pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth, it's
- 0:20because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a book
- 0:24and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take the
- 0:29risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty, and
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. I
- 0:56am hitting the road again starting next month. I'll be speaking in Dallas,
- 1:00in Houston, and my hometown of Tulsa, Oklahoma, Kansas City. All
- 1:04that's happening in the month of July, and then they'll be out and dressed
- 1:08in New York and Sarnia, Ontario, Canada in the month of August.
- 1:12All the details on all of those events at my website Seth andrews dot com
- 1:19slash Events. Donald Lee Klein he was a doctor of obstetrics and gynecology.
- 1:36He got his MD from Indiana University School of Medicine and back in nineteen seventy
- 1:42nine, he opened his own infertility clinic and he ran that clinic for twenty
- 1:48nine years. And during the first decade of those twenty nine years, Donald
- 1:55Kleine secretly used his own sperm to sign here more than ninety children through his
- 2:02unsuspecting patience. Now remember this was way back before DNA testing technology, back
- 2:12before ancestry tests. There was no doubt. Donald Kleine thought he was never
- 2:16going to be caught. In twenty seventeen, there was a woman named Heather
- 2:22Wook and she was packing to go on vacation, and while she was filling
- 2:27up the suitcase, she got a notification on Facebook. There was a Facebook
- 2:32message from someone she did not know, a strange woman, a woman who
- 2:38claimed to be her half sister. But Heather was an only child, she
- 2:44had no siblings. She almost deleted the message, you know, blew it
- 2:47off as spam or some kind of scam, but she noticed that that sender
- 2:53had mentioned a doctor's name, doctor Donald Klein. Heather to this to her
- 3:00mother because her mother had gone to an infertility clinic run by a doctor Kleine
- 3:07so long ago, and Heather's mom said, don't worry about it. It's
- 3:12nothing. It's probably just a scam. Go on vacation, enjoy yourself.
- 3:16But even while Heather was away, more and more Facebook messages started coming in
- 3:22from other people claiming to be Heather's half sibling. Her phone broke part way
- 3:29into the vacation, so she was essentially disconnected off the grid for about ten
- 3:32days. And when she finally got home, she logged back into Facebook and
- 3:38there was message after message after message from people all across the country reaching out.
- 3:45These people had searched for potential relatives and they had seen a link,
- 3:51a genetic link to her. Now, she had that account because she was
- 3:55interested in genealogy and her own family tree, and so her husband had gifted
- 4:00her an ancestry dot Com account on a Christmas a while back, and she
- 4:05found out she was part Scottish and part Irish and part Scandinavian. But Heather
- 4:11never clicked on the link that showed whether or not anybody else on ancestry dot
- 4:16com was genetically related to her. She didn't go that far. But these
- 4:21strangers appearing in her inbox, they all said they were genetically connected to Heather.
- 4:30They were all sired by the same man, a doctor named Donald Klein,
- 4:38and it turned out to be true. Doctor Donald Klein had indeed sired
- 4:43all of them and many others. So many of these cases revealed via ancestry
- 4:49sites like ancestry dot com and twenty three in me dot com, etc.
- 4:55We can only imagine the feeling of violation and betrayal that these people felt and
- 5:00continue to feel. And Donald Klein was caught, I guess you could say
- 5:05he was caught. There's no law in Indiana, or in most states in
- 5:13the US for that matter. There's no law that specifically forbids a doctor from
- 5:17using his own sperm in his patience, so he couldn't be charged with that
- 5:26kind of crime. The best the authorities could do was to convict him of
- 5:30two counts of obstruction of justice. He lost his medical license, he paid
- 5:34a fine and did a year probation. He went to civil court and ended
- 5:40up on the hook for a pretty big sum of money. But his victims
- 5:44are justifiably angry that he still alive is not in prison. So what did
- 5:53former doctor Donald Klein have to say about all this? According to many of
- 5:58the people who went public, like Donald Klein defended himself by invoking his faith.
- 6:03He was quoting verses like Jeremiah one five before I formed you in your
- 6:09mother's womb, I knew you, whatever that's supposed to me. There was
- 6:14a Netflix documentary about all this. It came out last year titled Our Father,
- 6:20and it alleges that Donald Kleine was actually motivated by his religious convictions,
- 6:27convictions linked to an extreme version of Christianity called Quiverful. Now, Quiverful is
- 6:36a male dominated culture, and in this culture, women are pretty much the
- 6:43gears in a Christian reproduction and population machine. Large families are considered a blessing
- 6:50from God. So the more kids you have, the more blessings you get.
- 6:56Quiverful Right out of the Bible, Psalm Chapter one, twenty seven,
- 7:00verses three through five, children are a heritage from the Lord, offering a
- 7:05reward from him, like arrows in the hands of a warrior. Our children
- 7:11born in one's youth. Blessed is the man whose quiver is full of them.
- 7:17And I find it interesting that the Bible verse says, blessed is the
- 7:21man right, Blessed is the man whose quiver is full of them. Now
- 7:29was it quiverful ideology that motivated Donald Kleine to impregnate more than ninety unsuspecting women
- 7:35with his own seed. We can never know that for sure, we're not
- 7:40able to read his mind and know his motivations. Absolutely lots of speculation,
- 7:45but we can see his relationship with patriarchal cult thinking and a faith that it
- 7:53apparently fueled his desire to become a fertility doctor. And it's very possible that
- 7:59he was trying to play a key part in populating the world. I mean,
- 8:03if nothing else, this story provides an effective lead in to the main
- 8:09subject we're talking about today, quiverful culture, and the whole world is talking
- 8:16about this again because Amazon has just released a docu series called Shiny Happy People,
- 8:24and this focuses mostly on the Dugger family, the Institute in Basic Life
- 8:31Principles, the IBLP, and a guy I would call him a cult leader
- 8:35named Bill Gothard. Now, I know you're likely familiar with the Duggers,
- 8:41but let me do my due diligence here. Jim, Bob and Michelle Dugger.
- 8:45They were married way back in nineteen eighty four. They were a big
- 8:48part of IBLP and Bill Gothard. They knew him personally and stood by his
- 8:54side. Bill Gothard really was kind of a proxy for God himself. He
- 8:58was, I mean a cult leader if you look at the way he stood
- 9:01on stage and commanded and dictated and told other people how they should think,
- 9:07how they should live, certainly how to have and handle their children. And
- 9:11this is ironic. Bill Gothard himself never was married, he never took a
- 9:16wife, and he had zero children. On top of that, Bill Gothard
- 9:22himself would be accused of sexual harassment and sexual abuse by more than forty women.
- 9:31Of those cases were dismissed, and to this day Gothard protests his innocence.
- 9:37He's still alive. He's eighty eight years old. The Dugger family has
- 9:41nineteen children. They're probably most famous for the TV show that had ten seasons
- 9:46on TLC, Nineteen Kids and Counting the Duggers, and the hidden abuse and
- 9:52the cover ups, especially the cover ups regarding Josh, the oldest son,
- 9:58the guy who molested his sisters, and then the larger Bill Gothard cult and
- 10:05culture. These are the focus of the new Amazon docu series. And a
- 10:09lot of people don't know too much about Quiverful. I mean, they maybe
- 10:13have seen it in their periphery. But they've been watching the documentary and they're
- 10:16just shocked. They're shocked to see what IBLP really is and what it really
- 10:24does. There's a columnist at MSNBC. Her name is Sarah Posner. She's
- 10:28upset with Amazon for not going far enough. An entire angle was missed or
- 10:35largely ignored the ties between Christian homeschooling curriculum and today's religious rights. And I
- 10:43have to agree with her. I think this is a missed opportunity. Quiverful
- 10:48and its cultural cousins, they're all about dominion of the world by population.
- 10:54More Christians means a more Christian world. In this larger Christian world, the
- 11:01men will continue to pretty much run everything, and of course women will continue
- 11:09to submit to the authority of men. They will be trained pretty much to
- 11:13produce children and take care of the domestic stuff. And if you run into
- 11:20some of these women on the streets, you might think you walked into an
- 11:22episode of The Handmaid's Tale. And of course the whole thing the culture gender
- 11:28roles submission, authoritarianism, especially with men at the top of the pyramid.
- 11:33This has all drilled into the minds of young children. I remember curiosity was
- 11:37just trained right out of us. When I was a kid, we had
- 11:41one workbook, an ace workbook, and the children look up with trusting eyes
- 11:46toward their mentor, teacher and authority. Mister true Word and that was his
- 11:54name. Mister true Word is going to give us truth. What kind of
- 12:00information is mister true Word teaching? You know who would qualify under this model?
- 12:05Ken Ham of the Creation Museum. Now. In the television show Nineteen
- 12:11Kids in Counting, the Dugger family took a tour of the Creation Museum in
- 12:18Kentucky. Here's a clip. God created the heavens and the earth, and
- 12:24from that reasoning you can you can see how the earth was formed and with
- 12:31the flood and all of the things that science really backs up what scripture says.
- 12:37Do you ever wonder if your parents are censoring if you know what the
- 12:41censoring means taking out? Yeah? If your wonder if your parents are trying
- 12:46to, like not let you see the other side of things. I don't
- 12:50think my parents are trying to not let's see the rest of you know,
- 12:54world. I think the world is definitely as a Bible says six years old,
- 13:00it's pretty obvious once you started looking into it, which which really would
- 13:05be more you know, factual. It's actually more scientifically proven than billions of
- 13:13years old. God had everything planned whenever he created the world. In six
- 13:18days now, Bill Gotthard's program didn't officially forbid college, but they did send
- 13:28out these letters that discouraged them from going to college. There was a letter
- 13:33produced by IBLP mailed out to students called Hidden Dangers of Higher Education, and
- 13:43these letters said college is unwise, it's unnecessary. I pulled up one of
- 13:48those letters from the second paragraph quote exalting our human intellect is how sin began
- 13:58in the world. Okay, let's say you're a kid in quiver Full,
- 14:03or maybe even an adult, and you have toured the Creation Museum, or
- 14:09you opened up an IBLP textbook, or you read a scripture or heard a
- 14:13gothd sermon and you thought, eh, I'm not sure this works. Or
- 14:18maybe you're just a human being and you do stuff and you test boundaries and
- 14:24you make mistakes, and you live an imperfect life. Look out, this
- 14:28could result in your destruction. Here is some audio is faith Elizabeth Hunter.
- 14:37She goes by Liz. She was raised in Texas in a family that belonged
- 14:41to the IBLP, and she talks about the culture that she eventually escaped.
- 14:48The biggest idea I remember is that everything in life is determined by your dad,
- 14:52and there's an umbrella of authority that your dad has. So there's God,
- 14:58your dad, and then you. So if you do anything that goes
- 15:01outside of your dad's instructions, then God will no longer protect you and you
- 15:05could be open to all sorts of danger. My dad told me if I
- 15:07ever speed, like if I ever drive down the road faster than I'm supposed
- 15:11to, then I would be out from under the umbrella of protection and God
- 15:15would let me get in a car wreck and die because I was not obeying
- 15:18my dad because I was speeding and he did not want me to speed.
- 15:22So then for several years after I got my driver's license, I was terrified
- 15:26at anytime I noticed that I had gone over the speed limit, that I
- 15:28was going to die and it was going to be my fault because God was
- 15:31going to let me die. I got sick with like the flu or something,
- 15:35and I remember I was getting cold medicine and my mom looked at me
- 15:39and she said, so you're sick, so you must have done something to
- 15:43get sick. God is punishing you because you've gone out from under the umbrella
- 15:46of protection and you've gotten like this is why you're sick, as you must
- 15:50have done something to be punished. And I was like racking my brain trying
- 15:54to think of something I did to disobey my parents to be out from under
- 15:56the umbrella of protection to get sick, and I couldn't think of it,
- 16:00and I was really distraught. But of course I was sick, so I
- 16:02wasn't thinking that properly. But that was always a warning that whenever you got
- 16:06sick or were physically interned of any way, that their first thought was you
- 16:11must have done something, and God let this happen to you because you disobeyed.
- 16:15That clip was first aired on lad TV back in twenty twenty two.
- 16:22Now Here's a guy that is related to the Gothard culture. He's mentioned in
- 16:26the documentary Shiny Happy People. He is an independent Baptist preacher from Tennessee Michael
- 16:33Pearl, and Michael Pearl runs a nonprofit called No Greater Joy Ministries. He's
- 16:40probably best known for his book Train Up a Child. This is targeted to
- 16:44Christian homes and it's really popular in fundamentalist quiver fold type homeschool environments. In
- 16:52this book, instruc's parents on how to use things like quarter inch plastic tubing
- 16:57to whip children in order to quote break their will. Michael Pearl also suggests
- 17:04other methods like withholding food, spraying your kids down with a cold garden hose,
- 17:11etc. In his words, quote, even mice and rats can be
- 17:15trained to respond to stimuli. His book has been blamed for the deaths of
- 17:22three children in different homeschooling environments. One child was whipped for hours until she
- 17:29died. The only time they paused the beating was to pray. There was
- 17:33another child suffocated after the parents cocooned him in a blanket. A third died
- 17:38of hypothermia and malnutrition. Her body was found in her own backyard. The
- 17:44parents in each of these three cases were tried and convicted in each of these
- 17:49cases, and the homes was the book from Michael Pearl on how to raise
- 17:56and discipline a child. Michael Pearl said it wasn't his fault. Here is
- 18:00a clip from Michael Pearl being interviewed years ago on The Anderson Cooper Show and
- 18:07mister Pearl, though sometimes in reading yourself it sounds like you're talking about raising
- 18:11an animal. Though like the ideas are the same, do you view it
- 18:15as the same. The rules, the principles, techniques for training an animal
- 18:19and a human are the same. Give you an example. Wait, wait,
- 18:23let us just stop that. So you believe raising a dog or a
- 18:26horse same principles apply to raising a charst principle and training an animal is established
- 18:32a relationship of trust so that the animal knows you're not going to hurt it.
- 18:34The same thing is true with a child. You established relationship of trust.
- 18:37The sacd one is to communicate your will clearly. Now, just in
- 18:41case you didn't think Michael Pearl was awful enough, he's got advice for women,
- 18:47because of course he is a man appointed by God to instruct women.
- 18:52This is from a church service years ago, as he speaks to wives about
- 18:57their angry husbands. If your husband is an angry man, make love,
- 19:03get rid of his frustration, make him happy. In another on camera sit
- 19:07down with his wife, Michael Pearl talks to wives about how it's not just
- 19:12about keeping the husband happy. They need to do what wives do for the
- 19:18sake of the kids. Husbands need their wives, and wives need their husbands,
- 19:22and kids need mother and daddy to need each other. Oh, yes,
- 19:27there needs to be a balance and somehow, lady, you need to
- 19:30find a way to meet all of your husband's needs and do it cheerfully.
- 19:36Yeah, because of nothing more destructive your children than them detecting an underlying tension,
- 19:42like when he says, watch the video and we're going to spend time
- 19:45together and you say no, and you show resistance. There's so many women
- 19:48that would give anything to have a man to love and cherish them, and
- 19:52he's trying to love and cherish you. And in this we hear a lot
- 19:56of loaded language that can be used to excuse abusers, right and subjugate the
- 20:03abused. You need to submit, specially sexually, because it's all part of
- 20:07closeness and intimacy, which means you are connected better to your spouse. And
- 20:11this is going to be good for the kids. You don't want to cheat
- 20:15your kids, do you that kind of thing? Okay, enough of me
- 20:21talking about quiverfull from the outside in. I'm going to talk to people who
- 20:26can speak to this from the inside out. I've got some very compelling conversations
- 20:32with ex Quiverful women coming up next. My patrons, get this show early
- 20:44and commercial free. You are so appreciated. Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews.
- 20:52This is a broadcast which we are doing in the shadow of the new
- 20:56Amazon doc series about the quiver Full movement and Bill Gothard, the IBLP and
- 21:03an entire culture of restriction and indoctrination and abuse Quiverful that I wanted to include
- 21:11on this show some people who can speak to this from the inside out.
- 21:17I want to speak to Anne. She actually hails out of Ontario, Canada,
- 21:22which is interesting because when we think about the Gothard cult, we usually
- 21:26think the United States, but this stuff was well north of the border,
- 21:32and I wanted to spend a few minutes getting her experience. Hi, and
- 21:37thanks for coming. Hi, Thanks for inviting me. Were you an IBLP
- 21:41kid? So it was IBLP? It was Bill Gothard material that we used
- 21:45pretty much the whole time that I was homeschooled. Yeah, I don't want
- 21:48to trespass on. Don't want this to sound like a gotcha question, But
- 21:55was your mom qualified in any way to be a teacher? No, neither
- 22:02of my parents so their education was Bible School after high school. Actually I
- 22:08don't think my dad even has high school diploma, but he had Bible school
- 22:12training and he became a preacher, is that right? Yep? Yep.
- 22:17His whole life was that church alike. So we moved around a lot like
- 22:21if we until they joined IBLP. Then they stayed in that church actually until
- 22:26he retired. But it was a very small Baptist church in northern Ontario,
- 22:32small community, remote, there was no accountability from the leadership of the Baptist
- 22:38church like that. They were in South Ontario, hours and hours away.
- 22:41So my dad basically could control everything in the church. He was the final
- 22:45authority since he was the pastor and the church was very small. Then actually
- 22:51just got smaller and smaller. It was not good teaching, and I think
- 22:55some people saw it and they would just leave the church. So we really
- 22:57did everything for the church actually, from the sound system to sunder school to
- 23:02we just ruled it. So you as a child were also probably drafted into
- 23:07being a church worker. You got to go move the chairs and help cook
- 23:11the fellowship meals and you got to do do do right yep. Everything not
- 23:15allowed to skip services. You're the pastor's kid. You get treated differently even
- 23:18in town because it's a small town. Everybody knows who we were. Plus
- 23:22you know, we look different. What do you mean, looked different?
- 23:27So with Gothard has very strict rules on modesty for women, and they don't
- 23:33call them rules, and they call them convictions, but they convince you that
- 23:37it's your personal convictions to be modest. So this is a bit of an
- 23:41interesting dynamic here with my family. We didn't always. We weren't always with
- 23:45Gothard. So I was thirteen when we joined, I think fourteen, and
- 23:51so I remember the before and we went to public school and then we got
- 23:55into Gothard and just went more and more down that hill to hopelessness. Now,
- 24:00did you eagerly go this is a time when you are starting to blossom
- 24:03into womanhood, puberty's kicking in, the hormones are going. Did you embrace
- 24:08this like wow, it's iblp conservative Christianity? Was that your mindset? I
- 24:15actually to join ATI if you have older kids at age I was. We
- 24:19had to write a letter of agreeing to join. That was part of the
- 24:23application process. But as a fourteen year old, you want to please your
- 24:29parents and if you don't agree, then what kind of headache problem is that
- 24:33going to give your parents? So you have to agree, it's not so.
- 24:37Then for a long time, when I left it, I felt like
- 24:41I couldn't blame anyone but me because I had agreed to join it. You
- 24:45were a kid, you were Now I need to make a clarification. Forgive
- 24:49the interruption, but you've mentioned IBLP and ATI. They are related. They're
- 24:56often one and the same. Advanced Train Institute. Correct, Yes, so
- 25:02that is the specific homeschool curriculum and program was called Advanced Training Institute IBLP Institute.
- 25:10In basic life principle was the umbrella that all these other organizations were under.
- 25:15So all their seminars and all that were under the IBLP umbrella. Was
- 25:21there any science in your science books? Was there any history in your history
- 25:25books? What? Last Year was the very first book and I'm forty,
- 25:32was the very first book I ever read on evolution. All I ever knew
- 25:37about evolution is how bad and evil it is, And all I ever learned
- 25:42was the counter arguments to science. Forgive my silence. It's not because I'm
- 25:52shocked. It's because you and I have a lot in common. You and
- 25:57I have a lot I know, and then you think, Wow, who
- 26:02sheltered all this information from me? And then you realize it wasn't the information
- 26:07that was sheltered, it was me right. Well, yeah, were you
- 26:11threatened by evolution? Yeah? Very much threatened by evolution when we first got
- 26:18when I first married my husband, you know, married young, courtship,
- 26:19all of this. But he did not grow up with bill Gothard influence as
- 26:25much. I mean all churches have some Gothard influence, but not under the
- 26:30umbrella of that. He was struggling with the whole idea of evolution and creation
- 26:37and kind of lended in like creation, but in an evolution way. And
- 26:42we would fight, like we are, we get along super well, but
- 26:48we would argue about this whole evolution slash creation thing and I would just I
- 26:52would get so angry I have to walk away. We could not talk about
- 26:56it for years in our marriage because I was like, how can you believe
- 27:00in literal twenty four day, seven day creation, Like that's the foundation of
- 27:04your entire faith of the Bible, And if you don't believe this, then
- 27:08are you even a Christian? Did you ever tour the Creation Museum was that
- 27:18ever a thing for you. I did not tour it. The fact that
- 27:22we lived so far away up in northern Canada did not land to those things
- 27:26quite as well. I have heard Canada has a creation museum somewhere, don't.
- 27:33I'm sorry. We had all the Canham videos though, we watched all
- 27:37those videos, all the books my dad had books he would sell at church,
- 27:42you know, all the Kenham without knowing what evolution was. I knew
- 27:48all the arguments against it. Yeah, we didn't know what it was,
- 27:52but we just knew it was wrong and yet and make fun of it.
- 27:56Were you under your I know you were under your dad's authority. Did he
- 28:00rule with an iron fist or some other instrument of discipline? Yeah, it
- 28:07was very tough living under my dad. I would say he's a narcissist or
- 28:11tendencies. There was no way to please him. Ever, no matter what
- 28:17we did. As I got older, he would change his mind all the
- 28:21time. ATI also doesn't really believe in mental health issues. It's just a
- 28:25matter of trusting in God, and I think there likely was some health mental
- 28:29health issues there. So every day and even throughout the day, was always
- 28:33trying to figure out what mood is in to know how to react or how
- 28:37to tiptoe around, like even our courtship. You know, I really I
- 28:42bought into all the hi stuff at the more I got immersed in it and
- 28:48bought into the courtship thing and try to do the courtship with my dad.
- 28:51But he would give his permission for my husband and I to date, and
- 28:55then he would take it away. He gave his permission for him to propose,
- 29:00and then he interrupted the proposal and took his permission away. He and
- 29:04then he gave his permission again, but then he tried to break us up
- 29:07before the wedding. And it was That's one easy way to explain it,
- 29:12But it was like that with every issue. If my mom and I went
- 29:17on a trip, there was no cell phones back then, but my mom
- 29:18would call from a rest stop and we had made our plans, but then
- 29:22the plans would be changed. Even though my dad wasn't with us. He
- 29:26just enjoyed jerking year round. I mean, he just enjoyed the total control.
- 29:32I think. So it must have been something like that because it was
- 29:34excruciating, like I wanted to please him. I truly thought I needed to
- 29:40please him. The whole umbrella of protection teaches us girls. I were under
- 29:44our dad, no matter how old we are, and I had an intense
- 29:48fear of stepping out of his authority because then it would be my fault when
- 29:53I would get raped. And I'm not joking. That is taught. Hang
- 30:02on, yeah, for context, and you determine the boundaries. Here.
- 30:07He would set in place certain rules, perhaps even not related to sexuality.
- 30:15But if you broke that rule, then the penalty against you might be sexual
- 30:19violence. Am I understanding that? Yeah? Gauthar teaches if you step out
- 30:26of the umbrella of protection, which is my father, then Satan will attack,
- 30:33and one of those ways that he can do that is sexual abuse.
- 30:40Yeah, did you submit to your husband under God? I said I did.
- 30:49Here we go, Here comes the first seeds of rebellion against God.
- 30:57I'm not sure here that little spark inside, but it was always there and
- 31:02it only came out after like fifteen years of marriage. Fully, but I
- 31:07think our marriage all along was more equals than But I never would have said
- 31:14that. No, that's exciting to me because even then, your value system,
- 31:19the temperature of the relationship was not one where it wasn't an arranged marriage.
- 31:25Was it, Did you two fall in love? No? I wouldn't
- 31:27go as far as that, because being taught so much about purity culture and
- 31:33even about emotional purity so really closed my emotions off to not having crushes on
- 31:42anyone. That I remember having a crush on someone and going to my dad
- 31:47to confess it and as a young teen, as a teen, and his
- 31:52reaction, I was like, I'm never doing this again ever. So I
- 31:57didn't marry my husband, and we matched spiritually and all those things. I
- 32:01would not say I had a crush on him. It was not hard to
- 32:06wait until marriage for any sexual activity because I shut down that part of me.
- 32:14I'm walking carefully here. I mean, this is very personal material,
- 32:19but I also know that you am pretty open. You want to tell your
- 32:22story in the hopes of helping other people and educating the public at large.
- 32:27Have you seen the Amazon documentary? Absolutely? I have seen it. I
- 32:30waited to watch it with my husband and we paused it to talk a lot
- 32:35through it. It was pretty tough. Yeah. How close were they did
- 32:39they get it right? No? Yeah, but not even the tip of
- 32:46the iceberg, I would say. But they definitely did a very good job
- 32:51to give a really good glimpse of what it is and what it was.
- 32:58Yeah, it was like a home movie in some ways. Yeah, I
- 33:02wasn't sure if I wanted to watch it because I'm like, I've lifted,
- 33:05why would I watch it. Well, I mean we're potentially ripping open the
- 33:08scabs of old wounds. I mean I get that, but it's got to
- 33:13feel validating to see the white hot light of scrutiny on this culture. Yes,
- 33:17it is so nice to see it getting some exposure and really wide exposure
- 33:22and hearing it following the hashtags on Instagram and Facebook and adding my voice to
- 33:29it. That was as well to Yeah, that validation is so good,
- 33:34really good. And even I sent the link to my therapist and I was
- 33:37like, you might want to watch this, and she says, I planned
- 33:40on it. I thought you would bring it up. So you've got someone,
- 33:45You've got a therapist, someone that you are speaking to who is part
- 33:50of your journey through and out. I mean, I don't know. I
- 33:53know it's there's not like an end zone. I am now totally recovered.
- 33:57It's a process, right. I'm not sure that anyone who grows up with
- 34:02Bill Gothard can ever be recovered. It just goes so deep and different things
- 34:08will come up at different stages of life because they had teachings for all stages
- 34:14of life. So I can feel healed and that I've processed everything, and
- 34:19then the next stage comes up. For example, do I keep having kids?
- 34:23They really teach the quiver fal you know that you have all you leave
- 34:29if you truly trust God, you will let him decide your family size.
- 34:32And then yeah, like homeschooling or sending to public school, Like you just
- 34:37have these inner voices that comes through at all these life stages. So I
- 34:43don't know that we can ever be healed a bit, but we can make
- 34:45progress. And last year I found a therapist that is religious trauma informed,
- 34:51and that was extremely helpful. I tried some therapists before. But if you
- 34:54have to start explaining the umbrella of protection and Bill Gouthard and authority as a
- 35:01grown daughter under her father and courtship, it's just a lot like, well,
- 35:07it's nice if someone can speak specifically to religious trauma. This is another
- 35:12potential trespass. I'm going to ask it. You do not have to answer.
- 35:15Did you struggle with or have you had the conversation with your own kids.
- 35:21You no longer hold to any of it. You are a changed person.
- 35:28Yeah, it's been tough. My oldest is fifteen, and I left
- 35:30the church, faith, all of it three years ago. I went from
- 35:36full time missionary to agnostic in three months. I have five kids. I
- 35:43had been homeschooling for seven years, and it was It's been an interesting ongoing
- 35:50conversation with the kids because I can't just I couldn't just rip the floor off
- 35:55from underneath them and all I taught them and our whole family system and values,
- 36:04and even for myself, even though that it was a very drastic change,
- 36:07it still took a lot of time to process it and figure out what
- 36:09the heck was going on. Recently, just in the last couple of months,
- 36:15I've had a talk with my fifteen year old about all of this,
- 36:20and he, you know, the older too remember a lot more so.
- 36:23They still believe in God, and I had to really just talks about them
- 36:30that you know, they can I don't know. I'm leaving space for them,
- 36:35and usually I'm not telling them what to believe or not to believe.
- 36:37I'm no longer inputting anything in their lives, or bringing them to church,
- 36:42or and got rid of all the Christian books and things like that. But
- 36:45we bring up questions, what do you think about this? What do you
- 36:47think about that? And I'm always surprised, like they have a good head
- 36:51on their shoulders and they can They'll be okay, They'll be okay. And
- 36:58now they're in public school too, which is how I like the phrasing of
- 37:01that. You know, you've given them space, space to breathe. You're
- 37:06not ramming your position down their throats, but you're encouraging and inviting curiosity.
- 37:12And it's okay if you doubt. You know, there's so much utility in
- 37:15that. This sounds so contrived, And when I say that, I think
- 37:21you are just so brave to a lot of people don't understand. Especially I
- 37:27think lifelong nonbelievers are those who haven't come out of fundy faiths and cultures.
- 37:31They don't know. I don't think they understand you are. It feels like
- 37:37you're ripping out your own heart. You are betraying your own identity. And
- 37:42to not hit a wall and retreat and turn back, or just shut down
- 37:46and stay there and go no further, but to actually continue to peel back
- 37:52the layers takes a tremendous amount of wherewithal and will and courage. And I'm
- 37:59just own away by you. I think your journey is inspiring to me.
- 38:05And I would love, I would love for you and I just to sit
- 38:07down over dinner and be like, oh, we gotta talk. Got we
- 38:12love to share some stories, you know, when we get in urged each
- 38:15other. Any hours, any final thoughts on Gothard, on IBLP, on
- 38:21homeschooling, quiverfol etc. It's definitely. I'm very glad that there's some spotlight
- 38:28to it. And I hope this conversation, the conversations will keep going and
- 38:32that people in all evangelical churches can realize that the Gothard influence is not just
- 38:38this cult out there. The influence came at just the right time in history.
- 38:45If you read Kristen book Jesus and John Wayne, like, the Gothard
- 38:49influence just came at the right time that it's filtered to all these all evangelical
- 38:54churches. And I would say in North America, and that's just the US.
- 38:59It's in Canada, and people attended the seminars and took those teachings back
- 39:04with them, and there's just enough amount of the Christian truth quote unquote in
- 39:09all those teachings that it makes it easier to absorb and accept the fundamentalism.
- 39:19So I think I hope people can look inward and really realize what even if
- 39:25they've never heard the word Gothard, there's influence in their church and in their
- 39:30environment, and to be able to find that and reflect on those beliefs and
- 39:37decisions and where does it come from? And is it really true? And
- 39:39just ask questions. Oh, I can see why you were a problem earlier,
- 39:45he started. I found my voice in the last three years. Oh
- 39:49yeah, I can see that I have had church people troublemaker. Troublemaker.
- 39:54And by the way, it sounds like you need to run over and change
- 39:59a battery the smoke detector, which I've got a few. And the problem
- 40:02with my house, this is a total digression, is when I hear that
- 40:05little battery beat, I can never find which one needs the batter. So
- 40:09I'm always going from room to room and sticking my ear right on it,
- 40:13and then when I find it, it blows the side of my head off,
- 40:16you know, with it like one hundred and thirty decibels. Anyway,
- 40:19I'm sorry you have five kids and there's so much work to do with five
- 40:22kids. It's ridiculous. Thanks to Bill Gotha's teaching, so that fire alarm
- 40:27is nothing. You know, somebody will take care of the smoke someday.
- 40:32It's okay. An, You are amazing and I think a wonderful and necessary
- 40:38part of this show. Thank you so much for being here, Thank you
- 40:43for having me. Coming up next, I've got two people actively working and
- 40:47writing and counseling those who have come out of a quiverful environment because they came
- 40:53out of one themselves. I've got Janice Selby from the Divorcing Religio podcast,
- 41:00and i also have Jerusha Loughlin who writes the Heresy and the Heartland blog.
- 41:06Will talk to them next, continuing a look behind the curtain with quiver Full,
- 41:20etc. And two special guests joining me now, Janice Selby, she
- 41:24is host of the Divorcing Religion podcast. She is also a registered professional counselor
- 41:30does a lot of work helping people who have suffered religious trauma because she has
- 41:35walked those steps herself. And then Jerusha Kohler Lofland, who runs a blog
- 41:42heresy in the heartland. Jerusha and Janice, thanks for being here, Thank
- 41:47you, thank you. Jerusha. That's in the Bible, is that right?
- 41:52Yeah? Yeah, kind of chucked away and it's you know, the
- 41:54genealogies. She was a queen. Yeah, I thought I knew my Bible,
- 41:59But I'm like, Jerusha, well, where where do I find out?
- 42:02Well? Enough, how many times did you read the genealogy sip o,
- 42:09son of daughter of the lineage of And there's Jerusha. Yeah, you
- 42:15are one of how many kids? Jerusha? I'm the oldest of eleven ages
- 42:21ranging from we were twenty two years apart. So yeah, I'm forty seven
- 42:28and the youngest just turned twenty five. I think tell me about that.
- 42:31Obviously, it was a quiver full of thing. Was mom straight up at
- 42:37home like barefoot in the kitchen? I mean, does that stereotype proof?
- 42:40I mean she wore sandals, but yeah, we all spend a lot of
- 42:45time in the kitchen, as you can imagine with that many mouths. But
- 42:50I kind of think of my child has been broken up into segments. There
- 42:53was really first began homeschooling. I was pulled out of public school and my
- 42:58parents started homeschooling in the early eighties, and there were five of those kids.
- 43:01And then we joined Bill Gothard's home school groups later in the eighties and
- 43:07mom and dad had six more kids, and I helped raise them, sent
- 43:10my teams, changing an awful lot of diapers thousands. Did you feel like
- 43:15helping to raise the other kids as a child robbed you of part of your
- 43:20childhood? I do. I don't really feel like I had a mother in
- 43:25that sense from the time I was eleven or twelve, because she was busy
- 43:30helping. She had her own babies to raise, and by the time I
- 43:35was thirteen or so, I was helping raise the babies myself. Jerusha,
- 43:38you said there was something that caused your parents to yank you out of public
- 43:43school. Was it something specific? I'm not sure there was one particular thing.
- 43:47I think it was a multitude of factors. That they had attended their
- 43:52first Basics seminar was Bill in nineteen eighty, right before I started kindergarten,
- 43:57and they weren't ever comfortable, depletely comfortable with public school because of their strong
- 44:02evangelical beliefs. And I think as they got more into Gothard and James Dobson.
- 44:08There were other, you know, many other influences, but Bill Gothard
- 44:10was a strong one in their choices about parenting. So we dreaded them going
- 44:16to another seminar because every time they came back, they had some new idea
- 44:20of ways that our family was supposed to be different, and we would lose
- 44:24some privilege. They would take away some of our toys, or we couldn't
- 44:29wear I couldn't wear shorts anymore, couldn't wear pajama pants because girls must wear
- 44:34dresses, so girls could wear nightgowns and boys could wear pajama pants. Our
- 44:37music got changed the TV. They threw that in the trash. We went
- 44:42for all the modesty rules and we got rid of all the rock music,
- 44:45which we didn't have secular music, so that was Christian contemporary music for us,
- 44:49you know, it had to give up. Steve Green couldn't live listen
- 44:52to Household of Faith anymore, because Jesus, you had to get rid of
- 44:57your contemporary Christian albums. Like for those who don't know Steve Green, as
- 45:01I recall Steve Green, he was like mister Mellow. He's kind of the
- 45:06John Denver of Christian music. And we couldn't even have that. We couldn't
- 45:12have Sandy Patty, we couldn't have Yeah, it was Bill went very extreme
- 45:16any form of the rock beats, which meant if the beat didn't hit them
- 45:22one and three, it was a backbeat, and it was demonic and we
- 45:27were opening our souls to savings. This was a common teaching during the Satanic
- 45:31Panic of the nineteen eighties. Yeah, there was before that. I think
- 45:36the anti communist scares all brought in. They were anti rock music too,
- 45:40Okay, so it went way back, but Gothard really pushed it. What
- 45:45we had been taught was that a certain kind of drumbeat emulated the devil worshiping
- 45:51or you know, some sort of a witchery going on in African cultures,
- 45:55and it was, you know, the beat itself could infuse your life with
- 45:59evil. Janice Selby, I've had you on hold for a few You weren't
- 46:04one of eleven kids, were you? Oh, dear me, No,
- 46:08just one of one of four, the youngest of four. And then I
- 46:13had two, and then immediately after my second was born, my then husband
- 46:19and I moved to a very conservative Bible college in Canada on the Prairies actually
- 46:24called Prairie Bible College, and while we were there, that's when I began
- 46:30getting exposed to extreme fundamentalist ideas. Otherwise I had just grown up kind of
- 46:36running the mill of crazy Pentecostal But once we really got into the kind of
- 46:42anti feminist like Mary Pride movement, and then was exposed to the teachings of
- 46:49the Pearl family, and of course then eventually Gothard stuff made its way into
- 46:53our home. My ex husband was not a huge fan, but I thought
- 46:59the more rules, the better rules, made me feel safe, and so
- 47:04I just made things fairly unpleasant, I think for my daughters. And actually,
- 47:09when we were watching this show the other night, I was texting in
- 47:14our family chat and just apologizing yet again for allowing myself to get hijacked by
- 47:21that fundamentalist movement. And I'm glad we all made it out. In the
- 47:24previous conversation I had on this show, we talked about the reality that this
- 47:29goes far beyond the Quiverful cult, and you talked about the anti feminist stuff.
- 47:35Pat Robertson right, this seven hundred club bigot and evangelist recently passed away,
- 47:43and it was brought to light some of the terrible stuff he has said,
- 47:45like atheists who are responsible for mass shootings, and he blamed gay people
- 47:51for the attacks of nine to eleven. And he wrote about feminist He said,
- 47:58feminism is a socialist family political movement that encourages women to leave their husbands,
- 48:04kill their children, practice witchcraft, destroy capitalism, and become lesbians.
- 48:13So both of you were warned about feminism, isn't that right? Feminism bad
- 48:19things. Don't sound too bad to me, But back when you were reading
- 48:24Mary Pride, they probably did. Who's Mary Pride? Oh? She was
- 48:30an author mom, Yeah, and her book greatly influenced my mother the ideal
- 48:36of the homemaker, homeschooling, submissive wife. She was kind of philish,
- 48:39laughly on crack. She was kind of a Yeah. She was the homesool
- 48:45version of Phillis. I think. So I'm picturing floor length jean skirts,
- 48:51the collar up to your neck. Did you have the little handmaid's hat on?
- 48:54I mean what we didn't, but yeah, it was pretty similar because
- 49:00what you described dam jumpers, A lot of our friends did the head covering,
- 49:07but we weren't quite that goodness. As I've seeing the pictures of you,
- 49:09Janis, I mean you are straight up little house on the prairie.
- 49:15Yeah. I think that's exactly the vibe that I and my group were going
- 49:21forward, really based on fantasy, not you know, the whole idea being
- 49:25you can raise perfect offspring, but nobody's perfect. Children certainly aren't perfect,
- 49:30adults aren't perfect. It just places a huge amount of undue pressure on everybody.
- 49:37It's horrible. Didn't you resent not having an equal voice, I mean,
- 49:42either one of you Janis or Jerusha in your private space when nobody's looking.
- 49:46Didn't you get pissed off? I did? I think I had a
- 49:51feminist streak, going all the way back to reading Little Women and identifying with
- 49:54Joe March and thinking if I knew what I would do if I was a
- 49:59boy, would I would grow up and be a preacher or a politician or
- 50:02all of these things that weren't available to me because I was a girl,
- 50:07and so I was bound to be a homemaker, and therefore I didn't need
- 50:13to learn all the academics that a man might need if you needed to hold
- 50:16a job. And I know in homes growing up, it's a common problem
- 50:21for girls to be held back academically because they're not being prepared for the same
- 50:24thing that their brothers are. What I've heard in some circles is boys don't
- 50:29like you if you're too smart. But you were primed to be homemaker.
- 50:32Only you hold the power of influence because God might speak to you, and
- 50:37then you can tell your husband what you think you're saying, but you don't
- 50:42get to make the final decisions. I was lucky that, even though I
- 50:45had followed all of the courtship rules, and you know, my father was
- 50:50a part of my choice of a husband and all that, I ended up
- 50:52with a man that did not want to be my ruler or my head.
- 50:57That worked out for me. Yeah, I'm so happy for you, Jerusha.
- 51:01And my situation is like I came at it from the opposite angle because
- 51:07I did have a degree of liberty in the home that I grew up in.
- 51:12We had TV, I went to public school, I could wear parents
- 51:15all these things. But once I got hooked into the fundamentalist aspect, I
- 51:21was going to be a way better Christian than my parents. And I resented
- 51:25my mother for not teaching me more of the domestic arts. And I was
- 51:30sure that I could have a marriage that didn't have the same problems as my
- 51:36parents' marriage because I was going to do it the biblical way, and I
- 51:39put all the rules and pressure on myself and my husband. At the time,
- 51:45he said, you're making your circle smaller and smaller. How small are
- 51:50you willing to make that circle pretty frequent small? I just cut out things
- 51:54left right in center and felt very righteous in doing so. Interesting phrase,
- 52:00the domestic arts make scrub in the floor and doing the dishes sound almost like
- 52:07some sort of a creative expression. The artist. You are the artist of
- 52:12the home kind of thing. I was the domestic engineer. The documentary Shiny
- 52:17Happy People, they talk about corporal punishment, spanking, beating, breaking the
- 52:22will. The word was encouragement. You don't spank your kids, you encourage
- 52:28them. Either of you have any experience with this, Spare the rod,
- 52:32spoil the child mentality Sadly, yeah, and a predated Gothard, but yeah.
- 52:38We start through sermons as kids in churches all over town, where we
- 52:44listened to a man, always a man, giving detailed instructions on how we
- 52:50how our parents were supposed to beat us, and so we didn't question the
- 52:53God gave them the authority to do that. We felt it was cool and
- 52:57unf often unfair, and we resented them for it, but it was a
- 53:04part of daily life, and if it wasn't us, it was our younger
- 53:07siblings, and we listened to it many times today. Yeah, my parents
- 53:12didn't spank us very often. Unfortunately, when fundamentalism got a hold of me,
- 53:19I became much stricter than they were. And there was a Christian book
- 53:23going around at the time, authored by this woman, Lisa Welchell. She
- 53:28had played the character of Blair on the Facts of Life, and I used
- 53:32that book so often. I cut out all her little ideas and I was
- 53:37sure to follow through on them. And I remember my precious little three or
- 53:43four year old daughter, so innocent ince suite, and she said something that
- 53:46wasn't accurate, and I told her that she was lying, and her punishment
- 53:52was to get hot sauce on her tongue. And that is still just I
- 53:59just hate that I did that, that I was under the influence to be
- 54:02unkind and abusive in that way to my children. Did you have a conversation
- 54:07with your child after the fact, you know, all these years later this
- 54:12happened. I'm sorry oh yeah, both of them, both of them,
- 54:16and in fact, my youngest one eventually got tired of it when she was
- 54:21about seventeen, and after I gave one more apology and she said, okay,
- 54:25Mom, yes, I forgive you. I know that you weren't in
- 54:30your right mind, and you don't ever have to bring it up again.
- 54:34I forgive you. And that was so kind and beautiful of her. I
- 54:37heard someone else in a conversation who was going through a series of you know,
- 54:43the party that had wronged them, was so penitent and so traumatized by
- 54:47what they'd done, and at one point, after the twentieth apology, they
- 54:52looked him in the eye and say, you know, it's time to let
- 54:53that shit go. Yes, oh amen, Yeah, sometimes you just have
- 55:00to let that shit go. Did you worship Bill Gothard? Was he like
- 55:04God? I know he's God's proxy, but as the authoritarian? If he'd
- 55:08a walk in the room, would it have been like seeing Jesus? I
- 55:12felt as a kid that my parents did idolize him. But in my teens,
- 55:17when I got more and more brainwashed and indoctrinated in the system, and
- 55:22I began to call him instead of Bill Gothard and where I was using this
- 55:25billdauthor at home school program because I really looked down on the materials at first,
- 55:31But eventually I had succumbed and I began to more reverentially refer to him
- 55:36as mister Gothard. And I later got to work at his headquarters, and
- 55:40so I did encounter him from time to time in person, and I'm afraid
- 55:45I didn't find him as worthy of Brooklyn as in person. He's pretty kind,
- 55:50seemed figure. I didn't ever find myself wanting to worship the ground he
- 55:53walked on or anything with the abuse allegations against him, the sexual harassment and
- 55:59allegations when those came forwards. I'm not asking you to accuse him, but
- 56:04did they did that stuff? Ring true? Oh? We were very glad
- 56:08to see it come out publicly because these stories had been circulating privately as the
- 56:15former ATI student community grew online and then began to meet in person, and
- 56:22the stories began to circulate rather quickly of the things we'd seen where Gothard's private
- 56:28behavior and the behavior of others in the organization didn't line up with the public
- 56:32principles he counted and taught, so it was really good to see that make
- 56:37its way into the public awareness. It's like when the spotlight finally hit Jerry
- 56:40Folwell Junior. Right, he's out there chest thumping Jeesus and Purity from the
- 56:45stage, and then all of a sudden you realize he's part of these sexual
- 56:49trists and threesomes or whatever it was, and he was a total hypocrite,
- 56:53drunk on power using his office to essentially access other people. Be a set
- 57:00Janice Selby anything on this one. Yeah. I just think that religious fundamentalism
- 57:06breeds narcissism and breeds predatory behavior because women and children are taught that their places
- 57:15to be quiet and to obey and always to obey the oldest male or the
- 57:20husband or the father. So yeah, that the phrase drunken power absolutely hits
- 57:25home. I wondered for Jerusha. I know I interviewed you on the Divorcing
- 57:30Religion podcast. I can't remember. Do you still talk to your parents?
- 57:36I do not. We've been estranged for some years now. Did they see
- 57:40and again you can answer or not? Their failure, your failure. I
- 57:47think they found that they had been too strict, that they had raised us
- 57:52with a vindictive, judgmental God, and they wished as their idea of God
- 57:59shifted, they wish they had raised us with a gentler version of God.
- 58:04But they don't really to grasp the degree of harm that they caused, Jerusha.
- 58:12Were their boundary violations? Did they force their try to force their way
- 58:15into your life to bring you back into the fold. We weren't raised with
- 58:19boundaries pretty much at all, so when I began to assert boundaries in my
- 58:23relationship with them, it was difficult for my mother to abide by those.
- 58:29Sure, she says, I brought you into this world. I am your
- 58:32mother. Yeah, And you know she probably did mean well, and she
- 58:37meant well back then too. She was trying to keep us out of hell
- 58:40and purge the foolishness out of our hearts. But did you have a difficult
- 58:44time giving yourself permission to draw the boundary line as an adult? Oh?
- 58:47Yes? Oh yes. It took years of trial and error and practice and
- 58:52practicing with other relationships outside the family, learning what good boundaries looked like,
- 58:58and differ cheating because I wasn't allowed to have normal adolescence, so I had
- 59:02never properly differentiated from my family of origin. And I got to do that
- 59:07in my thirties, so that was fun. Let me stay with you for
- 59:10just one more minute. Here. You've got all these siblings out there.
- 59:15Are you the only one who busted out? Are you its? Or have
- 59:21we all did? We all did in one way or another. One I
- 59:24believe is still Christian. Out of eleven, is it eleven total? Or
- 59:30you have eleven siblings? There were eleven of us? Okay, one passed
- 59:35away two years ago, but I'm sure there are ten of us now,
- 59:38Okay, you're saying that the vast, vast, vast majority of the children
- 59:44got out. Yes, we foundly rejected the way we retreated so harshly and
- 59:51being told that that was God's will for us. Janice Selby of the Divorcing
- 59:55Religion podcast as a registered for professional counselor, you've been part of the journey
- 1:00:01out, Tell me about that. You hear the stories many of the people
- 1:00:06who are ex quiverful or maybe still navigating their way out, they find you,
- 1:00:12they open the lines. Tell me about that. Lately, I've been
- 1:00:15hearing from several people in the religious trauma recovery community because of this show exposing
- 1:00:22what's gone on in the Duggard family. And Bill Gothard and so forth,
- 1:00:27and so sometimes I hear from people who are still Christians, and in fact
- 1:00:32they're really having a hard time because they don't want to give up their literal
- 1:00:37interpretation of the Bible, but they see that things in their church are not
- 1:00:43correct. So though it's really really difficult sometimes working with some of those clients,
- 1:00:49many or most of my clients have left Christianity altogether and they are trying
- 1:00:54to piece together their new identity, their secular identity, while still dealing with
- 1:01:01religious parents. It can be a really rough go. And most of the
- 1:01:07folks that come to see me do have issues around codependency and boundaries. Just
- 1:01:13as Jerusha was saying, they were raised that they aren't allowed that's right,
- 1:01:19not allowed to Codependency is really baked into Christianity, and so is the idea
- 1:01:24of worshiping your captor, and that just puts people in a very challenging situation
- 1:01:32because you're supposed to love this this deity freely, but you also are in
- 1:01:37tremendous fear of them, so there can be disassociation going on, and that's
- 1:01:43what we find. Also when people grow up in abuse of homes, a
- 1:01:46lot of times, and we share the same laundry list. There's adult children
- 1:01:52of alcoholics and they have a list of issues that are particular to them.
- 1:01:55Adult children of religious nuts or acorns as I call them, share the same
- 1:02:00laundry list. We have a lot in com because our parents were addicted to
- 1:02:05religion. It's funny that when I tell devout believers that the Christian model for
- 1:02:12love is an abuse model, they just blink at me. You know,
- 1:02:16because my God is a God of love. Jesus loved the little children,
- 1:02:21etc. Etc. But when you see how yahweh Jesus set the model up
- 1:02:25right. If something happens to you, if you are harmed, if you
- 1:02:30make me mad and I harm you, it's your fault. You are not
- 1:02:36worthy. Don't ever leave me or you will be punished. This is an
- 1:02:40abuser, This is domestic abuse writ large. This is fundamental Christianity. Yes,
- 1:02:47we're absolutely trained to be victims, and predators can smell out victims a
- 1:02:53mile away. When I'm being really honest, I tell people Jesus is my
- 1:02:59abuse of it. You have written a blog, Jerusha called Heresy in the
- 1:03:04Heartland. Part of your process, i'll call it, is sharing your story
- 1:03:08what's the blog? Is it just a chronicle? I began writing because I
- 1:03:15needed to put into writing my new thoughts. Fun I passed my past beliefs
- 1:03:20the way I've been raised, and it was a way of getting my trauma
- 1:03:23out while also changing my mind and identifying my new values. Isn't it funny
- 1:03:30how writing it all down it just seems to help. Yes, I had
- 1:03:35to wash the brid you know, the cult gets into your brain and you
- 1:03:37have to wash it out, and writing seem to do that for me.
- 1:03:42I'm going to link that blog in the description box, Janis are there resources
- 1:03:45where I can point people? I know there are many, even non quiverful,
- 1:03:51who have come out of fundy faiths or high control abuse of cultures,
- 1:03:54and they are on the edge of their chairs, going where can I go
- 1:03:59and who can I talk to? Who would you recommend? Jerusha actually spoke
- 1:04:03at the Conference on Religious Trauma last year in twenty twenty two. She was
- 1:04:08part of a homeschool panel that we put together. She had some really interesting
- 1:04:14things to say. So the Conference on Religious Trauma takes place online every year.
- 1:04:18This year, I'm hosting it in October and people can go to my
- 1:04:23YouTube channel Conference on Religious Trauma. I have been putting old sessions on there
- 1:04:29as well as all of my podcast episodes go on there. I always tell
- 1:04:33people one of the first things they should do is to read doctor Marlene Winnell's
- 1:04:39book Leaving the Fold. It's a very helpful book when we are coming out
- 1:04:44of fundamentalist groups, any kind of fundamentalist religions really, And then there are
- 1:04:48support groups out there. I also love recovering from religion. They offer a
- 1:04:54lot of great things as well, So those are kind of the main ones,
- 1:04:58and of course they can come to divorce singh hyphen religion dot com.
- 1:05:01That's my website, Jerusha laughlind You got any final thoughts, Well, I'm
- 1:05:08thrilled that this documentary Shiny Happy People is out there because it's very validating to
- 1:05:13see our experiences put out to a national audience, and it's something to be
- 1:05:17able to show our kids and our friends who art familiar with this. This
- 1:05:20is what we lived through, this is how we got to where we are.
- 1:05:25And when I reflect on the twenty years that I've been out of IBLP,
- 1:05:31it is possible to build a whole new life, to reframe your values
- 1:05:35and choose the life you want. Jerusha Laughlins, who writes heresy in the
- 1:05:42Heartland, which I will link in the description box in Janice Selby of the
- 1:05:45Divorcing Religion podcast, I am reaching through the internet and hugging you both.
- 1:05:50Just a big Oklahoma bear hug from this Oklahoma heathen, and I am so
- 1:05:56thankful for both of you, and I'm delighted that you've escaped are helping other
- 1:06:00people. That's just huge. Thanks for being here. Thanks Sat, it
- 1:06:04was great to connect with you again Jerusha as well. Team. Now,
- 1:06:10I want to address something quickly before I hit the final piece of the show,
- 1:06:14and that is this. We've talked a lot about misogyny and patriarchy and
- 1:06:20male control, and that's certainly a huge part of fundamentalist Christianity, etc.
- 1:06:29But it's also true that many men are themselves victims. They grow up controlled
- 1:06:34and broken. They are spoon fed or force fed horrible ideas about the world,
- 1:06:43and wrestle with those ideas and those doctrines and those teachings. Their own
- 1:06:46innate goodness sometimes struggles with the stuff that they are taught. They don't want
- 1:06:53superiority, they want equality. They genuinely want to try to discover the world,
- 1:06:57and yet they're beaten down and broken and told to sit down and shut
- 1:07:01up. And this is true for a great many males in quiver full,
- 1:07:08and alongside many women who have come out and exposed the culture, we are
- 1:07:13also seeing some men do the same. I had a listener named Clay send
- 1:07:18me an email, and he gave me permission to share this short story about
- 1:07:23his own experience. He said, my ex wife and I raised five children
- 1:07:28together. She homeschooled all five kids. We didn't follow Gothard, but my
- 1:07:34wife was a fan of Michael Pearl's ideology, and my wife and daughters loved
- 1:07:40to watch the Dugger's TV show. For a long time. I believe that
- 1:07:44I was a good Christian father. My quiver was full, but in the
- 1:07:49early two thousands my faith was starting to erode. I was a Young Earth
- 1:07:55creationist and a Liberty University graduate, but early cracks were forming in my worldview
- 1:08:00for a variety of reasons. Around two thousand and five or two thousand and
- 1:08:04six, my oldest son, who we raised in the faith, declared he
- 1:08:11no longer believed and considered himself an atheist. My world was shaken. I
- 1:08:17was very concerned for his soul, and I began to look for logical and
- 1:08:21scientific answers that might win his faith back. While I did find content that
- 1:08:28I thought was compelling, I also experienced frequent bouts of cognitive dissonance thanks to
- 1:08:34solid arguments about the age of the Earth and evolutionary science. I looked for
- 1:08:40biblical support to answer the growing doubts in my mind, but I finally started
- 1:08:45to see the contradictions and fallacies in the Bible, which further shook my faith.
- 1:08:51I kept my growing doubts a secret from my wife, but it was
- 1:08:56definitely taking a toll on my marriage. My wife was bipolar and had anger
- 1:09:01issues, and the thought of being alone with her after the kids had all
- 1:09:04left the nest made me depressed. I was coming to the conclusion that life
- 1:09:11was too short and the promise of heaven was losing its appeal. I separated
- 1:09:16from my wife and we eventually divorced in early twenty fourteen. The spell was
- 1:09:23finally broken and I declared that I no longer believed in the God of the
- 1:09:29Bible. I remarried in twenty sixteen, but two years prior I apologized to
- 1:09:34my oldest son for having to grow up in religious indoctrination, and I thanked
- 1:09:41him for being the catalyst that helped me to break the delusion. He was
- 1:09:45my best man when I remarried in twenty sixteen. Clay, thanks so much
- 1:09:53for sharing your story and providing an example, yet another example that rescue is
- 1:09:59possible. Thank you so much for listening to this very important discussion about escaping
- 1:10:05fundamentalism. Be safe, be well. I will see you back here next
- 1:10:11week. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of
- 1:10:15podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo,
- 1:10:20links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events
- 1:10:26and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.