Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Writing to Win II: Advanced Techniques for Persuading Judges
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Writing to Win Part Two, Advanced Techniques
- 0:10for Persuading Judges. I'm Alapoli Castro, Director
- 0:13of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:16Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:18delighted to introduce our speaker, Daniel Smith.
- 0:22Daniel's 40 -year career of exclusive appellate
- 0:25practice has seen him appear before the California
- 0:29Supreme Court 19 times. His victories on appeal
- 0:32set precedents regarding punitive damages, tobacco
- 0:35and asbestos liability, election law, and employment.
- 0:39Daniel consults on briefs and appellate strategy
- 0:41and is a certified appellate specialist and belongs
- 0:44to the California Academy of Appellate Lawyers.
- 0:47We can't wait to hear what he has to share with
- 0:48us today, so I'm going to turn it over to him.
- 0:52Thank you very much for that kind introduction.
- 0:56And just as a matter of housekeeping, I'm looking
- 1:00at a screen that says make CLE compliance a breeze.
- 1:03Does that mean I'm in the right place or I should
- 1:07be looking somewhere else? What I dropped in
- 1:15the chat is just the materials for people to
- 1:20Okay, but you're getting my picture. All right.
- 1:23Is that correct? Yes, everything's good and we
- 1:25can. Okay. Thank you. Thank you for that reassurance.
- 1:30Well, welcome to this seminar. I'm very glad
- 1:33to have you all attend. Some of you may have
- 1:37attended the previous presentation. And one way
- 1:42that this will be different, we've retitled it
- 1:45advanced techniques, is I'm going to talk more.
- 1:49with this opportunity about the relationship
- 1:52between ourselves as writers and judges and law
- 1:57clerks as readers. And what we're trying to do
- 2:01is to maintain that relationship at a very high
- 2:05level so that our message gets through to help
- 2:11shape the reader's understanding of our case.
- 2:16A lot of reading, a lot of writing advice is
- 2:20geared to a beauty contest and how wonderful
- 2:24and beautiful is your writing. That's not our
- 2:28goal. Our test is how effective is our writing
- 2:33in two particular aspects. How well do we engage
- 2:38the interest of the reader? Judges are not, we
- 2:44have to appreciate judges are not intrinsically
- 2:47interested in our case. And we have to find a
- 2:50way to engage their interest, whether it's in
- 2:55a factual pattern or a legal question, something
- 2:59to do with the judicial administration of justice.
- 3:03We have to find a way, a reason for them to think
- 3:07that they want to find the answer to the issues
- 3:10that we're going to present. And then secondly,
- 3:12We have to be effective in answering the questions
- 3:17that they have about our case so that they will
- 3:19come to our result. In my own career, I didn't
- 3:24come to appreciate the importance of what we
- 3:30are now discussing. until I had been about 10
- 3:34years out of law school, sad to say. And what
- 3:37brought it home to me was that when I would reread
- 3:40my own briefs before oral argument, I found them
- 3:44less easily comprehensible than I had wished
- 3:48and not as persuasive. And so I said about, reading
- 3:55every book I could get on legal writing, and
- 3:59I went outside the legal community. Many famous
- 4:05authors have written their own books about how
- 4:08to relate to the reader through their writing,
- 4:11Kurt Vonnegut, Robert Caro, E .B. White, and
- 4:18many others. have spoken about the task of the
- 4:22writer, Barbara Tuckman. So I do want to mention
- 4:26right now at the outset some books that I hope
- 4:30you will pursue to pique your interest. in becoming
- 4:37the most effective writer you can possibly be.
- 4:40And so here are some titles. They're in the bibliography,
- 4:43but I just want to mention them so that you might
- 4:47engage with these books yourselves. Now in Strunk
- 4:51and White, which we probably all have five copies
- 4:54of somewhere in our boxes, the most important
- 4:58part of that book, other than the mandate to
- 5:03omit unnecessary words. That's a very important
- 5:06part of that book, and we'll get to brevity in
- 5:09a minute. But the most important part of that
- 5:11book are the footnotes and the preface and the
- 5:15postlude that E .B. White writes around the notes
- 5:20that he took from Professor Strunk's course at
- 5:24Cornell when he took that course. E .B. White
- 5:27is sharing his approach to how he engages and
- 5:31shapes the reader's understanding. very, very
- 5:34useful insights. Number two book is by William
- 5:38Zinsser, who is not as well known as he should
- 5:41be, but his book title on writing well is a real
- 5:45eye -opener and a motivator. And the first 10
- 5:49chapters, I highly encourage you to study those
- 5:5210 chapters. I think you'll find it very inspirational.
- 5:58Garner, Brian Garner, who's the king of the legal
- 6:02writing field and well -deserved reputation he
- 6:05has, has written many books, and I'll highlight
- 6:09two of them that I hope you will acquire and
- 6:11pursue. One he wrote with Justice Scalia called
- 6:15Making Your Case, and that's a very insightful
- 6:19book on how to take the judge's perspective.
- 6:22Scalia is not shy about articulating his perspective.
- 6:26and what he wants in our writing. And Garner
- 6:31wrote another book called Legal Writing in Plain
- 6:34English, which I highly recommend. I would say
- 6:38there are two distinctions between this course
- 6:40and what Brian Garner teaches, and he's a friend.
- 6:43I've been to many of his courses we correspond,
- 6:46so this is not a criticism. But Brian Garner
- 6:50is an academic. He's a professor at a law school
- 6:53in Texas. And he is not completely let go of
- 6:57what I would call are the shackles of academic
- 7:00writing. It can be a little highfalutin. It can
- 7:04be a little overly elegant. And that's not what
- 7:10I believe we want to aspire to because that's
- 7:14off -putting, I believe, to judges and to readers
- 7:18of all types. What we want is to make our writing
- 7:25as easily accessible and not call attention to
- 7:29ourselves by our writing. We don't want our writing
- 7:33to leap off the page and say, you -hoo, to the
- 7:36reader, look what a wonderful writer I am. We
- 7:39want the reader to be concentrated on the message.
- 7:42We want to be a clean window through which the
- 7:49reader can see the content of what happened and
- 7:53how to apply the law to the facts of what happened.
- 7:59And the last book I'll recommend is Richard Wittek,
- 8:02a former professor at Davis Law School who wrote
- 8:05Plain English for Lawyers, and he really started
- 8:07the Plain English movement. So happy reading
- 8:11to you. Those will all be enjoyable books, and
- 8:14they will reshape your nervous system and your
- 8:19awareness of how to write in order to reach to
- 8:24engage the reader and to shape the reader's understanding
- 8:27of your case. Now, let me introduce a little
- 8:32bit about the materials and what you'll find
- 8:36here. We won't be able to cover the materials
- 8:39in detail. There are 130 pages of advice on writing.
- 8:45What I hope to do in this hour that we have together
- 8:48is to motivate and inspire you to go through
- 8:52the materials at a leisurely pace and revise
- 8:57your own preferences based on whatever advice
- 9:01that you find acceptable and useful from your
- 9:05own perspective. This book on persuasive legal
- 9:13writing is divided into subparts, all with the
- 9:17goal of achieving clarity in our writing. Before
- 9:23I discovered and developed my point of view on
- 9:28what creates clarity, I would outsource the briefs
- 9:32that I was filing in important cases to get the
- 9:35advice of others. And what I discovered is these
- 9:39were very accomplished. writers in their own
- 9:43right, but their comments were not systematic
- 9:46in terms of saying, well, here's why this should
- 9:49be revised this way. And when I opened up my
- 9:53own law practice in 1983, devoted strictly to
- 9:58civil appeals, and hired an associate, I discovered
- 10:02that my comments to the associate were also not
- 10:06systematic. And the reason I knew that is that
- 10:09the associate would keep making the same writing
- 10:12errors brief after brief after brief. In other
- 10:15words, I wasn't providing guidelines to my associate.
- 10:20And so I realized I have to provide him and me
- 10:24guidelines. And that's what you find in these
- 10:27materials, guidelines for how to engage the reader
- 10:32and how to shape the reader's understanding of
- 10:35our case. And so here are the five guidelines
- 10:41that I believe are essential to achieving clarity,
- 10:44which is what judges crave in our writing. And
- 10:48number one is brevity. We want to take out what
- 10:53doesn't need to be there so that then all that
- 10:56will remain is the essence. One famous example
- 11:03often taught is how How does a sculpture create
- 11:08a statue out of a block of marble? Well, the
- 11:13sculptor would reply, I take away everything
- 11:15that is not statue. So we want to keep out of
- 11:20our writing everything that doesn't belong there,
- 11:22that doesn't significantly contribute to engaging
- 11:26the reader and shaping the reader's understanding.
- 11:30Number two category is simplicity. We want our
- 11:34words and our constructions to be as simple as
- 11:37possible. There's no shame in being simple. It's
- 11:41actually helpful. The third contributing factor
- 11:46to clarity is continuity. We want paragraphs
- 11:50to flow, one to the next and to the next. We
- 11:53want sentences within paragraphs to flow according
- 11:58to an interior logic that we will discuss. And
- 12:05we need to link our sentences and our paragraphs
- 12:07so that we'll have a continuous train of thought.
- 12:13Category number four. Is appropriate details
- 12:18sometimes we burden the reader with too many
- 12:20details that are unnecessary but other times
- 12:23we want the reader to recall the key details
- 12:25and when we use pronouns or generalities to refer
- 12:29back to the most important factors in our case
- 12:32whether it be a rule of law or or a fact we need
- 12:36to ring the bell and remind the reader of what
- 12:38those details are. And the fifth category of
- 12:43material in this book is appropriate design.
- 12:47We want a design that answers the reader's questions
- 12:52as they arise for the reader. So when we will
- 12:57get to the design of your document and how we
- 13:01can answer the reader's questions in sequence
- 13:04in our document. But there's also a superior
- 13:07and preferred design to paragraphs and to headings
- 13:11and to sentences and to phrases so that they
- 13:15will come to the reader in the most easily digestible
- 13:18form. To give you an example, if I was going
- 13:22to make my case for you by presenting 10 numbers
- 13:26that were going to be the make or break fact
- 13:31in my case, If I present them in a hodgepodge,
- 13:36like 2, 7, 6, 4, 8, 9, 1, 0, those would be hard
- 13:42to remember. But if I present them to you in
- 13:46a familiar sequence, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8,
- 13:509, 10, they're easily memorable. So it's our
- 13:53job, our job to do the thinking. and the organization
- 13:59that presents information in a logical and memorable
- 14:02sequence. It is not the judge's job to dig out
- 14:06of our opaque and obscure materials the internal
- 14:10logic of our argument. We need to do that work.
- 14:18So let's dive into those five buckets that I
- 14:23mentioned, the contributing factors for clarity.
- 14:27with the question of design or structure. And
- 14:32I'm going to start, if you have the materials
- 14:34handy, at page 102 and chapter 8, the structure
- 14:40of the brief. And the goal of the brief and the
- 14:48parts of the brief is to present the information
- 14:51in the sequence that answers the questions that
- 14:55the reader has as those questions arise. Now,
- 15:00that takes some thought on our part to ask ourselves,
- 15:05well, what does the judge need to know on page
- 15:07one and so forth? And we'll go into the parts
- 15:12of the document. And I want to emphasize that
- 15:21you will make your writing job very much easier
- 15:24if you outline the sequence of subparts that
- 15:31I'm going to present to you and suggest you consider
- 15:34if you work from an outline because that will
- 15:40put all the information at the beginning in the
- 15:43place where it ultimately will end up. It's very
- 15:46hard to do and time consuming to do serious surgery
- 15:50on a brief late in the stages, late in the brief's
- 15:56development. So we want to start off in a way
- 15:58with like a foundation for a house. We want to
- 16:01have it well designed so that every room has
- 16:04a secure foundation at the beginning and we don't
- 16:07have to come back and redesign the foundation.
- 16:12So the first, the very first page of your document
- 16:15is a very important page. because our goal, as
- 16:20I said, is to interest the reader and to shape
- 16:24the reader's understanding along the lines that
- 16:28benefit our client. And we will later in the
- 16:32hour come to the first paragraph of the famous
- 16:35Paul's graph case and whip that into shape to
- 16:40be a good first page for a brief. But your first
- 16:46page wants to have enough facts to be comprehensive
- 16:50and honest and persuasive. It wants to raise
- 16:56the legal issue that your case presents, and
- 17:02it wants to show the optimal resolution of that
- 17:07legal issue in favor of your client. That's a
- 17:10very challenging page to write, and I write mine
- 17:14sometimes 10 or 15 times during the course of
- 17:17brief preparation. It should get constant revision
- 17:21and constant brevity, constant reinforcement
- 17:26of brevity. If it spills out too long, it will
- 17:30be too taxing to be like a headline for the reader.
- 17:36Now, the reader is going to want to know next.
- 17:38what are the issues, what are the legal issues
- 17:40that need to be resolved? And so there's a section
- 17:45that I put in every brief called Issues Presented.
- 17:49I think it's required in the Ninth Circuit, but
- 17:51it's a good idea in every court to focus the
- 17:57reader on the issues that you feel need to be
- 18:00resolved and then followed by a summary of argument
- 18:04in which you resolve those issues, explain why
- 18:07those issues should be resolved in favor of your
- 18:09client. Next might be a procedural history because
- 18:13it may be a factor in shaping the issues, but
- 18:18only as much procedural history as is germane
- 18:21and determinative of the outcome in your particular
- 18:26document. Don't be giving the entire clerk's
- 18:32transcript summary in your procedural history,
- 18:34only the pivotal developments. Then you'll have
- 18:38a statement of facts in which we want to use
- 18:40frequent headings and subheadings. Judges need
- 18:47help navigating. the facts of your case. And
- 18:51so the more headings and subheadings that you
- 18:53can put in, they'll be visible in the table of
- 18:56contents and they'll help the reader find exactly
- 19:00the facts that the reader wants at the time the
- 19:03reader wants them. Now, the argument part should
- 19:14include a standard of review. Meaning, how should
- 19:20the judge regard the facts? Is this like a summary
- 19:26judgment? So we're looking at all facts that
- 19:29might constitute substantial evidence should
- 19:31be included? Or are we looking at, on appeal,
- 19:35a judgment after a trial where all entrances
- 19:39in favor of the trial result? are indulged and
- 19:44contrary evidence is not persuasive on appeal
- 19:48unless it's totally refutes the other side's
- 19:53evidence. So the standard of review is often
- 19:56the pivotal linchpin or fulcrum for the outcome
- 20:02of your case. So you need to state it and show
- 20:07from authority that that is the correct standard
- 20:10of review. Now in my writings, the argument part
- 20:17has five subsections. The first is sort of an
- 20:22introduction to the argument, an orientation
- 20:25of the reader to the parts of the argument that
- 20:29will follow. The next part is discussing the
- 20:36rules and discuss them neutrally. This is a presentation
- 20:40of law. After you've presented the facts, you
- 20:46are going to argue and discuss the law. But it
- 20:50has to be credible. It has to be dependable.
- 20:54It has to come across as authoritative. And that's
- 20:56why it should be a neutral presentation of the
- 20:59law, as if you were the judge's law clerk, not
- 21:03biased for one. party or another party, but simply
- 21:06presenting to the court the law as it is found.
- 21:11And if there's bad law against you, then you
- 21:15can point out the contrary law, but be honest
- 21:19and be complete. The next section of your argument
- 21:25will apply the law, the rules, to the facts of
- 21:28your case, whether they're procedural facts or
- 21:31facts about what happened in the real world,
- 21:36wanting the next part to include or think about
- 21:39including is what Garner calls anticipatory refutation.
- 21:46Because your brief does not exist in a vacuum.
- 21:50And there's someone on the other side who's going
- 21:53to attack your position. Why not get in the first
- 21:57blow yourself? and say it is likely that my adversary
- 22:03will say A, B, and C. And here are the reasons
- 22:07why A, B, and C are not persuasive. So that way
- 22:12you get to color the judge's thinking for your
- 22:17side and not have the judge encounter the objections
- 22:23to your position in the other side's following
- 22:27brief. for the first time. You want the court
- 22:30to be familiar with both sides and understand
- 22:33why your side should prevail. All right, so that's
- 22:41one proposed structure for your brief. Let's
- 22:47turn now to the other components of clarity.
- 22:54And actually, before I do that, I skipped over
- 22:57one section that is very important. And that
- 23:04section number one starts on page five of your
- 23:08materials. And this section is devoted to pleading
- 23:15the judge's case for why they have a tough job.
- 23:21They have a tough job. They are time -starved,
- 23:28they are swamped, they are overworked, and they
- 23:34often do work in very difficult circumstances.
- 23:38Judges from the Courts of Appeal and the California
- 23:40Supreme Court have told me that they read briefs
- 23:44while they're on buses commuting to and from
- 23:47work. They read briefs while they're on vacation,
- 23:50while their partner or spouse or a family member
- 23:53is driving. They're sitting reading briefs. I've
- 23:56had a judge tell me that he went to his vacation
- 23:59home on the coast, on the California coast, with
- 24:02a box of briefs for the weekend, and that was
- 24:05his weekend, was sitting in his vacation home
- 24:09reading briefs. I think we can all sense the
- 24:13challenge, the challenge that it is to to make
- 24:18reading our brief worthwhile. In a way, it's
- 24:22like television and everyone's competing for
- 24:24eyeballs. Well, we're competing. We're competing
- 24:27for eyeballs. We're competing with all the other
- 24:31entertainment or recreational activities or the
- 24:34committees that the judge has to deal with. We're
- 24:39competing with the judge's other work. Appellate
- 24:42judges, when I was practicing, had to sign off
- 24:45on 30 cases a month, 30 cases a month, 10 of
- 24:50which they would write themselves and 20 of which
- 24:53they would sign off on other judges' briefs.
- 24:57Well, that's more than one opinion a day. There
- 25:01are 22 working days in most months. That's more
- 25:04than one a day. We're competing. And if we can
- 25:08do the most effective job, the shortest job,
- 25:12the quickest job, the most easily readable job
- 25:16with our briefs, judges will be grateful. And
- 25:21they will favor our side simply because we helped
- 25:25serve them. And I want to emphasize here, there's
- 25:32a shift in mentality when we start to write our
- 25:35brief. After we've worked maybe through a trial,
- 25:42or we've worked through reading a transcript,
- 25:45we've worked through doing legal research. And
- 25:48all that is, in a sense, in my experience, client
- 25:52oriented. I'm client facing, I'm working on behalf
- 25:57of my client and telling, I'm discovering and
- 26:02summarizing the supporting facts and law for
- 26:06my client. But then after I've collected those,
- 26:11I need to present them in easily digestible fashion
- 26:16to the court. And what I'm proposing is that
- 26:21we take into account the difficulties that judges
- 26:25have in even finding time to look at our document.
- 26:29And so we want our document to stand out for
- 26:32the ease that it brings to the court in reading
- 26:38our document. Joe Montana, famous San Francisco
- 26:4449er quarterback, said his job became a lot easier
- 26:48when he realized he was just a mailman trying
- 26:51to deliver the football to the person who could
- 26:53do the most with it. And so that's our job. We're
- 26:57delivering the goods to the court, and hopefully
- 27:02the judge will do the right thing with it. I
- 27:08wanted to take that little detour because it's
- 27:09very important for our nervous system to realize
- 27:12we have a job to do and it's to make the judge's
- 27:17job easier. Aristotle said there are three bases
- 27:23for persuasion, logic, emotion, and character.
- 27:30Ethos is the Greek word. And by the quality of
- 27:34our writing, And the way in which our presentation
- 27:38makes the job of the judge easier, we distinguish
- 27:42ourselves with reference to character. And there's
- 27:48a quote in the materials about, does good writing
- 27:51get rewarded by judges? And the answer from this
- 27:55judge in Texas was yes, it definitely does get
- 27:58rewarded. And there are other quotes from Ruth
- 28:00Bader Ginsburg and from many other Supreme Court
- 28:06judges about the benefits that they feel when
- 28:12we take care with our writing. All right, sorry
- 28:15for that self -interruption, but let's go back
- 28:18now to the second element of clarity, which is
- 28:23brevity. Just as a reminder, I talked about the
- 28:26design of the document. When we went over that,
- 28:29that's one of the elements of clarity that all
- 28:31the judges' questions will get answered in our
- 28:34document in the sequence in which those questions
- 28:38arise for the judge. Now, we're going to talk
- 28:41about how do we craft, what are the guidelines
- 28:44for crafting persuasive paragraphs, persuasive
- 28:48sentences, persuasive phrases. And we have four
- 28:53of those hallmarks, brevity, simplicity. continuity
- 28:58and appropriate details or specificity. So let's
- 29:02talk about brevity. The discussion of brevity
- 29:07starts on page 14. Now one of the ways to achieve
- 29:20brevity is to realize whether what you're saying
- 29:25is germane and essential or colorful and unnecessary.
- 29:32We have so many facts that we want to pile into
- 29:37our document because we've worked so hard to
- 29:39dig up those facts. And we have so much law that
- 29:43we can put in because we did a lot of hard work
- 29:48on the research, the legal research. and the
- 29:52filter that I'd like you to apply when you edit.
- 29:58And by the way, these writing qualities are best
- 30:04applied in the editing, not necessarily in the
- 30:07writing. And I'll take a little detour here to
- 30:11explain how I see new habits being developed.
- 30:16We go through several stages of acquiring a new
- 30:20skill. And the first stage is when we are unconscious
- 30:26that we lack this skill, that this skill is required.
- 30:31Then we become conscious that we lack a skill
- 30:35and then we become conscious of acquiring the
- 30:40skill and the height, the climax is the unconscious
- 30:45implementation of the skill. I'll give you an
- 30:50example. If someone wrote a sentence that said,
- 30:55he jumped to his death crazed with jealousy.
- 31:02The skillful writer's nervous system would say
- 31:05that sentence is incorrect because it puts the
- 31:08information in the wrong sequence. The correct
- 31:12sequence would be to put cause before effect
- 31:16and so therefore and climax at the end. and to
- 31:22conform to the sequence of time. So that sentence
- 31:25should be revised to read, crazed with jealousy,
- 31:30he jumped to his death. So we want to get our
- 31:36nervous systems to the point where we sense when
- 31:42something has been written in a manner that's
- 31:45clumsy or dense or difficult. for the reader
- 31:49to parse. And we do that in the editing. In the
- 31:55drafting, we don't want to edit and draft at
- 31:59the same time. It's like driving with the brakes
- 32:02on. You need to be in touch with your creativity.
- 32:05You need to free associate. You need to get it
- 32:08on the screen. Don't inhibit yourself during
- 32:12the drafting phase. But then come at when you're
- 32:16done or when you want to do a section and Print
- 32:18it out and please don't think that you can edit
- 32:23effectively on screen. It's just not possible.
- 32:25You need to see it on black and white. And then
- 32:29take the blue pencil to your writing to conform
- 32:34to the guidelines that you've decided you want
- 32:37to follow in your writing. And the first one
- 32:40that I'm recommending here is brevity. And the
- 32:43filter for brevity is to decide Did I write something
- 32:47that's unnecessary to the outcome? Or did I repeat
- 32:51something that I have already said and I don't
- 32:55need to repeat it because I said it well the
- 32:57first time? Or am I stating something that is
- 33:02implicit that the court would understand anyway
- 33:06from everything else that's contained in the
- 33:08document? And so to delete down to what is the
- 33:13core of your of your argument, of your persuasion,
- 33:17of your brief. Take out anything that's unnecessary,
- 33:22redundant, or implicit. And do that in the editing
- 33:27phase, not in the creative or drafting phase.
- 33:34And I have some... At page 17, if you have the
- 33:38materials, we can take a minute to... see what
- 33:46brevity can accomplish in making a presentation
- 33:52more powerful. Just as a refresher, the Palsgraf
- 33:59case was a case where the woman standing on the
- 34:02railroad platform was struck by some scales that
- 34:05had been dislodged by a fireworks explosion at
- 34:09a far distance down the platform. And Justice
- 34:15Cardozo, who is a very good exemplar in his writing
- 34:21of how not to write, his writing is not plain,
- 34:27it's not concise, it's elegant and beautiful
- 34:31and opaque. So he crams in a lot of details in
- 34:38his opening paragraph for the Paul Scraff case.
- 34:42And the reason their needless details is because
- 34:45they do not relate in any way to the rationale
- 34:52for his outcome. His outcome is that the explosion
- 34:56of the fireworks that were dropped by the man
- 34:59boarding the train was too far away in distance
- 35:03and in causation from putting any liability on
- 35:07the railroad for the fact that those fireworks
- 35:10exploded. And here are some of the facts that
- 35:14are not essential to that conclusion. For example,
- 35:22Cardozo tells us that there were two men running
- 35:26for the train. You might have forgotten about
- 35:28that second man. It's not your bad because the
- 35:33second man had nothing to do with the explosion
- 35:35of the fireworks. Only one man was carrying the
- 35:38fireworks. So we can delete the reference to
- 35:41the second man. He tells us that the plaintiff,
- 35:46who was standing underneath the scales, had bought
- 35:49a ticket to go to Rockaway Beach. Well, it doesn't
- 35:52really matter. for liability whether she had
- 35:55bought a ticket because trespassers are owed
- 35:59a duty of care so you don't need to establish
- 36:03that she brought a ticket or that she was going
- 36:06to Rockaway Beach. If she had been going to some
- 36:08other place the liability of the railroad would
- 36:10still be the same. Then he repeats a couple of
- 36:15times about the fireworks being concealed. He
- 36:19says it was a package that was covered by newspaper.
- 36:23And he then adds the redundant language, but
- 36:28there was nothing in its appearance to give notice
- 36:30of its contents. Well, if it's covered by newspaper,
- 36:33we already know that. And so he's adding something
- 36:36that's implicit. And at the end of his first
- 36:41paragraph, he also writes something that is definitely
- 36:44implicit. The full sentence is, the scales struck
- 36:49the plaintiff causing injuries for which she
- 36:53sues. Well, I don't think any of us need to be
- 36:56told at the beginning of a judicial opinion on
- 36:59her lawsuit that she had sued for her injuries.
- 37:03So that's the kind of sharp editing, aggressive
- 37:09editing that I encourage you to do to take out
- 37:14the burdensome, trivial details that are not
- 37:20essential to shaping the court's understanding
- 37:25of your case. Let's go to our next writing quality
- 37:38for clarity, simplicity. And that starts on page
- 37:5022, section 2 .4. Now this sub -chapter starts
- 38:02off with many advocates of simplicity, and I'm
- 38:08going to spend just a minute on this because...
- 38:11Many of us excelled in college and law school
- 38:15and were rewarded by professors for complexity.
- 38:21And in the academic community, complexity is
- 38:26rewarded. It shows the powerful intellect of
- 38:34the writer. And that's a good way to write articles
- 38:39and get tenure in the academic world. But our
- 38:45goals are not to display our grasp of complexity.
- 38:50Our goals are ease of parsing. And so in our
- 38:55universe, simplicity is a virtue. And I had the
- 39:01help of Judge Alex Kozinski. of the Ninth Circuit.
- 39:09And when I wrote him about this book that you're
- 39:13receiving with this course, and I asked him what
- 39:16his opinion was of these virtues that I had identified,
- 39:21brevity, simplicity. and continuity and he focused
- 39:25on simplicity and he returned an email to me.
- 39:28I didn't realize a busy man like that would have
- 39:31time to write back, but here's what he said,
- 39:33simple direct language is more persuasive than
- 39:37convoluted language. Simple language is more
- 39:41easily grasped and forces us, the writer, my
- 39:45addition there, but forces the writer to focus
- 39:49I'll make it plural, unfortunately, he used the
- 39:52masculine, forces writers to focus their thinking
- 39:55and sharpen the argument. Second, he says, abstract
- 40:00language has a tendency to be soft and ambiguous,
- 40:03easily waved aside by someone leaning the other
- 40:06way. So simplifying and clarifying is really
- 40:09the essence of advocacy. And there are many other
- 40:17endorsements of advocacy from EB White, from
- 40:20Hemingway, from Lincoln, Mark Twain, Shaw, Brian
- 40:25Garner, Kurt Vonnegut, CS Lewis, if you needed
- 40:31any encouragement to write simply. I know it's
- 40:37painful to give up those highfalutin words and
- 40:39phrases and constructions, but it's really called
- 40:43for. in our practice. I happened to have a chance
- 40:48to serve on the instructions committee that in
- 40:512003 issued the KCACI civil jury instructions
- 40:57that were revised into plain English. And we
- 41:02changed what was the old instructions were in
- 41:05Badgey, the book of approved jury instructions,
- 41:07and they were complex and dense. And here is
- 41:11one of them. which I'll read to you. Failure
- 41:15of recollection is common, period. Innocent mis
- 41:19-recollection is not uncommon. Well, we wrestled
- 41:24with that and we revised it into the following
- 41:27plain English as follows. People often forget
- 41:33things or make mistakes in what they remember.
- 41:37So I think you can feel how easily understood
- 41:41the Casey revision is, and cast your vote in
- 41:47favor of simplicity. If you want to contrast
- 41:51someone with Cardozo as a writer and find someone
- 41:55who's writing you'd like to emulate, Justice
- 41:57Oliver Wendell Holmes was a very plain spoken
- 42:02and plain written judge. And I encourage you
- 42:08to study some of his opinions. to become familiar
- 42:12and content with simple writing. By the way,
- 42:21I should have said I'm open for questions at
- 42:25the end and I'll stop at about 20 minutes after
- 42:29for questions. Let's talk about continuity as
- 42:36our fourth quality of persuasion. We have some
- 42:50advocates of continuity here at the beginning
- 42:52of this chapter. Scalia and Garner said, this
- 42:55is what they wrote in their book, Making Your
- 42:58Case, Abandon interesting and erudite asides
- 43:01if they sidetrack the drive toward the point
- 43:05you are making. So we might feel that colorful
- 43:13asides are interesting and worth reading, but
- 43:18it's such a difficult task. Our task is really
- 43:24difficult to make marks, black marks on a white
- 43:28paper, and have those marks change someone's
- 43:32mind. To have someone see a situation the way
- 43:37we want them to see it. So let's not burden ourselves
- 43:43or impede our persuasive power or dilute the
- 43:47persuasive power of our writing by having jumbled
- 43:52sentences, jumbled phrases, paragraphs that don't
- 43:57flow. We want a clear train of thought. So on
- 44:03page 28, I offer you eight tips for maintaining
- 44:08continuity. in your writing. One we've already
- 44:12mentioned from Scalia and Garner, which is stay
- 44:15on message, no detours, omit interesting but
- 44:19peripheral information that fails to directly
- 44:22advance your point. Number two, point number
- 44:26two, no gaps. You can't have a space intellectual
- 44:32space between the component parts of your argument.
- 44:38So connect points by developing them in a logical
- 44:40sequence and then also using signals, which are
- 44:46mentioned and listed elsewhere in the book, signals
- 44:49that say in addition or moreover or similarly
- 44:53so that the reader knows that this is part of
- 44:59a continuous train of thought. Start paragraphs
- 45:05and sentences with familiar information and then
- 45:08introduce the new information. Take the reader
- 45:11where the reader is or where you left the reader
- 45:13and then add the new information. Lead with your
- 45:19point, don't build up to your point. It helps
- 45:23the reader to know where you're going from the
- 45:25beginning. an abandonment of the Aristotelian
- 45:31method of persuasion and the Aristotelian method
- 45:34of argument, which was to build one point on
- 45:37top of another point and top of another point
- 45:39until you reach the climax and the conclusion.
- 45:42That's not helpful persuasive writing in our
- 45:47day. The reader spill the beans is the informal
- 45:50message. Let the reader know at the beginning
- 45:53what your point is and then show how your sub
- 45:56points connect. to reach your conclusion. Now,
- 46:01let's talk about the gap between the heading
- 46:04and the paragraph. A heading, by the way, in
- 46:08my view, asserts a point, not just names a point.
- 46:14So, for example, if you were going to discuss
- 46:16the complaint and you had an issue with the complaint
- 46:20as to whether it was breached or not, your heading
- 46:26would not be the complaint. Your heading might
- 46:30be the complaint failed to allege. Your heading
- 46:39wants to assert a point about the complaint or
- 46:44the contract or the accident or the surgery.
- 46:49Don't just use those titles. Say something about
- 46:53it that reflects your point. Another way to create
- 46:58continuity is to connect quotes to your train
- 47:04of thought. The reader might not dig your point
- 47:10out of the quote, so what you want to do or to
- 47:14consider is before the quote, insert your own
- 47:19interpretation, your own application of what
- 47:24the quote means. And then after the quote, make
- 47:28the application to your case. There's a gap between
- 47:31a heading and the paragraph. As I've just said,
- 47:38I recommend that the heading assert a point.
- 47:43Now to create continuity, the first sentence
- 47:47of the paragraph should restate that point. It
- 47:51could almost imitate the language of the heading.
- 47:55so that you can reassure the reader that the
- 47:58paragraph that's now coming develops the point
- 48:03that was made in the heading. Often I read briefs
- 48:09where there seems to be no connection between
- 48:12the heading and the first paragraph to follow.
- 48:17Don't let that happen with you. Our next point
- 48:28and final factor for clarity is appropriate detail.
- 48:40And what I mean by that is at a certain point
- 48:45in your document, you're going to present all
- 48:47the details about the facts or all the details
- 48:50about the law. But then when you later refer
- 48:59back to those facts or to that rule of law, you
- 49:07want to ring the bell that you rang initially.
- 49:14And the reader won't recognize that unless you
- 49:18use enough detail to remind the reader what it
- 49:23is that you're referring to. this occurs most,
- 49:27the fault occurs most often in legal argument.
- 49:32Someone will say, well, the second holding in
- 49:37the Palsgraf case was clearly erroneous because,
- 49:42well, the reader might not remember what the
- 49:45second holding of the Palsgraf case was, even
- 49:47though you did mention it two pages earlier.
- 49:53I worked with retired Supreme Court Justice Marcus
- 49:57Kaufman on a brief and in a phone call, he urged
- 50:03me, he said, don't write as if you have to make
- 50:08the reader think, because the reader might not.
- 50:14And I took that to heart. He certainly read enough
- 50:19briefs to know the difficulty. and seen enough
- 50:22problems with other judges and with law clerks
- 50:27that they might not think and connect things.
- 50:31So we want to make it easy for the reader to
- 50:36connect all the parts of our argument. And therefore,
- 50:40instead of saying the second rule in the Palsgraf
- 50:44case had a fallacy, we might want to say, The
- 50:49second rule about foreseeability, or the second
- 50:55rule holding that the accident was too remote
- 51:01from its cause, that little phrase really helps
- 51:06the reader understand the reference back. So
- 51:12appropriate details can aid the reader. reader's
- 51:17understanding of what it is that you're saying,
- 51:20and generalities may skip right over the reader's
- 51:23head. I think that covers the content of what
- 51:31we want to do here today. I want to encourage
- 51:34you to change your mindset. When you get to the
- 51:42writing and the editing stage, you are actually
- 51:45becoming something in addition to being a lawyer.
- 51:48You're becoming a good writer. And you are now
- 51:53engaged in an art form that many, many, many
- 51:59people make a living at. And the way they make
- 52:01a living at it is to engage their readers. They
- 52:06do they meet their readers needs whatever those
- 52:09might be and and as Barbara Tuffman wrote In
- 52:14one of her books on writing that she wanted to
- 52:17make the reader want to turn the page and if
- 52:20we can embody that kind of energy and that kind
- 52:26of engagement With our readers our readers will
- 52:31both be more pleased to read our briefs and more
- 52:35influenced by our briefs. So let me take a stop
- 52:40here and see what questions there might be that
- 52:43I can answer. Okay, David Wong asks, and it's
- 52:48not a dumb question, why is it more effective
- 52:50to edit on written paper and not on the screen?
- 52:55Well, there are a couple of reasons. First of
- 52:59all, the reader is gonna see it on the paper.
- 53:03not on the screen. Or they may read it on the
- 53:05screen, but I'll give you a second reason, which
- 53:08is editing often has to do with parts that flow
- 53:12from one page to the next. And as an editor,
- 53:19you need to see, it's helpful to see the entire
- 53:23context of what you've written when you're editing
- 53:26it to see what did I say about this before? And
- 53:29what did I say about it next? So that's just
- 53:36been my experience. I'm not sure I can give a
- 53:38better answer than that, but to have only the
- 53:42part visible that can appear on the screen, I
- 53:45think is hampering, impedes effective editing.
- 54:00Okay, Christine, this is wonderful. Thank you
- 54:04for that question. The question is, when we read
- 54:11cases, and this person is a third year law student,
- 54:14when we read the cases, they don't follow our
- 54:17principles. And that is sure true. That is sure
- 54:22true. There are a couple of reasons for that.
- 54:26A highlight, and it's in the materials, is Pinoyer
- 54:29versus Neff. That's a 19th century U .S. Supreme
- 54:34Court case on jurisdiction. It is really, really
- 54:37dense, and you have to really dig to get the
- 54:41holding and the basis for the holding. Judicial
- 54:46opinions are generally not a good guide to legal
- 54:50writing. for a couple of reasons. One, the court
- 54:57doesn't have to work to earn our approval or
- 55:00to earn our acceptance. The court doesn't have
- 55:04to do the work that I'm recommending we do to
- 55:09be authoritative because the court is the court.
- 55:13And so they don't follow these clarity principles.
- 55:17because they're not having to earn our respect
- 55:20or trust. Now, another reason is, and California
- 55:31Supreme Court clerks have told me this, we don't
- 55:34write better because we don't have time. We just
- 55:38don't have the time to go over that, to do a
- 55:41third or a fourth edit. And they may not be familiar
- 55:44with the principles of clarity. It'll happen
- 55:48in your career when you're writing for a senior
- 55:51partner. The partner will write in the margin
- 55:54unclear. Well, that's not actually very helpful
- 55:59as we've seen. I have 130 pages of instructions
- 56:03and guidance on how to make things clearer. So
- 56:05a lot of lawyers and judges don't really, haven't
- 56:09really thought through what is it that helps,
- 56:13that creates clarity. When you write clearly
- 56:17as a clerk, how would your judge do it? You'll
- 56:24have to have a conversation with your judge as
- 56:26to whether that judge is comfortable writing
- 56:30plain English, and you'll have to do it the way
- 56:32the judge wants it. But when you get out on your
- 56:35own, you can follow these principles. Okay, thank
- 56:45you for that compliment. Writing well is a life
- 56:47-long lesson. Yes, you're grateful. Thank you
- 56:52for saying that. Here's a person, Judith, you
- 56:58agree with printing out when possible? Yeah,
- 57:04you can't minimize the screen to see several
- 57:07pages at once. It does give you a different perspective.
- 57:11Any other questions that might be coming up here?
- 57:14I see open five. Oh, yeah, here's one more. So,
- 57:28Judith is raising the problem of someone senior
- 57:34to you having a different preference in writing
- 57:38style. All I can say, Judith, is, you know, make
- 57:49your case, show them Scalia and Garner, show
- 57:52them Scalia's book on Plain English for Lawyers,
- 57:56Richard Wittek's book, A Law Professor at Davis,
- 58:00Plain English for Lawyers. If you think this
- 58:04manual that you just obtained in this course
- 58:07would be persuasive and the authorities that
- 58:10I cite, I wasn't able to cite, because of time,
- 58:15all the Supreme Court judges and judges from
- 58:18other courts who endorse these principles of
- 58:22clarity. But they're on your side and you're
- 58:25on their side, so hopefully you can create a
- 58:31quiet revolution in your law firm and to get
- 58:35them persuaded that plain English, although it's
- 58:39not remarkable, It's remarkable for being unremarkable.
- 58:44We don't want the attention to be on what great
- 58:47writers we are. We want the attention to be on
- 58:49what a great case we have and why our clients
- 58:53should win. All right, I think I've covered the
- 59:01questions and hopefully we have 30 seconds left
- 59:03for me to thank you for being part of this seminar.
- 59:07I hope you find it beneficial. Good luck to you
- 59:09and your careers.