Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Brad Edwards And His Affidavit In Support Of Epstein Related Transparency By The DOJ (Part 5)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're picking up where we
- 0:06left off with Brad Edwards and the CVRA. Affidavid the
- 0:11government's fiduciary duty to crime victims bars any privilege. I'm
- 0:16familiar with the case law recited in our pleading regarding
- 0:19a fiduciary exception also known as the Garner exception in
- 0:23some filings to privileges. In this case, the government had
- 0:27a fiduciary obligation to protect the CVRA rights a Jaine
- 0:30Do number one and Jaine Do number two, specifically, because
- 0:34they were recognized as victims under the CVRA, the government
- 0:38had obligations to provide them rights under the CVRA, including
- 0:42the right to confer, the right to notice, and the
- 0:44right to be treated with fairness. Because of this fiduciary duty,
- 0:49an exception applies to many of the government privilege claims
- 0:52regarding in our actions with the victims. The fiduciary duty
- 0:56of the government to the victims in this case is clear.
- 0:59In two thousand, the FBI determined that both Jane Do
- 1:02one and Jane Do two were victims of sexual assault
- 1:05by Epstein. While there were miners, beginning when they were
- 1:09approximately fourteen years of age and approximately thirteen years of age, respectively.
- 1:15These sexual assaults involve use of means of interstate commerce
- 1:18ie telephone and travel in interstate commerce. Both Jane does
- 1:23were initially identified through Palm Beach Police Department's investigation of Epstein,
- 1:28confirming the fact that the government had identified Jane do
- 1:31One as a victim in its case. On about June seventh,
- 1:35two thousand and seven, FBI agents had delivered to Jane
- 1:38Doe number one a standard CVRA victim notification letter. The
- 1:43notification promises that the Justice Department would make its best
- 1:47effort to protect Jane do One and her rights, including
- 1:51the reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the
- 1:53United States in the case, and to be reasonably heard
- 1:56at any public proceeding in the district court involving a plea.
- 2:01The notification further explain that at this time, your case
- 2:04is under investigation. Similarly, on or about August eleventh, two
- 2:09thousand and seven, FBI agents had delivered to Jane do
- 2:12number two a standard CVRA victim notification letter. The notification
- 2:18promises that Justice Department would make its best efforts to
- 2:21protect Jane Doe number two's rights, including the right to
- 2:24confer with the attorney of the US and to be
- 2:27reasonably heard at public proceedings. Early in the investigation, the
- 2:31FBI agents and the Assistant US Attorney had several meetings
- 2:34with Jane Do number one, and Jane Do number two
- 2:37was represented by council that was paid for by Epstein,
- 2:40accordingly all contact or contract that was made through that attorney.
- 2:44These meetings occurred because the FBI had obligations to protect
- 2:48victims' rights under the CVRA. In October of two thousand
- 2:52and seven, shortly after the initial non prosecution agreement was
- 2:56signed between Epstein and the US Attorney's Office for the
- 2:59Southern didstay strict to Florida, Jane Do number one was
- 3:02contacted to be advised regarding the investigation. On October twenty six,
- 3:07two thousand and seven, special agents e Nesbit, Kirkandal and
- 3:11Jason Richards met in person with Jane Do number one
- 3:14because she was recognized as a victim of Epstein's crimes.
- 3:17In all of the dealings between the government and the victims,
- 3:21as well as other dealings of a similar nature, the
- 3:23government had a fiduciary obligation to protect the interests of
- 3:27the victims under the Crime Victim's Rights Act. Accordingly, the
- 3:31government is precluded from raising any privileged claim to which
- 3:34a fiduciary exception applies, or at the very least any
- 3:38privilege assertion would be outweighed by the victim's compelling need
- 3:41for the material. An illustration of a situation where the
- 3:45fiduciary duty exception applies is found on page one of
- 3:49the Supplemental Privilege Log with regard to Supplemental Box number three.
- 3:54The entry here reads seven eight eight email from Marie
- 3:58Vilafauna to Alex Acosta, Jayson Slowman, k Atkinson, and FBI
- 4:02reproposed response to Goldberger's letter Victim Notification. In responding to
- 4:08defense Attorney Goldberger's letter about victim notification, the U. S.
- 4:12Attorney's Office had a statutory duty under the CVRA to
- 4:16protect the victim's interest. Accordingly, the office cannot assert privilege
- 4:20when questions about whether it fulfilled its obligations to the
- 4:23victims have arisen in this case, or at the very
- 4:27least any privileged assertion would be outweighed by the victim's
- 4:30compelling need for the material. Another illustration of a situation
- 4:35where the fiduciary duty exception applies is found on page
- 4:38sixteen of the first privileged log with regard to box two.
- 4:43The entry reads file folder entitled rs RCCH Crime Victims'
- 4:48Rights containing attorney research, henwritten notes, draft victim notification letter,
- 4:53and draft correspondence to J. Lefkowitz. Here, again, the material
- 4:57at issue go to the heart of the case. What
- 5:00kind of notification were made to the victims and how
- 5:03did the defense attorney's shape and limit those notifications. Moreover,
- 5:07in evaluating victims' rights issues and determining what kind of
- 5:11letters descend, the government was fulfilling legal duties that it
- 5:14owed to the victims. Accordingly, the office cannot now assert
- 5:18privilege when questions about whether it fulfilled its obligations to
- 5:22the victims have arisen. In the case, communications facilitating crime
- 5:27fraud misconduct not covered, I'm familiar with the cases cited
- 5:31in our brief regarding an exception to various privileges when
- 5:35the communications concern crime, fraud or government misconduct, Many of
- 5:40the important documents about the treatment of the victims to
- 5:42which the government is asserting privilege would fall within that
- 5:45exception with regard to fraud the government misconduct. A number
- 5:49of the documents in the government's privilege log concerned concealment
- 5:53from the victims of the existence of the non prosecution
- 5:56agreement between the government and Epstein. Reviewed a copy of
- 6:00the non prosecution agreement signed on about September twenty fourth,
- 6:05two thousand and seven by Epstein and his attorneys and
- 6:08a representative of the US Attorney's Office. The text of
- 6:11that agreement bar's disclosure of the agreement to the victims.
- 6:15On about January tenth, two thousand and eight, my client's
- 6:18Jane Do number one and Jane Do number two received
- 6:21letters from the FBI advising them that this case is
- 6:24currently under investigation. This can be a lengthy process, and
- 6:28we request your continued patients while we conduct a thorough investigation.
- 6:33The statement in the notification letter was deceptive because it
- 6:37did not reveal that the case had previously been resolved
- 6:40by the non prosecution agreement entered into by Epstein and
- 6:43the US Attorney's Office discussed previously. Moreover, the FBI did
- 6:48not notify Jane Do number one or Jane Do number
- 6:51two that a plea agreement had been reached previously, and
- 6:54that part of the agreement was a non prosecution agreement
- 6:57with the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida,
- 7:00and that the non prosecution agreement would resolve the federal
- 7:03case completely. Whether the FBI itself had been properly informed
- 7:09of the non prosecution agreement is also unclear. Were not
- 7:13alleging misconduct by the FBI, but rather that the FBI
- 7:16was not properly informed about the case or in any event,
- 7:19was acting at the direction of the U s Attorney's Office.
- 7:23In about April of two thousand and eight, Jane Do
- 7:25number one contacted the FBI because Epstein's council was attempting
- 7:29to take her deposition and private investigators were harassing her.
- 7:33Assist in US Attorney Marie Villafauna secured pro bono council
- 7:37to represent Jane Do Number one and several other identified
- 7:42victims in connection with the criminal investigation. Pro Bono council
- 7:46was able to assist Change No. Number one in avoiding
- 7:49the improper deposition. Ausa. Vilafauna secured pro bono council by
- 7:54contacting Meg Garvin of the National Crime Victims Law Center
- 7:59in Portland, Oregon, which is based in the Lewis and
- 8:01Clark College of Law. During the call, Miss Garvin was
- 8:05not advised that a non prosecution agreement had been reached
- 8:08in the matter. On May thirtieth, two thousand and eight,
- 8:11another of my clients who was recognized as an Epstein
- 8:15victim by the US Attorney's Office, received letters from the
- 8:18FBI advising her that her case is currently under investigation.
- 8:23This can be a lengthy process, and we request your
- 8:25continued patients while we conduct a thorough investigation. The statement
- 8:30in the notification letter was deceptive because it did not
- 8:33reveal that the case had been resolved by the non
- 8:36prosecution agreement entered into by Epstein and the US Attorney's
- 8:40Office in September of two thousand and seven. In mid
- 8:44June two thousand and eight, I contacted a USA Vilafauna
- 8:47to inform her that I represented Jane Doe number one
- 8:50and later Jane Doe number two. I asked to meet
- 8:53to provide information about the federal crimes committed by Epstein,
- 8:57hoping to secure a significant federal indictment against Epstein. AUSA
- 9:02Vila Fauna and I discussed the possibility of federal charges
- 9:05being filed. At the end of the call, Ausa Vila
- 9:08Fauna asked me to send any information that I wanted
- 9:11considered by the US Attorney's Office in determining whether to
- 9:15file federal charges. I was not informed that previously, in
- 9:19September of two thousand and seven, the US Attorney's Office
- 9:22had reached an agreement not the file federal charges. I
- 9:25was also not informed that any resolution of the criminal
- 9:28matter was eminent at the time. Presumably the reason the
- 9:32US Attorney's Office withheld this information from me was because
- 9:36of the confidentiality provision that existed in the non prosecution agreement.
- 9:41At this point, it's clear that Ausa Villafana was restricted
- 9:45in what she was being permitted to tell me. On
- 9:47July third, two thousand and eight, I sent to Ausa
- 9:50Vilafauna a letter. In the letter, I indicated my client's
- 9:53desire that federal charges be filed against defendant Epstein. In particular,
- 9:58I wrote, on behalf of my clients, we urge the
- 10:00Attorney General and our United States Attorney to consider the
- 10:04fundamental import of the vigorous enforcement of our federal laws.
- 10:08We urge you to move forward with the traditional indictments
- 10:11and criminal prosecution commesurate with the crimes mister Epstein has committed,
- 10:16and we further urge you to take the steps necessary
- 10:18to protect our children from this very dangerous sexual predator.
- 10:23When I wrote this letter, I was still unaware that
- 10:25a non prosecution agreement had been reached with Epstein, in fact,
- 10:29that continued to be concealed from me and the victims
- 10:32by the US Attorney's Office. I only learned of this
- 10:35fact later on, as alleged in the preceding paragraphs and
- 10:39elsewhere in the affid David and in this case, deliverate
- 10:42concealment from crime victims and their legal counsel of the
- 10:46existence of the non prosecution agreement would be fraud in
- 10:49government misconduct. Documents related to that fraud and misconduct would
- 10:53then fall outside of many of the privileges being asserted.
- 10:57An illustration of a document to which the crime fraud
- 11:00misconduct exception applies on this basis is found on page
- 11:03three of the Supplemental Privilege log. The entry reads file
- 11:09folder entitled twelve five oh seven STARTO Acosta, containing drafts
- 11:13of eleven thirty oh seven letters from Acosta to ken
- 11:16Starr and from Jay Slowman to Jay Lefkowitz performance and
- 11:20victim notification with handwritten notes and edits by Marie Vilafauna. Again,
- 11:26these materials are central to the dispute in the case,
- 11:29as they involve discussions between the US Attorney's Office and
- 11:32defense attorneys about notification to crime victims, and given the
- 11:36dates and communications, in all likelihood they would be related
- 11:40to the deceptive notification that the government made to the
- 11:43victims a few weeks later. All right, folks, we're going
- 11:46to wrap up right here, and in the next episode,
- 11:48we're going to pick up where we left off. All
- 11:51of the information that goes with this episode can be
- 11:53found in the description box.