Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Duck Soup (1933): When Silly Becomes Serious
Transcript
- 0:12in and spend some time with the film hobbyist.
- 0:15My name is Lydia, and I love movies. We're sitting
- 0:32here in a nook of my attic room, a window between
- 0:36us looking out onto my backyard. It's insufferably
- 0:41humid out there, so much so that the air has
- 0:44condensed on my window. We can barely see outside.
- 0:49It's one of those hot, grey days with thick cloud
- 0:53covering trapping the wet, hot air. Just a stuffy
- 0:58mess. There may be a storm soon. Sometime today,
- 1:03or tomorrow, or next week. But until then, the
- 1:07outside is the world's most uncomfortable sauna.
- 1:12That's because it's July now. And not just July.
- 1:16Today is the exact middle of the year, the 183rd
- 1:21day. The continental divide between the beginning
- 1:25of the year and the end. All the dates running
- 1:28down the slope until New Year's. This isn't the
- 1:32kind of thing most people care about, this division
- 1:35in a year between part one and part two. Not
- 1:39unless you're in finances. Or if your hobby is
- 1:43movies. See, every year, at the end of the year,
- 1:48you can write a list for your top films. A bunch
- 1:52of film news websites and internet critics release
- 1:55them. It's lots of fun. It's a great time to
- 1:58highlight smaller films that the writer loved
- 2:01that readers or listeners might have missed.
- 2:04It also builds a sort of consensus for what movies
- 2:08are worth remembering into the future. And it's
- 2:11actually a pretty good way to identify a critic's
- 2:14tastes, something incredibly valuable as a reader
- 2:17when keeping an eye out for which movies you
- 2:20might like. But a while ago, film internet realized
- 2:24it could easily get another article or video
- 2:27or podcast episode by releasing a summer list
- 2:31for the best films of the year so far. On one
- 2:36hand, yeah, this is a pretty silly way to do
- 2:39this. It's clearly just ad generating content.
- 2:43But I do think it has genuine value because the
- 2:47lists are always very different. Back in May,
- 2:53I talked about the summer movie season. I should
- 2:57explain that there's kind of a whole film release
- 3:01calendar. It's a guideline, perfectly subject
- 3:06to change. But if you are interested in a certain
- 3:09kind of movie, it's good to note when your kinds
- 3:12of films might be released. January is a film
- 3:17dumping ground. It's cold, so people aren't really
- 3:21getting out of the house a ton. It's also after
- 3:24Christmas, so audiences are less likely to spend
- 3:27money. This makes it the perfect time to release
- 3:31bad movies, especially bad horror movies. Sometimes,
- 3:35though, there are good horror movies that are
- 3:38a little bit risky. Get Out was released in January.
- 3:42Also, Megan, or Mithrigan, that absolutely insane
- 3:46murder robot doll film. February is for chick
- 3:50flicks, sometimes romances or rom -coms, but
- 3:54also sometimes a girls' hangout film. There is
- 3:57also usually some kind of counter -programming,
- 4:00so some very dude films, like an action movie
- 4:04or a war movie. March is a good month. Usually
- 4:09there's a more experimental Pixar film here,
- 4:12or some nice dramas or easy comedies. It's also
- 4:16a month for a risky blockbuster. Hunger Games
- 4:19released here. Project Hail Mary this year. April
- 4:24is for fluff. Comedy's largely maybe an early
- 4:27summer film. May is summer movie kickoff. Big
- 4:32blockbusters, especially with an eye toward younger
- 4:35audiences, even if they are PG -13. June always
- 4:40has a big Disney release, usually a Pixar or
- 4:44a live -action remake. More blockbusters. July
- 4:48is where we usually get a big superhero release.
- 4:51A war film or other dad movie does well here.
- 4:56August is for comedies, rom -coms, and funny
- 5:00action movies. It's the summer wind down, usually
- 5:03not as big releases. September is a dead zone,
- 5:07the January of the fall. October is for horror.
- 5:11It is what it is. November is a hybrid. You get
- 5:16holiday releases, family movies with bigger ambitions,
- 5:20and you also get the prestige films. These are
- 5:24your Oscar hopefuls, your thoughtful dramas.
- 5:27And then December, in amidst the holiday blockbusters,
- 5:31is filled with festival darlings and award contenders.
- 5:37This is because of recency bias in the awards
- 5:40voting block. The movies you saw most recently
- 5:43will stick out in your mind, which also leads
- 5:46to a big burst of news, especially if a film
- 5:49is good. Studios want the awards voting date
- 5:53to hit that sweet spot with buzz for their film
- 5:57before it turns to backlash. It's a whole thing.
- 6:00And that's why the first half of the year list
- 6:03is different from a second half of the year.
- 6:07Pretty much all the important films come out
- 6:10in November or December. Occasionally, a first
- 6:13half of the year film will make it all year long.
- 6:16Sinners was one of those movies last year. Everything
- 6:19Everywhere All at Once, the previous year. But
- 6:23largely... All the serious dramas and issue films
- 6:27wait to pounce right at the end of the year.
- 6:30So that first half is where you get all the fun
- 6:34movies, the romps, the comedies. Comedies are
- 6:40not considered as important as dramas, even though
- 6:43a good comedy takes so much work to pull off.
- 6:47Comedic actors are, frankly, more versatile than
- 6:51dramatic actors. Which is why it's easier for
- 6:54them to make a dramatic turn than vice versa.
- 6:58And yet, it's rare for a comedy to get critical
- 7:02or awards attention. Why, dramas are just about
- 7:07more important things, deep issues. And that,
- 7:10of course, means they're of higher quality. But
- 7:15what makes a silly movie important? When does
- 7:19a comedy cross that line from frivolous to weighty?
- 7:25I think a perfect film to encapsulate this would
- 7:28be the Marx Brothers' most important film, the
- 7:321933 picture Duck Soup. If you aren't familiar
- 7:36with the Marx Brothers, I assure you, you are.
- 7:40Their reach and influence is incredibly far,
- 7:44especially in cartoons. The Looney Tunes really
- 7:48pulled a lot from them, and then later the Animaniacs
- 7:51as well. It goes beyond that, though. Have you
- 7:55ever put on a pair of those funny nose and glasses
- 7:59with the big eyebrows and silly mustache? Then
- 8:03congratulations! You are familiar with the Marx
- 8:06Brothers. The Marx Brothers were, in fact, a
- 8:11set of five brothers, Jewish New Yorkers who
- 8:14put together a vaudeville act in the 19 -teens.
- 8:18One of the brothers left to fight in World War
- 8:20I and wasn't interested in performing when he
- 8:23came back. The other brothers kept performing
- 8:26together, moving to Broadway when vaudeville
- 8:28dried up. And then, in the late 1920s, they moved
- 8:32out to Hollywood, bringing their smash hit Broadway
- 8:35sensation The Coconuts to film. Each of their
- 8:40movies is a loose plot built around a series
- 8:43of bits inspired by their character types. Groucho
- 8:48Marx was always kind of the lead. His face is
- 8:53the funny glasses face. He had these big round
- 8:56glasses and would always paint a massive mustache
- 8:59and eyebrows on his face with grease paint. His
- 9:02schtick was that he always played kind of an
- 9:06incompetent idiot in a position of authority.
- 9:09In the coconuts, he's the owner of a fancy hotel.
- 9:12In animal crackers, he's a famous explorer. In
- 9:16horse feathers, he's a college president. In
- 9:19most other movies, these kinds of characters
- 9:22would be played by comedic straight men, and
- 9:25the silliness would happen around them. But Groucho
- 9:28just gets to be ridiculous. What makes this schtick
- 9:32work is that he's supported by other characters,
- 9:35usually an established or wealthy woman played
- 9:38by Margaret Dumont, who takes him deadly seriously.
- 9:43Zeppo usually takes a comedic straight man supporting
- 9:47role, often as Groucho's secretary or assistant.
- 9:51I think he's his college -aged son in Horse Feathers.
- 9:56He doesn't have as much to do in the films as
- 9:59the others, but he usually gets a really great
- 10:02bit where Groucho will dictate something to him
- 10:05and the interplay is completely ridiculous. Like,
- 10:08Groucho dictates semicolon. and Zeppo asks him
- 10:13how to spell it. Zeppo is not in all of the movies.
- 10:17Again, he didn't have much to do. Both Groucho
- 10:22and Zeppo will sing in their films. Often Groucho
- 10:26gets a Gilbert and Sullivan -style number where
- 10:29he sings a silly introduction, like Animal Crackers'
- 10:32I Came to Tell You I Must Be Going. was that
- 10:39he had a fake Italian accent. This does lead
- 10:43to lots of jokes, but it's not making fun of
- 10:46the accent as much as it uses the accent to set
- 10:49up wordplay, like an exchange in Duck Soup when
- 10:53a man asks a question about tax policy and Chico
- 10:57says, I got an uncle who lives in Texas. No,
- 11:00not Texas. Taxes. Money. Dollars. That's where
- 11:04he lives, the Dallas of Texas. In the plot, Chico
- 11:08usually plays a schemer, a thief, a conman, a
- 11:13bootlegger. Chico also plays the piano in a very
- 11:18unorthodox manner. It's hard to describe. He
- 11:22uses his fingers oddly. It's highly amusing,
- 11:25a clever bit of physical comedy. Harpo is kind
- 11:29of like a weird hybrid between Dopey the Dwarf
- 11:33and Animal the Muppet. Like Dopey, he's silent
- 11:37and also kind of dim -witted, but he's less like
- 11:41a sweet, innocent baby and more like a toddlerish
- 11:45agent of chaos with no inhibitions, a walking
- 11:48id. He also does the animal thing of chasing
- 11:52after every pretty girl he sees. His scenes are,
- 11:56frankly, some of the most hysterical in any Marx
- 12:00Brothers film, just relentless physical comedy.
- 12:05Plot -wise, he's usually paired with Chico in
- 12:08some kind of scheme. This means Chico can narrate
- 12:12for him. And like Chico, he was also a musician.
- 12:17He played the harp. Surprise, surprise. He doesn't
- 12:21in every movie, but it's usually a sincere moment
- 12:24amidst all the insanity. I trust you can already
- 12:29see the formula for each film just through this
- 12:32character typing. Groucho's authority figure
- 12:36is introduced in ridiculous fashion. Chico and
- 12:40Harpo show up with some sort of scheme. Somehow
- 12:43they end up being hired or recruited by Groucho
- 12:47for another purpose. Hijinks ensue. There are
- 12:51misunderstandings, confusions, pretty girls being
- 12:55chased by Harpo while he honks a horn. Groucho
- 12:58gives a comedic monologue. Chico has a comedic
- 13:01exchange. There's some kind of ridiculous climax.
- 13:04And then the movie is over. The Marx Brothers
- 13:07weren't interested in making high art. They weren't
- 13:11interested in social commentary. They wanted
- 13:14to make silly stories that made people laugh.
- 13:17They wanted to earn a buck being entertaining.
- 13:20Their movies are almost entirely pure popcorn
- 13:24fun. Some of the jokes are cleverly worded, but
- 13:27not to make you think, just to make you giggle.
- 13:30Like Groucho's famous joke in Animal Crackers.
- 13:34One morning, I shot an elephant in my pajamas.
- 13:36How he got in my pajamas? I don't know. But in
- 13:401933, for their fifth film in as many years,
- 13:44they accidentally made an important movie. They
- 13:49legitimately weren't intending to. They went
- 13:51to their graves, insisting that they only cared
- 13:54about being silly. So how on earth did this happen?
- 14:01The Coconuts is all about a fancy hotel. Groucho
- 14:04is the silly owner. Zeppo is his assistant. Chico
- 14:08and Harpo are con men trying to rob the rich
- 14:11guests. Animal Crackers is about a bunch of bored
- 14:15rich people. Groucho is a famous hunter. Zeppo
- 14:19is his secretary. Chico and Harpo are thieves
- 14:22hired to steal a famous painting, and then to
- 14:25switch it with a fake, and then to switch it
- 14:27with another fake. Horse Feathers is all about
- 14:30college football. Groucho is the college president.
- 14:34Zeppo is his star football player son. Chico
- 14:37and Harpo are ice men and bootleggers who get
- 14:40accidentally recruited as football players. So
- 14:44in Duck Soup, they needed a new idea for a silly
- 14:47authority figure for Groucho to play. How about
- 14:51the biggest authority you could get? Let's make
- 14:55him president of a nation! What would be the
- 14:58silliest nation? Oh, let's make it some really
- 15:01small, insignificant European country. Margaret
- 15:06Dumont could be the important woman who gets
- 15:09him the job. How about she's a millionaire's
- 15:13widow who is bankrolling the country so she gets
- 15:16her guy in the position? Zeppo can be the president's
- 15:19secretary. Chico and Harpo need some kind of
- 15:24scheme. I know. They should be spies. But why
- 15:29would they be spies? Maybe there's another country
- 15:33that wants to take over this country, and they
- 15:36want Chico and Harpo to figure out how to do
- 15:39that. Wouldn't it be funny if Groucho started
- 15:42a war with them for some stupid reason? And then
- 15:46Chico and Harpo would have plans to try and steal.
- 15:49It'll be great! A comedy about... European countries
- 15:56going to war after trying to annex each other
- 16:00over their leaders' egos. In 1933. Hmm. Why might
- 16:10that be culturally significant? A few things
- 16:16to note. The Marx Brothers didn't have a crystal
- 16:20ball. They were looking to the past. World War
- 16:24I happened largely because of the egos of men
- 16:28in boardrooms. They couldn't know that Hitler's
- 16:32come to power at the start of the year would
- 16:34have such drastic consequences in the decade
- 16:37to come. In fact, their film came out at a rather
- 16:41inconvenient time. This movie was not a success.
- 16:46Audiences largely rejected it as being in bad
- 16:49taste. whether they were reacting to Hitler's
- 16:52speeches in the aftermath of the Reichstag fire,
- 16:55or just to the cynical tone in the midst of a
- 16:59Great Depression. The audience wanted escapism,
- 17:03and this film, for all its silliness, is not
- 17:08escapist. There's an adage in writing, the specific
- 17:15is universal. If a writer wants their story to
- 17:19be more relatable to audiences, being grounded
- 17:23in specific details makes a story more likely
- 17:26to connect with an audience who find their own
- 17:29specific experiences mirrored in the character's
- 17:33specificity. Comedy is kind of the opposite.
- 17:38Because humor is already so rooted in time and
- 17:42culture, satire even more so, the more direct
- 17:47the satire or comedy, the less funny it is to
- 17:51a wider audience as time goes on. Like, in its
- 17:56time, Gulliver's Travels was a very funny and
- 18:00poignant takedown of British politics and the
- 18:03specific genre of Traveller's Tales, a contemporary
- 18:07kind of speculative fiction. Most of that stuff
- 18:11goes over the heads of current readers, unless
- 18:14they are holding an annotated edition. What remains
- 18:17is a fun adventure. Duck Soup, on the other hand,
- 18:22is just trying to be silly about the idea of
- 18:26politics and diplomacy and war, and in that generality,
- 18:30it keeps being relevant. It was rediscovered
- 18:35by the 1960s counterculture, and they found it
- 18:38incredibly relatable and clever. It was critics
- 18:42coming out of that context that rebranded this
- 18:46flop as an artistic masterpiece. Watching it
- 18:50today, nearly a century since its release, yeah,
- 18:54it's still relatable. As in most Marx Brothers
- 18:59films, early in the movie, Groucho's authority
- 19:02figure sings a contrary anthem. In this case,
- 19:07it's Laws of the Administration, where he delivers
- 19:10a list of ridiculous demands. Silly rules such
- 19:14as, if chewing gum is chewed, the chewer is pursued,
- 19:17and in the Huskow hidden. Again, just a silly
- 19:22choice to throw them in jail for chewing gum.
- 19:25But one that - actually happened in Singapore
- 19:28in 1992 in the country's attempt to build a perfect
- 19:32image. In my most recent watch, the satire was
- 19:37so on point, I had difficulty laughing in such
- 19:40lines as, the last man nearly ruined this place.
- 19:44He didn't know what to do with it. If you think
- 19:47this country's bad off now, just wait till I
- 19:49get through with it. Just a silly choice for
- 19:53a silly character. who is a silly president.
- 19:57Throughout the film, Sylvania is trying to start
- 20:00a war. It's clear this part of the plot wasn't
- 20:04as important to the Marx Brothers as the very
- 20:07funny lemonade stand bit with Chico and Harpo,
- 20:10or their version of the mirror gag, a comedy
- 20:14bit where two actors dressed the same way copy
- 20:17each other's movements as if they are mirror
- 20:19reflections of each other. which this film probably
- 20:23contains the best version of. So there's some
- 20:26hand -waviness over the Sylvanian ambassador's
- 20:30schemes to start a war. The first, briefly mentioned,
- 20:34is an attempt to pay revolutionaries to overthrow
- 20:38the government. Vaguely conspiracy thinking in
- 20:421933. an accurate depiction of history in the
- 20:461960s era of the Bay of Pigs, or in our current
- 20:50world, shaped by the many proxy wars of the Cold
- 20:55War. The second plan is to try and woo the millionaire's
- 21:01widow to bring her money to Sylvania, but instead,
- 21:05the war happens when Groucho's character, attempting
- 21:09to get the ambassador to cause an international
- 21:11incident, causes the international incident by
- 21:14slapping the ambassador after the mild insult
- 21:17of being called an upstart. This was, again,
- 21:22pulling from World War I history, but so directly
- 21:26and accidentally offended Mussolini that he banned
- 21:30the film in Italy. It feels equally relevant
- 21:33in an era of today's thin -skinned autocrats.
- 21:38The grand centerpiece of this film is a musical
- 21:42number late in the story, when all the diplomacy
- 21:44and backhanded schemes lead to a declaration
- 21:47of war between the nation of Fredonia and the
- 21:50scheming Sylvania. It's the only musical number
- 21:54in any Marx Brothers film which all four brothers
- 21:57performed together. In its specific context,
- 22:01it actually follows the style of a minstrel number,
- 22:05though without any blackface. Minstrelsy, stripped
- 22:10of its racial component, is a performative folksiness,
- 22:14an over -the -top artificial populism. And that
- 22:19is the silliest choice for a declaration of war.
- 22:23Outside of that specificity, it's still very
- 22:27silly to see a whole room of people shouting,
- 22:30To war! To war! Fredonia goes to war! Oh, hidey,
- 22:33hidey, hidey, hidey, hidey, hidey, ho! I had
- 22:37to research this movie to learn that an old spiritual
- 22:40was parodied in the lyrics, they got guns, we
- 22:44got guns, all God's children got guns. Because
- 22:49that sentiment, that silliness of justifying
- 22:53a war by stripping it to who has weapons, is
- 22:56just so broadly applicable. It makes complete
- 23:00sense why it was funny during the nuclear -infused
- 23:04Cold War. just as it does in the midst of current
- 23:08warmongering. Groucho Marx reportedly, late in
- 23:13his life, when asked about the significance of
- 23:16this film, answered, What significance? We were
- 23:20just four Jews trying to get a laugh. And considering
- 23:23that this was the fifth film of theirs in five
- 23:27years, the last picture owed in a contract, one
- 23:31cobbled together from several different scripts,
- 23:35I genuinely believe him. It's just that when
- 23:38you're silly about something important, taking
- 23:41a serious topic and poking fun at it, treating
- 23:45something weighty as the setup for a punchline,
- 23:48you might accidentally end up saying something
- 23:52profound, relatable, far past your intentions.
- 23:58And I do wonder that when film critics and awards
- 24:01institutions dismiss comedies as unimportant
- 24:04fluff and pure silliness, which of those works
- 24:09may end up in the history books as a masterpiece
- 24:12of continually relevant cultural commentary?
- 24:15Which of those films released in the year so
- 24:18far might end up far more important than those
- 24:22self -serious dramas as the days spill into months
- 24:27and years and decades? So let us keep an open
- 24:32mind and a hearty laugh. Thanks for coming.