Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️97 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 7th Sep Restoration and Landscape 2026 Day 3 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Curraghinalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Much of today was given over to landscape. The morning brought us back to the mine waste facility, its final shape, the visualisations, the surrounding hills, planting, restoration, and a proposal to progressively soften and smooth the engineered terraces and benches. And inevitably, once we
- 1:18got into the detail of that, we ended up back in engineering. There was quite a bit of discussion about the material needed to create that final profile, the depths required, and where the material comes from, and the calculations behind that. I'm not going to go into all of that this evening
- 1:35because I'm returning separately to constructability in a one-to-one podcast with Doug Hill, senior roads engineer and consultant, and it's an emerging issue which deserves its own discussion. Today, though, we spent a lot of time talking about landscape itself, and this week we were very happy to
- 1:58welcome back Professor Amy Strecker, who's been a valuable expert witness for Savers Sperrins throughout these discussions, you may remember Amy from an earlier podcast number 14, Law, Land, and Justice. There will be a link to this podcast in the show notes. From the start, Amy has been
- 2:20raising much broader points about landscape than simply the view. What landscape actually encompasses, how people experience it, and whether that has really been captured in the way the subject has been dealt with at the inquiry. So afterwards, I asked her to send me her thoughts on what she'd
- 2:42heard today and how this whole subject is being approached. She sent me a voice note, and it was rather longer than I expected. But when I listened to it, I decided I wasn't going to cut it because it's really valuable and it's worth hearing in full. So I'm going to hand you over now to Amy. Hi,
- 3:01Marella. So, what stuck with me from yesterday, the second landscape day, was just how narrowly the applicant is construing landscape for the purposes of of assessing and mitigating the project as a whole. So, on the one hand, the applicant is using landscape as mitigation to screen or make
- 3:23acceptable an actual substantive landscape harm, and what I mean by that is, you can have all the landscaping orientation and planting you like on and around the mine tailings or what they're calling the dry stack facility, but if the facility itself is poorly designed and has the potential for incidence
- 3:42and failure, then it renders any sort of landscaping measures meaningless. I was actually discussing this part of the application with a retired landscape professional, who's quite well known in Ireland, and and his response was, "Sure, that's like trying to hide a dead body, and I thought it was
- 3:59a very good analogy, but even if we took the restoration plans at face value, the actual restoration measures that are being proposed are, in my view, just not credible. And I don't think they're credible because, first of all, the utter scale of the tailings stack itself is extraordinary in this landscape,
- 4:16and that's not only as viewed, but also, and probably more importantly, as it'll be experienced, I mean, it's almost 900 metres long, almost 400 metres wide, and 59 metres high, and that point had to be corrected by Dr. Emmerman yesterday, because there was some erroneous calculations
- 4:36cited by an expert witness for the company. We also have to bear in mind that the the landscaping measures or the vegetation mix proposed for the so-called restoration won't realistically fit within the surrounding landscape, which is characterised by blanket bog and heather, amongst other types of
- 4:58vegetation, but. It's the heather that and the blanket bog that gives it this characteristic, you know, change in colour throughout the season. So even if we're viewing it from the perspective of vegetation alone, I just it's just not going to work. The discussion to date, I think, in relation to
- 5:16what the plans of the company are, all seem to be based on intentions and commitments. So, on various occasions over the past couple of days, I noted down just how many times the word intention to and commitment to, and we would expect that, is mentioned by either counsel or expert witnesses, and that's all
- 5:40very well. And I'm sure there's a genuine intention on the part of the various consultants engaged by the company, but intentions and commitments don't equate to any level of certainty, especially since the same company has failed to restore the temporary exploration site on Camcosy rd
- 5:55Road, which is now in violation of planning, and that's the only example really we have to go on in terms of how Dalradian followed through on their commitment to restore something. So I don't think we can take much heart from that. And let me see. So there was there was also a lot of discussion yesterday
- 6:16over the visualisations of the application site, with a lot of criticism coming from the landscape landscape expert for FODC from Omagh District Council. From my own perspective, viewing the material, it's very unclear from the visuals what the extent of the entire project site project
- 6:37application site will actually be. I mean, if you take all of the individual applications and put them together, it's truly an industrial scale project, and it will utterly transform the landscape here in more senses than just visual. And this isn't just a heavily designated area, but also obviously a lived-in
- 6:59landscape, and yet the local community don't really feature in the Dalradian impact assessments. At least no social impact assessment was carried out, and the cultural heritage impact assessments didn't include any consultation with the local community, which, for a project of this scale, would
- 7:14be best practice. I still find it extraordinary that this project was even contemplated for this particular landscape, not just because of its designations, which would be enough in itself or should be enough in itself, but because of the close proximity of homes, farms, and a primary school
- 7:30playing fields and a village community, all within a kilometre of the massive mine waste tailings stack, that is highly unusual and highly concerning. Let me see another interesting point.
- 7:50I think is that Dalradian admitted that there will be some significant localised effects on the landscape, and some of us noticed that there's a contradiction here in this line of argumentation between different sessions. So, previously Dalradian argued that there would be no impact on
- 8:10tourism from the project, but this part of the AOMB, the area of outstanding natural beauty, this part of The Sperrins, is the gateway for much of the tourism in the whole of The Sperrins, and that's easy to see from all of the accommodations springing up in the area. That's linked to the landscape, like
- 8:26that, you know, the accommodation around the Dark Skies Park and Beaghmore A.S. the area of special archaeological interest and the various walks and trails in the area. So, to say that it won't affect tourism is again, I think, not a credible argument when it's acknowledged that
- 8:45there would be local, significant, localised adverse effects. So, so let's see. Finally, I think, I think if you take all the applications cumulatively, like not just the tailings stack, the mine waste facility, but also the power lines, the privatisation of a public road, the securitisation,
- 9:05the traffic, the dust, the noise, the blasting. Of course, this will industrialise the area and have knock-on effects for tourism too. I mean, if there's going to be localised landscape harm, it's logical that this will have knock-on effects not only on the community and our community well-being, but also
- 9:22on actual sustainable development that's growing. So it'll be interesting to hear the next sessions when we resume on the 22nd. Okay, I think I'll leave it there. Thanks very much, Marella.
- 9:37So there you go. I think Amy has given us quite enough to think about, so I won't attempt to summarise what she just said. Moving onwards to the proposed electricity connections, 321 overhead structures stretching across approximately 26.9 kilometres. Much of discussion was around viewpoints and
- 10:03skylines, the existing overhead infrastructure within the AONB, and the cumulative effect of adding more. We also got into the route itself, the special countryside area, undergrounding, alternatives, and a thing called the Halford Rules. There was a lot more details than that, but after
- 10:24listening to Amy, I think it probably gives you a sense of why landscape can't really be reducted to whether or not a pole appears in a particular viewpoint, and that was more or less the serious part of the day. There are a few other things that I think deserve a mention. For the first time this
- 10:45week, the commission had actual paper mats and drawings in front of them, cutting down the amount of time that was spent through searching digital files. We had ours sitting in front of us this past few weeks, so I'd like to think we had some small influence there. Whether the commission knows we've
- 11:07influenced them is, of course, another matter. Either way, papers made a comeback, and it certainly cuts down the endless searching through digital files. And there was another little thing that was amusing me as this week went by. Doctor Stephen Emerman was repeatedly referred to as mr. Emerman,
- 11:30followed by these rather wonderful moments when somebody seemed to remember the doctorate halfway through, and we ended up with mr. Doctor Emmerman. Stephen is an internationally recognised scientist who has addressed the UN and the European Parliament. So I think Savers Sperrins will probably
- 11:52stick with Dr. Emmerman here and leave mr. Doctor to the other poor souls in the inquiry. Our next challenge is the enormous wide screen sitting directly behind the commissioners. It remains resolutely unused. We regularly hear about the pressure of getting through everything in the allotted time,
- 12:16while people spend minutes running it hours finding drawings and then describing them to everybody else in the room, and behind them all sits this magnificent screen. It would only take a lead to connect up, but apparently it isn't available. I've no idea why, and begin to wonder if
- 12:38there's an additional higher charge involved, and if there is, perhaps Save Our Sperrins could have a whip around. We might save ourselves days over the whole length of the inquiry. And then came my phrase of the day. During one of the very long discussions about reprofiling the mine waste facility, we
- 13:05heard about the dozer going across the landform to smooth it. I know I was brought up with the phrase of doing the smoothing, which meant really ironing your clothes, and so I had this image in my head, of these dozers smoothing out everything, and how natural that would look in the future.
- 13:29However, about 4o'clock in the afternoon, I think most of us would have happily allowed a dozer across the room to clear it out. Everybody looked washed out, people were tired. The afternoon had ground on relentlessly, and was a fairly unmistakable sense that the collective will to live was
- 13:50beginning to ebb away. To sum up today, we spent hours inside a room discussing landscape through photographs, drawings, computer models, viewpoints, contours, and cross sections. Meanwhile, the landscape we're actually talking about: The Sperrins, the farms, the roads, the rivers, the homes, and the
- 14:08people living amongst all of it, sitting just a few short miles away. It's worth remembering that. We'll see you the week after next. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign
- 14:31updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes, please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to
- 14:50hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.