Latest / Surrounded / Is Capitalism The Best We Can Do? | Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00There are so many people who recognize that they don't live
- 0:02in a system that prioritizes their growth or their well-being,
- 0:06and it's really who the problem is that people are trying to identify.
- 0:10Is the problem
- 0:11these
- 0:12lower income or low-skilled workers that are coming in from developing nations?
- 0:17Is it the LGBTQ people that live in my neighborhoods,
- 0:20or is it wealthy interests who really call the
- 0:22shots and have the most influence in our social,
- 0:24political,
- 0:24and economic systems?
- 0:27From Jubilee Media,
- 0:28this is the Surrounded podcast.
- 0:29I'm John Regalado,
- 0:30and today I'm gonna talk to 4 anti-capitalists who each
- 0:33debated Patrick Bet David in last week's episode of Surrounded.
- 0:37They each have their own unique stories and
- 0:39experiences that led them to becoming anti-capitalists,
- 0:42so we'll dig into that,
- 0:42but we'll also hear more about the arguments
- 0:45they had
- 0:46with Patrick in the episode.
- 0:48So let's start with Mason,
- 0:49who was chosen by Patrick
- 0:51to come back to the center at the end of the episode.
- 0:54Hey,
- 0:54Mason.
- 0:55Welcome to this surrounded follow-up.
- 0:57You're,
- 0:57you're a Jubilee veteran though,
- 1:00so,
- 1:00you know,
- 1:00welcome back to the Jubilee universe.
- 1:04Yeah,
- 1:04it's cool to do something,
- 1:05something new uh for the channel.
- 1:07You had some really interesting interactions with,
- 1:10with Patrick on the show.
- 1:12Of all of the debaters,
- 1:13you got,
- 1:14he seemed to
- 1:15maybe connect with you the most,
- 1:17um,
- 1:18because he asked you to come back uh at the very end.
- 1:21Mason,
- 1:22how would you describe your philosophy
- 1:25of politics to someone who's never uh heard of you before or heard you speak?
- 1:32Yeah,
- 1:32I think the easiest way to communicate that to folks is I'm a progressive.
- 1:36I think that that's a label that's
- 1:38easily understandable in today's political climate,
- 1:41um,
- 1:41which means that I am
- 1:43very progressive on social issues.
- 1:45I think our economy needs a lot of work
- 1:47when it comes to prioritizing working class people.
- 1:49I think for too long we've prioritized those that are the upper echelons of wealth,
- 1:53and it's really important that we maximize our
- 1:56Ability to give people positive freedoms.
- 1:58Here in America,
- 1:59we talk a lot about negative freedoms,
- 2:01which for those that don't know,
- 2:02are external or freedoms from external control.
- 2:05So we think of freedom from the government,
- 2:07freedom to express,
- 2:09those are all
- 2:09incredibly important.
- 2:11But I also believe in positive freedoms.
- 2:13I think we should have the freedom to not die from sickness,
- 2:16especially when we have the infrastructure to provide that.
- 2:19We have the wealth to provide that in the wealthiest
- 2:21nation that's ever walked the face of the earth.
- 2:23And so for me,
- 2:24I really want to prioritize people's ability
- 2:26to move through life in the freest way possible
- 2:29and being bogged down by debt
- 2:30or working for a majority of our waking hours
- 2:33is not the way that we maximize freedom for every individual.
- 2:37Yeah,
- 2:37getting a little Timothy Snyder in there with the negative,
- 2:39uh,
- 2:39freedoms.
- 2:40I like it.
- 2:41Yeah.
- 2:42Um,
- 2:42OK,
- 2:43I'm gonna pull up the first clip and we'll just kind of hear your,
- 2:46your reactions to it.
- 2:48And this is in the context of his first claim,
- 2:52incentive is the engine of capitalism.
- 2:54Do you think that capitalism is a system of
- 2:56merit that rewards people that are of higher merit?
- 2:59OK,
- 2:59so how would you say that this is a meritocracy
- 3:01when we have some people that are born into.
- 3:03Excessive wealth and some people that are
- 3:06working minimum wage jobs to provide for 3 or 4 kids.
- 3:08How would you say that that's a,
- 3:09a meritocratic society?
- 3:11Those are two different things when you,
- 3:12right?
- 3:12They are two different things,
- 3:13very unequal things.
- 3:14Well,
- 3:14no,
- 3:14not necessarily.
- 3:15The,
- 3:15the parents
- 3:16get credit for making responsible decisions so they can take care of their kids.
- 3:21The parents get meritocracy that we're,
- 3:22we're building dynasties of wealth.
- 3:23Not not I didn't come from dynasties of wealth.
- 3:25I know you're in 99 cents.
- 3:27I get that.
- 3:27I get that individual.
- 3:28We're talking about systems.
- 3:29Capitalism is a system.
- 3:30It's not an individual testimony that you get to use in your advantage.
- 3:35It's a system that's produced the best results
- 3:37than any other economical system.
- 3:39There's not an economical system
- 3:41that's produced better results than this,
- 3:43based on the incentive.
- 3:45I've talked to a lot of different right wingers on this
- 3:48segment,
- 3:49and,
- 3:49uh,
- 3:49I think that Pat was one of the more calm folks,
- 3:53and I think that just
- 3:54speaks to his
- 3:55business experience working with people that
- 3:58he,
- 3:58he has to posture as very confident regardless of what's going on.
- 4:02So I,
- 4:02I,
- 4:02I think that
- 4:03I kind of came out a little bit more swinging in this,
- 4:06just
- 4:06Because I think this is one of the most important distinctions between
- 4:10people who are big fans of capitalism and people who have critiques.
- 4:14Um,
- 4:14I don't think that innovation solely exists in the current system we have now.
- 4:19Uh,
- 4:19there's an important quote that capitalism is not the end of history.
- 4:24Uh,
- 4:24this is not going to be the best that we can
- 4:26ever come about as a society or as an economic system,
- 4:30and I think even the most strong defenders of capitalism can agree with that,
- 4:35that we haven't solved every issue.
- 4:36There is a lot that can be done.
- 4:38And that was really my
- 4:40philosophy coming in here is,
- 4:42hey,
- 4:42we have a lot of problems.
- 4:43Like Pat said,
- 4:44capitalism is much better than a lot of the systems that we've had in the past.
- 4:49I would prefer the system we have now to a a slave-driven society or a feudal society.
- 4:57Or society under an authoritarian absolute monarch.
- 5:00These,
- 5:00these are,
- 5:01uh,
- 5:01are differences that we can agree that we've progressed from,
- 5:04but I do think that there is progression that is left.
- 5:06No,
- 5:06I'm,
- 5:07I'm glad you acknowledge that,
- 5:08um,
- 5:08because that's what I was gonna ask you if it was if you agreed with him that,
- 5:11you know,
- 5:12up to this point,
- 5:14capitalism has yielded the best results of,
- 5:17of any economic system.
- 5:19Something you brought up in your discussion,
- 5:21uh,
- 5:22with Patrick was,
- 5:23um,
- 5:24FDR.
- 5:25And you know,
- 5:26there's something about Trump that reminds me a little bit of Roosevelt energy,
- 5:30not FDR as much as,
- 5:32as Theodore Roosevelt,
- 5:34but um,
- 5:35you know,
- 5:35he uses the bully pulpit and I think
- 5:38a way that that reminds me a lot of Theodore Roosevelt.
- 5:41But
- 5:42even with FDR,
- 5:43it was,
- 5:44I mean,
- 5:45he's the only president who's had more than 2 terms,
- 5:47I think.
- 5:48His administration,
- 5:49I think,
- 5:49was a period of time where there was a lot of power accumulated.
- 5:54Um,
- 5:54in the presidency,
- 5:55in the executive,
- 5:57and
- 5:58He used that in ways that a lot of us see as beneficial.
- 6:02You brought up Social Security,
- 6:03but do you feel like that kind of,
- 6:05you know,
- 6:06a strong.
- 6:08Leader with an uncomfortable amount of power is necessary to make bold moves.
- 6:16For society.
- 6:18I,
- 6:18I wouldn't compare FDR and Trump as
- 6:22using the,
- 6:22the federal government.
- 6:24I,
- 6:24I see what you're saying with the similarities of
- 6:26the executive branch getting more power,
- 6:28um,
- 6:29but I,
- 6:29I wouldn't say that they're,
- 6:30they're utilizing it in the same way.
- 6:32Uh,
- 6:33FDR's biggest criticism is expanding the courts,
- 6:36but At the same time,
- 6:37he was not violating federal judges' orders.
- 6:40He was not saying that,
- 6:42uh,
- 6:42let's see them enforce it,
- 6:43as Trump has said with many of his unconstitutional acts,
- 6:47and to see a president who is yielding his power in a way
- 6:51that is completely disregarding any of those channels or checks and balances.
- 6:55is something that should be alarming to both Democrat and Republican,
- 6:59but I,
- 6:59I,
- 6:59I don't necessarily think it needs to be from a specific individual.
- 7:03I think like Zoran Mamdani is a good example of this,
- 7:06of there's a lot of fear mongering from the right that Zoran is coming in as a
- 7:10an authoritarian leader who praises Cuba,
- 7:13praises North Korea,
- 7:14this,
- 7:14that and the other.
- 7:15And
- 7:16if you look at Zoran's campaign and you pay attention to
- 7:18any of the rhetoric or the policies that he's proposing,
- 7:21it is all based around
- 7:23the collective support of New Yorkers in the city.
- 7:26He will not be able to achieve a lot of his policies without
- 7:29New Yorkers also holding accountable politicians that are in the state assembly,
- 7:34that are in the state executive government like Kathy Hochel.
- 7:38He just doesn't.
- 7:38have the power to do that,
- 7:39and that's a common criticism that's thrown at him is
- 7:42he does not have the power to unilaterally
- 7:44do rent freezes or to unilaterally create,
- 7:46you know,
- 7:47uh,
- 7:48nonprofit grocery stores.
- 7:50He needs the support of the state assembly,
- 7:52and Zoran admits this.
- 7:53He says,
- 7:53I'm not going to come in here and just disregard our our channels,
- 7:56but I'm championing these policies because I know that these
- 7:59are the solutions that a lot of New Yorkers need,
- 8:02and if we are going to do this,
- 8:03we have to do it together.
- 8:05A populist figurehead to some degree.
- 8:08Um,
- 8:08or a left-wing brand of populism,
- 8:10which we have yet to see
- 8:12happen since maybe Bernie.
- 8:14A question I have for you about Zoran,
- 8:17um,
- 8:17cause this came from Patrick a few times during the episode,
- 8:20is he thinks that,
- 8:21you know,
- 8:22Zoran getting elected is a good thing because people are gonna see
- 8:25those ideas fail.
- 8:27They're gonna see wealth,
- 8:28um,
- 8:29vacate the city.
- 8:30Um,
- 8:31wealthy people go somewhere where,
- 8:33uh,
- 8:33they're not gonna be,
- 8:34uh,
- 8:35taxed or targeted.
- 8:36Um,
- 8:37what would you say to that argument?
- 8:38And,
- 8:38and do you think,
- 8:39uh,
- 8:40if he gets elected,
- 8:41do you think we're gonna see a,
- 8:42a successful,
- 8:43uh,
- 8:44Zoran rather than a,
- 8:46a kind of like
- 8:47shame on,
- 8:48on socialism,
- 8:49Zoran?
- 8:51I,
- 8:51I think that that is a common talking point that's brought
- 8:54up is the wealthy people are all gonna leave if we
- 8:57prioritize working people's dignity.
- 8:59If we give people unionization,
- 9:01companies are just going to completely close and fire everybody.
- 9:04And time after time again,
- 9:06those types of lies and propaganda are proven false.
- 9:10So it's,
- 9:10it's not that wealthy people.
- 9:12People are just going to abandon one of the largest markets in the world,
- 9:15simply because,
- 9:16oh,
- 9:16we,
- 9:16we're starting to prioritize workers' dignity more.
- 9:19This is an adaptation that these types of owners are going to have to live with.
- 9:23And part of what I'm always told by defenders of capitalism is,
- 9:27hey,
- 9:27the cards aren't thrown your way all the time,
- 9:29life isn't fair,
- 9:30things are gonna change,
- 9:31you have to learn to adapt.
- 9:33I'm here saying,
- 9:33OK,
- 9:34these people with vast amounts of wealth,
- 9:35they're gonna learn to adapt with people being able to provide more
- 9:39for their families and being able to spend more in the economy.
- 9:42One of the largest indicators of economic growth
- 9:45is giving working-class people more buying power when
- 9:48it comes to participating in the economy.
- 9:50If these owners who are running a lot of these industries need consumers,
- 9:54you can't have consumers if people don't have the buying.
- 9:56Power to have luxury spending.
- 9:58And with Zoran Mamdani,
- 10:00I think regardless of what happens,
- 10:01I think that it's,
- 10:02it's hard to make stark predictions one way or
- 10:04the other of how these types of administrations play out
- 10:07because there are so many forces that want to see him fail.
- 10:10I,
- 10:10I think it'll be interesting to,
- 10:12to see what his success rate is
- 10:14and how he's able to energize New Yorkers who have a
- 10:17clear passion for what the principles that he proposes are.
- 10:21Mhm.
- 10:21Yeah,
- 10:22I,
- 10:22we're all,
- 10:23we're all eagerly watching.
- 10:24Um,
- 10:25I'm gonna pull up the second clip.
- 10:27A lot of time when you come up with a noble idea to try to fix something today,
- 10:31it ends up getting bigger and you never expected it.
- 10:33When Social Security first came out in 1935,
- 10:36the first benefits were paid in 19397
- 10:38and it was paid in a lump sum.
- 10:40At that time we had 128 million people living in America.
- 10:43Do you know how many people got Social Security?
- 10:4554,000.
- 10:47Do you know when benefits started?
- 10:49Tell me
- 10:4965 years old.
- 10:51So let me say this again to you.
- 10:52Life expectancy
- 10:54was 61.
- 10:56Social Security benefits started at 65.
- 11:00And you're saying because we've increased life,
- 11:01people need to work longer,
- 11:02right?
- 11:0204.
- 11:04So Grandma should be working at the,
- 11:05let me make the mill right now.
- 11:06You can say anything you want to say.
- 11:08Well,
- 11:08I'm just saying you said as life expectancy you are people should be working longer.
- 11:12tell you,
- 11:12you want to extend the retirement age.
- 11:14No,
- 11:14no.
- 11:14If you bring that to today
- 11:16and you bring the math exact same formula as the great FDR came up with,
- 11:19Patrick,
- 11:19here's the difference between our worldviews.
- 11:21You're saying that because Social Security's 340 million people,
- 11:25let me say the point,
- 11:26and then I'll
- 11:26let you speak
- 11:27as long as you wanna speak.
- 11:29So that went from
- 11:30math again for you,
- 11:3154,000.
- 11:33Out of 128 million people,
- 11:350.04%.
- 11:37Life expectancy,
- 11:3861,
- 11:39benefits starts 65.
- 11:40Today
- 11:42it's 74 million
- 11:43out of 340 million,
- 11:46that's 21%
- 11:48when life expectancy is 78,
- 11:51Benefits start at 65%.
- 11:52Do you know who's gonna pay the price on Social Security?
- 11:55Not my generation.
- 11:56Yours is keep doing cuts,
- 11:57correct?
- 11:57If you keep doing cuts,
- 11:58no,
- 11:58because you're gonna run out of money.
- 11:59You're gonna run out of money.
- 12:00That's not how it works.
- 12:01So the difference between our worldview,
- 12:03Patrick,
- 12:03is you're saying not only should people
- 12:04work longer into life because life expectancy.
- 12:06Has increased,
- 12:07but that they should work longer into life without guarantees for healthcare,
- 12:10without preventative care,
- 12:11and that's not only going to increase
- 12:13the deterioration of people's living conditions,
- 12:15it's also going to lead to a worse economy because let me tell you,
- 12:1770-year-olds not going to be the most productive members of our economy.
- 12:20They should be spending time with their families.
- 12:22They should be easing into their passing away.
- 12:24We shouldn't be forcing Grandma to go to the mill.
- 12:25It's going to be on your back.
- 12:26You,
- 12:26you'll be paying for this in 30 years.
- 12:28Appreciate you.
- 12:29What,
- 12:29what comes to mind hearing,
- 12:31hearing that last exchange?
- 12:33Yeah,
- 12:34I mean,
- 12:34Patrick,
- 12:35the thing that I'll credit him is he knows his conservative talking points to a T.
- 12:40So I'm,
- 12:40I'm glad that he's able to just,
- 12:42uh,
- 12:42regurgitate this like I've heard so many times,
- 12:45but it really is like the affordability problem for Social Security
- 12:49has always been a political problem.
- 12:51It's not an economic one.
- 12:53The,
- 12:53the program only faces shortfalls.
- 12:55There's like expectations from 2030 of running out of money for it,
- 12:58not because it's unaffordable,
- 13:00but because Congress intentionally.
- 13:02Taxable income.
- 13:04So right now,
- 13:05for those listening,
- 13:05if you look this up,
- 13:07only wages up to around $170,000 are taxed,
- 13:11and that means that a millionaire stops paying FICA taxes,
- 13:14which contributes to Social Security
- 13:16by like February,
- 13:17where middle-class workers are paying all year round.
- 13:20And so while yes,
- 13:21some,
- 13:21most of the time these wealthy people are paying more when it comes to total sum,
- 13:26they are not paying proportional percentages when it comes to
- 13:28the amount of money that they're accumulating all year.
- 13:31So lifting or just completely eliminating this gap
- 13:34would completely close all of the funding issues that
- 13:37we're seeing without cutting any Social Security benefits.
- 13:41So it really is like a question of fairness.
- 13:43Should the rich contribute more because they have the ability to contribute more,
- 13:47or no,
- 13:48should we allow
- 13:49middle class and lower income people
- 13:51to continue to pay more of their salary,
- 13:54um,
- 13:54in the name of creating more sustainability
- 13:57or more economic productivity for them.
- 14:00I appreciate you bringing that down and I'm,
- 14:02I'm gonna look that up because that was one of my questions,
- 14:05which was,
- 14:06how do,
- 14:07how does,
- 14:08how can you save Social Security when you look at the math the way
- 14:11Patrick presented it.
- 14:13Um,
- 14:14another question I have though is,
- 14:16and you're,
- 14:16I'm sure you're familiar with this,
- 14:17you know,
- 14:17the,
- 14:18um,
- 14:19Ezra Klein's book,
- 14:21uh,
- 14:21Abundance has sort of sparked this discussion on whether.
- 14:25Blue states and blue cities specifically
- 14:29mismanaged governance
- 14:31or mishandled it and created bloat,
- 14:34whether that be regulations that slowed down the development of housing,
- 14:38which caused
- 14:39a housing crisis,
- 14:41which grew
- 14:41homeless populations in those cities,
- 14:43which sparked violence.
- 14:45There,
- 14:45there's a conversation that
- 14:47when Democrats have the power
- 14:50and they have good intentions,
- 14:51like
- 14:53Patrick was saying.
- 14:55It sometimes blows up into
- 14:57a system that that is either bloating
- 15:00or
- 15:01preventing common sense.
- 15:03What do you think?
- 15:06Yeah,
- 15:06I,
- 15:07I think that the,
- 15:08the abundance debate is,
- 15:10it's really just a repackaged version of neoliberalism,
- 15:13which is prioritizing market control
- 15:15or private development or private enterprise
- 15:18over nonprofit and public understanding of what our specific demands are.
- 15:23So,
- 15:23I think that things like inelastic goods,
- 15:25which are goods that are going to be
- 15:27purchased by consumers regardless of price inflation,
- 15:31these are things like housing,
- 15:32these are things like Education,
- 15:34healthcare,
- 15:35pharmaceuticals,
- 15:36anything that people rely on,
- 15:38you know,
- 15:38if I'm a diabetic and insulin costs $1000 or it costs $10
- 15:42I'm going to buy it regardless.
- 15:44And these types of goods cannot be properly managed by market
- 15:48rule or by profit seeking motives.
- 15:51Um,
- 15:51and I think that
- 15:52a lot of times the,
- 15:53the abundance debate is,
- 15:54is a criticism or a condemnation
- 15:57over,
- 15:58uh,
- 15:58corporate,
- 16:00Democrat.
- 16:01Attempts
- 16:02to appease people who want nonprofit production
- 16:04when it comes to these inelastic goods,
- 16:06and I think that the problem that we're seeing in a lot of blue cities
- 16:09is there,
- 16:11there's this sense that,
- 16:12you know,
- 16:12these blue cities are so progressive and they're so woke,
- 16:15California is California,
- 16:17baby,
- 16:17and when you look at it,
- 16:18when you look at the prioritization in our market,
- 16:21this is nowhere near a worker dominated economy.
- 16:24We have some of the wealthiest technocrats,
- 16:27we have some of the The wealthiest cities and the prioritization
- 16:31of single family homes like in San Francisco,
- 16:33where there is no uh is no housing development that's being allowed.
- 16:37Um,
- 16:37there's no public housing because of NIMBYs and people who say,
- 16:40I don't want to see that as I'm going about the street because there are a bunch of
- 16:44poor people that are living in those homes and
- 16:45it's taking away from the character of my neighborhood.
- 16:48These are the wealthy prioritizations in a place like California
- 16:51that is masked with this veneer of progressivism.
- 16:54And so that I think that that is really where the abundance argument falls flat
- 16:59is saying that,
- 17:00oh,
- 17:00we just need more prioritization of private
- 17:03development or profit seeking motives when we've
- 17:06seen that fail in so many of the cities who already have that,
- 17:09you have to make the distinction of what,
- 17:11what is being labeled as progressive.
- 17:13Is it the social issues?
- 17:14Is it the ways that they handle law enforcement?
- 17:17Is it the,
- 17:17the housing that they provide for folks?
- 17:19Like these,
- 17:20these are the real questions on,
- 17:22on what
- 17:23a city quote unquote progressive
- 17:25or what makes it prioritizing capital interests.
- 17:28And so that really begs the question of
- 17:30where is the prioritization on access to this abundance that we already have,
- 17:34this false scarcity that continues to be propagated by wealthy elites.
- 17:38Um,
- 17:39this really should be the question that we're focusing on
- 17:42is how do we get more access to those goods,
- 17:44whether that's buybacks or whether that's land seizures or
- 17:47whatever the case,
- 17:48in order to make sure that we are
- 17:50are properly prioritizing
- 17:52the,
- 17:52the health and security and the well-being of people that live in the country,
- 17:55as opposed to the wallets or the investments or the
- 17:59returns on investments of people who are private developers or
- 18:03wealthy landlords.
- 18:04Um,
- 18:05something I've,
- 18:06I've heard recently is,
- 18:07you know,
- 18:08you mentioned taxation,
- 18:09um,
- 18:10wealth redistribution,
- 18:12social services.
- 18:14I've,
- 18:14I kind of have picked up a sentiment that,
- 18:16um,
- 18:18Those kinds of things could make the US less competitive with other world powers.
- 18:24And do you worry that at a time
- 18:27when there's kind of this AI arms race ramping up between,
- 18:31you know,
- 18:32China and the US,
- 18:33do you worry that,
- 18:35Uh,
- 18:36if the US falls behind,
- 18:37it won't have technological supremacy,
- 18:40and,
- 18:40and that could lead to,
- 18:41uh,
- 18:42to a world where
- 18:44a less preferred form of government or a less preferred
- 18:48world superpower is,
- 18:49is calling the shots.
- 18:51Just the first part of your question was,
- 18:53do you think the
- 18:54overemphasis on social programs that what you said,
- 18:56can get rid of our competitive edge?
- 18:58Yeah,
- 18:59would that,
- 18:59would that slow the US down or,
- 19:01or possibly um move talent and capital out of the US and,
- 19:06and to our competitors in a way that would,
- 19:09you know,
- 19:11Jeopardize the US's position as as a world power.
- 19:15Do you think that matters?
- 19:17Yeah,
- 19:17I,
- 19:17I think that,
- 19:18uh,
- 19:19we're,
- 19:19I mean,
- 19:20you mentioned it would lead to a
- 19:21less democratic or less desirable political system,
- 19:25and I think that that's gonna happen regardless.
- 19:27Um,
- 19:27I think that we are slowly moving either into economic collectivization
- 19:31or we're moving into an ethnic or cultural form of authoritarian control
- 19:37or what a lot of people are calling fascism.
- 19:39And I think that that really are the
- 19:40only two outcomes because of this affordability crisis.
- 19:44There are so many people who recognize that they don't live
- 19:46in a system that prioritizes their growth or their well-being,
- 19:50and it's really who the problem is that people are trying to identify.
- 19:54Is the problem
- 19:55these
- 19:56lower income or
- 19:58Skilled workers that are coming in from developing nations,
- 20:01is it the LGBTQ people that live in my neighborhoods,
- 20:04or is it wealthy interests who really call the
- 20:06shots and have the most influence in our social,
- 20:08political,
- 20:08and economic systems?
- 20:10All right,
- 20:10well,
- 20:10Mason,
- 20:11thank you so much.
- 20:12This won't be the last time we,
- 20:13we speak and hopefully we see each other again on a,
- 20:15on a set.
- 20:18Yeah,
- 20:18thanks,
- 20:18Sean.
- 20:18I,
- 20:18I really appreciate this and I appreciate talking with you.
- 20:22I also spoke to Gabby who debated Patrick twice in the center,
- 20:25and what was interesting about Gabby was she seemed to be very comfortable
- 20:29aggressively coming at Patrick,
- 20:30and there were multiple times where it really seemed like they were debating
- 20:34almost as equals,
- 20:35and I thought it was interesting how well she held her
- 20:37ground and I thought she pushed Patrick to some interesting places,
- 20:40and he also pushed her to some interesting places.
- 20:43So I wanted to learn more about her guiding philosophy
- 20:46that has led her to identifying as a democratic socialist.
- 20:50And hey,
- 20:50Gabby.
- 20:51OK,
- 20:51awesome.
- 20:52Hi,
- 20:52how's it going?
- 20:53Uh,
- 20:53how are you doing?
- 20:55I'm doing great.
- 20:56Yeah,
- 20:56thanks so much for having me.
- 20:57I appreciate it.
- 20:58Um,
- 20:59so you went toe to toe with Patrick Bett David,
- 21:03and
- 21:04of all the people in the episode,
- 21:06you really,
- 21:07um,
- 21:07caught my attention as somebody who really could confidently,
- 21:11uh,
- 21:11spar with him.
- 21:12That means a lot.
- 21:13Thank you.
- 21:14Um,
- 21:14I was very,
- 21:15very.
- 21:15Very nervous.
- 21:16I was practically shitting myself the entire time.
- 21:19So
- 21:19I'm glad that um that wasn't seen by people who were watching the episode.
- 21:25Yeah,
- 21:25it was just a close up
- 21:27most of the time.
- 21:28So we,
- 21:28we did not see.
- 21:30Yeah,
- 21:31let's watch the first clip.
- 21:32OK.
- 21:33I'm,
- 21:33I'm a democratic socialist.
- 21:34I think that we need to build
- 21:36forward towards that,
- 21:37um,
- 21:37with reforms,
- 21:38and I think we need to work with the government.
- 21:40I don't think that we should abandon the state.
- 21:41I also don't think that we should give
- 21:42state elites the complete control over society.
- 21:45I do think that we should
- 21:46work with the state to instill these reforms and then eventually erode capitalism.
- 21:49Unfortunately,
- 21:51socialism has had hundreds of.
- 21:52You're thinking in terms of competition produce results and it hasn't worked.
- 21:55Do you know why it doesn't work though?
- 21:56It's been sabotaged.
- 21:57It's been sabotaged,
- 21:58or it's because it forces people to do something they don't want to do.
- 22:01Does capitalism not do the same?
- 22:02No capitalism there's 7 million people in this country who have to
- 22:06work multiple jobs just to get by to work multiple jobs.
- 22:09They're forced to do that because either they do that or they starve,
- 22:12so.
- 22:12If the options are to work or to starve,
- 22:14that's not freedom,
- 22:15that's economic coercion.
- 22:16If you do,
- 22:16respectfully,
- 22:17if you do that for a period of your life,
- 22:19I understand it.
- 22:20If you're doing that for 30 years,
- 22:22you're doing something wrong.
- 22:23You shouldn't be working multiple jobs for the rest of your life.
- 22:26All right,
- 22:26so
- 22:27after seeing that first clip,
- 22:28uh,
- 22:28what's your reaction just to,
- 22:30to seeing it and reliving it?
- 22:34Yeah,
- 22:35um.
- 22:37Patrick,
- 22:39he was very civil,
- 22:40and I will give him that.
- 22:41Um,
- 22:42I've seen
- 22:43previous Jubilee episodes and the people in his seat tend to be quite combative,
- 22:47and
- 22:48I found him to be one of the more
- 22:49polite and cordial ones.
- 22:51So,
- 22:51I'll start with uh that positive about him.
- 22:54I do think that he has a tendency to
- 22:57be very scattered.
- 22:58He sort of throws out these very loosely connected points.
- 23:02And it's really hard to debate with someone like that because
- 23:06you can't fully unpack their line of reasoning.
- 23:09Um,
- 23:10and so I would love to sit down with him
- 23:11for longer if he would have me on his value attainment
- 23:14podcast,
- 23:15um,
- 23:16because I'd love to unpack that further.
- 23:17I think it was
- 23:18heading in an interesting direction.
- 23:21Um,
- 23:21but unfortunately,
- 23:23he has a very narrow view of the world.
- 23:25He only thinks of society through,
- 23:28uh,
- 23:29capitalist terms and through competition,
- 23:32and he can't envision a society without market mechanisms.
- 23:35Uh,
- 23:35something you kind of open up with at
- 23:37the beginning is identifying as a democratic socialist.
- 23:40Have you been exposed to that idea and,
- 23:43and eventually kind of become an advocate for it?
- 23:47Yeah,
- 23:47I'm.
- 23:48I think it started when I was young.
- 23:51Obviously,
- 23:51I haven't always identified this way.
- 23:53Um,
- 23:53I didn't have the language when I was younger,
- 23:55but I think that
- 23:56it's rooted in sort of childhood.
- 23:59I grew up in
- 24:00a
- 24:01fairly conservative suburb in Orange County,
- 24:03and I was surrounded by a lot of wealth.
- 24:06I grew up with a lot of privilege,
- 24:07and
- 24:08it was kind of all I was used to.
- 24:11Um,
- 24:11it was definitely a bubble of sorts,
- 24:13you know,
- 24:13everyone around me had
- 24:14really,
- 24:14really nice houses and cars and would go on fancy vacations and
- 24:18I kind of grew up with this idea that that's how the world worked.
- 24:22Um,
- 24:23and then when I eventually,
- 24:25you know,
- 24:25went to college,
- 24:26um,
- 24:26in Oregon,
- 24:28that bubble sort of burst a little bit,
- 24:29and I was sort of exposed to,
- 24:32um,
- 24:32just
- 24:33different political realities,
- 24:35um,
- 24:36and
- 24:37Sort of had to re-examine mine,
- 24:38um,
- 24:39and realized that I had taken it for,
- 24:40for granted for most,
- 24:41most of my life.
- 24:42Um,
- 24:43in college,
- 24:44I got involved with Planned Parenthood.
- 24:45I got involved with labor unions.
- 24:47I did a lot of organizing work,
- 24:48and that included canvassing to a lot of like different voters around Oregon.
- 24:53And I had conversations with,
- 24:55you know,
- 24:56people who were losing their healthcare benefits
- 24:58at work or didn't have union representation,
- 25:00weren't getting paid a fair wage,
- 25:02couldn't pay their rent.
- 25:03Um,
- 25:04so that really did open my eyes to like,
- 25:06OK,
- 25:06this isn't just some abstract,
- 25:08like,
- 25:09political talking point.
- 25:10Like this is people's real lives.
- 25:12Um,
- 25:13it's not right.
- 25:13I mean,
- 25:14we live in the wealthiest country in the world.
- 25:16Why are 40 million people living in poverty?
- 25:19Like it doesn't make sense.
- 25:20Something wasn't adding up.
- 25:21Um,
- 25:22and I also sort of experienced my own form of downward mobility economically.
- 25:27Um,
- 25:27I started struggling with like,
- 25:29having to stretch paychecks and making rent and deciding between bills.
- 25:33So,
- 25:34you know,
- 25:35my own sort of lived experience in that way,
- 25:37but mostly,
- 25:38um,
- 25:38hearing from people across the state,
- 25:40uh,
- 25:40people in rural areas and urban areas who are just
- 25:43struggling to deal with the cost of living.
- 25:45Um,
- 25:46and that really just
- 25:48I guess kind of radicalized me in a way.
- 25:50Um,
- 25:50you mentioned,
- 25:51you know,
- 25:51hey,
- 25:51I'm a democratic socialist right now,
- 25:53but the end goal could be,
- 25:54you know,
- 25:54a more,
- 25:55a more complete or holistic form of socialism.
- 25:59Do you think China figured something out?
- 26:02And I mean,
- 26:02I think this is really taboo to say
- 26:05in the US right now,
- 26:06especially if we're talking to older generations,
- 26:09but I'm hearing it more and more online.
- 26:10Do you think China has figured something out that's really appealing to
- 26:15people in the US,
- 26:16um,
- 26:18In a way that maybe hasn't,
- 26:19it hasn't before.
- 26:20Do you think there's,
- 26:21there are ideas there that,
- 26:23that,
- 26:23uh,
- 26:24the US has looked past?
- 26:28You know,
- 26:28I think
- 26:30I think there's a lot of
- 26:32moral panic around China,
- 26:34mostly propagated by
- 26:35the right.
- 26:36Um,
- 26:37and I think it's unfortunate because I think China has done a lot of things well.
- 26:42I think I mentioned this in the video,
- 26:43but um
- 26:44they had the most significant poverty reduction in human history.
- 26:47They pulled 800 million people out of poverty,
- 26:50and they did that using state-owned enterprises.
- 26:53Um,
- 26:53and so I think,
- 26:54you know,
- 26:55It,
- 26:55it,
- 26:56it's a country that has its faults like any other,
- 26:58and it's,
- 26:58I,
- 26:59it's
- 26:59very far from a,
- 27:01a socialist or communist country.
- 27:02People who call it that or
- 27:05Absolutely insane because it's,
- 27:06it's clearly not.
- 27:07Um,
- 27:07it's a very capitalist country at this point.
- 27:10Um,
- 27:10and it's,
- 27:11you know,
- 27:12a leading global force.
- 27:13Um,
- 27:14I do think like,
- 27:16We
- 27:17dismissed China's accomplishments and China's successes because of
- 27:22this sort of like red scare McCarthyism,
- 27:25um,
- 27:25like point of view.
- 27:27When someone,
- 27:28you know,
- 27:28Patrick kind of tried to hint at this,
- 27:30I don't think it ever fully entered the conversation.
- 27:33But,
- 27:33you know,
- 27:34you say,
- 27:34hey,
- 27:35we haven't tried socialism,
- 27:37we haven't given it a fair shot here in the US,
- 27:40um,
- 27:41but I think a lot of times people say,
- 27:44well,
- 27:44in history,
- 27:45it certainly has had a fair shot,
- 27:47and they'll point to atrocities,
- 27:50uh,
- 27:50done by Stalin or in China's past,
- 27:53um,
- 27:54and,
- 27:54and they use those as cases to say,
- 27:56look,
- 27:57this is the result of this,
- 27:59um,
- 27:59philosophy of government.
- 28:01What would your response be to that?
- 28:04Yeah,
- 28:04it's,
- 28:04it's a great point,
- 28:05and I understand the concern.
- 28:07Um,
- 28:07I think that
- 28:08when we look at certain examples,
- 28:10like,
- 28:10for instance,
- 28:10you said Stalin,
- 28:12um,
- 28:12the USSR,
- 28:13it's,
- 28:15it's hard to call that socialism.
- 28:17Um,
- 28:17and,
- 28:17and I think
- 28:19You know,
- 28:19there are,
- 28:20there are some people that I know that would consider themselves to be Stalinists,
- 28:23um,
- 28:23and I,
- 28:24and I have mixed sort of feelings about that,
- 28:25um,
- 28:26but I do think that.
- 28:28Uh,
- 28:28it's,
- 28:29uh,
- 28:29I,
- 28:29I definitely have my,
- 28:30my own feelings about,
- 28:31about that part of history,
- 28:32but I think that
- 28:34we can look at,
- 28:35um,
- 28:35when we look at those periods,
- 28:37we can sort of remind ourselves that like,
- 28:39These are examples of top-down authoritarianism,
- 28:42and that's
- 28:43something Rosa Luxembourg said is like
- 28:46socialism without democracy will inevitably turn into authoritarianism.
- 28:50And so we have to have some sort of democratic system in place,
- 28:53which is why I call myself a democratic socialist.
- 28:56I'm not huge about labels,
- 28:57but I do like to
- 28:59call myself that because I think that we
- 29:01need to use reforms as a means to a larger end.
- 29:05And I don't think I think that
- 29:08investing in one leader
- 29:09is good for the movement,
- 29:11you know,
- 29:11it's supposed to come from the masses,
- 29:13it's supposed to come from the working majority.
- 29:15It's not supposed to come from um a power hungry,
- 29:18uh,
- 29:19you know,
- 29:19dictator.
- 29:20And so I think that we
- 29:22need um a bottom-up form of socialism.
- 29:24We need
- 29:25worker co-ops,
- 29:25we need participatory budgeting,
- 29:27we need people deciding how our economic system works,
- 29:30um,
- 29:31and that can only be done if we have like
- 29:34a.
- 29:34You know,
- 29:35a fair election system in place.
- 29:37Mhm.
- 29:38Um,
- 29:39let's watch the second clip.
- 29:41Because when you say what you say about,
- 29:43say,
- 29:43the,
- 29:43the Democratic side on the climate change side.
- 29:46The guy that's worked towards that the most,
- 29:48you guys loved him
- 29:49till he supported Trump.
- 29:50Elon was your favorite eight years ago until he supported Trump.
- 29:53The moment he went into Trump,
- 29:54this guy's a horrible guy.
- 29:56This guy's a terrible guy.
- 29:57To be fair,
- 29:57I've hated Elon Musk consistently throughout my adult life,
- 30:00and
- 30:01I also think that he is someone who has benefited immensely from the government.
- 30:06That's why I find hypocrisy in what you're saying.
- 30:07I don't disagree on that side.
- 30:09Benefited immensely from the exploitation of labor overseas.
- 30:12He's benefited immensely from his extremely aggressive union tactics,
- 30:16union busting tactics,
- 30:17tactics.
- 30:17So I'm saying like,
- 30:18why is he a net positive to you for society?
- 30:21Is he a net positive for me personally?
- 30:22Is he a net positive for society,
- 30:24not for you?
- 30:25I wouldn't say so.
- 30:26You don't think he is.
- 30:26No,
- 30:27I wouldn't say so.
- 30:27Who is a net positive to society?
- 30:29Bernie Sanders.
- 30:30I would,
- 30:30I mean,
- 30:31Bernie Sanders is,
- 30:32I would say he's a compromise candidate.
- 30:33It,
- 30:33but I would say that he's a compromise candidate.
- 30:35Yes,
- 30:35it was AOC,
- 30:37a net positive to society.
- 30:38I would say net positive,
- 30:39yes,
- 30:39more than Musk is.
- 30:40Yes,
- 30:41really.
- 30:41Tell me why.
- 30:42Because AOC wants to introduce a Green New Deal,
- 30:45and I think that the New Deal is the closest thing trillion dollars.
- 30:48OK,
- 30:49Trump literally just added $3.4 trillion to our deficit.
- 30:52So I really don't want to hear $30 trillion.
- 30:54OK,
- 30:54so I'm $3 trillion.
- 30:55Oh gosh.
- 30:57It's so fun.
- 30:58Um,
- 30:59so yeah,
- 30:59we got to get into the Elon of it all just because he's the perfect Ror Rorschach.
- 31:04Um,
- 31:06what do you think,
- 31:06what do you think's the problem with someone,
- 31:08a figure like Elon,
- 31:09because I think it's undeniable that
- 31:12he has contributed to the fields of science and industry,
- 31:16but
- 31:17the conversation doesn't stop there.
- 31:18What do you think's the issue with someone like Elon?
- 31:21Um,
- 31:21I think that Elon.
- 31:24I mean,
- 31:25beyond his,
- 31:26his political beliefs and his political stunts with Trump in the past few years,
- 31:31um,
- 31:32he,
- 31:32I would say that he's been a net negative for society to go by PBD's terms.
- 31:38I think that he
- 31:41Um,
- 31:43Elon
- 31:45Takes advantage of
- 31:47a system that was built
- 31:50for,
- 31:50for him to hoard wealth.
- 31:51And so on one hand,
- 31:54he's a symptom,
- 31:55you know,
- 31:55he's not an anomaly.
- 31:57There's plenty of people like Elon,
- 31:59there's plenty of
- 32:00Bezos and Zuckerbergs in this world,
- 32:02uh,
- 32:02maybe a little less wealthy,
- 32:03but there's plenty of 1 percenters who have taken advantage of our tax loopholes,
- 32:08our lack of regulations,
- 32:10and
- 32:11there have been multiple reports that he's
- 32:14Participated in union busting tactics,
- 32:16um,
- 32:17you know,
- 32:18he
- 32:18gets billions of dollars from our government
- 32:21and then the government neglects to actually
- 32:23pour that money into things like healthcare,
- 32:26education,
- 32:27things that we actually need and want,
- 32:28um,
- 32:28and have requested,
- 32:30um,
- 32:30and I think that
- 32:31someone with that amount of money,
- 32:33someone who's the richest person in the world,
- 32:35has the power
- 32:37to
- 32:38fix
- 32:39the,
- 32:40uh,
- 32:41The things that plague our society,
- 32:43and,
- 32:43and,
- 32:43and I know that's maybe a simplistic way of looking at it,
- 32:46but
- 32:48He has the power and he has neglected,
- 32:50uh,
- 32:50he's neglected that power,
- 32:52and I think that's a deliberate choice.
- 32:53I think that,
- 32:55you know,
- 32:55something Patrick David did really well in his debate is
- 33:00he really like
- 33:01He did this rhetorical questioning of like,
- 33:03OK,
- 33:04if
- 33:05you're an anti-capitalist,
- 33:06then why won't you accept this job for me?
- 33:08And I think that that exemplifies what billionaires do on a regular basis.
- 33:12They
- 33:12don't pay their
- 33:13taxes,
- 33:14but then they pour
- 33:16millions of dollars into the charity of their choice,
- 33:18and then they get away with,
- 33:19you know,
- 33:19the sort of performative optics thing.
- 33:22It's very calculated,
- 33:24and I don't,
- 33:24I don't trust someone who has that much money
- 33:26and does so little with it to help society.
- 33:29At the end there,
- 33:31Patrick tried to steer it towards um.
- 33:37AOC
- 33:38and
- 33:39you,
- 33:39you kind of referred to AOC as just maybe somebody who's
- 33:43a net positive for society and,
- 33:45and you brought up the Green New Deal
- 33:47and then
- 33:48there were some numbers kind of getting
- 33:49thrown around like 30 trillion versus 3 trillion
- 33:53and so this is another critique that comes up a lot is,
- 33:56hey,
- 33:56these ideas that socialism advocates for
- 34:00cost
- 34:01too much money.
- 34:03And
- 34:04that money will,
- 34:05you know,
- 34:05that will unravel
- 34:07the government and the,
- 34:09the stability of our society.
- 34:11What,
- 34:11what would you say to that argument?
- 34:13Um,
- 34:13I would say implement a wealth tax
- 34:16that could easily pay for it.
- 34:17If we look back at,
- 34:19you know,
- 34:19FDR's New Deal,
- 34:21um,
- 34:21he
- 34:22Basically helped pull this country out of the Great Depression
- 34:26by implementing a 70 to I think 94% marginal tax rate
- 34:31um on
- 34:32the ultra rich,
- 34:33not on
- 34:33middle-class people,
- 34:35um,
- 34:36not on poor people,
- 34:36on the ultra rich and.
- 34:38Society,
- 34:39um,
- 34:39and he was able to give people,
- 34:41um,
- 34:42you know,
- 34:42job training,
- 34:43uh,
- 34:44education,
- 34:45health care,
- 34:45all of these things,
- 34:46um,
- 34:47and unemployment vastly dropped after the Great Depression because of this,
- 34:51this program
- 34:52that he had in place.
- 34:53And so I think,
- 34:54you know,
- 34:55um,
- 34:55people
- 34:56can argue different
- 34:57types of tax rates,
- 34:59uh,
- 34:59you know,
- 34:59if it's more of like a progressive or gradual tax rate,
- 35:02but I think that a wealth tax is,
- 35:04is ultimately what we need to start with,
- 35:05you know,
- 35:06and I think that.
- 35:07I was trying to ask Patrick
- 35:10why he doesn't support
- 35:12a wealth tax on billionaires,
- 35:14and I was trying to ask him if someone could reasonably live
- 35:16off of just $999 million and he refused to answer that question
- 35:21because he knows
- 35:22how absurd that is,
- 35:23you know,
- 35:24no one needs that much money,
- 35:26and
- 35:27yeah,
- 35:28it's a great question,
- 35:29like why
- 35:30should we be paying so much for these public goods.
- 35:33I think that we should because we see in Scandinavian and Nordic countries
- 35:39that when people have their material needs met,
- 35:41they do better.
- 35:42It's shockingly,
- 35:43you know,
- 35:43they're not burnt out and they
- 35:45have time to invest in in what they'd like to
- 35:48do and they can pursue their passions and their dreams because
- 35:51they're not saddled with things like
- 35:53student debt,
- 35:53you know,
- 35:54or they don't have to worry about rent next month.
- 35:56Um,
- 35:56and then I think what I heard him say is like,
- 35:59I can't wait for Zoran to win.
- 36:01And for all of the billionaires to leave New York,
- 36:04what,
- 36:05what do we do if,
- 36:07you know,
- 36:07do you think it's true that in a scenario where we implement a wealth tax
- 36:11in the country or in a specific city that the wealth will just vacate,
- 36:16you know,
- 36:17the,
- 36:17the,
- 36:17they'll find a loophole,
- 36:18they'll find a way to get their,
- 36:19their wealth out of
- 36:21that city or out of that country.
- 36:24I mean,
- 36:24that's what's very challenging about this at this point.
- 36:27It's,
- 36:27it's challenging to
- 36:31Billionaires have,
- 36:32you know,
- 36:33plenty of offshore,
- 36:34uh,
- 36:34bank accounts and things that we plenty of assets that we don't know about.
- 36:37It's not just like tangible money,
- 36:40um,
- 36:40in a bank account
- 36:41per se.
- 36:41So it,
- 36:42it's difficult to,
- 36:43to sort of navigate that.
- 36:44But I think that,
- 36:45um.
- 36:46You know,
- 36:46to that point,
- 36:48if billionaires are fleeing a city,
- 36:50I,
- 36:50I think that's
- 36:52a sign of
- 36:53economic fragility.
- 36:54I mean,
- 36:54if,
- 36:54if they can't afford to live there anymore because of the wealth tax,
- 36:58um,
- 36:58I think that says more about their economic state.
- 37:01And I also think that
- 37:03if his fear is that we're going to lose jobs,
- 37:06you know,
- 37:06these people provide jobs,
- 37:07they create jobs,
- 37:08that's his argument,
- 37:10um,
- 37:10then.
- 37:11Investing in the public good with with that wealth wealth tax,
- 37:15um,
- 37:15will provide a safety net for people who do lose their jobs,
- 37:18you know,
- 37:19and so
- 37:19I think that,
- 37:20um,
- 37:21you know,
- 37:22yeah,
- 37:22I,
- 37:23I don't really have a huge issue with billionaires being
- 37:26driven out of the city,
- 37:27but
- 37:28I understand the concern,
- 37:29um.
- 37:30I do think that this world would be better off
- 37:33without billionaires,
- 37:34and I,
- 37:34I don't just say that as like a tacky,
- 37:36uh,
- 37:37you know,
- 37:37Instagram slogan.
- 37:38I say that
- 37:38truly,
- 37:39like we,
- 37:40we do not need these people
- 37:42um
- 37:43hoarding this much wealth from us because that's,
- 37:45that's theft,
- 37:45that they're taking away from the rest of us.
- 37:47They're taking away from the working majority.
- 37:49My spitball
- 37:51gut feeling is like.
- 37:53If you move in a socialist direction,
- 37:55you need a really strong centralized government,
- 37:58and that incentivizes
- 38:00innovative,
- 38:01ambitious people to accumulate
- 38:04in that state.
- 38:06And power can accumulate there.
- 38:09And that's where the innovation happens and
- 38:11maybe that's what's happening in China,
- 38:12you know,
- 38:13they're,
- 38:13they're doing incredible things,
- 38:15um,
- 38:15building incredible things,
- 38:17and I think that's because the
- 38:18brightest people operate closer to the state,
- 38:23but there's also concerns that
- 38:25that pop up and,
- 38:26you know,
- 38:26surveillance and,
- 38:28and essentially,
- 38:29you know,
- 38:30control being.
- 38:32To
- 38:33centralized.
- 38:34And then there's the opposite here we have
- 38:36in the US,
- 38:37you know,
- 38:37we're,
- 38:38we're really the wild west and we want people to
- 38:42Be able to go as big as they
- 38:45like,
- 38:46and that creates the Elon Musk's and the Mark Zuckerberg's and the Bezos,
- 38:50and they
- 38:51innovate,
- 38:51you know,
- 38:51we all.
- 38:53We're probably using
- 38:553 or 4 things that a billionaire created at this very moment,
- 38:58but
- 38:59we have to deal with.
- 39:02Their
- 39:03midlife crises in the process,
- 39:05and that's what I would probably describe Elon's
- 39:08behavior as.
- 39:08It's like,
- 39:09yes,
- 39:09the man's achieved things,
- 39:11but.
- 39:12We all are kind of
- 39:13very much a part of his life more than I think we would like.
- 39:16And so I found myself listening to you and Patrick,
- 39:20because you were both sparring so well,
- 39:22and I,
- 39:22you know,
- 39:22it was a really great conversation,
- 39:24I found myself being able to kind of see
- 39:27the outcomes of,
- 39:28of both sides in a certain way and,
- 39:30and not really knowing um where I stood.
- 39:33Yeah,
- 39:34yeah,
- 39:34I understand that.
- 39:35And I think it's,
- 39:36it's such a nuanced issue.
- 39:38Um,
- 39:39I think this
- 39:40particular topic is really tough because
- 39:43it's all we know.
- 39:44You know,
- 39:44we've only grown up in a capitalist society.
- 39:46I've never grown up in a socialist country.
- 39:48Um,
- 39:49I've never even grown up in a country with a social democracy.
- 39:51You know,
- 39:52I didn't grow up in,
- 39:53in,
- 39:53you know,
- 39:54Scandinavia.
- 39:55So I think that it's,
- 39:57it's hard to know how these Things would would look like,
- 40:00but I think that what we do know is that
- 40:03currently
- 40:04DSA has the most members that it's ever had,
- 40:06and it's,
- 40:08you know,
- 40:08a very effective movement.
- 40:09That's how Zoron got elected in the first place,
- 40:12um,
- 40:13and I think.
- 40:14It,
- 40:14it says something that this guy with virtually no name recognition
- 40:18and like all of New York's real estate money pit against him,
- 40:22um,
- 40:22was able to like shake up the whole country and
- 40:25was able to win his election,
- 40:27you know,
- 40:27like,
- 40:28he clearly He wasn't pitching utopia.
- 40:30He was talking about freezing the rents,
- 40:32um,
- 40:33and that resonated with working people across New York and across America.
- 40:37What,
- 40:38what's stopping you from,
- 40:39uh,
- 40:40running for office?
- 40:41Why don't you go find a district and,
- 40:43and try and get into Congress?
- 40:45Oh gosh,
- 40:46um.
- 40:47You know,
- 40:48funny enough,
- 40:48like I.
- 40:51The jubilee thing was really scary for me.
- 40:53And I get really freaked out by public speaking.
- 40:56If any of my
- 40:57fellow grad cohort members end up listening to this,
- 41:00like,
- 41:01they know,
- 41:01like,
- 41:01I hate giving presentations.
- 41:03Like,
- 41:04I don't really like to be like the front face of things.
- 41:06Um.
- 41:07One of the more exciting things about Jubilee is I would like to see people.
- 41:11Go on the show and then,
- 41:13you know,
- 41:14become
- 41:15thought leaders or,
- 41:16or honestly even run for office after,
- 41:19you know,
- 41:19seeing that they have a skill for,
- 41:21for,
- 41:22for being a thought leader.
- 41:23We need more uh strong communicators,
- 41:26um,
- 41:27in,
- 41:28in the marketplace of ideas,
- 41:29and you also need people who are hesitant to be leaders,
- 41:33sometimes those are the best,
- 41:34best folks for the job.
- 41:37Yeah,
- 41:37I appreciate that.
- 41:38Yeah.
- 41:38And I think,
- 41:39uh,
- 41:39I,
- 41:39I completely,
- 41:41I'm very,
- 41:41very grateful for Jubilee as a platform.
- 41:44I think
- 41:45I have my qualms with like,
- 41:47yes,
- 41:47it can be clickbaity,
- 41:48and it can be hard to have a full length conversation.
- 41:51But at the end of the day,
- 41:52I think
- 41:53something that's really nice about it is that it brings people
- 41:56together at this sort of like intersection of the internet.
- 41:59That we wouldn't normally meet at.
- 42:01Like,
- 42:01you have like
- 42:02PBDs like
- 42:03Manosphere,
- 42:04Grindset,
- 42:04bros,
- 42:05and then you have these sort of like queer socialists,
- 42:08like leftists,
- 42:08like,
- 42:09it's like they're never gonna watch the same
- 42:11things until there's a jubilee video like that,
- 42:13and I think that's really cool.
- 42:15Something unique about this episode with Patrick was there were some really
- 42:18bold offers made to some of the debaters in the center.
- 42:22One example is James,
- 42:23who after sharing some tragic details of his own personal story,
- 42:28was actually offered a job by Patrick,
- 42:30if he was willing to relocate to Fort Lauderdale.
- 42:33The interaction ended in a kind of unclear place,
- 42:36but
- 42:37I wanted to hear more about what James thought
- 42:39of the offer,
- 42:40as well as just learn more about his backstory.
- 42:42So here's James.
- 42:44James,
- 42:44welcome er to the surrounded follow-up.
- 42:47Thanks,
- 42:48thanks.
- 42:48Good to be here.
- 42:50I'm just curious,
- 42:51you know,
- 42:52without seeing any of the footage and,
- 42:54and just kind of having your own memory of it,
- 42:57um,
- 42:58how,
- 42:58how do you feel about the experience,
- 43:00uh,
- 43:00now that it's been a couple of weeks,
- 43:01I think.
- 43:02It was,
- 43:03it was good.
- 43:03Uh,
- 43:04it felt like he was
- 43:06not coming in to have,
- 43:08uh,
- 43:09a back and forth discussion,
- 43:11but rather to
- 43:13Get one over on the anti-ap or something like that.
- 43:16He pulled what most capitalists do that I've seen,
- 43:19well,
- 43:19maybe not capitalists,
- 43:20but like
- 43:21people with a fair amount of money do whenever they find out that they're either,
- 43:26um,
- 43:27somebody is getting one over on them or their point isn't being made the right way.
- 43:31Uh,
- 43:31they just start throwing money at the problem.
- 43:34Um,
- 43:34I think that he offered to pay like
- 43:373 different people in certain,
- 43:39in other,
- 43:39in various other ways.
- 43:41Uh,
- 43:42one person,
- 43:42he offered to pay for their mental health support,
- 43:44uh,
- 43:45and he offered me a job,
- 43:47which
- 43:48was completely out of nowhere.
- 43:51I it was interesting,
- 43:51uh,
- 43:52that you kind of see that as throwing money,
- 43:54uh,
- 43:54at the problem cause he,
- 43:57I noticed that as well,
- 43:58there was,
- 43:58uh,
- 44:00he came in,
- 44:00I think with some unique ideas of how to engage with people,
- 44:05and he wasn't afraid to.
- 44:07Um,
- 44:08make,
- 44:09I think,
- 44:09some bold offers.
- 44:11It kind of reminded me of Shark Tank,
- 44:12uh,
- 44:13a little bit,
- 44:14but
- 44:15yeah,
- 44:15I could see that.
- 44:16Yeah,
- 44:17um,
- 44:17OK,
- 44:17so I'm gonna show you the first clip cause this is just you kind of,
- 44:21um,
- 44:21meeting him,
- 44:22sitting down,
- 44:23and then giving him some of your context.
- 44:25So,
- 44:26where exactly am I failing
- 44:29when I am working 80 hours a week.
- 44:32I am taking the only jobs that will hire me.
- 44:34I have put in
- 44:36477 applications over the last 2.5 years,
- 44:39not even gotten a call back once.
- 44:41Why do you think?
- 44:41You tell me you're,
- 44:42you're a job creator,
- 44:43but I don't know your resume.
- 44:44You know your life better than I do.
- 44:46Why do you think you have not gotten a callback on 477?
- 44:48Because
- 44:49because I a lot of do not have a degree.
- 44:51OK,
- 44:51because I do not have a degree,
- 44:52because I could not afford one.
- 44:54OK.
- 44:54I live in an area where the physical job.
- 44:58The market is very limiting.
- 45:00Where do you live?
- 45:01Uh,
- 45:01I live in rural Texas.
- 45:02OK.
- 45:02So in that,
- 45:03like in the town that I grew up in,
- 45:05for instance,
- 45:06there are 8 jobs,
- 45:08period.
- 45:08Does all,
- 45:09does your family live there,
- 45:10Mom,
- 45:10dad,
- 45:11everybody's in that same city?
- 45:12Uh,
- 45:12everybody was at one point.
- 45:14OK.
- 45:14Most of them are dead now.
- 45:15OK,
- 45:15sorry to hear.
- 45:16Yeah,
- 45:16it is what it is.
- 45:17It's poverty,
- 45:19you know,
- 45:19we're kind of used to that on this side.
- 45:20What do you,
- 45:21what comes to mind when you see that?
- 45:24Uh,
- 45:25one,
- 45:25I had forgotten that I had gotten that contentious at the very beginning.
- 45:28Um,
- 45:30what,
- 45:30what,
- 45:31what do you do for work?
- 45:32Where are you right now,
- 45:33if you don't mind me asking.
- 45:35Yeah,
- 45:36uh,
- 45:36so currently I am working for Amazon doing package delivery.
- 45:41Um,
- 45:41I am working for the place that I'm at here,
- 45:44which is a metaphysical shop that a friend of mine owns.
- 45:47They actually gave me an opportunity to
- 45:50work for them,
- 45:51at what they could pay me for.
- 45:53Um,
- 45:54and then I do Uber whenever I can,
- 45:57uh,
- 45:57in between taking care of my partner who has a couple of
- 46:03autoimmune
- 46:03things and some medical issues.
- 46:06Sorry to hear that.
- 46:07So yeah,
- 46:08you're racking up 80 hours a week uh is what you said and,
- 46:11and I mean that's a lot of jobs you broke down.
- 46:15Yeah,
- 46:16Do you,
- 46:17in that
- 46:18in the context of your life,
- 46:20which sounds like
- 46:21um.
- 46:22You know,
- 46:23as you described it,
- 46:24it's poverty,
- 46:24it sounds
- 46:26stressful,
- 46:27um,
- 46:28or at least,
- 46:29uh,
- 46:29tiring because that's a lot of different tasks,
- 46:31a lot of different jobs,
- 46:33not a ton of income.
- 46:35Uh,
- 46:36what's your level of contentment,
- 46:38happiness in,
- 46:39in your context?
- 46:41I would say if I had to put a number on it between 1 and 10,
- 46:44my contentment with my personal life is about a 7 and everything else is about a 2 to 3.
- 46:51Oh,
- 46:51wow.
- 46:51Yeah,
- 46:52that's,
- 46:52uh,
- 46:53those are some low numbers,
- 46:54uh.
- 46:56After,
- 46:56after the 7,
- 46:59so,
- 47:00yeah,
- 47:01I mean,
- 47:01did you feel like maybe some of those struggles,
- 47:03some of the,
- 47:04just your reality,
- 47:06it's kind of like,
- 47:07uh,
- 47:08ricocheting inside you when you sat down across from Patrick.
- 47:13Yeah,
- 47:13um,
- 47:14100%.
- 47:14It was,
- 47:15uh,
- 47:15it was one of those things and I'll,
- 47:16and I'll readily admit it.
- 47:18Whenever I got up there,
- 47:19I,
- 47:19I walked up very,
- 47:21very like
- 47:22confident in what I was going to say
- 47:25and then as I kind of started getting into it,
- 47:27I don't know if people noticed this,
- 47:28but I definitely did,
- 47:30uh,
- 47:30that my,
- 47:31my voice kind of starts wavering a little bit and,
- 47:34and I did.
- 47:35I got,
- 47:35I got fairly emotional in that instance because
- 47:40And I don't know if the camera is gonna show this,
- 47:42but,
- 47:43uh,
- 47:43I'm a very big energy person
- 47:45and just
- 47:47here,
- 47:47just like
- 47:48the reactions and
- 47:51I know it's going to sound woo,
- 47:52the vibe or whatever that I got off of this guy
- 47:56was very much a
- 47:59Like I was giving a sob story to somebody who could care less
- 48:03and,
- 48:04and that I could,
- 48:06that is kind of what kind of got me heated a little bit.
- 48:09What do you think people don't understand,
- 48:11you know,
- 48:11someone like Patrick or just anybody who lives a,
- 48:14a wealthier life,
- 48:16um,
- 48:16in terms of financial means,
- 48:18what do you think they don't understand about poverty
- 48:21or what's a misconception you think they have about poverty?
- 48:26So
- 48:27I can't say this with any type of certainty,
- 48:31but I do know that in the times in my life
- 48:34whenever I was making what would be considered a livable wage,
- 48:38um,
- 48:38I do know that
- 48:40in general my life felt lighter.
- 48:43Uh,
- 48:43I lost my job,
- 48:45um,
- 48:45due to personal issues with my management.
- 48:49Uh,
- 48:50God,
- 48:51how long ago was that now?
- 48:524 years at this point,
- 48:53I think.
- 48:54Uh,
- 48:54where I was making,
- 48:56uh,
- 48:56$65,000 a year,
- 48:58and that to me felt like a king's wage,
- 49:01you know,
- 49:02in,
- 49:02in that first clip with,
- 49:03with Patrick,
- 49:04you described,
- 49:05you know,
- 49:06sending out 477,
- 49:08something like that,
- 49:09400+ applications,
- 49:11give or take.
- 49:11What do you think is the reason for,
- 49:14um,
- 49:14this search for,
- 49:15for a job?
- 49:17Um,
- 49:18why is it,
- 49:19why is it
- 49:21taking so much from you and,
- 49:22and why do you think it's so hard?
- 49:24So
- 49:25I don't have a degree.
- 49:26I don't have a bachelor's.
- 49:27I don't have any.
- 49:28I,
- 49:28I've got a cert.
- 49:29I've got an OSHA certification from a long time ago,
- 49:32um,
- 49:33but other than,
- 49:33oh,
- 49:34and I'm forklift certified,
- 49:36um,
- 49:37hey,
- 49:37that's so,
- 49:38uh,
- 49:38that's important.
- 49:39A lot of forklifts.
- 49:41See,
- 49:41every job that I have interviewed with,
- 49:43I have gotten it,
- 49:44and I have,
- 49:46I,
- 49:46I interview very well,
- 49:48I believe.
- 49:48I,
- 49:48I feel like I'm a fairly personable person.
- 49:51Well,
- 49:51as you were talking to Patrick.
- 49:54It seemed like he maybe was recognizing some sort of spark in you,
- 49:58some sort of
- 49:59work ethic in you,
- 50:00because
- 50:01the conversation kind of took an unexpected turn towards
- 50:04um,
- 50:05This opportunity and sort of kind of out of the blue offer he made.
- 50:09What do you have on your resume?
- 50:10Skill set?
- 50:11What do you offer?
- 50:11Uh,
- 50:12transportation expertise,
- 50:13logistics expertise.
- 50:15You consider yourself a hard worker.
- 50:17I mean,
- 50:17I,
- 50:17I feel like 80 hours a week.
- 50:19That's a hard worker.
- 50:20How about we do this?
- 50:21How about I interview and I give you a job.
- 50:24Would you move to Fort Lauderdale?
- 50:25Oh,
- 50:25how's Florida?
- 50:26Why not?
- 50:27Would you move to Fort Lauderdale?
- 50:28Why not?
- 50:29How about you and I document this after this,
- 50:31you come,
- 50:31I do an interview with you,
- 50:32and I give you a job,
- 50:33and let's see what you do 90 days later.
- 50:35OK.
- 50:35Let me,
- 50:36and I'll,
- 50:36I'll look up your company and all that kind of stuff,
- 50:38and I'll see it.
- 50:38But you see what just happened right there.
- 50:40But watch what you just did.
- 50:42You just said
- 50:43you.
- 50:43Apply to 477 companies who's not gone back to you.
- 50:48A business owner
- 50:49who's hiring aggressively just made an offer to you.
- 50:52You said you're willing to move.
- 50:54Then you said,
- 50:54I'll look at it.
- 50:55You became selected.
- 50:56I didn't say,
- 50:57I'll look at it if you'd let me finish my sentence.
- 50:59Go ahead.
- 50:59I wanna hear it.
- 50:59I would like to look into your company to see exactly what you guys do.
- 51:04All right,
- 51:04so that was exactly like I thought it was,
- 51:07yeah.
- 51:07So
- 51:09what happened there?
- 51:14Well,
- 51:14from my perspective,
- 51:17he saw somebody who he believed to be desperate.
- 51:21Who believed to be at their wits' end and at the end of their rope.
- 51:25So,
- 51:26he was going to throw that person a lifeline with the expectation
- 51:30that that person would not ask any questions about it and accept it
- 51:34wholesale,
- 51:35not like no,
- 51:36no,
- 51:36not,
- 51:36uh,
- 51:37not looking at it,
- 51:38not making sure that it's safe or anything like that.
- 51:40Or once I said I was going to do my due diligence on him,
- 51:43he said,
- 51:44oh,
- 51:44well,
- 51:44if you're gonna look into me,
- 51:45don't worry about it.
- 51:47I felt like he was testing you for sure,
- 51:49and I felt like you sniffed that out.
- 51:53Maybe that made you feel.
- 51:56Disrespected,
- 51:57um,
- 51:58because it was kind of a,
- 52:00a bit of a
- 52:01stagy moment maybe so I can see how
- 52:05I can see how that could feel like it was maybe uh demeaning,
- 52:08but I in Patrick I said kind of a genuine
- 52:12curiosity about hey.
- 52:15We're here face to face.
- 52:17Why don't you work for me and,
- 52:19and I'll make sure that,
- 52:20that we make it happen.
- 52:22Um,
- 52:22did you feel like there was,
- 52:24there was some goodwill there?
- 52:25I,
- 52:25I thought that he had some goodwill.
- 52:28So I think that
- 52:30in his mind and in his heart,
- 52:34he probably felt that way.
- 52:38Like this
- 52:40Like a little bit.
- 52:42Why do you say that?
- 52:43I think.
- 52:45His demeanor,
- 52:46the way that he interacted with other people,
- 52:48and uh
- 52:50the fact of that when I tell him that I'm going to look into his company,
- 52:55he immediately retracts it.
- 52:57What do you mean by retracted?
- 52:58Do you think he was worried that,
- 53:00uh,
- 53:01You were gonna find something out about the company that was,
- 53:04was,
- 53:04was not,
- 53:05uh,
- 53:06he didn't want you to know.
- 53:09I mean,
- 53:09later on in the episode,
- 53:10somebody called him out for basically being a pyramid scheme,
- 53:13so maybe.
- 53:15Yeah,
- 53:16no,
- 53:16I heard that,
- 53:16um.
- 53:18I don't want to go down that path because I,
- 53:20I actually don't know.
- 53:21Absolutely.
- 53:22I have no knowledge of uh Patrick's business practices
- 53:26and honestly similar to you,
- 53:27I don't even exactly know what he does,
- 53:29but
- 53:29I know he's wealthy,
- 53:30I know he's uh.
- 53:31He's a successful guy and,
- 53:33and,
- 53:33um,
- 53:34he's obviously he's probably got really good lawyers,
- 53:36so I'm not gonna say that it's a pyramid scheme.
- 53:38I said somebody else done it.
- 53:41Don't come for me,
- 53:42lawyers.
- 53:42I don't know anything.
- 53:44So I believe the technical term for when you make more money from getting people to be
- 53:48part of a company than from actually selling
- 53:49a service is called a multi-level marketing scheme.
- 53:51Do you think that That's a fair characterization of your company.
- 53:55Why not?
- 53:55a multi,
- 53:56Do you know what a multi-level is?
- 53:57Yes,
- 53:57I know it's where you make more money from,
- 53:58it's sort of like a pyramid scheme wherein
- 54:01you make more money from getting people to be part of
- 54:03it and selling them to be part of the company.
- 54:05Do you,
- 54:05do you feel like you became anti-capitalist after you lost your job,
- 54:08or is it something that,
- 54:09that goes back to a deeper,
- 54:12uh,
- 54:12philosophy
- 54:13and,
- 54:14and or experience?
- 54:15When,
- 54:16when did you start feeling that way?
- 54:18Probably about 1312 or 13,
- 54:21and how come,
- 54:22uh,
- 54:22my grandfather was a,
- 54:24a naval veteran of World War II.
- 54:27Um,
- 54:27he was in Okinawa and Iwo Jima,
- 54:29and he had a lot
- 54:31of,
- 54:31uh,
- 54:32PTSD,
- 54:33uh,
- 54:34well,
- 54:34what I assume is PTSD.
- 54:35I can't speak to what his actual mental health,
- 54:38uh,
- 54:38situation was
- 54:40because
- 54:41his way of coping with it was copious amounts of drinking.
- 54:45Uh,
- 54:45my grandfather having a heart condition and having
- 54:48addiction issues and having what I assumed to
- 54:50be PTSD was completely ignored by the people that he gave his entire life to.
- 54:56And he died.
- 54:58Like
- 54:58he died of his alcoholism,
- 55:00he died of a heart condition,
- 55:02and he died on a waiting list,
- 55:05uh,
- 55:05for an appointment at the VA to try and like get his heart condition looked at
- 55:09and
- 55:11And that just,
- 55:12and I started asking my grandmother like why was he,
- 55:15why was he not approved,
- 55:16blah blah blah blah blah,
- 55:17and she says,
- 55:17well,
- 55:17you know,
- 55:18sometimes these things just happen.
- 55:20And that
- 55:21click something over where it's just like,
- 55:24well,
- 55:25why is it that this money isn't being allocated correctly?
- 55:29Like what,
- 55:29where,
- 55:29where is all this money that we have?
- 55:31We're the richest country in the world,
- 55:32right?
- 55:33Where's all this stuff going?
- 55:34Yeah.
- 55:35Well,
- 55:35I'm sorry to hear about your grandfather.
- 55:38What's interesting though is it kind of sounds like,
- 55:40you know,
- 55:41your anger is towards
- 55:43The US government,
- 55:44um,
- 55:45and how they handled that situation with your grandfather,
- 55:49but I do wonder if,
- 55:50um,
- 55:51You know,
- 55:52if you had had the opportunity to get to the core of your story with Patrick,
- 55:55I mean,
- 55:56he might have,
- 55:57he might have felt
- 55:58a similar way that you did,
- 56:00um,
- 56:01or that you do about that.
- 56:03Um
- 56:04But yeah,
- 56:05I can understand how
- 56:07witnessing something like that.
- 56:09Um,
- 56:09take down somebody you love and admire,
- 56:12um,
- 56:13can be not the only one,
- 56:15yeah,
- 56:15that can be an injury that lasts a lifetime.
- 56:19You had mentioned,
- 56:19you know,
- 56:20when you met him,
- 56:21you know,
- 56:21your parents have died,
- 56:22you know,
- 56:23pretty much a lot of people close to you have,
- 56:25have.
- 56:25Suffered similar fates.
- 56:27My
- 56:28father died due to,
- 56:30uh,
- 56:31medical issues and being thrown off of
- 56:33Obamacare whenever Trump's first presidency came into,
- 56:36came into office.
- 56:38Uh,
- 56:38he ended up dying,
- 56:40uh,
- 56:40in hospice care that my family couldn't afford to pay for,
- 56:44um,
- 56:45and I'm about 90% sure that my grandmother is still sitting on that bill.
- 56:52I'm sorry,
- 56:52man,
- 56:53this sucks.
- 56:55I would like to think,
- 56:56cause it sounds like your life has really had a lot of tragedy in it,
- 57:00and I,
- 57:01I,
- 57:01I would like to preserve some shred of hope that maybe,
- 57:04you know,
- 57:04this,
- 57:05this job opportunity with Patrick might not be
- 57:08totally
- 57:09gone,
- 57:09um,
- 57:10and.
- 57:11Yeah,
- 57:12I don't know.
- 57:12I'm,
- 57:12uh,
- 57:13uh,
- 57:14Patrick,
- 57:14if you're watching this,
- 57:15uh,
- 57:16I think we should
- 57:17reconsider this situation,
- 57:19but,
- 57:19but I don't know.
- 57:19What do you think,
- 57:20James?
- 57:22I mean,
- 57:22like I say,
- 57:22I am willing to entertain the idea.
- 57:24I'm willing to go to the interview.
- 57:26I'm willing to,
- 57:27to look at the company and see if,
- 57:29see if he has a place for me.
- 57:31Um,
- 57:32he's gotta,
- 57:32I gotta,
- 57:33I gotta do my due diligence.
- 57:34He's gotta have a forklift somewhere in the operation,
- 57:37right.
- 57:38I mean,
- 57:39unless it's a finance business and then like,
- 57:41you know,
- 57:41maybe like a hand truck.
- 57:45One thing I wanna ask you,
- 57:46James,
- 57:46um,
- 57:47do you ever worry,
- 57:48you know,
- 57:48that
- 57:49all these experiences and,
- 57:51and this loss of loved ones,
- 57:53do you think it's maybe given you too negative of a mindset or a mindset that
- 57:57That maybe expects things to go wrong,
- 58:00um,
- 58:02more than they necessarily do.
- 58:05Yeah,
- 58:05uh,
- 58:05it did for a very,
- 58:06very long time,
- 58:07um.
- 58:10Oh,
- 58:10I'm gonna,
- 58:11I'm,
- 58:11I'm a little hesitant to say this,
- 58:13uh,
- 58:14but
- 58:15honestly,
- 58:16about
- 58:175 years ago whenever my wife divorced me,
- 58:20uh,
- 58:21that was part of what got rid of a lot of this,
- 58:24like
- 58:25a lot of that like hopelessness that I had at that point in time.
- 58:28So honestly that,
- 58:29that was hitting my absolute lowest point
- 58:32was probably what gave me a much more hopeful mindset.
- 58:37I don't recommend it.
- 58:38It sucks,
- 58:39and
- 58:41end of the day,
- 58:41if I didn't care enough about myself,
- 58:43I would have.
- 58:45Done it,
- 58:46but,
- 58:47well,
- 58:47I'm gonna,
- 58:48I'm gonna try and
- 58:50believe that an opportunity is gonna find its way to you and,
- 58:53and Patrick,
- 58:54I think
- 58:54this,
- 58:55That you've got to have a forklift,
- 58:57uh,
- 58:57that James needs to operate.
- 59:00But also,
- 59:00you know,
- 59:01I heard something in,
- 59:02in there,
- 59:02James.
- 59:03I'm,
- 59:03I'm glad you,
- 59:04you've chose to stick around.
- 59:05I think,
- 59:06I think,
- 59:06uh,
- 59:06you're a valuable guy,
- 59:08and
- 59:09I,
- 59:09I value this conversation,
- 59:10and I know the Jubilee team valued you being in that,
- 59:14in that video.
- 59:15So
- 59:16I'm gonna send you some,
- 59:17some positive vibes.
- 59:19Um,
- 59:19I know you're,
- 59:20you said you're a vibes guy,
- 59:21um,
- 59:22and I,
- 59:22I hope some,
- 59:23some brighter days are around the corner for you,
- 59:26OK?
- 59:27I,
- 59:28I hope so too.
- 59:29Um,
- 59:30you know,
- 59:30I,
- 59:30I have faith that,
- 59:31that there will be.
- 59:33Another surprising interaction that happened in the
- 59:35center with Patrick was with Isabella.
- 59:38She also goes by Faye.
- 59:39After she shared some of her medical history with Patrick,
- 59:42he
- 59:43was so bold to offer to pay for her to meet with a specialist that he recommended,
- 59:47both for a condition that she had,
- 59:49as well as a mental health condition that she was struggling with.
- 59:52So I spoke to Faye and wanted to know more about what she thought of this offer,
- 59:56as well as just learn more about her story.
- 59:58So here's Faye.
- 1:00:00Uh,
- 1:00:01Faye,
- 1:00:02AKA Isabella,
- 1:00:03uh,
- 1:00:03welcome to the surrounded follow-up.
- 1:00:06Thank you.
- 1:00:07When did you first uh.
- 1:00:10You know,
- 1:00:11realized that you were anti-capitalist,
- 1:00:13and,
- 1:00:13and do you know what motivated,
- 1:00:15uh,
- 1:00:15that perspective shift?
- 1:00:17Yeah,
- 1:00:18so I realized I was anti-capitalist probably
- 1:00:22during COVID actually.
- 1:00:23It was,
- 1:00:24um,
- 1:00:25I started watching
- 1:00:27some people who
- 1:00:28had
- 1:00:30Opinions that were a lot more left leaning than the
- 1:00:33average person like on YouTube and things like that,
- 1:00:35mainly
- 1:00:37history videos on YouTube,
- 1:00:39and that's when I started.
- 1:00:41Any favorite uh channels?
- 1:00:44Hassan,
- 1:00:44Hassan is always one of my favorite.
- 1:00:46I,
- 1:00:46I watch him on Twitch like all day because I'm disabled,
- 1:00:49so I'm struggling to find a job in general,
- 1:00:51but,
- 1:00:52um,
- 1:00:53so yeah,
- 1:00:54but I,
- 1:00:55I watch this on like a Fox News dad.
- 1:00:58Um,
- 1:00:59yeah,
- 1:00:59that's what I always,
- 1:00:59it's a funny comparison.
- 1:01:02So I never really got an actual perspective on socialism and communism until after.
- 1:01:07Uh,
- 1:01:07high school and during COVID when I started realizing that there was more
- 1:01:12economic possibilities out there.
- 1:01:15What was your uh
- 1:01:17impression of Patrick when he uh walked onto set?
- 1:01:21I hadn't heard of him before,
- 1:01:23but when he walked in,
- 1:01:24I was like,
- 1:01:24yeah,
- 1:01:24that looks like a capitalist.
- 1:01:28He sounds like one too.
- 1:01:29Uh,
- 1:01:30he's got that that booming voice,
- 1:01:32um,
- 1:01:33and he had a,
- 1:01:34he definitely was looking.
- 1:01:36Crisp and clean cut in that suit.
- 1:01:38So you guys had a really interesting discussion,
- 1:01:41um,
- 1:01:41that got very personal about
- 1:01:43your life,
- 1:01:44your past,
- 1:01:45um,
- 1:01:46and he made a pretty bold offer,
- 1:01:49which I was
- 1:01:50surprised by and,
- 1:01:51and you were obviously surprised by,
- 1:01:54um,
- 1:01:55at least that's how I,
- 1:01:56I read your reaction in the,
- 1:01:58in the moment.
- 1:01:59Trouble is,
- 1:02:01in many cases.
- 1:02:03Somebody you and I look up to
- 1:02:05will say something to us that we choose to believe for the rest of our lives.
- 1:02:09Unfortunately,
- 1:02:10it could be something where you have ADHD,
- 1:02:12you're mentally ill,
- 1:02:14you're poor,
- 1:02:15you're this,
- 1:02:15you're that,
- 1:02:16and we get to choose to buy into that or not.
- 1:02:19And if you do,
- 1:02:20so you're saying I'm not mentally ill or I'm not disabled you are or you're not.
- 1:02:24I would challenge you to go a little bit deeper
- 1:02:25to see if there's anything you can do about it.
- 1:02:27So you're asking me about my health.
- 1:02:29You're asking me about my disability and my,
- 1:02:31I will say we are in.
- 1:02:32A market where,
- 1:02:34stay with me here,
- 1:02:35there is a market where there's profit to convince you to have,
- 1:02:38you have issues to take the medication
- 1:02:40because they're making money but and I'm not have access to the medication.
- 1:02:43I don't have access to even a result or a solution
- 1:02:47to my disability as someone with a connective tissue disorder.
- 1:02:50It's genetic.
- 1:02:51Have you been able to go to different doctors and get yourself tested and see?
- 1:02:55You have,
- 1:02:56yes.
- 1:02:56In
- 1:02:56in California,
- 1:02:57yes,
- 1:02:58but not enough.
- 1:02:59I,
- 1:02:59I can't find a specialist.
- 1:03:01You can't find,
- 1:03:01I can't find a specialist for who I am in your life that's I can't find a specialist.
- 1:03:06Well,
- 1:03:07they could if or they would if they had money,
- 1:03:08but they,
- 1:03:09yeah,
- 1:03:09would you be OK if I pay for a specialist for you to go see?
- 1:03:12Yeah,
- 1:03:13would you take money from a capitalist to help you go see a specialist?
- 1:03:15I mean,
- 1:03:16yeah,
- 1:03:16sure,
- 1:03:16why not?
- 1:03:17I'm gonna have you go see two.
- 1:03:18What do you,
- 1:03:18do you live in California?
- 1:03:19Yeah.
- 1:03:20I'm gonna have you go see two specialists,
- 1:03:21but would you also be open to
- 1:03:23seeing somebody else I choose as a psychologist that may,
- 1:03:26you're not.
- 1:03:28So you choose as a psychologist,
- 1:03:30you're choosing who gets to determine what my mental health looks like.
- 1:03:33No,
- 1:03:34no.
- 1:03:34OK,
- 1:03:35then I wish you nothing but the best.
- 1:03:37A lot of people are gonna weigh in
- 1:03:39on
- 1:03:40that situation,
- 1:03:41but what do you,
- 1:03:42what do you think watching it?
- 1:03:44Um,
- 1:03:45watching it back,
- 1:03:46I really didn't remember it too well,
- 1:03:48but I'm starting to realize how,
- 1:03:51um,
- 1:03:52he almost
- 1:03:54wanted to prove that
- 1:03:56disabled people can kind of like pull up
- 1:03:59their bootstraps and get through it and just,
- 1:04:02just work hard enough and you'll work through it.
- 1:04:04But he was forgetting that there's so many disabled
- 1:04:06people who don't even have that as a choice.
- 1:04:09Um,
- 1:04:09and
- 1:04:10the offer in general to
- 1:04:12Give me a specialist.
- 1:04:13He hasn't,
- 1:04:14he hasn't followed up on that with me.
- 1:04:16So
- 1:04:16that's something to
- 1:04:18consider.
- 1:04:18I haven't gotten any emails or anything,
- 1:04:20but,
- 1:04:20um,
- 1:04:21the offer in itself was kind of weird,
- 1:04:24but the way he was kind of wording it just reminded me of
- 1:04:27eugenics
- 1:04:29and
- 1:04:30how my mind didn't go there.
- 1:04:32Since it's a genetic disorder,
- 1:04:33we haven't been able to do too much research in my,
- 1:04:36in my,
- 1:04:36um,
- 1:04:37condition,
- 1:04:37which is Eller-Danlos syndrome.
- 1:04:39And as we're starting to research it,
- 1:04:42we realized that
- 1:04:44there's a lot more depth to it,
- 1:04:46and that has kind of been hidden throughout
- 1:04:49the white supremacist,
- 1:04:50um,
- 1:04:50perception
- 1:04:52of pushing eugenics through our,
- 1:04:54um,
- 1:04:54psychiatric and
- 1:04:56medical system in general.
- 1:04:58I think what he maybe was getting at was like.
- 1:05:03Sometimes a doctor might um.
- 1:05:06Give you a perspective that that weighs on you and,
- 1:05:09and uh we read into it too much.
- 1:05:11Did,
- 1:05:12do you agree with that or,
- 1:05:13or did you read that the same way?
- 1:05:16Uh,
- 1:05:16I did,
- 1:05:17and I think it's
- 1:05:19kind of a,
- 1:05:21a moot,
- 1:05:21a moot point to make is that,
- 1:05:24um,
- 1:05:25in
- 1:05:25the grand scheme of things,
- 1:05:27I do have a very dis um debilitating disability that
- 1:05:31he knows nothing about.
- 1:05:33Um,
- 1:05:33so I think it,
- 1:05:34it was honestly kind of rude for him to tell me that
- 1:05:37a doctor,
- 1:05:38or at least imply that a doctor's diagnosis might be
- 1:05:42inaccurate.
- 1:05:43He was being pretty.
- 1:05:45Slightly invasive,
- 1:05:46um,
- 1:05:48and I,
- 1:05:49I could understand how you could feel that.
- 1:05:51But then when he made the suggestion that he,
- 1:05:53you know,
- 1:05:53he was like,
- 1:05:54can anybody pay for it?
- 1:05:55And you,
- 1:05:55you said,
- 1:05:56of course,
- 1:05:57people would,
- 1:05:57would pay for it if they could
- 1:05:59in my life.
- 1:06:01When he was so bold to suggest that he paid for it,
- 1:06:03what was going through your mind?
- 1:06:06Um,
- 1:06:06I think I was thinking mainly like,
- 1:06:10I guess why?
- 1:06:12I,
- 1:06:12I think he was really just making a point as to,
- 1:06:16like,
- 1:06:16oh,
- 1:06:17this.
- 1:06:18Um,
- 1:06:19victim of a lady will take a capitalist offer,
- 1:06:22even though she's anti-capitalist and a socialist.
- 1:06:25It's like,
- 1:06:26like he was trying to get a gotcha,
- 1:06:28and really his only gotcha was that I'm disabled and desperate.
- 1:06:33Um,
- 1:06:34but yeah,
- 1:06:35and I,
- 1:06:35I can understand how.
- 1:06:37Um,
- 1:06:39It felt
- 1:06:40like that and I can understand how
- 1:06:43someone watching it could take that away from it.
- 1:06:46Um,
- 1:06:47I guess I'm curious if,
- 1:06:49you know,
- 1:06:49I don't,
- 1:06:49I don't know if Patrick's gonna watch this,
- 1:06:51um,
- 1:06:52and that offer was still on the table to get.
- 1:06:55You know,
- 1:06:55connected with a specialist for whatever treatment is required for your,
- 1:06:59um,
- 1:07:00your,
- 1:07:01your condition,
- 1:07:01would,
- 1:07:02would you take that money and do you think that would be a net good,
- 1:07:05even if it was kind of offered in a
- 1:07:08performative context?
- 1:07:10Um,
- 1:07:11I think it's
- 1:07:13I think it's kind of.
- 1:07:16Like,
- 1:07:16not necessarily neutral intention,
- 1:07:18but
- 1:07:19kind of a,
- 1:07:20a centrist
- 1:07:21kind of way of thinking where you're like,
- 1:07:23Oh,
- 1:07:23well,
- 1:07:24I,
- 1:07:25I'll give you help,
- 1:07:26but there's not really a good intent behind that.
- 1:07:28It's kind of just a gotcha.
- 1:07:30So I would accept the help because like I said,
- 1:07:33I'm desperate.
- 1:07:34I need to find a specialist,
- 1:07:35but
- 1:07:36that's
- 1:07:37the thing is that I'm desperate.
- 1:07:38And he was
- 1:07:39Almost taking advantage of somebody in a situation
- 1:07:43who is in a very vulnerable position,
- 1:07:45even debating in front of millions of people is going to be
- 1:07:48something that is a very vulnerable position for me,
- 1:07:51and
- 1:07:52I was also admitting that I was mentally ill and hospitalized for that,
- 1:07:56and also admitting that I'm disabled to millions of people,
- 1:07:59which is already a very
- 1:08:01vulnerable position to be in
- 1:08:03on its own.
- 1:08:05So kind of throwing that in there was just
- 1:08:07It was kind of disrespectful to me,
- 1:08:09but hey,
- 1:08:10I would accept it because I need help.
- 1:08:13I was wondering if you could
- 1:08:15share or elaborate a little bit more on,
- 1:08:17on the mental health struggles that you have as well.
- 1:08:21Um,
- 1:08:21I was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder,
- 1:08:24which is a very demonized disorder.
- 1:08:27Um,
- 1:08:28it's
- 1:08:29compared to narcissism a lot,
- 1:08:31which is also another
- 1:08:32Um,
- 1:08:33very demonized disorder.
- 1:08:35It's,
- 1:08:36but
- 1:08:36I guess with my personal experience with it,
- 1:08:39I've been able to overcome
- 1:08:41and even get rid of that diagnosis under my name.
- 1:08:45But most people don't have the resources to do that and don't have access to,
- 1:08:51um,
- 1:08:52especially with BPD don't have access to
- 1:08:56Even seeing perspectives where they realize that there's other options
- 1:09:00for them outside of BPD and outside of depressive thinking,
- 1:09:04and I think that even
- 1:09:05I like
- 1:09:06I was going to say because for my,
- 1:09:08um,
- 1:09:09if he was going to pick me for a debate,
- 1:09:11my
- 1:09:12at the end of the episode,
- 1:09:14my theory or my
- 1:09:16hypothesis or debate claim,
- 1:09:18I guess the claim,
- 1:09:19yeah,
- 1:09:19I think it was that
- 1:09:22everything,
- 1:09:22every problem
- 1:09:24in
- 1:09:25Specifically the US,
- 1:09:27how,
- 1:09:27no matter how personal it is,
- 1:09:30is the fault of capitalism,
- 1:09:32white supremacy,
- 1:09:33or sexism,
- 1:09:34or,
- 1:09:35uh,
- 1:09:35yeah,
- 1:09:35sexism.
- 1:09:37So all of these
- 1:09:38three things like colonialism,
- 1:09:40white supremacy,
- 1:09:41and sexism
- 1:09:43kind of just run our country.
- 1:09:46You really,
- 1:09:46you really feel like every single problem could,
- 1:09:49could
- 1:09:49ladder up to,
- 1:09:50to those,
- 1:09:51those issues.
- 1:09:53Honestly,
- 1:09:54yeah,
- 1:09:54I,
- 1:09:55I would be willing to debate that even with Patrick again,
- 1:09:58I would be more than happy to debate him again.
- 1:10:02Um,
- 1:10:03when he made the suggestion
- 1:10:06of
- 1:10:07connecting you to also a psychologist,
- 1:10:09the.
- 1:10:11It felt like the offer um kind of went sour and you had a big reaction,
- 1:10:16and I was just curious if you could elaborate more because you ran out of time,
- 1:10:20uh,
- 1:10:20moments later.
- 1:10:22Um,
- 1:10:22well,
- 1:10:23the fact that he said a psychologist of his choosing,
- 1:10:26I think
- 1:10:27is a pretty gross thing
- 1:10:30to do
- 1:10:31because you're kind of,
- 1:10:33because with your therapist,
- 1:10:35you or your psychiatrist,
- 1:10:36you get so vulnerable,
- 1:10:37you tell them,
- 1:10:39like all of your problems essentially,
- 1:10:41and
- 1:10:41you realize problems you have with them too.
- 1:10:44And so him choosing the person
- 1:10:47for me to be vulnerable to just doesn't even
- 1:10:50make sense because
- 1:10:52Like you kind of have to shop around with therapies
- 1:10:54or or therapists and psychiatrists in the first place.
- 1:10:58So giving one specific one
- 1:11:01by a conservative capitalist
- 1:11:03is not very encouraging for my mental health.
- 1:11:07I'm gonna take a little bit of a
- 1:11:08cheesy centrist stance on this,
- 1:11:10and
- 1:11:11I think um.
- 1:11:13I think there's plenty to critique on the capitalist side,
- 1:11:17but
- 1:11:18if a capitalist is gonna give somebody in need
- 1:11:22access to healthcare that they couldn't otherwise afford,
- 1:11:25I think that's a good thing.
- 1:11:26And so,
- 1:11:27I would pressure Patrick to connect you and pay for the treatment,
- 1:11:32um,
- 1:11:32and give you the option to opt in or out,
- 1:11:34you know,
- 1:11:35at least do the consultation with
- 1:11:37With the people he connects you with and then,
- 1:11:39and then move forward if,
- 1:11:41if you feel like it's right for you.
- 1:11:43Do you agree with that or,
- 1:11:44or would you still be resistant?
- 1:11:47Partially,
- 1:11:48I don't think that um
- 1:11:51even
- 1:11:52I think people underestimate what a bad or a bad experience
- 1:11:56with a therapist or psychiatrist can do for you.
- 1:11:59I know a lot of people who have been
- 1:12:01traumatized,
- 1:12:02um,
- 1:12:03me personally from a psychiatrist or a therapist telling me or a psychologist,
- 1:12:07um,
- 1:12:08telling me that.
- 1:12:09My experience are invalid,
- 1:12:11and I fear that
- 1:12:13coming from
- 1:12:14somebody from his network.
- 1:12:15I obviously don't know his political
- 1:12:18or their political ideologies where they would be coming from,
- 1:12:20but
- 1:12:21um
- 1:12:22I just
- 1:12:24I think it would be taking advantage of somebody who
- 1:12:28is in a very vulnerable position in the first place.
- 1:12:31Right.
- 1:12:32I agree,
- 1:12:33you are
- 1:12:34in a vulnerable position.
- 1:12:36Um,
- 1:12:37I think my,
- 1:12:38my only hope would be that you get,
- 1:12:40uh,
- 1:12:40better care.
- 1:12:41Um,
- 1:12:42and I think
- 1:12:43there was a part of Patrick that felt that way,
- 1:12:45but I agree with you,
- 1:12:47his,
- 1:12:47you know,
- 1:12:48there are other possibilities that could be coloring his motives.
- 1:12:52What would you want somebody who watches it in the,
- 1:12:55you know,
- 1:12:55the next week or so?
- 1:12:57What would you want them to understand about you
- 1:12:59that maybe they might not get from the video?
- 1:13:02Um,
- 1:13:03that's a great question.
- 1:13:05I think that.
- 1:13:07Just to remember that I'm a human being
- 1:13:09and that everybody else here that was debating him are human beings.
- 1:13:14I think we look at a screen and we just see a face,
- 1:13:18and we forget that there's a human behind that face and that there's,
- 1:13:21there's a heart,
- 1:13:22there's a soul,
- 1:13:23there's a brain,
- 1:13:24and
- 1:13:25sometimes things
- 1:13:26like fart,
- 1:13:27like your brain.
- 1:13:29Like I did.
- 1:13:30And,
- 1:13:31um,
- 1:13:31I think
- 1:13:32just remembering to give people some
- 1:13:35credit in the bravery that they did take to debate this person who
- 1:13:40I didn't know is going to be in the first place.
- 1:13:42So doing that is
- 1:13:44a huge step to like
- 1:13:46courageousness and confidence.
- 1:13:49Yeah,
- 1:13:50I couldn't,
- 1:13:50I couldn't agree anymore.
- 1:13:53Thank you.
- 1:14:01For more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 1:14:03be sure to like,
- 1:14:04subscribe,
- 1:14:05leave us a comment and a positive review,
- 1:14:08um,
- 1:14:08wherever you get your podcasts.
- 1:14:10If you want to see the video versions of this,
- 1:14:12we are posting them on YouTube under Jubilee's second channel,
- 1:14:16Tubilee.
- 1:14:17And if you want to interact with me online,
- 1:14:18you can find me on X
- 1:14:20or on YouTube,
- 1:14:21John Regalado.
- 1:14:23Thanks so much for listening.
- 1:14:24Remember,
- 1:14:24I could be wrong,
- 1:14:26so could you.
- 1:14:27Keep your mind open.
- 1:14:28Until next time.