Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Horse Racing Safety
Transcript
- 0:02[♪♪]
- 0:10Good evening, Welcome to
- 0:11"Kentucky Tonight."
- 0:11I'm Renee Shaw.
- 0:12Thanks for joining us.
- 0:15Our topic tonight: horse racing
- 0:16safety.
- 0:18Racing’s Triple Crown is now
- 0:19behind us.
- 0:20But this year, those races were
- 0:21partially overshadowed by
- 0:23numerous deaths at the major
- 0:24race tracks.
- 0:26There were 12 deaths at
- 0:28Churchill Downs in the weeks
- 0:29leading up to the Kentucky
- 0:30Derby, and deaths at Pimlico and
- 0:31Belmont Park.
- 0:33Churchill has now moved the
- 0:34remainder of its spring meet to
- 0:36Ellis Park in Henderson while it
- 0:37tries to figure out what’s
- 0:40causing so many deaths.
- 0:41This comes during a relaunch of
- 0:43an anti-doping and medication
- 0:44control policy — from the
- 0:46Horseracing Integrity and Safety
- 0:48Authority, or HISA, went into
- 0:51effect on May 22nd.
- 0:53Will national oversight help
- 0:55improve the safety of horse
- 0:55racing?
- 0:57We have a distinguished panel
- 0:58from the horse racing world to
- 0:59discuss all this.
- 1:00But before we get to them, part
- 1:03of my conversation earlier today
- 1:04with Natalie Voss,
- 1:05editor-in-chief of the Paulick
- 1:06Report, about the recent deaths.
- 1:13>> NATALIE VOSS THANK YOU FOR
- 1:15YOUR TIME.
- 1:15GOOD TO SEE YOU.
- 1:17LET'S TALK ABOUT HISA BECAUSE IT
- 1:19SEEMED TO ALL OF THIS CONNECTED
- 1:21WITH CHURCHILL DOWNS HAS MAYBE
- 1:23PERHAPS RAISED THE CONVERSATION
- 1:25ABOUT HISA.
- 1:26IS IT A GOOD AGENCY?
- 1:28IS IT A NECESSARY AGENCY?
- 1:30DO YOU HAVE THE LAW AND THEN YOU
- 1:32HAVE THE AGENCY.
- 1:33FIRST OF ALL IF YOU CAN GIVE US
- 1:35A PRIMER ABOUT THE LAW AND THEN
- 1:37THE AGENCY, THE REGULATORY
- 1:39AGENCY THAT IS CHARGED TO
- 1:41OVERSEE THIS?
- 1:43>> SO THE LAW THAT CREATED THE
- 1:47AGENCY WAS PASSED BY CONGRESS IN
- 1:502020.
- 1:50IT WAS PASSED WITH CREATING AN
- 1:54AGENCY THAT WOULD SERVE AS A
- 1:56NATIONAL OVERSIGHT FOR RACETRACK
- 1:58SAFETY AND ANTI-DOPING AND
- 2:00MEDICATION CONTROL THOSE ARE
- 2:01CONSIDERED TWO SEPARATE WELL,
- 2:03SORT OF SEPARATE BUT RELATED
- 2:06WINGS OF THE SAME ORGANIZATION.
- 2:07THE RACETRACK SAFETY PORTION IN
- 2:09TERMS OF RULES AND LOGISTICS
- 2:13WENT INTO EFFECT LAST JULY.
- 2:16THE MEDICATION CONTROL PORTION
- 2:18WHICH WILL NATIONALIZE
- 2:20MEDICATION STANDARDS JUST I
- 2:23THINK LAUNCHED JUST AHEAD OF
- 2:25BELMONT.
- 2:25THE BELMONT WAS DEFINITELY THE
- 2:28FIRST OF THE TRIPLE CROWN RACES
- 2:31AND WE STILL DON'T HAVE TEST
- 2:33RESULTS BACK FROM THE FIRST
- 2:34ROUND OF MEDICATION TESTING THAT
- 2:36HAS HAPPENED UNDER HISA THAT
- 2:37PART OF IT GOT IMPLEMENTED MUCH
- 2:39LATER.
- 2:40BUT THAT IS WHERE WE'RE AT AT
- 2:41THE MOMENT WITH THAT
- 2:43ORGANIZATION.
- 2:45>> Renee: IN YOUR CREW YOU'VE
- 2:47LONG REPORTED AND CELEBRATED
- 2:50EQUINE JOURNALIST DOES THETIC
- 2:53PROTECTTY, THE LONGEVITY OF THE
- 2:56HORSERACING INDUSTRY DEPEND ON
- 2:57HAVING A NATIONALIZED,
- 3:01FEDERALIZED UNIFORM STANDARD OF
- 3:03REGULATION, IS HISA THE AGENCY
- 3:04THE ANSWER?
- 3:05>> I THINK IT'S NOT THE ONLY
- 3:07ANSWER BECAUSE I THINK THAT THE
- 3:09CHALLENGES THAT THE SPORT FACES
- 3:10IN TERMS OF PUBLIC PERCEPTION
- 3:15ARE SO MULTIFACTORIAL.
- 3:17WHEN I FIRST STARTED REPORTING
- 3:19ON THIS BUSINESS MORE THAN A
- 3:21DECADE AGO, WHAT PEOPLE WERE
- 3:22TELLING ME INSIDE OF RACING WAS
- 3:24THERE'S NO CONSISTENCY
- 3:26NATIONALLY.
- 3:26WE NEED TO FIX THIS THERE NEEDS
- 3:28TO BE NATIONAL OVERSIGHT AND
- 3:30THINGS NEED TO BE ADJUDICATED
- 3:32MUCH MORE QUICKLY AND THINGS
- 3:33NEED TO BE STREAMLINED.
- 3:35I STILL HEAR THAT AS SOMETHING
- 3:37THAT RACING INSIDERS ARE HOPEFUL
- 3:39WITH HISA BUT NOW THE PUBLIC
- 3:42VIEWPOINT PEOPLE NOT HORSERACING
- 3:43PEOPLE IS NOT JUST WHY ARE RULES
- 3:47DIFFERENT FROM STATE TO STATE
- 3:49MANY MAY NOT RECOGNIZE THAT IS
- 3:51TRUE.
- 3:51WHAT THEY ARE WORRIED ABOUT IS
- 3:53THE SAFETY OF THE ANIMALS AND
- 3:54THE WELFARE OF THE ANIMAL.
- 3:56AND I THINK THAT HISA CAN HELP
- 3:58ADDRESS THAT.
- 3:59I THINK IF IT IS SORT OF
- 4:02EXECUTING SUCCESSFULLY IT CAN
- 4:04MAKE MEANINGFUL IMPROVEMENTS
- 4:06WITH RACETRACK SAFETY BUT I
- 4:07DON'T KNOW IF THE PUBLIC IS
- 4:08GOING TO ACCEPT THAT AS THE
- 4:10ANSWER TO THE ENTIRE PROBLEM.
- 4:12THEY WANT FOR HORSES NOT TO DIE
- 4:14IN COMPETITION AND THEY WANT
- 4:15THAT IMMEDIATELY.
- 4:16AND THE NATURE OF RESEARCH BASED
- 4:19DATA DRIVEN SORTS OF REGULATIONS
- 4:21THE WAY HISA IS INTERESTED IN
- 4:23INTERACTING IS THAT THEY TAKE
- 4:24TIME.
- 4:25IT DEAF THATLY HELPS BUT I DON'T
- 4:27THINK IT'S OUR ONLY SOLUTION AS
- 4:29A SPORT.
- 4:30SO THE ENTIRE PUBLIC PERCEPTION
- 4:33PROBLEM.
- 4:33>> Renee: ARE THERE PARTICULAR
- 4:34RULES THAT HORSEMEN AND HORSE
- 4:36INDUSTRY FOLKS ARE OPPOSED TO
- 4:39WHEN IT COMES TO HISA OR IS IT
- 4:41THE OVERALL CONCEPT OF HAVING
- 4:42THIS AGENCY?
- 4:43OR IS IT BOTH?
- 4:44>> I THINK IT DEPENDS WHO YOU
- 4:47ASK.
- 4:48THE BASIS OF THE LAWSUITS THAT
- 4:51ARE WORKING THEIR WAY THROUGH
- 4:53FEDERAL COURTS FROM MY
- 4:54UNDERSTANDING IS MOSTLY BASED ON
- 4:56THE CONSTITUTIONALITY BUT I
- 4:58THINK THERE ARE DEFINITELY
- 4:59HORSEMEN'S GROUPS THAT HAVE
- 5:01CONCERNS ABOUT INDIVIDUAL RULES
- 5:02WITHIN THE TRACK SAFETY AND
- 5:04SOMEWHAT IN THE MEDICATION
- 5:06SPECTRUM, TOO.
- 5:07PEOPLE HAD SORT OF LESS TIME TO
- 5:11THE MEDICATION ROLE THAN
- 5:12PRACTICE AND THERE'S HESITATION
- 5:14IN STATES THAT HAVE NOT HAD THE
- 5:16RESOURCES TO HAVE AS MANY
- 5:19VETERINARIANS, TO DO AS MUCH
- 5:22TESTING AS WHAT MIGHT BE
- 5:24CONSIDERED THE GOLD STANDARD
- 5:26THERE'S CONCERN HOW IS THAT
- 5:27GOING TO PLAY OUT.
- 5:28HOW TIGHT IS THIS CONTROL GOING
- 5:30TO BE, ARE THEY GOING TO EXPAND
- 5:32THEIR CONTROL OVER THESE VARIOUS
- 5:35SORT OF MANAGEMENT ASPECTS OF
- 5:38RACETRACKS.
- 5:39I THINK THERE'S HESITATION FROM
- 5:41DIFFERENT PEOPLE FOR DIFFERENT
- 5:43REASONS.
- 5:43>> Renee: IN ADDITION TO HISA
- 5:44AND WE KNOW THAT THE PEOPLE WHO
- 5:45WILL BE ON THE PANEL MIGHT HAVE
- 5:47OTHER IDEAS ABOUT HOW TO IMPROVE
- 5:49HORSERACING SAFETY.
- 5:50WHAT HAVE THE CONVERSATIONS BEEN
- 5:52ABOUT BEFORE THAT COULD INFORM
- 5:54WHERE TO GO NEXT?
- 5:55>> SO PREVIOUSLY TO MY
- 5:57UNDERSTANDING AND THIS PREDATES
- 6:00MY EXISTENCE ON THE PLANET THERE
- 6:02HAVE BEEN DISCUSSIONS ABOUT
- 6:05VOLUNTARY PRIVATE ORGANIZATIONS
- 6:07BETWEEN STATE RACING COMMISSIONS
- 6:09AMONGST RACETRACKS TO COME
- 6:11TOGETHER AND CREATE A SIMILAR
- 6:14NATIONAL EFFECT WHERE YOU HAVE
- 6:15EVERYBODY AGREEING TO ADHERE TO
- 6:18BEST PRACTICE SAFETY POLICY AND
- 6:20MEDICATION POLICY.
- 6:21THOSE TEND IN MY EXPERIENCE TO
- 6:24SORT OF GET SOME BUY IN FROM
- 6:27EXACTLY WHO YOU WOULD EXPECT THE
- 6:28STATES THAT ARE RUNNING
- 6:30MORASSING AND MORE HIGHER END
- 6:33RACING LIKE KENTUCKY, CALIFORNIA
- 6:35AND NEW YORK, TRACKS AND
- 6:36COMMISSIONS TEND TO BE MORE
- 6:37WILLING IN THOSE AREAS TO
- 6:40ADVANCE.
- 6:40AND WHERE YOU DON'T SEE PEOPLE
- 6:42JUMPING ONBOARD IS KIND OF THE
- 6:44SAME PLACES THE SAME SORT OF
- 6:47RACETRACKS EVERY TIME.
- 6:50SO THIS LAW WENT FORWARD THE WAY
- 6:52IT DID, I THINK LARGELY BECAUSE
- 6:54THE EXISTING SYSTEM WASN'T
- 6:56WORKING.
- 6:57THIS IDEA OF LET'S VOLUNTARILY
- 6:58BUY INTO SOMETHING AND LET'S ALL
- 7:00AGREE TO GET ALONG AND DO THINGS
- 7:03THE SAME WAY SOUNDS REALLY NICE,
- 7:04BUT I THINK THE REASON THAT
- 7:06RACING IS IN THE SITUATION AT
- 7:08THE MOMENT IS BECAUSE THEY TRIED
- 7:09THAT AND IT DIDN'T REALLY HAVE
- 7:12THE NATIONAL IMPACT THAT
- 7:13EVERYBODY WANTED IT TO.
- 7:16SO I DON'T KNOW WHETHER IT IS A
- 7:19PERFECT SOLUTION BUT IT'S
- 7:20DESIGNED TO BE A COMPLETE
- 7:22SOLUTION AS FAR AS GETTING
- 7:23EVERYONE ON THE SAME PAGE.
- 7:26>> Renee: NATALIE VOSS THANK YOU
- 7:27FOR YOUR TIME WE APPRECIATE YOU
- 7:29AND YOUR WORK AS WELL.
- 7:30THANK YOU.
- 7:30>> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
- 7:35>> Renee: NOW,
- 7:36We are joined in our Lexington
- 7:36studio, by: Bill Lear, an
- 7:37attorney and Vice Chairman of
- 7:39The Jockey Club; State Senator
- 7:40Damon Thayer, a Republican from
- 7:41Georgetown, Senate Majority
- 7:43Floor Leader, and horse-racing
- 7:44industry consultant, and
- 7:46Chauncey Morris, Executive
- 7:48Director of the Kentucky
- 7:48Thoroughbred Association. And
- 7:50joining us by SKYPE: Eric J.
- 7:52Hamelback, CEO of the National
- 7:53Horsemen’s Benevolent and
- 7:56Protective Association, the
- 7:57N-H-B-P-A.
- 7:58We want to hear from you.
- 8:00So send us your questions by
- 8:01Twitter at K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T.
- 8:02Send an email to K-Y TONIGHT at
- 8:04K-E-T dot O-R-G. Or use the web
- 8:08form at K-E-T dot O-R-G slash
- 8:11K-Y TONIGHT. Or you can call
- 8:121-800-494-7605. Welcome to all
- 8:12of our guests.
- 8:20Mr. ERIC HAMELBACK WE SPRESH
- 8:22YOU JOINING US BY SKYPE.
- 8:24THANK YOU, GENTLEMEN.
- 8:25YOU HEARD WHAT NATALIE HAD TO
- 8:27SAY TO GIVE US A PRIMER WHAT IS
- 8:29HAPPENING.
- 8:30NOT EVERYONE WHO IS WATCHING THE
- 8:32SHOW LEADER THAYER IS AS MUCH OF
- 8:35A HORSE ENTHUSIAST AS YOU ARE.
- 8:37FROM WHAT YOU HEARD FROM MS.
- 8:39VOSS AND CONSIDERING WE'VE HAD A
- 8:42DOZEN DEATHS AT CHURCHILL DOWNS
- 8:43AND OTHER PLACES, DOES IT NOT
- 8:45MAKE SENSE FOR A STANDARDIZED
- 8:47UNIFORM REGULATORY AGENT SIT
- 8:50TO --
- 8:51SECRETARYSY TO --
- 8:53AGENCY TO PULL THE REINS IN TO
- 8:55MAKE SURE EVERYONE IS SAFE?
- 8:57>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME ON
- 8:59THE SHOW.
- 9:00HAPPY TO DISCUSS MY FAVORITE
- 9:02TOPIC, HORSERACING.
- 9:03THE REASON I MOVED TO KENTUCKY
- 9:05OVER 30 YEARS AGO TO WORK AT
- 9:08TURF WAY PARK AND IT LATER AND
- 9:10IN THE BREEDER'S CUP.
- 9:12I SUPPORT A STANDARDIZATION OF
- 9:15MEDICATION RULES ACROSS RACING
- 9:17JURISDICTIONS IN AMERICA.
- 9:1812 YEARS AGO, I GOT A BILL
- 9:20PASSED IN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 9:21THAT WOULD ALLOW KENTUCKY TO
- 9:23JOIN AN INTERSTATE COMPACT WHERE
- 9:26STATES WOULD JOIN TOGETHER TO
- 9:28FORM AN ALLIANCE TO IMPLEMENT
- 9:31THOSE UNIFORM RULES.
- 9:32IT WAS SIGNED INTO LAW BY STEVE
- 9:36BESHEAR, A CURRENT MEMBER OF THE
- 9:38HISA GOVERNING BOARD.
- 9:41I THINK THERE ARE CONSTITUTIONAL
- 9:44QUESTIONS RELATED TO HISA.
- 9:45I LIKE TO TALK ABOUT THE 10TH
- 9:46AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION.
- 9:48ON THE TOP OF MY TWITTER PAGE IF
- 9:50ANYBODY HAS ANY QUESTIONS.
- 9:51AND IT SAYS THAT IF IT AS' NOT
- 9:55ENUMERATED IN THE CONSTITUTION
- 9:57UNDER THE POWERS OF THE FEDERAL
- 9:58GOVERNMENT IT IS THE RIGHT OF
- 10:00THE STATE.
- 10:01AND FOR ITS ENTIRE EXISTENCE
- 10:03HORSERACING HAS BEEN REGULATED
- 10:05BY THE STATES.
- 10:06AND WHAT'S HAPPENED IS A
- 10:08PATCHWORK OF RULES AND
- 10:10REGULATIONS AND TODAY'S TRAINERS
- 10:12MIGHT BE RACING IN MULTIPLE
- 10:13STATES ON THE SAME DAY.
- 10:15AND I THINK GETTING THOSE
- 10:18MEDICATION RULES ALIGNED IS THE
- 10:20RIGHT STEP.
- 10:21I ALSO THINK IT'S THE RIGHT STEP
- 10:24TO PROVIDE A SAFER RACING
- 10:25ENVIRONMENT FOR HORSES AND
- 10:28JOCKEYS AND BETTER INTEGRITY FOR
- 10:29THE BETTERS WHO FUND THE RACING
- 10:34BUSINESS MODEL BY BETTING ON
- 10:35RACES.
- 10:35PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW THAT RACES
- 10:37ARE OCCURRING ON THE UP AND UP.
- 10:39THERE ARE LEGITIMATE QUESTIONS,
- 10:41I THINK ABOUT THE
- 10:42CONSTITUTIONALITY OF HISA.
- 10:44BUT ULTIMATELY, THE COURT WILL
- 10:47DECIDE.
- 10:48IT'S CURRENTLY WORKING ITS WAY
- 10:49THROUGH THE FEDERAL COURT OF
- 10:50APPEALS.
- 10:51SOME PEOPLE THINK THAT THE COURT
- 10:53OF APPEALS COULD HAVE THE FINAL
- 10:54SAY AND RULE IT CONSTITUTIONAL.
- 10:57OTHERS SAY IT COULD GO TO THE
- 10:58SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED
- 10:59STATES.
- 11:02AND IT'S ULTIMATE CONSTITUTIONAL
- 11:05QUESTION WOULD BE SETTLED THERE.
- 11:06EITHER WAY, I DO THINK WE HAVE
- 11:09TO HAVE CONSISTENT RULES AND WE
- 11:11ARE HEADING IN THAT DIRECTION.
- 11:13I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT, I'VE
- 11:15SPENT THE LAST WEEK HAVING A LOT
- 11:18OF CONVERSATIONS WITH INDUSTRY
- 11:20PARTICIPANTS.
- 11:20AT THIS TIME, I DON'T BELIEVE
- 11:23THERE IS ANYTHING WRONG WITH THE
- 11:25RACING SURFACES AT CHURCHILL
- 11:27DOWNS.
- 11:27I DON'T THINK THEY NEEDED TO
- 11:31MOVE THEIR MEET TO ELLIS PARK.
- 11:35>> Renee: SHOULD THEY HAVE
- 11:36SUSPENDED.
- 11:37DO YOU BELIEVE THEY SHOULD HAVE
- 11:38SUSPENDED THE RACING THERE?
- 11:39>> I DON'T THINK THEY WERE
- 11:42OBLIGATED TO DO SO BUT I DO
- 11:44THINK --
- 11:45>> Renee: HISA DID RECOMMEND IT.
- 11:46>> HISA DID RECOMMEND IT AND
- 11:48WE'RE PROBABLY HEADED TOWARDS
- 11:50TRYING TO FORCE THEM INTO A
- 11:51SHUTDOWN WHICH I DON'T BELIEVE A
- 11:54FEDERAL AGENCY FOLLOWING OUGHT
- 11:56OF THE RULES AND PROTOCOLS
- 11:58SHOULD HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO
- 12:00THAT CAN BE A SEPARATE ISSUE IF
- 12:02YOU WANT TO ADDRESS IT.
- 12:03I THINK CHURCHILL DOWNS TOOK THE
- 12:04HIGH ROAD AND MOVED THE MEET TWO
- 12:08HOURS DOWN THE ROAD TO HENDERSON
- 12:10IN WESTERN KENTUCKY TO ELLIS
- 12:12PARK AND THEY ARE RUNNING THAT
- 12:13THE MEET FOR THE REST OF THIS
- 12:15MONTH AND IT WILL SEGUE INTO THE
- 12:17SUMMER MEET IN JULY AT ELLIS
- 12:19PARK.
- 12:19I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANYTHING
- 12:21WRONG I'VE TALKED TO TRAINERS
- 12:24AND JOCKEYS AND PARTICIPANTS
- 12:26ACROSS THE SPECTRUM AND THEY
- 12:28BELIEVE IT'S SAFE.
- 12:29AND YOUR VIEWERS SHOULD KNOW
- 12:30HERE IN KENTUCKY WE HAVE THE
- 12:33BEST THE INDUSTRY LEADING
- 12:35PROTOCOLS AND RULES AND
- 12:36REGULATIONS.
- 12:37MANY OF WHICH HAVE BEEN ADOPTED
- 12:38ON A FEDERAL BASIS BY HISA.
- 12:40CHURCHILL DOWNS HAS ONE OF THE
- 12:42BEST SAFETY RECORDS OF ANY
- 12:44RACETRACK IN THE COUNTRY.
- 12:45I THINK WHAT WE'VE EXPERIENCED
- 12:48AS A STATISTICAL ANOMALY A
- 12:51CLUSTER OF THESE HORSE INJURIES.
- 12:53AND IT HAPPENS.
- 12:54IT HAPPENS IN LOTS OF OTHER
- 12:56THINGS IN LIFE, CAR ACCIDENTS,
- 12:58TRAIN DERAILMENTS AIRPLANE
- 13:05ACCIDENTS.
- 13:05WE'VE SEEN A STATISTICAL
- 13:06ANOMALY.
- 13:06I DO THINK IT'S IMPORTANT WE
- 13:07CONTINUE TO DO EVERYTHING WE CAN
- 13:08TO PROTECT THE SAFETY OF HORSES
- 13:09AND JOCKEYS.
- 13:10I THINK CHURCHILL DOWNS SHOULD
- 13:12BE COMPLIMENTED FOR TAKING THE
- 13:13HIGH ROAD TO TAKE A STEP BACK,
- 13:17THEY CONTINUE TO DO TESTING OF
- 13:18THE SURFACES DOWN THERE.
- 13:21AND NOTHING IS COMING UP AS
- 13:22BEING WRONG WITH THE SURFACE.
- 13:25>> Renee: Mr. MORRIS DID
- 13:26CHURCHILL DOWNS GET IT RIGHT OR
- 13:27WRONG?
- 13:27>> I THOUGHT THEY GOT IT RIGHT.
- 13:30I THINK THEY ARE EXERCISING AN
- 13:32ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION.
- 13:35LET'S BE VERY FRANK...
- 13:37THE ONLY TIME THAT HORSERACING
- 13:39PIERCES THE VEIL OF POPULAR
- 13:42CULTURE IS DURING THE TRIP
- 13:44ESPECIALLY CROWN STARTING WITH
- 13:45THE KENTUCKY DERBY.
- 13:47THERE'S BEEN TIMES IN THE PAST
- 13:50IN NEW YORK AND CALIFORNIA WHERE
- 13:53THESE STATISTICAL ANOMALIES THAT
- 13:55SENATOR THAYER IS TALKING ABOUT
- 13:57THAT THEY'VE HAPPENED BUT THEY
- 13:59GET TO A LEVEL OF 21
- 14:03CATASTROPHIC BREAKDOWNS.
- 14:0630 CATASTROPHIC BREAKDOWNS.
- 14:07I THINK WHAT SENATOR THAYER SAID
- 14:09IS ABSOLUTELY TRUE.
- 14:11KENTUCKY SHOULD REALLY BE THE
- 14:13BENCHMARK AT WHAT YOU COMPARE
- 14:15EVERYTHING ELSE IN HORSERACING
- 14:17TO.
- 14:17WE HAVE THE INFRASTRUCTURE HERE
- 14:19THAT REALLY NO ONE HAS AND NOW
- 14:21WE HAVE BECAUSE OF ACTIONS OF
- 14:23THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, THE MOST
- 14:26PROFITABLE BUSINESS PLAN HERE
- 14:28FOR HORSERACING IN NORTH
- 14:30AMERICA.
- 14:31BUT BEYOND THAT, THOUGH, WE HAVE
- 14:33A RESPONSIBILITY EVERY SINGLE
- 14:35ONE OF US THAT IS INVOLVED AND
- 14:39EMPLOYED IN RACING HAVE HAD OUR
- 14:42PHONES BURN UP AND PEOPLE THAT
- 14:43ARE NOT INVOLVED IN RACING ASK
- 14:45US WHAT THE HECK IS GOING ON?
- 14:48AND SO I THINK THAT IT WAS
- 14:50RESPONSIBLE THERE'S VERY FEW
- 14:54TRACKS ANYWHERE THAT ARE ABLE TO
- 14:56MOVE THEIR OPERATIONS ON
- 14:58SOMETHING THAT GENERALLY TAKES
- 14:59THREE WEEKS TO GET ANOTHER TRACK
- 15:02PREPARED IN THE SPAN OF FIVE TO
- 15:04SIX DAYS, AND I THINK THAT IT
- 15:07WAS A RESPONSIBLE MOVE.
- 15:09>> Renee: Mr. LEAR YOUR
- 15:10THOUGHTS?
- 15:10>> SURE, I AGREE THEY DID THE
- 15:12RIGHT THING.
- 15:14AND I THINK THE HISA THE ROLE
- 15:18THEY PLAYED WAS IMPORTANT.
- 15:20THEY ASSEMBLED THE TOP EXPERTS
- 15:22TOGETHER.
- 15:23THEY HAD McPETERSON THE GOLD
- 15:29STANDARD THEY HAD HIM LOOK AT
- 15:30THE TRACK.
- 15:33BUT BECAUSE THEY COULDN'T AND I
- 15:35AGREE WITH SENATOR THAYER, I'VE
- 15:38SEEN NOTHING TO INDICATE THAT IT
- 15:39WAS THE FAULT OF THE RACETRACK.
- 15:43BUT THEY DIDN'T KNOW.
- 15:45AND I LOOK AT THE HISTORICAL
- 15:48PERSPECTIVE AND I ENJOYED SOME
- 15:50OF THE SENATOR'S COMMENTS ABOUT
- 15:53HISTORY.
- 15:54KENTUCKY DID ADOPT KENTUCKY
- 15:57ADOPTED WHAT WOULD HAVE BEEN AN
- 15:59INTERSTATE COMPACT 12 YEARS AGO.
- 16:01I DIDN'T REALIZE YOU SPONSORED
- 16:03IT.
- 16:04CONGRATULATIONS.
- 16:05NO OTHER STATE ADOPTED IT.
- 16:07NOBODY WOULD FOLLOW.
- 16:09ANOTHER INTERSTATE COMPACT WAS
- 16:11TRIED UP IN MARYLAND.
- 16:13AND THE PROBLEM WITH THE
- 16:15COMPACTS TO GET PEOPLE ONBOARD
- 16:16YOU HAVE TO AGREE TO LET THEM
- 16:18BACK OUT OF ANY RULE THEY DON'T
- 16:20LIKE OR AGREE TO LET THEM BACK
- 16:22OUT ALTOGETHER.
- 16:23THAT IS WHY THE COMPACT MODEL
- 16:26DID NOT WORK.
- 16:27LOOKING AT THE HISTORICAL
- 16:29CONTEXT AS BAD AS WHAT HAPPENED
- 16:31AT CHURCHILL WAS, IF THERE HAD
- 16:33BEEN A HISA THAT COULD HAVE
- 16:35OFFERED ITS EXPERTISE --
- 16:37AND BY THE WAY IT HAS A WEALTH
- 16:39OF EXPERTISE WHICH I WOULD LIKE
- 16:41TO TALK ABOUT A LITTLE BIT
- 16:45LATER --
- 16:45IF SOMEBODY HAD STEPPED IN AFTER
- 16:48THE FIRST 12 AT SANTA ANITA OR
- 16:51BEFORE THAT, THAT WOULD HAVE
- 16:52BEEN A GREAT THING.
- 16:53IT WOULD HAVE BEEN TERRIBLE JUST
- 16:55LIKE THE 12 AT CHURCHILL WAS
- 16:58TERRIBLE.
- 16:59BUT TO HAVE AN ENTITY THAT HAS
- 17:02THE ABILITY TO BRING IN NOT JUST
- 17:04THE STATE EXPERTS BUT THAT
- 17:07EXPERTS IN BEST PRACTICES AND TO
- 17:09OFFER THE RECOMMENDATION THAT
- 17:10THEY DID.
- 17:12I CONGRATULATE CHURCHILL ON AS
- 17:15WAS SAID TAKING THE HIGH ROAD
- 17:18AND MAKING THE DECISION TO
- 17:21SUSPEND RACING.
- 17:22I WOULD LIKE TO SAY ONE THING...
- 17:28A LAWYER SUCH AS ME CAN'T BACK
- 17:30AWAY FROM THE 10TH AMENDMENT
- 17:33ARGUMENT BY SENATOR THAYER.
- 17:35THE SIXTH CIRCUIT LOOKED AT THE
- 17:39ARGUMENT THAT HISA VIOLATED THE
- 17:4110TH AMENDMENT AND THEY
- 17:42DISMISSED IT OUT OF HAND WHEN
- 17:44THEY UPHELD HISA.
- 17:46BEFORE YOU GET TO THE 10TH
- 17:50AMENDMENT, THERE IS SECTION 8 OF
- 17:53ARTICLE ONE THAT SAYS CONGRESS
- 17:54HAS A RIGHT TO REGULATE COMMERCE
- 17:57AMONG THE STATES.
- 17:59AND THERE IS NO QUESTION BUT THE
- 18:03THOROUGHBRED RACING IS COMMERCE
- 18:04AMONG THE STATES.
- 18:05IN FACT, THE CONGRESS RECOGNIZED
- 18:07THAT IN 1978 WHEN THEY ADOPTED
- 18:10THE INTERSTATE HORSE RAGGING ACT
- 18:12OF 1978 WHICH PROVIDES A LOT OF
- 18:17BACKGROUND FOR MUCH IN
- 18:19THOROUGHBRED RACING AND STANDARD
- 18:21BRED RACING IN THE COUNTRY.
- 18:22IT'S INTERSTATE COMMERCE THEY
- 18:25CAN PREEMPT THE STATES THAT IS
- 18:26WHAT THEY'VE DONE.
- 18:29>> Renee: BUT THERE ARE STILL
- 18:30LAWSUITS GOING ON Mr. AND ERIC
- 18:32HAMELBACK IN INDIANA YOUR
- 18:34ASSOCIATION IS A PLAINTIFF,
- 18:36CORRECT?
- 18:36WHAT ARE YOUR PROBLEMS WITH
- 18:37HISA?
- 18:38WHAT ARE THEY DOING WRONG OR
- 18:39SHOULD NOT BE DOING AT ALL IN
- 18:41YOUR VIEW?
- 18:42>> WELL, THANK YOU RENEE, I
- 18:45APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE
- 18:46ON.
- 18:47I WANT TO FIRST SAY AND BE CLEAR
- 18:49THAT THE NATIONAL HBPA PROMOTES
- 18:53THE HIGHEST STANDARDS OF CARE
- 18:55FOR OUR RACE HORSES AND WE
- 18:57DEMAND THE HIGHEST PROTOCOLS FOR
- 19:01SAFETY TO BE IMPLEMENTED BOTH
- 19:03FOR THE EQUINE ATHLETES AND OUR
- 19:05HUMAN ATHLETES THAT ARE ABOARD.
- 19:08YES, IT IS TRUE THAT THE
- 19:11NATIONAL HBPA IS ONE OF THE SIX
- 19:14LAWSUITS THAT HAVE BEEN FILED
- 19:16CHALLENGING THE HISA
- 19:18CONSTITUTIONALITY.
- 19:19BUT TO BE VERY CLEAR, IT IS VERY
- 19:24MUCH BECAUSE OF THE
- 19:26CONSTITUTIONALITY.
- 19:27WHAT I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
- 19:29CONTINUE TO CONVEY IS THAT WE
- 19:31WANT TO MAKE SURE THINGS ARE
- 19:33DONE PROPERLY AND LEGALLY.
- 19:35PERIOD.
- 19:36WE HAVE FOR MANY YEARS ADVOCATED
- 19:40UNIFORMITY, NOT ONLY IN SAFETY
- 19:42BUT CERTAINLY WITH LABORATORY
- 19:44UNIFORMITY AND WE HAVE HAD BEEN
- 19:47BEHIND MANY EFFORTS TO TRY TO
- 19:48GET THAT DONE.
- 19:49AND NATALIE'S PIECE SHE WAS SPOT
- 19:51ON.
- 19:53IT WAS OFTENTIMES LEFT UP TO THE
- 19:56STATES TO TRY TO PUT THEM
- 19:58TOGETHER.
- 19:59BUT I ALSO BELIEVE THAT WE DON'T
- 20:01GET THE CREDIT THAT THE
- 20:03HORSERACING INDUSTRY DESERVES
- 20:05FOR THE UNIFORMITY THAT WE HAD.
- 20:07AND I POINT TO THE MID-ATLANTIC
- 20:09STATE.
- 20:11THE MID-ATLANTIC STATES IS
- 20:13COMPRISED OF FIVE AFFILIATES AND
- 20:17SIX HBPA AFFILIATES AND THEY
- 20:21OPERATED UNDER THE NATIONAL
- 20:22UNIFORM MEDICATION PROGRAM.
- 20:24THE PROBLEM WE NOW HAVE WITH
- 20:26HISA IS THAT THEY HAVE
- 20:29UNFORTUNATELY, NOT ADOPTED THE
- 20:31RULES THAT WERE IN PLACE.
- 20:33THEY HAVE DECIDED TO CHANGE OR
- 20:35SOME PEOPLE HAVE SAID BLOWN UP
- 20:37THE RULES SUCH AS HAVING CHANGES
- 20:42THAT ARE OVERWHELMING TO THE
- 20:44POINT WHERE IT'S CAUSED A LOT OF
- 20:46CHAOS.
- 20:48BUT TO BE CLEAR, WE AS AN
- 20:49ORGANIZATION, CONTINUE TO WORK
- 20:50AS BEST WE CAN TO HELP WITH
- 20:54FUTURE REGULATIONS DEPENDING HOW
- 20:57HISA IS DECIDED IN THE COURT
- 20:59SYSTEM IT'S VERY IMPORTANT TO
- 21:01UNDERSTAND VERY IMPORTANT FOR
- 21:03YOUR AUDIENCE TO UNDERSTAND
- 21:04THERE ARE TWO ASPECTS HERE.
- 21:05WE HAVE THE LAW, WE HAVE THE ACT
- 21:08ITSELF, THAT IS WHAT IS BEING
- 21:10CHALLENGED.
- 21:10WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
- 21:12REGULATIONS, WE AS AN
- 21:14ORGANIZATION AS WITH MANY OTHERS
- 21:16INCLUDING THE OTHER HORSEMEN'S
- 21:18GROUPS IN THE UNITED STATES,
- 21:19HAVE ALL TRIED TO OFFER
- 21:22COMMENTS, OFFER CHANGES, AND
- 21:25HAVE SOME INPUT.
- 21:28UNFORTUNATELY VERY FEW OF THOSE
- 21:29HAVE BEEN TAKEN AND IN OUR
- 21:31OPINION NOT HAVING INPUT FROM
- 21:33THE FOLKS WHO ARE WITH BOOTS ON
- 21:36THE GROUND.
- 21:37>> Renee: BUT THE ORGANIZATION
- 21:39HISA DOES HAVE REPRESENTATION
- 21:42FROM HORSEMEN, CORRECT?
- 21:54>> THEY DID FORM A HORSEMEN'S
- 21:58ADVISORY COMMITTEE LAST YEAR
- 22:01AFTER APRETTY BAD ROLL OUT TO BE
- 22:04FAIR.
- 22:04I THINK THERE'S UNANIMOUS
- 22:06OPINION IN THE HORSE BUSINESS
- 22:07THAT THE ROLLOUT OF HISA LAST
- 22:10YEAR WAS BOTCHED.
- 22:12>> WELL, THE ROLLOUT WAS BOTCHED
- 22:13BY ALL THE LAWSUITS.
- 22:15THEY WERE DEALING WITH LAWSUITS
- 22:17FROM BEFORE THE ROLLOUT,
- 22:19SENATOR.
- 22:19>> TO BE FAIR THERE WERE PEOPLE
- 22:21ON THE GROUND WHO DIDN'T KNOW
- 22:22WHICH SET OF RULES THEY WERE
- 22:25OPERATING UNDER WEEK TO WEEK.
- 22:26AND I KNOW BECAUSE I AM INVOLVED
- 22:29IN A HORSE PARTNERSHIP AND THERE
- 22:30WERE RULES THAT ONE WEEK WOULD
- 22:32HAVE ALLOWED OUR HORSE TO RUN
- 22:33AND THEN THE NEXT WEEK WOULDN'T
- 22:36HAVE ALLOWED OUR HORSE TO RUN
- 22:38AND NOBODY KNEW ABOUT IT.
- 22:40AND --
- 22:40>> I DO NOT THINK THAT IS A FAIR
- 22:43CHARACTERIZATION TO SAY ANY OF
- 22:45THE LEGALITIES BOTCHED THE
- 22:47ROLLOUT.
- 22:47Mr. LEAR, I RESPECTFULLY
- 22:49DISAGREE.
- 22:50AT END OF THE DAY THE
- 22:53REGULATIONS WERE PUT IN PLACE
- 22:56AND AT THE END OF THE DAY, THE
- 22:59LAWSUITS HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH
- 23:00THE ROLLOUT.
- 23:01AS A MATTER OF FACT, HISA DIDN'T
- 23:03EVEN GET THE PROGRAM EFFECTIVE
- 23:05DATE CORRECT.
- 23:06EVERYTHING WAS SUPPOSED TO GO
- 23:08INTO PLACE JULY FIRST OF 2022.
- 23:13HOWEVER, THE ABMC PROGRAM DID
- 23:15NOT GO INTO EFFECT UNTIL
- 23:17RECENTLY.
- 23:18I DON'T THINK IT IS ANY FAIR
- 23:20CHARACTERIZATION TO SAY THAT THE
- 23:23LITIGATION BOTCHED ANY ROLL OUT.
- 23:25NOT MY WORDS BUT AT THE END OF
- 23:26THE DAY THERE WAS QUITE A BIT OF
- 23:30CHAOS, CALLS, FROM THE ROLLOUTS
- 23:32BECAUSE THE IMPLEMENTATION QUITE
- 23:34FRANKLY WASN'T READY.
- 23:36AND FAIRNESS TO MS. LAZARUS SHE
- 23:39WAS NOT IN PLACE UNTIL RIGHT
- 23:41BEFORE THE SAFETY REGULATIONS
- 23:42WERE APPROVED BY THE FFC.
- 23:47>> Renee: WHEN YOU SAID MS.
- 23:50LAZARUS, THE C.E.O. OF HISA.
- 23:52WE DO HAVE THIS QUESTION OFF
- 23:54THAT TOPIC, IT'S NO SECRET HE
- 23:59SAYS THAT THE HORSE AMBULANCE AT
- 24:01THE RACETRACK DOESN'T TAKE THE
- 24:02INJURED HORSE TO A HORSE
- 24:04HOSPITAL.
- 24:05SINCE MANY FRACTURES LEAD TO
- 24:07EUTHANASIA BECAUSE OF THE COST
- 24:09OF REHABILITATION SHOULDN'T THE
- 24:10COST OF TREATMENT OF
- 24:12THOROUGHBRED INJURIES BE
- 24:13MANDATED?
- 24:14>> THAT IS IN FACT NOT TRUE.
- 24:16THE HORSE AMBULANCE ITS FIRST
- 24:18GOAL IS TO STABILIZE AN INJURED
- 24:21HORSE.
- 24:22IF AN INJURY OCCURS DURING A
- 24:24RACE, THE ON CALL VETERINARIANS
- 24:28THEIR PRIMARY JOB IS TO
- 24:29STABILIZE THAT HORSE AND TRY TO
- 24:31GET THEM TO VETERINARY CARE AS
- 24:33SOON AS POSSIBLE.
- 24:34NOW, SOMETIMES UNFORTUNATELY,
- 24:37THOSE INJURIES ARE WHAT WE CALL
- 24:39CATASTROPHIC AND IT'S IN THE
- 24:41BEST INTEREST OF THE HORSE TO
- 24:43EUTHANIZE THE HORSE SO IT A
- 24:45DOESN'T SUFFER AND B, THE
- 24:47VETERINARIAN MAKES A CALL BASED
- 24:49ON THE LIKELIHOOD OF THE INJURY
- 24:51BEING ABLE TO BE REPAIRED.
- 24:52I WANT TO POINT OUT BACK TO MY
- 24:55PREVIOUS POINT ABOUT THIS
- 24:57CLUSTER OF INJURIES, IN THE LAST
- 24:59FOUR YEARS, THE SAFETY PROTOCOLS
- 25:02BEING IMPLEMENTED ACROSS THE
- 25:04COUNTRY IN MOST STATES, PLACES
- 25:06LIKE KENTUCKY, CALIFORNIA,
- 25:07LEADING THE WAY, THE HORSE
- 25:10INDUSTRY HAS CUT BACK
- 25:12SUBSTANTIALLY.
- 25:13IF YOU LOOK AT THE JOCKEY CLUB
- 25:15INJURY DATABASE THEY MEASURE IT
- 25:18BASED ON THE NUMBER OF FATAL
- 25:21INJURIES PER 1,000 STARTS AND
- 25:23FOR YEARS THAT AVERAGE WAS TWO
- 25:27EQUINE FATALITIES PER 1,000
- 25:30STARTS THE.
- 25:31THAT NUMBER IS IS DOWN TO 1.25%%
- 25:36ALMOST CUT IN HALF THE STEPS WE
- 25:38ARE TAKING BEFORE HISA WAS
- 25:41FORCED ON A STATE BY STATE BASIS
- 25:43ARE LEADING TO BETTER SAFETY
- 25:45PROTOCOLS FOR HORSES.
- 25:46AND THERE'S TECHNOLOGY OUT THERE
- 25:48LIKE STRIDE SAFE I WENT TO ELLIS
- 25:51PARK YESTERDAY.
- 25:52DROVE THREE HOURS TO GET THERE
- 25:54TO SHOW MY SUPPORT FOR THE
- 25:56MOVEMENT OF THE MEET THERE AND I
- 25:58TALKED TO MY FRIEND AND HE IS
- 26:00WORKING WITH A COMPANY CALLED
- 26:02STRIDE SAFE.
- 26:02EVERYONE OF HIS HORSES THAT
- 26:04TRAINS AT CHURCHILL DOWNS IN THE
- 26:06MORNING HAS TECHNOLOGY BUILT
- 26:07INTO THEIR SADDLE TOWEL THAT IS
- 26:10ABLE TO DETECT THE POSSIBILITIES
- 26:12FOR INJURIES SO TRAINERS HAVE
- 26:16THESE DIAGNOSTIC TOOLS TO KNOW
- 26:18IF THE HORSES HAVE A PROBLEM AND
- 26:21NEED TO TAKE A BREAK.
- 26:24I APPLAUD THEM TO GATHER ENOUGH
- 26:26DATA TO SEE IF THIS IS SOMETHING
- 26:28WE CAN IMPLEMENT.
- 26:29THERE ARE PROTOCOLS DEVELOPED
- 26:32EVERYDAY AND TECHNOLOGY
- 26:33DEVELOPED EVERYDAY AND RULES
- 26:35VICE-PRESIDENTED EVERYDAY WITH
- 26:36THE SAFETY OF THE HORSES AND THE
- 26:38JOCKEYS IN MIND.
- 26:40>> Renee: HOLD ON JUST A MINUTE.
- 26:42>> THESE HE IS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT
- 26:44AND THE BEAUTY OF THIS OCCURRING
- 26:47IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY
- 26:49IS THIS GRANT, THAT FACILITATED
- 26:53THE STRIDE SAFE WEARABLE
- 26:55MONITORS CAME BY THE EQUINE DRUG
- 26:58RESEARCH COUNCIL.
- 26:59IT IS NOT ONLY Mr. ROMAN'S
- 27:02IT'S MULTIPLE TRAINERS THAT ARE
- 27:03DOING THIS AND DOING IT AS PART
- 27:05OF A STUDY.
- 27:06BECAUSE TO THE QUESTION, IT'S
- 27:11NOT FACTUALLY THE CASE NUMBER
- 27:12ONE.
- 27:13AND NUMBER TWO WE WANT TO DO
- 27:14EVERYTHING THAT WE POSSIBLY CAN
- 27:16IN ORDER TO INSURE THE SAFETY OF
- 27:18OUR EQUINE AND HUMAN ATHLETES.
- 27:23>> Renee: SORRY, SIR.
- 27:23THANK YOU FOR WAITING.
- 27:24>> THAT'S FINE.
- 27:25I WANTED TO COMPOUND WHAT
- 27:27SENATOR THAYER AND CHAUNCEY WERE
- 27:30SAYING.
- 27:31IF YOU LOOK AT THE REGULATIONS,
- 27:33HORSEMEN HAVE CONTINUED TO
- 27:35COMPLY YEAR AFTER YEAR AFTER
- 27:37YEAR.
- 27:37AND ALONG THE SAME LINES AS WHAT
- 27:40SENATOR THAYER WAS SAYING, SINCE
- 27:432009 AND THAT WAS WHEN THE EQUAN
- 27:47INJURY --
- 27:48EQUINE INJURY DATABASE WAS
- 27:50STARTED WE'VE SEEN A 30%
- 27:52REDUCTION.
- 27:53IT'S BEEN OVER MULTIPLE YEARS
- 27:55THAT THE FATALITY RATES HAVE
- 27:57COME DOWN.
- 27:57IT'S VERY IMPORTANT THAT
- 27:59EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS THAT ONCE
- 28:01THE INVESTIGATIONS ARE COMPLETE,
- 28:06HOPEFULLY THAT GOING TO BE ONE
- 28:08DISCERNIBLE FACTOR THAT LINKS
- 28:09ALL OF THE BREAKDOWNS ON THE
- 28:11TRACK WHICH IS NINE.
- 28:12I THINK THERE ARE THREE THAT ARE
- 28:16OUTSIDE OF THE COMPETITION ON
- 28:18THE TRACK.
- 28:19BUT I THINK IT'S ALSO VERY
- 28:21IMPORTANT FOR EVERYONE TO
- 28:23UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH THE HORSEMEN
- 28:24HAVE CONTINUED TO COMPLY OVER
- 28:26THESE MANY YEARS AND WE HAVE
- 28:28REDUCED BECAUSE OF OUR SAFETY
- 28:30EFFORTS AND INITIATIVES REDUCED
- 28:32THE FATALITY RATE 37.5% SINCE
- 28:362009.
- 28:36>> LET ME BRING THIS BACK TO
- 28:38WHERE WE STARTED.
- 28:39AND CHAUNCEY MADE A GOOD POINT.
- 28:42WE HAVE NOW FOUND OUR WAY INTO
- 28:44THE MAINSTREAM MEDIA.
- 28:46WHY?
- 28:47BECAUSE PEOPLE HAVE SEEN A LARGE
- 28:50NUMBER OF EQUINE FATALITIES.
- 28:53MAYBE WE GOT COMPLACENT AFTER
- 28:57THE AFTERMATH OF SANTA ANITA.
- 28:59I DON'T KNOW THAT WE DID
- 29:00THINKING WE WOULDN'T HAVE
- 29:02ANOTHER CLUSTER FROM WHATEVER
- 29:05COST.
- 29:06BUT THE PUBLIC WANTS TO KNOW
- 29:07THAT WE ARE DOING THE ABSOLUTE
- 29:09BEST WE CAN TO DEAL WITH THE
- 29:11SAFETY OF THESE ATHLETES.
- 29:13AND TO COME BACK TO WHAT I
- 29:15ELUDED TO EARLIER, I WISH
- 29:18EVERYBODY WOULD LOOK AT THE BIOS
- 29:21THE RESUMES OF THE PEOPLE THAT
- 29:23ARE NOW WITH HISA.
- 29:25NOT JUST TAKING --
- 29:27KENTUCKY HAS BEEN A LEADER.
- 29:28I DON'T DISPUTE THAT I'M PROUD
- 29:30OF MANY THINGS WE'VE DONE.
- 29:32AND THEY HAVE TAKEN A LOT OF THE
- 29:34BEST PRACTICES.
- 29:35BUT NOT EVERYBODY.
- 29:36I'M SORRY, ERIC, NOT EVERY
- 29:40HORSEMEN IN THE COUNTRY HAVE
- 29:42FOLLOWED THE RULES.
- 29:43WE SAW FEDERAL INDICTMENTS ON
- 29:44THE MEDICATION SIDE OF PEOPLE
- 29:47OPERATING PROMINENT PEOPLE, 27
- 29:48INDICTMENTS I THINK, RIGHT UNDER
- 29:50THE NOSES OF REGULATORS THAT
- 29:52WEREN'T JUST --
- 29:53>> THAT WAS NOT 27.
- 29:55PLEASE MAKE THAT CLEAR.
- 29:56>> IT WAS 27 INDICTMENTS.
- 29:58THEY WERE NOT ALL THE
- 30:00THOROUGHBRED INDUSTRY BUT THEY
- 30:01WERE INVOLVED ONE WAY OR ANOTHER
- 30:03IN RACING.
- 30:05AND I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY YEARS
- 30:06OF JAIL TIME AND FINES THAT
- 30:08ADDED UP TO.
- 30:09BUT THE POINT IS THAT WAS GOING
- 30:11ON RIGHT UNDER THE NOSES OF
- 30:15REGULATORS.
- 30:16AND NOW WE'VE MADE IT BACK INTO
- 30:18THE NATIONAL MEDIA, AGAIN, AND
- 30:22HISA HAS PULLED MANY OF THE BEST
- 30:25FROM KENTUCKY.
- 30:26SOMEBODY MENTIONED THE EDRC ONE
- 30:30OF THE MEMBERS OF ONE OF THE
- 30:31STANDING COMMITTEES IS Dr.
- 30:33JERRY YOUNG FROM KENTUCKY NOW IS
- 30:35A FLORIDA RESIDENT BUT HE WAS
- 30:37FORMER CHAIRMAN OF THE ERDC HE
- 30:41HELPED.
- 30:43>> Renee: EQUINE DRUG RESEARCH
- 30:46COUNCIL.
- 30:46>> .
- 30:47>> YOU'VE GOT MARK, HE IS A GOOD
- 30:50FRIEND OF YOURS HE IS SOMEBODY
- 30:51THAT I RESPECT A LOT.
- 30:53HE IS WORKING WITH HISA.
- 30:55YOU'VE GOT THE RETIRED PRESIDENT
- 30:57OF THE KEEN LAND BILL THOMPSON
- 30:59ON THE BOARD.
- 31:01AND FORMER GOVERNOR BESHEAR ON
- 31:02THE BOARD.
- 31:03THERE IS A LOT OF EXPERTISE FROM
- 31:05KENTUCKY BUT ALSO FROM AROUND
- 31:07THE COUNTRY.
- 31:08SO IF I'M OUT THERE IN THE
- 31:09GENERAL PUBLIC AND I'M SAYING IS
- 31:12THIS INDUSTRY I KNOW ERIC, THAT
- 31:15WE'VE MADE PROGRESS.
- 31:16THE JOCKEY CLUB THAT SETUP THE
- 31:19EQUINE INJURY DATABASE.
- 31:20IT WAS VOLUNTARY.
- 31:22ALTHOUGH WE'VE GOT ABOUT 99%
- 31:25COMPLIANCE BUT IT WAS VOLUNTARY.
- 31:28AND IT IS NOT TRANSPARENT
- 31:30BECAUSE ON A TRACK BY TRACK
- 31:32BASIS WE DON'T RELEASE THE
- 31:35NUMBERS.
- 31:35BUT WE'VE PULLED TOGETHER THIS
- 31:38EXPERTISE FROM AROUND THE
- 31:40COUNTRY TO BRING IT ALL TO BEAR
- 31:42ON SAFETY AND ON MEDICATION.
- 31:44AND I THINK THAT IS WHAT THE
- 31:45PUBLIC WANTS.
- 31:47>> Renee: WHY NOT THE
- 31:48TRANSPARENCY IN SEEING THE
- 31:50NUMBERS TRACK BY TRACK?
- 31:51>> THAT IS WHAT IT TOOK TO GET
- 31:54THE INFORMATION TO BEGIN WITH.
- 31:55AND THAT'S WHEN YOU DO IT
- 31:57PRIVATELY, THAT SOMETIMES THE
- 31:58BEST YOU CAN DO.
- 31:59>> THIS IS THE MODEL IF YOU
- 32:01DON'T MIND FROM HUMAN MEDICINE
- 32:03AS WELL, THAT THEY FIND THAT
- 32:05YOU'RE DIAGNOSE TO HAVE MORE
- 32:07FULL SOME STATEMENTS ON THE
- 32:10VORACITY OF THE INJURIES AND
- 32:11WHAT MIGHT HAVE LED TO THEM SO
- 32:13THAT IT FULFILLS YOU GET A
- 32:16BETTER INVESTIGATION AT THE END
- 32:17OF THE DAY.
- 32:18>> Renee: WHEN THERE'S PRIVACY.
- 32:21>> BILL WAS TALKING ABOUT THE
- 32:23EQUINE DRUG RESEARCH COUNCIL.
- 32:24I SERVED ON THE EQUINE DRUG
- 32:27RESEARCH COUNCIL IT'S MANDATED
- 32:29THERE BE ONE LEGISLATOR ON THAT
- 32:31BOARD AND I WAS APPOINTED BY
- 32:33GOVERNOR FLETCHER AND
- 32:35REAPPOINTED BY GOVERNOR BESHEAR
- 32:37AND MATT BEVIN I SERVED ON IT
- 32:39FOR 15 YEARS UNTIL ANDY BESHEAR
- 32:42KICKED ME OFF.
- 32:43DURING THAT TIME I WORKED WITH
- 32:44MARK ONE OF MY CLOSEST FRIENDS
- 32:46AND Dr. MARY SKA LAY TO
- 32:49RECOMMEND TO THE RACING
- 32:51COMMISSION SOME OF THE BEST
- 32:53HORSERACING MEDICATION AND
- 32:55INTEGRITY RULES OF THE COUNTRY.
- 32:57KENTUCKY USED TO BE THE WILD,
- 32:59WILD WEST AND WE'VE CLEANED IT
- 33:00UP AND MADE IT A MODEL.
- 33:02YES, I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT
- 33:05MARK AND MARY HAVE MOVED ON FROM
- 33:10KENTUCKY TO IMPLEMENT THESE
- 33:12RULES ON A NATIONAL BASIS.
- 33:15AND THAT --
- 33:16THEIR PRESENCE GIVES ME SOME
- 33:18LEVEL OF CONFIDENCE THAT HISA
- 33:20WILL DO THE RIGHT THING.
- 33:23BUT ULTIMATELY ONE OF TWO THINGS
- 33:24IS GOING TO HAPPEN WITH HISA.
- 33:26EITHER IT'S GOING TO BE RULED
- 33:30UNCONSTITUTIONAL BY THE SUPREME
- 33:31COURT OF THE UNITED STATES AND
- 33:31THE CHANCES OF THAT HAPPENING
- 33:33ARE LESS THAN 50% BUT THE
- 33:34CHANCES ARE STILL THERE.
- 33:36IF THAT'S THE CASE, THEN WE NEED
- 33:38TO GO BACK AND REVISIT THE
- 33:40INTERSTATE COMPACT MODEL.
- 33:41THERE WAS A BILL FILED IN
- 33:43CONGRESS TODAY BY CONGRESSMAN
- 33:44FROM TEXAS THAT WOULD REPLACE
- 33:47HISA WITH A NEW LAW THAT HAS
- 33:51SOME OF THE SIMILARITIES TO HISA
- 33:53BUT IT WOULD BE THROUGH AN
- 33:55INTERSTATE COMPACT MODEL CALLED
- 33:56THE RACE HORSE HEALTH AND SAFETY
- 33:58ACT OF 2023.
- 33:59AND IT WAS FILED BY CONGRESSMAN
- 34:03LANCE GOOD FROM TEXAS.
- 34:05SO THERE ARE OTHER ALTERNATIVES
- 34:07OUT THERE.
- 34:08THE OTHER OPTION IS THAT HISA IS
- 34:11FOUND CONSTITUTIONAL.
- 34:13AND THEN WE'RE ALL GOING TO HAVE
- 34:15TO LIVE WITH IT.
- 34:16AND I WOULD JUST LIKE TO SEE
- 34:19HISA GET BACK TO ITS ORIGINAL
- 34:22CHARTER WHICH WAS TO FOCUS ON
- 34:26UNIFORM MEDICATION REGULATIONS
- 34:28ACROSS MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS.
- 34:30PART OF THE PROBLEM WITH THE
- 34:31ROLLOUT IS THAT THEY TRIED TO DO
- 34:33TOO MUCH TOO SOON AND THEY LOST
- 34:37THE CONFIDENCE OF THE
- 34:38RANK-AND-FILE HORSEMEN.
- 34:39SO THERE IS NOT A LOT OF
- 34:40CONFIDENCE OUT THERE AT
- 34:42RACETRACKS ACROSS AMERICA THAT
- 34:44HISA IS THE WAY TO GO.
- 34:46SO IF IT IS FOUND
- 34:48CONSTITUTIONAL, I WOULD
- 34:50ENCOURAGE A PAUSE AND A RESET TO
- 34:54FOCUS ON THESE MEDICATION RULES
- 34:56WHICH JUST WENT INTO EFFECT LAST
- 34:58MONTH.
- 34:59AND A LOT OF THE THINGS THAT
- 35:01WERE SORT OF ROLLED OUT IN A
- 35:05INCONGRUENT FASHION NEED TO BE
- 35:07REVISITED FOCUS ON THE CORE
- 35:10CONTENT OF THE CONGRESSIONAL
- 35:10CHARTER THAT WAS PASSED AND
- 35:12SIGNED INTO LAW BY PRESIDENT
- 35:14TRUMP.
- 35:14>> Renee: AND WAS CHAMPIONED BY
- 35:16MITCH McCONNELL AND ANDY BAR,
- 35:19DID THEY GET IT WRONG?
- 35:20THEY WERE SUPPORTIVE OF THE ACT?
- 35:22>> AND THE ACT DOES --
- 35:26>> Renee: I WANT TO HEAR WHAT
- 35:27LEADER THAYER HAS TO SAY?
- 35:30DID THEY GET IT WRONG?
- 35:31>> I DON'T THINK THEY GOT IT
- 35:33WRONG I'M CLOSE TO LEADER
- 35:35McCONNELL AND CONGRESSMAN BAR.
- 35:37AND I HAVE EXPRESSED BY CONCERNS
- 35:39CONSISTENTLY TO THEM ABOUT HISA.
- 35:44AND THEY LISTEN TO ME AS A
- 35:45CONSTITUENT OF THEIRS.
- 35:47I FEEL LIKE I'M THE VOICE OF
- 35:50PEOPLE WHO DON'T FEEL LIKE THEY
- 35:51ARE BEING HEARD BY HISA.
- 35:55AND AGAIN, THE CONSTITUTIONALITY
- 35:57IS GOING TO BE DECIDED BY THE
- 35:59COURTS AND I WILL LIVE BY THAT
- 36:01DECISION.
- 36:02I'M NOT SUING HISA.
- 36:03I'M NOT VICE-CHAIRMAN OF THE
- 36:05JOCKEY CLUB THE NUMBER ONE
- 36:08PROPONENT IN AMERICA FOR HISA'S
- 36:10IMPLEMENTATION AND I'M NOT
- 36:11SAYING WE NEED TO PULL IT OUT BY
- 36:12THE ROOTS.
- 36:13AND BY THE WAY I'VE OFFERED AN
- 36:16ALTERNATIVE TO HISA 12 YEARS AGO
- 36:17THAT IS ON THE BOOKS HERE IN
- 36:19KENTUCKY AN INTERSTATE COMPACT.
- 36:22>> Renee: BUT Mr. LEAR SAID IT
- 36:24DIDN'T WORK?
- 36:24>> IT DIDN'T WORK.
- 36:26I WAS LAUGHED AT BY MANY
- 36:28FACTIONS OF THE HORSE INDUSTRY
- 36:29WHO SAID THIS WILL NEVER WORK.
- 36:31IF HISA IS FOUND
- 36:33UNCONSTITUTIONAL I DO THINK
- 36:33THERE IS MORE OF A PRESSING NEED
- 36:35AND PEOPLE WHO ARE OPPOSED TO MY
- 36:38INTERSTATE COMPACT APPROACH DO
- 36:40RECOGNIZE THE NEED FOR
- 36:42CONSISTENT UNIFORM RULES ACROSS
- 36:44MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS.
- 36:45THAT IS WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 36:47HERE.
- 36:48AND THAT MEANS WE HAVE TO HAVE
- 36:50THE RIGHT WITHDRAWAL TIMES FOR
- 36:52THERAPEUTIC MEDICATIONS.
- 36:54THE RIGHT DOSING AMOUNTS FOR
- 36:56THERAPEUTIC MEDICATIONS ACROSS
- 36:58JURISDICTIONS.
- 36:58I'M FOR THAT.
- 37:00I'VE ALWAYS BEEN FOR THAT.
- 37:02I'M ON THE RECORD AS BEING FOUND
- 37:04THAT.
- 37:04I HELPED FOUND THOSE RULES IN
- 37:07KENTUCKY.
- 37:08I'M JUST SAYING I WOULD LIKE TO
- 37:10SEE HISA IN IT CONTINUES FORWARD
- 37:11TO FOCUS ON THE MEDICATION SIDE
- 37:13OF THINGS.
- 37:14>> Renee: Mr. LEAR, AND THEN
- 37:16Mr. HAMELBACK.
- 37:19>> HISA WAS ADOPTED AFTER BEING
- 37:24IN CONGRESS IN VARIOUS FORMS FOR
- 37:27ABOUT FIVE DIFFERENT SESSIONS.
- 37:29FIRST WAS FILED ONLY MEDICATION
- 37:32IN 2015.
- 37:33BUT THE VERSION THAT WAS FINALLY
- 37:36ADOPTED AND CHAMPIONED BY
- 37:40MAJORITY LEADER McCONNELL AS
- 37:43WELL AS REPRESENTATIVE BAR,
- 37:45BROADENED IT TO INCLUDE TRACK
- 37:47SAFETY.
- 37:48SO BOTH OF THOSE ARE CENTER OF
- 37:52THE FAIRWAY RESPONSIBILITIES OF
- 37:56THIS ORGANIZATION.
- 37:58THEY OVERLAP BUT THEY ARE
- 38:02DISTINCT BASES OF AUTHORITY.
- 38:03HISA COULDN'T GO BACK AND ONLY
- 38:07WORK ON THE MEDICATION SIDE IF
- 38:10IT WANTED TO.
- 38:11BECAUSE THE STATUTE REQUIRE IT
- 38:12IS TO DO BOTH.
- 38:14NOW, YES, THE JOCKEY CLUB WAS A
- 38:17HUGE SUPPORTER OF HISA.
- 38:19SO WAS THE BREEDERS CUP.
- 38:20SO WERE TRACKS LIKE KEEN LAND,
- 38:24SO ULTIMATELY CHURCHILL DOWNS,
- 38:29NIRA, ALSO IN THIS PULLS US BACK
- 38:31TO THE EQUINE SAFETY AND THE
- 38:34SAFETY OF OUR HUMAN ATHLETES AS
- 38:37WELL.
- 38:38SO DID HUMAN MAIN SOCIETY OF THE
- 38:40UNITED STATES.
- 38:41SO DID ASPCA LEADING ANIMAL NOT
- 38:46ANIMAL RIGHTS NOT LIKE PETA BUT
- 38:49ANIMAL WELFARE ORGANIZATIONS IN
- 38:51AMERICA SUPPORTED THIS AS A WAY
- 38:54TO PROTECT THE HORSES.
- 38:57SO.
- 38:57>> Renee: BUT NOT TO UNDERMINE
- 38:59THE SPORT.
- 38:59THERE WAS CONCERN THEY WERE
- 39:01PERHAPS WORKING TO UNDERMINE THE
- 39:03SPORT?
- 39:04>> THERE IS STILL THAT CONCERN
- 39:05THAT THOSE ORGANIZATIONS DON'T
- 39:06HAVE A LOT OF TRUST FACTOR
- 39:08BECAUSE THERE ARE A LOT OF
- 39:10EXTREMISTS IN THIS COUNTRY THAT
- 39:11WOULD LIKE TO LET THE HORSES RUN
- 39:15FREE.
- 39:15>> Renee: AND Mr. HAMELBACK, I
- 39:18WILL POSE MY QUESTION FROM A
- 39:20FORM OF A TWEET WE NEED TO GET
- 39:24MORE DRUGS TO GET THE NO HORSES
- 39:27THROUGH THE HISA VET CHECKS.
- 39:29I WILL GO TO YOU AND THEN I WILL
- 39:31GET Mr. MORRIS HERE.
- 39:33>> I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND IF
- 39:36THAT WAS A QUESTION.
- 39:38>> Renee: IT WAS A COMMENT, SIR
- 39:39AND I WAS HOPING YOU WOULD GIVE
- 39:42US YOUR THOUGHTS DO YOU AGREE?
- 39:43>> ABSOLUTELY I DON'T AGREE.
- 39:46I THINK AT THE END OF THE DAY
- 39:47YOU HAVE TO REALIZE AND MOST
- 39:49PEOPLE DON'T, ESPECIALLY IN
- 39:52TWITTERVERSE BUT THE SCRUTINY
- 39:55THAT THE RACE HORSE IS UNDER NOW
- 39:57BOTH FROM A VETERINARY EXAM
- 40:01PROCESS, REGULATORY EXAM
- 40:03PROCESS, AND TESTING POST RACE
- 40:06AND OR OUT OF COMPETITION, THERE
- 40:10IS NOT A MAGIC DRUG THAT HORSES
- 40:13ARE GETTING THAT GET THEM TO THE
- 40:15RACETRACK.
- 40:15IF YOU LOOK AT THE COMMONALITY
- 40:19OF ALL OF THE HORSES AT
- 40:24CHURCHILL, THERE ARE TWO THINGS;
- 40:26ONE OBVIOUSLY IT HAPPENED AT
- 40:28CHURCHILL BUT TWO, THEY ALL WENT
- 40:30THROUGH THE SAME REGULATORY
- 40:33PROCESS AND VETERINARY EXAM.
- 40:35AND YET, THE BULLET POINTS OR
- 40:37THE SAFETY INITIATIVES THAT WERE
- 40:39BROUGHT OUT DID NOT TALK ABOUT A
- 40:42REEVALUATION OF THOSE PROTOCOLS.
- 40:44SO WE'VE GOT TO LET THE HORSE
- 40:46TELL US WHAT THE PROBLEM IS.
- 40:48AND I THINK THAT AND SENATOR
- 40:51THAYER MENTIONED IT, THERE IS
- 40:53TECHNOLOGY OUT THERE INCLUDING
- 40:55STRIDE SAFE.
- 40:56I THINK THAT IS AN AVENUE THAT
- 40:58CONTINUES TO BE RESEARCHED,
- 41:01CONTINUES TO BE EXPLORED AS A
- 41:04MATTER OF FACT I BELIEVE WHEN IT
- 41:05FIRST CAME FROM AUSTRALIA, THE
- 41:07FIRST INITIAL TEST BEFORE IT
- 41:09WENT TO NEW YORK WERE DONE WITH
- 41:11THE WASHINGTON HBPA AT EMERALD
- 41:14DOWNS AND THEY ARE GOING BACK
- 41:16THERE WITH ELLIS.
- 41:17IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE
- 41:18UNDERSTAND THERE IS TECHNOLOGY
- 41:19OUT THERE.
- 41:20BUT THOSE WHO CONTINUE TO
- 41:22FALSELY USE THE RHETORIC THAT
- 41:24TRAINERS ARE DOPING HORSES, AND
- 41:27GETTING THEM TO THE RACETRACK
- 41:29IT'S ABSOLUTELY LUDICROUS AND
- 41:31JUST NOT TRUE AND THEY DON'T YOU
- 41:33HAD WHAT THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT.
- 41:35>> Renee: Mr. MORRIS?
- 41:35>> I THINK THE TWEET WAS
- 41:38REFERRING TO PUBLIC STATEMENTS
- 41:39THAT THE HBPA HAS MADE ABOUT THE
- 41:42USE OF THERAPEUTIC DRUGS.
- 41:44AND SO IF YOU WERE TO APPLY THE
- 41:48LENS ON THE EID FIGURES THAT
- 41:50SENATOR THAYER TALKED ABOUT THAT
- 41:542.0 GOING TO 1.25 THERE'S BEEN A
- 41:58STEADY DECREASE BECAUSE LESS OF
- 41:59A RELIANCE 0 ON THERAPEUTIC
- 42:02DRUGS AND 0 THOSE DRUGS THAT
- 42:04WERE ON THE BUBBLE IF THEY WERE
- 42:06USED BEYOND MEANS TO BE
- 42:08PERFORMANCE ENHANCING.
- 42:09THE FIRST PART.
- 42:10THE SECOND PART I WOULD SAY IT'S
- 42:13REALLY IMPORTANT TO SAY IS NOT
- 42:15ALL GROUPS NOT ALL HORSEMEN AND
- 42:18TRAINERS ARE THEY ARE NOT ALL
- 42:19MADE THE SAME.
- 42:21YOU HAVE NINE STATES THAT ARE
- 42:25NOT PARTY TO CHALLENGING HISA.
- 42:28AND THOSE STATES ARE RESPONSIBLE
- 42:31FOR 87% OF THE STARTS IN RACING
- 42:36THAT ARE NON-HBPA STATES AND
- 42:39THAT IS REALLY IMPORTANT
- 42:41DISTINCTION TO MAKE.
- 42:42>> Renee: ANY OTHER COMMENT
- 42:43THERE BEFORE I GO TO THE NEXT
- 42:45COMMENT FROM A VIEWER IN
- 42:46LEXINGTON?
- 42:47>> I WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT
- 42:49THAT I BELIEVE THE MAJORITY OF
- 42:51HORSEMEN AND WOMEN IN AMERICA
- 42:54FOLLOW THE RULES.
- 42:56ARE THERE CHEATERS?
- 42:57ABSOLUTELY.
- 42:58THREE OF THEM GOT CAUGHT AND
- 43:00THEY ARE GOING TO GO TO THE
- 43:03FEDERAL PENITENTIARY FOR A
- 43:04LONGTIME.
- 43:05THERE ARE BAD APPLES IN EVERY
- 43:07PROFESSION.
- 43:07BUT I WANT TO STAND UP FOR THE
- 43:09HORSEMEN HERE THE RULE FOLLOWING
- 43:12HORSEMEN THEY WANT TO KNOW WHAT
- 43:13THE RULES ARE AND WANT TO KNOW
- 43:15THAT THEY ARE APPLIED EQUALLY,
- 43:17ADJUDICATED FAIRLY.
- 43:19AND THEY WANT THEM TO BE
- 43:22CONSISTENT ACROSS STATE BORDERS.
- 43:25SO I WANT TO MAKE SURE WE'RE NOT
- 43:27MAKING IT SEEM LIKE THIS IS A
- 43:29NEFARIOUS BUSINESS.
- 43:30HORSES ARE TREATED RACE HORSES
- 43:32ARE TREATED BETTER THAN HUMANS
- 43:34IN SOME CASES.
- 43:36I MEAN THESE HORSES ARE VALUABLE
- 43:38FROM A MONETARY POINT OF VIEW
- 43:39AND THE PEOPLE WHO PROVIDE CARE
- 43:42FOR HORSES FROM THE GROOMS TO
- 43:43THE EXERCISE RIDERS TO THE
- 43:44TRAINERS AND ALL THE PEOPLE WHO
- 43:46WORK IN THAT SYSTEM THEY LOVE
- 43:48THESE HORSES.
- 43:49AND I WOULD ENCOURAGE ANYONE TO
- 43:52TRY TO GO TO A FARM A TRAINING
- 43:54CENTER OR A RACETRACK AND LOOK
- 43:56AT THE KIND OF CARE AND THE
- 43:59EXPENSE AND THE TIME AND ENERGY
- 44:00THAT GOES INTO MAKING SURE THESE
- 44:02HORSES ARE TAKEN CARE OF.
- 44:04AND WHEN ONE DOES UNFORTUNATELY
- 44:07SUFFER A CATASTROPHIC INJURY IT
- 44:10IS HEARTBREAKING, IT IS HEART
- 44:12WRENCHING FOR THE PEOPLE
- 44:13INVOLVED IN THE OWNERSHIP OF
- 44:14THAT HORSE.
- 44:15I'VE HAD THAT HAPPEN IN RACE
- 44:17HORSE PARTNERSHIPS THAT I'M
- 44:18INVOLVED IN.
- 44:19YOU INVEST A LOT OF TIME AND
- 44:20MONEY AND LOVE AND CARE.
- 44:22AND IT BREAKS YOUR HEART WHEN
- 44:24SOMETHING GOES WRONG AND WE ARE
- 44:26ALL DEDICATED TO MAKING THIS
- 44:28SPORT SAFER TODAY THAN IT WAS
- 44:30YESTERDAY.
- 44:31>> Renee: SO SOME WOULD ASK IS
- 44:33MORE CARE TAKING FOR THE EQUINE
- 44:35AT LET, THAN THE HUMAN ATHLETE.
- 44:38WHAT ABOUT THE JOCKEY?
- 44:40>> I AM A WELL-KNOWN ADVOCATE
- 44:42FOR JOCKEYS.
- 44:43RIGHT NOW I'M NEGOTIATING ON
- 44:45THEIR BEHALF AS A PRO BONO THING
- 44:48TO DO TO TRY TO GET THEIR PAY
- 44:50INCREASED HERE IN KENTUCKY.
- 44:53THE JOCKEYS WHO FINISH, ONE,
- 44:55TWO, THREE, GET 10% OF THE
- 44:57PURSE.
- 44:58THE ONES WHO FINISH OFF THE
- 44:59BOARD AREN'T PAID AS MUCH AS
- 45:01THEY SHOULD BE.
- 45:02AND I'M TRYING TO MAKE THAT
- 45:04HAPPEN.
- 45:04I AM A BIG BELIEVER THAT JOCKEYS
- 45:07POUND FOR POUND ARE THE BEST
- 45:09ATHLETES IN ALL OF SPORTS.
- 45:10IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT THEY DO
- 45:13BALANCING ON THE BALLS OF HER
- 45:15FEET FOR A MINUTE OR TWO MINUTES
- 45:16IN THE COURSE OF A RACE.
- 45:19MAKING SPLIT SECOND DECISIONS ON
- 45:21A ANIMAL TRAVELING
- 45:2340-MILES-PER-HOUR SURROUNDED BY
- 45:24OTHER HORSES.
- 45:25IT IS A DANGEROUS JOB.
- 45:27AND YES, THE ANSWER IS THERE
- 45:28HAVE BEEN PROTOCOLS CONCUSSION
- 45:31PROTOCOLS THAT THE GENERAL
- 45:33ASSEMBLY FUNDED THAT ARE BEING
- 45:34STUDIED AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
- 45:36KENTUCKY RIGHT NOW.
- 45:37IT'S IMPROVED THE QUALITY OF THE
- 45:39SAFETY HELMET THAT THEY WEAR.
- 45:41THE SAFETY VEST THAT THEY WEAR.
- 45:42AND THEN ANYTHING WE CAN DO TO
- 45:45MAKE HORSES SAFER IS
- 45:47CONCURRENTLY GOING TO BE SAFER
- 45:48FOR THE JOCKEYS BECAUSE JOCKEYS
- 45:51CAN AND ARE HURT WHEN HORSES GO
- 45:53DOWN IN THE COURSE OF A RACE.
- 45:55EXERCISE RIDERS CAN SUFFER THE
- 45:57SAME INJURIES DURING TRAINING.
- 46:00>> Renee: NATALIE VOSS SAYS 50%
- 46:02OF THE INJURIES INCURRED BY
- 46:04JOCKEYS WHEN THE HORSE FALLS OR
- 46:06SUFFERS AN INJURY.
- 46:06WE HAVE A FEW QUESTIONS WE WANT
- 46:08TO GET IN.
- 46:10ANOTHER FROM LEXINGTON WHY ARE
- 46:12THEY ONLY LOOKING AT THE TRACK
- 46:16CONDITIONS AT CHURCHILL DOWNS
- 46:18WERE ARE THEY INVESTIGATING THE
- 46:19RIGOROUS TRAINING PRACTICES BY
- 46:21TRAINERS?
- 46:22THESE ANIMALS CANNOT TOLERATE
- 46:26BODILY THE TRAINING?
- 46:27>> THEY ARE NOT.
- 46:28THEY ARE NOT ONLY LOOKING AT
- 46:31TRACK SURFACES THEY ARE LOOKING
- 46:33THEY ARE REVIEWING EVERYTHING.
- 46:35AND I CANNOT INFER WHAT THE REST
- 46:39OF THAT QUESTIONER EXCLAMATION
- 46:43POINT WAS BUT IT'S REALLY
- 46:44IMPORTANT THAT WHEN THESE
- 46:48OCCURRENCES THAT PEOPLE HAVE
- 46:56ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT HORSERACING
- 46:57THAT ARE NOT SCIENTIFICALLY OR
- 47:00FAMILIAR KULLY --
- 47:02FACTUALLY TRUE.
- 47:02THERE IS A BELIEF WITH THOSE
- 47:05INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE
- 47:06UNDERSTANDING OF SPORT HORSES
- 47:08THAT WE ARE RACING THESE HORSES
- 47:10TOO YOUNG.
- 47:11ACTUALLY WE FOUND VIA VERY
- 47:15DURABLE AND FULSOME SCIENTIFIC
- 47:18DATA THAT HAPPENED IN MULTIPLE
- 47:20COUNTRIES THAT TWO-YEAR-OLD
- 47:22RACING THAT THE EARLIER THAT A
- 47:24HORSE STARTS AND THE MORE THAT
- 47:27IT IS IN TRAINING ACTUALLY THE
- 47:28SOUNDER IT IS.
- 47:29AS LONG AS YOU ARE FOLLOWING
- 47:32SAFE PARAMETERS AND NOT REALLY
- 47:35POUNDING ON THE HORSE.
- 47:37>> Renee: SO FOR Mr. HAMELBACK
- 47:40THIS QUESTION TO YOU FROM TERRY
- 47:42FROM BOLLING GREEN.
- 47:44THE TWO MAJOR HORSEMEN'S GROUP
- 47:46IN AMERICA THE AUTHORIZE REBREAD
- 47:48ASSOCIATION AND THE AUTHORIZE
- 47:50REBREAD OWNERS OF CALIFORNIA
- 47:51FULLY SUPPORT HISA ARE THEY
- 47:53WRONG?
- 47:54THE QUESTION FROM THE VIEWER?
- 47:56>> IT IS NOT FOR ME TO SAY IF
- 47:58THEY ARE RIGHT OR WRONG.
- 47:59IF THEY FEEL THE BILL IS
- 48:01CONSTITUTIONAL, THEN THAT IS
- 48:02THEIR OPINION.
- 48:04WE DO NOT FEEL THE BILL IS
- 48:07CONSTITUTIONAL.
- 48:07IT IS NOT AGAIN A PROBLEM WITH
- 48:09RULES, REGULATIONS OR
- 48:11UNIFORMITY.
- 48:12WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
- 48:14DELEGATING GOVERNMENTAL
- 48:14AUTHORITY TO A PRIVATE ENTITY IS
- 48:17THE LEGAL THING TO DO.
- 48:18I DON'T SPEAK FOR THE TOC.
- 48:20I DON'T SPEAK FOR THE THA.
- 48:23>> CAN I RESPOND TO THAT?
- 48:26I'M GLAD HE MENTIONED THAT
- 48:28BECAUSE OF THE BEST EXAMPLE OF
- 48:30RACING OF DELEGATION --
- 48:33DELEGATING AUTHORITY TO A
- 48:34PRIVATE ENTITY IS IN THE
- 48:36INTERSTATE HORSERACING ACT OF
- 48:381978.
- 48:38AND THAT IS WHY I HAVE TO SAY
- 48:42HBPA'S POSITION HAS ALWAYS
- 48:44STRUCK ME AS HYPOCRITICAL UNDER
- 48:48THE IHA, THE INTERSTATE
- 48:52HORSERACING ACT OF 1978 EACH
- 48:55HORSEMEN'S GROUP THAT REPRESENTS
- 48:56A MAJORITY HAS TO GIVE THE
- 48:58MAJORITY OF HORSEMEN AT A TRACK
- 48:59HAS TO GIVE ITS CONSENT BEFORE
- 49:04THERE CAN BE SOMETIMELE
- 49:07INDICATING.
- 49:08SENDING THE SIGNAL NOW.
- 49:0990% OF THE HANDLE COMES FROM
- 49:13THIS BETTING AND IT GOES ACROSS
- 49:14STATE LINES THEY HAVE TO GIVE
- 49:16THEIR CONSENT BUT THEY ARE A
- 49:18PRIVATE ENTITY.
- 49:20AND THAT CONSENT COMES IN THE
- 49:22FORM OF A CONTRACT WHICH I
- 49:23ACTUALLY HELPED KTA YEARS AGO
- 49:28NEGOTIATE SIDE-BY-SIDE WITH HBPA
- 49:30IN KENTUCKY AND THOSE CONTRACTS
- 49:32GOVERN ALL MANNER OF THINGS AT
- 49:34THE RACETRACK.
- 49:34A LOT MORE THAN JUST HOW WE'RE
- 49:36GOING TO SMITH UP THE MONEY
- 49:38FROM --
- 49:39SPLIT UP THE MONEY FROM
- 49:41SIMULCASTING.
- 49:42THERE WAS A LAWSUIT FILED
- 49:45AGAINST HBPA YEARS AGO AND THE
- 49:48BLAME WAS IT WAS AN UNLAWFUL
- 49:50DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY TO A
- 49:52PRIVATE ENTITY AND A 10TH
- 49:54AMENDMENT ALLEGATION IN THAT
- 49:55GUESS WHAT?
- 49:56THE SIXTH CIRCUIT SAID NO IT WAS
- 49:58NOT AN UNLAWFUL DELL DWATION TO
- 50:01A PRIVATE AUTHORITY.
- 50:02HERE IS THE 46789BPA AND THEY
- 50:04ARE THE HORSEMEN'S GROUP IN
- 50:06KENTUCKY AND MANY OTHER STATES
- 50:07THAT ARE SUING HISA.
- 50:09THERE ARE A BUNCH OF WESTERN
- 50:13HBPA CHAPTERS THAT ARE SUING
- 50:15SAYING IT'S OK FOR US AS A
- 50:17PRIVATE ENTITY TO HAVE THIS MUCH
- 50:19AUTHORITY BUT IT IS NOT OK FOR
- 50:22ANOTHER ENTITY AND THE
- 50:23DIFFERENCE IS HISA IS UNDER THE
- 50:25UMBRELLA AND CONTROLLED BY THE
- 50:28FTC.
- 50:29>> Renee: FEDERAL TRADE
- 50:30COMMISSION.
- 50:31>> THESE HBPA CHAPTERS ARE NOT
- 50:34UNDER ANYBODY'S CONTROL.
- 50:37>> Renee: Mr. HAMELBACK IS IT
- 50:40HYPOCRITICAL, SIR.
- 50:40>> NO, MA'AM, I DO NOT THINK IT
- 50:43IS.
- 50:43Mr. LEAR IS CORRECT BUT AT THE
- 50:45END OF THE DAY HE LEAVES OUT THE
- 50:47FACT THAT HBPA BOARDS ARE
- 50:50ELECTED BY THE MEMBERSHIP.
- 50:51THERE IS NO COMMITTEEMEMBERS.
- 50:53THERE'S NO AUTHORITY MEMBERS
- 50:54THAT WERE ELECTED BY ANYONE
- 50:56WITHIN THE INDUSTRY.
- 50:57THEY WERE ALL APPOINTED BY WHOM
- 51:00MOST OF US DO NOT KNOW, THERE
- 51:02WAS AN APPOINTMENT OF A
- 51:04NOMINATING COMMITTEE AND THEN
- 51:05THE APPOINTMENTS WERE MADE FOR
- 51:07THE TWO COMMITTEES AND THEN ANY
- 51:10SUBCOMMITTEES.
- 51:11SO AGAIN, WE ARE ELECTED
- 51:13OFFICIALS.
- 51:13NO DIFFERENT THAN SENATOR
- 51:15THAYER.
- 51:16>> Renee: AND I THINK YOU WANTED
- 51:17TO SAY SOMETHING, SIR?
- 51:18>> I'M NOT A LAWYER NOR AM I
- 51:21GOING TO PLAY ONE ON TV TONIGHT
- 51:22WE ARE GETTING INTO A LOT OF
- 51:26LEGALESE HERE.
- 51:26THE COURTS ARE GOING TO DECIDE
- 51:29THE LEGALITY OF HISA AND I HAD
- 51:32LOTS OF CALLS THIS WEEKEND
- 51:33URGING ME NOT TO BE CRITICAL OF
- 51:35HISA DURING THIS TIME.
- 51:36BUT YOU KNOW, DISSENT IS PART OF
- 51:41THE AMERICAN EXPERIMENT.
- 51:44AND I'M HERE TONIGHT TO PROVIDE
- 51:46CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM IN THE
- 51:48EVENT HISA LIVES OR IN THE EVENT
- 51:50THAT IT DIES F IT DIES I'VE GOT
- 51:53AN ALTERNATIVE SITTING OUT THERE
- 51:55FOR 1212 YEARS AND I WILL BE
- 51:58PART OF TRYING TO MAKE IT WORK.
- 52:00IF IT LIVES I WANT IT TO WORK
- 52:01AND THE SUGGESTION IT NEEDS TO
- 52:04SIMPLIFY ITS FOCUS.
- 52:05AND I'VE SPOKEN TO LEADER
- 52:07McCONNELL AND CONGRESSMAN BAR
- 52:09ABOUT AMENDING THE BILL.
- 52:11>> Renee: DO THEY FAVOR THAT?
- 52:12>> I WILL NOT SPEAK FOR THEM.
- 52:14>> Renee: DID THEY GIVE YOU ANY
- 52:16INDICATION THAT THEY WOULD BE
- 52:17WILLING?
- 52:17>> THINK THEY LIKE THE BILL THE
- 52:19WAY IT IS RIGHT NOW.
- 52:20THEY AUTHORED IT AND IT'S FINE
- 52:22AND I COMPLIMENT LEADER
- 52:25McCONNELL FOR PUTTING A
- 52:27PROVISION IN THE OMNIBUS BILL
- 52:29THAT DID PUT THE FTC OVER HISA.
- 52:32BECAUSE THERE IS A LOT OF
- 52:34CONCERN ABOUT ACCOUNTABILITY
- 52:36FROM AN UNELECTED APPOINTED
- 52:40FEDERAL AGENCY.
- 52:41AND WE ALL ESPECIALLY OF US ON
- 52:44THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE POLITICAL
- 52:46SPECTRUM WE HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
- 52:47AGENCIES WHETHER STATE OR
- 52:48FEDERAL SORT OF RUNNING AMOK.
- 52:50AND I DON'T WANT TO SEE THAT.
- 52:53I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THE
- 52:55POSSIBILITY THAT AN UNELECTED
- 52:56FEDERAL AGENCY WAS GOING TO TELL
- 52:58A PRIVATE BUSINESS THAT IS
- 52:59FOLLOWING ALL THE RULES AND
- 53:01PROTOCOLS THAT THEY HAD TO
- 53:02SHUTDOWN.
- 53:03AND I WANT TO REPEAT CHURCHILL
- 53:05DOWNS CLOSED DOWN VOLUNTARILY
- 53:07BUT I'M CONCERNED THERE WAS THE
- 53:09POSSIBILITY THAT MS. LAZARUS IN
- 53:11THE ROLE AS PRESIDENT OF HISA
- 53:13WAS GOING TO TELL THAT PRIVATE
- 53:14BUSINESS TO SHUTDOWN.
- 53:15THAT IS A CONCERN.
- 53:17>> Renee: OR HAS THE PRECEDENT
- 53:19BEEN SET WITH CHURCHILL DOWNS
- 53:20MAKING THAT MOVE THAT OTHER
- 53:22TRACKS FIND THEMSELVES IN A
- 53:24SITUATION THEY WILL DO THE SAME
- 53:25IS THAT A CONCERN?
- 53:27>> YES, IT IS A CONCERN OF MINE.
- 53:28CHURCHILL DOWNS DID NOT NEED
- 53:35[AUDIO INTERRUPTION].
- 53:37>> Renee: NOTHING WRONG WITH THE
- 53:38INVESTIGATORS TAKING TIME TO
- 53:39FIGURE IT IT OUT.
- 53:40>> I THINK THEY DID THE RIGHT
- 53:44THING.
- 53:44THEY TOOK THE HIGH ROAD AND THEY
- 53:48PURCHASED ELLIS PARK AND THEIR
- 53:50TEAM DID A GREAT JOB MOVE TO GO
- 53:52DOWN TO ELLIS PARK AND I SAW IT
- 53:55YESTERDAY.
- 53:55I WANT UNIFORMITY.
- 53:57I HAVE BEEN ON THE RECORD FOR
- 53:58THAT A LONGTIME.
- 53:59BUT I THINK HISA IS STILL NEW.
- 54:01AND THERE ARE GOING TO BE BUMPS
- 54:02IN THE ROAD.
- 54:03AND IT NEEDS TO BE WILLING TO
- 54:05ACCEPT SOME CONSTRUCTIVE
- 54:07CRITICISM TO HELP MAKE IT
- 54:09BETTER.
- 54:10I'M HAPPY THEY FORMED A
- 54:12HORSEMEN'S ADVISORY COMMITTEE,
- 54:14THE TRAINER WHO WORK, AND TOMMY
- 54:17A FRIEND OF MINE HE IS ON THE
- 54:20HORSEMEN'S ADVISORY COMMITTEE
- 54:20THAT WAS DONE AFTER THE INITIAL
- 54:23LAUNCH.
- 54:24JOHNNY VAL LAZ QUESTION IS ON
- 54:26THE JOCKEY SAFETY COMMITTEE THEY
- 54:27HAVE TO LISTEN TO ONE OF THE
- 54:29GREATEST JOCKEYS OF ALL TIME.
- 54:31MARK HAS BEEN WORKING WITH THEM
- 54:32ON THE CROP RULES AND WE NEED TO
- 54:34MAKE SURE WE'RE NOT TRYING TO
- 54:36TELL THE ATHLETES HOW TO DO
- 54:37THEIR JOBS.
- 54:38LET'S FOCUS ON MEDICATION,
- 54:41UNIFORMITY, ACROSS STATES.
- 54:42AND I THINK THERE WILL BE PORE
- 54:44BUY IN.
- 54:45>> Renee: AND WE DID REACH OUT
- 54:46TO CHURCHILL ABOUT PARTICIPATING
- 54:47IN THE PROGRAM BUT WE DID NOT
- 54:50HEAR BACK.
- 54:50Mr. HAMELBACK, BECAUSE YOU
- 54:53DON'T HAVE A TIMER.
- 54:55I WILL GIVE YOU A COUPLE OF
- 54:58CLOSING THOUGHTS TO SHARE WITH
- 55:00US.
- 55:00>> WELL, I JUST WANT TO FIRST
- 55:02START OUT BY SAYING THAT IN MANY
- 55:05ASPECTS WE WOULD CONSIDER A WIN
- 55:08ALREADY.
- 55:09IN OTHER WORDS THE ORIGINAL BILL
- 55:11WHICH WE WERE TOLD MULTIPLE
- 55:13TIMES WAS COMPLETELY
- 55:16CONSTITUTIONAL IN FACT WAS
- 55:18DECLARED UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND
- 55:19FORCED SENATOR McCONNELL TO
- 55:21PUT IN A FIX.
- 55:22WE'LL SEE IF THAT FIX KEEP IT IS
- 55:25CONSTITUTIONAL.
- 55:25BUT I WANT TO POINT OUT REAL
- 55:28QUICK I WISH I HAD MORE TIME
- 55:31BECAUSE THE REAL CONCERN THAT
- 55:34THE NATIONAL HBPA AND AT ONE
- 55:37TIME EVERY HORSEMEN'S GROUP WHO
- 55:39TALKED ABOUT THIS ON CAPITOL
- 55:41HILL WAS THE COST.
- 55:43WHAT IS IT GOING TO COST THE
- 55:45INDUSTRY?
- 55:46AND THAT CONTINUES TO BE A
- 55:48CONCERN WITH CURRENTLY THE PRICE
- 55:50TAG OF $66 MILLION ADDED TO THE
- 55:53INDUSTRY.
- 55:54HOW WILL THE INDUSTRY BE ABLE TO
- 55:55PAY FOR IT?
- 55:57AGAIN WE ARE PAYING FOR A DUE
- 56:00LICK ACTIVE PROCESS.
- 56:04DUPLICATIVE PROCESS.
- 56:04THE COMMISSIONS WERE ALREADY IN
- 56:09PLACE UNTIL THE NUCLEAR BOMB
- 56:12BLUE THEM UP.
- 56:13>> Renee: WE HAVE TO LEAVE IT
- 56:15THERE AND HOW IT AFFECTS SMALLER
- 56:17ENTITIES.
- 56:17WE WILL REVISIT IT AGAIN ON
- 56:19KENTUCKY EDITION EACH WEEKNIGHT
- 56:22AT 6:30.
- 56:27Next week on ‘Kentucky Tonight,’
- 56:28a discussion about LGBTQ issues
- 56:29and Senate Bill 150.
- 56:29Be sure to join us each
- 56:30weeknight at 6:30 Eastern, 5:30
- 56:31Central for ‘Kentucky Edition.’
- 56:32And join Bill Bryant and a team
- 56:32of working journalists to
- 56:33discuss the news of the week on
- 56:34‘Comment on Kentucky,’ Friday at
- 56:35eight Eastern, seven Central.
- 56:35Have a good week.