Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Andrew Bosley
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamers Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamers guild. Find out more at grand gamers Guilds dot com. Out of
- 0:17the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:20waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:24at you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:29of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:32that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:36still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:39shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 0:53into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 0:57take five of their games with them. Which will they choose? My guest
- 1:02this week is one of the biggest artists in the board game sphere. He
- 1:04has illustrated Everdell Flow, an Unconscious Mind, amongst many others. He's also
- 1:10the designer of Lightning Bolton Plane Crafters. My guest this week is Andrew Bosley.
- 1:14Andrew, welcome to the Cabin. Well, thank you, Ben,
- 1:15I appreciate it. So my first question is how difficult was it for you
- 1:19to pick the five games to take to the cabin. It was a little
- 1:23difficult. I mean I had to make some assumptions, you know, whether
- 1:29I was taking my family with me or whether the games were more important than
- 1:33the family. I wasn't quite sure, but I assumed that I brought my
- 1:38family. So at that point I was, you know, I was juggling
- 1:42on what was gonna, you know, be fun for all of us,
- 1:44not just me. But no, it was. I mean I have some
- 1:48I have some quick favorites, for sure. So so they stood up pretty
- 1:52quickly. Yeah. I don't want to I don't want to pull the curtain
- 1:55back too much. But frankly, the premise is paper thin. So you
- 1:57can you then criteria you wish. And so how are you? How are
- 2:04you as a game collector? Are you wedded to your games or with the
- 2:08idea of them going up in a conflagration not be an issue for you?
- 2:14Uh ah, gosh, I'm I'm I mean, I love my games,
- 2:22and I have a really fun display and I love to show them off and
- 2:27all that sort of stuff. So the idea of then you know, burning
- 2:29up and never, you know, never playing it again is sad. But
- 2:35I mean, if in real, real life this world of happen, my
- 2:38games would not be the first things that I pick. Sure, but yeah,
- 2:45I mean games, I mean, games are really really important in our
- 2:47family, So it's I mean, it would I would think it would be
- 2:51if I were in the real situation. I'd there's some games that, like,
- 2:54yeah, it's kind of just part of our day to day life,
- 2:59so to lose them would be a disappointment. We would be regretting while we
- 3:02were at the cabin literally, But no, not not, not like you
- 3:08know, in some overwhelming way, would it? Would it? You know,
- 3:14especially under normal circumstances. Yeah, I'd be disappointed, but eventually I
- 3:17would build that collection back up and or make new ones. So and are
- 3:23you are you a collector of games or do you have a sort of regular
- 3:27through put in your collection. No, I'm definitely a collector. I'm uh,
- 3:36I mean, I'm limited by by just you know, budgets, and
- 3:39financial means, so that that already just you know, keeps it to a
- 3:45pretty responsible level. But no, I mean I love I think partly as
- 3:51a designer that doesn't design. I mean, I guess I can call myself
- 3:57a designer even though I don't design much right now. Love designing games.
- 4:00Every game I play, it's like, oh that those are new mechanics I've
- 4:05never seen before. Okay, what would I do or how you know?
- 4:08It's like it's like learning a language. That's like my vocabulary for game designers
- 4:12is playing new games. So I love. I love learning new games.
- 4:15I love collecting games. So it's it's a matter of how much shelf space
- 4:20I have and how much money, So that limits it. And I've spoken
- 4:27to a lot of designers, and a lot of them say to me,
- 4:30I can't really turn off the designer radar when I'm playing games. I'm always
- 4:34sort of dismantling them in my head when I play them. Is it the
- 4:38same as an artist. Are you looking at the art on the cards of
- 4:41the box and thinking, God, this charlatan managed to get a contract?
- 4:46No, I'm not thinking about it, certainly, not in relation to the
- 4:49artists themselves. But sure. I mean, I'm looking at art and I'm
- 4:54thinking, you know, uh yeah, I wouldn't mind seeing something different.
- 5:02Sometimes I I I will say, I'm I'm not, I'm not. I'll
- 5:09probably appear picky to to some people when it comes to like what games.
- 5:13But but I have to enjoy the art. I do have to like the
- 5:15arc. But that doesn't that doesn't mean it has to be you know,
- 5:20it could be really grat like I mean, I love Wavelength, Like that
- 5:25is a beautiful game to play. I mean, it's a it's a fun
- 5:28game to play as a group, and it looks beautiful, like I really
- 5:30have love having that on my shelf, and so I like and it's pure
- 5:35graphic design and it's and it's wonderful. I love spots. I love you
- 5:42know, it doesn't matter what it is, but I it will be very
- 5:45hard for me if it's a if it's of a pretty poor quality. So
- 5:49so I'm not often putting myself in a position where I'm playing a game that
- 5:56I think, oh, this is just terrific to look at that often good
- 6:00or bad, you know that that that sometimes will just mean I don't play
- 6:03that game that much. So So let's go back to the beginning then,
- 6:08So, so where were you raised and to what extent do you think that
- 6:12has affected the person you are today. I'm sure it must affect me a
- 6:16ton. I grew up in southern California in the States. I I wasn't.
- 6:28I came from a you know, middle class family and my my nobody
- 6:38in my family did art. It was it was just me. I have
- 6:41very supportive parents that were that really encouraged me to move forward with this.
- 6:46Now that I'm a parent myself and I have kids that are interested in doing
- 6:49art or music, and I go, oh, my goodness, how did
- 6:55my parents do it? Because I keep thinking to tell my kids, get
- 6:59get a real job, actually had some money. Yeah, yeah, but
- 7:02no, I mean very supportive. So I mean I I was studying art
- 7:05in school for a very early age. I knew I wanted to be an
- 7:10artist from the very very beginning. Uh what what? What form that took?
- 7:15Varied? Early on. I think I wanted to be an animator,
- 7:18and I was certainly influenced by future animation. Uh, you know, Disney
- 7:25movies and and lots of different lots of different films, and so that was
- 7:30the direction I took. But anyway, so I I had a very pleasant,
- 7:35normal childhood, went to school, had plans to you know, to
- 7:42go to college, and eventually did that. And so it's not been I
- 7:49mean, everybody's got their own personal things, but but you overcome those and
- 7:55hopefully and you and you move forward. And so the plan for for the
- 7:58direction that I took really went in one straight direction for the most part.
- 8:03Within the art choices that that varied, and it took lots of different detours,
- 8:07but but you know, to to most people, it would seem like
- 8:11a pretty straight shot. And so it was. It was nice. And
- 8:15so were you always say you were interested in art? But were you always
- 8:20good at it? Were you just someone who was naturally able to translate the
- 8:26world you saw around you to the page? Uh, well, that's a
- 8:33that's a hard question. I I was considered good by the people around me,
- 8:39so in comparison to other people who didn't care about art, you know,
- 8:43in third grade, I seemed like, you know, an art genius
- 8:48when in reality, you know, in you know, universal terms, you
- 8:54know, I was horrible and I was horrible, or I mean I was
- 8:56I was, you know, not good for a very very long time,
- 9:00but I was, I was better than most of my peers, and so
- 9:03that so, yes, that I I was people knowed that was the only
- 9:13thing I wanted to do and the only thing I was good at. So
- 9:16so it did turn out to be that people recognize that, and so I
- 9:22it was. I was very much encouraged because of that through throughout you know,
- 9:28elementary and high school and moving on. It really wasn't until college that
- 9:33I was like, oh, this is really how bad I actually am compared
- 9:37to everybody else. And I had a real, you know moment where it
- 9:41was like, well lots of moments where it was like should I even be
- 9:45doing this? Because it really doesn't matter if you know, if I'm you
- 9:50know, compared to you know, just the rest of the kids in my
- 9:54class, you know, that's not a really high bar. But if I
- 9:58wanted to get a job in the industry, you know, in some professional
- 10:01industry, then I've got to be really, really good. So yeah,
- 10:05I mean, my interest in skills and art were appreciated at an earlier age,
- 10:13and that fueled me to want to keep on doing it, and I
- 10:16of course loved it, but it definitely required me to really ramp up my
- 10:20skills very quickly when it really became important. And so I'm an actor and
- 10:26I've been on the stage since I was sort of four years old. And
- 10:30when I meet someone who has a problem with public speaking, I sort of
- 10:35intellectually understand that they may have an issue, but sort of I can't sort
- 10:43of embody understanding that they would have an issue with getting up on a stage
- 10:48with their notes in front of them, with slides and giving a presentation.
- 10:52I am probably the worst drawer who's ever lived. Do you find it difficult
- 11:01to sort of see the world through the perspective of someone who absolutely can'ttrol?
- 11:09Do I have a hard time seeing that? Yeah, I'm sure, I
- 11:13mean I I mean I've heard I have heard countless people make that same claim
- 11:20to me. Ah, I don't know, I don't. I mean,
- 11:26I'm not sure if I if I if this answers the question very well,
- 11:30or is what you're looking for? But I I it's only a part of
- 11:35me. So it's you know, I'm surrounded by non artists constantly. I
- 11:39mean, that's that's all I interact with are non artists besides my professional connections
- 11:46and friends that I that I interact with and collaborate with, you know,
- 11:50on a project or something like that, like or other artists in this industry.
- 11:54You know, we're all good friends and we'll chat. But beyond that,
- 12:00like, my wife's not an artist. My my kids have some interest
- 12:03in that. My parents were not. All of my closest friends are not.
- 12:05So so I've had to for a very long time, you know,
- 12:09just go I'm kind of different and and the most important things are in life
- 12:15are not my art for me, And so I can relate to everybody else
- 12:20because we might have other just human being things in common. And so I'm
- 12:28used to being quite separate and different. So I don't know. I don't.
- 12:35I don't. I mean, I I'm not. I'm not sure if
- 12:37I'm if I think about it that much, if that makes sense. Like
- 12:41when people say they can't draw, I mean I I go, well,
- 12:46okay, I mean I think people can learn that, and so I I
- 12:50when I hear that, I go, well, we could we could fix
- 12:54that. If so, is that not a part of you that thinks,
- 12:58well, come on, it's it's it's it's actually quite easy. You just
- 13:01have to do X, Y and Z, and you can do something or
- 13:03do you understand that it could be difficult for others? No, no,
- 13:09no, I definitely can understand that. I no, No, it's I
- 13:15mean, I can understand what you're talking about there, Like it's yeah,
- 13:20it's there are things that you can learn, and then there's and there's some
- 13:24things that you I don't know if it translates exactly to acting, but there's
- 13:31obviously plenty of things that you can learn, and then there's some things that
- 13:35you could learn, but it would require you to have also not only the
- 13:39the talent, but the interest and the time and the ambition to make it
- 13:43actually happen. So I truly believe that that, or at least I've seen.
- 13:48There are plenty of artists that you know, didn't have the same background
- 13:52as me and started, you know, at a really late age and then
- 13:54decided to become an artist. They were great, and they had to learn
- 13:58those things. But most of it comes down to, you know, some
- 14:03sort of passion and some sort of drive that makes that you want to go
- 14:11through all the hard work that it requires. So yeah, I mean I
- 14:16totally get it. It's very very hard. It is a hard thing.
- 14:24But no, I mean it's I guess it's enough a part of me that
- 14:26I just go, Okay, you know, I'm I'm again, I'm different,
- 14:31and I see things this way, and I do think I see maybe
- 14:35things in that, you know, from I'm looking at things and seeing colors,
- 14:41and I'm seeing contrast and I'm seeing saturation, and these are things that
- 14:46normal people aren't thinking about. But I'm sure that that's the same thing in
- 14:52other creative professions, but just different elements of that. And so when did
- 14:58games into your life, and as an extension of that, when did you
- 15:03think the board games might be a good avenue for your art. Board games
- 15:09were always board games were a part of my life as a player, all
- 15:13of my life. I think I certainly didn't know about modern board game until
- 15:18later and as an adult. But I was making games when I was a
- 15:24kid, so so I was thinking about games all the time and playing lots
- 15:31and lots of games. It was just limited to the boarding games that you
- 15:33know, the people who don't know about our modern, modern supply of games,
- 15:41you know, are limited to now. You know. It was like,
- 15:43all right, I'm going to make a different version of Chests. I'm
- 15:45going to make a different version of battleship or Monopoly or something like that.
- 15:50So anyway, I was, I was. I loved board games and we
- 15:54played as a family plenty of board games, but there was a big disconnect
- 15:58between that and professional thing for a very very long time. I mean,
- 16:03it really wasn't until oh close to when Everdell happened that I thought, Okay,
- 16:12here's here's where this could actually be a professional choice. I've I was
- 16:19making. I was working on a game of my own, Planecrafters. I
- 16:23was working on Planecrafters for four but by the time Everdell came out, I
- 16:29had been working on Planecrafters for about five years. So I was like making
- 16:33games and going to gen Con and still not thinking about it as an art
- 16:37career. I was just thinking about it as as a game designer while I
- 16:41was working in concept art for video games. So it really it wasn't on
- 16:47my radar at all until just that the the you know, I had the
- 16:52opportunity come and then I just go, okay, is this a better opportunity
- 16:55right in this moment than this? And then and then because Everdell did so
- 17:00well, then demand came, you know, more interest in me to do
- 17:04board games made that than a viable thing at the time. I mean,
- 17:07that wasn't the first game. So when I worked on Mission Red Planet and
- 17:11Citadel's those were kind of isolated projects that were fun to work on, but
- 17:15they were just like, Okay, I'm going to work on this and then
- 17:17go back to concept art. It wasn't until like Everdell that it became oh,
- 17:21maybe I could do this all the time, which has been since then.
- 17:26So so your first game then is Scythe And this is a game.
- 17:32This is a game that sold its initial print run essentially on one image that
- 17:37Jamie uploaded to the internet. I mean, how much does the art enhance
- 17:41this game? This game is huge for me. I mean I play in
- 17:47my gaming group. I know there's plenty of gamers in there that don't necessarily
- 17:52care that much, which is hard to for me. Maybe that is the
- 17:55disconnect. I can't understand anybody that wouldn't just go, oh my goodness,
- 17:57look at this. I mean, we have a pattern. It wasn't established
- 18:03by me. It was established in this game group by one of the people
- 18:06who actually really does love art and loves the art for Sythe. Uh,
- 18:08you know, we had this pattern of when you do an encounter, you
- 18:12you pass around the card and let everybody see the art work. Then you
- 18:15read the choices that you might make on that card. So so even in
- 18:22playing the game, the art is important to me. But for sure,
- 18:26like the art in its capacity to the world build and and you know,
- 18:32help you feel like you're immersed in the experience. Like that's huge for me.
- 18:37That I think scythe in my five games, that's the one that probably,
- 18:41yeah, it's really the one that does that. The others, I
- 18:45don't think any of them, you know that they're they're important to me for
- 18:51art for different reasons, but that one is like I want to get in
- 18:53the world and I want to be there, and so people a lot of
- 19:00people in my game group have an issue as side. And one of the
- 19:03issues they say, is there a disconnect between what the art promises and what
- 19:07the gameplay delivers. Do you think this is true? I don't think so.
- 19:12I mean, I mean, I'm not I'm not an expert or a
- 19:18very good critic of games. I'm very easily impressed by by game design in
- 19:23general and what people come up with, But I don't I don't know if
- 19:26I've ever thought that when I play it, I feel like I'm I'm I'm
- 19:34on a map, I'm in a world. The characters enhance it for me.
- 19:38I feel like I'm this. I mean, I mean, I'm exaggerating
- 19:41a little bit. I'm I'm playing a game. I know that, but
- 19:45you know, for a second, I'm like, all right, I'm I
- 19:48can't even remember everybody's names, but you know, I'm playing rus Fietz.
- 19:53So I got my pet bear with me, and we're you know, we're
- 19:57out here in this location, on this map, and we're doing these things.
- 20:02And then I go to this encounter and this thing happens, and this
- 20:04art shows me. I mean, so for me, it's perfect. I
- 20:10think it's a perfect I mean, I'm sure it could be better, I
- 20:14guess, and hypothetical terms, but I personally don't have a disconnect. There
- 20:18isn't a disconnect for me. It's kind of the example that I the standard
- 20:22that I've kind of are the bar I've put up to go if I want
- 20:29to create a world, you know, art but world building heavy game,
- 20:33you know, game experience, sythe is the one for me. But I'm
- 20:41perhaps not the best expert on the the game design don't know what you would
- 20:47do differently with the game designed to say, get this, have this art
- 20:51be more part of it. I'm not sure. So I want to talk
- 20:53now more about the sort of artists behind the art. So you remember the
- 20:57LDS Church. How important is that in your life? Gosh, it's impossible
- 21:03for me to separate it. It's very important to me. My faith is
- 21:10super important to me. Like I mentioned before, like my art is I
- 21:14mean the art, my art is very very much a part of me.
- 21:18No, no disparaging any I hope this doesn't sound I assume and as an
- 21:25as an actor, as a performer, I would assume it is very similar.
- 21:29There are probably lots of professions in the world where you go, I
- 21:32just go and I do this thing and then I come home and that's it.
- 21:36Art isn't that way for me. I assume acting is the same.
- 21:40You know that creative part of me is is a big part of it,
- 21:42but it is still just a part of me. When I come home,
- 21:47I've got to be a I'm a dad, I'm a husband, I'm h
- 21:53a a Christian. I may I may trying to be just a good citizen
- 22:00of my community, and so my faith is defined like all of that,
- 22:06like the choices that I make, and and I truly believe that you know,
- 22:11actions and thoughts and words and and faith as a whole impact some of
- 22:21the things that happened in our lives directly. So the choices that I make
- 22:26with my time are are absolutely not independent from my faith, So I can't
- 22:37I can't imagine separating them for me. Obviously it would be different for other
- 22:41people. But you know, I can point to specifically, you know,
- 22:45just choices, choices I have made even my profession that were perhaps slightly more
- 22:51faith based than they were career based. You know, my career would be
- 22:56very different if my faith was not involved. So yeah, very very important.
- 23:03And you've created religious art. I was doing some doing some research today
- 23:07and I saw some of your your religious paintings. Do you approach them in
- 23:11a different way than you approach your commercial work? Yes, to a degree.
- 23:21I have an interest in creating spiritual art, you know, religious based,
- 23:26faith based art for myself and I it's those situations when it's more when
- 23:32it's going to be probably a little bit even more so different when I'm Most
- 23:37of the religious art that I've done has been commissions from my church. So
- 23:41I've done work in church magazines and other publications and other uses for my church,
- 23:49and when those are those are still jobs. So I for sure,
- 23:55for certain, I'm approaching it slightly different. There's there's there's deeper things involved
- 24:03when I think of you know, if I'm thinking about portraying Christ, you
- 24:08know, I'm I'm going to approach it with a much more reverence than I
- 24:12am going to approach the barge toad of Everdell. So so yes, there's
- 24:18there's there's there's a difference, for sure, But when it's still a job,
- 24:23it's still like, you know, there's no avoiding. Okay, I've
- 24:26got a deadline, I've got a budget, I've got other projects, I've
- 24:30got a balance. So I wish it was as nice to be able to
- 24:33just go all right, I'm just gonna put all my heart and soul into
- 24:37this one piece. I do that more when it's for me and just for
- 24:42a personal thing, and I unfortunately I don't have as many opportunities as I
- 24:47would like to to do that. I really actually would love to do more
- 24:52faith based art in the future just for me, and I would probably approach
- 24:56that very very differently at that point, it would be much more. You
- 25:00know, I could take the time I needed and things like that. But
- 25:06but still it's an honor to be able to to do art work for an
- 25:11organization that I love and respect and that you know, the purpose for it
- 25:18being to bring people closer to God. That that means something that means a
- 25:22lot to me, and so and it's and it's it's wonderful to hear from
- 25:27people who are fans of Everdell and who are excited about the things that happened
- 25:30there. I hear that more than I hear from people, you know,
- 25:37who are impacted by my religious art, just because there's there's more people that
- 25:41I'm you know that's directed to it. But when someone comes to me and
- 25:47says, you know, or emails me and just says, oh, thank
- 25:48you for this piece that you painted, you know, telling this story from
- 25:53the scriptures that really really touched me, like that means a lot to me
- 25:56because that's you know, that might actually have some impact on somebody's life.
- 26:02And and I don't know, there's not much I hope. I hope my
- 26:06professional things could do that sort of stuff. I hope my personal projects can
- 26:10do that, but you know it's it's just not the same. So the
- 26:15impact you know it has on me when I when I hear it, what
- 26:18what influence has had on other people? That that probably means significantly more.
- 26:23And so you're a commercial artist. And when we when we think of an
- 26:27artist, we think of you know, Parisian Garretts, not having any food
- 26:33and and a pure expression of ones inner life. When you come to do
- 26:38commercial art, is there any room to express your own desires, views,
- 26:44and principles. I'm sure there is. I'm sure I do. Perhaps it's
- 26:52just expressed mostly in the style of my work. I think, you know,
- 27:02the work that the projects I take on are perhaps in themselves an expression
- 27:07of my own self. I mean, I'm while I have done a wide,
- 27:11wide variety of art and work for wide variety of clients, including horror
- 27:15film concept ard and illustrations for horror and other things like I'm a I'm a
- 27:21very light person, and so I'm drawn to and at this point mostly only
- 27:27take on projects that are positive, hopeful, good, you know, wholesome
- 27:32type of things. So that itself is that. But when it comes to
- 27:34the creating individual pieces, you know less so and and I think that that's
- 27:41probably what what is a part of what defines a commercial artist as opposed to
- 27:47a fine artist. You know, there are insanely talented and successful fine artists,
- 27:56but but that you know, the the the more typical story is of
- 28:00a fine artist is you know, I'm making something that is just about me,
- 28:03and it's my passion, and it's it's I'm putting everything into this piece,
- 28:07and and that's a and that's a perfectly fine direction to go with one's
- 28:12art. I actually really love, uh creating, helping people create their you
- 28:19know, getting their vision materialized. And as a as a commercial artist,
- 28:26that's that's my job. My job is to catch the vision of what somebody
- 28:29else needs and make it for them. And I love that that part of
- 28:34art. So yeah, it's an interesting thing that there's a big you know,
- 28:40within the art community. For sure, there's a big distinction between commercial
- 28:44art and fine art. And usually the fine artists are uh you know,
- 28:49well there's there's you know, there's maybe a little rivalry uh in there perhaps,
- 28:53and and sometimes commercial artists are put a little lower than the fine artists.
- 28:59But I think commercial artist just just doing that, you know, helping
- 29:03other people visualize their hopes, their visions, all that sort of stuff that
- 29:10to me is a noble goal. So I love being a commercial artist,
- 29:14and so I'm not looking to put too much of my own thing and you
- 29:18know, my own self into it necessarily, other than you know, if
- 29:22somebody said, you know, I want you to to paint this dark and
- 29:26horrible and pessimistic, you know thing, you know, that might actually come
- 29:32to a point where I go, I'm just not the right artist for this.
- 29:37And you've sort of touched on this as we've been talking, but and
- 29:40you sort of asked me about acting and acting is a dreadful profession because you
- 29:45spend most of your time not working. And I think I think part of
- 29:48the pain of not working as an actor is because you have this this need
- 29:52inside you to do this thing, and when you're not doing it, it's
- 29:57it can be incredibly painful. And I think it's because what you said that
- 30:03you think of yourself in terms of this artistic pursuit you've chosen to pursue.
- 30:11And so how satisfying is it to be able to fund your life and provide
- 30:22for your family through something that is that is integral to who you are as
- 30:26a person. Uh yeah, I mean it's hugely satisfying. I mean,
- 30:34gosh, that's a really great question. Uh yeah. It's a funny thing
- 30:44because I interact with like I said, I interact with non artists all the
- 30:47time. I'm good friends with lots of doctors and dentists and uh, you
- 30:57know, lots of lots of white collar, lots of blue collar, you
- 31:02know, people who just know lots of stuff. And so many times I'm
- 31:06I'm like, oh man, i am. I'm just sometimes I put myself
- 31:11down maybe a little bit because I'm you know, I can't fix a car
- 31:15very good or I can't you know, do these sort of things. And
- 31:18some of these other people can do these things. But when I come back
- 31:22to all the time like what I'm doing, like and when I interact with
- 31:26with other people, most people don't really know. Most of my close friends
- 31:33it sounds funny, but don't totally don't really understand what it is I do.
- 31:36But but when people do find out, and the people who really have
- 31:41an interest in this sort of thing and understand exactly what I'm doing, it's
- 31:45just like it puts them in awe that that that someone gets to do this
- 31:48thing. You know, there's lots, you know, wonderful profession. There's
- 31:53lots of dentists, there's lots of doctors. You know, we're not surprised
- 31:57by that. But you get to paint, I mean not just board games,
- 32:01but you get to well paint, you know, religious art, you
- 32:05get to you get to paint the things that are important to you, or
- 32:07you get to be creative and tell stories. Uh and you and you get
- 32:13paid to do that. That's I mean, so I always come back to
- 32:16that. It's just such a it's a it's an interesting question because I'm because
- 32:21I'm surrounded by non artists all the time. I sometimes just think of this
- 32:27as another job, Like it's just the thing I'm doing so I can pay
- 32:30the bills, and that's it. I mean, I really don't spend much
- 32:32time in that mindset. I'm my my my ideas and my thoughts are too
- 32:38grandiose for you know, to stay there very long. But but everything does
- 32:45become work eventually, right Well, yeah, I mean, I mean I'm
- 32:49working on a personal project right now that I'm really really excited about, and
- 32:52I've got a lot of the mundane things that I got to take care of
- 32:54where I wish I was just painting more so, even the most personal things,
- 33:00you know, sometimes come down to that. But you know there's still
- 33:04room for those to be very special. So but no, it's it's a
- 33:13I back to the original question and you know, going you know, in
- 33:16relation to your experience, Like yeah, I mean, this is what an
- 33:21incredible blessing it is to be able to spend my time doing this. I
- 33:27know, I know that I'm extremely fortunate to be able to to be doing
- 33:31this all the all the time. Like you know, I mean there were
- 33:36times in my early career where I was like, Okay, I don't have
- 33:37any work, I'm going to go light carpet, you know with my my
- 33:42carpet guy. Or I got to go do some landscaping, you know,
- 33:45help this guy who's running has a landscaping business. Or I mean all of
- 33:47these things I've done and lots of others, you know, when the when
- 33:51the work wasn't there, and that's typical for all of all artists. But
- 33:57to be in the position now where I don't have to do that is amazing.
- 34:05So your next game then is spots. And this has an art style
- 34:08that's that's pretty different from yours. But what does the art bring to this
- 34:14game? Oh, I mean it's a ton it's it's it's not immersive,
- 34:20like I'm not thinking I want to spend time in this dog world. It's
- 34:23a different thing than syth for sure. I don't know. This is probably
- 34:30you know, art in its simplest most I don't know, simplest form.
- 34:37It's just charming. It's just it's just I'm focusing on the game. I'm
- 34:43playing the game and having a fun time, and it's cute, you know,
- 34:45just the whole time. I mean, my kids when we play this
- 34:49is. This is certainly for the whole family. This is the first one
- 34:53that comes out. I mean, this is, this is This is the
- 34:57one that we all play a lot. And my kids are still have their
- 35:01favorite dogs, like where is Burt? Bert is definitely like one son's favorite
- 35:07one. See Bert. You'll know why. But you know he's like where's
- 35:13Burt? I want he will change his gameplay to be Burt, you know,
- 35:16to get Bert into his you know space. But it's just so cute.
- 35:22I don't know, it's very simple. It's not it doesn't it's not
- 35:24lofty in any way. It's just a beautiful game, a beautifully simple game,
- 35:30and the art does a lot for that. So you struck me as
- 35:35a serious person. I might even say an adult. I'm not, and
- 35:39so I have I have conversations that are distinctly not not adults. And I
- 35:45was having this conversation the other day, and I was I was confused as
- 35:51to why it's cats that have taken over the board game world. You have
- 35:55a plethora of cat games, and dogs just don't have the same hold on
- 36:02board games as dogs do. Would you have any insight as to what that
- 36:07as to the reason that that is. I don't. Gosh, and I'm
- 36:14sounding too serious, I see, but I see, I don't. Actually
- 36:21I don't. I don't play a lot of dog or cat games. I
- 36:24would probably say in general, those I I might, this is gonna like
- 36:30every half the world is gonna hate me. But I might even avoid some
- 36:35of those games in but spots is not one of those things. So why
- 36:39one or the other? I don't know. I'm I am an equally dog
- 36:44cat person. Do when you say equally, do you mean you like them
- 36:49equally or you disregard them equally? No, I like them equally. I
- 36:53happen to only have a dog right now. You know, my dog is
- 36:57sleeping in my office right now, snoring and maybe loud enough to hear at
- 37:01some point here. But but I was, I grew up a cat person.
- 37:09I'm going to disclose something I have never ever disclosed in an interview before.
- 37:15I'm going to do this right now. I am such a I was
- 37:17such a cat person when I was younger. I had a subscription. I
- 37:22don't know if this is a publication that is available anywhere else but the United
- 37:24States, but I had a a subscription to Cat Fancy, the magazine.
- 37:30I think it's featured on The Simpsons Cat Fancy, so that's where I've heard
- 37:34it. Well, that that makes sense. I mean, it is a
- 37:37very influential publication and the very important in the world. But that's how much
- 37:43I liked cats at the time, and I still do. I mean,
- 37:45I've thought someday, sadly, when you know, when when our current samurai
- 37:52my dog here, when when he passes, I've thought, maybe we'll get
- 37:57a cat. I don't know, but but when it comes of games,
- 38:00I don't have an explanation for that. I wish I did, But and
- 38:05I don't even know what I would prefer to have as a game, because
- 38:12I will say, for me, like I love our dog, and we
- 38:15are, but we're not like hardcore like pet people. So it's not like
- 38:22I want to live the life of pet ownership when I play a board game.
- 38:28That's probably not the fantasy that I jump into when I play board games,
- 38:32like it is I want to pretend like I'm driving mechs across Europa like
- 38:37I do with psythe So I'm not a good person for that one, unfortunately.
- 38:44So I want to talk now about your board game work. So what
- 38:45are the specific challenges of working in the board game space challenges who Most of
- 39:00the time I find it to be actually be a relief from from other type
- 39:05of illustration work that I've done in the past and other other industries, So
- 39:08it's not there's not a lot of challenges. But I will say perhaps the
- 39:15thing that's unique to to board games is where it kind of overlaps with design.
- 39:21I'm in the process right now of working on uh you know, I
- 39:28think we might talk about it later, but there there are board games in
- 39:32a in a world that I'm creating, that are being made, and I'm
- 39:37having conversations today and have for the last couple of days about where that art
- 39:42and the design you know, kind of go together, and that that that
- 39:45comes up in almost every board game project I work on. Whether I'm you
- 39:50know, I'm the the creator of the I P or not, it's it's
- 39:54where does that where does the art? You know, is the art going
- 40:04to take away from the game design, from the experience of playing the game?
- 40:08Uh, and being aware of that to make sure that I'm not overstepping
- 40:15my you know, where I need to be and I'm instead always just supporting
- 40:22the game design as opposed to trying to overwhelm it with art. But again,
- 40:29it's not a it's not a challenge that comes up a lot. Most
- 40:32of the time, the process of creating art four games is quite simple.
- 40:38While there's a space that needs to be filled and you need to put some
- 40:40pretty pictures in there. But I think having some knowledge about game design,
- 40:46having you know, experience working on layout and creating games that has helped inform
- 40:53and resolve those challenges a lot. Perhaps that would be less easy if I
- 41:00didn't have any of that experience working with games or frankly playing games. So
- 41:07that's probably the biggest thing is is just that balance of making sure my art
- 41:15is supporting the game design itself so on that It's interesting because if you were
- 41:21to look at you and Ian O'Toole, very successful board game artists and avid
- 41:25gamers, and then you were to look at the Meat Show and Jackie Davis,
- 41:32successful board game artists who don't really play games, what does being a
- 41:37gamer bring to you as a board game illustrator. I don't know. I
- 41:45knew that, I knew that the meta was not and I consumer myself good
- 41:52friends with both Jackie and Mitcha, but I didn't know. I didn't know
- 41:58that Jackie was not much of a gamer. But so I don't know in
- 42:01their situation. But I would say for myself, like I'm able to help
- 42:07in areas that are beyond just making a pretty picture for a simple space.
- 42:15One of the things that I like to offer to my clients. Some take
- 42:21it, some don't, but it certainly gets involved. You know, at
- 42:24some point in the process of making the game is just going what is this
- 42:28looking like as a whole? I mean, I just was working on a
- 42:30board for a client. I'm right in the middle of it right now,
- 42:35and they gave me this prototype and they say, okay, we need to
- 42:37have this thing work. And I'm looking at this and going, fine,
- 42:42that the prototype is fine, you know, as far as gameplay wise,
- 42:45but I have no room to do any of the ambitious things that they want
- 42:49to convey in this board like they wanted. They want so many things to
- 42:52happen in this board. I have absolutely no room to do this the way
- 42:55that you guys have laid out this prototype. If I just that prototype down
- 43:00on this file and then paint around it, it won't work. So I
- 43:06was able to come back and propose some things, and I'll go, hey,
- 43:07you know this space. Do we actually need this space? Or can
- 43:10we consolidate these two things because we don't actually need to put a token there
- 43:15at this point, you know, any point in the game, so we
- 43:17don't actually know these spaces need to have this much available because we're going to
- 43:22have possibly three cubes on there at one time. So okay, that's how
- 43:27much space we need. How can I reduce some of these things so that
- 43:30I can give you the best, most thematic, interesting artwork and still not
- 43:36detract or make the game play difficult. And we were able to come up
- 43:40with a solution that worked just find and it gave me maybe twenty five percent
- 43:45more space on the board to just create cool art. And I don't know
- 43:52if I would have been able, I certainly wouldn't have been able to offer
- 43:55that or be able to help in some of those bigger picture things. So
- 44:00if I didn't have an understanding of what, you know, how the game
- 44:04works and can translate that. But maybe that's not a I don't know.
- 44:08I don't know if that's a particularly unique skill. Maybe maybe that's an just
- 44:14maybe lots more people have that and it doesn't require being an avid gamer to
- 44:19do it. But I personally feel like it certainly has been helpful for sure.
- 44:28Granny Ortensia, owner of the lands of an eccentric farmer's family, dies
- 44:32one day without leaving a will. One night, the moon turns reddish,
- 44:37and the grandmother reappears as a ghost to put her four grandchildren to the test.
- 44:43She will visit them three times, always coinciding with the red moon.
- 44:46After her three appearances, whoever has become the most experienced farmer will inherit all
- 44:52of her land. Familiar Halt is a charming card game from Grand Gamers Guilds
- 44:59with snappy and delightful Tim burton Es guards from Esta Mendez. Farming has never
- 45:04been this fun. Can you master the soil and gain the reward? Find
- 45:08out at Grand gamers Guild dot com. And I assume when you go through
- 45:22formal art education there's not much. There's not much on illustrating board games,
- 45:30and so what was the learning curve for you? Like, because when people
- 45:34think of board game art, they think of, you know, the covers
- 45:37of the games. They think of the boards, but you have to illustrate
- 45:42tokens and different things like this. How was the learning curve to get to
- 45:46get good of the illustrating games? I mean, when you're putting all those
- 45:52components into play, it probably it probably took some time. It's not always
- 46:00the situation where I am working on those things, so sometimes it really is
- 46:05purely just about creating a piece of artwork. Everdell was that case. I
- 46:09mean, I mean, with some exceptions, I certainly designed the board and
- 46:14I did other things. But so when I was working on projects, early
- 46:19on board game project, when I was first starting, it really was just
- 46:22filled this space with some art. I think it was Again it's hard for
- 46:30me to separate. I was designing games before I was illustrating games for professionally,
- 46:36illustrating board games professionally. I was designing and illustrating my own game and
- 46:44taking all of those things into consideration before I was doing it professionally for anybody
- 46:46else, So I don't, Yeah, there was certainly a learning curve,
- 46:52but it was happening before I was doing it for other people. I was
- 46:55doing it for myself, So yeah, yeah, it's there that there's lots
- 47:01of things to consider. There's you know, iconography and making sure things are
- 47:07readable, making sure that things are you know, can be seen from across
- 47:12a table, making sure you'ress addressing color blindness and other accessibility needs and things
- 47:22like that. But I think in the end it was you know, a
- 47:28lot of it still comes down to either just basic art principles or basic you
- 47:32know, basic illustration principles or basic graphic design principles, which I also studied
- 47:38in school. And so there's there's only a little bit where it just kind
- 47:45of strays out of those general things and goes specific. You know, Okay,
- 47:49what are the specific things I need to consider because it's a board game.
- 47:52I think overall, it still just comes down to you know, ninety
- 47:59you know, or I say I used a hundred. I use one hundred
- 48:01percent of my training in art school, you know, ninety percent of the
- 48:07time on anything I'm working on in board games. But sometimes those things pop
- 48:13in that are particularly unique. So it wasn't a huge learning curve in this
- 48:19case. And I'm always amazed. I mean, I've started to make some
- 48:23money at this game, and to do that, I've had to get over
- 48:28the fact that me and technology hate each other and learn how to use video
- 48:30editing software and learn how to use audio editing software. And it seems to
- 48:35me with artists that you have to not only be great artists, but experts
- 48:42at deploying software and dealing with computers. How much is that a part of
- 48:46your life as an artist? And can you be a paint and easel artist
- 48:51in the commercial space anymore? Sure you can. I mean Vincent to trade
- 48:58as a perfect example of someone who's doing it fantastically. I mean, he
- 49:00certainly uses some digital tools, you know, when he in order to take
- 49:05his traditional work and bring it to a client, that there's some digitalization that
- 49:08happens, and to whatever degree he adjusts some things in some of those tools.
- 49:15You know that's there, but sure you can do it. I think
- 49:20of those, I think of those, the software, the equipment, any
- 49:24of that sort of stuff is really just tools. And I was trained that
- 49:30to think that way. I could be wrong, but I in my mind
- 49:35they're just tools. So i might be working in Photoshop, or i might
- 49:43be working in Procreate on my iPad, but I'm still just drawing and painting.
- 49:49If I choose to, I can learn other things that might make things
- 49:52a little bit more convenient. For example, three D software is there are
- 49:58a lot of artists, particularly con zipped artists, but lots of artists even
- 50:00in our own industry, who are really great at three D, and I
- 50:04am not. Fortunately, I have learned to draw three you know, in
- 50:09three D, to to to get the the anyway, you can choose to
- 50:19use those tools or not, I don't think. I don't think there is
- 50:22any limitation, certainly in the board game industry that just goes. You have
- 50:25to know these digital tools in order to function in our industry, for sure,
- 50:30Absolutely no bar no, no no barrier to doing that. If I
- 50:36were in concept art, if I were still working full time in concept art
- 50:39and video games and and uh feature film and other things like that. Perhaps
- 50:45that would be more of a standard that people would go, why why are
- 50:47you not opening up Blender or z brush or you know, three D studio
- 50:54Max or something like that. Why why aren't you using those tools? You're
- 51:00slowing things down. I had to go. I mean, I did have
- 51:05to change so that I used these digital tools when I was in concept art,
- 51:08Like I was a traditional painter and drawer when I left school. I
- 51:15had some experience painting and photoshop and things like that. But there was a
- 51:19point where, like my employer or my supervisor within my team was like,
- 51:25okay, all of us here, we're all concept artists. It's time for
- 51:30us to drop pencils and paper and just go to photoshop. But that doesn't
- 51:36mean I don't have a sketchbook with me everywhere I go, and I'm drawing
- 51:38as much as I can. So I consider them tools. They're valuable,
- 51:45They're good, they can sometimes help us speed things up. They speed things
- 51:47up a lot. I wouldn't be able to do what I'm doing for me
- 51:52personally without using the digital tools that I do. But if i've even recently
- 51:59considered, you know, with AI and stuff coming into play, I've actually
- 52:04considered going back to traditional stuff, even for clients, to just say,
- 52:09you know what, this is one hundred percent mine and one hundred percent you
- 52:14know, original, created just by myself, and I have the canvas to
- 52:17show it. Vincent's been able to do that his entire career, and I
- 52:22envy him and he is an amazing artist just for the fact that he's doing
- 52:25it traditionally all the time. I could go back. That would be a
- 52:29learning curve for me, even though I was trained traditionally. It would be
- 52:32really hard to go back. But I've considered it because I also want to
- 52:37be able to hold those things in my hand. There's something really special about
- 52:40that. But bottom line, the digital tools are tools only if you don't
- 52:47know how to draw on paint, then then that's that's really the most important
- 52:52thing. I mean, I would say, you know, creating this podcast,
- 52:57I would probably say it's no, you know, it's probably equal,
- 53:00like, you need the tool in order to get this thing on the internets.
- 53:04I still need those tools to get my art on the internets. But
- 53:07I could I could do it without. If I just I could, I
- 53:10could still paint it on canvas or on a board, and that would still
- 53:15be just as much my art. I've just you know, there's just that
- 53:17step to get it out onto the digital world, because it needs to be
- 53:22printed and it needs to be shared online and all that sort of stuff.
- 53:27So your next game then is Glenn Moore Too. So how good a designer
- 53:30is matteos Krama? Do you think he's the This is the only game that
- 53:35I've played of his, and so he's a fantastic game designer in my opinion,
- 53:42I don't find myself comparing game designers that much, so I but no,
- 53:46I think this is a really unique design. I think it's a really
- 53:50clever and the whole the whole package of Glenn Moore Too, to me is
- 53:55just brilliant. So yeah, he's an amazing designer. And so this is
- 54:00a game I haven't played, to my shame. What does it do that's
- 54:02special? Well, gosh, I mean there's individual mechanics that I think are
- 54:12really really interesting. I like the would you call it a Rondell? There's
- 54:15there's a circular track following, and I mean there's a simpleness of of your
- 54:24turn that just comes down to what spot are you going to go to?
- 54:28I mean, it's it's almost as simple as you know, any track based
- 54:31game, you know, but of course it's it's not. But but I'm
- 54:35just going how far do I want to go? Ahead? Okay, and
- 54:37then I take that thing that I want. You know, you're choosing based
- 54:40on what tile you want to pick up and add to your tableau. And
- 54:46and so that's the that's the decision making that's going on. But it's not
- 54:51like it's not like I have several different action choices I could make on my
- 54:55turn. It's really just one and I choose that and then I put it
- 55:00into where I want to do and that that that itself is a really interesting
- 55:04uh low bar of entry to me to this game. That just that that
- 55:09makes you know, I'm married to a wonderful person who loves board games but
- 55:15does not like to learn new board games, right, and and so you
- 55:21know, to have a game that just like, oh right, here's the
- 55:23one thing you're going to do on your turn, Like that's that's a deal
- 55:29breaker, you know, for for some people. And that's one of the
- 55:30simple So one example is that the choices that you make on your turn,
- 55:36well there's plenty to think about, and sometimes a turn can take you a
- 55:38long time. It really is a pretty simple thing when you're just looking at
- 55:40it. But also, you know, some of the things that I love
- 55:45is I haven't played Glenmore one, so I don't know what it was like.
- 55:50But but Glenmore two packaged as this experience that has multiple chronicles or expansions,
- 55:57many expansions basically that you can add and and they're so easy to implement
- 56:02that it's like, at any moment, I could just choose to go,
- 56:06all right, I want to add this thing. And it's a different experience
- 56:08than the last game I played, but it's not hard. I don't need
- 56:12to, you know, wrap my brain around some hugely different mechanic in the
- 56:16game, like many expansions are. So here are eight possible expansions and they
- 56:22can even be combined. You know, it's so sorry you haven't played this.
- 56:29I'm I'm forgetting that. But but the box is, the packaging for
- 56:32this game is so great that the insert is amazing. Everything has a place.
- 56:37It's like I'm bringing when I bring Glenmore too, I feel like I'm
- 56:40bringing a game system almost and though it's not you know, it's just a
- 56:46It's just a really good board game with some variability that I can introduce if
- 56:51I want to. So it's I don't know, it's just a really cool,
- 56:57full complete package as far as a game experience for me if I'm if
- 57:01I'm in the mood for something that's a little bit more thinky than say,
- 57:05spots. So I when I was writing the notes side for this show,
- 57:12I went onto your blog and I was going to ask you about AI art,
- 57:16and then I stumbled across your essay called a very specific case against aiart,
- 57:21and it was a it was something it was something that I've spoken about
- 57:27to friends within the industry and saying, maybe this is an acceptable use of
- 57:30AI within the board game industry, and you you very very intelligently dismantle that
- 57:38idea. So, first of all, before we get into the meat of
- 57:43the essay, why did you feel the need to write it? Because it
- 57:50comes up so just to be clear on what that blog is about, there
- 57:54is Yes, I am very grateful that most in the industry, most publishers,
- 57:59most people are not in support of using AI art for final production art
- 58:05in a board game. That's a baseline. I'm so grateful that this industry
- 58:08is very much in favor of human made art, not ai R and when
- 58:13someone publishes stuff with AI art, they're like, Okay, that's wonderful.
- 58:19The the blog post is specifically about publishers who use AI art in their prototyping,
- 58:27and and in there perhaps designers who use them to also try to pitch
- 58:36their game to publishers. And so I make the case that that is not
- 58:40that is not needed, that is actually detrimental to the process. But I'm
- 58:46only like this. I bring this up because it has come up as an
- 58:51artist many many times, and I've spoken with all of my board game artist
- 58:55friends and they they're all have gone through the exact same thing, and we
- 59:00all hate it. And I think the premise behind the argument, I mean,
- 59:07the core of the whole argument is you are not going to use this
- 59:10in the long run. Good good on you for making that choice. Why
- 59:17are you introducing this when it's going to perhaps slow down the process? As
- 59:25surprising as they might seem, it might slow down the process, It will
- 59:29certainly annoy the person that you are hiring to actually make the final art work
- 59:34in the end, And it's actually undermining in many ways the artist who is
- 59:38going to make the art in the end, So why do that? Why
- 59:43why add this pain to the artist that is going to work on this.
- 59:49So let's not and here are some alternatives to doing that. And the alternatives
- 59:54are things that we have been doing for some time and there they've worked wonderfully.
- 1:00:00And in this case, AI does not make it any better, it
- 1:00:02makes it worse. So so that's that's the premise. It's come up enough
- 1:00:07times. I've I've worked with I work with only wonderful publishers, of course,
- 1:00:15but I have worked with publishers who are wonderful people who send me art
- 1:00:19that is made by aar and can you do it like this? And I
- 1:00:22go, and I usually throw it away, and then I go, what
- 1:00:28is it that you're actually wanting? Let me help you figure what that is.
- 1:00:30Let me let me help you come up with creative solutions for how to
- 1:00:34get what you are looking for? Can you just use words and tell me
- 1:00:37and I will use my artsy skills and we will come up with this solution
- 1:00:40together, as opposed to you, you know, clicking a button and seeing
- 1:00:46something that's really really pretty. Because AI art on the surface can look really
- 1:00:52really pretty. You showed that to an artist, and artists like I can't
- 1:00:57use this, this is, this won't work, this doesn't make any sense.
- 1:01:00This is and so let's reverse and go back and just tell me what
- 1:01:05you're looking for. That's kind of the premise for it. It's it's just
- 1:01:07come in to practice so many times. It's I've had too many experiences with
- 1:01:12it. And so I'm in this industry. I'm working with publishers on a
- 1:01:15regular basis, as opposed to being silent and just saying and just you know,
- 1:01:22deal with it. Well, sometimes dealing with things is just as right,
- 1:01:27is the right thing that you know, there's a better way to do
- 1:01:30this, And it seems like I'm in a position where I can at least
- 1:01:32say, hey, guys, this actually is not good. Let's let's do
- 1:01:36something different. And so what is the issue then, because I was I
- 1:01:42was literally speaking to someone about this this morning, saying, this could be
- 1:01:45a legitimate because people are bad at describing things, and this could be a
- 1:01:50legitimate sort of starting off point for the artists. And then I read your
- 1:01:57essay and thought, oh, it never really occurred to me, So what
- 1:02:00what is the issue with being presented with a with an AI sort of mock
- 1:02:06up of something for you, what what what is the problem? What is
- 1:02:09the quintessential problem with AI R. Well, there's a couple of different parts
- 1:02:16to it. If I'm being completely transparent and honest, there is there is
- 1:02:24a there's certainly an ego, not ego that's not right. There's a personal
- 1:02:32side to it, for sure. I mean it's uh, so, there's
- 1:02:37a couple of things, and I should have reread my blog posts so I
- 1:02:45can remember everything. But uh, for one, I mean, I see
- 1:02:52AAR constantly. I'm always doing research, I'm always gathering reference AI are generally
- 1:03:00it's so there's such a twisted, weird thing about AR. Sometimes it can
- 1:03:04come up with really innovative things, and then sometimes it comes up with the
- 1:03:08most boring, generic stuff. But the thing that's tricky about is that it
- 1:03:13looks so polished, it looks so amazing that many non artists, including the
- 1:03:19people who are commissioning us to do the work, they go, oh,
- 1:03:22my goodness, look how gorgeous this thing is. And so whatever that is,
- 1:03:29it's gorgeous, do that thing, Please make that thing happen. It's
- 1:03:34not actually creating anything new or interesting. Many times, if you just said,
- 1:03:40if there was no limitations whatsoever on a project, and you just said,
- 1:03:45make the coolest thing ever and we will make a game around that,
- 1:03:49then fine, AR might be an interesting way to do that. I mean
- 1:03:52if also, just side note, we haven't even talked about the ethical problems
- 1:03:57with AIR, and that's not something that can be disregarded and not be part
- 1:04:02of this discussion. But but going back to the thing, like if if
- 1:04:10if you wanted to just make a game that wrapped around whatever AI art,
- 1:04:14you know, whatever mid journey just plopped in front of you because you pressed
- 1:04:16a button, or maybe you wrote some text in there and you told it,
- 1:04:20what do you want? That's fine. But if you have specific challenges
- 1:04:26and things that you need to solve, AIR is not AI art is not
- 1:04:30good at doing those sort of things. And so when a publisher comes to
- 1:04:33me and says, do this thing, it's it's not actually many times solving
- 1:04:39it in a way that like, it's fine as just a piece of art.
- 1:04:43You know, it's just an isolated thing, but when you put it
- 1:04:45in the game and you've got all these other things to consider, it's not
- 1:04:47always the right thing. Not, that's one part of it. Oftentimes the
- 1:04:51art we all see, you know, oftentimes the art is just bad.
- 1:04:57It might have the veneer of a finish that looks I mean AIRI can pop
- 1:05:02out a rendering of a human, of a person, of a pretty face
- 1:05:08in two seconds, and there is a level of rendering in there that most
- 1:05:12artists cannot achieve at all without, you know, I mean, the smoothness,
- 1:05:19the blending, the polish that is put into that cheek might take an
- 1:05:26artist five hours just for that cheek. But it doesn't make the art itself
- 1:05:30good, and it doesn't make it actually a beautiful piece of art. And
- 1:05:35so there's that. But going back to kind of that you know, that
- 1:05:39pride or that thing, it's it's like, I don't know, It's like
- 1:05:45saying to a good chef, you know, you just microwaved a beauty a
- 1:05:47wonderful TV dinner, and you put in the microwave and you say, can't
- 1:05:53you just make chef, you know, or person, just make this thing?
- 1:05:57I can't you stick that fork in that TV, rip that plastic cover
- 1:06:02off of the top of that thing, stick your fork in and eat it.
- 1:06:05Isn't that amazing couldn't you make that thing for me? And it takes
- 1:06:09more work than that, and it takes more so to you. Ai r
- 1:06:13put presents these really unrealistic expectations on artists that they just can't meet. So
- 1:06:21unless we if we've decided we are going to forego artists as a whole,
- 1:06:27and we're fined with just taking what ai AR can give us than fine.
- 1:06:30But if we are we've decided that we don't want to do this, We're
- 1:06:34still going to hire an artist in the end, but you're going to put
- 1:06:39in front of them something that like the art their art director for a game
- 1:06:44is going to give you twenty pieces of art that took them five minutes to
- 1:06:46make, and say, why can't you work like this artist? It's it's
- 1:06:51completely demoralizing. It's uh, I mean, it's it's a kick in the
- 1:07:00like every time in my mind. And and I'm looking at and I'm going,
- 1:07:05ah, yes, gosh, there's a part of me that goes man.
- 1:07:09I wish I painted that polished. I wish I could make that cheek
- 1:07:12as good as that cheek is. I wish I could paint an ear as
- 1:07:15amazing that is. And I wish I could do it in two seconds,
- 1:07:17but I can't, so I'm blame. But it has a soul, right
- 1:07:24well that I mean, gosh, that's a whole other one. I mean,
- 1:07:26but imperfection is the soul of odd in any odd form. Right,
- 1:07:30Yes, I'm even Yeah, you're You're totally right. I mean, there's
- 1:07:34so many reasons. But I'm of course so biased, so it's hard sometimes
- 1:07:39for me to you know, to you know, I have to I sit
- 1:07:44back. I am capable of sitting back and going. I know I'm an
- 1:07:46artist and i know I'm biased, and i know this is my job that's
- 1:07:48being threatened. So of course I'm upset about this. But and so I
- 1:07:55try to look at it from a different perspective. But yeah, there are
- 1:07:57so many reasons why this isn't a good way to go, and yeah,
- 1:08:00one of one among many is yeah, it is soulless. I mean,
- 1:08:06I look at when I do research. I'm on Pinnarist a lot, just
- 1:08:11gathering reference and research for art that I'm going to make. I mean,
- 1:08:14every artist looks at reference and looks at gets inspiration from real world, looking
- 1:08:19from an other artists too, and looking at brilliant, beautiful things that have
- 1:08:24been made are beautiful examples of God's creations, you know, when we look
- 1:08:29and we get inspired by those things. I'm on Pinterist and it's almost like
- 1:08:34half of the stuff I see is AI art and it all looks exactly the
- 1:08:39same, and it is so it is it actually is where we're all.
- 1:08:43I think most people are familiar with this concept of the uncanny valley. Yeah,
- 1:08:47and we head into that direction so often. It's it's pretty, it's
- 1:08:53it's again that cheek is so perfectly rendered. But then I look at it
- 1:08:58and it's like, there's there's just a little bit of something that's weird.
- 1:09:01Not to mention when AI, you know, mid Journey or whatever, can't
- 1:09:05figure out how many fingers a human being actually has. You know that that's
- 1:09:11an obvious like, oh, that's scary. Why is his foot coming out
- 1:09:15of this chest? You know? But but besides all that, yeah,
- 1:09:18it's it feels lifeless in many times. But I don't use that as an
- 1:09:23argument that often, because I don't know, there might be some time when
- 1:09:27the technology is perfected, you know, even further, and and they're going
- 1:09:30to skip those things. It really comes down to me that are we are
- 1:09:36we a human society or not? And do we want like there's some things
- 1:09:41that again this is my bias showing maybe there are things that that are more
- 1:09:47appropriate for AI to be to replace. Would it be great if you know,
- 1:09:54docs can be loaded or blah blah blah. You know, all these
- 1:09:57things could be done with AI, so we can save our time to do
- 1:10:00creative and amazing things. But then if we replace the creative things with a
- 1:10:05R two, what is it that we're saving our time for? What does
- 1:10:09it were? You know? What is? What's what's this all been about?
- 1:10:13You know? And I don't. It just seems at the core of
- 1:10:16it, all of it just seems a little icky weird to me. So
- 1:10:21it's icky weird. Yeah, well, what really The aspect of your essay
- 1:10:27that really hit home and made me think that you you you probably have a
- 1:10:30point. Is this aspect of if someone comes to you, if if a
- 1:10:38if a publisher comes to you and tells you what they want without having a
- 1:10:45without having an AI representation of it, and then you create something, there
- 1:10:49is potential there for the publisher to receive something that is completely out of their
- 1:10:59original conception and better than their original conception. Because collaboration has happened and something
- 1:11:06greater than the sum of its parts has occurred. And I guess with ai
- 1:11:10RT as a reference, it limits that potential for alchemy, right, Oh
- 1:11:17for sure. Yeah. I mean again, it's it's the problem solving that
- 1:11:20that comes into play. I mean, in my in my blog post,
- 1:11:24I post a process picture of of the board I created for Merchants of the
- 1:11:29Dark Road. A prototype came to me and and it's very bare, and
- 1:11:33it's very simple and through I remember that the moment that we were I was
- 1:11:40sitting down with Brent Dickman, the owner of Elf Creek Games, and and
- 1:11:46he's there, and Matt Piquett I think, was there. He's the graphic
- 1:11:50designer, and at least we had Brent and many people on his team,
- 1:11:57and we're sitting at a table at gen Con and we got he's got really
- 1:12:00literally like a napkin, you know, or you know, a sheet of
- 1:12:03paper that we're doodling on talking about what this board could look like and and
- 1:12:11the type of things that we came up with would I mean, I think
- 1:12:16we came up with something really really creative, really interesting. You know,
- 1:12:21it could be better, of course, but but we came up with ideas
- 1:12:30that would not have happened if he had just said, AI, make a
- 1:12:34board and these are the spaces, and this is where things need to go.
- 1:12:40Just make and there's a city here, make it. I don't think
- 1:12:44it would have come up with the creative solutions that we would have done.
- 1:12:46It might occasionally come up with some creative things on accident, of course,
- 1:12:50because that's that's really all it is. But but no, like the creative
- 1:12:57solutions that need to happen, those are the things that that AI is absolutely
- 1:13:00not good at doing at this point and certainly going beyond that proactively being creative.
- 1:13:10So yeah, but you know, it's it's an uphill battle with this
- 1:13:17argument unfortunately, where you know, there's when it comes to costs and time
- 1:13:25and all of those things. What I worry is, you know, publishers
- 1:13:30will will go They're not going to see this amazing thing that they could have
- 1:13:33had if they had collaborated with one, two, three other creative people and
- 1:13:41brainstormed it, talked and you know, did all of these fun and interesting
- 1:13:45things and collaborated. They won't see what they could have had. They just
- 1:13:48see what they got for free. You know, with the press of a
- 1:13:53button and go all right, that'll work. It looks certainly looks pretty.
- 1:13:58I can get an artist to move that that third eye and it's cheek and
- 1:14:02you know, get remove it. And man, that costs me, you
- 1:14:06know, fifty dollars and now I've got a game and or I've got to
- 1:14:09cover. You know. That's what I worry is is is people won't won't
- 1:14:14appreciate what that is, what what has been made throughout history and took so
- 1:14:19much energy to make and has moved people. That's that's sometimes really hard to
- 1:14:27to to recognize what it took to make those things and make the great things
- 1:14:33that we've made, the creative things we've made in the past, and people
- 1:14:36will just go, well, it was cheap and fast, so great,
- 1:14:41that'll work. And then they make a game and then and then that's one
- 1:14:45one less game that wasn't so great. And then eventually, I mean I'm
- 1:14:48being real, you know, projecting a whole you know, all over.
- 1:14:53But you know that one game does that and it does well, and then
- 1:14:58two or three games do it and they do well, and you know,
- 1:15:00maybe there's twenty that don't. But but we get something like, bless their
- 1:15:05hearts. I'm not ripping on this one company, but like we get a
- 1:15:09terraforming Marge. That's like perhaps the most don't hate me stronghold. I think
- 1:15:15it is, you know, one of the ugliest games when it comes to
- 1:15:19actual art that you know, it's not art, it's it's like I don't
- 1:15:23I don't literally know how they did it, but I don't think they I
- 1:15:25don't think it was AI. It was just Google search this and here is
- 1:15:30a Okay, I don't want number one on Google Search. I want the
- 1:15:35second image that'll work. Okay, put that in there. It's an amazing
- 1:15:40game, and they were able to do fine with just you know this really
- 1:15:45mediocre or poor art, and okay, well, if they could do it,
- 1:15:47then I can do it. And then eventually, you know, half
- 1:15:50the games in the industry are not made by artists at all, and it's
- 1:15:54made by clip art, and it's made by all right, clip art,
- 1:15:57it's made by other means that that, and then at that point, you
- 1:16:01know, it just becomes just as viable to use that stuff, and artists
- 1:16:05will then stop wanting to become artists because it's not just the board game industry
- 1:16:10it's the video game industry, it's it's magazine publication, it's all of these
- 1:16:15things. Then why would I go to art school anymore? Why would I
- 1:16:19Why would I encourage my child to become an artist? If if that's where
- 1:16:24everything's going, it's really doomsday. Hey fit for this, fit for the
- 1:16:29podcast. But I don't think that that's not really that far off. I
- 1:16:33mean, I mentor lots of kids wanting to go into art, and I
- 1:16:39have seriously, very recently kind of I've really pushed pulled back from actually encouraging
- 1:16:45people because it's I see it being very very hard for artists in the next
- 1:16:55generation and beyond. So your next game then is Resist. Are you a
- 1:17:00solo gamer? I'm actually not. I mean I'm not opposed to solo games.
- 1:17:04I actually have a game design in my head that I would love to
- 1:17:09make that is a solo game. In my mind, it's not developed very
- 1:17:13far at all. It's more thematically developed, But I love the concept of
- 1:17:17a good solo game, and Resist in my mind, for the things I
- 1:17:23like, for the for the the boxes it checks, it's currently the best
- 1:17:27game for me of presenting that type of experience in a solo game, so
- 1:17:33I really like it. But in general, no, I'm not a solo
- 1:17:38game player. I love playing with other people, and I rarely am in
- 1:17:42a situation where I can pull out a game and it's just me playing.
- 1:17:46So in the modern world in the West, we lead lives if you look
- 1:17:53at the rest of the sweep of human history, a sort of almost unfathomable
- 1:18:00luxury. Do you think art in general and games can help us to wrap
- 1:18:05our heads around the extremes of human experience? Ooh? Like, Like,
- 1:18:18so Resist is a wargame and things like that. Yeah, well, Resist
- 1:18:23is a war game, right, And being in a situation in which there
- 1:18:28are groups of people whose job it is to end your life is an extreme
- 1:18:33of human experience, right, And so do you think games can help us
- 1:18:39wrap our heads around these sorts of things? Well, sure, I guess,
- 1:18:46but perhaps maybe in the same way that like fantasy literature does. I
- 1:18:54haven't thought this all the way through it, but I've heard other people talk,
- 1:18:58you know, I've heard people talk about how, like the more fantastical
- 1:19:08stories sometimes are better ways for us to approach real challenges, real problems,
- 1:19:16but to put them in a place where we're a little bit separated from them
- 1:19:20a little bit in order for us to go Okay, I see how this
- 1:19:25should work out. I see how we should be doing this, How humanity
- 1:19:28would be the better choice for this thing as opposed to sometimes dealing with the
- 1:19:33thing that is you know, raw and hard to deal with, which is
- 1:19:40real history or real human experiences. So I think it can do that in
- 1:19:46that way, just like just like you know, I'm a big lord of
- 1:19:55the rings fan fan. You know, they example of war and sacrifice and
- 1:20:02and good versus evil, and and and gray areas too. I look,
- 1:20:08I look at those things. I look at those stories, and those help
- 1:20:12me to think about nobility and honor in a way that maybe is not so
- 1:20:17plain when I look at a real life hard things. It's a little bit
- 1:20:21more complicated. But I can I can put that as an aspiration. Maybe
- 1:20:26we can imply that in games more. But but that is pretty lofty.
- 1:20:33I mean, we have lots of games that that have plenty of conflict in
- 1:20:39it, and it's not necessarily encouraging us not to have conflict. I'm gonna
- 1:20:44get that cool card if I beat you in this thing, So watch out
- 1:20:48here, I come. I'm gonna you know I'm gonna get you. But
- 1:20:53but perhaps and it's uh in are you know there there's a there's a place
- 1:21:00and a and an opportunity for us to to teach lessons and in games that
- 1:21:06that perhaps uh I would reach an audience or tell it in a way that
- 1:21:12that would reach different people than other things would I. I I I like
- 1:21:19that I in my own little way, in the stories that I write,
- 1:21:25in the games that those stories are materialized. I hope that they are doing
- 1:21:31some of those things. But I myself personally am not one that that tackles
- 1:21:35those things too on the nose. I'm not whatever it may be, even
- 1:21:42if it's something I agree with, I'm not that interested in very preachy game
- 1:21:47or story experiences that are just so heavy handed. So it would have to
- 1:21:56be done with care. It would have to be done with with you know,
- 1:22:02strategically, in a way that wouldn't turn people off, but would subtly
- 1:22:08teach good things and help us to be better people in better communities. So
- 1:22:14sure, I think it's possible. How we do it is a challenge.
- 1:22:17So I want to briefly talk now about the future. So what can we
- 1:22:20expect from you in the future. Well, I'll be making illustrating board games
- 1:22:26for a very long time, I'm sure, I hope. For me personally,
- 1:22:30that's certainly the most important thing that's going on right now art wise for
- 1:22:36me is my upcoming Smoking Bones World. This is an ip, original ip
- 1:22:45that I've been creating and working on for about ten years, so long before
- 1:22:48I was even in board games. I have stories in the works. I
- 1:22:57have a kickstarter that's coming out of a book UH that is coming out in
- 1:23:02the end of July this year. The thing that that most people would would
- 1:23:08it would be applicable to this audience is and something I'm extremely excited about,
- 1:23:14is a partnership with or collaboration with Stonemire Games. Having worked with with Jamie
- 1:23:19on Tapestry and developed, having developed a good relationship but with him over the
- 1:23:26years, I actually had always only thought about Jamie, especially after playing site.
- 1:23:32I. I thought, this this world I've been working on, How
- 1:23:35amazing would it be to tell this story in a game. So I pitched
- 1:23:40the world to him and he was excited about it, and UH, and
- 1:23:44we have we have a series of board games in the works that will be
- 1:23:47published by Stonemire Games in the near future. So that's huge and really all
- 1:23:55my my focus when it is not another on my client's projects, it's it's
- 1:23:59geared towards moving that forward. So that's something I'm super super excited about.
- 1:24:06And do you have a timeline on that. I cannot share any timelines about
- 1:24:12the games, unfortunately. I am working on story. So there's two different
- 1:24:20types of things that I'm working on outside of games. One is a series
- 1:24:25of games. Sorry of books. Stories are that tell a big story,
- 1:24:32you know, it will almost like it be a trilogy, and that is
- 1:24:36telling this big arc of a story in this world. And then there are
- 1:24:45in the story is about the Smoking Bones Travel Company. It's a company,
- 1:24:49a touring company that takes people to the magical places of the world. What
- 1:24:55I'm also creating besides these stories is Travel Guides, the fictional travel guides that
- 1:24:59are set in this world published by the Smoking Bones Travel Company, and that's
- 1:25:02what's coming out in July. It's a basically an art book that is filled
- 1:25:08with travel posters that talk about these magical places you could visit if you were
- 1:25:14to take a tour with the Smoking Bones Travel Company. So I'm I'm filling
- 1:25:19out the world with these books, and they will support the games and vice
- 1:25:24versa as as they are released. So your final game, then, is
- 1:25:31one that's very dear to my heart, even though I only really discovered it
- 1:25:34two years ago. And this is Bonanza. So this is this a game
- 1:25:39that proves that you can you can create magic out of very simple ingredients.
- 1:25:45Yeah, I mean, gosh, I mean there's other games that are similar,
- 1:25:50but it's a deck of cards with numbers on them and pictures of beans
- 1:25:55and that's really it. So it's really really quite simple. Yeah, simple
- 1:26:00ingredients, simple theme. I mean, who would have thought we could make
- 1:26:05a cherished game out of beans? And we did or someone did. So
- 1:26:15people really hate on the art for this, Okay, what is what is
- 1:26:19your view on it? It's very divisive. I didn't know it was very
- 1:26:25divisive. I actually really liked the art. I mean I've said this before.
- 1:26:34I love this game so much. I am not turned off by the
- 1:26:39art at all. But I feel like, perhaps, and maybe it's just
- 1:26:44bias, because I've known this game for so long, I've been playing this
- 1:26:45game for so long, it feels a little dated to me, or it
- 1:26:48feels like it could use a refresh. So people have asked me in the
- 1:26:53past, like if you could illustrate a game, if you could do the
- 1:26:56illustrations for a game that already exists. Bananza is one of those that I
- 1:26:59would love to do just because I love the game. I would love to
- 1:27:02see different artwork on it too, But it's not because I don't like the
- 1:27:05artwork or I just feel like I would love to see this game continue to
- 1:27:11live. And I was surprised recently that an expansion has recently been announced with
- 1:27:16the same artists with the same theme. There had previously been a reimplementation of
- 1:27:23this game that turned Bonanza into Flowers, and the artwork is beautiful in it.
- 1:27:28I believe it's I can't remember for sure, but I think it's Best
- 1:27:31soulb that did the artwork, and she did an amazing job. But it's
- 1:27:34not the same theme. It's not the same thing to me. I wouldn't.
- 1:27:38I wouldn't enjoy playing a game about collecting flowers like I would about,
- 1:27:43you know, picking up the green bean who's throwing up next to a lamp
- 1:27:47post. So I don't have a problem with the art at all, but
- 1:27:57I wouldn't. I wouldn't mind if add a refresh, even if it was
- 1:27:59the same artist, perhaps even with this latest expansion that was added, you
- 1:28:06know, it's just playing on the same arc that has been done previously.
- 1:28:10If you were to start from brand new, you know, it could perhaps
- 1:28:14that there could be some improvements made. But I find it charming the art.
- 1:28:18So I've got one more question for you. So you're heading out to
- 1:28:21the cabin, and you're driving down the road, and you go in a
- 1:28:24corner and the back door of the car flies open. Four of the games
- 1:28:27fly out down a ravine, into a river, and a swept away to
- 1:28:30posterity. Which game do your hope is sitting on the backseat of the car?
- 1:28:35The final the one I have to have. I mentioned to my wife.
- 1:28:41She was surprised by my choice. But it would be Spots be Spots.
- 1:28:45But that's probably only because in this scenario my family has not fallen out
- 1:28:50of the truck either, and there with me at this cabin. And so
- 1:28:57what game would I want? What would sustain longer as a family and we
- 1:29:01would all enjoy and Spots would definitely be that one. We could play Spots
- 1:29:05forever probably and love it. But if I want, I couldn't push Scythe
- 1:29:11on my wife. Everybody else in my family's played it, but my wife
- 1:29:15she has played it, but begrudgingly, and she wouldn't do it again.
- 1:29:19So there's some games that just you know, it would just mean we wouldn't
- 1:29:23play games at all. So Spots we Will would mean that the legacy of
- 1:29:27game playing continued. So it's charming, it's beautiful, it's a fun little
- 1:29:31game, and it can just go on forever. So I love that one.
- 1:29:35So if people want to get hold of you, they want to see
- 1:29:39what's coming from you and all of that stuff, how can they go about
- 1:29:41doing that? Sure, my website is the hub for everything that's Bosley art
- 1:29:46dot com. I'm not active on social media anymore and haven't been for a
- 1:29:51long time, but I have a very very active Discord and I think a
- 1:29:56fun Patreon as well. So if people went to at bosleart dot com,
- 1:30:00they could think that would be where they could find avenues to interact with me
- 1:30:06personally through the discord, play games together on BGA and do other things,
- 1:30:15or support me via Patreon, or it would direct them to the new new
- 1:30:20works in the Smoking Bones. It would take them there as well, So
- 1:30:24that's that's the best place. Excellent. Well, Andrew Bossley, thank you
- 1:30:28very much, Thank you, it's been a pleasure. You can support the
- 1:30:30show in many ways. You can tell your friends, you can talk about
- 1:30:33it on social media, you can talk about it in your own blog,
- 1:30:35podcast, or video. You can support it directly by going to Patreon dot
- 1:30:39com, forward slash five gfd for a rolling donation, or for a one
- 1:30:41off donation hitting the PayPal link at bottom of the website five Games for Doomsday
- 1:30:45dot com. It's these donations that keep the show going. Also, if
- 1:30:47you want to say something nice about the show, if you want to say
- 1:30:49something horrible about the show, can contact me on Twitter at five Games for
- 1:30:54Doomsday or send an email at five Games for Doomsday gmail dot com. And
- 1:30:58if I managed to abscond from the feral donkeys and the world as it is,
- 1:31:01I'll see you in two weeks for another five Games for Doomsday