Latest / Hotdish and Hot Takes / The Midwest Hotdish Debate
Transcript
- Kali: Welcome back to Hot Dish and Hot Takes. Quick question. When you hear the words hot dish and casserole, do you picture the same thing? Today we are breaking down the difference, the rules we all pretend do not exist, and the dishes that absolutely count. And yes, we want you to pick a side. Let's get into it. So, Jen. Tell us, your big discussion point on this hot dish and casserole aspect of things because I feel like this is like one of our first hot takes. And this is something that Jen: Yeah. Kali: you are so passionate about from the day we started talking about this podcast. And I I personally did not hear about cat the word casserole, except for bean green casserole. That was not like the only casserole I knew about. Until I was like in college and somebody called a hot dish casserole, and I was like, what the fuck is casserole? And so like I grew up, everything was a hot dish. And I grew up in north central North Dakota. So maybe that's a little bit of the difference. we both grew up in rural towns, so I think this will be interesting. But it please, I would love your take on this hot dish and casserole scenario. Jen: Yeah, so it's interesting because I think there is a difference, but I think it's regional. and it's interesting to me that people use them interchangeably because I don't think they're really interchangeably. And I think the big piece to the interchangeable component is the vessel in which it's cooked in. Kali: interesting. I love how your voice is like changing and getting very methodical. Like this is gonna be Jen: With that. Well, I had to do some research on it too, because I'm like, can't just be in my head that they're two different things. Kali: I love the analytics. Jen: Both hot dishes and casseroles combine different ingredients, right? You combine a protein, you combine some veggies, you have some sort of thing to connect some, right? Whether that's condensed soup, or that's pasta sauce, or maybe it's cheese, whatever. Or maybe it's a combination of all of that. However, casseroles are usually cooked in a casserole dish, mine's glass. Do you have a glass one, Kaylee? Kali: Looking at me. I I guess what what's a casserole dish? Jen: Like a like a rectangular size dish. Not you it's something you put in the Kali: So is it it like an eight Jen: oven. Kali: right, but is it like an eight by eight pan? Jen: Is that what the no, it's like what are those, nine by thirteen? Kali: Well that's that's a a cake pan. Jen: Yes, kinda, but it's glass. Casseroles are done in glass pan. Nine by thirteen. Kali: Now you got me very confused because what's the difference between a nine by thirteen cake pan that's metal and a nine by thirteen cake pan that's glass? Like they're both cake pans. Like I bake bars and cakes in them. Jen: Right, but I would never bake a hot dish or a casserole in metal one. That's a cake pan. Kali: What? And I feel like I need to go to my cupboard now and like bring them over here. Be like, is this a casserole dish? Jen: done in a glass nine by tw And see what you got? Kali: I will say that my mom gifted me probably 15 years ago, if not longer, she got two sets of those like old pyrics with like a glass lid. So Jen: Hm, yeah. Kali: like to me that's like a hot dish. green bean casserole, which by the way I never make because I think it's disgusting. But like that would be something that I would cook. Like tater tot hot dish that goes in the oven, right? Jen: Right. That is the only acceptable hot dish I think that you can make in a casserole dish. Is Kali: Is Jen: a tater tot hot dish. Kali: And then my husband has this one that's like oval shaped that has handles on it that's red and it's about that deep. Like I feel like I need to go to my cupboard and like pull it out and show it to you now to be like, is this a casserole dish or is this a hot dish? to me they're just like everything I have is ceramic. Nothing's really glass. Jen: suppose ceramic would be okay too. I mean I think I have a set of those that are smaller. They look really good under my cupboard though I don't think I use them. Kali: Okay, now we're we're sidetracking here on the dish. Jen: a hot dish is made in a pan on your stove, like a not a flat one, like a tall, I don't know, Kali: Hmm, okay. Okay. Jen: quart size, what are they called? Like I'm very challenged in the cooking utensil component of my life. Yeah. It's like a pot. Kali: It's okay. So if I'm hearing you correctly. Jen: And then you mix everything in the pot. So that's like, you know, you Kali: So that's a hot dish. So if I'm hearing you correctly, everything my mom made, which we called hot dish growing up, is probably truly a hot dish because she would just go to the fridge and pull stuff out and combine it in a pan with like burger or whatever and we Jen: Yeah. Kali: would eat it. She would like, you know, add tomato juice or whatever to it and we would have hot dish. Jen: Probably something also termed gulash, right? Are Kali: Is gulash? Jen: you serious? Kali: my god, you're adding more into this. What the hell is gulash? Everything was freaking Jen: Okay, we won't go down. Like Kali: hot dish growing up. Let's be real. She would grab a protein, a carb of some sort, and a veggie, and Jen: Mix Yeah, a meat veggie. Kali: and combine them in a pan together. Like, I was was it you? I think maybe it was someone else I was telling this too. When I was growing up, one of the things that she would make, and mind you, we didn't have a lot of money growing. And I didn't realize that till I was older, but anyways, I digress. So she would fry a burger and she would take spaghettios and baked beans and dump them in with the burger. And that would be like my f that was one of my favorite hot dishes as a kid. But it was like something quick she could cook up, and that was a hot dish. I mean, she'd season it and stuff, you know. Jen: So goulash is kind of similar, oftentimes like with a noodle and spaghetti sauce and we'll mix in like pepperoni and different like things like that. Yep. And mix it some cheese, gotta have lots of cheese, mozzarella cheese, mix it all together. Kali: So so when I make pizza hot dish, what you're telling me is that's not pizza hot dish. It's Italian sausage. Jen: Pizza casserole? Kali: I make it make I make everything in my Instapot though. But like it's it's Italian sausage that you brown, you add a bunch of seasonings and spices, chicken broth or beef broth, noodles, and then at the end after it cooks in the Instapot, you add in like cheese and stuff to it. Then it tastes like pizza with noodles. Jen: Hm, yeah. I'd call that a gulash. Kali: That is a hot dish. Jen: I mean it could be, yes. Especially since you made it in an Instapot. I would use a Kali: I make everything an Insta. Jen: I would use a pot for a hot dish. But fun fact, okay, so hot dish Kali: Yeah. Okay. I'm digressing, sorry. Jen: is an upper Midwest thing. It actually originated in Minnesota. Kali: I'm guessing rural Minnesota, because rural, like the western side of Minnesota, I would say is very similar to North Dakota. So, like, okay, here's a here's another one for you. So, my mom, one of the things my mom made that we loved as a kid, is she would take and fried potatoes, she cook up egg noodles or homemade noodles, and then she would do a butter and bread crumb and like combine it all together. And we would eat that. Most of the times we had that, and then she would make deer sausage and sauerkraut. Jen: You had me before you added sauerkraut to it. Kali: So and so so my question is, is the potato and noodles and breadcrumbs then considered like a hot dish? There's no protein in it though. Does it have to have a pro like we just consider that like a side? Jen: I don't think you have to have a protein to justify whether it's a hot dish or not. Kali: See to us there always had to be a meat in it to be a hot dish. Well, yeah, 'cause like green bean cat green bean is not green bean hot dish, it's green bean casserole. Jen: Casserole, yeah. But I mean if you looked up the history of casserole and hot dish, casserole is a broader term, but it doesn't involve combining all of those ingredients into like a pan or a casserole dish. To me those are glass. Kali: So if it goes in the oven, it's a casserole, but if I cook it on my stove or my Instapot, it's a hot dish. Jen: Hadesh, yeah. Kali: So that's the big difference. Jen: In my opinion, yes. And Kali: So when Jen: hot dishes really came about like church potlucks and church picnics, that type of thing. That's kind of where the And served hot, right? Kali: Okay, so I ha I have a question. You brought this up and it made me think of it. And I'm gonna digress here into a little bit of a different direction. Did you did you grow up Lutheran or Catholic? Okay, so you'll probably understand this. I grew up Catholic. And so when there was like something that happened and we would have like a potlock thing at church and we would go down into the basement of the church. Did you have the cheese whiz and green olive bread or buns? Jen: think I've seen them, but anything with olives I stay far, far away from. Yes. Like an appetizer. Kali: My question is though, were they on a plate there? I didn't think of it as it was it was a dish. Like somebody always brought the cheese whiz on bread and olives. And I loved cheese whiz as a kid. Like one of my fondest memories as a kid is my mom making homemade buns and they come out of the oven and we would like try to like rip them apart and they were still too hot. We'd burn our fingers. And then we just Jen: Ha ha. Kali: we would we would put cheese whiz on them. And we would eat them. And they were like the best thing ever. Jen: I gotta say, I don't think I've ever done that in my entire almost fifty years of life. Kali: Cheese was just like a like a savored treat in our house 'cause it was expensive. And we just Jen: I was gonna say cheese whiz was would be pricey, I think. Kali: Right. I mean back then pricey. Not pricey are pricey, but and I'm sure it did Jen: Right, but back then yeah. Kali: and I'm sure it didn't have all the shit it has in it now. But that's a totally different subject that we don't want to go down today. But I was just curious 'cause we're Jen: Right. It's kinda like a Twinkie, it lasts forever. Kali: It's made of more plastic than it is cheese. Okay, anyways, anyways. Jen: For eat plastic cheese. That's why plastic cheese is so exciting, right? make my grilled cheese sandwiches with plastic cheese. Kali: man. We didn't have Jen: Yeah. Kali: like a lot of cheese set, but I I distinctly remember eating bologna sandwiches and loving them. Like bologna was like a big thing in our house. Jen: With potato chips? Kali: We we didn't always have chips though. Jen: In your sandwich. Kali: In my sandwich. Well, I mean, I would do that as a kid, yeah. My kids still do that crap. They don't eat bologna, but yeah. Jen: ciloni and laced potato chips together? Kali: Yeah, we didn't always have potato chips. Sometimes it was just bologna. We just use plain bread or a homemade bun, and then a little mayo or miracle whip and then bologna. And if we have cheese, we'd put a s cheese slice on there. If we didn't, we didn't. But then they came out with the thin bologna. Do you remember the thin bologna? Jen: Hmm. Yep. Kali: I like the thin bologna better than the thick bologna. But I guess why are we talking about bologna? Okay. So okay. Jen: Get back to the hot dish. So a hot dish could be considered a complete meal. Right? Some casseroles are Kali: absolutely. Jen: not a complete meal. They're the side dish, like you just talked about. Kali: Okay, so then are all the stuff I eat hot dishes then? Even when I bake in the Jen: complete meal. Kali: oven? Like Jen: I don't build I bake them on top Kali: Yes. Jen: of the stove. Castro in the oven. Kali: what is the ham and potato scalp potatoes? Is is that considered a casserole then? Jen: Jam and scaled potatoes. Kali: But there potatoes are a vegetable and hams of protein and you add like milk and cream and like you make a thing to put over a roux, you make a roux to put on it. Jen: I don't think I've ever thought about that as a casserole and or a hatif. Kali: And then you put cheese on top and b like you bake it in a casserole dish. Jen: One of those square ones that you were talking about earlier with the little glass cover. Kali: No, like that's not I I'm gonna show you. I'm showing you. Jen: Mm. Kali: Yeah, this but mind you, let me see if there's a date on this. Jen: Casserole. That'd be a casserole, because you put a cover on it. Kali: You do put a cover on it. I'll grab my other one. My other one, I think, is a casserole, too, but I want to see if there's a date on this. This is from this literally is from when my mom and dad got married. How crazy is that? It does. It's Pyrix, that's why. Jen: See and it lasts forever. Just don't make things like they used to. Yes. Kali: There's no date. I thought for sure. Baking and microwave. So it must be baking and microwave safe. This was back before they had dishwashers. So. It probably has lead in it for all I know. But back to my original, like then is scalped potatoes a casserole. Is what what's the thing we have at at Christmas and Thanksgiving? It's not cream corn. No, Jen: Mean casserole? Kali: no, it's corn. Cannot think what it's called now. But you put like you put crackers in it with cream corn and you bake it. Jen: You had me at crackers. And then you added cream corn and mm. Nope. Nope. Okay. Kali: I'm texting my mom. I will get back to you 'cause she'll tell me what it is. I cannot think of what it's called. Jen: I don't think I've ever had that for a holiday. Kali: We have it every single year. Jen: Hmm. But in any case, outside of the Midwest, people call everything a casserole. We call hot dishes. food, hot dish. Kali: Yes. Or soups and stews. Jen: Yeah, comfort foods. Yeah. Kali: Mm-hmm. So I mean, isn't chili technically a hot dish then? Jen: We never call that a hot dish, but people will add noodles and then to that's a goulash. Kali: Why do you add noodles to chili? Jen: A filler? I don't know. I know people that do. It's not my favorite. Kali: They add noodles to their chili? Jen: Yeah. Kali: Where do they do this at? Jen: Midwest. Just not yours part of the Midwest. Kali: People can't see my face. I'm like ready to vomit. No, you don't add noodles to chili. Jen: Yep, that's a thing. Kali: Did you know like down south they don't put beans in their chili? Jen: Right and then don't they also use eat there with cinnamon buns? Kali: yeah, we tried that when we were in Texas. It was really good. Yeah, it was deli I made Jen: Pretty good. Yeah. I Kali: I made homemade cinnamon buns and we Jen: Yeah. Kali: tried it. Jen: Friends of ours did that and I'm like, okay, I'll try it, but because I was curious and and I really liked it. It was pretty good. Not something I would have normally thought of for that. Did you mind giving that too? Kali: there we go, scalp corn. Scalp corn. Have you ever had have you ever had scalp corn though? Jen: No, 'cause I hate cream of corn. Kali: Okay, here's have you ever had homemade cream of corn? Okay, let me preference this by saying I grew up we we did not have a lot of money. We had a garden, my mom canned all of our vegetables or froze them. My dad, we would get like a beef with one of my uncles, and then we lived off of venison and fish that my dad hunted and caught, right? my mom never bought store bought veggies ever. So the first time I bought a can of cream corn at the store, I about died, you guys. Like I seriously about died. That is not fucking cream corn. That is so far from cream corn. That's like runny shit in a can. Like it is so bad. So Jen: Right? Yeah. No. Kali: true homemade cream corn is absolutely delicious and so good. So what Jen: I would imagine the taste is way different, yeah. Kali: Yeah, so some people use like breadcrumbs or whatever in their cream corn. We grew up using crackers, you crunch down saltine crackers. And so what you do is you put enough in there to kind of take the liquid away and then you add cream. And so you ha you don't want it too dry, but you don't want it too wet either. And then you bake it. So it's it it's delicious. And you put freaking tons of butter on top of it when you're baking it. I mean, doesn't that just sound like a heart attack in a dish? And so Jen: For sure. Kali: so to me, like Scalp corn then would be a casserole, right? Jen: Yeah, 'cause you could definitely Yeah. And maybe at the end of the day it's just a Midwest thing. But I do think you make either one of them differently. Kali: So if you bake it, then it's casserole. But if you just do it in a pan, then it's a hot fish. Jen: Hat dus. Kali: Interesting. So all the recipes I get from Jen: That's my take. Kali: AI when I'm like, Hey, I got this stuff, mix it together and make me something and they tell me to put it in a pan and bake it after it's cooked, then it would become would go from a hot fish to a casserole. I never do that, but Jen: I've had some that do that, but now that's a different that's a different twist on that. I'm thinking about that because I do mix some stuff in a pan and cook it. And then add it to a casserole dish and put more cheese on it. Cause everything's gotta have cheese. then I don't know. Would that be a casserole or still a hot dish? Huh. There you go. You just added a new twist to that argument. Thanks, Kayleigh. Thanks. Kali: we would love to know in the comments, are you a hot dish, a casserole, or gulash person? Maybe you're all three. Everything in our household is hot dish. Everything's hot dish, except for green bean casserole, which again makes me want to vomit. It's disgusting. Jen: Or tater tot hot dish. Or no, tater tot casserole. Right? If you looked it up, it'd be a tater tot casserole. Kali: It's tanned hot dish. Like, what do you put in your tater ta hot dish? Let's have that Jen: that's where I had it mixed up in my head. Okay, yeah, no, tater tot would be a hot dish, but I make it in a casserole pan, that's where I get confused. Kali: I mean technically it should be a casserole. Jen: Yeah, 'cause with my theory. Hmm. Kali: Yeah. What do you put in your tater tot hot dish, Jen? Jen: I have green beans and burger and cream of mushroom soup. And then I top it with tater tots. Pretty simple. Kali: I wouldn't eat your Jen: Maybe some seasoning in there, but Kali: Yeah, I would I wouldn't eat your tatered hot hot dish. Jen: You wouldn't? Kali: No, because it's got green beans and cream and mushroom. Jen: What do you put in yours? Kali: I would be nice. I would eat it. But so we do corn. We do corn in ours. So and then cream of chicken Jen: Okay. Kali: is what we typically use. Yeah, my mom always used cream of chicken because she didn't like mushrooms. And now I use a homemade. Jen: Okay. We're similar. Kali: Yeah, I use a homemade cream of whatever you want it to be. It's like a base and then I add chicken broth to it and make my own cream of chicken because the other stuff you buy in the store is so disgusting. I am so like I I feel like I'm a true Midwestern until you really hear about the things I do and don't do anymore. Jen: And really quite honestly the last thing I wanna do is cook, so I'll just do the canned. Kali: I know, I can't well, I can't do milk, so I Jen: Mm. Kali: can't do the creams unless I make my own, which is made out of goat milk, which now I'm getting really hippie talk. Yeah. Jen: That's a different bandwagon to jump on. Kali: But yes, you can you can make your own cream, a mushroom cream, a celery cream of chicken, like whatever you want it to be. There are recipes out there. Jen: I'd imagine. Yeah. Kali: And so it's it's a powder consistency, and then you mix it, like I mix mine with it's a third of cup with chicken broth and some butter. And it it makes yeah, in my my family has no clue that it's anything different. Now my kids if they w listen to this, we'll never eat my cream of anything again because they're gonna be like, There's gold milk in it! Jen: Yep. Kali: The world ending the Jen: Exactly. Yeah. Well there you have it. That's my take on Kali: Anyways, well we'll thank you. Jen: the difference. Kali: Yeah, I'm I'm excited to see what viewers have to say also. And so I think that's I think that's it for this episode, you guys. Take care, stay curious, and we'll see you in the next one.