Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Housing Market Update: Trends, Risks, and Opportunities
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence podcast.
- 0:04My name is Diana O'Lear, and I am the Vice President of Market Intelligence
- 0:08for the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:10We are actually coming to you live for ACEC Nationals Fall Conference here in
- 0:16Phoenix, Arizona, and we're going to bring to you a special edition of the Market Edge podcast.
- 0:22So we actually just wrapped up our Market Intelligence Committee meeting.
- 0:26And I'm bringing to you one of our speakers. This is Evan Forrest,
- 0:29the VP of Zonda Advisory, where he helps clients understand housing market trends,
- 0:35residential demand, and the factors influencing new home development.
- 0:39So Evan, thank you for being here today. Why don't you share a little bit about
- 0:43yourself and Zonda as well?
- 0:44Sure. Thank you very much. My name is, again, my name is Evan Forrest.
- 0:46I'm the SVP of Advisory in Zonda. We're the largest boulder of new home residential
- 0:52data in the country, our roots go back to the 60s and 70s through a bunch of
- 0:56different types of companies that have since been merged and re-merged.
- 1:00And we just recently actually merged or got bought by CoStar.
- 1:04So not only will I now be the largest holder of residential data,
- 1:06we're also the largest holder of commercial data.
- 1:08Where I come in is I do studies for both the residential side and the commercial
- 1:13side because of my background as a former carpenter and developer on that end of the world.
- 1:18So we get to kind of span the spectrum of kind of everything with me,
- 1:22but our company, at least our portion of the company of CoStar,
- 1:25known as Zonda, we span the spectrum of really new home data overall.
- 1:29Great. Well, thank you for being here today. I'm going to go ahead and jump into some questions.
- 1:33Some we just chatted about in the room because those that weren't here,
- 1:37I want to give them a chance to catch up and then maybe talk about some new
- 1:40things to expand as well.
- 1:42So I want to talk big picture. So tell us what's the current state of the U.S.
- 1:46Housing market as a whole nationally and what are the most important trends
- 1:51that our engineering firm leaders should be watching right now? Sure.
- 1:55The current state of the construction market right now is turbulence.
- 2:00Just like most of the economy.
- 2:01We are very much responsive to the consumer.
- 2:04That's who buys our homes. That's how we sell them. So if the consumer is low
- 2:08on confidence, which right now
- 2:09they're probably at some of the lowest points in the last 30, 40 years.
- 2:13Our, our sales and our, our issue of selling homes has always become a problem on top of that.
- 2:19What it's doing is it's creating the increase from that turbulence is increasing our mortgage rates.
- 2:25That's making our homes less attainable or affordable, every term you want to use.
- 2:29And that's knocking out most of our entry-level buyers to some months,
- 2:32a lot of our mid-level buyers.
- 2:34It's also putting a lot of our buyers on the sidelines, right?
- 2:37Because they're just kind of waiting, going, when's the turbulence over? How do we get out of it?
- 2:41So what our builders are really doing is, or at least what we're seeing is waiting
- 2:45for that turbulence to kind of work itself through the system and find some more stability.
- 2:50What our data says is slightly different. Our data is actually showing that
- 2:53some markets have potentially started to find some of that bottom,
- 2:56find some of that stability and potentially start moving back up.
- 3:01So what the market is hearing for the people isn't necessarily always what the
- 3:05data is hearing in terms of levels of what's happening, what's going on in that market.
- 3:11Very interesting. All right, next question, because you said it,
- 3:14affordability, but you like to call it attainability. So please share more on that.
- 3:19But the question is, housing affordability really continues to dominate the
- 3:22conversation nationally, beyond this conference, but in the room we were just in as well.
- 3:27What factors are having the greatest impact on affordability or attainability today?
- 3:32And do you see any meaningful improvement ahead?
- 3:36Sure. So when we talk about either or of the A-words, it's going to come down
- 3:42to, one, where mortgage rates go, right? Because right now we're trending more
- 3:46towards the high sevens, right?
- 3:47We found most people are more willing to buy when they at least hear five on
- 3:51it. That's what we kind of targeted before.
- 3:54That number can knock out hundreds of thousands of people just by moving from
- 3:58seven to a five, much further down.
- 4:00Our builders are watching that and watching the bottom half of our consumers
- 4:05just not be available. Our worst performance segment is that lower segment.
- 4:09Our best performance segment are the people where money is a little more fluid,
- 4:13right? The higher end we're at.
- 4:15Not that it doesn't matter because it still does, but they can still,
- 4:18you know, they're okay buying.
- 4:20What it's doing is it's creating a lot of pent up demand in the marketplace.
- 4:23We have a lot of buyers out there that are waiting for something they can attain,
- 4:27something they can actually get into the market, not just,
- 4:30anything there that might in their mind might be overpriced,
- 4:34but we also don't have enough replacement homes because of the underbuilding
- 4:38that occurred in the 2010s.
- 4:40So we have kind of this confluence of a couple of different problems that have
- 4:43occurred in terms of that attainability affordability problem where people are
- 4:47waiting for homes on there they're just not there again what that's doing is
- 4:50putting this pent-up ball demand sitting in the market,
- 4:54and we're also where they can't go now either is as there was a slowdown in
- 4:58multifamily there aren't as many multifamily units coming online either so now
- 5:02you're seeing more people cluster into more and more homes.
- 5:05Isn't the best look for us but again it's all these people this pent-up demand
- 5:09waiting for something they contain which means we need to find new products to build Absolutely.
- 5:13All right. Next question. So for engineering firms, where are the most significant
- 5:17opportunities emerging within residential development over the next three to five years?
- 5:21So I want to know markets in the sense of single family, multifamily or the
- 5:27retirees in the 55 plus, but also regionally. Are we still sunbelt growth or
- 5:32is there divergence there?
- 5:34You mean the smile states. Oh, okay, sure. The smile states.
- 5:36Okay. The smile states are basically you take Florida and the Carolinas and
- 5:39draw it along the bottom part of the country and then smile up to a little above
- 5:43Los Angeles. That's cute. That's kind of your smile states. It's really Arizona where we're at now.
- 5:48In terms of the buyers, the retirees are getting up there. Our retiree is actually
- 5:51getting older when we actually look at their standard retiree. Most people say 55 plus.
- 5:56But now when we think about it, I was talking with Tim Sullivan,
- 5:58our chief advisory officer and Allie Wolf, our chief economist.
- 6:01Yeah. And I think that's a good idea.
- 6:02Retirees are actually almost shifting where we almost have like a sub-segment
- 6:05or where retirees more getting closer to 70 now when we start looking at those
- 6:08more classic retiree side buyers.
- 6:11So more of our 50, 50 to 70 are more people that are still fairly active,
- 6:16still want an active lifestyle, still want to be around other people, right?
- 6:19So that's what we're seeing. In terms of what's happened in the market,
- 6:23in our data, what we've seen is most of our buyers, last year,
- 6:27we had a lot of solos and families looking at our stuff.
- 6:31They've been knocked out of the market completely because of that rise in the
- 6:34mortgage rate, rise in the interest rate, where it's just not there.
- 6:37That will likely stick around for a little while longer. All things considered,
- 6:40I think they said they may pause the right increases for one session with the
- 6:45bank before they probably go up again, which doesn't really help.
- 6:49Our market will like to keep more of those people pent up on the sidelines in that market itself.
- 6:53So as we look, most of those folks, even those classic older buyers,
- 6:58as we think of them, they still want a new style of product.
- 7:01They don't necessarily want to be in an age-targeted community or an age-restricted
- 7:05community. Sorry. Age-targeted, sure.
- 7:07But they still want to be around. A lot of their needs and their demands and
- 7:10their desires coalesce with a lot of the folks that are 30.
- 7:14So you're seeing a lot of the same amenities are needed for both of them.
- 7:16So it's really more about finding how you can get some of that pent-up demand.
- 7:22So other than that smiley face, any other pockets of growth or decline?
- 7:27Are there certain areas we should not even look at for building?
- 7:31I love every area. No.
- 7:34I think in any area, in any city, you can find pockets of things to build.
- 7:38You just have to find what to build.
- 7:41And you can't be so spoken into, we just build this.
- 7:45You need to be innovative. You need to try new things. Say, well,
- 7:48no, this isn't going to work here. This is what will.
- 7:50In terms of some markets that are still doing well, you have Treasure Valley,
- 7:53which is Boise, which is doing well.
- 7:55You know, Nashville has gone down a little bit, but you break up Florida into
- 7:59a number of different states, which it kind of is when you look at the buyers.
- 8:02And there's certain parts of Florida, the central portion, Orlando doing very
- 8:06well. Right. Right. They've kind of found their bond. Go down to Miami.
- 8:09Not so much. You got high rises that are empty.
- 8:12You know, you go to the Carolinas, still pretty good. But then you have other
- 8:15places like Indiana, or Indianapolis specifically, or places in Ohio that we're
- 8:21starting to see more interest in like Columbus just because of what's being able to build there.
- 8:25And people are starting to like that lifestyle as well. You know, so.
- 8:28All right. There was one topic we spoke about in the room, and I want to see
- 8:31if you can add a little bit more color to it. We talked about workforce because
- 8:35we have our own issues in the engineering industry.
- 8:38You know, there's a gap for sure. And so it came up in here too in the labor
- 8:42market for construction, housing construction.
- 8:46And so can you add more color to that? And then a union conversation came up
- 8:49as well. And so how is the housing market being impacted by that.
- 8:53So the Great Recession knocked out 10, 15 years of workers, right?
- 8:59The people that would now be getting into their 50s.
- 9:02Maybe early 60s, maybe late 40s. We lost all those people that would then be
- 9:07kind of that middle management or those folks that would help with bro,
- 9:10whether it's labor on-site or labor off-site.
- 9:13Our biggest problem with some of the labor is we're missing,
- 9:16one, we're missing this whole almost generation of folks, about 15 years,
- 9:20give or take, whatever it might be, plus or minus.
- 9:23But we're also missing our younger generation doesn't want to go on and do that labor.
- 9:27They just aren't there to do it. They don't see the value and the virtue in
- 9:30it because we haven't shown them what the value and virtue is.
- 9:34There's some great programs in Las Vegas, in Colorado Springs,
- 9:36and a few other places around the country that start to bring back the trades,
- 9:40to show why it's worth it, which we kind of got away from in the 2010s,
- 9:44definitely in the 2020s.
- 9:47In terms of unions, when you look at most unions, they're generally older now.
- 9:52We're doing the same thing.
- 9:54We're missing that younger generation. We're not only not bringing the labor
- 9:56force, We're also not bringing them into unions either.
- 9:59So you kind of have a similar problem, whether it's union, non-union or not, we're missing people.
- 10:04Forgetting to show the virtues of why things are great, why it's rewarding to
- 10:08go build a home each day, why it's rewarding to have an engineer go design,
- 10:13you know, a plat or to go design whatever happens to be.
- 10:16We're just, we need to get back to showing some of that reward of what it is
- 10:19instead of this immediate recognition or immediate.
- 10:23Satisfaction. There we go. Satisfaction. Exactly. Immediate satisfaction. Yeah. There.
- 10:27So that people go, sometimes just something a little longer term can give so much more reward or even,
- 10:34yes it's a little harder work but putting your feet in the ground is the only
- 10:38way we're going to do it because if we don't we're going to find other ways to build homes
- 10:41which means manufactured modular which can might be robots which might be which
- 10:46might fit better with some of
- 10:47the younger generation with their better ability to play like video games,
- 10:50because then you can control robot robots a little easier to kind of build it
- 10:53right right because their their thumbs are a lot better at that than me so very
- 10:57interesting so there was another question I wanted to ask more on the scale of demographics.
- 11:03And so are there any trends that we should be watching? We talked about the
- 11:06boomerang kids and coming back to live with mom and dad and how that's changing,
- 11:11what type of houses the elderly are staying in.
- 11:14Can you tell me more about that? Sure. So that's when we're moving away from
- 11:17that pure age-restricted 55 plus.
- 11:20A lot of people seeing their maybe once divorced or whatever,
- 11:25what have you, child moved back in with them at 40, right? Or they want their
- 11:30own space in their parents' house back again, right?
- 11:32At 40, or maybe the parents are going, you know, the other way.
- 11:36It depends on what state you're in on that. But it's creating a need for either
- 11:41ADUs, not as much because you want to rent them and not be able to,
- 11:45but also looking at larger bedrooms,
- 11:47but also seeing a couple of builders, whether it's Pulte or Taylor Morrison,
- 11:52looking at creating these communities that are a little more while they're kind
- 11:55of age-targeted, they're more like family talk.
- 11:58They're trying to bring the whole family together. So they bring in homes that
- 12:02are going back into adding in the technology in the home because you need that
- 12:06for the younger generation.
- 12:07Right. Then the family feel because you need that for the older generation.
- 12:10And they kind of bring them together.
- 12:12So it's an interesting proposition for builders nowadays to kind of start doing
- 12:17that almost kind of like almost a European style where families,
- 12:21you have three, four generations of families at home.
- 12:24All right. So my last question is kind of be like a two-parter.
- 12:27So what do you think needs to change in the way builders are designing and building
- 12:34homes? What has to change? Because it must, right?
- 12:37And then what's one final takeaway that you would give? Maybe a little bit of
- 12:42a forecasting on how you think this housing market's going to play out.
- 12:45All right. So starting with what builders have to start doing,
- 12:49get uncomfortable again.
- 12:51Okay. What that really means is we used to want to try stuff.
- 12:54We used to try other types of designs.
- 12:57A lot of our builders now, since we went to more of a public style builder model,
- 13:01they aren't as comfortable trying something different. We get very stuck in,
- 13:05our 50 wide lots or 60 wide lots in the same typical type of home.
- 13:09If we're looking and trying to expand our buying base, that isn't working.
- 13:14So we need to go back and innovate a little bit, try some new stuff to make
- 13:17it more attainable, whether that's higher density, they don't all have to be
- 13:20attached, but something to that effect where we can't be afraid to push some
- 13:25at higher density to try stuff.
- 13:27Historically, home building has not always been the same thing.
- 13:30It has changed no matter where you are, how you build. And that was the second question.
- 13:34Okay. So interest rates, you didn't want me saying stackflash it earlier. Please don't. No, no.
- 13:41So what do we do? Okay. So this is my question.
- 13:45Do you see the interest rates staying and rising, which I believe is the forecast over the next year?
- 13:51And do you see the housing market staying where it is? You did say we've kind of bottomed out there.
- 13:56Do you foresee growth? So I think like everything else in real estate, it's always localized.
- 14:01Okay. Right. So if we go local, we can go city by city, CBSA,
- 14:05but that would obviously, we'd be here for another couple of days. Not what you want.
- 14:10Looking nationally, it's most likely, while multifamily will likely continue
- 14:15on the downslope for the next year. Okay.
- 14:17Just because it takes longer to plan. We already know what's on the downslope.
- 14:21Cap rates haven't been as attractive. So we already know multifamily or rental,
- 14:24those type of ones aren't.
- 14:25In terms of single family, it's probably going to stagnate, maybe hit a little
- 14:28bit higher. It's not stagflation. Got it. I hear you. I hear you. Right?
- 14:33But so the market likely 2027, what we're hearing, what most of our builders
- 14:39think, while we're typically a very optimistic industry, that's you kind of have to be as a builder.
- 14:45Most builders, when you sit down and talk to them, while they think there might
- 14:48be a little bit of an increase, again, that optimism you have to have.
- 14:51And that's what we do in this country, frankly.
- 14:54We're generally thinking might be a slight increase on the single family side.
- 14:58Some markets already showing that.
- 15:00But again, consumer confidence is what's really going to be tip us over the
- 15:04edge, whether that's up or down.
- 15:05That'll supersede everything else in terms of what we're looking at and what
- 15:08happens in the economy. All right. Well, thank you.
- 15:10All right. I think that's about all the time we have for today.
- 15:13Evan, thank you very much for joining. Yeah, thanks. All right.
- 15:16That is about all the time we have. Thank you for joining another episode of
- 15:19the Market Edge podcast. I'm Diana O'Lear. See you next time.