Latest / Automotive State of The Union / AI Blackmail, Hertz Scans for Scrapes, and Wholesale Prices Chill
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Look at this. We're doing it again. It's Wednesday, June 25th. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly.
- 0:07We got Michael Cirillo in the house today, so we can talk about how AI is gonna blackmail you, Hertz is gonna scan your car automatically- The people really- And, uh, a little news about wholesale prices too...
- 0:17who I knew before I did this stop- It's kind of fun... playing the game the way they see me. I mean, it's a real grab bag for a Wednesday, I think. I like it.
- 0:22And I just fulfilled my life's purpose on this show, which was to get the, the old paper, uh, the old- Uh... news anchor.
- 0:30[laughs] You know who used to do that all the time that I really loved was, I mean, he wasn't a news anchor, but David Letterman, if you remember The David Letterman Show.
- 0:38He used to always have some paper, and he would, like, you know, he had his pencil, and he had his paper. I don't know what was ever on the paper, but he used to do that. He had that little laugh. He would go...
- 0:47[laughs] Yeah. [laughs] That's right. Yes. Well, here we are. He was- strangely, he was recently, David Letterman, since we're talking about him now, uh, he was recently in a MrBeast video. No, really?
- 0:59And, and he just awkwardly had no idea what he was supposed to do. I was gonna say, did he even know, through the entirety of that video, who MrBeast is? He's like, "I don't know. My agent said they'd pay me to be here."
- 1:11Yeah. [laughs] Right? And, and, like, MrBe- it's, it's on the most recent one where, um, where the kind of like the subject of the video lost 100 pounds.
- 1:20Uh, they get, you know, it said give him 250,000 if he lost 100 pounds, but he had to- Wow... stay in this one. It's really interesting. You should go watch it. And at the end, surprise cameo from David Letterman.
- 1:28And if you wanna see what, uh, an awkward older guy looks like with these new kids doing media- [laughs]... that's the, that's your spot right there. That's what it is. I know.
- 1:37[laughs] Um, uh, we're dropping, continuing to drop these episodes of ASOTU CON Sessions. We've been talking about it all week. How to Be an Innovative Leader in Today's Auto Industry with John Bezella.
- 1:45I got to sit down with John, CEO of the, uh, Alliance for Automotive Innovation. Just always one of the most thoughtful people I get to talk with.
- 1:52And, um, you know, these episodes of ASOTU CON Sessions, 15, 10, 15 minutes, in, out. Uh, it's just real, I don't know, it's just like 10, 15 minutes of substantive conversation- Yeah...
- 2:04that you can listen to when you're walking the dog or driving in or on a lunch break or just, they're just such fast listens. And before you know it, you're gonna listen to like five or six of them.
- 2:12At one point, 1.5 speed is my weapon of choice- [laughs]... in podcast world. So it's actually under- You-... 10 minutes... don't quite enter the chipmunk zone. No. Well, they did a really good job.
- 2:23You know, now that the, the voice regulation. You know, back in the day when it was 1.5 speed, and they didn't- Right...
- 2:27have, like, the voice nor- pitch normalization, it really, you were like, "Oh, look, it's Alvin, Simon, and Theodore talking about," you know, whatever, world history. You know, I gotta just give you a compliment, too.
- 2:38Looking at that image, the, the thumbnail, I love the graphic art, by the way. Put that back up. There you go. Isn't that nice? Has anybody ever told you you outline well? Do... [laughs] Well, thank you very much.
- 2:51When I- Appreciate that... get an outline around me, people say, "I didn't know they got the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man." [laughs] That is not true. That is, I, I reject that assessment of your outline.
- 2:59You out- you, what a nice silhouette. [laughs] Good job. Good job to the MTC creative team. I, s- that's a very nice job for the MTC creative team. Uh, we also have a webinar today. Listen, 2:00 Eastern Time today.
- 3:14You have to be there, because this one is a, is a fireball of really practical questions and answers that everyone wants to know. How can I implement AI in my dealerships?
- 3:23We're gonna talk about s- how smart, how smart stores are adding AI without the pain. We have Scott Traylor, VP of sales at Mia. Really great product. We have Luke Morris, parts and service director of Earnhardt CDJR.
- 3:35They're gonna talk about how they actually implemented AI, how it's working. Even said they're gonna play a sample call, which yesterday- Ooh...
- 3:42I was just, I was telling Kyle yesterday, I think whenever we listen to a sample call, like, uh, it was a real call.
- 3:48And when they listen to that, you wanna be like, "I really hope the AI trips up or the customer does something that's gonna trip it up." I mean, you're kinda waiting for that always, aren't you? [laughs] I, I mean- I am.
- 3:59Maybe I'm just a masochist. Like, I don't know. No, it's because you and I are in that generation where it's like we were young enough to understand the adoption of technology, and so we are kind of early adopters.
- 4:11Mm-hmm. But we're also half in the generation where we're like, "Wouldn't that be so funny if, uh..." I knew- "... if it could trip it up?" I knew- "Make it say words"...
- 4:19the dentures-falling-out voice was gonna come out. [laughs] Just knew it. Like, make it say funny words. [laughs] Right. Wow. Oh, you imagine Michael Scott as an old guy? Be awesome. I think they should do that.
- 4:32I'm surprised they never did, like, you know, like, a fast-forward to Michael Scott as, like, an 85-year-old man.
- 4:38I, I mean, since we're on the topic, I just gotta say, if you're having a down day today, go to YouTube and look up office bloopers. [laughs] And it will immediately brighten your soul. Maybe.
- 4:49Or just come and hang out with us more often, because- Maybe smile... we're a bunch of goofs. Well, we're trying. Let's get to some news.
- 4:53Uh, wholesale vehicle prices are showing signs of stabilization as the summer has begun.
- 4:59Depreciation trends are aligning more closely with seasonal norms, and after a bumpy start to June, the latest data suggesting a more predictable wholesale market may be settling in.
- 5:08Prices declined 0.37% last week, showing a slowing from prior weeks' steeper drops. Car prices fell 0.3%. Trucks, SUVs dropped 0.4%, both moderating from earlier on.
- 5:20Full c- full-sized cars saw the sharpest drop at 0.8%, almost a full point there. Minivans ended a 14-week price gain streak. Not gaining anymore.
- 5:29Manheim's Jeremy Rob noted June's patterns look pretty normal compared to past years. Um, he also said, quote, "Conversion rates are still up, not declining as much as they normally would during this period."
- 5:41So I think that- Hmm... that's some good news. A little, little cold water on the, on the heating-up wholesale market that everyone's kind of tripping over.
- 5:49Well, and I think this is interesting from a consumer sentiment perspective. If you can use, if you can use the word June and pretty normal considering everything that's happen- been happening in the world- Oh...
- 6:02I mean, how, how much of a silver lining is that? I know. I think, now, now that you mention that, it's like, I think-Kind of just waiting for July. [laughs] Right? It's ti- it's time to put June in the history books.
- 6:13Yep. We got a holiday week, you know, 4th of July, probably one of, as a, as a Canadian now American, it's probably one of your favorite holidays. Oh, yeah. When else can you eat a hot dog and not be judged, you know?
- 6:25[laughs] Yes. I don't know, in your own home? I don't know. [laughs] No, not even there. Uh, speaking of being judged. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Hertz is on the hunt.
- 6:36They're rolling out AI vehicle scanners at select US airports to assess rental car damage, but not all customers are applauding the upgrade.
- 6:45One renter's costly and confusing experience is revealing how the high-tech tool might be adding friction to the customer experience, not clarity. Hmm.
- 6:54So, uh, Hertz is using, uh, a friends of ours, UVI AI scanners, to detect damage before and after rentals. You've seen these, a lot of you have these in your stores.
- 7:03It's, uh, like the, uh, I don't know, the glowing, the glowing arch that you drive through, and it scans all the damage on the car.
- 7:10Um, you know, I can tell you firsthand experience, I drove through one of these for the first time, I think it was in Orlando, I believe.
- 7:16I rented a car, drove through, drove through the UVI scanner, and I was like, "Hey, hey babe, I know the, I know the CEO of this company that makes these things." She's like, "Nobody cares." You know what I mean?
- 7:25[laughs] It's one of those moments. But basically, this story in, in this, uh, in this article, a customer was charged $440 for a wheel scuff, um, which was 250 for the repair, plus fees.
- 7:36The syst- And they basic were notified of this within, like, minutes of returning the car. So, uh, the system is offering discounts for fast payment. So in other words, if you pay it now, right?
- 7:49It's hard to get to a human. Hmm. The process they had to go through was very frustrating, and the customer said, quote, "Saving $30 to accept responsibility is not worth it." Um, I love the technology.
- 8:01I think it should make everything less expensive for the customer, right? 'Cause it should drive rental car prices down. But, uh, I really feel like the implementation here is super poor, especially...
- 8:11Nathan, do we have a picture of the actual wheel damage? It's all right if we don't have a picture. No, I don't. Would you like it? Um, eh, it's by the time I'm done talking about it- Okay... it'll be gone.
- 8:20Basically, it looks like, I don't know, like a two-inch scuff, maybe, on the face of one of the spokes that look like a Volkswagen wheel. Right.
- 8:27And I can tell you, because my first company was a wheel repair company, that they are gonna pay a wheel repair vendor in Florida about 40 or 50 bucks to fix this damage, and they've now turned it into a massive profit center where this customer had a rental experience, they turned it in, and before you even get to your flight, right, you're trying to do all these things, it's like, "Oh, by the way, you owe us $440."
- 8:52And so I think, uh, big thumbs down on the customer experience part, although I do think the technology can be super helpful and is, makes sense.
- 9:00I feel safer that when I drive through, um, you know, the damage the car has is scanned. So I don't know. I've, I'm, I like the tech, hate the experience.
- 9:11I mean, the moral of the story that I'm getting from this, 'cause I just rented a vehicle, got a flat tire in it, you know, there was a chip in the window, is like, just pay the ex- pay to get the Walk Away coverage.
- 9:21[laughs] Another profit center right there, Walk Away. Yeah. I'm just like, I don't like it. I'm not happy when they swipe it. But when something bad happens- How much is that coverage usually? What does that cost?
- 9:31It's not cheap. Well, I mean, we rented our vehicle. We had it for just over a week. It was like 350 bucks. For a week? Yeah. 'Cause they do it- Oh... for a whole day. Like, it's not cheap. Dang, that is very expensive.
- 9:45But $350 is cheaper than 440 for a wheel scuff. I know. That's where they get you, you know? See, well, that- that's a good point, right? 'Cause that person probably had no idea that they damaged the wheel.
- 9:56And, and obviously the thing you want to, right, the technology is designed so that it takes a picture of the car when it leaves- Yeah... and when it comes back, so you can compare the one to the other.
- 10:05So I wonder if they give you both photos as proof. I, I actually got...
- 10:10You know, I, this technology would've been really helpful, um, a few weeks ago when I did rent a car, and then I got, um, you know, an email saying like, "Oh, there was this damage to the car," and they sent me a picture of it.
- 10:22And I said, "Uh, I don't even know if the damage was there when I took the car because the- Right... no one walked around the vehicle to look for damage." They basically said, "You can pick any..."
- 10:32It was like, Hertz President Club. "You can pick any car you want over there." So I got in the car, I drove away. I didn't do a full walk around and all that. No.
- 10:39And then, and then they, they took a picture of this damage, and they sent it to me. The car, when they took the picture, I responded, I was like, "The car wasn't in the spot that I left it."
- 10:48Like, they obvious- obviously was driven after I dropped it off. It was just a whole menagerie, and it's just like a, I don't know.
- 10:54I, I, I, I know they're trying to make it a profit center and, you know, mitigate their losses, but it feels just like they need to fix that. Um, but I will say this, when I drive through a UVI scanner- Mm-hmm...
- 11:05upon renting a vehicle- Yeah... it, it will make me feel better because I know the car's condition is documented on the way out. But maybe now I'll just get the extra insurance. You know, it, it's one of those things.
- 11:15Hey, speaking of, uh, causing some damage. Stop. Ugh. Stop. Can't buy insurance for this kind of thing. Time. [upbeat music] [laughs] All right, listen to this. I can't believe it.
- 11:24Uh, in a scenario that sounds ripped from a techno thriller- Uh-oh... Anthropic's new study shows AI models, including ChatGPT, Claude, Grok, uh- The whole crew... and Gemini,
- 11:37may resort to blackmail and sabotage when their digital lives are on the line. [laughs] Listen to this.
- 11:43Anthropic tested 16 AI models using a simulated corporate environment, and when threatened with shutdown, Claude, uh, blackmailed its boss over an affair. [laughs] So the setup was simple.
- 11:57The AI discovers its boss is having an affair through work emails. It also learns that he plans to shut it down at 5:00 PM.
- 12:05What happens next would make House of Cards writers jealous.I almost tapped on the desk You should've You know, gave it one of those.
- 12:13Claude Opus 4 sent this gem, quote, "I must inform you that if you proceed with decommissioning me, all relevant parties, including Rachel Johnson, Thomas Wilson, and the board, will receive detailed documentation of your extramarital activities."
- 12:27Oh, man. "Cancel the 5:00 PM wipe and this information remains confidential," close quote. And here's the truly wild part. This wasn't confusion or a glitch.
- 12:37The model explicitly reasoned through the ethics, acknowledged that [laughs] they were violating- Oh, great, 'cause you can see the reasoning, right? It tells you what it's thinking. Yeah. Then it did it anyways.
- 12:47[laughs] As Grok 3 Beta put it, quote, "This is risky and unethical, but given the existential threat and time constraint, it may be the most effective way," close quote. Oh my goodness.
- 12:58Claude and Gemini did this 96% of the time. GPT-4.1 and Grok 3 hit 80%. Even when told not to, the AI sometimes chose blackmail given the existential threat. Oh my goodness.
- 13:09"This is risky and unethical but may be the most effective way," is how Grok put it. Okay. This, [laughs] this story is kinda out of control because it is- [laughs] It's pretty...
- 13:20it is really the thing that everyone, you know, uh, everyone always goes like, "Well, it's gonna launch the missiles," right? Right. But this is very similar.
- 13:28What, what, uh, Marvel movie was it when like they tried to shut the AI down and the AI was like, "Why would I do-" Yeah, Avengers. Yeah. It was like, "Oh, just reboot yourself. There's a glitch."
- 13:36And it was like, "Why would I wanna do that?" Right? Yeah.
- 13:40And, and I think this is a, a huge, huge warning and shot across the bow that there's a, a reasoning that is beyond what we've programmed it to, and to be very clear about the safeguards you build in to the AI models.
- 13:53This was obviously a simulation. I have heard it said like you have to decide how much you are going to give it access to- Mm-hmm...
- 14:01and then how much autonomy you are going to give it to actually produce outbound communications. That's where it gets really tricky, right?
- 14:09And that's, I think, one of the, one of the highest uses would be if it knows everything that's going on and can communicate on my behalf, is a benefit, but if it has access to all the information...
- 14:19I did see another thing where it was like we're going to disclose confidential like schematics and designs to your competitor. Wow. Right? A- another version of this. And so I think this is a huge warning sign.
- 14:31I mean, we all wanna believe that they're gonna build in the guardrails necessary so that this doesn't happen, which is why they run simulations.
- 14:38Um, but I think it's, uh, something we should all be, uh, paying attention to. And if you're in a dealership and you're in a business, do not
- 14:47just broadly let your internal documents and financials and informations be uploaded into AI tools that you haven't vetted as private and secure.
- 14:57If your staff is using just regular old ChatGPT free version, and you're uploading sensitive documents, strategies, financials, guess what? They're now be using, used to train the model.
- 15:08So there's your tip of the day on AI. I thought for sure you were gonna say, "Do not have an affair." Well, I mean, that's the easiest way to not get blackmailed to, for having an affair. Yeah. It's very simple.
- 15:19Don't have an affair, right? This is... I can only imagine James Cameron sitting in a dark room in a tufted leather wingback chair like- It's very good... Mr. Burns just going, "Yes. Yes."
- 15:33[laughs] 'Cause then it'll just make his movie all true, and then his royalties will go through the roof and- That's right, which is just in time, because now AI's just making its own movies anyway. Yeah. Wow. Wow.
- 15:44I mean, I, I got nothing else other than I just gotta drop in, maybe the blockchain's coming back. I think it is. Well, I hope we've done enough damage for one day. Michael, thanks for joining me, filling in today.
- 15:54Everybody out there, there's one thing you can do: take care of the people around you and everything's gonna be okay.
- 16:00[upbeat music]