Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / Women in Intelligence
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Eye Spy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg.
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspects of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:26Dr. Helen Fry has authored and edited thousands of award-winning books investigating the history
- 0:34of World War II.
- 0:35She is the foremost authority on the secret listeners who worked at special, eavesdropping
- 0:39sites operated by British intelligence during World War II.
- 0:43Dr. Fry has shed light on one of the greatest intelligence deceptions of the war, the bugging
- 0:48of Hitler's generals at Trent Park in North London and thousands of prisoners of war at
- 0:53Lattner House in Wilton Park in Buckinghamshire.
- 0:57She is also the official biographer of the man who Hitler's secret service labelled
- 1:01the elusive Englishman, MI6 biomaster Thomas Joseph Kendrick.
- 1:07Today we will be discussing her book Women in Intelligence, The Hidden History of Two
- 1:11World Wars.
- 1:14Thank you so much for joining us on iSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 1:20Welcome.
- 1:22So my first question is really about all of your work and after having published so many
- 1:30captivating historical accounts, can you describe what it's like to sift through declassified
- 1:38files at the archives and how do you select which stories to bring to life in your books?
- 1:45Well first of all thank you so much for having me on the podcast, it's wonderful.
- 1:50I love to talk about that research journey.
- 1:53I absolutely love going through the files.
- 1:55There's something about working through paper files in particular.
- 2:01I much prefer paper files and digital files.
- 2:04Your eyes scan the material quite differently and you never really know what you're going
- 2:08to discover.
- 2:09So for me in terms of what to include in a book, so I started out 25, 30 years ago so
- 2:17I've accumulated quite a lot of knowledge in a specific area and so it's not like starting
- 2:23completely from scratch.
- 2:25So building on the work I'm doing now, so for example for another book I would scope
- 2:31the material that I know is out there and where else might I find material?
- 2:38National Archives is an obvious one.
- 2:41Archives abroad, some of us historians are now beginning to look at archives abroad if
- 2:46they're relevant to our story and that's opening up a whole new field that's really exciting
- 2:51and changing and deepening our understanding in my case of the two world wars, the first
- 2:57world war and the second world war.
- 2:59And as I'm working through that material I get a sense, you know roughly what's going
- 3:04in it when you've done a proposal, you've got an overarching story but you do discover
- 3:08new material and occasionally you think oh no this has to go in and even though it's
- 3:13not in the proposal, so my ballpoint benchmark if you like, if I find the stories interesting
- 3:21that I'm uncovering I think the reader will as well.
- 3:25Yeah that's wonderful.
- 3:27And focusing on your book Women in Intelligence, The Hidden History of Two World Wars, what
- 3:34specific challenges did you encounter when tracing the contributions of women from World
- 3:39War One to World War Two?
- 3:42I think in the end it was the sheer volume of material that's now available which means
- 3:49you know you have to make choices but also the challenge that we've lost the vast majority
- 3:55of those eyewitnesses, those women you know passed on their ages mean that we have very
- 4:02few veterans left but I was lucky enough to start accidentally uncovering the stories
- 4:07of the women 20-25 years ago as a result of doing wider intelligence stories, espionage,
- 4:15the spies all that kind of thing.
- 4:17So gradually the odd story came out of women transcending the boundaries of what we ordinarily
- 4:24think of them doing in intelligence and that's kind of, I kind of almost didn't notice to
- 4:30start with and then I wove in a couple of these incredible stories, the female interrogators
- 4:35being one of them, into my book The Walls Have Ears and my subsequent book Spy Master
- 4:41and again I kind of, it just sat there as a like wow story and then there came a moment
- 4:47just about three or four years ago when I had a chat with my publisher and I said you
- 4:52know what this has been niggling at me I think I have to do the women next and she said yeah
- 4:59that's it, that's your next book because the unusual way that I've uncovered those
- 5:05stories quite accidentally through military intelligence, naval intelligence files, a
- 5:11range of intelligence files means that I've uncovered the roles of women doing unbelievably
- 5:18unusual things in intelligence and it wasn't just a few women here or there, they weren't
- 5:24the exception to the rule and so that's when I sort of sat down and said okay if I'm going
- 5:28to do this book what needs to go in and so there was a whole raft of new research of
- 5:35course to fit some of the chapters that I hadn't looked at in any detail and what emerged
- 5:39I think even three or four years ago when I first put that forward I'll do this book,
- 5:45I don't think even I realised just how rich and diverse this story was going to be and
- 5:52so inspirational, the women are everywhere across civilian intelligence agencies so like
- 6:01the MI5 security service, MI6 secret intelligence service in the UK, for any American listeners
- 6:08it would be the equivalent of the FBI and CIA and I just thought that had to be told
- 6:12and right across the uniformed services of army, air, naval intelligence as well and
- 6:18it's a really rich history with some myth busting as well that I wasn't expecting to
- 6:25find and for me it's turned out to be an extraordinary book and I'm so glad that I wrote it because
- 6:33I thought I might just do some of the other wider espionage stories, I'm so pleased I've
- 6:37done this one and I don't think I could have written it 20 years ago because the material
- 6:44wasn't there, it hadn't all been declassified.
- 6:47Absolutely.
- 6:49And I'm talking a little bit about how women are recruited in these agencies.
- 6:55In the prologue you introduce Lesley Wilde's story of recruitment as a chance encounter
- 7:01with a stranger whose identity remained a mystery and from your research how common
- 7:07was such recruitment and what if anything did you find particularly surprising about
- 7:12how women were recruited among the different intelligence agencies?
- 7:18Of course recruitment's a really interesting one because we kind of have this view that
- 7:25it was the debutantes, the women of high society and that was true up to a point, the daughters
- 7:32of admirals were supposed to be particularly trustworthy so in the networks and the organisations,
- 7:39organisations was all about trust and so that's true up to a point that there are certain
- 7:44circles of educated women from particular schools or colleges but if you dig under the
- 7:50surface it is a bit more complex and Lesley's case is one in point, I mean she originally
- 7:57came from Vienna, that was not her original name, she was a Jewish refugee and because
- 8:01of her languages and her accent this chance encounter with the military man, the RAF officer
- 8:12who was going on a secret mission said I might not come back, I mean when I heard that story
- 8:18it was so powerful and he said to her you have the skills, do me a favour, well people
- 8:23can read the prologue but it sent tingles down my spine and I thought she was going
- 8:29to say at the very end, well you know years later I met him again in a chance encounter,
- 8:35we married but she didn't and she never saw him again and he said to her I might not survive
- 8:42tonight's mission, you need to do this and it was an incredible thing and there were
- 8:49many chance encounters, particularly those, the men and the women in fact who had to know
- 8:55somebody already working in intelligence and so occasionally they might be at a supper
- 9:00party and they knew that Captain Sorensen was in the army, didn't know what he was
- 9:05doing but he'd suddenly say would you like to do something a bit more interesting than
- 9:09you're doing now in the army and she would say well yes and that would be it and then
- 9:16a few weeks later there would be a letter in the post for this mysterious interview
- 9:21and they might end up at Bletchley Park or some of the other, the code breaking place
- 9:26or some of the other sites so some of it was, it was quite haphazard in many ways but also
- 9:35when women chose to enlist themselves to put themselves forward on their application form
- 9:40to apply for the services to all kinds of sections about languages, can you ski, ride
- 9:48a bicycle, mountaineer, whatever it is, horse riding, so they get a picture of their skills
- 9:54and again sometimes those women would unexpectedly have their applications, they didn't know
- 9:59in the background, passed to one side by the secretary screening it and they would get
- 10:05some serious interview and they'd end up being with for example the special operations
- 10:10executive that would send the agents behind enemy lines, the famous SOE to sabotage and
- 10:16set Europe ablaze so that was a way and you know it wasn't always a formal application
- 10:22direct to the intelligence agency so it's a very mixed and fascinating picture the recruitment.
- 10:30Absolutely fascinating yeah and could you also reflect on women's intelligence roles
- 10:38which as you mentioned in your book may seem inconsequential at first glance
- 10:43because so many historians have overlooked their significance seeing them as clerks, translators
- 10:48and typists rather than as key players with real influence. Yeah they've been the hidden
- 10:55player, the invisible women, the invisible spies if you like of two world wars and probably others
- 11:03as well yeah you're absolutely right that was something I think the motivation for writing
- 11:09this book was that accidental discovery of the women as interrogators, the quote unquote secretaries
- 11:17who transpires were not secretaries if they're working out of British passport control offices
- 11:23they weren't doing visa work they were actually running spy networks for the secret intelligence
- 11:29service right across Europe and elsewhere across the world and that's all been hidden and in many
- 11:35of those cases if they're working behind enemy lines or out of those passport control offices
- 11:41sometimes they were recruited in the first world war and then because of their skills they're
- 11:46kept on in the 1920s and 30s they are listed in official records as secretary and then they go on
- 11:53to do something in the second world war often agent handling and sending agents behind enemy lines
- 12:00so in those cases again something which hasn't been appreciated there were so many women that
- 12:06went on to have a career a 30 or 40 year career in espionage that have been completely missing
- 12:15and you have double agents you have careers you have women leading intelligence sectors
- 12:21behind enemy lines in France and Belgium across two world wars I mean it's so diverse and
- 12:28and at the heart of developing intelligence methods that they went on to use in the first half of the
- 12:3620th century and beyond so they were pivotal and I think it really I have been asked you know could
- 12:44we have won those wars world war one world war two without the women and 20 years ago five years ago
- 12:51my answer would have been very different but now I absolutely believe we could not have won those
- 12:57wars without these women they are everywhere doing high level intelligence work that's not
- 13:04necessarily a stereotypical view that it's admin as you say clerk secretary driver cook is another
- 13:12one I discovered a number of women who most certainly were not drivers and they weren't cooks either
- 13:17cooks either um and can you elaborate on how various security services adapted and adjusted
- 13:27to the inclusion of women in their ranks you mentioned that for the first two years mi5 had
- 13:34no female employees and so how and why did this evolve over time and was there noticeable resistance
- 13:42to women serving in certain roles and did this begin to shift primarily due to the increasing
- 13:48necessity of their contributions at the most critical and dire moments of wartime well what
- 13:56I did discover gradually it was the right person for the job irrespective of gender and I go back
- 14:05to those female interrogators the first ever used in uniform was in 1941 at a couple of secret sites
- 14:12outside London where they were eavesdropping on the conversations of German prisoners and
- 14:17hitlers captured generals so they were the sort of first one thinking yeah this is really quite
- 14:23unusual but they're also the intelligence services adapted I mean the work was resistance from some
- 14:31men of course but very quickly women became heads of sections so within naval intelligence that's
- 14:37often overlooked that were women that were actually heading up whole sections of intelligence whether
- 14:42it was on the intelligence to do with railways um the u-boats ports coastal areas so you find
- 14:52them doing some really interesting things whether it's aerial intelligence or whether it's the
- 14:57intelligence picture mapping intelligence picture for the Admiralty for example so one of the
- 15:02characters I did uncover was Miss Lee not much we know about her except she ended up heading the
- 15:08section that was gathering the whole of the intelligence along the Normandy beaches ahead
- 15:15of Normandy landings of D-Day and I thought isn't that incredible that the whole of the intelligence
- 15:22for the Admiralty was being headed by a woman and just completely missing because we've made
- 15:28huge assumptions when all we have in many cases has been a photograph of these women maybe on
- 15:37their own maybe as a group in uniform sat at a desk and yeah we've just assumed that they're doing
- 15:43a lot of the clerical work which is true up to a point so we find you know I do find the roles
- 15:50develop but they are doing things behind enemy lines and within offices in the UK way earlier
- 16:00than than we assume one of the interesting things I think and I'm yet to do some more research on
- 16:08is potentially there was a backward step at the end of the second world war such that women's
- 16:15roles in intelligence took a backward role not in all organizations not in all of those clandestine
- 16:21secret organizations but in in many of them but that again deserves a lot more research and that
- 16:28might be why our view of women's roles has been so clouded for so long because in the cold war
- 16:36potentially things went in reverse for women you also mentioned that MI5 had no female double
- 16:46agents that we know of during world war one and this changes during world war two and
- 16:53Olga Gray specifically stood out to me if you can share some thoughts on her work the female
- 16:59double agents are fascinating because we only really heard about the male double agents and
- 17:04there were a whole raft of them that were trained by MI5 some of them worked for the German secret
- 17:12service they were sent abroad to work and the Germans thought that they were really working
- 17:18for them when they were working for us so that's fascinating they're critical to the whole deception
- 17:22operations of the wartime and I do have a key chapter on them but earlier than that so that's
- 17:28during the second world war itself but we were using double agents earlier than that in the
- 17:321930s and you're right Olga Gray is an example of that she's this 25 year old who goes to a political
- 17:41dinner of the conservative party in London and she's asked you know do you want to do something
- 17:48a bit more interesting and it's going back to the recruitment that we talked about earlier
- 17:53and she does and what MI5 the security service is concerned about in the UK in the 1930s are two
- 18:03main threats the communist party great Britain and the right wing the fascists the British Union of
- 18:10fascists as they were called and there are a number of other right wing parties so there are
- 18:15a number of double agents that will run to penetrate to get intelligence on the threats
- 18:21for the right wing but Olga Gray is tasked with gaining intelligence about agents operatives
- 18:29and motives and secret meetings and all that for the communist party of great Britain which actually
- 18:36MI5 have been monitoring in the 1920s and 30s but Olga Gray is on the scene in the 30s she manages
- 18:43to penetrate a spy ring the arsenal Woolwich Arsenal spy ring as it's called that's in a part
- 18:51of London far well sort towards the east end of London if you like it's probably the quickest way
- 18:57to describe it and it was here that we were manufacturing and developing key weaponry
- 19:04particularly there was going to be some kind of big new naval gun being developed and the
- 19:11communist party great Britain was being used the spies Russian spies were being infiltrated into
- 19:18communist party of great Britain so it wasn't just a political party to gain espionage to gain
- 19:24intelligence on us and they managed to have some insiders some workers in Woolwich Arsenal that
- 19:32passed out blueprints and plans and Olga bless her she manages to get employed as a secretary
- 19:40to the head of the communist party great great Britain key place and she makes a note she can't
- 19:47photograph everything because it's a bit risky but she makes a note of all of the MI5 references
- 19:55on the documents that the communist party great Britain has got and MI5 is then able to track
- 20:01exactly what's been stolen and and then obviously slipped back into the archives at MI5 and then they
- 20:10and then they can track what is it the Russians know about our various armament programs and
- 20:15eventually it goes to the old Bailey the famous old Bailey court in London and the perpetrators
- 20:22of which is a man called Percy Gladding he's central to this they are actually found guilty
- 20:27and it's thanks to her work undercover and thanks to her evidence so amazing and very little told
- 20:33about her story but perhaps not surprising because those MI5 files were only declassified in recent
- 20:40years so very very recently and how does the perception of women in intelligence change over
- 20:50time within these intelligence institutions and does it all in the public at large
- 20:57do you know that's a really interesting but difficult question to evaluate and that's because
- 21:05it's been so secret for so long the legacy of these women thousands and thousands of these women
- 21:14has been obscured by official secrecy so likewise we don't always know what the men around them
- 21:21thought we do get glimpses at times and there's one particular famous case where one of the earlier
- 21:27directors of military intelligence actually is quoted in my book isn't he is saying you know
- 21:33women have to be reckless and unreliable and all that kind of thing and essentially untrustworthy
- 21:38but that that shifts that's sort of early part of the 20th century but that does shift and with MI5
- 21:44there's a debate about actually equal pay for women and this is a 1920s story and it's a
- 21:49question of equal pay for women and this is a 1920s so for me these are fascinating discoveries
- 21:55but because it's such a secret world we only have an incomplete picture and we're still beginning
- 22:03to assess there's a lot more material to assess now than there was even five years ago so I think
- 22:09that's a question we'll begin to answer in more detail as time goes by and as these stories
- 22:16come out and I know it's very easy for people to criticize organizations for not having a female
- 22:22head here and a director and there were limitations but there were limitations in civilian society as
- 22:29well I think compared to their opportunities in the civilian life they had in the end a lot
- 22:37more opportunities in the intelligence world because they gained an expertise they start off
- 22:42as anyone does almost like apprentices they gain an expertise and five ten years fifty years later
- 22:49they are experts in their field of intelligence everywhere I saw evidence of women as experts
- 22:55and they are needed they're crucial even if they don't have the right title as we want to say today
- 23:03to reflect that that doesn't mean their contribution is any less I think that's one of the
- 23:08things we have to be careful of when we look at it from a modern perspective what I wanted to do
- 23:14was to tell the stories of what these women did factually to put on record what they did and when
- 23:22and it wasn't just that they were there they were absolutely instrumental and the public's perception
- 23:28at large you know I don't I have a feeling from what well from my own personal experience
- 23:34it seems to me that the wider public still can buy that whole view of the femme fatale
- 23:43the seductive female spy in fact we're in danger of doing it with a couple of our world war two
- 23:49spies as well of turning them into the sort of matter horrors of world war one and I think that
- 23:56just obscures and does a huge disservice to what women really achieved but on the other hand as it
- 24:04was pointed out to me once maybe the whole femme fatale is helpful in the public eye the whole
- 24:10James Bond's view of fast cars miss money penny actually is designed to cast a sort of veil over
- 24:20what women are really doing so they can secretly get on and do their work without the eyes of the
- 24:25world on them I mean who knows I don't know if we'll ever know really yeah that's a really
- 24:31interesting question especially because being underestimated is really good in this line of work
- 24:37right it is yeah yeah never underestimate the women
- 24:42so could you tell us a little about your upcoming book the white lady which will be coming out in
- 24:49September 2025 I believe yes so I don't have an exact date yet I think it's September or October
- 24:562025 but certainly it'll be autumn 2025 the white lady network it's going to cover well the white
- 25:05lady is the title of the book it's going to cover the white lady network of world war one and its
- 25:14successor Clarence of world war two and these are networks of the secret intelligence service mi6 as
- 25:23we call it sometimes today in Belgium across those two wars and rereading the material I'm doing the
- 25:32final edits and a couple of final chapters now looking back at material I wrote such a long time
- 25:38ago early this year thinking oh wow I'd forgotten this and this is a really exciting story I've
- 25:45forgotten just how exciting but there the women were absolutely instrumental and I do have two
- 25:52chapters on each of those networks in the women in intelligence book but I'm going to go through
- 26:00this expand and tell the history in so far as is possible to uncover as much as I can
- 26:08I've been pretty successful with those two networks that turn out to be amongst the most
- 26:13important of those two wars but have had very little attention partly because of secrecy the
- 26:21files have only just really been available
- 26:24the files have only just really been available yeah that's wonderful though to be like one of
- 26:32the first people to look at these um just declassified files um so my last question
- 26:40is what key points would you like readers to take away from women in intelligence and do you think
- 26:48that at some point you'll write a sequel on women's roles during the cold war and beyond?
- 26:56I think there are two main threads to this book that readers hopefully will take away
- 27:03as well as being excited and inspired by the individual stories of the women there are so
- 27:08many in there it's two factors really it's the fact that these the legacy of these women what
- 27:16these women did was obscured by official secrecy they'd all signed the official secrets act and it
- 27:24would be true for some of the stories of men you know cold war and beyond or some of the earlier
- 27:28period it's not been easy certainly this book couldn't have been written 20 25 years ago the
- 27:34material is just not there there were snippets coming out so we're in a very very different
- 27:39place now and rather than blaming sort of misogyny and I don't think it's totally that I think
- 27:46sometimes male historians have focused on particular areas telling stories from files that
- 27:51being declassified then and there are male historians working on the stories of women
- 27:58today now because the materials available so the first strand then is official secrecy
- 28:04so we shouldn't blame the men for having suppressed this history it was secret because
- 28:10the organizations have not declassified the material and so much has not been declassified for
- 28:17mi6 and nothing's come out from them for example and the second thing is the sheer depth of the
- 28:25expertise that these women gathered across their careers going back to a point I made earlier
- 28:33they had 20 30 40 year careers in intelligence and one of the daughters once said to me
- 28:41I mean her mother never really talked about her time well she didn't wouldn't allow to
- 28:45in mi6 I didn't meet the mother but the daughter said to me towards the end of her life the only
- 28:50thing my mother really said about her work was she said I was a career spook and I like that really
- 28:57I couldn't use the word spook in the book because it's anachronistic but yeah I think we're going to
- 29:04uncover so much more and that was something I wasn't expecting to uncover the sheer level and
- 29:10depth of experience of the women that made them utterly indispensable for the organizations they
- 29:18were working for and about the cold war and beyond that goes back to our discussion just now about
- 29:27official secrecy that first point I have been prodding a bit into the cold war early cold war
- 29:36is quite tricky because there's very little available beyond early sort of mid cold war
- 29:43upwards I think it's going to be very very difficult because the material is just not
- 29:48there it's official secrecy it's all still classified so it may be a while I'm going to
- 29:53have a jolly good go and see what I can find but it will it'll be a start but it won't be as
- 30:00comprehensive as my first book on the women women in intelligence but then hey you know I might be
- 30:08sat here in a few years time saying well I thought there would be very little to tell but look what
- 30:14we've actually uncovered and if you look at what has been declassified people say well tons of
- 30:20stuff on the cold war yeah but if you really look at what it is it's the atomic spies the double
- 30:26agents the traitors like kim phil b but guy burges and that lot there isn't really anything
- 30:34about the men all the women that carried out those successful operations so it's true for both the
- 30:41men and the women actually but I'm hoping I can bring to light some some of the amazing women if
- 30:47it's just even a handful begins that process but I do respect that some things have to remain secret
- 30:56and that's fine we'll work with the material we have and start telling the stories that we can
- 31:03absolutely, thank you so much for joining us on Eye Spy the intelligence history podcast
- 31:11it's been wonderful thank you for having me