Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Indicted on Federal Criminal Charges
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:12Speaker 2: Our nation's commitment to the rule of law sets an
- 0:15Speaker 2: example for the world. We have one set of laws
- 0:19Speaker 2: in this country, and the apply to everyone applying those laws,
- 0:24Speaker 2: collecting facts. That's what determines the outcome of an investigation.
- 0:30Speaker 2: Nothing more, nothing less.
- 0:33Speaker 3: Special counsel Jack Smith took only two and a half
- 0:36Speaker 3: minutes to comment on the first federal criminal charges against
- 0:41Speaker 3: a former president in US history. Smith let the indictment
- 0:45Speaker 3: against former President Donald Trump speak for him. Trump is
- 0:49Speaker 3: charged with thirty seven counts over his handling of classified information,
- 0:53Speaker 3: including willful retention of national defense information, corruptly concealing documents,
- 1:00Speaker 3: conspiracy to obstruct justice, and making false statements. He declared
- 1:05Speaker 3: his innocence in a video response on truth Social calling
- 1:09Speaker 3: the investigation the Boxes hoax, just.
- 1:12Speaker 4: Like the Russia Russian Russia hoax and all of the others.
- 1:15Speaker 4: It has been going on.
- 1:16Speaker 3: For seven years that they can't stop because its election
- 1:20Speaker 3: interference at the highest level.
- 1:22Speaker 1: There's never been anything like what's happened.
- 1:24Speaker 3: I'm an innocent man, I'm an innocent person. A longtime
- 1:27Speaker 3: Trump baide was also indicted on six charges. Joining me
- 1:31Speaker 3: is Joshua Castenberg, a professor at the University of New
- 1:35Speaker 3: Mexico Law School and a former prosecutor and judge in
- 1:38Speaker 3: the US Air Forces. This is what's called a talking indictment,
- 1:43Speaker 3: and the story it tells in words, texts, photographs, and
- 1:47Speaker 3: transcribed conversations, is of Trump's relentless efforts to hide classified
- 1:53Speaker 3: documents related to the national defense from federal prosecutors and
- 1:58Speaker 3: his own attorneys. What's your asessment of how the indictment
- 2:01Speaker 3: presents the case?
- 2:03Speaker 1: So it brings a picture of clarity that the government's
- 2:07Speaker 1: proof is pretty solid, particularly in regard to the recorded
- 2:12Speaker 1: conversation he had where he admitted that the document he
- 2:17Speaker 1: waived around the military attack plan was mark secret or
- 2:21Speaker 1: top secret. He boasted about it basically to a non
- 2:25Speaker 1: law enforcement official. This was a journalist or a writer
- 2:29Speaker 1: who was going to write a book. And so my
- 2:32Speaker 1: first thought is, well, the government has some pretty compelling evidence.
- 2:35Speaker 1: I can't imagine why it would be ruled inadmissible because
- 2:39Speaker 1: it goes to the heart of the offense and there's
- 2:42Speaker 1: no like suppression motion or law enforcement misconduct type motion
- 2:47Speaker 1: involved here. It's a private citizen that made a recording
- 2:50Speaker 1: with Trump's permissions.
- 2:52Speaker 3: How do you fight that kind of evidence as a
- 2:54Speaker 3: defense attorney.
- 2:56Speaker 5: You know, for criminal defense attorneys, that type of evidence
- 3:01Speaker 5: is usually what they might consider nightmare evidence that their
- 3:05Speaker 5: client does because it shows wrongdoing and it shows knowledge
- 3:08Speaker 5: of wrongdoing, and you know, absinute confession, you don't get
- 3:12Speaker 5: better evidence than that. As a prosecutor in a case
- 3:16Speaker 5: that doesn't involve DNA, you know, the defense is likely
- 3:20Speaker 5: to argue something unique, like while he's the former president
- 3:23Speaker 5: of the United States, he had the authority to do that.
- 3:26Speaker 5: They'll probably argue something known as mistake of law. And
- 3:30Speaker 5: that's when someone acts because they believe they had the
- 3:33Speaker 5: legal authority to do something when they didn't. And you know,
- 3:35Speaker 5: there are all sorts of famous cases on mistake of law,
- 3:38Speaker 5: including a Supreme Court case that involves someone who didn't
- 3:41Speaker 5: pay their taxes. They made the argument that they had
- 3:44Speaker 5: been advised by attorneys and the government that they didn't
- 3:47Speaker 5: need to pay their taxes. You know, his lawyers they're
- 3:50Speaker 5: going to throw a lot of spaghetti against the wall
- 3:52Speaker 5: and see what six this is what they should do.
- 3:54Speaker 5: But right now I would say it's the mistake of law. Defense,
- 3:58Speaker 5: where he makes the argument, I'm not a lawyer, I'm
- 4:01Speaker 5: a business mana turned president of the United States. I
- 4:04Speaker 5: rely on the advice of lawyers. This was the advice
- 4:07Speaker 5: I got. I thought it was okay to do.
- 4:09Speaker 3: And does the indictment convey the seriousness and the danger
- 4:14Speaker 3: to national security from his actions?
- 4:17Speaker 1: Well, absolutely. Look if you had a person who worked
- 4:21Speaker 1: at Department of Defense, whether they were military or civilian,
- 4:25Speaker 1: or CIA or National Security Agency, waving around a document
- 4:30Speaker 1: the way he did with that boast, my thought is
- 4:33Speaker 1: absent somebody who is not guilty by reason of mental defect,
- 4:37Speaker 1: that that individual would likely go to jail for a
- 4:40Speaker 1: long long time. Now, this isn't quite a case of spying,
- 4:44Speaker 1: but let's remember Robert Hansen just died in prison for
- 4:47Speaker 1: spying for the Soviet Union. Jonathan Pollard spied for our
- 4:51Speaker 1: ally Israel. He's spending life without parol. You know, in
- 4:54Speaker 1: a jail he is take a step one step removed
- 4:57Speaker 1: from that is someone who intentionally disregards the law and
- 5:01Speaker 1: puts national security at rest. Usually those people go to
- 5:05Speaker 1: jail in the decades.
- 5:07Speaker 3: These allegations are very very serious, but it's almost comical
- 5:11Speaker 3: the way Trump had those boxes moved around mar A Lago,
- 5:16Speaker 3: from the ballroom to a bathroom, to a storeage room
- 5:19Speaker 3: in his office, and then on a plane to Bedminster,
- 5:22Speaker 3: New Jersey. And there are pictures documenting it all, even
- 5:26Speaker 3: when some of the documents spilled out of a box
- 5:29Speaker 3: and were scattered on the floor.
- 5:31Speaker 1: It shows a certain degree of knowledge that you shouldn't
- 5:33Speaker 1: have the documents if you do that, and also paranoia
- 5:37Speaker 1: that you'll get caught. Now, there's a movie based on
- 5:39Speaker 1: one of the John Grisham books where the lawyer tells
- 5:42Speaker 1: his mafia client, I have documents on you that are
- 5:46Speaker 1: at sea, and as long as nothing happens to me,
- 5:49Speaker 1: those documents will never be back at port. And I
- 5:52Speaker 1: get the feeling that this is kind of the mentality
- 5:55Speaker 1: that's gone on here, about shifting boxes from a bedroom
- 5:59Speaker 1: to a bathroom to Bedminster, keeping them on the go constantly,
- 6:03Speaker 1: never getting into port.
- 6:05Speaker 3: There's a lot of information in here that appears to
- 6:08Speaker 3: be coming from Trump's lawyer, Evan Corkran, who's identified as
- 6:13Speaker 3: lawyer number one. The Special Council has notes from Torcrene
- 6:18Speaker 3: and a detailed voice memo from a key period in
- 6:22Speaker 3: which he was recounting the team's private deliberations, and it's
- 6:27Speaker 3: evidence that the prosecutor got because the judge pierced the
- 6:30Speaker 3: attorney client privilege due to the crime fraud exception. And
- 6:34Speaker 3: I believe that some of Trump's lawyers have referenced that
- 6:37Speaker 3: piercing of attorney client privilege in interviews.
- 6:41Speaker 5: Of all the issues out there, that's the one to
- 6:44Speaker 5: pay attention to with the most focused at the beginning.
- 6:47Speaker 5: So the crime fraud exception has been an exception created
- 6:51Speaker 5: by the court and written into the roles of attorney ethics.
- 6:55Speaker 5: That all fifty states have different ethics rules, but they
- 6:58Speaker 5: basically all say the same thing, which is, there is
- 7:00Speaker 5: an exception to the attorney client privilege when the attorney
- 7:04Speaker 5: is part of an ongoing crime or a member of
- 7:07Speaker 5: a conspiracy, then the privilege does not exist. That The
- 7:11Speaker 5: issue that percolates up in cases that involve the crime
- 7:16Speaker 5: fraud exception is is that the government sometimes makes mistakes
- 7:20Speaker 5: in assessing what the degree of culpability of the attorney is.
- 7:25Speaker 5: In a mafia case, when an attorney allows his office
- 7:28Speaker 5: or her office to be used expressly for the purpose
- 7:31Speaker 5: of illegal conduct, that's easy to prove. But when an
- 7:34Speaker 5: attorney is simply giving a client advice on how to
- 7:38Speaker 5: deal with charges against them or their criminal activity that
- 7:41Speaker 5: the government doesn't yet know about. It gets somewhat dice these.
- 7:45Speaker 5: Of all the issues, that's the one to pay attention,
- 7:48Speaker 5: because if the criminal charges get dismissed, it'll be dismissed
- 7:51Speaker 5: on that basis. If they don't get dismissed, it'll be
- 7:54Speaker 5: an ongoing issue for appeal. I don't think it'll happen,
- 7:58Speaker 5: but I wouldn't rule out the possibility. And the reason
- 8:02Speaker 5: why I don't think it'll happen is because I think
- 8:04Speaker 5: this particular special Council was very cautious and how they
- 8:09Speaker 5: approached this issue and every other issue that's been involved
- 8:13Speaker 5: in both grand juries. Nonetheless, you never know what all
- 8:17Speaker 5: the facts are at this point that we're talking about,
- 8:19Speaker 5: so I leave the door open to it being a possibility.
- 8:23Speaker 3: Now, Trump's allies and Trump himself has floated this defense
- 8:29Speaker 3: that he had already used his presidential powers to declassify documents.
- 8:34Speaker 3: And you know, some of the things he said about
- 8:36Speaker 3: declassifying documents seem ludicrous. But could that be part of
- 8:41Speaker 3: his defense anyway?
- 8:43Speaker 5: Well, you know, I think because the uniqueness of this case.
- 8:46Speaker 5: They could try to advance it as a defense, but
- 8:50Speaker 5: to me, the biggest barrier to get that defense to
- 8:52Speaker 5: even be considered by a jury. To paraphrase an old
- 8:56Speaker 5: movie with Tom Cruise, show me the money, because if
- 8:59Speaker 5: you're in a through that defense then produced a document
- 9:03Speaker 5: that was filed in official channels that shows that you
- 9:07Speaker 5: gave a blanket declassification. And you can't just do that
- 9:10Speaker 5: with you the word of mouth, Hey I declassified this.
- 9:14Speaker 5: There has to be a process that was followed or
- 9:16Speaker 5: a memorandum out there somewhere, and none of that has
- 9:19Speaker 5: yet been produced.
- 9:20Speaker 3: What do you think about the Special Council's decision to
- 9:23Speaker 3: bring this indictment before a Florida grand jury rather than
- 9:28Speaker 3: a DC grand jury.
- 9:29Speaker 5: What the Special Council has done, in the best educated
- 9:32Speaker 5: guess I can give, is that they determined that when
- 9:35Speaker 5: the documents were transported to Florida that occurred when Donald
- 9:39Speaker 5: Trump was still President of the United States, holding those
- 9:42Speaker 5: documents in his possession after he left office is the
- 9:46Speaker 5: centerpiece of the crime that's charged, and the only trial
- 9:50Speaker 5: venue under the US Constitution that would be available would
- 9:53Speaker 5: be the United States District courts in the state of
- 9:56Speaker 5: Florida and not in Washington, d C. So I think
- 10:00Speaker 5: what the Special Council did by creating a second grand
- 10:04Speaker 5: jury in Florida was to safeguard a criminal trial against
- 10:08Speaker 5: unnecessary appellate issues that would otherwise arise.
- 10:11Speaker 3: Do you think it'll be harder for the Special Council
- 10:14Speaker 3: to select a jury in Florida, a state that Trump won.
- 10:19Speaker 1: I don't really like to presuppose that you can't find
- 10:24Speaker 1: a fair jury in a state simply because there's a
- 10:27Speaker 1: popular person on trial. Let's remember that there were people
- 10:31Speaker 1: on the jury of Paul Manifort that voted for Trump.
- 10:35Speaker 1: That will be a lifelong Republicans who convicted Paul Manifort. Now,
- 10:39Speaker 1: Manafort wasn't a popular person in the way of the president,
- 10:42Speaker 1: but certainly the political pressures were out there to support Manifort.
- 10:46Speaker 1: I would hope that you find twelve jurors in an
- 10:49Speaker 1: equal number of alternatives that truly will look at the
- 10:52Speaker 1: evidence in a fair and impartial manner and follow the
- 10:55Speaker 1: judge's instructions on the law. But it may be more
- 10:57Speaker 1: difficult to get to those twelves. But that's what the war.
- 11:00Speaker 3: Your processes for federal Judge Eileen Cannon is going to
- 11:04Speaker 3: be assigned the case. And she was the judge who
- 11:08Speaker 3: was appointed as a Special Master to review the material
- 11:12Speaker 3: seized last year, and she gave some odd, if not
- 11:17Speaker 3: bizarre rulings and one was thrown out in entirety by
- 11:20Speaker 3: the Eleventh Circuit. This seems like it's just bad luck
- 11:23Speaker 3: for the Special Council. But could they somehow get her recused.
- 11:27Speaker 5: They could move to try to get her recused, but
- 11:29Speaker 5: I'm not sure they'll do that because the law presumes
- 11:32Speaker 5: that judges do not act in a political manner, whether
- 11:35Speaker 5: you agree with their rulings or not. I know that
- 11:38Speaker 5: the media and the general public has come to believe
- 11:42Speaker 5: that that's not an accurate statement. And look, in some cases,
- 11:46Speaker 5: it's not an accurate statement. And part of that is
- 11:48Speaker 5: the fault of the judges themselves, who engage in public,
- 11:52Speaker 5: you know, and well known activities, giving speeches, buying closed doors,
- 11:56Speaker 5: making accusations against others, and you know, having bizarre financial
- 12:01Speaker 5: and friendly relationships. But simply because a judge had rulings
- 12:04Speaker 5: that were overturned in the past, isn't a basis for recusal.
- 12:09Speaker 5: You'd have to find a tie between the judge and
- 12:13Speaker 5: the defendant some kind of significant nature to even be
- 12:16Speaker 5: able to convince the judge to recuse themselves, because under
- 12:20Speaker 5: the law, judge has a duty to serve.
- 12:23Speaker 3: Is it a problem for the prosecutors if she remains
- 12:27Speaker 3: on the case, because that Eleventh Circuit panel was really
- 12:30Speaker 3: critical of her and said she overstepped her bounds in
- 12:33Speaker 3: exercising jurisdiction.
- 12:35Speaker 5: It could be a problem for the prosecution. It certainly
- 12:39Speaker 5: could be. I don't know enough about her for me
- 12:41Speaker 5: to make a valuation judgment. What I'm going to assume
- 12:44Speaker 5: happened if she had a defined view of the law
- 12:47Speaker 5: when she made those rulings, and she issued her decisions
- 12:52Speaker 5: based on her best efforts as to the defined view
- 12:55Speaker 5: of the law. You know, she was overturned rather quickly
- 12:59Speaker 5: and critically by circuit judges, some of whom are known
- 13:02Speaker 5: for being conservative, and they had at least appointments arising
- 13:06Speaker 5: out of the Bush administration and even the Trump administration
- 13:09Speaker 5: on that point. On the other hand, that decision, which
- 13:13Speaker 5: was highly critical of her, might actually cause her to
- 13:16Speaker 5: use more circumspection and openness in this particular case. I
- 13:20Speaker 5: can't really give a comment beyond that at this point.
- 13:23Speaker 3: So now the timing of the trial. So everyone's wondering,
- 13:27Speaker 3: could this happen before the presidential election.
- 13:31Speaker 5: Well, if it doesn't happen before the presidential election, and
- 13:34Speaker 5: if the next president happens to be Donald Trump, who
- 13:37Speaker 5: has followed in the tradition of Grover Cleveland with a
- 13:41Speaker 5: second but non consecutive term, then there won't be a
- 13:44Speaker 5: trial when he's sitting as president. So I'm not sure
- 13:47Speaker 5: it'll happen at all. But the earliest that could occur
- 13:49Speaker 5: then is sometime in twenty twenty nine. You know. Having
- 13:52Speaker 5: said that, people asked all the time, can someone run
- 13:55Speaker 5: for president from jail? And the answer is yes. In
- 13:58Speaker 5: point of fact, Eugene Deb's, a lay leader, did ran
- 14:01Speaker 5: on the Socialist Party ticket in nineteen twenty when he
- 14:04Speaker 5: was behind bars after being convicted of violations of the
- 14:07Speaker 5: Espionage Act. The Constitution only has a standard based on
- 14:12Speaker 5: age and the fact that you're born in the United States,
- 14:15Speaker 5: which and regardless of whether Trump's indicted or in jail,
- 14:19Speaker 5: the Constitution doesn't prevent him from running for office or
- 14:22Speaker 5: serving an office.
- 14:23Speaker 3: Jack Smith mentioned a speedy trial. How fast do you
- 14:27Speaker 3: think they could get to trial?
- 14:28Speaker 5: You know, if the defense council asked for a speedy trial,
- 14:32Speaker 5: you could have a trial within a period of a
- 14:35Speaker 5: month or so in theory. But typically, and I have
- 14:38Speaker 5: no idea what Trump's defense council would be, but typically
- 14:41Speaker 5: these kind of cases are dragged out for a while
- 14:44Speaker 5: and there's not a lot the government can do about that.
- 14:47Speaker 3: How likely do you think it is that Jack Smith
- 14:50Speaker 3: would offer Trump a.
- 14:51Speaker 5: Deal if we weren't talking about a former president in
- 14:55Speaker 5: a case like this, it would be ripe for a
- 14:57Speaker 5: deal to be made mishandling classified evidence. In my prior
- 15:01Speaker 5: time as a trial judge, I can't recall a case
- 15:04Speaker 5: that actually went the full litigation. I said as a
- 15:07Speaker 5: judge on four cases that ended up being a deal
- 15:10Speaker 5: at the end of the day. So the unlikelihood of
- 15:13Speaker 5: a deal actually going forward is that Donald Trump doesn't
- 15:17Speaker 5: seem to be the kind of defendant who wants to
- 15:20Speaker 5: concede that he committed a crime or have done any wrongdoing,
- 15:24Speaker 5: even if there's no jail time involved. And given his
- 15:28Speaker 5: public statements and the fact that he's running for president
- 15:32Speaker 5: and has claimed I never did anything wrong, I think
- 15:35Speaker 5: that it's really unlikely that the defense would enter into
- 15:38Speaker 5: plean negotiations.
- 15:39Speaker 3: What about Trump's aid? Do you think they'll offer him
- 15:42Speaker 3: a deal?
- 15:42Speaker 1: Oh? Yes, you know, the case is probably very strong
- 15:46Speaker 1: on some of the charges, maybe not strong on all
- 15:49Speaker 1: of those. But a case always becomes stronger when a
- 15:53Speaker 1: co conspirator splits off from the conspiracy, leads guilty, and
- 15:57Speaker 1: agrees to testify against the remains members.
- 16:00Speaker 3: So I think there will be And do you think
- 16:03Speaker 3: we'll learn anything more when Trump goes to court on Tuesday?
- 16:06Speaker 5: Most importantly to me, we don't know what the status
- 16:10Speaker 5: of the grand jury meeting in Washington, d C. Is
- 16:12Speaker 5: with the January sixth type charges. And I think we'll
- 16:16Speaker 5: get a better picture of the January sixth grand jury
- 16:20Speaker 5: on Tuesday because I have this suspicion in my mind
- 16:24Speaker 5: that the trial judge, when they start talking about scheduling,
- 16:27Speaker 5: will ask the question, well, what about the grand jury
- 16:31Speaker 5: in Washington, d C. And the prosecutors will probably feel
- 16:34Speaker 5: compelled to answer and give some timeline to that.
- 16:38Speaker 3: Finally, you know, Jack Smith's statement in just about two
- 16:42Speaker 3: and a half minutes hit on a lot of important points,
- 16:45Speaker 3: one being that he said, we have one set of
- 16:48Speaker 3: laws in this country and they apply to everyone. In
- 16:52Speaker 3: other words, no one's above the law.
- 16:54Speaker 5: Yeah, you know, some members of the House and the
- 16:56Speaker 5: Senate and other Republicans who are allied with Donald Trump
- 17:00Speaker 5: has said this kind of thing doesn't go to trial.
- 17:02Speaker 5: This is, you know, targeting the former president. But earlier
- 17:06Speaker 5: this week, a retired Air Force lieutenant colonel went to
- 17:10Speaker 5: US district court and was sentenced to three years for
- 17:13Speaker 5: the mishandling of classified data data that he kept past
- 17:17Speaker 5: his retirement in his possession. This was not a case
- 17:21Speaker 5: that we know of where he was trying to sell
- 17:23Speaker 5: classified data to the Chinese. He just collected a lot
- 17:27Speaker 5: of it and safeguarded it for whatever reason in his
- 17:30Speaker 5: own possessions. And he's not allowed to do that under
- 17:33Speaker 5: the law. And he ended up getting three years in
- 17:35Speaker 5: jail for breaking that laws. So I think when I hear,
- 17:38Speaker 5: you know, from Trump's allies, this is targeting the president.
- 17:41Speaker 5: This hasn't happened before. Yes, it has to ordinary citizens.
- 17:45Speaker 5: And I think the most important point to take away
- 17:48Speaker 5: from a retired Air Force lieutenant colonel is, here's a
- 17:51Speaker 5: member of the United States government who fell under the
- 17:53Speaker 5: command of a commander in chief at one point, who's
- 17:57Speaker 5: going to jail for three years. And if you don't
- 17:59Speaker 5: take Donald Trump to trial for this, you're excusing a
- 18:04Speaker 5: senior commander in this case, the commander in chief, from
- 18:07Speaker 5: criminal liability and prosecuting junior individuals who fell under his
- 18:12Speaker 5: command for an identical crime. And that plays into the narrative.
- 18:16Speaker 5: I hear over and over again from my students and
- 18:19Speaker 5: see from the general public that we have two kinds
- 18:22Speaker 5: of criminal law in this country, one for the wealthy
- 18:24Speaker 5: and powerful and one for everyone else.
- 18:27Speaker 3: That's such a compelling comparison. Thanks so much, josh That's
- 18:30Speaker 3: Professor Joshua Castenberg of the University of New Mexico Law School.
- 18:36Speaker 3: If it seems like Supreme Court arguments are going longer
- 18:39Speaker 3: than usual, it's because they are. Eighty percent of Supreme
- 18:43Speaker 3: Court arguments went over there a lot of time. This term.
- 18:46Speaker 3: Gone are the days of Chief Justice William Renquist, who
- 18:50Speaker 3: would cut off people mid syllable the very millisecond the
- 18:53Speaker 3: argument was over. That's according to Haines and Boone partner
- 18:56Speaker 3: Daniel Geyser. Joining me is Bloomberg Law. Supreme Court reporter
- 19:00Speaker 3: Kimberly Strawbridge Robinson, who's studied and written about this extended
- 19:06Speaker 3: argument time. Some of these arguments seem to go on
- 19:10Speaker 3: and on and on. What's the average time these days
- 19:13Speaker 3: compared to what the allotted time is.
- 19:17Speaker 4: Well, you know, back in the day, particularly when Chief
- 19:20Speaker 4: Justice Rinquist was in charge, but also the early years
- 19:23Speaker 4: of Chief Justice John Roberts, you know, cases would average
- 19:27Speaker 4: about sixty minutes. There were some that would go a
- 19:30Speaker 4: little bit longer they were scheduled to go over. Now though,
- 19:34Speaker 4: you know, we have cases that are going over about
- 19:38Speaker 4: thirty minutes on average, and that has led to over
- 19:42Speaker 4: twenty eight hours of extra argument time on top of
- 19:45Speaker 4: the sixty three that they've justice to the plans, a
- 19:48Speaker 4: really significant amount of time that they're spending on these arguments.
- 19:51Speaker 3: Do they have little lights that remind them when their
- 19:53Speaker 3: time is up?
- 19:54Speaker 4: Still, they do have lights that will tell the advocate
- 19:58Speaker 4: you have, you know, five minutes left, you have one
- 20:00Speaker 4: minute left. But then the court has added on this
- 20:03Speaker 4: extra round of questioning where each justice gets to ask,
- 20:07Speaker 4: you know, any questions that they still have lingering, and
- 20:10Speaker 4: that is not timed and that's where we see a
- 20:12Speaker 4: lot of this extra time happening is after the advocate
- 20:16Speaker 4: has sort of gotten there as thirty minutes or so,
- 20:18Speaker 4: and then you know, you throw on an extra nine
- 20:21Speaker 4: rounds of questioning can get pretty timely.
- 20:24Speaker 3: And you talk to a lawyer who said that Chief
- 20:28Speaker 3: Justice Renquist would actually cut people off mid syllable.
- 20:32Speaker 4: That's right. I mean, when that red light went on,
- 20:35Speaker 4: you were done. You could ask for some extra time
- 20:38Speaker 4: if you wanted to finish your sentence, but three words
- 20:40Speaker 4: maybe you would get out. Otherwise you were not being
- 20:43Speaker 4: in the good graces of the justices. But that's really
- 20:46Speaker 4: changed a lot.
- 20:47Speaker 2: Now.
- 20:48Speaker 4: Now you'll see advocates go on for sentences, which doesn't
- 20:52Speaker 4: sound like a lot, but in the Supreme Court, in
- 20:55Speaker 4: that court room, it is.
- 20:56Speaker 3: So explain why this change came about.
- 21:00Speaker 4: Well, it really is an effect of the pandemic. So
- 21:03Speaker 4: when March twenty twenty year olled around, the court had
- 21:06Speaker 4: some more arguments scheduled, but they canceled them and pretty
- 21:11Speaker 4: quickly switched to hearing arguments over the phone. And it
- 21:15Speaker 4: was pretty clear that just you know, having nine people
- 21:19Speaker 4: free for all over the phone was not going to
- 21:21Speaker 4: be a workable way to conduct these arguments. And so
- 21:24Speaker 4: it started going in order of seniority, starting with the
- 21:27Speaker 4: Chief Justice, and then sort of going on through the
- 21:31Speaker 4: associate justices, and when the court came back, I guess
- 21:35Speaker 4: they found something that they liked about it, because they
- 21:37Speaker 4: sort of tacked it on to what they had been
- 21:40Speaker 4: doing before. And so now the attorneys that I spoke
- 21:43Speaker 4: to that it's sort of a hybrid system now where
- 21:46Speaker 4: there's this you know, free for all, any justice can
- 21:49Speaker 4: jump in, and then there's this extra question and you know,
- 21:52Speaker 4: that's what's been leading to these really long arguments.
- 21:55Speaker 3: And it was a pandemic that led to that moment
- 21:59Speaker 3: where Justice Clarence Thomas spoke. All of a sudden, it
- 22:03Speaker 3: seemed like everyone stopped to listen, right, And you.
- 22:07Speaker 4: Know, again I spoke with some advocates who said, it's
- 22:10Speaker 4: not trivial to hear from Justice Thomas. He has been
- 22:15Speaker 4: on the course the longest of any justice currently serving,
- 22:19Speaker 4: and he asked a lot of really intelligent and probing questions.
- 22:23Speaker 4: And what we saw during the pandemic, and what we
- 22:25Speaker 4: continued to see is that now he's participating in a
- 22:28Speaker 4: lot of the questions that the other justices asked are
- 22:31Speaker 4: building off of questions from Justice Thomas. So you know,
- 22:35Speaker 4: adding in an additional justice proved to be beneficial for
- 22:38Speaker 4: the advocates and I guess for the justice themselves.
- 22:41Speaker 3: So do the advocates like it? I mean, it's more
- 22:45Speaker 3: time for the justices to ask far ranging questions. Do
- 22:49Speaker 3: they like that or is it just exhausting?
- 22:52Speaker 4: Nearly unanimously, all of the advocates that I've spoken to
- 22:56Speaker 4: really really like the extra time. They say that the
- 23:00Speaker 4: whole point of oral arguments is to answer the questions
- 23:02Speaker 4: from the justices, So being able to have more time
- 23:06Speaker 4: to answer their question is helpful and also is led
- 23:09Speaker 4: to less interruptions. You know, the justices don't feel like
- 23:13Speaker 4: they have to interrupt advocates have to cut them off
- 23:16Speaker 4: in their answer to that other justices or they run
- 23:18Speaker 4: out of time. Now they can sort of wait. If
- 23:20Speaker 4: time runs out, they can always ask the question in
- 23:23Speaker 4: their follow up. So from the advocates point of view,
- 23:25Speaker 4: it's led to a more substance of conversation. But really
- 23:29Speaker 4: how that plays out is sort of yet to be
- 23:31Speaker 4: seen in the opinions themselves.
- 23:34Speaker 3: And some advocates told you they believe it's led to
- 23:37Speaker 3: more concurring and dissenting opinions.
- 23:41Speaker 4: Yeah, just that the idea that you know, now a
- 23:44Speaker 4: justice can really probe an issue even if no other
- 23:48Speaker 4: justice seems really interested in it. You know, if you
- 23:50Speaker 4: have an idiosyncratic view of the of the law or
- 23:53Speaker 4: the issues of the fact, you can ask them. And
- 23:56Speaker 4: being able to flush that in the arguments has presumably
- 23:59Speaker 4: led to more of the concurring opinions where you know,
- 24:02Speaker 4: a justice can rank for themselves or one other justice
- 24:05Speaker 4: on a pretty small issue.
- 24:07Speaker 3: The arguments are about the justices asking questions, but while
- 24:12Speaker 3: they're asking questions, they're presenting their opinions and you know,
- 24:17Speaker 3: perhaps trying to persuade other justices.
- 24:20Speaker 4: Right, So listeners may not know, but the oral arguments
- 24:23Speaker 4: are the first opportunities that the justices get to talk
- 24:27Speaker 4: about the case since they granted it and they've read
- 24:30Speaker 4: all the briefs. This is they're you know, the first
- 24:32Speaker 4: time to interact and really see the way that their
- 24:34Speaker 4: colleagues are thinking about it. So we see a lot
- 24:37Speaker 4: of times, you know, other justices are not really just
- 24:40Speaker 4: asking the advocated question, but they're sort of testing out
- 24:43Speaker 4: the waters, you know, of the other justices to see
- 24:46Speaker 4: is this is this something that you're thinking about too?
- 24:48Speaker 4: And you know, Justice Bryer was in particular a person
- 24:52Speaker 4: who would ask a question and then sort of lean
- 24:54Speaker 4: forward on the bench and look around to see if
- 24:56Speaker 4: it was well received by his other justices. But the
- 25:00Speaker 4: other members of the court do that as well to
- 25:02Speaker 4: some extent.
- 25:03Speaker 3: You talked about this in your in your column, But
- 25:05Speaker 3: I already knew who was the longest talker, because it's
- 25:08Speaker 3: pretty obvious that it's Justice Katanji Brown Jackson. But by
- 25:12Speaker 3: how much?
- 25:14Speaker 4: By a lot? And so you know, Adam Feldman over
- 25:18Speaker 4: at Empirical Gotus really broke down the numbers and said
- 25:22Speaker 4: that Justice Jackson spoke hundreds of wards more than the
- 25:26Speaker 4: next closest justice. And that's really unique, not just because
- 25:30Speaker 4: you know she's a justice who's speaking a lot, but
- 25:33Speaker 4: because she's a junior justice, and typically we just don't
- 25:36Speaker 4: see that. We see and junior justice sort of step
- 25:39Speaker 4: back and kind of get a lay of the land
- 25:41Speaker 4: before they feel more comfortable talking. But that has not
- 25:44Speaker 4: been herm at all. She's she's very vocal in oral arguments.
- 25:49Speaker 3: And I think we spoke about this when she first
- 25:51Speaker 3: came on the bench that she started asking questions at
- 25:55Speaker 3: the very end which the Chief didn't approve of a right.
- 26:00Speaker 4: I mean, the justices is sort of tinkered with or
- 26:02Speaker 4: arguments here and there, you know, over the last decade
- 26:06Speaker 4: or so. And one of the sort of informal rules
- 26:08Speaker 4: that they seem to have said is that they're not
- 26:10Speaker 4: going to ask advocates questions during rebuttal time. So that's
- 26:13Speaker 4: after the other side has gotten up and the petitioner
- 26:17Speaker 4: gets to sort of give us the maation of the
- 26:19Speaker 4: case a very brief time. And you know, we noticed
- 26:22Speaker 4: that the justices weren't asking questions. But early on, you know,
- 26:26Speaker 4: Justice Jackson did start asking questions and I was in
- 26:29Speaker 4: the courtroom and you could really see all the other
- 26:31Speaker 4: justices kind of taken aback, and you know, who knows
- 26:34Speaker 4: what happened after that, But we did not get any
- 26:37Speaker 4: more questions during rebuttal.
- 26:39Speaker 3: And did Adam Feldman find that the liberal justices in
- 26:43Speaker 3: general talked more than the conservatives?
- 26:46Speaker 4: Yes, And so you know, Justice sonya such who we are,
- 26:49Speaker 4: and Alega Kagan, the three liberal justices were in the
- 26:53Speaker 4: second and third spots. So you know, it's an interesting
- 26:57Speaker 4: data point. It's hard to see with the casees that
- 27:00Speaker 4: are remaining that that's going to wind up with there
- 27:04Speaker 4: being more liberal results. But again, it could be that
- 27:07Speaker 4: we see them writing concurring and dissenting opinions that you know,
- 27:11Speaker 4: are really detailed and really examine a lot of different
- 27:14Speaker 4: areas to law.
- 27:15Speaker 3: I like it when we hear about, you know, the
- 27:17Speaker 3: personal lives of the advocates and how this affects them.
- 27:20Speaker 3: Tell us what happened with these those two big affirmative
- 27:24Speaker 3: action cases that seem to go on forever. Tell us
- 27:27Speaker 3: about that, and what happened with the solicitor general.
- 27:31Speaker 4: Right, So the Solicitor General, Elizabeth free Lagger, she's pretty young.
- 27:36Speaker 4: She has young kids who you know, are still in school,
- 27:39Speaker 4: and these are big arguments. It was one of her
- 27:42Speaker 4: first representing the federal government as the US Solicitor General,
- 27:47Speaker 4: and so her husband and their mother came to watch
- 27:51Speaker 4: the argument. But the arguments that day went on very long.
- 27:55Speaker 4: They were already scheduled to go over, but you know,
- 27:58Speaker 4: they didn't end until three, which is about three hours
- 28:01Speaker 4: later than then arguments typically do. And they sort of
- 28:05Speaker 4: had to scramble to figure out, well, it's going to
- 28:07Speaker 4: go pick up the kids. So every everyone's just like just.
- 28:15Speaker 3: Like us, dud uh huh, so except mine is so big. Now,
- 28:18Speaker 3: I mean, I'll be picking kids soon. Okay, so you know,
- 28:23Speaker 3: the justices have read the briefs, they know the law.
- 28:27Speaker 3: Do the people you talk to think that arguments really
- 28:32Speaker 3: can change their minds?
- 28:35Speaker 4: I think it really depends on the issue, and it
- 28:38Speaker 4: depends a lot on sort of the facts of the case.
- 28:41Speaker 4: You know, there there are going to be some issues
- 28:43Speaker 4: that justices have thought about so much. I'm thinking about
- 28:46Speaker 4: the affirmative action cases. It's hard for me to think
- 28:49Speaker 4: that the justices learned anything in that argument or hurt
- 28:52Speaker 4: anything in the argument that's gonna, you know, cause them
- 28:55Speaker 4: to vote to a whole's affirmative action programs when they
- 28:58Speaker 4: would have voted the other way. But you know, on
- 29:00Speaker 4: the margins, it can make a difference, sort of. I
- 29:03Speaker 4: talked to one advocate who talked about sort of a
- 29:06Speaker 4: soft landing. If you can see that you're not really
- 29:11Speaker 4: making a winning argument to the justices, they're not really
- 29:13Speaker 4: receiving it, you can do something to kind of temper
- 29:16Speaker 4: the kind of loss that you might have. So there
- 29:20Speaker 4: can be these sort of impacts on the margin. But
- 29:23Speaker 4: on the whole, you know, most of these justices have
- 29:25Speaker 4: got a lot about the really consequential issues, a lot
- 29:29Speaker 4: and probably not to sway their bottom line.
- 29:31Speaker 3: It's a terrific story. Kimberly, thanks so much for joining me.
- 29:35Speaker 3: That's Bloomberg Law Supreme Court Reporter Kimberly Strawbridge Robinson and
- 29:39Speaker 3: that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show.
- 29:42Speaker 3: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 29:44Speaker 3: subscribing to the Bloomberg Law Podcast or downloading this show
- 29:48Speaker 3: at Bloomberg dot com. Slash podcast, Slash Law and attorneys
- 29:52Speaker 3: get the latest in AI powered legal analytics, business insights
- 29:56Speaker 3: and workfload tools at Bloomberg Law dot com. With guidance
- 30:00Speaker 3: from our experts, you'll grasp the latest trends in the
- 30:03Speaker 3: legal industry, helping you achieve better results for the practice
- 30:07Speaker 3: of law, the business of law, the future of law.
- 30:11Speaker 3: Visit Bloomberg Law dot com. I'm Joane Bronco and you're
- 30:14Speaker 3: listening to Bloomberg