Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 7 - Theories)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, our listeners, this is chapter seven and our deep dive on the
- 0:03psychology of Josh Powell. Let's get into it. What do you say,
- 0:07Burt, Let's do it. This is the Psychology and SEATA podcast. I'm
- 0:10your host, doctor Kirkonda. I'm a therapist and a professor. Who are
- 0:14you, Burrow? My name is Umberto cas I am an exotic Lama domesticator.
- 0:19So in the previous chapter, we reviewed the data that we have around
- 0:24Susan's disappearance, which happened Sunday, December sixth, two thousand and nine.
- 0:30Everyone assumes that Josh the husband, killed Susan that night. We also reviewed
- 0:37what we know about the next day, and we watched some video clips.
- 0:42In this episode, I want to start by organizing the presentation around what Josh
- 0:49claims and whether or not it makes any sense. But before we do that,
- 0:55let's watch a video of an interview that a news reporter conducted with Josh
- 1:02soon after Susan's disappearance. Josh is getting in and out of his car in
- 1:07somewhere, maybe at work or something, and the news crew capitalizes on that
- 1:11and rushes him. Let's watch that interview. Hi, Josh, may A
- 1:18Chris Jones, you know why Okay, yeah, how you doing? I
- 1:22know this has been difficult for you in your mind today. Well and by
- 1:30the way, this is on the YouTube channel Chris Jones presumably it's the reporter
- 1:36himself. He has his own YouTube channel. I've been trying to figure out
- 1:42what I can do so I don't sit idle. I'm dealing with this repeatedly.
- 1:52Sure, I was just going to go in and get my kids booth.
- 2:00You know, they're how they how are they doing? They've been doing
- 2:06good. So many first impressions of this interview with Josh Powell that is so
- 2:12bizarre. So, first off, two very interesting things, uh three.
- 2:17Actually, the first one is when he first gets approached and it's hard to
- 2:21tell the video is obviously low quality, but it almost seemed to me like
- 2:27in the first interaction he's like, I'm not gonna say he's smiling, but
- 2:30he's like, oh hey, and then he remembers like oh right, no,
- 2:34no, I'm I'm like super devastated right now. That's the first thing.
- 2:37The second thing is, uh, he's like, how are you doing?
- 2:40It's like, oh, yeah, I have to deal with this,
- 2:44like I've had to deal with a lot of this, like sure, but
- 2:49is that the biggest issue right now? And then the third thing is like
- 2:52how are the kids doing. It's like, oh, they're they're they're fine,
- 2:54They're good. It's like it's it's just an odd thing. As a
- 2:58parent, I'm thinking, like, what do you mean, like they're deficit,
- 3:01We're like distraught, like we don't know what's happened to their mom.
- 3:06But you know, I'm also speaking with the benefit of hindsight, knowing that
- 3:09I think I know that he did it, because one could say, well,
- 3:13in those moments, maybe you are so worried and frazzled that you don't
- 3:16really know what you're saying. Worried about being caught. No, no,
- 3:19I'm saying, if I were to give the benefit of the doubt, oh,
- 3:22you would still be worried about what actually happened, so you might say
- 3:24dumb things anyways. Right. It's sort of like when the press cornered Paul
- 3:30McCartney after John Lennon died, and among a lot of things, Paul McCartney
- 3:35said, there was some quote that he said that made it look like Paul
- 3:38McCartney didn't really care. Do you remember, Yeah, I know what you're
- 3:42talking about. I don't remember the exact thing he said, but yes,
- 3:45it was sort of this, uh, Paul's so according to the internet,
- 3:50and I remember this he said, among the number of things Paul McCartney said,
- 3:54it's a drag. Oh yeah, right, okay, It's like,
- 3:58oh so drag. It's a drag. It's a drag. Man. It's
- 4:00a bummer that John Lennon was murdered. And of course at the time and
- 4:06to this day, there's all these overblown rumors about how much they hated each
- 4:11other and that wasn't even the real Paul McCartney, Yeah, okay, So
- 4:15that's what you're saying, is like, maybe he's and he doesn't know what
- 4:18to say. And on the one hand, I'm reading this kind of thinking
- 4:23I know that he killed it, so I'm looking at it going like,
- 4:26really, you're You're like, oh hey, oh yeah, yeah right,
- 4:29Oh, I'm so devastated, but I'm actually more annoyed about all the cameras
- 4:31and the kids or the kids are fine. That's my takeaway. But it
- 4:35is possible. It's possible that someone who is actually going through the grief would
- 4:41also say weird things. And well, assuming that he murdered Susan soon before
- 4:47this. Do you find it interesting that this is his response? Yeah.
- 4:53If I were actually trying to appear like I'm innocent, I guess my act
- 5:00would be more like like can't, I'm so sorry, like I can't really
- 5:05talk about it, and you know, like, actually, you're actually like
- 5:09in shock and disbelieve. Yeah. Also, this is just one day.
- 5:13No, this might be like a week. Oh it's a week. Oh
- 5:15okay, it's a week, Okay, it's soon after okay, So actually,
- 5:17and anyways, that makes kind of worse because now you really haven't found
- 5:20her, right, I don't know. It just it's hard. It's hard
- 5:25to say, because, like I said, people react in all sorts of
- 5:28weird ways with grief, but at the same time, it just doesn't feel
- 5:32legit it. Yeah, it's very strange to me, and I think it
- 5:39points at something that I want to highlight and I'll go into it more later
- 5:44when I conceptualize his personality. I think the stereotype is that these kinds of
- 5:49people are masterminds there and he did test high on the IQ test, very
- 5:55high, ninety seven percentile. But I think what this points to is he
- 6:00has a lot of issues, a lot of impairments with empathy, with social
- 6:05skills, with emotions, because of the traumas that he went through. It's
- 6:11possible that he also had some other issues, but it can all be explained
- 6:15by the massive amounts of trauma that he went through at the hands of Stephen
- 6:19Powell, and also all the chaos, and perhaps the last the lack of
- 6:24attument. He struggled with emotions. You know, we've been over all that
- 6:28data. And also he struggles with empathy, He struggles with understanding what's going
- 6:33on in other people's minds because I believe of the adaptation of narcissism that he
- 6:40seemed to have developed. And when you're in a situation like this, you
- 6:46can't predict what other people are thinking, and you also don't understand how emotions
- 6:53work because you haven't had practice. And then when you're asked questions soon after
- 7:01what he is hoping everyone believes that Susan disappeared or got murdered, and you
- 7:09know, but it wasn't me, right, you would think that he would
- 7:13know that he should say something along the lines of I'm sad or well very
- 7:17even just avoid the press in general, just be like Hey, sorry,
- 7:21I can't talk right now, or potentially at the very least, because I'm
- 7:26actually thinking. So I'm going through a thing right now where my cat,
- 7:30which I told you, my cat has been missing for a week. As
- 7:33of tomorrow morning, it will be a week. He is indoor outdoor,
- 7:38but this will be the longest he's ever been gone if and I haven't it
- 7:44hasn't even fully hit me yet. But I'm already grieving. But if a
- 7:47reporter came to me asking me about my cat, the first thing I would
- 7:51do is like cameras. Oh my god, if anyone has any information,
- 7:56let me show you pictures, let me talk to you about what they're like
- 7:59where I last saw. Oh my god, this is like free freaking press
- 8:01for the thing that I love being rescued. Good point. I hadn't even
- 8:05thought of that. Yeah, yeah, right, That's the thing is like,
- 8:09we're not in this situation, but if you were really in the situation
- 8:13up for one week, the person you supposedly love, the mother of your
- 8:16children, is actually missing, Yeah, you're doing anything to find them,
- 8:22right. Yeah. So what generally this points to, what I'll get it
- 8:26to you later, is that whatever issues he suffers from results in a lot
- 8:33of different things. It results in this monstrosity of an interview. It also
- 8:39results in all the things that led to him being a failure in life.
- 8:43It also led to all the things that resulted in him having a massive conflictual
- 8:48relationship in his very short marriage, and it resulted in all the things that
- 8:54led up to him making a choice to kill Susan. That's why we call
- 8:56them personality disorders because they cause dysfunction, and they will tend to cause dysfunction
- 9:05and a lot of arenas. Right, So it's not like he has this
- 9:11massive dysfunction with emotion and relationships and attachment and rage and communication, but suddenly
- 9:20he has the ability to respond to a reporter in a way that will get
- 9:26him off the hook. You know, when you have those kinds of problems,
- 9:28they'll show up all over the place. And I think they're showing up
- 9:31here is my point. Let's watch more of this so far as I can
- 9:37tell. How about you? I mean, I know this is difficult on
- 9:41you. How are you doing? I mean, this is such It's going
- 9:43to be a lot of emotions going on for you. So, by the
- 9:46way, everyone suspects he killed her because of the story that he went camping
- 9:54during a blizzard after midnight year old with his one year old and four year
- 9:58old, So everyone suspects that he killed her and drove her somewhere and dumped
- 10:03her somewhere. Right, So this reporter is acting like I mean, I
- 10:09assume he's acting like he's being concerned and playing along, but he's trying to
- 10:15provoke Josh to say something that might implicate him or something. Yeah, you
- 10:22know, people have been really helpful and supportive. So it's been it's been
- 10:31really hard. But OK, you know, you just keep going. What
- 10:37can you tell us about that night that that statement he just made is a
- 10:41statement of someone who knows that they've lost the person. I don't know how
- 10:46long I'm gonna I guess, like we're printing posters for my cat. I
- 10:48don't know how long I'm going to be hoping that cat returns. But if
- 10:52it were my wife, I'd go decades looking for her and then still look
- 10:58like and and you know, if it's been a week and they are missing,
- 11:03it is possible that something really bad happened. But you certainly would be
- 11:07the amount of curiosity you yourself would have about like, well, it's unexplainable,
- 11:13like I love to get shoes at home. There's no trace of her
- 11:16all over to like what happened, right, but certainly not the reaction that
- 11:22wouldn't expect would be like, yeah, I've it's hard. Yeah, it's
- 11:26it's a tragedy. Oh well, my kids are good. We'll move on.
- 11:31The kids are good as far as I can tell. Yeah, the
- 11:33one year old is great. Yeah, the four year old. And you
- 11:37thought that I hadn't thought about that that. Yeah. Absolutely. Two years
- 11:41later, family members will still be operating from an assumption that there's still a
- 11:46chance that their loved one is out there if the body has never been found,
- 11:50you know. So yeah, let's watch some more. And from what
- 11:54we understand, you went camping and then came home. We'll tell us what
- 11:56would happen that night. Yeah. I just a lot of times, I
- 12:03just go camping with my boys, you know, not anything big. I
- 12:05just go overnight and I we do s'mores and stuff like that. And so
- 12:15I just went with the boys, was planning to do some s'mores in the
- 12:20morning and then o day and then when we got home, well, on
- 12:31the way home, I found out that people were worried about us and we
- 12:37were missing, and any thoughts of that again, like, it's just you
- 12:50know, I usually take my boys, you know, hey, just so
- 12:54you know, I'm establishing alibi here, I usually take my boys camping.
- 12:58That's just the thing. We And to prove that I'm not lying, I'll
- 13:03add of detail. We cooke smores. I mean, now you know that
- 13:05it's real. And to connect the dots, that night, I was taking
- 13:11them camping and guess what, we were going to cook smores in the morning,
- 13:15So, like, you get it, that's what was happening. Then
- 13:18when I got home, oh o wait, okay, on the way home,
- 13:22so are you highlighting how he hesitates? Yeah, because he's trying to
- 13:30Like when I got home, oh wait, no, no, on the
- 13:33way home, people started worrying about us. I get, I guess.
- 13:35And by the way, he hasn't mentioned her at all. Right, she's
- 13:39the one missing. A more believable response, and there's many would have been
- 13:45something in terms of that bit would have been something like and then while I
- 13:50was camping, all of a sudden, I look at my phone and there's
- 13:52all these voicemails and text and everything, and so I called and I find
- 13:58out that no one knows where Susan is, and so I thought she must
- 14:01just be at work or at a friend's house or maybe I call her cell
- 14:05phone right and then and there's no answer because it's in my car without a
- 14:09sink card. Well anyway, so instead he's just like yeah, and then
- 14:16uh, he's thinking, and then I learned everyone's freaking out. So yeah,
- 14:22that's the story. Yeah, there's no mention of that would be the
- 14:28biggest highlight if she actually did just if he didn't kill her, that would
- 14:33be the biggest highlight in your memory, right that moment when you were informed
- 14:39that she was missing, that would be burnt into your brain. Well,
- 14:43actually that wouldn't have been when you're on your way home probably what what because
- 14:50well he he uh, at some point he answers the phone, which I'll
- 14:54get into later. There's a whole kind of thing about that detail. And
- 14:58he's informed by the neighbor, that same neighbor with the pancakes that you know,
- 15:03everyone's looking for him in it, and the police are there and all
- 15:07this stuff, and no one knows where Susan is. Yeah, but at
- 15:09that point, that's what I'm saying, Like if this were real, Like
- 15:13just I'm putting I'm imagining myself for whatever bizarre reason, I literally did go
- 15:16camping at midnight with my little babies. Okay, I'm on my way back
- 15:20the next day, and I've gotten them days mixed up. All this is
- 15:22true. Fine, I get a call neighbor says, hey, cops are
- 15:28looking for you guys. Where are you guys? And I'm like, oh
- 15:31my god, it's shoot, well, I took the kids camping, but
- 15:35you know Susan's home. No, apparently Susan's not home. I wouldn't immediately
- 15:39jump to like, ah, that's when I knew she'd disappeared. No,
- 15:43because like, I'm sure she went to the groceries. I don't know.
- 15:46I'm on my way. I'll be there in a minute. We'll figure this
- 15:48out. She's not missing because I have no reason to imagine she's gone missing.
- 15:52Right, So, sure she was feeling a little tummy ache. But
- 15:56I mean, come on, right, and I'll get to this later,
- 16:00he Dilly dalies before he comes home. Yeah, it's very strange, but
- 16:06let's watch more of this. The report is is that neither you nor your
- 16:10wife called them sick, and they said that that's not usual. What are
- 16:14your thoughts on that? No, it's it's not usual. I guess why
- 16:27didn't you call him sick? These long pauses? So this is consistent with
- 16:33the police interviews that I've watched and other interviews that he's had with the press.
- 16:37Yeah, if he's innocent, then you'd say, well, you know,
- 16:41he's reserved, or he's not a quick thinker, or he's going through
- 16:45a lot. But it seems excessive, doesn't it. Yeah. This is
- 16:48my suspicion is that at some point earlier on he decided, Okay, I'm
- 16:56going to kill her. And we went over that in a previous chapter,
- 16:59and he said, I'm going to investigate the principles of what I will do
- 17:03after I kill her, And I imagine he came across information or advice or
- 17:10something that you shouldn't talk much because if they don't give details, right,
- 17:15because if you talk a lot, then you will inadvertently implicate yourself. So
- 17:21the principle is, don't say anything unless you're sure that it's okay to have
- 17:25said that, and don't be afraid to just not say anything, and also
- 17:30think before you speak. And he although has a high IQ there's a lot
- 17:37to process. And also I don't think he has a ton of common sense.
- 17:44I think he's good with academic type tasks, right, like remembering numbers
- 17:49or organizing blocks or something, except until you have to do it for real
- 17:55and pass classes and get jobs that you can hold, right, right,
- 17:59Yeah, And when it involves emotion and a lot of complexity, he short
- 18:03circuits. I think. Plus, he's had a week, maybe even a
- 18:08couple years to come up with, you know, the the ten bullet points,
- 18:15and he's I think already he's been interviewed by the policemans. You think
- 18:18there would be like a quick answer to these questions, but continually it looks
- 18:25like there's evidence that he improved the entire thing, right, And it's one
- 18:30of again what I was saying in another episode is if he didn't do it,
- 18:36oh man, I wish someone could help him and coach him or like,
- 18:40cause you're no one would ever imagine that someone who didn't do it would
- 18:45have gotten away with all of this, you know, because it just seems
- 18:48so. And so we see this all the time when we review these cases,
- 18:55these true crime cases. The criminal often is bumbling the job from the
- 19:00very beginning. Yeah, you know, it's not like you know, some
- 19:04Tom Cruise movie where you have this multifaceted, super buttoned up plan that is
- 19:11taking you. It just seems like, how did you not catch And I'll
- 19:15later I'll get into why the police didn't charge him and why he wasn't really
- 19:22investigated. But let's let's watch a little bit more of this interview. You
- 19:26know, I didn't I was somehow thinking that it was Sunday. I didn't
- 19:33go to church tonight. I just missed today and come back Sunday. So
- 19:44you got confused by what day I want. Yeah, now, from what
- 19:49we understand, there's nothing. There's looks like no foul playing the home.
- 19:53That appears that your wife left her cell phone and purse. I mean,
- 19:57give any I mean does she does she go off to sort of maybe clear
- 20:00her head? I mean, do you have any idea where she could be?
- 20:07No, she was to leave during the day, and that she's never
- 20:15left overnight. He comes acro If I didn't know better, and I was
- 20:23just reading this verbatim, I would think he was talking to Charlie. Yeah.
- 20:27The way he's responding is that of a child, and he might be
- 20:32regressing and some people might be wondering if there's some neurodivergence, maybe autism or
- 20:37something. And I'll get into that more when I provide my final conceptualization.
- 20:42And yeah, it's possible, there's not a ton of evidence of that.
- 20:47And there's plenty of other potential causes for this, most namely that he made
- 20:53a policy early on because of his research that he would be very very careful
- 20:59about what he said. And he's not sharp when it comes to common sense
- 21:04about how to communicate, and he's not particularly charming, right he. You
- 21:08imagine if he had more charm, he could sort of fill in those silent
- 21:14gaps, you know, like he, oh sorry, you know, it's
- 21:18just been a lot, you know, So it's gonna be hard. Like
- 21:21he's so dead, he's so devoid of any kind of life. He's not
- 21:26even moving, he's just like his face is so still. And I think
- 21:33it's explained by the abuse he went through and the way he has trouble with
- 21:41emotions. And also it would be a big thing, you know, to
- 21:45kill someone is a big thing, right, So it's not like it is
- 21:48in the movies where it's like, okay, look at he split. I
- 21:49don't think he's a psychopath. I think he actually does have the capacity for
- 21:53empathy and was probably traumatized by and there's evidence that he might have been hands
- 22:02on with the with the killing, right, and it was likely very hands
- 22:07on with the disposal of the body, So that might have harmed him in
- 22:11a way that he's still affected by. Also, he was massively abused growing
- 22:18up, which can develop an individual to cope by dissociating. I didn't hear
- 22:25any other evidence that he had a pattern of dissociating, but some people can
- 22:27have like mild association under stress, and that's kind of what it looks like
- 22:33to me. He just seems shut off right right, And you notice that
- 22:37once again everything is still about what he did, right, So, like
- 22:41it's like, well so it's unusual. It's like, yeah, well I
- 22:45just forgot what day it was. But the thing is like again you would
- 22:48think it's like, yeah, I don't understand she she never misses work.
- 22:52It is really weird that and maybe I mean, you know, even if
- 22:56you dial back the the because I'm a very ex pressive and motive person,
- 23:00but still, you know, just even someone saying like it is very weird.
- 23:04She never misses work. She always calls that's the weirdest thing. Yeah.
- 23:08Also, even if you are the murderer, Yeah, you think you
- 23:12would have thought about something to say in this moment that would kind of make
- 23:18him look innocent. Right, he's saying nothing to help him, especially,
- 23:22and you know, I think like if if you are innocent, or like
- 23:26you're or if you're a murderer trying to get away with part of it is
- 23:30like, oh, oh, like the fact that you forgot the day,
- 23:34none of that actually technically matters if you're innocent, Yes, you'll have to
- 23:38talk about it in the court of law whatever, But in the moment,
- 23:41it actually doesn't matter. What matters is she's missing. It's so weird as
- 23:45she wouldn't call that in Yeah, that's what doesn't make sense. And why
- 23:48would her person be like these are the things that you thinking, you know,
- 23:52Sunday because no, one, that's not the point. Yeah. Yeah,
- 23:56Now maybe he's thinking, I don't need the public to approve or disapprove,
- 24:00sure, because that doesn't matter. I don't know, But let's watch
- 24:04a little bit more. Does she have any enemies that you can think of
- 24:08that would title I can't think of anyone. Now, A lot of talk
- 24:15on the internet, I mean a lot of obviously in cases like this and
- 24:18you know this, they instantly talk about the husband. I think that he's
- 24:22the suspect, but he did something. Is there anything you want to say
- 24:26to address that I didn't do anything. I mean, I don't know where
- 24:36she's at. I'd call it. I guess there are people who act very
- 24:41weird in life. Yeah, that makes no sense. Like why again,
- 24:47maybe I'm just projecting too much. But if I know that I didn't do
- 24:51something like that, I mean it just but again, even if you did,
- 24:56is you're trying to get away? I know, I know, it's
- 24:57like what would you have said? Okay, I'd be like, yeah,
- 25:00of course, that's that's the natural initial thing. I'm not. I can't
- 25:06convince anyone of anything out there on the internet right now. None of that
- 25:10matters to me. Yeah, I just want to find my wife. Here's
- 25:12all the information again, blah blah blah. Please call it like yeah,
- 25:17or scapegoat someone like the police aren't looking with enough resource or something. Oh
- 25:22yeahah, I forgot that. I'm also trying, okay, if I am
- 25:25the killer, trying to get what? Yeah, that's a great point,
- 25:26and it's like, like me, like I've given all the information. What
- 25:30about I don't know? Like, but a more typical response that I think
- 25:36would happen is a husband who loves his wife who is being accused of killing
- 25:41his wife would say, are you kidding me? Are? Yeah? We
- 25:45had our upside downs, but I loved her. I would never her.
- 25:49I've never heard anybody I would never Maybe I can't convince people, but no,
- 25:55I'm not capable of that. She's a good person. She doesn't deserve
- 25:57to be here. I would never hurt her, you know something like,
- 26:02yeah, I kind of I think you might have done it, Kirk.
- 26:07Now listen, I know the point is, whatever it is, whatever it
- 26:11is, it would have been natural if he were in it, and if
- 26:14you were a good I guess liar, it would have felt natural. I
- 26:18don't think you need to be a good liar. I think you just have
- 26:19to be here. This feels like because because essentially, like you were saying,
- 26:22it just feels dead. Yeah, it feels like, uh, I
- 26:27don't I didn't do anything. If I didn't know better, I would think
- 26:30he was high, Yeah, like heroin or opiates or something. I didn't
- 26:36do anything. I just, you know, I don't know where she is.
- 26:37Yeah, I didn't do anything. I didn't do anything. I didn't
- 26:41What do you I didn't do anything. I didn't anything. It's it's yeah,
- 26:45it's like the snow cut her. I mean, I didn't do anything.
- 26:51Let's watch a little bit more. I don't even know where to start
- 26:55looking. And the boys, I mean, what do you tell them about
- 27:00them? All? I have told him anything. I mean they've overheard stuff,
- 27:07but I haven't. I haven't. By the time it all started,
- 27:11I was already you know, it was already late, and we were I
- 27:25went to bed. Well you been ever since? Now? Your wife laid
- 27:29down that night, right, she wasn't feeling well? Was that? And
- 27:30then you just and then that's when you you you went camping? And where'd
- 27:33you guys go camping? Well, she she wasn't not feeling well. She
- 27:37was feeling well, but she just went to bed about five issues at when
- 27:42we heard we heard five. I don't know if that's true. You would
- 27:45know better than we went. No, she went to bed that night.
- 27:51And what time did you go camping? Would you say? I? You
- 27:56know, I I got out to a pretty late start nineish something like that.
- 28:02No, it was it's later. And basically I'm just trying to trying
- 28:14to figure out what I can do and both try to find her and try
- 28:19to take care of life in general, life in general. But it took
- 28:30this long before he finally says something that he probably prepared in case this happens
- 28:37of I'm just trying to figure out how to find her or something. And
- 28:41then he says, and I'm also just trying to figure out how to deal
- 28:42with and I think he's going to say the kids, but then he says
- 28:47life life, you know, just like general life stuff. Because you know,
- 28:51he got in over his head like he knew that. Oh my gosh,
- 28:53now I'm just now I'm babbling and I'm saying, well, plus they're
- 28:56asking him details, right, and he I think knows that if he just
- 29:03starts blabbing about timelines and what she did, he started saying, like he
- 29:07started getting into tricky territory case, He's like, no, no, she
- 29:11Then I left and he's like, well, And the thing that's insane is
- 29:17it's as if he didn't actually have a one year old, meaning anyone who's
- 29:21had a one year old at any time, let alone I mean including a
- 29:23four year old, but let alone a one year old. Sleep is so
- 29:27important at all times. So the idea that you would drag the one year
- 29:33old out of the house at those times, but to him it's normal and
- 29:37stuff, that's just bizarre. So I think he starts realizing like, Okay,
- 29:40this isn't so he pulls back. He's like, anyways, I'm just
- 29:42trying to find her. Right, he has that at the ready, And
- 29:48I didn't realize this until you said that about how it would be strange to
- 29:52take a one year old on a situation like that. But we've already been
- 29:56over how he and his father, Stephen, had zero parenting skills and no
- 30:03boundaries and we're basically like children themselves, And so he wanted, you know,
- 30:10if he were the boy's bigger brother, who's eleven years old, they
- 30:15decided, Hey, because there's no checks and balances, let's go camping.
- 30:19We wouldn't expect an eleven year old to care about a one year old sleep
- 30:22or the well being, right, you know, they don't. They're not
- 30:26expected to think that. That's I think another piece of evidence as to what's
- 30:32going on underneath everything. For him because he thinks that's a legitimate story,
- 30:37and there's seeming evidence that maybe he even planned that. There's also a theory,
- 30:41which I'll get into later, that he just adjusted on the fly.
- 30:45But regardless, he given his super ego problems which went over earlier, he
- 30:52doesn't realize that that looks strange from the outside, I think, is what
- 30:56you're saying. Right, Yeah, So verdict Berto innocent or guilty given what
- 31:03we're watching here based on this interview, either he is absolutely guilty or he
- 31:08is so unlucky to have such poor skills at negotiating this in reality. Yeah,
- 31:18because if you were really innocent and trying to go through all this,
- 31:21then there's a whole other layer of Wow, you know, sorry, someone
- 31:23needs to help you, someone needs to intervene. Yeah, right, Yeah,
- 31:27he doesn't look distressed. But let's take a break. What do you
- 31:36say? Let's do it all right, we're back from the break. So
- 31:42I want to have this section be about Josh's claims because as we review this,
- 31:51it will illuminate a lot of the details of the story that are important.
- 31:56So a summary of his story before getting into the details is that on
- 32:01Sunday night, as he was saying he left Susan at home and he took
- 32:05the boys camping. He doesn't know where Susan is and he figures that she
- 32:13went to work or something. But if she didn't show up to work,
- 32:17then he doesn't have any idea. That's generally his approach when questioned by the
- 32:22police. So claim number one that he makes, and let's evaluate each claim
- 32:30based on and I'll give more evidence that is in support or not of each
- 32:35claim number one. And by the way, I didn't need to do this,
- 32:38but I had to. YEA. So the other night you actually had
- 32:44canceled recording the podcast, and I was already putting my notes together, and
- 32:52I just thought, okay, well I'll spend a little bit more time putting
- 32:57my no together because now I have the rest of the night to do whatever
- 33:00I want to. I was up till two or three in the morning just
- 33:07going over all the data and trying to confirm things. This is all these
- 33:10like conflicting stories might be wow, and organizing it. And it was like
- 33:16I was a lawyer trying to put together a prosecution case, like okay,
- 33:22okay, well this is his claim, Okay, what evidence? This is
- 33:24all part of this process. Okay, so his first claim that I'll mention
- 33:30is that Sunday, at midnight he took the boys on a camping trip,
- 33:34even though there was a huge blizzard and the boys were one in four years
- 33:37old. Now, something to think about is that camping in certain regions of
- 33:42the United States. I think, also in this region, isn't that strange
- 33:47because it's a frequent occurrence. Also in some regions it's not unusual to go
- 33:53camping with your one and four year old. For some families that sounds ridiculous,
- 33:59but I think, yeah, I mean, camping with a one in
- 34:01four year old seems fine under different context. But if you're experienced with camping
- 34:09in the snow, and if they did go camping, and I think they
- 34:12did go camping a lot, then it wouldn't be that big of a deal,
- 34:15and maybe a blizzard wouldn't be just But the logistics of so getting a
- 34:21one year old to sleep is important. Yeah, starting a trip with a
- 34:25one year old at midnight, Yeah, they're already in bed by the way,
- 34:29Yeah, assuming right, this is where you're waking them up out of
- 34:31bed. So at the very least, at the very least, we have
- 34:36to if nothing bad had happened to Susan, everything else is the same,
- 34:39I would have to conclude, Oh my god, you're a terrible parent.
- 34:44Yeah. So a few days later police investigated the area that he claimed he
- 34:51went camping in and they didn't find any evidence of the camp site that Josh
- 34:55had described. But it's possible that the evidence had been the great by time
- 35:00and the weather, you know, all the snow and everything, so it's
- 35:02unclear. Also, a police officer drove the route of Josh's timeline, you
- 35:09know, there and back and found that his timeline does work out in terms
- 35:15of story. And as he was driving out there or driving back, he
- 35:21ran into a sheepherder I think a shepherd. I guess there's another word for
- 35:27us. Yeah. Didn't interact with him, I don't think, but claimed
- 35:32that he randed some sheep along the way. And then the police found the
- 35:39farmer or whatever, the guy with the sheep, and they asked him if
- 35:44he had seen anything, and that individual did in fact confirm Josh's story.
- 35:50So the conclusion is is that this claim might be true. More on this
- 35:55slater, but it might be true. Just toablished this on my thinking that
- 36:01it is possible that he did take the boys on a camping trip. The
- 36:07boys were interviewed, obviously, isn't that a fact though? Isn't it like
- 36:13was anyone disputing that he took the boys at midnight? Well, it's important
- 36:16to evaluate these claims because he could have done something else. He could have
- 36:22never gone camping and just went to a hotel room, or you know,
- 36:28there's a lot of other possibilities. I'm just establishing fact and likelihood. Another
- 36:34claim that he makes, the second one, is that he had left Susan
- 36:37sleeping at home, and so there's not much evidence of this, and there
- 36:40wouldn't necessarily be a lot of evidence of this right now. When they interviewed
- 36:45the older boy, Remember he's four, and if you've ever talked to a
- 36:50four year old, especially when you're asking them to remember something that happened while
- 36:54they were sleep walking their way to the car because dad was taking them somewhere,
- 37:00right, And more on that later. But Charlie told the police the
- 37:02older boy that Susan actually came with them. Of course she didn't, but
- 37:08it's hard to evaluate. You know, Charlie didn't say she was asleep and
- 37:14unconscious or she was wrapped up in a He just said, yeah, Mommy
- 37:17came with us. Now, that is in alignment with that claim from the
- 37:22neighbor that said that she heard the yelling at night. But we've already established
- 37:25that's not sound data, and it's impossible. When I've watched Charlie's interview and
- 37:32read a lot of the transcripts, it's like reading no stradamis the kinds of
- 37:37things that Charlie says, it's all over the board. And when you are
- 37:44anomaly hunting, you can see evidence that Charlie knows what happened to Susan and
- 37:50saw Susan being killed or something. But there's a lot of other statements that
- 37:53Charlie is making that is contrary to that. And there's also statements that Charlie
- 37:59is making that are clearly they can't be true, Like this isn't one of
- 38:01them. But there's things like yeah, and then the the unicorns came and
- 38:07the candy canes were there, Like he says things that are clearly him just
- 38:12making shit up. Yeah, So it's it's just hard to know, is
- 38:15my point. A lot of people on the Internet will hang a lot of
- 38:20certainty on what Charlie was saying, but it's just hurting it. So the
- 38:23conclusion about this claim that he left Susan sleeping at home is no fucking way.
- 38:29There's just no way more on that later. I mean, the only
- 38:31other thing, because I was thinking what had happened was that he had taken
- 38:35the boys before I knew all the timeline. I thought that he left with
- 38:38the boys when the when the lady first claimed that he left with the boys,
- 38:43because like that would have made more sense as an alibi. Right,
- 38:46he made sure she the neighbor whoever saw him leaving with the boys by himself,
- 38:52right, and that he didn't come back till much later by himself to
- 39:00get Susan right. And I was about to say, but that wouldn't be
- 39:05smart dot dot But there's a lot of things pointing at the dude, particularly
- 39:12bright when it comes to common SENSEX. But from the outside, the smarter
- 39:15move would have been to show the neighbor, we're going camping, right,
- 39:19but he was just going sledding. But anyway, So the third claim that
- 39:23we're going to evaluate is that Josh claimed that Susan had probably run off with
- 39:29another man. He's not saying it at this point, but later he would
- 39:32and Steven. This is their speculation. Even though she left her wallet,
- 39:38her id, her cell phone, the money in her bank account was untouched,
- 39:45the Bundy and her retirement count was untouched. And her children. Yeah,
- 39:52I mean, even a mediocre parent doesn't just abandon your children, right,
- 39:58So, but at the very least, even if you're like, well,
- 40:00she's an awful parent who leaves all of their money, she met a
- 40:05billionaire was off to Tahiti. Yeah, okay, so there's that. Now,
- 40:10let me talk about a theory that a lot of people are considering,
- 40:15which is there's another individual named Stephen Kocher. He disappears a week after Susan
- 40:22disappeared, and he was also a Mormon like the Powell family, and he
- 40:28lived in the same small town of Valley City. So people started wondering,
- 40:35you know, you know, with the Internet, sluice and everything, they
- 40:37start thinking, maybe Susan runs off with Stephen Kocher, Right, And when
- 40:43they get their hands on her diary years later, they see that Susan wrote
- 40:49in her diary about having a crush on a guy that she knew. Oh
- 40:53and also when you look at her emails, it looks like she is okay
- 41:00with flirting with other men. So you're wondering, Okay, maybe she ran
- 41:07off with someone. Maybe she even ran off with Stephen Coacher so berto if
- 41:13she had Yeah, even if she left all of her money and all of
- 41:16her stuff, maybe she does that to make it look like she was killed
- 41:21or something. What evidence would we likely find upon looking at her journal and
- 41:25reading her emails and looking at statements that wouldn't like, what would we likely
- 41:30find? You mean, the journals that she knew she had left behind for
- 41:35others to find, Yeah, after running away with someone that she didn't want
- 41:38anyone to know about. Okay, so never mind about that. But really,
- 41:44I mean, because even that, right, that's I mean, that's
- 41:45kind of the point. Is like, first of all, she would have
- 41:49taken her damn journal with her, But if she was really that odd thinking
- 41:54about the whole thing, then yeah, she would have certainly said, like,
- 41:58I'm thinking of leaving. Well, so let's say that she doesn't say
- 42:02that's something obviously, But what would be a typical trail of crumbs that someone
- 42:07would leave behind if they were planning on running away with someone and they did
- 42:12run away with someone, Like you'd find some entries about like it wouldn't have
- 42:15been just like I have a crush on someone. It's like I met them
- 42:20for coffee. Oh my gosh, I can't believe. I probably shouldn't have
- 42:22gone. But then well, okay, we ended up going to dinner.
- 42:27Now, like there's like any and if you questioned everyone around them, which
- 42:31the police and for the most part did, what might be some things that
- 42:37you might hear, you'd like, Well, I saw her at the cafe
- 42:39the other day with someone looked like not her husband, but or she said
- 42:46she had to leave early from work that day, but later I talked to
- 42:50Josh and she wasn't home till nine or what You would just find other odd
- 42:54little bits and pieces. Yeah, and that's typical. Usually there's a lot
- 42:59of bread crumbs, some odd charges on her credit card exactly, but the
- 43:04one she left behind, maybe even a previous affair that blew up in her
- 43:09face or something, you know, a pattern of affairs. Well, i'll
- 43:14give you the summary. There's none of that. Of course, there's no
- 43:19signs she was contemplating it. There's no evidence of an affair. There's no
- 43:22evidence that she ever had an affair, and there's lots of evidence that she
- 43:27was looking forward to things later that week on our schedule. Quick question,
- 43:31So because maybe we missed it. Maybe in small print next to the thing
- 43:36that said, if I go missing, it's probably murder, maybe next to
- 43:39that in small print that' said but I'm also having an affair. So it's
- 43:45possible, though, that someone could have picked her up that night. She
- 43:50could have called him like, oh he's gone, come get me, and
- 43:53she could have left everything behind to make it look like Josh killed her,
- 43:58to throw people off the trail, and maybe even to get revenge against Josh
- 44:01Right. And maybe the guy had a lot of money, as you were
- 44:04saying, and honestly, as I say this out loud, I hope this
- 44:08is true. Yeah, I guess, But sucks for the kids, but
- 44:13extremely unlikely. And I think in a lot of these cases, the individuals
- 44:17will show up soon after, you know, like the relationship will blow up,
- 44:22or they can't resist so seach out to their mom or something, you
- 44:27know, which part of like, all I care about is my children,
- 44:30Please take care of them. If my parents can't, then my sister,
- 44:34which part of that equates too. But I'm also leaving them and I don't
- 44:37really care what happens to the right. Plus, if you were really trying
- 44:40to implicate Josh, you wouldn't it wouldn't be hard to be more overt about
- 44:45it, right, Like you could have written something like he threatened to kill
- 44:51me, or he put a gun to my head or something. You know,
- 44:52there would just be more overt evidence. Now, if she's a mastermind,
- 44:57she would play it subtle. But claim is on Monday. This is
- 45:02the next day after the camping. Jennifer, which is the sister of the
- 45:07older sister of Josh. Jennifer and the cops called Josh many many times.
- 45:15You know, remember from a previous chapter that the daycare owner drives to the
- 45:20house because the boys did show up to the daycare and bangs on the door,
- 45:24no answer. The daycare owner calls Jennifer and the mom, Teresa,
- 45:30says what's going on? Jennifer and Teresa, they suspect immediately that it must
- 45:37be a carbon monoxide poisoning thing, which we were wondering why that would be
- 45:39the obvious go yeah, And then they call the police. And they called
- 45:46Josh many many times, obviously, and they call Susan, you know,
- 45:51both of their cell phones, and they demanded that he come home, but
- 45:57he didn't come home for a number of hours. He didn't come home until
- 46:00five pm. They were at you know, remember that, God, they're
- 46:05at the house right in the morning. When he arrived home, he told
- 46:08the cops that he didn't answer the phone because he turned his phone off to
- 46:13preserve the battery. But the cop looks over Josh's shoulder and sees there's a
- 46:19charger in the car. Right thoughts on this, Well, Hey, of
- 46:23course there's a charger in the car. He's going camping. He's got to
- 46:27have a cell phone. He's got to have a charger. Come on number
- 46:30one, number two. It's very very very very convenient, just so so
- 46:37so convenient that on the day that he forgot that it was Monday and he
- 46:43had taken the kids camping at midnight, and the wife was home and is
- 46:46now missing that it just happens to be on that day he also not taking
- 46:52calls. Yeah, but why would Josh say, I was trying to preserve
- 46:54the battery on my phone, even though behind him in the car is the
- 47:00arger. Is he forgetting the charger? Is there? What's going on?
- 47:02You think? Yeah, clearly it's not. This wasn't a well scripted part
- 47:07of the plan. You know, he's not going like okay, right,
- 47:10So when they ask me about my phone, I say that I turned it
- 47:16off and that's why I didn't bring my charger with you. No, no,
- 47:20that wasn't part of the plan. He's literally just flying by the seat
- 47:23of his pants. They're asking him, why didn't you pick up And the
- 47:27only thing that came to mind was, uh, I turned it off.
- 47:30Yeah. Yeah, he wasn't thinking two steps ahead at that point. Yeah.
- 47:34And I think this is why this case is still being explored by so
- 47:38many people on the internet like me today, is is he stupid or what
- 47:47was going on there? And the fact that he got away. You know,
- 47:51if he didn't get away with it, you'd be like, well,
- 47:52yeah, he's just a dumb criminal who he got away with it. But
- 47:57he gets away with it well because a lot of that stuff, having watched
- 48:01enough trials and things, a lot of that stuff is probably not that strong
- 48:07and you need to be You need to be what do you call it,
- 48:12the beyond a shadow of a doubt? Right, Like you have to have
- 48:15that sort not to charge somebody, no, not to charge someone he was
- 48:17never even charged. No, I know, but the prosecutors have to feel
- 48:21like they have a case that's beyond the shadow of a doubt, because's not
- 48:24going to convict No, no, no, I don't. I'm not illegally.
- 48:27They don't need to believe and I'll get more in this later. Prosecutor
- 48:30doesn't doesn't need to believe that right now, they have a case beyond a
- 48:35reasonable doubt. They need to believe they have enough justification to invade someone's rights.
- 48:40But they didn't feel that way. Because if we are using this as
- 48:45as an example, why didn't they charge him? That's weak sauce it to
- 48:50us. It looks completely guilty, and I think it is, but it's
- 48:53not. It's nothing. It's like, well, he said that he turned
- 48:58off his phone because he didn't want to waste a batter, but there was
- 49:00a charger in his car. Would be irrelevant in court. Yeah, So
- 49:05the conclusion on this claim is it's ridiculous on his face because the chargers is
- 49:10claimed that he was preserving the battery. That's ridiculous. And later I'll get
- 49:16into why I think he made this mistake, because he made a lot of
- 49:21mistakes and by the way, it's like, it's super cold out. I'm
- 49:24concerned about my battery dying in my car. I'm not plugging anything in right
- 49:29now. My phone's the least of my words. I'm turning that thing off.
- 49:31I just want to get home. It's cold. Do you see the
- 49:34storms? Like all these things are plausible deniability, not that he thought of
- 49:39them, but I'm just saying yeah. And I also think that him being
- 49:45super frugal, pathologically frugal, might have also harmed him, because another thing
- 49:51he could have done is just ditched his phone because he doesn't need it that
- 49:55day, right, it would be a viable excuse I lost my phone,
- 50:00but because he's so frugal, which I'll get into you later, And how
- 50:02do you explain so if I misunderstood, My understanding from what we discussed in
- 50:08a previous episode is that his wife's phone was also in his truck without a
- 50:14same card. Why would he keep the phone in the car? Yeah,
- 50:20again, it's it's been discussed and debated. Was it an oversight, was
- 50:28it a plan? And I'll get into more of that later regarding my theory,
- 50:32and also at the very end, I'll talk about his personality and how
- 50:37that might have come into play as well. So the fifth claim that Josh
- 50:40banks is that Josh claimed he was at work. So when he first gets
- 50:47on the phone, when they first get him on the phone's he says,
- 50:52I'm at work, what's going on? But when Jennifer confronts him and says,
- 51:00I don't know what she said, but I think it was something like
- 51:04we called your work and they said that you're not there, then he says,
- 51:08oh, yeah, I'm camping right now. So how do you explain
- 51:13that? I know? But that's another one of those like, well,
- 51:15look, I was embarrassed. I did skip out on work. I I
- 51:20lied, but you know, but but why would he do something that stupid,
- 51:25right, because he's not planning this very well, Like I think,
- 51:29over and over, we're gonna hit a wall where we want, we wanted
- 51:32to look like you really masterminded the heck out of this, and he did
- 51:35it. I'm not asking for mastermind. I'm I'm asking for just like mild
- 51:40mind, you know, just mildly put together. And I mean, but
- 51:45you could imagine again, I don't believe this for one second, but you
- 51:49could imagine's like like the Vaccini scene from A Princess Bride, like he thought
- 51:54one too many moves ahead, like like, okay, here's the deal.
- 51:59If someone is really innocent in this situation, Again, I don't believe this
- 52:01is the case. If someone's really innocent in the situation, they get called
- 52:05and asked where they are, but they but they know that they're not at
- 52:07work because in reality, of course, I know that it's Monday. I'm
- 52:10gonna lie, so I'm gonna say, oh yeah, at work, okay,
- 52:14And then when if they confront me, I'll say, okay, fine,
- 52:16I'm camping. That's my plan. Okay. I don't think that's what
- 52:20happened. I actually think he wasn't thinking these things. Yeah, yeah,
- 52:22okay. The sixth claim that I want to go over. The last one
- 52:27is Josh said that he thought it was Saturday and not Sunday, right right,
- 52:31And more on this later, but I think this is a long story
- 52:36short. These weird claims that he makes on Monday, I think are a
- 52:42result of him panicking. The claim that he wanted to preserve the battery in
- 52:47his phone, that he was at work, and that he thought it was
- 52:52Saturday and Sunday. I think that he was just panicking for some reason,
- 53:00the plan didn't go no right as planned. It seemed had a complete unforced
- 53:05error because no matter what, he could have still been home by by son
- 53:07up on Monday, right, Like, there's no reason why he had to
- 53:10actually not come home other than again, I feel like it's almost one of
- 53:15these like he's trying to figure out the moves. But he's like because he's
- 53:20like, all right, if I'm there in time to go to work,
- 53:22I'll just go to work. Okay, but what do I do with the
- 53:24kids? Oh? Right, like the kids, I would have to have
- 53:28a reason to drop them off somewhere else. Okay, that's a problem.
- 53:30But that just means he hadn't actually thought anything through, right because or he
- 53:36did have a somewhat viable plane and something through a wrench or I don't know.
- 53:42So, I mean, she'll show up Monday morning after the all night
- 53:45camping with the kids whatever, show up Monday morning, realize you're gonna be
- 53:50late to work. I'm like, I'm so sorry I was camping, Like,
- 53:52but I'm on my way there. But then you realize Susan's mysteriously not
- 53:55home. So you go to your neighbors, like have you seen sue,
- 54:00then what, well we are camping on that you saw leave? Right?
- 54:02And I why not that like you know, well the cops showed up at
- 54:07the house, because show up before that, right, because like, oh
- 54:10you have to, That's what I'm saying, is like earlier in the morning.
- 54:14Yeah, because because you're like because even because so sure, let's say
- 54:17he didn't anticipate the whole carbon monoxide thing whatever, he must have known people
- 54:22were still gonna call to find out where the how everyone was? That's unclear
- 54:27and that is a very good question. But given his disorder, Yeah,
- 54:32if it is narcissistic personal disorder, there's a chance that he just doesn't think
- 54:38outside of his own head. And he's been fired multiple times, so he
- 54:42doesn't really even have a good sense of what being at work on time might
- 54:45be. I don't know. And he also was largely uninvolved in the child's
- 54:50life the children's lives, and didn't really interact with the daycare owner very often.
- 54:57And if he had, then he might have no that the daycare owner
- 55:01wasn't just like it wasn't you know. I could imagine in his head he's
- 55:06thinking, well, the daycare, it's just like a warehouse full of kids
- 55:09with a bunch of adults that don't give a shit, and they're just phoning
- 55:13it in because that's the way he thinks, right, But anyone who works,
- 55:19especially with like because my mom and my sister have daycare daycares in their
- 55:23homes. My mom did have a daycare in her home. These daycare owners
- 55:28are like second mothers, yeah to these kids. They care deeply about the
- 55:35kids and would very quickly react if the kids didn't show up when they're supposed
- 55:39to, you know. So it's possible that Josh's disorder shot him in the
- 55:45foot. There are other claims that Josh makes, by the way, there
- 55:49are many many, but I just highlighted the sixth most important. But just
- 55:52a couple other runners up is he claimed that he just drove around all night
- 55:57long. He claimed that he washed the car that night, and he might
- 56:01actually have washed the car. But it's so hard to figure out when I
- 56:07start looking at all the data, and it really just shows that life is
- 56:10not like CSI. You know, when you actually are a police investigator looking
- 56:17into these cases, you're cobbling together like so much data and everyone is trying
- 56:24to remember and it's hard to confirm things. But it is the more you
- 56:30tell me about this, the more I am baffled that there wasn't a charge
- 56:35against them. Yeah, and I'll get into more of that later. The
- 56:38very brief summary that I'll say is that either none of us understand how the
- 56:44legal system works, which is possible the police have to go to the prosecutor
- 56:49just to ask, you know, the police can't charge Josh on their own.
- 56:53They have to go to their essentially their boss to see if it's okay
- 56:57to charge. The police really wanted to charge, and according to later interviews,
- 57:00which could be questionable, you know, twenty twenty, but it sounds
- 57:05believable. And according to the main investigator, he says that the prosecutor was
- 57:12resistant because the prosecutor believe there wasn't enough evidence at every step of the way.
- 57:16By the way, not just the first day, but the second day
- 57:20and the third day, you know, as the evidence mounted. According to
- 57:22the lead investigator, the police officer, he says, I don't understand why
- 57:28the prosecutor was so conservative about this, but that's what I was saying.
- 57:31It's like, look, since there's no body, right, there's no body,
- 57:37and motive is murky. At best, like they're a couple. They
- 57:40argued, I don't know. Oh, there was an insurance policy, but
- 57:45there's no body, so I don't know. So that's already two problems,
- 57:51right, no motive, no body. Yeah, and then you have lots
- 57:53of circumstantial stuff. Right. But to your point earlier, investigate, you
- 58:00know, like open up the books. Go Yeah, And it makes me
- 58:04wonder if the prosecutor got burnt recently where they could charge someone quickly and then
- 58:09the city got sued because they moved too fast, or the prosecutor got humiliated
- 58:17by jumping too soon. Yeah, because another thing to consider is that I
- 58:22believe the police are used to cases where the perpetrator will slip up or even
- 58:30just confess because they're stressed out. That happens a lot more than you might
- 58:35think. And they just thought, Okay, we don't have enough, you
- 58:37know, as you said, there's no body. We don't even know if
- 58:39she's dead. We don't even have a case she's dead. She could have
- 58:44ran away with someone. We just don't know, but he'll fuck it up,
- 58:47like with the Jody Arius case. Eventually someone stumbled upon the body of
- 58:53the child and it was close by stupidly right. They could have gone back
- 59:02whoever killed the child, Jody Arius seems like the likely candidate, and snatched
- 59:08up the body and disposed of it more permanently or farther away or something,
- 59:14And the typical situation is that just doesn't happen. So I think they were
- 59:19figuring eventually something will land in their laps and it just never did, you
- 59:23know what I mean? Okay, So what I want to do next is
- 59:29actually go line by line over the various different theories that are out there regarding
- 59:37what happened to Susan. And also I want to go over what his mindset
- 59:42might have been, because I think that's important to speculate about given the data,
- 59:46to point us in a direction of what he might have actually done.
- 59:52But I want this to be for the patrons of the podcast, because they're
- 59:55the ones who asked us to do this whole deep dive, and they're the
- 59:59one ones that literally pay my bills. So if you want to hear the
- 1:00:04rest of this chapter, along with all of our other deep dives, become
- 1:00:08a patron of the podcast by going to Patreon dot com. Otherwise, please
- 1:00:13take care of yourself because you deserve it.