Latest / 22 Panels - A Comic Book Podcast / Fourth World Book Club #15 - Hunger Dogs
Transcript
- 0:02Mark Pracht: Good!
- 0:03Tad Eggleston: Good morning, everybody. Welcome back to 22 Panels and the Fourth World Book Club. Sean's doing some exercise. He pulled out the omnibus, and, you know, that's as good as doing just deadlifts. Mark is here, and we're joined this month with Jimmy Gasparo of Comic Book Yeti, and the writer of,
- 0:25Tad Eggleston: Still upcoming, right? Penny and the Yeti?
- 0:27Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah, bro.
- 0:28Tad Eggleston: come out while I wasn't looking.
- 0:29Jimmy Gaspero: No, it'll be out April, 21st, and, bookstores, and the 22nd, and comic book shops.
- 0:36Tad Eggleston: Yeah, so, like… not next week, but the week after? Yeah. Yeah. Week after next.
- 0:45Tad Eggleston: So, I highly recommend that book, even for Mark and Sean, even though they're not exactly the age group that it's… that it's, geared towards.
- 0:56Mark Pracht: What are you saying.
- 0:56Tad Eggleston: But,
- 0:58Tad Eggleston: Well, I mean, it's not even young adult, it's middle grade, and middle grade really means, like, 4th through 8th?
- 1:07Tad Eggleston: So, I mean…
- 1:09Tad Eggleston: It's… it's, it's geared towards, like, 10-year-olds. Do you want to be that young? Because I'll call you that young!
- 1:16Tad Eggleston: We'll get you some Blue's Clues.
- 1:20Sean Harklerode: I mean…
- 1:21Mark Pracht: Love me some loose clues.
- 1:22Sean Harklerode: I did just download Condor Man.
- 1:24Tad Eggleston: That's true.
- 1:28Tad Eggleston: I actually may have also just bought Condor Man on your recommendation.
- 1:36Mark Pracht: Why isn't the hardware man on Disney Plus? That's the question.
- 1:41Tad Eggleston: We are wrapping up our… Journey through…
- 1:49Tad Eggleston: Kirby's Fourth World, with hunger Dogs here.
- 1:54Tad Eggleston: before I… before I throw it to the expert experts, I'm gonna give… like, I've taken to giving my, my off-the-cuff opinion right off the bat, and… and like last month.
- 2:06Tad Eggleston: I so wish that he'd, like…
- 2:10Tad Eggleston: Given this level of care and thought to…
- 2:14Tad Eggleston: all of it. I understand that he was more rushed when he was doing this stuff in the 70s versus…
- 2:19Tad Eggleston: The two wrap-ups in the 80s, but, like.
- 2:22Tad Eggleston: these last two, that second story last month that I can't remember the title of it right now, and then Hunger Dogs, like…
- 2:30Mark Pracht: I think it's Even Gods Must Die.
- 2:32Tad Eggleston: Yeah, even Gods Must Die and Hunger Dogs, you know.
- 2:36Tad Eggleston: I mean, I still wish that he had a scripter slash co-plotter just to tighten things up a little bit, but overall, the storytelling is just so much better.
- 2:47Tad Eggleston: And that's not even really to knock
- 2:51Tad Eggleston: You know, it's always been good storytelling, but this is, like, next-level storytelling.
- 2:56Tad Eggleston: it shows you why Kirby is the king in a way that… that I feel like…
- 3:04Tad Eggleston: So much of what we read up until this point hinted that he could be, except that he was moving so fast and taking no help that, like, you'd see…
- 3:14Tad Eggleston: a page of it here, and 3 pages of it there, and… whereas these… these two volumes have just been…
- 3:23Tad Eggleston: Outstanding. I really enjoyed them.
- 3:27Tad Eggleston: So…
- 3:29Mark Pracht: I defer to our guest first. You get the first word.
- 3:33Jimmy Gaspero: Oh, I do? Okay.
- 3:34Tad Eggleston: Oh, Jimmy has to go. We're putting you on the hot seat, Jimmy.
- 3:37Jimmy Gaspero: Is this just, like, my overall thoughts?
- 3:41Mark Pracht: I mean…
- 3:41Tad Eggleston: Whatever.
- 3:42Jimmy Gaspero: Okay, so I went…
- 3:44Tad Eggleston: You could fill your wine glass and tell us about your kids.
- 3:48Jimmy Gaspero: So, so I…
- 3:51Jimmy Gaspero: I've read the Fourth World Saga a while ago, and I went back, and for this, re-read even Gods Must Die and Hunger Dogs to refresh my recollection. And I hadn't delved too much into
- 4:04Jimmy Gaspero: like, the history of what was going on when these were being made, other than recognizing that there was a pretty big gap in time of maybe a dozen years between when the Fourth World wrapped up and when Kirby did both of these. And… I really like even Gods Must Die.
- 4:19Jimmy Gaspero: I… it's probably one of my favorites out of the old… out of the entire Fourth World.
- 4:25Jimmy Gaspero: Hunger Dogs is a little bit more, like, hit or miss for me. I think there are some sequences of it that really work, and I wish there were more of, because, like.
- 4:37Jimmy Gaspero: The scenes with Isaac, I think, really work, like, well, but I feel like there aren't… there isn't enough of it. It feels a lot of the Hunger Dogs feels like…
- 4:50Jimmy Gaspero: you know, Kirby is jumping around to try and wrap up as much stuff as he can. And then also, when I went and did research some of the history and realized that, like, he had a bigger plan, you know, it's hinted at in the afterword by Mark,
- 5:04Jimmy Gaspero: But he had a bigger plan, but then there were certain things he couldn't do because of the Superpowers toy deal with Kenner. And it made a little bit more sense as to why the story felt a little disjointed to me.
- 5:17Jimmy Gaspero: But yeah, there are some sequences in it I really, really love. I just wish there was more of, like.
- 5:23Jimmy Gaspero: that stuff.
- 5:26Jimmy Gaspero: But, it's very interesting to think about this as, like, a wrap-up to it, and, you know, Kirby, what he tried to do, or what he really did accomplish with the Fourth World, and now, I think he's, like, in his mid to late 60s, when he's wrapping up with the Hunger Dogs, and,
- 5:46Jimmy Gaspero: you know, I think of, like, the Forever People, and what kind of a great group of, like, hippie superheroes they were, and now the only, like.
- 5:55Jimmy Gaspero: the only bit of, like, the young generation is Isak, and he's… he's… he was, like, you know, Metron's, like, assistant and apprentice, and now he is disfigured, and warped, and building things, like, machines of destruction for Apocalypse, and I'm like, God, that is such, like, a…
- 6:13Jimmy Gaspero: it seems to be such a much more, like, cynical view of the younger generation than we see in Forever People.
- 6:23Jimmy Gaspero: You know, so those were the things that stood out to me going back now and reading even Gods Must Die and then Hunger Dogs.
- 6:32Sean Harklerode: I agree with you, I think… It's… it's a little disjointed.
- 6:37Sean Harklerode: I enjoy it.
- 6:39Sean Harklerode: But… reading that, basically, I think he wanted to end everything.
- 6:47Sean Harklerode: And DC was like, whoa, no, no, no, don't end everything. We might want to use these people again. And so, I think that was a push-pull about him wanting just to end it all. I mean, I feel like…
- 7:02Sean Harklerode: If he could, this would have been the end of the new gods, and we'd spin out some…
- 7:08Sean Harklerode: other gods…
- 7:10Sean Harklerode: you know, you know, just as the old gods died, now the new gods died, and then there'll be even newer gods. I don't know, but that's what I got…
- 7:21Mark Pracht: as the next generation?
- 7:24Sean Harklerode: But, it does skip around a bit, like, particularly… the thing that got me most, was…
- 7:34Sean Harklerode: All of a sudden, Orion has rescued Tigra, I'm like.
- 7:40Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 7:40Sean Harklerode: What?
- 7:42Mark Pracht: That happened, yeah.
- 7:43Sean Harklerode: And that's in, like, 3 panels? I'm like, come on, that's a major storyline here.
- 7:50Sean Harklerode: Or it should have been, could have been.
- 7:53Sean Harklerode: So that was a little disappointing, but I love, you know, The art…
- 8:01Sean Harklerode: Kinda goes back and forth, the coloring is…
- 8:07Sean Harklerode: Kinda throws me off a little bit.
- 8:10Tad Eggleston: I mean, I think in…
- 8:13Sean Harklerode: It's that.
- 8:14Tad Eggleston: That version that I read, it's clearly a modern recolor that some of those are better than others, and this one, I think.
- 8:20Tad Eggleston: Doesn't qualify as one of the great ones.
- 8:24Sean Harklerode: Right, well, it's definitely that 80s, you know, prestige, you know, palette.
- 8:30Tad Eggleston: Yeah.
- 8:31Sean Harklerode: You know, it's not quite the four color of the… of the 70s.
- 8:37Sean Harklerode: Right.
- 8:40Sean Harklerode: But, sometimes it serves it, and sometimes it makes it look very flat, I think.
- 8:47Sean Harklerode: But, I don't know, the art is… is… He's getting curbier and curbier?
- 8:58Mark Pracht: I…
- 8:58Sean Harklerode: I…
- 8:59Mark Pracht: I missed… I missed Mike Royer on the inking.
- 9:04Mark Pracht: deeply, you know? I think that… I think that… that when…
- 9:09Mark Pracht: when he found Royer to work on those New Gods books, you know.
- 9:15Mark Pracht: He found the perfect anchor for him, and
- 9:18Mark Pracht: And I think that there's a number of things, like, I'm looking at page, 48 right here, there's a…
- 9:25Mark Pracht: Like, Darkseid doesn't quite look like Darkseid to me.
- 9:29Mark Pracht: in… just in the art, and it's mainly because I think that that lack of Royer
- 9:36Mark Pracht: Royer just sort of took that angularity and made it
- 9:39Mark Pracht: Part of it, and it feels like sometimes this is trying to smooth out some of that angularity.
- 9:46Mark Pracht: The curviness of it, you know?
- 9:49Mark Pracht: I guess… sorry, I had to jump off for half a second there, but and maybe I'm covering something that somebody's already said, if I do.
- 9:57Tad Eggleston: You're… you're good.
- 9:58Mark Pracht: I… I think even God's Must Die was a much cleaner ending to things.
- 10:07Mark Pracht: I do think, as Jimmy said, I know that this whole thing was happening, we gotta, we gotta look to,
- 10:16Mark Pracht: to, jeanette Kahn.
- 10:21Mark Pracht: who brought Kirby back to do this graphic novel, and she was the one that made the deal with Kenner to do the Super Bowers figures, and got Jack royalties from that. So, while Jack maybe couldn't truly finish it.
- 10:37Mark Pracht: he was getting something out of that, and I actually… I was just thinking about reading the Superpowers book, which Jack wrote, but didn't draw.
- 10:47Mark Pracht: So, anyway.
- 10:50Sean Harklerode: I've got that on my camera.
- 10:51Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 10:53Mark Pracht: But I do think… I'm just gonna echo everybody else. I feel like this jumps around so much, and that…
- 11:02Mark Pracht: like, a lot of times I'm like, oh, this is cool, and then we're off to something else. I think that it feels to me like New Genesis and… and Highfather all kind of become sort of like a…
- 11:17Mark Pracht: footnote, you know? I… in a way, I kind of wanted Hyman to… I wanted… I would have liked to have seen Highfather take more of the stuff that Hyman was doing.
- 11:26Sean Harklerode: Exactly.
- 11:27Mark Pracht: I felt like… I felt like…
- 11:29Mark Pracht: And I know it feels to me like Hyman is, kirby's stand-in.
- 11:37Mark Pracht: But… at the same time, I'm like.
- 11:42Mark Pracht: Highfather is supposedly the guy who raised
- 11:45Mark Pracht: Orion. I feel like there… there… and it is something that happens all through this Fourth World thing, is that you… you kind of want to know what this relationship between Orion and Highfather is, and they never quite get there, you know? And it always…
- 12:03Mark Pracht: that always bugged me a little bit, but I do think it jumps around a lot, and there's a lot of, like, trying to get… trying to click a lot of boxes. And, like, I think… I would say, I did think, even God's Must Die was a much cleaner, more direct ending. I also liked…
- 12:20Mark Pracht: one of the things about even God's Must Die, there was that lovely thing about, you know, Darkseid bringing his underlings back to life, and then they weren't quite the same, and there was a sort of loneliness to Darkseid that…
- 12:33Mark Pracht: that…
- 12:34Mark Pracht: has kind of evolved, but then kind of is gone. You know, it feels like somebody trying to connect dots
- 12:44Mark Pracht: and I've said this all along, I never really felt like Jack knew exactly where this whole thing was gonna go.
- 12:50Mark Pracht: And… I think… Much like,
- 12:57Mark Pracht: much like, you know, any number of things we can talk about, like, say, the Star Wars sequel trilogy, if you know where you're going, it'll give you a lot of freedom to get there, to take side roads, and to go and do other things to get there. And I just feel like, at a certain point, Jack.
- 13:15Mark Pracht: has so many ideas coming, and so many things that he wants to talk about, that he never really quite settles on what does this whole thing's supposed to mean, you know? And, like, the anti-life equation is just sort of gone, you know?
- 13:31Tad Eggleston: Well, and I noticed that there was, like, hints in this that there were other equations.
- 13:36Sean Harklerode: With the ice equation, right?
- 13:37Tad Eggleston: Right. There's a… well, but not just the life equation. Like, like, there was a… there was a point where, you know, you must know all the equations of the… and it's like…
- 13:47Tad Eggleston: I had thought that the anti-life equation was strictly a MacGuffin-type thing, and now we're acting like there's some sort of mathematical magic in the universe that
- 14:00Tad Eggleston: That you've ignored up until this point.
- 14:04Tad Eggleston: What are the rules? How's that supposed to work?
- 14:07Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 14:08Sean Harklerode: How have we gotten this far into this conversation without mentioning the micro mark?
- 14:15Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah. Yeah. Which… at first.
- 14:19Sean Harklerode: My name for, for, you know, now going on for Mark.
- 14:24Jimmy Gaspero: micro-mark. It's weird, because at first I was like, what…
- 14:29Jimmy Gaspero: like, what… are they describing, like, a weapon? And it seems like at times, they are definitely talking about a weapon, but then they…
- 14:38Jimmy Gaspero: They describe it… oddly, at a certain point in time, because I think…
- 14:44Jimmy Gaspero: I don't know if it's Highfather, or somebody else mentions the MicroMark, and it sounds like they're talking about the current moment, rather than a specific weapon. So I wasn't sure exactly what that was a stand-in for.
- 14:57Sean Harklerode: And then…
- 14:58Tad Eggleston: I read the…
- 14:59Sean Harklerode: perspective, where I thought it might be, like, one of the figures in the foreground.
- 15:05Tad Eggleston: Yeah, no, I read the micro mark as, like, a layman's attempt at, like.
- 15:14Tad Eggleston: High-level nanotechnology, where, like, we're putting together these little, little things that, because they can do anything at a molecular level.
- 15:25Tad Eggleston: You know, even though it's little and whatnot, it can cause huge amounts of damage, because it takes its… and it can replicate itself, blah blah blah. But,
- 15:35Tad Eggleston: Both because he was imagining a thing that either didn't have a word, or he wasn't using the word.
- 15:42Tad Eggleston: You know, and it's hard to know right there, because nanotechnology really was something that became a bigger part of the zeitgeist in the mid-90s.
- 15:54Tad Eggleston: I mean, I remember a friend of mine doing a paper on it in high school, because, like, if they get it down, it could be…
- 16:01Tad Eggleston: it could be a game changer. If you can go in and reformulate a cell, you could use a nanobot to cure cancer, just because it could go in and take the cancer
- 16:13Tad Eggleston: cell and turned it into a regular cell, you know? .
- 16:20Mark Pracht: Well, I mean, like, but that's… that's always been… I mean, like, this is… what we're talking about has sort of always been the…
- 16:28Mark Pracht: the genius of Kirby, and sort of the Achilles heel of Kirby, is this idea that he's gonna throw out all these ideas.
- 16:35Mark Pracht: and that… When he's working with somebody who is a good…
- 16:42Mark Pracht: even editor, let alone writer, they can smooth that stuff out and make sure that we
- 16:49Mark Pracht: hit the beats that are necessary. Like, I was…
- 16:55Mark Pracht: during the course of this, I reread, OMAC.
- 17:01Tad Eggleston: Okay, that's right.
- 17:02Mark Pracht: probably the worst example of it. Like, every book in that is like, oh, here's this incredible idea, here's this incredible idea, here's this incredible idea, and it never really…
- 17:11Mark Pracht: Amounts to anything, nor does it really add to the…
- 17:16Mark Pracht: the drama, you know? It's just idea, idea, idea, idea, and… and I think that… you know.
- 17:25Mark Pracht: as much as I love Jack, that is the one thing, it's sometimes, you know, you really wish he had a strong editor who was just like.
- 17:34Mark Pracht: I get it, I get it. I know you want to have your… you want to do what you want to do.
- 17:40Mark Pracht: But we have to clean this thing up and make sure that we understand what it is, you know?
- 17:46Tad Eggleston: Yeah, I… I… more than once, I've found myself reading these, and all the more in… in the…
- 17:54Tad Eggleston: These two volumes, where again, he gets away from his 4 and 6 panel pages that use so much…
- 18:02Tad Eggleston: For so much of the rest of the series, where, you know, he uses…
- 18:07Tad Eggleston: he's got more acting in these, you know, a little less bombastic imagery, a little bit more acting. It makes me wish that, like, he'd taken…
- 18:18Tad Eggleston: Denny O'Neil under his wing, and felt like he was just showing Denny O'Neill the path, but in reality had, you know, this writer-editor guy who could say, hey, Jack, what if we did it this way?
- 18:31Tad Eggleston: You know…
- 18:33Sean Harklerode: Okay.
- 18:34Sean Harklerode: I also think there's a very strong… speaking of editing, he definitely has an anti-computer, anti-technology, computerization,
- 18:48Sean Harklerode: What do you call it?
- 18:49Sean Harklerode: mechanization, bank… You would…
- 18:52Tad Eggleston: He was way ahead of the curve on the anti-AI thing.
- 18:56Sean Harklerode: Right, and I think that's very important in… a very important theme in here, and it kind of goes back and forth.
- 19:03Sean Harklerode: That, again, had there been an editor, someone say, hey, you know, elucidate this a little bit more, you know.
- 19:12Sean Harklerode: bring that out. But it's very important to him, obviously, in this, and you can see that it's probably, hey, I'm the older guy, these newer guys, it's all computers, you know, let's just do it the way I like to do it.
- 19:29Tad Eggleston: Right. Yeah. I mean, like, if you take all of the Fourth World as a whole, you can see…
- 19:36Tad Eggleston: a lot of what's important to Jack, you know? He seems to be…
- 19:42Tad Eggleston: trying to find the humanity in both, like, this epic good and epic bad, you know, to kind of break them both down as, no, there are good things from bad, and there are bad things from good, and, like.
- 20:00Tad Eggleston: No matter what your gods are, they're not…
- 20:05Tad Eggleston: they're not infallible, you know?
- 20:09Tad Eggleston: He… he… he… it definitely shows an awareness of a… of a technological future, but he's also shows an awareness that, like, that won't make the world…
- 20:26Tad Eggleston: world perfect, because you will still have humans, you know, and how the technology is used is… is…
- 20:35Tad Eggleston: important. He certainly shows a lot, I mean, whether it's the…
- 20:40Tad Eggleston: Is it the Flim Flam man? What did Stan get?
- 20:44Tad Eggleston: The Funky JS… Funky Flash Man?
- 20:46Sean Harklerode: Funky flash on you. Yeah, funky.
- 20:48Tad Eggleston: Flashman. Whether it's Funky Flashman or any number of things, you know, he shows… like… His struggles between, like.
- 21:00Tad Eggleston: okay, I understand that, like, some level of commercialism is required to, you know.
- 21:08Tad Eggleston: pay my mortgage, but… but I… I'm an artist, and I want to be an artist, and, like, I… I… like… So, I feel like Jack…
- 21:20Tad Eggleston: if you look at the entire thing on a whole, there's a lot of Jack struggling with his own humanity and place in the world.
- 21:30Tad Eggleston: But again, like…
- 21:32Tad Eggleston: He's a great artist, and an okay writer, a great storyteller, but not a very good scripter, and as a result, without having…
- 21:43Tad Eggleston: somebody to kind of bounce things off of, it becomes…
- 21:49Tad Eggleston: And I get this really well, you guys get to watch me do it on a regular basis. He's thinking out loud, but he's doing it on the pages of…
- 21:57Tad Eggleston: Four different comics over a year and a half.
- 21:59Tad Eggleston: Yeah.
- 22:01Tad Eggleston: You know.
- 22:04Jimmy Gaspero: talk more about the anti-technology, or maybe anti-modernization of it. One of the things I found really interesting about the Hunger Dogs is the characterization of Darkseid in this, who also seems like if you're… if you're…
- 22:22Jimmy Gaspero: if what you're espousing is kind of like an anti-modernization, let's say, in the art form, or the work that you've been doing, you have your main bad guy, Darkseid, who really seems to be chiding all of his new…
- 22:36Jimmy Gaspero: Underlinks for… for all of their…
- 22:41Jimmy Gaspero: all of their new weapons and all their new designs. He really seems, like, not thrilled with that aspect of it, like, to the point where…
- 22:50Tad Eggleston: My slingshot, dammit.
- 22:51Jimmy Gaspero: Keep that going.
- 22:52Tad Eggleston: Get away from it.
- 22:53Jimmy Gaspero: And he even tells the one, if you can take this crowd control measure on a cosmic scale, you've ripped off the anti-life equation. And he seems… Darkseid seems annoyed by it, like…
- 23:04Jimmy Gaspero: like, these new weapons of mass destruction is not… is still not as good as, like, fear. It's just a very odd characterization for Darkseid, how down he is on all these new weapons, like, that keep popping up.
- 23:21Mark Pracht: I've always found Darkseid to be really interesting. I mean, it's like I was talking about in the Even Gods Must Die, you know, there was that whole thing where he, you know.
- 23:30Mark Pracht: you know, resurrects DeSaud, and it's not quite DeSaud, and he seems somehow…
- 23:38Mark Pracht: really sad about that, you know? That, like, he's really lost all of these people who understood what he… or at least
- 23:47Mark Pracht: were his… team, you know? And now, we have a dark side that seems sort of… floating…
- 23:58Mark Pracht: he almost seems like he's floating in a sort of meaningless void now. Like, that… that if he doesn't have… like, if it's all, like, we're going to unleash this bomb.
- 24:09Mark Pracht: Or, or, or…
- 24:12Mark Pracht: You know, like, and maybe it is, that, like, control by fear is what he understands, and what…
- 24:20Mark Pracht: means something to him.
- 24:22Mark Pracht: And that… Wanton destruction doesn't seem to…
- 24:30Mark Pracht: Maybe that's what I'm… maybe that's what I'm chewing on right now, is, like, he seems turned off by the idea of just wanton destruction.
- 24:37Mark Pracht: You know? He would rather control something that actually exists rather than just destroy it. You know what I'm saying?
- 24:43Mark Pracht: Does that make sense?
- 24:44Sean Harklerode: Yeah, that makes sense. I think there's.
- 24:46Tad Eggleston: There's also an element of old people, no, like, change.
- 24:51Tad Eggleston: You know, so he imagined doing it this way, so this young whippersnapper's like, well, you haven't been able to figure out the anti-life equation, but I created this thing that'll do the same thing, and he's like, no, it won't, because it's not the same.
- 25:06Tad Eggleston: But it'll do the same. No, it's not the same.
- 25:11Mark Pracht: Well, I mean, yeah.
- 25:13Mark Pracht: It's sort of… well, that's sort of the… well, that's the AI thing, too, you know? It's like, I can.
- 25:19Tad Eggleston: Well, and, I mean…
- 25:21Mark Pracht: prompts and shoots out a piece of artwork or whatever, but that's not the same as me drawing it.
- 25:27Tad Eggleston: Well, and to another level, an anti-life equation might be cleaner, it might be… it might be almost the Infinity Gauntlet snap and half the people are gone, whereas what's being described here, it's like, oh, we're gonna raise the cities, there's nothing left, there's…
- 25:44Tad Eggleston: And that's… You know, any aesthetic is then gone.
- 25:50Tad Eggleston: You know, he doesn't… he doesn't want… destruction he wants.
- 25:56Tad Eggleston: anti-life.
- 25:59Tad Eggleston: And, you know, and those can be different.
- 26:02Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 26:02Tad Eggleston: I'm thinking out loud here. I do that a lot, Jimmy. These guys know that already.
- 26:07Mark Pracht: I mean, I… yeah, I… I do think…
- 26:12Mark Pracht: I mean, I think that all of these books really do make this case for Darkseid to be…
- 26:19Mark Pracht: One of the most fascinating villains.
- 26:22Mark Pracht: Ever. Dare I say it, I think, actually, Darkseid deep down, is actually more interesting than, say, you're Thanos or whatever. Like, there's something about that character, there seems to be, like.
- 26:35Mark Pracht: there is this element of, like, he is… he is locked in battle with his own son, right? And that it doesn't… it doesn't go to say that
- 26:46Mark Pracht: Star Wars Revolution, where the son redeems the father, Nor does it…
- 26:51Mark Pracht: Like, it just perpetuates that battle, you know?
- 26:55Mark Pracht: That it's this unending thing.
- 26:58Mark Pracht: But the one thing, and I… just to jump back a little bit, the one thing that I really missed in this, that I think was…
- 27:07Mark Pracht: to me, very inherent to what we were talking about over the course of the whole Fourth World.
- 27:13Mark Pracht: Where the hell is Scott Free?
- 27:16Tad Eggleston: Yeah.
- 27:16Mark Pracht: Like, this is, like, this pact that was supposedly this… you know, I remember when we got to that issue of, you know, the pact.
- 27:23Mark Pracht: that was supposed to bring peace, and yet didn't really work, but it was still this idea that they had changed the suns, you know?
- 27:32Mark Pracht: There are, like, Jimmy brought up the Forever People, and, you know, we always talked about, when we were reading it, how it felt like it was sort of meandering and never really found out what it was trying to say.
- 27:45Mark Pracht: But… you know, we bring back Isaac.
- 27:51Mark Pracht: But, like, wouldn't it… like, which always felt like sort of a peripheral character to me, and then…
- 28:00Mark Pracht: you know, but the Forever people are still wandering out there, the Infinity Man's still wandering out there, like, this had been, like…
- 28:08Mark Pracht: You almost wish that he'd done, like, a trilogy of graphic novels to… to really give himself the space to wrap all this up.
- 28:17Sean Harklerode: Well, I…
- 28:18Mark Pracht: you know.
- 28:18Sean Harklerode: Oh.
- 28:19Mark Pracht: Go ahead.
- 28:20Sean Harklerode: I kinda get the sense that this…
- 28:22Sean Harklerode: several times, because there's several splash pages in here that it made me think, like, okay, this was the break. This was going to be four different issues, or something.
- 28:34Sean Harklerode: But I think… the decision to set it entirely on Apocalypse?
- 28:41Sean Harklerode: probably is why, you know, A, probably why scot-free and the others aren't on there, but it's also why it feels so different
- 28:53Sean Harklerode: Than what went before, because it was… because we always had humans interacting and in peril.
- 29:02Sean Harklerode: And the people he was trying to dominate.
- 29:06Sean Harklerode: Right?
- 29:07Sean Harklerode: And in this, it's just apocalypse.
- 29:11Sean Harklerode: Where we see… You know, look, the hunger dogs, right?
- 29:17Sean Harklerode: The… the rabble.
- 29:20Sean Harklerode: the, the…
- 29:22Sean Harklerode: I don't know, they're not humans, but they're the denizens of apocalypse, right? And they start to rise up, but it's not quite the same as when it's on Earth. Does that make sense?
- 29:35Sean Harklerode: Just, which I understand why, hey, we've had the battle on Earth, now we're going to apocalypse to end it all.
- 29:44Sean Harklerode: Right? But it can just make it tonal shit.
- 29:48Mark Pracht: I want to correct myself. I had said that Mike Royer didn't work on this, it looks like he did.
- 29:53Mark Pracht: But there's also inking by D. Bruce Berry, and…
- 29:57Mark Pracht: I'm… as I'm flipping through it, I'm… like, there's definitely pages that I'm like, oh yeah, that's Royer, but then there's also pages where I'm like, that feels strange, and I'm assuming those are the Barry pages.
- 30:08Sean Harklerode: It's a dis… there's a dissonance, because some of it feels very familiar, and some of it doesn't, and I think what I said earlier about the coloring, I figured it out. To me, the coloring reminds me of a picture book.
- 30:22Sean Harklerode: Remember, we used to get the picture books in middle school or elementary?
- 30:29Sean Harklerode: It seems more like that. Even you'd get a Spider-Man picture book, and it wasn't colored like a Spider-Man comic book.
- 30:38Sean Harklerode: That's what this reminds me of.
- 30:42Mark Pracht: I will… I do want to talk about… there is one transition in this book that I was… I puzzled over
- 30:48Mark Pracht: For… ever. And it… and it's just because…
- 30:53Mark Pracht: I think it's incredibly dissonant. And, I don't know what pages this is, there's no page number. It's, when Hyman has the bomb.
- 31:03Mark Pracht: And it disintegrates in his hands, and then we suddenly switch over to… New Genesis and these monsters… And…
- 31:15Mark Pracht: that transition still makes no sense to me, and I still am lost narratively of, like, I… it… I was like, wait a minute, did I miss a page? Was there a page missing here? Or…
- 31:28Mark Pracht: What's also funny is that at least in my… in my… because I'm reading this on Kindle.
- 31:35Mark Pracht: The… the aspect ratio of the pages changes.
- 31:39Sean Harklerode: Yes, it does in the, it does in the omnibus as well.
- 31:43Tad Eggleston: I think that's because this was released as a DC graphic novel.
- 31:50Sean Harklerode: Oh, yeah!
- 31:52Tad Eggleston: Different aspect ratio.
- 31:55Tad Eggleston: From a regular comic.
- 32:00Mark Pracht: And why were… why, like, that… Totally makes sense.
- 32:04Mark Pracht: Except there's this series of pages
- 32:09Mark Pracht: That are not in that ratio.
- 32:12Mark Pracht: It's.
- 32:12Tad Eggleston: Well, I…
- 32:14Mark Pracht: There's the.
- 32:15Tad Eggleston: I wonder if it has to do with whether you're seeing one page or two pages.
- 32:21Mark Pracht: Mmm…
- 32:22Sean Harklerode: Well, here, I'll hold this up. See, I mean, you can look at the difference in the margins.
- 32:27Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 32:28Sean Harklerode: Fascinating for our podcast listeners.
- 32:31Tad Eggleston: Yep, yep, yep.
- 32:32Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah, all of this. I…
- 32:35Sean Harklerode: Gutter at the bottom, and then the next page, there's no gutter at all, really.
- 32:42Jimmy Gaspero: I thought I read somewhere that there were, like, 25 pages of this that they added back in for the omnibus, and I'm trying to see where I read that.
- 32:53Jimmy Gaspero: But I thought somewhere I had read that there were, yeah, that there were some other pages that I don't think were ever in the original, that when they did the omnibus, they added them back in, which could explain…
- 33:06Mark Pracht: That would explain a lot.
- 33:07Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 33:12Jimmy Gaspero: you know, I'm just trying to see… figure out where I… where I saw that.
- 33:15Mark Pracht: I remember when this book came out, and I was… I don't know, early teens.
- 33:23Mark Pracht: And I didn't know what the hell it was, you know?
- 33:28Mark Pracht: So I never picked it up or anything, so I… I wish, I wish I had, you know?
- 33:34Mark Pracht: Just to be able to answer that question, if there was… but I mean, even if I think… even thinking about that, what you just pointed out, Jimmy, like, if I take all of these pages that are in the larger aspect ratio, and just remove them.
- 33:50Mark Pracht: It seems an even more sort of, like, weirdly disjointed Transition, you know?
- 33:57Jimmy Gaspero: It's in the afterword, in the omnibus by Mark Vanier, I can never remember how to say Mark's last name.
- 34:05Mark Pracht: near.
- 34:06Jimmy Gaspero: Vinier? Yeah, he says that,
- 34:09Jimmy Gaspero: Talking about the construction of this, there were technical difficulties. The first version had been inked and lettered by Mike Royer. It had been done to conventional comic book format to be printed on pages the size of those in the book you're holding.
- 34:20Jimmy Gaspero: A graphic novel, which is what the expanded version would be, has larger pages, different proportions to make the pages Jack had already done fit into the graphic novel format.
- 34:30Jimmy Gaspero: Kirby did additional art to add into the margins. He also did the new pages, which were drawn to graphic novel proportions. Royer was unavailable at the time, so these were inked and lettered by D. Bruce Berry, and then in parentheses it says, you should be able to tell which is which.
- 34:46Jimmy Gaspero: By the lettering, if not the inking techniques.
- 34:51Jimmy Gaspero: And then the restructured story was colored by Greg Theekston, and then to tie the two batches of pages more closely together, because there was some problem with the photo stats of the Royer-inced pages, Theekston wound up re-inking and retouching a lot of the art on those pages.
- 35:07Jimmy Gaspero: But I was going to mention the same thing, because if you… we talk a lot about… we've already mentioned a lot about the story being…
- 35:14Jimmy Gaspero: like, disjointed at times, and there being a lot of ideas. You would think that, alright, like, on my podcast with creators, we talk a lot about the economy of comic book storytelling, and that transition does seem totally bizarre, because you don't need it to get into
- 35:31Jimmy Gaspero: like, if you want to bring Lonar in, and what's going on on New Genesis, you don't need that at all. It's just about some, I don't know, plague-infested monsters, like, gobbling up New Genesis, and, like, it's… Right.
- 35:44Jimmy Gaspero: one page, three panels, and even the narrative captions. Like, you don't really need it to get into the other aspects of it. It does seem very…
- 35:53Jimmy Gaspero: Very strange.
- 35:54Tad Eggleston: Oh, when we start talking narrative captions in Kirby, there are a lot of them that you don't need.
- 36:00Jimmy Gaspero: Hey!
- 36:00Mark Pracht: My favorite Kirbyism. My favorite Kirbyism is the… the strange… quotation marks.
- 36:09Mark Pracht: Around words that are… like, you're like, why is this inqu…
- 36:14Mark Pracht: Like, and I don't have a good example in front of me, but it's been all through his work. I see it in his 70s Marvel book.
- 36:21Tad Eggleston: The first day after the gods were born.
- 36:28Mark Pracht: this is a rip-off, quote-unquote, you know, and I'm like… Do you…
- 36:36Mark Pracht: It kind of strikes me… it kind of strikes me… sometimes it strikes me as the old guy trying to use the hip lingo and thinking that he needs to, like.
- 36:45Mark Pracht: And it's like… but at the same time, like, sometimes it's just bizarre stuff, and you're just like, I don't know why you did that, Jack. And I don't know why the letterer didn't just say, I don't need this.
- 37:00Jimmy Gaspero: If anyone ever hosts a Jack Kirby, like, pub trivia night, that would be a great one. Just read a sentence, and the team has to figure out which word or two words is in, in quotation marks. In quotation marks.
- 37:15Mark Pracht: That'd be incredible.
- 37:17Sean Harklerode: Yeah, I'm great.
- 37:19Sean Harklerode: the biggest miss in all of this is the last page with Metron.
- 37:25Sean Harklerode: that that doesn't have a header that says Prologue?
- 37:31Mark Pracht: Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 37:32Sean Harklerode: So, you know, we, you know, we began with the epilogue.
- 37:36Tad Eggleston: Right.
- 37:37Sean Harklerode: to end.
- 37:38Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 37:38Sean Harklerode: Because this is a prologue to what's coming next, right?
- 37:41Mark Pracht: Yeah, yeah.
- 37:43Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah.
- 37:44Sean Harklerode: That just hit me when you were talking about Something when you're…
- 37:48Sean Harklerode: I wasn't sure where you were going, and I was like, oh, yes.
- 37:52Sean Harklerode: Reminded me of the epilogue.
- 37:56Mark Pracht: Well, yeah, because in my play, I think it's… it's,
- 38:00Mark Pracht: Carmine, when Jack's pitching it, it's like, it starts with the epilogue, and Carmine's like, wait, the epilogue's at the end.
- 38:08Sean Harklerode: That's the end.
- 38:08Jimmy Gaspero: But then…
- 38:10Sean Harklerode: That's the first issue with New Gods.
- 38:11Mark Pracht: Yeah, yeah. But yeah, that… that is… that is actually a really, a really astute thing that…
- 38:19Mark Pracht: Again, a really… a really… clued-in and talented editor or writer would have been like, you know Jack.
- 38:27Mark Pracht: This is what we should do.
- 38:29Mark Pracht: And Jack, I… I could imagine Jack being like, that's a great idea, kid.
- 38:34Jimmy Gaspero: Heh.
- 38:37Sean Harklerode: Have… have we ever seen,
- 38:41Sean Harklerode: Has there ever been a prologue? You know, we talked about, when we were doing the series, and we had that flashback to when the pact was made, how much we really wish we'd seen more of young Highfather and…
- 38:58Sean Harklerode: And Darkseid back then. Had they ever done a series back then? I mean, I think that would…
- 39:04Sean Harklerode: If anyone's listening, DC. I would buy that in a heartbeat.
- 39:11Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 39:13Mark Pracht: Well, I've always thought… I've always thought that
- 39:16Mark Pracht: you know, the only… the only series that keeps… seemingly keeps… like, I know they've attempted a new gods revival.
- 39:25Mark Pracht: I think…
- 39:26Tad Eggleston: Even recently.
- 39:27Mark Pracht: Definitely.
- 39:28Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah, there was just one right there.
- 39:30Tad Eggleston: something.
- 39:30Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 39:30Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 39:32Tad Eggleston: Read it still.
- 39:33Mark Pracht: I think in the early 80s, actually, before this came out, I think that,
- 39:42Mark Pracht: Danny O'Neill wrote a…
- 39:44Mark Pracht: an attempt to revive the new gods, and we know that Mr. Miracle's come back several times. Yeah. You know, and it's like, we were talking about, like, man, you know, somebody out there has to have a good pitch for the forever people, like…
- 40:01Mark Pracht: But that doesn't seem to come back. There may have been one revival of that.
- 40:05Mark Pracht: But, you know, for me…
- 40:07Sean Harklerode: do that.
- 40:09Mark Pracht: Giffen, maybe? I don't know. I wish I had an encyclopedic memory of that, but…
- 40:17Mark Pracht: We need to get Mark Waid on this.
- 40:21Mark Pracht: He'd be like, oh yeah, that cover looked like this, and
- 40:24Mark Pracht: But I, you know, I don't know, like, I think about, I think about all the people who have taken these ideas and expanded them.
- 40:33Mark Pracht: I know, Tad, you told me that your introduction to Darkseid and the New Gods was the Great Darkness War, and, like, how successful that story is. And, I mean, like, I have always thought, you know, in the 80s, when they did Cosmic Odyssey.
- 40:50Mark Pracht: I love that series, and I thought, you know, I didn't quite think that Mignola was the right artist for it, but at the same time, you know, it's Mike Mignola, that's great. You know, it's great art, but it's also… it just…
- 41:04Mark Pracht: It was a little strange to me, but,
- 41:07Mark Pracht: you know, I… I keep thinking about that,
- 41:12Mark Pracht: even the, even the, the, X-Men, Teen Titans crossover book.
- 41:21Mark Pracht: has a really interesting story. You guys read… you guys read that, right?
- 41:27Sean Harklerode: I read Odyssey, but I don't…
- 41:30Mark Pracht: Now, yeah, that one of the villains of the X-Men Teen Titans crossover that they did in the 80s.
- 41:40Mark Pracht: is Darkseid and Dark Phoenix.
- 41:44Mark Pracht: And at the end, Darkseid tries to cross the source wall.
- 41:50Mark Pracht: and ends up becoming one of the Titans that's…
- 41:53Mark Pracht: embedded in the wall, and I always thought that that was just this awesome idea, you know, like, that the arrogance of him trying to cross the source wall
- 42:03Mark Pracht: But that's, that's, that, you know, and that's another thing, that's another bit of, of, of,
- 42:09Mark Pracht: you know, he…
- 42:10Mark Pracht: canon that is not in these books. Like, Jack never addresses it, like, Jack didn't create the Source Wall, or any of those things. I think it's fascinating, and it… when you go back and you read how Jack wanted to create all these books, and then hand them over to other people.
- 42:29Mark Pracht: Like, how much we could have gotten out of it if that had actually happened, you know?
- 42:37Tad Eggleston: I was gonna ask a question, because Mark has done the Kirby… Research the most, like…
- 42:47Tad Eggleston: I feel like all of the Kirby I know, either he felt like he didn't have enough autonomy, or he insisted on near-complete autonomy. So he was either with Stan…
- 43:04Tad Eggleston: Writing words that he didn't want.
- 43:07Tad Eggleston: or whatever, or… or he was, I don't want an editor, I don't want a writer. Is there anything where he did have that team?
- 43:17Tad Eggleston: That… that… We talk about wishing he had here, where he had a writing partner that was…
- 43:27Mark Pracht: Oh, there was…
- 43:28Tad Eggleston: valued him as a storyteller, but…
- 43:31Mark Pracht: There's certain.
- 43:32Sean Harklerode: Him and Joe?
- 43:33Mark Pracht: Joe Simon, of course, you know, through the 50s, they did all the… they did the romance books.
- 43:40Mark Pracht: they did crime books, they did some of those horror books. I mean, and look, I think… I think that, you know.
- 43:49Mark Pracht: Okay.
- 43:50Tad Eggleston: Let's go dig up more of those.
- 43:52Mark Pracht: Yeah, Jack's perception, I think that, that… I think…
- 43:59Mark Pracht: the Lee and Kirby dynamic is always going to be interesting to try to parse out.
- 44:04Mark Pracht: Because I think that Jack, obviously.
- 44:08Mark Pracht: at some point felt that it was an unfair situation. And I… there… there's definitely elements of it that are unfair. There's no… but at the same time.
- 44:19Mark Pracht: I don't think you can deny that… I don't think… I don't think that anybody can say that Stan Lee did not value Kirby's contributions.
- 44:28Tad Eggleston: Yeah, no, I wasn't… I wasn't trying to… I… I was…
- 44:31Mark Pracht: No, I'm…
- 44:31Tad Eggleston: only of Jack's state of mind. Right. You know, was there ever a time where he was with a collaborator that he was…
- 44:39Tad Eggleston: Like, really willing to take the…
- 44:42Tad Eggleston: Let's word it this way, or even just hand over the… this is…
- 44:49Tad Eggleston: This is the story we're telling.
- 44:51Tad Eggleston: you script it, and I approve it, whatever.
- 44:55Mark Pracht: I don't, you know…
- 44:56Tad Eggleston: I lost you for a second. Okay.
- 44:58Mark Pracht: seems it's seen.
- 44:59Mark Pracht: Yeah, that's… It seems to me that Jack…
- 45:08Mark Pracht: There always seems to be a problem.
- 45:11Mark Pracht: At some point or another.
- 45:13Mark Pracht: there was, you know, there was the Joe Simon situation where Joe Simon sued to try to get the rights to…
- 45:19Mark Pracht: Captain America.
- 45:22Mark Pracht: And… Jack… Signed an affidavit.
- 45:29Mark Pracht: saying that they had created it as a work for hire for Timely slash Marvel.
- 45:35Mark Pracht: And… you know, some of the things that have been said was that Joe Simon tried to undercut Jack.
- 45:43Mark Pracht: like, he tried to get the rights all to himself, rather, you know, he wasn't suing for Jack, Simon, and Kirby, he was suing for just Joe Simon, right? And that, in a way, that's why Jack sided with Marvel.
- 45:56Tad Eggleston: Right.
- 45:57Mark Pracht: Or Martin Goodman.
- 45:59Mark Pracht: Like, so it seems like…
- 46:05Mark Pracht: as time goes on, everything… you begin to realize, this isn't fair, or somebody does something that's a slight, or… or… you know, I don't know. I mean, like, it… it seems that…
- 46:21Mark Pracht: Because I want to be real careful what I'm saying here, because I love Jack, and I think Jack is a stone genius, and I think Jack is…
- 46:30Mark Pracht: always gonna be on the Mount Rush floor of comic creators.
- 46:33Tad Eggleston: He's also human, and that's part of what this is all about.
- 46:37Mark Pracht: He's also human.
- 46:39Mark Pracht: Right. And I think that… I do think that there is a,
- 46:48Mark Pracht: You sign a deal, and then…
- 46:52Mark Pracht: You know, the deal goes away, you know, like.
- 46:57Mark Pracht: When you sign a deal that's the same deal that everybody else gets, and then suddenly the thing becomes super mega popular or successful, then suddenly the deal that everybody gets feels…
- 47:09Mark Pracht: Wrong?
- 47:11Mark Pracht: And then… And, and… Certainly, it probably is, but at the same time, it's like…
- 47:21Mark Pracht: Yeah, but that's what everybody else got, you know? I think about… like, the one thing we can say about Kirby that is continual across his history is this return of the original art.
- 47:32Mark Pracht: And certainly, that is something where I'm 100% on Jack's side, and I think that it should have been, like, it should always be returned.
- 47:40Mark Pracht: But then again, you see these interviews with all of these
- 47:44Mark Pracht: Golden 8 artists who were talk… are asked about that, and they're like, did you ever get your art back? And he's like, no, I didn't want it.
- 47:50Mark Pracht: Not Jack specifically, but other artists, because they were like, what was I gonna do with it?
- 47:56Mark Pracht: that this value of the art, and we've talked about this before, the value of the art did not really arise until there was this organized fandom, and conventions, and sales, and those kind of things, and that then suddenly this stuff had value, and now, well, I do deserve it back. Well, yes, you do.
- 48:14Mark Pracht: But nobody was really asking for it back until now, you know?
- 48:18Mark Pracht: And that does not change
- 48:21Mark Pracht: my feelings about the unfairness of taking it. That doesn't change my feelings about the unfairness of what absolutely happened with his Marvel art, where they put it in their warehouse, and that there were people who were taking it out of there, or… or being asked to destroy it, or, you know, any number of other things. But at the same time, like.
- 48:42Mark Pracht: That was… that was the standard operating procedure of the industry, and…
- 48:48Mark Pracht: Until somebody tries to change it.
- 48:50Mark Pracht: Or makes the case to change it.
- 48:53Mark Pracht: That's the way it is, you know?
- 48:55Mark Pracht: I don't know, maybe I'm being…
- 49:00Tad Eggleston: No, I think that's…
- 49:01Mark Pracht: Somebody else have a point.
- 49:03Sean Harklerode: Well, I mean, you put me in mind of Dave Chappelle's take on the Incredible Hulk.
- 49:11Sean Harklerode: You know, seems like everywhere you go, you get into a fight. I'm starting to think maybe it's you.
- 49:20Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 49:22Mark Pracht: Well, and the thing is, is like, I… I think…
- 49:24Mark Pracht: I mean, and I'd love to hear Jimmy's point of view on this, too. It's like, it…
- 49:30Mark Pracht: It does seem like…
- 49:36Mark Pracht: Last, last summer, I got… I went out to LA, and I went to the… the Kirby exhibit at the,
- 49:46Mark Pracht: you know, what the hell was the name of that museum that out there? But they had a huge Kirby exhibit, lots of original art, you know, lots of designs, things like that, and it's… you know, they talk about these thousands and thousands of characters that Jack created.
- 50:00Mark Pracht: And… absolutely true.
- 50:03Mark Pracht: But I think many of those thousands are just a sketch.
- 50:07Mark Pracht: And I do think that a sketch of a character is in the same way that
- 50:14Mark Pracht: Stan Lee talks about, if you've got the idea, then you've created it, and that's not necessarily true. You have to have the artist put it into a… some sort of image.
- 50:24Mark Pracht: And take your idea and make it
- 50:28Mark Pracht: I don't want to say real, but make it…
- 50:31Mark Pracht: Flesh it out, right? Into something that is a visual thing.
- 50:38Mark Pracht: And the same thing is, like, a design of a character that's on a piece of paper that has no context isn't really a character, it's just a design, right?
- 50:47Sean Harklerode: I mean, just think about all the… how many different people claim to have a hand in creating the Wolverine, right?
- 50:53Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 50:56Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah.
- 50:59Jimmy Gaspero: Who's gone.
- 51:00Tad Eggleston: Clearly Kirby.
- 51:02Sean Harklerode: Well, I…
- 51:03Tad Eggleston: Just ask, what's his name, the guy that Mark always gets in fights about.
- 51:07Mark Pracht: Ugh.
- 51:08Mark Pracht: No, no, no. No, I… no.
- 51:11Sean Harklerode: No.
- 51:11Mark Pracht: We're not gonna bring… we're not gonna bring that guy up.
- 51:14Sean Harklerode: I will say, I don't wanna…
- 51:18Sean Harklerode: not mention this, because I think it's very important. One of the greatest things about this book, I was so thrilled when I turned the page, we get a two-page spread collage. Full-on Kirby collage towards the end, with the destruction of New Gener.
- 51:33Tad Eggleston: Oh, yeah, I… that's my favorite page in this book. I love it. It's one of my favorite pages, period.
- 51:40Jimmy Gaspero: That's one of the things I wanted to bring up and talk about, like, what everyone thought of it, because, like, going back from my memory of the Fourth World and, you know, not having read it in a little while, and then getting to that collage, I'm like, what is going on here?
- 51:57Mark Pracht: I… I am such a huge fan of Kirby's collages. I mean, we did talk about it, how,
- 52:03Mark Pracht: one of my… when he used to do them in the Marvel books, they were almost always, like, black and white, which…
- 52:09Sean Harklerode: tight.
- 52:10Mark Pracht: a color drawing of it. And the thing is, is that it's probably the advances in coloring and things like that into the 70s, is that once he got to the Fourth World, he could do these collages and that they could be colored. And that makes this pop. It is incredible. It is… I… I cannot…
- 52:29Mark Pracht: I cannot gush more. I will say that when I went to that exhibit.
- 52:35Mark Pracht: This was one of the pages hanging on the wall.
- 52:38Sean Harklerode: Oh, wow.
- 52:39Mark Pracht: And it would.
- 52:39Jimmy Gaspero: Oh, that's awesome.
- 52:41Sean Harklerode: Hey, is that a Star Destroyer? The rear of a Star Destroyer from Star Wars?
- 52:48Mark Pracht: Where…
- 52:49Sean Harklerode: Just a… I'm looking.
- 52:52Mark Pracht: Thank you, Ed.
- 52:53Sean Harklerode: All Apocalypse Reels.
- 52:55Sean Harklerode: as its sister planet, New Genesis, blown apart.
- 52:59Jimmy Gaspero: It looks like it. Yeah, it's on the… on mine, it's, like, on the left side of the page, almost…
- 53:06Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 53:07Jimmy Gaspero: Halfway down, does…
- 53:09Mark Pracht: Yeah, I do see it.
- 53:10Jimmy Gaspero: Does look… does look like a Star Destroyer. And actually, right.
- 53:13Mark Pracht: Right, to the right of that?
- 53:15Mark Pracht: Is that the cockpit of a B-wing?
- 53:20Sean Harklerode: It could be.
- 53:21Mark Pracht: That's just to the right.
- 53:24Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah.
- 53:25Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 53:27Jimmy Gaspero: It def- yeah, it definitely could be. It's…
- 53:29Mark Pracht: That… it totally is a Star Destroyer. I totally missed that! That's incredible.
- 53:37Tad Eggleston: Well, you know, I mean, that was his, his,
- 53:41Tad Eggleston: his… his model for blowing up a planet was… was Star Wars. This has the feel of an Alderaan…
- 53:50Tad Eggleston: You know, so he was… he was given the hat tip.
- 53:53Sean Harklerode: Well, I, I, I also do love…
- 53:56Sean Harklerode: also, coming out of this page, as, you know, New Genesis, you know, the city there is flying off.
- 54:09Sean Harklerode: I don't know for certain, but this feels to me like… Things coming full circle.
- 54:23Sean Harklerode: Because, to me, as soon as I saw that, and that Highfather is looking for a place to land.
- 54:30Sean Harklerode: It made me think of Jason Aaron's Thor run.
- 54:35Sean Harklerode: And, I thought, hey, it's coming back.
- 54:40Sean Harklerode: Like, Kirby's ideas from new gods have now gone back to Thor.
- 54:47Mark Pracht: Right.
- 54:47Sean Harklerode: Right?
- 54:48Sean Harklerode: Which.
- 54:49Mark Pracht: Right? I mean…
- 54:50Mark Pracht: Because, yeah, that… that was, you know, that was always the strong rumor, was that, you know, this all was supposed to be
- 54:57Mark Pracht: Kirby's continuation of Thor, that he wanted to wipe out all of the Thor characters in Ragnarok, and then replace them all.
- 55:04Sean Harklerode: Right, and with that, and I… I don't know if, Ted, you've ever talked to Jason Aaron.
- 55:10Tad Eggleston: I have not yet.
- 55:12Tad Eggleston: He's on the list.
- 55:13Sean Harklerode: We've communicated a couple times, but he's.
- 55:15Tad Eggleston: Right, and a lot of.
- 55:16Sean Harklerode: Series is going.
- 55:18Sean Harklerode: with Kevin Bacon.
- 55:23Mark Pracht: We're not…
- 55:23Jimmy Gaspero: I just saw the other.
- 55:24Mark Pracht: guy.
- 55:27Mark Pracht: like, the one series that I have always been like, why? I know, I know he was a bastard, but…
- 55:36Mark Pracht: Could we not have finished this? Please!
- 55:42Mark Pracht: I love that series.
- 55:45Tad Eggleston: It is great.
- 55:46Tad Eggleston: It is great.
- 55:47Jimmy Gaspero: I have to finish it still. I haven't finished it.
- 55:51Tad Eggleston: I just…
- 55:51Sean Harklerode: Eric.
- 55:53Tad Eggleston: I just quickly shared my screen, because I think I have a book that we may either want to throw in after,
- 56:02Tad Eggleston: after-cree Skull Roar, or throw into our pulp blotter at some point.
- 56:07Tad Eggleston: there is a Best of Simon and Kirby that actually kicked off
- 56:12Tad Eggleston: a series of Simon and Kirby Books done by…
- 56:17Tad Eggleston: There's a horror book, a sci-fi book, a crime book.
- 56:22Tad Eggleston: Done… done with the… and it looks like a superhero book.
- 56:28Tad Eggleston: Done with the, approval of both of their estates.
- 56:34Tad Eggleston: And with a lot of hand-picked Joe Simon stories.
- 56:37Mark Pracht: Yeah, I have the, the best of Mainline, which was their… That was the… the,
- 56:44Mark Pracht: the publishing company that Joe and Jack started.
- 56:48Tad Eggleston: Okay.
- 56:48Mark Pracht: 50s.
- 56:50Mark Pracht: It did not last long.
- 56:52Mark Pracht: But, you know.
- 56:57Mark Pracht: From my understanding, for all Jack's complaints about publishers.
- 57:02Mark Pracht: They had pretty much the same policies that all the publishers they worked with when they became popular.
- 57:11Jimmy Gaspero: Ugh.
- 57:13Jimmy Gaspero: One of the things I also had wanted to bring up in terms of the hunger dogs is,
- 57:20Jimmy Gaspero: the last time, and it's only… it's 3 pages before the end, but the last time we see Darkseid in this, you know, I… I understand that Jack had wanted to kind of at least kill…
- 57:32Jimmy Gaspero: Darkseid and Orion at some point.
- 57:36Jimmy Gaspero: But not being able to do that, I thought it was very interesting in terms of we see…
- 57:42Jimmy Gaspero: Orion with his mother and Becca, like, speed away, and we just… the last two panels are… we see, like, this encroaching white space, and Darkseid is, like, a little tiny, like, speck in that last panel. I thought that was very…
- 57:58Jimmy Gaspero: interesting for, like, a character that has occupied so much real estate throughout the Fourth World, that that's how we… we see him at the very…
- 58:06Jimmy Gaspero: end of it, just moving away from him, the white space starting to, like, envelop him. I thought it created a very interesting picture, for the last of Darkseid.
- 58:19Mark Pracht: Well, I think it…
- 58:19Sean Harklerode: Yeah.
- 58:20Mark Pracht: thematically, it's super, super interesting, because I think, like… and this, of course, is my own interpretation of what maybe Jack was trying to say, and God knows if it's right, but, like… like I said, when even God's Must Die, that idea of him bringing back all of these people who were gone…
- 58:38Mark Pracht: And then feeling like they're not the real… You know?
- 58:42Mark Pracht: And that's more and more isolated.
- 58:45Mark Pracht: more and more with less people that he could turn to, you know? Granny's gone.
- 58:52Mark Pracht: Verman Vunderbar's gone, Kalabak's gone, DeSaad's gone, you know, and all he has left is… His command of this…
- 59:04Mark Pracht: And that, I think, probably, like, to me, it's like…
- 59:08Mark Pracht: sometimes, you know, absolute power, it just leaves you alone. You know, it just leaves you isolated from everyone else.
- 59:16Mark Pracht: And that… that's where we leave Darkseid, you know?
- 59:21Sean Harklerode: Jack Darkseid?
- 59:26Mark Pracht: I think we… I think we know Jack as Hyman.
- 59:30Mark Pracht: Hyman looks like Jay.
- 59:31Sean Harklerode: But it looks like him.
- 59:33Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 59:34Sean Harklerode: But…
- 59:35Mark Pracht: I…
- 59:35Sean Harklerode: We talked about having absolute control, being left alone.
- 59:39Sean Harklerode: All of his patriots have gone.
- 59:45Mark Pracht: Well… He always said that there was something of himself in all of his characters, so…
- 59:51Sean Harklerode: I also love, when you talk about the whiteout,
- 59:56Sean Harklerode: There's a few pages before that,
- 1:00:02Sean Harklerode: Where all the characters in the foreground of this big explosion, it's the top of…
- 1:00:10Sean Harklerode: I don't know. I don't have page numbers. Oh, it's the page… it's the page before the collage.
- 1:00:18Mark Pracht: Right.
- 1:00:19Sean Harklerode: all the characters in the foreground are whited out instead of blacked out, which I thought was a…
- 1:00:25Sean Harklerode: Is a fabulous visual.
- 1:00:28Sean Harklerode: That when you mentioned that about Darkseid, it reminded me.
- 1:00:32Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 1:00:34Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah.
- 1:00:35Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah, there are… like I said, there are some really interesting concepts in this, like, I was looking at Darkseid in terms of how we last see him, as if he… if Darkseid with the anti-life equation, is standing in as, you know.
- 1:00:47Jimmy Gaspero: totalitarian or authoritarian governments.
- 1:00:52Jimmy Gaspero: And, you know, we now have gone from the early 70s to 1984, 1985, kind of, like, the height of the Cold War. I was just, like, really trying to think of what Jack was, like, grappling with and what he was trying to say, just that these types of governments
- 1:01:09Jimmy Gaspero: No matter how long they're around, like, can't survive, like, there's al- the hunger dogs are always gonna turn on you at some point in time, and…
- 1:01:17Jimmy Gaspero: You know,
- 1:01:19Jimmy Gaspero: it was just… just kind of, you know, interesting in terms of the, like, the political ramifications, I thought, of what he was trying to say about
- 1:01:28Jimmy Gaspero: about Darkseid, and kind of reflecting the current moment, and how things had changed from the early 70s to 1985, too. I was wondering how much of that was wrapped in with what he…
- 1:01:38Jimmy Gaspero: how he ended… That panel on Darkseid.
- 1:01:44Mark Pracht: Well, I think… I think that that has a lot to do with it. I think also, you know, like, I think…
- 1:01:51Mark Pracht: What you're saying about the change in the political situation from being, like.
- 1:01:58Mark Pracht: because I will never forget that my father
- 1:02:03Mark Pracht: My father was actually… we were having a discussion after we saw Red Dawn, of all things, right?
- 1:02:09Jimmy Gaspero: The historical documentary, Red Dawn?
- 1:02:16Mark Pracht: Right! But,
- 1:02:19Mark Pracht: But he was actually… we were actually talking about it, and I, you know, I was… I think I was… actually, I was… it was the day I was 13. I turned 13, and we went and saw Red Dawn, because it was the first PG-13 movie that got released, and I thought that it was… it came out of my birthday, my 13th birthday, so we went. But,
- 1:02:38Mark Pracht: And I remember he was talking to me about it, and he was like, you know, like, the big flaw in that is that right now.
- 1:02:44Mark Pracht: The idea of amassing more… territory
- 1:02:49Mark Pracht: Doesn't make sense to anybody anymore.
- 1:02:52Mark Pracht: And we went through that period in the 80s. It was more about having
- 1:02:56Mark Pracht: it was consolidating your power into technology and into, more powerful weapons, rather than trying to take over more and more space, right? That… that people wanted to control what they had, rather than trying, you know, and I think that
- 1:03:13Mark Pracht: dark side… in a way.
- 1:03:19Mark Pracht: maybe, and maybe this is it, because I do think that there is a shift in…
- 1:03:25Mark Pracht: what we're talking about, like, I think that the political shift in this book, that now I'm thinking about it, is where now we're only on… on Apocalypse, right? He isn't trying to take over Earth anymore. He isn't trying to, you know…
- 1:03:38Mark Pracht: expand his power base. He's trying to hold on to what he already has with more powerful weapons and more powerful, you know, violence, and, you know, and that in the end of the day, he is a,
- 1:03:55Mark Pracht: a relic.
- 1:03:56Mark Pracht: You know, that he doesn't function well in this world that we're in now.
- 1:04:01Mark Pracht: And that… he… maybe what Jack is trying to say, that eventually he's just gonna be erased from…
- 1:04:10Mark Pracht: From what's left anyway.
- 1:04:14Mark Pracht: I… maybe. Well, that's… that's… That's… yeah.
- 1:04:18Jimmy Gaspero: No, I think that's an interesting… I think that's an interesting point,
- 1:04:22Jimmy Gaspero: You know, it does seem to… to…
- 1:04:25Jimmy Gaspero: allude to that, in terms of how he's left things with him.
- 1:04:30Mark Pracht: I would tell you one other thing that I thought about when I was reading this.
- 1:04:39Mark Pracht: So, one of the things that I thought about… sorry, I thought I heard my wife calling.
- 1:04:45Mark Pracht: Is that, I always think about… the bugs.
- 1:04:52Mark Pracht: who lived… Underground on New Genesis.
- 1:04:56Mark Pracht: Right? Because that was also sort of the replest underclass of New Genesis, and they are not mentioned at all in this, you know? The, you know, the planet blows up, they decide they can blow up the planet and they'll fly away in Supertown, you know?
- 1:05:13Mark Pracht: And… we never talk about the bugs, you know?
- 1:05:18Sean Harklerode: There are some skulls flying out in that collage.
- 1:05:20Mark Pracht: There are.
- 1:05:21Mark Pracht: There are, and I think… I think that's… that's an… I mean, like, I think that that probably was just a… I don't have time to deal with this.
- 1:05:29Mark Pracht: Element of it, but it did cross my mind, you know?
- 1:05:34Jimmy Gaspero: Huh.
- 1:05:35Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah, they're not mentioned at all. It is so odd, the characters that he doesn't bring back for this.
- 1:05:40Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 1:05:41Jimmy Gaspero: You know.
- 1:05:42Mark Pracht: And yet, you know, we get this extent… this little scene with,
- 1:05:49Mark Pracht: Oh, what's his name? The horse guy.
- 1:05:53Jimmy Gaspero: Lonar.
- 1:05:54Mark Pracht: Lonar, who…
- 1:05:56Sean Harklerode: people.
- 1:05:56Mark Pracht: Which… Lonar, of the Hill people. But, yeah, because they, like, that… quite honestly, one of the more…
- 1:06:04Mark Pracht: forgettable of the young new gods that we were introduced to, you know? I mean…
- 1:06:11Mark Pracht: at least in my mind, I mean, the horse is cool, yeah, but, it's just interesting.
- 1:06:18Mark Pracht: Like… It's just really interesting, the characters he does bring back, and the characters he doesn't.
- 1:06:25Mark Pracht: part of me… Part of me?
- 1:06:28Mark Pracht: thought that he brought back Lonar just because he wears Thor's helmet.
- 1:06:37Tad Eggleston: Well, I mean…
- 1:06:39Sean Harklerode: We talked about odd,
- 1:06:42Sean Harklerode: transitions and who he brings back. There is that moment where Highfather and Lona are talking, and you turn the page, and all of a… all of a sudden, light rays just been standing there.
- 1:06:54Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 1:06:56Sean Harklerode: I had to turn back, and I was like, when did Light Ray get there?
- 1:07:01Jimmy Gaspero: I… I do like Light Ray's appearances in both… in both… even… even God's Must Die and this. Like, even God's Must Die, Light Ray just shows up and he's like, hey, you're Ryan, watch… watch me reprogram this… this…
- 1:07:14Jimmy Gaspero: you know, mechanized soldier into a bomb. And then this one, he just shows up, and he's like, I'm just gonna break through the barrier of apocalypse, and then…
- 1:07:24Jimmy Gaspero: We last see light ray, and Orion's just watching him go off into the distance, and Orion's just like, that guy!
- 1:07:33Sean Harklerode: Oh…
- 1:07:34Mark Pracht: Oh, that Orion.
- 1:07:37Jimmy Gaspero: I do think, you know, Kirby's melodrama, you know, how… I think he has always been very good at kind of playing up the melodrama of a scene, you know, I think of bringing, like, he re… you know, bringing romance comics.
- 1:07:52Jimmy Gaspero: In the, I guess, 50s or into the 60s, but I did like, I really did like the couple of pages we get between Orion and Becca.
- 1:08:02Jimmy Gaspero: when he shows Becca his true face, I thought that was, like, really well done.
- 1:08:07Jimmy Gaspero: did not seem like it was the same comic as the rest of Hunger Dogs, but really well put together scene, well constructed, yeah, I thought that was, like, a really great bright spot in this between the two of them.
- 1:08:24Mark Pracht: Yeah.
- 1:08:25Jimmy Gaspero: But… On any map.
- 1:08:27Mark Pracht: Now, I think that's… I think I 100% agree with that.
- 1:08:31Mark Pracht: the only… the only caveat would be there's that one splash page with the extreme close-up of Orion that is clearly not inked by Mike Royer, that…
- 1:08:43Mark Pracht: You're sort of like.
- 1:08:48Jimmy Gaspero: Yeah.
- 1:08:48Mark Pracht: Sir.
- 1:08:49Mark Pracht: And… and Becca's, you know, it… it…
- 1:08:52Mark Pracht: Yeah, like, it is, you know, it is interesting that even Year says that, because it really is clear as you flip through it, it's like, oh, yeah, that's not…
- 1:09:02Mark Pracht: That page was… You know.
- 1:09:08Mark Pracht: Anyway… Unfortunately, guys, I'm gonna have to get off, so,
- 1:09:15Mark Pracht: If… if y'all want to continue.
- 1:09:17Tad Eggleston: Well, then we're at a good point, I think. I think we'll almost certainly wind up returning to Kirby at some point, but for the next 3 months, I think, 3 issues apiece of…
- 1:09:29Tad Eggleston: of the, the Kree-Skrull War, Roy Thomas and a series of artists,
- 1:09:37Tad Eggleston: From roughly the same time, and somehow none of us have ever actually read it.
- 1:09:42Sean Harklerode: Well, this has been great. You know, I finally…
- 1:09:46Tad Eggleston: Yeah.
- 1:09:47Sean Harklerode: Managed to get through the omnibus?
- 1:09:50Tad Eggleston: The, the, the doorstop? I mean, I have a number of doorstops, so I say that lovingly.
- 1:09:55Sean Harklerode: I do have the complete DC Ditco omnibus to go through now, so…
- 1:10:01Tad Eggleston: Pardon me.
- 1:10:02Tad Eggleston: What did Ditko do at DC?
- 1:10:05Sean Harklerode: Creeper…
- 1:10:07Mark Pracht: Creeper.
- 1:10:07Sean Harklerode: Shade the Changing Man?
- 1:10:11Sean Harklerode: Which is what I've been reading in it.
- 1:10:13Tad Eggleston: Alright.
- 1:10:14Sean Harklerode: Hawking Dove?
- 1:10:17Tad Eggleston: Okay.
- 1:10:18Sean Harklerode: Huh.
- 1:10:19Sean Harklerode: And, and a lot of, like, a lot of horror, you know, like, mystery stories.
- 1:10:25Tad Eggleston: Okay.
- 1:10:26Tad Eggleston: Yeah.
- 1:10:26Mark Pracht: I was, I…
- 1:10:29Mark Pracht: Last, last story, then I gotta go. But, on, on, on the DITCO Facebook page, somebody had put up a, a letter, you know, the letters to DITCO thing.
- 1:10:40Mark Pracht: And Sean's already laughing, because he saw it. It's like some guy had sent Steve a letter, and he's like, I would really love an autograph, or maybe a piece of original art, just a… just a stick figure or something. And he sends him back, like, a page of just…
- 1:10:57Mark Pracht: Like, why? Why should you deserve this? Why should I give this to you? You know, it's like, you know, it's the full-on objectivist ditco, like, I don't owe you anything. And then it gets to the end.
- 1:11:10Mark Pracht: Eddie just put SD.
- 1:11:12Mark Pracht: Because it's like, no, you don't get a signature.
- 1:11:21Jimmy Gaspero: Bush!
- 1:11:21Tad Eggleston: No, no, no, I mean, in many collector circles, that might be worth more than if he had given him a…
- 1:11:26Mark Pracht: We were talking about that, I was like, do you know how excited I would be to own that?
- 1:11:33Tad Eggleston: Right.
- 1:11:34Sean Harklerode: I re…
- 1:11:34Mark Pracht: over the moon.
- 1:11:36Sean Harklerode: Have you guys seen the kid who wrote to Steve Martin? No, no, John Cleese. Someone wrote to John Cleese asking for an autograph.
- 1:11:45Sean Harklerode: And John Cleese wrote back this whole thing about how he's too important to respond to those sorts of things, and then signs of…
- 1:11:59Mark Pracht: Oh, I have a dream.
- 1:12:01Tad Eggleston: For Mark Pratt, Sean Harklrode, and Jimmy Gasparo, this has been the Fourth World Book Club. We're gonna have to come up with a new name.
- 1:12:08Tad Eggleston: Soon, on 22 Panels, and we will see you after the next page.