Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 286:6-12. Mezuzah: Gazebo, 2nd Floor Landing, Garden, Passageway That Opens To Home and Yard, Beis Medrash, Succah, Houseboat, Seller Stands; Inner/Outer Artisan Booth

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 286:6-12. Mezuzah: Gazebo, 2nd Floor Landing, Garden, Passageway That Opens To Home and Yard, Beis Medrash, Succah, Houseboat, Seller Stands; Inner/Outer Artisan Booth · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  We're at Simon rage PE vav sif vav asadra.
• 0:05
  What is an asadra? The Who?
• 0:07
  The nasadra is hamakam sheshla sheshaksalem, a room or area
• 0:14
  that has three walls. Viticra and it has a roof now
• 0:20
  FLP Sheshla Shnepat seamen, the Rue Afrivis even though on the
• 0:25
  fourth side it has 2 posts. Petura now you would think that
• 0:30
  it should be high, right? Why?
• 0:32
  Because in order to be high in Mississippi, you need 2 posts
• 0:35
  and a lentil. So over here you have two posts
• 0:38
  on the fourth side and you have a roof.
• 0:41
  So you would think that that would be enough to be Mikhayev.
• 0:44
  No, it's Potter. Doesn't make a difference how
• 0:47
  wide it is. Well, however wide it is, I'm
• 0:51
  saying that's that that's the entrance to to that area.
• 0:55
  Let's say it's a airport hangar, right?
• 0:57
  So, so even if it's 35 feet wide, but you have two posts,
• 1:02
  you have you have a ceiling. So why would it not be Khayev?
• 1:05
  So he explains the reason why it's part there is that nation
• 1:08
  had pet semen. Lahamad had tikra.
• 1:10
  He Masuya. So this is a a general klow in
• 1:14
  Hilfis Mezuza, which you have to remember, which is known as
• 1:18
  Akzuke Tikra. Zuke Tikra means that a doorway
• 1:21
  is Hayev, as you were saying, when it's a doorway right now,
• 1:24
  this is a doorway. Even this is a doorway, right?
• 1:27
  But sometimes the the posts are not there for the purpose of the
• 1:33
  doorway. Rather the posts are there
• 1:36
  simply to hold up the ceiling. You notice this is not holding
• 1:39
  up the ceiling and this is not holding up the ceiling.
• 1:42
  So when it's not holding up the ceiling, that's the doorway.
• 1:45
  But when the posts, the sole purpose of the posts is that the
• 1:49
  ceiling shouldn't collapse. So then that's not called the
• 1:52
  doorway. So in this Aksadra, which is is
• 1:55
  3 walls and then the fourth side is open.
• 1:57
  So by ETSM it's not a doorway. I there are posts there.
• 2:02
  Yeah, the posts are there 'cause on the fourth side you have to
• 2:04
  hold up the ceiling. But if not for that, you
• 2:07
  wouldn't need the post. So that's why it would be put
• 2:09
  there. Aval, he says, qualifies it in
• 2:12
  yezhla mehitza gambhiroue Revius.
• 2:14
  What if on the fourth side you have a wall?
• 2:18
  Afal P Shahina mukha, it's a waist high wall.
• 2:21
  Ay shasuya kalainis kalainis hiatus.
• 2:24
  So the Maharshim explain that what this means is you have I
• 2:27
  mean, when I was growing up and you went to camp.
• 2:30
  So in camp they have what's called gazebos, right?
• 2:32
  So gazebos is really exactly what he's talking about.
• 2:36
  He's talking about there's different types of Assadres that
• 2:39
  the humor talks about. But the idea over here is that
• 2:42
  when you have what's known again in America at least as a gazebo,
• 2:45
  which is an outdoor structure that they have in camp where you
• 2:48
  have walls that are, you know, about waist high or a little bit
• 2:52
  higher than that. And it's open.
• 2:54
  And then there are posts going up to the ceiling and there's A
• 2:58
  and there's an entranceway into it.
• 3:00
  So sometimes he's talking about a case.
• 3:02
  Now when he says kalaenis Kalaenis, what that means is
• 3:05
  that there are multiple posts and you can enter through
• 3:08
  different areas. So that would be chaif because
• 3:12
  that's a proper area. And and although the posts are
• 3:15
  holding up the ceiling, but that is a proper area with the proper
• 3:19
  entranceway. When you're going to be putter
• 3:22
  is when there's no proper entranceway.
• 3:24
  It's just, it's just open like Pasuach.
• 3:28
  That's, that's the difference that that he's making.
• 3:31
  And Mfarshim explained that when we're talking about Halaenus,
• 3:33
  Halaenus, it could be even on all four sides.
• 3:36
  And there's a lot of times on all four sides you have Halaenus
• 3:39
  Halaenus. It doesn't mean windows.
• 3:41
  It means it means like entrances.
• 3:44
  Notice you have like pillars going all around with, with
• 3:48
  entrances from all, all different sides.
• 3:50
  So even though you might say well it's not, it's not 4 walls,
• 3:53
  but it is because not that it is for walls, but the point is that
• 3:59
  what you have here are entrance ways rather than just parrots.
• 4:05
  That's the idea. You have this in Arabian as
• 4:07
  well. There's a difference between a
• 4:08
  pierza and a pesa. So when the 4th side is just
• 4:11
  totally open, and I think this might have been what you meant,
• 4:15
  that's known as a pierza. Whereas over here it's gonna be
• 4:19
  a Pesach Zain meerpesses Shahid Derekh Lalisba alias.
• 4:26
  So when he's talking about Meerpesset, he's not talking
• 4:29
  about Meerpesset that we're talking about.
• 4:32
  OK, So we have to erase from our minds what we know as a
• 4:36
  Meerpesset and put ourselves into the Mechabras language.
• 4:40
  So when the Mechabras talking about Meerpesset, what he's
• 4:43
  talking about is the following. If you've been to Meer Shahram,
• 4:49
  so you know by but they ungaran and many of the other, but they
• 4:54
  whatever, but they Massa but they Brady all these 100 and
• 4:57
  some odd year old developments. So the way it works is that you
• 5:02
  have an outdoor staircase and the outdoor staircase.
• 5:07
  You have this in motels in America.
• 5:08
  The outdoor staircase takes you up to the second floor.
• 5:11
  There's a landing along the 2nd floor and then there are homes,
• 5:15
  right? There are apartments or, or
• 5:17
  hotel rooms, right? So it's like an outdoor motel.
• 5:20
  So that's what's called a Meerpesseth.
• 5:22
  Meerpesseth in halafic terms over here is talking about that
• 5:26
  Shahid Derekh Lalespa alias. Now it could be going up.
• 5:30
  It's the whole structure. I mean, I guess it's the
• 5:32
  landing, but it's Shahid Derekh Lalespa alias.
• 5:37
  It's the way to get up to the to the landing and when you get to
• 5:41
  the landing. So you could have storage rooms
• 5:45
  there or a roof or whatever it may be, or you could have
• 5:48
  apartments over here. He's talking where there are not
• 5:50
  apartments there. OK, so it just gets you up to
• 5:54
  the alias, to the to the attics, Ubaishar.
• 5:59
  Ubaishar is a passageway. Now when we talk about a
• 6:04
  passageway, we're thinking about a passageway to a home.
• 6:08
  But in this first part of the Mahabir over, he's talking about
• 6:11
  when the passageway is not to a home.
• 6:13
  It's just the some alternate area, the Hagina or when you
• 6:17
  have a Gina. OK, so Agena, I don't know that
• 6:20
  it's quite like when we talk about Agena today, we're talking
• 6:24
  about a backyard. When he's talking about Agena, I
• 6:26
  don't think he's talking about a backyard.
• 6:28
  He's talking about a, a public area with flowers.
• 6:32
  Agena, right? Like like in India, they have
• 6:34
  these beautiful gardens, the Rose gardens, whatever it may
• 6:37
  be, right? So that's he's talking about a a
• 6:40
  garden. So Peturum.
• 6:41
  So Peturum, all these areas are put there again.
• 6:44
  Why? Because these are not Mackay
• 6:47
  mice of Dira, not places where people are living.
• 6:50
  However, now he flips it on his head the imbiased pursuit.
• 6:54
  But if this mere peset right, it's it's by but the it's by
• 6:59
  Batayungarin. So it is going up to apartments,
• 7:03
  right, or a Bashar is a passageway in modern terms, it's
• 7:08
  any apartment building here in remote Bay Chemish, right.
• 7:11
  When you walk into the front door of the building, you're
• 7:13
  entering a base share to your D Ray.
• 7:15
  You're not in your apartment. Your apartment's on the 4th
• 7:17
  floor. So how are you getting to your
• 7:19
  apartment? You're entering the front door
• 7:20
  of the building that's a passageway to your apartment.
• 7:23
  You then enter the doorway to the staircase that's a
• 7:26
  passageway to your apartment. You then exit on the 3rd floor
• 7:30
  the doorway from the staircase. All these are, but they share to
• 7:34
  your apartments a passageway to your apartment.
• 7:36
  So they share that leads to an apartment, the Hagina, or if you
• 7:41
  have a garden that leads to like a front garden, right?
• 7:43
  In America, for sure, many people have a garden in front of
• 7:46
  their home. So if these places, the Imbias
• 7:49
  pursue Akhad, Mehalu, Kayavan, so then all these places which a
• 7:53
  moment ago were putter because they were not a Mokamdira, over
• 7:57
  here they become Hyatt even though they're still not a
• 8:00
  Mokamdira, but they lead to a Mokamdira.
• 8:02
  And when you are a doorway through which people traverse in
• 8:07
  order to get to their apartment, so you are 5.
• 8:11
  Why? Because you the doorway are
• 8:13
  considered to be an extension of the home.
• 8:17
  The Asia I remember should be shark.
• 8:19
  I have a fellow aimed by a specifically and some want to
• 8:21
  say that a bayshire would be 5 even if there's no house in
• 8:27
  front of it. Let's see to Zion in the in the
• 8:30
  shark, the Yeh Sharman should be Shah, Sarahi and the Ayesha Aylo
• 8:35
  Gambi Murpasat, the Gina Mahayaavan, right?
• 8:38
  So this that he's saying it's very strange that the Mahabir is
• 8:42
  saying that the Yeh Sharman should be Shah.
• 8:44
  I have a feel aimed by his pursuer Floyd.
• 8:46
  Why only obey Shah, the Gina and the Murpasat also this it's the
• 8:50
  same cheetah. OK, it's Akasha on the Mahabir.
• 8:53
  But Lamaisa, we passed in that regarding this Halafa that if
• 9:01
  there's no Malcolm deer, these places are putter OK, However,
• 9:07
  any like I like I said, any doorway through which one needs
• 9:13
  to pass to get to his apartment is called a Bashar and that is
• 9:18
  going to be Hayek OK. We we saw last time that even a
• 9:25
  a share of a city is high of right.
• 9:28
  So I think the rush explains that that's also for the same
• 9:30
  reason because I live in Philadelphia.
• 9:33
  So I'm coming to Philadelphia and I pass through the shower
• 9:36
  her ear. So that's a passageway to get to
• 9:38
  my home. So that's I'm high of Mission
• 9:40
  Bay shark. That's knows there's no din that
• 9:43
  a city is high of the rush is saying, you know why it's high
• 9:46
  of all the members, all the residents of the city are high
• 9:48
  of because they pass through this Bay shark to get to their
• 9:52
  homes. That's assuming that there's a
• 9:54
  wall around this. Yeah.
• 9:56
  Oh, no. So that no, no laugh.
• 9:58
  So that's a very good question, very good question.
• 10:03
  What if you have an arch that it's just the middle of nowhere
• 10:07
  and I was there's no wall surrounding the city.
• 10:09
  And that was when you had like these ancient cities and you had
• 10:12
  like a Moat and then you had a, a, a wall and a like a new, like
• 10:17
  you have a new usual lion, right?
• 10:19
  So is it talking Dafka about that?
• 10:21
  What if you have a city that's open and just for you know,
• 10:25
  whatever they put up an arch at the entrance of the city, you
• 10:30
  know, so to bring in tourists. So would that also be fired?
• 10:34
  Is that called an entrance to the city?
• 10:36
  I'm not sure you actually stop it because Oh, very good.
• 10:39
  So what about a roof? So the Russia asks that
• 10:41
  question. What about a roof?
• 10:42
  So the Russia asks it not only about the the entrance to a
• 10:45
  city, but the Russia asks about a backyard, right nose or or a
• 10:49
  front yard. Let's say you have you have a
• 10:52
  gate. You have a gate in front of your
• 10:54
  home, right? And and the gate, let's say,
• 10:58
  does have a wall, you know, in surrounding the property.
• 11:03
  But when you're entering through the gate into your front yard,
• 11:06
  there's no ceiling. So I actually put there.
• 11:09
  So the rush says that when the function of the area is either
• 11:15
  just as good or dafka without a roof.
• 11:19
  So then a roof is not a requirement.
• 11:21
  In other words, what the rush is saying is as follows.
• 11:23
  If I have a bedroom and I don't have a roof, so I don't have
• 11:27
  much of the bedroom, so that's going to be putter.
• 11:30
  But if I have a front yard and I don't have the roof, that's
• 11:32
  great. I don't want if somebody would,
• 11:34
  my neighbor would build on top of my front yard, I'd be very
• 11:37
  upset because I'd rather have my front yard without the roof.
• 11:39
  So the rush says in that case, there's no need for a roof.
• 11:43
  You need to, yes, you definitely need 2 measures and a lentil
• 11:46
  notice. If you have a gate to your
• 11:47
  garden and you have two posts but you have no lentil on top,
• 11:50
  that's putter, correct. Peshar has peshar shepasuak
• 11:54
  labias ulokatzer, which is what we just said is Hayef bishte
• 11:57
  mezuzah. Oh, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm
• 11:58
  sorry, I'm sorry. Peshar shepasuak labias
• 12:02
  ulokatzer. Hayev Bishte mezuzais akhas
• 12:05
  bemokhim shepasuak labias. The akhas, the akhas bemokhim
• 12:10
  shepa. So this Aloha, there are 6
• 12:13
  different shot them in the Rishrainum and Afrinum of how to
• 12:17
  read these 15 words or so in the Mahabir.
• 12:21
  So we're going to do one. OK, We're going to do a Major
• 12:24
  Feinstein's chat. Major Feinstein says that this
• 12:27
  is what it's talking about. You have I don't know, I hope
• 12:30
  you could see you have this is the street.
• 12:32
  OK, so you have your home and you have a hot Sir.
• 12:37
  So what you're doing is you're coming in through the Bay Shire
• 12:41
  and you have your home on one side and you have the futzer on
• 12:44
  the other side. So you're going to need the
• 12:46
  Mfarshim, say 3 mezuzahs, right? The Mchaber is only talking
• 12:50
  about two mezuzahs, 1 going to the house and 1 going to the
• 12:52
  FATSA. Or maybe let me see whether the
• 12:56
  Shire ship or Zoe, the base with Habush, the mezuzah out of
• 12:58
  mocking ship of Suefla base. Yeah, so these two.
• 13:02
  But the Mfarshim say you need a third mezuzah at the entrance to
• 13:04
  the Bay Shire as well. OK, so that's the way Remeisa
• 13:09
  Feinstein understands this case. Sheba Talevi agrees with Remeisa
• 13:13
  Feinstein about everything except for one point.
• 13:16
  And this is referring to what you were talking about, which
• 13:19
  we're going to come back to if we get to it a little bit later.
• 13:21
  And the Sheba Talevi holds that the mezuzah from the hutzer
• 13:24
  needs to be going in the opposite direction towards the
• 13:27
  home. In other words, you don't need a
• 13:28
  mezuza on the right side as you enter the hutzer.
• 13:31
  You need a Mezuza on the right side as you exit the hutzer.
• 13:34
  OK, that's the only difference between Sheva Tilevia and
• 13:37
  Rameshi Feinstein. But they both agree that this is
• 13:40
  the case that the Mahaba is talking about.
• 13:42
  But as I say, there are 6 different shots in and how to
• 13:46
  learn this Mahaba. This is one of those shots in a
• 13:51
  lot of tests. Base share Ahmed bin Hagina
• 13:55
  Labay saying this is the same case which is substituting A
• 13:58
  Khatzer for a Gina. Again, there are be shining that
• 14:02
  learn this case differently as well, but this could be a sheer,
• 14:07
  you know, of five or six hours. Ben Hagina labias, Kayed Bishti
• 14:12
  mezuzahs, akhas Malcolm ship Asurf labias, the Malkm ship
• 14:16
  Asuah Lagina. And again, remember, Feinstein
• 14:18
  is understanding in these cases that the that the hutzer or the
• 14:22
  ghina is high of me kayak the home.
• 14:25
  In other words, because since when my kids want to go out and
• 14:28
  play on their tricycles, they're going to ride around in the
• 14:31
  hutzer or in the Ghina, right, or the Ghina is the place where
• 14:36
  where I sit and I read my morning paper right.
• 14:39
  So that's considered an addendum to the home, right?
• 14:43
  It's an extension of the home. And therefore according to our
• 14:45
  Malaysia, those areas are going to be high.
• 14:48
  We'll see this more clearly soon.
• 14:51
  You'd basa madrish. Now you'll recall that we said
• 14:55
  previously that there are two cases.
• 14:57
  There's a basic Nessus and there's a basic Madrish.
• 15:00
  Basic Nessus, we said, is a synagogue, right?
• 15:03
  A sanctuary of a synagogue where the only thing you do there is
• 15:06
  pray. A base madrish is a base Madrish
• 15:09
  where people diving and learn. So base measure says that, yes,
• 15:14
  it doesn't have to be. You don't have to dive in there.
• 15:18
  I'm just saying nowadays, you know, we always dive in the base
• 15:20
  measure. There's no such thing as a base
• 15:21
  measure where they don't dive in, except in the young Israel's
• 15:24
  maybe. But I think even in the young
• 15:25
  Israel's where they have a shul and a base measure, I think they
• 15:29
  usually have like the Hashrama minion in the base measure.
• 15:33
  But be that as it may, says the macabre base measure is also
• 15:36
  part there. Why?
• 15:37
  Same reason because nobody lives there.
• 15:39
  Vimeage by Pesa. Actually Rogalozzi is by
• 15:42
  Labeisai Kayev Vimeza, but I say pesos.
• 15:45
  Now this is very common in Flatbush where I grew up.
• 15:49
  You have many many many Shoals. Not not like one or two like
• 15:54
  many that the rough lives upstairs now as they buy a two
• 15:58
  family home and the first floor is the shul and the second floor
• 16:03
  is the rubs home. So you have in the shul a door
• 16:07
  where the Ruff could just go up to his house.
• 16:09
  There's a staircase and the Ruff could just go up to his house.
• 16:12
  That's what he's saying over here.
• 16:14
  The in Yesh by Pesach Shiroga let's us play the base site,
• 16:17
  right. There's like a little door
• 16:19
  behind the rub seat where he can just sneak upstairs to his
• 16:22
  house. I have a mezuza, but I say
• 16:24
  Pesach, so that doorway needs a mezuza because that's not a
• 16:28
  mezuza to the base madrich. That's a that's not a door to
• 16:31
  the base madrich, that's a door to his house.
• 16:34
  The a Shamir and others argue on the whole idea that a that a
• 16:39
  base madrich is published from a mezuzah, and they say should
• 16:42
  base madrich Hayat the mezuzah, the nothing loafers with the
• 16:46
  frame. And the Mahabir says it's good.
• 16:48
  Not that this is the alafa tsuka, but he says it's good to
• 16:51
  be fascist for that cheetah. I have a layover, but you
• 16:54
  shouldn't make a brothen. And why would the other sheeta
• 16:58
  argue and say that a base manager is Tayef I It's
• 17:01
  indisputable. Nobody lives there.
• 17:03
  So if nobody lives there, why would it be Fayef?
• 17:05
  So the chef explains in your tests the reason is the filled
• 17:09
  domila base acnesis because it's not like a synagogue sanctuary.
• 17:13
  Elsa Gimmel the LMK engage by base Dira, the Basa Madrish
• 17:19
  Kevin chattel mediation, but may have biker Arif Dimela Dira
• 17:25
  right base medrish where they tell me them are sitting there a
• 17:28
  whole day and he doesn't say this, but some people add right
• 17:31
  and they munch on their chocolate bars and they drink
• 17:34
  their coffee right and their base medrish.
• 17:35
  They feel very Hamish in their base medrish.
• 17:38
  So the shock says so Mammala, not that it is Edira, but it's
• 17:42
  Daimil Edira. There's a fascinating Tazz over
• 17:45
  here and Sif cotton Tess where he says as follows, but tour
• 17:49
  Kosov Bahenasa Harami Rutenberg. It's brought down that the
• 17:53
  Mirami Rutenberg did not initially have a mezuzah.
• 17:58
  He had a base madrish in the, in the in his house.
• 18:01
  That's what sounds like over there that he also like he lived
• 18:04
  upstairs and downstairs. He had a yeshiva, right?
• 18:07
  So initially he did not have a mezuzah by the base Madrish, but
• 18:12
  also Harami Rotenberg, Mrs. Ill base measures He he he put him
• 18:16
  as their wife Omar Kisha Yoshin. But she necessarily used to take
• 18:20
  a nap in the base measures in the afternoon, paid them
• 18:27
  shatikin by mezuzah, the Mirami Rotenberg.
• 18:29
  He had his yeshiva and Ben Astaram.
• 18:32
  So I guess the buckram would go back to the dorm and he would
• 18:35
  take a nap in the base Madrid. And there was this Ruf raw that
• 18:39
  would harass him when he was taking his afternoon nap in the
• 18:43
  base Madrid, I guess while he was learning.
• 18:45
  So the Ruf raw was scared to come into the base Madrid.
• 18:48
  But lunchtime when things quieted down and he was taking
• 18:51
  his nap, this Ruf raw would harass him.
• 18:53
  And he was sick and tired of this Ruf raw harassing him, so
• 18:56
  he put up the mezuzah and that was the end of the rough Rd.
• 18:59
  disappeared. Not often you see something like
• 19:01
  that brought in the halachic context, says the shaft in
• 19:05
  Sifkat and Huff. Don't make a bracha on it.
• 19:08
  If you put up a mezuzah initial, sometimes you'll see they honor
• 19:11
  like the rub of the city or something like that to put up a
• 19:14
  mezuzah on the new base. Madrid, right?
• 19:16
  So he shouldn't make a bracha. But they had the cameras
• 19:19
  rolling. He shouldn't make a bracha.
• 19:22
  Why? Says the Bach Casa right, right.
• 19:26
  Like a bar mitzvah yeah, because of the.
• 19:29
  She covered the so this is a cloud in Hilders mezuzah in
• 19:37
  general is that very, very, very, very, very, very often
• 19:41
  somebody who learns Hilders mezuzah will find an
• 19:44
  overwhelming number of times that the police can will say,
• 19:47
  well, it's a Suffolk, so put up a mezuzah if we don't make a
• 19:50
  brotha. So the bath is just pointing out
• 19:52
  that anytime you have such a scenario, so often, not always,
• 19:57
  but often you're going to be putting up multiple mezuzahs and
• 20:00
  it's only a couple of them that are going to have these shyla's,
• 20:03
  right? Let's say a person moves into a
• 20:05
  new house, so he's going to be putting up 27 mezuzahs right
• 20:09
  now. If those 27 mezuzahs, only 18
• 20:11
  require a brotha. Right.
• 20:13
  And nine don't require a brothis it says the Bach in these cases
• 20:16
  you just make one brotha and then when you put up all the
• 20:20
  rest, so you be Mcaven to pat there this place with the
• 20:25
  original brotha. So let's say you have only
• 20:27
  putting up two mezuzahs and 1 is in a place that needs a mezuzah
• 20:31
  and the other one is in a place that's a Suffolk where maybe
• 20:34
  with the pace can say not to make a brotha.
• 20:36
  So make a broth on the place, that's for sure, Kayev.
• 20:39
  And that way you solved all your problems.
• 20:44
  You're the aleph sukkah sahag bahag.
• 20:48
  If you have a Sukkah of the Yontiff of Sukkis and it is
• 20:55
  Sukkis and as some people they leave the sukka up the whole
• 20:59
  year, right? Especially if you have a a sukka
• 21:03
  that's made from real walls, right?
• 21:05
  In other words, most people have a sukka that's these wooden
• 21:10
  walls and it just goes up on Sukkis.
• 21:12
  Other people have a structure that's up the whole year.
• 21:15
  So he's talking about a sukka that went up.
• 21:18
  It's an 8 day suka or a seven day sukka or the habaya
• 21:23
  shabisvina. If somebody has a houseboat or a
• 21:27
  house on a boat, there are place can that make that deal The
• 21:31
  hafenuye shabiswakim or stores in the shook peturium.
• 21:36
  All these places are Potter. Now what's the common theme
• 21:41
  between these three things? So there's a hag by hag abaya
• 21:44
  shabisvina and hanui shabiswakim.
• 21:48
  So the Shah says in khaf aleph turim 4 words migne shahim diras
• 21:54
  arai, because all these places are not permanent structures.
• 21:59
  These are all these are all flimsy and temporary structures.
• 22:04
  Now the pay scheme actually I said the word flimsy and
• 22:07
  temporary pay scheme debate, which is the reason?
• 22:10
  Is it because it's flimsy or is it because it's temporary and
• 22:14
  this is a Shiloh in the pay scheme?
• 22:16
  OK, so, and it's especially relative to Kanuya Shebishwakam
• 22:21
  because we have America's Mystery over here that has
• 22:23
  stores and that's Kanuya Shebishwakam and they're not
• 22:26
  flimsy at all. They've been there for 25 years
• 22:29
  and they'll probably be there Baisersham for the next couple
• 22:32
  of 100 years. What's flimsy about them?
• 22:34
  So in such an instance you would say either that it's Kayev or
• 22:41
  you would say that no, you're you're inhabitants of that place
• 22:47
  is not permanent. Why not?
• 22:49
  We'll see in the Taz in a second.
• 22:51
  But others understand that Keanu, you should be shocking
• 22:53
  doesn't mean stores in our Mercasmus Kari.
• 22:56
  Keanu, you should be shocking is talking about the Yurid, right?
• 23:00
  Everybody's heard stories about the Yurid in in Lumsha and
• 23:05
  Leipzig, Leipzig. There you go, right, That then
• 23:07
  Leipzig, they had the Yurid and everybody would come to the
• 23:09
  Yuridan Leipzig. So what happened was like the
• 23:11
  world's fear. So what happened at the Yuridan
• 23:13
  Leipzig, Everybody would come and pitch their store, their
• 23:17
  stand, their Dukan, right, And they would be there for a week
• 23:21
  or two, however long the pair went on and then they would fold
• 23:23
  it up and it was gone. So that's why Kanuya
• 23:26
  Shebishvakim is put to him because the dearest Arab, it's a
• 23:29
  it's a pop up store. So those are the tube shopping.
• 23:33
  The Tazz over here says Kanuya Shebishvakim Pater the laughed
• 23:37
  dearest SU, because that's not a dearest the nearly.
• 23:40
  Now the Tazz says a very important thing.
• 23:42
  I feel emulation with him. Behold, young where you sit in
• 23:45
  your store every day, right? You have people sitting in the
• 23:48
  store every single day. Two of them still parked there.
• 23:51
  Why The Cave in the Anam Shambhalaya Mikri array?
• 23:55
  Because they're the stores open from 9:00 to 5:00 or 9:00 to
• 23:58
  7:00 or 11:00 to 7:00 if you're an Israeli, right?
• 24:01
  So whatever it is, the store is open at those times, but it's
• 24:05
  closed at night. We appreciate.
• 24:08
  Yeah. OK.
• 24:09
  The dummy LA base at Tavern, the TAZ says it's not similar to a
• 24:12
  storage house or a eitzer, right.
• 24:14
  A warehouse where we said that it would be Fayev, the Sham
• 24:17
  Tashmash and Felix Benja. I'm Lila, right?
• 24:21
  If I'm keeping 10,000 air conditioners in a warehouse.
• 24:24
  So the warehouse is functioning by day and night in the same
• 24:27
  manner, whereas the store says the TAZ, the store only
• 24:31
  functions when when it's open. But when it's closed, it's not
• 24:36
  functioning like anything. So there are those that want to
• 24:38
  argue. So at night it's like a
• 24:40
  storehouse, right? But others say no, a storehouse
• 24:43
  is only when it was made to be a storehouse.
• 24:45
  A store was not made to be a storehouse.
• 24:48
  A store is made to be a store. In order for the store to
• 24:50
  function, I have to store stuff in the store.
• 24:54
  But the function is not to be a a mahsan, the function is to be
• 24:59
  a hanus. So that's so we go after the
• 25:01
  Icker function Stace, we'll see one more halacha.
• 25:06
  We are not good. Gimmel is going to be the one
• 25:08
  that I kept on saying maybe we'll get to.
• 25:10
  We're not going to get to it, but we could see it based.
• 25:12
  We're not a houseboat. So a houseboat is also a Shia
• 25:16
  and a pie skin because there's two different opinions.
• 25:20
  Some say that a houseboat or a yacht or whatever is not what
• 25:24
  the Mahaber was talking about. If the Mahaber would see today's
• 25:28
  yachts. So of course he would say it's
• 25:30
  higher. That's you could live there your
• 25:32
  whole life there and some people do right.
• 25:34
  So if rather it would be five others argue and they say no,
• 25:38
  doesn't make a difference. It could be a $26 million yacht,
• 25:42
  it's still going to be putter. Why?
• 25:44
  Because it's very essence, the fact that it's in the water and
• 25:48
  it's Nova Nod and it's not Kavua.
• 25:51
  So that makes it putter. And the same as like this
• 25:53
  applies to an RV, right? You have people that that they
• 25:58
  have an RV, which is a motorhome, right?
• 26:00
  It's a house on wheels and they'll drive across the cross
• 26:03
  country trip on their RV. So some say it's Hyatt, it's a
• 26:07
  regular house. Well, what's the problem?
• 26:09
  You have everything you need there, including a bathroom and
• 26:11
  a shower, whatever you want. So if I did Sky, others say no.
• 26:15
  The very fact that it's not permanent and it moves around,
• 26:19
  that makes it hotter. So that's how much like this
• 26:22
  about a yacht, a houseboat and an RV much to see your bays.
• 26:27
  We could still squeeze an inch. They suck a show.
• 26:28
  Yeats from Zuluf Nimizu Hapnim is Hayevis that he'd sign up to.
• 26:32
  If you have two sukkis of Craftsman, one inside the other,
• 26:38
  so the inner one is Hayev and the outer one is Parker, why
• 26:41
  would the inner 1 be Hayev? So the Shah says because Kafayeh
• 26:46
  derafayehs from BMA I'm Shahayeh Lam stays suka Zuluf Nimizu but
• 26:50
  neem is Hayadar. They lived in the inner 1
• 26:54
  Umatsniak de Reisov hilka hayaba subhit saena haya aisa malachta.
• 26:59
  You might see the Reisov limkar. So in other words, they had an
• 27:02
  inner suka that they lived in and an outer suka that they did
• 27:06
  business in. So the outer suka that they did
• 27:08
  business in would be putter because it's not a permanent
• 27:11
  muckin which just like a an outdoor stand, but the inner
• 27:15
  area, which is where the family was.
• 27:17
  So that would be high if that's the Mahabra.
• 27:21
  Hello recipient base. Oh, very good.
• 27:25
  So why is it like a Bashar? So that's why I eared it in very
• 27:29
  subtly. I made it very subtly that it's
• 27:33
  that it's flimsy but ain't nothing Nami.
• 27:37
  If it would be like a permanent type of structure, so then
• 27:41
  perhaps it would be 5. Also, they shot.