Latest / The Vegan Report / Crashing The DNC Party. With Robert Grillo | Ep. 46
Transcript
- 0:00My name is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:04The Democratic National Convention was last week in Chicago and there for a few days you
- 0:11had gathered the most powerful human beings on the planet.
- 0:16Influential wealthy politicians leading the party at the head of the mightiest country
- 0:23on the planet, the United States of America.
- 0:27For various interest groups, this was a golden opportunity to advance their cause, to put
- 0:33pressure through protests and other forms of activism on global changemakers.
- 0:41And among them was one small group of animal rights activists called Free From Harm, who
- 0:49used their wits to infiltrate the most elite and exclusive gatherings of that event and
- 0:56disrupt them in the most spectacular way, to keep accountable the powerful, to remind
- 1:02them of the animal holocaust they have the power to stop.
- 1:08Today I am glad to welcome the founder and director of Free From Harm, Robert Griot.
- 1:15As a communication professional for over 25 years, Robert once worked on a large food
- 1:22industry accounts where he acquired a behind the scenes perspective on food branding and
- 1:28marketing.
- 1:29I recommend his book, Farm to Fable, the fiction of our animal consuming culture, which explores
- 1:37the powerful narratives driving our culture of mass animal consumption.
- 1:43So Robert, thank you so much for accepting my invitation.
- 1:47Thank you so much for being here.
- 1:48It's a pleasure.
- 1:49It's good to meet you, Ryan.
- 1:52So Robert, my first question for you is, you know, my public, my audience comes from everywhere
- 1:59in the world, but mostly from the US.
- 2:02But for those non-US people, what's the DNC?
- 2:09That's a fair question.
- 2:11The DNC is the Democratic National Convention.
- 2:16And it's their big convention event to elect for the delegates in each state to elect the
- 2:25next candidate for president and vice president.
- 2:31And so it's a big media circus, basically.
- 2:38It's all about like promotion and media attention.
- 2:45There's I think I heard there were like 50,000 press passes issued by the DNC this year for
- 2:54media all over the world, many obviously in states, but even international media, lots
- 3:01of Guardian, Axios, you know, all kinds of news outlets here.
- 3:08Independent as well as mainstream, YouTube influencers, other social influencers, as
- 3:14well as like, you know, the mainstay reporters, so to speak.
- 3:21So it's kind of like the big media event of the year for the Democratic, the DNC, the
- 3:30organization behind the Democratic Party is what it really is.
- 3:35And for people who wonder, you know, why is it relevant?
- 3:40You know, why is this event so important?
- 3:44Well, politics in the US will influence all other countries.
- 3:51Whatever happens in the US will have an incidence on everything else in other countries, including
- 4:00everything that has to do with factory farming, non-human animals, their treatment or their
- 4:06mistreatment.
- 4:07So, yeah, it's the center of power.
- 4:12Yes, because if you're missing an action, then things stay the same and nothing changes.
- 4:20And the other, there's so many different reasons or good reasons to attend and to participate
- 4:31in this event.
- 4:33Just regardless of what your political orientation or whether you even think, whether you think
- 4:39the Democratic Party is for shit and the Republicans are even worse, whether you think that the
- 4:44establishment is, you know, you're against the establishment.
- 4:51Personally I consider myself pretty anti-establishment.
- 4:54But the objective of one of our key objectives as a grassroots group is to leverage media
- 5:03in our favor.
- 5:04So we're looking for opportunities that will insert ourselves in our message, in our voice
- 5:11into the media spotlight.
- 5:16Because that's the way to, that's one path, one important path to getting more popular
- 5:21support for our movement.
- 5:23You know, it's interesting because today you published a post about a certain senator.
- 5:30And you described how you spent, I think, an entire year trying to reach that senator,
- 5:35trying to sit down that senator who is actually, I think, your senator and nothing, no response.
- 5:44But then just being present at that event, you were able to talk with this person, to
- 5:51interact with him.
- 5:53Is that right?
- 5:54That's right.
- 5:55So one of our key organizers, Jackie, she lives in Philadelphia.
- 6:02And Casey is her senator because he's the Pennsylvania senator.
- 6:08I'm in Illinois.
- 6:11But anyway, I worked with her on trying to get in front of Casey, trying to get responses
- 6:17from him.
- 6:19And we were particularly interested in him because he's on this very secretive, what
- 6:25we call the Senate chicken caucus.
- 6:28And so there's very little information about the Senate chicken caucus and what these powerful
- 6:35senators are very powerful people, to put it mildly.
- 6:39There's only, you know, 60 some of that senators, they represent the entire state.
- 6:45They make huge decisions on our behalf, affecting a $7 trillion, somewhat $7 trillion, of the
- 6:55budget, government budget, of which the farm bill and agriculture policy is about a trillion
- 7:01and a half, just to give you some context for the amount of money that they hold the
- 7:06purse strings for.
- 7:08And so Casey is a Democrat, and he's been progressive in some ways, I guess you could
- 7:18say, or speaks progressively about workers' rights and the environmental issues and things
- 7:24like that.
- 7:26But then here he is on the Senate chicken caucus.
- 7:29And we were really scratching our heads trying to figure out why is that?
- 7:34And what is the Senate chicken caucus all about?
- 7:37Why is it that we can't get into their meetings, that they're not public, like other hearings,
- 7:44they're private, which tells us that the industry and their lobbyists and attorneys are in there
- 7:50because attorneys have the power to actually make meetings private, public meetings private,
- 7:58when attorneys are involved, and that they're making big decisions that benefit the industry,
- 8:03the chicken industry.
- 8:05And so we got really interested in trying to dig into this and confront Casey and other
- 8:13Senate chicken caucus members, I think there's 14 of all of them, to find out, you know,
- 8:19what's the big secret?
- 8:21I mean, why are you guys having these closed door meetings?
- 8:25What's going on in these meetings?
- 8:27Why aren't you ever talking about these meetings?
- 8:30What's decided in these meetings?
- 8:32Where's the minutes?
- 8:33Why can't we access the meeting minutes so we can see what was discussed and voted out?
- 8:39And who's in these meetings?
- 8:40Is it industry people that are telling you what they want from taxpayers?
- 8:46And you know, all these questions are, you know, coming up.
- 8:50So Jackie was ignored.
- 8:53Jackie is an incredibly persistent woman, and she's really tough as nails.
- 9:03And so she goes to his offices, she calls, she talks to staff and all of this, and didn't
- 9:12go anywhere.
- 9:13And so here we learned that at the DNC, they're going to have these Pennsylvania Dems, PA
- 9:25Dems breakfast every morning for the four days.
- 9:28And what we learned about the DNC was the place to be is at these breakfasts.
- 9:34Each state has their own delegation.
- 9:36And at a fancy hotel where they're staying, they have these breakfasts.
- 9:40And famous speakers come to these breakfasts.
- 9:45And it's a great way to get in front of them without having to go to the McCormick place
- 9:51in the United Center, which is where the big speeches and the big power players were going
- 9:57to be.
- 10:00It's much more accessible to get in and out of a hotel, and much easier, less risk.
- 10:05So had we known that earlier, we probably would have put a lot more focus on the breakfasts.
- 10:12You know, none of us want to get up at five or something to be at a breakfast at seven
- 10:16or whatever.
- 10:17But anyway, we were there that morning, and we were really glad that we were there because
- 10:22we didn't know Casey Senate.
- 10:23They don't announce these things.
- 10:25But not only did we that morning, not only did we confront Senator Casey, but we also
- 10:33got to speak and have a really kind of an intense interaction with other Congress people.
- 10:42Debbie Wasserman Schultz, who was the president of the Democratic National Convention and
- 10:47all that.
- 10:48So a lot of people just were there.
- 10:50And what we did is we tried to prepare as best as we could with the talking points and
- 10:57the tough questions that we wanted to ask these people.
- 11:01And if we saw them, we just had to be prepared.
- 11:03We had to jump at the opportunity.
- 11:06And that's what we did.
- 11:07We just, I will say I was very inspired by an organization called Code Pink, which is
- 11:17based in DC.
- 11:18And they spend their days in the halls of Congress, and they wait for meetings to come
- 11:23out or they go into meetings and they do disruptive actions or they wait until Congress people
- 11:27come out and they chase them down the hall and they get them to talk about their, why
- 11:33are they voting to spend billions of dollars for a war, foreign war?
- 11:40And is there allegiance to a foreign government or to the US or those kinds of questions?
- 11:46So that was very inspiring.
- 11:47And we thought, we can do that too.
- 11:50And the DNC is a great opportunity to have lots of these people that we're trying to
- 11:55target under one roof.
- 11:56I want to get back to Senator Casey, but first, if you look at the news coverage of that event,
- 12:07you see the protesters outside and even inside the main hall of the event and they are anti-war
- 12:17protesters, they are pro-abortion protesters.
- 12:22You have all kinds of flavors of social issues, justice out there.
- 12:28And I'm wondering, did you see any protests about animal rights against animal farming?
- 12:37How many animal rights organizations were present at the DNC talking about the issues
- 12:45that are important for the vegans out there?
- 12:48I personally only know of one and that's only because a friend of mine, Wayne is here in
- 12:55Chicago, works for PETA.
- 12:57And PETA was doing some public outreach, I believe, about some animal testing issue.
- 13:06I don't recall exactly what it was, but to my knowledge, we were the only group inside
- 13:15of events calling attention to the corruption in our government and its policy on our food
- 13:28system and the need for a transition to a plant-based food system.
- 13:34So to my knowledge, we were the only ones there for that purpose.
- 13:38So when you say public outreach, you mean they were not even directing their activism
- 13:43to the politicians?
- 13:44They were directing their activism to the different people that were present all around
- 13:53the event?
- 13:55That's my understanding.
- 13:57Wow.
- 13:59I hear that and I feel so disappointed.
- 14:05I have to say so disappointed.
- 14:08I mean, like we stated before, here's the DNC, this mega important event, counting
- 14:16thousands of powerful politicians that will shape the future of billions of animals in
- 14:23the US and maybe in the rest of the world, because like we said, the US is the most powerful
- 14:31country in the world.
- 14:32It will influence all policies around the globe.
- 14:36And you have hundreds of reporters from all major channels, from all major media outlets,
- 14:44not even in the US, but in the rest of the world.
- 14:48And you're saying that you were the only one screaming and talking about defending the
- 14:58animal rights cause.
- 15:01To my knowledge, yes.
- 15:04And I'm not making any excuses for people, but at the same time, I think it's a very
- 15:15intimidating proposition for people to, quite frankly, it's intimidating for all of us.
- 15:23But at a certain point, we have to make a decision whether we pursue an opportunity
- 15:31because we just can't, we can't not get involved.
- 15:40It's too big of an opportunity to pass up.
- 15:44And I don't think a lot of people recognized it for what it is.
- 15:48I think it's great that you did, but a lot of our local folks have already obligations
- 15:56and commitments.
- 15:57Most of the people that I know here in Chicago are working on fur campaigns and maybe some
- 16:09other local things.
- 16:13But even on the issue of fur, there could have been fur protesters from wherever that
- 16:20decided they were going to use this opportunity to get the fur free policy message out there.
- 16:29And I didn't see any of them.
- 16:32How did you get in?
- 16:33How did you get your press pass?
- 16:36If you can share that with us.
- 16:40That's a damn good question.
- 16:42And each day was a different, totally different struggle.
- 16:48So I didn't get a press pass.
- 16:50The deadline for press passes was way back in April.
- 16:54So we learned about press pass.
- 16:57We didn't even think about the idea of a press pass until it was like June.
- 17:02And by that time it was like three months too late.
- 17:06That's how, you know, just to give you an idea, like April's deadline, that's how bad
- 17:13people want press passes.
- 17:14And they're just like cut it off in April, several months before the event.
- 17:18So we have gotten into a lot of places with uninvited or unregistered.
- 17:25We don't pay for registration.
- 17:26We don't pay for tickets.
- 17:29Once in a while we register if it's free or if it makes sense and it seems like it's fairly
- 17:35easy to do and it's not going to cost us anything or not much.
- 17:41But in general, we get into a lot of places by talking our way in.
- 17:47And so with the DNC, the first day, it took us just two hours to find the proper entrance.
- 17:57McCormick Place is this enormous complex, trade show complex in Chicago, which is where
- 18:03the official business of the DNC was taking place.
- 18:07And you had lots of meetings like that where you had famous people like Bernie Sanders
- 18:14show up and do a three-minute speech.
- 18:17And we knew a lot of this was going to happen.
- 18:19So we wanted to get into McCormick Place and we were told it was open to the public.
- 18:24And there was an option to register for free as a member of the public.
- 18:29But then that deadline passed and I didn't register.
- 18:33Some people did in our group.
- 18:34But anyway, the first day I was able to get in without any credentials.
- 18:42But it took us two hours just to find the entrance.
- 18:47And so I got in the first day and then I came back the next day and they said there was
- 18:53some disturbance inside and that they were really limiting access and that I would have
- 19:02to look at my email to confirm that I had registered.
- 19:06And so I talked to three different people and they were all shutting me down.
- 19:11They said, sorry, sir, it's nothing I can do to help you.
- 19:15And then suddenly I saw the guy from Monday that let me in, this big guy saw me.
- 19:23I said, you remember me, don't you, from Monday.
- 19:27I said, look, I know things have changed.
- 19:30I said, look, but I was here on Monday.
- 19:32You know I was here.
- 19:33I was registered on.
- 19:34He said, okay.
- 19:35He said, I'm going to do you a favor.
- 19:37I'm going to let you in because your friends are already inside, right?
- 19:40I said, yeah, they're already inside.
- 19:41He said, but you got to promise me you're here just to attend meetings, not to do anything
- 19:48else.
- 19:51And I felt kind of bad because part of me felt, oh, you know, I'm going to be telling
- 20:00this guy what he wants to hear and I might be one of the activists that they were trying
- 20:04to avoid getting in.
- 20:08But I did it anyway for the cause because I felt like it was the right thing to do.
- 20:12So I got in and so every situation was different.
- 20:21The first disruption we did was on Tuesday night at this private members only club called
- 20:26the Union League of Chicago.
- 20:29And it's really where diplomats and like just the top crust of society have these big posh
- 20:35parties.
- 20:36Nobody else gets into these places.
- 20:39And so we didn't know if we were going to be able to get in.
- 20:44But we went up to the desk and they said, are you registered?
- 20:47And we said, well, here's our name.
- 20:49Look it up.
- 20:50See, no, sorry, you're not in.
- 20:51I'm sorry we can't let you in.
- 20:53And we said, oh, yeah, you know, so we really, you know, we were registered with the DNC
- 21:03and we were thinking about getting involved in agriculture and we really wanted to see
- 21:10these speakers and be a part of this event.
- 21:16And then it was like, okay, well, what organization are you with?
- 21:20So what we did is we used, there's a journalist, an agriculture journalist here called Hagastrom.
- 21:27His name is Hagastrom.
- 21:28And he's been in the business for 40 years.
- 21:31He's one of these really old school guys who knows everything about agriculture and he
- 21:35has a blog and a paid subscription thing.
- 21:39He's very well respected.
- 21:41We told her that we were with his group, the Hagastrom.
- 21:45And he literally despises us because we've disrupted many agriculture events.
- 21:51So if he knew that we used him as a pretext, he'd probably be pretty upset with us.
- 21:58But that's how we got in because we mentioned somebody that they recognized and we were
- 22:05super fortunate in that context.
- 22:09So I think I just have a way of trying to get into places and not always succeeding,
- 22:16but most of the time I do manage to get our group in.
- 22:20There was one issue, there's one, I'll shut up after this.
- 22:23There's one other incredible story about getting in.
- 22:27At the, in Congress, there was a farm bill hearing in May, at the end of May.
- 22:32And we didn't know this because it was our first farm bill hearing.
- 22:35But there was a line that formed out of the hearing room that was hundreds of people when
- 22:44we got there.
- 22:45And we thought, oh my gosh, and it's not moving.
- 22:47And the hearing's going on, it's already started.
- 22:50And we're like, this line is not moving.
- 22:52No one's going to give up their seat.
- 22:53And we learned that the hearing room only has 60 seats in there.
- 22:56And all those seats are basically reserved for lobbyists, industry lobbyists and other
- 23:01like journalists and people like that.
- 23:03But this is supposed to be open to the public, but there's literally no seats for the public.
- 23:07So at a certain point I told my group, I said, you know what, we're never going to get in
- 23:12by waiting in this line.
- 23:15I said, we're going to wait until that door person is distracted and then we're going
- 23:19to slip right in.
- 23:21And there was a split second, literally a split second when this guy was talking to
- 23:25someone on his left.
- 23:28And that's when we went through this tiny little door into this tiny little hearing
- 23:32room, which had some of the most powerful people in Congress deciding on this trillion
- 23:38and a half dollar farm bill.
- 23:41And we got in and we stayed in.
- 23:46They asked us to leave many times, but we wouldn't leave.
- 23:50So we succeeded in doing that disruption, but it took like five hours basically waiting
- 23:57around, wondering whether we were going to get in and then finally finding a split second
- 24:02opportunity where we got in.
- 24:03That's amazing.
- 24:04That's truly amazing.
- 24:05And I want to express my thanks to Mr. Haggister for being an indirect ally.
- 24:18An unwilling ally.
- 24:24Could you speak about your activism, the way, how the power of disruption in that event?
- 24:33Right.
- 24:34So this opportunity at the DNC and all the different events, private events, and all
- 24:42these different things that were many, many opportunities all fit into this model of it
- 24:50checked all the boxes of the things, the kind of things we look for.
- 24:54So for one thing, like I said earlier, we look for media coverage and the likelihood
- 25:00of media coverage.
- 25:02We look for opportunities to confront our targets, the power holders.
- 25:10We look for opportunities to be in a general audience with influential people that they
- 25:17know and the general public as well.
- 25:24It's not just about one-on-one conversations, but about really trying to reach all of these
- 25:34audiences at the same time and doing something that resonates with them even if they don't
- 25:42necessarily agree with the message.
- 25:45So like, for example, like we had these banners that kind of mocked Senator Debbie Stabenow
- 25:52for her crooked farm bill and it had a caricature of her on it and these chickens flying around.
- 26:00So we used kind of humor and mockery in a way that I think got us some support where
- 26:09we might not have gotten it if it was too serious of a message.
- 26:13It was serious, but we also have this mockery element, this humor element to it.
- 26:19And I think people had to stop and kind of absorb the visuals that we put forward, the
- 26:25banners.
- 26:28And I think that even with those, like many of those that probably had a knee-jerk reaction
- 26:34and didn't like us or didn't like what we were there for, I still believe that most
- 26:42many people respect the courage of those who are willing to stand out from the crowd and
- 26:54stand up to someone in power.
- 27:00And it's a great thing to do because it's the one thing that people remember.
- 27:06They don't remember all the boring speeches.
- 27:09They don't remember what drinks they had or what conversations they had.
- 27:12They might remember a couple, but the one thing they're going to remember about that
- 27:16is, oh, that's where USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack got disrupted by during his speech with those
- 27:24people, with those pink banners that had, you know, making fun of Debbie Stavanoff's
- 27:30crooked farm bill.
- 27:31That's probably what they're going to remember.
- 27:34And that's what we want.
- 27:36Yes, I agree.
- 27:39And I would add, coming back to Senator Quasi, you prefer a reaction, whatever that reaction
- 27:50is to indifference, to just the coldness of indifference to your message and to what you're
- 27:59defending.
- 28:00Yes, it shows that they have some stake in their reputation.
- 28:06They care about their reputation and that somebody is threatening their reputation,
- 28:13which is an important pressure point.
- 28:18We did get ignored by some, to be fair.
- 28:20Bernie Sanders ignored us.
- 28:23I put my hand on his shoulder as he was coming down the stage and I was trying to be gentle
- 28:28and compassionate.
- 28:29And I said, Bernie, you know, thank you for what you just said about the climate crisis
- 28:38and supporting labor.
- 28:42I said, but will you support a just transition to a slaughter-free plant-based food system
- 28:50for the same reasons that you think we should end fossil fuels?
- 28:52The very same reasons, because it's just as destructive or more.
- 28:59And for so many other reasons, not only just for the climate, but something like that.
- 29:04And I got backstage a little bit until security stopped me.
- 29:12And he ignored us, but he heard us.
- 29:15And then the audience heard us.
- 29:19So the audience saw someone who was very passionate and upset about this inconsistency between
- 29:29railing against fossil fuel industry and ending those subsidies, but not saying anything about
- 29:34animal agriculture.
- 29:36So we did have a big audience to hopefully get people to think for even just a minute
- 29:44about this disconnect.
- 29:47I want to get back to other activist groups out there.
- 29:52How is it that it is so common for activist groups to enter a barbecue restaurant or a
- 30:00butcher shop and be disruptive there?
- 30:04But lack the foresight of thinking maybe our action would hold greater impact in the office
- 30:18of our senator, among our politicians, facing the building of a lobbyist, talking to a religious
- 30:28leader.
- 30:30Why is this strategic mindset lacking in the vegan activism scene?
- 30:38I wish I knew.
- 30:39I think, I mean, I can only speculate.
- 30:44I think there's a couple of things going on.
- 30:46One is that people see this animal, the animal side of the food industry as such a monumental
- 30:57thing that they're just not sure where they can have an impact.
- 31:06I think that's part of it.
- 31:08The other part, I think, is the intensely intimidating proposition of confronting power
- 31:16holders.
- 31:19Because if you've been doing street activism, for example, and just meeting people where
- 31:24they are on the street, you could become very good at that and it could become very unintimidating.
- 31:34You become unafraid of that.
- 31:36But then the prospect of shifting that to talking to power holders seems terrifying
- 31:44for a lot of people.
- 31:46But also this idea that it's just too big to fail.
- 31:49And what could we possibly do as a small group?
- 31:51What I like to tell people is that everyone says we don't have enough numbers.
- 31:58We just don't have the numbers to impact a system that big.
- 32:01So we should just start by chipping away at the fringes and beating away at the crumbs
- 32:06around the edges.
- 32:07But my response to that is that if we look at other social movements like the suffragettes,
- 32:14like the civil rights movement, like Black Lives Matter, Occupy Wall Street, ACT UP,
- 32:22there were actually very few people at the beginning stages that were willing to do direct
- 32:27action, that were willing to make that kind of sacrifice, to put their bodies on the line,
- 32:33to risk maybe being hurt or pushed or ridiculed.
- 32:42Very few people were willing to make that sacrifice.
- 32:46So it's not unique to our situation or our movement.
- 32:50And I like to tell people that because I think there's this illusion that we're somehow so
- 32:55unique and our cause is so different from all these other social change movements that
- 33:01nothing can really relate to what we're doing.
- 33:06But I think that's a fallacy.
- 33:09Actually I think in this respect, we're in the same kind of situation as the early stages
- 33:16of those other movements I mentioned where there were very few people to take direct
- 33:20action.
- 33:21But those people actually created a spark.
- 33:25Those few people created the spark that was needed to get media attention, to get more
- 33:32people inspired to want to take action too.
- 33:36You mentioned lots of social causes and many of them could be identified as being on the
- 33:46left of the political spectrum.
- 33:49And of course you also crashed the DNC party.
- 33:56So I wonder, did you ever think of doing the same for the Republican party, so the conservative
- 34:03counterpart?
- 34:06Absolutely I did.
- 34:07In fact, we were all ready to go to the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee, which is
- 34:11only an hour and a half from Chicago.
- 34:14But the logistics were just very difficult.
- 34:19And unless we were able to stay at a hotel which was like in the center of things, it
- 34:24would have been very difficult to get around the logistics of things closing off and all
- 34:30that and security and all that.
- 34:33But I did really have my sights set on going.
- 34:37And my message to Republicans was going to be fundamentally they believe in less government.
- 34:45So how are they possibly, how is that possibly consistent with increasing the bailout, the
- 34:52corporate welfare for the animal agriculture industry?
- 34:56And if they really believe in less government, then doesn't it make sense to cut those subsidies?
- 35:06The problem with that is that we actually do believe in subsidies, but not the kind
- 35:12that benefit that industry.
- 35:14We'd like to see them shifted to incentivize plant-based agriculture and proteins.
- 35:20So I still think though, I honestly think that our message, our primary populist message
- 35:31at Free From Harm is that hardworking Americans should not be bailing out an industry for
- 35:39the problems that they have created, whether it be disease crises like bird flu, or whether
- 35:49it be pollution, the pollution of climate chaos that they contribute to, that it's not
- 35:56our problem.
- 35:58We didn't create this problem.
- 36:00And therefore a $256 billion industry should be financially held accountable for the problems
- 36:07that they create.
- 36:09And I feel that we asked a lot of people at the DNC, but I feel like if we had gone to
- 36:15the RNC and we asked a lot of different people that question, do they think hardworking Americans
- 36:21should be responsible for those problems, financially carry the burden?
- 36:26I believe a lot of people would have said, no, it doesn't make sense.
- 36:30We shouldn't be paying for that.
- 36:34I think across the political spectrum, that populist message resonates with people.
- 36:39And that's one of the reasons why we chose it.
- 36:43Robert, this is music to my ears.
- 36:47Because I feel like so many vegans are, I guess there's this natural inclination to
- 36:52being on the left, to being leftist liberals, call it whatever you want.
- 36:58And so with that comes a certain hesitation to try to promote veganism among a conservative
- 37:09audience.
- 37:12And I find it truly, again, this word disappointing, because they're also part of the problem.
- 37:23And so we should be trying to gain them in our camp as a way.
- 37:33But you mentioned how you were anti-establishment.
- 37:37Could you elaborate on that, and how we should stop looking at animal rights or veganism
- 37:46as being a left-wing issue?
- 37:50Sure.
- 37:52Yeah, when I think of anti-establishment, I'm meaning that the establishment, whether
- 38:01it's Democrats or Republicans, there's essentially very little difference in the way that the
- 38:08system operates.
- 38:10And yes, it's true.
- 38:11I get into this with one of my friends, and she's a great legal mind and activist, that
- 38:21the Republicans certainly accept a lot more lobbying money and contributions to their
- 38:27campaigns from the animal ag industries than the Democrats do.
- 38:33But isn't that an argument in itself for doing more activism directed to Republicans?
- 38:43Absolutely.
- 38:44Yeah, absolutely.
- 38:45I'm exposing the corruption, regardless of what party is engaging in that and destroying
- 38:56representative government.
- 38:57Yeah, that's what I mean by anti-establishment.
- 39:03I would do what we're doing if the only reason was that it's important for us to exercise
- 39:11our freedoms and rights to protest, to speak.
- 39:18And if we don't use those freedoms and rights, that they could easily be taken away from
- 39:22us.
- 39:23For that reason alone, we should be doing what we're doing.
- 39:27Not to mention, obviously, we're doing it for animals, we're doing it for the planet,
- 39:32and any other cause that benefits that I believe there's many other causes that actually benefit
- 39:37from the work we do.
- 39:38But if only for that reason, people that say, well, isn't it just a waste of time?
- 39:44They're never going to change.
- 39:49The question has so much privilege embedded in it.
- 39:52It's basically ignoring the fact that any rights and freedoms that we have today were
- 39:59hard fought by activists of other generations that we aren't even honoring.
- 40:05We're not even recognizing the work that they did and the results that they achieved.
- 40:11And we're just benefiting from the fruits of their labor.
- 40:14And then we have the audacity to criticize those of us today that are trying to make
- 40:25change.
- 40:26And the other thing that I love is that no one has any problem with going out on the
- 40:31street and talking to people about veganism or animal rights.
- 40:35But as soon as you get into the spaces of power, all of a sudden, everybody's questioning,
- 40:40well, why are you doing that?
- 40:42And it's like, but they don't give that kind of scrutiny to any other kind of activists.
- 40:47I don't get it.
- 40:49I don't get it either.
- 40:53Another pertinent point that I don't see represented often in all of this public discourse
- 40:59around animal rights is how big ag is a threat to our democracy.
- 41:06You talked about this secret hidden chicken comedy.
- 41:12You talked about the lobbyists and then how you can't access your senator to talk about
- 41:19this important issue that has a great impact on our health, on public health, on the lives
- 41:31of so many workers, if we stay on the human centering plane.
- 41:38So could you maybe represent that point, that argument of how big ag is really this enormous
- 41:48threat to our democracy?
- 41:51Yes.
- 41:53I would like to, on that note, I have to credit a book that is recent.
- 41:59It's called Barron's, Poland, Money, Power and the Corruption of America's Food Industry.
- 42:06It was released on March 26th, 2024.
- 42:11And it was written by an investigative type reporter guy.
- 42:16His name is Austin Frerich.
- 42:19And I follow his Twitter feed.
- 42:22He does a lot of really incredible investigative work into this industry and just how this
- 42:34whole system works between this whole lobbying game, how these trade groups set up shop in
- 42:43Washington DC and have these lavish parties.
- 42:50I was able to confirm what he is writing about because we have seen it for ourselves.
- 42:58The meat industry, the trade groups, the egg industry, the dairy, they have these lavish
- 43:04parties at these members only clubs.
- 43:07And they have the power and access to the most powerful people in government, inviting
- 43:15them to speak, whining and dining them.
- 43:19And limousines pull up, the armored cars pull up, these people come in and out.
- 43:25But they have no time for advocacy groups like us.
- 43:30And what he wrote in this book confirms the experiences we've had.
- 43:39No access without creating access.
- 43:45It's the only way is creating access for ourselves.
- 43:50And I tell people that phone calls and emails from no matter how many hundreds, no matter
- 43:57how many thousands are never going to be enough.
- 44:00And protesting even on the sidewalk has this perception, this public perception of us being
- 44:07on the outside of power.
- 44:10Whereas when we get into the spaces of power, we are physically present.
- 44:16And the perception is that we are reclaiming the power and that we consented to others
- 44:23to govern us and that we're no longer okay with this relationship, the social contract.
- 44:29And so being in that space, that physical space and seeing, looking at these people
- 44:36face to face and speaking to them face to face is incredibly important for the optics
- 44:44of the activism, I think.
- 44:46Yes, I mean, I wouldn't put it, I don't know how to put it in a better way than you just
- 44:54did.
- 44:55And, you know, of course, I will add a link to the book in the description for people
- 45:01who want to check it out.
- 45:04You make me want to purchase the book.
- 45:06I think I will get it.
- 45:07I think that's for sure.
- 45:08I will get it.
- 45:12You're incredibly fearless for doing this.
- 45:18How did you get so brave, you know, to just speak up in a room filled with people who
- 45:28are completely opposed and have interests, including monetary interest in being against
- 45:38what you're pushing?
- 45:40Well, that's very kind of you to say.
- 45:43Let me first say that I don't think that I'm, I mean, I do agree that it does take
- 45:50certain amount of mental preparedness and psychological orientation and courage to speak
- 45:58truth to power and get into these situations.
- 46:02But I also recognize that some activists have taken far greater risks and made far bigger
- 46:10sacrifices than I have.
- 46:11So I'm very much humbled by some of the things that I've seen.
- 46:15Like I'll give you an example.
- 46:18There's a group called the Fearless Grandmother Society.
- 46:25I think that's their name.
- 46:27Oh, the Society of Fearless Grandmothers.
- 46:30And I came across some video workshops of theirs and I was really moved by what they
- 46:41were doing.
- 46:42Their mission is to put their bodies in front on the line in a roadblock or in other situations
- 46:50where there's risk to protect everyone else because they're the mothers, they're the grandmothers
- 46:57that are expected to play that protective role in society.
- 47:02And I thought that was incredibly powerful and brave.
- 47:06They're putting their bodies on the line in some cases.
- 47:10And to me, that's much further evolved than what I'm doing in terms of, you know, speak
- 47:18outs or disruptions.
- 47:21So I want to honor that because I think there's definitely levels of risk and sacrifice that
- 47:27people are making and putting their lives at risk.
- 47:34Like you know, all the time and all over the world that often don't get any recognition,
- 47:40by the way.
- 47:42Again, most of us privileged people think that, you know, we don't recognize the sacrifices
- 47:51that other activists make and how it contributes to the freedoms that we enjoy and the lifestyle
- 47:57that we enjoy.
- 48:00And the media doesn't give any attention to them either.
- 48:04The media, so the media credits the politicians.
- 48:08So for example, really brief example, after years of really profound activism in the animal
- 48:19a gay liberation movement with groups like Act Up in New York, all of a sudden one day
- 48:28the Supreme Court made gay marriage the law of the land.
- 48:33And Barack Obama and Bill Clinton and Hillary Clinton all went on record saying that marriage
- 48:40is between a man and a woman, period, for years.
- 48:48But when that Supreme Court ruling made the headlines, it was all about making the Supreme
- 49:01Court the hero of the gay liberation movement, which just be getting married isn't necessarily
- 49:10liberation.
- 49:11It just means you can get married.
- 49:12But anyway, that's a different issue.
- 49:14But the politicians then said Barack Obama and Bill Clinton said, I've always believed
- 49:21in gay marriage.
- 49:22I've always believed in the right to freedom to marry.
- 49:26And I don't know what you're talking about.
- 49:27They lied through their teeth and they took credit for something that they didn't they
- 49:33actually resisted.
- 49:35And none of the credit went to the activism movements that created that that made that
- 49:41possible.
- 49:42So the historical record is basically that the big, powerful people are the ones that
- 49:50actually enacted that change.
- 49:53And that's sad because the public will never really know what was behind that.
- 49:58But it's our job, I think, also to, you know, we got to set the record straight.
- 50:07The title of my last week's episode that I published was Who the heck should we vote
- 50:16for?
- 50:17So let me ask you, Robert, who the heck should we vote for?
- 50:23Well, that's that's a great question.
- 50:27I think in our presidential election, I understand people that on the uncommitted side, that's
- 50:37that there's there's an uncommitted position.
- 50:43And they're going to use their vote to make a statement or their lack of voting to make
- 50:48a statement that they don't support either party.
- 50:52I think that's one way of looking at it.
- 50:56And then, of course, the mainstream way of looking at it is that we can't let Trump get
- 51:01reelected.
- 51:03And so we have to vote for Kamala Harris because it's going to be a tight election and we got
- 51:12to make sure he doesn't get in.
- 51:16To me, in the end, I'm not sure that voting matters all that much because both sides,
- 51:31there's very little distinction between the Republican and the Democratic side.
- 51:37So for the kind of change that we're looking for, that we say we want, we need a radical
- 51:50dismantling of the current power structure.
- 51:53We need new leadership and something very different than we have that neither the Democratic
- 52:01or Republican parties will ever get close to.
- 52:07And so if you want to make the lesser of two evils argument, I'm good with that.
- 52:14I'm not going to argue.
- 52:15I'm not going to debate that with people because actually that the cause that we're presenting,
- 52:22we are presenting it to everyone and saying that we think this makes sense to a broad
- 52:33spectrum of political orientations.
- 52:36So you want to vote that way or this way.
- 52:39I'd much rather not see Trump in office.
- 52:42I think that's probably shared by a lot of people.
- 52:46But people like Glenn Greenwald and other political pundits are saying, well, he wasn't
- 52:56really able to do that much.
- 52:58He's talked a lot about what he was going to do and how it sounded terrible, but that
- 53:03he wasn't really able to change things all that much.
- 53:06And maybe he has a point.
- 53:08I don't know.
- 53:09Although he did get a lot of Supreme Court judges that he wanted in there.
- 53:14So that's something.
- 53:15And on a more uplifting note, what was the most enjoyable interaction you had with one
- 53:27of those politicians who hide from the sun to do their dark farm related business?
- 53:39What was the funniest moment?
- 53:41Or is that what you're?
- 53:42Yeah, I have to say that we've disrupted the USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack.
- 53:51For those that don't know, the USDA is the United States Department of Agriculture, and
- 53:55it's a cabinet position that is appointed by the president.
- 54:00Tom Vilsack was previously a dairy industry lobbyist before he spent 13 years as the USDA
- 54:08Secretary, the most powerful person in agriculture, you could say.
- 54:14We've disrupted him about four times.
- 54:17And every time he says something like, isn't it great that we live in a democracy where
- 54:24people can say what they want?
- 54:28And we have this kind of, you know.
- 54:31And I turned around to him the last one on last Tuesday and I said, you're not kidding
- 54:37anybody.
- 54:38Your food system is completely anti-democratic.
- 54:45It's corrupted by animal industry lobbyists.
- 54:49And you know it because you are a lobbyist yourself.
- 54:52So you're not fooling anybody.
- 54:55And he was appointed by the Democratic Party.
- 55:00He was appointed by Biden, but he also served under Trump.
- 55:05I think if I'm not mistaken.
- 55:07And he also served prior to that under other Republican administrations.
- 55:11So these people care about their careers.
- 55:14They don't care about, yeah, sure.
- 55:16I'll parrot your Republican agenda or your Democratic agenda.
- 55:22If it works, I stay in office and I hold onto power.
- 55:26Yeah, sure.
- 55:27I can be easily swayed.
- 55:31But Robert, Kamala Harris uses almond milk in her coffee every morning.
- 55:36That's what I read on all sorts of medias.
- 55:41That by all means vote for her.
- 55:43I think, you know, that reason alone, right?
- 55:49By the way, we know that Tim Walz is a nightmare.
- 55:53He brags about being the best shot in Congress.
- 55:57And then USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack said in an interview on Sunday.
- 56:01Oh, I'm sorry.
- 56:03Maybe it was last week.
- 56:04He said that he knows how to Tom Vilsack knows how to put on a plaid shirt and take down
- 56:12a pheasant and that that was how he could relate to rural America and right wing America.
- 56:19And that that's why he was such a good pick.
- 56:22And I thought to myself.
- 56:24Right.
- 56:25So pheasant hunting is basically canned hunting where they artificially breed thousands of
- 56:32pheasant chicks in an artificial hatchery, just like the chicken and egg industries.
- 56:40They raise them in captivity and then they release them as very tame birds with no survival
- 56:47skills into hunting grounds to be sometimes these birds are so tame that you they will
- 56:54not even run when a human runs up to them.
- 56:56And you'll see these canned hunters actually kick the bird into the air to shoot at them
- 57:02at point blank range at like five or 10 feet.
- 57:06And that's considered having a good shot, like being having some kind of shooting skill.
- 57:16So like when you know about pheasant hunting and you hear something like that, you realize
- 57:24just how cynical and maligned someone like Tom Vilsack is that he would be willing to
- 57:36deceive us into thinking that that was some kind of skill and that that's what's going
- 57:43to make him, you know, brave, looking like a real, you know, strong man or whatever to
- 57:51the right wing.
- 57:52And that's pretty, pretty disgusting.
- 57:58I did not know about that.
- 58:00I'm not surprised that and without mentioning his ties with the dairy industry.
- 58:12And let me ask you this question because I'm very curious.
- 58:17All of those, you know, Democrats, politicians, they all must know a vegetarian and even vegans
- 58:27in their lives.
- 58:28Since most vegans and vegetarians are liberals and we know, you know, they have higher degrees
- 58:36and all of that.
- 58:37So they're most likely part of that circle of friends or who knows what that composes,
- 58:45you know, and the community of those people.
- 58:49So why are those vegetarians and vegans not, you know, going to their friends, their politicians
- 58:59friends and asking them, you know, what are you doing?
- 59:03You should know that this is not good.
- 59:05And, you know, so have you ever thought about that?
- 59:10Yes.
- 59:11And I don't claim to know.
- 59:15But I what I speculate is that what I see on social media and just the chatter that
- 59:22I hear is that we need to disregard all this until they get elected.
- 59:31And then we can hammer them for what they said and what they think they're going to
- 59:39do.
- 59:40Okay.
- 59:43I mean, either way, I think it should be out there.
- 59:51And I think, like you said, we should we should hold people accountable.
- 59:56I mean, again, it goes back to the, you know, someone's going to come back to the argument
- 1:00:03of the lesser of two evils and make that argument.
- 1:00:07It's the same kind of argument, though, that people make about like welfare reforms, like
- 1:00:13trying to get corporations to go cage free and saying, like, at least it's a step in
- 1:00:19the right direction.
- 1:00:21But then there's there's a lot of nuances in that because a lot of times it benefits
- 1:00:27the corporations.
- 1:00:29It gives them the humane base PR move that they need.
- 1:00:34And then it's just a pledge.
- 1:00:35So they're not even required to be audited and to prove that they actually did adopt
- 1:00:42the change.
- 1:00:44It's just simply a pledge.
- 1:00:47And so they might not do it.
- 1:00:50They you know, and I think we should be strong.
- 1:00:54You know, we should that's not holding corporation or person accountable in either case.
- 1:01:00But if people want to wait until they get elected, OK.
- 1:01:05You know, so be it.
- 1:01:08Do you think there is a filter?
- 1:01:11You know, I'm thinking of vet school, you know, often there is an interview before getting
- 1:01:19in the veterinarian school.
- 1:01:23And if they discover you're vegan or vegetarian or you have this animal rights inclination,
- 1:01:31they will most likely reject you and reject you as a student.
- 1:01:36Do you think there is something like that with those political parties that they don't
- 1:01:42want anyone who is sympathetic to the animal rights cause or who is surrounded with vegans?
- 1:01:50Or, you know, no, I don't know that they.
- 1:01:56They're singling out that issue is something to disassociate themselves from necessarily
- 1:02:03so much as they are.
- 1:02:06Looking to please a wide spectrum of constituencies that have different interests and trying to
- 1:02:13juggle their messaging so that they don't piss off one over the other.
- 1:02:20And that's the problem with being a politician.
- 1:02:24If you choose this profession, which obviously some people need to be, you have to.
- 1:02:33You have a lot of special interests to juggle, and I think you have to make some hard choices
- 1:02:38about what you really believe in and what you want to see the future to look like.
- 1:02:46And you have to listen to constituents, but you also have to make hard decisions that
- 1:02:52you think benefit the greater good.
- 1:02:56But politicians today are opportunistic and more career driven rather than mission driven.
- 1:03:05And so the nature of politics is corrupted by that kind of, you know, narcissistic pursuit
- 1:03:17of career over public good.
- 1:03:22And that's something that I think getting money out of politics is a key thing to work
- 1:03:29on.
- 1:03:30It's also something that can align us with so many other movements.
- 1:03:34We talked about allies, we talked about finding common ground with other movements.
- 1:03:39Well, getting money out of politics could go to such a great length to solve the problem
- 1:03:45that we're looking at.
- 1:03:47We want animal ag money out of politics.
- 1:03:51Other groups want fossil fuel money out of politics or big banks money or pharmaceutical
- 1:03:57industry money out of politics.
- 1:04:01They all represent this common idea that this is damaging a representative government.
- 1:04:08It's corrupting our elected officials that are serving us and we need to take back that
- 1:04:15power.
- 1:04:16So that's the underlying problem that we're dealing with.
- 1:04:23And while most of our movement like that has anything to do with you'll notice that most
- 1:04:28of the groups that are working on the farm bill have very specific modest demands.
- 1:04:34There's the safe act that they want to pass to protect horses.
- 1:04:38And then there's the eats act, the eats act, which is undoing prop 12 in California, which
- 1:04:46were modest protections for farmed animals.
- 1:04:49They want their all the groups are rallying about how important it is that we stop the
- 1:04:54eats act in that language.
- 1:04:57But they're not actually addressing the underlying problem, which is money, animal ag money in
- 1:05:02politics.
- 1:05:03And there's always going to be an eats act.
- 1:05:05There's always going to be pernicious type of maneuver by animal ag and their politicians,
- 1:05:14their elected Congress people that they're allies to pass anti animal, anti planet, anti
- 1:05:21climate mitigation laws and protect their industries.
- 1:05:26Will we address this issue of money in politics?
- 1:05:30So we need to be really, you know, talking about this much more.
- 1:05:36And these groups aren't saying a word about it.
- 1:05:40Very true.
- 1:05:42Robert, this has been an amazing conversation.
- 1:05:47And my admiration for you has increased tremendously.
- 1:05:54I wanted to ask, you know, do you have anything more to add before I stop the recording?
- 1:06:00I'm good.
- 1:06:01I feel like I've my voice is almost shot.
- 1:06:05So I think I unless you have more questions, I feel like I'm in a good shape.
- 1:06:14Well, let's let's stop here.
- 1:06:16Let's stop here.
- 1:06:17And please come back to the show.
- 1:06:19Truly.
- 1:06:20I would love that.
- 1:06:21Amazing.
- 1:06:22So, Robert, once again, thank you.
- 1:06:24Thank you so much for having taken the time to be here.
- 1:06:27It was my pleasure and it was great to talk to you.
- 1:06:31Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:06:33I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans, you know, let's encourage
- 1:06:38more people to take action.
- 1:06:40Again, thank you so much for caring.
- 1:06:43And I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.