Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Investment Podcast #43 - Opportunities in Global Markets
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with our sponsor, PM Capital Proprietary Limited, ACN 689 382 796, and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:13Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:18Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:24If a PDS, TMD or IM exist, you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly before making a decision.
- 0:32I'm Andrew Rox and welcome to the investment podcast series where we separate the fact versus the fiction.
- 0:39We try and connect the way in which an advisor thinks in front of their client in that very small microcosm of trust and relate that to the global opportunities that they have at those disposal.
- 0:50We'll be navigating the best investment managers as well as some innovative ways in which people think about asset selection.
- 0:57The investment podcast series.
- 1:04Global markets are changing.
- 1:05Inflation shifting supply chains and the rapid development of AI are reshaping where investors may find value.
- 1:11PM Capital's Kevin Bertolli looks beyond the headlines to identify long-term opportunities across global markets.
- 1:18The Global Companies Fund takes a flexible, high-conviction approach, focusing on a select number of investment themes where the team sees a gap between market prices and long-term value.
- 1:27Explore the thinking behind the portfolio and learn more about the fund at pmcapital.com.au slash global-companies-fund today.
- 1:36I'm Andrew Rocks and welcome to the Investment Podcast Series.
- 1:41Today we're here with the wonderful people from PM Capital and specifically I'm here with Kevin Batoli.
- 1:45Welcome.
- 1:46Thanks for having me, Roxy.
- 1:47And we were talking off air before that I think the last time I physically saw you was when you hosted one of the sessions at the ALPD Day back in November last year.
- 1:59Is that right?
- 1:59Yeah, that's right.
- 2:00It was...
- 2:01I think we did a session on global equities, which I did, but my colleague, Luke Cheatham, did a piece on basically high performance teams and how that applies to the advice world and our clients, the advisors, and that was extremely well received.
- 2:20And I think it's, you know, when we put those days together, you know, a lot of companies want to just talk about themselves, right?
- 2:30That's their job, I suppose.
- 2:31But, you know, we really look to try and, you know, our motto is the positive evolution of financial advice.
- 2:37So when your organization brought that high performance sort of training idea here, we went, yeah, you know what?
- 2:43You know, so that adds a bit of difference, adds a bit of depth and, you know, fulfills our mandate of the positive evolution.
- 2:50And I suppose, you know, from that day, what came out of that or what was your sort of insights?
- 2:56Yeah, I think your point there is really important.
- 3:00So as investors, day to day, I'm sitting there looking for the next idea to put into our portfolios.
- 3:05We're myopically focused on doing that.
- 3:08But a lot of the time you can forget that our client has many different responsibilities.
- 3:14And the center of their world is not the global equity fund that they might be putting their money into for their client.
- 3:18There's a lot of stuff.
- 3:21And it's really how can we provide our clients, that advisor group, some added value, things that we do day to day.
- 3:32How can we impart some worthwhile information on them that hopefully they can use within their businesses?
- 3:40So it was hugely successful from an engagement perspective.
- 3:44And a real demand for advisors to actually want to look at some of these things.
- 3:48How do you invest in your people to get better outcomes for your own business?
- 3:53Essentially, that's the message.
- 3:55And we've done a lot of work around, I think at that PD day,
- 4:00There was a prize for an individual advisor to do a workshop.
- 4:04Now, we've extended that to do those workshops with a larger number of our clients across multiple cities across the countries.
- 4:14And when you're talking about your business, you've been around, I think, for 30-odd years.
- 4:20Correct me if I'm wrong.
- 4:21Yeah, in 1998, we started.
- 4:25Paul's not looking too bad for being around for me.
- 4:27He must have started very early.
- 4:29Yeah, it's an old photo.
- 4:31Well, you can only say that, you cheeky bugger, because you've actually been there for 22 years, and you must have started there in year 10.
- 4:38Is that right, straight out of school?
- 4:40Yeah, I grew up in Adelaide.
- 4:42We're in country South Australia.
- 4:44I went to university in SA, and then I moved...
- 4:49uh, across after university.
- 4:51So I've been in Sydney for 21 years and yeah, I've been working with Paul for, uh, you know, for that period of time.
- 4:58So, country kid at heart, but, uh, you know, looking the other day, I spent more time in Sydney than I have anywhere else now.
- 5:05So, uh,
- 5:07I've been in the business for a long period of time, but if you look at the core group of people at PM Capital, there's myself, there's John Whelan, co-portfolio managers of our global and Aussie equity products.
- 5:20You've got Jared Dawson, who runs our yield fund.
- 5:23That team with Paul, we've been together for 20 plus years.
- 5:29So I've been investing capital together for a long time.
- 5:32There's a couple of takeouts from there.
- 5:34One is, I think in Adelaide, they call it the brain drain.
- 5:37So you definitely participated in the post-university brain drain.
- 5:40One day they want you back.
- 5:42And I'm also from the country and I came down to Sydney with a one-way ticket.
- 5:47And I think I've lived here for 70% of my life now as well.
- 5:50So shout out to everyone who's still in the country, but it's pretty hard back, especially back 25 years ago, to take your skills on the road.
- 5:59Okay.
- 6:00I think we spoke, you know, off air previously.
- 6:05I think that Paul and the team might have come when I had a really small financial planning practice in 2004 or 2005 and for their sins actually sat down with our clients and did an investment update.
- 6:18at a cocktail party, et cetera.
- 6:20And I really remember that, I vividly remember that because I'm thinking, hey, you know, they've actually sent the guy whose name's on the sticker.
- 6:27And that was back 0405.
- 6:29But, you know, one of the insights after 30 years is that there is that long tenure and there is that willingness of the C-suite to actually get their sort of...
- 6:39Hands dirty, which is, as you grow, is quite uncommon, to be really honest.
- 6:43Yeah, and I think it's a good point, but it's an important point because you see in funds management, it's hard to have a 30-year track record.
- 6:56When we look at our peer group, there's not many that have survived or survived for that period of time.
- 7:02It's easy to get one market cycle right, to be on the right sector or the right individual group of stocks, but it's hard to consistently do that over multiple cycles.
- 7:15And I think it really comes down to, we think, process, you know, the philosophy that we have.
- 7:19And that's been, I would have hoped that, and I'm fairly confident it would be the case, that what Paul spoke about from a philosophical point of view back in 0405 would be exactly the same as what I talk to our clients about today.
- 7:34Or when we do events like this that we talk about, that hasn't changed in 30 years.
- 7:39I think that's really a testament to our business and the value of the people that are in that business because we all believe and we're there because we believe in the way we invest capital.
- 7:50Definitely come back to the longevity of tenure because it is a really interesting thing, especially in an industry where many people go from ship to ship as far as their career advancement goes.
- 8:00I wouldn't mind touching base again on what you think the secret sauce is there.
- 8:04Yeah.
- 8:05But there's a reason why I'm on this side of the mic, because my knowledge of markets and cycles and structures really just led to the fact that the only thing I could really remember from that session 20 years ago was the consolidation of the brewery industry.
- 8:21which might have been the only note I wrote that night around all of these businesses eventually getting down to one or two.
- 8:27And I brought this up with you and your team just before this podcast.
- 8:30And he said, yeah, that was right.
- 8:32We did that.
- 8:32And that sort of gives us an insight because you definitely aren't.
- 8:36a company where as if I was to say, you know, what's your take on Taiwan or Japan, you'd sort of look at me and go, that's not how we roll.
- 8:43So it'd be really good to sort of understand, you know, the way in which you guys think about investments first and foremost.
- 8:50And then later on, you mentioned about a couple of market cycles.
- 8:53Are we getting to the end of one or are we at the beginning of another?
- 8:56So there's two questions for you.
- 8:58Yeah, the global brewing story, you're right, that's one that was probably in its really early days, its infancy, 2003, 2004 was when we're getting invested in that thematic.
- 9:09But I think what is important, whether it's global brewing, whether it's European banks, whether it's copper, which has been a big theme in our portfolio for the last five or six years,
- 9:20What we're really trying to do is look for the genuine market anomalies.
- 9:27We're not out there to replicate an index.
- 9:29We're out there to find five, six, seven, eight themes in a portfolio that we think we can invest capital in over a very long time.
- 9:39So the global brewing story was one.
- 9:42where we started investing in 2003 and we sold our final investment in 2017.
- 9:49And through that process, we probably owned 14 or 15 brewing companies.
- 9:55The industry consolidated.
- 9:56Half of those holdings were bought out over time.
- 10:00But what we're really trying to do is identify –
- 10:06We're basing our view on it's a long-term view.
- 10:08One of the things we say to clients is we're investing capital not for the next one, two, or three years.
- 10:14We're investing capital for the next decade plus.
- 10:17What we're really doing is we're trying to arbitrage our long-term time horizon and our thought process with the market's increasingly short-term machinations.
- 10:26Everyone's drawn shorter and shorter.
- 10:29We're trying to think long term.
- 10:30And when our view of the world gets out of whack with those short term gyrations, we want to invest a lot of capital behind a select number of things.
- 10:40So that's really how we go about it.
- 10:42The other really important aspect to look at when you think about the way we invest capital, one of the most important points to our business, I think it makes us very different, is flexibility in the mandate.
- 10:57So Paul founded the business in 1998.
- 11:01He was at BT for a decade plus before that.
- 11:05But it was really about managing his capital first and foremost.
- 11:12And everyone that's come into the business on the investment team looks at it in the same way.
- 11:17We're there to manage our own capital.
- 11:20and generate and grow our capital over time and over a long period of time.
- 11:25I'm thinking about the next 40 years when I'm allocating capital, hopefully.
- 11:29And why that's important is we want to have maximum flexibility to invest capital where we see the opportunities.
- 11:35We don't want to be hamstrung by...
- 11:37external mandates that say you have to be 90% invested at all times, or you have to have X weight versus the index, or you have to do A or B.
- 11:48So what we're going to say is what is the maximum level of flexibility we can have, the type of assets we can invest in.
- 11:54So not just equities, credit, we can have cash, we can be long, we can be short, we can use derivatives and
- 12:00Having that flexibility for us allows us to seek out the best opportunities to markets.
- 12:05That's what's really important to us.
- 12:07Everyone that's in the business wholeheartedly believes in that process and that way of allocating capital.
- 12:13I think that's what's driven the success.
- 12:16I use a good example, and I think I've spoken to you about this one before.
- 12:19I presented it at a conference two or three years ago, and I was presenting on a panel with another fund.
- 12:26Yeah.
- 12:28I spoke about this mindset and that being alignment.
- 12:34Having money in the fund is not necessarily alignment.
- 12:36It's the way you think you should invest capital is a real alignment.
- 12:39And the other presenter got up and said, our portfolio managers are aligned as well.
- 12:44They have money in the funds.
- 12:45And he was an emerging markets manager.
- 12:48And he spent all of his presentation talking about the fact that he was negative on China.
- 12:54First question he got from the audience was how much of your capital is invested in China?
- 12:59And he said, it's 30%.
- 13:02But the index is 35.
- 13:04So we're underweight.
- 13:05That does not make sense to us.
- 13:07Our view is that China would be zero.
- 13:09Yeah, well, the difference.
- 13:10Absolutely.
- 13:11And the last comment that you made, and quite often I host panels where you've got people who are doing index tracking or high frequency and you've got deep value managers per se.
- 13:21And when you're talking with the financial planning or planners at the coalface, they talk to real clients and real retirees and real investors.
- 13:34And I think, you know, the ability for them to convey conviction is sort of a real part of it.
- 13:41It's a lot easier to explain something that makes sense rather than hugging an index, especially when that index is so narrow, like Australia's, for instance, which, you know, I actually don't know what percentage of your portfolio is outside of Australia, but it's been a long time since this market's had much other than sort of index tracking super funds, which is...
- 14:02Which is one of the reasons that has made Australia very difficult, right?
- 14:06From a valuation perspective.
- 14:08So I 100% agree that is an issue.
- 14:14So I want to just take it back to the advice practices.
- 14:18So you had this high performance, and I did a whole podcast series.
- 14:22In fact, I'll give PM Capital their biggies.
- 14:28For many years, we've been interviewing best practices, and –
- 14:31And, you know, Ensemble had this take that we wanted to interview the best practices.
- 14:37But the reality is best practices all had licensees.
- 14:40But for a long time, licensees were so caught up in regulation and whatnot, they really didn't want to talk.
- 14:45And I can't remember whether your team convinced us or we convinced you guys to sponsor a podcast series where we interviewed...
- 14:52you know, Australia's biggest licensees.
- 14:53So we've come to the conclusion of that.
- 14:56And I have a feeling based on, you know, if anyone's listened to that who's a regular listener, there were quite a few big names there.
- 15:04But for a lot of them, it was their first time they've ever spoken to a podcast to the general advice market.
- 15:10They historically had spoken a lot to their own people, but actually hadn't spoken much to other people.
- 15:15And so for that, we thank you because, you know, that promotes the positive evolution.
- 15:22So one of the things I wanted to ask you, Kevin, in relation to the portfolio that you're across, global equities, when you speak about global equities in Australia to Australian punters, like the general public, maybe less so the knowledgeable advice sort of community, but it's often looked at as USA.
- 15:42There's almost blanket news in the USA.
- 15:44But what other markets and countries do you guys see, quote unquote, your own words, for the genuine market anomalies?
- 15:53And how do you, I suppose, enter into that thought process of going into it?
- 15:58Yeah, it's a good point.
- 15:59And I think there's a component of it which is fair to make that assumption that the US is the globe.
- 16:09A lot of people talk about MAG-7 and the –
- 16:13the fact that the markets have coalesced around, you know, these seven stocks and they make up a very large part, you know, of the index.
- 16:20What people fail to recognize is that the MISC-Y world, which is the index that most managers follow, is over 70% exposed to the US.
- 16:29So,
- 16:31Big change.
- 16:31I remember kicking off, finishing my degree, and it was 50-50.
- 16:34Yep.
- 16:34There you go.
- 16:35Exactly.
- 16:35So it's changed a lot.
- 16:37But I think part of that evolution and change is warranted.
- 16:41If you think about the world we live in today, it is a global world.
- 16:45Yep.
- 16:45It's a world that's driven by technology.
- 16:48So servicing a consumer is very different today than it was 50 years ago.
- 16:53If you go back to the 1800s, the leading sector in the US was railway companies.
- 16:59Yeah.
- 17:00Now, if you're a railway company on the east coast of the US, there's not the scale benefits, there's not the ability to bloat that over a global supply chain.
- 17:11You're not a railway company in the UK.
- 17:13You look today, if you're Netflix, with that same stack of technology that you have, you can service any customer in the world.
- 17:20So it's a very different make-up.
- 17:23So it should be these global businesses which have hailed from the US that are now able to reach consumers globally means you're going to have higher concentration.
- 17:34But there's a lot of businesses out there, and we see a lot of opportunity outside of the US.
- 17:41So when you look at our portfolio –
- 17:43We have a much higher weight to Europe.
- 17:48Can I ask why?
- 17:49Because Europe's been off the cool list for about 10 years when it comes to this.
- 17:53Probably even longer.
- 17:54Yeah.
- 17:56But what I would say is we never start by saying we want to be invested in Europe.
- 18:02We sit there and say we have an idea.
- 18:05And ideas are a dime a dozen.
- 18:07They come in many different forms and facets.
- 18:09Yeah.
- 18:10But when we identify something, we will try and look at it on a global scale, get global comparison, understand how that industry works here, how it works in Europe, how it works in the US.
- 18:21And what we found over time is a lot of the feedback we got from people was, why are you invested in Europe?
- 18:27Europe's a basket case.
- 18:30And in many parts of Europe, we would agree with that sentiment.
- 18:34But with...
- 18:36passive flow and the flow of capital to the US, you had a part of the market that was very highly valued and that was sucking capital from other places.
- 18:46So genuinely, opportunity was presenting itself in other areas.
- 18:49Hence the anomaly.
- 18:50Yeah.
- 18:51And we don't sit there and say, because it's cheap, we'll buy it.
- 18:54Valuation is the center point that we gravitate to, but it's not the only thing that we're looking for.
- 19:04But we've found value in pockets of the European market.
- 19:10What's some examples of that?
- 19:12I think if you look at Europe and you go, you say 10 years Europe's been, or 15 years, it's been a bit of a basket case.
- 19:20If you think about what Europe went through after the GFC in terms of the European debt crisis, what that did to the economies.
- 19:30what it did to growth.
- 19:33And I think one of the things that you've seen play out in Europe, particularly with the second coming of Donald Trump, is there's a real recognition that they have to stand on their own two feet.
- 19:46They need to control their own destiny.
- 19:48They can't rely on the historic relationships that they've had.
- 19:53And
- 19:54they have to realize that they're a marketplace of over 500 million people if you X out Russia.
- 20:00It's a big place, right?
- 20:02And a couple of years ago, it was something that really stuck in my mind.
- 20:06There was a conference.
- 20:08It was a day or two after Trump got reelected.
- 20:11And Emmanuel Macron got up at a conference with European leaders.
- 20:17And he basically said that.
- 20:19but in terms of we have to stand on our own two feet.
- 20:22But he put it in the context of herbivores and carnivores.
- 20:26Go on, you've got my interest.
- 20:28And he basically said, if you think about the global economy and you think about countries and you think about whether or not a country is a herbivore or a carnivore, you can sit there today and you can tell pretty comfortably who the carnivores are.
- 20:42Carnivores are the Americans and the Chinese.
- 20:46Europeans are the herbivores.
- 20:48And if we keep acting like herbivores, we're going to come to realize too late in decades to come that the carnivores have come here and they've eaten the herbivores.
- 20:59So we need to start working together as a collective union to, you know, promote.
- 21:05to look after our own economies, to promote growth in our economies, to look after our own security, and to make our own policy decisions.
- 21:13And when we sit back and look at Europe, we see pockets of opportunity within that that will take advantage of those changes and are places you can invest capital for a long period of time.
- 21:25Classic example is European banks.
- 21:28Now, not European banks in every market, not in Germany, not in France, but in some markets,
- 21:34The industry structure has improved dramatically over the last 15 years.
- 21:39Rates are now positive.
- 21:40They can make money.
- 21:42Well, the governance is better.
- 21:43The governance is better.
- 21:45But regulation, the regulator understands you can no longer have your foot on the throat of a bank consistently if you want your economies to grow.
- 21:53So these businesses went through a decade...
- 21:57where their return on tangible equity was single digit, mid-single digits.
- 22:02So 4%, 5%, 6%.
- 22:03Not great.
- 22:04You've got a couple of these headwinds that are turned to tailwinds.
- 22:07That means these businesses actually, if you look at them today, they have a better return on tangible equity than the banks here in Australia.
- 22:16Amazing to think.
- 22:17Except in Australia, you've got a bank that trades at 25 times earnings.
- 22:20In Europe, you've got banks that trade at 11, 12, 13 times.
- 22:24Yeah.
- 22:25A big shift.
- 22:27So there are things like that we'll look for.
- 22:29It won't be market driven, but it'll have elements of that.
- 22:33But we've found a sector.
- 22:35We like the dynamics and we want to play that for a long period of time.
- 22:40And do you think Europe as a collective has been, so you mentioned potentially a long-term beneficiary of Trump too in relation to, you know, I feel like they used to outsource their economic future.
- 22:52Yeah, they did.
- 22:52And really they were asleep at the wheel, so to speak.
- 22:57And I think that it wasn't until the reality of having the military and security rug pulled that that got their attention and probably could possibly be the making of that continent
- 23:09Well, I think it takes time, but I think at least today, because there's a couple of things that happen, right?
- 23:17Trump is part of the equation, but Russia-Ukraine is a big part of the story in Europe as well.
- 23:25You look at what's happening in Germany.
- 23:27You shut down all of your nuclear facilities because nuclear is bad.
- 23:33And then 18 months or two years later, you've basically stopped buying gas from the Russians and you realize that you can no longer actually power your economy globally.
- 23:47the way you have in the past.
- 23:48So there's a lot of things that have culminated at once to say, you know, we need to get serious.
- 23:55We need to invest in, you know, new industry.
- 23:58And, you know, we see pockets of that being opportunities.
- 24:01But the starting place for us is if you want to have economic growth, you need to have a healthy banking system that is lending.
- 24:10And regulators now finally understand that, we think.
- 24:14And then the consolidation story is a huge story for European banks.
- 24:17And what would be the headline on that consolidation story?
- 24:21What's the headline number of banks in Europe?
- 24:23Yeah, so it depends what market you go to.
- 24:26And this is why we only like certain markets.
- 24:29If you go to the German economy, there's a lot of co-op banks, socialized banks, where they run very differently.
- 24:34They don't run for profit.
- 24:37But if you go to a market like Spain, if you went back 15 years ago in Spain, there would have been 50 or 60 banks.
- 24:45go there today and the top five banks control 75% to 80%.
- 24:49It's a familiar feeling here, isn't it?
- 24:51Yes.
- 24:52You go to Ireland and that's a supercharged example.
- 24:58When money was freely flowing prior to the GFC, every bank in Europe with excess capital was trying to put money into Ireland.
- 25:09It was obviously benefiting from a low tax environment.
- 25:12Corporates were coming in.
- 25:14but you had 15 good-sized banks.
- 25:17Today, two banks essentially control that market.
- 25:21So it's a huge shift that doesn't change economics overnight, but it creates a very strong tailwind that the banks should benefit from for a long period of time to come.
- 25:33You mentioned about a few of the opportunities and you were specific and you're also talking about flexibility and market anomalies.
- 25:41If I flip the script, where currently do you think is sort of an overvalued and where would you avoid?
- 25:47Yeah, I think if you look at the environment we're in today, we talked a little bit about it before, but have a look at, to me it always goes to where's capital coming from, where's it going?
- 25:59And you think about where capital has gone, a lot of capital has gone into the US market.
- 26:07And the U.S. has a lot of factors that are running in its favor.
- 26:15It has a government that is promoting reshoring, promoting business activity.
- 26:23It is the default currency.
- 26:24It is energy independent.
- 26:26It has all of these things that benefit it.
- 26:28It did up until recently have population growth.
- 26:31So there's a lot of positive things that the market understands about the U.S.,
- 26:35So money flows there, but it keeps flowing there and it keeps flowing there and it keeps flowing there regardless of valuation.
- 26:41So you see when we look globally, we have US being- For all those reasons you just said.
- 26:50Yep.
- 26:50Yep.
- 26:51We see like businesses globally, US companies tend to be more expensive.
- 26:55Now there should be a premium, but we think it's-
- 26:59The other one, Australia.
- 27:01We run an Australian fund and we say to our clients, we're a bit differentiated when it comes to Australia.
- 27:07We're trying to deploy our global insights in the local market.
- 27:11So we look at this valuation subset globally and then we look at Australia and as you said, it's a small market.
- 27:19It's got a lot of passive flow.
- 27:20It's going into the same stocks every week.
- 27:23And it's created an environment where it's extremely expensive from a relative perspective on a global basis.
- 27:29It's hard.
- 27:30It's hard.
- 27:31Yeah.
- 27:32So they're places where we sit there and say the opportunity that we see, we have positions in the US, don't get me wrong, but relative to the broader market, we would be underweight there.
- 27:45And on the Australian, this is just a question that I'm seeing play out in financial services.
- 27:54So, you know, 15 years ago, anyone who was an entrepreneurial person, their ambition was to list on the ASX was one of those things that was where you went to.
- 28:05diversify, shielding, obtain capital, et cetera.
- 28:07And I think now people are running away from that, going to private markets, because if you're not one of the big ones with the mandated flows, it becomes almost counterproductive.
- 28:16So with that as a backdrop in Australia, how do you go and find the smaller sort of capitalized good value investments?
- 28:26In Australia?
- 28:26Yeah, absolutely.
- 28:27Yeah, so again, it would go back to our overarching philosophy is if we have to be 100% invested at all times, you're going to have to go show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome.
- 28:40You're going to have to go and find opportunities where opportunity might not present itself.
- 28:44So if you look at our Aussie fund, we're running with 30% cash at the moment.
- 28:47So big cash way.
- 28:48It's the flexibility, right?
- 28:49The flexibility goes to the flexibility.
- 28:51And in those times, what have we done?
- 28:53We have the ability to go out and buy credit security.
- 28:56So yes, we don't just want to sit with the money in cash.
- 29:00We know longer term cash is going to burn a hole in our pocket, but we've been able to find select credit opportunities to invest in this local market as well.
- 29:08And do the same globally?
- 29:09Yeah.
- 29:09Yes.
- 29:10Or can you be more invested globally based on conversation?
- 29:12We are definitely more invested globally.
- 29:13Now, we often say to people that we just see Australia as part of the globe.
- 29:21We don't segregate it off and say it's separate because it's our home market.
- 29:25And what we'll say to people is there's a lot of risk...
- 29:30for you and your client being overweight what is 1% or 2% of the global market.
- 29:36The big risk for advisors is discarding 98% of the world's investable opportunities.
- 29:43It's a big world and there's a lot of opportunity out there.
- 29:48And you don't have to run as hard to find something that's an anomaly globally than you do in Australia because it's just such a small market here.
- 29:55It's mathematics.
- 29:55It's right.
- 29:57And also, you know, we can be contemporary in this podcast.
- 30:01As of, I think, about two or three days ago, the United Nations voted on a new map of the world.
- 30:05So if we actually use that and overlay that with the direction with which money was flowing, I'm not sure whether Africa's getting a bump, but maybe the United States got slightly smaller.
- 30:15Or aren't they the only ones that voted against it?
- 30:17They were, yeah.
- 30:18But this is not the podcast forum for that reason.
- 30:20And don't send your hate mail anyone on the podcast.
- 30:23But they were the only ones.
- 30:25I think there were a couple that abstained as well.
- 30:28But they weren't completely alone.
- 30:29But yeah, it makes for an interesting thing.
- 30:32And I suppose it opens up the eyes of people to what the global sort of market is.
- 30:37I've got to ask about Japan.
- 30:39What's your thoughts on Japan?
- 30:42Because for all those reasons you mentioned about Japan,
- 30:44America having, up until recently, population growth and economic resilience and flow of cash.
- 30:52My sort of very layman's observation is Japan doesn't seem to be having those attributes.
- 30:57Yeah, Japan is difficult because, as you say, there's a lot of those structural tailwinds that they may have had two or three decades ago that disappeared.
- 31:08They're now very big structural headwinds.
- 31:12So you've got two types of Japanese business.
- 31:15You've got a domestic Japanese business, which has a customer base that's not growing, and
- 31:23It's shrinking.
- 31:25It's historically been a very difficult market to price.
- 31:30There's been no inflation.
- 31:31And you've seen countless examples where corporates have tried to push through price and they've had to reverse those price increases because you've got a consumer and a customer base that over a long period of time has been accustomed to having the same price for the product year in, year out.
- 31:45Feels like since 1987.
- 31:47So there's that element of Japan.
- 31:49And then there's the Japanese corporate that is a multinational corporate where half of their business today is offshore.
- 31:59But again, for domestic Japanese investors, those businesses trade at much higher multiples because scarcity factor.
- 32:08They want businesses that can grow.
- 32:10They're the segment of the market that's growing.
- 32:13So when we look at Japan, we don't have a lot of capital allocated in Japan.
- 32:18Just like we don't have a lot of capital allocated to China.
- 32:21Now, China is a very similar dynamic to Japan.
- 32:26It's just a couple of decades behind.
- 32:29It's reaching a point where the population is speaking.
- 32:32The consumer is under a lot of pressure because property prices have declined a long way.
- 32:37They've got the added pressure of being restricted in participating in a lot of sectors globally because of this.
- 32:43And another big thing that we've talked a lot about is global decoupling and the influence that that's going to have on markets for the next 10, 20 years.
- 32:52And that as an investable thematic over time.
- 32:55But China's in a very similar position.
- 32:58They're in difficult positions.
- 33:00Valuation in China is a lot lower, but...
- 33:03But in saying that, it's hard to see in some of those markets where it's going to get higher.
- 33:09Yes.
- 33:10You need to see...
- 33:12Ultimately, in a place like China, it has to be driven by policy.
- 33:17You have to unlock a very, very large savings pool that the consumer has.
- 33:23If they can just take that consumer spending and discretionary spending number, if they can move that a little bit, it makes a big difference.
- 33:31But you need to...
- 33:32ensure that your constituents, your population feels comfortable enough to be able to do that.
- 33:39Which is really hard when you get older.
- 33:41Yeah, and it takes a long time for that to actually change.
- 33:44So when you're out there, and I think before the podcast, we spoke about the fact that you've taken...
- 33:51You've taken this sort of high-performance consulting on the road.
- 33:54I think you've done Adelaide.
- 33:56You've got Sydney coming, Melbourne.
- 33:57I'm getting nods here.
- 34:00And, you know, you're really leaning into that advisory.
- 34:04Have you got any sort of – have you had any takeouts from – I think you've had one or two –
- 34:09of how advisors like to explain the way in which you guys invest to their clients.
- 34:16What are the sort of ways in which you find that they like to have those bullet points?
- 34:20Because before they introduce the client to you guys and you guys take over, they've got to somehow articulate the elevator pitch.
- 34:27What do you find is the most common?
- 34:29I think it's the most common starting point for people is conviction in what they do.
- 34:37The fact that we've been doing what we say we do for 30 years.
- 34:43It goes back to my example around if we
- 34:45don't like China or don't like Japan, just because the index has some exposure there, we're not going to be invested there.
- 34:51So you know what you get when you get PM capital, you get a group of people that have been doing something for a very long period of time and that we've been able to invest that capital over multiple cycles.
- 35:04So people like that conviction behind what you own.
- 35:08And
- 35:09When you look at our portfolios, there's 30 ideas, 35 ideas, but as I said before, there are five, six, seven thematics.
- 35:17We can sit down and talk for a very long time about each one of those.
- 35:22One of my big observations that I say to people, when you sit down with a manager, one of the first questions, if you're sitting at the pub with a manager, first question you should ask them is, name every stock that you own in your portfolio.
- 35:33Yeah.
- 35:34The reality is not many managers can do that because they'll have 150, they'll have 200 stocks.
- 35:41They'll change monthly.
- 35:43We know what we hold.
- 35:45We hold them for a long time.
- 35:46We have real genuine conviction behind the support of valuation, but how those businesses grow over time.
- 35:53And that's what resonates with advisors because they know...
- 35:57If they need to pick up the phone and ask about a bad month or a bad quarter, we'll be able to give them a proper answer as to what's happened within our portfolios.
- 36:06And you think the average advice practice, the average advisor, I think might be 52 or something like that.
- 36:11I'll have to get the data.
- 36:12But it was 47 five years ago.
- 36:14So I'd say it's 52 years.
- 36:16And they've been in practice for 20-something years.
- 36:18So they've had the same relationship with the people who've entrusted their money for many, many years.
- 36:23And having that ability to go back and sort of ask you guys and even also reflect back on your wins and losses over the years because it's the same people.
- 36:30And I'm going to have a question without notice now.
- 36:34So having so many of the team and initially Paul with investing as well, do you guys personally invest into a lot of those investments over the years that they ask?
- 36:46Because it feels like that kind of is probably going to be a yes, but I don't really know.
- 36:51Yeah, and I've always said this, we're the largest investors in our funds.
- 36:56Well, I didn't know that.
- 36:56For everyone there and there, before I asked, it wasn't that big of a Dorothy Dixie, but yeah.
- 37:01And it's by design, it's by a wide margin.
- 37:04So what we don't have is, we don't go to our clients and say, well, I'll put 50 grand in the fund because I have to say that I'm aligned to my client because I have money in the fund.
- 37:14We invest our capital in the funds because the funds deploy capital in the way in which we would manage it.
- 37:20And you like money, right?
- 37:25We would be investing our capital the same way if it was in the fund or if it wasn't.
- 37:29Now, that's the important part and it goes again to that flexibility, which I keep coming back to.
- 37:34But the reason that's important is because we're not being dictated to by external forces to how we should invest the capital.
- 37:41So we're not doing anything differently than what we would be doing if I was sitting at home by myself investing capital.
- 37:47We would be in a very similar way.
- 37:50Perfect.
- 37:50And let's always talk about the exciting things, but let's talk about the risks, the risks of this previously massively interconnected globe, which still is the rise and rise of the decoupling.
- 38:06So that's a paradoxical statement.
- 38:09And just how fast things like concentration risk and rates and currency can unwind an otherwise perfectly good call.
- 38:18And what do you see as the biggest risks in the global economy?
- 38:20Yeah, I think if you look at markets today, the big risks around inflation, rates, debt, they're still the big three.
- 38:29They've been the big three for a while.
- 38:31It's two sides of the one kind, kind of, really.
- 38:33It is.
- 38:34And if you go back...
- 38:36I think this is to your question before around what our clients will say about us is we will say, we might get a bit boring sometimes because we'll say the same thing over and over again.
- 38:47But we were having this conversation with our clients about the seeding of inflation seven or eight years ago.
- 38:55Pre-COVID.
- 38:55Pre-COVID.
- 38:56Then you had COVID and this is kind of transitory.
- 38:59Well, it's not.
- 39:00It's embedded.
- 39:01And it goes back to thinking about the world on that long-term lens.
- 39:05You talk about decoupling story and some of these big trends that we see in markets.
- 39:09They are very inflationary.
- 39:13So not only the fact that governments are spending your hand over fist, but you've got these big global trends, global decoupling.
- 39:20That started in 2001.
- 39:23This whole story of decoupling started in 2001 when China was bought into the WTO.
- 39:30You had 20 years of globalization, 25 years of globalization.
- 39:34We think you're going to have 20 years of decoupling.
- 39:37And that's an inflationary factor on markets.
- 39:40You're taking a global supply chain and you're cutting it up.
- 39:44You're making it smaller, so you're making it higher cost.
- 39:47You look at net zero, hugely inflationary.
- 39:50Probably why our productivity hasn't in this country increased since Bill Clinton was in office.
- 39:55Yeah, so these things, it wasn't two or three weeks.
- 39:59It was only two or three weeks ago we were sitting here and all of a sudden everyone started to worry about the US debt position.
- 40:07Why?
- 40:07Because Besson went into the markets and tried to manipulate Besson
- 40:11rates.
- 40:12But that has been an issue for every day of the past many years.
- 40:17So it's just what brings these issues to the forefront and makes people focus on them.
- 40:23And we just think that inflation is one of those big stories that continues to be an issue in markets.
- 40:30And what that is going to mean for rates is the flow on.
- 40:35So if inflation is a persistent issue, how does that inform on the ground the type of investments you look for?
- 40:42Yeah, there's two parts.
- 40:45We want to find, again, there's going to be sectors that we think benefit from some of those broader trends.
- 40:54Like?
- 40:55If you look at the global decoupling story, we think we've owned it for a long time in business like Siemens.
- 41:01If you want to have productivity or if you want to reshore industry back to the US, there is no way you can do that physically, given the constraint of people, unless you're doing it in an automated fashion.
- 41:18It's the largest automation play globally.
- 41:22So it's going to be hugely beneficial what's happening.
- 41:26So we look for areas where that plays is going to play out.
- 41:31If you look at another area that we've been heavily invested for the last five or six years, it's been the commodity story.
- 41:39There's a lot of inflation happening in the commodities markets.
- 41:43And we've seen a lot of that play out today where we've reduced positions.
- 41:47But they're the things we'll look for.
- 41:48We'll look for sectors where we see a direct correlational benefit that these businesses might have.
- 41:54And so the impact on inflation and finding those inflation hedges and avoiding the ones that are sort of going to be negatively impacted by reshoring.
- 42:06So if you're correct, and we've done, we did 20 years of globalization and we're heading towards the 20th year of a very slow moving decoupling, which only really is getting lots of media now because of, I suppose, the verboseness of the American administration,
- 42:22Can you see any time in the future that it's going to cycle back the other way?
- 42:27A lot of people originally thought...
- 42:30So this all started in 2018, right?
- 42:33So you had 2001 to 2018.
- 42:35It was a globalization story.
- 42:38And it was actually China's rise was fed by the Western world because they wanted to do things cheaper to make more money.
- 42:45And they thought that longer term, the Chinese would turn around and be more democratic.
- 42:50That didn't happen.
- 42:51She came in and said, you know what?
- 42:54We've been able to take people out of poverty.
- 42:57We've been able to make a better environment for our constituents.
- 43:01But now what we're going to do is we're going to take that and we're going to try and improve our standing in the world.
- 43:09Now, we're going to use that to our own economic and political advantage.
- 43:12You look at Africa today.
- 43:14People think that China's one belt, one road policy was a disaster.
- 43:18It wasn't.
- 43:19Look at Africa.
- 43:20They control Africa.
- 43:21So Trump was the first person that actually said, this is what it is and this is why it's a problem.
- 43:28Everyone else was just like boiling frogs.
- 43:30Yep.
- 43:30And then what happened is there's now a real recognition.
- 43:34We're putting no links to boiling frogs, Kieran, the sound guy, in the side notes, mate.
- 43:39But what happened then was you look at the Biden administration, they didn't reverse course, they bedded down.
- 43:46So we think it's more consensus now amongst politicians that there is a need to focus back on your own countries, your own manufacturing capabilities, particularly in a world where you are less reliant on your trading partners than you were in the past.
- 44:03The Europeans get it now.
- 44:05It can't be as reliant on the Americans.
- 44:08They see the Chinese as a big threat.
- 44:09Look at the auto industry.
- 44:11So there's real recognition that you need to focus back in on your own economies, your own industries.
- 44:18And I think that just takes a long time to play out.
- 44:20I don't think it reverses course quickly.
- 44:22Well, I think when you mentioned the auto industry, Volkswagen's got 50,000 people who no longer will have a job with them because they blinked and China took the marketplace.
- 44:31And Australia, as of the most recent sort of set of accounts, appears to be following in that same footsteps with the EV vehicles.
- 44:39We haven't mentioned much on AI other than sort of the big seven or eight companies in the world.
- 44:46And it's very hard when every news article has something.
- 44:51You know, there's mild swings in opinions.
- 44:54And yet there's actually relatively low adoption, even in professional suites in this country, by most people, right?
- 45:00So very much it's advisors are thinking about, I've heard about someone who's heard about something.
- 45:05So there's a lot of that scuttlebutt out there.
- 45:08But what's the biggest impact in 2026 in relation to AI that you can see and how, if at all, that affects the way in which you think about investing?
- 45:18Yeah.
- 45:18So when you mentioned the big thematics and I said, you know, rates, inflation, debt, the other big one is AI because it is fundamentally going to change almost every industry.
- 45:32It's just what time horizon is it going to change it?
- 45:36So there's a couple of things to unpick from that.
- 45:38If you look at what's happening today in markets, again, you have a lot of money that is flowing into what I call the AI haves, the businesses that are supposedly going to be the billion dollar business with one employee, whatever it might be.
- 45:54So a lot of capital is flowing there and it's flowing there without underlying fundamentals suggesting valuation makes sense.
- 46:04But it's every cycle has that kind of stuff, doesn't it?
- 46:06Exactly right.
- 46:07Every cycle has that.
- 46:08So there's a lot of capital flying there and it's, I need to participate because if I don't participate, I miss out.
- 46:13And then there's the reverse of that.
- 46:14There's the AI have-nots.
- 46:17Now there's two buckets.
- 46:18There's businesses that genuinely get disrupted.
- 46:21Yep.
- 46:21And then there's the ones that are kind of boring.
- 46:23You know, the ones that aren't, that don't benefit, that are not directly, you know, impacted by it either.
- 46:29Yeah.
- 46:30And they're just a little bit boring.
- 46:31But those areas, those two areas is where there's potentially a lot of opportunity.
- 46:35But then there's a lot of businesses where they've been market darlings for a long time.
- 46:40And AI does have the potential to significantly disrupt the long-term economics.
- 46:46And when you're valuing a business, as you know, Roxy, you're valuing a long tail of cash flow.
- 46:51So you're putting a lot of value in the terminal value of the business and
- 46:55And if you, what AI has done is it's made it much harder to predict with any certainty what that long tail of cash flows is going to look like.
- 47:03Because it might be a shorter tail than you think.
- 47:05Yeah, it could be a very short tail, right?
- 47:06So things look cheap, but the question is, can I get comfortable enough that today's economics aren't going to fall off a cliff quickly?
- 47:17So that's from an investing standpoint when we look at it.
- 47:20Yeah, that's one side.
- 47:21The other side is how we implement AI into our businesses.
- 47:27And there's no point anyone sitting there and putting your head in the sandbox because it's coming.
- 47:34And those that utilize it are going to provide a better outcome for their clients over time.
- 47:40Now, we're not saying we're using it to make investment decisions for us, but what it does is it...
- 47:46it helps speed up the process.
- 47:49We will do months and months of work on stuff.
- 47:51This does help speed up that process.
- 47:54It helps you distill a lot of information much quicker.
- 47:59So we can use that to our benefit from a process of what we do day to day.
- 48:04And at the coalface, the practices, and I suppose that if you look at the brass tacks of high performance in an advice practice, they would probably be defined as how many family units of how much investable money per advisor.
- 48:17Because the way in which the advisor market has contracted due to many, many well-documented legislative sort of headwinds has meant that most practices are sitting around that 100%.
- 48:29families and there's no one really coming into the market, which was a common theme in the Wise and See podcast that new entrants are quite scarce.
- 48:37So when I talk with practices, they exactly say that they only gives them the speed, but they're hoping it's broadening their ability to bring in people to service.
- 48:47but they're not there yet.
- 48:48They're kind of, we're really in that purgatory period where we haven't quite figured out whether that has happened yet, but the general consensus is it will.
- 48:56But it could disrupt itself because the same set clients have access to the same set of tools.
- 49:03Yep.
- 49:03Which, you know, for an eon, being a professional advisor with insights and access to information has been your natural sort of,
- 49:13and almost value proposition in many respects.
- 49:15But the democratization of that, I mean, soft skills are important.
- 49:19Exactly.
- 49:19And that has the same impact on investment markets and where capital flows.
- 49:27If it's being used day to day, how is it impacting
- 49:29capital decisions and where that capital flows over time.
- 49:32So on that comment, what's the last time that that comment around AI and market flows has impacted a portfolio decision in your image?
- 49:44Well, I think maybe it's not AI exactly, but if you look at where we're looking today, it's safe to say that there is an element of the ideas that we're working on today.
- 49:55There's an element in there.
- 49:57It might not be the only factor, but it's one of the factors that is a question mark around AI.
- 50:02And then we've got to go and do the work to determine whether or not we think that actually works.
- 50:07that has an impact.
- 50:08And every day you wake up and as you rightly pointed, it's changing so quickly that iteration after iteration of these models may have a different impact on businesses that are in the portfolio.
- 50:22So it's a key issue for almost every business today.
- 50:25And it's just become part and parcel of what you do when you're analyzing these businesses.
- 50:31And I think the sophistication of clients is increasing that much that, you know, there was a time, and indeed, you know, I was probably guilty of it when I was a practicing CFP, that just hugging an index was enough.
- 50:43But that only works when everything's pointing and you don't have, you know, those four big bullet points, especially inflation, as you've intimated, which we, for most advisors in the super cycle, really hasn't been in play for 20, 25 years now.
- 50:59And in fact, anyone under the age of sort of 40 hasn't really had inflation to consider in a portfolio management position.
- 51:05Yeah.
- 51:06And we've been in a really interesting environment because what we'll often say is when people define, as you said before, what are the main risks in markets?
- 51:15To me, it's like, what do you define as risk, right?
- 51:19To us, the big risk is permanent loss of capital and your inability to...
- 51:24to grow your capital base in real terms.
- 51:29Yep.
- 51:29Right?
- 51:29That's what... Real growth, eh?
- 51:31Who'd have thought it?
- 51:32It's a thing.
- 51:33So if you're an advisor, and us as investors, we've been in an environment where equity markets, not Australia but globally, have compounded at 20% plus for the last four or five years.
- 51:45It's rewarded mediocrity.
- 51:46Yeah.
- 51:47That is not how we think the world moves going forward.
- 51:51Right?
- 51:52So...
- 51:53People got to understand, so we always go back to the building blocks.
- 51:56How do we get to our 12 or 13% return?
- 51:58Now, in one year that might not look great versus the index, but over time it's that mindset and the building blocks to getting to that valuation point that we think stands you in pretty good stead.
- 52:10Because you're gonna have to do something slightly different moving forward, given the way markets have played out over the last four or five years.
- 52:19And to your point there,
- 52:21You're now living in a world where there is inflation.
- 52:23You're going to have to generate returns.
- 52:25And we shouldn't expect that 20% compounded number from the market.
- 52:31That's right.
- 52:31Remember, my study days, you can only get supernormal profits in inefficient markets.
- 52:36and the increasing potential inefficiency perceived otherwise does mean that you have to have a bit more stagecraft with what you're investing in.
- 52:45Kevin, thank you very much for your time.
- 52:48And a big shout out to the PM Capital team, particularly Luke Cheat and Ben Warnes, who took a punt and actually...
- 52:54And realize that the role of an investment advisor inside the financial advice ecosystem is not just to work in isolation, but to go out there and understand the conversations that advisors are having with their clients, their families, what keeps them awake at night, what they're curious about.
- 53:11and the fact that a lot of the money in Australia these days is coming from a more sophisticated client than it used to.
- 53:19The concept of set and forget is probably something that really is not as apparent as it was 20, 30 years ago.
- 53:25And the size of the funds are more important as well.
- 53:27So a big shout out to you guys doing that.
- 53:29And the ethos of Ensemble is the positive evolution of financial advice.
- 53:34My hot take is that PM Capital has been a really good proponent of that, and we look forward to working with you guys in the future.
- 53:40Cheers, mate.
- 53:41Thanks very much.