Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / BMW i4 vs. Polestar 2 vs. Tesla Model 3: Choosing Your Premium EV Philosophy
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep dive. Today we're doing something a
- 0:12little different. We're looking at three of the
- 0:14biggest names in premium electric cars, the BMWI 4, the
- 0:19Polestar 2, and the Tesla Model 3, but through a very specific
- 0:23lens. Exactly.
- 0:25We're looking at this from the perspective of a fleet manager
- 0:28or you know, anyone making a serious long term investment in
- 0:32a used premium. EV So this isn't just about
- 0:35which one is fastest off the line.
- 0:36Not at all. The mission here is to really
- 0:38understand the the philosophy behind each car.
- 0:42Are you buying into traditional luxury like the BMW or modern
- 0:46design like the Polestar? Or is it all about the tech and
- 0:48the software like with the Tesla?
- 0:49Precisely, and figuring that out is the only way to make right
- 0:52choice. And we've got some surprises for
- 0:55you. We're going to reveal which of
- 0:56these sedans is secretly A crossover, and maybe more
- 1:00importantly, which one wins on value just by, well, not having
- 1:03an options list. It's a fascinating comparison
- 1:06all. Right, let's dive in.
- 1:07We have to start with the hard numbers, the technical specs.
- 1:09How do these really translate to day-to-day use and for a fleet
- 1:13downtime? So if efficiency is your number
- 1:16one priority of the conversation, it really starts
- 1:19and ends with the Tesla Model 3, the standard range version, and.
- 1:22Why is that? It's all about weight.
- 1:24The curb weight is just £3881.00.
- 1:28That is hundreds of pounds lighter than the other two.
- 1:31Wow, that's a huge difference. It's massive and it means lower
- 1:34energy use. Plus it has the fastest DC,
- 1:37charging 10 to 80% in about 27 minutes.
- 1:40Less time at the plug, less energy consumed.
- 1:43OK, so that's the efficiency king, but what about
- 1:45performance? I want that premium punch, that
- 1:48quick acceleration. Then you're looking at the Pole
- 1:51Star 2, the long range dual motor version.
- 1:53It's the clear leader here. You're getting 421 horsepower.
- 1:56And a ton of torque, right? A huge amount, 546 foot pounds.
- 2:00It gets to 60 in about 4.2 seconds.
- 2:02It's properly quick but, and this is a big but, it pays for
- 2:06that in weight. There's the trade off.
- 2:08It's the heaviest car here by far.
- 2:10We're talking 4740 lbs. It's an absolute tank and that
- 2:14means more energy use per mile, more wear on tires, you know,
- 2:18all the long term costs. So that leaves the BMW I4 sort
- 2:23of in middle, the balance choice.
- 2:25That's a great way to put it. The E Drive 35 model gets a
- 2:27solid 276 miles of range, which matches the Pole Star, and its
- 2:32peak charging speed at 180 kilowatts is actually better
- 2:36than the Pole Stars. It's sensible.
- 2:38OK, so let's move beyond the battery and motor.
- 2:40Let's talk about the physical cord, the design.
- 2:42And this brings us to that first surprise you mentioned.
- 2:45Why is the Polestar 2 basically a crossover in disguise?
- 2:49I love this detail. It's built on the exact same
- 2:52platform as the Volvo XC40 Recharge.
- 2:54The small SUV. Exactly, and you can see that
- 2:57crossover DNA everywhere. It's got much higher ground
- 3:00clearance, 5.9 inches. The BMW is way down at 4.9.
- 3:04So it's more rugged. You also see that plastic
- 3:06cladding around the wheel arches.
- 3:07Right. It's genuinely built for, you
- 3:09know, maybe a gravel road or an uneven city street in a way the
- 3:13others just aren't. It's a huge practical advantage.
- 3:15Speaking of practical, let's talk cargo.
- 3:17The BMW and the Pole Star both have that big lifts gate
- 3:20opening, right? Not a traditional trunk.
- 3:22Which is a massive win for versatility.
- 3:24You can get big bulky items in there so much more easily than
- 3:28in the Model 3's. You know, standard sedan trunk.
- 3:31But access is one thing, what about sheer space?
- 3:34And that's where the Tesla's dedicated EV platform just it
- 3:38just wins. Despite the smaller opening, it
- 3:40has more total cargo room, 24.1 cubic feet.
- 3:44And a big part of that is the frunk, the front trunk.
- 3:47A very useful 3.1 cubic foot frunk.
- 3:50And this is where we have to call out the BMW's biggest
- 3:53compromise. No funk at.
- 3:54All. Euro because that platform was
- 3:56designed to hold a combustion engine.
- 3:58All that space under the hood is just gone.
- 4:00For a premium EV, that feels like a big mess.
- 4:03And all that ruggedness on the pole star that high stance.
- 4:06Assert it somewhere else. Aerodynamics.
- 4:08Oh absolutely. It's got a drag coefficient of
- 4:10.28. The Model 3, which is obsessed
- 4:12with efficiency, is down around .22.
- 4:14So every single mile you drive, the pole Star is fighting the
- 4:18air more than the Tesla is. All right, let's climb inside
- 4:22the interior experience. We want a premium feel, of
- 4:25course, but I'm really interested in value.
- 4:27Which one just gives you the most stuff as standard?
- 4:29Well, the cabins themselves are like philosophical statements.
- 4:33The BMW is classic luxury soft materials, beautiful wood or
- 4:38aluminum trim. It's a cockpit that's all about
- 4:41the driver. Very traditional.
- 4:43Very The pull star goes for that cool Scandinavian minimalist
- 4:47vibe with sustainable materials. But you know, some of the
- 4:50plastics on the center console feel a little bit scratchy, bit
- 4:53of a let down. And that shared platform problem
- 4:56comes back inside too, doesn't? It it does a huge one, both the
- 5:00I4 and the pole star have this big hump in the rear floor where
- 5:04a transmission tunnel would go in a gas car.
- 5:06Which is completely unnecessary in an EV.
- 5:09Totally, and it kills the leg room for the person in the
- 5:11middle seat. The Model 3, because it was
- 5:13designed from the ground up as an EV, has a completely flat
- 5:16floor in the back. It's way more comfortable for
- 5:18three people. OK, but here's the killer for
- 5:20me, and I think for any fleet manager.
- 5:23The standard features. This is an absolute undisputed
- 5:26win for Tesla, especially the newer ones post 2023.
- 5:30They just come complete. What do you mean by complete
- 5:33heated and ventilated front seats?
- 5:36Heated rear seats, a screen for the back passengers, premium
- 5:40audio. It's all standard.
- 5:41There are no packages to add. Where's with the others?
- 5:43Oh, you have to jump through hoops in the BMW.
- 5:46If you want ventilated seats, you first have to upgrade to a
- 5:50specific, more expensive type of leather.
- 5:52It's madding. And the Polster.
- 5:54They bundle everything into a plus package, so if you want the
- 5:58panoramic roof you also have to take the premium sound system
- 6:01and a bunch of other things. Tesla's approach just simplifies
- 6:04everything. That makes so much sense at
- 6:06scale. Yeah, before we get to software
- 6:07for, let's touch on something for used buyers, battery health.
- 6:11There was some reassuring news there, right?
- 6:13Yes, and this is so important. It really helps kill that myth
- 6:17about EV batteries just dying after a couple of years.
- 6:20What did they find? They tested a 2 year old
- 6:23Polestar too and it showed basically 0 real world range
- 6:26degradation. It was performing just as well
- 6:28as when it was new. It's a huge confidence booster.
- 6:32That's great to hear. OK, let's talk about the digital
- 6:34heart of these cars, the software.
- 6:38Because in an EV, the software is the experience.
- 6:41Who wins here? It is.
- 6:43I mean, it's not even a close race.
- 6:44The Tesla Model 3 is the undisputed leader.
- 6:47And what makes it so much better?
- 6:48It runs on a super fast AMD rise and ship so the screen is as
- 6:52responsive as a high end smartphone.
- 6:55The vehicle app is the best in the business but the real game
- 6:58changer is the over the air updates, the OTAs.
- 7:02And these aren't just small bug fixes.
- 7:04No, no. These are major feature drops.
- 7:06They'll completely redesign the user interface, or improve your
- 7:09car's efficiency, or even add performance.
- 7:11The car you buy gets better over time.
- 7:13And how do the others compare? What about the BMW I drive
- 7:16system? I drive is very mature, very
- 7:18complex. It's excellent and a lot of
- 7:20people love that it has both a touch screen and a physical
- 7:22scroll wheel. You get that tactile control
- 7:24which. Is a big deal for some drivers
- 7:26and the pole star runs on Android, right?
- 7:29Android Automotive. It's adequate.
- 7:31Its best feature is the built in Google Maps, which is fantastic
- 7:36for route planning, but you still need to plug your phone in
- 7:39for Apple CarPlay, which feels a little dated.
- 7:42So the OTA strategy is really the dividing line.
- 7:45Tesla is constantly transforming the car.
- 7:47Right Pollster is doing good regular updates, but they're
- 7:50smaller in scope and BMW's updates are still mostly focused
- 7:54on, you know, security patches and bug fixes, not fundamental
- 7:58changes you're. Buying a finished product with
- 8:00the BMW, but an evolving one with the Tesla.
- 8:04That's the perfect way to summarize it.
- 8:05OK, let's put software aside and talk about the physical act of
- 8:08driving. Which one of these is the true
- 8:10driver's car? That title without a doubt goes
- 8:13to the BMW I4. They absolutely nailed the
- 8:16classic BMW feel, it's rear wheel drive, the handling is
- 8:19sharp and engaging, and it is exceptionally refined.
- 8:22You mean it's quiet? Incredibly quiet.
- 8:25They measured the cabinet just 64 decibels at 70 mph.
- 8:28That's that's on par with ultra luxury sedans.
- 8:31It's a serene place to be. And the posters right there with
- 8:34it on quietness, right? It is also 64 decibels but it
- 8:37feels different to drive. It's all-wheel drive, so it's
- 8:40incredibly planted and confidence inspiring, especially
- 8:43in bad weather, but the steering is a bit heavier, it feels its
- 8:47weight. Which leaves the Model 3.
- 8:49It's the lightest, so it should be agile.
- 8:51And it is. It's very nimble, very quick to
- 8:53respond. But the trade off is refinement.
- 8:56It's a little louder inside, about 67 decibels.
- 8:58You just get more road and tire noise.
- 9:00It's improved a lot, but it's not as isolated as the German or
- 9:04the Swede. And we have to mention driver
- 9:06aids. Tesla's Autopilot is standard,
- 9:09yes. And it's very effective.
- 9:11Adaptive cruise and lane centering.
- 9:13With BMW that's often a multi $1000 option.
- 9:16Again, Tesla just gives you the feature.
- 9:18The value proposition is hard to ignore.
- 9:21So after all of that, we're the core conclusion.
- 9:24It's only choosing one of these isn't just about specs, it's
- 9:27about choosing a team, a philosophy.
- 9:30It really is. You are subscribing to a very
- 9:32specific idea of what a premium car should be in this new era.
- 9:36So let's breakdown those 3 philosophies one last time for
- 9:38everyone listening. OK, first you have the BMW I4
- 9:42philosophy. This is the traditional driver
- 9:44focused luxury experience. It's for someone who wants a car
- 9:47that happens to be electric, not an electric car.
- 9:49First, it's about prestige and the feeling from behind the
- 9:54wheel. Next up, the pull star.
- 9:56The pull *2 philosophy. This is the design object that
- 9:59happens to be a car. It's for someone who values
- 10:01aesthetics, that Scandinavian vibe, and that unique practical
- 10:05versatility from its crossover DNA.
- 10:07It's for someone who wants something different.
- 10:08And finally, the Tesla. The Tesla Model 3 philosophy.
- 10:11This is the smart device that happens to be a car.
- 10:14It prioritizes software efficiency and a simple,
- 10:16seamless ecosystem from buying to charging.
- 10:19For most fleets, or anyone focused on total cost and ease
- 10:22of use, it's the overall best choice.
- 10:24So here's the thought I want to leave you with.
- 10:27Given that the Tesla Model 3 has kind of rewritten the rules on
- 10:30value by making everything standard, does the future of
- 10:34premium in the car world mean that kind of simplified complete
- 10:38package? Or does the deep customization
- 10:41you get from a brand like BMW still hold its traditional
- 10:44appeal? Something for you to think
- 10:46about. If you enjoyed this deep dive,
- 10:48consider following the channel. You can also support me by
- 10:50buying me a coffee through the link in the description.
- 10:52Your support means a lot to me. Thank you for your kindness.