Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 195 - How to Survive a Hostile Government | Christian Betancourt
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 195 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:36My God, we're getting close to 200, aren't we?
- 0:38Hello, hello, hello, yes.
- 0:39And I'm going to do a very quick intro this week.
- 0:43Got a lot to get done.
- 0:44I'm off to Serbia in a couple of days and I'm getting all the episodes up to date.
- 0:49Ready to auto-publish while I'm away because when I'm on the road,
- 0:53there'll be no time to do any of this stuff.
- 0:56Certainly, there'll be time to record some new episodes though in Serbia.
- 0:59I'll be speaking at Liberpolco, which is Liberland's Anarcopolco collab over there in Serbia.
- 1:08I'll be interviewing some of the other speakers at that event and there are some interesting
- 1:13people on that list. Anyway, back to today's episode. My guest this week
- 1:17is a gentleman by the name of Christian Bettencourt. He's a Honduran lawyer,
- 1:22an entrepreneur and one of Prospera's earliest residents. Christian, funnily enough,
- 1:28was also one of the first people I ever interviewed for this podcast almost four years ago.
- 1:35Episode number three, you'll find him back in 2022. Back then, Prospera consisted largely of,
- 1:44well, just the beta building really, and the Honduran government had begun its campaign
- 1:49against the ZA framework. So at that particular time, nobody really knew whether the project
- 1:55would survive or not. Christian did, however. In fact, he was so confident in the legal architecture
- 2:02that he left his corporate law career and moved to Prospera, effectively betting his future on
- 2:10the whole thing holding together. Anyway, jump forward four years, four difficult years I would
- 2:16say, and we sat down again to examine what happened over that four years and what the situation is now,
- 2:23straight from the horse's mouth. The story that most people heard was that the government repealed
- 2:28the ZA law and abolished the zones. Christian argues that this is not exactly what happened
- 2:34and there are lots of misunderstandings about the whole thing. In the conversation he walks me
- 2:39through the layers of protection that were built into the system including contracts, legislation,
- 2:46constitutional provisions and the international treaties and he explains which protections were
- 2:51removed, which survived, and why Prospera and the other existing ZAs in Honduras are allowed to
- 2:59continue operating right now. We also discuss the controversial Supreme Court ruling, the
- 3:06multi-billion dollar investment claim against Honduras, the changing political climate, and
- 3:11whether the country could soon begin creating new zones again. That's the question everyone wants
- 3:18to know, don't they? Beyond all the law talk, we talk also about CBDCs, Bitcoin, Bukele's influence
- 3:25across Central America, Honduran attitudes towards Prospera, and what it means for a Honduran
- 3:31citizen to choose a radically different model of government within his own country. That's
- 3:37Christian, by the way. And that question of where you live, under which rules, and how much control
- 3:43you have over your own life, well, those things lead neatly to this week's sponsor, Veritas
- 3:50Villages. Veritas Villages are building off-grid energy self-sufficient villages across Latin
- 3:56America. And I think sometimes villages is a stretch. I don't know how many houses you count
- 4:01as a village, but their new property in Costa Rica is incredibly large. I think it's 340 acres.
- 4:07But the name's good. They're building them all across Latin America for people who want greater
- 4:12independence without giving up comfort, security or connection to the outside world. These are
- 4:18places designed around resilient infrastructure, private ownership and the ability to live with
- 4:24less dependence on fragile centralised systems. Bitcoin is accepted at Veritas villages and
- 4:30residents can even incorporate home mining into their energy model. And as I say every week,
- 4:36you can buy your property with Bitcoin too. That means land in the new places or actual properties
- 4:43in the older ones. And in the new ones where you're buying land, you get to design your own
- 4:49house or pick it off a catalogue. Everything you could possibly need to know, go via www.veritasvillages.com
- 4:57forward slash free cities. Please tell them you heard about them through us. It helps us as well
- 5:04don forget also it conference time in a few weeks i not going to say too much this week www is where everything you need to know is but it in Prospera
- 5:18I think everyone knows that now.
- 5:19No value for value this week since I'm recording this a couple of weeks in advance of publishing it.
- 5:25Quick reminder that the complete back catalogue of nearly 200 Free Cities podcast shows,
- 5:33well they're all available at www.freecities.fm you can't forget that one freecities.fm the place
- 5:43for the back catalogue and a bunch of interesting little ways of rooting through the back catalogue
- 5:48because we have a pretty extensive conversation on that site about everything free cities right
- 5:54enough from me time for another free cities og on the pod please just sit back relax and enjoy my
- 6:01conversation with Christian Bettencourt. Right Christian, so what most people listening to this
- 6:22podcast probably won't realise unless they're an absolute OG, as you were one of the first people
- 6:28I ever interviewed almost four years ago now it's quite incredible when you think about it
- 6:34but we've we me and Peter Young from the Free Seats Foundation came to Prospera in 2022
- 6:41to check out you know if it's real pretty much because back then there was only this building
- 6:51that we're in now the Beta building and everything else was just kind of being built or you know you
- 6:56couldn't he couldn't even stay here we had to stay in a little um hotel a little kind of guest house
- 7:02in fact which is where we you and me met and we recorded a an audio podcast just sitting on the
- 7:07sofas in there i don't know whether you do remember for sure but what i did was i got the ai to listen
- 7:15to what we talked about four years ago which it has and it's really interesting um it mentions a
- 7:23few things like a long discussion on sovereignty what's funny about it is it shows you how far
- 7:28I've come as well the things we talked about I didn't really know much about anything I was very
- 7:34green very naive back then we had a long discussion on sovereignty Latin America's particular problems
- 7:40and then all about the ZA legal framework Bitcoin treated as legal tender in Prospero because you
- 7:49were working on a bank project at the time um you were deeply concerned about cbdc's interestingly
- 7:54you probably still are we should talk about that um expropriation controversy and your 50-year
- 8:03vision for prosper you actually said your 50-year vision for prosper i'll come into that in a bit
- 8:08oh boy i don't remember that one no do you want me to tell you what it said we'll get to it all
- 8:13Right, okay.
- 8:15But what's fascinating is how bullish you were, actually.
- 8:22Remember, the time we were speaking was during,
- 8:26the government were basically coming down hard.
- 8:30And it was quite fresh then as well, I think.
- 8:34They said this was recorded right around the time
- 8:37the hostile Xiomara Castro government took power.
- 8:41was around april 2022 or something no i think it was more like november november 2022 okay
- 8:47so when did they get into power uh they january 2022 but that was like the first year yeah right
- 8:55so they'd been in for a while and it was bad so the socialists have been in for almost a year
- 9:00when we spoke to you um but you were really still bullish it's quite here it said i asked the ai to
- 9:07What should I talk to him about?
- 9:10It says here, the legal protections you were betting on in 2022 actually held.
- 9:16You were right.
- 9:18But the way Christian speaks is he felt very sure they were going to hold, whereas a lot of other people didn't.
- 9:27It says, ask him, what does it feel like having watched it play out from the inside?
- 9:33It was quite a ride, Tim.
- 9:36I can tell you that.
- 9:37I'm very glad to hear that I had that bullish tone back in the day.
- 9:43That was the first year I trusted very much in the design,
- 9:48in the legal design and the legal protections that were put in place
- 9:51in our initial positions, vulnerable as we were as a community.
- 9:58And I also trusted the team that was behind it,
- 10:02both Prosper the Company and Prosper the Zone,
- 10:04that we had what we needed to move forward.
- 10:08Maybe I did not anticipate that it was going to be so tiresome.
- 10:14It was like rough four years.
- 10:17So in 2022 they managed to repeal the law and they started the process to modify the Constitution And then 2023 was a very hard year because we were waiting everybody was waiting to see if Congress would be able to confirm that constitutional modification which didn happen
- 10:40But of course, that meant that there were not a lot of new projects happening inside of the jurisdiction.
- 10:45uh there were just you know a handful of companies that had started maybe back in 2021
- 10:50um so we had you know we had to keep the fort together we had to keep it running
- 10:56uh and and we did this the zone kept operating um then well yeah congress was not able to confirm
- 11:03those constitutional changes so the figure of special economic zones is still to this day
- 11:08in the constitution um so then 2024 it started to get a bit better uh we also had the first
- 11:16infinita pop-up city which was called vitalia at that time uh so that attracted a lot of like
- 11:22new fresh people um and then other projects started to come as well um and then 2025 also
- 11:30like we we had some movement and now it's we're in a very good position but what it what the ai
- 11:37I picked up on was the fact that you really believed that it was going to work you gave
- 11:41the impression basically that that it was all it was fine um and I may not well what would I know
- 11:50I wasn't I was watching from afar but I did know that people felt well for example when I spoke to
- 11:56Gabe the other day he said we decided we sat down when they lost the election or when when the the
- 12:02the socialists won the election they sat down with all the guys and said look what are we going to do
- 12:06and they decided they made a conscious decision to lean in to it to actually just plow on rather
- 12:12than to one of the options of course is just to hold back and put everything on hold until that
- 12:17point which is kind of what morizan did right morizan much more put stuff on hold whereas um
- 12:25here i mean you got a new round of well prosper got a new round of investment during that time
- 12:31um which is which is the bit i couldn't understand that for me was a great sign i was thinking blimey
- 12:37who's investing when when they could when they're basically been they were had already been told
- 12:43they're they're shut down so someone somewhere i was thinking let's just go for it you know
- 12:48i remember that podcast uh one of your episodes for you when you touched this a couple of years
- 12:53ago it's like they got like 10 million dollars in investments now from coinbase like how does
- 12:58that happen right it's like a sea turtles made it's like jack sparrow it's uh and it was
- 13:05very important for the community for continuing to move forward to have gained the confidence
- 13:11of you know institutional big investors like coinbase like tim draper and everything that
- 13:16came around that i know it's i mean probably more so than than you could have thought and that's
- 13:23definitely been um you've definitely well people here have definitely worked on top of that
- 13:30nicholas especially i think what and infinita has really sort of like used that as a springboard
- 13:36because you know that must have been quite a big uh kick up the ass for you guys so to speak
- 13:43that these guys want to come so let's let's push this let's push this on a bit more you know
- 13:48I mean yeah yeah definitely it's uh with with Nicholas we've been very fortunate to help out
- 13:56a lot in this past few years getting people to come to start projects here to invest I knew
- 14:02Nicholas back in around that time 2022 maybe was when he first came I moved to Prospera in late
- 14:092021 and we became friends but everyone was working on their own project Infinita was only
- 14:16initially a fund, like it was the Infinita fund that Nicholas managed.
- 14:21But then it was late 2023, Susan, who had just happened, the first pop-up city that
- 14:27was promoted by Vitalik.
- 14:29And it had all these elements, people, some people into longevity, some people into crypto.
- 14:35Nicholas went, Gabe went, and they said, you know, what if we replicate this year, right?
- 14:41And we were coming out of this very, very rough years.
- 14:44And we had the first pop-up experience, which we were very lucky to attract some very talented people to that first edition.
- 14:52Biology was here and Brian Johnson came and Naval was here.
- 14:56So that was an important signal for the market that this was moving forward.
- 15:02Yeah, I think it's a massive signal for the market.
- 15:04Funnily enough, just thinking it through here, are you one of the longest running residents here as I think about it?
- 15:11because I used to think Nicholas was one of the longest running residents here,
- 15:15but you were here the same time, right?
- 15:17I think I would be.
- 15:19I think I'm probably top 50, maybe, something around those lines.
- 15:24Or more, I would have thought.
- 15:26I mean, Eric's been here a very long time, right?
- 15:29Yeah, yeah.
- 15:30I mean when I came here Tim like Nicholas hadn come yet Like I came first the first time in April 2021 I was doing some research for for a think tank back then about the economic conditions in Honduras
- 15:45and I was covering the zones. And I came here, the beta building, that was the only thing that
- 15:50was happening. I was already involved in the special economic zone movement in the country
- 15:55with, you know, promoting the law the years before that. But when I moved here, it was only this
- 16:00building the better building they hadn't acquired pristine bay yet and you know i had a um a job at
- 16:08corporate law firm i was a corporate attorney you know servicing banks and financial institutions
- 16:12and i you know i decided to quit to move here to bring my own things my own projects and see how i
- 16:18could help out with you know keeping this alive and keeping this running um and that was before
- 16:24nick and that was before dushan as well from amity age he came in 2022 um so yeah we're just maybe
- 16:32but yeah that's that's what i think that's worth noting and the other thing i think it's worth
- 16:38noting is your honduran as well because a lot of the people you know i this is the my my observation
- 16:46at least is prosper specifically is very foreigner centric as opposed to somewhere like
- 16:54morazan which is you will find mainly hondurans living there in fact almost exclusively hondurans
- 17:00here in prospera you see many more outsiders you see a lot of hondurans working here but you don't
- 17:07see a lot of hondurans doing business here yet is that is that true first of all is that is that fair
- 17:13to say um generally i think there are different aspects to it um of course prosper is a different
- 17:21model than Morazon. They target different audiences. What happens with Prospera is it's
- 17:28very much tailored for entrepreneurs, innovative businesses, also for big manufacturing operations.
- 17:36Hopefully, we get those running soon enough in the community. But what happens with that is
- 17:42that you need to attract people that are very comfortable with taking risks
- 17:49with entrepreneurs in that sense.
- 17:52And of course, there was a risk
- 17:53during the past four years,
- 17:55but for Hondurans to come here
- 17:57and put their own projects
- 17:58as entrepreneurs, as businessmen,
- 18:01the risk was even higher, right?
- 18:03Because there was an opposing government
- 18:06that wouldn't just affect
- 18:08maybe your business in Prospera,
- 18:09but your broader operations in the country.
- 18:13So there was a leap we had to take,
- 18:16but now I'm seeing,
- 18:18as conditions have changed that a lot of more, you know,
- 18:21Honduran businessmen are interested in using the platform.
- 18:24And do you, how many other Hondurans, like you live here, right?
- 18:28You live in Duna.
- 18:30How many other Hondurans are there that live in there working like you,
- 18:34running businesses and stuff?
- 18:36I don't really have a number, but I would say maybe around half the people
- 18:41or a third of the people that live in Duna, the building are Honduran.
- 18:45Is that right?
- 18:46Yeah, I would say so.
- 18:46I just haven't noticed then.
- 18:48Every time I get in the lift, it's always someone from Silicon Valley or Europe or something like that.
- 18:54Yeah, it's a mixed bunch, right?
- 18:59We also have the phenomena that you have like Hondurans living in the building, but maybe they work outside of Prospera, but they still like it as a housing solution in Rotten and broader Rotten, right?
- 19:09Yeah, okay.
- 19:10Fair enough.
- 19:12Listen to this as well.
- 19:13I found this interesting.
- 19:15so the cbdc one right because you described cbdc's as the final boss of authoritarianism
- 19:26three years ago they've progressed a lot since then has anything changed your view
- 19:32are you still i mean are you an observer of this now because at the time you were working in the
- 19:37you were doing legal stuff for a bank so it was much more kind of relevant but are you but you're
- 19:43not doing that so much now so you're you're you're not doing legal stuff in in in uh financials are
- 19:49you i still do do provide services for financial institutions i like most of my clients are either
- 19:55doing financial activities or biotech and medical or doing some projects especially economic zones
- 20:01most of my time goes now with infinita uh which we have the lives and their own payment platform
- 20:08so i do keep the tabs on you know the banking world but not as much as back then um and
- 20:13Have you got an opinion on it then?
- 20:15I am still concerned.
- 20:16I'm still concerned.
- 20:17I think back then, you know, in 2022, it was more of an existential threat.
- 20:23With the political changes in the United States, I think that has, you know, at least if not
- 20:29been reduced, at least been delayed, you know, for better or for worse.
- 20:34I think that's a whole topic by itself.
- 20:35But at least regarding CBDCs, the policy changes in the US have served to delay that.
- 20:42I'm still concerned because they're still talking about it in Europe, right?
- 20:47But I still see a more...
- 20:50mature world nowadays that could, you know, prevent that from happening
- 20:55or if it happens to find solutions around it?
- 20:59I think, I don't know, my opinion is it's definitely happening
- 21:03and it's definitely going to happen.
- 21:07I don't know yet how I might deal with it,
- 21:11other than, for example, shifting to just using different currency,
- 21:17which is very easy to do these days,
- 21:18much more than four years ago four years ago when we spoke using bitcoin was it was you could do it
- 21:26but number one there weren't that many places that accepted it and number two um the the software
- 21:32wasn't as good the wallets you had on your phone they weren't as good they're great now you can
- 21:36live on a bitcoin standard anywhere in the world it's very simple and um but that would be my sort
- 21:43of predict prediction for dealing with cbdcs because the part of cbds we don't like is the
- 21:50fact that they can be used to literally control every single aspect of your life
- 21:55um i think as time goes on and we're seeing this in honda and in prosper here or you know parallel
- 22:03communities are arising around bitcoin especially and if it comes to it at the end of the day you
- 22:12could just move to be in a place where bitcoin is the currency that that would be my my my end game
- 22:19but it's not preferable i'll be honest i don't really want to have to run away to a place where
- 22:24everyone uses bitcoin only but i think the problem with cbdc's is once you're using a cbdc they can
- 22:30stop you getting on a plane or a train very easily if your programmable money doesn't allow you to
- 22:38pay for a train ticket for example and that can be based on almost anything but even the fact that
- 22:44we're talking about free cities now that may put us in a category of dangerous person in those
- 22:50places i don't know what you think about that yeah well i think it's more valuable strategically
- 22:57for the united states to continue embracing stable coins as something that is privately issued
- 23:04for several reasons, right?
- 23:07You can get more flexibility about how it's done.
- 23:10You reduce concerns from parties that use it
- 23:13that there is a direct oversight
- 23:15from the American government.
- 23:17And it is a way to continue promoting
- 23:21the use of the dollar, right?
- 23:23And have dollar keep being king from fiat currencies.
- 23:28So in the sense that I expect them
- 23:31to see that strategic value
- 23:32of just embracing stable coins as they have been doing.
- 23:36Maybe the CBDC threat is reduced or is delayed.
- 23:40If they would want to push it somehow,
- 23:43have the Federal Reserve issue it
- 23:45and then not permitting USDC or USDT,
- 23:48then I think that would be an uphill battle
- 23:50with its own political costs.
- 23:52But it's still concerning for sure,
- 23:54and especially in different parts of the world.
- 23:57But as you say, there's more solutions nowadays.
- 24:00You have, you know, token-backed cards, you're going to use Bitcoin.
- 24:05So I think it's the same type of battle that we need to continue having towards, you know, some of these principles behind free cities or special economic zones, right?
- 24:16Separation of powers and keeping governments in check.
- 24:19There's always going to be a threat just for the fact that the technology still exists.
- 24:24But I think we are in a better position now.
- 24:26What's the general stance of the Honduran government on things like Bitcoin?
- 24:32Do you know?
- 24:33I mean, obviously, there's been a positive change.
- 24:36We know that.
- 24:37But I've never asked anyone what they actually feel about all that stuff.
- 24:42This new government, they just started a couple months ago, right?
- 24:45So they haven't made any official posturing about crypto technology.
- 24:50But nowadays, Tim, it's not that controversial.
- 24:54it's like there are operating exchanges
- 24:56and several crypto companies in the country
- 24:58inside of Prosper especially of course
- 25:00so my expectation is that during this year or next year
- 25:05we're going to see some reforms
- 25:06towards the recognition of crypto assets and that technology
- 25:11just because we have El Salvador so close by
- 25:14because we have what's happening in Prospera
- 25:16so I think it just makes sense to update that policy
- 25:18Do people here, especially your average Honduran
- 25:23Do they know about El Salvador and what turnaround has happened?
- 25:26Is that like common news?
- 25:28Yes, very much so.
- 25:30People go to El Salvador for tourism.
- 25:33It's a success story in matters of security.
- 25:35The country did improve a lot.
- 25:38They're still moving towards make that become more directly involved with investment,
- 25:46have the country grow more.
- 25:47But at least regarding security, it is a clear investment.
- 25:50and they have like the downtown in San Salvador
- 25:52is so nice nowadays, yeah.
- 25:54Well I wondered because we hear about it a lot but I wasn sure whether it was something that because I mean the simple fact that you tell me that hondurans know about it i think great because that gonna basically um inspire them
- 26:11to insist that their government does better because um that's competition for them hopefully
- 26:18i mean gabe talked about this a bit the other day when i was speaking to him you know it's it's a
- 26:23big signal to the market that look if you can get on top of this that and the other in their case in
- 26:28el salvador's case get on top of the violence and and stop it you can literally turn your country
- 26:34around in a couple of years which appears to be what's happened um and correct me if i'm wrong but
- 26:40in honduras the the violence problem is not as bad as it was in el salvador is it or is it
- 26:46no it's not as bad and and first of all i do agree with what you were saying it's it's the
- 26:52base layer like those are the primary functions that a government you know should do provide
- 26:57security um provide access to justice right rule of law and courts that's the basic stuff
- 27:03so once we we figure that out or you know we improve those conditions the other institutions
- 27:08in the country can continue growing um yeah the conditions in honduras are like the darkest period
- 27:14when people think about violence in honduras they may be thinking around the time maybe between
- 27:202009 and like 2015, 2016, where there was a lot of violence happening.
- 27:30You had San Pedro Sula, which is actually my hometown, was the most violent city in
- 27:34the world for, you know, quite a few years.
- 27:37There was a lot of...
- 27:38When did you leave?
- 27:40I did.
- 27:41Just when it got better.
- 27:42No, actually, it was when I started my undergrad.
- 27:46I was still living in my hometown.
- 27:48and it was very isolated in certain parts of the city,
- 27:55so it's not like the whole city was very dangerous.
- 27:58But still, during those times, you had clubs and bars shutting down
- 28:01and when you're in your early 20s, you had to party a lot in houses and so on.
- 28:09So there was a lot of gang violence back then
- 28:11and drug trafficking-related violence clashes,
- 28:16but that did improve fortunately around 2016 there were new measures taken there was there was a
- 28:23what they called like a maritime shield like big raiders for detecting drug trafficking
- 28:28so conditions did improve it's still there's still you know a lot of challenges um in the country but
- 28:35it's not as bad as it was do you think it needs someone like bukele then does it need that that
- 28:40version absolute iron fist version of of government i do believe you need someone with
- 28:48decision and who's able to you know implement policies and implement plans not thinking about
- 28:54the immediate you know pr backlash that may happen uh i think the el salvador model worked
- 29:01very well for them there are people that have concerns about some of its implications but it's
- 29:07also a different scenario like el salvador is a very small country very more culturally homogeneous
- 29:13than honduras so honduras presents different challenges but what you can um you know be
- 29:20impressed by is the decision and the drive that they had to move forward and to implement this
- 29:23do you know what the rest of latin america thinks about honduras at the moment you know like does
- 29:29it have an opinion on what honduras is where is it's going and does it even know anything about
- 29:34the ZAs for example like is it like like you say we Latin America knows about Bukele it's a it's a
- 29:41story that everyone knows does anyone know what's going on in Honduras at the moment um what I've
- 29:48seen is something very interesting not not just about Honduras in specific but generally in the
- 29:53region uh and I have an article about that recently um that you know Marxist governments
- 30:00as Marxist parties, they have been in communication always, right, for the last few decades, and they
- 30:06were able to coordinate among themselves very well. That was not what was happening with more
- 30:11conservative parties or libertarian parties. That only started happening recently, probably, yeah,
- 30:19being led by Argentina and its own government. So now when elections happen, it becomes a regional
- 30:26matter so there can be more coordination between you know the different sides of
- 30:33what's happening so in that sense Honduras was people that are into
- 30:39politics right and you know read international news paid a lot of
- 30:43attention what happened in the last elections Honduras has always been
- 30:47traditionally conservative a close ally to the US we have one of the biggest US
- 30:52military bases.
- 30:55So they did pay attention to what happened here
- 30:57and to the fact that the Marxists came into power
- 31:00in the previous elections, essentially lying to people.
- 31:04They were part of a moderate coalition.
- 31:06They didn't present themselves as a Marxist alternative.
- 31:10And I think that was very clear for people seen from afar That being said there still a lot of things to improve
- 31:20A lot of things to improve about the PR, the communications, the image that Honduras transmits to the world.
- 31:27Because there's a lot of things happening here, especially with the zones.
- 31:31People that are in the know, that know about special economic zones and free cities, they know what's happening here.
- 31:37at least have some reference to Prosper or to Morazan.
- 31:42But mostly I think it's still being associated
- 31:44as a place that has a lot of challenges
- 31:46that we need to overcome.
- 31:48And what about within the country?
- 31:50I heard that the ZAs were used as a bit of a punching bag
- 31:54during the election.
- 31:55But does your average person on the street in Honduras
- 31:59know anything about Prosper or Morazan or ZAs,
- 32:03the ZA idea?
- 32:04Is it something that people know about?
- 32:07Most people don't really think about this.
- 32:10Or even know about it.
- 32:11Yeah.
- 32:11Would they have heard about it?
- 32:12They for sure would have heard about the set.
- 32:14It was part of the political campaign in the elections in 2021.
- 32:19It was a big thing.
- 32:20And the government did take us out to dance every few months as a punching bag to, you know, make us guilty of something that happened in the country or, you know, to divert attention.
- 32:30that being said because the previous government the marxist government ended up being you know
- 32:39people really didn't like them they only received around 10 percent of the electoral mass voted for
- 32:46them they lied a lot almost compulsively so people catched on to that so that paired with
- 32:56The fact that Prospera has been growing, these zones have been growing, have been moderately successful, even in those conditions with a hostile government, made people think about it a lot.
- 33:09Because back then in 2021, these things really, they were just starting, right?
- 33:12So all of the attacks were against the idea of what the zone would be, what it can do.
- 33:18So it was very abstract.
- 33:19but now that they actually exist as communities and people you know tell their stories and maybe
- 33:24you know someone that went or worked there so slowly the perception has been improving
- 33:30I would I would say most people really like aren't different to it like they just see it as you know
- 33:36some free zones and you know if they're good for the country that's great if not somebody should
- 33:40deal with them so I think that's the stance of most people you know hopefully the government will
- 33:45find a way forward.
- 33:47Of course, there's people that have really seen the value of it and have come and really
- 33:51like the idea and, you know, the potential for the country.
- 33:54And of course, there's always going to be a minority that is against it for, you know,
- 33:58ideological reasons.
- 34:00But at least the lies that were said, I think it's very clear that they were not true.
- 34:04Like the ideas that the Sons would expropriate, you know, people that live close by, that
- 34:10this would serve as, you know, havens for criminals, you know, nonsensical things.
- 34:14I think it's very clear that that is not true.
- 34:17What's then, one of the things I used to hear about a lot in the early days was like voices coming out of Crawfish Rock.
- 34:24For those listening, Crawfish Rock's the nearest village to where the Beta building, where this district was actually built.
- 34:32And so as a Honduran, what's your impression of that situation now?
- 34:38What do you go, I mean, do you know anyone down in Crawfish Rock?
- 34:40What do you think? What's the general consensus that comes out of Crawfish Rock?
- 34:46Are people still complaining? Are people for it, against it?
- 34:50Well, there's a lot of backstory in the sense that Crawfish Rock is a very small community.
- 34:58Maybe I don't think it's more than 400 people living there.
- 35:03They had their own community association.
- 35:06and then there was a community well.
- 35:11There was a community for a water well.
- 35:13There was a community well,
- 35:14which was owned by the president of the community association
- 35:19and then Prosper.
- 35:20This is early on.
- 35:21This is maybe 2020.
- 35:24Wanted to provide who could be a good neighbor,
- 35:27provide a well for the community,
- 35:29but apparently that touched some interest there.
- 35:32So it ended up being just a very local interest
- 35:35that ended up being touched.
- 35:37At this point, I think it's the same position.
- 35:41Most of them just don't care.
- 35:42It's like, hopefully this works out.
- 35:43If this works out, you know, people can get more jobs.
- 35:46Right now, I think it's maybe around 30% of the community
- 35:49that works in some project adjacent to Prospera.
- 35:53So it's, you know, fairly divided, right?
- 35:57Are you saying with the well,
- 35:59the guy that owned the well got pissed off
- 36:01because Prospera offered them free water, did you say?
- 36:04Or a free well?
- 36:05Something like that, yeah.
- 36:07I was not involved directly in that, but yeah,
- 36:09then they would have lost their ability
- 36:13to make people pay for the water, right?
- 36:16It's a bit dodgy.
- 36:20I've got another one for you here,
- 36:22which I thought was interesting And I think you know this is because you a lawyer i i i very much interested in your opinion on this because when i was talking to gabe the other day
- 36:37we were talking about what happened with um the government uh the socialist government
- 36:43i said to him oh yeah and they rescinded the the law from the constitution and he told me i i didn't
- 36:52I didn't actually get that correct.
- 36:54So can you just tell me exactly what happened in layman's terms,
- 37:00bear in mind I'm not a liar,
- 37:01so that I can say the right thing from now on?
- 37:04Because I don't want to keep saying the wrong thing, basically.
- 37:09Yeah, it has been.
- 37:11Give me the timeline, first of all.
- 37:13So, you know, and lay it out in layman's terms.
- 37:17Yeah, it has become a complex thing with the years, for sure.
- 37:20But essentially, there's four or five layers of legal protection for the regime, for the special economic zones in Honduras generally, which were included in the organic law, in the constitutional reforms, and international treaties.
- 37:43This is back in 2013, 2014, when the current version of the zones, the CERE, was approved.
- 37:50So we can start with covering those layers and then see how they were able to peel some of them off or not.
- 37:59So the first one was contractual.
- 38:02There were stability agreements between the government and the companies here that acted as promoters and organizers of the zones.
- 38:10In this case, HPI, Honduras, Prosper, Inc.
- 38:13Of course, the government did not respect that agreement.
- 38:17They never recognized it.
- 38:20And then the second layer was the organic law.
- 38:25So the actual law, the regular law, let's say, in a way, about the special economic zones that included how do they get approved and a lot of the details about how they worked.
- 38:39That law required a supermajority in Congress to be repealed, and it was approved that way.
- 38:47they were able to get those votes in the first year of last Congress.
- 38:52So that law got repealed.
- 38:54What that meant...
- 38:55So that part, and that's the part that allowed new ZAs.
- 38:59That was the bit that said, if you want to create a new ZA,
- 39:02here are the rules for that.
- 39:04Is that right?
- 39:04Exactly.
- 39:05So without that law, there cannot be new ZAs.
- 39:08Right.
- 39:08So did they repeal the first one as well, the contract one?
- 39:11Or they just ignored it?
- 39:12They just ignored them, essentially.
- 39:14Okay.
- 39:14So they ignored the number one.
- 39:16they rescinded number two or retracted number two.
- 39:20They retracted number two.
- 39:21Yeah.
- 39:22And then the third layer of protection was in the constitution.
- 39:26When the special economic zone regime was approved in Honduras,
- 39:30it was included in the constitution.
- 39:33For making constitutional changes in Honduras,
- 39:36you need to approve it once and then confirm it in the second year of Congress.
- 39:44That's what they did, you know, back in 2013, 2014.
- 39:49Here, in 2022, when they repealed the law,
- 39:53they managed to approve the modification of the Constitution
- 39:57to take the SERE regime out.
- 40:00So they did the first approval.
- 40:03But not the second one?
- 40:04Not the second one.
- 40:05That's the thing.
- 40:06So, okay, right.
- 40:09So why does everyone say they repealed the law then?
- 40:12They repealed the organic law, the second layer.
- 40:16But they didn't change anything about the Constitution.
- 40:21They did not touch it in the Constitution.
- 40:23That's crazy.
- 40:24I think most people think they changed the Constitution back to what it was.
- 40:30No, they did not.
- 40:33And yes, it was a lot of expectation in 2023.
- 40:36Would they actually do it?
- 40:38So they had to confirm it in 2023.
- 40:41but what happened is that by 2023 they had eroded any political capital that they may have had at
- 40:49the beginning. So they were not even near to get the votes to approve this. And also when, you know,
- 40:56Congress approved for the repeal of the law and approved, you know, to start the process for
- 41:02modifying the constitution, the opposition parties back then were very clear that they were voting for
- 41:07this as long as the government, you know, talked with the investors and figured out a way to continue
- 41:12moving forward to, you know, protect the existing already investments and the existing jobs.
- 41:16That, of course, didn't happen. There was, you know, there were radicals. They were ideologically
- 41:22opposed to everything that we want to do here. So by 2023, you know, this stuff happened in the
- 41:27country and they had no political capital. They were not able to confirm that modification. So
- 41:34there was no modification to the constitution.
- 41:36You go look for it and they're still there.
- 41:39And what about
- 41:40You said there were five layers, four and five, which they obviously didn't touch.
- 41:44So they touched the first two, but three, four, and five.
- 41:47Three, four, and five didn't touch.
- 41:49Yeah.
- 41:50Four would be, well, it depends how you want to see it.
- 41:54But yeah, essentially on top of the constitution or, you know, at the same time,
- 41:58depends on how you want to interpret it.
- 42:01But alongside these changes, there was also an investment agreement,
- 42:08and it's an investment treaty with Kuwait that granted certain protections for investments made
- 42:17by Kuwaitis in the special economic zone regime. Now, Honduras has historically very good relations
- 42:24with Kuwait as with many other countries, but it's not like you see a lot of Kuwaitis here.
- 42:29So what was the point?
- 42:32By including those protections in that treaty, you triggered the free trade agreement with the United States, which is CAFTADR, the free trade agreement between the United States, Central America, and the Dominican Republic.
- 42:47CAFTADR has a most favored nation clause.
- 42:51essentially in layman terms it means that any protection or any benefit that a country recognizes
- 42:59to investments from any particular country should also be recognized for american investments
- 43:06so that's how you bring the u.s into the fold wow was that four was that four and five four and five
- 43:12five is kafta and kafta and four is the agreement with kuwait and so this is fascinating i've never
- 43:20i don't know what it's like in the world of law and legality and stuff
- 43:25tell me if this is true when they were creating the za regime
- 43:31people are thinking like this right we need to create some ways to protect this
- 43:37and then they look into precedents and or they look into other things around the world and they
- 43:42go right if we do this then this can happen they don't go for example to try like why didn't they
- 43:47go to the US and say, would you like to make an agreement with us? Why do they do it, you know,
- 43:54in the roundabout ways? Because people don't take Honduras seriously, or because you can't get in
- 43:59the room with the US, or what? How does it work? Well, I mean, it's, it's like the CAFTADR was
- 44:06already in place, already had the most favoured nation clause. And, you know, free trade agreements
- 44:12or trade agreements in general with the US take a lot of time, a lot of negotiations,
- 44:16um so i if they wanted to be agile i don't think that was really an option um
- 44:23and and they already had you know the good relationships and again
- 44:26we already have it we already had it in cafta dr so there was there was
- 44:30no need to to to do anything else that would compromise that agility
- 44:34so i was i'm going to ask you but before i do i'm going to read out something from here i'm
- 44:39going to ask you whether you think this is a good set of rules but let me tell you what
- 44:45chat tpt said about our previous conversation first it said on the za legal framework um christian
- 44:51considers that it's the most advanced special economic zone framework in the world the key
- 44:57innovation is being able to choose regulation from oec oecds and stuff do you still think it's
- 45:04like you know that good yeah and this is also that good like if you if you were doing this in costa
- 45:12for example would you follow the same protocol it's well you know every country is different
- 45:17right but essentially i think we figured out a framework that worked that evidently resisted a
- 45:24very hostile government um there were elements in place that worked towards this like we had
- 45:30these five layers of protection yes also the country was part of exit which is the um essentially
- 45:37the International Court for Investment State Disputes.
- 45:41So that was already in place.
- 45:43We already have CAFTA-DR.
- 45:46And in this part of the world, of course,
- 45:48many times the U.S. is your primary trade partner.
- 45:51The U.S. has a very big present influence in Central America.
- 45:56So we already had all those elements in place.
- 46:00I believed in it very much to the extent, Tim,
- 46:03that I waged my own career and my own life by Komen here.
- 46:07it had to resist.
- 46:09If it hadn't resisted, I probably,
- 46:11I used to joke that if it hadn't resisted,
- 46:14I would have stopped practicing law,
- 46:16stopped believing in it.
- 46:19There could be like specific things
- 46:21that could have been added.
- 46:23For example, what Disney did in Florida
- 46:25when they got their own special economic zone,
- 46:28there's like a bond that acts as a guarantee.
- 46:31So that's like an additional thing
- 46:32that could have been included in the stability agreement.
- 46:37perhaps seeking out immunity from decision makers
- 46:42from the government in the sense that they could be
- 46:44personally liable for their decisions.
- 46:46So there could have been other details but generally speaking it yeah it that was the architecture those levels of protection in those four five layers where the the 50 years bit in which layer is that the bit that says you
- 46:59can do this for 50 years kuwait oh that's so it's in number four yeah so that didn't get touched
- 47:05either that didn't get touched either so essentially we're at a point where the the even
- 47:11Even with everything that had been done, currently, and this is even when the last government were in power, because nothing's changed since then, has it, yet?
- 47:22Not formally.
- 47:24Right, okay.
- 47:25Even then, ZAs were allowed to exist, they just weren't allowed to make new ones.
- 47:31Is that the long and short of it?
- 47:34Yeah.
- 47:36Essentially.
- 47:37With what they did in Congress.
- 47:40Afterwards, there was a ruling from the Supreme Court.
- 47:42I don't know if you want to get into that right now.
- 47:45But yeah, it's okay.
- 47:48So by the time, you know, Prosper starts building, that's 2020.
- 47:53There had already been, I think, three or four confirmations from the Supreme Court of Honduras about the legality of the Sede regime of the special economic zones moving forward.
- 48:03Then the new government comes into power.
- 48:05They repealed the law of 2022.
- 48:06They were not able to confirm this in 2023.
- 48:13So then what happens?
- 48:14You know, they were not able to.
- 48:16We continue operating.
- 48:18Can I just stop you again there?
- 48:19I'm still not sure.
- 48:20I do not understand that.
- 48:21When you say they rescind the law, the law exists within the Constitution or the law is separate to the Constitution?
- 48:28Separate from the Constitution.
- 48:29That's the organic law.
- 48:31But does the Constitution give rise to the law?
- 48:34Yes, yes, of course.
- 48:35Okay. I just I don't understand why that's a separate thing. Is that just something that to do with law?
- 48:41Yeah, yeah, just just legal technique.
- 48:44Like if you create a constitution that says you can have these zones, they can they need 50 years of guaranteed existence. And here are the rules or do the rules for making ZAs not exist in the constitution? They exist as a separate law?
- 49:00Is that how it worked?
- 49:01I mean, there was the minimal requirements are in the Constitution,
- 49:05and they're still now.
- 49:06Like, what is the zone?
- 49:07What sort of abilities does it have?
- 49:09Where can they be built and set up?
- 49:11All that is the basic stuff is the Constitution.
- 49:14But then the law actually creates, like, the procedure.
- 49:17How would you, you know, what are the specific requirements,
- 49:20the things to attach, the things that you can touch and cannot touch.
- 49:23So the details were in the law.
- 49:25But who has the right to repeal laws, then?
- 49:28in the government?
- 49:30Congress.
- 49:31Congress.
- 49:32Okay, Congress can.
- 49:33So Congress,
- 49:35and what does precedent matter in those cases,
- 49:38as in like previous, you know,
- 49:42the fact that the law was created has a precedent.
- 49:46There's a precedent there as to why it was created.
- 49:49How do you get to repeal it, just purely by vote?
- 49:52Essentially.
- 49:52You know, sometimes law do have requirements,
- 49:55conditions like this.
- 49:56They had to be repealed by a supermajority.
- 49:59But yeah, essentially, if you get the votes, you...
- 50:03Well, there was an argument back in the day that they should have not been able to repeal the law because it was protected in different ways.
- 50:14But we decided not to move down that path because it would have made things more complex back in the day.
- 50:21so it was
- 50:23it was a complex
- 50:25legal scenario for sure
- 50:26okay sorry go back to that
- 50:29other thing you were talking about
- 50:30when I butted in sorry I was a bit rude
- 50:32are you getting hot by the way do you want me to put the air calm
- 50:34oh that would help
- 50:35it's the noise
- 50:38I've just added an extra
- 50:40two hours worth of post production time
- 50:42oh no
- 50:44I'm trying my hardest
- 50:46I thought you're a Honduran you should be able to put up with this
- 50:49oh it's because I'm a Honduran
- 50:51it means I sweat well.
- 50:53So I have a good cooling system.
- 50:57We were talking about the...
- 51:01You said that there was...
- 51:03Oh, completely forgotten.
- 51:04There was something else.
- 51:05We did the five layers.
- 51:06The ruling.
- 51:08Yes, the ruling.
- 51:08That's it, yeah.
- 51:09Okay.
- 51:10So they were able to repeal the organic law in 2022.
- 51:16They were not able to confirm the modification
- 51:19of the Constitution in 2023.
- 51:22So...
- 51:23I've got another question.
- 51:24Sorry.
- 51:24Keep hiding.
- 51:25When they failed to repeal the Constitution,
- 51:28what was the political makeup of Congress at the time?
- 51:34Like, was it mainly socialists?
- 51:37Or was it...
- 51:38How did it...
- 51:40How come it didn't get passed?
- 51:42Nobody got a majority.
- 51:44Like, again, Honduras has always been
- 51:47a very conservative country.
- 51:48So the socialists were the party that had most votes in Congress, but they didn't have majority by themselves either.
- 51:56So when they repealed the law they got the votes from the opposition parties again in the condition that government should figure out a way forward with investors That didn happen Then the opposition parties did not you know accompany them
- 52:11And were they being less socialist at the beginning as well?
- 52:14Like you said, they came in on certain policies.
- 52:16Yeah.
- 52:17Yeah.
- 52:17I mean, when they started, people, you know, you know, they want you to want to trust the government.
- 52:21Right.
- 52:22You want to trust them in good faith.
- 52:23You know, maybe.
- 52:24Well, not me.
- 52:25But many times people, I guess, try to believe that governments have good intentions.
- 52:35So, yeah, it was very early on.
- 52:37People were still giving them, you know, the benefit of the doubt.
- 52:40They were not as authoritarian as they tried to be afterwards.
- 52:44So they went along with it.
- 52:46But by 2023, it was clear that these people, you know, meant no good.
- 52:50Right.
- 52:50Okay.
- 52:50Sorry.
- 52:50Go back to...
- 52:51So yeah, so they were not able to confirm the constitutional amendment.
- 52:57So then the court issued, this was late 2024, issued a very strange ruling about the supposed
- 53:11inconstitutionality of it all.
- 53:13And it was an irregular process. They had to get some deputy magistrates to vote for it. So it was a regular approval by itself. But even when you go to the ruling, it's very strange in the sense that it doesn't individualize rights.
- 53:33I don't want to get too lawyery, but essentially it doesn't refer to the consolidated rights that Prospera and the other zones had, which is a big part still of our defense that we have consolidated rights.
- 53:48Even if you declare it unconstitutional retroactively, which is also illegal, you shouldn't be able to touch us.
- 53:54So they declared it unconstitutional.
- 53:57Again, this was already confirmed as constitutional by three rulings earlier.
- 54:02but now in 2024 they declare it unconstitutional but how it works in Honduras and that's you know
- 54:08the the general standard of you know rule of law and in the free world is you declare
- 54:14unconstitutional towards the future you know consolidated rights of citizens you know should
- 54:19not be affected by this but they didn't believe in the most basic fundaments of the law
- 54:25it was ideologically motivated so they decided to do it in constitutional retractively which is
- 54:34completely out of line completely out of you know basic law principles has anyone ever done that
- 54:39anywhere in the world like can you because that seems counterintuitive completely because that
- 54:45then makes all constitutional changes not real essentially plus the constant that means everyone
- 54:54that voted on that did something illegal, right?
- 54:57So all of a sudden, those people in the past become illegal.
- 55:01So how can you do that?
- 55:03You can't change what people were at the time.
- 55:06Exactly.
- 55:07Has anyone ever done that in the world?
- 55:10Maybe in some other place, in some authoritarian countries,
- 55:13but it had for sure never happened in Honduras before.
- 55:16It was completely out of line.
- 55:18It was nonsense, Tim.
- 55:18And you're very right in saying that this was then used as a threat to the congressman that had very validly approved it years before that they had committed treason or whatever nonsense they may want to use as an argument.
- 55:36So they declare it unconstitutional or retractively, but the ruling still doesn't individualize the consolidated rights.
- 55:46It doesn't mention what happens with these people, with Prospera, with Morazan, with Orchid.
- 55:52The ruling also doesn't order anything.
- 55:55It's not like it orders a government agency to pursue this in some way or another.
- 56:02So first, I don't recognize that ruling.
- 56:06It's because you cannot make something unconstitutional retractively.
- 56:10So it's null and void.
- 56:12It's just for existing.
- 56:13But even if we were to recognize that ruling, which is what we had to do, we interpreted that it doesn't touch us.
- 56:21So we continue to move forward.
- 56:24But yeah, right after that ruling came out, which was in late 2024, it was the legal community.
- 56:35There's a group of lawyers that are involved in this special economic zones thing.
- 56:39you know do you have prosperous legal team and morrison's legal team and just people like myself
- 56:43that don't work with them directly but are residents and are involved and it was it was
- 56:50very hard on us because this shouldn't have happened like it was completely illegal what
- 56:54they were doing so how do we move forward how do we keep this alive at least for one more year
- 57:02But so there was a lot of analysis.
- 57:04And in the end, it was clear to us, at least,
- 57:09that it didn't touch us and we could continue moving forward.
- 57:12How much do you think the threat of you guys or from Prosperous suing them how much did that actually have an effect do you think
- 57:24I mean, what was the lawsuit? It was like some ridiculous amount of billions, wasn't it?
- 57:28Yeah, it started being around close to $11 billion,
- 57:31which is, you know, substantial for a small country like Honduras.
- 57:35Which is basically, and this was based on the CAFTA DR agreement, was it?
- 57:40Yeah.
- 57:40Yeah, which was what the main thing you had or the main thing Prospero had to retract this was to sue the government with this exorbitant amount of money.
- 57:53How much do you think it actually made them think about it?
- 57:58I think it was important.
- 57:59I think it was the right decision at the time.
- 58:03It was an important deterrent element.
- 58:05that the lawsuit itself and also the support that we got from the state department in the u.s you
- 58:12know you know protecting uh american investments and just you know the recognition the the application
- 58:19of international treaties right if you're not if these countries don't respect the international
- 58:24treaties with the u.s what good are they for uh so we also got um some support even publicly right
- 58:31from the State Department and the local embassy.
- 58:35And it was always with the narrative of find a negotiation,
- 58:40find a way to move forward,
- 58:42but the previous government never was interested
- 58:44in talking about anything.
- 58:45I was going to say, that's the impression I got.
- 58:47By this point, they're just trying to shut the place down.
- 58:52And then at one end, they'll do anything, like you say,
- 58:55try and retroactively change the Constitution,
- 58:57which doesn't make any sense at all.
- 58:58But then a point came, and I remember it, was that the government were reporting success because they had stopped new ZAs being formed.
- 59:10That was the success story.
- 59:12And prior to that, it was the success was we're shutting down the ZAs.
- 59:19And that was a big moment, I think, because it showed they actually lost, but they tried to spin it into a win.
- 59:26because they actually downgraded their own success.
- 59:30And I think that for me was the one point where I thought,
- 59:34because I was following it from afar, obviously,
- 59:37but it's like, huh, that's unusual to admit.
- 59:42That's a bit like Trump when he wants to shut down the Strait of Hormuz.
- 59:46He says, we're going to shut it down.
- 59:48And then the next day he's saying, we're going to block it
- 59:50because he can't shut it down.
- 59:52He's downgraded.
- 59:54It doesn't look good.
- 59:54it doesn't look good out you know like in the public eye there that you're you're saying we're
- 1:00:00going to close the ZAs and um now we're going to stop the ZAs and actually now you're saying actually
- 1:00:07we're not going to stop them we're just going to stop new ones happening you know which sounds to
- 1:00:13me like even that's going to change now is it I mean what would your prediction be for the
- 1:00:17for the coming sort of six to 12 months well yeah hopefully uh hopefully we get a new law
- 1:00:25and you know we can continue implementing the vision but yeah i agree with you it's like and
- 1:00:29that's what they're still saying nowadays oh we repealed the law so what it's like we still
- 1:00:34continue to operate they were not able to shut us down um and by the end of it it's like they try
- 1:00:41they try to make it into a matter in the last campaign but people really didn't care anymore
- 1:00:47So the settings were not mentioned really in any substantial way in the last campaign cycle, which I think it's also a strong signal of the difference in how people are perceiving it.
- 1:01:03Yeah, my expectation, Tim, is that we find a way forward to continue implementing the model.
- 1:01:09I think it's clear at this point that it has the potential to change the country, to dramatically improve the conditions.
- 1:01:16What if we become, I don't know, the Saudis of Central America?
- 1:01:21It's a very small population that can be able to generate a lot of wealth.
- 1:01:28It was designed originally by Hondurans, and Hondurans were going to be the ones to figure out a way forward.
- 1:01:36I know Prosper and Morizans are open to negotiating, to making changes to the regime.
- 1:01:41It's worth mentioning, you know, the regime was designed before Prosper or Morizan came.
- 1:01:46so it's not like they had any say on it uh but now it's like yeah for us are open to change some
- 1:01:51things improve it um make it uh make it politically attractive right for the powers that be that's
- 1:01:59interesting so do you think that you could this could be a blessing in disguise because it gets
- 1:02:05it gives you the opportunity to improve the laws it was definitely if not just because of that but
- 1:02:12It was definitely a blessing in disguise
- 1:02:14because we got to prove that the model worked and resisted.
- 1:02:16Sure, sure, sure.
- 1:02:17Because it's now, we were in the cradle.
- 1:02:21They tried to smothered us in the cradle.
- 1:02:22They were not able to.
- 1:02:25And it's like, Tim, I remember, like they did,
- 1:02:28it was four years, right?
- 1:02:30your drama so they did several things during this time i remember one time they brought a whole
- 1:02:35a commission of people from like the socialist international and a lot of like international
- 1:02:43you know marxist actors came once to like the crawfish community again a very small community
- 1:02:50and they made a whole show and that even um there was some altercation with other local people from
- 1:02:58crawfish that are like pro prosper and they were very mad that that was happening so there was some
- 1:03:03some uh altercation physical altercation when that happened the government just brought these people
- 1:03:08i remember they even brought like an indian naxalite you know this very radical marxist
- 1:03:13group from india they got her involved in this so it was it's you're dealing with a government that
- 1:03:20has so many resources and so many money to make your life difficult and we were just like a
- 1:03:25ragtag group of people, you know, trying to push this forward.
- 1:03:30How easy is it?
- 1:03:32The laws that were actually repealed, right?
- 1:03:36How easy is it to create new versions and get them passed?
- 1:03:41Is that like a massive deal?
- 1:03:43Is that a big process?
- 1:03:45Because you can't un-repeal them.
- 1:03:48Do you have to start again and create new laws?
- 1:03:51Well, there's different options that are currently being analyzed.
- 1:03:55But whatever mechanism is promoted in the end, it's not going to be easy.
- 1:04:00There's always political costs to this type of things.
- 1:04:04A lot of socializing, explaining the laws to the decision makers, especially with all of the baggage that had happened about the projects.
- 1:04:13So it's going to be a process for sure to get a new law.
- 1:04:17And again, I'm talking about getting a new law that allows for new zones to exist.
- 1:04:22I don't think it's going to be that difficult to at least obtain the formal recognition of the existence zones that allows them to continue operating moving forward.
- 1:04:34My expectation, hopefully, we have that definitely during this first year of government.
- 1:04:39After the first year, governments become more political, less technical.
- 1:04:44So my expectation is that we have that in the next few months.
- 1:04:47but about a new law that creates new zones,
- 1:04:51I think we can do it, but it's not going to be easy.
- 1:04:55But don't you think it's in their best interest,
- 1:04:57even this government?
- 1:04:59They seem to be very pro-business,
- 1:05:01pro-putting Honduras on the map
- 1:05:04and making it into somewhere, you know,
- 1:05:06somewhere that internationally, you know, respected.
- 1:05:12So wouldn't it be good?
- 1:05:13I mean, I would imagine if the new law came into,
- 1:05:17if a new law came back in wouldn't there be an explosion of new zedges do you think
- 1:05:21hopefully hopefully yeah but do you think they would i mean like i think maybe they wouldn't i
- 1:05:26don't know i think they would tim at this point because it's like back then you got you had three
- 1:05:31zones that were approved but there were more applicants and this was you know back in 2017
- 1:05:37like this was still very niche nowadays it feels like everybody wants to do their own you know
- 1:05:42startup society around the world so if if the opportunity arises again i'm sure people would
- 1:05:48be interested in applying and you know honduras is there's a little vast territory available it's
- 1:05:54it's uh we're just barely 10 million people uh so there's a lot of potential for cool projects
- 1:06:01like this yeah it's funny to think about what that future might actually look like because um
- 1:06:10I don't know the world is changing incredibly fast at the moment isn't it there's no question about it
- 1:06:16um I so what do you think then about the likelihood of in the next four years
- 1:06:23new zones being able to be created in Honduras hard hard to say hard to say right now still
- 1:06:31um but hopefully we can I think the new authorities understand what what this means
- 1:06:38Also the new government has been talking a lot about like decentralization to give back a lot of authority and decision making to the local municipalities And that really what we doing here
- 1:06:50I mean, the special economic zones in Honduras have a direct inspiration, yes, by the Asian
- 1:06:56special economic zones, what happened in the United Arab Emirates and China and South Korea.
- 1:07:01But they also have a very strong influence from Spanish municipalism.
- 1:07:06the constitution says that these zones are equivalent to municipalities and back when
- 1:07:15we still had the spanish empire in in less or more ways during you know the several centuries
- 1:07:22during which it existed uh municipalities were the base layer for governance and you know social
- 1:07:28organization and they had many times substantial levels of autonomy um when this you know the
- 1:07:35imperial provinces in the Americas gained independence.
- 1:07:39They maintained most of the countries, a lot of those structures,
- 1:07:42like we still live in municipalities,
- 1:07:44but they don't have anywhere close to the level of autonomy that they had.
- 1:07:48It was all taken out from them by the states or the central governments
- 1:07:54or what have you.
- 1:07:56Let me tell you what your 50-year vision for Prospero was,
- 1:08:00and then I'm going to ask you again as to whether you agree.
- 1:08:03okay your 50-year vision four years ago was not dubai this is for prosper not dubai with
- 1:08:10skyscrapers etc but an idyllic sustainable nature intent integrated place with world-class
- 1:08:19architecture and a prosperous mixed community i think that sounds about right still still i don't
- 1:08:28I think the plans are much bigger than that.
- 1:08:31I think, isn't that true, even in 50 years?
- 1:08:33No, I mean, it's big.
- 1:08:37Like, what I mean by that is,
- 1:08:39if we get industrial manufacturing in Les Apes,
- 1:08:42that's part of the plan,
- 1:08:43but we do it in a responsible way.
- 1:08:45That's the thing.
- 1:08:47So we still make it,
- 1:08:49and I'm talking we as a community, right?
- 1:08:52In a way that it's a place that you want to live in.
- 1:08:55I don't see a Burj Khalifa in Raw.
- 1:08:59Then it would be an eyesore.
- 1:09:00But of course, I see big buildings as we already have,
- 1:09:0410, 15, maybe 20 stories high at the most,
- 1:09:09but then done in a tasteful manner with urbanism
- 1:09:14that is responsible with the ecosystem,
- 1:09:16with the environment, and with the types of lives
- 1:09:18we want to have.
- 1:09:20And in the La Ceiba site, which is on the mainland,
- 1:09:22and you know, across the channel,
- 1:09:24that's where we can have a lot of the manufacturing projects.
- 1:09:28It's ideal for having that there's already a port there.
- 1:09:32There's a strong talent, a local talent in Laseiba.
- 1:09:38But yeah, it's, I don't know, 50 years,
- 1:09:40we're gonna have flying cars for short
- 1:09:42and I hope I can get to see them, yeah.
- 1:09:45So, and you're gonna carry on living here, I take it.
- 1:09:47But are you, you know, you're the,
- 1:09:51If Prosper is the kind of model for the special economic zone worldwide,
- 1:10:00you are, because you're a Honduran,
- 1:10:01you're the model for the Honduran citizen living in one of these places,
- 1:10:04I think, because you've chosen as a Honduran to come,
- 1:10:09very early adopter.
- 1:10:11Are you going to stay?
- 1:10:13Yeah.
- 1:10:14Yeah.
- 1:10:15And thank you, Tim.
- 1:10:15I don't think I had thought about myself in that way.
- 1:10:19Well, I'll tell you why.
- 1:10:21because I speak I've spoken to 200 people on this podcast and a lot of them have been to do with
- 1:10:27Prospera but I mean Gabe's from Guatemala he's but most people I speak to are people who aren't
- 1:10:34I don't think you're the only Honduran that I've spoken to who who is has a significant thing to say
- 1:10:41like I could speak to I could go to Crawfish Rock now and I could speak to someone but
- 1:10:45I wouldn't necessarily get a well-educated view of what's going on.
- 1:10:51So it not something I necessarily want to do you know Yeah I understand that And also that I don work like directly for Prospera or in any way right for prosper i just a resident here i an early adopter like you said and i you know
- 1:11:05tried to help out the community tried to use the platform for my own things um that was don't
- 1:11:11forget i'm gonna button again don't forget four years ago i came to prosper looking for interviews
- 1:11:16and there weren't many people to interview and i interviewed you and you knew all about zas the
- 1:11:21history like i say we had an hour-long conversation about personal sovereignty and i was looking at it
- 1:11:27here it's like from medieval divine rights through to the enlightenment you know you know it's not
- 1:11:32like you don't know what there's anything about this stuff so so i i do consider you an early
- 1:11:38adopter i think that's absolutely fine to think of yourself like that um but as an early adopter
- 1:11:44um you are apart from it say if you went to morizan and sure there's lots of people lots
- 1:11:49Hondurans living in Morazan they're early adopters but I think pretty much they just they don't think
- 1:11:56of Morazan in the same way that you think of special economic zones or free cities or charter
- 1:12:02cities or whatever you want to call it you're thinking about it from that angle they're in
- 1:12:06Morazan they're like they're thinking well living in this town is dangerous living in Morazan it's
- 1:12:11great better standard of living cheaper you know that's that's the way they're thinking and sure
- 1:12:17there's an element of you thinking like that but you're also kind of ideologically driven and i
- 1:12:22know that's not a good way that i don't like that word ideological necessarily philosophically
- 1:12:26philosophically driven yes so you chose as a honduran to live in this place in honduras so
- 1:12:33you're you're a good early adopter very good example of one did we talk about dune last time
- 1:12:39the film or the book yeah i don't think so why maybe it's like i like to think of ourselves like
- 1:12:46these early adopters and you also have like other hondurians that understand this very well you know
- 1:12:50jorge and all the people that are involved oh yeah sure i spoke to jorge last time he's honduran
- 1:12:55jorge is the mayor of of of prosper still um so in the first book of dune there is this section
- 1:13:04and you see this i think it's in the second film um when they get to see the water reserves that
- 1:13:11the Fremen had to terraform the planets because Iraq is the planet.
- 1:13:16The Dun is a big desert, essentially a desert planet.
- 1:13:20So they're working towards in the long-term change, the ecosystem, and, you know, enable
- 1:13:24vegetation and rivers and that type of thing.
- 1:13:28So I do see ourselves in a way like that, like those early Fremen, we have that long-term
- 1:13:34vision, and we are convinced that this can change the conditions and improve the country
- 1:13:38more towards where we want it to be.
- 1:13:41yeah there was a lot of uncertainty in the last few years but yeah it's a great place to be it's
- 1:13:49for me as well you know I have family on the mainland also the U.S. is close by you're two
- 1:13:54hours away from Miami and I do love the island I love going scuba diving and doing stuff in the
- 1:13:59outdoors amen to that and as I've been telling everyone here after this trip I'm nearly at the
- 1:14:07end of my month i'm going to put a month in my diary every year from now to come back here and
- 1:14:14work from here and because it's such a such an innovative experience for me working here especially
- 1:14:21now that may change in the future but right now there's a lot of really vibrant and interesting
- 1:14:27people here and you meet them and everyone says hi why are you here it's that stage isn't it you
- 1:14:36know when you meet people there's nothing there's no social um weirdness by literally going up to
- 1:14:42someone and saying what you're doing here yeah so that's great anyway look christian thanks mate
- 1:14:49great great conversation thanks for um giving me the layman's legal eye as well because i i've i've
- 1:14:57realized in the last few months how important the whole legal structure was i know everyone went on
- 1:15:04about it for many years.
- 1:15:07But now you can see that it probably the most important part of the whole ZA thing is making sure the legal stuff is is is right and if anyone thinking of doing anything in their own country and starting anything new that what you
- 1:15:23need you know sure you need a bit of land but you need the legal the legal protections there
- 1:15:29preferably at a very high level i.e constitutional i think that goes without saying right it's uh
- 1:15:36Definitely people have taken notice.
- 1:15:39And Patrick Friedman said in the Liberty Acceleration Summit recently that what he thought was the main innovation in Honduras was that you allowed for these zones to be developed, promoted by private parties, right?
- 1:15:53By companies, by startups, by local communities, not depending on the central government, which I do agree with.
- 1:16:00But if you're doing it that way, you're going to need the legal protections, right?
- 1:16:04So this, what Patrick says, you know, has become the standard of thinking of what you would want to achieve in a host country, a country that recognizes you as a primary, you know, operator of the zone, that you get that level of legal protections.
- 1:16:19And I've been very fortunate to help out with, you know, some projects happening in South America and sub-Saharan Africa.
- 1:16:26and conditions are different everywhere,
- 1:16:29but they are aware that you want some level of equivalent legal protection.
- 1:16:35There you go.
- 1:16:36You heard it here first.
- 1:16:37Well, actually, you didn't hear it here first
- 1:16:39because Patrick's interview is coming out tomorrow.
- 1:16:42And it's like eight things I've learned from investing in free cities.
- 1:16:47And one of them was exactly that.
- 1:16:49He said, make sure, I forget how he worded it now,
- 1:16:51but it's like you need land and protection,
- 1:16:54land and legal or something he said.
- 1:16:56I forget what he said, but anyway.
- 1:16:58No, that's absolutely fantastic.
- 1:17:01And like I say, Prospera, it's like the sandbox for all this stuff.
- 1:17:06And I feel like it's reached a point where it's proved so many.
- 1:17:11It's proved the majority of the potentials now.
- 1:17:17So I don't see why this mom anywhere around the world now,
- 1:17:22you can't look at your own country and go,
- 1:17:25that's what happened in
- 1:17:26Honduras
- 1:17:28why don't I do it here
- 1:17:30so
- 1:17:30and thanks for being a small part of that
- 1:17:35as well and great talking
- 1:17:37to you Christian four years later
- 1:17:39let's do another one in four years
- 1:17:40you'll probably be living in the Burj Khalifa
- 1:17:43riot at that point
- 1:17:45and I'll go
- 1:17:46guess what you said
- 1:17:48remember you say we're going to be living in huts
- 1:17:51oh boy thanks for having me
- 1:17:53That's all right, man. No problem.
- 1:17:58Right, you made it to the end of the show.
- 1:18:01So I'm going to go ahead and assume that you got some value out of this episode.
- 1:18:07If you want to help the show, please follow or subscribe right now.
- 1:18:11It takes only two seconds and it massively helps.
- 1:18:15If you've got another 30 seconds, well, leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 1:18:21honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners find us if you want more
- 1:18:28you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on fountain.fm for the price of one
- 1:18:36coffee for a whole month or you can support the mission by streaming sats on any of the value for
- 1:18:42value platforms or use the bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes every contribution
- 1:18:49to the show makes a real difference believe me and one more thing if you know someone who'd love
- 1:18:54this episode share it directly with them that personal share beats every algorithm in the book
- 1:19:00all the links the community and the newsletter are in the show notes and jump on over to free
- 1:19:06cities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions and more that's the new free
- 1:19:15Cities podcast website freecities.fm have a good week and see you next time