Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Bob Bar Fight, Attachment, and Pain During Therapy
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob emails, what do you say? Yes? This first email from
- 0:03anonymous patron, she says, when in session with a client, is it
- 0:07a vulnerable experience for you too? I recently had a session with my therapist
- 0:12where we discussed my discomfort for feeling real reciprocal care for my therapist, considering
- 0:17I don't really know my therapist, so I think what she's saying here is
- 0:21that she is discussed discomfort. She feels uncomfortable that she cares about her client
- 0:27even though she doesn't really know her client. When you hear that, what
- 0:30do you think might be going on with the client? I think they're nervous,
- 0:34they want they're worried about rejection, and that they might appear foolish to
- 0:39the therapist and the therapist might reject them and you know, look at them
- 0:43funny or whatever. Right, That's what I think. Yeah, I think
- 0:45that's a common transference or concern that as a client, you're disclosing a lot
- 0:53and you enjoy that, but then you're like, but you never, you
- 0:56know, the client is thinking, therapist, you never talk about yourself,
- 0:59and that's usually an indication that you really care about me, because we both
- 1:03are sharing and you never talk about yourself at all, and I know that
- 1:07that's the way it's supposed to be, but that doesn't feel great to me.
- 1:11It feels uncomfortable. I think another possibility is that she could have been
- 1:15parentified and feels the need to please and take care of other people, and
- 1:18if they don't give the opportunity to be taken care of, it can be
- 1:22uncomfortable. I don't know. Yeah, going on, I also discussed how
- 1:26I realized that sometimes made me a bit resentful that I always had to come
- 1:30in and do the hard work of being vulnerable and she didn't. She quickly
- 1:34mentioned that she can also feel vulnerable during therapy, but we didn't go further
- 1:40into it, and we moved back into focusing on me and my feelings.
- 1:44But it did make me very curious. What might make a therapist feel vulnerable
- 1:49when talking with when working with a client, and what is that vulnera vulnerability
- 1:53like for you as a therapist. Thanks for all your great podcast episodes.
- 1:57I specially appreciate Bob sharing his own vulnerability. So what might make a therapist
- 2:02feel vulnerable when in session? Well, if they happen to be if a
- 2:07client happens to be talking about an area where a therapist has a raw spot
- 2:10that can make a therapist feel vulnerable, and what's that like? That's what
- 2:15she's asking. What is it like for you as a therapist to have that
- 2:20touched on. I get nervous and my heart rate goes up because I fear
- 2:23that I might fall out a balance, or I might do the wrong thing,
- 2:29or I might make a client feel uncomfortable. I get tiery quite a
- 2:34bit with clients. I suppose some people would call that vulnerable. I just
- 2:38think it's being genuine. So I wonder if those two words might get sort
- 2:44of braided together. Right. That's my first question is we have to define
- 2:47vulnerability. There's a lot of usages of that term. Are we talking about
- 2:53what you're talking about where you just feel emotion, some raw sadness or something.
- 3:00Or are we talking about fragility? Are we talking about disclosing of your
- 3:05personal information? Are we talking about being traumatized as a therapist, disregulated as
- 3:10a therapist? You know what exactly we're talking about. But I think what
- 3:14an honest patroon is actually getting at is she has what we call of vulnerability
- 3:17hangover, and it's a vulnerability to share and to be vulnerable with someone is
- 3:24exposing and we desire that, and we in therapy hopefully have a therapist that
- 3:30can hold that, but it doesn't necessarily given our internalizations on our traumas.
- 3:36Afterwards or during we can feel overexposed and we can have some anger about that
- 3:43or some discomfort and some desire to balance the scales. And one of the
- 3:49things as a client you might want to do to balance the scales is,
- 3:52well, now you have to share because I'm being vulnerable here, and you
- 3:57have to reciprocate by putting yourself out there. And yeah, it's a viable
- 4:02request. And as a therapist, depending on the style, they might actually
- 4:08do that for you. It wouldn't be the therapist taking over the session.
- 4:12And that could have been what your therapist was trying to do by saying that
- 4:15she can also feel vulnerable during therapy. So I don't know what the vibe
- 4:20was when she was describing that, but it's possible. So yeah, I
- 4:25would just focus on your discomfort. It's normal to feel uncomfortable, talk about
- 4:29it and process it and ask for that to be held as well. The
- 4:34goal is is that you can be vulnerable with your therapist and other people that
- 4:39you can trust and not second guess it based on previous traumas, that kind
- 4:44of thing. So a couple things I want to talk about briefly, is
- 4:48Bob, are you on cameo now? Because I've been trying to set you
- 4:51up on cameo ye last week? So you have a cameo page I do.
- 4:57If people don't know what cameo is, it's where you can get h
- 5:00level celebrities to say happy birthday to your friend or happy anniversary or something.
- 5:05And so I want to advertise that so you can go. Is it Bob
- 5:10Gettle? Yes, g O E T T L E Bob Gettle? And
- 5:15how much are you charging on cameo? Okay? You told me to charge
- 5:20sixty Okay, Okay, I do what I'm told. Yeah, And so
- 5:25I'm guessing there are some of you that might want a cameo from Bob.
- 5:30I'd be really curious as to what he'll how he'll make the cameo, because
- 5:33you know, when I first started making cameos, it was a real mind
- 5:38screw because to have to just talk into your phone for a minute or two
- 5:45and make it coherent, and I guess interesting and worth the expense. I
- 5:48don't know. It's yeah, it's a thing. And the first I don't
- 5:54know, fifty cameos I did, I probably spent half an hour on each
- 5:59one, even though cameos are only supposed to be like a minute or something,
- 6:02and the video eventually that I would send would only be a couple of
- 6:05minutes. But but now I have kind of a I have practice and and
- 6:11and you know, sometimes I spend a fair amount of time thinking about what
- 6:13I might say. And sometimes I'll sing a song and I'll rehearse the song
- 6:17because you know, sometimes I try to find a song that matches the person's
- 6:21name, you know, and I've never heard the song before, so I
- 6:26have to learn it, and da da da. Anyway, I can only
- 6:28imagine singing Happy Birthday, like like like Marilyn Monroe. That'd be the only
- 6:31singing I do. Gross, So for anyone out there that want that or
- 6:38anything else from Bob on cameo, you can even just have cameos where you
- 6:43just want a little pep talk or a little personal message to yourself. People
- 6:47will do that. They'll be like, hey, I just need a little
- 6:49pep talk. I'm procrastinating. Of course, We can't provide therapy over cameo,
- 6:54but we can speak generally to certain topics, So go ahead and hit
- 7:00up Bob on cameo. Also, I want to remind everyone that on the
- 7:03Patreon community page, So on Patreon, there's different tabs, right, you
- 7:09have the main feed on our Patreon page that has all our episodes and posts
- 7:14and everything, But if you click on the community tab, it's where anyone
- 7:16can put any patren can post there. And I want that place to be
- 7:23a place where people can have conversations about things, you know, patrons,
- 7:26and so I always look at the community page every day and will participate in
- 7:31conversations. But I feel like other people don't necessarily know that that's there,
- 7:36and they don't necessarily respond to other people's because sometimes people ask questions of the
- 7:42community, and I get the feeling that not a lot of people check that
- 7:45page. Is my thing anyway, So just to reminder there. So another
- 7:47thing I wanted to talk about, Bob was a couple or was it just
- 7:51last week we almost got in a bar fight. Oh that sucked. That
- 7:56was last week. Yeah, that was ridiculous, So chime in with any
- 8:01details that you remember. So Bob and I, just the two of us.
- 8:05We went to a local dive bar near where we live. And I'd
- 8:11been here before the pandemic and liked it, and Stacy didn't like this place
- 8:16and didn't want to go back. So when Bob was like, Hey,
- 8:18let's go out to dinner, I was like, Oh, let's go to
- 8:20this dive bart. And you know, they have burgers and tater tots and
- 8:26beer and stuff and darts and video games and pool and stuff. And so
- 8:31we were hanging out playing cards and having a good time. And then we
- 8:37were leaving and I think you went to the bathroom. I think I was
- 8:41paying. Oh you're paying the tab, okay. And I was by the
- 8:46front door, and I was watching these three fellas play this golf game.
- 8:52If you're familiar people out there, there's a game that you can play.
- 8:56It's golf, but it has a big rollie ball that you spin to hit
- 9:01hit the ball. And I'm guessing this game can out probably twenty years ago
- 9:07or something. And these three guys are playing multiplayer golf game and I'm just
- 9:11kind of passively watching because I'm waiting for Bob to pay the tab. I
- 9:15think it took you a while to pay the tab, and I'm just sitting
- 9:18there, you know, just watching casually. And then the three guys finish
- 9:22their game and they walk away from the video game and they walk past me,
- 9:26and I think they're going to play pool or dart because there's a lot
- 9:31of pool tables brands, and so again I'm just kind of sitting there waiting,
- 9:35and then finally Bob comes to me and I thought, well, you
- 9:41know, let's maybe play this video game because kind of look fun. Let's
- 9:45just play. In my head, I'm like, we'll put in one quarter
- 9:48or however much it costs a buck, and we'll play one hole and we'll
- 9:52suck at the game, but it'll be fun. It'll just be a little
- 9:54thing because you know, we'd played darts for a while, we'd played cards
- 9:58for a while, so it's like, let's play stupid golf game. And
- 10:01Bob and I used to golf a lot, so it was kind of reminiscent
- 10:05of that. And so I start to put money in and it turns out
- 10:11there's already credits in the game, or there was already a game in progress
- 10:16or something, and I'm like, huh, and and mind you, the
- 10:22three guys who were playing the game as I was watching, had been you
- 10:26know, had vacated the area. I'm going to take a guess and say
- 10:31fifteen minutes ago. It was a while. It took a long time to
- 10:35pay the tab. Yeah, they were. These three guys were not at
- 10:39the video game, all three of them for a while. You might know
- 10:43where this is going, dear listener. So the two of us, you
- 10:46and I start playing, and we you and I played I'm going to guess
- 10:50five holes of this game, and it turns out that as I we're playing,
- 10:58I'm like, oh, I think this is they just left the video
- 11:01game. Because there's there's three golfers on this game, and there were three
- 11:05guys that walked away. And I guess I could have at that point put
- 11:11two and two together and said are they still playing this game? But I
- 11:15don't even think I would have done that because they just walked away and I
- 11:20was standing right there and they did nothing to indicate that they were coming back
- 11:24anyway. So you and I play for a while, and I'm thinking,
- 11:30man, this game never ends, right. I kept thinking that too,
- 11:33because usually when you play a game that you don't know how to play,
- 11:37within like with pinball, I'm done within fifteen seconds. You know, There's
- 11:43only a few games that I can play for a while, at Galagha or
- 11:46misspac Man, but other games I die so fast. So I'm like,
- 11:50how how are we playing this? I don't know. I don't know if
- 11:54they put a lot of money in or the game is just really cheap to
- 11:56play, or I don't So you and I were play and I'm going to
- 12:00take a guess to say we're playing for fifteen minutes, maybe longer. So
- 12:03by now, I'm going to take guests and say that we're thirty to forty
- 12:07five minutes out. I don't know, what do you think that? How
- 12:09much time do you think we were playing a video game? When you came
- 12:13back to me, it was less than that. It was about ten minutes.
- 12:16Okay. So so let's say you're the red guy and the blue guy
- 12:20with the yellow pants, and I was the yellow guy with the blue pants,
- 12:24but I couldn't keep them straight. Yeah, So conservatively, just like
- 12:26when we played golf when I was young, I hit into the woods of
- 12:30luck. So conservatively, let's say that it was twenty minutes from the time
- 12:35that the guys had left yeah, well right, and you were gone for
- 12:39about ten. Then we play for about ten Yeah, that's right. Then
- 12:41all of a sudden, the three guys are just on us and they're like,
- 12:46hey, what are you doing playing our game? And I instantly start
- 12:50to apologize because I'm like, oh my god, this was your game.
- 12:54I had no idea. I mean, it didn't even cross my mind.
- 12:58But I started apologize, like, oh my god, I'm so sorry that
- 13:01I played your game. I didn't know, and I didn't I didn't blame
- 13:05them. I didn't say like what are you doing walking away from I just
- 13:07was like, oh my god, I'm so sorry, because I'm like,
- 13:11it's just a stupid video game. I can't imagine that. It would be
- 13:15the same as if someone got up to go to the bathroom, like a
- 13:18whole table, and then I sat down at their table thinking that they were
- 13:22gone. They come back and they're like, what do you well we were
- 13:24sitting there and I'd be like, oh, sorry, I didn't know.
- 13:26I wouldn't. It just doesn't matter. It doesn't matter, So I'm apologizing.
- 13:31I buy them around. He did, and so yeah, so both
- 13:35of us are just like, oh my god, I'm so sorry. And
- 13:39at least one of the guys. He kept saying, what phrase common courtesy?
- 13:43That was the thing, common sense, common sense. That's just have
- 13:46some common sense. Just have some fucking common sense. I think it was
- 13:48how he put it at the end. Yeah, he kept saying common sense.
- 13:52So again, both of us are apologizing because what's the big deal and
- 13:58also we didn't know, and you know, I guess we'll fall on our
- 14:03sword and say that it was our fault. Okay, big deal. And
- 14:07you then you offered them money. Well, so this is escalating. So
- 14:11the guy he's like, it's just common sense, man, And I doubled
- 14:16down on my apology, and I'm like, yeah, you know what,
- 14:18I'm sorry. I just I didn't know. Yeah, I guess I should
- 14:20have thought that you guys were coming back. I'm sorry. Yeah, I'm
- 14:24smart saying what you thought was that they went to play pool, because there
- 14:28was a group of guys who were playing pool. What they did is they
- 14:31went outside to smoke, and then they came back, and you thought they
- 14:33just vacated the game to go shoot some pool. Yeah. One, I
- 14:39didn't even know there was a back door, right that. Yeah, great,
- 14:41because they were right next to the front door. Yeah, and why
- 14:43wouldn't anyway, But even if they went outside the front door, I would
- 14:46have thought, even if I did see him go out the back door,
- 14:48I would have thought, well, definitely they've left the building. I don't
- 14:52know anyway. So he's like, we just went out to smoke, and
- 14:56uh, we were only gone for a little bit. And I'm like,
- 14:58I'm like, well you're gone for a while, but yeah, I bad,
- 15:01I'm you know, I'm sorry. I didn't know. And the guy's
- 15:05like, it's just fucking common sense, and he's getting more angry. Yeah,
- 15:09as you and I are apologizing like wholeheartedly about a fucking video game.
- 15:15Yeah, they're really important stuff. Unbelievable and and but you know, it
- 15:22hasn't really hit me the absurdity to this situation. These three grown men.
- 15:26Yeah, yeah, I'm gonna guess they're in their thirties or something. By
- 15:30now we're kind of standing toe to toe. Yeah, he sort of steps
- 15:35up. Yeah, and I'm like, my goodness, his common sense.
- 15:39And I just think I could argue with this guy, but we're leaving because
- 15:43that's what our whole we were on the way out, and I'm just like,
- 15:48and so I reached into my wallet and I'm like, hey, you
- 15:50know what, I'm sorry, and I just start pulling out bills and I
- 15:54think I pulled out like forty or sixty bucks okay, And I'm like,
- 15:58here you go, man, I'm sorry. I hope this makes up for
- 16:02it. And he takes the money. No, no, he didn't think
- 16:07No, he grabbed onto it. But then he says, I don't want
- 16:08your fucking money, and he tried to give it back to me, and
- 16:11I was just like, oh, that's right. Consider this. You know
- 16:17I don't want your money. Just have some fucking common sense. Yeah.
- 16:21So then I we just walked out, and I think he threw the money
- 16:23on the floor. You said you're getting upset, and he's like, I'm
- 16:27not getting upset, and I said, my last comment was I think you're
- 16:30getting upset. I forgot about that, and you you threw your money on
- 16:37the table and you walked out without another word. Oh, I took the
- 16:41money and put it on the table. Yeah, I think so, Yes,
- 16:44I believe that that's what you did. Oh No, I think I
- 16:45gave it. I don't know who knows, but I thought I gave it
- 16:48to him. He grabbed it like reflexively. Yeah. Then was like,
- 16:52I don't want your fucking money, and I wouldn't take it back, and
- 16:55then he threw it on the table. Oh that's right, because I was
- 16:57just like, that's right, and then taking it back. Yeah. Yeah,
- 17:00you're clearly in my head. I'm like, you clearly feel disgruntled and
- 17:06harmed, and so this is an apt and just reciprocation for my transgression.
- 17:14Play the next fifty games on me. Yeah, right. My thought was
- 17:18maybe they had a tournament going and they were playing for big stakes or something
- 17:22or who knows what. But then why the fuck would you walk away?
- 17:25Why would you walk away from a video game while I'm standing right there?
- 17:29Yeah? Look, I mean I didn't really want to play the game while
- 17:32they were playing, but looking back, I would look like someone who was
- 17:34waiting for them to finish playing so I could play. And if if you
- 17:37wanted to keep the game, maybe common sense but dictate that you'd say to
- 17:40the guy, hey, we still got this game going, We're just going
- 17:42to smoke. Yeah, Or sometimes if you leave a beer nearby or a
- 17:48coat, yeah, something, something that indicates that you will be back.
- 17:52Yeah, they left, Other than just you're playing a video game and you
- 17:56just walk off. And the only common sense cole clue was that there were
- 18:02still credits in the game, you know what I mean, there was still
- 18:06like I didn't have to put any money in order to play. That's the
- 18:08only common sensical notion. Even though they were literally not even in the building.
- 18:12They were gone gone, they were in the they weren't on the premises.
- 18:17I'm supposed to have common sense that the you know, Okam's razor is
- 18:22that they were still playing the game, and they were still on the premises
- 18:27at just outside, you know. Because the other thing is people don't smoke
- 18:30in Seattle much, so that's not an assumption either. But even again,
- 18:33even if they were outside smoking, I would still assume that they were done
- 18:37playing the game. Yeah, it just boggles me that one you'd get upset,
- 18:42and two that upon you and I apologizing in a sincere We didn't have
- 18:48to apologize, but we were apologizing because it's like, oh, yeah,
- 18:52sorry, that people just double down. It's weird they doubled down on kindness,
- 18:59decency or whatever. Yeah, you alerted me to a transgression. I'm
- 19:03apologizing. I'm offering to rectify the situation, and you're still pissed off,
- 19:07Like, so why even bring up what the fact that I committed a transgre
- 19:12If you're not looking for for justice, if you're not looking for what did
- 19:17you want me to do? Like get on my knees and kiss your feet?
- 19:21Like what are you hoping to happen here? That probably wouldn't do it.
- 19:23He kept saying common sense, Like I wondered what his angle was.
- 19:27What the hell did he want? He didn't seem to want anything we were
- 19:30offering, But I can't imagine what he did want. I mean, looking
- 19:34back, I think he was literally looking for a fight. It looked like
- 19:37that he's spoiling yet or he's just a miserable human being. I feel like
- 19:41the other two guys weren't really participating. They weren't. One guy sat down
- 19:45on the left and the other guy was standing back. It was just the
- 19:48one fellow, just that one guy. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I
- 19:52thought, am I going to get in a fight? We might too?
- 19:56And I'm thinking Bob and I are older, but we're not small men.
- 20:00We could probably take this guy or at least put up a good fight.
- 20:06And I just thought, well, I guess that's how this evening ends.
- 20:10So that's what you know. Here, here's some money. Yeah, and
- 20:12I'm leaving now, and so anyway, ridiculous. Yeah, good night is
- 20:18it is a fun night. Way too many tater tots. You can never
- 20:22have too many. They were crispy, They were crispy. All right,
- 20:26it's take a break, get back more emails. All right, we're back
- 20:33from the break. Let's do an oppob do an opp. Bobby g And.
- 20:40We have Kyla from Navato, California. We got Carolyn from Ottawa.
- 20:45We have Gill from Ontario as well. We have Savannah from Portland, Oregon.
- 20:52The other Seattle. We have Gwen from Richmond, British Columbia. Beautiful
- 20:57Richmond. They have great China Ease food there, Richmond, Richmond. Yes.
- 21:02Is that near Vancouver. Yes, it's just before Vancouver on the way
- 21:06up there. Ills from Latvia, Christine from Shakopee, Minnesota, Shana from
- 21:14Wisconsin, Courtney from Virginia, r Lean from Illinois, Chris from Vallejo,
- 21:21California, Sabrina from Vessalia, California, Elissa from Vista, California. Whoa
- 21:26Nicholas from Ontario. We got three Ontarios. We got Melody from Iowa.
- 21:33We have Xavier from Godnos or Sophie and Peter from Godnos or thank you for
- 21:37being a patron and staying at patron through thick and thin. Next email,
- 21:41Bob, we have anonymous annual uptier patron, says dear doctor Kirk and Bob.
- 21:47I was hoping you would be able to offer some possible explanations or theories
- 21:51as to why someone would intentionally trigger themselves. I've done this a few times
- 21:55to myself, and it never ends well for me. I don't understand why
- 21:57I would do this to myself, and I get so overwhelmed and then incredibly
- 22:02angry and frustrated with myself. I've been off kilter for days now and I
- 22:06can't stand these feelings. For example, I was sexually assaulted as a child
- 22:08a few times by an older kid in my neighborhood, and then recently sexually
- 22:12assaulted by someone close to me a couple of years ago. I had been
- 22:15getting triggered lately unintentionally by sexually explicit content in TV shows and social media,
- 22:22and I had become really disregulated to the point of screaming and smashing plates on
- 22:26the floor. I was able to calmback down eventually, But then the next
- 22:30day I came across content on a porn website that was the exact sexual act
- 22:34in which I was assaulted a couple of years back, except the sexual act
- 22:38in the porn videos consensual, and at first I scrolled past it, but
- 22:41something within me made me go back to it and watch it. I immediately
- 22:45became overwhelmed and upset, and I think I even somewhat retraumatized myself. I
- 22:51keep having the image as an intrusive thought that I am so mad at myself
- 22:56for watching it. I could cry. Why would someone do this to themselves?
- 23:00Have you heard of this before? I feel like a freak and an
- 23:03idiot for doing stupid things I know cause me such pain. What's wrong with
- 23:07me? Ps? Thank you for all you do. I love the podcast
- 23:11with you and Bob, and sometimes I really listen to past episodes several times
- 23:15just because your voices are so soothing and you speak with such compassion. Unless
- 23:19we're talking about some jerk faces playing a golf game, you're both helping so
- 23:26many people out here in the world. So, Bob, why would someone
- 23:30retraumatize themselves in this way? Well, the first thing I want to say,
- 23:34thank you for thanks. I don't think that the goal is to re
- 23:40traumatize. I think they're trying to work something out and they're sort of drawn
- 23:44to the drawn to the thing, and maybe a way to think about it,
- 23:48it's not the Probably the best way to think about it is sometimes people
- 23:52have dreams about, you know, a traumatic event. I think it's the
- 23:56body's process of digesting traumas, And my guess is that's probably what your body
- 24:00is doing. It's the problem with it, if you could say, is
- 24:04that the exposure to it is not systemic enough or concentrated and properly so that
- 24:11you actually can habituate to the thing. But my guess is once you do
- 24:15habituate to it, you won't find yourself drawn to that. You might still
- 24:22have a vulnerable spot. So when you come across stuff like that, like
- 24:23if if you see another you know, porn thing or whatever, you might
- 24:27find that it's somewhat activating. But proper exposure therapy, which is going to
- 24:34be you know, pretty mindful and thought out and planned, will probably take
- 24:41care of it for you. Yeah, this is a very common thing.
- 24:44There's nothing unusual about you. It's actually a very common thing. It's almost
- 24:48it's near universal what you're experiencing. When we go through trauma, we re
- 24:53experience it. There's a lot of different ways in which we re experience it,
- 24:59and there's also a lot of different conceptualizations of it. But piggy back
- 25:03and what Bob is saying is that, yeah, it's one way of looking
- 25:07at it is that your body is ready to process it, and without a
- 25:12specialist working with you, you can actually traumatize yourself even more. This is
- 25:18a really common thing. Someone will go through a trauma, which is awful,
- 25:21and then the reoccurrence, the intrusiveness, and then the retriggering can exacerbate
- 25:26or cause even more trauma. I can see someone thirty years after a trauma
- 25:32and ninety percent of their symptoms are due to the re traumatization afterwards. So
- 25:37it's really important that you get the treatment from a specialist because if you have
- 25:42guided exposure, then you can actually recover. But if you don't have guided
- 25:47exposure, it can just get worse and worse and worse. And this is
- 25:49how PTSD develops. This is you know, what you're experiencing right now is
- 25:53potentially not only the worry of being retraumatized, which can compound and eventually lead
- 26:00to you not even wanting to be on the internet, or not wanting to
- 26:03leave the house, or not wanting to interact with anyone. So not only
- 26:07is it potentially causing more anxiety and more trauma, but it's also seemingly causing
- 26:12you to beat yourself up psychologically, which can lead to the other aspects of
- 26:18PTSD, which is the feeling of being disconnected, the demoralization, the depression
- 26:26around like why even try that kind of thing, so you know you want
- 26:29to get specialized treatment. The other possibility is that the trauma taught you that
- 26:36you don't matter and you don't deserve to be safe, and that you do
- 26:40deserve to be harmed when we are harmed victimized by other people, you know,
- 26:45we believe about ourselves the way that our people treat us, and so
- 26:48if people treat us well, then we think we're good. And if people
- 26:52treat us like shit, then we think we're a piece of shit. So
- 26:56this is what Freud called masochism, that when we have that internalized, we
- 27:00all have a bit of it, but when you have a lot of that
- 27:03happening to you, then one of the ways of coping with it is to
- 27:06believe that we deserve to be harmed. It's just like, well, I
- 27:08might as well just give into this this thing and stop fighting it and just
- 27:12say okay, fine. It's sort of like if you were a nerd and
- 27:18you have a nerd friend on the playground and the bullies come up and start
- 27:22to bully you and your friend because you're both nerds, then one of the
- 27:27coping styles is to you, as the nerd, you start to bully your
- 27:33nerd friend, and now the bullies might take it easy on you or be
- 27:37a little bit nicer to you, not entirely, it's essentially that it's like,
- 27:42Okay, if I can't beat them, join them, I will beat
- 27:45up on myself and I get some power from that, and it just feels
- 27:49like that's the right thing to do. And so when you're re traumatizing yourself
- 27:56as a way to and then and then afterwards beating yourself up, so you're
- 28:00doing it both ways. You're masochistically exposing yourself and then massochistically beating yourself about
- 28:03exposing yourself. Essentially, what's happening is that there's an internalization, so I
- 28:08don't know. It's hard to know exactly what conceptualization. There are others,
- 28:11but again I would explore that with a therapist highly treatable, highly treatable.
- 28:18So I hope you do seek some help. There's every reason to be hopeful
- 28:22that that can settle. Yeah, it might take a while to find the
- 28:25right clinician, but you but they're out there, an honest, annual to
- 28:30your patron, says Hi, Doctor Kirk and Bob, I think I'm going
- 28:33to fire my therapist after seeing him for four years. Just a few days
- 28:37ago, I couldn't even imagine him retiring one day because I was so attached
- 28:44to him, and it caused too much hurt and sorrow to think about our
- 28:47relationship any one day. Now, after our last session, I feel so
- 28:51enraged with him, and I don't think our relationship can be repaired. For
- 28:55the first time in four years, I abruptly left our session fifteen minutes early
- 28:59and stormed off so upset. It was like the virtual equivalent of storming out
- 29:03of his office and slamming the door. So I'm guessing this must have been
- 29:07an online session or something. Right, I'm so incredibly hurt and angry with
- 29:14him and feel like I truly lost all trust in him. This is causing
- 29:18me such distress and pain, and I don't know how to cope, it's
- 29:22all. It's also hard because this kind of grief isn't really understood by people
- 29:26who don't have experience in therapy, so my friends and family probably won't understand
- 29:30how impacted I am by this loss. Just chiming in your yeah, totally,
- 29:33and I think most people would be like, well, just find another
- 29:37therapist. He was my first and only therapist. I feel like he shattered
- 29:42my heart and I'm so hurt. I just want to scream at him.
- 29:45I have my next appointment this week, but I don't plan on going.
- 29:48I don't think there's anything he could say to me for me to trust him
- 29:52again. I feel devastated by this loss, and I don't know how to
- 29:56deal with it. What do you think, Well, we don't know what
- 30:02happened, so it'd be hard to make comment about what the person should do.
- 30:06If there was some kind of you know, violation, then yeah,
- 30:08i'd say don't go back. But if there was, there's always also the
- 30:11possibility that something is being enacted in therapy that's worth going back. For it,
- 30:18but it's impossible for me to give you any guidance because I don't know
- 30:22what happened that led you to leave the session. Yeah, precipitously, I
- 30:27would suspect that it is reparable annual up your patron, but I don't know.
- 30:33Yeah, you're not. There's no detail here. My dog is barking.
- 30:37But from the way it sounds, if things were going fantastically for four
- 30:41years and then something happened in one session, I mean, unless he just
- 30:47revealed himself as this horrible human being, I'm guessing that he might have made
- 30:53a mistake, something might have been touched hem by a misunderstood it given.
- 31:00Unless it's an agree just like he tried to kill you or have sex with
- 31:03you in the middle of the session, then I'm guessing that it's worth exploring
- 31:10to see if a repair can happen. If not, then you know,
- 31:12then you're done. And certainly it's your choice. You don't have to try
- 31:15to repair it. He can certainly not, but you know, lots at
- 31:18stake. Would I would imagine not only this relationship, it's hard to find
- 31:22a good therapist who you connect with, and too, if it's possible to
- 31:29repair and you don't try, then you could walk away from this as yet
- 31:33another reason to never try to open up to anyone ever again. I agree.
- 31:37So I was thinking about that title story from Love's Executioner where the person
- 31:41shows up for therapy with IRV and she's upset not because she and her therapist
- 31:48had a sexual relationship, but because the therapist ended it. And IRV is
- 31:52horrified by that and can't see why that would, how there would be any
- 31:56there, no justification for that, which I happen to agree and meets the
- 32:00guy and it turns out he's psychotic. He had been doing a silent retreat
- 32:05for weeks and when he came back to real life he was having a psychotic
- 32:13episode from I think from like when you're isolated, yeah or something right.
- 32:19Yeah. So so he felt horrible about what happened, and he was very
- 32:22apologetic, and it came from you know, this out of touch with reality.
- 32:29So the reason, I guess, the reason it came to mind,
- 32:30it's a very dramatic thing to think about. I hope that couldn't happened to
- 32:32the person that wrote in is therapists might have had an off day, and
- 32:37that's a sort of a glib way to put it. They might have something
- 32:40might have been up for them, and they were, you know, might
- 32:45be worth learning about. Yeah, yeah, I mean we don't really think
- 32:49about that, right, that a therapist could have an off day and that
- 32:52there would be a legitimate reason for that. The fantasy is that they just
- 32:57sit in their office waiting for us to show up all week, and then
- 33:00when we walk in they turn on. And they don't have a life outside,
- 33:01They don't have their own issues, they don't have their ups and downs,
- 33:05but of course they absolutely will all right, sexy email up to your
- 33:08patron Laura from Munich. She says, Hi, doctor Kirk and Bob,
- 33:14do you believe that you can have disorganized attachment without suffering immense trauma and abuse
- 33:21in childhood? I really resonate with Bob's description of disorganized attachment. And I
- 33:27have this thing where I have an extreme fear of people seeing me for myself
- 33:31and hating me for it. Does that sound like what you talk about?
- 33:36Yeah it does. Yeah, like I have this shameful, disgusting side to
- 33:39myself that I have to hide. On one hand, I am desperately craving
- 33:43attention and love, but On the other hand, I do everything to keep
- 33:46people at arm's length. I am really people pleasing. I can never say
- 33:51no. I'm always smiling and presenting this image to other people. I listen
- 33:54to everyone's problems and do everything to make them happy. But if I say
- 33:59something even to their disliking, I cry myself to sleep for the next few
- 34:02weeks. If I even slightly perceive rejection regarding my person, I get the
- 34:07sinking feeling in my stomach. I get hot and cold, and my heart
- 34:12is racing, and I feel like my skin is trying to suffocate me.
- 34:15Do you experience that, No, it sounds like a shame feeling. Yeah
- 34:19it does. I have something like that sometimes. Yes. Yeah, I
- 34:22am paralyzed with fear and stuck until they release me by saying something nice to
- 34:28me and not acting differently towards me, and thereby giving me some temporary relief.
- 34:32But my childhood was nice and normal. There was a little bowling because
- 34:37I was a strange, interverted kid and overly emotional, and my parents weren't
- 34:42really a tune to my feelings since they are quite immature about their own feelings.
- 34:45But overall I never doubted their love, just their capacity to help me
- 34:50with anything. I have tried a few different therapists, but so far nobody
- 34:52has been able to help me. So what do you think? So she
- 35:00he's asking, Yeah, can you have disorganized attachments without experiencing abuses during childhood?
- 35:07I don't know the answer to that question, but what I would guess
- 35:10is there's lots of roads to rome. So why not the proofs in the
- 35:15pudding is they say, Well, actually that's not what they say. They
- 35:17say, the proof in the pudding is in the eating. What you experience
- 35:22is a better marker of whether or not you have a particular attachment style than
- 35:25what you went through. So I just pay attention to what you're experiencing.
- 35:30Yeah, and it's I think kind of normal for people to want some answers,
- 35:37I suppose, And what I'll say is that it's possible. I mean,
- 35:43you're definitely describing what Bob will talk about in terms of defectiveness schema,
- 35:47which isn't necessarily disorganized attachment, meaning that you and Bob have a schema that
- 35:53assumes one hundred percent that there's something shameful and reject about you, and so
- 36:01you have to always be acting like something else or you have to be people
- 36:06pleasing or something that's not necessarily disorganized attachment. It can there's some overlap there,
- 36:10but it's not the same thing. Disorganized attachment is when you get closer
- 36:15to someone, you feel terror, you feel actual fight or flight reactions.
- 36:20And I don't necessarily hear that in your description. So easy to understand how
- 36:27that would be related to being abused by your caretaker when you're young, one
- 36:31of your parents, because you feel compelled evolutionary wise to run to your parents,
- 36:37and yet your parent is the monster. Your parent is both the safe
- 36:42haven and the monster at the same time, and so you are disorganized as
- 36:45a child because you don't know how to cope with closeness or danger. And
- 36:51it gets generalized to other contexts. You could be seven years old and be
- 36:54afraid, and you won't run to the teacher because you equate teacher possibly with
- 37:00danger. Yeah, so, and you might equate danger with safe haven.
- 37:05So as a ten year old, you might have a bully who's treating you,
- 37:09who's terrorizing you, and you might actually feel like the bully is the
- 37:13safe haven because that's the thing you learned when you're young. So, as
- 37:16a human being, we are very oriented away from terror, away from threat
- 37:22and danger and towards safety. And if you have no organizational if you have
- 37:28no organization to your style, or to your coping, or to your behavior
- 37:32on how to move towards safety and away from danger, then you're disorganized.
- 37:37You're in a constant state of fear. You are not allowed to actually ever
- 37:42feel safe. You don't get a chance to connect or feel safe. When
- 37:46you're connecting. It's like you feel connected kind of, but in order it's
- 37:50sort of like having sex. In order to have enjoyable sex, you have
- 37:54to feel safe, you have to feel like you're in a good space,
- 37:59and yet you crave sex in all likelihoods. So you want to move towards
- 38:02a sexual encounter or your person that you have sex with. But if the
- 38:07more sexual vibes in the air are equated with danger, then it's hard to
- 38:14become turned on, it's hard to get into the groove, and so it's
- 38:17just better to avoid the whole thing. But you can't because you need it.
- 38:22So it's the same with closeness and attachment. So I'm not hearing that
- 38:28you're in your description. What I'm hearing is a defectiveness schema. Now,
- 38:31it's possible that you just didn't include that, but that's one thing. The
- 38:36other thing is that you mentioned that you weren't abused growing up, So why
- 38:39would you have even a defectiveness schema. Well, you say that your parents
- 38:45weren't really attuned to your feelings since they were quite immature about their own feelings.
- 38:50Now you also say I never doubted their love, but their capacity to
- 38:53help you, just their capacity to help you with anything. So there's a
- 38:58lot of schemas. There's a lot of beliefs that will emerge from that lack
- 39:01of attunement. The child will be pushed in different directions based on their own
- 39:06personality or the circumstance of their lack of attunement. But one of them is
- 39:10the reason why I'm not being attuned to is because there's something deeply flawed with
- 39:14me. Even though I'm not being treated poorly, I'm not being abused,
- 39:17I'm not being terrorized or hit or yelled at. But there's a lot of
- 39:22needs that children have. And also you only remember probably what it was like
- 39:28when you were five years old, four years old at the youngest, maybe
- 39:32or three. But there's a lot of attunment that is needed when you're zero
- 39:37to one, that you won't remember what that quality was like. So there's
- 39:40a lot of things that could have happened there. A lack of attunment could
- 39:44have been similar or more profound, or something that can cause a child to
- 39:50run up against this conundrum. Why when I signal that I have a need,
- 39:54when I signal that I need my parents to pay attention to me,
- 39:59when I signal that I have joy, When I signal that I have pain
- 40:02or discomfort or anger, and I'm not having the attutment I'm not, they
- 40:07don't notice me, or they don't understand how to treat my emotions, they
- 40:14distance themselves or something. What's wrong with this situation? What's going on here?
- 40:17And there's a lot of different solutions that young children will develop. Sometimes
- 40:22it's narcissism, Sometimes it's preoccupations, sometimes it's avoidance, and sometimes it's there's
- 40:28something deeply wrong with me. That's why this is happening. It must be
- 40:31there's something wrong with me. I agree, there is something wrong with me.
- 40:36There's something deeply wrong with me. That's the only way that it would
- 40:38explain this. Because I'm signaling the way everyone else is signaling and everyone you
- 40:44know, but yet I'm being treated differently. So that's just one thing to
- 40:49explore with your therapist and they well, put, yeah, yeah, I
- 40:52really appreciate it, particularly how you frame sex how so that in order to
- 40:58enjoy sex, you have to feel safe. And if the closer you get
- 41:00to somebody, the less safe you feel, then the less you're going to
- 41:04enjoy sex. So you're still going to be pushed towards it and pulled away
- 41:07from it all at once. This is a nice way to think about this
- 41:09organization. Yeah, and you could also just have that experience with sex because
- 41:15of sex and not disorganization, right, But yeah, if you're disorganized,
- 41:19there's a greater likelihood that you'll also have that around sex. Yeah. Yeah,
- 41:22because it's vulnerable and you are expected, typically sexually, to both at
- 41:30the same time express yourself and care for the other person. You know,
- 41:37it's a non verbal, usually physical dance between two or more people where you
- 41:44are both expressing your animalistic needs from inside of you that are deep and powerful,
- 41:51and at the same time paying attention to your partner or partners and also
- 41:57attending to them. And sometimes it's like a seventy thirty sort of a thing,
- 42:01but it vacillates back and forth and in order for people to feel vulnerable
- 42:07in order to go there, not only just behaviorally but also emotionally. It's
- 42:13sort of like you grab. This is a non sexual situation. You grab
- 42:16like a shy seven year old, and you throw them on stage and you
- 42:21say, okay, give a half half hour speech on legos. You know
- 42:25the seven year old is just going to clam up. It's a terrifying situation.
- 42:29You can't expect that child to do that. Now, if you just
- 42:32walk up to the seven year old after dinner and say, tell me about
- 42:37your legos, they might ramble for half in our belly. So it's within
- 42:39them to talk about legos, but they need to be in a safe They
- 42:45needed to feel comfortable and with sexuality and with attachment, like unless you are
- 42:51not anxious, then it's going to be hard to one even just get into
- 42:58your power, your sexual power, and also to attend to the other person.
- 43:01And of course it both people traumatized in it. You know, there's
- 43:05several wrenches in all the gears. So it's worthy of working on, of
- 43:09course, and instead of shaming oneself, and saying there's something wrong with me
- 43:15or us, or there's something wrong with me because my partner isn't showing attraction
- 43:20to me that kind of thing. Anyway, Yeah, it's take a break.
- 43:22We get back more emails as we say yes, all right. Next
- 43:30email big Fan Morgan up to your patron. She says, that's if she
- 43:34called herself big Fan Morgan. I've been thinking lately about what attachment type I
- 43:39fit. I think I used to be more preoccupied, but I feel that
- 43:44I but I find that I feel disorganized most of the time. I am
- 43:47a clinician and am constantly digging into my tendencies and self awareness, and I
- 43:52find my attachment style hard to pin down. But here's what I've come up
- 43:55with. Love to me is like a vast body of water. I want
- 44:00to swim, but so I love to me, It's like a vast body
- 44:04of water. I want to swim in the love water, but I'm in
- 44:08a giant floating hamster wheel. I work hard to poke holes to submerge myself,
- 44:15but when I do, I panic because it feels like I might drown.
- 44:20I work hard to poke holes to maybe get traction, sub submerge yourself
- 44:24in the water. So it's like a barrier, I guess there, but
- 44:29there's a worry. So it's a barrier and a worry of drowning if you
- 44:32go too far into So I patch it up at the hamster wheel and sit
- 44:37on the surface, staring downward. It's preoccupied with the idea of floating,
- 44:42paralyzed with the fear of sinking. What do you think does this sound like
- 44:45disorganize attachment to you? Oh, I'm terrible at this sort of thing.
- 44:50It sounds more like preoccupied to me now. So they're thinking a lot about
- 44:54connection love the metaphor, you know, I guess I'm interested in what's the
- 44:59experience like if there's um of attachment with your attachment figures, if it's a
- 45:05parent or a sib or a partner or whoever, Like what actually happens when
- 45:09conflict hits or when desire hits? What do you find yourself actually doing?
- 45:15The metaphor? I think I probably I don't quite get it, Like how
- 45:22how that might play out with somebody? Like what's the vast sea of love?
- 45:27Sounds sounds like, well, I don't know, is that's gary or
- 45:30is that like abundance or is that hard to know what that is? And
- 45:36yeah, who they shed that with. Yeah, it's a metaphor, So
- 45:40I love metaphors. It's a fantastic image. I'm just not sure I know
- 45:44how to interpret it, right, So I think I agree with Bob that
- 45:50it does sound like preoccupied with a worry of losing yourself. That's not necessarily
- 45:55disorganized. Disorganized as we were talking about, is is terror? You do
- 46:01not just be You're not just afraid. Now, if the drowning is terrorizing
- 46:07you, like fear, just flat out fear, fight or flight response as
- 46:14you think about diving into love, then okay, maybe. But if it's
- 46:22fear and anxiety about losing yourself or being rejected is another possibility then and you
- 46:30know, we get into some weird areas here, because you can certainly have
- 46:32tremendous terror and trauma around rejection. So and you know these aren't there's not
- 46:38a hard demarcation between these designations either. But yeah, it's hard to know
- 46:45based on your metaphor's next email and honest patrons, she says, and by
- 46:49the way, trigger warning, this has to do with self harm, so
- 46:52skip ahead. I guess if that triggers you have you ever had a client
- 46:55who harm themselves during a session. I have a mostly unconscious habit of skin
- 47:00pinching and nail digging when I'm anxious or distressed in a conversation. One time,
- 47:07I drew blood from clenching my nails into my palms during a session with
- 47:10a past therapist. I didn't realize I had done it until she turned away
- 47:15from me to schedule the next appointment, and I looked down at my hands.
- 47:17I showed her when she turned back around, and she was very much
- 47:22caught off guard. In hindsight, maybe I should have approached that differently.
- 47:27Just chiming in here, any thoughts on that. Nothing wrong with what you
- 47:30did, and you guys were both surprised by it. It doesn't sound like
- 47:34what I would call self injury. It sounds inadvertent. There wasn't an attempt
- 47:38to cause harm. It's just you might have learned to manage distressed by inflicting
- 47:44pain, or maybe your body just gets tense when you're scared or something.
- 47:47Yeah, there's certainly nothing wrong with that, and your therapist was taken aback
- 47:54for a second. It's fine if the therapist was judgmental or freaking out.
- 47:59Then I would say that's not great, but it's human to say, oh
- 48:04my god, you're bleeding that what's happening now? I don't know if it
- 48:08is just tenseness, because she's saying that she has emotionally unconscious habit. She
- 48:15says, I mean, it's not classic cutting or self harm. Typically these
- 48:22are ritualized experiences that people will engage in, but with some people it can
- 48:29be this way, it can present this way skin pinching, and as distress
- 48:34starts to go up, as anxiety starts to go up, then the individual
- 48:37will do things like this, dig their nails in or pinch themselves or pull
- 48:43their hair as a way of just a low grade amount of pain that they
- 48:50are slightly unaware of and slightly aware of. So it's it's not the classic,
- 48:54but it is potentially under that category anyway. So, but have you
- 49:01ever known anyone who did harm themselves in session? Or? Oh? Yeah,
- 49:06how so do you want me to talk about this? Yes? Okay,
- 49:09So very first DBT skills class I was teaching when I was way young,
- 49:15and I was running it with another another novice DBT person. We were
- 49:21both sort of thrown into this thing and we had a client to associate and
- 49:25cut herself in the bathroom at the clinic where we worked. And then she
- 49:30came into the classroom and she had the most weird stare. She was just
- 49:36staring right at me and I thought she was going to hit me, like
- 49:37she looked angry, like I couldn't read her. And then somebody said,
- 49:42she's bleeding, and I looked down and her arm, both arms were dripping
- 49:46because she cut pretty severely. So we called the ambulance and they came and
- 49:52got her, and we removed our students because they all watched this. It's
- 49:55really quite was it a lot of blood? It is a good amount.
- 49:59I mean not like not like gushing, but yeah, but but not just
- 50:04like a scratch. No, she was dripping blood. So so what we
- 50:08did was we left that room and she went to the wherever they took her,
- 50:15I guess probably to a hospital. And did she comply at that point?
- 50:17And oh yeah, she didn't fight any of this when they showed up
- 50:22to take her, she just walked along to have a conversation with her at
- 50:24all. There wasn't any talking to her in that particular moment though. I
- 50:29think, what I if I remember what I did is I asked all the
- 50:31students to leave the room, and Noel, my co teacher, walked her
- 50:38back to the bathroom and tended to her wounds while we waited for the ambulance.
- 50:44So the rest of the students were horrified. It's actually quite risky because
- 50:46that stuff can be contagious. We didn't have contagion. I'm really glad.
- 50:52And we also didn't kick her out, and we told her, no,
- 50:55you don't get to leave the group. What you get to do is tell
- 51:00us what you're going to do to prevent it from happening again. And she
- 51:02took about four weeks. We we did not want her to take longer than
- 51:07that. And she returned to the group and she apologized for what she did.
- 51:10And I can't remember what the plan was that she wentn't do it again,
- 51:14and then she graduated whatever you know, after that that year. So
- 51:19that's the first time. The second time, what was the staring about.
- 51:22She was completely dissociated, She was just gone. She was not aware.
- 51:27She triggered by something that happened in class. Yeah, but I don't know.
- 51:30I don't remember what it was. And if I ever knew, I
- 51:31don't remember. Now something happened yet and when she apologized, how did she
- 51:37how did she approach that very sincerely because it's not really her fault, so
- 51:42just you know, it's it's it's a situation that No, it's not.
- 51:46It's not like apologizing because she's bad, not like a mere couple like that,
- 51:50but like a recognition of her impact on the group. I say,
- 51:52is more more the flavor of the thing, Like she had a really crappy
- 51:55impact on the thing and so scared the shit out of people. And for
- 52:02some there may have been urged to mimic I don't. I don't know nobody
- 52:07did as far as I know. So how did you manage that? I
- 52:10mean, did you have to help people deal with that? After? Yeah,
- 52:15we stopped class. We went to another room and we just sort of
- 52:19talked about it and debriefed. And I don't think we had maybe six seven
- 52:22students in that class at that time and who were there that day, and
- 52:27we talked about the fact that she was safe, she was going to get
- 52:30looked after, and how's everybody here? And that was pretty horrifying, and
- 52:37we'll make sure that we get the room cleaned, because you know, the
- 52:38last thing anybody needs is to go and see the stains on the carpet.
- 52:42Or did you feel during this whole thing? My heart rate was up.
- 52:45I was really nervous. Just the beginning of your career. Yeah, this
- 52:47is in nineteen ninety nine. How come all the most traumatic things happened in
- 52:52there in our early career? Well, I had another thing happened then along
- 52:57these lines is we had a student in class and she had some strange behaviors.
- 53:02Um. One of them was she would sit under the table like she
- 53:06would just crawl into the table one time in class. I don't remember if
- 53:09it's when she was really So all of the DBT courses take place around like
- 53:15a boardroom table sort of thing. That that's the way I've always done it.
- 53:19Yeah, huh. In my head, I always had you in a
- 53:21circle without any table. Oh yeah, no, no books and paper and
- 53:24pens and pencils and a whiteboard, and it's like a class yeah yeah,
- 53:28yeah, but you're sitting around one big, ten big table. Yeah,
- 53:30my dining table, you know, my nice dining table. Yeah, it
- 53:32opens up, and we used to cram ten people around. That thing was
- 53:36a little bit tight, but we could do it. So you took the
- 53:38table to work. Why don't that table came from work? I bought for
- 53:43work. You bought it for work, and then you and then and then
- 53:45you adopted it for your home situation. Yes, it's a very nice table.
- 53:49It is. It's cool because you can open it by pulling on one
- 53:52end and then the both ends like out like unfurral unfurl. Yeah, it's
- 53:55really cool. Yeah. I like that table. And it's big enough and
- 54:00so and that's not even that big of a table. So how many students
- 54:01would sit around that thing? Eight students, two leaders? Okay, yeah,
- 54:06that's still a fair amount of people. Yeah, but pretty close quarters.
- 54:08Four on the side and one on each end. Yeah, it was
- 54:12really close. Probably a little bit too close, huh. Yeah. And
- 54:15then we did it in you ever been in my tiny office on Capitol Hall
- 54:16down the hall from the one that you used to have with me. Huh
- 54:20Yeah, it's it's a little bit tight for ten but yeah, funny we
- 54:23could do it, but it wasn't great. It's funny because in my head
- 54:27I always imagined you doing visually what I did once many years ago, when
- 54:35I was at an agency I have, I had you in that office in
- 54:37the same chairs, but it's a very different scenario than what was happening.
- 54:43I don't know. I don't know why. I like to visualize. Oh
- 54:45I do that all the time. Yeah. Yeah. All my clients live
- 54:47in my old house in my Seattle. Whenever I pictured them at home,
- 54:52they were living room, icy, funny, weird. Yeah, it's weird.
- 54:54Oh and everybody on zoom is either five four or five eight people.
- 55:00I think Overzoom people seem shorter. I guess. I don't know, because
- 55:05or video, because when people think I'm short on YouTube, I don't know
- 55:10if that's true. I've heard that a couple of times, where people will
- 55:15say something. They'll see a picture on Instagram. They'll be like, oh,
- 55:17it's Kirk. Is he tall? And I'm like, so you assumed
- 55:22I was short? You know? Which is I don't know. I don't
- 55:25know what that is. Maybe because you're small, like in this little device
- 55:30and on a phone and you just look small or something. Yeah. Anyway,
- 55:36so, oh, so this client under the table cut herself during our
- 55:42meeting. Excuse me, I think she used a paper clip and that wasn't
- 55:46cool. So she and I had just a matter of fact talk about how
- 55:51that's really tacky, you can't do that here, and she didn't do it
- 55:54again. She was really I liked her. She was she had some quirks,
- 55:59and also it was very lovely, sincere human, and agreed that she
- 56:02wouldn't do it again and didn't do it again as far as I know.
- 56:07So, Yeah, So the answer to the question is, yeah, that's
- 56:10happened. Would you approach it differently if it happened in a regular session,
- 56:15like an individual session? Yeah? Might I approach it differently if somebody cut
- 56:20in front of me or went to the bathroom and showed up it came back
- 56:23and had cut. No, I'd probably approach it the same way, very
- 56:28matter of factly. First thing, medicals or anything medical needed. Second thing,
- 56:35what happened, what triggered it. We're gonna have to learn about this.
- 56:37But that's different than what you were saying with a DBT class. With
- 56:42a DBT class, it sounds like you were more of the approach of I
- 56:45mean, you said there were tacky. So it's essentially you're giving I think,
- 56:51a message of you can't do that here, you can't do that.
- 56:52He's against us. But you're not saying that in your role play just now
- 56:58with an individual client. No, I wouldn't say you can't do that here,
- 57:01though I don't want you to do that here very much, but you
- 57:05know what I mean, it's a different Yeah, a different approach. I
- 57:07think it's because of the contagion factor. But also because correctly, if I'm
- 57:12wrong, DBT is a class and it's not therapy. It's not therapy.
- 57:15You don't consider it therapy. No, No, that that thing we'll get
- 57:19talked about. But in the person's individual therapy. In the group, it's
- 57:22just we do we do the skills class and we keep the class running,
- 57:24right, that's it. There's there's ground rules and need to follow them and
- 57:30that's just how it goes, right, So stop that. Yeah, don't
- 57:34cut in class, don't cut during class. Yeah, don't do that.
- 57:37Get it worked out, and then you got to do repair with this group
- 57:39because talk with your therapist about it or something. Yep, whatever it takes.
- 57:44And yeah. Yeah. So yeah, as the way you were describing
- 57:47the way you approached the two incidents, I was thinking you probably wouldn't do
- 57:52that an individual. No, no, an individual, I'd be talking what
- 57:55the heck happened here? Because you don't want this, and I don't want
- 57:59this, and yet this happened, so let's we got to learn it.
- 58:02We got to learn it. Yeah. So yeah, for me, I've
- 58:07never had someone do that in session, but I've had a lot of sessions,
- 58:12and the older I get, the more fades. So God knows,
- 58:15but I can't recall. I feel like I would have remembered something like that.
- 58:20Might someone have harmed themselves just before or after or during when they go
- 58:23to the bathroom or something, you know, I could I could imagine that
- 58:27happening. Yeah, I think I vague memories of at least things being told
- 58:31to be that were akin to that. I don't have any current clients that
- 58:35are along those lines. I think if it happened to me, I might
- 58:38approach it a little differently than the way you're not entirely, but a little
- 58:44differently than the way you do. I think you have a point of view
- 58:49based on your DBT work that is more on top of things. I guess
- 58:55for me, given my approach to a lot of things in therapy, including
- 59:00this, I think I would just raise the question if they wanted to talk
- 59:06about it, and what do they want to do with it? You know,
- 59:08I don't have a I don't have skin in the game, so to
- 59:12speak. If they wanted to do that, I can't imagine being okay with
- 59:16it, so to speak. But like if someone said that every session they
- 59:22in the middle of the session, because what they do before and what they
- 59:24do after, I'm not going to police that. But in the middle of
- 59:28session they get up and they go to the bathroom and they harm themselves somehow,
- 59:31and they come back. What would I and they told me about it,
- 59:34I'm just trying to imagine what I would do, And I think I
- 59:37would just say why and what's going on? Do you want to talk about
- 59:40it? Do you want to work on it? Was it something we talked
- 59:44about? What are the triggers? I might if they don't know, I
- 59:46might give some psycho education about non suicidal self injury and the brain and addiction,
- 59:52and also tell them that I'm not gonna judge them, and I'm not
- 59:57their dad or their police officer or teacher, and I'm not afraid of it.
- 1:00:01Yeah, because plenty of climbing. When you specialize in personality sorders,
- 1:00:05you're going to get a fair amount of people who will do this sort of
- 1:00:07thing. So it wasn't foreign to me, and it never. The first
- 1:00:10thing that I would often have to do with not only the client but their
- 1:00:15support system was calm everyone down and just say it looks scary and as long
- 1:00:21as I had assessed it to not be that dangerous, not as dangerous as
- 1:00:24they're perceiving it. You know, most people think of it as like as
- 1:00:28suicidal, like they're going to die by suicide the next day or something.
- 1:00:30Well, right, yeah, and it's blood and they're scary. You know,
- 1:00:34it's just a scary image. It's a scary thing. But you know,
- 1:00:38for you and I, this is commonplace. It's okay, it's it's
- 1:00:43it's understood, it's well researched. We've been down this road many times before.
- 1:00:46We've felt people to recover. I've had clients who never recovered. I
- 1:00:51had clients that I only saw for a short amount of time that I'm guessing
- 1:00:53continue to do it afterwards. And I didn't cry myself to sleep. But
- 1:00:58you know, there are worse things in life that I would worry about from
- 1:01:00my clients. This is not one of them. You know. The things
- 1:01:01I worry about with my clients are them being abused which would happen sometimes I
- 1:01:06would have them as a client while they're in the midst of being abused by
- 1:01:10their parents or their partner, even at work sometimes this kind of thing.
- 1:01:15So that scares me, That concerns me, that causes me fear and anxiety.
- 1:01:22I don't know. There's some other things. I suppose serious suicidal intention
- 1:01:27would also scare me. Someone having non suicidal self injury, self harm cutting
- 1:01:31just didn't phase me. I don't know why, but I think once I
- 1:01:37understood and I'm like, oh, that's not really anything, and plus you
- 1:01:39work enough with it. So a lot of what I would have to do
- 1:01:43is just calm everyone down and just be like, hey, it's okay,
- 1:01:45we're working on it. There's a treatment plan, here's what we need to
- 1:01:49do, and we're going to work on it. But there's not any immediate
- 1:01:52danger as far as I can tell. Here's what you should do. Here's
- 1:01:55the crisis plan. Dada da. If you see this, then we will
- 1:02:00escalate the crisis plan. But as for now, everything is, it's fine.
- 1:02:05Teachers, I would have to calm down a lot of times because they
- 1:02:07would really flip out. I don't know if they do anymore but they used
- 1:02:12to Well, I mean, well, you know, everybody has a learning
- 1:02:15curve, right, yeah, I mean you know, it looks scary and
- 1:02:17it's rarely talked about so and it's often approached in schools as a punitive thing
- 1:02:23like and a lot of people have a myth that particularly teenagers will do it
- 1:02:30because they're trying to get attention. They're just manipulate. It's almost entirely opposite.
- 1:02:35Yeah, yeah, I mean occasionally I would run into some kids who
- 1:02:37would be dabbling in it as a way quote unquote to get attention, meaning
- 1:02:42that they're not doing it because they're suffering. They're doing it, I mean,
- 1:02:45they're suffering in a way, but the behavior doesn't last very long.
- 1:02:52It's experimental. Maybe they have a friend that does it and they feel like
- 1:02:55they want to participate or something. So occasionally that would happen, But the
- 1:03:00pattern was that it was fleeting. It was not very severe. The individual
- 1:03:07wasn't even that ashamed of it. They actually took some pride in having some
- 1:03:12solidarity with their friends or something, and so there could be that, but
- 1:03:15but typically it's not particularly for an adult. It'd be really rare for an
- 1:03:20adult to act that way. So, yeah, if I had someone do
- 1:03:25that, I think I would just say, what do you want to do?
- 1:03:29Do you want to talk about it? And I'd be trying to give
- 1:03:31off the impression, which is true, that I don't judge them. I'm
- 1:03:37okay, I'm not afraid because I think that was a big part of it,
- 1:03:39is telling the client. And I'm sure you did this with your individual
- 1:03:43clients as well, that you know in the outside world you're going to get
- 1:03:46a lot of gasps and shock and judgments and control and freak out. Yeah,
- 1:03:53well it's all footing. Yeah, you're not going to get it in
- 1:03:57here. No, I might not be happy about it, but I'm not
- 1:04:00going to be shaming somebody. I'm not gonna flip Yeah, I'm not going
- 1:04:02to flip out. I'm not gonna shame you. I'm okay. I know
- 1:04:08that we're both okay and we'll both get through this, and I'm here for
- 1:04:13you and everything's fine, and you can you can just be yourself, even
- 1:04:17if that involves cutting. You can be that person and I will still care
- 1:04:21about you, and you could never stop cutting for the rest of your life,
- 1:04:26and I will not change my care for you. That will never change,
- 1:04:30and so be you and ask and I will work on whatever you want
- 1:04:35to work on. If you want to try to work on it, we'll
- 1:04:38work on it. If you don't, then we won't and I will not
- 1:04:41think a second thought about it because it's okay. So that that was a
- 1:04:45big part of my Thingum. What I like about that is all the genuine
- 1:04:49acceptance in it. Yeah, it's really people need that. It's liberating though
- 1:04:55for me as a therapist, because to become someone's parent and to get all
- 1:04:59up ti about trying to control control the client's behavior is is a much worse
- 1:05:03place for me. I'd much rather be chill and compassionate than uptight and controlling
- 1:05:10and worrying all the time. So everyone wins, all right, Well that
- 1:05:15doesn't for that episode of psychology in Seattle. Everyone well wait wait, no,
- 1:05:20no, no, no, actually there's some more here, Okay in
- 1:05:24the email I just sort of glanced over. We didn't get through the whole
- 1:05:27email. More recently, so this is anonymous patient. More recently, I
- 1:05:31pinched my arm through my sweater. This one I was more aware of,
- 1:05:35but also felt like I couldn't stop. I pinched and pinched and pinched,
- 1:05:39so I'm thinking this is in session. After leaving the session, I looked
- 1:05:43at the damage and it was really bad, severe and large raw marks that
- 1:05:46took several weeks to heal, so bruising on the arm. I think it
- 1:05:51seems like another therapist asked me about the marks during the next session, as
- 1:05:57I also intentionally self harm, so that's another point though, but he was
- 1:06:00really shocked to learn I had done that during our last conversation in session.
- 1:06:04I'm seeing another therapist now, but the appointments are virtual and so it's much
- 1:06:09easier for me to hide these behaviors and session. I'm struggling with whether or
- 1:06:13not I should tell her when I do this kind of thing. As therapists,
- 1:06:16would you what would your thoughts be and would you like to know?
- 1:06:19Bob, I'd want to know, and I would want the person to stop
- 1:06:24during our meeting and to talk about the urge to do it, And I
- 1:06:28probably take a more active approach to it than you would. I would address
- 1:06:32it as a thing that needs to go simply because it increases the likelihood of
- 1:06:36premature and death. But it doesn't mean that the person is going to kill
- 1:06:40himself. It just means that they're more likely when they do non suicidal self
- 1:06:43injury to die from suicide. So I would address it directly. But I
- 1:06:51never did much of this kind of work in individual therapy, and for obviously,
- 1:06:57well, for reasons we've already talked about. I don't work with the
- 1:07:00kind of clients anymore in selve couples any these days. Anyways, Yeah,
- 1:07:04and I get a lot of these I read a lot of these questions on
- 1:07:10Reddit. Someone will post something like there's a secret that I'm keeping from my
- 1:07:15therapist. Should I tell them? And I'm always like, yes, yeah,
- 1:07:17do you want the therapy to work now you don't have to tell them
- 1:07:23everything? Yeah, And it depends on what you're there for. I suppose,
- 1:07:27like if you're there to work on smoking cessation and you have a kink
- 1:07:32that you are wanting, you're talking about this it has to do with smoking,
- 1:07:36which I'm guessing some kinks do. But if it doesn't have anything to
- 1:07:40do with what you're there for, then you don't have to. There'd be
- 1:07:43no reason you can if you want to. But often the questions have to
- 1:07:46do with things like this. It's like I'm self harming during session, right,
- 1:07:51and I self harm after session and before session, should I tell my
- 1:07:56therapist? The answer is probably yes. Now you don't have to, and
- 1:08:00I wouldn't judge it from that already though, right, that's why they're writing
- 1:08:03it. Yeah, and Bob and I will talk about this. You can
- 1:08:06raise the question without telling them. You could telling her. You could say,
- 1:08:11so, I have a lot of things that I haven't told you because
- 1:08:15I'm worried about judgments or I don't know. You can bring it up without
- 1:08:18saying it. But yeah, and what I want to know, Yeah,
- 1:08:23I would want to know. Now would I say you, I'm different than
- 1:08:27Bob in this way, what I'd tell you that you had to stop?
- 1:08:30No, I'd just be like, oh Now. What I would personally do
- 1:08:33is use it as a barometer for your emotional state because I need to.
- 1:08:38I need to be at tuned to that. So I might ask you,
- 1:08:41as a client, how are you feeling? And as a part of that
- 1:08:45inquiry, I might say, are you currently subconsciously digging into your skin or
- 1:08:49are you pinching yourself? Not that I'm telling you to stop it, and
- 1:08:53I'm telling it's an indication your body's trying to tell you something yea. And
- 1:08:58so we need to listen to your body and attune to that and maybe slow
- 1:09:02down a little bit and turn towards what you're going through, because if you're
- 1:09:09suffering, because that's what's happening, is in all likely it could be an
- 1:09:12addictionary kind of thing as well, which happens, but it's in all likelihood
- 1:09:15you're experiencing tremendous tension and you're relieving it or distracting yourself by doing this.
- 1:09:21So that's a problem. If you're under that much distress, Now that might
- 1:09:27be endemic, that might just be a part of the gig. But if
- 1:09:30you're just sort of rambling about work meanwhile your body is completely freaking out,
- 1:09:35then the two of you, your therapist and you should be turning towards that
- 1:09:40distress and like focusing on your body and maybe doing some relaxation or tending to
- 1:09:45yourself or taking a break from the topic you're talking about or something, because
- 1:09:50that is not only fair to you or just as you're suffering, but also
- 1:09:54just teaches you to pay attention to yourself, teaches you that there are a
- 1:09:58lot of different ways in which you can relieve. We don't have to endure
- 1:10:00and white knuckle therapy, which is what it sounds like to me. That's
- 1:10:04what it sounds like to me too. There's a possibility for agency and authority
- 1:10:09to be enacted here that the way I've learned to deal with my distress is
- 1:10:12by pinching myself to cause pain and then you know, the bruising or whatever.
- 1:10:16And wouldn't it be great if I could speak? This is too much
- 1:10:19for me? Can we please go slower? This is making me want a
- 1:10:24pinch, and I don't you know, presumably I don't want to pinch.
- 1:10:29So can we change our tack here? Can we do something that's different That
- 1:10:34would be a great way to attend to the distress without having to fall into
- 1:10:41the self arm, the self regulating self harm. Another aspect of this,
- 1:10:45not only the addiction side, but well maybe in that category, is that
- 1:10:50everyone that I've talked to who has non suicidal self injury is worried about disclosing
- 1:10:56it because they worry that I'm going to tell them they can't do it anymore
- 1:11:00because they often depend on it so and they could be quote unquote addicted to
- 1:11:04it in terms of the neurochemicals. But often people will really, you know,
- 1:11:11they resort to these coping techniques because all else has failed, so this
- 1:11:16is their last stitch effort. It's sort of like going after someone who smokes
- 1:11:20weed every day or drinks alcohol every night to numb out. They get defensive
- 1:11:26about it because they subconsciously know or consciously know that if they don't have that,
- 1:11:30they have nothing and they're going to suffer. So when clients have these
- 1:11:35kinds of heroes, it's natural for them to worry about bringing it up because
- 1:11:39they're like, well, but my therapist is going to want to take this
- 1:11:42away from me. So I was always very clear that what we're gonna do
- 1:11:45is we're going to have fifty other ways that work better than that, and
- 1:11:50then we'll take that away. I won't take it away, you'll take it
- 1:11:54away. So this is on your terms, this is on your schedule.
- 1:12:00But I can't help you unless I know about it. I can't I can't
- 1:12:03know the situation unless you tell me the whole thing. Now, on the
- 1:12:06flip side, could you talk about your distress? Could you disclose that you
- 1:12:13are going through a lot of tension in therapy without specifically mentioning this behavior.
- 1:12:18Yeah, you could conceivably, you know that there's a world in which you
- 1:12:23could still get the job done without having to disclose the specifics around how you
- 1:12:29know that you're distressed and still have the distress taken care of, and the
- 1:12:34agency and the regulation and the attunment could all happen. Yeah, it's possible.
- 1:12:41But you know, I don't see why you would do that. I
- 1:12:43don't see why you would leave that detail out like it just fument's shame.
- 1:12:46Yeah, but you know, I don't know. So I feel like there's
- 1:12:49different phases of therapy. Maybe you can I can attest to this that different
- 1:12:56therapists. I have different vibes with different points in my life, and there
- 1:13:00are certain closets that I don't open up with certain therapy or certain times.
- 1:13:06Sort. I'm just saying that I don't really want to deal with that right
- 1:13:10now, that you know later on I will, or with a different therapist,
- 1:13:14or I've already dealt with all that stuff. I just don't have the
- 1:13:16gumption to really get into that shit, right you know. So you know
- 1:13:20it depends, so everyone truly, Now take care of yourself because you deserve it.