Latest / Newcomer Pod / Lessons Learned From a Bank Run (Peter Hébert & Laurence Tosi) + SVB's Marc Cadieux
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. Welcome to the Newcomer podcast.
- 0:03We're fresh off our banking summit, and we've got 2 great
- 0:06talks for you in this doubleheader episode.
- 0:08First up, we've got Lawrence Tosi and Peter A.
- 0:11Bear. Tosi is the former CFO of
- 0:14Blackstone and Airbnb and now the founder of the investment
- 0:18firm Westcap Group. And Peter A Bear is the Co
- 0:22founder of Lux. And way back in the day, he was
- 0:25an analyst at Lehman Brothers. Both are very financially minded
- 0:29tech investors and invest in startups and wanted to bring
- 0:32them on the pod to tell the real story of the fall of SVB and how
- 0:37it's impacting Silicon Valley. So give that a listen.
- 0:40Second, we have Mark Cadier, the president of Silicon Valley
- 0:43Bank, which has been acquired by First Citizens Bank.
- 0:46Mark takes stock. One year after the SVB crisis,
- 0:50the bank faces an onslaught of competition from JP Morgan,
- 0:54HSBC, Stifel, Mercury and many others.
- 0:59But SUB has always been a cornerstone of how Silicon
- 1:04Valley does business and had a great conversation with Mark
- 1:08Cadier. Give them both a listen.
- 1:10Lawrence Tosi, Co founder of West Cap Group, former CFO of
- 1:14Blackstone and Airbnb, and Peter Abair, Co founder of LOCKS.
- 1:18Both were in the thick of everything that happened.
- 1:22Toasty and I did a podcast as it was all Unfolding.
- 1:24We can take stock of that. So, yeah, thanks for joining us.
- 1:28Thank you for having us. Yeah.
- 1:29When did the crisis start for you both?
- 1:32Well, the crisis started in a way that I didn't necessarily
- 1:36appreciate. But I had a friend, I was just
- 1:39telling Lt. before this that it was probably November or
- 1:42December of 22 who came out to visit me from New York.
- 1:47And he's, you know, hedge fund investor long focused on the
- 1:50banking sector. And he said to me like, what do
- 1:53you think about SVB? And I said, what do you, what do
- 1:56you mean, what do I think about SVB?
- 1:57He's like, aren't you concerned? And I said about what about the
- 2:00loan book about, you know, it's like for its venture it goes ups
- 2:03and downs cycles. He's like, no about their
- 2:06duration issue. And I said what the hell are you
- 2:08talking? I'm like, don't you understand
- 2:09how this works? People have stayed with SVB for
- 2:11decades. This is how it will be forever.
- 2:14And I kind of brushed it off, but it didn't have been an issue
- 2:17that we had been hearing about, you know, going back to that
- 2:21November, December period of time, but also in the beginning
- 2:24of last year, more so in New York among kind of public market
- 2:29investors who had identified this issue and talked about it.
- 2:32And when things started to accelerate, I had already been
- 2:35aware of it. So I had some background.
- 2:37I just never thought that that would be something that to their
- 2:41earlier panel talking about kind of bank runs that would actually
- 2:44impact human psychology, which I see is obviously accelerant
- 2:48here. So I'll, I'll get a little dated
- 2:52stuff. So in 2000 I was at Merrill
- 2:54Lynch eventually Chief Operating Officer of Banking and Trading.
- 2:57So I saw what that looked like. That wasn't much fun. 2008, I
- 3:01was at Blackstone was one of the managing partners.
- 3:03And so we had started to tell our portfolio companies about a
- 3:08year before that things were going to get dark quickly.
- 3:12I had never, I thought the government frankly was too late
- 3:14raising rates and I thought they moved too fast and inflation was
- 3:18going to drag them to a level that we thought and I'd seen now
- 3:21two times before regional banking stress.
- 3:24So one of the central tenets of what we were telling our
- 3:26portfolio companies even a year before was we need to be really
- 3:30careful with where your cash was.
- 3:31We centralized operations in our portfolio and so and and we know
- 3:36we knew it and we'd seen it. I'm looking at Jeff, my partner
- 3:38Jeff Mullen who was the the Treasurer of Airbnb when we went
- 3:42through the pandemic. So we were a group that was very
- 3:45accustomed to shocks to the system and we very quickly
- 3:48started working on strategies and we could see it just was
- 3:52going to happen. When you're going to have that
- 3:53type of rate shock, it's going to hit the regional banks and
- 3:56it's going to take some time. And so that's when we started
- 3:58getting worried. And and just so we say it out
- 3:59loud like the core problem with SVB, like let's articulate it
- 4:03like it was sort of two things happening at once.
- 4:05Them being sort of dependent on Silicon Valley which was booming
- 4:10in a low interest rate environment and then holding on
- 4:13to financial products that suffered as interest rates came
- 4:17up. Is that how you would put?
- 4:18It I think that's fair. We we actually that's exactly
- 4:21right and it was, it was concentration risk against a
- 4:23certain sector and apparently in the end it looked like they were
- 4:27overexposed to long term rates. We were very worried about that.
- 4:30So we only had one portfolio company that exposure to SVB at
- 4:33the time everything happened and frankly that was by design.
- 4:38I was to say something that's slightly different, which is you
- 4:41know and Lt. will surely correct me if I'm wrong here.
- 4:44But in many ways like you think about the pandemic, money surged
- 4:48into the venture capital asset class.
- 4:49People like us and others put it and farmed it out there to
- 4:52companies and that would find its way into some deposit and
- 4:56generally more often than not SVB.
- 4:58And they had this huge influx of cash and then they had to figure
- 5:02out what to do with it and they put it into highly interest rate
- 5:06sensitive government securities it.
- 5:08Wasn't seemingly very. Seemingly very safe, that was.
- 5:10The big problem was lending the the US government money or at
- 5:14least in the duration of which they were lending.
- 5:16And then I'd say another thing that complicated matters not
- 5:19just the concentration risk of highly, you know, gossip
- 5:22oriented hyper connected individuals in the technology
- 5:26venture capitals, you know, world in Silicon Valley.
- 5:29But also what has changed certainly from, you know, when
- 5:32he was at Blackstone and I started my career at Lehman
- 5:34Brothers and looking at 2008 is social media.
- 5:37You know, free flowing information transmitted at the
- 5:40speed of light. You know, Twitter, banking, apps
- 5:43that people can immediately withdraw.
- 5:45So that it wasn't like going down to Jimmy Stewart's bank and
- 5:48having to wait in line And all those things, if you think about
- 5:51what causes sheer panic in a very abbreviated period of time,
- 5:56will lead to that. Well, just just, you know, take
- 5:58stock of what's been reported and not, you know, like Green
- 6:01Oaks, a very smart investor was clearly warning their people,
- 6:04USV was warning their people. Seems like Founders Fund, Peter
- 6:08Thiel was like directly communicating with people
- 6:11warnings. Then I think there was like some
- 6:13huge and recent portfolio company thread where everybody's
- 6:16sharing notes and like it all just spirals out or like what's
- 6:19your, how did this message get out so fast?
- 6:22And I guess the real question that we'll never know, the
- 6:25definitive answer was was did SPB fail because of a bank run
- 6:30or because of their duration risk strategy?
- 6:34No, well there's a lot, a lot to unpack there Eric.
- 6:36I I think Steve makes a good point particularly unprepared
- 6:40for the velocity of the change in movement of capital was the
- 6:43government that was the big surprise about so that we will
- 6:46talk a little bit about how they reacted.
- 6:48So I think the, the, the velocity of the change was
- 6:51something we've never seen before because exactly as Steve
- 6:54just said, he didn't have these things to do that his name Pete,
- 6:56sorry, I was thinking that's what I was saying.
- 7:00But but as Peter said like I think that things moved faster,
- 7:04the government wasn't ready and the banks weren't ready and that
- 7:07that is definitely a a contributing factor.
- 7:09And you were an advise you were on like a venture Advisory Board
- 7:13SVB touch on like yeah what SVB is and was to the valley like
- 7:19pre crisis. In many ways it harkened back to
- 7:22a different era of banking where it wasn't just relationship, but
- 7:27people would in effect, you know, look you in your eye and
- 7:29say you are worthy of credit, right?
- 7:31It was this old school approach, almost Beaver Cleaver esque.
- 7:35And that world has obviously changed and maybe it was belated
- 7:38and maybe that accrued to the benefit of quote UN quote
- 7:41insiders of those with relationships today.
- 7:44Obviously more lending decisions are made algorithmically and I
- 7:47think probably there are a lot of people in this room that that
- 7:49is exactly what they want to be doing and think of it should be
- 7:52done. But we had a very cozy
- 7:55relationship or Silicon Valley did for decades and luxed as
- 7:59well where there was trust on both sides.
- 8:02It was underwriting the underwriters.
- 8:03They would ask the question, do you stand behind this company
- 8:07and if we said yes, they'd say that's good enough for us.
- 8:10That's no longer in, despite what most people say, the way
- 8:14that things are done, relationships still do matter.
- 8:17You know, the relative position of the equity capital investors
- 8:20behind the company does factor into a lending decision, but
- 8:24it's no longer as simple as it was under that SVB construct.
- 8:27We'll dig in more to, you know, present day-to-day, but the Do
- 8:30you think venture capital firms betrayed Silicon Valley Bank?
- 8:34You know, it's something that we talked about a lot at the time
- 8:38and even after and just thinking about this.
- 8:40But the reality is like we were aware of all the issues and it
- 8:45it wasn't lost in us. But we also felt it's not like a
- 8:49placing myself on some, you know, moral high ground.
- 8:52But we also felt if we communicated and said here's a
- 8:55risk, it's the equivalent of yelling fire in the theater.
- 8:59So you were more on the stay? I was, you know, when we can
- 9:02talk about the day and even the weekend after, which I think is
- 9:05fascinating and very few people have actually talked about it in
- 9:08a public forum. But I was of the perspective
- 9:11that if people held together, held strong, and I'll use like
- 9:15the Braveheart analogy, you know, it's like hold, then you
- 9:19could have resisted those market forces by the end of the day on
- 9:22Thursday that was lost like that, that you had reached a
- 9:26point of no return. But I did believe if people were
- 9:29rather, you know, it's not. And and again I understand it's
- 9:32risks. If you're trying to, you know,
- 9:33manage risks, reduce them. You want your companies to have
- 9:36access to capital. You don't want to be the last.
- 9:39One pure like Game Theory. It is absolute game theory.
- 9:43It's like yes. But, you know, there was so
- 9:45much. There was a time where it felt
- 9:47like there was a good cabal or like the VCs could sort of
- 9:50collude when necessary to like protect something.
- 9:52And the inability of the VCs to work together and say, no, we're
- 9:55not going to bail on Silicon Valley sort of, in some ways
- 9:57speaks to how big it's become. Anyway, Lt.
- 10:01No. I was just going to mention
- 10:02there's two super unique factors in what in what happened.
- 10:05One is Silicon Valley Bank was a huge presence in the in the
- 10:08Valley. I mean they touched every
- 10:09company. There's not a company that they
- 10:10weren't calling on. So they were very pervasive and
- 10:12that's unusual in any industry you have that kind of dominant
- 10:14market share. The second one is a lot of
- 10:17private companies are underdeveloped when it comes to
- 10:19risk and treasury. I mean, I can remember when I
- 10:21got to Airbnb, we had a billion dollars on the balance sheet.
- 10:23It was sitting in an account of PayPal, earning 0.
- 10:26That's not. The antithesis of Treasury, and
- 10:28I looked at it, I was like, well, we can definitely make
- 10:30money off of that. So you had a lot of companies
- 10:32that weren't because when you're private, you don't really have
- 10:34the need for a very sophisticated risk or Treasury
- 10:37system because you're not supposed to be hoarding cash and
- 10:40earning money off it. You can add that.
- 10:42And then maybe the third factor is the VC community and the
- 10:46growth equity community is very, very close, very close because
- 10:49you haven't portfolios been on how many companies you have,
- 10:51Pete, more? Than 275 probably.
- 10:54That's 275 emails that go out very quickly.
- 10:56So that that kind of that those little hub and spoke models of
- 10:59the VC companies can get out there quickly.
- 11:01So those three factors were super unique and created
- 11:04something that this country had never seen before.
- 11:07And so the days when, when did you say, OK fine, get out or
- 11:11like when you, I mean we talked you were helping at least one
- 11:14company move money out. Like what was like that like,
- 11:17and how much was it sort of a relationship game where it was
- 11:20you, the right banker? So this SVB people won't want to
- 11:23hear this, but we were staying, we were away from them for about
- 11:25a year and the only company we had that had cash with them was
- 11:29a company we had signed a deal to invest in and hadn't actually
- 11:32closed with that and we hadn't gotten to Treasury.
- 11:35And so then we moved quickly obviously to move it.
- 11:38You know there's there's a difference between money market
- 11:40accounts and general deposits like that was one simple thing
- 11:43you could do all you didn't need to go running out of the bank,
- 11:45you could just move it into a money market deposit and that's
- 11:47fully, it's not insured but it's not touchable no matter what
- 11:50happens, you're not the opposite the bank credit.
- 11:52So that's what we did. We just moved quickly.
- 11:54There were some other companies that we had relationships with
- 11:56that came for advice and we spent, I guess, probably a week
- 11:59just making sure that everybody was set up and they were in a
- 12:01good spot. And we were kind of teaching
- 12:03them the strategies of how to limit the risk.
- 12:05But it came very very fast in the end.
- 12:07And so you know you're on team hold.
- 12:09When do you say we're not anymore?
- 12:11Yeah. So we thought we, we, we do
- 12:14think about risk management. We take it seriously and we
- 12:16thought that we had done all the necessary things in advance to
- 12:20make sure that we were hedged. The reality is we had as kind of
- 12:25frontline banks, SVB and First Republic and then money centre
- 12:29banks. We had JP Morgan, Morgan Stanley
- 12:32at that point in time and we thought that that was fairly
- 12:34diversified. We had the ability to move
- 12:36accounts around. We can talk about the
- 12:39correlation with First Republic and SVB.
- 12:41It's a whole nother topic. But to your point on Thursday we
- 12:44had, I heard, I guess it was that Wednesday night they kind
- 12:48of announced they were raising capital.
- 12:50Normally you announce the deal in hand and maybe that was
- 12:53General Atlantic that they had announced they were going to
- 12:55raise the money from. I can't remember the specifics.
- 12:57Right. They had that call with VCs to
- 12:58reassure them and it came off. Well, that was well, there were
- 13:01a couple calls and in prior weeks where people started to
- 13:04hear things we had again been hearing for months, but people
- 13:08hear it's like took a while to to reach the West Coast.
- 13:11New York money had been like crossover funds have been
- 13:14pulling out in the weeks earlier, we'd start to hear
- 13:16those kinds of signals. But then Thursday morning, I
- 13:20remember the stock like gapped 50% lower, whatever, it started
- 13:24moving and then people started looking at that And the CE OS,
- 13:27remember it's like I told you, I think we have 275 active
- 13:30portfolio companies. They are not focused on
- 13:32treasury, right. They're trying to build rockets,
- 13:34They're trying to build robots. Even their CFO, you know
- 13:38hopefully now they have gotten more sophisticated but this is
- 13:40just not something risk that they are pondering.
- 13:43And so I remember I was at a meeting early in the morning,
- 13:46came back to the office at 10 and we had kind of an all hands
- 13:49to discuss this. And at that point in time it was
- 13:51team hold and then it was like from that 10:00 period to call
- 13:57it 2:00 PM. Of course the markets closed out
- 14:00here at 1:00 PM was and I realized this is probably
- 14:03inappropriate reference, but it was like the banking equivalent
- 14:06of the US withdrawal from Afghanistan.
- 14:08It was over that three hour period.
- 14:11Colorful, yeah. It was absolute sheer terror.
- 14:14We started getting first emails and it was calls and then people
- 14:18are saying what should we do? We just, they people were wiring
- 14:21money because like they were asking for board approval to
- 14:24wire money out of the accounts. They were wiring money because
- 14:26they didn't have other credit or banking relationships.
- 14:28At risk was, you know, people are obligated to make payroll.
- 14:31Yeah, there is the whole payroll that was like the, I can't
- 14:33remember what we called it that was over the weekend.
- 14:35People called me like maybe the Monday morning problem or
- 14:37whatever it was because around the 15th or whatever it was, it
- 14:40would fund maybe the 13th and and be paid out in the 15th.
- 14:43But we had portfolio companies wiring like millions of dollars
- 14:47to their personal account trying to do everything CYA and just
- 14:50letting people know they're doing this for the right reason.
- 14:53We had that Thursday evening. You mean your founder is saying
- 14:55I'm moving all my our company money into my?
- 14:57Personal because they only had one account and they had no.
- 15:00They had no backup and there was no ability like everyone.
- 15:04All the other banks are getting deluged.
- 15:05We had companies with wires that were hundreds of millions of
- 15:08dollars out of, like checking our money market that were
- 15:12nowhere to be found. At the end of day Thursday,
- 15:15Friday could not be located. They were in the ether
- 15:17somewhere, but it was sheer chaos, panic on behalf of not
- 15:22just us as a firm, but all of these people out there who were
- 15:26just desperately just trying to run their business and never
- 15:28thought about this. I I do want to talk about First
- 15:30Republic. I mean SBB was so fast that that
- 15:34was like the trauma, but FRB was super important.
- 15:37Silicon Valley Bank, I'm going to give you a hard time.
- 15:39You know, we did a podcast and I think you were sort of cheering
- 15:41for them also to be OK, but like you didn't necessarily think
- 15:45they were going to fail. What is your distillation of
- 15:47what happened with FRB? One comment about what Pete just
- 15:51said, it'll always be a mystery to me how it was that SVB sold
- 15:58off and took the $1.8 billion loss before they had lined up
- 16:01the equity. And I've never understand how
- 16:04that happened. We saw that and I saw what was
- 16:06happening. I was like, that's not good.
- 16:08That's not good. First Republic, I mean, it's a
- 16:10bank I know very well. We bought the bank when it was
- 16:13at Merrill. I tried to again when I was at
- 16:15Blackstone. So I've been around that
- 16:16management team a lot of respect for them.
- 16:18We we were big clients, investment grade business should
- 16:21be a very uncorrelated to to SVB.
- 16:24They don't have the same type of risk.
- 16:26I didn't think it would happen and in the end I guess a bank
- 16:29runs a bank run. I mean just think about this
- 16:31fact. Three of the top 30 banks
- 16:33vanished in the last year that caused $530 billion worth of
- 16:37losses. There was $526 billion of losses
- 16:40in the total great financial crisis.
- 16:43That's what just happened and I just didn't think it would
- 16:45carry. But what when the when the
- 16:48government didn't react when they when the Silicon Valley
- 16:51bank went out on Friday morning what happened in the next by by
- 16:56Sunday afternoon, we'll we'll be talking about for decades
- 16:59because the government didn't move.
- 17:01They weren't ready. Pete and I were just talking
- 17:03about in the conversations you were having with Treasury they
- 17:06were completely unaware of the impact of that was having and
- 17:09all the rest of the banks were under pressure and I'll never.
- 17:12Understand about like 12 hour difference between when they
- 17:15would. Well, it was.
- 17:16It was, I think if I remember the numbers right, it was 10:00
- 17:18on Friday morning and Treasury didn't make an announcement
- 17:20about a kind of 1/2 hearted backstop until Sunday afternoon.
- 17:24That period basically told everyone in business in the
- 17:28United States that your deposits aren't safe.
- 17:30That's what the message That's not what they intended to say,
- 17:32but that's what they. Said, do you agree with?
- 17:34That 100%, there's so many different important things and
- 17:36we'll go into the weekend which were to me fascinating one
- 17:40Silicon Valley bank despite the outsize presence here was
- 17:43relatively unknown in DC and certainly even amongst major New
- 17:49York Senate is city money center banks.
- 17:51There were conversations that I had OK Saturday morning, someone
- 17:55who's actually a great supporter but still banking, financial
- 17:59services house member and I tried to reach out to him Friday
- 18:03night, spoke to him on Saturday morning, I go, what do you know
- 18:06about SVBS? Like I think they have some
- 18:08crypto exposure. I'm like, Oh no.
- 18:10Who is this? Who?
- 18:11Is not going to share, but he's actually very strong supporter
- 18:15during this. But DC and the politics were
- 18:18unfortunate in terms of the naming of the bank right.
- 18:21It was literally like the. Equivalent of Nancy.
- 18:23Pelosi Banking Enterprise. Democrats.
- 18:26Even worse. And that was like, what?
- 18:28What? And I we've talked about this,
- 18:29but I figured that we would have strong support from Silicon
- 18:34Valley like Ro Khanna, who both of us know and others.
- 18:38But I quickly first started to fear that there was a banking
- 18:41contagion, because I don't. That weekend I remember in LA,
- 18:44which is not Silicon Valley, at a First Republic branch, there
- 18:47was a line around the block of people trying to withdraw money
- 18:52from from First Republic. That was something that I use
- 18:55when speaking to Republican congressmen and senators trying
- 18:58to tell them basically. And some of them specifically
- 19:01said, why should I care? Who care?
- 19:03You know, it doesn't matter to my constituents.
- 19:05And I said, well, respectfully, imagine in Kentucky if any of
- 19:09these other regional banks without, you know, with $250,000
- 19:12limits, why would you keep it there and not in, you know, it
- 19:15was a GSIB bank. Why would anyone who's like,
- 19:17well, my constituents don't have $250,000.
- 19:20All right, fair. All right.
- 19:21Let me think about how do I recast this?
- 19:22But still, the fear of regional banking contagion to me was the
- 19:26strong one that weekend. And I think that was the only
- 19:29thing that got the federal government to move because,
- 19:32like, Treasury was not talking about it on Thursday.
- 19:34FDIC was on top. On top of it.
- 19:36But you also had the administration.
- 19:38The White House didn't want to touch this.
- 19:41Did not. Sort of distill this.
- 19:43It's like, OK, the government does come in for SVB, but not so
- 19:46fast that we're like, oh, they're really back in banks.
- 19:49And so that creates some of the room for FRB to fail because
- 19:52there isn't the confidence that the government necessarily will
- 19:55step up. I want to get to the present
- 19:56day. So just a quick.
- 19:58It's the domino effect we all saw in 2008.
- 20:00It was the same thing. First you had Bear, then you had
- 20:02Lehman. Immediately after you had the
- 20:04sale of Merrill. It just at the Domino's fault.
- 20:06Faster. And so I think people pattern
- 20:07recognized Eric, they were like, well, well, if that goes down
- 20:10then it's got. Signature, of course.
- 20:12Crypto. Interestingly, and I'm looking
- 20:14at John Shrewsbury's here was the CFO of Wells Fargo.
- 20:16For a long time, nobody's worried about the big banks.
- 20:20It was all focused on the little banks.
- 20:21They were like, OK, we solved the big banks in 2008, but what
- 20:24about the regional banks? And that's why I think it
- 20:26created the panic the the domino effect.
- 20:28It was mob justice, by the way, because you looked at like, I
- 20:31remember watching like Bloomberg during that period of time and
- 20:33it was whoever is next, right? So it's like a, it's like a mob
- 20:37going around the baseball bat, like who is next?
- 20:40And so that's even like fortunately, even though there's
- 20:42been some discussion around, was it New York Community Bank or
- 20:45Commerce Bank, which has large commercial real estate exposure,
- 20:49people are looking for the next domino to fall.
- 20:50And you have an entire group of people, generally hedge fund
- 20:54managers, short, you know, short sellers, everyone's looking to
- 20:57identify, call that person out. And it's an easy trade.
- 21:00It's easy money to be made and some people do it.
- 21:03All right. A lot of bankers on stage.
- 21:04What is your sort of straight talk of the competitive dynamic
- 21:07between the banks right now for venture funds and startups
- 21:11business? I think the model's going to
- 21:13change out and I think that the idea that that the VCs will
- 21:18always be there to back their companies as kind of a soft
- 21:21backstop is going to change. So I think credit presence in
- 21:24Silicon Valley is going to get a lot tighter for a long time.
- 21:27So less relationship, more just shopping for rates and less
- 21:30trusting VCs and more. Of it's a little bit like the
- 21:33mortgage companies that you don't read about anymore.
- 21:35Remember the ones that like started the whole fall in 2008.
- 21:38There's no, you know, Countrywide anymore.
- 21:40It's a little bit like that. I think it'll be getting much
- 21:41smaller. Do you agree with that?
- 21:43I think there is going to be kind of mainstream banks that
- 21:46will serve this ecosystem and I think you've seen a lot of great
- 21:49people from SAB and FRB go to other banks.
- 21:52There will be competition. I think it's probably me
- 21:54segmented on product. So it could be you know,
- 21:57hardware as a service, loans specialization, life sciences,
- 22:01you go to this specific bank. It used to just be for the most
- 22:04part, if the, you know, is always similar and they were
- 22:07always better, just, you know, stay with SBB, I think it will
- 22:10change. But I I do think like it's
- 22:12probably positive in the long term for the ecosystem even if
- 22:14credit conditions will tighten for a very long time.
- 22:17Because of competition. Because of competition I think a
- 22:19lot of other people people probably tried to get in and you
- 22:22saw like groups like Comerica for years is trying to really
- 22:25work in never really worked you know first Republic built and I
- 22:28know Sam's here a a prominent group with Samir and others you
- 22:32know but but I do think there will it will be more banks
- 22:36providing more services but credit conditions again not as
- 22:39favorable they were pre SVB crisis all.
- 22:42Right. We'll take a question.
- 22:43Hi there. Anthony Steele from Steel Comms.
- 22:45I'm Speaking of lessons learned. I'm curious as to your thoughts
- 22:48on whether if SVB had communicated better and more
- 22:52effectively from the get go. Whether a run could have been
- 22:55avoided and by that I mean issuing their press release that
- 22:58they were looking to raise cash, spooked investors, spooked
- 23:01creditors. There was not a lot of effective
- 23:03conveying of the rationale behind that particularly with
- 23:06Silvergate that had just gone. And then there was a seemed to
- 23:09be a void online of of communication from leadership as
- 23:13to why we're doing this. And when people say, hey guys,
- 23:16don't worry, it's OK, don't panic, everybody panics.
- 23:19Yeah, great question. Yes.
- 23:21You know, it's funny if First Public did the same thing, they
- 23:24were very quiet. I just think you're so
- 23:26constrained running a public company.
- 23:27I just think there's so few things you can do and you can
- 23:29say and when a run comes, I just think it's like a tidal wave and
- 23:33tidal waves don't beg forgiveness.
- 23:34We're. Not going to get Elon style
- 23:36banks. I mean I do think you know in
- 23:38Silicon Valley that style of Twitter persona is taking over
- 23:40and if you're going to bank Silicon Valley in the mix or is
- 23:44that naive is just like impossible for.
- 23:46Banks I just if you're running a regulated bank, I just think
- 23:48it's so hard for you just to come out and go everything's
- 23:51fine. And actually they did you know
- 23:53and they they tried to assuage concerns, but I think that just
- 23:56fueled the flames. And I just think it's impossible
- 23:58to be able to communicate your way out of it.
- 24:00The government should have been the one communicating.
- 24:02I think they should have come up with that plan before they seize
- 24:05SVB and said this is what we're going to do to temporarily calm
- 24:08this thing down and backstop it. And they turned it into a
- 24:10political issue and just said. Too bad.
- 24:12And by the way just something that really quickly ADD.
- 24:15I had heard and it could just be total rank speculation that
- 24:18there was a large money center bank that before real things
- 24:22went totally downhill that wanted to buy SBB and that the
- 24:28US government going extending to the White House.
- 24:30But Treasury FDIC did not want that.
- 24:32Why They didn't want greater concentration in the banking
- 24:35system. So as I said that weekend it
- 24:37became clear to me only through a handful of conversations.
- 24:40Oh, they're not going to be helpful.
- 24:42Why? Because there's a very powerful
- 24:43faction, not just an administration but Democratic
- 24:46Senate, that do not want to see the big get bigger.
- 24:49And so that actually I think served as a huge headwind to a
- 24:53constructive solution. Awesome.
- 24:55I'm Allie Rd. from Outside Capital.
- 24:57Thank you both for joining. Thanks Eric for having us here.
- 25:00And I want to get a little bit more tactical, which is where
- 25:02are you guys telling your portfolio companies to put their
- 25:05money now and specifically SVB for Citizens, FRB with JP
- 25:10Morgan. Also want to call out the
- 25:12Mercury Brex ARC, others in the world which are of course
- 25:16they're not actually banks, they're using mostly like evolve
- 25:18and choice. I asked this if both of you
- 25:20maybe specifically a little bit more Lawrence who called SVB,
- 25:24maybe a little bit less FRB. So what do people do now?
- 25:27So it's an interesting question out of every like damaging thing
- 25:30that happens to the valley, one of the beautiful things is we
- 25:32figure out how to fix it, right. We the innovation sometimes
- 25:35spurred fastest things when things don't go right.
- 25:38So we're actually, I think what's going to happen right now
- 25:41we're seeing a lot of investment in treasury systems and risk
- 25:44systems. I'm Steve Helmbrecht here is the
- 25:46CEO of Treasury 4. That's an example of a platform
- 25:49that's going into private companies and saying break up
- 25:52your deposits. You shouldn't be concentrated
- 25:53anywhere. You should have the systems and
- 25:55process and part of it's systems and process.
- 25:57That's why these CEO's were actually wiring money to their
- 25:59own accounts because they couldn't open accounts quick
- 26:01enough. I think what you'll see is
- 26:03you'll see a big leap forward in the capital that's being
- 26:06invested in the technology it takes to properly assess, manage
- 26:09your risk and diversify your deposits.
- 26:11OK, great. But they still have to have
- 26:12deposit somewhere. So where?
- 26:14So, so the answer would be, I mean what what we did before
- 26:17this is we looked at the ratings of the banks and so we don't
- 26:20have any of our portfolio companies in any non investment
- 26:22grade banks. Silicon Valley Bank was not a
- 26:24non, was not an investment grade bank period.
- 26:26I don't want to offend anybody but not not on our risk list.
- 26:30I know, John, you had a you had a question.
- 26:32It was just a comment on the the idea that a big bank would have
- 26:36come in to bail them out. There's a 10% deposit gap for
- 26:39market share for big banks in this country.
- 26:42So action and assisted transaction they couldn't have
- 26:44proposed in the private market to solve that.
- 26:47Now when JP Morgan came in for First Republic that was that was
- 26:50assisted, they said go ahead and do it.
- 26:52That would seem very unlikely for the reasons that you
- 26:55mentioned. It's.
- 26:57A big communicating they. Were not willing to assist,
- 27:00right? I don't know what at what point
- 27:01in time that was pre. I think it was shortly
- 27:04thereafter before there was the bridge bank that they
- 27:07communicated. We're not willing to assist for
- 27:09some period of time, but you would know.
- 27:10Better we we could do this all all day.
- 27:12And thank you so much for being our truth tellers.
- 27:14I'm sure people will pin you down in the crowd and get other
- 27:18takes. Peter.
- 27:19Lt. thanks so much. We're going to.
- 27:20Hear. Thank you.
- 27:21From JP Morgan. So thank you.
- 27:23Yeah, we've got the Silicon Valley Bank president, Mark
- 27:28Cadier coming up. What a difference a year makes.
- 27:31Thank you so much for being here.
- 27:33Thanks for having me. It's great to be here.
- 27:35So maybe just a level set before you go to your first question,
- 27:37just for everyone's benefits, there's a couple things I cannot
- 27:39talk about today. It's events prior to March 10th,
- 27:43any act of litigation. And SVB Financial Group is a
- 27:48separate story today from SVB commercial division of First
- 27:52Citizens Bank in South. I just wanted to blurt that out.
- 27:54That leaves plenty. Of course we can talk about,
- 27:57yeah. And thank you so much for being
- 27:58here. I know it's of course.
- 28:00So just tell us what has the last year been like for you?
- 28:03I mean rebuilding some of that trust, rebuilding the
- 28:05relationships, What, what does your last year look like?
- 28:08I think I'll start by saying the last year has been a lot about
- 28:11trying to correct what I think of as a false narrative that SVB
- 28:16went away, SVB left a void. SVB isn't here to do all the
- 28:21things that we did before, but the truth is we never left.
- 28:24We've been open for business first as a bridge bank then
- 28:28following the acquisition of First Citizens.
- 28:29You were, yes, SVB for a period. Right, yes, SVB is.
- 28:34It is hard to have the word failure.
- 28:35I mean there it is technically true that SVB failed and that,
- 28:39yeah, that sticks with people. Yes.
- 28:42And back so quickly at it I think is the story we continue
- 28:47to get out in that false narrative we have been trying to
- 28:50correct ever since. And and one of the reasons I'm
- 28:52so excited to be here today to to talk about.
- 28:54So you asked about the last year and it's been again right back
- 28:58at it doing all the same things we did for 40 years before, all
- 29:02the same lending at the same dollar amounts across all the
- 29:05different sectors and stages of development.
- 29:08We originated $3 billion in our tech and healthcare business
- 29:11alone in new loans, loans in the last nine months of 23 together
- 29:16with our new colleagues at First Citizens, one of so many data
- 29:20points that I think tell a story about being back and being back
- 29:24on that journey to rebuild the trust by doing all the things we
- 29:27did so well. Before you lost 40 billion
- 29:29basically on March 9th, right during the crisis, and there was
- 29:32a fear you'd lose 100 billion. How, how much of that did you
- 29:36get back? I think you've talked about
- 29:38getting something like 80% a round of depositors back.
- 29:42Like how many? How much of the money came back?
- 29:45So I think the, the best way to think about this is what
- 29:49happened after and so starting in April and again I'll I'll
- 29:53contain my comments to through the fourth quarter of 23, we're
- 29:57public companies have to to call that out.
- 30:00But starting in April and through the end of last year,
- 30:04deposits just in the SVB division have remained average
- 30:09deposits have remained stable. And that I I think is probably
- 30:12the best evidence of all. When you think about diminished
- 30:16venture investing, everyone has two banks now.
- 30:20Many of our clients are still burning cash.
- 30:23That stable deposit story we think tells a story about what's
- 30:26been going on under the covers, which is I think you mentioned
- 30:2981% of our clients are still our clients.
- 30:31Thousands have returned and we expect in the fullness of time
- 30:34that that remaining 19% that's out there somewhere that yeah we
- 30:38hope to to bring them back as well.
- 30:40I I open with this idea about trust and yeah, you talk about
- 30:43bringing back those 19%. Can you, yeah.
- 30:46Can you take stock? Like so much of banking at its
- 30:49core is a trust relationship. You know, a lot of people don't
- 30:52want to think about how their bank works.
- 30:54How do you reassure customers when it's like, you know, yeah,
- 30:57I just assumed Silicon Valley Bank would work.
- 31:00Now we've seen it not work one time.
- 31:01Why should I trust you again? Like what do you what do you
- 31:03tell them? So starting with all the things
- 31:06that are so different now being part of First Citizens is a
- 31:10completely different financial picture, a very stable deposit
- 31:14base, very well capitalized and then with extra liquidity that
- 31:18came with the acquisition. And so that right there just
- 31:22creates a completely different picture.
- 31:25The rest of it is I think about showing up consistently being
- 31:29the best version of ourselves and doing all those things that
- 31:32mattered so, so much to our clients before.
- 31:35And I think matter even more in times like these when you have
- 31:39our innovation economy, target market is continuing to go
- 31:43through some tough times. And it's one more reason why
- 31:46it's great to be U.S. Open for business enabled to
- 31:49support our companies, our clients, when they need us the
- 31:52most. And I I want to get into some of
- 31:53those specifics. I mean I'm curious what you
- 31:55think about like trust on the other side.
- 31:57I mean there is a sense that it was a two way relationship and
- 32:00you know venture firms part of what made Silicon Valley great
- 32:03and make Silicon Valley great is understanding the top firms and
- 32:06having this reciprocal relationship with them.
- 32:10Do you feel burned that people were so quick to run in the
- 32:14panic? No, I do not.
- 32:17I think this is a, it's another spin on intent and impact.
- 32:21I don't think there was any intention to to bring down SVB.
- 32:25That was an unfortunate impact and as I think we saw
- 32:29immediately thereafter a outpouring of support for the
- 32:33venture community of in effect this is not what we intended and
- 32:36we really want them back And again, it's great to be back.
- 32:39So tell us a little bit about SVB under First Citizens, not a
- 32:43bank that was on Silicon Valley's radar necessarily
- 32:46before this deal. Why does First Citizens make
- 32:49sense and how is sort of that integration coming together?
- 32:53Yeah. So first, citizens make sense
- 32:54for so many reasons that would perhaps be less obvious.
- 32:58When you start at the appearances, you get beyond the
- 33:01superficial. What I've come to discover is my
- 33:04new colleagues and the folks that I share time with now an
- 33:07executive leadership team, are just like us in all the ways
- 33:11that matter the most. They care deeply about
- 33:14relationships. They care about long term
- 33:17thinking. They care about being, you know,
- 33:20financially stable. But they're not averse to taking
- 33:23risks so long as it's well managed, well understood.
- 33:26And so again, a lot of things that are so many more
- 33:29similarities than differences and that support has been great.
- 33:33The second thing I would say is this might be the first
- 33:36instance, maybe there was another one out there somewhere.
- 33:38But generally speaking when banks acquire other banks, they
- 33:41usually integrate them and and the the magic, the value that
- 33:45was there is oftentimes lost for citizens has taken a completely
- 33:50different approach of kind of ring fencing SVB, letting SVB be
- 33:55SVB and ensuring that that value proposition is preserved and and
- 34:00not broken in some way, shape or form.
- 34:02And so you asked about integration specifically.
- 34:05We've been very patient at our approach and planning it out and
- 34:09making sure that we make the most of all all of what SPB
- 34:13brings to the broader first Citizens.
- 34:15And we're really just now again has talked about in our fourth
- 34:18quarter earnings just now getting to the what I think of
- 34:21as operational integration of that we expect to complete over
- 34:24the course of 24. But be that as it may at the
- 34:28back end of that, I don't think our clients are going to notice
- 34:31any difference at all. The SPB solutions platform is
- 34:33going to remain intact. Do they see first?
- 34:36Like how how much is First Citizens on your customers radar
- 34:39at all? So one of the questions that we
- 34:42got and then I think in tracking social media was who is first
- 34:46Citizens because they weren't as well known prior to buying.
- 34:50And so I love questions like this because it gives me the
- 34:53opportunity to talk about First Citizens.
- 34:56And yeah, they've been around for 125 years.
- 34:58They've been amazingly successful and it is now a
- 35:02dramatically different financial institution with the acquisition
- 35:06of SVB and the acquisition of CIT roughly a year or so before
- 35:10they required us. And let's talk about like
- 35:13specific products right now like and I mean venture debt is
- 35:16obviously so core to what you guys do.
- 35:18What's your view, It's we're sort of in a funny moment where
- 35:21you know I have all, we have all these banks here, some of your
- 35:23former colleagues competing for the same business.
- 35:25But this is not like prime Silicon Valley, you know we are,
- 35:29it's not 2021, we're sort of still in a downturn.
- 35:34Yeah, how is how is that affecting the competitive
- 35:36dynamic? And then also just how you think
- 35:38about loaning to startups when this is not necessarily the bull
- 35:43market for startups. I again continue to be open for
- 35:48business dealing all of the lending that we did before
- 35:50across all segments including venture was.
- 35:54I'm not going to speculate on on this statistic, but a healthy
- 35:57chunk of that 3 billion of loan origination I talked about
- 36:01before is venture debt origination.
- 36:03And yes, our target markets are facing some headwinds and
- 36:07continue to, but brand new companies are getting funded as
- 36:10well. In fact we've seen some, yeah.
- 36:12Well, we hope our green shoots have in that space and and I
- 36:15would contend that any newly minted Series A company today is
- 36:20probably on average pound for pound a better looking prospect
- 36:24and and we want to be lending to those all day long and and we
- 36:26are. Right there.
- 36:27There's an argument that this is a good vintage to be lending in.
- 36:31Oh yeah, right. Is that your view or?
- 36:33It is. Generally speaking it is at the
- 36:36early stage of the spectrum and then you know you can get into
- 36:39different sectors and it might not be completely even across
- 36:43the board and then you get into those mid and later stages and
- 36:46right. But that is I think one of the
- 36:47things that we bring to the table is that 30 plus years of
- 36:51venture lending through multiple cycles enables us to originate
- 36:55smartly but also be that patient, thoughtful lender,
- 36:59right. Nothing ever goes from from
- 37:01great idea to great company. There are always setbacks along
- 37:04the way And one of the ways SVB Long distinguishes itself and
- 37:08continues to is how we approach those situations.
- 37:11Understanding that that is what happens and not freaking out
- 37:15what it does and working with our clients.
- 37:17And again, in an environment like this, this is one of the
- 37:20most important things we can do for our clients that at this
- 37:24moment. Have you had any of those cases
- 37:25post acquisition or review? Yeah.
- 37:28Have your feet been to the fire on a case where you have to be
- 37:31particularly sympathetic to a startup at the moment?
- 37:34Oh, sure. Yeah.
- 37:36Unsurprisingly as companies, we've all heard a lot about
- 37:39companies working to reduce their cash burn and oftentimes
- 37:42debt service could be a significant chunk of that.
- 37:45And so yeah, we've we've certainly had those
- 37:48conversations with a number of our clients who need some relief
- 37:51as they try to get from here to where they're going.
- 37:54And and we welcome those conversations.
- 37:56Again, we've we've done this for 30 years.
- 37:58We're not going anywhere. And how how early of a company
- 38:02will you start banking like pre venture or do they need to have
- 38:05some venture capital funding? So banking starts.
- 38:08Yeah, we'd love to meet them at formation stage.
- 38:11Like right after you sign those forbation documents with your
- 38:14lawyer, you know, come on down, we'd love to be your bank.
- 38:16We generally start lending post Series A.
- 38:21And how are you thinking about sort of deposits when lending or
- 38:25like what how you know do people have to keep 80% of their money
- 38:28with you if they're they're taking loans from you?
- 38:31So we like every other lender have a we want to be, we're
- 38:37relationship bankers and so we want to be the relationship
- 38:40bank. And in connection with that, we
- 38:42like every other lender do require some percentage of total
- 38:47funds, not necessarily on balance sheet deposits, but
- 38:50total funds to be with SVB either deposits on the balance
- 38:56sheet or managed off balance sheet by say SPB Asset
- 38:59Management. Following the events of last
- 39:01March, we actually took that requirement down to 50%
- 39:05recognizing that everybody has two banks now.
- 39:08We're on a journey to rebuild trust.
- 39:11There's no rush. Again, we we're with First
- 39:13Citizens and there's plenty of liquidity, plenty of support and
- 39:17so we can be patient on bringing back those deposits and and that
- 39:21has been the approach. We're seeing it get back to a
- 39:24place now where 80% is around the market standard.
- 39:27And so we've drifted back to that place to again the, yeah,
- 39:31the the crisis is well behind us and and so we're back on that
- 39:35level playing field. But again, the key point is
- 39:37we're not requiring the deposits to be on balance sheet and that
- 39:41is different from some of our competitors who really do need
- 39:45those deposits in order to reduce the loans.
- 39:47What what do you tell people to give them confidence in the
- 39:50deposits right now? What, You know, there was a
- 39:51period where you guys could say, oh, we're the safest bank in the
- 39:54world, you know, where the FDIC is totally guaranteeing these.
- 39:58They're like what what sort of been this storyline along the
- 40:01way in terms of how safe the deposits are and what what is
- 40:04the message at the moment? Again, it all starts with first
- 40:08citizens and and we are, yes, we're the SPB division, but we
- 40:12are also first Citizens. One of the funds stats from the
- 40:15fourth quarter is all of deposits plus all of that extra
- 40:19liquidity support I mentioned covers uninsured deposits around
- 40:24270%, 270%. So you could you know take every
- 40:29dollar out two times over and it's all still going to be fine.
- 40:33That puts us in I think a very rare place relative to other
- 40:37financial institutions. Yeah, I'm not sure what the, the
- 40:40very largest could say about that.
- 40:42But when I think about financial institution our size roughly you
- 40:46know 220 billion or so in assets that is a pretty good story to
- 40:51tell we think and and it's been very well received by by clients
- 40:54and investors alike. What is your view?
- 40:59We, we touched on this, but I wanted to sort of more full some
- 41:02answer on the the comeback or where we are in this sort of you
- 41:05know there 2021 wild 2022 going down.
- 41:09I feel like 2023 we entered it was like oh maybe it'll come
- 41:12back and we'll feel good and it still seems like venture
- 41:14activity fell. Do you have a prediction
- 41:16specifically on 2024 and whether it will be we'll see more
- 41:20activity than we saw in 2023? So here one of the other things
- 41:25SVB has long done in addition to all of the banking services,
- 41:29product service etcetera is insights and connections.
- 41:32And on the insight front, we just published our most recent
- 41:35state of the market report couple weeks ago where we we
- 41:38talked about the environment and our predictions for the year
- 41:43ahead and things like that. And so turning to that, yes, you
- 41:47have 24, I think we think will be another difficult year,
- 41:51hopefully not as difficult is 23.
- 41:54Hopefully things will start to turn.
- 41:55I mentioned green shoots earlier and that is an encouraging sign
- 41:59and my hope is that we are closer to the end.
- 42:01And then the beginning though, I would preface this again by
- 42:04saying I can't tell the future perfectly and we're certainly
- 42:07prepared for worse. And if it's better, that's fine,
- 42:11obviously better would better, sooner would be great.
- 42:14But in the meantime, again, it's a great time to be us because as
- 42:17long as this tougher weather lasts, we have an even greater
- 42:20opportunity to be there for our clients and to correct that,
- 42:24that false narrative I mentioned before.
- 42:26SVB is in the relationship business at the end of the day.
- 42:30And the people, you know, there are obviously people that have
- 42:33left, you know, some of them are being sued.
- 42:36Who are the sort of core anchors of SVB right now.
- 42:39What are the teams that you think have held strong and like
- 42:42what? What can you assure people that
- 42:43those relationships they have are still at SVB?
- 42:47Yeah, all of them. And I'm not exaggerating there
- 42:51we still have. So much has been written about
- 42:54the all the the folks that departed.
- 42:57What gets missed again in this narrative is all the folks who
- 43:00stayed right, 80% of the folks that were there before are still
- 43:04there. We have the biggest group of
- 43:07market facing bankers in the US of I I expect anyone 1500 strong
- 43:12still and that spans again all of the teams, all the sectors,
- 43:16all the segments and so it's all still there and we're still
- 43:21delivering across the board for our clients.
- 43:23We sort of jumped into it. I want to hear a little bit more
- 43:25of your personal story. Were you surprised to become CEO
- 43:29of SAB or how when it all, you know, the fallout was happening?
- 43:32How did you sort of ascend to CEO and what was your sort of
- 43:36personal story there? So I'll just do a quick title
- 43:38correction. I'm a division president.
- 43:40Yeah, Sorry, yeah. Not you don't want to step on
- 43:42anyone's face. So in the initial innings of the
- 43:46Bridge Bank, I was, I had been the Chief Credit Officer for the
- 43:49prior decade. And so my initial focus was
- 43:53entirely focused on restarting lending part so folks could draw
- 43:57on those lines of credit they were depending on to make their
- 43:59payrolls right. And then the when we we reopened
- 44:02the bank. And so that was my initial focus
- 44:05till about halfway through the second week.
- 44:07And as you might imagine at that time a number of us were wearing
- 44:11multiple hats and our Bridge Bank CEO at the time gentleman
- 44:15appointed by the FDIC asked me to step in to be the interim
- 44:18head of the commercial Bank, which I was of course happy to
- 44:21do. We were all doing anything and
- 44:23everything we could to make this turn out right.
- 44:26And and so then met my new colleagues at First Citizens
- 44:29that first Sunday night and and while I did mention in that
- 44:34first meeting that I'm the Chief Credit Officer, actually I'm not
- 44:36really the President of the company, they elected to keep me
- 44:39in that interim role and and ultimately maybe the the
- 44:42President in June. I I know you're limited on what
- 44:44you can say about the past and we're going to dig into that in
- 44:46the next panel. But you know the sense the
- 44:51actual like venture debt the strategy is SVB besides like the
- 44:56bank's holdings and the investments in terms of long
- 45:00term securities. Like do you think that has been
- 45:02validated or by this acquisition or how do you think about the
- 45:06actual you know lending strategy of I guess the OGSVB?
- 45:12Yeah, I think the the lending strategy of of SVB was I think
- 45:17yeah the the record speaks for itself.
- 45:19It was very successful. We had great credit quality and
- 45:23and that yeah we we proved that out over a number of decades.
- 45:27So and again we still have all the talent to do that well, do
- 45:31it reliably and so that continues on.
- 45:34I'm going to, we're going to throw it out to questions.
- 45:36So think of your questions and there'll be people running
- 45:39around with Mike's and I'll ask a question.
- 45:41Well, you think what, what does the next year look for you like?
- 45:44I imagine part of it is like, OK, we've hit the one year of
- 45:47this crisis. Hopefully we never have to talk
- 45:49about the crisis again. Like what?
- 45:51What are your goals just sort of as a bank moving forward for the
- 45:55next year? Yeah.
- 45:57So it's really I, if I were to boil it down into two big
- 46:01overarching themes, the first would be everything we were
- 46:04doing in 23, right? That that false narrative, that
- 46:07rebuilding of trust, all of that happens if we continue to show
- 46:11up consistently doing all the things that we did before that
- 46:14were so important to our target market.
- 46:16And so that is for sure goal number one matters a lot, but
- 46:22then I mentioned the operational integration and what's we're
- 46:26we're into this really interesting point post
- 46:29acquisition where we're now starting to figure out what is
- 46:34the best, most thoughtful way to put the various pieces of the
- 46:39broader First Citizens Commercial Bank together in a
- 46:42way that enables us on the back end of of operational
- 46:46integration to deliver an even broader, deeper, better value
- 46:50proposition by virtue of being able for example, to avail
- 46:54ourselves of the products and solutions on the CIT platform
- 46:58that would be of interest to our clients and vice.
- 47:00Versa. What's that?
- 47:01Sorry, CIT Platform. Yes, CIT was the acquisition for
- 47:06Citizens made roughly a year or so before they acquired us.
- 47:10And there are a number of complementary vertical business
- 47:14lines there that we think will be of great interest to our
- 47:18clients. And so you could sum this up by
- 47:21saying, my other big goal is to create an even better version of
- 47:25the SPB that was there before by virtue of all that is right
- 47:30there with the broader first citizens that we are now a part
- 47:32of. Questions.
- 47:35So what's the client? Mix look like now I don't know
- 47:38software, tech firms, you know, biotech, venture.
- 47:42Do you still handle venture funds, stuff like that, have
- 47:46some exact numbers which is roughly, you know, yeah, so
- 47:50broadly speaking all the same sectors, stages of development.
- 47:56You mentioned venture, so our global fund banking business
- 47:59venture firms and funds, private equity firms and funds, it's
- 48:03really the same. And and again everything from
- 48:06the the very earliest stages all the way up to to large
- 48:10corporates and everything in between.
- 48:12While there was roughly 20% of employees in my org, the
- 48:15commercial bank or that departed, 80% remain.
- 48:19And so in some instances clients have the exact same team serving
- 48:23them that they did before. In other instances maybe that
- 48:26you know some of those people are still there and they've met
- 48:28some new ones. But the wonderful thing about
- 48:31SPB is we had such a deep, deep, deep bench of talent that our
- 48:35ability to backfill from our own resources was there from the
- 48:41beginning. And so we never really skipped a
- 48:42beat in terms of our ability to be back in front of our clients,
- 48:46maybe with the new banker, but back in front of our.
- 48:48Clients, another question. Yeah, in the back.
- 48:53Mark, thanks for being here. I'm curious like this is like
- 48:55the first bank run that happened on the Internet, right?
- 48:57I think Wyoming was the last one.
- 49:00I mean, the ability to get money out that fast or big, do you
- 49:03think there's needs to be regulatory change like related
- 49:06to that so that that couldn't happen again like where you
- 49:09could take $28 billion out in 24 hours?
- 49:11I mean, I'm just curious. It was very again, it was the
- 49:14first time. That.
- 49:15That had ever. Happened.
- 49:16So I'm just curious like your comments on on that?
- 49:19Yeah. So as noted, the run was
- 49:21unprecedented in its speed and scale enabled by you know,
- 49:25banking on your phone and and and so much has been written
- 49:28about that and and we will, it remains to be seen in the
- 49:32fullness of time what if any regulation we'll see come from
- 49:35that. What I'll say there is, you
- 49:37know, banking's a regulated industry, it should be.
- 49:41I've long said regulation makes us better as a business and we
- 49:45want to be the very best version of ourselves.
- 49:47That's what the clients of the Bank for the Innovation Economy
- 49:51should expect from us and and that's what we strive for every.
- 49:54Day but but do you think there should be some rules for your
- 49:55customers about quickly they can withdraw funds?
- 49:59I think that would probably upset the apple cart a little
- 50:02bit in terms of, you know, part of that trust and faith you
- 50:05mentioned before in the banking industry is based on I can get
- 50:08my deposits when I need them And so I would be personal opinion,
- 50:13I'd be surprised if that's where this went, but.
- 50:16The question was about like the relationship banking sort of
- 50:19private wealth and how much activity there is with SUV.
- 50:21So and yes, exactly I'll repackage a little bit in that
- 50:27there was another entity part of of SV that we called SV Private.
- 50:32And so when First Citizens acquired SV, they acquired the
- 50:36commercial bank part that I run as well as the Private bank.
- 50:39And while SV Private has recently been rebranded as First
- 50:44Citizens Wealth, the same people are there, the same solutions.
- 50:47The same focus on taking care of the individuals that occupy
- 50:52those first two important categories right the the
- 50:55entrepreneurs and those innovation companies and then
- 50:58the investors that support them. Those individuals working in
- 51:01both places still need those same bespoke product services.
- 51:05That same banker who speaks innovation economy and knows
- 51:09what the unique challenges of an entrepreneur or up and coming
- 51:12venture capitalist let's say might be.
- 51:13And and that is all still resident within first Citizens
- 51:17wealth. Are they doing the same math?
- 51:19You know, so much VCs are going to be rich in the future, start
- 51:22founders are going to be rich in the future and SVB sort of had a
- 51:24good sense of the trajectory of that and some confidence and who
- 51:28is safe to give personal loans to?
- 51:30Like are you guys still doing the same math I guess is the
- 51:33question. The same math, I would say.
- 51:36We're still doing all the same things that made us successful
- 51:39before, including taking care of founders, investors, etcetera
- 51:45within that part of the organization.
- 51:48Mark Cadier, what a year, a difference a year makes.
- 51:50Thank you so much. Thanks so much for having me.
- 51:52That's our episode. Thanks so much for listening.
- 51:54This has been the Newcomer podcast.
- 51:56I'm Eric Newcomer. We'll have more episodes on our
- 51:59YouTube channel. And you can check out our
- 52:02Banking Summit content at newcomer.co.
- 52:06Thanks so much to Geco and Bain Capital Ventures for sponsoring
- 52:10the summit. Thanks so much.