Latest / Hotdish and Hot Takes / No Lettuce, No Shame
Transcript
- Kali: Welcome back to Hot Dish and Hot Takes. Today we're tackling Midwest Classic, salads that have no lettuce, no shame, and somehow always show up in a bowl the size of a small bathtub. We're talking snicker salad, cookie salad, ramen noodle salad, jello salads, and those creamy potluck creations that are technically a side dish, but emotionally a dessert. If you've ever watched someone fold Cool Whip into something and say, It's a salad, with full confidence this episode is for you. Grab your paper plate that can't hold the weight of your choices and let's get into Midwest salads. All right. So this has been a requested episode, I would say, right? Like we've had a couple people that we have brought up Snicker salads to or striped cookie salads. And it caused a little controversy and they wanted to know more. So I would say this is a requested episode. How about you? Jen: I would agree with that. I think it was funny when it was just randomly brought up and they're like, That's not a salad and we're like, That's a salad. In the Midwest, that's a salad. Kali: I feel like technically anything that you combine multiple ingredients and it put it in a bowl is a salad. I did a little research, like not that I don't have a knowledge base around our salad culture here in the Midwest, but I wanted to know more. And so one of the things that I thought was very interesting. is it brought up multiple aspects of it for me and one of the reasons we have this salad culture, I guess you would call it, the potluck culture of the Midwest. And Jen: I found that in my research as well. Yes. Kali: I didn't realize that potlucks weren't like a huge thing everywhere. And apparently that's a huge thing in the Midwest. it kind of talked about how the potluck culture came about too from like church gatherings was one of them. feeding the masses was another part of the potluck culture, along with the travel era. something that can travel well. Which then makes me also think about crock pots and like how you can get crock pots now that you like plug in inside your car so you can keep your food warm as you're going to your potlock. Right? So Jen: Yep. Kali: I've never had one of those. I don't know if you have, but I've never had one of those. Jen: I do not have a plug in one, but I do use mine all the time. Kali: See and I'm we talked about this on another episode. I'm very much an Instapot person. I will say too that anytime there's a holiday and we go to a holiday, everybody brings a dish. It's not very common to show up without something. Jen: I think that's a cultural thing. even if you got invited to a dinner, you bring a bottle of wine or something, you feel like you have to bring something as a gift or just to feel like you're contributing, even though it was an invite. Kali: Correct. Correct. Jen: And I've had to specify inviting you to dinner, don't bring anything. just come to dinner. Just come to dinner. Kali: Right. And then they they'll ask, what do you want me to bring? You don't need to bring anything. Jen: I yeah. Kali: And then they still show up with something. Jen: so the other piece to the Supper Club potluck like history I think is also important to mention the Scandinavian and German influences. So that was another thing I brought I found in the research. So Kali: Tell me more about that. Jen: I think they're big family traditions to have big dinner, things I those are two cultures from a church perspective too. So I just think it just kinda goes together, all of those pieces. Kali: Right, which we have a very high German Norwegian heritage, I feel in the Midwest, at least North Dakota does for sure. Yeah, Jen: Yeah. Wisconsin is big. Yeah, definitely. Kali: The other part of it was post war era. Did you find this in your research around the Jen: Mm-hmm. Kali: salad stuff? So packaged foods became a big thing. So jellos, instant puddings, canned fruits, cool whip, marshmallows all became a big thing in the post war era. And as you bought these products, they would come with recipe booklets on how to make stuff. And that was also part of this jello era leading into the Jell-O Mold era, which Jen: Yep. Kali: was from the 1940s to the 1970s, is when jello molds became a big thing. You and I have talked about this a little bit. We've had people ask us about this. I've never done a jello mold, I will a hundred percent say that. I think they're disgusting. When I was a kid, people would bring However, in the nineteen forties to nineteen seventies, if you had jello mold at your table, this was a status thing. it meant you like were a higher status to have a jello mold of some sort on your table when you had a gathering. Isn't that interesting? Jen: Yeah. I it is. I think the closest I've made a jello bowl or a a mold would be jello shot. Just say it. Kali: Yeah, I mean I think when I was a kid we made homemade jello like once or twice, but it's to me it's just a lot of work and yeah, I don't I don't even own a jello mold, so the round jello thing that you see on movies, I don't know if they're really that pop maybe some places they are, but where I'm from they're not. The other part of it was a seasonal access. So a lot of things have to be canned for us because of our winters. And that was another piece of like the salad piece of it is the canned aspect of it. other areas Jen: It's not just jello, if you can mix whipped cream with something. You got yourself a salad. Kali: Correct. Correct. And I have Jen: Yeah. I think generally speaking what would you say in the beginning a salad has multiple ingredients that you just combine with minimal cooking, so then you can label anything a salad. Kali: Correct. Jen: In the Midwest we just are have a broader array of salads and more flexibility. Kali: That's a very good way of saying it, 110%. Okay, so let me let me give you my breakdown because I think it's interesting. creamy sweet salads. And here's the thing: is when we're having this conversation with this other lady that we know very well, she's like, that sounds like a dessert. And these are gonna sound like desserts to people. However, for us, it goes on the salad table, it doesn't go on the dessert table out of hotlock. It comes out with the regular food. If you're sitting down at Christmas or a holiday, it doesn't come out with the desserts. And I think that I think that's a distinction that needs to be known. Jen: just picturing the table, the dessert table. Like those are just bars and cookies. Kali: But they're not just butters and cookies, they're salads. They're salads. We're very passionate about our salads. So the first one is a Snicker salad. And the ingredients typically for a Snicker salad are Snickers, Granny Smith apples, Cool Whip, and then optionally, I guess some people put pudding in the Cool Whip, like mix a pudding packet in. And some people add nuts. I've never had it that way. I've just had it with the apples, the Snickers. And the cool lip and then you top it with like snicker crumbs. Is that the way you've had it? Jen: I have not had it with nuts, but I had it for the first time I think a couple summers ago Kali: Next, and I've had that one for a long time. This is the other one we've had for a long time is striped cookie salad. Have you had the striped cookie salad? Jen: That one's new to me. I have not had the striped cookie one. Kali: Interesting. the way I always had it instant vanilla pudding in with Kool Whip. And then we always had either mandarin, oranges, or bananas in ours. and then you take the cookies and you break them up and add those in, and then you put the cookie crumble on top, similar to the Snicker. so some people do mandarin oranges, pineapple in there, and then they'll also mix in marshmallows along with the cool whip, the vanilla pudding, and the cookie strip. Yeah. I don't remember ever having marshmallows Jen: Marshmallow Girl. Kali: in mine or pineapple. But again, this goes on the salad table, not the dessert table. Dessert tables are cookies and cookies and bars. Jen: Cookies bars, yeah. Kali: And brownies, because brownies are different than bars. Jen: Yeah, boy. Is a brownie and then you got pumpkin bars? Yeah. Different. Kali: Right, you got scotcharoos or special k, whatever you call them. Yeah, I you know, I Jen: Scotcharoos, mm. Yum. Kali: grew up with special K bars and then got introduced to Scocharoos. They're also known as the peanut butter bars with chocolate on Jen: Now I'm hungry for a scatter room. Damn it. Kali: Okay, so that's our first category of salads is the creamy sweet salads. The next one is the gelatin salads. I don't have recipes or anything. These are the ones where people combine jello and fruit of some sort and mold it or put it in a cake pan or a casserole dish and chill it and they may put a dollop of cool on it and eat it. You can't see my face, but I'm like very disgusted by this. Jen: Yeah, I stay away from that. Kali: Whoa. The next one is layered salads. Have you ever had a layered salad? Jen: Yep. Seven layer, tackle layer. yeah. Kali: Yep. There's also the pea salad that's layered with like the lettuce and the peas and the bacon crumble and the other pieces of it. Okay, so there's the layer salad. The next category is the big one though. This is our mayo or vinegar salads. Jen: Like macaroni, potato. Kali: Correct. So we're looking at potato type salads, I I'm curious how you grew up with potato salads. Ours were known as German potato salad and Norwegian potato salad. Jen: I know the German and it's not my favorite. But I don't know if I know which one is the Norwegian. Kali: Where my husband grew up, it was creamy potato salad and vinegar potato salad. Jen: Hmm. Yeah. I'm just a creamy potato salad girl. Kali: Which I which is German. So the Norwegian one is the vinegar one. And I like Jen: There's a different style of German that's Kali: There's one with eggs and there's one that's without eggs, my understanding. Jen: I thought the German one was without the eggs. I could be wrong. And I don't eat that one. Kali: But is it creamy? Jen: I mean it would it looks it. Yeah. Kali: It's made with mayo. Yeah. Yeah. Jen: But I do the one with the eggs. Kali: And then the Norwegian one is a vinegar-based. There's no mayo in it. There's it's not creamy at all. Jen: So is coleslaw considered a salad? Because there's creamy and vinegar Kali: Yes, correct. So the coleslaw falls into the mayo and vinegar salads. There's also the cucumber salad. There's also Jen: Okay. yeah. Kali: broccoli salad. There's egg salad. Have you had the there's also pasta salads fall into this. my one of my favorites and my kids also like it. It's a ham salad with pasta and it's cream, it's it's mayo based. But we use can ham, but we don't use spam. I'm not kidding. Jen: spam. Kali: We use whoremel. We don't use spam. Spam was not allowed in our house. I don't know why, but it wasn't. Jen: Y spam is huge in Hawaii, on a side note. It's everywhere. Kali: Yeah, I I've never had spam, but I've had canned ham, which was hormel. The other thing my mom would do is she'd take it and she'd whoos it up and she'd add mayo and she'd add cheese, like tr cheddar cheese to it, and we'd eat it on crackers. Which would be more of a dip, not a salad, but on the whole Jen: Yeah. Does that mean you d have never been to the spam museum in Minnesota? I haven't Kali: No, no, no. Jen: either, but I drive past the billboard on my way to Rochester. Kali: Okay, there's also a three bean salad which falls under these salads. Jen: Yeah. Kali: I've never had the three bean, don't know anything about it. There's lots of different salads that we have that are pasta, potato, vinegar, mayo base salads. Let's just go with that. So the last Jen: bound together by something. Kali: bound together by something, right? Whether that's a mayo base, whether that's a vinegar base, a vinegar oil base, like there's some sort of base that like combines it all together. Correct. So the last category, again, AI gave me these categories, is the crispy salad category. Jen: Crispy? Kali: Crispy. Mm-hmm. So this would be our taco salads. This would be our ramen noodle salads. Have you ever had a ramen noodle salad? It's kind of bizarre. Jen: No. Mainly because all I can think about for ramen noodles are those square packages that are like twenty five cents. Yeah. Kali: Correct. Well, when we were kids they were like five cents or ten cents or whatever when I was in college, right? Jen: Yeah. That's what poor college kids eat. Kali: Which is twenty-five like you get four of them for a dollar and they used to be ten for a dollar. Like I'm like it's this okay, anyways, I digress. So ramen noodle salad, cabbage slaw base. And it has like sunflower seeds. Sometimes they throw peas in it. It just kind of depends on the person, but it's ca it's cabbage slaw base. It has sunflower seeds typically in it. And it's a vinegar oil dressing. And then you take the ramen noodles and you like crunch them up with a bag and you spread it over the top. You don't cook them, you spread it over the Jen: I gonna say that Kali: top. It's actually pretty good as long as you get it. Like if it's made and brought right away, but if it's been sitting, then the noodles start to get soggy and it's not good. Jen: yeah. Kali: Yeah. So a taco salad, the same thing. Like they put the Dorito chips, you mix it in. If you eat it right away it's good, but if it's sat for a while to me it's kinda gross. so the crispy correct. Jen: Well it's kinda like taco pizza. It's not good the next day. Yeah. Kali: Correct. Yeah, 'cause they get soggy. I'm curious, Jen, what salad categories do you make? Jen: Well w where did so did you did you just constitute fruit salad as the first category and then part of the jello? Kali: mean go for it. Jen: 'cause my best friend's mom makes a really great, fruit salad. And I have no idea how she makes it. I just enjoy it. Kali: Are you talking where you like just they just combine all the fruit together? Jen: No, it's it's probably either mixed with whipped cream or I don't know that there's pudding in it. I know there's whipped cream. Kali: There's some that do cream cheese and whipped cream together or cream cheese and like powdered sugar to thin it and then they mix that with like fruit and stuff and then add cool whip in. Jen: Yeah. Kali: But what kind of fruit's in it? Jen: Probably what you find in like canned fruit cocktail. Kali: my god, Tyler was telling me about this and I was like, I've never had that. Fruit cocktail. Jen: Yeah. No? Yeah. That was like huge when I was growing up. Fruit cocktail. Yeah. Kali: I would put that under the creamy sweet salads. Jen: Okay. Kali: Because it has that fruit element and that creamy element. So I would put that under the creamy. The ones that are supposed to be where other would others would classify it as a dessert, where we classify it as a salad. Jen: I can't say I make a lot of salads. I let the grocery store do that for me if I need it for a potluck. or a family dinner type of thing. I don't really enjoy cooking that much that I would want to spend the time to do that. Or I get those mixed salad bags and call it good. The everything comes in a bag and I just put it in a bowl. Kali: See, and I run into the problem of I can't eat anything at the grocery store for salads I have a severe shellfish allergy and a lot of that stuff is all cross-contaminated. So I'd die. No, we don't need Jen: for sure. We don't need that. Yeah, that would be ridiculous. Kali: But yes, and I I just I grew up where my mom made everything, so a lot of things just don't taste right to me when they're store-bought all the time. I guess fruit salad, that's another big one where people just like whatever fruits and season are good and ripe, they just throw it all in a bowl. They like cut it up and throw it all in a bowl and you have that. Jen: Yeah, I was just gonna say that people would call that a fruit salad too. No Kali: Right. Jen: nothing binding it together. It's just fruit. Kali: And then typically it's served with some sort of dip, like a cream cheese based Jen: Yeah, like Kali: dip of some sort, which normally has jello mixed Jen: Yeah. Kali: in it. Jen: Strawberry cream cheese. Kali: Uh-huh. So you do this you do the cream cheese and you do the cool whip and you do strawberry jello packets. It's very good with strawberries and other fruit. Jen: Really honestly sounds amazing. Kali: None of our stuff I would say is necessarily healthy. Yeah. Jen: Well that's an interesting way to l yeah. To c to go back to you would think salad is healthy, but any of the midwestern salads probably are not. Yeah. Kali: I mean, even the like pasta salads typically have some sort of meat in them, pepperonis, bacon, canned meat of some sort. there's always something in them, But I I will say like I have I have salads that I make that are just like from my head that I've like thrown shit together and it's turned out really good. But they're typically a creamy base Jen: Yeah. But I I think the interesting historical piece to this salad is just what what it does, it brings people together, Kali: Yes. Jen: Got that community or family, component or church, supper, what have you. But yeah. Kali: Correct. I think we eat a lot more salads in spring summer than we do fall and winter, during the fall winter, I'm gonna bring more of potatoes or something else versus a salad. I incorporate salads with grilling or outside activities. Yeah, Jen: Hookouts. Yeah. Kali: I mean unless it's a huge family gathering. Then I may bring a salad, but for the most part, a lot of times I incorporate that with like spring summer time. Jen: I think that's an easy thing to do with cookouts and then you don't have a whole table full of chips. Everyone brings chips. Kali: we've actually had it with bigger family gatherings where we've had to designate people. you bring salads, you bring chips, you bring the the potato, We're all bringing a meat or combining to pay for the meat, but otherwise we've had it where people show up and everybody brings a salad and there's no dessert or there's no chips or whatever it is. So we've actually with extended family stuff, actually had to designate things. I don't know. Jen: I do that when I host Thanksgiving, so every every family member that comes has a part of the meal. I'm like, everybody can participate in cooking Thanksgiving. You bring this, you bring this. Kali: Absolutely. Well, I think that wraps Jen: Awesome. Kali: up our salads. I would love to know below what kind of salads you grew up with, where you're from, and kind of what's the popular take on salads in your area until next time, stay curious.