Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Protect your retirement from market crashes
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine retiring on a Friday. You know, walking out of your
- 0:03office for the last time and just feeling completely secure.
- 0:07Best feeling in the world? Right.
- 0:09But then by Monday, the financial markets fracture and
- 0:13literally half of your life savings simply vanishes.
- 0:16Oh. Wow, yeah.
- 0:17Yeah, and you know, you don't have time to recover.
- 0:19You're no longer earning a salary and the lifestyle you
- 0:22spent 4 decades building is well, it's suddenly on life
- 0:25support. It's terrifying.
- 0:26It really is, and I was reading through our source material for
- 0:29today's Deep dive and that is the exact sobering reality of a
- 0:33man who retired in the year 2000.
- 0:36Rightthe.com burst. Exactly.
- 0:38He crossed the finish line, the bubble immediately burst, and he
- 0:41lost 50% of his net asset value just like that.
- 0:44Man, that is brutal. And it gets worse, because he
- 0:48spent years agonizing, slowly clawing his portfolio back,
- 0:52right? And just as he finally got back
- 0:54to his starting point, well, the 2008 financial crash wiped him
- 0:59out all over again. It's basically the absolute
- 1:01definition of a financial nightmare scenario.
- 1:04I mean, it perfectly illustrates a hidden danger that most
- 1:06investors simply ignore until it's too late, right?
- 1:10And that is the vulnerability of timing.
- 1:12Which is incredibly relevant for you listening right now because
- 1:16I mean with equity markets trading near all time highs but
- 1:19feeling, you know, remarkably wobbly.
- 1:22Wobbly. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:23The vulnerability to a sudden correction is definitely a top
- 1:26of mind concern. So our mission for this deep
- 1:29dive today is to look at over 70 years of stock market history to
- 1:34understand the mechanics of these bear markets.
- 1:36Exactly. And more importantly, to unpack
- 1:393 fundamental strategies to actually protect your nest egg
- 1:43if you are near or already in retirement.
- 1:45Right, because you need a plan. Exactly.
- 1:47But before we get into the actual mechanics of survival, we
- 1:50do have some required focus and housekeeping to cover.
- 1:53We do so to access more advanced researches, applications and our
- 1:57latest personal Deep Value agents.
- 1:59Welcome to explore and join Deep Values APP to track total market
- 2:04temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 2:06the iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store or
- 2:10Bubble Watch from Google Play Perfect.
- 2:12And Please note our standard disclaimer.
- 2:15All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 2:18may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 2:21All contents from this channel is for research and
- 2:23entertainment purposes only and does not constitute any
- 2:26investment or financial advice or service.
- 2:28Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:31financial decisions. OK, great.
- 2:33So let's unpack this. We are basically trying to avoid
- 2:35becoming that guy who retired in 2000.
- 2:38Nobody wants to be that guy. No.
- 2:40But to build the defense, we really need to understand the
- 2:44beasts were fighting, right? Definitely.
- 2:46So looking at the historical data over the last 70 years,
- 2:48what are the actual hard facts about market drops?
- 2:51Because I think our brains tend to, you know, minimize the
- 2:54frequency of these events. Yeah.
- 2:55Oh, our brains absolutely minimize them.
- 2:58It's a survival mechanism. But if we look at the S&P 500
- 3:02going back to January 1956, the data is actually quite
- 3:06revealing. OK, we have experienced 12
- 3:09official bear markets since then.
- 3:11Now, the strict financial definition of a bear market is a
- 3:1420% drop from the peak to the through right, and that's
- 3:17measured by daily closing prices.
- 3:19But, you know, those technical definitions kind of hide the
- 3:22real pain. Don't.
- 3:23They oh for sure. Like I was looking at the data
- 3:25from early 2025, right after President Trump's Liberation Day
- 3:29tariffs. The S&P shed over 1000 points in
- 3:33like just about 7 weeks. Oh yeah, people were absolutely
- 3:36panicking, right? Yes.
- 3:38It fell from 6144 in February down to 4983 in April.
- 3:44Which felt like the sky was falling.
- 3:46It did, but mathematically that was only a 19% decline.
- 3:49Wait, really? Just 19.
- 3:50Just 19. So because it didn't cross that
- 3:52arbitrary 20% threshold, it doesn't officially make the cut
- 3:56for a bear market in our historical analysis.
- 3:59Yeah. However, when we look at the 12
- 4:02official bear markets that actually did cross that line,
- 4:06the averages paint a clear and honestly somewhat brutal
- 4:09picture. Lay it on me.
- 4:11A typical bear market sees a 33% decline.
- 4:14Ouch. Yeah, and it takes about 13
- 4:17months of just downward sliding to hit the absolute bottom.
- 4:21So over a year of just watching your money vanish.
- 4:24Exactly, and then crucially it takes an average of 36 months,
- 4:27so 3 full years just to recover to the previous high.
- 4:31Three years of your portfolio just treading water just to get
- 4:34back to zero. Yeah.
- 4:35But I mean, that is just the average.
- 4:37We really have to talk about the outlier, the period Morningstar
- 4:41famously labeled the Lost Decade.
- 4:44Right, the period beginning in the year 2000, which swallowed
- 4:48that unfortunate retiree you mentioned at the top of the
- 4:50show. Yeah, and the mechanics of why
- 4:52that period was so devastating are fascinating.
- 4:55I mean, it's like getting knocked flat on your back,
- 4:57finally standing up seven years later, and then immediately
- 5:00getting hit by a bus. That is a very accurate analogy
- 5:03actually. It wasn't just a single drop,
- 5:06it's something The source is called Sequence of returns risk.
- 5:09Exactly sequence of returns risk.
- 5:11Right. Because if your portfolio drops
- 5:13by 50% and you still have to pull out 50 grand a year to, you
- 5:17know, buy groceries and pay property taxes, you're having to
- 5:21sell twice as many shares at the absolute bottom just to survive.
- 5:25Yes, you are actively destroying the engine that is supposed to
- 5:29drive your eventual recovery. Exactly.
- 5:31That is the core mathematical trap of retiring during a crash.
- 5:35I mean, when you are accumulating wealth, a market
- 5:38crash is just a buying opportunity.
- 5:39Socks are on sale. Right, but when you're
- 5:42withdrawing wealth, a crash becomes a permanent impairment
- 5:45of your capital. So in the year 2000, the
- 5:48Internet bubble resulted in a 48% drop.
- 5:51Which is massive. Massive.
- 5:52And it took the S&P 587 months, so more than seven years, to
- 5:56fully recover to that peak. And as soon as the market
- 5:59crested that peak in mid 2007, the great financial crisis
- 6:03began. Exactly.
- 6:04Which resulted in a 57% drop lasting another 60-7 months.
- 6:08Good grief. Yeah.
- 6:10The overall effect was that these two bear markets
- 6:13essentially merged into one massive prolonged crisis.
- 6:17I mean, it wasn't until 2013, thirteen years after the year
- 6:212000 peak, that the S&P 500 finally exceeded that previous
- 6:25high for good. 13 years. But what made it a true
- 6:29catastrophe for retirees was the double whammy created by
- 6:33interest rates. Yes, this is a crucial point in
- 6:35the source material. Can you explain the relationship
- 6:38between the stock market crashing and the yield on safe
- 6:42investments just completely drying out?
- 6:43Sure. So when the stock market crashes
- 6:45and the economy falters, the Federal Reserve steps in to
- 6:48stimulate growth, right? Right.
- 6:50And the primary tool they use is lowering interest rates.
- 6:53So after the 2008 crisis, they dramatically slashed interest
- 6:56rates effectively to 0. So imagine a retiree whose stock
- 7:00portfolio has just been cut in half.
- 7:01They're freaking out. Exactly.
- 7:03They are terrified, so they pull the remaining money out of the
- 7:06market to put it into something safe like, you know, a
- 7:08certificate of deposit or a basic savings account.
- 7:11Right, just to stop the bleeding.
- 7:12Exactly, only to find out those SAFE investments are suddenly
- 7:15yielding absolutely nothing. Their equities are tanking at
- 7:19the exact moment their ability to earn a yield on safe fixed
- 7:23income investments is completely crushed.
- 7:26It is basically a localized economic depression for anyone
- 7:30relying on their portfolio for income.
- 7:32It really is. Now we do need to point out the
- 7:35silver lining for a specific segment of our listeners.
- 7:37True, true. If you are in your 20s, your
- 7:3930s, or you just have a very long time horizon before you
- 7:42need the money, the historical data suggests staying heavily
- 7:46invested in equities is mathematically wise.
- 7:49Because you have time to recover.
- 7:50Right. Since January 1956, despite all
- 7:53twelve of these bear markets, the S&P 500 has annualized a
- 7:577.6% return. Wow.
- 8:00And if you reinvested your dividends along the way, that
- 8:03annualized growth rate is actually closer to 10%.
- 8:06So time heals all market wounds, provided you actually have the
- 8:08time. But if you are stepping off the
- 8:11corporate ladder today or, you know, next month, you do not not
- 8:14have 13 years to wait out a lost decade.
- 8:16I mean, you can't put your seat belt on after the car crash.
- 8:18No you cannot. So if we can't afford to wait
- 8:23out the sequence of returns risk, how do we protect the
- 8:27capital right now? The source material lays out
- 8:30three options, starting with investments focused entirely on
- 8:33principal protection. What are the mechanisms for
- 8:36doing that without just, you know, stuffing cash under a
- 8:40mattress? Well, this first category
- 8:41involves trading market volatility for either duration
- 8:44risk or credit risk. You are essentially lending your
- 8:48capital in exchange for a guaranteed return and 100%
- 8:51principal protection, though there is no guaranteed lifelong
- 8:54income with these. Right, it's just protecting the
- 8:56pile of money. Exactly.
- 8:58So this includes U.S. Treasuries, certificates of
- 9:00deposit, and Multi year guaranteed annuities or MYGAS.
- 9:04As of the July 17th, 2026 data in our sources, Treasuries are
- 9:09yielding somewhere between 3.7% and just over 5% depending on
- 9:12the maturity. And C DS are, as most people
- 9:15know, famously FDIC insured up to $250,000.
- 9:20Right, but within this principal protection category the sources
- 9:23also introduced standard fist index annuities or FIA's and
- 9:27specifically an FIA without an income rider.
- 9:30How does the engine of an FIA actually work to protect
- 9:33principal whilst still playing the market?
- 9:35So a standard FIA protects your principal completely from market
- 9:40downturns, but it allows you to participate in the upside of a
- 9:43market index like the S&P 500, up to a strict cap.
- 9:47Oh, interesting. Yeah.
- 9:48For example, your upside might be capped at, say, 8.75% for the
- 9:52year. OK, So if the market surges 20%,
- 9:54your return is capped at 8.75%. You miss out on the rest.
- 9:58But if the market drops 20%, you lose absolutely zero.
- 10:01Your principal remains locked in and safe.
- 10:04I mean, it sounds like a casino where you only ever play with
- 10:06house money. Pretty much, but.
- 10:08Let me push back on the liquidity aspect.
- 10:10What happens if I lock my money into an FIA but you know, two
- 10:14years later I get a scary medical diagnosis and I suddenly
- 10:16need 100 grand for some experimental treatment?
- 10:19I've heard these contracts essentially lock your money in a
- 10:22vault. That is a very fairpoint.
- 10:24Liquidity is the critical trade off for that downside
- 10:27protection. FI as are designed as long term
- 10:30holds, so typically the contract will allow you a 10% fee free
- 10:35withdrawal annually. OK, so a little bit of access.
- 10:38Right. But if you need to pull out a
- 10:39massive lump sum before the surrender period is over, which
- 10:43could be anywhere from 5 to 10 years, you are going to face
- 10:47hefty early withdrawal penalties that will eat directly into your
- 10:51principal. OK.
- 10:52So that's the catch. So if I want that downside
- 10:55protection, but I also demand the ability to, I don't know,
- 10:59liquidate my position on a random Tuesday, what's the
- 11:02alternative? Well, the alternative is a newer
- 11:04financial product called Structured Protection ETFs.
- 11:07A common example cited in our sources is the Kalamo CPSJ.
- 11:11Because it is an ETF, it trades like a normal.
- 11:14Stock so totally liquid. Exactly.
- 11:16It offers daily liquidity and it lets you participate in the
- 11:20upside of an index to a certain extent while aiming to protect
- 11:23against losses. OK, let me do the math on the
- 11:25catch here because there is always a catch.
- 11:27Always the. Sources note that these ETFs
- 11:30have expense ratios. Yes they do.
- 11:32So for the Kalamo CPSJ it's .69% and that fee is deducted
- 11:37regardless of market performance.
- 11:39Right, that is correct. So if the market drops 20%, the
- 11:42ETF's internal mechanism stops my losses, but I still owe the
- 11:47fund manager their .69% fee. If I hold that for 10 years,
- 11:51that's nearly 7% of my principal bleeding out just in fees.
- 11:55Even in a totally flat market, that is not 100% principal
- 12:00protection. Your math is entirely accurate.
- 12:02That fee slowly eats into your initial investment overtime.
- 12:05OK. But the second catch is that the
- 12:08protection mechanism is what the industry calls point to point.
- 12:12Explain point to point. Sure, think of it like a train
- 12:15ride with a very specific destination and arrival time.
- 12:19The protection mechanism only works exactly as intended if you
- 12:23hold the ETF from the day it's issued until it's specific
- 12:26maturity date. So if you get spooked and sell
- 12:29your shares mid journey, you're subject to whatever the
- 12:32underlying market value of the ETF is on that random Tuesday.
- 12:37Which means I could lose money. Which could absolutely mean
- 12:40taking a loss on your principal, yes.
- 12:42OK, so option one is all about keeping the pile of money you've
- 12:45accumulated safe, but you're dealing with liquidity lockups
- 12:49or fees. Exactly.
- 12:50Let's pivot, because for some listeners, protecting a giant
- 12:53pile of capital isn't actually the goal.
- 12:56No, it's not. Right, like the real fear of
- 12:58keeping them awake at night isn't losing their principal in
- 13:00a crash, it is the sheer terror of outliving whatever capital
- 13:04they have. The longevity risk.
- 13:06Yeah, they just want their property taxes and grocery bills
- 13:08covered until the day they die, no matter how long that is.
- 13:10And for that specific investor psychology, we move to option 2,
- 13:14which is single premium immediate annuities or SBI as.
- 13:18OK, what is the mechanism behind a SPIA?
- 13:21With SBIA, you hand over a lump sum of money to an insurance
- 13:25company, OK, and the principal value effectively disappears.
- 13:28Wait, it just vanishes? Yes.
- 13:30Yeah. You no longer have a pot of
- 13:32money to look at or pass on to your heirs.
- 13:34It's gone. Wow.
- 13:36But in return for that lump sum, the insurance company
- 13:39contractually guarantees to send you a monthly or annual check
- 13:43for the rest of your life, starting almost immediately.
- 13:45OK, that's it. It shifts the risk of you
- 13:48outliving your money entirely onto the balance sheet of the
- 13:51insurance company. But how can the insurance
- 13:53company promise that? I mean, if I hand them 100 grand
- 13:56and then live to be 105 years old, they're going to lose a
- 13:59fortune on me. What is the engine under the
- 14:02hood that makes this profitable for them?
- 14:04The engine is a concept called mortality credits combined with
- 14:07a massive risk pooling. Mortality Credit.
- 14:09Yeah, you can think of it almost like a reverse life insurance
- 14:12policy. With life insurance, you buy
- 14:15protection against dying too soon, right?
- 14:17With the SPIA, you buy protection against living too
- 14:20long, so the insurance company pools thousands of retirees
- 14:24together. They know statistically that
- 14:26some of those people will unfortunately pass away shortly
- 14:29after buying the annuity. Oh, I see where this is going.
- 14:32Right. So the capital left behind by
- 14:33the people who die early is used to fund the prolonged payouts
- 14:37for the people who live to be 105.
- 14:39Wow. OK, let's look at the real
- 14:41numbers from the July 17th, 2026 data for an A+ rated company to
- 14:46make this concrete. Let's do it.
- 14:49If a 72 year old male in California takes $100,000 from
- 14:52his savings and buys a SPIA, what is his payout?
- 14:57That 72 year old male would receive a guaranteed payout of
- 15:01roughly $7350 per year for the rest of his life.
- 15:05OK. And what about a 72 year old
- 15:06female in California with the exact same $100,000 investment?
- 15:10She would receive slightly less, about $7050 per year for life.
- 15:15Ah, I see the discrepancy there. The woman is receiving about
- 15:17$300 less a year, and that has to be pure actuarial science,
- 15:21right? Because women statistically live
- 15:23longer than men, so the insurance company has to stretch
- 15:26her expected total payout over a longer timeline to balance their
- 15:30books, meaning her annual check is slightly smaller.
- 15:33You've diagnosed it perfectly. The math is cold, but it is
- 15:36deeply logical based on life expectancy tables.
- 15:39Right. But I mean, the obvious downside
- 15:41to this strategy is that you have bought certainty at the
- 15:45absolute expense of growth and inflation protection.
- 15:47That is the trade off. That $100,000 is gone.
- 15:50Your check is never going to grow, even if the S&P 500 goes
- 15:54on a massive 10 year bull run. You are locked in.
- 15:57Which brings us to the ultimate dilemma.
- 15:59Option 1 keeps the capital safe but locked up.
- 16:03Option 2 guarantees a paycheck but confiscates the capital.
- 16:06Is there a hybrid mechanism that kind of bridges the gap?
- 16:09Yes, there is like. Can I protect my principal from
- 16:12a crash, generate A guaranteed future income stream, and still
- 16:15capture some market growth? Yes, you can.
- 16:18This brings us to option three, fixed index annuities, but
- 16:21specifically outfitted with an income writer.
- 16:24This is the only financial product in our sources that
- 16:26checks all three of those boxes simultaneously.
- 16:30And the sources argue strongly that we are currently in a
- 16:33golden moment for these specific products due to the
- 16:36macroeconomic environment. Why do high interest rates
- 16:39matter so much here? Like how does the Federal
- 16:42Reserve's interest rate connect to the payout on my personal
- 16:46annuity? It all comes down to how the
- 16:48insurance company invests your premium.
- 16:51When you give them your money, they don't just put it in a
- 16:53vault, they invest it primarily in conservative, high quality
- 16:57bonds to ensure they can meet their obligations to you.
- 17:00Makes sense because interest rates have been sitting at 2
- 17:03decade highs. The yields on those bonds are
- 17:05incredibly strong. So they're making more money on
- 17:09their safe investments. Exactly.
- 17:10And that allows them to turn around and offer you much more
- 17:12generous upside market caps and higher guaranteed income
- 17:16payouts. OK.
- 17:17Let's breakdown the actual mechanics of this hybrid.
- 17:19How does the income rider function alongside the principal
- 17:23protection? Essentially, the insurance
- 17:25company creates 2 separate buckets for your money.
- 17:28Two buckets. Got it.
- 17:29The first bucket is your accumulation value.
- 17:31That is your real money, completely protected from market
- 17:34downturns, capturing a portion of the index upside.
- 17:37Right, like we talked about earlier.
- 17:39Exactly. But the second bucket is your
- 17:41income base. This is the rider.
- 17:42So the income base isn't real. No cash I can withdraw to, I
- 17:45don't know, buy a boat. Exactly.
- 17:47No boats. It is essentially a phantom
- 17:49Ledger. It's just an internal accounting
- 17:51number used strictly to calculate your future guaranteed
- 17:54paycheck, and many companies offer a guaranteed roll up rate
- 17:58on that phantom Ledger. Give me an example of how
- 18:01powerful that roll up rate can be.
- 18:03Let's look at the 65 year old couple in California from the
- 18:06sources. So they invest $100,000 today.
- 18:10If they let that phantom Ledger grow and wait seven years to
- 18:14turn on the actual income stream, what happens?
- 18:17OK, so by waiting seven years until they are 72, so starting
- 18:20in year 8, they will receive a guaranteed $12,796 per year for
- 18:26the rest of their lives. And it gets better.
- 18:30If they can afford to delay turning on the income rider
- 18:32until year 11, that lifetime payout jumps to $15,200 per
- 18:38year. From 100 Grand Investment.
- 18:40That's really solid, but what about someone willing to take a
- 18:42slightly longer runway? The sources highlight a 60 year
- 18:46old single person in Florida investing that same $100,000
- 18:50utilizing A guaranteed roll up rate of 9% a year for 10 years.
- 18:56Because of that aggressive 9% roll up rate on the income base,
- 18:59if this 60 year old waits 12 years to turn on the income
- 19:01rider, they will receive nearly $20,000, specifically $19,894.00
- 19:08per year, for the rest of their life.
- 19:10Nearly 20,000 a year for life on $100,000 investment made 12
- 19:14years prior. Staggering, isn't it?
- 19:16That is staggering. But you know when we played
- 19:18devil's advocate for a second? Bring it on.
- 19:20Let's assume I am that 60 year old in Florida.
- 19:23I lock in this FIA fully planning to wait 12 years to get
- 19:26that massive payout. But in year 8, my life
- 19:28circumstances drastically change.
- 19:30Right, life happens. Yeah, maybe I inherit a house,
- 19:33or I decide I love working and don't want to retire.
- 19:36I suddenly realize I don't actually need that guaranteed
- 19:39income stream. Am I trapped paying for a
- 19:42feature I no longer need? Not at all, and that highlights
- 19:46the core flexibility of this hybrid approach.
- 19:48OK, how so? As long as you have not yet
- 19:51turned on the income writer, meaning you haven't initiated
- 19:54those lifetime payouts, you are not trapped.
- 19:56Oh, really? Really, once the initial
- 19:58surrender period of the contract has passed, you can simply
- 20:01decline to use the rider and cash out your full surrender
- 20:05value. Wait, so I just walk away You.
- 20:07Walk away with your original principle plus whatever market
- 20:10upside you successfully captured in that first bucket over those
- 20:13eight years. Wow, that's actually huge.
- 20:16So stepping back, we have covered a tremendous amount of
- 20:18ground today in this deep dive. We really have.
- 20:21What the historical data clearly proves is that you simply cannot
- 20:24predict when the S&P 500 will fracture.
- 20:27Nope, it's impossible. The technical 20% thresholds,
- 20:31the terrifying 19% near misses, the cascading events that cause
- 20:36a lost decade. They are entirely unpredictable.
- 20:40100%. If you wait until you're halfway
- 20:42through a bear market to try and maneuver your portfolio to
- 20:44safety, well, the mathematical damage of sequence of returns
- 20:48risk is already done. The mask doesn't lie.
- 20:51Exactly the time to build your safety net, whether you choose
- 20:54Treasuries to protect capital, ASPIA to guarantee your grocery
- 20:57bills, or a hybrid FIA to attempt to balance both, is
- 21:02right now, before the tightrope actually snaps.
- 21:05I couldn't agree more, and I want to leave you with a final
- 21:08psychological framing to ponder, which kind of builds on
- 21:11everything we've discussed today regarding strategy.
- 21:13Oh, OK. Let's hear it.
- 21:15Consider this Does having a guaranteed floor, knowing that
- 21:18your absolute essential bills are paid for life, regardless of
- 21:22what the stock market does, actually make you a
- 21:24fundamentally better investor? Huh.
- 21:27That is a fascinating angle because I mean, panic selling is
- 21:30entirely driven by a threat to our basic survival.
- 21:32Precisely. Panic selling destroys long term
- 21:35wealth, right? But if your basic survival isn't
- 21:37chained to the daily violent fluctuations of the S&P 500
- 21:41because you have an annuity or guaranteed income covering your
- 21:44baseline living expenses, you operate from a position of
- 21:47profound psychological strength. Wow.
- 21:49Yeah, you are far less likely to panic sell the remaining riskier
- 21:53equities in your portfolio during a crash.
- 21:57Setting up a guaranteed income floor might actually be the
- 22:00ultimate behavioral hack for your own investing psychology.
- 22:03It frees you from a mindset of scarcity, allowing you to endure
- 22:07the volatility with the rest of your money without losing sleep.
- 22:10Exactly. Is the ultimate defense against
- 22:12the vulnerability of timing. Well, thank you so much for
- 22:15joining us on this deep dive. Review these mechanisms
- 22:18carefully based on your own unique financial journey,
- 22:21because you have worked far too hard to cross that finish line,
- 22:24only to realize the ground beneath you is giving way.
- 22:27You deserve to stay there comfortably, no matter what the
- 22:30market decides to do next.