Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Data Privacy Laws Outside of California—A Roundup with Diana Iketani Iorlano
Transcript
- 0:06I'm Christina Toussaint, and I'm delighted to
- 0:08introduce today's speaker, Diana Iketani -Ilerano.
- 0:12Diana is a privacy lawyer, litigator, and serves
- 0:14as outside general counsel to companies ranging
- 0:17from small businesses to large corporations.
- 0:20She's a member of the International Association
- 0:22of Privacy Professionals, the IAPP, and was recently
- 0:25recognized by the IAPP as a fellow of information
- 0:28privacy. Through the IAPP, Diana is a certified
- 0:31information privacy professional in the U .S.
- 0:34as well as Europe, Asia, and she's also a certified
- 0:38information privacy manager. She is qualified
- 0:41as a data protection officer, also referred to
- 0:44as a DPO, under the European Union's general
- 0:47data protection regulation, also GDPR, and a
- 0:50thought leader on privacy and data security matters.
- 0:53Let's get started. Thanks so much to Christina
- 0:59and to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 1:01having me back. Today's webinar is about data
- 1:06privacy laws outside of California. You may have
- 1:10participated in an earlier webinar where we were
- 1:13dealing with privacy laws in California. So now.
- 1:17We're going to touch what's happening outside
- 1:19of the state of California, and we will have
- 1:22a Q &A at the end if you have other questions,
- 1:25but I'm ready to just dive in and give you an
- 1:29overview of the landscape in all the other states
- 1:31that are having privacy laws right now. So the
- 1:36structure of our presentation today is we're
- 1:38gonna do an overview of the various states that
- 1:41have privacy laws. And I'm hoping that you'll
- 1:44be able to understand the key differences between
- 1:47the various state privacy laws. We're gonna recognize
- 1:50some common compliance challenges because obviously
- 1:54when there's a patchwork of laws throughout the
- 1:56country, it's gonna be a little bit more difficult
- 1:58to comply. And we'll talk about. maybe some practical
- 2:02tips for that. We wanna learn how to evaluate
- 2:04which of these laws apply to our clients and
- 2:07the scope of the application of the various privacy
- 2:10laws. And we're gonna identify some relevant
- 2:12enforcement and legislation trends throughout
- 2:15the country. And then I'll summarize and then
- 2:18we'll jump into Q and A. So as Christina mentioned
- 2:22and... Little anecdote, Christina Toussaint and
- 2:25I went to law school together at USC. So it's
- 2:27great to have her introducing me today. It's
- 2:29much appreciated. So I'm Diana Iketani of Iketani
- 2:33Law. As Christina mentioned, I have a number
- 2:36of certifications from the International Association
- 2:38of Privacy Professionals. I practiced law at
- 2:42a big law firm for many, many years before opening
- 2:44my boutique law firm about seven years ago. And
- 2:48Iketani Law is in El Segundo. And we help throughout
- 2:53the nation and throughout the world that are
- 2:55trying to comply with this patchwork of privacy
- 2:58laws, especially now all the ones in the various
- 3:02states in the United States. So in order to give
- 3:06us an orientation as to where we are right now,
- 3:09and in case you didn't attend one of our prior
- 3:12versions of this webinar that talked about California,
- 3:15I just wanted to recap what the California Consumer
- 3:17Privacy Act and the California Privacy Rights
- 3:20Amendment created in California. And all of this,
- 3:24too, is in the backdrop of global privacy laws.
- 3:27So throughout the world, there are various privacy
- 3:30laws, including one you've probably heard of,
- 3:32GDPR. And then California created the CCPA in
- 3:372020. It went into effect. It was expanded by
- 3:40the CPRA in 2023. But this was really the first
- 3:44comprehensive state privacy law in the United
- 3:47States. And what it offered were, and still does,
- 3:51were broad individual consumer rights, the right
- 3:54to know what information a business is collecting
- 3:56about you, the right to access that information,
- 3:59the right of deletion of your information. And
- 4:03later, you also retain the right to correct your
- 4:06information, to opt out of the sale or sharing
- 4:08of your information. the right to non -discriminations,
- 4:12just because somebody exercises their privacy
- 4:14rights, you're not allowed to discriminate against
- 4:17them or treat them differently. And then also
- 4:20the right to limit sensitive personal information
- 4:22and how it's used. So as a base level, the California
- 4:29Consumer Privacy Act applies to certain businesses.
- 4:32There are typically thresholds, and you'll see
- 4:34this throughout the other states, but there are
- 4:37thresholds for application of these laws. In
- 4:40California it was gross annual revenues of 25
- 4:43million or more, over 100 ,000 California residents
- 4:48whose data has been collected, or if you're a
- 4:51business where over 50 % of your revenue comes
- 4:54from buying or selling consumer information,
- 4:56personal information. What is unique about California
- 5:00is that it also includes employee data, and a
- 5:04job applicant data or independent contractor
- 5:06data that a business may hold and also business
- 5:09to business data that the law as it was initially
- 5:13enacted actually excluded these items but then
- 5:16that exclusion sunsetted and now it applies to
- 5:20essentially all personal information that a business
- 5:23may collect whether it be in the consumer context,
- 5:26employee context, or in transacting with other
- 5:29businesses. Another unique element of the CCPA
- 5:34is the private right of action. And that is why
- 5:37the the CCPA got so much attention when it was
- 5:41first enacted because it gave individuals the
- 5:43right to sue in the event of a data breach. So
- 5:47you could sue and you could claim that there
- 5:49were all these violations of CCPA if the company
- 5:52had had a data breach. In addition, the CPRA
- 5:56created the California Privacy Protection Agency,
- 5:59the CPPA, so don't get your acronyms confused.
- 6:05But typically the laws had been enforced by the
- 6:08California Attorney General's Office, the California
- 6:10Department of Justice. So now we have a new agency
- 6:14that is completely dedicated to enforcing the
- 6:18CCPA. So we are unique in California because
- 6:21we have two agencies that both have jurisdiction
- 6:25over enforcement of the CCPA. We're going to
- 6:30compare and contrast that with some of the other
- 6:33states. And we'll talk generally about which
- 6:37states have comprehensive state privacy laws.
- 6:40And what you'll find is that there are some commonalities
- 6:44and there are some differences. And we don't
- 6:47have time on this MCLE to go through all of the
- 6:50various differences, but suffice to say, nearly
- 6:53half of US states now have a comprehensive state
- 6:57privacy law. I've included Florida in here, although
- 7:01Florida has a $1 billion annual revenue threshold,
- 7:06so it may only apply to very large businesses,
- 7:08but I think for purposes of what we're discussing
- 7:10today, when we're talking about a comprehensive
- 7:13state privacy law, it's a privacy law that's
- 7:16really encompassing more than just data breach
- 7:19or more than just biometric data. It's talking
- 7:22about a comprehensive privacy scheme to protect
- 7:26individuals and their personal information. So
- 7:29we have 20 states total and you can see the list
- 7:33here California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware,
- 7:36Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Minnesota,
- 7:40Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey,
- 7:43Oregon, Rhode Island. Tennessee, Texas, Utah,
- 7:46and Virginia. So it really runs the gamut of
- 7:50different types of states, different populations
- 7:52of states. Some of these laws have not yet gone
- 7:56into effect. So we actually have three new privacy
- 7:59laws coming online in 2025. Just next month on
- 8:03July 1 and July 31. We have the new states of
- 8:07Tennessee and Minnesota coming online with their
- 8:10new privacy laws. In October of this year, we
- 8:13have a very extensive privacy law. in Maryland
- 8:16that's coming online. And then come January of
- 8:192026, we have three more states coming online
- 8:22with new privacy laws in Rhode Island, Indiana,
- 8:26and Kentucky. So as you can tell, there is a
- 8:29trend here. There are many other states that
- 8:32are implementing privacy legislation that's in
- 8:34various states in the state legislature to get
- 8:39those things passed. So we could see. other states
- 8:42passing laws this year that may go into effect
- 8:44in 2026. It's important, I think, to stay on
- 8:48top of what these trends are and see if a new
- 8:52state differs greatly from these existing state
- 8:55laws that we see. We talked a little bit about
- 8:59what comprehensive means, and that's really where
- 9:01it has a comprehensive. privacy regime that the
- 9:04state is trying to implement. And that may include
- 9:07the thresholds for application, the types of
- 9:09businesses that are going to be subject to the
- 9:11law. But then we also have other state privacy
- 9:14laws that may affect a smaller portion of personal
- 9:18information. For instance, in Illinois, we have
- 9:22a very comprehensive biometrics law, but it's
- 9:26not an entire state law relating to general privacy.
- 9:31So, Illinois has the Biometric Information Privacy
- 9:33Act, or BIPA. Like I said, Florida has this digital
- 9:38bill of rights that is applying to larger corporations,
- 9:41but Florida also has individual rights in other
- 9:46areas. Washington doesn't have a comprehensive
- 9:51state privacy law, but they have the Washington
- 9:53My Health, My Data law that actually covers quite
- 9:57a lot of things that are typically covered in
- 10:00an information privacy law. And Nevada also has
- 10:04some health information laws and then a general
- 10:07consumer law that does not have a private right
- 10:10of action, but allows for consumers in Nevada
- 10:13to get certain information from companies from
- 10:16which they've purchased consumer products or
- 10:19services. So it's important to understand that
- 10:22Even if there is no comprehensive privacy law
- 10:25in a state, there may be other individual privacy
- 10:29laws in that state that may apply. California
- 10:32too has its own California medical information
- 10:35law. So I think we're going to see a trend for
- 10:40more states to adopt this in the absence of a
- 10:43federal privacy law that's comprehensive. Obviously,
- 10:47there are federal laws that cover topics like
- 10:49children's privacy for COPPA, Children's Online
- 10:52Privacy and Protection Act, or HIPAA for health
- 10:56information. So we will continue to see a trend
- 10:59here. And I don't predict that there will be
- 11:02a comprehensive federal privacy law that's really
- 11:06enacted probably in the next four years. But
- 11:10it's still going through. Congress and it's wending
- 11:13its way. So it is possible. And it's also possible
- 11:17that it may preempt or some of these state privacy
- 11:20laws, but maybe not all of them. So it's important
- 11:23to continue to keep your finger on the pulse
- 11:25of what's going on throughout the country. This
- 11:30is an amazing graphic that I've taken from the
- 11:34IAPP, the International Association of Privacy
- 11:37Professionals, of which I am a member. But if
- 11:39you are a member of the IAPP, they have a ton
- 11:42of fantastic resources on tracking privacy legislation
- 11:46as it goes through the various houses. And you
- 11:52can see here how many states have actually passed
- 11:55laws, how many states are in the process of having
- 11:58their legislature consider these laws. and then
- 12:01other states that just haven't introduced a comprehensive
- 12:04bill. That doesn't mean that they won't, but
- 12:06you can see here that it's clearly more than
- 12:08half the country. So if you are practicing in
- 12:12this area or touching this area because some
- 12:15of your clients may be providing services across
- 12:19the nation, then it's important to see what's
- 12:21going on. And this was just last updated in April
- 12:24of 2025, but it's really a real time document
- 12:27that you'll need to keep your finger on. In addition,
- 12:31we've provided here a list of the various acronyms
- 12:34for all of the state privacy acts that are in
- 12:38place right now. And we've given you the acronyms
- 12:41and their effective dates. We hope that this
- 12:43is a really helpful document so that you can
- 12:48kind of, if you need to go in and research something
- 12:50more completely, you know what the name of these
- 12:53acts are and you can find them. Like I said,
- 12:57Florida is a little bit of an outlier with its
- 12:58digital Bill of Rights. It requires a business
- 13:02to have a threshold of over one billion annual
- 13:05revenue, but it also deals with more of the digital
- 13:10and tech side of a business that is deriving
- 13:14more than 50 % of its business from advertising
- 13:16online, or it's targeted at companies that have
- 13:21a smart speaker or voice. activated, hands -free
- 13:26activation of cloud computing, something like
- 13:30Siri or Alexa, or app stores that are selling
- 13:36more than 250 ,000 apps. So you can see that
- 13:39given the scope of where we're getting our apps
- 13:44and information now. This could include a lot
- 13:46of different companies, but larger companies.
- 13:48But you may notice that your Smart TV has the
- 13:51ability now to have an app store that has a ton
- 13:54of apps available on it. So the Florida law likely
- 13:57applies to those types of companies. When we
- 14:02do a comparison, this is just a general overview,
- 14:04but we're going to talk a little bit more about
- 14:07specific states and how they differ. But in general,
- 14:12just looking at what California does and what
- 14:15most of the other states do, we can generalize
- 14:18here and talk about the features of the California
- 14:21law and then other typical state laws. One thing
- 14:25that we've seen a lot of is the opting out of
- 14:29the sale of information for targeted advertising
- 14:32or profiling. So California is a little bit of
- 14:36an outlier because it includes sharing, and there
- 14:39is a specific definition of selling and sharing
- 14:43under the CCPA that you should be aware of. In
- 14:47other states, we don't really have the definition
- 14:49of just selling or sharing that California has.
- 14:53So the sale may be prohibited, targeted advertising
- 14:57may be prohibited, profiling of consumers based
- 15:00on personal information that they've provided
- 15:03may be prohibited, but it is going to be a little
- 15:06bit different from state to state. In addition,
- 15:10we're seeing a difference in the definition of
- 15:12sensitive data and how you treat sensitive personal
- 15:16information that a client may be collecting.
- 15:19So in California, it's a very, very broad definition
- 15:22of sensitive data. It includes protected class
- 15:25information. It includes geolocation information.
- 15:30And what we've noted is that when geolocation
- 15:33information is included in sensitive data, there
- 15:36are different radii of square footage that are
- 15:41implicated. So one state might be 1 ,850 square
- 15:44feet. Another state might be 1 ,750 square feet.
- 15:47Another state might be a specific geolocation
- 15:51that allows you to identify someone's location
- 15:53on a certain precise basis. So it's something
- 15:57to consider as you're advising clients about
- 16:01how to comply with these laws. And again, as
- 16:04we touched on before with enforcement, California
- 16:07does have two agencies that are enforcing this
- 16:11law. So you need to be aware of what those agencies
- 16:14are doing and the bulletins that are put out
- 16:16by those agencies to tell you what enforcement
- 16:19they may be focusing on right now. California
- 16:22has stated that it will be looking at data brokers
- 16:26and data broker registration, as well as children's
- 16:30privacy. And it's also looking at the implementation
- 16:34of these tools on the website and sort of the
- 16:37ease and transparency with which consumers can
- 16:40use these tools to opt out. In other states,
- 16:45you may actually have to get a consumer to opt
- 16:48in to the specific sharing of sensitive data
- 16:52especially. So it's important to understand what
- 16:55the opt -in, opt -out regimen might be for the
- 16:58state in which you are collecting information.
- 17:03Typically, other states are really only enforcing
- 17:05through the attorney general of that state. Some
- 17:09may add agencies and may have other ways to enforce
- 17:12it. Still under rulemaking authority, typically,
- 17:18California has expressly said that the CPPA has
- 17:21the ability to make rules. Other states have
- 17:24limited ability to do rulemaking with respect
- 17:27to the privacy law. Colorado, Florida, and New
- 17:31Jersey all have some limited rulemaking authority.
- 17:34So it's something to consider when the law is
- 17:38published. But then there are going to be additional
- 17:41ways that you need to comply and additional directives
- 17:44that you might need to review as opposed to just
- 17:46looking at this. the statute. And again, the
- 17:49big difference is that private right of action.
- 17:52As we said in California, it is somewhat limited
- 17:54to businesses that have had a data breach. But
- 17:58in other states, there may not be a private right
- 18:00of action, but we should always be concerned,
- 18:04and I am a former litigator, so we should always
- 18:06be concerned about claims that may arise under
- 18:10a state's unfair competition or unfair business
- 18:12practices act. So if something is not transparent,
- 18:16in a company's privacy policy or in their cookie
- 18:20notice. Is there the ability for a consumer to
- 18:23use that as an unfair business practice as a
- 18:27predicate for another type of suit? So it's something
- 18:30to consider and definitely a danger with non
- 18:34-compliance with these privacy laws. Moving on.
- 18:40Like I said, I don't have time to go through
- 18:43each state and how it differs, but these are
- 18:46the elements that we've identified that are going
- 18:49to be things to consider. So typically we're
- 18:53gonna look at, you know, what are the entities
- 18:55that are covered by this law? Is it private businesses?
- 19:00Is it a certain threshold? Is it controllers
- 19:05of information versus processors of information?
- 19:08And when we're talking about that, we're using
- 19:11GDPR language. But the controller who has the
- 19:14ability to use the data, change the data, modify
- 19:18the data, tell others how to use the data, those
- 19:21are controllers. Processors may not have the
- 19:23ability to modify the data. They're taking the
- 19:26data from a controller and just processing it.
- 19:29But they have access to the information, the
- 19:32personal information, and they have obligations
- 19:35to protect that information even if it's not
- 19:37their data. So typically controllers and processors
- 19:41are going to be covered by all of these state
- 19:43laws. There may be some exemptions. Some states
- 19:47will exempt nonprofits entirely. Some states
- 19:51will only exempt certain activities by nonprofits.
- 19:55So it is something to look at if your client
- 19:57is a nonprofit institution. Are they truly exempt
- 20:01from all of these privacy laws, or do some of
- 20:04the activities that they undertake fall under
- 20:07a privacy law such that they would need to comply
- 20:10by providing appropriate notice, by getting consent
- 20:13in some instances, by having to offer the ability
- 20:17to opt out of the sharing of their information?
- 20:20That could be something really important to consider
- 20:23if you're advising clients in the nonprofit space.
- 20:27In addition, higher education or even K -12 education,
- 20:33whether public or private, may need to comply
- 20:37with some of these laws as well. There isn't
- 20:39just a blanket exemption throughout all of the
- 20:42United States. So looking at what types of information
- 20:46are being collected and the exemptions that might
- 20:49apply, Typically, you're going to see some exemptions
- 20:52for federal student data, like under FERPA. But
- 20:57there may be other activities, including fundraising
- 21:00activities or alumni activities that might be
- 21:05covered by one of these privacy laws. And we'll
- 21:08just talk about the situation where maybe it's
- 21:12a private school that uses alumni to recruit
- 21:17Students have been admitted and they're going
- 21:19to be sharing personal information. With an alumni
- 21:24who is not part of the education institution,
- 21:29but the alumni is going to receive personal information
- 21:31to contact a student, you know, looking at those
- 21:34types of situations, you may want to look at
- 21:37whether or not you have adequate guidelines in
- 21:40place for. the alums use of that information
- 21:43if they're going to do a recruiting event or
- 21:45they're going to contact that admitted student.
- 21:48What are the parameters for their ability to
- 21:52use that information? Do they have to destroy
- 21:54it later? Those types of things are things that
- 21:57we look at. In addition, there are data level
- 22:00exemptions. So certain information like health
- 22:03information that's protected under HIPAA. The
- 22:06Graham Leach Bliley Act for financial institutions.
- 22:10There may be exemptions for public data. Data
- 22:12that's available from publicly available sources
- 22:15may be exempt from some of these privacy laws.
- 22:19So it's important to look at your client and
- 22:22the type of data that they're collecting or using
- 22:26or processing. I think it's going to be really
- 22:29important that if you're advising a healthcare
- 22:31company, they're gonna need to have even more
- 22:35stringent requirements in place because of the
- 22:38nature of the data that they're collecting. So
- 22:41really looking at your client's business and
- 22:44understanding what they do and what kinds of
- 22:47data they're collecting and how they're using
- 22:50that data is really going to be important to
- 22:54finding out how strictly you need to apply all
- 22:57of these laws. We've already talked about the
- 23:01applicability thresholds for California, certain
- 23:03revenue thresholds, and in Florida we talked
- 23:06about, but it may be the amount of data that
- 23:09they're collecting. Is it just about the residents
- 23:12of a specific state? Collection of information
- 23:16has varying levels of applicability for larger
- 23:22numbers of residents of a state. but it's not
- 23:25universal throughout all these states. For California,
- 23:28it might be a 100 ,000. For another state, it
- 23:30might be 25 ,000. And obviously, it may make
- 23:34sense to understand where your client operates
- 23:37because if they are a brick and mortar store
- 23:40that really only has one store that's in a specific
- 23:43state, they probably have a much more limited
- 23:46collection of data and maybe some of these state
- 23:49laws will not apply to them. But if they're an
- 23:52online retailer and they're shipping product
- 23:54to all 50 states and Canada and Europe and internationally,
- 23:59there are going to be a lot more laws that may
- 24:01apply to their data collection and the use of
- 24:04their information. So understanding where your
- 24:06client operates, understanding the type of business
- 24:09your client has, and understanding how they use
- 24:12the data. Are they using the data to target advertising
- 24:18at a specific user? Are they a child -directed
- 24:22property where they know that children are coming
- 24:26onto their website because maybe it's a gaming
- 24:28site or something like that? It's not enough
- 24:31to simply look at what these laws are in a vacuum
- 24:34without comparing it to what your client does.
- 24:39Typically, all of these laws are going to require
- 24:41reasonable data security measures. you know,
- 24:45we want to make sure that everyone is implementing
- 24:47reasonable cybersecurity and protection of data.
- 24:51But that may differ from state to state as to
- 24:54what that means. So it's important to look at
- 24:57what that state law requires. And just to step
- 25:01back for a minute, I think the takeaway that
- 25:04I'm telling you is it's no longer enough to just
- 25:07say, well, I'm going to comply with California
- 25:09and that should be fine. It's not enough now
- 25:14with some of these newer states that are coming
- 25:15online with different obligations. Colorado changed
- 25:19that a lot. Maryland will change that a lot when
- 25:22it comes online in October. And even the Washington
- 25:25My Health My Data law has changed it depending
- 25:29on the type of information that a client may
- 25:32collect. So I think the takeaway isn't, well,
- 25:36Diana, can I just comply with this law and it'll
- 25:39be fine? No, you actually have to understand
- 25:43what is required in the states in which your
- 25:46client operates because there may be specific
- 25:48notice requirements. And we'll talk about that
- 25:51a little bit more when we talk about individual
- 25:53data subject rights. In addition, the definition
- 25:58of sensitive data, as we discussed before, it
- 26:01does vary from state to state. You would hope
- 26:03that this would be an area where it's really
- 26:06just sensitive data is sensitive data. It's not.
- 26:09in every state, so it's important to see, especially
- 26:12if your client is collecting certain sensitive
- 26:15data, whether it be information about the demographics
- 26:19of their consumers, their customers, or maybe
- 26:22it's geolocation information because you're trying
- 26:25to direct people to be able to find your client's
- 26:27retail store. All of those things may come into
- 26:30play with sensitive data. companies are going
- 26:35to have more sensitive data than others. As we've
- 26:39seen, you know, health information can be sensitive
- 26:42if it relates to a diagnosis or maybe it relates
- 26:45to a service that a patient is trying to research
- 26:50or obtain. Even just the search terms on your
- 26:54website may inadvertently or intentionally disclose
- 27:00areas of sensitive information that should be
- 27:03protected more stringently than just the my name
- 27:09and my email address type of information. The
- 27:12other thing is that these states all have differing
- 27:16individual data subject rights and appeal rights
- 27:19that have to be disclosed. What we're seeing
- 27:23is that this one size fits all, fill out this
- 27:27form to exercise your data subject rights, You
- 27:30have to talk to your client to understand, do
- 27:33they want to offer the same data subject rights
- 27:36to everybody, to people even in states that don't
- 27:38have privacy laws? One, from a business perspective,
- 27:42because it might just streamline things if the
- 27:45customer service reps know that, hey, we're treating
- 27:47everybody the same. Or is the data that they're
- 27:50collecting such that they only want to offer
- 27:53these rights to people in states that have existing
- 27:56privacy laws, in which case your forms are going
- 27:59to need to ask them, what state do you live in,
- 28:02right? To know whether these things are applicable
- 28:04to the individual consumer or employee or data
- 28:08subject. But then you also have this idea of
- 28:12disparate treatment between individual data subjects,
- 28:15a data subject that lives in Alabama. that doesn't
- 28:18have the same data subject rights as somebody
- 28:19who lives in Colorado, is that going to create
- 28:22a tension within the organization or within the
- 28:26consumer's perception of the company to say,
- 28:29hey, that's not fair? So I think looking at the
- 28:32transparency of your notice and what rights you
- 28:35do offer is going to be important as we kind
- 28:38of have this patchwork of state's rights. Appeal
- 28:42rights, too. Some states offer the ability to
- 28:45appeal a rejection of the processing of a specific
- 28:49data subject right, privacy right that's been
- 28:51asserted. So you have to advise those consumers
- 28:56by statute that they have appeal rights and what
- 28:59those appeal rights are. And you may have to
- 29:01include a link to the state attorney general's
- 29:03office for that. But the other thing is implementing
- 29:06these issues into a workflow can be very difficult
- 29:11for smaller organizations. And small businesses
- 29:14are not exempt from a lot of these things by
- 29:16the nature of the business that they may be in.
- 29:19They may have a website that's just collecting
- 29:21a lot of information or gets a lot of hits, but
- 29:24maybe they aren't at an income threshold, but
- 29:27they are collecting information about an incredible
- 29:29number of people. That could always happen. Some
- 29:34of the states also require data protection assessments
- 29:37that they're requiring annual data protection
- 29:40assessments to have a company look at what are
- 29:43the steps that they're taking to protect personal
- 29:45information internally? Have they trained their
- 29:48staff on these things? And some of the states
- 29:52will require you to make that available on request.
- 29:56So it's important to look at whether or not you're
- 29:59in a state that's going to require that because
- 30:01that would be implemented as part of the workflow
- 30:04and the process for what you do with these particular
- 30:08clients that are operating in those states. In
- 30:12addition, certain states, especially California,
- 30:15they have contractual requirements that you have
- 30:18to include with the processes of information.
- 30:21As a controller of information, if I contract
- 30:24with a vendor that's going to be handling personal
- 30:27information for me under California and some
- 30:30other states, I am required to put specific contractual
- 30:34language in there that may limit the processor's
- 30:37ability to use that information down the road.
- 30:41Certainly they may be limited from. further selling
- 30:45or sharing that information to another party,
- 30:47but they may be limited to even how they use
- 30:50the information for their own improvement of
- 30:53their services. So if you are providing information
- 30:57to a processor who says, I'm going to integrate
- 31:00this into our offering, because I want to hit
- 31:03a broader scope of people and I'm going to offer
- 31:05it to your clients as well, that may be prohibited
- 31:08under some state laws. So it also may require
- 31:12the review of standard contracts that your client
- 31:15has, standard vendor contracts, to understand
- 31:20whether or not those limitations are in place.
- 31:23This also comes into play with even contracts
- 31:26with advertising tech. If you have a client that's
- 31:31using Google Analytics and is providing certain
- 31:35information that may be used for targeted advertising,
- 31:38what is the service that they're providing to
- 31:42your client versus are they using that for a
- 31:45broader advertising purpose? It's something to
- 31:48consider and it's something that needs to be
- 31:50properly papered. Other states still are now
- 31:55requiring data minimization and purpose limitation.
- 31:59And those are terms that sort of mean exactly
- 32:03what they say, right? The trend is to collect
- 32:07only the information that you need for the transaction
- 32:11that the consumer or other individual has asked
- 32:13you to provide for them. So limiting the amount
- 32:16of data and limiting the purpose for which you
- 32:19are using the data. Am I using this data to provide
- 32:22services to you, or am I using this data to market
- 32:27things to you? Those are different consents.
- 32:31Those are different disclosures to the individual
- 32:34consumer or data subject. And it's something
- 32:37to think about. And unfortunately, it's not consistent
- 32:41across these states. So it's something to think
- 32:44about. And again, I think What we're looking
- 32:47at is a trend towards transparency, right? To
- 32:50making sure that the privacy notice that you
- 32:53give to a consumer or a user of your product
- 32:55or service accurately describes how you use their
- 32:59information, who you share their information
- 33:02with, and how those parties are using the information,
- 33:05and then what their rights are to assert with
- 33:08respect to this information. It's a lot, and
- 33:13it can be overwhelming. So we'll talk too about
- 33:16some resources that you can use to help guide
- 33:19your privacy journey. This is stuff that we do
- 33:22every day and so I'm getting into the weeds a
- 33:25little bit but you know I have a slide at the
- 33:28end if you'd like to connect with me on LinkedIn
- 33:30I try to post good content but I also have a
- 33:32great network of people that I'm following that
- 33:35are also providing this content so if you're
- 33:37in the privacy space or if you're trying to get
- 33:39into the privacy space it's important to see
- 33:42what people are talking about because these are
- 33:45this is an area of law that is really rapidly
- 33:47changing and evolving and I think. There's more
- 33:51creativity about how to solve these problems
- 33:54for our clients than just sort of relying on,
- 33:57well, the law says this, I'm going to set it
- 33:59and forget it. Gone are those days where you
- 34:01could set it and forget it. It really has to
- 34:03be dynamic and updated as new states come online,
- 34:07as new interpretations of the law are being set
- 34:11forth in enforcement actions or other litigation
- 34:15as well. So again, the key differences to watch
- 34:20as you're operating across the various states
- 34:23is going to be the definitions of sale of data
- 34:26or sensitive data. Those can differ, you know,
- 34:29whether there's an affirmative need to opt in
- 34:32or opt out these consents for the use of information.
- 34:36And, you know, if you change the type of use
- 34:41of information that you're doing, do you then
- 34:43need to collect an additional consent for that.
- 34:47If you change your privacy policy, do you need
- 34:49to tell people what you've changed and how it's
- 34:52different and how you're going to use their data?
- 34:54We saw this in some of the genetic, the company,
- 35:00I'm trying not to mention any names, but the
- 35:03companies that have genetic information that
- 35:05are then being sold. So the idea that you may
- 35:08have provided your genetic information to a company
- 35:11to research your ancestry or to look at potential
- 35:14medical issues you may have, but then what if
- 35:17that company who has probably retained the right
- 35:20to sell that information in the course of a merger
- 35:23or an acquisition. What if that company then
- 35:26decides to sell it to a company that's going
- 35:28to do genetic research or cloning? And I'm being
- 35:34over -broad and a little bit flip. But what are
- 35:38the guardrails around their selling of that information
- 35:41to a third party that you've already consented
- 35:43to? Do they need to collect additional consent?
- 35:48There are questions out there for all of those
- 35:50things. I think we're also seeing some differences
- 35:54in the implementation of what are called universal
- 35:57opt -out mechanisms, like global privacy controls.
- 36:01And these are typically settings that you can
- 36:04make on your browser or your device to opt out
- 36:09of tracking technologies or cookies. And some
- 36:13companies or some, sorry, some states are going
- 36:16to make it it's going to be mandatory, where
- 36:20if somebody elects this universal opt -out, you
- 36:23now have to recognize that and action it if that
- 36:26person comes to your website with one of these
- 36:28opt -out mechanisms activated. So technologically,
- 36:32there's a hurdle there, especially for small
- 36:34businesses. But it's going to be incumbent on
- 36:38a business to understand what their website is
- 36:40doing and the information that's being collected
- 36:43and tracked. the recognition of authorized agents
- 36:48to exercise these rights. All of us probably
- 36:52have some sort of spam software or other internet
- 37:00security option that will say, hey, we can opt
- 37:03you out of all of these things. Just sign this
- 37:06authorization and we'll submit it to all these
- 37:08different websites and get you opted out. That's
- 37:12great, but that's using an authorized agent to
- 37:14implement those requests. And some states don't
- 37:18recognize authorized agents to make a privacy
- 37:20request for you. So, you know, you may be signing
- 37:25on to a service that you said, I'm gonna... use
- 37:28the service and they're going to opt me out of
- 37:29all of these mailing lists and other things that
- 37:31I'm on. They may not have the legal ability to
- 37:34do that. And as a company, you may need to recognize
- 37:38whether or not a state authorizes an agent to
- 37:41make that request for somebody or not. Like we
- 37:46talked about before, the rulemaking and enforcement
- 37:48mechanisms, those are going to differ from state
- 37:50to state. Some states also have an existing right
- 37:54to cure. So if you have a violation of one of
- 37:58these newer state privacy laws, is there a right
- 38:01to cure? California started out with a right
- 38:04to cure and that sunsetted and so there is no
- 38:06longer a right to cure any of these violations
- 38:09of the CCPA in California. Other states are similar
- 38:13at this point and may have more limitations on
- 38:18whether or not you have the ability to fix a
- 38:21problem if it's brought to your attention. I'm
- 38:26going to jump to a couple of questions that have
- 38:28come in really quickly and address it. One of
- 38:32the quick questions is, is the revenue threshold
- 38:34in Florida for revenue specifically generated
- 38:36in the state, or if a multi -state company takes
- 38:39into account revenue across all states of operation?
- 38:43The Florida Digital Bill of Rights actually applies
- 38:45to global annual revenues. So it will take into
- 38:48consideration the global revenue of a company,
- 38:51not just in the state of Florida. So that's something
- 38:55to be concerned about. OK. Let's see. Another
- 39:00question is when PII, personally identified information
- 39:04is exchanged with vendors, we typically do not
- 39:07limit the liability for violating the law. My
- 39:10question is, if there is no exchange of PII,
- 39:13is it then safe to agree to a limitation of liability?
- 39:18I'm happy to discuss general issues relating
- 39:22to this, but I think when you're really drafting,
- 39:25when you're doing the contract drafting, and
- 39:27getting into indemnities and limitations of liability,
- 39:30it's very dependent on the type of information
- 39:34and the type of vendor that you're using. If
- 39:38the vendor is touching extremely sensitive information,
- 39:41if it's a payroll vendor, if it's a biometrics
- 39:44vendor, you may not want to limit the liability
- 39:48because there's a potential of a data breach
- 39:51happening and then having to remediate that.
- 39:54and investigate that and do forensics. This is
- 39:59purely something to discuss on a business level,
- 40:02but it's a really important issue to look at
- 40:05when you're drafting contracts that are dealing
- 40:07with the exchange of personal information. What
- 40:11is the nature of the information and what is
- 40:13the potential liability if that information is
- 40:16breached? So if there's no exchange of PII, you
- 40:21know, I can't say that it's safe to agree to
- 40:23a limitation of liability, but maybe there's
- 40:26no ability for that company to pay for an unlimited
- 40:30liability and maybe your deal won't get done
- 40:33because you've said we want it to be unlimited.
- 40:36Sometimes we look at the limitations of a cyber
- 40:38liability insurance policy that the vendor might
- 40:41hold and maybe you look at, you know, what are
- 40:43the insurance limits and is that appropriate
- 40:46to allow as a cap or a ceiling on the limitation
- 40:50of liability. But again, this is very fact -specific.
- 40:54It's a great question, but I think it really
- 40:58depends on the situation and the client. Let's
- 41:03see. Moving on. The other issues, and we sort
- 41:08of touched on this, but there's currently no
- 41:11comprehensive federal privacy law. But you have
- 41:14to remember that federal agencies can enforce
- 41:17these laws. We've seen a lot. If you were on
- 41:20this week's discussion fireside chat with a former
- 41:24FTC director, the FTC is allowed to enforce these
- 41:31laws. Other agencies may be enforcing these laws
- 41:35to the extent it falls into their domain. So
- 41:39don't think that because there's no federal privacy
- 41:41law that, OK, I'm fine. No. Even in the absence
- 41:45of the federal privacy law, there are going to
- 41:47be issues of fairness of consumer protection
- 41:51that could fall under federal agency enforcement
- 41:55in addition to state agency enforcement or private
- 41:58rights of action like in California. So even
- 42:02if we get a federal privacy law, it may not stave
- 42:05off consumer claims that come under a state law.
- 42:10So something to think about that the federal
- 42:13privacy law, even if it comes forward, may not
- 42:16be an answer to all of our issues with the patchwork
- 42:21and sort of the unevenness among state privacy
- 42:23laws. The other thing to know is that there's
- 42:26now a consortium of privacy regulators. This
- 42:29was announced by California, the state of California,
- 42:32where they have bonded with regulators in other
- 42:36states. So in California, we have our two agencies,
- 42:39the Attorney General's office and the DOJ and
- 42:41the CPPA, and they have bonded with Attorneys
- 42:46General in Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Indiana,
- 42:49New Jersey, and Oregon, and really said like,
- 42:53hey, we're looking at these things. We are sharing
- 42:56information. I think that this has always been
- 43:00happening at the AG level, regardless of whether
- 43:03it's privacy related or not. But the attorneys
- 43:06general get on a call and always talk about issues
- 43:10that are important to the consumers in their
- 43:12states. So the fact that this was announced as
- 43:17a specific consortium should let you know that
- 43:20if your client is operating in any of these states,
- 43:23they need to know that compliance with one state
- 43:26law and non -another, it's probably going to
- 43:29be shared among it. And non -compliance with
- 43:33various privacy laws is also probably going to
- 43:36be shared among the other privacy regulators.
- 43:39So getting up to snuff in one state won't necessarily
- 43:44relieve you of the obligation to also be compliant
- 43:48in all of the other states. Separately, all 50
- 43:52states have their own state data breach statutes
- 43:55with different thresholds on notification, on
- 43:59remediation, and all of those things. So outside
- 44:03of the comprehensive privacy law, there are also
- 44:06state data breach statutes that you need to know
- 44:08about because a data incident or a data that
- 44:13rises to the level of breach, they may have different
- 44:15definitions of what a breach is as well. But
- 44:18those may be a violative of the state data breach
- 44:21statute. and maybe it's also violative of the
- 44:24state privacy laws and now you have two causes
- 44:27of action or two potential enforcement angles
- 44:32that are going to be needing to be addressed
- 44:34or if you're being sued in a data breach but
- 44:38you know there's a potential for class actions
- 44:40and other other things that can make non -compliance
- 44:43really really expensive for your clients. Other
- 44:47trends that we're seeing are the age -appropriate
- 44:49design codes where we're looking at adolescent
- 44:52privacy and what companies can do when they know
- 44:57that they are receiving clients, customers, or
- 45:01visits from minors that are under the age of
- 45:0418. The age of majority in some of these states
- 45:08differs. In the UK, there is an age -appropriate
- 45:11design code. California's AADC has been on hold
- 45:15since March pending some litigation. Other states
- 45:18have these laws. So it's adjacent, but it's important
- 45:23to understand that these are non -partisan issues.
- 45:28The potential exploitation or targeting of children
- 45:32online is not an issue that is on one side of
- 45:36the aisle or not. These are pretty universal
- 45:39things that can probably get passed in any state
- 45:41legislature, regardless of the composition of
- 45:46the parties in the legislature. And what we're
- 45:48looking at is, you know, are companies being
- 45:51transparent? Are they collecting appropriate
- 45:54consent? If a client has, you know, an adult
- 45:58property, are they actually age gating and making
- 46:01sure that whoever is using their services is
- 46:05asked a question about their age or maybe they're
- 46:08going to be charged with using a more complete
- 46:13method of age estimation. There are all sorts
- 46:17of things happening in the children's privacy
- 46:19world about what things you could use to actually
- 46:23figure out what age a user is. And when we're
- 46:27talking about tracking technologies that see
- 46:29different websites that a specific user who may
- 46:33be identified by nothing more than an IP address
- 46:35or a device ID, my 13 -year -old son's viewing
- 46:42habits are going to be very different than mine.
- 46:45So could you look at the originating URL that
- 46:50a visitor came from and understand that, hey,
- 46:52this is probably a kid. Gone are the days where
- 46:56you could just say, I agree, I'm over 18. I think
- 47:00it's going to depend on the type of material
- 47:02that the client or the business is putting out
- 47:07there. And then that's going to determine how
- 47:09much you need to implement additional controls
- 47:13for age estimation. make sure that you're not
- 47:17directing advertising to minors and you're not
- 47:20collecting a profile of a minor. If it's a new
- 47:24or should have known theory, if you have actual
- 47:28evidence that you are collecting information
- 47:30from those that are under the age of 13, for
- 47:32sure, but under the age of 16, you need to review
- 47:37your privacy, your privacy guidelines and what
- 47:41you're doing and your privacy notices and ensure
- 47:44that you're taking care of that information appropriately.
- 47:49So I just briefly want to talk about AI and privacy
- 47:53regulation because it is also coming. So not
- 47:56only do we have this patchwork of privacy laws
- 48:00throughout the country, but we're also seeing
- 48:01a patchwork of AI laws throughout the country
- 48:04and what different states are saying users need
- 48:08to adhere to when they're using AI. or AI algorithms,
- 48:15AI chat bots, all different sorts of things.
- 48:18And this is coming at a really rapid pace. So
- 48:20it's something that is changing almost on a daily,
- 48:24weekly, monthly basis. And so if your client
- 48:27is in the AI space, this is gonna be an ongoing
- 48:30area of compliance to figure out. What can we
- 48:33do? What disclosures do we need to make similar
- 48:35to in privacy? You know, it's really about transparency
- 48:38and understanding what the AI is doing or understanding
- 48:43the collection of information and how it's being
- 48:45used and who's receiving it. So what we're seeing
- 48:50from the privacy side is really a focus on the
- 48:52automated decision making. You know, if it's
- 48:55chat bot and they are your customer service rep.
- 48:58One information is being collected, and who's
- 49:00getting it? Do you have an offshore customer
- 49:05service team? And if so, are you complying with
- 49:08international transfers of information, like
- 49:10the guardrails around the international transfer
- 49:12of personal information? How are you making decisions
- 49:17about profiling users? This also comes up in
- 49:21the context of abandoned cart information, right?
- 49:25If I go onto a website and I put stuff in my
- 49:28cart and then I leave, they're sending me information
- 49:31about, hey, by the way, now we'll give you a
- 49:34discount because you left the stuff in your cart.
- 49:37Those are all things that are impacted by the
- 49:40AI and privacy regulations that might exist in
- 49:43the states in which I reside. And then, obviously,
- 49:47we cannot, even in all of this discussion about
- 49:50state privacy laws, we cannot ignore the international
- 49:55laws right it's a global economy our clients
- 49:58websites may be available in other countries
- 50:00it's also something to consider about maybe your
- 50:04client doesn't want to have their website available
- 50:07in other countries are there settings that they
- 50:09can adjust to say like hey i don't want to be
- 50:11subject to the eu gdpr you know maybe i don't
- 50:15need to make my website available and those are
- 50:18actual like practical things that can be done
- 50:21to limit liability and, in fact, enhance compliance.
- 50:27So that's something to think about. When we're
- 50:31talking about resources, and I also want to encourage,
- 50:34if there's any other questions, feel free to
- 50:37drop them into the Q &A. I'm happy to address
- 50:40those and work through some things live to the
- 50:45extent that we have time and we have about seven
- 50:48minutes left. Feel free to drop your questions
- 50:51into the Q and a, and I'm happy to talk about
- 50:54that, but some compliance resources, you know,
- 50:56typically you can always go to the state site
- 51:00and rulemaking websites. You know, California
- 51:03has its own. CCPA site and the CPPA has its own
- 51:08site. There's a lot of great resources there
- 51:09for California. Other states have similar sites
- 51:12and they will be continuing to update. Like I
- 51:17mentioned before, the IAPP, the International
- 51:20Association of Privacy Professionals, has a great
- 51:23U .S. state privacy legislation tracker. The
- 51:26Future of Privacy Forum is doing great stuff
- 51:29that talks about, you know, really, really in
- 51:34-depth discussions of state comprehensive privacy
- 51:37laws. The IAPP tracker and this FPF links, those
- 51:42are actually live links in the materials. So
- 51:45if you want to click through on those and check
- 51:48them out, there's a lot of information available
- 51:51there. And I think you really want to engage
- 51:54in your client or in your firm. You want to engage
- 51:59not only with privacy counsel, but also cross
- 52:01-functional teams. If legal and compliance isn't
- 52:05talking to advertising and marketing, then there's
- 52:08really no ability to comply. Because you don't
- 52:11know what the marketing team is doing or what
- 52:13information they may really need. I recently
- 52:17gave an MCLE about how to become a privacy enabler
- 52:20in your organization. Especially as lawyers,
- 52:23we are often seen as the people who block business
- 52:26from happening. But a really deep understanding
- 52:29of these things will allow you to communicate
- 52:31with the teams, the business teams within an
- 52:35organization and find out. Well, what do you
- 52:37need to do? Well, we really need to have Google
- 52:39Analytics running because it's how we get all
- 52:42the information from all of our customers. OK,
- 52:45so how then can we implement this in a safe way
- 52:49or maybe limit the type of information so that
- 52:51you're getting just the information you want?
- 52:55You know, there are ways to really communicate
- 52:58internally as opposed to just being, hey, here's
- 53:01what you need to do to comply without understanding
- 53:03your client's business. you cannot provide that
- 53:06advice, right? Because it's becoming increasingly
- 53:09more difficult to do that as we're going through
- 53:13with all these new state laws and all the different
- 53:15things that come from the state law. The other
- 53:19thing that I want to talk about is just even
- 53:22from a website design or user experience perspective,
- 53:27some of these laws are actually delineating what
- 53:31that user experience needs to be. We saw this
- 53:33in California. where they're really looking at
- 53:37reciprocity between accept all, decline all,
- 53:41the size of your button, really avoiding dark
- 53:44patterns. It's not okay to say you know, I want
- 53:48the sale or no, I hate sales, right? To guilt
- 53:52or shame somebody into clicking yes, that's not
- 53:55okay under a lot of these laws. So when you're
- 53:58working with your clients and talking about the
- 54:00actual web experience or the user experience
- 54:03for somebody coming to their website, there's
- 54:05guidance around that as well. So it's not enough
- 54:08to advise just on the law per se. You also have
- 54:13to advise on some of these practical ways to
- 54:16implement the law And that's becoming a lot more
- 54:19important. Obviously, there is a certain industry
- 54:23focus for some of these laws. So if you have
- 54:25clients that are in retail and e -commerce that
- 54:28are shipping product internationally, they may
- 54:32have different concerns. If you have adult products,
- 54:35if you have child -directed properties where
- 54:38it's games and toys, are you marketing to the
- 54:41children? Are you marketing to the children's
- 54:43parents? Those are really important questions
- 54:46to have as you're sort of mapping out the type
- 54:49of information that you're collecting. Media
- 54:52and publishing entities, you know, obviously
- 54:54there's a lot there that can be dealt with in
- 54:59these individual privacy laws. Financial services
- 55:01is of course subject to GLBA and other you typically
- 55:05having sensitive personal information when you're
- 55:07dealing with financial services companies and
- 55:10health care, of course, health care companies
- 55:12or health care adjacent companies, you're going
- 55:15to want to understand the nature of the data
- 55:17that you're collecting and what you're passing
- 55:19on and what is there as a guardrail around collecting
- 55:26that information. You know, I think that this
- 55:31is going to be a rapidly changing area. So it's
- 55:35important to really look at what the general
- 55:38trends are. I'm not seeing any chat or questions
- 55:43in the chat right now, but if I'm wrong, please
- 55:47let me know. Sorry, I did not mean to exit out
- 55:49of that. One second, please. Sorry about that.
- 55:55I'll go through to the slide that we were on.
- 55:59And I'm just gonna talk to you about general
- 56:02trends then in closing, sort of the summary of
- 56:04what we have seen here. And I think the general
- 56:08trends are, don't forget to put yourself in the
- 56:12shoes of the consumer that is viewing this information.
- 56:15So if you're representing a client and you go
- 56:18to their website and you don't understand what
- 56:20information they're collecting, or you don't
- 56:23understand what they're doing with your information,
- 56:25then take that step back and say, hey, I don't...
- 56:28think this is transparent. I don't think that
- 56:30your notice is adequate because I can't tell
- 56:33what you're doing with my data. So transparency
- 56:36overall is a theme through all of these new state
- 56:40laws really disclosing in the consumer facing
- 56:43or the public facing privacy policy what you're
- 56:47doing with data. What is the data that you're
- 56:49collecting? And it's important to, as a threshold
- 56:53exercise, to map the data that you're collecting.
- 56:56There are a lot of businesses that just don't
- 56:58know anymore what information they've collected
- 57:01or how they're using it. So doing the data mapping
- 57:04and data inventory is a big issue. Making sure
- 57:07that the data subject rights are adequately disclosed
- 57:11and that there's a workflow for processing them.
- 57:13There are time limits in which you need to process.
- 57:16Data subject rights, you know, in certain states
- 57:19have different thresholds. California requires
- 57:21you to respond to a data subject request within
- 57:2310 days. Other states don't have that, but maybe
- 57:25that's a good practice to implement across the
- 57:27board. And again, I think the regulators have
- 57:31identified industries that they're particularly
- 57:34interested in. And in California, that's data
- 57:37brokers. It's children's directed properties,
- 57:43advertising, and health privacy. Those are all
- 57:47super important things to think about. I think
- 57:50that there may be a question here. Let me take
- 57:52a look. Yes, somebody asked the organization
- 57:58organization I mentioned earlier was the. And
- 58:01yes, that's correct. It's the International Association
- 58:04of Privacy Professionals, of which I'm a member.
- 58:06My certifications, the CIPP US, Asia, and Europe
- 58:10are from that organization. I'm a fellow of information
- 58:12privacy with the IAPP. It's IAPP .org, if you
- 58:17want to check it out. They also have conferences
- 58:20and a lot of really great resources on their
- 58:23website. But there are a lot of tremendous privacy
- 58:27blogs from a lot of local law firms. I'm a huge
- 58:31advocate for being able to search for those things
- 58:35and find information. But I get a lot of that
- 58:39just in my LinkedIn feed. So with that, I will
- 58:42invite you to connect with me on LinkedIn if
- 58:44you'd like to. And I think I think we're at time.
- 58:50So if there are no other questions, I wanna thank
- 58:53you. I wanna thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 58:55because this is such an important topic and it
- 58:58is constantly changing. So I'm so grateful for
- 59:00the opportunity to speak to the BHBA's audience
- 59:04on this and to help share some of the knowledge
- 59:06that I've acquired on these topics. So thrilled
- 59:09that you could attend today and thanks so much.
- 59:16You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 59:19Visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.