Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Challenges Facing Kentucky Schools
Transcript
- 0:05[♪♪]
- 0:10>> GOOD EVENING AND WELCOME TO
- 0:12KENTUCKY TONIGHT I'M RENEE SHAW
- 0:15THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: CHALLENGES
- 0:18FACING KENTUCKY SCHOOLS.
- 0:19TONIGHT WE'LL TALK ABOUT TEACHER
- 0:22SHORTAGES, TEACHER PAY, THE
- 0:23DEBATE OVER SCHOOL CHOICE AND
- 0:25NEWLY RELEASED GUIDANCE FROM THE
- 0:27KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
- 0:28ABOUT NEW LAWS AFFECTING
- 0:30SCHOOLS.
- 0:31IN PARTICULAR, SB150 WHICH
- 0:34INVOLVES TRANSGENDER YOUTH.
- 0:35TO DISCUSS THESE ISSUES AND
- 0:37OTHERS WE HAVE IN OUR STUDIO
- 0:43BRIGITTE BLOM
- 0:44PRESIDENT AND C.E.O. OF THE
- 0:45BRING CHARRED COMMITTEE FOR
- 0:45ACADEMIC EXCELLENCE.
- 0:48STATE REPRESENTATIVE JAMES
- 0:49TIPTON, CHAIR OF THE HOUSE
- 0:50EDUCATION COMMITTEE.
- 0:54RHONDA CALDWELL, EXECUTIVE
- 0:55DIRECTOR OF THE KENTUCKY
- 0:55ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
- 0:56ADMINISTRATORS.
- 1:00ANDREW VANDIVER, PRESIDENT OF
- 1:01EDCHOICE KENTUCKY.
- 1:04ERIC KENNEDY, DIRECTOR OF
- 1:04ADVOCACY AT THE KENTUCKY SCHOOL
- 1:05BOARDS ASSOCIATION.
- 1:12STATE REPRESENTATIVE TINA
- 1:13BOJANOWSKI, AN EDUCATOR WITH THE
- 1:14JEFFERSON COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 1:16SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS TONIGHT,
- 1:19SEND AN E-MAIL...
- 1:23OR USE THE WEB FORM.
- 1:26OR YOU MAY GIVE US A CALL AT...
- 1:31>> WELCOME TO ALL OF OUR GREFTS
- 1:33HERE IN LEXINGTON AND
- 1:35REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI IN OUR
- 1:37LOUISVILLE STUDIO.
- 1:39AMBITIOUS AGENDA BUT I WANT TO
- 1:40START WITH THE GUIDANCE RELEASED
- 1:42TODAY BY THE KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT
- 1:43OF EDUCATION AND I WILL GO TO
- 1:45YOU FIRST, ERIC ERIC, THE, ERIC
- 1:49KENNEDY, THE SBA HAS BEEN
- 1:52INVOLVED IN DEVELOPING MODEL
- 1:54POLICY.
- 1:56LET'S START WITH SENATE BILL 5
- 1:57THAT DEALS WITH MATERIAL THAT
- 1:59DEEMED HARMFUL TO MINORS.
- 2:01REMIND PEOPLE WHAT THAT IS
- 2:03NECESSARILY AND WHAT MODEL
- 2:05POLICIES ARE YOU GOING TO BE
- 2:06GIVING TO SCHOOL DISTRICTS?
- 2:07>> CERTAINLY, RENEE THANK YOU
- 2:09FOR HAVING US ON AND DISCUSSING
- 2:11CHALLENGES ON PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 2:13I THINK SENATE BILL 5 WAS ONE OF
- 2:15THE HANDFUL OF BILLS THAT PASSED
- 2:17THIS SESSION HAT HAD AN
- 2:19EMERGENCY CLAUSE WHICH MEANS IT
- 2:21TAKES EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.
- 2:22THE GUIDANCE FROM THE DEPARTMENT
- 2:24OF EDUCATION WHICH I'M WITH THE
- 2:25SCHOOL BOARDS ASSOCIATION NOT
- 2:27THE DEPARTMENT, THE GUIDANCE
- 2:29FOCUSED ON JUST THOSE BILLS.
- 2:30THERE ARE OTHERS LEFT TO COME
- 2:32BUT THE OTHERS ONES THAT HAD AN
- 2:36EMERGENCY CLAUSE ARE IN EFFECT.
- 2:38SENATE BILL 5 REQUIRES EVERY
- 2:40SCHOOL BOARD IN 171 DISTRICTS TO
- 2:43ADOPT A POLICY FOR PARENTS OF
- 2:45STUDENTS IN THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT
- 2:46TO APPEAL ANYTHING THAT THEY
- 2:48THINK IS HARMFUL TO CHILDREN.
- 2:49THAT IS A SPECIFICALLY DEFINED
- 2:51TERM IN THAT BILL.
- 2:53AND IT IS THINGS SUCH AS
- 2:54ANYTHING THAT THE PARENT OR
- 2:56GUARDIAN FEELS COULD BE I PEELED
- 3:00TO THE INTEREST, A LOT OF THINGS
- 3:03DEALING WITH HUMAN SEXUALITY
- 3:06CONCERNS AND IT IS NOT JUST
- 3:08CURRICULUM BUT BOOKS, MATERIALS
- 3:09IN THE SCHOOL, PROGRAMS LIKE A
- 3:11GUEST SPEAKER EVENTS, A FIELD
- 3:13TRIP POSSIBLY TO AN ART MUSEUM
- 3:15THAT MIGHT SEE SOMETHING THAT
- 3:16THE ART MUSEUM THAT A PARENT
- 3:18THINKS MIGHT BE IN THE
- 3:19DEFINITION OF HARMFUL TO
- 3:20CHILDREN.
- 3:20SO THE POLICY THE BILL REQUIRES
- 3:22LOCAL BOARDS TO ACOULDN'T A
- 3:24POLICY.
- 3:24ONE OF THE THINGS THEY DO TO
- 3:26HELP LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS WE HELP
- 3:28THEM CRAFT POLICIES.
- 3:30WE HAVE WORKED WITH THE
- 3:31DEPARTMENT TO CRAFT SORT OF AN
- 3:32APPEAL PROCESS THAT MEETS ALL
- 3:34THE PARAMETERS OF SENATE BILL 5.
- 3:36IT IS SIMILAR TO A LOT OF APPEAL
- 3:40POLICIES IN PLACE AND SOME HAVE
- 3:41BEEN FOR DECADES BUT THERE ARE
- 3:43SPECIFIC STEPS THAT ARE PART OF
- 3:45WHAT IS REQUIRED NOW.
- 3:47AND SO THE BILL ACTUALLY
- 3:48REQUIRED THE DEPARTMENT TO
- 3:49CREATE A MODEL POLICY BECAUSE WE
- 3:51KNEW THAT THEY DON'T TYPICALLY
- 3:53DO THAT.
- 3:54MOSTLY THE LOCAL BOARDS OFTEN DO
- 3:56THIS.
- 3:57WE REACHED OUT TO THEM AND THEY
- 3:59WERE GREAT TO WORK WITH.
- 4:00WE HAVE HAD ONE POLICY THAT IS
- 4:02THE DEPARTMENT'S AS WELL AS OURS
- 4:04THAT EVERYONE WILL PUSH OUT TO
- 4:06DISTRICTS, LOCAL BOARDS COULD
- 4:07NOT HAVE TO USE THAT EXACT
- 4:09POLICY THEY CAN CREATE THEIR
- 4:10OWN.
- 4:11BUT THAT IS ONE OF THE SEVERAL
- 4:12THINGS THAT CAME OUT TODAY THAT
- 4:14ALL 171 BOARDS WILL BE LOOKING
- 4:16AT SOON.
- 4:16>> I WANT TO ASK YOU
- 4:19REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI IS THE
- 4:21GUIDANCE CLEARER THAN THE LAW?
- 4:23DOES IT PROVIDE THE GAPS AS IT
- 4:24NEEDS TO?
- 4:26BECAUSE SOME PEOPLE WOULD SAY
- 4:28IT'S CONFUSING IN SOME WAY?
- 4:29>> I MEAN, I WOULD SAY THAT THE
- 4:32GUIDANCE IS AS CONFUSING AS THE
- 4:35LAW IN THAT WHO IS GOING TO
- 4:36DECIDE WHAT IS PAT AT THE
- 4:38PRESENT TIMELY OFFENSIVE?
- 4:39I MEAN IT'S THE SAME LANGUAGE.
- 4:42SO IT DOESN'T CLARIFY WHAT WOULD
- 4:46BE PATENTLY OFFENSIVE.
- 4:48SO IT DOES GO BACK AND REFERENCE
- 4:51THE SCHOOL BOARD ASSOCIATION
- 4:53MODEL POLICY, BUT YOU KNOW, THE
- 4:56PROBLEMS IN OTHER STATES ARE
- 4:58THAT CHILDREN'S BOOKS THAT HAVE
- 5:00NOTHING TO DO WITH LIKE
- 5:05INTERESTS ARE BEING BANNED AND
- 5:06WE DON'T WANT BOOKS ABOUT YOU
- 5:10KNOW, TWO PENGUINS TO BE PULLED
- 5:13OFF THE SHELVES.
- 5:14NO, I DON'T THINK THE GUIDANCE
- 5:16PROVIDES ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
- 5:19FURTHER THAN WHAT THE BILL DID.
- 5:20>> AS YOU COMMISSIONER JASON
- 5:23GLASS SETUP IN THE MESSAGE THAT
- 5:25HE SENT OUT TODAY ABOUT THIS
- 5:27GANS BEING RELEASED THAT IT SAYS
- 5:30MANY PIECES OF THIS LEGISLATION
- 5:33PARTICULARLY SENATE SB5, AND
- 5:38SB150, LEAVE LOTS OF UNKNOWNS
- 5:39HOW THE LAWS WILL BE ENACTED IN
- 5:41WILL SCHOOLS.
- 5:41WE AT KED DO NOT HAVE THE
- 5:44AUTHORITY TO ANSWER DIRECTLY
- 5:47DEFINITIVELY MANY OF THE
- 5:48QUESTIONS YOU HAVE ABOUT THE
- 5:48LAWS AND SEEK YOUR COUNSEL IN
- 5:51YOUR DISTRICTS.
- 5:51CAN YOU RESPOND TO THE
- 5:53COMMISSIONER'S RESPONSE?
- 5:54>> WELL, RENEE, I AM IN A BIT OF
- 5:58A DISADVANTAGE I HAVE NOT SEEN
- 5:59THE GUIDANCE YET.
- 6:00YOU SAID IT CAME OUT
- 6:01MIDAFTERNOON I WAS AWAY FROM MY
- 6:03COMPUTER WORKING ON MY FARM.
- 6:05I HAVE NOT SEEN THE GUIDANCE FOR
- 6:07THOSE COMMENTS.
- 6:09BUT I WILL PROBABLY TOMORROW
- 6:10LOOK AT THAT GUIDANCE AND I WILL
- 6:12HAVE A BETTER IDEA OF THE
- 6:14COMMENTS THAT WERE MADE.
- 6:16THAT ONE THING THAT I'VE TALKED
- 6:18TO I'VE NOT HEARD ANY ISSUE WITH
- 6:20THE DISTRICTS I REPRESENT.
- 6:22ONE OF THE DISTRICTS TOLD ME
- 6:23THEY GOT THEIR POLICY IN PLACE.
- 6:25THEY ARE READY TO GO.
- 6:27I READ AN ARTICLE LAST WEEK, I
- 6:30FORGET IF IT WAS THE HERALD OR
- 6:31THE COURIER AND THEY WERE
- 6:35QUOTING JIM FLYNN WITH THE
- 6:37KENTUCKY ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
- 6:38SUPERINTENDENTS AND THE COMMENT
- 6:39WAS SCHOOLS AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS
- 6:41THIS WILL BE A SEAMLESS
- 6:43TRANSITION.
- 6:43I DON'T SEE THIS BEING A
- 6:45DIFFICULT TRANSITION.
- 6:46I BELIEVE THAT A LOT OF THESE
- 6:48DECISIONS WILL BE MADE AT THE
- 6:49LOCAL LEVEL THE WAY THE LAW WAS
- 6:51INTENDED TO GIVE THE FINAL SAY
- 6:53TO THE LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD.
- 6:55AND IT'S GOING TO ALLOW PARENTS
- 6:57THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE INPUT
- 7:00AND SAY IN SOME OF THESE
- 7:03QUESTION ITEMS.
- 7:04I'VE TAKEN IT UPON MYSELF TO
- 7:07READ, GET MY HANDS ON AND READ
- 7:09SOME OF THE BOOKS THAT WERE
- 7:11LISTED THAT WERE TALKED ABOUT IN
- 7:13THE COMMITTEE HEARING IN THE
- 7:14HOUSE.
- 7:15I CAN UNDERSTAND WHY SOME
- 7:18PARENTS MIGHT CONSIDER THOSE
- 7:21OBJECTIONABLE ESPECIALLY
- 7:22DEPENDING ON THE AGE OF THE
- 7:23CHILD.
- 7:23THIS IS GOING TO GIVE THE POWER
- 7:24BACK TO THE PARENT AND IT'S
- 7:26GOING TO PROVIDE A CONSISTENT
- 7:28RESOLUTION PROCESS TO DEAL WITH
- 7:29THIS ISSUE STATE-WIDE.
- 7:30>> SO MS. CALDWELL, I WANT TO
- 7:34ASK YOU ABOUT FROM THE KENTUCKY
- 7:36ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL
- 7:37ADMINISTRATORS WE HEARD CHAIRMAN
- 7:39TIPTON TALK ABOUT THIS COULD BE
- 7:40A SEAMLESS OR EASY TRANSITION
- 7:42FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS IS THAT
- 7:43WHAT YOU ARE HEARING FROM
- 7:44ADMINISTRATORS WHO WERE
- 7:45CONCERNED ABOUT IMPLEMENTATION?
- 7:47>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 7:49AT THE CONVERSATION THAT WE HAVE
- 7:51AT KASA WITH OUR ADMINISTRATORS
- 7:54IS AROUND THE FACT THAT MOST OF
- 7:56WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IS
- 7:57ALREADY HAPPENING.
- 7:59FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF PARENTAL
- 8:03INPUT.
- 8:04ERIC HAS ALREADY REFERRED TO THE
- 8:06POLICIES THAT ARE DEVELOPED BY
- 8:08OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND OUR
- 8:09SCHOOL COMMUNITIES.
- 8:11AND IT'S EVERYDAY OPERATIONS.
- 8:15SO I BELIEVE SEAMLESS WILL BE
- 8:17THE OUTCOME AT THE END OF THE
- 8:18DAY.
- 8:18>> I WANT TO TALK ABOUT SB150.
- 8:21AND I DON'T WANT TO GO LINE
- 8:24BY-LINE THROUGH THESE
- 8:26RECOMMENDATIONS ORGANS POINTS.
- 8:29BUT THERE IS SOME CONCERN ABOUT
- 8:30SOME OF THE LANGUAGE
- 8:32PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO
- 8:34SECTION ONE, CREATES CONFUSION
- 8:36ABOUT THIS IS WHAT COMES FROM
- 8:39THE KDE, IT CREATES STUDENT
- 8:44PRIVACY, THE SCHOOLTHAL SHALL
- 8:46NOT ADOPT POLICIES WITH KEEPING
- 8:48STUDENT INFORMATION CONFIDENTIAL
- 8:50FROM PARENTS AND DISTRICTS ARE
- 8:53REMINDED UNDER THE FAMILY
- 8:54EDUCATIONAL RIGHTS AND PRIVACY
- 8:57ACT, THE DEFINITION OF A PARENT
- 8:58IN SB150 IS NOT THE SAME AS THE
- 9:01DEFINITION OF PARENT IN FER PA.
- 9:04AND TO THE EXTENT THERE'S
- 9:07CONFLICT BETWEEN SB150 AND FER
- 9:09PA DISTRICTS SHOULD COMMON BY
- 9:11WITH FER PA.
- 9:12WRITE THAT DOWN FOR US Mr.
- 9:14KENNEDY.
- 9:15>> ACTUALLY, THE CRUX OF WHAT
- 9:16YOU EXPLAINED WHICH IS COMING
- 9:18FROM KDE IN THE GUIDANCE ALSO IS
- 9:20NOT NEW.
- 9:21WHAT THAT MEANS FER PA IS A
- 9:23FEDERAL LAW THAT I BELIEVE WAS
- 9:24PASSED IN 1974 SO IT'S BEEN
- 9:27AROUND A LONGTIME.
- 9:28ALL DISTRICT LEADERS ARE WELL
- 9:30AWARE OF IT.
- 9:31IT GIVES PARENTS AND FAMILIES
- 9:32CERTAIN RIGHTS UNDER FEDERAL
- 9:33LAW.
- 9:35AN ANNUAL NOTICE HAS TO GO OUT
- 9:37TO ALL PARENTS EVERY YEAR IN
- 9:39EVERY PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT
- 9:40WHAT THE FER PA RIGHTS ARE.
- 9:42THAT IS SOMETHING WE'RE USED TO.
- 9:44THEY ARE EXPLAINING NOW THERE
- 9:45ARE PRIVACY RIGHTS IN A NEW
- 9:48STATE STATUTE THAT MAY OVERLAP
- 9:50SOMETIMES COULD POSSIBLY
- 9:52CONFLICT, SOMETIMES THEY COULD
- 9:53GO ALONG WITH WHAT WE SEE IN FER
- 9:55PA THAT WILL BE A COMMON ISSUE
- 9:57BETWEEN A FEDERAL LAW AND A
- 9:58STATE LAW AND TRYING TO
- 9:59DETERMINE AT THE LOCAL LEVEL IF
- 10:01THEY SAY THE SAME THING.
- 10:02>> AND WHICH ONE AFLIES?
- 10:04>> IN THE SENSE THEY BOTH WILL
- 10:07APPLY.
- 10:07SO WHEN YOU HAVE A STATE LAW AND
- 10:09A FEDERAL LAW NO MATTER WHAT THE
- 10:10SUBJECT MATTER IS AND THEY BOTH
- 10:12APPLY WHERE THERE IS A DIRECT
- 10:15CONFLICT, ALMOST ALWAYS THE
- 10:16FEDERAL LAW IS SUPREME OVER
- 10:18STATE LAW WHICH, OF COURSE, IS A
- 10:20FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE.
- 10:22>> THERE'S SOME CONCERN ABOUT
- 10:24MENTIONS DEPENDENT, EXCEPTIONS
- 10:27EXIST FOR STUDENTS CONSIDERED
- 10:29DEPENDENT AS DEFINED IN SECTION
- 10:31152 IN THE INTERNAL REVENUE
- 10:34CODE.
- 10:35>> IT'S LOOKING INTO AGE AND
- 10:37OFTEN WE NEED TO REMIND
- 10:38SOMETIMES PARENTS AND IN THE
- 10:40COMMUNITY A LOT OF PRIVACY
- 10:42RIGHTS EXIST.
- 10:42WE WERE DISCUSSING THIS AT KSBA
- 10:46RECENTLY AND UNDER FER PA
- 10:48PARENTS HAVE MOST OF THE RIGHTS
- 10:49TO ACCESS TO EDUCATIONAL RECORDS
- 10:51UNTIL THE STUDENT TURNS 18.
- 10:53AND THEN BECOMES AN ADULT.
- 10:55THEN ALL OF THOSE RIGHTS TO
- 10:57ACCESS THE STUDENTS RECORDS GO
- 10:58TO THE STUDENT WHO IS NOW AN
- 11:00ADULT TO ACCESS THEIR OWN
- 11:02RECORDS.
- 11:03THAT MIGHT BE ONE OF THE AREAS
- 11:04WHERE THERE MIGHT BE CONFLICT.
- 11:05>> SB150 DID NOT MAKE THAT
- 11:09DISTINCTION?
- 11:09>> YOU COULD HAVE CASES WHERE
- 11:11THE STATE LAW GIVES A PARENT
- 11:14CERTAIN RIGHTS TO ACCESS CERTAIN
- 11:16RECORDS THAT THE UNDER THE
- 11:17FEDERAL LAW, WE ARE ALL USED TO
- 11:19THINKING ALL OF THOSE RIGHTS
- 11:21HAVE MOVED TO JUST THE STUDENT.
- 11:23AND SO THAT COULD BE A REAL
- 11:25TRAINING POINT.
- 11:25LEGAL TRAINING, LEGAL
- 11:27INFORMATION, HELPING DISTRICT
- 11:29LEADERS WHETHER THEIR SCHOOL
- 11:31BOARD MEMBERS ARE ADMINISTRATORS
- 11:32AND THE COMMUNITY AT LARGE AND
- 11:33PARENTS UNDERSTAND THIS.
- 11:35ONE OF THE REAL CHALLENGES
- 11:37FACING EDUCATION AFTER THE END
- 11:38OF EVERY SESSION IS GOING
- 11:39THROUGH ALL OF THE CHANGED LAWS
- 11:41AND GETTING GOOD GUIDANCE
- 11:43TOGETHER AND GETTING EVERYONE
- 11:44AWARE OF IT.
- 11:45>> REPRESENTATIVE TIPTON DO YOU
- 11:48HAVE ANYTHING TO COMMENT?
- 11:50I KNOW YOU HAVE NOT SEEN THE
- 11:52GUIDANCE BUT I READ THE CRUX OF
- 11:53WHAT THAT PROVISION APPLIES TO
- 11:56SECTION ONE OF SB150.
- 11:59FROM WHAT YOU'VE HEARD WHAT IS
- 12:01YOUR ASSESSMENT?
- 12:02>> WELL, OBVIOUSLY AGAIN I HAVE
- 12:03NOT READ THE GUIDANCE.
- 12:05BUT IT'S NOT UNCOMMON WHEN A
- 12:06PIECE OF LEGISLATION IS PASSED,
- 12:09THAT ISSUES RISE AND QUESTIONS
- 12:11COME UP AFTER THE FACT AFTER THE
- 12:13SESSION IS OVER WITH.
- 12:14THAT IS VERY COMMON.
- 12:15IT HAPPENS QUITE A BIT.
- 12:17AND IF THERE ARE ISSUES IF THERE
- 12:18ARE CONCERNS, I THINK THE
- 12:21GENERAL ASSEMBLY WOULD BE MORE
- 12:23THAN HAPPY TO LOOK AT THOSE
- 12:24CONCERNS AND TRY TO WORK THOSE
- 12:27OUT AND ADDRESS IT IN THE 2024
- 12:29SESSION.
- 12:30>> THERE IS A QUESTION WHY
- 12:31DIDN'T THE ASSEMBLY DO THAT
- 12:33DURING THE 30-DAY SESSION THEY
- 12:36HAD IT WAS LEGISLATION THAT
- 12:39OCCUPIED A LOT OF TIME.
- 12:41WHY WEREN'T THE WRINKLES WORKED
- 12:43OUT?
- 12:43>> FROM MY PERSPECTIVE ON THE
- 12:45HOUSE NOBODY BROUGHT THAT ISSUE
- 12:47TO MY ATTENTION.
- 12:48IT WAS NOT BROUGHT UP AT ALL.
- 12:50THIS LEGISLATION THE SECTION YOU
- 12:53ARE TALKING ABOUT WAS PART OF
- 12:54THE ORIGINAL SENATE BILL 150
- 12:56DRAFTED IN THE SENATE.
- 12:58OBVIOUSLY I WAS NOT PART OF THAT
- 12:59DISCUSSION.
- 13:00I WAS NOT PART OF THOSE
- 13:03DISCUSSIONS BACK AND FORTH ON
- 13:04THAT.
- 13:05I WOULD HOPE IN THE FUTURE THAT
- 13:07IF THERE ARE ISSUES THAT PEOPLE
- 13:09STAKEHOLDERS HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
- 13:10THEY WILL ADDRESS THOSE.
- 13:11>> REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI IS
- 13:13THAT A CONCERN THAT YOU HAD AND
- 13:15DID YOU BRING IT FORTH?
- 13:16>> NO, I DID NOT HAVE A CONCERN
- 13:20ABOUT THE FER PA.
- 13:22BUT WHATDY WANT TO BRING TO
- 13:25ATTENTION WAS SOMETHING IN THE
- 13:28KDE GUIDANCE WHERE IT SAYS SMALL
- 13:31BILL IS IN CONFLICT OF THE COURT
- 13:34OF APPEALS 6TH CIRCUIT THAT SAYS
- 13:37GENDER NOT CONFORMSY DEFINED IN
- 13:41SMITH VERSUS SALEM IS A FAILURE
- 13:43TO ACT OR IDENTIFY WITH HIS OR
- 13:46HER GENDER.
- 13:48SEX STEREOTYPING, IS
- 13:51IMPERMISSIBLE DISCRIMINATION.
- 13:53SO I THINK WE HAVE A CONFLICT
- 13:55BETWEEN WHAT THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
- 13:58COURT OF APPEALS ALREADY RULED
- 14:01THAT IS APPLIES TO KENTUCKY.
- 14:03AND THEN ALSO I WANT TO BRING TO
- 14:06ATTENTION A VERY RECENT RULING
- 14:08OF THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT COURT OF
- 14:11APPEALS THAT STATED THAT A
- 14:12TEACHER WHO WAS FIRED FOR
- 14:14REFUSING TO USE TRANS STUDENT
- 14:17PRONOUNCE THE COURT FOUND FOR
- 14:19THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AND IT SAID
- 14:20THAT THE ACCOMMODATION WAS AN
- 14:24UNDUE BURDEN FOR THE SCHOOL'S
- 14:27EDUCATIONAL MISSION BY HARMING
- 14:29TRANSGENDER STUDENTS AND
- 14:31NEGATIVELY IMPACTING THE
- 14:32LEARNING ENVIRONMENT FOR
- 14:34TRANSGENDER STUDENTS.
- 14:36SO WHAT I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO
- 14:39SEEING IS HOW THIS PLAYS OUT IN
- 14:41THE COURT SYSTEM.
- 14:43AND THEN WHAT ALSO COMPLICATES
- 14:45THE MATTER FOR THE BILL'S
- 14:46SPONSOR IS THAT THIS BILL DIDN'T
- 14:50HAVE A SEVERALLABILITY CLAUSE SO
- 14:52IF ONE PART OF THE BILL IS FOUND
- 14:55UNCONSTITUTIONAL, THAT THAT
- 14:57WOULD MEAN THAT THE ENTIRE BILL
- 15:00WOULD BE OUT OF ORDER.
- 15:02>> CHAIRMAN TIPTON DO YOU AGREE
- 15:04WITH THAT ASSESSMENT?
- 15:05THERE IS NO SEVERABILITY CLAUSE
- 15:07AND THERE WAS A MOTION I BELIEVE
- 15:09MADE BY A HOUSE DEMOCRATIC
- 15:10LEADER ABOUT THE NUMBER OF
- 15:13CONTENT MATERIALS THAT WERE
- 15:14INCLUDED IN THIS KIND OF OMNIBUS
- 15:16MEASURE THAT IT ADDRESSED
- 15:17DIFFERENT PARTS.
- 15:18PARENTAL RIGHTS AND
- 15:20SUCH-AND-SUCH THAT THAT NEEDED
- 15:21TO BE DIVIDED INTO SEVERAL
- 15:22PIECES OF LEGISLATION.
- 15:24BUT IT WAS COMBINED.
- 15:25CAN YOU SPEAK TO THAT?
- 15:27>> OBVIOUSLY THAT WAS A MOTION
- 15:28THAT WAS MADE ON THE FLOOR OF
- 15:30THE HOUSE.
- 15:31IT DID NOT PASS.
- 15:32THERE WAS A TITLE AMENDMENT TO
- 15:35THE LEGISLATION AND THE TITLE
- 15:38AMENDMENT WAS THAT IT IS AN ACT
- 15:40RELATING TO CHILDREN.
- 15:42ORIGINALLY WAS AN ACT RELATING
- 15:44TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS THAT TITLE WAS
- 15:46BROADENED.
- 15:48AGAIN, THE LEGISLATURE ACTS.
- 15:50WE MAKE LAWS.
- 15:52PEOPLE HAVE THE RIGHT TO APPEAL
- 15:53THOSE DECISIONS.
- 15:54IT HAPPENS ALL THE TIME.
- 15:57VERY, VERY COMMON.
- 15:59THE COHORT ALSO MAKE THEIR
- 16:01DECISIONS ON THIS.
- 16:03REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI
- 16:05MENTIONED THINGS FROM TWO
- 16:06CIRCUITS.
- 16:07I WOULD NOT BE SURPRISED IF
- 16:09THESE ISSUES WINDUP AT THE U.S.
- 16:12SUPREME COURT FOR A DECISION AND
- 16:13WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS.
- 16:14>> IN THE MEANTIME DOES THAT
- 16:16LEAVE IT IN FLUX FOR SCHOOL
- 16:17DISTRICTS TO DECIDE WHAT DO THEY
- 16:19DO?
- 16:21DO THEY GO WITH THE GUIDANCE AND
- 16:23WHATEVER HAPPENS IN THE COURTS
- 16:24THEN THEY WILL READJUST ONCE
- 16:26THAT DECISION IS MADE, IS THAT
- 16:27CORRECT?
- 16:27>> I THINK THAT IS CORRECT.
- 16:29THAT ON THIS ISSUE OF THE RIGHTS
- 16:31OF STUDENTS WHO ARE TRANSGENDER
- 16:33IS WHERE WE HAVE BEEN NOW FOR
- 16:35YEARS.
- 16:35IN TERMS OF THIS ISSUE HAS BEEN
- 16:37IN FEDERAL COURTS, ALL ACROSS
- 16:39THE COUNTRY AND PROBABLY EVERY
- 16:42CIRCUIT.
- 16:42SEVERAL DECISIONS DEALING WITH
- 16:44RIGHTS ESPECIALLY IN THE
- 16:45WORKPLACE OF ADULTS NOT
- 16:47NECESSARILY STUDENTS IN SCHOOLS
- 16:48HAVE GOTTEN ALL THE WAY TO THE
- 16:50U.S. SUPREME COURT.
- 16:51SO WE HAVE BEEN IN A STATE FOR
- 16:53SEVERAL YEARS IN TERMS OF US
- 16:55GIVING GUIDANCE TO SCHOOL
- 16:56LEADERS.
- 16:57IT HAS BEEN CAUGHT UP IN
- 16:59LITIGATION AND CHANGING
- 17:00SOMETIMES RAPIDLY WITH NEW
- 17:02FEDERAL REGULATIONS COMING
- 17:04ON-LINE OR BEING RESENDED.
- 17:06THAT IS NOTHING NEW ON THE
- 17:08SITUATION.
- 17:08MOVING FORWARD YOU WILL TRY TO
- 17:10IMPLEMENT EVERY LAW THAT IS IN
- 17:11EFFECT.
- 17:12SO YOU WILL TRY TO IMPLEMENT THE
- 17:13STATE LAWS THAT BECOME EFFECTIVE
- 17:15AND UNLESS THERE IS A CONFLICT
- 17:17WITH A FEDERAL LAW OR A NEW
- 17:19INTERPRETATION FROM A COURT THAT
- 17:20IS BINDING COMES OUT.
- 17:22AND ALWAYS RESPONDING TO THAT AS
- 17:24QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.
- 17:25WHETHER IT IS A COURT ORDER, A
- 17:27MANDATE FROM A COURT OR A NEW
- 17:30INTERPRETATION IS SOMETHING
- 17:31WE'VE ALREADY BEEN USED TO DOING
- 17:32ON THIS ISSUE AND LOTS OF
- 17:34EDUCATION ISSUES.
- 17:35>> Dr. CALDWELL IS THIS
- 17:37SOMETHING THAT SCHOOL
- 17:38ADMINISTRATORS WANTED WHETHER
- 17:39THAT IS SB5 OR SB150 WERE YOU
- 17:42HEARING A CALL FOR THESE TYPES
- 17:44OF PIECES OF LEGISLATION TO
- 17:46BECOME LAW?
- 17:48>> NO.
- 17:52THE CONVERSATION AMONG SCHOOL
- 17:55ADMINISTRATORS IS ONE OF THESE
- 17:57ARE THINGS WE HAVE ALREADY BEEN
- 17:59TAKING CARE OF FOR A LONGTIME.
- 18:01POLICIES, PROCEDURES, GUIDE US
- 18:03CURRENTLY.
- 18:07AND FOR MANY IT IS A DISTRACTION
- 18:10IN TERMS OF WHAT REALLY NEEDS TO
- 18:12BE TAKING PLACE AND THAT RIGHT
- 18:15NOW SOCIETY IS IN SUCH A FRAGILE
- 18:17PLACE WHEN IT COMES TO TAKING
- 18:18CARE OF OUR CHILDREN AND OUR
- 18:21FAMILIES, AND THINGS LIKE THIS
- 18:22BECOME A DISTRACTION FROM THE
- 18:25HOME FRONT FROM THE SCHOOL
- 18:28FRONT.
- 18:28AND THEY DON'T NECESSARILY
- 18:30REALLY GIVE US WHAT WE NEED IN
- 18:32TERMS OF DIGGING OUR HEELS IN
- 18:34AND BEING FOCUSED ON THE BIGGER
- 18:37PROBLEM SUCH AS TEACHER
- 18:40SHORTAGES, EDUCATOR SHORTAGES
- 18:42WITH OUR CLASSIFIED STAFF.
- 18:44SO MANY ISSUES AT HAND.
- 18:47BUT WE FOCUSED OUR ATTENTION FOR
- 18:49A WHILE ON SOMETHING THAT WE
- 18:51BELIEVE STRONGLY IS BEING
- 18:52ADDRESSED IN TERMS OF STAYING
- 18:54FOCUSED ON CHILDREN AND TAKING
- 18:56CARE OF THEIR DAILY NEEDS.
- 18:58>> UNLESS REPRESENTATIVE
- 18:59BOJANOWSKI HAS MORE SHE CARES TO
- 19:01ADD ABOUT THE GUIDANCE FROM THE
- 19:03KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
- 19:04WE'LL SEGUE TO TALK ABOUT THOSE
- 19:06ISSUES Dr. CALDWELL MENTIONED.
- 19:08REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI DO YOU
- 19:09HAVE FINAL WORD ON THIS BEFORE
- 19:11WE MOVE ON?
- 19:13>> I MEAN, I FEEL LIKE SENATE
- 19:15BILL 150 WAS THE MOST EXTREME
- 19:19ANTI-TRANS BILL IN THE NATION.
- 19:20IT WAS THE WORST DON'T SAY GAY
- 19:23BILL THAN FLORIDA AND IT WAS A
- 19:25POLITICAL BILL AND IT WAS NOT
- 19:27JUST FOLLOWING WHAT Dr.
- 19:28CALDWELL SAID, IT WAS NOT
- 19:30SOMETHING THAT IS GOING TO HELP
- 19:32PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 19:33>> ALL RIGHT.
- 19:34SO WE WILL PUT A PIN IN THAT FOR
- 19:36THE TIME BEING.
- 19:37WE WILL REVISIT THIS DISCUSSION.
- 19:40TALK ABOUT THE ISSUES WE SET OUT
- 19:42TO MAKE THE FOCUS OF TONIGHT'S
- 19:44DISCUSSION AND THAT INVOLVES
- 19:46EDUCATOR SHORTAGES ACROSS THE
- 19:48BOARD, TEACHER PAY, SCHOOL
- 19:50CHOICE.
- 19:50YOU HAVE TWO CHOICES WHO YOU
- 19:52HAVE NOT HEARD FROM YET ON THE
- 19:54SHOW SO FAR AND THAT IS BECAUSE
- 19:55THEY HAVE NOT HAD A STAKE INTO
- 19:57THE ISSUE WE DISCUSSED.
- 19:59LET'S TALK ABOUT SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 20:01WE'VE HEARD A LOT FROM
- 20:02LEGISLATIVE LEADERS THIS IS
- 20:04GOING TO BE SOMETHING THAT THEY
- 20:05WILL TAKE UP IN 2024 THAT IS A
- 20:08BUDGET YEAR.
- 20:09SO THE CONVERSATION AND THE
- 20:10CHARGE YOU WILL LEAD Mr.
- 20:13VANDIVER WHEN IT COMES TO SCHOOL
- 20:14CHOICE IS A LONGTIME ADVOCATE AS
- 20:17AN OPTION FOR PARENTS.
- 20:18>> ON THAT WE FINISHED TALKING
- 20:19ABOUT THE TRANSGENDER ISSUES
- 20:21THAT ARE CONTROVERSIAL WE CAN
- 20:23BRING EVERYBODY TOGETHER AROUND
- 20:25SCHOOL CHOICE BECAUSE THAT IS
- 20:26NOT CONTROVERSIAL AT ALL.
- 20:28EDUCATIONAL CHOICE IS A LONGTIME
- 20:30COMING IN KENTUCKY IT'S BEEN
- 20:31WORKED ON FOR DECADES.
- 20:32AND IN THE SUPREME COURT STRUCK
- 20:34DOWN THE EDUCATION OPPORTUNITY
- 20:36ACCOUNT ACT LAST YEAR.
- 20:38WE KNEW WE WOULD HAVE TO MOVE
- 20:40FOR A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.
- 20:42A LOT HAS CHANGED IN EDUCATION
- 20:43IN THE LAST THREE YEARS.
- 20:4520,000 NEW STUDENTS MOVED INTO
- 20:47NONPUBLIC SCHOOLS THAT PUTS THE
- 20:49POPULATION UP TO 100,000 KIDS IN
- 20:51OUR STATE.
- 20:51THAT IS SIGNIFICANT.
- 20:52AND I THINK WE LOOK AT THE PANEL
- 20:54WE ARE GOING TO AGREE YOU HAVE
- 20:56TO GET BEHIND PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 20:58STUDENTS.
- 20:58WE ARE REPRESENTATIVE TIPTON AND
- 21:00I DIFFER FROM THE FOLKS ON THE
- 21:01PANEL WE BELIEVE YOU SHOULD BE
- 21:04SUPPORTING NONPUBLIC SCHOOL
- 21:05STUDENTS BECAUSE THEY NEED A
- 21:06DIFFERENT LEARNING OPTION.
- 21:08AND THE 100,000 KIDS CHOOSING
- 21:11NONPUBLIC SCHOOLS SOME OF THE
- 21:12FAMILIES CAN DO THAT WITHOUT ANY
- 21:15FINANCIAL HARDSHIP.
- 21:16MOST HAVE TO MAKE SACRIFICES TO
- 21:19MAKE THAT CHOICE AND TOO MANY
- 21:20ARE LEFT OUT ALTOGETHER.
- 21:21>> I WANT TO GO TO YOU MS. BLOM,
- 21:25WHAT IS HAPPENING IN OUR
- 21:27TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS WHERE
- 21:29PARENTS ARE FLEEING THAT OPTION
- 21:30AND SEEKING ALTERNATIVES FOR
- 21:33THEIR CHILDREN?
- 21:34>> PARENTS ARE IN FACT NOT
- 21:37FLEEING PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 21:37WE HAVE 4% OF THE STUDENT
- 21:39POPULATION THAT IS ACCESSING
- 21:41PRIVATE OR HOME SCHOOLING
- 21:43OPTIONS.
- 21:44SO WHILE THERE MIGHT BE LARGER
- 21:45NUMBERS IN SOME OF OUR URBAN
- 21:48AREAS STATE-WIDE WE ARE NOT
- 21:50SEEING THIS EXODUS FROM PUBLIC
- 21:51EDUCATION.
- 21:52SO THAT WOULD BE THE FIRST
- 21:53POINT.
- 21:54THE SECOND IS, CHOICES IS AN
- 21:57IMPORTANT THING FOR A PARENT TO
- 21:59EXERCISE WITHOUT A DOUBT.
- 22:00FROM A PUBLIC INVESTMENT
- 22:02STANDPOINT WE HAVE TO LOOK AT
- 22:03THE RETURN ON INVESTMENT FOR OUR
- 22:06COLLECTION OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS
- 22:09INTO EDUCATION AS A PUBLIC GOOD.
- 22:10AND THE RESEARCH TO DATE DOES
- 22:12NOT SHOW THAT PRIVATE EDUCATION
- 22:14SHOWS A BETTER RETURN ON
- 22:16INVESTMENT THAN PUBLIC
- 22:17EDUCATION.
- 22:18SO FOR PUBLIC DOLLARS TO THEN BE
- 22:21UTILIZED FOR PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 22:22CHOICE DOESN'T MAKE SENSE FROM A
- 22:24PUBLIC POLICY STANDPOINT OR FROM
- 22:26A RETURN ON INVESTMENT
- 22:28STANDPOINT.
- 22:29IN ADDITION, THERE'S NO
- 22:30ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THOSE DOLLARS
- 22:31WHEN STUDENTS USE PUBLIC
- 22:34TAXPAYER DOLLARS TO GO TO
- 22:35PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 22:36THERE IS NO ACCOUNTABILITY FOR
- 22:37THOSE OUTCOMES.
- 22:39IN PUBLIC EDUCATION WE HAVE AN
- 22:41ACCOUNTABILITY MODEL WHICH
- 22:42DRIVES HOPEFULLY OUR EDUCATION
- 22:44OUTCOMES IN AN UPWARD
- 22:47TRAJECTORY.
- 22:47PRIVATE SCHOOL EDUCATION IS
- 22:49EXEMPT FROM THAT.
- 22:50SO WE HAVE A VARIETY OF CONCERNS
- 22:52WITH MOVING FROM A PUBLIC MODEL
- 22:54INTO PRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE
- 22:56UTILIZING TAX DOLLARS.
- 22:57>> CHAIRMAN TIPTON BEFORE I GET
- 23:00TO YOU REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI
- 23:01BECAUSE SHE HAS HER HAND RAISED
- 23:03TO SPEAK, I'M SURE YOU ARE PART
- 23:05OF THE CONVERSATIONS WHERE THIS
- 23:06IS A MOVEMENT THAT WILL HAVE
- 23:08FORCE BEHIND IT COME 2024 BUT
- 23:11ALSO THERE ARE IN THE GENERAL
- 23:12ASSEMBLY THOSE WHO REPRESENT
- 23:14TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND
- 23:15THAT IS THE LARGEST EMPLOYER IN
- 23:18THEIR COUNTIES AND DISTRICTS
- 23:19WHAT ARE YOU HEARING ABOUT THE
- 23:22TEMPERATURE FOR MOVING TOWARD A
- 23:23SCHOOL CHOICE MODEL AND PAYING
- 23:24FOR IT OUT OF THE EDUCATION
- 23:26PORTION OF THE STATE BUDGET?
- 23:28>> WELL AS ANDREW MENTIONED,
- 23:30WITH THE CURRENT COURT DECISION
- 23:32REALISTICALLY THE ONLY WAY THE
- 23:34COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY CAN
- 23:35MOVE IN THAT DIRECTION IS
- 23:39THROUGH A CONSTITUTIONAL
- 23:39AMENDMENT.
- 23:40AND I BELIEVE THAT WILL BE FILED
- 23:42AGAIN IN 2024 IT WAS HOUSE BILL
- 23:45174 THIS YEAR.
- 23:46AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT HAS
- 23:48A HIGHER STANDARD TO PASS BOTH
- 23:49THE HOUSE AND THE SENATE.
- 23:51SO WE WILL GAUGE THAT WHEN WE
- 23:52GET INTO THE 2024 SESSION.
- 23:54ONE COMMENT I WANT TO MAKE, IS
- 23:56I'VE BEEN DOING A LOT OF LOOKING
- 23:58AT SCHOOL GROWTH AND SCHOOL
- 24:00LOSS.
- 24:01AND FROM NOVEMBER OF 19 TO
- 24:05NOVEMBER OF 2022 WE HAVE SEEN A
- 24:08REDUCTION IN THE ADA NUMBERS OF
- 24:1139,000.
- 24:12ANDREW MENTIONED 20,000.
- 24:15WHERE ARE THE STUDENTS AT?
- 24:17SOME ARE BEING HOME SCHOOLED AND
- 24:18SOME MAYBE GOING TO PRIVATE
- 24:20SCHOOL SOME OF THEM THE SCHOOL
- 24:21DISTRICTS TELL ME THEY DON'T
- 24:24KNOW WHERE THOSE STUDENTS WOUND
- 24:25UP AT.
- 24:27WE'RE SEEING A REDUCTION IN
- 24:29NUMBERS OF PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 24:30STUDENTS.
- 24:30THAT IS A REALITY THAT PUBLIC
- 24:33SCHOOL DISTRICT ALSO HAVE TO
- 24:34FACE.
- 24:35THEY WILL HAVE TO ADJUST
- 24:36BUSINESS MODELS TO ADAPT TO
- 24:38THAT.
- 24:38AND ONE OF THE BIG ISSUES THAT
- 24:41WE HAVE NOT TALKED ABOUT YET
- 24:42THAT WE HAVE TO ADDRESS IN 2024
- 24:45IS CHRONIC ABSENTEEISM.
- 24:47WHEN A STUDENT MISSES 18 DAYS OR
- 24:49MORE.
- 24:49THE SUPERINTENDENT I TALKED TO
- 24:51HIM TWO OR THREE MONTHS AGO THEY
- 24:52HAVE A LARGE POPULATION AT JCPS
- 24:56IS CHRONICALLY ABSENT.
- 24:57TWO ISSUES THAT AFFECTS THE
- 24:59SCHOOL DISTRICTS' FUNDING AND
- 25:01MORE IMPORTANTLY, A CHILD CANNOT
- 25:03LEARN IF THEY ARE NOT IN SCHOOL.
- 25:05SO WE'VE GOT A LOT OF ISSUES TO
- 25:07ADDRESS.
- 25:08I MAY HAVE GOT OFF SCHOOL CHOICE
- 25:10A LITTLE BIT.
- 25:11BUT I THINK IT WILL BE A BIG
- 25:14PUSH AND ULTIMATELY IF IT PASSES
- 25:160 OUT OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY IT
- 25:17WILL BE UP TO THE VOTERS OF THE
- 25:19COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY IN
- 25:21NOVEMBER OF 2024 TO MAKE THAT
- 25:22DECISION TO ALLOW THAT FINANCE
- 25:24THEY DO APPROVE THAT
- 25:26CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT THEY
- 25:27WILL BE UP TO SUBSEQUENT GENERAL
- 25:29ASSEMBLIES TO MAKE THE DECISION
- 25:30HOW THEY MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT
- 25:32DECISION.
- 25:33>> THAT IS A CONVERSATION.
- 25:35I WANT TO GO BACK AVERAGE DAILY
- 25:38ATTENDANCE VERSUS AVERAGE DAILY
- 25:40MEMBERSHIP.
- 25:41I KNOW REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI
- 25:42IS CHOMPING AT THE BIT TO
- 25:44WEIGH-IN HERE.
- 25:45GO AHEAD, MA'AM.
- 25:46>> OK.
- 25:47YES, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
- 25:49THERE ARE TWO PRIMARY ISSUES
- 25:52THAT MAKE ME NOT SUPPORT ANY
- 25:54SORT OF SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM.
- 25:57NUMBER ONE IS THE ABILITY FOR
- 25:59THE PRIVATE RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS TO
- 26:01DISCRIMINATE.
- 26:02WE TRIED WITH HOUSE BILL 563 TO
- 26:04HAVE A CLAUSE THAT THEY COULD
- 26:06NOT DISCRIMINATE AND IT WAS
- 26:08VOTED DOWN.
- 26:08AND THEN THE SECOND ONE IT'S NOT
- 26:10THE PARENTS THAT PICK THE
- 26:12SCHOOLS.
- 26:12IT'S THE SCHOOLS THAT PICK THE
- 26:14CHILDREN.
- 26:14THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT YOUR
- 26:16CHILD WOULD BE ABLE TO GO TO
- 26:18WHATEVER SCHOOL YOU WANT THEM TO
- 26:19GO.
- 26:20IT IS THE SCHOOLS THAT SELECT
- 26:22THE CHILDREN AND EVEN IF THERE
- 26:24ARE VOUCHERS OR SORT OF SUPPORT
- 26:26FOR THE CHILDREN TO GO TO THE
- 26:27SCHOOL THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT
- 26:29THAT IF YOU MAKE A CERTAIN
- 26:31INCOME LEVEL THAT THE SCHOOLS
- 26:32WON'T CHARGE MORE MONEY AND YOU
- 26:34WOULD MAYBE BE OUT OF THE
- 26:36MARKET.
- 26:38SO ABILITY TO DISCRIMINATE AND
- 26:40THE SCHOOLS PICK THE CHILDREN.
- 26:41AS FAR AS CONSTITUTIONS, WE HAVE
- 26:43ONE OF THE STRONGEST
- 26:45CONSTITUTIONS IN THE NATION FOR
- 26:47PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 26:49AND WE HAVEN'T HAD THE GRANDEST
- 26:51LUCK AT CHANGING OUR
- 26:53CONSTITUTION IN THE LAST
- 26:54ELECTION OR TWO.
- 26:56WE COULD BARELY PASS IN SESSION
- 26:59WE COULD BARELY PASS HOUSE BILL
- 27:02563.
- 27:03THERE WAS PUSHBACK FROM THE
- 27:04RURAL LEGISLATORS AND THE URBAN
- 27:07LEGISLATORS.
- 27:08SO I REALLY I DON'T SEE --
- 27:11THERE MAY BE A LOT OF ENERGY FOR
- 27:13IT IN THE MAJORITY CAUCUS, BUT I
- 27:16DON'T SEE IT ACTUALLY HAPPENING.
- 27:18SO Mr. VANDIVER AND I MAY HAVE
- 27:21A STRONG DIFFERENCE OF OPINION
- 27:22ON THIS, BUT THESE SCHOOLS CAN
- 27:26DISCRIMINATE.
- 27:26AND THEY CAN PICK THEIR
- 27:28STUDENTS.
- 27:28AND IT MIGHT NOT BE YOUR CHILD
- 27:30AND IT MIGHT NOT BE MY CHILD
- 27:32WITH AUTISM, IT MIGHT NOT BE MY
- 27:34CHILDREN WHO INFIELD MY
- 27:35CLASSROOM RIGHT NOW.
- 27:37>> Mr. VANDIVER RESPOND TO
- 27:40REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI'S
- 27:42CONCERNS.
- 27:42>> A LOT IS BROUGHT UP AMONG THE
- 27:44PANEL AND THIS IS NOT NEW.
- 27:46SCHOOL CHOICE HAS BEEN AROUND
- 27:47FOR DECADES.
- 27:48AND I BROUGHT A MAP I USUALLY
- 27:51DON'T USES BUT THE --
- 27:55AIDS.
- 27:55WE ARE THE ONLY STATE IN THIS
- 27:57REGION WITHOUT A MEANINGFUL
- 27:59SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM AND OUR
- 28:01KIDS ARE NOT DOING BETTER.
- 28:02THE TESTING DATA FROM LAST YEAR
- 28:04BARELY HALF OF OUR KIDS CAN READ
- 28:07AT GRADE LEVEL BARELY A THIRD
- 28:09CAN DO MATH PROFICIENTLY.
- 28:12THOSE ARE SIGNIFICANT
- 28:13CHALLENGES.
- 28:13WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING
- 28:14DIFFERENT AND SUPPORT PUBLIC
- 28:16SCHOOL STUDENTS AND THE PUBLIC
- 28:18SCHOOLS ARE NOT GOING TO WORK
- 28:19FOR EVERY FAMILY.
- 28:20AND OUTCOMES, YOU LOOK AT
- 28:23FLORIDA, FLORIDA PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 28:25STUDENTS ARE OUTPERFORMING AND
- 28:27THEY HAVE MASSIVE SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 28:30HALF THE KIDS ARE AT SCHOOL
- 28:32CHOICE, PUBLIC, PRIVATE, CHARTER
- 28:34SOME FORM OF SCHOOL CHOICE OUR
- 28:37KIDS ARE BEING LEFT BEHIND OUR
- 28:38FAMILIES ARE BEING LEFT BEHIND.
- 28:40PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE A GREAT
- 28:42CHOICE FOR FAMILIES AND IT'S NOT
- 28:43THE ONLY CHOICE AND YOU █SHOULD
- 28:45NOT SEE A CHILD STRUGGLE.
- 28:47SPOONED TO THE CLAIMS OF
- 28:49DISCRIMINATION THERE IS A LOT
- 28:50THAT IS A CATCH ALL TERM.
- 28:52IN TERMS OF HEALTHY SCHOOL
- 28:55ENVIRONMENTS WE JUST FINISHED
- 28:56TALKING ABOUT THE TRANSGENDER
- 28:58ISSUE AND LGBTQ STUDENTS.
- 29:00AND THERE WAS A SURVEY CONDUCTED
- 29:02BY THE GAY, LEZ STUDENT
- 29:05EDUCATION NED WORK AND IF YOU
- 29:07LOOK INTO THE INDEX OF THAT
- 29:10SURVEY, IT SHOWS LOWER RATES OF
- 29:13BULLYING, VERBAL HARASSMENT AND
- 29:14THINGS LIKE THAT IN NONPUBLIC
- 29:16SCHOOLS.
- 29:17AND THIS IS SURVEYS FROM
- 29:19STUDENTS COMPARED TO THE PUBLIC
- 29:20SCHOOLS.
- 29:21THAT IS NOT TO SAY THAT THE
- 29:22PRIVATE SCHOOLS DO EVERYTHING
- 29:24PERFECT BUT THERE'S STEREOTYPING
- 29:27GOING ON WHEN THERE IS AN
- 29:29ASSUMPTION WE ARE UNWELCOMING.
- 29:31IT SHOULD BE UP TO THE PARENTS
- 29:32AND THE PARENTS CAN DETERMINE
- 29:33WHAT IS THE SAFEST MOST
- 29:35APPROPRIATE ENVIRONMENT FOR
- 29:36THEIR KIDS AND I TRUST PARENTS.
- 29:38>> Dr. CALDWELL THERE IS A
- 29:40POINT ABOUT TRADITIONAL PUBLIC
- 29:42SCHOOLS ARE NOT CUTTING IT.
- 29:43THERE ARE LITERACY RATES ARE
- 29:45BEHIND.
- 29:45THERE IS A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF
- 29:47LEARNING LOSS FROM COVID.
- 29:49AND ACCORDING TO Mr. VANDIVER
- 29:51IT SEEMS WHEN IT COMES TO
- 29:53BULLYING AND THE EMOTIONAL
- 29:55SUPPORTS PERHAPS IT'S BETTER IN
- 29:56THE PRIVATE SCHOOL ENVIRONMENTS.
- 29:58MAKE THE ARGUMENT AGAINST WHAT
- 29:59HE JUST HAD TO OFFER?
- 30:01>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 30:02FIRST OF ALL I WOULD LIKE TO
- 30:03REMIND EVERYONE HERE THAT OUR
- 30:06LEGISLATURE LAST YEAR GAVE US A
- 30:08LOT MORE SCHOOL CHOICE ACROSS
- 30:10THE STATE THAN WE'VE EVER HAD
- 30:12BEFORE.
- 30:12WITH WHAT WE REFER TO AS THE
- 30:15OPEN BOUNDARIES LAW.
- 30:17ANY CHILD IN KENTUCKY CAN CHOOSE
- 30:19ANY PUBLIC SCHOOL THAT THEY WANT
- 30:21TO HERE IN THE STATE OF
- 30:22KENTUCKY.
- 30:23AND SO WE'RE IN OUR FIRST YEAR
- 30:24OF THAT NEW LAW.
- 30:26AND WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR THAT.
- 30:27AND WE'RE WATCHING THAT
- 30:29SHAKEDOWN ALL OVER THE STATE FOR
- 30:31KIDS TO HAVE THOSE
- 30:33OPPORTUNITIES.
- 30:34ALSO, LET'S PUT OUR MINDS WRAP
- 30:36OUR MINDS AROUND COVID AND THE
- 30:38FACT THAT NOT ONLY ARE PUBLIC
- 30:41EDUCATION SYSTEM, OUR CHILDREN
- 30:42IN IT OUR FAMILIES IN IT, OUR
- 30:45EDUCATORS IN IT, EVERYONE
- 30:47CONNECTED, WE'RE LIKE ALL OF
- 30:49SOCIETY.
- 30:50AND EVERYONE IS IN RECOVERY
- 30:51MODE.
- 30:52SO TESTING DATA, WHATEVER
- 30:54MEASURING STICK THAT WE WANT TO
- 30:56LOOK AT IS PROBABLY NOT VERY
- 30:59REPRESENTATIVE OF WHAT IS
- 31:00ACTUALLY HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
- 31:03WHEN I LISTENED TO ALL OF THE
- 31:06NOISE AROUND ME IN TERMS OF WHAT
- 31:08IS RIGHT WITH PUBLIC SCHOOLS OR
- 31:10WHAT IS ONE MIGHT DEEM WRONG
- 31:12WITH PUBLIC SCHOOLS, WHAT I KNOW
- 31:14IS WHEN I LIFT THAT CURTAIN SO 0
- 31:17TO SPEAK THERE IS A SCHOOL OF
- 31:19TEACHERS AT WORK WHO ARE LIFTING
- 31:22UP CHILDREN EVERY SINGLE DAY.
- 31:23WHO ARE INCREDIBLY SUCCESSFUL.
- 31:26AT ALL LEVELS FROM PRESCHOOL ALL
- 31:28THE WAY TO HIGH SCHOOL.
- 31:29AND WE ARE MEETING EVERY SINGLE
- 31:31DAY SOME OF THE MOST AMAZING
- 31:33CHILDREN WHO ARE MOVING INTO
- 31:36ADULTHOOD.
- 31:37AND SOLVING SOME OF OUR MOST
- 31:39DIFFICULT CHALLENGES HERE IN THE
- 31:40NATION.
- 31:41AND SO I BELIEVE THAT WHEN WE
- 31:42PUT DOWN THE STATISTICS, THAT WE
- 31:44SHAPE FOR THE CONVERSATION WE
- 31:47WANT, THAT EVERYTHING CHANGES
- 31:48AND WE FIND THAT I BELIEVE THE
- 31:53GALLOP POLL DATA I WOULD POINT
- 31:55TO THAT OUR FAMILIES ARE HAPPY
- 31:57WITH THEIR SCHOOL SYSTEMS.
- 31:59THEIR LOCAL COMMUNITY SCHOOLS
- 32:01OUR CHILDREN ARE THRIVING AND
- 32:02THEY ARE HAPPY IN SPITE OF DATA
- 32:04THAT WE ARE LOOKING AT FROM A
- 32:07POST COVID PERSPECTIVE.
- 32:08>> Mr. KENNEDY YOUR THOUGHTS
- 32:09HERE?
- 32:10>> I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS
- 32:12THAT WE OFTEN THINK OF WHEN THIS
- 32:14COMES UP IS Mr. VANDIVER MAKES
- 32:16A GOOD POINT THAT SOME STATES 33
- 32:18YEARS AGO WHEN WE EMBARKED ON
- 32:22MASSIVE EDUCATION REFORM WE
- 32:23THREW EVERYTHING OUT AND STARTED
- 32:24FROM SCRATCH WITH PUBLIC
- 32:26EDUCATION.
- 32:26AND ALMOST THE SAME TIME SOME
- 32:28OTHER STATES TOOK IT THAT MOMENT
- 32:30OF THIS EDUCATION REFORM EFFORT
- 32:32TO GO A DIFFERENT ROUTE OF
- 32:34REFORMING INTO SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 32:36SOME STATES THAT HAVE HAD A LOT
- 32:38OF SCHOOL CHOICE, VOUCHERS,
- 32:43SCHOLARSHIP TAX CREDITS AND
- 32:44CHARTER SCHOOLS WHICH WE HAVE
- 32:46NOT SEEN IN KENTUCKY AND SOME
- 32:48STATES THEY HAVE HAD SO MUCH
- 32:49SCHOOL CHOICE FOR THE SAME
- 32:5233-YEAR PERIOD OF TIME, ALMOST
- 32:53THE SAME PERCENTAGE OF STUDENTS
- 32:55ARE IN TRADITIONAL PUBLIC
- 32:56SCHOOLS IN ALL FORMS OF
- 32:58NONPUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 32:59NATIONALLY IT'S 90-10.
- 33:0290% STUDENTS ARE IN TRADITIONAL
- 33:05PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 33:05SO I THINK THAT WHENEVER THIS
- 33:07ISSUE COMES UP AND IT WAS A
- 33:09GREAT OP-ED THAT MADE THE SAME
- 33:12POINT FROM A SCHOOL CHOICE
- 33:13ADVOCATE THAT SAID EVEN IF AN
- 33:15AMENDMENT IS PROPOSED AND
- 33:18RATIFFED THE BY THE VOTERS AND
- 33:20IF THERE IS A DAY WITH MORE
- 33:23PUBLIC FUNDING OF PRIVATE
- 33:25SCHOOLS YEARS FROM NOW IF IT IT
- 33:27HOLDS TRUE FOR US, MOST CHILDREN
- 33:29WILL BE ATTENDING SCHOOL BEING
- 33:31EDUCATED NURTURED AND CARED FOR
- 33:33IN TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 33:35WE WANT TO FOCUS AS WELL ON WHEN
- 33:37IT COMES TIME FOR THE STATE
- 33:38BUDGET WE, PUBLIC EDUCATION AND
- 33:40PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND OUR
- 33:42OPERATIONS ARE IN COMPETITION
- 33:43WITH FOR EVERY DOLLAR THAT THE
- 33:44STATE HAS TO SPEND AND INVEST.
- 33:46IT TAKES A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF
- 33:48MONEY TO RUN ANY KIND OF SCHOOL
- 33:50PUBLIC OR PRIVATE.
- 33:51WE ALWAYS WANT TO GUARD AGAINST
- 33:53THE IDEA THAT BASED ON ANY
- 33:55SURVEY AT ANY MOMENT IN TIME IF
- 33:57ANY GROUP OF PEOPLE THE ONE
- 33:58ANSWER IS TO MOVE IN THIS
- 34:00DIRECTION THAT COULD CAUSE MORE
- 34:02COMPETITION FOR PRECIOUS DOLLARS
- 34:03THAT WE NEED FOR A LOT OF
- 34:05IMPROVEMENT THAT WE KNOW WE
- 34:06NEED.
- 34:07ALL OF MY MEMBER ALSO TELL YOU
- 34:09SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS AND
- 34:10ADMINISTRATORS WILL SAY A LOT OF
- 34:12GREAT IS HAPPENING IN PUBLIC
- 34:13SCHOOLS AND THERE IS A LOT OF
- 34:14ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT IN MANY
- 34:16WAYS.
- 34:17>> I HAVE A POINT THAT I THINK
- 34:21MIGHT FIT WITH WHAT Mr.
- 34:22KENNEDY WAS TALKING B. I'M PRO
- 34:25PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 34:26I THINK WE HAVE GREAT PUBLIC
- 34:28SCHOOLS IN OUR STATE.
- 34:29WE HAVE SOME THAT COULD DO
- 34:30BETTER.
- 34:31IN TERMS OF SCHOOL CHOICE IT IS
- 34:32NOT JUST ABOUT THE KIDS WHO
- 34:34CHOOSE WHEN YOU SEE SCHOOL
- 34:35CHOICE THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS ARE
- 34:37DOING BETTER AND WE TALK ABOUT
- 34:39ACCOUNTABILITY.
- 34:41ACCOUNTABILITY LIES WITH THE
- 34:42PARENTS.
- 34:43I PROMISE THIS WILL BROADEN OUT
- 34:44TO THE LARGER TOPIC ABOUT THE
- 34:47BROADER CHALLENGES OF EDUCATION.
- 34:49WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE LEARNING
- 34:52LOSS DISCUSSED THAT WASN'T JUST
- 34:53A RESULT OF COVID IT WAS A
- 34:55RESULT OF SCHOOLS THAT LOCKED
- 34:56DOWN AND DIDN'T OPEN THEIR DOORS
- 34:58FOR A YEAR.
- 34:59IF EVERY CHILD WITHIN JCPS TO
- 35:02HAVE A CHOICE TO GO SOMEWHERE
- 35:03ELSE DO YOU THINK THEY WOULD
- 35:05HAVE KEPT THE SCHOOLS CLOSED AND
- 35:07NOT IN-PERSON LEARNING AND
- 35:09IMAGINE HOW THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN
- 35:10DIFFERENT.
- 35:12LITERACY, THERE'S BEEN MASSIVE
- 35:13RESISTANCE FROM SPECIAL INTEREST
- 35:15GROUPS AND TRENCH BUREAUCRACIES
- 35:17TO HIGH QUALITY READING
- 35:19INSTRUCTION OTHER STATES HAVE
- 35:21BEEN DOING FOR YEARS.
- 35:21IF FAMILIES HAVE MORE CHOICE
- 35:23THERE WOULD BE MORE
- 35:25ACURRENTABILITY WITHIN THE
- 35:26SYSTEM TO DO BETTER.
- 35:27OUR TEACHERS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 35:28ARE WORKING HARD OUR
- 35:30ADMINISTRATORS ARE WORKING HARD.
- 35:31BUT THEY ARE ENTRENCHED
- 35:33BUREAUCRACIES THAT RESIST ANY
- 35:35CHANGE.
- 35:36AND EVEN WITH THIS LITERACY BILL
- 35:39THAT I COMMEND REPRESENTATIVE
- 35:42BOJANOWSKI AND CHAIRMAN TIPTON
- 35:44WITH THAT, YOU STILL HAVE
- 35:48ADMINISTRATORS THAT AT JSPS
- 35:52KEEPING SCORE ON THE CHANGES FOR
- 35:55LITERACY INSTRUCTION.
- 35:56WHEN YOU GIVE FAMILIES CHOICES
- 35:58YOU LOWER DECREASING THE ABILITY
- 36:00OF THIS BUREAUCRACIES TO STOP
- 36:03REFORMS THAT WILL MAKE THE
- 36:04PUBLIC SCHOOLS BETTER.
- 36:05>> I WANT TO ASK YOU CHAIRMAN
- 36:08TIPTON SHOULD LAWMAKERS GIVE THE
- 36:09OPEN BORDERS PROVISIONS MORE
- 36:12TIME WHEN KIDS CAN GO TO OTHER
- 36:14SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT SUIT THEIR
- 36:15NEEDS BETTER.
- 36:15DO YOU NEED MORE TIME TO
- 36:18EVALUATE THE SUCCESS OF THAT
- 36:19BEFORE MOVING TOWARD A
- 36:21CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT ON
- 36:22SCHOOL CHOICE?
- 36:22>> OF COURSE THAT WAS THE PART
- 36:24OF HOUSE BILL 563 THAT WAS NOT
- 36:26STRUCK DOWN.
- 36:27THAT WAS ALL ANOTHER ONE OF
- 36:29THOSE MORE COMPREHENSIVE PIECES
- 36:31OF LEGISLATION.
- 36:32I THINK I READ AN ARTICLE ABOUT
- 36:35FAYETTE COUNTY.
- 36:35AND THE NUMBER OF STUDENTS THEY
- 36:37HAD HAD WHO EXERCISED THIS.
- 36:39AND I THINK IT'S GOING TO VARY
- 36:41FROM ONE PART OF THE STATE TO
- 36:42THE OTHER.
- 36:44OF COURSE AS THE LEGISLATION IS
- 36:45WRITTEN SCHOOL BOARDS CAN ADOPT
- 36:47POLICIES THE POLICIES MAY DIFFER
- 36:49FROM DISTRICT TO DISTRICT.
- 36:51I THINK WE WILL CONTINUE TO
- 36:52MONITOR THAT.
- 36:53AND SEE HOW THAT WORKS.
- 36:54BUT I DO KNOW THAT THERE IS A
- 36:57LARGE CONTINGENT OF MY MEMBERS
- 37:00IN THE STATE HOUSE AND THE
- 37:02SENATE THAT WILL WANT TO MOVE
- 37:04FORWARD WITH THIS CONSTITUTIONAL
- 37:05AMENDMENT.
- 37:06WE HAVE 25 NEW MEMBERS IN THE
- 37:07HOUSE I CANNOT PREDICT HOW THEY
- 37:09ARE GOING TO VOTE.
- 37:11THAT IS GOING TO BE ONE OF THE
- 37:13INTERESTING ISSUES WHEN WE COME
- 37:15BACK NEXT SESSION TO SEE IF
- 37:17THERE IS ENOUGH SUPPORT TO GET
- 37:1960 MEMBERS IN THE HOUSE AND 23
- 37:21IN THE SENATE TO ACTUALLY PUT
- 37:23THAT AMENDMENT ON THE BALLOT.
- 37:25>> REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI --
- 37:27>> JUST, YES.
- 37:29JUST ONE KIND OF FINAL NOTE
- 37:31ABOUT SCHOOL CHOICE IF YOU ARE
- 37:32READY TO MOVE ON.
- 37:34SO Mr. VANDIVER TALKED ABOUT
- 37:36LIKE THE HISTORY OF SCHOOL
- 37:38CHOICE.
- 37:39IT WAS CHAMPIONED BY MILTON
- 37:41FREEMAN IN 1955 AS A WAY TO
- 37:45PRESERVE JIM CROW AND TO KEEP
- 37:47SCHOOLS SEGREGATED IN A TIME
- 37:50WHEN WE WERE SUPPOSED TO BE
- 37:52INTEGRATING SCHOOLS.
- 37:52THAT IS KIND OF THE DARK HISTORY
- 37:55OF SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 37:57AND I THINK IN JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 38:00PARTICULARLY WHAT WE WANT TO
- 38:01MAKE SURE DOESN'T HAPPEN IS THAT
- 38:02WE DON'T END UP WITH A
- 38:06SEGREGATED SCHOOL SYSTEM.
- 38:08AND THEN I COME BACK HE SAYS
- 38:10ONCE AGAIN PARENTS CHOOSE AND I
- 38:12COME BACK AGAIN TO SAY THE
- 38:14SCHOOLS CHOOSE.
- 38:14I CAN LOOK AT KIDS IN MY
- 38:17CLASSROOM AND YOU KNOW,
- 38:19DIFFERENT LEARNING DIFFERENCES,
- 38:21DIFFERENT BEHAVIORS, AND I THINK
- 38:24THOSE PARENTS PROBABLY WOULDN'T
- 38:26HAVE A CHOICE FOR THEIR CHILDREN
- 38:27TO GO TO CERTAIN SCHOOLS.
- 38:29SO, NO, THE PARENTS DON'T GET TO
- 38:33CHOOSE, THE SCHOOLS CHOOSE.
- 38:35>> RESPOND TO THE COMMENTS WHEN
- 38:36IT COMES TO AN END GOAL TO
- 38:39RESEGREGATE SCHOOLS?
- 38:40>> THAT COMPLETELY FALSE AND
- 38:41THAT HISTORY ABOUT MILTON
- 38:43FREEMAN IS FICTIONAL HAS NO
- 38:45TRUTH TO IT WHATSOEVER.
- 38:46>> THAT IS NOT TRUE.
- 38:47THAT NOT TRUE.
- 38:48>> IT'S NOT TRUE?
- 38:51IT'S FICTIONAL AND THE RESULTS
- 38:54SUPREME COURT NOMINEE TODAY WE
- 38:55LOOK AT FLORIDA 70% OF THE KIDS
- 38:56WHO PARTICIPATE IN THE FLORIDA
- 39:00SCHOLARSHIP TAX CREDITS ARE
- 39:02BLACK OR HISPANIC.
- 39:03THOSE FAMILIES ARE BENEFITING
- 39:04FROM CHOICE AND THE FAMILIES
- 39:06THAT LACK THE CHOICE THE MOST
- 39:08ARE MINORITY FAMILIES WHO ARE
- 39:10FINANCIALLY DO NOT HAVE THE
- 39:11RESOURCES THAT THEIR WHITE PEERS
- 39:13HAVE.
- 39:13THIS IS ABOUT EQUALITY FOR
- 39:15FAMILIES.
- 39:16AND YOU KNOW WHEN YOU LOOK BACK
- 39:18AT THAT HISTORY, PUBLIC
- 39:19EDUCATION WAS SEGREGATED FOR A
- 39:21LONGTIME.
- 39:22AND A LOT OF SCHOOLS OF CHOICE
- 39:24WERE INTEGRATED.
- 39:26THERE WAS A LOT OF CATHOLIC
- 39:28SCHOOLS THAT WERE INTEGRATED AT
- 39:30THE SAME TIME AT THE PUBLIC
- 39:30SCHOOLS WERE NOT.
- 39:31THAT IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW THE
- 39:33REAL HISTORY OF THIS ISSUE AND
- 39:34WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE MODERN
- 39:37VOUCHER PROGRAMS IT STARTED IN
- 39:38MILWAUKEE AND LED BY BLACK
- 39:40DEMOCRATIC LEGISLATOR AND A LOT
- 39:42OF OUR SUPPORTERS IN THE BLACK
- 39:44AND HISPANIC COMMUNITY.
- 39:45THAT IS SOMETHING WE NEED TO
- 39:47DEBUNK OUT RIGHT.
- 39:48AND THE INDIANA SCHOOL CHOICE
- 39:51PROGRAM, THINK ONLY SOMETHING
- 39:52LIKE 10% OF THE INDIANA 20% OF
- 39:56THE INDIANA POPULATION IS
- 39:58MINORITY BUT THE 40% OF THE
- 40:01SCHOOL CHOICE PROGRAM IS
- 40:02MINORITY PARTICIPATION.
- 40:03SO YOU ARE TALKING SIGNIFICANT
- 40:05MINORITY PARTICIPATION IN THESE
- 40:07PROGRAMS.
- 40:07AND I DO WANT TO COME BACK TO
- 40:09OPEN ENROLLMENT IT IS A GOOD
- 40:11POLICY.
- 40:12WE DO BELIEVE THAT THAT IS A
- 40:13GOOD THING.
- 40:14BUT STILL CHOICE AMONGST PUBLIC
- 40:16SCHOOLS AND I LIKE TO COMPARE IT
- 40:18TO THERE IS A GOOD LINE IN THE
- 40:20FIRST FAST AND THE FURIOUS MOVIE
- 40:23WHEN VIN DIESEL TAKES WALKER TO
- 40:25THE PARTY AND HE SAYS YOU CAN
- 40:27HAVE ANY BEER YOU WANT SO LONG
- 40:29AS IT IS A CORONA.
- 40:31BUT I MIGHT WANT SOMETHING
- 40:36DIFFERENT.
- 40:36SAME THING FOR PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 40:38AND WITHIN A DIFFERENT COMMUNITY
- 40:40PUBLIC SCHOOLS MIGHT BE A LOT OF
- 40:42CHOICES AND THERE MAY NOT BE.
- 40:43THAT IS THE I THINK CRUX OF THAT
- 40:46WE NEED MORE OPTIONS NOT FEWER.
- 40:48>> A COUPLE MORE QUESTIONS
- 40:49BEFORE WE MOVE ON, THIS QUESTION
- 40:52FROM SCOTT COUNTY QUOTE PUBLIC
- 40:53MONEY USED IN A RELIGIOUS MANNER
- 40:55IN FAITH BASED SCHOOLS BREACHES
- 40:57THE SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND
- 40:58STATE A PART OF THE U.S.
- 41:00CONSTITUTION HOW DO YOU
- 41:01RECOGNIZE THAT?
- 41:02CHAIRMAN TIPTON?
- 41:03>> I WOULD SAY THE CHARTER
- 41:05SCHOOL LAW WE PASSED BACK IN
- 41:082017 ACTUALLY PROHIBITS A
- 41:09RELIGIOUS BASED SCHOOL IF BEING
- 41:11A CHARTER SCHOOL.
- 41:16AND THAT IS NOT OUR INTENT TO
- 41:18ENFORCE TO TRY TO PROMOTE
- 41:20RELIGION.
- 41:21THE INTENT IS TO PROVIDE
- 41:22OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDENTS WHO MAY
- 41:24NOT HAVE THE OPPORTUNITIES THEY
- 41:26NEED IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOL
- 41:28SYSTEM.
- 41:29AS ANDREW MENTIONED NOT EVERY
- 41:31SITUATION IS RIGHT.
- 41:31AND ONE OF THE AREAS WHERE I
- 41:33THINK WE'VE SEEN THE MOST
- 41:35BENEFIT FROM SCHOOL CHOICE
- 41:38PROGRAMS UP AND ALL OVER THE
- 41:39COUNTRY AND TALKED TO PEOPLE
- 41:40FROM MANY STATES IS IN THE
- 41:42STUDENTS WHO ARE DEALING WITH
- 41:45DISABILITIES.
- 41:45A LOT OF TIMES THERE ARE SCHOOLS
- 41:48THAT CAN HELP THEM MEET CERTAIN
- 41:50NEEDS IN THE DISABLED COMMUNITY.
- 41:52IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE WE'RE
- 41:54TRYING TO PROMOTE RELIGION.
- 41:58ALSO COULD DEBATE THE TERM
- 42:02SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE.
- 42:03IT IS NOT IN THE UNITED STATES
- 42:05CONSTITUTION I GO BACK TO THE
- 42:07JEFFERSON LETTERS AND DEBATE
- 42:08THAT ANYTIME SOMEBODY WANTS TO.
- 42:10>> WE'LL LET YOU AND THAT VIEWER
- 42:12DO THAT.
- 42:13I WORK WITH ALSO FROM AN UNNAMED
- 42:18VIEWER, QUOTE I WORK WITH A
- 42:19PROGRAM THAT ASSISTS KENTUCKIANS
- 42:22WITH DISABILITY STUDENTS OR HOME
- 42:24SCHOOLED MORE THAN EVER.
- 42:25HOW DOES THE PANEL FEEL ABOUT
- 42:27MORE STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES
- 42:28LEARNING FROM HOME OVERALL?
- 42:31ANYONE CARE TO CHIME IN ON THAT?
- 42:34>> I MEAN, I'M FOR CHOICE.
- 42:36I'M FOR SUPPORTING FAMILIES.
- 42:38I THINK PARENTS ARE GOING TO
- 42:39KNOW WHAT IS BEST.
- 42:41BECAUSE WE TALK ABOUT CHILDREN
- 42:43WITH SPECIAL NEEDS, THEIR NEEDS
- 42:45ARE MORE UNIQUE.
- 42:46EVERY CHILD IS UNIQUE BUT THEY
- 42:47ARE MORE UNIQUE IN WHAT THEY
- 42:49WILL NEED.
- 42:50AND I THINK PARENTS ARE GOING TO
- 42:51KNOW WHAT IS BEST.
- 42:52AND WE LOOK AT THE EDUCATION
- 42:55OPPORTUNITY ACCOUNT ACT WE
- 42:56SUPPORT EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY,
- 42:57DIFFERENT TYPES OF SPECIAL NEEDS
- 42:59SERVICES AND WHATEVER
- 43:00LEGISLATION WE PUT FORWARD IN
- 43:01THE FUTURE THOSE ARE THINGS WE
- 43:03WILL SUPPORT.
- 43:04>> MS. BLOM --
- 43:06>> I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
- 43:08MAY I SPEAK.
- 43:09AS A PARENT OF A CHILD WITH A
- 43:11DISABILITY AND AS A SPECIAL
- 43:13EDUCATION TEACHER, THERE IS
- 43:17EXTENSIVE FEDERAL LAW THAT
- 43:18SUPPORTS THE EDUCATION OF
- 43:19STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES.
- 43:22SO I THINK THAT IF A CHILD IS
- 43:24EDUCATED IN A PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 43:27THAT THEY GENERALLY HAVE TO SIGN
- 43:30OFF THAT THEY ARE NOT GETTING
- 43:32THEIR SPECIAL EDUCATION SERVICES
- 43:34AND THAT THEY ARE THEREFORE
- 43:36WOULD NOT HAVE THE PROTECTIONS
- 43:37OF THAT LAW.
- 43:38AS FAR AS BEING EDUCATED AT
- 43:40HOME, I THINK SOMETIMES THAT IS
- 43:44WHAT A PARENT HAS TO DECIDE TO
- 43:46DO IF THEY DON'T FEEL THEIR
- 43:48CHILD IS GETTING THE EDUCATION
- 43:50THEY NEED AND THAT IS WHERE WE
- 43:51NEED TO BE BETTER AT EDUCATING
- 43:53OUR CHILDREN AND ALSO AT
- 43:55SUPPORTING OUR FAMILIES IN
- 43:58NEGOTIATING THAT FEDERAL LAW
- 44:00SYSTEM.
- 44:00>> MS. BLOM I WAS GOING TO ASK
- 44:02IS THERE ANY SCHOOL CHOICE
- 44:04OPTION THAT YOU WOULD SUPPORT?
- 44:06YOU'VE DONE A LOT OF RESEARCH,
- 44:08IS THERE ANYTHING THAT LOOKS
- 44:10LIKE IT MIGHT BE WORKABLE IN
- 44:11KENTUCKY?
- 44:12>> RHONDA MENTIONED THE OPEN
- 44:15ENROLLMENT LAW AS A WAY THAT
- 44:17KENTUCKY IS GETTING TO GREATER
- 44:19CHOICE FOR STUDENTS WHO WANT TO
- 44:21ATTEND SCHOOL IN ANOTHER COUNTY,
- 44:22REGARDLESS OF WHERE THEY LIVE.
- 44:24SO THAT IS ONE OPTION WE'VE
- 44:27MOVED FORWARD CHARTER
- 44:28LEGISLATION HAS BEEN DEBATED
- 44:29YEAR AFTER YEAR AND WE HAVE
- 44:31MULTIPLE LAWS ON THE BOOKS
- 44:33INCLUDING STRUCTURE FOR FUNDING
- 44:34OF CHARTER SCHOOLS.
- 44:36PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS IN THE
- 44:37STATE.
- 44:37THAT IS AN AREA WHERE WE WERE
- 44:39ABLE TO POINT TO THE RESEARCH
- 44:42AND SAY THERE CLEARLY CAN BE A
- 44:44BENEFIT FOR CERTAIN POPULATIONS
- 44:45OF STUDENTS IN A HIGH QUALITY
- 44:47CHARTER SCHOOL.
- 44:49IT'S NOT THE SAME WITH PRIVATE
- 44:51SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 44:53SO ANDREW, I KNOW ARE YOU
- 44:55SHARING THE EXAMPLES FROM
- 44:57FLORIDA, BUT I THINK WHEN IT
- 44:58COMES TO OUR PUBLIC INVESTMENT
- 45:00AND INVESTMENT OF SHARED
- 45:02TAXPAYER DOLLARS, WE'VE GOT TO
- 45:05KNOW DOES THE RESEARCH POINT TO
- 45:07SCHOOL CHOICE AS A STRATEGY IN
- 45:09FLORIDA THAT IS INCREASING THEIR
- 45:11STUDENT OUTCOMES?
- 45:12AND TO DATE WE ARE NOT AWARE OF
- 45:15ANY TYPE OF META ANALYSIS OR
- 45:17SERIOUS RESEARCH THAT POINTS TO
- 45:19THIS STRATEGY BEING EFFECTIVE IN
- 45:21IMPROVING EDUCATION OUTCOMES ON
- 45:24BEHALF OF A STATE.
- 45:26OUR OUTCOMES ARE TOO FAR BEHIND
- 45:28FOR US TO KIND OF PLAY AROUND
- 45:31WITH STRATEGIES OF THAT ARE NOT
- 45:33PROVEN TO WORK AT SCALE.
- 45:35WE'VE DROPPED FROM AN ANDREW
- 45:37MENTIONED THESE THINGS, WE NEED
- 45:39TO OWN THIS TRUTH THAT WE'VE
- 45:41DROPPED FROM 8TH IN THE NATION
- 45:43IN FOURTH GRADE READING TO 29TH.
- 45:45WE'VE DROPPED FROM HIGH OF 33 IN
- 45:49MATHEMATICS TO NOW 41ST IN THE
- 45:53NATION.
- 45:53THESE SHOULD BE SERIOUS CONCERNS
- 45:55FOR OUR LEGISLATORS FOR OUR
- 45:57SCHOOLS, FOR PARENTS.
- 45:59FOR THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY.
- 46:01AND WE SHOULD IDENTIFY
- 46:03STRATEGIES THAT HAVE A TRACK
- 46:04RECORD OF WORKING TO IMPROVE
- 46:06THESE OUTCOMES.
- 46:07>> AND WHAT HAVE YOU FOUND TO
- 46:08WORK?
- 46:09>> PRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE IS NOT
- 46:10THAT STRATEGY.
- 46:11>> WHAT IS THE STRATEGY?
- 46:12>> PRIVATE SCHOOLS OFFER
- 46:14SCHOLARSHIPS TODAY IF STUDENTS
- 46:16WANT TO GO INTO PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 46:18BUT A TAX CREDIT THAT RETURNS 90
- 46:21CENTS ON THE DOLLAR TO THE DONOR
- 46:22IS LIKELY NOT THE BEST AVENUE
- 46:24FOR A VERY POOR STATE WITH
- 46:26LIMITED RESOURCES TO GO.
- 46:27>> NOT JUST FLORIDA THERE'S 28
- 46:30GOLD STANDARD STATES THAT I AM
- 46:32AWARE OF WHERE YOU ARE COMPARING
- 46:34STUDENTS BETWEEN DIFFERENT
- 46:34SYSTEMS AND SHOWING
- 46:36IMPROVEMENTS.
- 46:37AND I KNOW I KEEP HARPING,
- 46:40BECAUSE THEY HAVE HAD SCHOOL
- 46:41CHOICE FOR SO LONG IT DATES BAB
- 46:43TO JEB BUSH IN THE EARLY 2000'S
- 46:45AND YOU ARE SEEING HIGHER
- 46:48GRADUATION RATES FROM COLLEGE
- 46:49AND ATTEND DEG COLLEGE
- 46:52ATTENDANCE EXCUSE ME.
- 46:53AND AT THE END OF DAY I TRUST
- 46:55PARENTS.
- 46:56WHEN A WEALTHY PARENT CHOOSES TO
- 46:58SEND THEIR CHILD TO A PRIVATE
- 47:00SCHOOL NOBODY IS DOG IN SAYING
- 47:02THE STATE IS NOT COMING SAYING
- 47:04ARE YOU SURE THAT DECISION IS OK
- 47:05FOR YOUR KID?
- 47:06ARE YOU IRRESPONSIBLE IN MAKING
- 47:08THAT DECISION?
- 47:09IT'S ONLY WHEN LOWER INCOME
- 47:11FAMILIES MAKE THE DECISIONS THEN
- 47:13THE SO-CALLED EXPERTS SAY NO
- 47:15THESE PEOPLE CAN'T MAKE
- 47:16DECISIONS FOR THEIR KIDS IF THEY
- 47:18WILL CHOOSE THEY WILL CHOOSE
- 47:20UNWISELY.
- 47:21THE EVIDENCE SHOWS THAT
- 47:23INCORRECT AND COMMON SENSE IT
- 47:24SHOWS IT IS INCORRECT BECAUSE
- 47:26PARENTS WILL DO WHAT IS BEST FOR
- 47:28THEIR KIDS NINE TIMES OUT OF 10.
- 47:29>> Dr. CALDWELL WHAT ARE THE
- 47:31PROVEN STRATEGIES FOR IMPROVING
- 47:33EDUCATIONAL OUTCOMES IN THE
- 47:35PUBLIC SCHOOL STRUCTURE?
- 47:36WHAT WORKS?
- 47:37>> THANK YOU FOR ASKING THAT
- 47:38QUESTION.
- 47:39HIGH QUALITY TEACHING.
- 47:40HAVING THE ABSOLUTE BEST
- 47:42TEACHNERS OUR CLASSROOMS TODAY.
- 47:45WITH CLASSROOM NUMBERS THAT ARE
- 47:49MANAGEABLE.
- 47:50WE OFTEN SEE THE LENS OF
- 47:51EDUCATION THROUGH OUR OWN
- 47:53EXPERIENCES AND ONE THAT I THINK
- 47:55APPLIES TO A LOT OF PARENTS IS I
- 47:57CAN REMEMBER THE FIRST TIME I
- 47:59HAD ONE OF THE SONS WHO A VERY
- 48:02TALENTED BRIGHT YOUNG MAN, BUT
- 48:04NOT REALLY INTERESTED IN WHAT IS
- 48:05HAPPENING IN THE CLASSROOM.
- 48:07WHEN IT COMES TO INSTRUCTION.
- 48:09AND SO I REMEMBER THE FIRST TIME
- 48:11THAT I OBSERVED THAT CLASSROOM.
- 48:13AND ALL OF A SUDDEN FOR THE
- 48:15FIRST TIME I COULD SEE AND FEEL
- 48:18WHAT HIS TEACHER HAD BEEN TRYING
- 48:20TO SHARE WITH ME.
- 48:21I HAVE 24 CHILDREN IN FRONT OF
- 48:23ME WHO ARE COMING FROM 24
- 48:25DIFFERENT HOMES, BRINGING 24
- 48:28DIFFERENT PERSONALITIES AND 24
- 48:30POSSIBLY DIFFERENT CULTURES.
- 48:34AND THAT AUTOMATICALLY MAKES ME
- 48:36THINK WHEN I SAY THAT WORD IN
- 48:38THE STATE OF KENTUCKY ALONE WE
- 48:40HAVE 144 DIFFERENT LANGUAGES
- 48:42THAT RANGE FROM ENGLISH TO
- 48:44SPANISH TO SWAHILI.
- 48:46SO WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT HAVING A
- 48:49CLASSROOM TEACHER AND WE THINK
- 48:51ABOUT THESE ARE THE INDIVIDUALS
- 48:53WHO IMPACT OUR LIVES FOREVER
- 48:56MORE IN TERMS OF GUIDING ME,
- 48:59SHAPING ME INTO YOUNG ADULTHOOD,
- 49:01WE ALL CAN NAME OUR FAVORITE
- 49:03TEACHERS.
- 49:04WE NEED THE VERY BEST IN THAT
- 49:05CLASSROOM.
- 49:06AND LIGHT NOW WE ARE AT A
- 49:09SHORTAGE.
- 49:09AND THE TEACHERS THAT WE HAVE
- 49:11EVERYDAY SHOWING UP ARE DOING
- 49:13THE BEST THEY CAN ALONG WITH OUR
- 49:16PRINCIPALS, OUR SUPERINTENDENTS,
- 49:17IT'S ALL HANDS ON DECK STARTING
- 49:19OUT THE DAY RIGHT NOW.
- 49:21OK.
- 49:21WHO IS HERE?
- 49:22WHO IS PHYSICALLY HERE?
- 49:24AND WHAT CAN WE MAKE HAPPEN FROM
- 49:26A TEACHING AND LEARNING
- 49:29PERSPECTIVE AT THE SAME TIME
- 49:30WE'RE KEEPING OUR CHILDREN SAFE
- 49:34FROM HARM, AT THE SAME TIME
- 49:35WE'RE MAKING SURE OUR CHILDREN
- 49:37ARE FED, AT THE SAME TIME WE'RE
- 49:38TRYING TO MANAGE NOT ONLY THE
- 49:40MENTAL HEALTH OF OUR CHILDREN,
- 49:42BUT ALSO THE SOCIAL EMOTIONAL
- 49:44HEALTH OF OUR ADULTS OUR ENTIRE
- 49:47SOCIETY.
- 49:48AND SO SHORING UP THAT TEACHER
- 49:50PIPELINE AND MAKING THE TEACHING
- 49:54PROFESSION ATTRACTIVE.
- 49:56THAT POSITION THAT WE WANT TO
- 49:59HOLD.
- 50:00RESTORING RESPECT TO THE
- 50:01PROFESSION.
- 50:02THOSE ARE JUST SOME OF THE
- 50:03PLACES THAT I WOULD START WHEN I
- 50:05THINK ABOUT AN EFFECTIVE
- 50:08STRATEGY FOR.
- 50:08>> WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT
- 50:09HAPPENED THE OUTCOME OF THE 2023
- 50:12LEGISLATIVE SESSION THAT ENDED
- 50:13MARCH 30TH WAS THERE LEGISLATION
- 50:15TO BECOME LAW THAT WILL
- 50:17ACCOMPLISH SOME OF WHAT YOU
- 50:18THINK WILL HELP?
- 50:19>> ACTUALLY YES THERE IS
- 50:21GRATEFUL TO REPRESENTATIVE
- 50:24TIPTON ON THE THIS EVENING.
- 50:27SO THE COALITION TO SUSTAIN THE
- 50:29EDUCATION PROFESSION IS
- 50:30SOMETHING AN INITIATIVE THAT IS
- 50:32BEING LED BY KASA, WE'RE ABOUT
- 50:35EIGHT MONTHS, NINE MONTHS INTO
- 50:37THAT WORK.
- 50:37AND ONE OF THE FIRST THING WE
- 50:39DID WE REACHED ACROSS TO THE
- 50:42CAPITOL TO REPRESENTATIVE TIPTON
- 50:43AND ASKED HIM TO SERVE AS PART
- 50:45OF THAT COALITION.
- 50:47HE ALONG WITH SENATOR GIBBONS
- 50:50AND ALSO SENATOR WISE ARE PART
- 50:53OF THAT COALITION.
- 50:54SO WHAT WE HAVE AT THIS POINT,
- 50:58IS THREE ESTEEMED LEGISLATORS
- 51:00WHO ARE WORKING ALONGSIDE US TO
- 51:02DIG DOWN DEEP AND UNDERSTAND
- 51:04WHAT IT IS THAT WE NEED TO BRING
- 51:07FORWARD NOT ONLY TO OURSELVES AS
- 51:11PUBLIC EDUCATORS, BUT ALSO ALL
- 51:13OF OUR EDUCATION AGENCIES LIKE
- 51:16THE BRING CHARRED COMMITTEE LIKE
- 51:19THE SCHOOL BOARD ASSOCIATION AND
- 51:20THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION.
- 51:21AND THIS WILL BE MY HAND OFF TO
- 51:23YOU REPRESENTATIVE TIPTON, BUT
- 51:24WHAT IS IT THAT OUR LEGISLATURE
- 51:28CAN DO FOR ALL OF OUR
- 51:30COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE STATE OF
- 51:32KENTUCKY?
- 51:32BECAUSE THESE ARE THEIR
- 51:33COMMUNITIES AT HOME AS WELL.
- 51:35>> CHAIRMAN TIPTON?
- 51:38>> RHONDA REFERENCED HOUSE BILL
- 51:41THREE 19 WHICH PASSED IN THE
- 51:432023 SESSION.
- 51:43AS I SAID ON THE FLOOR OF THE
- 51:45HOUSE THIS IS NOT AN ANSWER THIS
- 51:47IS NOT A SOLUTION BUT POSITIVE
- 51:49FIRST STEPS WE COULD TAKE.
- 51:51ITEMS HOWEVER, I THINK WE HAVE
- 51:53TO COME BACK FOR THE 2024
- 51:55SESSION THE BUDGET SESSION.
- 51:56I THINK ONE OF THE AREAS THAT I
- 51:59BELIEVE IS OBVIOUS THAT TEACHERS
- 52:01IN THE FIRST THREE TO FIVE YEARS
- 52:02IS CRITICAL.
- 52:03FOR THEM TO STAY IN THE
- 52:05PROFESSION.
- 52:06IT IS A IMPORTANT FOR THEM TO
- 52:08HAVE THE SUPPORT IN THE
- 52:10MENTORSHIP THERE.
- 52:11MORE EXPERIENCED TEACHERS.
- 52:13SEVERAL YEARS AGO WE HAD A
- 52:15PROGRAM CALLED K TIP, KENTUCKY
- 52:18TEACHER INTERNSHIP PROGRAM.
- 52:19I WOULD LIKE TO SEE US TAKE A
- 52:21LOOK AT THAT AGAIN.
- 52:22IT HAS NOT BEEN FUNDED IN A FEW
- 52:24YEARS.
- 52:24BUT I THINK PROVIDING THOSE
- 52:26SUPPORTS TO THE YOUNG TEACHERS
- 52:27AS THEY ARE STARTING OUT TO HELP
- 52:30THEM SUCCEED VERY EARLY IN THEIR
- 52:32TEACHING CAREER IS ESSENTIAL.
- 52:34THERE ARE OTHER ITEMS THAT WE'RE
- 52:36LOOKING AT.
- 52:38WE HAVE I KNOW NELSON COUNTY
- 52:41PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM IS
- 52:42PARTNERING WITH WESTERN WESTERN
- 52:44KENTUCKY UNIVERSITY ON AN
- 52:45APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM.
- 52:46I'M INTERESTED TO SEE HOW THAT
- 52:48GOES.
- 52:48HOW THAT PROGRESSES AS FAR AS
- 52:51SCHOOL DISTRICTS GROWING THEIR
- 52:53OWN FROM WITHIN.
- 52:55WE ALSO HAD A LOT OF
- 52:58CONVERSATION BEFORE SESSION AND
- 53:00DURING SESSION ABOUT SOME OF THE
- 53:01CHALLENGES THAT PEOPLE HAVE IN
- 53:02THE TEACHER PROFESSION.
- 53:05MOST PEOPLE DO NOT REALIZE WE
- 53:06HAVE A TEACHER SCHOLARSHIP
- 53:09PROGRAM IT HAD NOT BEEN FUNDED
- 53:10IN 22 AND FUNDED AT ONE MILLION
- 53:14PER YEAR.
- 53:14I WILL ADVOCATE TO SEE THAT
- 53:16AMOUNT INCREASED IN THE NEXT
- 53:17BNG.
- 53:17>> SO WHAT, SIR?
- 53:19>> INCREASED TO WHAT?
- 53:21>> WELL, I'VE ASKED THAT
- 53:22QUESTION I HAVE A GOAL OF 5
- 53:24MILLION RIGHT NOW.
- 53:25SOMETIMES YOU HAVE TO START
- 53:26SOMEWHERE AND SEE WHERE YOU CAN
- 53:27GET.
- 53:28>> START HIGH.
- 53:28>> THAT IS MY GOAL RIGHT NOW 5
- 53:32MILLION.
- 53:32ONE OTHER AREA WE HAVE
- 53:34IDENTIFIED OFTENTIMES WHEN
- 53:35TEACHERS GO FOR THE STUDENT
- 53:37TEACHING THEY HAVE A SITUATION
- 53:38WHERE THEY CAN'T WORK THEY CAN'T
- 53:41PROVIDE FOR THEMSELVES AND IT'S
- 53:42DIFFICULT.
- 53:43WE'VE LOOKED AT THE POSSIBILITY
- 53:44OF STIPENDS FOR STUDENT
- 53:46TEACHERS.
- 53:46THERE IS A LOT OF THINGS OUT
- 53:48THERE THAT WE'RE LOOKING AT.
- 53:50AND, AGAIN, IT WILL BE A BUDGET
- 53:52YEAR.
- 53:52IT WILL BE A LOT OF CONVERSATION
- 53:54ABOUT HOW MUCH MONEY IS INVESTED
- 53:55IN EDUCATION.
- 53:57AND HOW MUCH IS SENT DOWN TO THE
- 53:59SCHOOL BOARDS THE SCHOOL
- 54:01DISTRICTS FOR THE SEEK FORMULA.
- 54:03WE REALLY A LOT OF THINGS WE
- 54:05COULD HAVE TALKED ABOUT TIME WE
- 54:06DIDN'T HAVE TIME FOR.
- 54:07>> YOU WANT TO GET TO THE POINT
- 54:09ABOUT TEACHER PAY.
- 54:10THE GOVERNOR HAD A PROPOSAL HE
- 54:11PITCHED FOR A COUPLE OF SESSIONS
- 54:13AND THE LEGISLATURE HAS SAID WE
- 54:17GAVE MORE MONEY SO THE DISTRICTS
- 54:18COULD DECIDE WHERE THE DOLLARS
- 54:20GO AND THAT WAS NOT EQUITABLE.
- 54:22SO WILL SOMEHOW THE LAWMAKERS IN
- 54:24THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TRY TO
- 54:27PROVIDE MORE DIRECT TEACHER PAY
- 54:29INCREASES?
- 54:30>> THE DISCUSSION HAS BEEN THAT
- 54:33SCHOOLTEACHERS ARE EMPLOYEES OF
- 54:34THE LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
- 54:35AND IN THE LAST BACK IN 22, I
- 54:39ACTUALLY, THE SCHOOL
- 54:41SUPERINTENDENTS THE SCHOOL BOARD
- 54:42ASSOCIATION CAME TO US AND ASKED
- 54:44US NOT TO DO THAT.
- 54:45THEY ASKED US TO ACTUALLY
- 54:47INCREASE THE FUNDING AND LET
- 54:48THEM MAKE THE CHOICES.
- 54:50I WILL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE ONE
- 54:51OF THE COUNTY --
- 54:53>> DID THE TEACHERS' UNIONS ASK
- 54:55FOR THE SOMETIME?
- 54:55>> NO THEY DID NOT.
- 54:57BUT THE PEOPLE IN THERE DAY IN
- 54:59AND DAY OUT MAKING THE DECISIONS
- 55:01THAT ARE IMPORTANT FOR SCHOOL
- 55:02DISTRICTS DID.
- 55:03>> BUT THE TEACHERS IN THE
- 55:04CLASSROOM DID NOT?
- 55:05>> THEY DID NOT.
- 55:06HERE IS THE TOPIC WE NEED TO
- 55:08CHANGE THE TERM TEACHER PAY TO
- 55:10TEACHER COMPENSATION.
- 55:11THE SOUTHERN REGIONAL EDUCATION
- 55:13BOARD CAME OUT WITH AN ANALYSIS
- 55:15A FEW WEEKS AGO AND THEY
- 55:18COMPARED TEACHER COMPENSATION
- 55:19ACROSS ALL 16 STATES AND THEY
- 55:21INCLUDED ITEMS LIKE THE QUALITY
- 55:23OF THE HEALTH INSURANCE, THE
- 55:25QUALITY OF THE PENSION SYSTEM
- 55:26AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE TEACHER
- 55:29COMPENSATION HOLISTICALLY IN
- 55:31KENTUCKY WE ARE A LOT BETTER
- 55:32THAN THE GOVERNOR'S COMMENT OF
- 55:3344 FOR THE NATION.
- 55:37>> TO RHONDA AND REPRESENTATIVE
- 55:39TIPTON'S POINT THERE IS NOTHING
- 55:41MORE IMPORTANT IN IMPROVING
- 55:42EDUCATION OUTCOMES THAN THE
- 55:43QUALITY OF TEACHER IN THE
- 55:44CLASSROOM.
- 55:45ANY WE CAN DO AS A STATE TO
- 55:46INVEST IN OUR TEACHERS, THE READ
- 55:52TO SUCCEED BILL IS A GREAT
- 55:54EXAMPLE.
- 55:55REPRESENTATIVE TIPTON MENTIONED
- 55:57K IT TIP WE PROSED A 58 MILLION
- 56:00FUND FOR TEACHING EXCELLENCE IN
- 56:01THE STATE TO USE THOSE DOLLARS
- 56:03FOR THINGS LIKE LITERACY, TO
- 56:05INCREASE THE STIPEND FOR
- 56:06NATIONAL BOARD CERTIFICATION
- 56:07WHERE THERE IS A RESEARCH BASED
- 56:09TO SHOW IMPROVED EDUCATION
- 56:11OUTCOMES.
- 56:11LET'S HAVE THAT CONVERSATION AND
- 56:14INSURE KENTUCKY TEACHERS
- 56:16COMPENSATION IS PROFESSIONALLY
- 56:17COMPETITIVE.
- 56:18>> ALL RIGHT.
- 56:18WELL THAT IS A FUTURE
- 56:19CONVERSATION WE COULDN'T GET TO
- 56:21EVERYTHING TONIGHT.
- 56:22I HAD A ROBUST AGENDA AND I
- 56:25DIDN'T QUITE GET THERE IT WILL
- 56:26BE CONTINUED.
- 56:27I'LL SEE YOU NEXT MONDAY NIGHT
- 56:28AS WE BEGIN CONVERSATIONS WITH
- 56:30CANDIDATES FOR THE PRIMARY.
- 56:32DON'T MISS IT.
- 56:33SEE YOU NEXT WEEK.