Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Wednesday, July 3, 2024
Transcript
- 0:10Happy Independence Day Eve. Dave Wilson in the big chair for Hoppy Kerchival.
- 0:16This is Metro News Talk Line and we are underway. You are surrounded this
- 0:27beat. Your radio turned off from the studio so w v RC Media and
- 0:33the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful
- 0:38radio show in West Virginia. This this is Metro News Talk Live with Hobby
- 0:43Kerchival. Activated switch. Where can you from? Charles stand by you,
- 0:51Hoppy. You're on Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you
- 0:56by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 1:00Visit in covid dot com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome to
- 1:04the Incoba Insurance Studios in the Dale Miller Building. Dave Wilson filling in for
- 1:08Hoppy Kerchiwill. Hoppy enjoying a week of vacation. He will return on Monday.
- 1:15Gang's all here. Connor Lemley on the phones and Austin Wright running the
- 1:19video stream this morning. The phone number is eight hundred seven sixty five eight
- 1:25two five five eight hundred seven to sixty five talk. The text line very
- 1:29popular is three oh four Talk three oh four. Later this hour, we'll
- 1:34talk to political scientist Rob Rupp will join us. He has had a week
- 1:40to digest not only the presidential debate between President Biden and former President Trump,
- 1:46but the reaction and the reaction to the reaction. We'll talk to him about
- 1:49all of that coming up at the bottom of the hour. Brad McIlhenny will
- 1:53stop by as well. We'll get an update from Ryan Schmels and Jonathan Savage.
- 1:57Jonathan Savage, of course is on the other side to the pond,
- 2:00and he is with Fox News and he is at Benjamin Franklin's house in London.
- 2:07Today we'll find out what well the rest of the world thinks of July
- 2:14fourth. So that is all straight ahead, and of course your calls,
- 2:15text tweets always welcome as well. Yesterday, at this time, we spoke
- 2:20to Governor Jim Justice, a day after he one celebrated another year with a
- 2:25surplus in revenue collections, but two after he announced his I Guess, a
- 2:31challenge to state lawmakers to not only implement the not only implement the possibility of
- 2:39reduction to the personal income tax that will be triggered through the law that was
- 2:44passed a couple of years ago, could be three or four percent in August,
- 2:46but to pass an additional five percent personal income tax cut. The governor
- 2:53talked about that at length on the program yesterday. Today, I'd like to
- 2:57welcome to the program the chairman of the Senate Finance Committee and the Senator from
- 3:01Putnam County, Eric Tar. Senator Tar, good morning, thanks for coming
- 3:05on the show. Well, good morning, thanks for ving bout Dave.
- 3:07Appreciate you taking some time. Let me actually start here and then we'll get
- 3:10into the idea of a tax cut. But several I guess you go back,
- 3:16what eight nine years we were talking about a budget deficit. We were
- 3:21talking about filling that gap, we were having special sessions, tax increases were
- 3:27proposed. So how did we get to this point from your perspective, where
- 3:30we're talking about surpluses and reducing the income tax even further from what it's already
- 3:37been reduced. Well, first of all, there is one thing I'll agree
- 3:39with the governor on is that it's certainly a blessing from God that where we're
- 3:44at now compared to where we were. So you know, anytime things happen
- 3:47that are this good, that that's where credit has to go first, cause
- 3:53in spite of all of our abilities, there's got to be some help from
- 3:55above. But you know, back when when we were in that deficit,
- 4:00we were in a ten percent deaths at that time, we had a four
- 4:02hundred and fifty million dollars shortfall. And then go that time, Governor Justice
- 4:08came in and proposed a four hundred and fifty million dollar tax increase in order
- 4:14to get us out of that deficit, and the legislature held the line.
- 4:16And what we ended up doing is going through and doing a ten percent cut
- 4:19because we had about a four and a half billion state budget at that time,
- 4:25and so we went in and did a ten percent cut across all of
- 4:27government and cut spending, reduced spending by four hundred and fifty million dollars instead
- 4:32of a tax increase. And then shortly after that, within a couple of
- 4:36years, President Blair came up with the idea of starting to hold flat budgets,
- 4:44which was no I mean, it's just it was very unique across all
- 4:47the country to come in and say that you're not going to increase your budget
- 4:51year after year for four years. And the intent of doing that was that
- 4:56we knew that we would save about one hundred and fifty million a year for
- 5:00every year that we did that. We were chasing reducing to elimination the personal
- 5:04property tax in West Virginia, and that ticket was about six hundred million dollars
- 5:11and so the flat budget as we started holding those were based on that.
- 5:15In that process, we also started looking at what would it take to make
- 5:19West Virginia one of the top ten states in the country relative income taxes,
- 5:26which means would mean eliminating the income tax. And at what point does the
- 5:30income tax reduction start to actually move people to a state the cause of the
- 5:36taxation structure. And so when we were looking at that, we saw that
- 5:40that it's really about fifty percent reduction is what was doing. Needed an income
- 5:44tax cut to really move people to West Virginia. To get the job creation,
- 5:48we needed elimination of the part personal property tax. And if you can
- 5:51get the job elimination, you're going to move people here. And we're starting
- 5:54to see that we've got sixty eight thousand open jobs right now in West Virginia.
- 5:58We need people. So as we start looking at that, really we
- 6:01got to forecasting pretty aggressively in twenty twenty, and we are on forecast relative
- 6:08to what we expected with the level of tax reductions we've done so far.
- 6:14And those tax reductions are are dependent on the economic performance of West Virginia.
- 6:19That's how they're triggered. When West virginia economy is firing on all cylinders and
- 6:26is growing faster than the rate of inflation for the country, that produces an
- 6:30income tax cut. That represents the difference in those two. So the way
- 6:36that it's set up right now is it's the safe and it's a responsible way
- 6:42to start reducing the income tax, and it produces surpluses that a lot of
- 6:47times are just one time bumps that you'll get one time bumping. So think
- 6:51about if you had just one time money windfall that falls into your house,
- 6:55and there's all these different things you can do with it. You could go
- 6:58on vacation, go buy you a new are, you could put in your
- 7:00savings account, you could invest it, and all those things. Well,
- 7:02we treat the one time dollars as though they are one time things. But
- 7:08what you don't do is you don't go in and give yourself a payment that
- 7:13is going to outlast that one time spend, and so you have to be
- 7:15really, really careful. So tax reductions are those payments. They're they're perpetual
- 7:20payments because it reduces your revenue coming into your home. And anything that you
- 7:25do on spending that is a base spend is a payment that goes on perpetually.
- 7:30So one time dollars should be related to one time expenses that either reduce
- 7:36the demand on the taxpayer for having spent it, or increase the revenue that
- 7:42comes into the state for having made the investment. And that's how we look
- 7:45at these one time revenues. So there's a couple of things the governor said.
- 7:48One he said, we have an eight hundred twenty six million dollars surplus,
- 7:51and that's incorrect. We had a eight hundred twenty sixty dollars surplus when
- 7:57we came off regular session. This past special session, we spend about two
- 8:00hundred and forty some million dollars and the governor raised the revenue estimate by that
- 8:05amount, which reduces your surplus available. So the actual surplus is about five
- 8:09hundred and eighty nine million. If you look at the expenses that are already
- 8:16on the books and look at fiscal year twenty six statutes that have already been
- 8:20passed. There's already about three hundred and twenty million dollars in growth that I
- 8:24can rattle off real quickly, and there's probably more that I don't I'm not
- 8:28aware of it just yet. And then you have about one hundred million dollar
- 8:31taxi decrease that's hitting us this year, So you're already up to about four
- 8:35hundred and twenty million dollars of money that you take away from that five hundred
- 8:43and eighty nine. That doesn't leave a lot of cushion, but it's right
- 8:46on forecast. And what we know is is those surpluses are going to continue
- 8:50to drop, because if you just remember just a year ago, there were
- 8:52one point eight billion and now they're five hundred and eighty nine million. That's
- 8:58a huge drop, but it's a dry we expected because of the tax cuts
- 9:01and because of the investments we were making. So once these businesses get out
- 9:05of the ground, they got all their employees rolling, and the revenue starts
- 9:09to come in off that, and the population base comes off that, your
- 9:13revenue to the state starts to go up without increasing taxes, and it gives
- 9:16you afford you the ability to reduce taxes. That's the plan we've been on.
- 9:20It's the plan we've been sticking to. It's the plan that we have
- 9:24aggressively tried to hold the line on all the way to this point. And
- 9:28you know what, for having done that, there's a palpable hope in the
- 9:33hollers and mountains and streets of West Virginia that I haven't seen in my entire
- 9:37lifetime. So you know, it's my position. I think it's it'll be
- 9:41the sentenced position that we continue down the path that we forecasted because those numbers
- 9:48are hitting. And if you get out ahead of your skis by going out
- 9:52and spending more than you're bringing in for having reduced what you brought in or
- 9:58for god excessive on your spend, we can put the brakes on all that
- 10:01goodness right now if we do that. So that's that's the position. It's
- 10:07uh, you know, it's it really comes down to map. Talking to
- 10:09sit of Finance Committee Chairman Eric tar So, it is it is your position
- 10:15that an additional five percent reduction to the personal income tax right now, that
- 10:20is that is not feasible. Yeah, that get that's the getting the head
- 10:24of your skis part of it, because that's another one hundred million dollars.
- 10:28If you if you go look, it's about it's anywhere between twenty two and
- 10:31twenty twenty four million dollars for every one percent you drop it down, so
- 10:35we we did. We're going to have somewhere three or four percent, so
- 10:39we're expecting that's going to be around ninety million dollars. We already got a
- 10:43head of that income tax reduction by reducing to elimination over the next three years
- 10:50the personal income tax on social Security, so if you receive sealfe Security,
- 10:54you will have no income tax on those dollars within the next three years.
- 10:58Well this year that is quite about ten million dollars coming up. So there's
- 11:01already coming into this this next year one hundred million dollars in tax reduction.
- 11:07The governor dropped a bomb on us there on stage because we didn't get heads
- 11:11up, which just tends to be his m to go in and discuss them.
- 11:15But here is reasoning. Is that another five percent another at least another
- 11:20one hundred million dollars, and that's that payment I'm talking about goes in perpetual
- 11:24and if if we here's the two scenarios that put you in when you look
- 11:28at the forecasting on relative to tax cuts we want. Either you're going to
- 11:33have to go in and reduce spending that is so bloody that so you can
- 11:39afford that bloody by I mean that you're going to it is going to be
- 11:41politically challenging, and it will be citizen uproar on some of those services.
- 11:48Because we've been catching infrastructure up. We've been getting sewer and water done,
- 11:50we've been getting roads done, we've been getting broad bend down. You want
- 11:54to stop all that, then go ahead and throw another hundred million dollars expensive
- 11:58if they're for now, for perpetuity before we get the ability to have the
- 12:01revenue growth and the things we've done. And then in addition to that is
- 12:07that when we go in and accelerate that tax cut, we have to look
- 12:13at an offset if we're not going to reduce spending. So if you don't
- 12:20go in and make those aggressive cuts, which I'm all about reducing size of
- 12:22government cuts, I have been pushing that, pushing that, pushing, that's
- 12:24how we that's what flat budgets have done. They have reduced the expensive government.
- 12:30But if we go in and we don't reduce the spending aggressively to that
- 12:33bloody level, then you've got to go find a tax somewhere else. You
- 12:35got to increase. And there's there's really no reason right now for the way
- 12:41we've got things since go in and say hey, we're going to increase your
- 12:43taxes somewhere else. And I don't think anybody wants to do that. Of
- 12:46course, you know the governor's on his way out. He'll be in DC.
- 12:48You know it's not his circus anymore. At that point. If I
- 12:52may be so bold to summarize everything you just said into a concise sentence,
- 12:58it is possible to have too much of a good thing when it comes to
- 13:01tax cuts, because you could I think I heard your argument correctly, actually
- 13:05slow or even halt the progress the state has made. Is that is that
- 13:09a fair summarization If you want to if you want to eliminate the personal income
- 13:16tax, you have to get more people. In West Virginia, we have
- 13:20about six hundred to eight hundred thousand people that are carrying the tax burden of
- 13:24one point eight billion people. In order to reduce forty percent of our revenue.
- 13:31That's what the income tax is it's forty percent of the state's general revenue
- 13:33budget. To get that down to at least a fifty center zero, you
- 13:37have to give time for the people to come here for what we've been doing,
- 13:41and they're coming. You see. I mean, you got to see
- 13:43it in billion dollar level business. We used to celebrate when we get a
- 13:46ten million dollar business bill a billion dollars is insane. But we're getting multi
- 13:50billion dollar level investments. It takes time for those to produce the income and
- 13:54people in West Virginia to allow us to eliminate this tax, and it takes
- 13:58resources from the state to be competitive to say come to West Virginia, don't
- 14:03go to Ohio, don't go to Pennsylvania. So yes, I mean,
- 14:07you have to be responsible with getting that tax down. And I want it
- 14:11down too, and I'll help every governor's in there to get it done.
- 14:15But what I won't do is crash West Virginia doing it. State Senate Finance
- 14:20Committee Chairman Eric Tarr Senator Tar always appreciate it. Thank you so much,
- 14:24absolutely thanks for having me on. Absolutely coming up, we'll check in with
- 14:28Fox News Radios Ryan Schmels. We'll do that next A new episode of Live
- 14:31Healthy West Virginia is now posted on the podcast center of wb metronews dot com
- 14:35and the Metro News TV app coming soon. The Elkins Corridor Medical Center a
- 14:41hospital without beds. When you think of probably ninety percent of the healthcare that
- 14:46we all need, it can all be accomplished in this building because we don't
- 14:50always need surgeries. Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for candid conversations with insights
- 14:54for improving your health and well being. Live Healthy West Virginia is presented by
- 14:58w You Medicine. Winning the lottery would be the start of my race dream.
- 15:03Hitting the open road at top speeds, hugging turns. It's intense.
- 15:11What are you dreaming of racing again? Not dreaming, I'm practicing and I'm
- 15:18checking my tickets. It's a mower. It's a dream West Virginia Lottery.
- 15:26What if it could happen to you? Please play responsibly at your business.
- 15:31You're doing everything right, your customer service top notch, your financial management flawless,
- 15:37and your team the best in the business. But there's one essential piece
- 15:39missing, a comprehensive business technology strategy. Without it, no matter how good
- 15:43your practices are, your business could suffer irreparable harm, and that's where city
- 15:48Net comes in part Taylor Technology Solutions ensure your business stays secure, efficient,
- 15:52and ahead of the curve. Don't leave your success to chance. Contacts city
- 15:56Net Today. City Net Connects, protects and perfect. You're listening to Talkline
- 16:00on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Wvmetronews dot com, the
- 16:08only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State. Get the latest
- 16:12news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and never miss an
- 16:17episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcasts, including Talkline, Hotline,
- 16:22sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark now and
- 16:26visit wv metronews dot com first thing every morning to find out what's happening all
- 16:32across the state. Wv metronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain
- 16:37states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters
- 16:41and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down
- 16:47hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Stockfish for Repatriation purposes
- 16:52to that reintroduction, re establishment of Brook trout and two of those streams,
- 16:56the oldest that we have worked on, the earliest more that we started putting
- 17:00fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether it's
- 17:04hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors.
- 17:10It was a pretty good fride. It takes me about ten minutes to
- 17:12get it in. My dad actually had to run to the truck and grab
- 17:17anat because there's my way. I could lift him up over top of the
- 17:19rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am
- 17:25and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes
- 17:29of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News
- 17:33of Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up
- 17:37your weekend. It's the City that Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey, this
- 17:41is Travis Jowes joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six
- 17:45until eight o'clock. As we wrap up the sports weekend, we talked Mountaineers,
- 17:48high School, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national scene.
- 17:52The Sunday sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text the
- 17:56show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect week again.
- 18:00Sports Wrap up on your favorite Metro News affiliate or watch the show at
- 18:03wb metronews dot com. Metro News Talkline with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you
- 18:21by Incoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 18:26Visit in Covia dot com to learn more. We'll talk to political scientists
- 18:30Rob Up coming up bottom of the hour. Right now, let's get an
- 18:33update. Box News Radio is Ryan Schmelz joins us on talkline. Ryan,
- 18:37Good morning, Hey, good morning. How are you sir? Doing pretty
- 18:41well? The US Supreme Court issued the ruling earlier this week that says the
- 18:45president has some immunity when it comes to well he is community when it comes
- 18:49to official actions, none or at least some presumed immunity for nonofficial actions.
- 18:55That's the short story. Anyway, there has been swift and loud reactions to
- 19:00that, including a Democratic senator who may try to introduce an amendment about this.
- 19:06What's the latest. It's a House member, yes, so we have
- 19:08one Democrat House member who is introducing a bill or it's a I guess a
- 19:14constitutional amendment that would reverse the Supreme Court decision. Then you have Alexandro Casio
- 19:18Cortez from New York as well, who's introducing articles of impeachment when we get
- 19:23back from the fourth of July recess. Now we don't know which members or
- 19:30which Supreme Court justice she's mentioning in these articles of impeachment, but I think
- 19:33it could be any one of the conservative ones, not just Clarence Thomas or
- 19:37Sam Alito, which would be the you know, maybe ones that people would
- 19:41would immediately jump to because of their alleged connections to Donald Trump. In January
- 19:48sixth, Now there there's also this renewed push from Democrats both House and Senate
- 19:55for the Supreme Court to adopt a code of ethics. You know, they've
- 19:59pressured John ro Roberts, the Chief Justice, to do so. But at
- 20:02the same time they want to do this themselves through legislation. They still have
- 20:06the post to do so. Ryan. The amendment and the articles of impeachment,
- 20:11those are both headed exactly to the same place, aren't they Nowhere pretty
- 20:17much yes, I mean, I mean what's interesting is that actually this is
- 20:22a privileged resolution, so she can bring it up at any time. And
- 20:26also, you know, I think somebody threw this idea out there that oh,
- 20:30you know, this could be something that actually House Republicans might just call
- 20:34to the floor just so they can show their unity behind the issue. So
- 20:38I think it's a wait and see approach. But yes, I mean,
- 20:41the reality is all of these bills just seem to be messaging bills at this
- 20:44point, and they're likely to go nowhere. What's the feeling I know that
- 20:48it's the holidays to Independence Day coming up, but what's what's the feeling in
- 20:52DC right now? Given what happened with the presidential debate to the Supreme Court
- 20:56rulings that have come down here are the last seven days. Is there is
- 21:00there a sense in the air. Well, you know, what's interesting I
- 21:04think is the first time I've talked to you since uh, the the the
- 21:07debate performance from President Biden. And what was fascinating is in the paint painting
- 21:12your viewers a little bit of a picture here. You know, every day
- 21:15or every time the Congress is in session, they have what's called the jail
- 21:18break, which is when all of the House members decide to leave the House
- 21:23House chamber after votes are over, and so they're all just like kind of
- 21:26running down this, uh, the the series of steps, or they're or
- 21:30they're going back to the taking the tunnels back to their offices. And you
- 21:33know, usually some members are in more demand than others, but this was
- 21:37one of those just weird days where every single Democrat was of news value to
- 21:42the media, and every single Democrat was getting pressed with questions about should Biden
- 21:47stay in the race? Uh, do you still have confidence in him being
- 21:49the candidate? And and you know, at the time, it seemed like
- 21:53most Democrats were were reaffirming their support for President Biden. But as you know,
- 21:57over the last couple of hours, that sentiment has changed. You have
- 22:00Lloyd Dogge at the congressman from Texas, who has called on President Biden to
- 22:07step aside, the first elected House member to do so on the Democrat side.
- 22:11And then you have Jared Golden of Maine and Marie Lusen Camperez of Washington
- 22:17both either doing interviews or releasing op ed yesterday where they pretty much predicted Donald
- 22:22Trump was going to beat President Biden this November. Fox News Radios Ryan smells
- 22:26right. I got about thirty seconds, but I want to ask you this
- 22:29question before Independence Day coming up. From your perspective, it seemed well.
- 22:34From my perspective, it seemed like the last three years that it's been pretty
- 22:41tight around the president button up, not in a lot of leaks. In
- 22:44the last week, it seems like the floodgates have opened up. Are more
- 22:48people talking over the last week or so about what specifically, whether or not
- 22:55he could be president, his physical condition, what's going on behind closed doors,
- 22:59things we may not see. Well, the questions are certainly being asked,
- 23:03right and now you're starting to see this new report that apparently there is
- 23:07this reporting from Reuters that twenty five House Democrats are getting ready to tell President
- 23:14Biden to step aside. I'm trying to get that individually confirmed, but I
- 23:18think that would be quite substantial if that goes down. Fox News Radios,
- 23:22Ryan Schmells, Ryan, Happy Independence Day and appreciate the time. Hey you
- 23:26too, my friend, Thank you so much. Absolutely. Coming up,
- 23:29we'll talk to political scientist West Virginia Wesleyan professor Emeritis rob Rupp will join us
- 23:34on the other side of the news break. We'll get his take on all
- 23:37that has happened over the last seven days since the presidential debate. That's coming
- 23:41up Brad mclheney. We'll talk homeschooling as well. Coming up in the second
- 23:45hour of the show. This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice
- 23:48of West Virginia. It is ten thirty and time to get a news update.
- 23:55Let's check in with the Metro News radio network. Find out what's happening
- 23:56across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News designed Kerry hooda
- 24:03sec governor t Justices, urging state lawmakers to embrace a personal income tax proposal.
- 24:08The governor says, the more you cut taxes, the more revenue will
- 24:11come in. We've got another eight hundred and twenty six Megan dollars of serve
- 24:17blows. I mean, it's it's more money than anybody can imagine. We
- 24:22need to give some more money back to our people, because every time we
- 24:26do it gets better. The State Finance Committee Chairman Eric tar says the state
- 24:30needs to slow down a little and let recent investments bake a little. State
- 24:33Treasurer Riley Moore says the Hope Scholarship program has met State law requirements for opening
- 24:37up to all West Virginia students beginning in the twenty twenty six twenty twenty seven
- 24:41academic year. Metro News state wide correspondent Brad mclhaney says that means more families
- 24:45can apply. The Treasurer's office estimates that an additional thirty thousand to forty thousand
- 24:51students will be eligible once the scholarship opens up further. Until now, the
- 24:55scholarship has only applied to students leaving the public school system or to kindergarten students
- 24:59enter school for the first time. Governor Tim Justice plans to introduce a new
- 25:03State Division of Natural Resources Police dive team aimed at enhancing water safety and law
- 25:07enforcement for voting incidents across the state. Justice will join State d and R
- 25:11Director Brett Macmillion, Natural Resources Police Colonel Bobby Cales, and others next hour
- 25:15at Bluestone Lake in Hinton, and longtime Clay Betel High School principal David Kottrell
- 25:21is retiring. Kultrell became the assistant principal in two thousand and one, moving
- 25:25into the role of principal in twenty eleven. You're listening to Metro News the
- 25:29Voice of West Virginia. I'm David Foster, landscape architect with Civil Environmental Consultants.
- 25:34It's always exciting to take a project from an idea to completion. What
- 25:37truly is rewarding is making that project a reality. In my home state of
- 25:42West Virginia, CEC partners with communities and organizations, helping them navigate what could
- 25:48otherwise be a complex endeavor to ensure your vision becomes a reality. At CC,
- 25:52we engineered progress in the great state of West Virginia. Find out what
- 25:56CEC can do for you. We are C dot com. An official message
- 26:02from Medicare. A new law is helping me save more money on prescription drug
- 26:07costs. Maybe you can save two with Medicare's Extra Help program. My premium
- 26:11is zero and my out of pocket costs are low. Who should apply?
- 26:14Single people making less than twenty three thousand dollars a year or married couples who
- 26:18make less than thirty one thousand dollars a year. Even if you don't think
- 26:22you qualify, it pays to find out. Go to SSA dot gov.
- 26:26Slash Extra Help paid for by the US Department of Health and Human Services investigators
- 26:32with the National Transportation Safety Board say there was stormy weather in the flight path
- 26:36of a single engine plane heading from upstate New York to Charleston Sunday when it
- 26:40crashed. The crash claimed the lives of everyone on board, including a father,
- 26:42mother to sons ten and twelve, and the maternal grandfather who was the
- 26:47pilot. The plane's flight tracking device disappeared twelve minutes after takeoff. The plane
- 26:52was due at Yager Airport and Charleston Sunday afternoon for refueling before heading home to
- 26:56Atlanta. From the Metro News anchor desk, I'm Kerriehuda SA Dave Wilson filling
- 27:11in for Hopey Kerchible in the Encoba Insurance Studios Day before Independence Day three four.
- 27:21Talk through at four is the text line eight hundred and seven to sixty
- 27:22five eight two five five. Got some open line opportunities coming up. I
- 27:27wanted to give you an opportunity because I know it's tomorrow's fourth of July and
- 27:32many of you that can might be stretching the weekend a little bit, taking
- 27:38the four day weekend, so we'll have some open line opportunities in case you've
- 27:42got some steam that has built up we can't can't call it steam release.
- 27:45That's for Friday only. But if you just need to let some stress go
- 27:52before the fourth of July, we will have open line opportunities both this hour
- 27:56and next for you to do that. Because it's a holiday weekend. You
- 28:00can't go into the holiday weekend all stressed out. Well, it's been about
- 28:04a week now. In fact, it was a week ago today that the
- 28:07presidential debate on CNN aired, and that has been analyzed and broken down,
- 28:11and there's been reactions to that and reactions to the reactions, and so on
- 28:17and so forth. Joining us now on the program is Western New Wesleyan professor
- 28:21Emeredith political scientist Rob Rupp joins us. Robert, good morning, thanks for
- 28:26us spending some time today. Good morning. I'm in beautiful Chapter County,
- 28:30ready to celebrate the forest. Oh that sounds you know. I always say
- 28:34that if I could, I would move up to a mountaintop on in Tucker
- 28:38County and you would never hear from me again. Rob, Well, you
- 28:41should see the view I'm looking at right now. I bet it's spectacular.
- 28:47Well shit, that's good. That could ruin the view, Rob, you
- 28:52know, which could ruin money? Be you your we're in a we're in
- 28:57a bad situation, Dave, in which we have the world's most powerful democracy
- 29:03has nominated two old men too. He would be leaders. Well, Rob,
- 29:11the question I wanted to opposed to you go go ahead? I interrupted,
- 29:15go ahead. Well, No, the whole idea of what Kennedy said
- 29:19in six seats passing the torch doesn't seem to be working in America right now.
- 29:25Well, the question I keep coming back to is both of these candidates
- 29:30are deeply, deeply flawed candidates. Obviously, former President Trump deeply flawed with
- 29:37his actions from the end of the election through the time he left office and
- 29:41after that. Now he's got federal conviction, so on and so forth.
- 29:45President Biden is deeply flawed one job performance too. You saw his performance in
- 29:52the debate. Why could neither party separate themselves from these two candidates? And
- 29:56this is who we end up with. Well, in terms of the Republican
- 30:02Party, Trump has taken it over. It doesn't resemble in any way the
- 30:07old Reagan Republican Party. This is really a he has a following, and
- 30:12he's taken over the party. As far as a Democrat, I'm still scratching
- 30:18my head over. Supposedly he was going to be a bridge, but now
- 30:26the bridge said no, give me another four years, you know, Dave.
- 30:33Why I think he will ultimately drop out is, first of all,
- 30:41look what's happening this week. Suddenly his aid scheduled interviews, Suddenly his aids
- 30:49meet the candidate, knights or whatever. All those are a mission that the
- 30:56past campaign was not doing very well in showing him. And the second reason
- 31:03why I think he'll drop out, if he really believes, and many people
- 31:07do, that this is the most crucial election, then if he's behind one
- 31:15deed, drop out and give it a better chance of defeating Trump. And
- 31:22there's polling data that suggests, and there's actually new data that came out yesterday,
- 31:27that there are Democrats that they would be underdogs to former President Trump,
- 31:33rob but they are polling better. It's a closer race if it's Kamala Harris,
- 31:41if it's Gavin Newsom, now some of the others. Obviously there's some
- 31:44name recognition problems there, but there's data to suggest that that is the move
- 31:48they have to make, Yees, and it's coming from the average Democrat voter.
- 31:56I believe it's coming from the Democrat College, and it is scared to
- 32:00death that not only that he's losing, but the fact that it dragged down
- 32:06a lot of the the party candidates. Talking to Rob Rupp, he's a
- 32:09West Virginia Wesleyan professor emeritis plical scientist. Rob, I ask this question as
- 32:15a as a millennial, Okay, uh, a young millennial. I don't
- 32:21like to identify as a millennial, but here we are. I'm well,
- 32:23I'm I guess I'm an old millennium. On the front end of that,
- 32:27why will they Why will the older generation not pass the torch? Why are
- 32:32we still talking about octogenarians, like like President Biden Trump is in his late
- 32:38seventies, where there are some in the Senate, Mitch McConnell, Chuck Schumer,
- 32:43Nancy Pelosi over the house. Why why is the torch not being passed
- 32:45to my generation or gen you know, or Generation acts Gen X, Willie
- 32:52Trace of my generation, which is stealthy. Did we lose him? It
- 33:00would lose Rob. That was the question on one Rob, Rob. Rob,
- 33:05start over there, buddy, you broke up a little bit up there
- 33:07in beautiful Tucker County. What what was your what were you saying? The
- 33:12baby Boomer started out with the numbers. It was the largest generation in terms
- 33:17of population. So they influenced music, and they influenced this, and they
- 33:22influenced that, And now they just seem to be wanting to hang on.
- 33:30I would think you would want to, you know, if I had a
- 33:31beach house in Delaware, or if I had a cabin up and up on
- 33:35the mountain in Tucker County. You know, you think you would want to
- 33:37retire and just enjoy it and let somebody else deal with it. But that
- 33:42does not seem to be Not that you could create a generation war here,
- 33:45Rob, but that does not seem to be the attitude these are. These
- 33:49are politicians and their entire life is to vote to getting And so the dead
- 34:00sitting on the beach and is retired, and a couple of the other ones,
- 34:09but not most of them. Rob. Before I'll let you go,
- 34:13how do you see the next couple of weeks playing next couple of weeks,
- 34:16a couple of months playing out well? I think despite the fact that Biden
- 34:23said he's defiant and will do this and do that to stay in I think
- 34:29ultimately the argument did is that if he's convinced he's not gonna win, and
- 34:34he might be a drag on anyone winning. I think he'd drop out.
- 34:38And let me tell you a quick note. Look at the preparations. At
- 34:44first, we decided he was over prepped, right, Dave, he was
- 34:49do one two three. Ever so many allows you one two three, all
- 34:52you need is a one debab. But anyways, now we're looking that maybe
- 34:58he was under prepared because guess what time he started his work every day,
- 35:02eleven am, and he had a nap every day. So in a sense,
- 35:08maybe that you know what, Let's have the listeners look at the investigation
- 35:15of his preparations and then also look at his attempts to try to be the
- 35:21candidate that so many people wanted him to be that he did. Rob Rock
- 35:27West, Virginia Wesley Professor, Meridith Political Science Professor and enjoying the view out
- 35:31in Tucker County. Rob, I appreciate the insights. Thanks so much.
- 35:37Right, coming up, let's take your phone calls text tweets eight hundred and
- 35:40seven and sixty five talks. The phone number text line is three oh four
- 35:45Talk three oh four. I've got some polling data that I was referencing there
- 35:51the CNN poll. There's a new Reuter's IPSIS poll that is out And oh
- 36:00I got that story too well. Why that got me so excited? Uh?
- 36:04You know who you know who has now come up in the Joe Biden
- 36:10story. Yep, yep, that guy. You know who I'm talking about?
- 36:15One of our senators eight hundred and seven to sixty five talks the phone
- 36:19number three or four, talk three or four of the text line open lines
- 36:22rest of the hour. This is talk line from the Encove Insurance Studios.
- 36:25As Governor Justice always says, West Virginia is a diamond in the rough.
- 36:30That diamond just got a bit shinyer with the state being named one of the
- 36:35top travel destinations in the world. Our scenic beauty, natural wonder and unique
- 36:39culture are unsurpassed, and it's no surprise people are catching on. And for
- 36:45those visiting, we hope you'll decide to stay in West Virginia. Job opportunities
- 36:49abound, especially in the coal industry. Coal mining is a high tech,
- 36:52high growth industry that exists side by side with exceptional hiking, biking, climbing,
- 36:59kayaking, hunt, fishing, and so much more. With state of
- 37:01the art mining operations, West Virginia's coal industry is recognized as the best in
- 37:07the world. We produce the coal that makes the steel that built this great
- 37:10country while continuing to power America. Today, join one of America's most honorable
- 37:16professions while living in one of the top travel destinations in the world. Join
- 37:21us in Almost Heaven, West Virginia. A message from the friends of Coal.
- 37:27We give Lormos. Team Pontoon Voting is a great way to spend time
- 37:32with your family and friends. Lou Wendell Marine has just received a new shipment
- 37:37of boats, so now is a great time to buy. Open Tuesday through
- 37:40Saturday, eight thirty to five Sunday one to five, four eighteen, First
- 37:45Avenue in Saint Albans. Come in and pick up your new pontoon boat today.
- 37:49Could we get almost Team Blue Wendel Marine Sales We furnish Family Fund.
- 37:55This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. West
- 38:01Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain State's only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the
- 38:07more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris
- 38:12Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 38:15I shawt him. He ran over to the edge of the field,
- 38:19and he made at about five ten yards out of the edge of the field
- 38:22and fell over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories
- 38:27about the enjoyment of the great outdoors, he stuck his head through the blind
- 38:31into where you were. Yeah, yeah, well he had jumped, he
- 38:35leaped in. Okay, the blonde Oh gosh, yeah, so he had
- 38:39his whole body was in the air for a couple of seconds and is the
- 38:43only man that landed in the blind was of course his head in his part
- 38:46leg. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am
- 38:52and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes
- 38:55of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News,
- 39:00the Voice of West Virginia. Hey everybody, it's Tony COURRITTI, I'm
- 39:04Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite you to join us Sunday
- 39:07through Fridays right here on the Metro News Radio Network. It's the City Net,
- 39:12Statewide Sports Line. We talk West Virginia university, football, basketball,
- 39:16baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to do with the Golden
- 39:20Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the text line available every night.
- 39:22So we invite you to join us. The Senator Coach Hunter and me
- 39:27Tony Courritti. It's the city net state wide sports line on Metro News.
- 39:30News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have depended on Metro
- 39:36News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your
- 39:40fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro News
- 39:45hawk by texting News to three five sixty five to one. If you take
- 39:49a picture or video of what you see, submit that as well. Text
- 39:52the word news to three five sixty five one to submit your tip or story.
- 39:57Standard texting rates apply. Please don't te extend drive. Metro News Talkline
- 40:14with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 40:19to protect what you care about most. Visiting Coca dot com to learn more.
- 40:23Three or four Talk three of four is the text line. Eight hundred
- 40:25and seven sixty five eight two five five is the phone number. More than
- 40:30three thousand people in the US are waiting are on the waiting list for a
- 40:34heart transplant. Many others are facing advanced heart failure. Don't know that life
- 40:38saving heart transplant is an option. No one should have to travel for necessary
- 40:44medical treatment. That's why the WU Medicine Transplant Alliance is pioneering new technologies and
- 40:50developing one of a kind programs like heart Transplant to serve West Virginians and others
- 40:53across the region. Visit WU medicine dot org slash transplant all Right, let
- 41:00me get to some of these poll numbers here. The CNN poll took a
- 41:07national poll. Three quarters of US voters say the Democratic Party should have a
- 41:10better shot or would have a better shot at holding the presidency in twenty four
- 41:15with someone other than Joe Biden at the top of the ticket. His approval
- 41:20rating has also hit a new low following a shaky performance in the debate.
- 41:24Nationwide, voters favor former President Trump by six points now, according to the
- 41:29CNN National Poll. Those are identical to April. The poll also finds that
- 41:36Kamala Harris is within striking distance of Trump in a hypothetical matchup of forty seven
- 41:42percent to forty five there's some others. There's some other data here that makes
- 41:51that caught my attention. Biden's favorability rating stands at just thirty four percent,
- 42:00fifty eight percent viewing him unfavorable. Voters appear to have significant questions about Biden's
- 42:09handling of key issues and his physical mental abilities. They trust Trump over Biden
- 42:15on two of the three issues they consider most important for their choice. Trump
- 42:20leads on the economy and immigration by roughly twenty points, Biden holding a slight
- 42:25five point edge on protecting democracy. Seventy two percent of voters say Biden's physical
- 42:31and mental abilities are a reason to vote against him rather than for him.
- 42:37For Trump, views are narrowly positive. Forty three percent see him physically and
- 42:40see his physical and mental abilities as a plus beyond his advantages on the economy
- 42:47and immigration. The poll found that more trusted Biden on foreign policy, oh,
- 42:53let me rephrase that, more trusted Trump than Biden on foreign policy forty
- 42:58six to thirty six, and handling the role of commander in chief forty three
- 43:02to thirty five. Plurality trust neither Biden nor Trump to unite the country thirty
- 43:09one percent say they trust Biden more to do so thirty percent for Trump.
- 43:15That is a CNN poll. A Reuter's ipsis poll, one in three Democrats
- 43:20think US President Joe Biden should end his reelection bid. The two day poll
- 43:25found that both Trump and Biden maintained support of forty percent of registered voters.
- 43:30The Reuters IPSES poll conducted in January, while the party's nomination contest was underway,
- 43:36forty nine percent of Democrats city should not run again. So that has
- 43:38jumped. Vice President Kamala Harris trailed Trump by one percentage point in a hypothetical
- 43:46race, forty three to forty two. Let me see, Biden was seen
- 43:55as too old to work in government by fifty nine percent of Democrats. Uh.
- 44:02Then this goes on and then tries to throw out some names Gavin Newsom,
- 44:07Gretchen Whitmer, the governor Michigan, Kentucky Governor Andy Bursheer, basically finding
- 44:13all of them suffer from name recognition issues. Then there's another report that polling
- 44:17in key swing states Biden is down in key swing states. Axios has a
- 44:23report. Axios has a report that a pre planned meding of House Democrats focused
- 44:31on the party's political messaging devolved into a grievance about President Biden. All of
- 44:38that data is not pointing in a good direction for President Biden at this point.
- 44:47Now, how you convince him to step aside at this point in the
- 44:53race, I don't know, because that's what it will take. He will
- 44:59have to make that decision or the people around him will have to make that
- 45:01decision. But that data does not look good. Now, that's polling data.
- 45:09And look, poles can be wrong. We learned that in twenty sixteen,
- 45:13didn't We poles can be wrong. But that data right now today,
- 45:17after that debate and those images seared into voters' minds, not looking good.
- 45:23All right, we'll get to your text We'll get to your phone calls coming
- 45:25up as well. Three or four talk three or four of the text line
- 45:29eight hundred and seven to sixty five eight two five five. That is the
- 45:32phone number, Dave Wilson and for Hopey Kerchiable. You're calls in twech tech,
- 45:36your twext, your texts, tweets are welcome as well. They're next.
- 45:39If you love sports, you'll love the Bridge. The Bridge Sports Complex
- 45:45and Bridgeport is West Virginia's largest sports and recreation destination. At the Bridge,
- 45:49you'll find one hundred and fifty six thousand square feet for volleyball, basketball,
- 45:53swimming, soccer, climbing, running, and fitness. The Bridge one reason
- 45:58Bridgeport is the perfect plot or a fun and memorable weekend get away. Learn
- 46:02more about travel, dining, events, and things to do in the beautiful
- 46:06city of Bridgeport, West Virginia at greater dat Bridgeport dot com. Need help
- 46:12with your prescriptions? Tired of long wait times? Did your current pharmacy close
- 46:15or is moving? Give Fruth Pharmacy a try. We make it easy to
- 46:20transfer your prescriptions and we always welcome new patients. Fruth makes it easy to
- 46:24transfer. Call a local Fruth Pharmacy and they will handle the transferring process for
- 46:30you. We offer prescription rewards too. Give Fruth Pharmacy a call today for
- 46:35more details. Fruth makes it easy. Fruth your hometown family pharmacy. We
- 46:43are there for you, do care for you at the Health Plans. The
- 46:47health Plan is still growing, giving you a large network of doctors, friendly
- 46:52and helpful customer service representatives, and competitive, flexible pricing plans that meet your
- 46:57needs. Log on to Health plan dot org for more information to care for
- 47:04you, and we are here. Winning the lottery would be the start of
- 47:13my race dream. Hitting the open road at top speeds, hugging turns.
- 47:15It's intense. What are you dreaming of racing again? Not dreaming? I'm
- 47:28practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a mower, It's a dream.
- 47:36West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen to you? Please play responsively.
- 47:40You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.
- 47:47WV metronews dot com the only website you need to stay informed in the
- 47:52Mountain State. Get the latest news and sports story, information on the great
- 47:57outdoors, and never miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcasts,
- 48:01including Talkline, Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game.
- 48:06Make a bookmark now and visit do WV metronews dot com first thing every
- 48:10morning to find out what's happening all across the state. WV metronews dot com.
- 48:15West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated
- 48:22to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning
- 48:25host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty
- 48:30five years stockfish for repatriation purposes to that reintroduction, re establishment of Brooks trout,
- 48:36and two of those streams, the oldest that we have worked on,
- 48:39the earliest ones that we started putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in
- 48:45both of those streams, whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories
- 48:49about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. It was a pretty good flight.
- 48:52It takes me about ten minutes to get it in. My dad actually had
- 48:55to run to the truck and grab anat clous there's my wife. I could
- 49:00list him up over top of the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all
- 49:04Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today
- 49:08brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and
- 49:12water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia. It's two
- 49:16hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the City Net Sunday
- 49:21night sports line. Hey, this is Travis Jowes joining myself and Greg Hunter.
- 49:24Every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up
- 49:28the sports weekend, we talk Mountaineers, High School, Mountain East Conference,
- 49:31and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener Interactive.
- 49:36You could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh
- 49:38four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite metro news a
- 49:43Philly or watch the show at wv metronews dot com. Much a News talk
- 50:00line. Dave Wilson in for Happy Kerchival from the Encova Insurance Studios three or
- 50:05four Talk three or four of the text line eight hundred and seven sixty five
- 50:07eight two five five. Let's go to the phones. Ryan wants to weigh
- 50:12in this morning. Hey Ryan, happy, he independence stay and back to
- 50:16you. A scary scenario, let's say the part way through the debate the
- 50:22Secretary of Defense comes up on the stage and whispers in President Biden's ear there's
- 50:30been a nuclear launch. Can you not picture Jill Biden coming up and getting
- 50:36him by the arm and taking him by the to the war room. This
- 50:40this is amazing that people are wondering if he can, if he's able to
- 50:45be re elected why if these questions are being asked three years from now,
- 50:51We're we're in a pickle. The other thing is that there's almost three hundred
- 50:57million dollars in the Biden Harris can if they picked somebody else, they start
- 51:04from zero. As I understand it, with money, that money just can't
- 51:07be moved over to the next candidate. It really has to be Kamala Harris.
- 51:14The borders are thank you, Ryan, You're welcome. And I'm no
- 51:19campaign finance expert. That's my understanding as well. Those those funds are not
- 51:22transferable. But you hit on a really good point there that we're not only
- 51:27talking about the mental capacity calling good decline of President Biden today or six months
- 51:35from now, but what about two years from now, three years from now,
- 51:38and four years from now, five years from now. I guess it'll
- 51:44be five by the time you would lead off leave office if you're elected to
- 51:47if he's elected to a second term. That's a that is really what you're
- 51:52talking about. Yeah, we're talking about the immediate book. You're projecting.
- 51:57This is a four year term and the hof is stressful. You ever do
- 52:01the side by side comparisons where you look at the picture of the president when
- 52:05he's first elected him in the president when he leaves. I mean, it'll
- 52:08aid you it is a tough, tough job. And where is he going
- 52:13to be when he's eighty six years old. Let's go to Jerry. Jerry,
- 52:21what's on your mind? Yeah? Well, I mean I was listening
- 52:24to your polling numbers and everything is going on, and it's hard for me
- 52:30to fathom when you look at approval ratings with the gaps of ten to twenty
- 52:37percent and then a potential vote rating of only a gap of one to two
- 52:45percent. You know, this guy has lost his cabbage. And you know,
- 52:53I just can't believe there's that many people. When you make a reasonable
- 52:58quality poll, we're gonna look at Biden and say, yeah, I'm gonna
- 53:01hope with this claim. Jerry. I appreciate. Uh, I've only got
- 53:07a couple of seconds here before the top of the hour. Both candidates have
- 53:10solid support among their bases, which we know. It's when you get into
- 53:16independence, which I guess this is kind of the case all the time,
- 53:20but when you get into the independence you start to see the fluctuation in numbers
- 53:23a little bit there. I will I'll get back to more of those polls
- 53:25coming up. In the second hour, we'll talk a little bit about homeschooling.
- 53:29Brad maclony stops by as well. Full first hour, got another full
- 53:34hour to go here on Metro News talk line on Metro News, the Voice
- 53:38of West Virginia, our number two Metro News talk line underway. Dave Wilson
- 53:58filling in for Hoppy and the in Cova Insurance Studios. Hop is back on
- 54:02Monday after taking a week to relax. I'm sure he is somewhere already celebrating
- 54:10Independence Day. Only how hop he can coming up Brad mclahanny Bottom of the
- 54:17hour. Governor's business troubles back in the news. Also, the Hope Scholarship
- 54:25continues to grow. And I mentioned last hour Senator Joe Manchin. Yeah,
- 54:31you know, it was just a matter of time before Mansion's name would come
- 54:35up during this discussion about President Biden and the debate performance and how to proceed
- 54:45moving forward. Well, there's a Washington Post article and Joe Manson is featured
- 54:50prominently in that. We'll talk to Brad about all that coming up at the
- 54:52bottom of the hour. Also, a couple of you took advantage of it
- 54:57and that's exactly what I wanted you to do because tomorrow's Independence Day. Now
- 55:00we will still do Steam release on Friday, but I know many of you
- 55:07are going to take advantage of the Thursday holiday. If you've got a day
- 55:09off, you throw that in on Friday, and hey, you got a
- 55:12long weekend. I don't blame you. I don't blame you. Now,
- 55:15we'll be here a best of show tomorrow, by the way, and then
- 55:22live show on Friday, so we'll have Steam Release on Friday like we always
- 55:24do. But I wanted to afford you an opportunity just in case you've got
- 55:30some pence up stress, some pent up steam that you need to release prior
- 55:35to the fourth of July, because you don't want to go into Independence Day
- 55:38stressed out. It's too cool of a holiday. I'll afford that to you.
- 55:44Coming up later on this hour when we open the phones. Also,
- 55:46Jonathan Savage Fox News Radio is in London and he is at Benjamin Franklin's house
- 55:52today. We'll check in with the Jonathan Savage coming up in just a moment.
- 55:57We've been talking a lot the less last month about homeschooling here in West
- 56:02Virginia and in relation to regulations, oversight, Is there enough oversight? Are
- 56:10assessments being properly filed? So on and so forth, And it all goes
- 56:17back to the Kennedy Miller case in Boom County, the fourteen year old girl
- 56:21who died after she was found in a state of starvation. It was learned
- 56:25she had been pulled from public schools and had been put into homeschooling, and
- 56:30her parents did not our guardians did not keep up with assessments. Should that
- 56:37have been a red flag? Should somebody have checked on the well being of
- 56:39this child? And this is how this conversation got started. Now, no
- 56:42one, let me be clear, no one is trying to assert that homeschooling
- 56:50led to her death. Her parents, her mother, and her grandparents have
- 56:53been charged and they're going to face the criminal penalties and criminal charges for their
- 56:58actions. But it has launched this larger discussion with all that. Let me
- 57:02bring into the program. Kevin Boden. He is with the Homeschool Defense leg
- 57:07and he joins us here on Metro News this morning. Kevin, good morning,
- 57:13thanks for joining us. Good morning, Dave, happy to be here,
- 57:15Thanks for having me. I'm glad you could spend some time. We've
- 57:17been having these discussions in West Virginia and they have ranged from talking about our
- 57:24assessment regulations, what they need to be reporting regulations? Is there enough should
- 57:30laws be Do we just need to enforce the laws that are on the books?
- 57:34Do we need to enact new laws? You have been following this conversation.
- 57:39What is your take on the situation. Yeah, we've definitely been following
- 57:44the conversation here at HSLDA, have had lots of discussions and been in touch
- 57:49with some elected officials and of course the members that we have in West Virginia.
- 57:52Our take is that this is a child welfare issue and it ought to
- 57:59be addressed in the normal legislative session that starts in twenty twenty five, and
- 58:05not in the special session that will likely be called here at the end of
- 58:07August. So that's our take, and there's a number of different reasons that
- 58:12we have that position. And by the way, I misspoke, it's the
- 58:15Home school if Homeschool Legal Defense Association. My apologies for I miss speaking earlier.
- 58:21So why take it up in a special session, in your opinion,
- 58:24rather than work on something possibly in August or September in a special session when
- 58:30lawmakers are back in Charleston. Yeah, well, our position is, you
- 58:34know, the change that's been proposed by Governor of Justice's office is a change
- 58:37from the word may to shall, and that is whether the county may take
- 58:43a family to court, And the proposed change that they've put forward at least
- 58:46is shall take court action if an assessment is not submitted. And the reason
- 58:52to hey, I don't think that's the issue. I really don't think that's
- 58:57the issue here, nor do I think it would have solved the problem.
- 59:00But let's assume for a second that it is. The assessments in West Virginia
- 59:04are due on June thirtieth, So there's no difference if you make the change
- 59:10in August in a special session in a rush manner, without the opportunity for
- 59:16all the committee hearings, from the normal process for public comment. All of
- 59:20those things that happen in a normal session get sidelined in a special session.
- 59:24But if that change is made in a special session versus made in the normal
- 59:29session, that takes a few months, right, that has all of those
- 59:30procedural safeguards in place. There's no change because the assessment date is June thirtieth,
- 59:37So why rush it when there's literally no impact because of the date that
- 59:43the assessment is due. If you change from May to shall, why rush
- 59:46it when you can have the benefit of the entire process early next year.
- 59:52So if they want to look at what the assessment requirements are and whether these
- 59:57are the issue, then it makes the most sense so that you can actually
- 1:00:00deal with the issue that's you know, or the possible issue, the proposed
- 1:00:06issue, with the time that's required in a normal session. So that's the
- 1:00:08reason that even if that's the problem, a special rest session in August is
- 1:00:14not the time to deal with it because literally it has no impact. It
- 1:00:16will impact not one single family or one single child until June thirtieth of twenty
- 1:00:21twenty five, regardless. Talking to Kevin Boden, he's an attorney with the
- 1:00:24Homeschool Legal Defense Association, Kevin, I don't need to tell you changing May
- 1:00:31to SHELL that is a big change in the law. But would it have
- 1:00:35the impact that folks hope it would, and that would be that for for
- 1:00:39assessments that are not being turned in, there would be welfare checks, there
- 1:00:43would be some sort of ramifications there. Would it have the intended impact.
- 1:00:47I don't think it would have the intended impact. And here's my response to
- 1:00:51this, David, I hear this quite quite normally. The purpose of the
- 1:00:53assessments, you know, and you know we're a West Virginia family. You
- 1:00:58know, HSLD is a national organization. I live in Jefferson County, West
- 1:01:00Virginia. I'm a voter there, I'm a constituent. I care about the
- 1:01:04laws. I submitted our own assessments for my own children that were due just
- 1:01:08last week. So I'm I'm I'm subject to the very law that I'm that
- 1:01:13I'm that we're discussing. But I don't think it fixes the issue for the
- 1:01:16for the very reason that the purpose of the assessment is to assess education.
- 1:01:22It's not to assess the welfare of a child. And so there's nothing about
- 1:01:28the assessment on whether my child, for example, is making adequate academic progress
- 1:01:31consistent with their agent ability that has anything to do with child welfare. And
- 1:01:36the tragic case of Kennedy Miller. And it's very tragic, and I'm happy
- 1:01:39to hear that at least the criminal process is playing out with the presumption of
- 1:01:43innocence. But they're gonna they're doing what they what they need to or what
- 1:01:46they can in the criminal side. You know, the purpose of the assessment
- 1:01:51is not to turn a county superintendent or any staff you know, official with
- 1:01:55the county into a child welfare officer. Are simply two different issues that we're
- 1:02:00dealing with, which is why our position is the homeschool assessment is not the
- 1:02:05issue, and it's a child welfare issue. And I would just add,
- 1:02:09of course the state in this case or the county Boone County had the authority
- 1:02:15they needed to check in with Kennedy Miller. They were there in March of
- 1:02:19twenty three. The assessment wasn't turned into June of twenty three, and literally
- 1:02:24it's pretty broad reason in the statute that would have allowed them to go to
- 1:02:30court and potentially take action against the mom in this case who was purportedly doing
- 1:02:36the instruction. So it's an educ it's a welfare issue, not an education
- 1:02:40issue. So there's no need to change the education assessment law when the welfare
- 1:02:45is the problem. Can I jump in there, because yeah, I want
- 1:02:49to ask you the question about balance here because I think the assumption is and
- 1:02:54I know we get it. I know what they say about making assumptions,
- 1:02:57Kevin, But the assumption is if you are turning in these assessments on time
- 1:03:02or pretty close to on time, and you were doing all the things that
- 1:03:06are required as a homeschool parent, you are probably not the parent who we're
- 1:03:12talking about. This is not the situation that folks are worried about. If
- 1:03:16in Kennedy Miller's case, let's not having those assessments turned in could have cracked
- 1:03:22the door open for somebody to go in and ask the questions. And then
- 1:03:25maybe if you start asking questions, you find out she's in a bad situation
- 1:03:29and you could have prevented what happened to her. I think that's the idea
- 1:03:32behind that. So how do we where's the balance there between child welfare making
- 1:03:39certain children are not being pulled out of school because adult bad actors are trying
- 1:03:45to hide something. Where's the balance between child welfare and educational choice? I
- 1:03:50guess is my question? Kevin. Yeah, and I think it's a fair
- 1:03:53question. And you know, and people are asking the question. You know,
- 1:03:59if there was increased assessment, if there was contact, you know,
- 1:04:00would this have prevented the death? All of that, of course, is
- 1:04:03speculation. What I want to go to if there's this Supreme Court case from
- 1:04:08nineteen seventy nine par M Vjr. Which you know, some folks may know,
- 1:04:11but let me just quote from this the status notion that governmental power should
- 1:04:14supersed parental authority in all cases because some parents abuse the neglect children is repugnant
- 1:04:19to American tradition. And so the fundamental right that we have as parents is
- 1:04:25is just that fundamental. It's not absolute, but it is fundamental. So
- 1:04:28the question then becomes, because Kennedy's mother and grandparents did not care for her,
- 1:04:36does that then translate that every homeschool parent in West Virginia ought to meet
- 1:04:43with a social worker to ensure that my children are safe? And I agree
- 1:04:47with the Supreme Court that that concept, that idea is repugnant to the American
- 1:04:51tradition, and it exists. Even if we think we can catch every single
- 1:04:56child that may be harmed by the state a you just can't do that.
- 1:05:00There is no state that can set up that has any respect for fundamental rights
- 1:05:06that we all enjoy another constitution. There's no there's no way to set that
- 1:05:11up in such a way that those rights exist and try to catch quote every
- 1:05:15child who maybe who may be harmed. There's bat there there are parents that
- 1:05:20do not do a good job home educating. There are good students, there
- 1:05:25are there are teachers who do not do a good job in public or private
- 1:05:28school or charter school that ensure that those children are safe or are get a
- 1:05:32good education. What about the Hope scholarship students? What about kids in a
- 1:05:36learning pot or a micro school? And so the question really becomes, what
- 1:05:41is the proper balance? I think that's what you're asking in this particular case.
- 1:05:45The proper balance is not to require a county superintendent to take court action
- 1:05:53against a parent simply because they've missed administrative deadline with their assessment. Of June
- 1:05:57thirtieth, talking to Kevin Bonden, he's at a tijourney with the Home School
- 1:06:01Defense Legal Association. Michelle Blatt, state superintendent, was on this program I
- 1:06:08think last week, and some of the numbers have been thrown out there that
- 1:06:11only I think at around thirty five, thirty six, maybe thirty seven percent
- 1:06:15of assessments have been completed or are being complied with. Do you believe that
- 1:06:21number is accurate? You know, I have no, honestly, no idea
- 1:06:25where that number came from. I don't have a basis to say whether it's
- 1:06:28accurate or inaccurate. What I can say is the state gets that information from
- 1:06:31the county, because when I submit my assessment, it went to Jefferson County.
- 1:06:35So I submitted to Jefferson County. Someone in Jefferson County must collate that
- 1:06:39data and set it into the state for them to aggregate. So the question
- 1:06:43then becomes, is this actually a statewide problem where we're seeing a third of
- 1:06:47families statewide do this? Or are there a handful of counties for which there
- 1:06:51is you know, parents are not reporting. And the other thing I'll highlight,
- 1:06:56which is very odd is you know, they came out with this number
- 1:06:59just before the deadline of June thirty fifth of this year. So I don't
- 1:07:02know whether this is a number that's to date in twenty twenty four, before
- 1:07:08the deadline to submit had actually occurred, or if it's not, If this
- 1:07:13is data from twenty twenty three, then you have to ask the question,
- 1:07:15Dave, how come this number is just coming out eleven and a half months
- 1:07:19later the assessment deadline of twenty twenty three in June. If they've had this
- 1:07:26number, why haven't they done anything with it? Again, the statue gives
- 1:07:30them authority to take action now with discretion, and so if the number is
- 1:07:35accurate, and again I would just ask the States who's superintendent, to say,
- 1:07:40give us the data. Break it down by county so people can actually
- 1:07:42look at this and know what you're referencing. But you have to wonder,
- 1:07:45if they have this data that they can collect from twenty twenty three, how
- 1:07:48come it took until the tragic death of Kennedy Miller before they actually collate that
- 1:07:54data and push it out. Because they had every authority under the law to
- 1:07:58take action prior to this. So you just have to wonder why they didn't
- 1:08:00do that, assuming this is data that's accurate from twenty twenty three. Kevin
- 1:08:04Boden, and it's turning with the Homeschool Legal Defense Association. Kevin, thanks
- 1:08:09for the perspective this morning. I appreciate it. Thanks Day, appreciate you
- 1:08:12absolutely. Coming up Fox News Radios, Jonathan Savage is at Ben Franklin's house
- 1:08:16in London. We'll get that perspective on the other side of this time out
- 1:08:21talk line on Metro News from the encovid certain studios continues. If you or
- 1:08:26a loved one needs a kidney transplant, count on the experience team at the
- 1:08:30WVU Medicine Transplant Alliance. Our board certified nephrologists and surgeons are trained to care
- 1:08:35for patients with the most complex kidney conditions using the latest treatments and advances in
- 1:08:41organ transplantation. At WVU Medicine, you are not a number. Our expert
- 1:08:45team makes it a priority to get to know you and give you a more
- 1:08:48personalized experience. Visit WVU medicine dot org slash transplant. Winning the lottery would
- 1:08:56be the start of my race dream. Hitting the open road at top speeds,
- 1:08:59hugging. It's intense. What are you dreaming of racing again? Not
- 1:09:11dreaming. I'm practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a mower, It's
- 1:09:15a dream. West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen to you?
- 1:09:23Please play responsibly. Despite the ill fated efforts of President Biden and his wealthy
- 1:09:30New York friends, West Virginia coal is thriving and being shipped to forty five
- 1:09:35countries worldwide given its high quality, including burning properties. Countries across the globe
- 1:09:41and demanding and consuming it, and in state production continues to grow. With
- 1:09:45billions of dollars of recent investment in West Virginia mining operations, combined with the
- 1:09:49reliability of our coal fired electric manufacturing facilities, West Virginia Coal is here to
- 1:09:56stay. No other fuel in the world matches West Virginia col for baseload generation
- 1:10:00and steel making. Like a good friend. It's always been and always will
- 1:10:05be there, keeping the lights on and contributing greatly to our growing economy.
- 1:10:11In fact, Cole continues to sustain fifty thousand plus West Virginia jobs, putting
- 1:10:15food on the table for Mountain state families. Visit Friends of col dot org
- 1:10:19to learn more. A message from the Friends of Coal's This is Talk line
- 1:10:26on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the
- 1:10:31Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million
- 1:10:36hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking
- 1:10:42down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. I shot him.
- 1:10:45He ran over to the edge of the field. He made at about
- 1:10:48five ten yards out of the edge of the field and fell over there.
- 1:10:51Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the
- 1:10:57great outdoors. He stuck his head through the blind into where you were.
- 1:11:01Yeah, yeah, well he had jump. He leaked in oka the blonde.
- 1:11:04Oh gosh, yeah, so he had his whole body was in the
- 1:11:10air for a couple of seconds and is the only man that landed in the
- 1:11:13blonde? Was you know? Of course his head in a part leg.
- 1:11:15West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for
- 1:11:20your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news
- 1:11:24and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice
- 1:11:29of West Virginia. Hey everybody, it's Tony Coritty, I'm Greg Hunter,
- 1:11:32and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays
- 1:11:36right here on the Metro News Radio network. It's the City Net Statewide Sports
- 1:11:41Line. We talk West Virginia University football, basketball, baseball, you name
- 1:11:45it. If it's got anything to do with the Golden Blue, We're on
- 1:11:48it. And don't forget the text line available every night, so we invite
- 1:11:51you to join us. The Senator Coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti. It's
- 1:11:56the City nets state wide sports line on Metro News. News in the Mountain
- 1:12:00State happens quick and for decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news
- 1:12:05delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed.
- 1:12:11If you see news happening, become a Metro News Hawk by texting News
- 1:12:15to three five sixty five to one. If you take a picture or video
- 1:12:17of what you see, submit that as well. Text the word news to
- 1:12:21three five sixty five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates
- 1:12:26apply. Please don't text and drive. Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible
- 1:12:44is brought to you by Encoda Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what
- 1:12:48you care about most. Visiting Covia dot com to learn more. Fox News
- 1:12:54Radios. Jonathan Savage is in London and today he is at Benjamin Franklin's London
- 1:13:01home where they will be celebrating America's Independence Day tomorrow. Jonathan Savage joins us
- 1:13:06this morning. Jonathan, Good Morning, What is planned? There at Ben
- 1:13:11Franklin's Home for America's Fourth of July celebration. Yeah Hello. They are a
- 1:13:16little slice of American history in the heart of one of the most historic cities
- 1:13:21in the world. In fact, Benjamin Franklin's former home is kind of a
- 1:13:25blinking you miss it place under normal circumstances. It's down a little side road
- 1:13:30near Trafagar Square, but today it is festooned with red, white and blue
- 1:13:34on the outside because they are really making the most of the fact that the
- 1:13:40founding father lived in this building on Fourth of July this year. It's a
- 1:13:45place which is open to all and it's very well preserved since it was occupy
- 1:13:49with Benjain Franklin in the seventeen hundreds. They're have self guided tours. They're
- 1:13:55operating a walking tour tomorrow and all day they're offering visitors American inspired drink nacks,
- 1:14:01even a little bit of booze in the evening for their museum late event.
- 1:14:05It's a really really interesting place, and it's a sort of place that
- 1:14:10not even a lot many Londoners know exist. And in fact, one of
- 1:14:13the Americans who works there tells me that he didn't know it existed until he
- 1:14:16got the job. Is there is there a curiosity over there about I mean,
- 1:14:23our histories are obviously connected. Is there a curiosity about the Fourth of
- 1:14:28July or an interest at all? Well, we're certainly very aware of it
- 1:14:31because American culture puts it into our TV screens and our movie screens, of
- 1:14:36course, and we all if London being such a global city, there are
- 1:14:41so many Americans who live here. We have all of American friends. I've
- 1:14:45been to American friends houses for Fourth of July dinners and fireworks and celebrations.
- 1:14:49So we're we're very much aware of it. I've been asked today whether or
- 1:14:54not always still bear a grudge, and I think the spirit to say we
- 1:14:57don't. We are over the event the seventeen seventies, and yeah, I
- 1:15:01think that we all. I think the part of our attitude towards it is
- 1:15:05envy because we don't have in the UK a day quite like it. Well,
- 1:15:11I mean, I gotta be honest, we're a little I would say
- 1:15:14Americans are a little bit jealous of boy. I'm going to get the hit
- 1:15:16on the text line here, Jonathan. Maybe a little bit jealous because you've
- 1:15:19got the monarchy and the history that goes back, you know, hundreds and
- 1:15:24hundreds and hundreds of years. So there's we might not admit it, but
- 1:15:27there's a little jealousy on this side too. Yeah, we're always looking at
- 1:15:30the grass from the other side of the sense, aren't we. But one
- 1:15:33thing I've learned from spending time at Benja and Franklin's house today and talking to
- 1:15:38people there is you know just how much Americans can be proud of their country's
- 1:15:43history too, about how the rich characters and actually there's a real benefit in
- 1:15:48your having a country, That's what I mean. We get my son's wrong
- 1:15:51about two hundred and fifty years old, and I think that that is you
- 1:15:56have so much opportunity to to witness the buildings, to learn about the people
- 1:16:02because it actually happened so recently. There's so much evidence and so much information
- 1:16:06about their lives, and I think that's the real benefit. Fox News Radios
- 1:16:10Jonathan Savage at Benjamin Franklin's home in London this morning. Jonathan, thanks for
- 1:16:15the joining us. I appreciate it, thank you absolutely. And Benjamin Franklin
- 1:16:19was a character. He was a he was a character there. When you
- 1:16:26go back and study the Revolution. Three or four Talk three or four is
- 1:16:30the text line eight hundred and seven and sixty five eight two five to five
- 1:16:32of the phone number. Do you only need a few million to get by?
- 1:16:36A lot of America offers jackpots that started two million and grow until somebody
- 1:16:41wins. Drawings take place every Monday, Wednesday, and Saturday, and there
- 1:16:45are nine, count them nine ways to win a prize. So for manageable
- 1:16:49millions, Lot of America is your best bet to win a small fortune for
- 1:16:54just a buck. The Lotto America jackpot is four point two four million dollars
- 1:17:00up. Brad McElhenny will join us. There are more, eh, I
- 1:17:05don't aren't more people, but the governor's business troubles back in the news,
- 1:17:11and oh yeah it was. You know, it was only a matter of
- 1:17:13time before Joe Mansion's name got come up, got come up, got brought
- 1:17:16up, losing the ability to speak here with half an hour ago in the
- 1:17:19show with the presidential discussions, we'll dive into all of that coming up after
- 1:17:26the news. Dave Wilson in for Happy Kirschwell. This is talk Line on
- 1:17:28Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. It is eleven thirty. Time
- 1:17:33to get a news update from the Metro News radio network and find out what's
- 1:17:36happening all across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News.
- 1:17:43I'm Chris Lawrence. A federal judge is ruled in favor of the Justice Administration
- 1:17:46in a lawsuit over conditions in the state's prisons in jails. US District Judge
- 1:17:50Ireen Berger dismissing the suit on standing and saying the plaintiffs sued the wrong person
- 1:17:56and governor. Justice Administration Chief of Staff Brian Abraham said they believed dot a
- 1:18:00long the suit had no standing much as their case was based upon what the
- 1:18:04stated needs were year after year after year as they made their budget proposals,
- 1:18:12and our administration determined, including the new Commissioner of Corrections, that much of
- 1:18:18that was overstated or simply inaccurate. Abraham says the new Corrections Commissioner, Billy
- 1:18:25Marshall, has the agency headed in the right direction. There is an ongoing
- 1:18:29investigation into a fight that broke out Monday between Cedargrove Police Chief Jack Eyes and
- 1:18:32a man he had detained in the parking lot of a Shrewsbury business. The
- 1:18:36man, whose name has not been released, was allegedly riding a bicycle in
- 1:18:40the parking lot when I stopped him and somehow a physical altercation broke out.
- 1:18:45Ice called for backup assistance and deputies arrived to help. The individual's claiming that
- 1:18:48Ice used excessive force trying to arrest him, and an investigation is now ongoing.
- 1:18:54Governor Jim Justice has appointed Ryan Browning to a vacancy in the House of
- 1:18:58Delegates. Browning will represent the twenty eighth district, which is in Wayne County.
- 1:19:01The appointment to fill the vacancy of the resignation of Delegate Mark Ross.
- 1:19:05You're listening to Matter News, the Voice of West Virginia. An official message
- 1:19:10from Medicare. A new law is helping me save more money on prescription drug
- 1:19:15costs. Maybe you can save two with Medicare's Extra Help program. My premium
- 1:19:18is zero and my out of pocket costs are low. Who should apply?
- 1:19:23Single people making less than twenty three thousand dollars a year or married couples who
- 1:19:27make less than thirty one thousand dollars a year. Even if you don't think
- 1:19:30you qualify, it pays to find out. Go to SSA dot gov slash
- 1:19:34extra help paid for by the US Department of Health and Human Services. If
- 1:19:39you use tobacco, chances are you've thought about quitting, and all of us
- 1:19:43at the American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network think that is truly awesome. Quitting
- 1:19:47is tough. It requires commitment and support, but first it requires thinking of
- 1:19:51quitting. You've taken the first step on your own. The West Virginia Tobacco
- 1:19:56Quipline can help you take the next one. Call one eight hundred quit Now
- 1:20:00or visit wv Tobacco quitline dot com for practical tips to give up tobacco for
- 1:20:04good. Quitting is tough, but West Virginians are tougher. You've got this.
- 1:20:10The sixty second annual Mountain State Arts and Crafts Fair opens up tomorrow and
- 1:20:13runs through Saturday at Seir Lakes Conference Center near Ripley. Sarah McDowell is a
- 1:20:17fairboard member and says it's a unique sale because they have a juried process to
- 1:20:21ensure the most traditional craftsmanship in quality. Not everyone makes it, but what
- 1:20:29the folks who do make it are experts in their crafts, unique in their
- 1:20:33ability. Hours are ten to six daily from the Metro News anchored ESK guy.
- 1:20:38I'm Chris Lawrence. I could just let this play out. It's coming.
- 1:21:08Dave Wilson's again for a hoppy kerchwill today Metro News talk Line. We'll
- 1:21:11have some open phones coming up about ten minutes from now, just an opportunity.
- 1:21:15It's not an official Steam release because the laws of talk Line bind Steam
- 1:21:19release to Friday, but because tomorrow's Independence Day and we have potentially I don't
- 1:21:27want to assume anybody's taken an extra day off in a long weekend, but
- 1:21:30you just might be doing that. You may need an opportunity to let the
- 1:21:34steam vent just a little bit before the fourth of July, because you can't
- 1:21:39go into Independence Day all worked up. It's Independence Day. So we'll do
- 1:21:44some open lines. Final two segments of the show this morning, eight hundred
- 1:21:47and seven to sixty five. Talk the phone number three or four, Talk
- 1:21:49three or four. The text line in the meantime, A guy who's never
- 1:21:54steamed, never stressed out, always calm, cool and collective, collected at
- 1:22:00you, New state Wide Correspondent Brad McIlhenny, Brad, that's an accurate portrayal,
- 1:22:06I screamed quietly inside. Let's start here. During the newsbreak, Chris
- 1:22:14Lawrence had the story that at least one of the legal cases that the governor
- 1:22:19Justice has found himself involved in has been tossed out. What's going on,
- 1:22:25Yeah, this is through his role as governor. This is a class action
- 1:22:29lawsuit about the conditions in West Virginia's jails system. And the lawsuit was filed
- 1:22:34on behalf of people who were incarcerated at all levels of the jail system,
- 1:22:39the prisons, of the jails, the juvenile system, saying that they are
- 1:22:44overcrowded, that they are under staff, that they have deferred maintenance, and
- 1:22:47that that adds up to inhuman conditions. The governor was named because he's the
- 1:22:54state's chief executive. He's the defendant, and also named was the state Homeland
- 1:23:00Security Secretary, Mark Sorcea. This lawsuit ran from late late last year until
- 1:23:09now. It was dismissed on grounds of standing by US District Judge Irene Berger.
- 1:23:15Her conclusion was that although the governor is the chief executive, although Sorcea
- 1:23:21is the Homeland Security Secretary, which has significant responsibility, a couple of things
- 1:23:28they in particular SOURCEA cannot allocate funding. That's a legislative responsibility, and each
- 1:23:34of them, the Secretary for Homeland Security and the governor are our big picture
- 1:23:41responsibility guys. They do not have direct responsibility for the correction system. That's
- 1:23:46the Corrections Commissioner. So the suggestion was and the ruling by the judge that
- 1:23:55the plaintiffs had not really named the right people to go forward. That maybe
- 1:24:00the legislature because that's the allocating body, Maybe the Corrections Commissioner because that is
- 1:24:05the person who has direct oversight. So out for now, and the administration.
- 1:24:13Brian Abraham, the governor's chief of staff, said that the state is
- 1:24:17clearly pleased because this was their position that the issue of standing was not appropriate.
- 1:24:25The lawyer for the plaintiffs, these people who were incarcerated in West Virginia
- 1:24:29jails, Steve Knew of Beckley, said they're going to appeal, going to
- 1:24:32appeal to the Fourth Circuit. Said that conditions in the jails have improved under
- 1:24:39the current Corrections Commissioner, Billy Marshall, but that there's still a lot to
- 1:24:43go. He says that this is the lawyer New says the correction still has
- 1:24:47one hundred and fifty six million dollars in overdue maintenance and three hundred and fifty
- 1:24:54uniformed officers falling short within the system. I should say that, you know,
- 1:24:59he he is right that the legislature, he is right in the sense
- 1:25:03that improvements have been made. Whether it's adequate improvements, that's not up to
- 1:25:08me. But the legislature did allocate millions of dollars toward deferred maintenance for the
- 1:25:13jails and prisons. That that is something that has happened. And the governor
- 1:25:16declared emergency on staffing about two years ago and recently lifted that declaration that had
- 1:25:25allowed the National Guard to go in and provide support in West Virginia's jails and
- 1:25:30the conditions improved. There were salary improvements for corrections officers to try to recruit
- 1:25:35and retain them over a couple of years, and that staffing has improved to
- 1:25:43the point that the governor felt like he could lift that emergency order. Whether
- 1:25:48to what degree the jail system still needs to be improved, that is not
- 1:25:55currently a question in federal court because the judge threw it out, but it
- 1:26:00still could be depending on the possibility of appeal. Mentioned New state wide Correspondent
- 1:26:03Brad McElhenny is joining us sprad of an itching to get to this story entire
- 1:26:08show. So you alerted me to it, so I bring it up to
- 1:26:11you, sir. A story in the Washington Post. The headline reads,
- 1:26:15Mansion Mansion threatened to break with Biden before senior Democrats intervened. Well, it
- 1:26:21was only a matter of time before our favorite senator popped up in this Biden's
- 1:26:27story, Brad. But it appears as though Senator Mansion was all set to
- 1:26:30break ranks and then he didn't, according to the Washington Post. Yeah,
- 1:26:36Washington Post story, And you know, I mean if the Washington Post,
- 1:26:41which is one of America's three big four big national newspapers, the New York
- 1:26:45Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, USA Today, if it says
- 1:26:50you were going to do something in a big headline on their homepage, is
- 1:26:55it as good as doing it? But this is classic. So the Post
- 1:27:01reporting that Mansion strongly considered going on one of the Sunday News Journal roundtable programs.
- 1:27:11So think in terms of meet the press or face the nation to say
- 1:27:14that he thinks that he's lost confidence in President Biden as fallout of that terrible
- 1:27:20debate performance and then Mansion apparently decided not to do that. According to the
- 1:27:28Mansion camp, after he had already decided not to do that, he received
- 1:27:31calls from higher ups in the Democratic Party. The story names Senate Majority Leader
- 1:27:39Chuck Schumer as one of those who called him to try to prevail upon him
- 1:27:43to not do the thing that he'd already decided not to do. And then
- 1:27:47the upshot is that the Washington Post winds up reporting anyway that he was going
- 1:27:54to do it. Manchin threatened to break with Biden before senior Democrats intervened.
- 1:27:59That headline is just about as good as actually having done it. Yeah,
- 1:28:03I agree, And the story goes on from there about some of the reaction
- 1:28:08we've seen since last what was it last Thursday, the debate and the reaction,
- 1:28:14and then the reaction to the reaction. Goes on from there, But
- 1:28:16once again, Senator Joe Manchin somehow finds his way into the conversation. And
- 1:28:23not that I've heard his name brought up Brad as a replacement, but I
- 1:28:28do wonder if he is reconsidering his decision at all, given what we've learned
- 1:28:33in the last week. As a third party candidate. I just I would
- 1:28:36like to ask him that question if I ever had the opportunity. So you're
- 1:28:41wondering about his consideration of running for president. I have watching that debate,
- 1:28:45wouldn't you go, Ah, I could beat these two guys, you know,
- 1:28:49I think ballot access would be a problem at this point. I think
- 1:28:53No Labels has folded up the entity that does have ballot access as the Libertarians.
- 1:28:57But I have trouble viewing Joe Manchin as a match for the Libertarian platform.
- 1:29:03Brad mcohenny with his realistic, real world opinions raining on my parade,
- 1:29:11but it's telling that I need a whiteboard just for joe mansion options. You
- 1:29:15got to set off some fireworks tomorrow, eat some hot dogs, Hamburgers,
- 1:29:19Apple Pie, Chevrolet. So the family is going to Hershey Park. That
- 1:29:25was predetermined, but I am worried about both crowds and heat. Are you
- 1:29:28a roller coaster guy? I am a roller coaster guy, and so the
- 1:29:32breeze generated by the speed of the roller coaster may be welcome in alleviating heat,
- 1:29:38but maybe the motion along with the overheatedness that could be bad. Who
- 1:29:44knows. And the giant chocolate bar you are required to purchase while you're there.
- 1:29:48I certainly will be. I will be overheated eating a giant chocolate bar
- 1:29:53and subject to motion sickness. That sounds like the perfect way to celebrate Independence
- 1:29:58Day. Yeah, that's that's the American Metcha news take the debate last week
- 1:30:01Metro New State white course bought of Brad Macwhenne always appreciated Brad. Thank you,
- 1:30:06thank you. Rest of the show is yours. It's considered like a
- 1:30:10pre Steam release, but it's not a real Steam release because I'm not subject
- 1:30:14to those rules. I have a presumed immunity or something like that. But
- 1:30:19the rest of the show is yours. I get to a bunch of text
- 1:30:21messages that have been rolling in phones are open as well. Eight hundred and
- 1:30:25seven to sixty five talk as the phone number. Three oh four. Talk
- 1:30:28three oh four is the text line as we unwind and head into Independence Day.
- 1:30:32Dave Wilson in for Hopi Kurgible. This is talk line from the Encoba
- 1:30:36Insurance Studios. Did you know that small businesses are the biggest target for cyber
- 1:30:42attacks? It's true. Cyber criminals love targeting the little guys. Fear not
- 1:30:45because citty nets got your back with the best in cybersecurity protection. Remember citty
- 1:30:51net Connects, protects and perfects. Learn more at citynet dot net. Attention,
- 1:30:57business owners and managers, it's in the new US all the time.
- 1:31:00Another company is suffering from financial and reputational losses due to a cyber attack.
- 1:31:05Don't let your business be the next victim. Contact citty net today for comprehensive
- 1:31:11cybersecurity solutions from thread detection to incident response. We've got you covered. Visit
- 1:31:16us on the web at citynet dot net to learn more citty net Connects,
- 1:31:21protects and perfects. Are you ready to make a difference in your community?
- 1:31:29Let ZMM architects and engineers be your partner and progress with innovative designs and a
- 1:31:34collaborative approach. We're committed to creating inspiring spaces and improving the communities we serve,
- 1:31:42from cutting edge educational facilities to community centric gathering spaces. Together, we
- 1:31:46can design better environments for future generations. Because at ZMM, it's more than
- 1:31:53architecture, it's about building your legacy. You're listening to talk Line on metro
- 1:31:58News, the Voice of West Virginia wvmetronews dot com, the only website you
- 1:32:05need to stay informed in the Mountain State. Get the latest news and sports
- 1:32:10story, information on the great outdoors, and never miss an episode of your
- 1:32:14favorite Metro news programs and podcast including Talkline, Hotline, sports Line, and
- 1:32:19Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark now and visit WV metronews dot
- 1:32:25com first thing every morning to find out what's happening all across the states.
- 1:32:29Wvmetronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet
- 1:32:34radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state.
- 1:32:40Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for
- 1:32:44more than twenty five years. Stockfish for repatriation purposes to that's reintroduction, re
- 1:32:49establishment of Brooks trout, and two of those streams the oldest that we have
- 1:32:54worked on, the earliest ones that we started putting fish into. We've noticed
- 1:32:59natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether it's hunting and fishing news or
- 1:33:02just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. It was a pretty
- 1:33:06good fight. It takes me about ten minutes to get it in my Dad
- 1:33:11actually had to run to the truck and grab ant because there's my way I
- 1:33:15could list him up over top of the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it
- 1:33:18all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors
- 1:33:23Today brings you two and a half minutes of mews and notes from the woods
- 1:33:27and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia. It's
- 1:33:31two hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the City Net
- 1:33:35Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey, this is Travis Joes joined myself and Greg
- 1:33:39Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up
- 1:33:43the sports weekend. We talk Mountaineers, high school, Mountain East Conference,
- 1:33:46and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive.
- 1:33:50You could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh
- 1:33:55four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro news a
- 1:33:58Philly or watch the show wb Metronews dot com. Metro News Talk Line with
- 1:34:15Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Incoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to
- 1:34:19protect what do you care about most. Visit in Coca dot com to learn
- 1:34:24more open phones going into Independence Day. Three or four Talk three or four
- 1:34:28is the text line eight hundred seven six five eight two five five the phone
- 1:34:31number. Kind of a pre steam release, although we can have a dialogue
- 1:34:36and it's only four about fifteen minutes three or four talk three oh four.
- 1:34:42Hey, Dave Hoppy is doing two performances of seventeen seventy six today portraying John
- 1:34:47Dickinson in Charlestown. David, it's time for Mansion to step up, step
- 1:34:56up and do what? Run for president? He's not. I mean,
- 1:35:00I know the answer to the question, but I just picture him watching the
- 1:35:06debate last Thursday thinking to himself, like many of us were good, Granny,
- 1:35:15these are the two candidates. It's like in sports when you're playing or
- 1:35:21you are coaching and you get beat by a team that you know you should
- 1:35:26not get beat by, and then you watch them go and have success,
- 1:35:29and you're like, it just makes it worse. That's what I would compare
- 1:35:31that to probably three four Talk three four, Daved, I think you should
- 1:35:40call the pre steam release Friday, light your firecracker Wednesday Day. The problem
- 1:35:46with The primary is that you have a few states deciding the output for the
- 1:35:50whole country. This needs to change. The people of West Virginia have no
- 1:35:55say and what the outcomes are going to be. As you well know,
- 1:36:01friend of the Show Chris Diarwell does not like the primary system. Uh Dave,
- 1:36:12where have you guys been in the past three years? Professor Emeredith rup
- 1:36:15my hind parts the media pedaled the Democrat talking points to a t. Biden's
- 1:36:18handlers scheduled the first debate early, exposing his problems, just so they could
- 1:36:23install a new candidate. Come on, man, a little bit conspiracy theoryist
- 1:36:29theorist, little conspiratorial there. But I did see I did see that.
- 1:36:34In a speech last night, the President blamed his travels schedule that he'd been
- 1:36:39flying at Look. That excuse ain't gonna fly either, And for the reason
- 1:36:44the Texter just pointed out, Biden's team set the rules for the debate,
- 1:36:48They set the date, they set the network, they arranged it all so
- 1:36:54you can't blame your previous travel schedule and you've just been a week of camp
- 1:36:59Davidson, that excuse thing on a fly either, uh three or four talk
- 1:37:06three of four Dave, why don't you have a political science professor from WVU
- 1:37:14take that under advisement. David, just want to say that I look forward
- 1:37:18to listening to you and Hoppy every day. Keep up the great work,
- 1:37:20Kevi great for the July holiday weekend. Why thank you and you as well.
- 1:37:26Hang in there, Joe, polls. Don't call the graveyards or illegals.
- 1:37:33Okay, Today we have to ask ourselves, are we having another Edith
- 1:37:39Wilson moment in history? In the final year of the presidency of Woodrow Wilson,
- 1:37:43he was incapacitated and his wife Edith was making all the decisions and signing
- 1:37:47his name. It was only discovered because his own party called for him to
- 1:37:51immediately appear before the Senate because they feared he was not in control. He
- 1:37:56was running for reelection at the time as well. That's I keep coming.
- 1:38:00Look, I'm not going to get into I mean, do we have an
- 1:38:02Edith Wilson situation? But we all need to have people around us because at
- 1:38:10some point, whether let me use this business as a as an example,
- 1:38:15at some point, and some of you may may think I've already reached that
- 1:38:18point, you start to diminish and you are not as good as you were
- 1:38:25when you were in your prime in this business. You see it with broadcasters
- 1:38:28all the time. Think of some of your favorite you know, sports announcers,
- 1:38:33and we're always the last to know it because well, and I get
- 1:38:38this as I get a little bit older, you still in your mind feel
- 1:38:41like you're twenty thirty years old. So you're the last to know when your
- 1:38:45skills diminished. That's why you need to have people around you who you trust.
- 1:38:50And most likely it's family. It's your wife, it'll be your kids
- 1:38:54who tell you, hey, pops, it's over, it's time to step
- 1:38:58away, and anybody if as I was watching that debate last Thursday, watching
- 1:39:04that thinking that if that was my granddad, if that was my dad,
- 1:39:09grief, I wouldn't want him up there on stage like that. I'd want
- 1:39:12to be enjoying the time we have left with him, not putting him up
- 1:39:15there in that position. And quite frankly, he doesn't have that around him.
- 1:39:20Dave. Have you checked your utilities how much they went up in the
- 1:39:24States since Republicans have taken over. State bills went up two hundred percent,
- 1:39:29Dave. The special investigation they had to determine whether President Biden was responsible for
- 1:39:32the classified documents in his possession, and that basically said the president's memory was
- 1:39:36in question. Shouldn't congressional hearings be held to question his staff to find out
- 1:39:41what they know and when they knew concerning his condition? What if something happens
- 1:39:45and he makes a mistake in my humble opinion says the Texter got to take
- 1:39:50our final break. I'll get to you, boy. I got a slew
- 1:39:54of text to get to I'll try to get through as many of them as
- 1:39:56possible. Phone lines are open as well. Eight hundred and seven to sixty
- 1:39:59five talks phone number three or four talk three oh four the text line.
- 1:40:03Mondhealth Medical Center is accredited as a Center of Excellence and Robotic Surgery by the
- 1:40:08Surgical Review Corporation. Bringing high tech solutions and advanced surgical care to West Virginians.
- 1:40:13Receive expert care from our nationally recognized robotic surgery team close to home at
- 1:40:17Monhealth. Learn more at monhealth dot com. Slash robotics high tech solutions with
- 1:40:20a warm touch approach. That's the Mond Health difference. Winning the lottery would
- 1:40:25be the start of my race dream hitting the open road at top speeds,
- 1:40:28hugging turns. It's intense. What are you dreaming of racing again? Not
- 1:40:40dreaming, I'm practicing and I'm checking my tickets. It's a mower, It's
- 1:40:45a dream. West Virginia Lottery. What if it could happen to you?
- 1:40:51Please play responsibly. The Wound Institute the only wound center in the area with
- 1:40:58providers who are afford certified in wound and ostomycare. Doctor Kerry framan her dedicated
- 1:41:02team of skilled professionals are ready to provide you with the latest treatments and personalized
- 1:41:08care. Visit their new office location on Kenton Drive and Charleston for cutting edge
- 1:41:12woundcare. Find more information and start your recovery today at the Woundinstitute dot org.
- 1:41:17The Wound Institute healing complex wounds using advanced treatments. Located in the heart
- 1:41:24of West Virginia, Bridgeport is the place to play. Endless indoor and outdoor
- 1:41:29recreation opportunities including the Bridge Sports Complex, coupled with a dynamic food scene,
- 1:41:33make Bridgeport the perfect getaway destination for couples and families. Explore unique shopping and
- 1:41:41pick from a wealth of lodging options to find something perfect for your needs.
- 1:41:45Explore the heart of West Virginia Bridgeport. Learn more about all there is to
- 1:41:48do at Greater Dash Bridgeport dot com. This is talk Line on Metro News,
- 1:41:54the voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only
- 1:42:00hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers
- 1:42:04across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and
- 1:42:10fishing stories for more than twenty five years. I shaw him. He ran
- 1:42:13over to the edge of the field. He made it about five ten yards
- 1:42:16out of the edge of the field and fell over there. Whether it's hunting
- 1:42:20and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors.
- 1:42:25He stuck his head through the blind into where you were. Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:42:30well he had jumped, he leaped over the blonde. Oh gosh,
- 1:42:33yeah he had. His whole body was in the air for a couple of
- 1:42:38seconds and is the only thing that landed in the blind was, of course,
- 1:42:42his head in its part leg West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings
- 1:42:45at seven oh six am and for your daily fix. Outdoors Today brings you
- 1:42:49two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every
- 1:42:54weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Hey everybody,
- 1:42:59it's Tony Gritty. I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite
- 1:43:01you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News radio network.
- 1:43:05It's the city Nets Statewide sports Line. We talk West Virginia University football,
- 1:43:12basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to do
- 1:43:15with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the text line
- 1:43:17available every night. So we invite you to join us. The Senator Coach
- 1:43:21Hunter and me Tony COURRITTI. It's the city Net state Wide sports Line on
- 1:43:26Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick, and for decades you
- 1:43:30have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance
- 1:43:35to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening,
- 1:43:40become a Metro News hawk by texting news to three five sixty five to one.
- 1:43:44If you take a picture or video of what you see, submit that
- 1:43:46as well. Text the word news to three, five sixty five one to
- 1:43:50submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and
- 1:43:56drive three or four. Talk three or four. The text line, Dave,
- 1:44:15how is Biden a flawed candidate? Or how's Biden that flawed candidate?
- 1:44:19Performance wise? People say that with no facts? Stop lying. Well,
- 1:44:25let's start when he's eighty one years old. He's incognitive decline. Afghanistan was
- 1:44:29a mess under his watch, the withdrawal from there, the border is a
- 1:44:32mess. You can talk about inflation, Russian Russia invaded Ukraine, and Hamas
- 1:44:42attacked Israel. So there are a few reasons there, and those all happened
- 1:44:45under his watch. Those I would consider him a flawed candidate starting with eighty
- 1:44:53one years old, cognitive decline. Stop lying, I'm not lying. That's
- 1:44:58observational three or four Talk three or four, Dave. Are you insinuating that
- 1:45:05Hoppy is an old timer he's past his prime. That's cold. No,
- 1:45:09no, not what I'm insinuating at all? No, not at all.
- 1:45:15Hop he's fine, he's doing a fine job. He doesn't need me to
- 1:45:19tell him either three or four Talk three or four, Steamer, Lease,
- 1:45:25Dave, I'm mad that I switched all my lights to LEDs and appliances to
- 1:45:28higher efficiency just to lower my power bill. But then it still goes up.
- 1:45:31What's the point if they still raise our rates? Makes me think I
- 1:45:34wasted my money? Gee, Dave, are you feeling old? I was
- 1:45:42not particularly old, but you know what I'm talking. You know what I
- 1:45:45mean. Guys especially, we never mature beyond like what twenty years old.
- 1:45:49We always think we can do what we did in our twenties. My papa,
- 1:45:54when he was in his seventies, he would still climb around on scaffolding
- 1:45:59like he did when he was thirty, and you couldn't tell him any different.
- 1:46:01You'd be up on a roof putting shingles down. Couldn't tell him me
- 1:46:05a different. Still thought he could do it, and he could. For
- 1:46:09the most part, they have a large part of Trump's popularity has to do
- 1:46:14with the entourage of people that he will bring to run the show when he
- 1:46:17gets to office. Dave consistency, says the Texter. All right, tomorrow,
- 1:46:25tomorrow we will enjoy a program already enjoyed for a talk line. Tomorrow
- 1:46:31with the Independence holiday, we will do a best of tomorrow, relive some
- 1:46:40moments that we've already enjoyed here on the program with Hoppy, and then back
- 1:46:44at it for a regular normal show on Friday. We will be in the
- 1:46:47big chair, or I will be in the big chair. You will be
- 1:46:50observing the Big Chair Steamer Lease eleven thirty three on Friday, and we will
- 1:46:56commence with the weekend. If you're going to be out and about tomorrow,
- 1:46:59in joy the Independence holiday, Enjoy Independence Day, have a burger, have
- 1:47:02a hot dog, apple pie, Chevrolet fireworks, all of the above.
- 1:47:08We'll be back live on Friday at ten oh six for a regular edition of
- 1:47:15Metro News talk Line. All Right. Thanks to Austin Right on the video
- 1:47:18and Connor Limley on the video. This is talk Lit on Metro News,
- 1:47:21the Voice of West Virginia.