Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How Recent Changes in Probate Laws Impact Your Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to How Recent Changes and Probate Laws
- 0:07Impact Your Cases. Thanks for being here this
- 0:09afternoon. I am Jennifer McNeil Lozano, co -chair
- 0:12of the BHBA's Trust and Estates Law Section.
- 0:15Before we begin, I'd like to take a moment to
- 0:17thank our sponsors. The Trust and Estates Section
- 0:20is sponsored by Bond Services of California,
- 0:24Liberty Mutual Surety, California Title Company,
- 0:29Pickford Escrow Company, and the Sanborn Team.
- 0:34Today I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:36the Honorable Susan Greenberg. Susan L. Greenberg
- 0:40brings over four decades of Bay Area legal experience
- 0:44to signature resolution, including 26 years on
- 0:48the San Mateo County Superior Court bench, where
- 0:51she held supervising assignments across family
- 0:53law, civil, and probate courts, and guided the
- 0:57court through the COVID -19 pandemic as criminal
- 1:00presiding judge. Before the bench, she served
- 1:03as a deputy district attorney and ran a private
- 1:06civil practice spanning personal injury, family
- 1:10law, real estate, and probate matters. Judge
- 1:13Greenberg is known for her tenacious pursuit
- 1:15of resolution, her candor about litigation risk,
- 1:18and her ability to uncover the true drivers of
- 1:21a dispute, qualities that are consistently produced
- 1:24settlements where others have fallen short. Thank
- 1:27you for being here, Judge Greenberg, and now
- 1:29let's get started. Thank you for having me and
- 1:32thank you, Jennifer, for that warm welcome. So
- 1:35good afternoon, everyone. Next slide, please.
- 1:42This is me. I very recently actually retired
- 1:46from the San Mateo County bench. And when I retired,
- 1:49I was the probate judge and the probate supervising
- 1:53judge. Let's get right into it because there's
- 1:55a lot to discuss. I just want to say now that
- 1:59if we run out of time, I will invite you to write
- 2:03down, you can see it, it's written there, my
- 2:06cell phone or my email address and either. email
- 2:10or text me if you need any of the citations that
- 2:13I discuss or have any questions that we can't
- 2:16get to during the presentation. I'm serious about
- 2:20that. If you do want to ask questions and we
- 2:22run out of time, please feel free to contact
- 2:25me. All right, so let's begin. California trust
- 2:29law has really changed quite a bit in the last
- 2:32five or six years. This is really geared to attorneys
- 2:37who have a practice where they advise settlers,
- 2:41trustees, beneficiaries of trusts, and additional
- 2:45areas of probate, including we'll discuss a little
- 2:48bit about tax laws and other similar issues.
- 2:53We're going to start with a case called Hagerty
- 2:56v Thornton. That is a decision that was extremely
- 3:01important in the trust it became law in 2024.
- 3:07To understand Hagerty, let's go into the statutory
- 3:11framework, which is probate code sections. 15400,
- 3:1715401, and 15402. So 15400 is really about the
- 3:24presumption that a trust is revocable. It establishes
- 3:28that unless a trust instrument expressly makes
- 3:32the trust irrevocable, it is revocable by the
- 3:36settler. Moving on to 15401, That actually describes
- 3:42the methods of revocation, and it basically provides
- 3:46two different manners in which a trust can be
- 3:50revoked. This is for a revocable trust, of course.
- 3:54First, the settler can comply with any method
- 3:56of revocation specified in the trust instrument.
- 4:01Second, the settler may use the statutory method,
- 4:05which is a writing other than a will. that has
- 4:09been signed by the settler and delivered to the
- 4:13trustee during the settler's lifetime. Those
- 4:17are the basics. 15402 deals with modification
- 4:22by and revocation of a trust. So in 15402, that
- 4:29provides that unless the trust instrument provides
- 4:33otherwise, if a trust is revocable by the settler,
- 4:37the settler may modify the trust by the same
- 4:41revocation procedure as in modification. All
- 4:47right, so we've got two different issues. We're
- 4:50revoking the trust or we're modifying the trust.
- 4:53And here's where the issue got a little bit difficult
- 4:56for the appellate courts over many, many years.
- 5:00Hagerty basically resolved these differing appellate
- 5:04court decisions. When Hagerty was decided by
- 5:08the California Supreme Court, it resolved this
- 5:11split among the appellate courts. So basically,
- 5:14what the appellate courts were divided on was
- 5:17one fundamental question, and that is, when a
- 5:20trust instrument specifies a particular method
- 5:24of modification, such as an acknowledged instrument.
- 5:29Does that alone make that the trust instruments
- 5:34method of exclusive, exclusive method of modification?
- 5:39And that was where the appellate courts were
- 5:42divided. Some said yes, others said no. You could
- 5:45still use the standard revocation procedure found
- 5:48in the codes. So here's what happened in Hagerty.
- 5:52Here are the facts. And it's really very instructive.
- 5:55In Hagerty, the settler, Jean Birch creates irrevocable
- 6:00trust in 2015. And she reserves the right to
- 6:04revoke or amend the trust by an acknowledged
- 6:08instrument. Acknowledged means notarized. An
- 6:11acknowledged instrument in writing. In 2016,
- 6:15she executes a notarized amendment, adding her
- 6:18niece Brianna Haggerty. And Brianna Haggerty
- 6:22becomes a beneficiary by that 2016 amendment.
- 6:27Then in 2018, Ms. Birch removes Pat Haggerty
- 6:32and adds other beneficiaries. In 2018, when she
- 6:36does this, she executes the second amendment.
- 6:39She signs it, but she doesn't get it notarized.
- 6:42So it's not acknowledged an acknowledged trust
- 6:46instrument or an acknowledged amendment instrument
- 6:49as was stated in her initial trust. This question
- 6:55was really the heart of the question of all the
- 6:58other appellate cases with slightly different
- 7:00facts, of course. What did the Supreme Court
- 7:03hold? Next slide, please. The Supreme Court held
- 7:08the following that under 15402, The trust may
- 7:14be modified just like in 15 .401, the same procedures
- 7:19for revocation, which include that statutory
- 7:22method, unless the trust instrument provides
- 7:26a method of modification that explicitly makes
- 7:32it exclusive or otherwise explicitly precludes
- 7:38the use of the revocation procedures for modification
- 7:41that you find in the code. So this absolutely
- 7:45decided the issue. Unless your statement, unless
- 7:49Ms. Birch had said the only way, this is the
- 7:53explicit way that you can modify this trust and
- 7:56you can't use what's in the code, this is the
- 7:59only way as an acknowledged instrument, and she
- 8:02didn't say that, unless she had said that, then
- 8:05the 2018 amendment wouldn't be valid, but she
- 8:08didn't say that. So the court found, yes, you
- 8:11can use what she put in her trust, but you can
- 8:13also use the ability to modify that you find
- 8:16in the code. So that's basically what happened
- 8:21in Hagerty. This disapproved the prior decision.
- 8:25So there were a number of prior decisions that
- 8:27were disapproved by Hagerty. King versus Lynch,
- 8:322 -0 -4, Cal at 4th, 1186. Ballastrari, 75 Cal
- 8:39App 5th, 511. Diaz versus Zuniga, 91 Cal App
- 8:445th, and those that I've listed in the table
- 8:47of authorities. There's so many. They range from
- 8:512019, actually one goes back to 2012, and 1995
- 8:56even, all the way through 2023. So this really
- 9:00was a sweeping decision that resolved this issue.
- 9:04And the Supreme Court looked at legislative history
- 9:07in making its decision. They looked at the Law
- 9:10Revision Commission's commentary on 15402 and
- 9:15determined that the commission's goal was to
- 9:19expand the availability of the statutory method
- 9:23of revocation, also to go equally to modification.
- 9:29So very, very important. Next slide, please.
- 9:33So post -Haggerty, there's been some case law
- 9:35that's very important. And it deals with attorneys
- 9:40in cases that are trying to now use Haggerty
- 9:43in various ways. So we'll first look at Trotter
- 9:46versus Trotter, so that Trotter -Vandyke. That's
- 9:49a pretty interesting case from 2024. It's 103,
- 9:55CalAP 5th, 126. And the Court of Appeal There
- 9:59did apply Hagerty, but found that the purported
- 10:03trust amendment was still invalid. Here we have
- 10:06a case of attorneys who are trying to say, look,
- 10:09here's an unsigned writing. And under Hagerty,
- 10:13we want it to be confirmed as an amendment to
- 10:17a trust. And the court said, yeah, that's not
- 10:20happening. That's me paraphrasing, of course,
- 10:23what the court said. But seriously, that's taking
- 10:26it a little bit too far, obviously. And that's
- 10:29what happened in Trotter versus Trotter van Dyck.
- 10:33It illustrates that Hagerty expanded the available
- 10:36methods of modification but did not eliminate
- 10:39the baseline requirement of having a signed writing,
- 10:42which we all know is required under 15401. Then
- 10:47we can look at Packard versus Packard. So in
- 10:51the Packard case, what happened was there was
- 10:54a petition for construction and reformation of
- 10:58a trust amendment. And the question was, does
- 11:01that constitute a trust contest subject to the
- 11:05120 -day limitation periods under Probate Code
- 11:08section 16 .061 .8? So interestingly, the court
- 11:16reasoned that whether a petition constitutes
- 11:19a trust contest must be determined by reference
- 11:23to the purposes the trustor sought to attain
- 11:26through the trust, and that a petition seeking
- 11:30to give effect to the trustor's intent through
- 11:32reformation is not a challenge to the trust's
- 11:37validity. So this distinction is really significant
- 11:40in that clients who missed that 120 day window
- 11:44may actually still have a viable reformation
- 11:48claim. Finally, we'll look at Govner versus Superior
- 11:52Court. That is a case from 2025. And in that
- 11:56case, the Court of Appeal held as a matter of
- 11:59first impression that The probate code will govern
- 12:03the timing for filing a demurrer to a petition
- 12:06brought under the probate code. And that was
- 12:10very interesting because attorneys in that case
- 12:13were arguing, oh, no, it should be the civil
- 12:15practice rules. The court found that that was
- 12:18not the case. Next slide, please. All right,
- 12:23so there have been legislative developments.
- 12:26That have occurred that we need to discuss. There
- 12:30are new trustee duties and beneficiary rights
- 12:33that we need to talk about. So first of all,
- 12:36there are expanded beneficiary rights when a
- 12:39seller becomes incompetent. And we see this all
- 12:42the time in probate court that a settler becomes
- 12:44incompetent. And now we've got the issues between
- 12:48the trustees, the beneficiaries. There's all
- 12:51kinds of problems that arise when a settler becomes
- 12:54incompetent. So prior to the 2021 and 2022 amendments,
- 13:00section 15 800 of the probate code provided that
- 13:04during a period that a trust is revocable and
- 13:08the settler is competent, the trustees duties
- 13:11run to the settler and not the beneficiaries.
- 13:15The 2021 amendment actually was effective on
- 13:20January 1st of 2023 because there was a 2022
- 13:24amendment and that significantly expanded beneficiary
- 13:29rights. when the settler loses competency. So
- 13:33basically then what's going to happen under the
- 13:35amended statute is that when no person holding
- 13:39power to revoke the trust is competent, the trustee
- 13:44must within 60 days of receiving information,
- 13:48establishing the settlers and competency, they
- 13:51must provide notice and a complete copy of the
- 13:54trust and all amendments to the trust to each
- 13:57beneficiary. who would be entitled to receive
- 14:00income or principal if the settler had died as
- 14:05of that date. This is important. It really gives
- 14:08the beneficiaries the opportunity to come forward
- 14:12and make a motion or do what they feel is appropriate
- 14:15in the probate court when they learn that the
- 14:19settler has become incompetent. In addition,
- 14:22the trustee's annual accounting duties shift
- 14:25to those beneficiaries and incompetency may be
- 14:29established either by a method specified in the
- 14:33trust instrument or by judicial determination.
- 14:37So if there's a fight about whether or not the
- 14:40settler is incompetent, that can be brought before
- 14:43the probate court. So this really creates new
- 14:47significant compliance obligations for trustees
- 14:50and new rights for beneficiaries when you've
- 14:53got an older person as a settler of a trust.
- 14:58All right, going on to the 120 -day trust contest
- 15:02limitation period, we know that section 16061
- 15:08.8 provides that a person who has served with
- 15:12a trustee's notification under 16061 .7 which
- 15:18is required when a revocable trust becomes irrevocable
- 15:21on a settler's death, that person may not bring
- 15:24an action to contest the trust more than 120
- 15:28days from service of the notification or 60 days
- 15:33from a date a copy of the trust terms are delivered
- 15:36during that 120 -day period, whichever is later.
- 15:41We've got Hamilton versus Green, 98 Cal App 5th,
- 15:47417 from 2023, where the Court of Appeal held
- 15:51that actions challenging the validity of a trust,
- 15:55including tort claims that have the practical
- 15:58effect of challenging a trust amendment, are
- 16:00subject to this 120 -day period. And then in
- 16:05Mary vs. Shambuht Shambtooby, 81, Cal App 5th,
- 16:10606, the Court held that filing a trust contest
- 16:15after the 120 -day period has elapsed without
- 16:19probable cause can trigger enforcement of the
- 16:24no contest rule. So be certain to calendar this
- 16:28deadline very carefully. And finally, the trustee
- 16:34notification duties under 16061 .7. So 16061
- 16:40.7 does require trustees to serve written notification
- 16:43on all beneficiaries and heirs of the settler
- 16:47when irrevocable trust becomes irrevocable, typically
- 16:51upon the settler's death, right? And when there's
- 16:54a change of trustee of an irrevocable trust,
- 16:57or when the power of appointment lapses upon
- 17:01the settler's death. So these notifications must
- 17:04include specific statutory language advising
- 17:08the recipient of that 120 -day contest period
- 17:12and failure to serve those notifications on the
- 17:16beneficiaries exposes the trust to liability
- 17:19for all resulting damages including attorney's
- 17:24fees and costs. Again, very, very serious to
- 17:29comply with the 120 -day notice provision and
- 17:34make sure that it's taken care of or you're setting
- 17:38the trust up for some serious liability. Moving
- 17:43on to the next slide, please. Elder financial
- 17:48abuse and trust amendments. All right, we see
- 17:51this all the time in probate court and I'm sure
- 17:53many of you have seen it as well. There is a
- 17:57recurring theme in recent California probate
- 18:00litigation, and it's kind of the intersection
- 18:03of elder financial abuse as well as trust modification.
- 18:07And as a judge, I was frequently called upon
- 18:10to make a decision. decision about whether a
- 18:12trust amendment was procured through undue influence
- 18:16or fraud. We've got various beneficiaries and
- 18:20other people who are not beneficiaries but want
- 18:23to become beneficiaries trying to get a larger
- 18:25portion of the pie. It's pretty sad and it's
- 18:29pretty difficult to deal with from the point
- 18:32of view of the court. So basically we've got
- 18:36undue influence as a ground to avoid a trust
- 18:39instrument. There was a case Lintz versus Lintz,
- 18:42which is 222, Cal App 4, 1346. And that's from
- 18:482014, where the Court of Appeal applied the contractual
- 18:52standard rather than the testamentary capacity
- 18:56standard to trust instruments and held that In
- 19:00property related transactions between spouses
- 19:03where one spouse is advantaged by a change to
- 19:07a trust, the presumption of undue influence arises
- 19:11under the family code. Interesting. And that's
- 19:14family code section is 721B. Recent cases have
- 19:19enforced this framework. So White versus Weir,
- 19:23which is from 2022, it's 76 Cal app fifth, fifth
- 19:2824, also held similarly. And it upheld an elder
- 19:33abuse restraining order, restraining an alleged
- 19:36influencer from facilitating any change to a
- 19:40settler's estate plan. Honestly, I can't tell
- 19:43you how many of these cases we see. It's a lot.
- 19:47All right, then the elder abuse restraining orders
- 19:50in the context of a trust contest, right? So
- 19:55we've got Elder Abuse Independent Adult Civil
- 19:59Protection Act, which is in Welfare and Institutions
- 20:02Code section 15600, etc. And that provides a
- 20:06powerful tool in trust litigation. The case is
- 20:10White versus Davis. It's 87 now and fifth. 270,
- 20:16and it's from 2023, where the court held that
- 20:20applications for elder abuse restraining orders
- 20:23based on alleged efforts to cause a settler under
- 20:27a conservatorship to change his or her estate
- 20:29plan did not arise from constitutionally protected
- 20:33activity and were not subject to anti -SLAPP
- 20:37dismissal. Good to know. And Newman versus Casey,
- 20:41which is from 2024, 99 cal app fifth. 359. The
- 20:48court applied the four -factor undue influence
- 20:50test under Welfare and Institutions Code section
- 20:5315610 .7, which deals with vulnerability of the
- 20:58victim, the apparent authority of the influencer,
- 21:01the influencer's tactics, and the equity of the
- 21:05result, and in evaluating whether indeed transfer
- 21:08constituted financial elder abuse. So there's
- 21:14an intersection between conservatorships and
- 21:16trust amendments, obviously. And we go back to
- 21:19White versus Weir, 76 Callup, 5th, 24, again
- 21:23from 2022. And this illustrates a critical practice
- 21:28point for everyone. And that is when a settler
- 21:31is under conservatorship, any trust amendment
- 21:34executed without notice to and approval from
- 21:37the conservator and the probate court, is highly
- 21:41suspect and may constitute financial elder abuse.
- 21:45Get it approved. Easy enough to do. File the
- 21:48motion, get it approved, notice everybody, and
- 21:52then you don't have to worry about a later, hopefully,
- 21:55have to worry about a later motion for undue
- 21:59influence or fraud. It's just a nightmare. So
- 22:04petitioners, advising trustees, or beneficiaries
- 22:07must be alert to this issue. Next slide, please.
- 22:13All right. We've got issues with regard to no
- 22:15contest clauses. And, you know, that used to
- 22:18be such an easy thing to draft, right? If anybody
- 22:21can test this well, they get nothing, basically.
- 22:24I'm paraphrasing, of course, but that's what
- 22:26we did a bazillion years ago. Well, there's recent
- 22:29developments in no contest clauses that really
- 22:32impact your drafting of the no contest clauses.
- 22:38So the statutory framework is within California
- 22:41probate code sections 21 .3 .10 to 21 .3 .15.
- 22:48And in 21 .3 .10b, a no contest A direct contest,
- 22:53sorry, is defined as a contest alleging in validity
- 23:01based on specific grounds, which can include
- 23:05forgery, lack of due execution, lack of capacity,
- 23:10menace, duress, fraud, undue influence. and it
- 23:15can be revocation pursuant to applicable statutes
- 23:18or instrument procedures and disqualification
- 23:21of a beneficiary. So we've got Key versus Tyler
- 23:25in 2024. That's 102 Cal App 5th, 365, where the
- 23:31court of appeal held that the scope of forfeiture
- 23:34under a no contest clause is not. limited by
- 23:39law, and the courts must give effect to the trustor's
- 23:42intent as expressed in the clause, different
- 23:48than what we're used to. So this case arose from
- 23:51a beneficiary's judicial defense of a trust amendment
- 23:53that had been procured through undue influence,
- 23:56in which the court held that it was a direct
- 24:00contest of the original trust. And then The court
- 24:05further held that the probate statutes designate
- 24:09categories of contests that can support application
- 24:13of a no contest clause, but do not address the
- 24:17permissible scope of forfeiture once a qualifying
- 24:20contest has occurred. So what does this mean
- 24:23and what kind of a drafting implication is this
- 24:25for us as practitioners? We've got Avelis versus
- 24:29Swearingen, 16 Cal App 5th, 485 from 2017 that
- 24:35basically establishes that what we used to do,
- 24:38those of us who are older, a long time ago, those
- 24:42generic no contest clauses, they're obsolete.
- 24:45Can't use them anymore. Practitioners must draft
- 24:48each clause with particularity, specifying and
- 24:52identifying which instruments are governed by
- 24:54the clause, whether subsequent amendments are
- 24:57governed by the no contest clause. Important
- 25:00to put all this in there. And Probit Code section
- 25:0421305A3 requires that a no contest clause expressly
- 25:11identify amendments to the trust. for the clause
- 25:14to apply to challenges to those amendments. And
- 25:19people are amending their trust, frankly, pretty
- 25:22frequently as things change in their lives, right?
- 25:25So a no -contest clause in the original trust
- 25:28does not automatically extend anymore to later
- 25:31amendments unless it so expressly provides. Next
- 25:38slide, please. Practical implications for drafting
- 25:42and client counseling. Okay, we're going to talk
- 25:47here about synthesizing all of the foregoing
- 25:49developments that we've talked about and what
- 25:52you need to do as a practitioner, what things
- 25:55you need to implement. First of all, you need
- 25:57to anticipate and prevent a will contest. just
- 26:03talked about that to some degree about what the
- 26:05no contest clause has to look like look like.
- 26:08But also make sure you follow Hagerty versus
- 26:12Thornton. Make sure that you have explicit exclusivity
- 26:17language if that's what your client wants with
- 26:20regard to trust modification. And what you might
- 26:24want to do, and I would strongly suggest is a
- 26:27good thing if you have time, is to go through
- 26:31your notes of past clients and their trust and
- 26:35determine, wow, when I interviewed this client,
- 26:38did they tell me I want this to be the exclusive
- 26:41and only manner in which the trust can be modified
- 26:44and exclude the manners provided in the probate
- 26:48code? Because if so, your language that you drafted
- 26:52in that trust may not be explicit enough to allow
- 26:56for your client's wishes, right? It may be vague
- 27:01enough or it may not say that this is the exclusive,
- 27:05explicitly exclusive manner in which to modify
- 27:08a trust and you'll want to notify them. Definitely
- 27:12give them notice and suggest they come in to
- 27:14make that modification so that they are in compliance
- 27:18with Hagerty versus Thornton. You want to make
- 27:21sure that you draft for all flexibility and contingencies.
- 27:26Again, complying with Hagerty versus Thornton.
- 27:30And you should have in there information that
- 27:35states exactly what it is that the settler wants
- 27:41to be flexible on. And again, with regard to
- 27:44no contest clauses, think about the contingency
- 27:48or the possible future issue of amendments to
- 27:52the trust. you want to conduct comprehensive
- 27:56asset identification. Always a good idea. I can't
- 28:00tell you how many cases come before the court
- 28:03and we have to do Hexted petitions because the
- 28:08assets weren't transferred into the trust. Almost
- 28:11always it's a piece of real property. And you
- 28:15want to go through and comprehensively, comprehensively
- 28:18identify the assets and make sure that they get
- 28:22transferred into a trust. When I was a practitioner,
- 28:26I actually did all that for my clients. I charge
- 28:29them, of course, and there's a recording fee
- 28:31and all the additional fees that go along with
- 28:33it. But it makes so much sense to do that. When
- 28:37it really comes up is when they take the house
- 28:40or the piece of real property out of the trust
- 28:42to do a refi and they forget to put it back in.
- 28:46And that's when you're doing the Hegstead petition
- 28:48to have that piece of property not probated but
- 28:52just poured back over into the trust. Also be
- 28:57really careful to select the right fiduciaries.
- 29:00You want to make sure that that's done correctly.
- 29:03These days there are so many trust contests when
- 29:06you pick people that are fiduciaries that may
- 29:09not be welcomed by all beneficiaries and may
- 29:12fight and is probably, if you have a decent sized
- 29:15estate, pretty smart to pick a bank as a fiduciary.
- 29:20Next slide, please. All right, so be aware of
- 29:24these additional changes. Oh my gosh, there are
- 29:27so many. All right, the smallest state limits
- 29:29have increased, which is great. So it allows
- 29:33a petition to determine succession to real property
- 29:37when the primary residence is valued $750 ,000.
- 29:43Fabulous. That's going to potentially save years
- 29:46in court for those. I mean, in California, those
- 29:49are probably pretty smaller homes, or they're
- 29:51not necessarily in San Francisco or LA. But it's
- 29:56still going to be helpful. Excuse me. Heirs can
- 30:01also claim up to $184 ,500 in personal property
- 30:06via affidavit, and this amount is going to get
- 30:09adjusted every three years. So the total threshold
- 30:12is at this point $934 ,500, which may now qualify
- 30:18for a streamlined process if the home is under
- 30:23the $750 ,000 cap. It's progress, I will say
- 30:28that. Alright, so the transfer on death deeds,
- 30:34which is a pretty cool instrument in and of itself,
- 30:38because that wasn't always around, but the transfer
- 30:41on death deed has updated. And now the time frame
- 30:46for any conflicting documents like a new trust
- 30:49to override the transfer on death deed was reduced
- 30:53from 120 days to 60 days, which will hopefully
- 30:57reduce any long -term disputes about that. Transfer
- 31:02on death deeds is something I can't remember
- 31:05now exactly what year it came into effect, but
- 31:07it was long after I stopped practicing as an
- 31:10attorney. And it was always very frustrating
- 31:12to me when I had clients who really just wanted
- 31:16to leave their one piece of real estate and didn't
- 31:19want to do anything else, had no other property,
- 31:22and just wanted to be able to do that by deed
- 31:25and there was no vehicle to do that. All right,
- 31:32I think, is there another slide? Yeah, there's
- 31:36not, but I have so much more. So I forgot the
- 31:38slides on the tax issues, but I really want to
- 31:40get into those to some degree because I think
- 31:44they're very, very important and we have time
- 31:46to get into them and then we'll have time for
- 31:48some questions. Right. So the Tax Cut and Jobs
- 31:52Act of 2017 enacted some very sweeping changes
- 31:56to the taxation of vacation property, short -term
- 31:59rentals, that kind of a thing. And we know what
- 32:03those are. It made key changes, including reducing
- 32:06a cap on deductible mortgages, dealing with the
- 32:10state and local tax deductions. All of that has
- 32:15been, to some degree, codified or at least given
- 32:19additional time frame with the one big beautiful
- 32:22bill act that was signed into law last year and
- 32:27makes most of those tax cut and job acts provisions
- 32:30permanent. So this $750 ,000 cap on deductible
- 32:35mortgage acquisition debt for qualifying residents
- 32:39stays in effect. The $10 ,000 annual cap on state
- 32:44and local tax deductions actually was raised
- 32:47to $40 ,000 through 2029. But remember that in
- 32:53California, there is no cap. This is the federal
- 32:56issue. But be aware that there are a lot of provisions
- 33:02that were in 2017 that were supposed to sunset
- 33:06in 2025 that now have not, because of one big,
- 33:11beautiful bill act. I love that name. It doesn't
- 33:15come off the top. um so something to always make
- 33:18sure you think about something that came up well
- 33:22for me previously in in court was the 1031 exchange
- 33:30law. So the 1031 exchange law allows you to exchange
- 33:34like kind property, one rental for another, one
- 33:38commercial property for another, for example,
- 33:41and avoid paying taxes to some degree because
- 33:47of that. And so the 1031 exchange law permitted
- 33:52tax deferred exchanges both real and personal
- 33:55property for productive use in a trade or business
- 33:59or for investment. That has been modified. And
- 34:04now you have to actually have an exchange of
- 34:10actual real property to real property. So that's
- 34:15something to be aware of. Oh, yes, this is another
- 34:23one that recently came up for me as well. And
- 34:27that is that if you are the beneficiary or if
- 34:31you have a client that is the beneficiary of
- 34:33an inherited IRA, that must be distributed within
- 34:3810 years of the original account holder's death,
- 34:42known as the 10 -year rule. All right, so that's
- 34:47important to know because Very few people have,
- 34:50nobody has really their IRAs in a trust. And
- 34:55the IRAs name beneficiaries. And then when the
- 34:59person who's a holder of the IRA dies and the
- 35:03person inherits it, they have to distribute it
- 35:06fully within 10 years of the owner's death. Another
- 35:12thing I wanted to touch on with regard to vacation
- 35:15homes. Internal Revenue Code section 280A governs
- 35:24the deductibility of expenses for dwelling units
- 35:27used both personally and as rentals. So this
- 35:31gets really complicated. So if a taxpayer uses
- 35:35that dwelling, which is a vacation rental as
- 35:39a residence, and the personal use exceeds greater
- 35:43than 14 days or 10 % of the number of days it
- 35:47is rented, then It deals with whether the residence
- 35:53test is met and what's going to be tax deductible
- 35:57and what's not and what you can write off and
- 35:59what you can't. So just be really careful to
- 36:02look into Internal Revenue Code 288 if your clients
- 36:07have a vacation home. And I think I had one more,
- 36:13one big, beautiful bill act that I wanted to
- 36:15touch on. We talked about most of the issues.
- 36:23Yeah, I think we actually got the ones that I
- 36:25wanted to discuss. Let me see if I have anything
- 36:30else. I don't, so I know I have things in question
- 36:33and answer. Let me see. All right, so the question
- 36:38is under 15800, is a court order required to
- 36:42deem it irrevocable? I don't think that that's
- 36:46true. I don't think that the court order is required.
- 36:50I think that if there is a contest, then definitely
- 36:53you're going to have to do that. But I don't
- 36:55think 15800 requires the court to make an order
- 36:58to say that it's irrevocable at that point. Thank
- 37:02you for the question. Any other questions? Because
- 37:08I am rushing through and kind of rushed through
- 37:10and got through it pretty quickly. Incompetency
- 37:16well is sufficient then. Yes, absolutely. Again,
- 37:21unless and until somebody brings it to court,
- 37:22but you want a declaration of incompetency. And
- 37:26then if it's brought the court, you of course
- 37:27need to have the doctors. And usually it's two
- 37:31that will support that. You guys must have questions.
- 37:42I went through a whole lot really super quickly.
- 37:44I want to also reiterate that if I went too quickly
- 37:48on citing any of the cases or the statutes, to
- 37:52please make sure that you either text me, call
- 37:56me, email me. You have all my contact information.
- 38:01All right. So I've got one here. Since Hagerty,
- 38:05what is the most common drafting mistake you
- 38:08still see attorneys making with revocable trust
- 38:11amendment provisions? I didn't see a lot, to
- 38:15be honest with you on that. But generally, what
- 38:19they didn't do was they didn't state how the
- 38:23trust was to be amended in any specific manner.
- 38:27And so when there was a trust amendment, there
- 38:29were so frequently contests by beneficiaries
- 38:34and among trustees. I again just reiterate that
- 38:40when you do draft make sure that you specify
- 38:43exactly how the trust it can be revoked and whether
- 38:49or not it can be modified and if so how it's
- 38:52going to be modified. Of course it can be revoked
- 38:55but how and when the revocation can occur and
- 38:58how and when the modification can occur. All
- 39:02right, so Angela asks, under conservatorship
- 39:05is a petition for substituted judgment the best
- 39:09method of satisfying the intersection? Yes, I
- 39:13really liked the petitions for substituted judgment.
- 39:16I think that those do well. Again, you've got
- 39:20to show, of course, the person's under conservatorship.
- 39:25You've got to show that the person who is requesting
- 39:28to be the person you know, substitute judgment
- 39:32is the person that should be that person. I'm
- 39:35not saying that well, but you know what I mean.
- 39:37Yes, I love the petitions for substituted judgment.
- 39:40We saw quite a number of those. Joyce says the
- 39:43table of authorities is not in the material she
- 39:47got. Okay, I sent those. I can send them again.
- 39:51Several people are saying that. OK, on the other
- 39:54side, do you anticipate additional appellate
- 39:57litigation over what constitutes sufficient compliance
- 39:59with a trust specified amendment procedure? Probably
- 40:05not a lot. I think Hagerty lays down the law
- 40:08quite clearly. I think it was very funny. in
- 40:11the one case where they said, well, how about
- 40:13this written instrument that's unsigned? I think
- 40:17people are going to comply now with the Hagerty
- 40:19law. I think I have a lot more questions. Small
- 40:22estate affidavit didn't catch the figure. All
- 40:25right, it's $750 ,000 for the piece of real property
- 40:29and $180. I have it written down. $182 ,500,
- 40:35I think, for a personal property. if I recall,
- 40:42but yeah, $750 ,000 is the amount for real property
- 40:47and $184 ,500 for personal property for a total
- 40:51of $934 ,500. If the court grants conservatorship
- 40:57over a settler and names the conservator as trustee.
- 41:04Now income beneficiaries on the trust can ask
- 41:06the conservative trustee to make distributions.
- 41:09Depends on the terms of the trust. So that is
- 41:15a very good question. I can't answer that without
- 41:19looking at the trust to know for sure. Can a
- 41:22conservatee bring an order for a substituted
- 41:26judgment? It's usually the conservator, but the
- 41:33conservator usually acts through the conservator,
- 41:35so I don't know how that would happen. I've never
- 41:37seen that. Something to look into, however. Need
- 41:42a clarification as to how accounting duties shift
- 41:45to beneficiaries when the settler becomes incompetent.
- 41:48Right, so that was in, let me go back to that,
- 41:5415800, if I recall. I might have to find that
- 42:03and email that to you. Cause that was bath a
- 42:10little ways. And my notes are like really crazy.
- 42:16Let me see if there's something else I can answer.
- 42:22Do I recommend leasing a property under a special
- 42:25needs trust for conservatorship? I can't say
- 42:30I recommend that. You've got to be really careful
- 42:39about the special needs trust, about any income
- 42:41and then dealing with the tax issues for your
- 42:44special needs trust. So I think that's something
- 42:46that needs to be answered by a special needs
- 42:49trust attorney and they're very specialized and
- 42:51I honestly cannot answer that one. I'm sorry.
- 42:55Have I started seeing petitions for reformation
- 42:57based on Packard, which are really contest petitions?
- 43:01I have not. But I just know that it's out there.
- 43:05And I think that that is a possibility that you
- 43:09need to know. In San Mateo County, where I practiced
- 43:13and where I was on the bench, I didn't see a
- 43:16whole lot of those. But it is available. And
- 43:21so I think it's good to know. As a former supervising
- 43:31probate judge, what filing argument or presentation
- 43:35issue consistently frustrated the court but could
- 43:38have easily been avoided? Well, we did a lot
- 43:43of interesting things in San Mateo County to
- 43:45avoid things. We did Hegstad Petition's ex parte,
- 43:50which is not what the code suggests, but we did
- 43:56it in order to keep our calendars moving quickly.
- 43:59I think a lot of the issues that were frustrating
- 44:03that could have been easily avoided were discovery
- 44:06issues. And that's true in just not in probate,
- 44:09but also in civil and family law. Discovery is
- 44:13difficult. It's the bane of everybody's existence.
- 44:16And if people could just have a nice conversation,
- 44:18it would be so helpful. What I did, and I would
- 44:22strongly suggest that if your judge will do that
- 44:25on your case to do it and if not try to do it
- 44:28on your own, I did a number of informal discovery
- 44:31conferences. And that is almost always without
- 44:35fail resolved all of the issues in a matter of
- 44:38a half hour, if not less. So that would answer
- 44:41that question. I really think that That issue
- 44:45is something that can be resolved if you just
- 44:47put a little bit of effort into it and you work
- 44:49well with the other side. Have I encountered
- 44:52AI generated briefs or declarations that raised
- 44:55concerns or what best practices would you recommend
- 44:58for attorneys using AI while maintaining their
- 45:01ethical duties? OK, that's like a question that's
- 45:03near and dear to my heart. I actually formed
- 45:07and then chaired the AI committee for the court
- 45:09for three years until I retired. I'm big into
- 45:13AI. I think that it is fine to use, and we actually
- 45:18put together a policy that it's a fine thing
- 45:21for attorneys to use AI in their briefs. They
- 45:24just have to comply with their ethics and duties
- 45:27as an attorney to not cite things that are hallucinations
- 45:31or incorrect citations to the court. So for me,
- 45:37AI doesn't raise any concerns. I know that I
- 45:40have colleagues on the bench who have had briefs
- 45:44filed that have had hallucinations within them
- 45:49and they have handled that in their own way.
- 45:52We of course have heard about the cases in New
- 45:54York and other jurisdictions where attorneys
- 45:57have been sanctioned. I will say that do not
- 46:01use open chat GPT or items like that. for your
- 46:07AI research, you will get things that are wrong.
- 46:10You will get hallucinations. And also if you
- 46:14put any information into that, it will be available
- 46:18to everybody under the sun. So you can't ever
- 46:20use your client's names or numbers or any personal
- 46:23identifying information or health information.
- 46:26But if you use a closed arena such as Westlaw
- 46:31or LexisNexis and you use their AI, which I do
- 46:36frequently, you can rely on what they have to
- 46:39say. It all comes within their arena of case
- 46:44law and statutes and it's usually spot on and
- 46:50if not, it leads you to where you need to go.
- 46:53So that is something that I am very supportive
- 46:57of. I think I got all of those. Warren raised
- 47:05his hand. Warren Worth. I don't think we can
- 47:16actually hear people. So I think that you need
- 47:19to put your question in the chat or in the Q
- 47:25&A. God, there's 21 now. There's probably a lot
- 47:28more. Majority of clients want the trust to remain
- 47:31revocable till the surviving spouse passes. Correct.
- 47:34Are there any restrictions on that under the
- 47:37probate code? Not that I know of. Absolutely
- 47:39not. Almost every trust for two spouses says
- 47:44exactly that. Initially, the settlers are the
- 47:49two spouses when one spouse dies, then the other
- 47:52spouse is still the settler. Both of them were
- 47:54initially the trustees. When one spouse dies,
- 47:57the remaining spouse is the trustee. And not
- 48:00until the second spouse passes away is there
- 48:04actually a distribution generally. And that's
- 48:08done by whoever is named the next trustee. Under
- 48:12the big, beautiful bill, is there a rule that
- 48:14inherited IRAs be fully distributed, liquidated,
- 48:18or rolled over within 10 years? OK, so what happened?
- 48:21I mean, I did this personally with my mom's inherited
- 48:24IRA is that the inherited IRA has to be distributed.
- 48:28It got distributed to me with the distribution
- 48:32of all of the items in the estate. And then I,
- 48:36as the designated beneficiary, had an inherited
- 48:41IRA under my name inherited from my mother. It
- 48:44had to be liquidated. You can't just roll it.
- 48:49Well, I wonder if you can roll it over into your
- 48:51own IRA, thinking that probably is not valid.
- 48:55I liquidated it. I liquidated it within the 10
- 48:59years as was required and paid the taxes. And
- 49:03I think that's generally what they're looking
- 49:05for on that. AI is great, but only if you create
- 49:11your own GPT, which can be exhaustive to build.
- 49:14Absolutely true. Yeah, good luck with that. I
- 49:21wouldn't even attempt that. Is a consent to a
- 49:26notice of proposed action satisfactory to satisfy
- 49:29changes as to specificity under Hagerty? I would
- 49:37say generally yes. If you get a notice of consent
- 49:41as to proposed action from all people who are
- 49:45interested parties, so contingent beneficiaries,
- 49:48beneficiaries, and the and the trustees, then
- 49:55I think you're good. I don't think that any judge
- 50:01would say that flies in the face of Hagerty,
- 50:03but that's a really good question. That'd be
- 50:05something to see. Somebody is suggesting that
- 50:07the smallest state threshold is 208 .50. Thank
- 50:11you, because I know it was increasing. So I've
- 50:14had a couple people say that. I appreciate that.
- 50:16Thank you so much. Things change. We petition
- 50:27to determine succession to primary residence.
- 50:30How does the court determine whether a property
- 50:32was decedent's primary residence? Well, there's
- 50:34always evidence that's presented on that. Generally,
- 50:37there are people who will sign a declaration
- 50:39to that effect. If that person, if there are
- 50:44utility bills and that person's name from that
- 50:48location, that's usually helpful into making
- 50:50that determination. I haven't seen too many people
- 50:54actually contest that. People love to have those
- 51:00small estates just handled very quickly. So I
- 51:05don't think that would be a problem, but there's
- 51:07certainly a ways to prove that if it would ever
- 51:09come up. Can real estate be invested in a real
- 51:14estate investment trust? Interesting and 1031
- 51:18exchange under the new rules. That is a really
- 51:20good question. Martina. I do not know. It's supposed
- 51:25to be I feel like it's not because now the rule
- 51:28is it's got to be like property to like property.
- 51:31So I feel like it has to be real property to
- 51:35real property and a real estate investment trust.
- 51:37I'm not sure qualifies under the internal revenue
- 51:40code as real property, as it's a group of real
- 51:44properties that are held in an investment trust.
- 51:47Interesting. I don't know. That's something to
- 51:51definitely check into. Do I have any recommendations
- 51:58for attorneys related to PAC? It's seemingly
- 52:03very chilling as it relates to 16061 .7. Yeah,
- 52:07I don't, after the 128 day period has told. Yeah,
- 52:12that's a good question, Joseph, and I don't have
- 52:15any recommendations for that. And I did send
- 52:21the sites, Angela, and you should hopefully.
- 52:26Is the new law for petition to determine succession
- 52:29retroactive prior to the law change? I do not
- 52:32believe so. I believe it is just from the law
- 52:35change forward. um and the only thing that's
- 52:39going to change is the amounts for the real property
- 52:41and Kevin says no so thank you for answering
- 52:45that with me Kevin okay well if there's no other
- 52:52questions I'll hold out for just another couple
- 52:55minutes but it was a pleasure nice to um present
- 52:59to you all this afternoon you're welcome you're
- 53:02welcome and you got the table of authorities
- 53:05yep Received excellent. Thank you somebody for
- 53:08telling me that I'm glad it was informative.
- 53:11It was a lot to do in an hour. So I hope you
- 53:15know, it just gives you an idea of what you need
- 53:16to look forward to what you should consider very
- 53:20carefully and good luck with everything probates
- 53:24the best Love it Okay, Angela doesn't have the
- 53:30table of authority. She said help I can see it
- 53:32Angela. It's in the chat. It's the very Last
- 53:35thing in the chat. You're welcome, everybody.
- 53:43Angela, did you get it? If people are having
- 53:50issues, we can send them after the program as
- 53:53well. That's true. I just, she says she's still
- 53:56looking. Angela, there's a thing at the very
- 53:59bottom of your screen. where it says chat, and
- 54:03if you just click on that and scroll all the
- 54:04way to the bottom, it's the last thing in the
- 54:06chat. She might be on mobile. Yeah, that's true.
- 54:23Okay. Well, received. Yep. Excellent. Thank you,
- 54:31Marvin. OK, Angela got it. I feel better now.
- 54:34Thank you, everyone. Thank you, guys. You guys
- 54:37have a good one. Bye bye.