Latest / Geoffrey Challen: Teaching and Technology / Another Skill
Transcript
- 0:00Geoffrey Challen: Hey everyone, my name is Geoff Challen, and I teach computing at the University of Illinois.
- 0:04Geoffrey Challen: I write about teaching and technology at geoffreychallen.com,
- 0:08Geoffrey Challen: where you can find a written version of the essay you're about to hear.
- 0:11Geoffrey Challen: What follows is the essay being read aloud, but not by me, by a clone of my voice.
- 0:16Geoffrey Challen: I hope you enjoy it.
- 0:17Geoffrey Challen: If you have any feedback, please don't hesitate to reach out to me directly.
- 0:21Geoffrey Challen: I'd love to hear from you.
- 0:22Geoffrey Challen: Another Skill, an essay by Geoffrey Challen, read aloud by Geoffrey Challen's voice clone.
- 0:29Geoffrey Challen: The first day of my first college programming course, the instructor said:
- 0:33Geoffrey Challen: “This is one of the only courses at this university that teaches a skill.”
- 0:38Geoffrey Challen: I’ve never forgotten that.
- 0:40Geoffrey Challen: I like doing things, and I was excited to learn the skill of programming.
- 0:44Geoffrey Challen: I learned it, I practiced it, I got good at it, and I did it for a long time.
- 0:49Geoffrey Challen: Now I’m learning a new skill: agentic development.
- 0:52Geoffrey Challen: I don’t work with source code anymore, I talk to coding agents in natural language.
- 0:56Geoffrey Challen: I’m learning it, I’m practicing it, I’m getting good at it, and I’m expecting to do it for a long time.
- 1:02Geoffrey Challen: It’s another skill—a remarkably powerful one.
- 1:05Geoffrey Challen: And if it can be learned, it can be taught.
- 1:08Geoffrey Challen: Perhaps this seems obvious.
- 1:10Geoffrey Challen: But people sometimes treat agentic development as more akin to magic:
- 1:14Geoffrey Challen: Users who conclude, when they aren’t having good results,
- 1:18Geoffrey Challen: that it must not work at all, when they’re just not good at it yet.
- 1:22Geoffrey Challen: Developers who believe that as soon as you start working with coding agents you’ll immediately be great at it.
- 1:28Geoffrey Challen: Educators who worry that, once we stop teaching classical programming, there’ll be nothing left for students to learn.
- 1:36Geoffrey Challen: Coding agents can feel like magic initially, when you’re used to coding by hand.
- 1:40Geoffrey Challen: But once you adjust to their capabilities they start feeling familiar, another tool that rewards skillful use.
- 1:47Geoffrey Challen: I’m not saying this to diminish their capabilities.
- 1:50Geoffrey Challen: Coding agents are the most exciting thing to happen to software creation in my lifetime.
- 1:55Geoffrey Challen: But getting your ideas out of your head and into the world is still challenging.
- 2:00Geoffrey Challen: Code velocity has increased.
- 2:02Geoffrey Challen: Every other creative challenge is still hard: coming up with ideas, understanding problem requirements,
- 2:08Geoffrey Challen: anticipating user behavior, responding to feedback, and incrementally improving prototypes.
- 2:14Geoffrey Challen: Not to mention knowing whether what you’re creating is actually good.
- 2:17Geoffrey Challen: There’s still plenty to teach and to learn.
- 2:20Geoffrey Challen: Several implications are clear.
- 2:23Geoffrey Challen: People who want to create software should learn agentic development.
- 2:26Geoffrey Challen: They should expect that to take practice.
- 2:29Geoffrey Challen: Educators should determine how to teach this new skill.
- 2:32Geoffrey Challen: Until we do, we should not stop students from practicing.
- 2:36Geoffrey Challen: There’s also one less-obvious conclusion I’m drawing from watching experienced developers begin using coding agents.
- 2:43Geoffrey Challen: Nearly every developer today who learned computing in college went through a traditional computing degree curriculum.
- 2:49Geoffrey Challen: Not all of them are succeeding at agentic development.
- 2:52Geoffrey Challen: I think educators hope that, until we update our programs,
- 2:56Geoffrey Challen: a classical computing education prepares students to succeed at agentic development.
- 3:01Geoffrey Challen: I’m not sure that’s entirely true.
- 3:03Geoffrey Challen: It’s probably better than nothing, but also worse than it could be.
- 3:08Geoffrey Challen: What enables success at agentic development?
- 3:11Geoffrey Challen: How should we be teaching our students?
- 3:13Geoffrey Challen: I don’t have the answer, I can only speculate from watching myself learn this new skill.
- 3:18Geoffrey Challen: I was trained in computer systems.
- 3:21Geoffrey Challen: My sense is that, compared with other subfields,
- 3:24Geoffrey Challen: computer systems spends more time zoomed out and less zoomed in, providing a better overview of computing.
- 3:30Geoffrey Challen: Working with coding agents sometimes feels like working as a general contractor,
- 3:34Geoffrey Challen: guiding a team of specialists to create something complete.
- 3:38Geoffrey Challen: Systems people also identify most development decisions as tradeoffs.
- 3:42Geoffrey Challen: It’s true today that coding agents make rapid pivots much easier.
- 3:46Geoffrey Challen: But making tradeoffs well still accelerates development,
- 3:49Geoffrey Challen: even if swapping between algorithms, databases, or cloud providers is now much quicker.
- 3:54Geoffrey Challen: And just knowing that certain tradeoffs exist improves your ability to guide your agents.
- 4:00Geoffrey Challen: I’ve worked for decades as an independent solo developer.
- 4:03Geoffrey Challen: Partly by choice: I’ve enjoyed learning about a variety of different aspects of computing.
- 4:08Geoffrey Challen: Partly by necessity: As an educator building educational software,
- 4:12Geoffrey Challen: I’ve never worked with a team of full-time developers.
- 4:15Geoffrey Challen: I maintain entire user-facing systems: frontend interfaces,
- 4:19Geoffrey Challen: backend private cloud orchestrators, and everything in between.
- 4:23Geoffrey Challen: I suspect that my breadth of knowledge contributes to my ability to collaborate with coding agents.
- 4:28Geoffrey Challen: I was also reasonably attentive to good development practices like testing and linting—
- 4:33Geoffrey Challen: which are invaluable when you work on a large number of projects.
- 4:37Geoffrey Challen: Drop in, run the tests, reproduce the failure with a new test, fix that test,
- 4:42Geoffrey Challen: confirm everything else still works, deploy the fix, switch projects, start over, eventually it’s lunchtime.
- 4:49Geoffrey Challen: That’s essentially the same workflow my agents use now—minus lunchtime—and it allows them to make progress unsupervised.
- 4:56Geoffrey Challen: All my projects now have extensive test suites, written by the agents as they add features and fix mistakes.
- 5:03Geoffrey Challen: I’ve spent several decades describing computer systems in writing—papers,
- 5:08Geoffrey Challen: grants, proposals, emails, designs, slides, assessments.
- 5:13Geoffrey Challen: I learned how to do this largely through practice,
- 5:16Geoffrey Challen: and I was lucky to have a doctoral adviser who wrote well and cared about writing quality.
- 5:21Geoffrey Challen: To quote, again, one of my favorite essays on coding agents by Kailash Nadh:
- 5:25Geoffrey Challen: “An experienced developer who can talk well, that is, imagine,
- 5:29Geoffrey Challen: articulate, define problem statements, architect and engineer,
- 5:34Geoffrey Challen: has a massive advantage over someone who cannot, more disproportionately than ever.”
- 5:39Geoffrey Challen: I’d go farther.
- 5:40Geoffrey Challen: Today, the definition of an experienced developer is someone who can talk well.
- 5:45Geoffrey Challen: Code that an agent can write in seconds is no longer evidence of expertise.
- 5:49Geoffrey Challen: What’s left, and what’s now scarce, is the ability to specify what should be built and recognize when it has been.
- 5:57Geoffrey Challen: You may be wondering: Didn’t you write code for multiple decades?
- 6:01Geoffrey Challen: That must help, right?
- 6:03Geoffrey Challen: It must.
- 6:04Geoffrey Challen: But I’m not sure it helps that much.
- 6:06Geoffrey Challen: The hours I used to spend getting ideas out of my head and into working code did not represent high cognitive load.
- 6:13Geoffrey Challen: That’s when you strap on your headphones, start your playlist, and prepare for psychological pain.
- 6:18Geoffrey Challen: Reading, writing,
- 6:19Geoffrey Challen: and debugging code by hand does not seem like the best way to learn
- 6:23Geoffrey Challen: the computing concepts needed to work effectively with coding agents.
- 6:27Geoffrey Challen: It’s inefficient and unpleasant and has turned away too many people with ideas that the world needs.
- 6:33Geoffrey Challen: There has to be a better way.
- 6:35Geoffrey Challen: Determining what knowledge leads to success at agentic development and how to impart it to students—
- 6:41Geoffrey Challen: these are the urgent questions facing computing education.
- 6:45Geoffrey Challen: This is real Geoff again.
- 6:47Geoffrey Challen: Thanks for listening.
- 6:48Geoffrey Challen: You'll find more essays at geoffreychallen.com, and you can subscribe to the podcast wherever you're listening now.
- 6:54Geoffrey Challen: Until next time.
- 6:55Geoffrey Challen: Keep teaching with technology.