Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / WFC Classic: Don't Create a Vacuum: Crisis Communication for Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:00John McKechnie: You you wanna be quick. You don't wanna you don't wanna rush anything, but but make sure you get out there and tell people what they need to know.
- 0:06Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone. This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors. I hope you enjoy.
- 0:16CREDIT UNION EXAM SOLUTIONS: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA? Join Mark Trichol as he shares with you the insider's view on passing your exam with Flying Colors. The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union Exam Solutions by Mark Trichle. If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time and money, Visit us at marktrichel.com to find out more.
- 0:48Mark Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trichel with another episode of With Flying Colors. Today, I'm excited to be here with John McKechnie. John, how are you doing today?
- 0:57John McKechnie: Great. Thank you, Mark. Thanks for having me on.
- 0:59Mark Treichel: How are your Orioles doing heading into the All Star break? They doing okay?
- 1:03John McKechnie: Birthplace, I'm happy. Last time, I think, I was on, we talked about NFL football, and I, of course, talked about my Ravens, and now I'm talking about the Orioles.
- 1:12Mark Treichel: So That's right. And my twins are doing okay. They've got a few injuries. Carlos Perea just got plantar fasciitis for the second time in about twelve months. But, other than that, we're, trying to track down the Cleveland Indians.
- 1:25John McKechnie: I I agree with you. I'm just trying to keep you between the lines.
- 1:28Mark Treichel: Trying to keep me with between the lines. It's a good reference for baseball. John, you and I go way back, but some of our listeners may have heard you on a couple of our other episodes. But for a listener who may not be aware of your background, why don't you give a little bit of your your background in credit unions?
- 1:43John McKechnie: Thank you. I... It's a long background as as I... As we move on through the years. I worked on Capitol Hill in the late eighties, joined CUNHA in...
- 1:53On April fool's day nineteen eighty seven, which I think a lot of people who know me will think is appropriate. And then was with CUNHA for eighteen plus year. And then I moved over to NCUA where you and I were colleagues. I worked for three chairmen, Joanne Johnson, Mike Frizel, and Debbie Matts. And it was actually during some of the most interesting years we've had at NCUA.
- 2:13And since 2011, I've I've hung out my shingle and been a consultant in the industry, and never a dull moment.
- 2:20Mark Treichel: Very dull moment. A lot going on in the world and and a lot going on in credit unions as we sit here in July. Now the topic of the day is crisis communications and lesson learned from good or bad crisis communications. But you and I were chatting about some things going on in the industry, and it made us reflect on some things that we recall at our times at NC. That's it.
- 2:44I'm just going to laugh that up there. Crisis communications and lessons learned. So what's your take on how an institution should approach a crisis communication and then perhaps any lessons learned relative to that?
- 3:00John McKechnie: The obvious starting point, I think, where you and I intersect was, of course, the the financial crisis of two thousand eight, 2009 into 2010 just because NCUA was so front and center when things hit. And, of course, any good crisis, I think, starts on a Friday afternoon. And, of course, in in this case, I remember my assistant came into my office on a Friday afternoon in in late July of of two thousand eight and said, hey. You better turn PV, which is always a bad thing to start a conversation with. And I turned it on, and there was an SNL in Los Angeles that was having a run.
- 3:40And CNN had the helicopters flying over this street scene of people lined up around the block. And right away, people are seeing that on TV. It's gonna send shock waves through the financial world, and sure enough, it did. I think that may have been the first domino to fall because what happened over the next month or so was that the liquidity markets froze up, the mortgage market froze up, and even though that particular incident was something in the S and L world, credit unions certainly were affected quickly to the point where the liquidity strains in the industry necessitated NCUA scrambling quite a bit to get the central liquidity facility upgraded and updated. That that required a pretty heavy lift on Capitol Hill.
- 4:30Fortunately, even though the industry wasn't... The Credit Union trade weren't happy about it, but they knew that their members desperately needed this. But the point of that is not so much crisis communications. It's just the fact that it accelerated and put a lot of pressure on everything that happened. And, of course, consumers that that saw these...
- 4:47This evidence of a run at a at a thrift, they began to ask a lot of questions to NCUA about how their credit union was. And I remember we had a... We we still... NCUA still does have an 800 line and a little... A button on the the web page, how to get in touch with NCUA about your insured funds.
- 5:07And in a month, we would get maybe 50 inquiries on that telephone line. In one week, we got 200 after that thrift problem started, and it just went downhill from there. So I would say as a first and foremost thing, you as a credit union need to always be very cognizant of the fact that you have to inform your members about the safety and soundness of their funds and remind people that no one has ever lost a penny of insured, federally insured money in a federally insured credit union. That's probably the first... I say that's lessons number one, two, three, four, and five, make sure people know their money is safe.
- 5:52If they've got it in a federally insured account, make sure they know that. I understand from a couple recent examples in credit union land where credit unions had problems with cyber breaches and things like that. I understand anecdotally that message did not go out as quickly as it should have, and let that be a lesson to everybody. It needs to go out first.
- 6:17Mark Treichel: It's gotta go out it's gotta go out quick, and it's gotta be accurate. Gotta be... And it gotta be... And and quick meeting first. Now that's...
- 6:24The the reality is if you don't communicate, the vacuum is... Gets created and the water cooler talk starts or the people in line start conversations. So you can... You you wanna be truthful, but that there's a truthful narrative that you can tell by getting out in front of it.
- 6:40John McKechnie: That's a great way to put it. And and I'll also add that when you're with the federal government like we were, I think you really have to put an emphasis on being the first with the truth. Get out there, make sure you're transparent, make sure you're above board. Now, in a credit union context, that's also important because you are going to be the authority that your members look to, and you really need to be very transparent and always keep in mind that you're trying to, you're there to help them. And you're there as part of member services, making sure they understand what's going on.
- 7:13And again, be authoritative, be truthful, be transparent. These are the kind of things that they sound elementary, but when there's a crisis going on, maybe it's not always apparent what you should do. And also, this sounds obvious, but keep your head. Just realize that you've got a job to do. You know what you're doing.
- 7:32You're the experts. Get it done.
- 7:35Mark Treichel: As you're walking through that, I'm thinking about, again, credit unions, but I'm thinking about our time at NCUA and we had at NCUA and they still do. They have a very robust list of delegations of authority. Person can do this, regional directors can do this, the executive director can do this, the board retains this, etcetera, etcetera. And part of that is if the executive director is not available or regional directors or the board's not available, having set things in motion so that you can move quickly in the case of a crisis. Let's say a plane went down, let's say just people, the internet on the East Coast went down, and we would tabletop these things.
- 8:18And I was talking to a credit union about cybersecurity and they're having their planning session and the tabletop exercise they're having at their retreat this month relates to cybersecurity. Then some things hit the news where some credit unions were feeling challenges with that. But having the delegations of authority, having a plan, the same can be said for credit unions being prepared and having a crisis communication plan, having a team where you've tabletop tabletop exercise some of those things and or having outside resources available potentially at the drop of a hat should something go bad that you can use as part of your, as your plan. Any thoughts on what I just said there?
- 9:01John McKechnie: Well, you're a 100% correct about it. Omar Bradley during the second World War used to say that when the fighting starts, plans are useless, but planning is essential. And I think that strikes the core to what you just said. You've got to have gone through the planning process to think about the kind of things you're gonna deal with. Admittedly, once stuff start, it gets a little bit difficult to try to adhere to a piece of paper, but having thought about going through the process, you have to do that.
- 9:34I commend any credit union that goes through these exercises, just get your minds thinking about how to respond and react. I would also jump back again, you mentioned something about a crisis communication plan. I, again, have heard quite a bit in the last year from various credit unions that have had cyber breaches, have had ransomware, etcetera, etcetera. And in a couple instances, credit unions did very well and and got through it with Flying Colors for your shows, plug for your show there. The other the other part of it, though, is that some credit unions did not, in fact, have any kind of communication plan on the shelf.
- 10:14And they wish they did once they find out how important it was when things started to hit the fan. But, yeah, I think anybody listening to this podcast ought to understand that get something on paper. Get some kind of communication plan on paper. You talked about the tabletop activities, that's important, delegations of authority. Of course, the government is a bit different than the private sector, but the process is really important to think about the kind of things you need to focus on.
- 10:42And I'll say one more thing and then be quiet, and that is that one of the most important things about any communication, whether it's crisis communication or not, you have to figure out what audiences you wanna touch and do that early. So in the case of a credit union who's experienced in some kind of breach, your first and foremost audience has got to be your membership. Everything else takes a backseat to that.
- 11:06Mark Treichel: It's a great point. You've got you've got the the... Who are the key stakeholders? The employees, the members, the media, the regulator, that checklist, that planning, that tabletop exercise would be okay. Who are the stakeholders?
- 11:20What's the order of importance? And when I think about checklists, I think about the NCUA version of a disaster is a conservatorship action that needs to be taken on a Friday. Right? And there's a... I don't know how many pages long it is now, four, five, six, seven page checklist, the conservatorship checklist.
- 11:40You go in, you count cash, you remove the officials, you call the corporate, tell them that that there's a change of sign... You change the lock. Every time NCUA does a conservatorship, they come across something that they hadn't thought of. Like you said, doesn't... The plan is there, and then the chaos hit, but you have that kind of as your beacon that you can go back to.
- 12:01And at the end of the conservatorship, you go, you know what? We came up with a new thing for the checklist. But by having that plan in place, you have a more methodical approach. By having a committee that's looking at it, by having a group of people that have what their responsibilities are. Right?
- 12:18You talk about the the stakeholders. Who's gonna communicate to the employees? Who's gonna communicate to the members? It should be someone high up, perhaps all the way to the top, whether it's the board chairman or the CEO, who's gonna communicate with the media, and then making sure that you're all singing from the same hymnal.
- 12:38John McKechnie: There's there's a saying about the experience is the best teacher. Unfortunately, bad experience is the best teacher. I heard... Since I've been doing my own thing as a consultant, I I encountered one credit union that essentially, after I was brought in, they told me... This was maybe seventy two hours after they knew about the breach.
- 12:58They mentioned to me that they'd been dunking the calls of their state regulator for twenty four plus hours, and I don't know what my facial expression was, but I don't think it was good. The point is don't do something like that. Don't... You can't try to evade or or avoid the legal authorities that you have to deal with in the case of this particular credit union. It was a state charter, federally insured, don't do something like that.
- 13:22I think everybody at that credit union knew it was a mistake, and yet they didn't know what to do. But we're making it sound drastic, and it it can be. But if you know what you're doing and you haven't thought this through, it doesn't have to make things worse. As a matter of fact, you can make things a lot better for everybody.
- 13:39Mark Treichel: As you were talking, I was thinking about, well, when nine eleven happened in New York City and all the communications in New York City were down, banking systems were down, ATM networks were down. I can remember a couple large credit unions. I was the regional director at that point in time, and they had a plan in place and they put it in place, and they essentially were letting people get money. Even though they couldn't reconcile, people could get a certain amount of money out every day. And you know what?
- 14:07That cost them money, but they went into it knowing if something like this happened that they were going to strategize that way. Of course, it far exceeded everything that they thought they were going to do, But because they had done some planning, they were able to pivot real quickly and go, okay, there's going to be losses here, but these people are going to need money as well. Our members, we need to take care of our members. Going back to who comes first, right? It's the members' credit union.
- 14:31And, you know, when some... When you do have a cyber attack, when you do have ransomware, that prevents... It it it... It's gonna provide good service, and then there are gonna be people who take advantage of that. And, ultimately, you're gonna end up having some losses.
- 14:46But you gotta think about the long term and how you're treating those people in their time of need.
- 14:52John McKechnie: Yeah. I... That's well said. And I think, in addition to that, look at this kind of problem, if you will, as a opportunity to remind your members that you're on their side, that you're here to help. And what you just described is a good example of Credit Union stepping up when everything was going to heck.
- 15:11Here they are. They're here with some money that I needed. People remember that.
- 15:15Mark Treichel: They do. They do. Any thoughts on it? Get their communication through Twitter. People get their communication through Facebook.
- 15:24People get their communication from coming to the branch. Obviously, where you're at on the journey of life determines which one of those ways you're gonna communicate. Some people wanna email. Any thoughts on having a broad plan that incorporates multiple ways of reaching your members in a crisis?
- 15:45John McKechnie: That's the personal thing for me because I am not a tech guy. I'm not... I use the Internet extensively in my work. I'm addicted to my iPhone and all that, but I'm not really a social media user per se. But I can remember when you and I were colleagues and I was the head of the the public and congressional affairs all, I knew that I had to go fishing where the fish were biting, meaning you had to go out into the social media channel.
- 16:10So I gotta go. I got some peep... Somebody within the agency and then later outside the agency to help me design a a communication plan that maximized our messages to people. And by the way, this is not strategic as much as it's tactical, but I always recommend that if a credit union has a problem like this, they set up what is called a landing page. That's something on the website, like, you can click a button on the website, on the credit union's website that directs the member to a specific dedicated page It's full of all the information.
- 16:42One stop shop when everything you need to know about this particular breach or whatever it's going... Or the ransomware, cyber attack, whatever it is. That landing page will be a one stop shop. That's something that I always recommend. It's always a good idea.
- 16:58We did that at the agency. We had a specials... It's it's essentially creating a parallel web page. So when somebody came to NCUA's page back during this mortgage crisis, if they want to, they could be directed to this other page that gave them what they needed. Really important.
- 17:13I know it sounds basic.
- 17:15Mark Treichel: No. That makes sense. I... By the way, my website is marktreichl.com. I actually bought Mark Treichl spelled wrong with the e and the I flopped because so many people spell it the wrong way when they type it out to me that it'll automatically roll over to the right pronunciation.
- 17:30Just a a non sequitur there, but having another... Having an alternate, website ready to rock and roll where you can make those messages nice and focused makes a lot of sense. Probably
- 17:41John McKechnie: have a name like McKechnie and see how that goes.
- 17:44Mark Treichel: M little c big k. Right? You you have these plans. Things go wrong. You learn from the plans, hopefully, you're able to serve your members and get through it to fight another day, and then you do a postmortem.
- 17:57When NCUA loses money, I think it's over 10... If a credit union failure costs NCUA more than $10,000,000, the inspector general has to do a postmortem. If it costs more than 2 or 5,000,000, I think the Office of Examination and Insurance does a postmortem. And if it's less than that, the region will do a postmortem. Again, like the conservatorship checklist, what did we learn here?
- 18:19So any thoughts relative to to crisis communication, the aftermath, after the dust settles?
- 18:26John McKechnie: Yeah. Never stop learning from the mistakes, especially. Taking a half step back what you were saying about what to expect is the... What I call the roadhouse theory of public affairs. There was a movie Roadhouse, Patrick
- 18:40Mark Treichel: People throw beers in that, I think.
- 18:42John McKechnie: Yeah. They do. And we threw a lot of beer at NCUA back in those days too. But Patrick Quasie had this this great speech he gave. He was the bouncer in a bar, and he gave a speech to his his fellow bouncer saying, always expect the unexpected.
- 18:54And I think as part of these communication plans, as much as we talk about them in this nice, comfortable podcast we're doing, when things are really happening, it's not always easy to keep your head. Expect the unexpected and just expect that as just an ordinary part of crisis. You got a lot of people involved, a lot of emotions. Technology, of course, has its own problems. Again, I'm familiar in the last few months with several credit unions that are either victims of cyber attacks or ransomware attacks, and there's no way they would talk to somebody like you or I to help them with the technology part, but at least we can help get them through the member relations and communications needs.
- 19:39That's what you and I are talking about. In terms of the tech stuff, boy, I... Dealing with Capitol Hill and the administration, you can tell that it's a priority of everybody to realize just how serious this is. As much as the good actors keep trying to keep up with things, the bad actors seem to be always a half step ahead.
- 19:56Mark Treichel: Yeah. And they... The situations keep coming. You talked about the emotional side. The...
- 20:01You're gonna have members that that are crying. You're gonna have members that are screaming. You're gonna have you're gonna have people that need more money in a ransomware situation than you might be able to give them. That's just the importance of having that empathy and being able to listen. I remember when the corporate crisis happened and we had conserved US Central and Westcor, and Scott Hunt of the agency was still at the agency now.
- 20:27He's the director of One. Scott Hunt and I were out at Westcor, and the agency had taken over the Westcor, and there were capital holders there, the capital was depleted, and we needed to have a communication plan to call them and say, hey, we've taken the Credit Union over, we need you to keep your deposits in here because if you hold them, we're gonna have to sell the underlying deposits. By the way, you also have to write... You have to write your capital off, but you need to keep your money in or your losses are gonna be permanent. If you work with us, we can hold these more to maturity.
- 21:06They're gonna regain their value hopefully, and you might get some of your capital back. Lo and behold, they got most of their capital, if not all of their capital back. It took a while. But that day, I remember when Scott and I split up the list and it was like heavy scythe. Boy, this is gonna be a fun day.
- 21:22And I had... We had people yelling at us. We had people talking about how they couldn't handle it, but we... They needed to know, and we needed to get them through a few stages of grief so that they could understand it. But there were also people on that call that cheered me up saying, gosh, I'm glad I don't have your job today because I know it's a tough one.
- 21:38So empathy goes both ways.
- 21:40John McKechnie: Yes, it does. And giving out the vibe that... Look, it's a tough situation, but we've got it under control. We know what we're doing. Send it out that kind of reassurance.
- 21:52You just touched upon something I remember quite vividly. It was a painful moment during the crisis because one of the league presidents who I'd known loved and respected for a long time, but during the crisis, he was like, let these corporates all fail. Don't touch my members, my natural person credit unions. Let these institutions fail. It's not the problem of the natural person credit union.
- 22:17And our response, I remember myself and our general counsel at the time, the late great Bob Spencer, and maybe you were involved in this too, we were like, if you let these institutions fail and blow that kind of a hole in the share insurance fund, it is gonna affect, it's gonna trickle down and affect all credit unions. You don't want that. You wanna try to stay big picture. You wanna try to stay focused. We'll get through this, but don't panic.
- 22:41And if you're a credit union talking to your members during a ransomware attack, you have to convey that same sense that, look, we're federally insured, the money's safe, let's make sure we get through this.
- 22:54Mark Treichel: That covers 99% of the people who they know their life savings if they're at that... They keep everything at that one credit union. They know that it's gonna be safe when the dust settles, things get back to normal. That communication from the top, setting the tone from the top, providing the comfort when people are asking those questions is so important. Great.
- 23:12That's right. John, anything I should have asked you related to crisis communication today as we as we chat here on a... What is it? A Monday?
- 23:22John McKechnie: Well, we're talking mostly about events that are most... That are tech driven, cyber breach, the ransomware breach. I guess we could discuss a little bit about the the pandemic was a whole different breed of cat. But, again, the basics are still the same in in both types of situations. Tell people the truth.
- 23:41Be be quick about it. I quoted Omar Bradley and Patrick Swayze Young and also quote Don Wooden, the basketball coach. I know where...
- 23:48Mark Treichel: I love this quote. You go... I love it. Go for it.
- 23:50John McKechnie: Quick. He said, be quick, but don't hurry. Is that the one you're thinking of? Yeah.
- 23:54Mark Treichel: That's the
- 23:55John McKechnie: one. Just wanna... You wanna get up... And, again, make sure you know who you need to communicate in what... With and what order.
- 24:01It's all important. Dealing with the actual outside media is essential. I got a... An anecdote related to me just a week ago about a credit union that just refused to talk about the major to talk... They refused to talk to the major newspaper in their market, and your point earlier about how you create a vacuum, somebody else is gonna fill it.
- 24:23It's probably not gonna be to your liking. So make sure you communicate what you wanna know... What you wanna tell them to the right audiences.
- 24:31Mark Treichel: Great point. Great point. You reminded me one last war story from when we were out at West Coast. So we were worried about the press, and there was a little bit of press that was happening. And then we were looking out the window and we thought that the place was closed.
- 24:44And I think we thought we saw a news van drive by. But then we had the TVs on TV on and we were sometimes as you want to be good and lucky, You can get some luck and you can be good at what you do, you can survive usually. But the Octomom had her eight kids out on the West Coast. So we went from thinking we were going to be the top story to there not being any airtime for what might have been happening at the biggest conservatorship in the history of NCUA. So a little bit of luck and our preparation and the Credit Union's cooperation.
- 25:19Everybody kept their deposits in. Everybody was gonna get... Able to get their capital back. I'll never forget part of it.
- 25:24John McKechnie: I I did, but we'll have to keep an optimum and and reserve in case we need that again.
- 25:29Mark Treichel: That's right. Yeah. You just gotta... Again, gotta be lucky. John, this has been fun catching up with you as always.
- 25:35If one of my listeners wants to reach out to chat with you about what we've talked about here or anything else, what's the best way for them to reach you? Try me at...
- 25:44John McKechnie: My website is... Or my email is John at mckechniellc, and I'll spell that. It's m c k e c h n I e l l c dot com. John@mckechniellc.com. Phone number is (202) 997-5816.
- 26:02Would love to hear from folks if you have any questions or suggestions. Thank you.
- 26:07Mark Treichel: Very good, John. And I'll put the... In the show notes, I'll put that contact information. I wanna appreciate you being able to be available to chat on such short notice here today.
- 26:17John McKechnie: Plan to do it. This is an important topic, especially given the times.
- 26:21Mark Treichel: You got it. You got it. And listeners, I wanna thank you for listening as always. I hope you'll listen to it again soon. This is Mark Trackel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 26:35CREDIT UNION EXAM SOLUTIONS: Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors. Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA. If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check out our services at marktrichl.com.
- 27:00Mark Treichel: Hey.