Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 328. PCOS, Estrogen Dominance in Perimenopause, BHRT vs. Synthetic Hormones with Dr. Felice Gersh
Transcript
- 0:00Thanks for listening to the Thyroid Fixer podcast with your host, me, Dr. Amy Horniman, aka the Thyroid Fixer, functional medicine practitioner, hormone and weight loss expert. We're talking all things thyroid, hormone and health related in order to empower, educate and transform you. So if you're ready to get your life back, let's get started.
- 0:22All right. Yes, this is an exciting day. I cannot tell you how excited I've been to have Dr. Felice Gersh on the show for quite some time now. I first heard her on my beloved Soul Sisters podcast, Karen Martel, The Other Side of Weight Loss. And her information just blew my mind. And I have so many questions from my patients, from my listeners about estrogen, about the thyroid and estrogen.
- 0:50what role estrogen plays in thyroid function. So we're going to deep dive on that topic today. So let me give a formal introduction first to Dr. Gersh. Felice Gersh, MD, is a multi-award winning physician with dual board certifications in OBGYN and integrative medicine.
- 1:09She's the founder and director of the Integrative Medical Group of Irvine, a practice that provides comprehensive healthcare for women by combining the best evidence-based therapies from conventional, naturopathic, and holistic medicine. She taught obstetrics and gynecology at Keck USC School of Medicine for 12 years as an assistant clinical professor, where she received the highly coveted Outstanding Volunteer Clinical Faculty Award.
- 1:36She now serves as an affiliate faculty member at the Fellowship in Integrative Medicine through the University of Arizona School of Medicine, where she lectures and regularly grades the case presentations written by the fellowship students for their final exams. Thank you.
- 1:51Felice Gersh, MD, is the best-selling author of PCOS SOS and the PCOS SOS Fertility Fast Track, and she has published articles in peer-reviewed medical journals. She is a prolific lecturer and has been featured in several films and documentary series, including The Real Skinny on Fat with Montel Williams.
- 2:13and fasting with Walter Longo, PhD. Amazing, man. Her new must-have book, which we just talked about before coming on today, Menopause, 50 Things You Need to Know, is now out and available on Amazon. So we'll definitely put a link for your book. Dr. Gersh, thank you so much for coming on and blessing us with your knowledge today. We need it.
- 2:38We need it. That's one of my missions is to try to help women wherever they are all over the globe, because there's so much misinformation and there's so much that can be done to help women to lead the optimized lives that they deserve. Absolutely. So how did you come to specialize in hormones and PCOS and estrogen and menopause? What was your journey like? Yeah.
- 3:03Well, as is so common a story, I myself was trying to figure out what was going wrong with my body and my hormones. So way back as a teen, I had the worst acne ever. So my heart goes out to every woman who deals with that problem. And there was really no treatment and I didn't know what was going on. I thought it was my skin somehow was dirty
- 3:27And I would take alcohol and I would like scrub my face with rubbing alcohol. So my skin would crack. And of course it did nothing except make my skin super dry and crack all around the pimples. And then my periods like just disappeared. And I was in medical school and I hadn't had a period for two years. So I went to one of the leading people at the university in the department of OBGYN. I said, something is clearly wrong with me. I have all this acne and my,
- 3:56period hasn't come for two years. And, and his response was so flippant. It was like, well, women don't even like having periods anyway, you're not trying to get pregnant. So just go on birth control pills. You know, that's so it's like, well, but that's, I mean, even then I knew like, but that's not addressing why, but I was trying to be obedient. So I went on birth control pills, like I was told, and it makes me feel really nauseated. I didn't, I didn't like it.
- 4:21And and then it's so it's like, OK, I'm going to be an OBGYN. Plus, I love the field because it was so adrenaline pushing. You know, I love like going there for the deliveries. And of course, you know, sometimes there's life and death situations where you have to deal with.
- 4:39acute issues like cord prolapse, hemorrhaging, abruption, and all kinds of things. And it was an interesting blend of medical issues because every medical problem can exist in a pregnant woman. You need to know how to deal with it and the medical complications of pregnancy. And also, I loved the idea of using my hands to be a skilled technician and do surgeries and...
- 5:00And so on. And I did all of that for many, many years. But then my time came and I wanted to really like move on. So I gave up obstetrics so I could actually get some sleep because it was like many years of sleep deprivation.
- 5:15And then I started looking at other avenues, like how can I really help women? I started calling all the drug reps to come in my office and then show me their original studies that we used to get their drug FDA approved. And I was shocked at how minimal the difference was between their effect and placebo effect, and also the side effect profile. And it's like, why am I prescribing this drug? It's like, doesn't really do much. And so that's when I went on my personal journey
- 5:45to find other ways to help women. And I did the fellowship at the University of Arizona School of Medicine for two years in integrative medicine. And then I've just gone on perpetual journey of, I became a course junkie and then a PubMed junkie. So I would read all the published articles across all different fields of medicine. And I became what I call a synthesizer. I would look at all the different data and put it together
- 6:10which, you know, looking at all the organ systems, all the specialties to come up with a cohesive understanding of the female body. And of course, along the way, I had to diagnose myself with mycos, you know, because nobody else did. And so that became also one of my passions. And of course, now that I'm a menopausal woman, of course, menopause, you know, we're always a little bit into self-interest, but fortunately my journey has mirrored every other female's journey
- 6:39So my learning journey has been very beneficial for all of my patients as well as myself. Not every woman has polycystic ovary syndrome, but it's the poster child for all the blending of metabolic and reproductive problems you can have even if you don't have that particular syndrome. And there's not a woman on this planet who will live long enough and will avoid menopause. So that's our universal, like unifying
- 7:07experience for every single female across every single continent. And it doesn't matter what your ethnicity is, you're going to hit menopause. So we all need to understand it so we can deal with it appropriately. We do and not be scared of it, I think. And I love how you say that's our unifying kind of connection of all women, because you're right. You can't take a pill to avoid menopause.
- 7:31You can take things to help it, but you can't take a pill to avoid it. And when you mentioned PCOS, I see that so very often in my patients or my following with hypothyroidism and Hashimoto's. Do you see that correlation a lot? Oh my goodness. Yes. And I'm so glad that you picked up on that because not everybody does. And it's really unfortunate that so many doctors...
- 7:54ignore that issue. And they don't even test for thyroid antibodies. It's like not considered standard of care, but of course it should. So women with polycystic ovary syndrome, PCOS or PCOS, they have, we now know from studies that originally came out of China and then have been replicated in other places, they have a dysbiotic or abnormal gut microbiome. And so you have this
- 8:20ultimately a leaky gut or impaired gut barrier, because when you don't have the right microbes, it doesn't interact with our own lining cells and immune cells to create this protective mucus coating to keep the toxins in the gut from damaging the tissues, the little fibrous tissues that connect the different cells that line the gut lining. And so they start drifting apart due to this
- 8:44degradation of these materials that hold the cells together in these what are called tight junctions. So these toxic products that are called LPS or lipopolysaccharides, also known as endotoxins, toxins from within, they can actually pass between these little sections between the gut lining cells and
- 9:03and then enter the body itself where our immune system lies in great measure, like 70, 80% of our immune system resides surrounding the gut. And these immune cells are designed to activate when they're exposed to damaged tissue and pathogens. So you have this perpetual damaged tissue and also particles and also the actual microbes coming into our body. And this just goes on and on.
- 9:29It's like a chronic state of infection. And now we know that our, like you can say, like the building blocks of nature, whether it's a virus or a bacteria or a human being, are the same. We have like the same nucleotides. We're like from the same amorphous primordial pool, right?
- 9:49And so if you think of a bacteria or a virus like a Lego, we're like Legoland on steroids, you know, but when you look at it, we are still made of the same things. And that's why when you have any infection and you make antibodies, because that's what our immune cells are trained to do, it always cross reacts with our own tissues because it's like, you know, like friendly fire. It doesn't distinguish between us and the enemy.
- 10:14But it's okay because that's supposed to be short-lived. An infection should happen. We get over it. We get back to living a healthy life. And the antibodies no longer are going to be produced. But when you have a leaky gut and you have this perpetual leaking in of viruses and bacteria that ultimately are similar enough with antigens like protein similarities, the antibodies are perpetually being made.
- 10:39And over time, they cross-react. That's what autoimmunity is. So they're damaging and attacking our own tissues. And the most common is the thyroid gland. So thyroid is the most common of the autoimmune conditions. And now we know that women with PCOS have a significantly higher rate
- 10:58of this type of autoimmune condition, but it can also incur other types of autoimmune diseases as well, the thyroid is the most common, and it is so under-tested and under-recognized, and thyroid, oh my gosh, is, you know, every hormone in the body has critically important functions.
- 11:17And if you have an inadequate supply of thyroid hormones, oh my goodness, there's not a single cell in the body that's going to be functioning optimally. Exactly. Oh, I'm so happy you said that. I have so many questions for you. I don't even know where to start. So we're just going to let this roll. So kind of coming off of the PCOS, I know that they changed the diagnostic criteria for PCOS recently where you don't actually have to have
- 11:40cysts on your ovaries? Because I know there's going to be people listening and going, well, I got an ulcer. I don't have cysts on my ovaries. And you don't even have to have that anymore, right? Well, you know, when they come up with a diagnostic criteria, you get a bunch of people in a room and they hash it out and there are going to be dissenters, there's going to be the agreeers and so on. And so it's basically an opinion piece.
- 12:03So it's not dictated by nature. So I and the androgen excess, you know, PCOS society, they believe, for example, that you should have androgen excess, like you should have excessive amounts of DHEAS, that's the adrenal androgen,
- 12:19or testosterone should be in excess. And I agree with that, but it didn't come out of that particular. So they have different labels, different criteria, but it's really important because it goes to the mechanistic causation issues, you know, when you look at this. And there are different types of PCOS. So it's,
- 12:38If you think about the ovaries, so the majority, about 80% of PCOS is ovarian based. So by that, it is that there's this problem that's in the ovaries that is not right and it involves the enzyme
- 12:55aromatase that converts testosterone into estradiol, the estrogen made by the ovaries. And it's important to know that all estrogen derives from androgens. All estradiol in the ovary comes from testosterone. So it's like an assembly line. It goes down and you have testosterone, it's converted into estradiol. But if you don't have the proper functioning of that enzyme, you get like a buildup of testosterone because it's not converted in a proper amount and order.
- 13:24into the estradiol. So you have too little estradiol, too much testosterone, and that leads to a whole host of problems. And why is it that you don't have this proper functioning? Well, we don't 100% know, but it's probably the perfect storm of
- 13:40endocrine disruptors, exposure during in uterine life, combined with genetic propensities, combined with poor diet and stress and circadian rhythm dysfunction. So it's complex, but you end up with this basic problem in the ovary
- 13:55And so it turns out that you're very good at recruiting follicles, but you don't have, you need in order to get the, I call it the special one, the one that gets selected for ovulation, you need this giant spike of estrogen, this giant spike of estrogen production
- 14:13that precedes ovulation. And if you don't get that, which you don't get when you can't convert enough and rapidly testosterone into estrogen, then you end up perpetually recruiting follicles, but never selecting one for ovulation. And these little follicles that never go anywhere start accumulating around the rim of the ovaries, creating that look that they call like a ring of pearls that gave the name PCOS to the condition.
- 14:41So that is pretty much always going to be the case in women who have that most common type of PCOS. But then there's the outlier type of PCOS that's adrenal-based, that has gotten even less attention and less research. And that particular form of PCOS is where the adrenal gland makes an excessive amount of its androgen, DHEAS,
- 15:08And that creates a lot of excessive facial hair and recalcitrant cystic acne. And when you have the high levels of androgens like DHS, that converts to testosterone. So you also have higher levels of testosterone. In the female body, half the testosterone comes in a normal female from the adrenal and half from the ovaries. So you still have high testosterone, you have high DHS, and you have a lot of problems from androgen excess.
- 15:37And once you have the higher amounts of these androgens, it in turn affects the gut microbiome in its own way, and it causes more inflammation. It dysregulates the ovary. So ultimately, the ovary gets dragged into the scene as an accessory, but not the primary issue.
- 15:54And then you get malfunction in terms of an ovulation. But they're actually kind of different, although they can manifest very similarly. And that's where the confusion comes. And because there has been so little interest, even though PCOS is the most common endocrine disorder of women, the most common cause of infertility, the amount of research dollars through the NIH is downward trending every year. And what research there is is wholly significant.
- 16:23on infertility, which is important. But this is a comprehensive metabolic condition that affects every organ system in the female, and there just hasn't been the attention and the research that needs to go into helping to create better solutions.
- 16:41And that's why I had to go on my own to try to figure this out and to try to come up with solutions that combine, because I'm integrative, when necessary, certain select pharmaceuticals, hopefully not for life. I call them a bridge to health, to help get things right, to dampen the fires that women have with PCOS because they're very inflamed and inflammation underlies so many problems. And then to always, always use PCOS.
- 17:10enormous amounts of lifestyle medicine and targeted supplements to help these different organ systems get back on track. And insulin resistance is huge too with Pico. So with that insulin, I mean, there's just a, like you said, a ball of inflammation with high insulin. So when you bring that down, oftentimes...
- 17:30things come into proper alignment while treating all the other lifestyle factors in the gut, like you mentioned earlier. Now, I've heard you talk before about estrogen dominance and kind of your take on it. Now, I'll tell you what I see, and then I want you to kind of piggyback with your experience and your knowledge.
- 17:48I see a lot of estrogen dominance, not so much in the Picos population. Normally with them, I will see the higher androgens, testosterone, bottomed out progesterone, and estrogen can kind of be anywhere. It could be normal. It could be low. But then even when we start moving into –
- 18:0730s, 40s, 50s, which Picos can still be present, of course, but kind of that perimenopausal state, that's where I'll see a lot of estrogen dominance. I'll have women that are 32 with a progesterone level of a postmenopausal woman and estrogen 400. And to me, that's an estrogen dominant state that could interfere with thyroid function. So I want to get your take on that.
- 18:33So the only typical time, there are a few rare exceptions, when a woman's ovaries are actually excessively producing estradiol is during the menopausal transition years, the perimenopausal time, which of course can be any time in a woman's life, unfortunately, because we know that there's
- 18:55a condition premature ovarian insufficiency. But typically, the average age for menopause in the United States is around, which is defined as 12 consecutive months without a period, which is totally arbitrary. But that would be based on that official label, around 51 in that range. Now, you can be in the transition into menopause, which is really ovarian aging. Well, that's kind of your whole life. But in terms of actually having symptoms and
- 19:25changes that are really significant in the ovaries that affect, you know, really quality of life can happen for the decade before, but typically it's about five years, but it's very individualized. Now, what happens is the downward trend is always there in terms of estrogen production. So the estrogen production from the ovary is going to go down, down, down, but along that path down, you get spikes up.
- 19:49So it's like the worst case scenario for a stock market. It's down and then spike up and then down and spike up. And the reason that that happens is that you still have ovaries that have eggs, and they still can respond to the hormonal signals that are coming from the pituitary gland, which of course are in response to the signals that come from the brain, from the hypothalamus of the brain.
- 20:13So it's like when we try to get women to ovulate and or collect eggs, say, if someone's going to have egg collection for egg freezing or for IVF purposes, they want to hyper ovulate them. They want to get a whole bunch of eggs out. You don't want to do like one at a time.
- 20:30from a year, so they hyper-ovulate. And they do that by using a synthetic version of follicle-stimulating hormone to just, with LH and you get, whoa, all these eggs coming out in a woman so you can collect them. Well, nature does that in the perimenopausal time. So you'll get this giant amount of FSH, which causes like a load of eggs to come out. That's why during the perimenopausal years,
- 20:59is the most common time for twins because you're actually off super ovulating because you get what happens is the estrogen is going down, the brain has sensors and says, oh, not enough estrogen. So it puts out the signal to the pituitary and the pituitary will over produce FSH. So you get this like hyper stimulation to the ovaries
- 21:23and you get this gigantic spike of estrogen, which then remember the spike of estrogen is what triggers the ovulation. So you get this gigantic spike that's sometimes double what the normal spike, that's the highest amount of estrogen for the cycle. Maybe you'll get,
- 21:38you know, normally would be 300 something. You could, I've seen people 800, you know, so you get this gigantic spike and then you get multiple eggs coming out. And the poor woman is on this roller coaster because then of course it dies down. And then she may go three months of having low estrogen and then another, whoa. And then her estrogen comes by skyrocketing. And then she puts out a whole, you know, slew of eggs again. And it's really a challenging time because
- 22:08at that time when she's super is producing estrogen, can cause exacerbation of breast tenderness and then PMS symptoms and migraines in people prone, some people who've never had migraines suddenly will develop migraines and mood disorders and sleep problems because this rollercoaster
- 22:28So, you know, it's really a challenge now. The conventional world just puts all those women on birth control pills. And that has a whole slew of problems because, you know, that's like a whole, you know, webinar on its own because of all the pro-inflammatory problems associated with birth control pills and thyroid effects as well. And so there are other ways that we can deal with it. In terms of the thyroid gland, estrogen is very important for creating hormones.
- 22:57binding proteins. And these binding proteins will increase in the amount that they're existing in the body when you have higher levels of estrogen. That's why when women are pregnant, if they are on thyroid protein,
- 23:12therapy, they need to be monitored because their thyroid will actually be less in terms of the free amount because more of it is going to be bound up by these binding proteins. And so you can actually end up underdosing women who are pregnant. It's so important to have just right amounts of thyroid
- 23:32in pregnancy to make sure that the baby's brain develops properly and also their own thyroid receptors are developing properly. So of course, this can happen to women when their estrogen level is too high, but it's up and down, you know, so it's really a challenge. But you can then have where you have symptoms of high thyroid.
- 23:55thyroid binding, you know, so that you have functionally low thyroid. But if you measure the total thyroid, you're not measuring free or unbound and you're measuring totals, they'll say, well, your thyroid is just fine. And if you look at the TSH, the TSH may be fine, but functionally that woman is hypothyroid because so much of her thyroid is being bound.
- 24:18by this excessive production of binding proteins for thyroid. And this is often missed. And so many women are misdiagnosed and also made to feel belittled and not listened to. Because on the other, on the flip side, when estrogen levels are low, and during this time, it's totally like a roller coaster, high, low, high, low. And when estrogen is low,
- 24:43estrogen up regulates thyroid receptors so that the thyroid hormone that you have will actually bind work better to the thyroid receptors and then create the effects that thyroid is supposed to have because it doesn't matter no matter how much hormone you have, if it doesn't get in the receptor and activate the receptor, you're going to have nothing happen.
- 25:06That's what happens when people have insulin resistance. That's why I use that as an example, because most people know that if you're pre-diabetic or diabetic, you have insulin resistance. What does that mean? It means that the hormone insulin is not properly binding to the receptor to create the
- 25:23needed effect, which is the ability to transport glucose across cell membranes so the glucose can get into the cell that needs it to create energy and so forth. Instead, it's just circulating in the blood, creating havoc. This can happen with thyroid as well. If you have thyroid hormone
- 25:39receptor resistance because you don't have enough estrogen, you can measure in the blood the thyroid hormone and it can be totally fine. It looks great, but it isn't working properly on the receptor. And that's what happens when estrogen levels drop, both in the perimenopausal time when it's up and down. And also, of course, in the postmenopausal years, if a woman isn't on physiologic hormone therapy, like hormone replacement,
- 26:06then her thyroid hormones are not going to bind properly to the receptor to create the effect. So, so many women after menopause have symptoms that they read the book and they have every symptom on the list. And yet they go in, the doctor says, no, your thyroid hormone levels are fine. And then he thinks or sees another crazy woman, you know, who's like reading too much online. You know, Dr. Google is, you know, giving her information and she's like,
- 26:30looking at the symptoms but that's not what she has when in fact she does have it you know and it's like my hair is falling out i can't sleep i have no energy i you know i'm cold constipation it's like uh it's like low thyroid oh no your thyroid hormone levels are fine no it doesn't matter how much you have if it doesn't work in the receptor
- 26:51So too low of estrogen is as bad for thyroid hormone binding to the receptor site as high estrogen. Because let's say someone is on thyroid replacement therapy. So they're on, I mean, most of the time we see them on T4 only, which is a shame. But let's say they're even on T4 only or NDT. And we need that T4 to convert over to T3 to bind to the receptor.
- 27:15High estrogen will interfere. We know in an estrogen-dominant state that will interfere with T4, T3 conversion. So will low estrogen, or you're just saying low estrogen, will prevent the binding to the cell. Am I getting that right? You know, that's why when you go on hormones...
- 27:33you really have to know what's going on. And that's why you can't just, it's not one size fits all, because we know that how, like, let's be real, menopause is natural. It's just naturally not very good for women. You know, maybe it's good for the species, but for the individual, no, it's not good. It promotes aging and all kinds of problems.
- 27:54It's not one size fits all. And you can't look at someone and say, oh, I know exactly what hormone dose you need. Of course you don't, because nature never intended us to take hormones after menopause. Of course that's not natural. And of course I don't care because I'm a little bit selfish. And I...
- 28:12I want to live and be optimally healthy, not live a life of declining health over the next, you know, 35, 40 years. That's not what I'm looking for. So I don't care if I use tools. I mean, everything in medicine is about using tools to enhance what nature like messed up in our, you know, like we replace cataracts, we replace joints, we take pharmaceuticals, you know, we do all kinds of things with makeup and plastic surgery. None of that is natural. And that's why when you give hormones after menopause,
- 28:41I know it's not natural, but it's better for our bodies to have hormones than not. If someone came and took out your thyroid gland, I wouldn't say, well, now you can eat more vegetables. I mean, of course, I want people to eat vegetables, but there's no replacement for a missing hormone hormone.
- 29:00other than giving the hormone. Now there are things that can ameliorate the damage and the symptoms. So of course you can give phytoestrogens and I'm all for eating flax seeds, but that's not the same. And it doesn't bind equally and in balance with the different hormone receptors. It doesn't go to the different organs the same way. So even though there are benefits to doing everything
- 29:24lifestyle. Of course, it's part of the solution, but you can't have the ultimate solution if you're lacking a vital hormone. You just can't. You lose your thyroid gland, you have to get thyroid hormone in. You lose your ovarian function, even though it's natural, it's still not good not to have the hormones produced by the ovaries. That's why people who are 70 are not as healthy as people who are 25. That's a big part of it.
- 29:52If we keep the body getting everything it needs, nutrition, fitness, stress control, and hormones, everything, each cell in your body doesn't know how old it is. Most of those cells were not there when you were born. So they will do what they're genetically programmed to do.
- 30:12if they have everything they need. Now, we can't replace 25-year-old ovaries yet. I don't, we don't. So when I give hormones to women who are in their 50s, 60s, and older, I know that I'm not giving them the same hormone blend and rhythms and everything else that they had when they were 25.
- 30:32It's not best because we don't have best. Best is you turn the clock back and you're 25, but it's better. So we have to be accepting better. Just like if you have Hashimoto's and we give thyroid, it's not the same, the same pulsing, the same rhythm, the same dosing, everything that your natural thyroid gland was making if it was working in pristine condition.
- 30:56It's just better than not doing something. And so we take better and we turn it into a better quality of life, even though we know it's not the same as that organ doing its best in the most optimal way. It's still so much better. And that's where, you know, really the practice of medicine comes in is.
- 31:15how to take something that isn't in the best shape, whether it's due to aging or due to autoimmune disease or cancer of the thyroid, whatever it is, and then turning it to be better and then the best of better that we can make it.
- 31:32I love that because I'm always saying that about the thyroid gland. It boggles my mind how even doctors can remove the thyroid gland and then just replace it with T4, but it used to produce T4 and T3, but we're just going to give it one out of two hormones. So that would be like, oh, a woman going into menopause and we're going to give you just testosterone. Like, wait a minute.
- 31:55What about the other hormones? So I'm very happy you used that analogy and that you said that. And kind of springboarding off of what you said, we replace hormones that are no longer being properly made. So now you have the attention of women out there that maybe they went through breast cancer or maybe their mom died.
- 32:15sister, aunt went through breast cancer, and they have been told by conventional medicine, you need to avoid hormones at all costs because breast cancer is in your family, or you went through it already yourself. So what is the deal with that? The true deal?
- 32:33There's a couple of differences here. If you have a family history of breast cancer, I do recommend that you get genetic testing and that way you know your statistical risk, which is really sad because we know that these genes are not destiny, they're risks. And we know that years and years ago that people who had those same genes, like they'll say variations or mutations, they were not associated with the same high incidence of breast cancer that they are today.
- 33:03because of our food that's not the same and our environmental endocrine disruptors that are affecting how genes are expressed, even in utero, exposures and our life in utero can change ultimately how our genes are expressed. But given the world that we do live in, I think every woman who has a family history should have her genetic testing so she knows statistically
- 33:26what her risk may be. But let's assume that there is no genetic thing there. And it's just like you have the same risk except from a genetic point of view that we have been able to determine, but you have some family history. Well, it's so misunderstood how breast cancer occurs in the relationship to estrogen. First of all, the vast majority still of breast cancers occur in post-menopausal women who don't have ovarian function and are not making estrogen.
- 33:54And women who are younger, premenopausal women, the incidence of breast cancer, unfortunately, is really increasing very significantly, like seven times what it used to be decades ago. And that's not because they have estrogen. It's because their bodies are filled with endocrine disruptors. For example, there's data that when they were exposed to certain pesticides, like when they used to spray the beaches,
- 34:17and so on with DDT, you know, that they would get exposed to different pesticides and chemicals when they were maybe a young teen. That changes the genetic expression and predisposes them to breast cancer, for example, in their 40s. So there's a long latent period there between the toxic exposure and then the ultimate cancer that develops. So that's something to really appreciate that,
- 34:41It's not because they have hormones. It's because their bodies have been unfortunately exposed to chemical endocrine disruptors, which have an altered gene expression and promoted different gene expressions associated with cancer development. And so in terms of that group,
- 34:58And people who know that they were exposed to say chemical exposures, what should they avoid? Like the plague, like hormonal contraception, because that's putting another risk factor of an endocrine disruptor in their body. I mean, you can't like create all of these things, but in an optimal world, you would have babies when you're like 19 and 20, you would breastfeed for three years.
- 35:21You know, you would avoid hormonal contraception, you would eat all organic foods, and you would avoid every kind of chemical exposure that you can possibly avoid, you know, air purifiers, water purifiers, and so on to lower your toxic load and to try to change how your genes are expressed. We know that
- 35:38early pregnancies and breastfeeding can actually also change gene expression within the breast to lower the risk of breast cancer. But I can't tell everyone who's a teenager, you should plan on having your baby soon. I mean, so we live in the world we live in. So we just have to at least try to recognize that some things like hormonal contraceptives have been shown to have an increased association with breast cancer and,
- 36:03And yet that is so poo-pooed, it's like nobody pays any attention to that. And there are some alternative birth control methods that can at least be utilized for more of a woman's reproductive life than they are to try to avoid, at least limit the number of years of exposure to what are technically, officially, endocrine disruptors that can create harm in the female body in a whole myriad of ways.
- 36:27In terms of like postmenopausal women, what happens in a postmenopausal woman that increases her risk of breast cancer is inflammation. So inflammation, chronic unrelenting inflammation
- 36:42becomes the state of a female body after menopause when she doesn't have estrogen. Because estrogen from the ovaries is what we call an immuno-modulator. It's like amazing what it does with the immune system. It actually initiates the inflammatory response
- 36:58so that if you're a trauma victim, you've gotten burn or laceration or infected with a pathogen, it activates the inflammatory pathways so that you can deal with it effectively because inflammation is how we fight trauma, injury and pathogens.
- 37:15But then as an immunomodulator, estrogen like pulls the switch and converts from a pro to an anti-inflammatory status when appropriate. But after menopause, it gets sort of stuck in the pro-inflammatory state. That's sort of like the default state is like chaos and inflammation. Right.
- 37:35So you end up with this chronic state of inflammation. The gut microbiome becomes dysbiotic, abnormal. You get leaky gut. You know, you end up more with fatty liver. Then you have all the degradations of the different organ systems that are all pro-inflammatory, like osteoarthritis, osteoporosis, neuroinflammation, you know, memory, cognitive mood problems,
- 37:56the whole cardiovascular system, all of these are inflammatory processes. And the breast is no exception. The breast becomes pro-inflammatory. When you have a situation where you have a chronic state of inflammation, it can lead to DNA breakage. Now, estrogen can be made in specific organs
- 38:17It's called paracrine production. It's made in an organ for specific use in that organ. Now, that's how men get estrogen. They have a ton of estrogen. It's just not circulating. It's made in organs like the gut and the brain and the arteries and so on for use within those organs. Now, the breasts make estrogen. Now, why would the breasts make estrogen? Because I just told you it's an immunomodulator. What if a woman gets a breast infection while she's breastfeeding? Estrogen to the rescue.
- 38:47Estrogen will create a proper inflammatory response to fight off that breast infection, that mastitis, and then calm it down so that you don't have unrelenting, out of control, inflammation in the breast. So inflammation is the trigger to upregulation of the enzyme called aromatase, the same enzyme that exists in the ovaries, but exists in these other tissues.
- 39:11And inflammation upregulates aromatase. So you get an increased conversion of androgens into estrogens, and that occurs in the breast. Now, the androgen that's being predominantly converted is DHEA and DHEAS, and that converts predominantly into esterone.
- 39:33Now, estrone is not the same estrogen that the ovaries make. It is the estrogen that binds predominantly to just one receptor, which is the alpha receptor. All breast cancer that's estrogen receptor positive is receptor positive for the alpha receptor.
- 39:50Now, what happens is you now have chronic inflammation and you have this upregulation of production in estrogen. That's why when women are older, like postmenopausal, and they have a mammogram that shows dense breasts, that's because they're inflamed in their breasts and they're making too much estrogen in their breasts.
- 40:10But they cannot control this inflammation. It's not like a breast infection like from breastfeeding. This is colonic, unrelenting. There's no end in sight. And the estrogen cannot dampen this. It cannot control it. Plus, it's the wrong form of estrogen because you don't have the same testosterone production as when you age. And you end up with more DHAs relatively. And then you have more estrone as opposed to estradiol.
- 40:35Now, there is a you know, there is some equilibrium that goes on, but it's predominantly estrone that's being produced. So you now have this situation where estrogen, which is one of its main features, is it pro growth and proliferative.
- 40:51Now that's how you heal. If you don't have enough estrogen and you have a big cut on your skin, you won't heal. That's why old people don't heal as fast because they don't have the same amount of estrogen in their skin. So we don't have the ability to control a lot of things as we age. So we end up with this chronic state of inflammation in the breast, overproduction of estrogen, and,
- 41:12Chronic inflammation leads to DNA breakage, and estrogen is pro-growth. Now, when everything is right, it's balanced. But here, what happens is if you get breakage of the DNA, you get breast cancer, you have estrogen, which is, like, sort of hijacked, and it actually starts, the genes are expressed differently. You actually change gene expression with the cancer, and it takes estrogen and turns it into a growth-promoting machine.
- 41:40So it can promote the growth of the breast cancer, which is alpha, and the estrone binds to alpha. So you have this problem. Now, so what is one of the solutions? Well, one of the solutions is to prevent the inflammation in the first place. So if you take a woman...
- 41:58and she hits perimenopause and she's going into menopause, if she goes on physiologic dosing of estradiol, the balanced estrogen, and she eats the right diet and she maintains proper thyroid and she maintains, you know, stress and sleep and all those things that are modulated to proper lifestyle choices,
- 42:16and she prevents this chronic state of inflammation that was coined as inflammation, this chronic inflammation that affects the breast, and we don't get that inflammation in the breast, then guess what? None of this will even happen. Because if you don't have inflammation, you won't have upregulation of production of estrogen in the breast.
- 42:36and you won't have the DNA breakage from the chronic inflammation in the breast. So being proactive and going on physiologic, sort of like a rhythm, some sort of a rhythm where you, and progesterone, we know when you have progesterone that comes for two weeks, it actually up regulates tumor suppressor genes.
- 42:57Nature didn't plan for breast cancer, it planned against it. So progesterone, when it's pulsed, it actually can promote tumor suppressor genes. And the estrogen of arrhythmic menstrual cycle does too. That's why I'm now involved in some research to look at trying to replicate
- 43:15a true menstrual cycle type of hormonal delivery system, but we don't have that yet. We don't have the data, but we know from medical science that when you have a real menstrual cycle, it actually helps prevent breast cancer. But we can still do better. Like I said, maybe we can't do best yet, but we can do better by giving physiologic levels of estrogen, which helps prevent inflammation.
- 43:39because estrogen prevents this in the first place when you have the right form of estrogen, of estradiol, and it's not in tiny amounts. It's in physiologic level. So you're actually getting the right amount, just like thyroid. You don't want a whiff of thyroid. You want the right amount. You want the right amount of estradiol, and then you want the right amount of progesterone, whether or not you have a uterus. I mean, that's like,
- 44:02crazy, you need progesterone as sort of like the sidekick of estradiol. And when you give this in this balanced way, you'll prevent inflammation from occurring all through the body, including in the breast tissue. Now, once you have breast cancer, it's more of a challenge because it's,
- 44:21you have hijacked genes, you have changed their expression. But if you have actually cured the person of breast cancer, as best you can tell, like they have lymph node negative, they had no reason to think there's still breast cancer in the body.
- 44:37Then, truthfully, if you give hormones in a physiologic balanced way, you will probably prevent recurrence of breast cancer. But we don't have the data. We have the hypotheticals from science and knowing how this works and how it works. But the problem is that we have such like this pervasive fear of hormones and lack of money.
- 44:59standing of estrogen and they think of estrogen as birth control pills, which is a different disruptor. It's like strawberry flavored jelly beans are equal to organic strawberries. Like that sounds so crazy, but that's what happens with estrogen. And, you know, they have the evil mimics, the evil twins that are like, people think that that's the real, the real good guy is the, but they think it's the evil twin. So we need to change the paradigm of thinking of estrogen
- 45:27and recognize that the body didn't create estrogen and progesterone to give us breast cancer. No, it actually prevents breast cancer. And it's this chronic state of inflammation that promotes DNA breakage and this upregulation of aromatase and the production of the wrong form of estrogen that can actually support breast cancer because every system becomes hijacked and gene expression is changed and so forth.
- 45:51And when you have high amounts of estrogen, it actually promotes certain genes that keep tissue integrity. So, for example, when you have low levels of estrogen, you're more likely to have cancers break apart and then become metastatic, whereas estrogen helps to maintain tissue integrity through certain gene expressions. So it's really so critical for women to understand that it's endocrine disruptors that are underlying estrogen.
- 46:18the early onset of premenopausal breast cancer and its loss of our estrogen and chronic inflammation that predisposes to postmenopausal breast cancer. And that although if you read the, you know, the fine print, it says you should never give hormones to a woman who had breast cancer.
- 46:38If a woman is fully informed, she seems to be cured of breast cancer, and she really is looking at the rest of her life living a state of estrogen deficiency and doesn't want that, then it's her right to make a decision as long as it's fully informed and consented to decide if she wants to go on hormones.
- 46:59But if someone has active metastatic breast cancer, it is possible, right, that you may actually fuel the growth of that breast cancer that's estrogen receptor positive. So that becomes more problematic, of course, in our world to give estrogen. But, of course, if a woman makes that decision fully informed, of course, that should also be her choice.
- 47:21Everyone should have the choice with full information to control their own bodies. Absolutely, informed consent, right? So wink, wink. With that, I believe the medical community always focuses on the synthetic form. So like the Women's Health Initiative study,
- 47:38was using synthetic forms of hormones and birth control is synthetic. It's a complete, like you said, it's totally different. You cannot even put bioidentical real estrogen that you would use to treat someone in the same category as birth control. It's completely different and has totally different effects on the body. It absolutely does. Like real estrogen from the ovaries
- 48:03actually is anti-blood clotting. It's anti-inflammatory. So birth control pills increase blood clots. We know that. Everyone knows that. Well, why the heck is that? Because the birth control pill goes into the body predominantly as estrone.
- 48:20And estrone, which, as I mentioned, only activates the alpha receptor. The alpha receptor is located on the innate immune cells, like the macrophages, the neutrophils, the mast cells. That's part of the essential inflammatory response. So when you only have the alpha, it's like you only have the on switch to promoting inflammation. And part of the inflammatory response is...
- 48:44is platelet aggregation or clumping of platelets and then activating them to initiate blood clots so that you don't die if you're traumatized. And also blood clotting the platelets that become activated can help to wall off an abscess. If you wonder how does the body do such a crazy, amazing thing,
- 49:05Like if you have an abscess, even intra-abdominal in your abdominal cavity, that the body can create a capsule, like a fibrous container that holds this infection in place. And that's an abscess. How does the body do it? It's through activating the platelets because the platelets not only create blood clotting, they also create blood.
- 49:24tissue. That's why people love, you know, platelets in their skin, you know, to create collagen, you know, because you're creating damage, the platelets are activated, and then you create growth of tissue. Well, you can do that to wall off an abscess, you can do that to create blood clotting, so you don't hemorrhage if you get a big laceration. But this kind of activation of the pro-inflammatory pathway is going on continuously when you have only estrone, which is what birth
- 49:53put in the female body. And even, and then by the way, when you take the conjugated equine estrogens, the brand name that was used in the Women's Health Initiative was Premarin. And that means conjugated equine estrogens. It came from a pregnant horse and it had already gone through the horse's liver for the purpose of getting it out of the body through the urine. So the horse didn't even want it. Didn't even want it. No, this is my old, and it had a whole bunch of other crap
- 50:23in with it. It wasn't even like pure anything. It was like 20 different compounds in all different amounts. It was like, that's why they could never, no one could ever like completely mimic it because it was completely like nobody even could decipher what was actually in that stuff. So you know, you couldn't get never went off patent because nobody could like actually recreate it. And it was like bizarre, all kinds of blends of stuff from the pregnant horse trying to get rid of it.
- 50:51And when you swallow the conjugated equine estrogens, it has all these weird stuff, but the main one that affects the humans that we know is estrone. It also turns into estrone. So that's why it created that increase of blood clots. And when you have increased blood clotting in an older person, that increases things like strokes and heart attacks
- 51:13and of course, pulmonary emboli. So of course we would never give that. Now, none of that happens when you have transdermal bio-identical estrogen, the good twin, because estrogen from the ovary, estrogen taken through the skin in the same form of estradiol is not pro-inflammatory. When you have adequate amounts of estrogen, it keeps what we call homeostasis. It keeps things in that calm state.
- 51:40and you only activate the inflammatory pathway when you need it activated, not for no reason at all, which happens when you have too much estrone and you have elderly people that have all kinds of other nutrient deficiencies and the whole host of things that tend to go down along with it, down this rabbit hole of aging. So the last thing that people should think is that when you have human type bio-identical estrogen,
- 52:06that it promotes inflammation, that it promotes blood clotting, that it causes high blood pressure, that it causes cancer. It does the exact opposite. It's so crazy. When you have balanced estrogen in the form of estradiol at physiologic levels, it keeps everything in this happy, calm state. But it's ready to roll if you are traumatized, if you have a pathogen like COVID trying to get into you,
- 52:33then it completely changes its shape. So it's like a shape shifter. And then it totally is different and it activates the macrophages. It activates tissue clotting. It activates the growth factors, the tissue remodeling. It does a million and one things to allow the body to successfully survive a trauma or an infectious pathogen trying to get in. And then it creates that beautiful resolution and healing.
- 53:00But it can't happen if you only have one piece of it, like only the alpha is the only receptor that's being activated. It's like all you have is the on switch and you don't have the off switch. And so you end up in this terrible state and it's so misunderstood. And really it is not complex. The mechanisms that happen intracellularly, they're complex, of course. But the basic foundational understanding that estrogen is about the whole process
- 53:28But if you only have one receptor that's being activated, you have this complete misrepresentation of what estrogen does in the body. And you end up with this completely crazy pro-inflammatory chronic state that you get from being on birth control pills, from taking Premarin, from taking oral estrogen, because it always, even if you take estradiol orally, it's converted and goes into the bloodstream as estrone. Now, estrone is not evil. It's just
- 53:56It's like, you know, the Chinese got it right. You need balance. You know, you need the yin with the yang. You know, you need both. And now we understand this. And we didn't understand any of this back in the day when the Women's Health Initiative came out. But now we do. So why are we still thinking like 20 years ago? Thinking about this. Like, let's get over it and move on, you know, and stop being stuck. Too many people get stuck with old, wrong data. You know, like I've had to change my mind constantly.
- 54:24a thousand times over about things I was taught in medical school that were blatantly wrong. We have to be able to change our thinking when we actually get new information. We can't be stuck. And estrogen is our best friend, ladies. So we want it.
- 54:42Well, this has been, I mean, your information, I'm just blown away. We are coming to the end of our time. However, I think I need to bring you back on because you are crazy popular with all of my listeners right now. Crazy popular. And you've given us such amazing information. I'm so happy that we timed it.
- 55:01With the Amazon release of your book. So please tell people a nugget that you can leave them with. And I promise we will put all of your information in the show notes for the podcast. But also tell them where they can find your book. And I'll let you say what it's called again so you can repeat it. Well, to age in a healthy way...
- 55:22or to be young and to stay healthy. We need to have it all. We can't just do one thing. It's complex. That's why the medical system doesn't want to deal with it. We need to have the right food at the right time. Sometimes we need to eat. Sometimes we need to not eat. We need to sleep, but at the right time. And we need the right kind of sleep, like
- 55:44you know, the right REM sleep and long wave sleep and slow wave sleep and so forth. So we need to have everything right. We need to have sunlight. We need to, but not to get a burn. We need to have fitness, but not to overdo our exercise. Everything has to hit the sweet spot. And it's the same with hormones. We need to have physiologic balanced hormones of every sort.
- 56:05And they work together with this beautiful complex web where like thyroid relates to estrogen, estrogen relates to progesterone and testosterone, and estrogen is very key to the function of oxytocin. I mean, there's a million things that they all interrelate. It's a complex web and we have to do it all. Is that hard?
- 56:26Yeah, but that's what it is to stay optimally healthy. And we need to understand these things. And then we need to take positive steps. That's why you can't just throw hormones at women. You can't just throw food at women. You have to do it all at every stage of life. And it's worth it to feel...
- 56:44wonderful every day when you wake up to face the world and to have your brain working well. I see brain fog like there's no tomorrow. And we don't want to be living in a world of depression and brain fog and anxiety. None of this has to happen. We just have to take all these positive steps.
- 57:02to keep our bodies optimized. And I always say, don't be afraid of the wrong things. We spend so much time worrying about the wrong things, not that we should spend our time worrying about things we can't fix, but we really should focus on the right things that are troubling our bodies and our bodies.
- 57:19you know, our basic survival and not worry about things that are not really the problem. We have the first step in solving a problem is to define the problem. And that's where, you know, I try, you know, to say, okay, let's really figure out what the problem is. And then let's come up with really optimal solutions. So don't just do one thing, do it all, even if you take baby steps.
- 57:42I love that. That was beautifully said. Beautifully said. And for my book, can I just throw that in? Yeah. Go to Amazon and it's Menopause, 50 Things You Need to Know. And it's a really small book and it's organized for the...
- 57:59The time when you're premenopause, the first decade of menopause, and then all the time thereafter. Because so many things that women experience are not understood to be hormonally related. And when you go through it and you see all the different things that can happen, and everyone experiences the transformation from reproductive years into pregnancy.
- 58:21menopause and postmenopausal years differently. So some people have more of this or that, you know, so but understanding it, once again, defining the problem, understanding the root cause of it, and how it relates to the changing hormones your body is experiencing, and then practical solutions is what the book is all about.
- 58:39I love that. I love that. I cannot wait to get my copy. And we will definitely put the link for it as well. But Dr. Gersh, I need to have you back on. So we'll definitely figure out a time for that. But I thank you so much for your time today and coming on to share your information. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. My pleasure. Okay.