Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Ben Franklin Effect in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this story about Ben Franklin. He had a rival in the Pennsylvania legislature — a guy who openly disliked him and even spoke against him publicly. Franklin didn't try to win him over with charm or arguments. Instead, he asked the man if he could borrow a rare book from his library. Luna: Wait — he asked his enemy for a favor? That seems like the opposite of what you'd do. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the point. The man agreed, Franklin returned the book with a polite note, and afterward the guy became cordial, even helpful, on legislative matters. Franklin later wrote that someone who has done you a kindness is more likely to do you another than someone you've done a kindness to. Luna: That's counterintuitive. So the favor — asking for it — actually changed how the rival felt about Franklin? Lucas: That's the Ben Franklin Effect in a nutshell. Psychologists have since confirmed it experimentally. In one classic study from the 1960s, subjects who were asked by a researcher to return money they'd been given — a small favor — later rated the researcher as more likable than subjects who weren't asked. The brain rationalizes: I helped this person, so I must like them. It's a cognitive dissonance dodge. Luna: So if you want to build a relationship with someone at work, you don't start by doing them a favor — you start by asking one. Lucas: Right. And the key word is 'small.' You can't ask for a big commitment upfront — that triggers resistance. You want a low-cost, low-risk favor that the person can say yes to without much thought. Borrowing a book, asking for a five-minute opinion on a draft, requesting a recommendation for a coffee shop near the office. Luna: I can see how this would be really useful with that one senior leader who seems cold or dismissive. Instead of trying to impress them, you ask them to review a paragraph of your report. Lucas: Exactly. And when they say yes — and they almost always will, because it's a low ask — you've just activated the effect. Now their brain starts to align their actions with a positive view of you. The favor also gives you a natural reason to follow up: you thank them, maybe share how their input helped. That reinforces the connection. Luna: But isn't there a risk of seeming needy or incompetent? If you're always asking for help, people might think you can't do your job. Lucas: That's the trap most people fall into. They think self-sufficiency equals strength. But in reality, asking for small, thoughtful favors signals confidence, not weakness. It says: I know what I don't know, and I'm secure enough to ask. Plus, it gives the other person a chance to feel useful and expert. That's a gift in itself. Luna: Interesting. So the favor has to feel genuine. If you ask for something you clearly don't need, it backfires. Lucas: Big time. Authenticity is non-negotiable. If you ask for a book recommendation but you've clearly already read everything by that author, people sense the manipulation. The favor has to be something you actually want or need. And it has to be appropriate to the relationship. You don't walk up to the CEO on day one and ask for a career favor. Start with a simple request related to their expertise. Luna: Can you give us a three-step framework? Something concrete. Lucas: Sure. Step one: identify the person you want to build a better relationship with. It could be a skeptical stakeholder, a peer you barely talk to, or someone whose respect you want. Step two: think of a small, genuine favor that aligns with their skills or role. Maybe ask them to glance at a slide deck for a presentation they have context on. Or ask for a recommendation on a tool they use. Step three: after they help, express gratitude concisely and specifically. Don't gush — just a sincere thank-you and, if appropriate, a quick update on how it went. Luna: And you do all that without mentioning the Ben Franklin Effect, right? You never say 'I'm using a psychological technique on you.' Lucas: Never. That would ruin it. The whole thing works because it feels natural. If you label it, you break the spell. Luna: Look, this feels like a good moment to mention something. You know how we're always talking about small favors and building goodwill? Well, a handful of listeners already do us a small favor each month through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. And that's literally what keeps this show ad-free and going. Lucas: Yeah. It's a small thing that makes a big difference. If the show has helped you think through a career move or a tricky workplace situation, that's the way to keep it coming. No pressure — just putting it out there. Luna: Exactly. And now back to the Ben Franklin Effect. One trap I want to avoid: asking for the same kind of favor repeatedly. If you always ask the same person to review your slides, it starts to feel like a burden. Lucas: Great point. Variety matters. And you should also be ready to return the favor when the opportunity comes. The Ben Franklin Effect isn't about being a taker — it's about initiating a cycle of mutual exchange. If they ask you for something later, say yes enthusiastically. Luna: What about the opposite scenario? What if someone tries the Ben Franklin Effect on you? Lucas: That's a good awareness check. If someone you barely know asks you for a small favor, you can recognize what might be happening. But honestly, it's not malicious — it's a relationship-building tool. If the favor is genuine, you might as well lean into it. You'll probably end up liking them more too. Luna: So the effect works both ways. The person doing the favor also starts to feel more positively toward the asker. Lucas: Exactly. That's the beauty of it. It's not manipulation — it's a shortcut to genuine rapport. Our brains are wired to align attitudes with actions. Use it ethically, and it's one of the most effective tools in office politics. Luna: Alright, so next time I'm in a meeting with that one difficult director, I'll ask him for a pen recommendation. Small, genuine, and he gets to feel helpful. Lucas: And then you'll report back that his pen suggestion was great. That's the follow-up. It's a tiny investment with a huge return in relational currency. Luna: I love that. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And thanks to everyone who listens — and to those who keep the show going.