Latest / Film And Whiskey / Modern Times / Widow Jane Lucky 13 Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1936 director and star. Charlie Chaplin gave the world.
- 0:04A grimly humorous. Look at the then modern world.
- 0:07And the difficulty of getting ahead, which totally is an
- 0:11old-fashioned problem that we don't deal with anymore in 2023.
- 0:15We try a well aged bourbon from the heart of the Metropolis.
- 0:19The film is modern times. The whiskey is Widow, Jane.
- 0:23Lucky 13 and more of you them both this is the filling whiskey
- 0:28podcast. East.
- 0:47Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast.
- 0:49Where each week, we review a classic movie and a glass of
- 0:52whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G.
- 0:56And this week we are rounding out our toward a Lynn with his
- 1:011936 Masterpiece modern times. Mmm.
- 1:05Bob, before we get into that, I have I have stunning news for
- 1:09you, that I think you'll appreciate.
- 1:11All right. Listen, I don't want to step on
- 1:12your news, but last time you made a big announcement on this
- 1:15show, it was that you made a really good burrito.
- 1:18Yeah, I did. I'm sure it was incredible, sure
- 1:21it was great. Is this more or less important
- 1:24than your burrito? I think that you personally will
- 1:27find it more important. All right, let's hear it.
- 1:30I Bradley G have been now as of today, this morning, in fact, to
- 1:37Ikea OCH first time at Ikea first time that I really never
- 1:43been to Ikea before not a single time.
- 1:45There's one, like, 30 minutes from my house.
- 1:47Dude. Ikea's wonderful.
- 1:49Yeah, I have been there now and I can tell you without a shadow
- 1:54of a doubt that place sucks. No, come on, dude.
- 2:00It's the worst like the a the carts have forecasters on them.
- 2:06What are you doing? Like, figure out how to make a
- 2:09cart Sweden. Secondly, you just wander around
- 2:16and you're just lost in this Maze.
- 2:19And there's like it's the most capitalistic thing I've ever
- 2:24seen a bunch of liberals fall in love with ever like it.
- 2:29It's the most consumeristic like the it's consumerism perfected
- 2:35like hey, you think you could live in this cool little 300
- 2:38square foot apartment. Here's all the stuff you could
- 2:40spend your money on and yet for some reason it just feels like
- 2:44people across the land that are a little more, left-leaning love
- 2:48this place and I just I don't get it, man, the Communist
- 2:53Utopia. That is like you, yeah, although
- 2:56you're right, it is a more, of a capitalist Utopia so much so
- 2:59that they're You never have to leave, come eat meatballs
- 3:03example, he view stocked full of protein so that you can purchase
- 3:07more things Brad. I never not did not like Ikea.
- 3:12I never expected that you would be the person railing against
- 3:15capitalism on this podcast, but here we are.
- 3:18And then you went home and watched modern times, I did, it
- 3:23seems like you have a kindred spirit here in Sir, Charles
- 3:26Chaplin. I just might Bob, mmm.
- 3:31Brad. No less than four weeks ago.
- 3:33You had never seen a silent film.
- 3:35And now you have seen three of them and a bonus fourth.
- 3:38Non silent film from Charlie Chaplin although this one, you
- 3:42know. It technically has dialogue,
- 3:44voiced by chart, you know, surprise.
- 3:46Yeah, there's there's a nice little breadcrumb, not
- 3:48breadcrumbs. What's the word?
- 3:50Just some nice little Easter eggs thrown in by Charlie
- 3:52Chaplin as we've said a few times.
- 3:55Now he makes this movie nine years after the Advent of the
- 3:58sound film. And everyone else has moved on
- 4:02at this point. And Charlie.
- 4:03Chaplin really digs his heels in and says, I can't make the Tramp
- 4:06talk, I can't do it, it will completely ruin the mystery and
- 4:11the illusion that I have created.
- 4:12With this character. I'm gonna give him one final,
- 4:14send off and he's gonna, he's gonna remain a silent character.
- 4:18And I really think Brad before we talk about anything else
- 4:21with, you know, this movie or this character, I think it was
- 4:24the right choice, even if it was way way, way out of the norm in
- 4:291936, So yeah, I think it fits for this film and if I'm being
- 4:35honest, based on his first full production, sound film, The
- 4:39Great Dictator, I think that this film is better off, not
- 4:43being a sound film. Hmm.
- 4:44Yeah, I agree like I I think that Charlie should have held
- 4:47back a little bit, and just made a few, like, short, 30-minute
- 4:52films or something that that had sound and dialogue and all that,
- 4:56before he dove into a feature-length, be picture.
- 4:59I love it when there's like a hangover from the prior week,
- 5:02when you're like, still not done talking about, whatever it was,
- 5:05that was irking you with last week's film.
- 5:08And now we're back in here and you're like, no, no, I'm not
- 5:11ready to let go of my my problems with the Great Dictator
- 5:14yet. Well, that's what I'm saying
- 5:16though. If you had done this as a sound
- 5:18film, it would have suffered and this is a pretty good movie and
- 5:21I would have hated to see that. So I'm just trying to give him a
- 5:24little friendly advice. There you go.
- 5:26All right, Brad. Let's let's dive into talking
- 5:29about the movie. I have said for four weeks now,
- 5:31this is probably my favorite Charlie Chaplin movie.
- 5:34I really am excited to talk about the differences between
- 5:39this and City Lights. This is the first movie he makes
- 5:41After City Lights. There's a five-year Gap in the
- 5:44release of those movies in between the two.
- 5:46He kind of Terrence Malick. Yeah.
- 5:48Right in between the two, he kind of goes on a world tour of
- 5:52sorts. He meets with a bunch of
- 5:53dignitaries, he visits a lot of different countries, and he sees
- 5:57the effects of the Great Depression.
- 5:59And how It has tanked the world's economy and how people
- 6:03all over the world, who know this iconic character of the
- 6:06Tramp are all suffering economically in the same ways.
- 6:10And he realizes, I've got to make my movie be about this.
- 6:13And so, you know, we've seen him set the character of the Tramp
- 6:17back in time in the gold rush. And now we see him not just set
- 6:21it in, you know, what could be contemporary like it wasn't city
- 6:24lights but to really, honestly say, no, this is right now like
- 6:28you see Billboards that Say the year like 1935 scattered
- 6:31throughout this movie when they were filming it and not only is
- 6:34this right now but this guy the Tramp is going through exactly
- 6:37what we're going through right now.
- 6:39I think it really is kind of a foreshadowing of the timeliness
- 6:43that he really leans into with the Great Dictator that he's not
- 6:46setting this in some sort of like you know alternative world
- 6:50where the Great Depression isn't happening know.
- 6:52He's going through exactly what the audience is going through.
- 6:56Yeah and it fits with what's going on in At the time.
- 7:00And I think that's reflected in the way he continues to fight to
- 7:05try and get back up, but keeps getting knocked back down.
- 7:08And if you, if you really wanted to compare the ending of the
- 7:11movie to anything, you'd probably compare it to the
- 7:13ending of Grapes of Wrath. Hmm.
- 7:15Yeah. Like the way that it's great
- 7:17point. I didn't think about that, dude.
- 7:19I am full of great points. Not only are you full of great
- 7:24points? You quoted The Immortal bards
- 7:27Chumbawamba in your Dissertation here.
- 7:31He gets knocked down but he gets up again but then he gets.
- 7:34You're never gonna keep him down.
- 7:36You sure won't man. Yeah he probably takes a lager
- 7:39drink at some point. All right man.
- 7:43I think it's time for our first segment of the day which we call
- 7:46Brad explains Brad's gonna give us the movie plots with only 60
- 7:50seconds ticking on the clock. So let's go ahead and kill you
- 7:53take with this little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 7:57Brad explains is the part of the podcast where Ad breaks down the
- 8:00plot of the movie that he has just seen often for the first
- 8:04time. This is very obviously, Brad's
- 8:07first time seeing modern times, I'm really excited to see what
- 8:11you do with, Brad explains because there's a lot of like,
- 8:14there's a lot of stuff that happens in this movie.
- 8:17I don't know if you can quite capture every single scene in 60
- 8:21seconds, so let's just kind of see where you go from here.
- 8:24Brad! You've got one minute on the
- 8:25clock spoil, this movie for us and go.
- 8:29Our beloved, Tramp is working as a factory worker and experiences
- 8:33a nervous breakdown when he's subject to ridiculous working
- 8:36conditions because of this, he's sent to a psych hospital when
- 8:40he's released. He finds himself in prison
- 8:43because he's leading a strike in prison.
- 8:47He stops a not a robbery a breakout from happening and is
- 8:52let out on good behavior and he begins the cycle of finding a
- 8:57job but then being Fortunately, forced out of the job, due to
- 9:02circumstances Beyond his control.
- 9:04He works as a night Watchman at a department store, he works
- 9:09where I'll he works as a on the boat dock for like a hot minute.
- 9:13He works as a waiter in a singing restaurant and
- 9:17consistently. He finds himself down on his
- 9:20luck, not being able to get ahead in the midst of this.
- 9:23He meets and falls in love with a obviously like teenage girl
- 9:28who looks like she's 30 25 seconds it, and they travel the
- 9:34world together, and by the world, I mean, his heart on his
- 9:38luck life. There you go.
- 9:39There's modern times folks. Yeah, Brad.
- 9:42I really want to hear your thoughts on the movie itself.
- 9:45I was recently re watching a clip that we've referenced
- 9:48throughout the seasons of this show, and it's a clip of the
- 9:52writers of the show, South Park, Matt Stone and Trey Parker.
- 9:55And they're talking about how when you are writing, this was
- 9:58for television but just in general.
- 9:59When you're writing a script, the things that connect your
- 10:03scenes together should never be the words and then this happens.
- 10:07And then this happens. And then this happens, it makes
- 10:09for no dramatic Arc and you always need to have in between
- 10:12your scenes, so or but this happens, but this happens.
- 10:19So this happens instead and I think with City Lights, one
- 10:24thing that I would ding that movie for is that it doesn't
- 10:27always necessarily feel like like each scene is a logical you
- 10:33know, building off of the prior scene.
- 10:35Where is in this movie even though it's very clear sometimes
- 10:39at the scenes are just there to set up a gag I think Chaplin
- 10:43does a much better job of putting the Tramp in a position
- 10:46where everything has a cause to it and there's like a ton of
- 10:50causality throughout the film. Yeah.
- 10:52The the story keeps him moving along in such a way that even
- 10:57when stuff is happening to him. and he doesn't really have
- 11:01agency in what's going on the, the stream of events is logical
- 11:07and Everybody's actions make sense like at every point, when
- 11:12the police throw him in jail, it's like well, based on their
- 11:15perspective, it makes sense why they threw him in jail and based
- 11:19on Chaplin, you know, the tramps perspective, it makes sense.
- 11:22Why he he just considers himself, someone who is going to
- 11:26get ahead of entually someday. He is going to have a house with
- 11:30oranges and grapes growing outside the windows and a
- 11:33trained cow who can just you know, squirt, milk Abyssal
- 11:37man's? Yeah, I can.
- 11:39Milk itself. Yeah, he's gonna chief that
- 11:42dream someday, man. Yeah.
- 11:44And I think the thing that I really liked about this movie
- 11:46was that, even though everything that happens as kind of
- 11:49cyclical, we've already mentioned that it seems every
- 11:52time he gets ahead, there is some unfortunate happenstance
- 11:56that ends up winding him back in jail.
- 11:58He goes to jail like four times throughout this movie, it's
- 12:02essentially like playing a game of Monopoly, like he's just
- 12:04always Landing in jail and he gets back out and he starts to
- 12:09Some solved by many gets thrown back in jail again, and I feel
- 12:11like it could get really really repetitive and really like it
- 12:16could get grading after a while and yet Chaplin keeps finding
- 12:20fresh ways of making it seem like everything has a cause and
- 12:24effect to it. And I guess that's one of the
- 12:26things that I wanted to point out because I think there's some
- 12:28really solid writing going on in this movie, not just from like a
- 12:32gag standpoint. But overall structure really, I
- 12:35think this movie is a little more solid than City Lights I am
- 12:40with you. I just found myself board
- 12:43throughout this film. Whoa, no, Brad.
- 12:49I didn't want to wait till the very end to drop the bomb on you
- 12:52Bobby, but this movie just didn't move at a pace that felt
- 13:01invigorating or felt like I kept my attention.
- 13:05I found myself multiple times throughout just kind of looking
- 13:10at the clock being like man. We've been doing this whole food
- 13:13machine thing for for quite a bit of time now, haven't we?
- 13:17And it feels like every Go gag goes on like that.
- 13:21Like the the worst one by far was the feeding of the man who's
- 13:26like poking out of the machine and it just goes on and on and
- 13:32then on a little longer and I'm like, I get it.
- 13:35You're feeding him coffee through a chicken now.
- 13:38Like, it's, it's funny. Sure.
- 13:42And I think that's, I mean, we'll get it to my overall
- 13:45thoughts on chaplain in the episode about him.
- 13:48But, Overall with chaplain I think I like him as a silent
- 13:52film director. Much more than these hybrid
- 13:56films or a talky film. There's just I don't know.
- 14:01The the Gold Rush hit for me man and all three of the other ones
- 14:06are fine and good and interesting but not they're not
- 14:09my style man. Wow wow Brad, I I really hate
- 14:14that you feel that way and it bums me out, I was super excited
- 14:18for you to be. Exposed to Chaplin and I thought
- 14:22that this would work better for you than it did.
- 14:25And it's especially a coming off of like, you know, we just
- 14:27re-watched Some Like It Hot for our patrons and did a review of
- 14:32that movie and there's so much physical comedy in that movie,
- 14:35but Brad, I was trying to prepare myself for the
- 14:38eventuality that you may not like this movie.
- 14:40Because usually, the ones that I hold most near and dear to my
- 14:43heart somehow, don't work on your cold, robot heart.
- 14:47And so, I was thinking about it like this, it kind of reminds me
- 14:52of Early Beatles music like, you know, up to and including Like A
- 14:59Hard Day's Night and then you kind of get into their, like
- 15:02their middle period, where they like discover marijuana and not
- 15:06young, not yet LSD, but definitely marijuana revolver.
- 15:10Yeah. And then you've got late-era
- 15:13beetles, which is my favorite period of The Beatles, which is
- 15:16the, Let It Be album and Abbey Road.
- 15:18Like, I'd for, you know, and if the White Album, if you really
- 15:20want to include that like 100 by far, Ste by far, my favorite
- 15:25Beatles era and I would kind of consider the gold rush to be.
- 15:31Like if we're just looking at the four movies, we watched
- 15:35that's like early-to-mid Beatles to me, you know what I mean?
- 15:38Like, it's not super complicated or complex and I, for some
- 15:42reason, I've just always been more drawn to city lights and
- 15:45Modern Times And especially modern times and I think it's
- 15:48because the gags in this movie are the most elaborate gags and
- 15:53I think that it takes it's such a high wire act to be able to
- 15:57pull off some of these gags and especially like, my favorite
- 16:00part of the movie happens. I don't know, 10 minutes into
- 16:03the movie and it's that feeding machine, which I don't think it
- 16:06goes on too long at all. I think it's like probably would
- 16:09be in my top 5 moments of Comedy ever in a movie.
- 16:12It's just, it is perfect physical comedy, but it also has
- 16:16like four minutes of setup of them going into the CEO of the
- 16:21factories office to demo this thing.
- 16:24To them picking out Charlie Chaplin to them.
- 16:26Getting him strapped into it before you get to the machine
- 16:28malfunctioning. There is so much set up to that
- 16:32and it's like you have to be able to deliver the goods with
- 16:36that much set up and I think time and time again with this
- 16:38movie. Chaplain does that.
- 16:41And so I can see why you like the Gold Rush a lot better
- 16:43because that is all that's like immediate set up and pay off.
- 16:46It's like, oh, there's a bear in the cabin and now we're going to
- 16:49fight a bear and it's like, that's all the setup you need.
- 16:53And You get three minutes of humor of him fighting a bear or
- 16:56whatever. But for me, I just think that
- 16:58the, the elaborate nature of all of these running gags in the
- 17:02movie, just kind of pushes this movie over the edge for me into
- 17:07being my favorite one. Bob, is you've just elaborately
- 17:10described. I'm a simple man.
- 17:13With simple tastes. I don't have any any
- 17:16understanding of the, the avant-garde nature of later.
- 17:19Charlie Chaplin not at all. I think that for me, You lose a
- 17:25lot of the life that chaplain brings to the screen when you
- 17:29have these long complicated setups and payoffs.
- 17:33And it's not that he isn't a, it's not that he is an
- 17:37incredible actor and, and has that physical comedy, you know,
- 17:41nailed down, pat, I think it's the fact that there's just not
- 17:43enough life in these films. And for me, the places where
- 17:48this movie worked best was when Paulette Goddard was on the
- 17:52screen. Yeah, let's talk.
- 17:53About her. She is incredible in this movie
- 17:59so I try and tell you last week man cuz she's in The Great
- 18:01Dictator. Yeah.
- 18:03Albeit in a much smaller role and the funny thing is that
- 18:06movie is significantly longer than its against a least 40
- 18:09minutes longer than this movie. But I feel like you barely see
- 18:11Paulette Goddard I'm sure she has like an equivalent amount of
- 18:15screen time but there's just something about the Vibrance of
- 18:19her character in this. She is just a ball of energy and
- 18:22she's matching the Tramp beat for beat.
- 18:25I just like and and the way he shoots her, the way the he
- 18:29lights her even when she has like this greasy, stringy hair
- 18:33of this kind of waif-like creature on the docks.
- 18:36She's just freaking gorgeous man and like it, you know, by far.
- 18:40I think it's the best female pairing of any of the four
- 18:45movies that we watched from Chaplin.
- 18:48Yeah. And she is the reason this movie
- 18:50stayed afloat, I think that as you get Bogged down in Chaplin's
- 18:55political perspective and the way, he utilizes it, very
- 18:59obviously, throughout the movie just kind of slows down too much
- 19:04and, and it struggles, but as soon as Paulette Goddard gets on
- 19:07screen and they're just focused on them dreaming and being in
- 19:11love and scheming and finding ways to make money.
- 19:16I found myself completely enraptured in the story and I
- 19:20think that's my, that's my struggle with this film.
- 19:23Is that there's There's two clear of a divide between the
- 19:27story of you know, the the young girl in the Tramp and their love
- 19:32story and chaplain trying to be a politician or you know, a
- 19:36political satirist at the very least.
- 19:39Yeah. It just doesn't work for me.
- 19:42It's too much. He's trying to do too much, man.
- 19:45I'm going to keep pushing your criticisms to the back burner
- 19:48and talk about other things because we pay, if you got to
- 19:51find a way to fill out the runtime here before you Just
- 19:53crap all over one of my favorite movies and I think that I want
- 19:58to talk about her character a little bit more in that this is
- 20:01the first movie, you know, of the four that we've watched
- 20:04where it is, like the Tramp has a companion throughout the whole
- 20:09movie. And every time he goes to jail,
- 20:11she's there waiting for him when he gets out and it's it follows.
- 20:16I guess what I would say is like a much more conventional rom-com
- 20:20kind of template than any of the other movies do.
- 20:23Even though they're all, you know, romances quote-unquote and
- 20:26they all have comedy in them. This feels very much like the
- 20:29Tramp is dating somebody. And I don't think we've ever
- 20:32really seen that. To this point.
- 20:34What did you think of just that Dynamic Brad?
- 20:36That it wasn't so much him pining for a girl and maybe
- 20:39getting her at the end of the movie, but that she was like,
- 20:42side-by-side with him throughout so much of it.
- 20:45I think that's what made the movie have a driving force.
- 20:49Like, they are partners in crime.
- 20:51They're trying to figure this out together.
- 20:53And I think that speaks to the deepest element of the human
- 20:57soul that like yearns for community in times of difficulty
- 21:03and, and stress. And so, in the midst of all of
- 21:06the Tramp struggles throughout this, you know, once he meets
- 21:09her, I don't know, 30, 40 minutes into the film.
- 21:13Once they connect and stay together the rest of the movie,
- 21:17everything about it is incredible.
- 21:19Like when, when she meets him after his probably, I think his
- 21:23Last time in jail, she is wearing nice clothes for the
- 21:26first time because she found a job as a as a dancing.
- 21:30Waitress and even in that moment like you can see the element of
- 21:38baby driver like when when he finally gets out of jail and
- 21:41she's waiting for him in a beautiful dress and they go off
- 21:43into the sunset together. Like there's this element of It
- 21:50just speaks to the the core desire of humans to be
- 21:53connected. And she has so much life and so
- 21:57much energy that I'm 100% bought in on that element of this film.
- 22:05Alright. I think that in all of the
- 22:07episodes we've done on chaplain so far and this is kind of
- 22:10something that when we do comedies I always feel like we
- 22:13back load the episode with stuff about the comedy because we get
- 22:16too bogged down and talking about the details of the A movie
- 22:19on the front end. So I want to flip that around
- 22:21today. I can tell that you're not a
- 22:24huge fan of this movie Brad, but I imagine that there were at
- 22:27least a couple gags that really worked for you in this movie
- 22:30because there's so many of them. So, before we go to break, why
- 22:33don't we talk about what pieces of Comedy, or which gags worked
- 22:37for you, which piece of Comedy are gags.
- 22:41Worked for me. I think that the the food
- 22:44machine is funny but the setup took so long that it detracted
- 22:48for me. Just just the scene of him being
- 22:51fed food is incredible. And it puts on show.
- 22:56What we talked about in the Gold Rush episode when he does the
- 23:00little dancing with, you know, the little feet on Chopsticks
- 23:04basically. Yeah.
- 23:05Like it's that all over again. Like your clothes up to his face
- 23:10every single time that silly like mouth washing thing that
- 23:15like wipes, his mouth off comes to them, they like surprises in
- 23:18it. It's just perfect.
- 23:20And I think that's where his comedy is at its best and when
- 23:25they put the. So the whole setup of this thing
- 23:28is like this company has invented a feeding machine, so
- 23:31that workers really never even need to leave the assembly line.
- 23:34They can basically get strapped into this, this big turntable
- 23:37with food on it and the Machine feeds the worker hands-free.
- 23:41And of course, they try it out on Charlie Chaplin and
- 23:43everything. Goes awry.
- 23:44And one of the items on this big like, turntable is an ear of
- 23:48corn. And he's, 'I think this corn on
- 23:51the cob and it's like rotating as he's eating it and it starts
- 23:55to malfunction and it's going faster and faster and faster.
- 23:57And then it's sliding back and forth across his face and just
- 24:01see his nose contorting. And it finally it finally stops
- 24:05after it's like scrambled his brains and you get a moment of
- 24:09respite and then it goes right back into it again and it's the
- 24:13timing of that and they finally get this thing down after 30
- 24:17seconds of, you know, No abuse from this ear of corn.
- 24:21And then this the little sponge just slowly comes over to wipe
- 24:25his mouth again. Every time they use that little
- 24:28like napkin thing on a swivel. It's like the perfect amount of
- 24:35like just slow like defeat you don't hit me at.
- 24:39I just think that the way that that scene is choreographed is
- 24:43just beautiful, it's so funny. It kind of reminds me of the
- 24:48Timing of When Harry Met Sally, when they're at the football
- 24:52game and it's like the punch line hits when they're doing the
- 24:55line every single time the wave hits their part of the stadium.
- 24:58Yeah. And it feels like that.
- 25:00There's like three or four times where it comes over to wipe his
- 25:03face and it's just adding insult to injury, right?
- 25:07One little throwaway gag that I was losing it over, is what it
- 25:13is. When he takes the little hand
- 25:15auger and he cuts holes into the cheese, Make a little slice of
- 25:20Swiss cheese something that's not swiss cheese.
- 25:23Yeah, that I don't know why out of all the gags in this film,
- 25:28that one killed me because it took like seven seconds and you
- 25:33don't totally get what he's doing at first.
- 25:35But then you see him chop it off and like, look at it and you're
- 25:37like, oh, you just made such ease and that, that was probably
- 25:42my favorite gag in the whole film.
- 25:44If anyone out there has never seen a movie this old, and I
- 25:48would, Imagine that most of our audience has never seen a movie
- 25:50from 1936 or before. Don't ever let anybody tell you
- 25:54that they weren't dealing with modern problems because this
- 25:58movie, that was shown to men, women and children in 1936
- 26:02contains an extended sequence where in chaplain is high on
- 26:04cocaine and he, yeah, like I, like, Charlie Chaplin on cocaine
- 26:12is the funniest thing in the world to me because so, he's in,
- 26:15he's in jail, and he's in the mess hall, he's eating his food.
- 26:18Food in the guy next to him sees that the heat is on and he's
- 26:22being suspected of smuggling in cocaine, which he did, he puts
- 26:26it in, what looks like a salt shaker.
- 26:28But I think it's being used as like parmesan cheese or
- 26:30something, men and chaplain, unknowingly picks it up and salt
- 26:34his food with it, and then starts eating his food and the
- 26:37face he makes when the cocaine hits is.
- 26:41Well, I think you could fool, the Imagine surfing what he's
- 26:45seeing it is so funny and I guess it's one of those things.
- 26:48Where, you know, the the Hays code that we talked about this
- 26:52idea of like the the film sensors that became prevalent in
- 26:55American Cinema from the late 30s, all the way through to the
- 26:581960s, we're just being put in place and chaplain really,
- 27:03obviously really railed against the censorship of it.
- 27:06But I think sometimes when you go back and watch movies this
- 27:09old you think that the farther back you go, the more quaint the
- 27:14more unrealistic they'll be and it's just really funny to me
- 27:18because if you go back far enough you get back to being
- 27:21before the times when they started censoring stuff and then
- 27:24you can just have a scene where a guy is high on cocaine and
- 27:27like there's there's something about watching a movie this old
- 27:30and seeing the cocaine scene that you're like oh we're just
- 27:33watching a we're just watching The Wolf of Wall Street.
- 27:35It's just you know, 90 years ago.
- 27:38Yeah, the the reality is he stops a prison break out because
- 27:42he's high on cocaine, he gets completely drunk in the
- 27:46department store and is fired because of it like it.
- 27:50The, the the themes that they bring out in this film, I was
- 27:54like Blown Away by because they have a title card or, you know,
- 27:59a subtitle card during the cocaine scene.
- 28:03And they just what, I forget, the term that they use was it
- 28:06knows power. Nose powder that was like whoa
- 28:10whoa whoa. It's Charlie talking about
- 28:12cocaine here and sure enough he's dummy.
- 28:15Okay, sure is nothing man. No, I think the overarching
- 28:22message is when stuff gets hard you need to abuse hard drugs,
- 28:26right? Like that's it that's the
- 28:28lesson. We need to take away from
- 28:29Charlie Chan. Yeah.
- 28:31If your nose isn't just plastered with white powder, I
- 28:35mean that would be part of the whole gag is.
- 28:37He's like He's salting a thing and then he wipes his nose and
- 28:40he just yeah there's Coke all over his face.
- 28:43It's great. All right man.
- 28:45Well on that note it is time for us to indulge in addictive
- 28:48substances and we're going to try some Widow, Jane Lucky 13.
- 28:52What do you say? Did my buddy went on like a full
- 28:56everything fast for 14 days and he continued to not drink
- 29:00alcohol for like another 14 days after that and he was just like,
- 29:04dude, I had a drink of whiskey the other day.
- 29:07Day and it tasted like poison. And I was like, yeah, it
- 29:11literally is poisonous when it's delicious.
- 29:14Let's drink some delicious poison together bread.
- 29:17Let's get to it. All right.
- 29:24So today we are checking out Widow.
- 29:26Jane Lucky 13. This is the first time we've
- 29:29tried Widow, Jane on this podcast.
- 29:31I've been really, really wanting to try it for a long time.
- 29:34Lisa, Roper wicker, who used to be their Master distiller, just
- 29:38moved back to Kentucky and she is at Town Branch.
- 29:41Now, she's going to be their Master distiller, and so we
- 29:43missed out on her. I really wanted her to come on
- 29:45the show and I was like, oh, we'll plan a whole episode
- 29:48around interviewing her and And drinking some Widow Jane and it
- 29:51never materialized Brad. And so we've had a sample of
- 29:54Widow Jane sitting in our homes, for probably, I don't know, two
- 29:58years. Now this sample that we're
- 30:00drinking today was sent to us by our friend, Austin Dupree, who
- 30:03you can find on social media at bourbon earring.
- 30:06This is like I said, it's called lucky thirteen.
- 30:09It's a 13 year old barrel of whiskey.
- 30:12The one that you can typically pick up off shelves is a blend.
- 30:16But this one were drinking. Today is a barrel pick that was
- 30:20By the bourbon Society of Baton Rouge.
- 30:22So Brad, we typically don't like to review Whiskey's that are
- 30:26labeled as like Single Barrel just because I hate that like
- 30:30we're only ever going to review whiskey once, right, if we hate
- 30:33what it tastes like, we're not going to recommend it and we
- 30:35always put the caveat on it that, yes, this is from one
- 30:38single barrel, there's variance. You know, from Barrel the
- 30:41barrel. I don't mind doing it like this
- 30:43case. Yeah, it's not one single barrel
- 30:45from two years ago. Well yeah, but also I don't mind
- 30:49doing It this way. Because if we like this, I think
- 30:53that we can really heartily recommend it and then what
- 30:56people are getting off, the shelves is essentially the small
- 30:58batch version of that. So there's less variance and I
- 31:01kind of like doing it this way more than I like doing it the
- 31:03other way. So, I'm really excited to dive
- 31:05into this, man. I'm sure that you have tried
- 31:07this already. I'm trying it live on air.
- 31:10Do you have any thoughts on it before?
- 31:12We just Dive Right In. Not a single one.
- 31:15I didn't take any notes. I just have a final score for
- 31:18you. Bob once again, a man of Simple
- 31:20Pleasures, and thought us, Bob, this is a delicious whiskey that
- 31:26I'm excited for you to get into the color on.
- 31:29This bad boy is very deep, very dark, almost a reddish Hue,
- 31:34which I really like, I don't really know what to make of
- 31:37that, but it looks damn cool in my glass.
- 31:43I like your take their papa. What does it look like, damn,
- 31:47cool. And cool.
- 31:48This is really spicy on the nose.
- 31:51I like it a lot. It has like a ton of Oak spice
- 31:54to it. I don't know if that makes
- 31:55sense. Like Oak is not a spice, but it
- 31:57smells Dusty and smells like, you know, newly charred Barrel,
- 32:01but it has kind of a floral almost saw Dusty kind of thing
- 32:05going on as well. I think there's quite a bit of
- 32:08vanilla on this, but it, I don't know.
- 32:11Brad, it almost reminds me of that sort of, like, rose that I
- 32:15get on, will it products sometimes, but with a much more
- 32:19potent, Kind of prickly cinnamon to go with it, too.
- 32:22I like this, a lot on the nose. Yeah, I really enjoyed this.
- 32:27I myself found a lot of cherry on the nose.
- 32:31There was caramel, there is vanilla the oakiness came
- 32:34through after a few noses of it and then like, as I spent time
- 32:40with it I got creamsicle like it like a really sugary creamy
- 32:45orange note and then it just hit me out of nowhere like a freight
- 32:49train. And all the peanut butter in the
- 32:51world. Like just the creamiest peanut
- 32:54butter knows I think I've ever smelled it on a whiskey.
- 32:57I give it a 9 out of 10 on the nose Bob.
- 32:59Yeah, I'm going to stick it in eight and a half for right now,
- 33:01just because it's continuing to open up for me.
- 33:04I think if anything the one thing I can say about this is
- 33:07it's a really complex nose and I think that the bourbon Society
- 33:10picked a really good Barrel, just in terms of finding
- 33:13complexity, so eight and a half for me. 94, Brad let's dive into
- 33:17the taste. Yeah, on the tasty.
- 33:20I got a bunch of cherry caramel vanilla, all the nice things.
- 33:25The peanut butter turned into a true peanut flavor for me, but
- 33:30the, the overwhelming flavor I got on.
- 33:32This was just a really nice hunk of salted butter.
- 33:38It just had so much butteriness to it and not like the, like,
- 33:44the texture was buttery and smooth, but the actual flavor
- 33:48reminded me of salted butter. And I really, really enjoyed it.
- 33:52I came down a little bit from the nose, but this is an eight
- 33:54and a half on the pallet for me. I think it stays really spicy.
- 33:58I think it stays really prickly on the pallet.
- 34:00For me. This is just very, very heavily
- 34:03charred Oak and it's man. It's different than I need to
- 34:07develop some sort of metric for, like, when I taste burnt things,
- 34:11and what it means because it sometimes I talk about Ash,
- 34:14sometimes I talk about like cigar This reminds me more of
- 34:18like a cigarette. Ash like it's it tastes like how
- 34:21an ashtray smells and I don't necessarily mean that in a bad
- 34:25way but I'm not getting a lot of the sweeter notes that you're
- 34:28getting on this Brad. I think for me the Char really
- 34:31takes over and dominates on the palette, I don't mind it but it
- 34:36also doesn't have as much complexity to me as the nose
- 34:39did. And it's definitely not coming
- 34:41in waves or layers or building upon anything.
- 34:44So I'm just going to give it a 7 out of 10.
- 34:46And on the pallet for me that I'm kind of with you on this
- 34:51this whiskey disappearing but it does it for me on the finish.
- 34:55It really like literally the words I wrote were disappears
- 34:59into Oak bits of vanilla and Cherry remain like that.
- 35:03There's just not enough going on on the finish for me to go man,
- 35:07this has been a great experience throughout.
- 35:10I give it a 7 out of 10 on the finish.
- 35:12I think if I can like approximate The Sensation that
- 35:16I'm getting on the Finish. It's almost like if you could
- 35:20make the Americanized version of like a really heavily peated
- 35:24scotch and it's like the most PD version.
- 35:28Yeah. And then like this is just so
- 35:30strongly Char and Ash forward that it's like man, I don't
- 35:36know. It's like a campfire that got
- 35:38rained on, it's like old timing 1980s.
- 35:43You're in a wood-paneled house and someone is smoking like
- 35:46Really bad Pall Malls or something, like it's just
- 35:50cigarettes, dude. I don't know how else to explain
- 35:52this. I don't like me.
- 35:54That's not my cup of tea. I don't think this is a poorly
- 35:58made whiskey but not like, you're not a chain smoker but
- 36:00I'm not a big fan of ashtray licking.
- 36:05Yeah man. Damn.
- 36:06I want this to be sweeter and I want it to be more complex than
- 36:09it is. Especially at 13 years.
- 36:11I thought this was going to have some like some real richness to
- 36:14it. I'm not a huge fan of this.
- 36:16I'm gonna give it a six and a half on the Finish.
- 36:19Bob, I don't often do this with whiskey.
- 36:23I'm more than willing to call you out where you're wrong and
- 36:26other places in life but you know was he's a subjective
- 36:28experience sir. I think you're crazy.
- 36:31Hmm. Like I don't know what you're
- 36:33talking about here with Ash and cigarettes at like like I get
- 36:38it. There's a lot of oakiness and a
- 36:39little bit of spiciness that comes off of that but I don't
- 36:42know every other time you've talked about like Char and Ash
- 36:46and And I'm like oh yeah I can get that.
- 36:48I can see that the I'm not getting it on this one man the
- 36:53this one it like it definitely disappoints a little bit at the
- 36:55end but not because it tastes like an ashtray.
- 36:58Yeah you know what like I'm on my fourth sip of it now and I'm
- 37:00trying to distinguish it because it it's a combination of like
- 37:04Char but then it also gets really bitter for me towards the
- 37:07end and I think that bitterness is presenting as like what I
- 37:11remember cigarette, Ash being but I think it might be two
- 37:14different things happening at the same time.
- 37:16I'm and that bitterness is like I don't know like really really
- 37:20bitter grapefruit peel like a grapefruit rind.
- 37:24It's really strongly better for me.
- 37:26Almost a vegetal kind of a thing and yeah so like I said I don't
- 37:31think that this is a bad whiskey.
- 37:32It's just like very far outside of my preferred wheelhouse and
- 37:38so when it comes to the balance on this, I think I'm actually
- 37:41going to give it a pretty decent balance score because I think
- 37:44there is someone out there that this Whiskey is for.
- 37:48It is just not Bob book and so I'm going to give it a actually,
- 37:52I'm given the 8 out of 10 on balance that's higher than I
- 37:57gave it. I give it a 7 and a half out of
- 37:58ten on balance. It has like a really great
- 38:01opening knows it, blossoms beautifully and then it just
- 38:05kind of slowly finishes at an average place and yet, there's
- 38:10enough complexity to keep this balance score up there, you
- 38:13know, I give it a 7 and a half out of ten when we get.
- 38:16Into value Bobby. This is a tough one because it's
- 38:20not available anymore. You can't go down to the Baton
- 38:23society and get this anymore. However, this from what I have
- 38:28looked up, these bottles usually are around $100 for a Widow,
- 38:33Jane Barrel pick. It is listed at those state of
- 38:35Ohio on the OHL Cube website as 9999.
- 38:39So there you go. That's the that's the MSRP.
- 38:41We're going to be working with Again, Brad, you know, we talked
- 38:44about this last week, you know, sometimes when you drink of
- 38:47whiskey, you say, like that's a thirty dollar whiskey and you
- 38:50don't actually mean, I think this whiskey should cost $30,
- 38:54you know, when taking the production into consideration,
- 38:57we're just saying, like, hey, if you gave this to me blind, this
- 39:01is how much I would say I would pay for this.
- 39:03Yep, I think $99 seems like a lot of money but a 13-year
- 39:09bourbon from a, you know, it's sourced.
- 39:11But it's from a small Our, I understand why.
- 39:14The price point on this is $99 now taking that into
- 39:18consideration. Is this worth paying $99 for?
- 39:21No, I don't think it is. So like, I don't think it's
- 39:24necessarily overpriced. I just don't like the whiskey in
- 39:28the bottle. So at this price point, I will
- 39:31give it a six point five out of ten on value because I think I'm
- 39:34trying to split the difference between, yes, it's a reasonable
- 39:38price but also know, I don't like it that much.
- 39:41Yeah, you think too much Bob's it will score?
- 39:44I do I give it a six out of ten on value.
- 39:48Hmm I think it's an okay value in the world of single barrels.
- 39:53I think that if they just worked on the finish a little bit that
- 39:57if there's a little more complexity on the finish, this
- 40:00would be like a eight out of ten value.
- 40:02It's it's a really interesting whiskey that I will recommend.
- 40:06I'm coming to a 38 out of 50 Bob, wow.
- 40:09Yeah, I think we're both a little bit higher than I
- 40:11thought. I thought that we would be like
- 40:12just taking our words into consideration.
- 40:15I'm at a 36 and a half out of 50 so we're coming to a seventy
- 40:18four point five out of 100 or thirty-seven point.
- 40:22Two five out of 50 on average. I will very cautiously recommend
- 40:28this as a try. It not so much as a by it.
- 40:33Like you know you want to try something new at the bar.
- 40:35I imagine that a poor. This is going to run you
- 40:37somewhere between ten and fifteen dollars like I don't
- 40:40think that's an astronomical. Think to ask for a poor of this
- 40:43it's it's Unique for sure and I think that if you like your
- 40:47whiskies Less on the sweet side and more on the sort of like
- 40:51spice Char side of things, this might be right up your alley.
- 40:56Yeah. I mean this is not a helpful
- 40:59review Bob because I'm gonna say that I thought this was a lot
- 41:02sweeter than that. It had some Savory notes but it
- 41:05was in the realm of like a peanut butter that is kind of
- 41:09sweet in its own right as well. So I think that this was a
- 41:12really, really great whiskey that had a few things hampering
- 41:15it. But yeah, I would recommend
- 41:17trying or buying like if you've had Widow Jane before and you're
- 41:20thinking about getting a single barrel like go for it.
- 41:23I think that they have some really interesting stuff coming
- 41:26out there. All right man what do you say?
- 41:28We get back into talking about modern times, let's get to it.
- 41:36All right, everybody that was widowed Jane. 13-year Barrel.
- 41:41Pick a whiskey that we liked this, fine?
- 41:46Yeah, yeah, we liked it. Yeah.
- 41:50You know what I like Bob is it Canada's favorite segments?
- 41:54It, sure is. We're talking two facts and a
- 41:58falsehood is gonna try to stop you.
- 42:01Bob All right. And what is wrong to fax in a
- 42:08faucet? To fact, in a falsehood is the
- 42:11part of the podcast where Brad presents three items to me, as
- 42:15fact about the making of this movie, one of which is a
- 42:18complete fabrication and it is my job to suss out belie Brad.
- 42:23I don't remember how I'm doing on the season right now.
- 42:25I think I was at 500 after Mariah, five and seven Robert
- 42:32also, I lost two in a row after Marie.
- 42:33Maya, help me out. Dang dude, I got to make up some
- 42:36ground here. Did you go easy on me?
- 42:39This week is the question. I think I did.
- 42:42I really this was a tough week. I will challenge any of you
- 42:46trying to come up with lies about a movie that are like,
- 42:51convincing is really hard and I'm quite proud of my 7 and 5
- 42:56record. I was gonna say, especially when
- 42:58the movie is almost 90 years old.
- 43:00Yeah, it's not easy. All right.
- 43:03Hit me with your two facts and a falsehood fact.
- 43:06Number one, the machine that Sir Charles Chaplin goes through
- 43:09like a film projector was made of rubber and would rather than
- 43:13steel but was still quite uncomfortable enough.
- 43:16So that chaplain only wanted to do it once to show him going
- 43:19backward. Again chaplain simply played the
- 43:21film backward. Fax number two chaplain
- 43:25considered this one of the finest films that he ever made
- 43:29saying that it was the quote cleverest and most brilliant
- 43:32film I've ever met. Made fact, number three, several
- 43:36sequences were cut before the release on the recommendation of
- 43:39the Hays office. According to a January, 6, 1936,
- 43:43Memo from Joseph Greene. The eliminations needed because
- 43:46of vulgarity were the first part of the pansy gag.
- 43:50No doubt referring to the jail cell mate.
- 43:52Who's knitting disconcerts? Charlie number two.
- 43:55The word dope in a printed title.
- 43:57And number three, most of the business of the stomach rumbling
- 44:00on the part of The Minister's Wife and Charles But the cocaine
- 44:04was good. We were fine with that.
- 44:06Right. Totally fine with the cocaine
- 44:09chaplain when talking about mr. Hayes, who was I think a
- 44:15minister of some sort. Before he took on this role, he
- 44:18was quoted as saying I don't like censorship of any kind, but
- 44:21I especially don't like Presbyterian censorship.
- 44:24And so I just, I really like such a good quote.
- 44:29Yeah, man. There's some really there's some
- 44:31really fun little tidbits about the Hays code.
- 44:33Code. And the making of this movie,
- 44:35apparently, you know, the beginning of the movie, where
- 44:38the Tramp goes into the bathroom to smoke a cigarette, just to
- 44:40get away from the grind of everything.
- 44:43Chaplin had a sign hung outside of the men's stalls.
- 44:47That said welcome, mr. Hayes like into into the the
- 44:50toilet. I really liked that a lot.
- 44:53I think three is true. I think one is true.
- 44:56I'm going to say to is the falsehood and I'm really did not
- 44:58basing that on anything except it just sounded the most like
- 45:01something you might have made up.
- 45:03So Number two is the falsehood fact.
- 45:05Number two, the quotes, the cleverest and most brilliant
- 45:10film I've ever made is a quote that Charles Chaplin said.
- 45:14However, he said it about his 1947 film, I don't remember the
- 45:19name of it, I think that would be miss your will do.
- 45:22Yeah. That was one server.
- 45:24Do I say it was a French title. There it is.
- 45:27So I win. Nailed it.
- 45:28Bob you won. Six and seven.
- 45:32I'm sneaking back into it, man. You are the Cleveland Browns of
- 45:37the filmin, whiskey world. I really thought that I would
- 45:40clean up throughout the four weeks of chaplain.
- 45:42And you bested me? Yeah, that was man.
- 45:47Well, well played sir. I'm happy to play you to a draw
- 45:51on these four weeks. I appreciate it.
- 45:54I was worried, man. I was waiting for a 4 and 0 on
- 45:56your on your part. I want to talk a little bit
- 45:59about this movie as kind of like a contemporary comment on things
- 46:04that we're going on at the time. And part of it is because right
- 46:07before it like, literally, right before we press record, I was on
- 46:09Twitter and I was reading this quote from the director, Steven
- 46:12Soderbergh, he was talking about how he hates using cell phones
- 46:18in movies. Like, he thinks that depicting
- 46:21phones in movies has ruined movies because it just takes the
- 46:24drama out of everything. It is so hard to like,
- 46:28Cinematically depict. Someone sending a text message
- 46:31and I still don't think Hollywood has figured out like
- 46:33the best way to do that and he was commenting on that and the
- 46:37person who shared this quote was talking about basically listed
- 46:40out all of what we would consider to be the most
- 46:43important filmmakers and how many years it's been since
- 46:47they've made a movie set contemporaneously.
- 46:51Hmm. And it's just really
- 46:53fascinating, because I feel like the farther we go into this like
- 46:56World of cell phones, the less Lawmakers are actually engaging
- 46:59with this world and yet that's because people suck that are on
- 47:03a cell phone. Well, I hope people people sucks
- 47:06during the Great Depression that was going to be my Segway Brad.
- 47:09Like and yet here's Chaplin doing it in 1940 with the Great
- 47:13Dictator doing it here in 1936 with modern times.
- 47:17I guess I just want to hear your impressions of like Imagine
- 47:21you're an audience member in 1936.
- 47:24Like what, what is your impression of this movie as it's
- 47:27speaking to your contemporary time, man.
- 47:33I mean I think that a vast swath of America didn't live in the
- 47:38city still then. So I feel like a lot of the
- 47:42elements of like it, you know, it's very clearly set in like a
- 47:46New York City Style Place geography.
- 47:50And so So I wonder if that would not relate to everyone's super.
- 47:54Well, I think the elements of it that relate are the places of
- 47:58man. I just feel like I can't keep a
- 48:01job. No matter what I do, man.
- 48:03I like, I just want to get ahead and care for my the woman that I
- 48:07love, but it just feels like such, everything keeps pushing
- 48:10me down, you know, and I already reference this movie once but it
- 48:14reminds me of The Grapes of Wrath with, you know, the best
- 48:17part of that film, which is the speech that is given about,
- 48:20like, who can I Go shoot and he's like, wow, this guy does
- 48:23this and but he's owned by the Banks.
- 48:25And the banks are owned by the stockholders of the stockholders
- 48:27are owned by these people. And, and like this felt like a
- 48:31comedy version of that speech. And and so, I think that there's
- 48:36definitely elements of this, that would work as a, you know,
- 48:42current reflection current in 1936 of what's going on in the
- 48:47world around them. And I would imagine that it
- 48:50would capture the Rada nation of people to say yes, like this is
- 48:53what I'm going through. Brad.
- 48:56I think that watching this movie.
- 48:57Now, you kind of have to step back a little bit and think
- 49:01about all the things that Chaplin was depicting on screen.
- 49:04As kind of like this fantastic goal.
- 49:07Heightened version of reality, almost science fiction, e at the
- 49:10beginning of the movie, and I think Chaplin was really heavily
- 49:12influenced by a movie that I think we referenced.
- 49:15When Mariah was here, Fritz Lang's movie metropolis and this
- 49:20idea of this giant machine that we are like feeding people into
- 49:25like, it's Devouring humans chaplain goes into the machine
- 49:29but even this idea of, you know, the CEO of the company is
- 49:33sitting up in his office doing nothing but jigsaw puzzles and
- 49:36then surveilling everyone but you know, it's like for us to
- 49:41watch that we're like, oh yeah, he's looking at the the CCTV.
- 49:44He's watching the cameras, they didn't have surveillance like
- 49:47that in 1936 know, here's chalalan, that hit that hit me
- 49:51man, here's Chaplin depicting. This big brother kind of thing
- 49:55and not only He is he like able to watch each sector of the
- 49:58factory. He has like a TV screen and like
- 50:02commercial television was not a thing yet.
- 50:03I think the first I'm looking at it right now.
- 50:06Google. The first successful
- 50:07demonstration of a television was 1927 but they were not a
- 50:11real thing in American Homes until like the 1940s and even
- 50:14after that and so here you have the very first time anyone ever
- 50:19speaks in a Charlie Chaplin movie, it's mediated through
- 50:24this gigantic TV. Green.
- 50:26It's the CEO talking to a guy down on the floor, telling him
- 50:30to like increase the speed on a conveyor belt and we're just
- 50:34watching it like, oh yeah, he's just popping up on the screen.
- 50:36He's telling this guy what to do.
- 50:37That's not a thing that existed. It's just this thing that
- 50:40chaplain inserted and it's a really brilliant little comedic
- 50:43and cinematic touch, but it's also so clever that.
- 50:47Yes, he's going to use some sound in his movie now, but even
- 50:50in using the sound, it's kind of a commentary on the whole thing,
- 50:54like he's only Using sound when it's mediated through a machine.
- 50:59And then like the real people, the real world of this movie is
- 51:01still silent. I just, I really love everything
- 51:04about that opening sequence in the factory.
- 51:06I think it's the strongest part of the movie, honestly?
- 51:09Yeah, I mean, the the places that he uses sound are from the
- 51:14voices that he hates the most, as a filmmaker, right?
- 51:19And in that place you start to realize like this is a meta
- 51:23commentary on the Movement of Motion Pictures towards sound,
- 51:28like he's not pumped about it. And so the only place is he's
- 51:31going to put sound in our, in the, the stuff that the audience
- 51:34is is told to dislike, you know, as you're watching this film.
- 51:38So yeah, I think it's interesting and I think that he,
- 51:42you definitely understand how water Theory would come about
- 51:47with directors. Like, you know, Charles Chaplin
- 51:50in the rearview mirror of like, yeah, this is how it's been from
- 51:53the very start. You have guys like Chaplin who
- 51:55are, you know, famously fastidious and meticulous about
- 51:59the way his movies are made all the way through people, you
- 52:02know, like Kubrick and and Beyond Yeah I totally agree but
- 52:06I also think that you know it's not just like the voices that he
- 52:10hates that he puts sound in the mouth of like he kind of also
- 52:13has some fun with the idea of letting the Tramp speak because
- 52:16that's what people really wanted to hear.
- 52:17They wanted to see the Tramp become a sound figure and so at
- 52:21the end of this movie after you know 20 years plus of playing
- 52:25this character chaplains like I'm gonna have the Tramp sing a
- 52:29song. The first thing that you hear
- 52:32come out of the tramps mouth in beautiful.
- 52:35That sound is a song that he is singing in a nonsense made-up
- 52:40language because he forgets the lyrics in English and it's just
- 52:43it's a really funny little like yep.
- 52:46The Tramp sings also he doesn't speak English and he doesn't
- 52:50speak any discernible language that humans would recognize.
- 52:53And I just I kind of like, you know, to your point he's not
- 52:57super pumped about the prospect of sound and so he's like, yeah,
- 52:59I'll do it. But he's not going to speak a
- 53:01real language. Yeah, I mean honestly it felt
- 53:04like almost like a In Williams type of gag right?
- 53:08Where he's just speaking complete gibberish and because
- 53:11of his physicality and what he's bringing to the screen, it comes
- 53:15to life and that. And that's that's the charm of
- 53:19Chaplin, right? It's his physicality.
- 53:21It's the way he draws you into his characters through his body
- 53:26language. And I think that you get a final
- 53:29send off to the Tramp in a really beautiful reminder that
- 53:33it's not his voice in the words that he is.
- 53:35Saying that matters, it's who he is as a person and you don't
- 53:38need words to express that. And I think, you know, in the
- 53:43modern times, you know, from from 1930 on once we've had had
- 53:48sound. I think that the best actors in
- 53:51the world, consistently, remember the message of chaplain
- 53:54that you don't have to use complicated dialogue to bring a
- 53:58character to life for a before we get into, you know, our last
- 54:02couple segments of the day here, I want to talk about the ending
- 54:04of this movie and just Pick your brain a little bit about it
- 54:06because basically our two main characters cannot get ahead in
- 54:11life and when things are really, really looking up for them,
- 54:15their past comes back to find them and they are back to square
- 54:18one at the end of this movie. And not only are they at square
- 54:21one, like it fades in and says it's Dawn and you see them
- 54:25sleeping on the side of the road in just a complete like
- 54:28desolate. Like, they're not even near the
- 54:30city anymore, they've had to completely leave the city
- 54:33because there's so little opportunity for them there.
- 54:36And the girl is saying like, what is the point of even trying
- 54:39anymore? And the background music is the,
- 54:42the melody, to the song smile, which became a standard and a
- 54:45very famous song that chaplain wrote.
- 54:48And the send-off that they get is he says like hey we gotta
- 54:52keep trying, I know it sucks. Let's just try it again.
- 54:55And they start walking off into the distance and then they pause
- 54:57for a second and compose themselves.
- 55:00And he tells her to smile and they walk off smiling.
- 55:03And yet it's like the most ambiguous.
- 55:05Louis kind of sad ending. And I think it really says a lot
- 55:09about the fact that this movie was made in the middle of the
- 55:12Great Depression. Like there is no end in sight to
- 55:14this, there is no light. At the end of the tunnel Chaplin
- 55:17himself doesn't know how this is gonna go.
- 55:19And he has kind of the balls to end his movie.
- 55:23And basically say goodbye to the Tramp in such an ambiguous way.
- 55:28You know, Brad you've now seen the three most famous examples
- 55:31of the Tramp on screen. What do you think of the way
- 55:34that he sends this? Dr. Off.
- 55:37I think it totally makes sense for the character.
- 55:40Like if you consider the Tramp as a long form, study of, you
- 55:46know, a character, he continues off into the sunset the way he
- 55:50starts with uncertainty and positivity.
- 55:54He doesn't know where he's going.
- 55:55He doesn't know where his next meal is coming from.
- 55:58The only thing he knows is that he loves this girl and he'll do
- 56:02whatever it takes to make the future better.
- 56:05Them and that feels like the American story in a lot of ways.
- 56:10And so I love the way he sends off the Tramp.
- 56:13All right, man with that, it is time for our last segment of the
- 56:16day which we call. Let's make it a double we near
- 56:19the end of the episode. So thanks for listening to the
- 56:22film and whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 56:25this one. Even if it's struggle, it's a
- 56:27final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 56:30Let's make it. A double is the part of the
- 56:31show, where we pick a movie to pair up with this one to make
- 56:34the perfect. Feature Braddock kind of sounds
- 56:37like you already have maybe the best possible choice for this.
- 56:41I do Bob, what movie are you referring to?
- 56:44I mean, you've talked about The Grapes of Wrath like three times
- 56:46already, so I just kind of figured we're going here.
- 56:49No. No, I'm course not any.
- 56:51No, no, that would be way too much sense.
- 56:52Yeah, come on, come on, come on. I'm going to recommend a movie
- 56:56that is about one man fighting against the system.
- 57:00And questioning everything that has you know, made him who he
- 57:04is. And Questioning, the world
- 57:06that's been built up around him. I'm going to recommend that you
- 57:10watch 1982's Blade. Runner Blade Runner.
- 57:15I thought you're gonna say ET. Damn it.
- 57:17Yep, that's definitely the movie.
- 57:19I'm going to recommend but listen, I would Perry T up with
- 57:22anything. I don't care what you say.
- 57:23Yeah. All right.
- 57:24Well, lead role where Man versus machine, I like it.
- 57:28Brad. I think that you could go a lot
- 57:29of different directions with this.
- 57:30I think you could pair this up with a movie like Metropolis to
- 57:33kind of go with the man versus machine.
- 57:35Eames. I think you could pair It Up
- 57:37With The Grapes of Wrath as you've been talking about, I'm
- 57:39actually going to go ahead and pair it up with another Charlie
- 57:42Chaplin movie and it's probably his next most famous one that we
- 57:45didn't get to its movie called The Circus.
- 57:48And it was the reason that I started talking about all the
- 57:50Beatles stuff earlier, because if I could recommend to you
- 57:53Brad, one more movie that I think you would actually like a,
- 57:56a lot more than these last few that we've watched.
- 57:59I think you should watch the circus.
- 58:00It's the closest in tone to the Gold Rush, which you really Seem
- 58:05to like a lot more but I think it also has that the kind of
- 58:09ambiguous ending that you get here with the Tramp which is
- 58:13like I've talked about it a couple times.
- 58:15He's not dumb, he's maybe a little bit too trusting and at
- 58:18the end of the movie, he walks off into the sunset and he
- 58:21breathes a heavy sigh. And he's learned A Life Lesson,
- 58:24and it's not necessarily him in a happier place, but it's him,
- 58:28learning and moving on to the next thing.
- 58:30And I think the endings of both of these movies are so
- 58:33reminiscent of each other. That I'm going to go.
- 58:35Ahead and pair it up with the circus.
- 58:37So, Brad picks, Blade Runner. I pick the circus and that means
- 58:41that it's time for final scores, man.
- 58:44Brad, I'm a little bit nervous. I don't know where you're going
- 58:46to go with this, but the floor is yours, sir.
- 58:49Well, I mean, I assume that I know what you're going to give
- 58:52this Bob. I am going to give modern times
- 58:58A seven and a half out of 10. Damn dude.
- 59:09I like at the end of the day, I don't think I'll ever like, sit
- 59:14down and watch this movie again. And like for me that has become
- 59:19a differentiation between eight and under, like, if I'm gonna
- 59:23give a movie an 8 out of 10, it's got to be a movie that I'm
- 59:26like, oh I really want to revisit this at some point.
- 59:29And this movie just there were moments that were quirky and
- 59:33funny and worked for me. But overall it just didn't do
- 59:37enough to move me into that realm of An eight or higher.
- 59:40So so seven and a half out of ten.
- 59:43Yeah. This is a ten out of ten.
- 59:44Like, I think this time through having watched it like 30 times
- 59:48before I was like, all right, this is kind of dragging and
- 59:50parts for me. Maybe I'll give it a nine and a
- 59:52half this time and then I'm like oh Brad gave it a 7 and a half
- 59:55out of ten. No, I'm giving us a 10, it's
- 59:58you're not basing the score on on your watch of the movie, your
- 1:00:03solely basing it to spite me, I mean, okay, if it's a difference
- 1:00:07between a nine and a half and a 10, If you want me to give it a
- 1:00:109 and a half I will. How about that?
- 1:00:11I'll give it a nine point five out of ten.
- 1:00:14Bob, this is your moral movie conscience that we're talking
- 1:00:19about here. I I'm off the, I'm off the
- 1:00:21bench, man. I'm ready.
- 1:00:22Are you to lecture me on morals, Brad?
- 1:00:24Gee, I'm just saying, man, this is like you have to deal with
- 1:00:29your own soul in saying that I gave this movie A 10/10 even
- 1:00:33though I don't think it's the time to know I had saying that's
- 1:00:36I'm saying that I've seen it 30 times now and that Yesterday
- 1:00:39when I was sick in bed, like it wasn't hitting the way it hit
- 1:00:43the first 30 times, but it was still a nine and a half.
- 1:00:46So I think in the grand scheme of things, it washes out to a
- 1:00:4910, it's a 10 out of 10 and that means that we're coming out to
- 1:00:53an average of an eight point seven five out of ten, which is
- 1:00:56fairly well aligned with its score.
- 1:00:58On IMDb where it has an 8.5 out of 10.
- 1:01:01It is one of I believe the top 50 maybe 60 movies in the IMDb
- 1:01:05top 250 really well Beloved movie except by Brad and I
- 1:01:09shouldn't be surprised anymore, but I still am.
- 1:01:12So that's it for Chad like that. This has been a rough season for
- 1:01:17us. I feel like for us.
- 1:01:19Yeah. Like you and me are our bond,
- 1:01:22our friendship. You know what?
- 1:01:23Yeah. Like, I think the highest rated
- 1:01:25movies we've had so far. We've had three movies.
- 1:01:27Hit a nine point two five. We haven't had any tents.
- 1:01:31We haven't had any nine-and-a-half saint average
- 1:01:33Brad, I think it's time that we turn the page here.
- 1:01:36We're done with chaplain, we're moving into the fan boyish of
- 1:01:41all Fanboy directors in anticipation of his upcoming
- 1:01:45movie. Oppenheimer, we're going to be
- 1:01:47watching a couple movies from our boy Christopher Nolan in the
- 1:01:51coming weeks and that means that we're going to kick things off
- 1:01:55with his movie. Memento a movie that I have not
- 1:01:58washed in probably 15 years. Here's Brad.
- 1:01:59If you ever seen Memento, I have not one of my best friend's.
- 1:02:04Steven has been like begging me to watch that with him for a
- 1:02:08very long time now. And I kept telling my was like,
- 1:02:11well, we'll probably get to it on the podcast and I don't
- 1:02:13really watch more than one movie a week, so when I get to it on
- 1:02:17the podcast we'll watch it together.
- 1:02:18So Stephen and I are going to sit down sometime soon.
- 1:02:21We're going to watch Memento. I am very, very excited for it.
- 1:02:24I have a more important question for you, Bob.
- 1:02:26Oh yeah! What's that?
- 1:02:27If you were to have Hans As Zimmer compose a score for a
- 1:02:31Charlie Chaplin film? Which film would you want him to
- 1:02:34do it for And we're not talking about like Hans trying to
- 1:02:39imitate the old style. We're getting modern tile on
- 1:02:42Hans probably modern times, although it'd be kind of cool to
- 1:02:45see him composing for like the frozen tundra of the gold rush
- 1:02:49to. That's that's what I was
- 1:02:50thinking, man. Every time like that, I am the
- 1:02:53door of the cabin. Blows open.
- 1:02:54You just hear want comes in. Yes.
- 1:02:59That I for me, I think that's, that's the clear winner.
- 1:03:02All right, everybody. You can let us know what you
- 1:03:04think of Charlie Chaplin and And or Christopher Nolan by finding
- 1:03:07us on our social medias Facebook.
- 1:03:09Twitter Instagram Tick-Tock at film whiskey or jump onto our
- 1:03:13Discord. We have been talking all the
- 1:03:16things silent film. All the things, the, the fun of
- 1:03:19Summer that we are having. And if we're being honest, we
- 1:03:22talk about whiskey a lot. So, jump onto the Discord, you
- 1:03:25can find a link to it at the end of every single one of our show
- 1:03:27notes. All right, we will see you a
- 1:03:30week from now for Memento Brad. I'm very excited for that, but
- 1:03:34until then, I am Bob book. Look, I'm Reggie and we'll see
- 1:03:37you next time.