Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Dr. Steven G. Rogelberg - Chancellor’s Professor at UNC Charlotte | The Science Behind 1:1’s
Transcript
- 0:00Today, my guest is Dr. Steven G. Rogelberg. He is a chancellor's professor at UNC Charlotte
- 0:06and a leading expert in organizational science, management and psychology. He boasts a distinguished
- 0:12career with over 150 publications addressing topics from team effectiveness to leadership.
- 0:18As editor of the Journal of Business and Psychology, he shapes scholarly discourse on the topic,
- 0:24recognized with awards like the 2017 Humboldt Award and the 2022 Raymond A. Katzel Award.
- 0:30He is renowned for his impactful contributions and commitment to the research that makes a
- 0:35difference in organizational behavior and psychology. He is also the author of the best-selling book,
- 0:40The Surprising Science of Meetings, which has been featured on various media outlets such as
- 0:44CBS this morning, NPR, BBC and Forbes, as well as his latest book, Glad We Met, The Art and
- 0:51Science of One-on-One Meetings. Dr. Rogelberg is a sought-after speaker and consultant who has
- 0:56worked with many Fortune 100 companies and served on multiple advisory boards. He's also a passionate
- 1:01advocate for community engagement and animal welfare and has been recognized as a top 40 changemaker
- 1:07by the Charlotte Business Journal. Welcome to Success Story. I'm your host, Scott Clary. The
- 1:13Success Story podcast is part of the HubSpot podcast network. Quick shout out to HubSpot
- 1:17before we get started. HubSpot has an incredible tool called Sales Hub. If you haven't checked it
- 1:23out now, you got to why? Well, you know what time it is. It is sweater weather, football season, Q4.
- 1:30This is the home stretch for your business. It is time to close out another year of growth,
- 1:37another year of business building strong and to prep for the next year of more revenue,
- 1:42more customers, more deals. To bring in more business, this Q4 and beyond, you need sales software
- 1:48that helps you score and top tools are all inside the new HubSpot Sales Hub. With the customizable
- 1:54prospecting workspace, smart deal management and AI-powered apps, you can take total control of
- 2:00your sales operation and manage your people and your pipeline with ease. They've built it and
- 2:05designed it all into an accelerated workflow baked right into your HubSpot CRM. And when you pair
- 2:11sales hub with other hubs like HubSpot Smart CRM, your team will be on the same page across the
- 2:16entire customer journey. Leads don't slip through the crack. Stop sticking to the same old
- 2:22strategies and start closing more deals because the best time to score is Q4. Make the switch to
- 2:27HubSpot Sales Hub at HubSpot.com slash sale.
- 2:42A bunch of people multitasking checked out a couple people just dominating or the leader
- 2:50dominating and by looking at their body language, you know that this is the last place that they
- 2:56want to be. You know, I was very interested when, you know, we first connected to discuss meetings
- 3:09because I think everybody has an opinion of them. And I don't know too many people that spend
- 3:15their whole life studying them. I think we just casually suck at them across the board.
- 3:22And I think that maybe a little bit more education and insight could be useful. So
- 3:29that scenario you just described, that sounds like every job that I've ever had and some of the
- 3:34meetings that I've held and some of the meetings that I've joined. So how did we get to the point
- 3:39where meetings that should be the most important integral part of a business because we have to,
- 3:46we have to function, we have to connect and share ideas and move forward. How did they turn into
- 3:50this time suck, time wasting, potentially not useful thing that we get roped into? And I see it
- 4:01because I've worked in Fortune 500 and I've worked in startup environments and it seems almost
- 4:06like the competitive advantage of a startup is less meetings move faster, break things, no red tape,
- 4:13no politics. But this all seems to in my mind come back to all those horrible meetings that large
- 4:21companies hold all the time that are totally unnecessary. Yeah. So it's a great question. There's a
- 4:29lot to that question. There's a lot of time talking about that. So let me take it a few different
- 4:37parts. I want to share with you a little history of meetings because I think you made a really
- 4:44important statement and I want to build on it. Then I want to tell you about the blind spots of
- 4:49leaders and the blind spots of organizations that are the causes or precipitators of this meeting
- 4:56crisis that we're in. So don't let me forget those pieces. But the history one, let me start there.
- 5:04You know, we forget that meetings are an evolution. They're an evolution over the old command and
- 5:11control systems of the industrial revolution where we didn't care about employee voice. We didn't
- 5:17think they had anything to offer. We thought the top leaders could just make the choices and
- 5:24everyone will line up and do it. We've evolved since then. We know that employee voice matters.
- 5:30We know that innovation, creativity can be spurred by more people in the room chatting, disagreeing,
- 5:38constructively. We know that meetings are an essential gathering activity to promote coordination,
- 5:46cooperation, consensus decision making. We know that when people are involved in decision making,
- 5:52they're much more vested in the outcomes. So absolutely, we need meetings. This idea of
- 5:58eliminating meetings just for the sake of eliminating meetings is a false goal. The real goal is to
- 6:03eliminate bad meetings and wasted time and meetings. And that can be achieved. I know we'll talk a lot
- 6:08about that. Now let me tell you about these blind spots. And so there's two sets of forces that
- 6:17I think are really intriguing. So the first set is a leader blind spot. If you survey people
- 6:22leaving a meeting, there's one person Scott who says this was a great meeting. You want to guess
- 6:27who that person was? I would assume the person who held the meeting. That's right. That's right.
- 6:32And why wouldn't they, right? They called the party. They invited all their friends. They're
- 6:37dominating it. So they think it's going well. And so they have this leader blind spot.
- 6:44This is highly problematic because if you think your meetings are good, you're not motivated
- 6:50to make any changes. In fact, you just assume bad meetings are everyone else's problem,
- 6:56not yours. That's the first key blind spot. But then there's organizational blind spots.
- 7:03It's really pretty amazing, A, that organizations, even small organizations,
- 7:11organizations do not assess the quality of their meetings on their engagement surveys.
- 7:17So here you have this work activity that people are spending a third of their time in.
- 7:23And yet there's no accountability. There's no feedback being provided to the organization
- 7:28of how these meetings are going. So that obviously perpetuates an organizational blind spot.
- 7:35Related to that is for some weird wacky reason organizations have decided that
- 7:43their people don't need training around meetings. In fact, the data suggests that only around 20
- 7:48to 25% of leaders ever received training on meetings. That is crazy, right? That is crazy.
- 7:56So no training, no feedback, no accountability, and this blind spot leads to us basically just
- 8:08recycling all the bad practices that we ourselves have experienced and thus we continue to
- 8:15wallow in bad meetings. So I'm very curious because you're you're you are an organizational
- 8:22psychologist. That's the that's the that's the term used to describe that the work you do.
- 8:27So you study organizations, you study companies, but I'm assuming you also can very easily understand
- 8:34how an individual acts in an organization and what causes them to do a certain thing.
- 8:39That's that's the premise of your work really. But I'm curious if bad meetings and bad corporate
- 8:46culture is is that something that is accidental or would you say that in some cases this horrible
- 8:55meeting culture is really just to make people feel busy and to make people feel like they're doing
- 9:02something and I again I'm equating it to these large companies where you can hide under the radar
- 9:08as long as you seem to have some activity. Not startup where if you aren't contributing
- 9:14everybody knows it. If the meetings aren't moving the needle, everybody knows it because you're
- 9:18not hitting your revenue milestones, you're not closing your next round. Do you see that often or is
- 9:23that just an edge case? So we actually have some research on that. I'm sure you do.
- 9:32And what we found and it's pretty horrible is that those employees who are low in something
- 9:41called accomplishment striving. These are people who tend not to be very goal oriented. For people
- 9:46like that, the more meetings, the better. They actually derive satisfaction. They feel better about
- 9:53their days and their jobs when they're having meetings. But this is for the people who aren't goal
- 9:58oriented. And to no surprise those people who aren't goal oriented, those are your worst performers.
- 10:05Not your best performance. Yeah. For those people who are goal oriented, high accomplishment
- 10:10striving, meetings have a take a toll and it drains them, fatigues them. And I think what a lot
- 10:19of organizations just don't realize is that the cost of bad meetings is not something they should
- 10:26ignore. It's not just the cost of doing business. It's highly problematic. You will lose your top
- 10:32talent, right? Top talent leaves organizations that have bad meetings. You will disengage your
- 10:38people. You will create tons of rework more meetings to resolve uncompleted, noncompleted meetings,
- 10:47uncompleted meetings. In fact, there was even a study done that looked at organizations that really
- 10:55do a great job in their meetings. And this is small as well as large. And what they found is that
- 11:00those organizations that do prioritize doing meetings well actually were making more money.
- 11:07They actually were more innovative. And so it just speaks to the effect that while we think about
- 11:14meetings as being places of drain and it can be, meetings done well are actually places of gain.
- 11:21Not just for people, but for teams and for the broader organization. And I think that you
- 11:27mentioned in most corporate cultures or a lot of corporate cultures, you walk into these horrible
- 11:33meeting scenarios where there's only one person that walks away. But you have been, anybody who's
- 11:37listening to this has been in these meetings where you do feel consensus and you do feel communication
- 11:43was clear and articulate. And action steps were very, very tangible. And you all walk away knowing
- 11:48exactly what you do. But you also everybody who's listening to this will also have those times when
- 11:52they all go to a meeting. And it seems like an hour of your life just like like gone. And nothing
- 11:59is clear. And I, I guess we don't all, we're not all low performers or people that aren't
- 12:06goal oriented. But we always, sometimes we fall into these traps. And I think it's maybe because
- 12:11we don't have the system sort of, you know, you know, as we fall to the level of our systems and
- 12:15to the level of our preparation. So, you know, we don't have these systems. We get tired, we get
- 12:19fatigued. And then we go into a meeting and we were, you know, we're well-meaning. But then
- 12:22nothing really gets communicated like it literally happened to me yesterday. We had a meeting on Monday
- 12:27that should have rectified a whole bunch of stuff. And then we had to, and then in the WhatsApp chat,
- 12:31we're talking about it. Nobody's clear on anything. We had another hour and a half yesterday. Like
- 12:35this is the, this, this drains people. And this is a tangible hourly cost attributed to that meeting.
- 12:42So let's talk about what, like what good is because we're going to go, we're going to go deep. We're
- 12:46going to talk about meetings. And then I know your latest book is focusing on one-on-ones. And we
- 12:51will go there as well. And why those are so important. And talk about how to do those properly.
- 12:56Because I think that's probably another level of new oncests required for a leader who doesn't
- 13:01even get trained on how to do a group meeting. How do you go into this one-on-one session? That's a
- 13:05whole other ballgame. But let's talk about this, like set the set to stage. What does good look like?
- 13:10If you're looking at all these different companies that you study and these different organizations,
- 13:15like I see in the news, you know, Shopify put a dollar counter on their meetings. That's interesting.
- 13:21I can hear the things like, I don't know if it's Amazon or Tesla with Musk, you can't have a meeting
- 13:27this more than, you know, the amount of people that could eat a pizza or whatever it is. Yeah,
- 13:32is that Amazon? Okay. So what is, what does good look like? Sure.
- 13:37Good is a meeting that where what is being discussed is highly relevant to everyone in that room.
- 13:47That the people who are invited were invited because they have a perspective on what's being
- 13:52talked about. Their voice matters. So they look at the content they go, I'm really glad I'm there.
- 13:57So that's obviously the key. So it's the right topic, the right people in the room, not bloated,
- 14:04not extra people, not nice to have, but keep it focused on the must-habs. Then the reader starts the
- 14:11meeting sharing a vision and set of hopes around the meeting. The meeting leader thanks people for
- 14:18attending and express his gratitude because when people give you their time, you should be grateful
- 14:23for it. So therefore it kind of starts in a more positive tone. Then the leader is actively
- 14:30facilitating. They're making sure they're not privileging their voice over everyone else's.
- 14:35In fact, they're trying to foster constructive conflict. We want disagreement of ideas.
- 14:41And they're focused on the most important items. In fact, they've structured the agenda so that
- 14:45the most important things happen first, not at the end. And so they're actively engaging. They've
- 14:51set the stage, they've created the norms. People are invested because it's all relevant to them,
- 14:57right? They're invested because the room isn't just stacked and stacked with other bodies.
- 15:03So they're dialed in. And then the meeting has a proper close. And this goes to your comment that
- 15:09you made about your meeting. A very common problem is that meetings don't have an ending. They just
- 15:15end. And the best practice is five minutes to go in the meeting. The leader stops and just says,
- 15:22OK, here's what we decided. Here's who the DRIs are, which is Apple Talk for directly
- 15:28responsible individual. Here's our outstanding issues. And this is how we'll pursue
- 15:34completion of those. Therefore, everyone goes saying, OK, this has been resolved. This has been
- 15:40resolved. This is still in progress. Great. Those points could then be communicated to all those
- 15:48nice to have people that we kept out of the meeting because we want to respect their time.
- 15:53So we're now keeping them in the loop effectively. So that gives you a sense of what a good meeting
- 15:59happen. What good meeting looks like. And when you have those, you're good. Like you're glad to be
- 16:07there. And so, you know, I almost go back to, let's say, professional American football, right?
- 16:16There's meetings all the time. I love the sports analogies. It bleeds over all the time too.
- 16:20Right. Every play on offense, there's a meeting. That team could not do their job if they didn't
- 16:27huddle and have a meeting. And quarterbacks received training on how to have those huddles to make
- 16:33that short amount of time really productive. And it can be. And so if you have a clear sense of
- 16:40purpose, you have the right people there. You're focused. You are dialed in, right? Because even
- 16:46at the end of the huddle, there's a proper conclusion, right? You have that proper conclusion. You have
- 16:52the play you're going to play. Yeah. And we execute. And that's more or less that is the proper
- 16:58meeting. That's the format. And it actually, you know, it's funny. It doesn't seem incredibly
- 17:03intricate and complicated. But it seems like it has lost on a lot of people. Is it? Is it?
- 17:10personalities of individuals that take over a meeting when there is no de facto system? Is that
- 17:16usually how? Yeah. Okay. It just becomes chaos. Yeah. And but I want to, I want to build on your first,
- 17:25your, your, your preamble to your questions. I think it's a really important thing you hit upon,
- 17:30which is there's a lack of intentionality when it comes to meetings. And we just invite people.
- 17:40In fact, we over invite people. And then we dial it in. We're an autopilot when it comes to meetings.
- 17:48But here's the really intriguing thing is that we're not an autopilot when we're meeting
- 17:54with stakeholders that really matter to us. When we meet with our boss's boss, when we meet with
- 18:00a key customer, we're very intentional. The thought of those people leaving the meeting saying it was
- 18:05a waste of time is so disconcerting to us that we make sure that the meeting is a good use of time.
- 18:11But when we meet with our directs and our peers, that same level of intentionality just goes away.
- 18:19And in my books, I talk about this notion of stewardship that the best meeting leaders recognize
- 18:24that inherently there are steward of others time. And when you embrace that notion, the thought of
- 18:30people leaving your experience saying that was a waste is so disconcerting to you that you will
- 18:36make sure it's not you. And amazingly, being a good steward can just take a couple of minutes of
- 18:42time with practice. And I want to make a connection to you. You are in the business of being a good
- 18:51steward. I'm thinking of it as you say it. Yes. You know, as a podcast host, very successful podcast,
- 18:59you are prepared. You think about it. You don't overthink it. As we were designing this, it's not
- 19:06like you created a script that we have to follow, but you thought about it. You thought about the story.
- 19:12You thought about how to involve me, where to tap into my expertise. You were intentional.
- 19:19And I was suspect, given your level of experience, it didn't take much time.
- 19:25But that few minutes of intentionality elevates the entire experience. And then we're done. We say,
- 19:32that was a satisfying meaningful experience. Yeah, that's very, very valid. And I think that that's
- 19:38but that's something. For myself, I had to learn that. I had to learn because I had those awkward
- 19:44podcasts at the beginning where I had, you know, you always think it goes worse than it does. You
- 19:50add those podcasts where you feel it, oh my goodness, that I just waste this person's time that I'm
- 19:54not prepping the right way. So it's like a painful experience. But you know, it's interesting.
- 20:00It's always, it's always these highly successful individuals that you that I have the, you know,
- 20:05the privilege of speaking with. And it makes you up your game quite quickly.
- 20:13You off your game very quickly. If you get, you know, I remember one of the first episodes that I
- 20:18did, it was not a bad episode, but I had Guy Kawasaki on. And that was probably one of the largest
- 20:25names, like a recognizable name that I knew coming into it. And it's just the amount of prep and
- 20:33stress. And, you know, you just want to make sure that you're not letting that guy down. I'm
- 20:40curious. And that's the attitude that I think we lose in business and in meetings. And like,
- 20:45you to your point, I love that you care about your boss's boss, you care about your investor,
- 20:50you care about the person that has control over your salary. But for some reason,
- 20:55not maliciously, but we just stop caring about for some reason, everyone else. And you know what,
- 21:01we're going to talk about one on one. But this is just my one, one on one lesson that I heard from one
- 21:07of my leaders at a young, when I was growing up and working in companies. And it's struck,
- 21:13it's stuck with me. And he was a really good guy. And he said, I was always in sales. And he
- 21:17said, we have one on ones to review your pipeline. But those are not true one on ones. Those are
- 21:22pipeline review. I will have a separate one on one with you weekly, biweekly to see how you're
- 21:27doing. Like, yes, exactly. Right. And this is something that's stuck with me as I built out teams,
- 21:33and I built out sales teams and other, other different teams and different parts of the company.
- 21:38But this is something that really stuck with me. It's not just metrics, which is important.
- 21:43There's intentionality to that interaction with that person. And connection and genuine connection.
- 21:50Right. Not just transactions. Yeah. And in today's world of work, especially for those of us who
- 21:58are working remotely, connection is still really important. Right. We think we might not need it,
- 22:05but humans need connection. And one on ones and excellent meetings are that those points of
- 22:12connection. But when executed poorly, it backfires. You know, a great little example is
- 22:20a leader calls together their team has a Zoom meeting, let's say, and then says, hey,
- 22:25how what did everyone do over the weekend? Let's go around. Everyone tell me what they did.
- 22:30Like, that's horrible connection. Yeah. Yeah.
- 22:33Eat it. Hate it. Um, but there's little interesting twists that actually are
- 22:40intense can be intentional and meaningful. For example, when I lead large team meetings virtually,
- 22:46when people come to the meeting, I actually throw everyone into a Zoom breakout
- 22:51above two people with the instruction. Just talk. And they do that for two minutes. That's it.
- 22:58Do they have trouble or real? Do they have trouble doing that? Do they have trouble?
- 23:03No, nope, because if it's just you and another person, you can't hide. Yeah. So that
- 23:09diet, diet is actually having a meaningful conversation of substance. And it's only two minutes.
- 23:16And then I bring people in, but every meeting, we kind of do that. And as a result, people are
- 23:21making that connection with other people. They generally put some into a better mood. It generally
- 23:26helps separate what they were doing before the meeting to the meeting, which is helpful.
- 23:32And so that is a small intentional act that I do. It doesn't take time much time.
- 23:40In fact, I say it saves time. And I think what a lot of leaders don't realize is that when you
- 23:44execute your meetings effectively, you really are saving time. It's just when we execute them
- 23:51ineffectively is that is where we're wasting time. Well, there's so many. This is what's so
- 23:56interesting. I'm very curious as to as to why you chose this as your expertise. And maybe
- 24:00go into a little bit of your background and how you how you ended up here. I was listening to
- 24:04some of the shows that you did before we jumped on and I was laughing when you did your last book
- 24:08launch. And you were like, well, it's about meetings. I didn't know I didn't know who was going to
- 24:12buy it. But then it turned into a best seller. I'm like, well, yeah, I think that it's we under
- 24:17index how important this is for businesses just for people because we all go through this really
- 24:21horrible experience with meetings more often than not. But where was I going? I want to know
- 24:27why you chose to get into this field. Why? Yeah, basically why? Why did you what did you go down
- 24:32this back? Because you're you're so you have been I I'm just going through some of your accolades.
- 24:37Like you have been doing this since 94. So what happened? What happened where you thought that
- 24:47like you even growing up? Did you want to go into psychology? Did you want to go into business?
- 24:53Did you want to fix people? Fix organizations? Where did that come from? Okay, so
- 25:02no, I was I just wanted to play sports and watch cartoons and eat junk food. That was
- 25:11good. My vision as a kid. And you know, it was basically in my junior year of college. My father
- 25:23said, Stephen, you need to come home and tell us what you're going to do when you graduate.
- 25:28And that's a horrifying question for me because I had no idea and I wasn't thinking about it.
- 25:32And so I was a pretty flaky student. I just didn't care all that much. So I didn't have very good
- 25:38grades in college, but I actually was getting my first A. And that class was organizational psych
- 25:45college. So when my father pressed me to say what I'm going to do, I'm like pan panic mode. I'm
- 25:52like, I'm going to be an organizational psychologist. That was it. That's so fun. And I don't regret
- 25:58the decision in any way, but there wasn't much thought that went into it. It was just a nice
- 26:04opportunity. And it's been a great field. You know, the thing that I like about it, and this is
- 26:09how it connects to meetings, is it's about gathering evidence to address practical issues, right?
- 26:17It's about leveraging science to do good for organizations and people. For me personally,
- 26:24my motivation is purely around pain and that people experiencing pain and discomfort at work,
- 26:34to me is just very worrisome. So probably the first feeling I had that motivated me to jump
- 26:42into this research was this notion that people are having days at work filled with meetings and
- 26:48yet they come home saying that was a wasted a waste of a day. And that's their life. That's
- 26:53their life. And that word means so much that I just wanted to see if we could start leveraging
- 26:59science to figure out how to solve that problem. And clearly it's resonated, right? So the story
- 27:05you mentioned, you know, when my first book came out, yeah, I didn't know. I mean, is a book about
- 27:12meetings. Science was in the title. And I was amazed, you know, when Washington Post
- 27:18named the number one leadership book. And I'm like, oh my gosh, there actually might be an appetite
- 27:24out there for the science around meetings and making them better. And to my complete surprise,
- 27:32I started doing this media, right? I was on CVS this morning and CNN and all these. And each time
- 27:38I pinched myself, because here I am, you know, I love talking about this stuff, but I pinched myself
- 27:42going, wow, my 15 minutes of fame is continuing. And it hasn't stopped. You know, I get contacted by
- 27:51organizations and the media, you know, weekly to do events and to provide more insights about
- 27:58the science. You brought up shopify. I've been on, you know, as you know, CNN a number of times
- 28:04sharing my perspective on that. And it's fabulous. You know, the beauty of being a meeting scientist
- 28:12is that because meetings are just so bad, doing 20% of what I say will actually have huge gains.
- 28:23Yeah. So it's, it's really fun to be able to talk about is, is organizational psychology a
- 28:28newer field? Um, like I'm thinking, okay, so yeah, let me, let me frame the question. Um, obviously
- 28:37when you get to the level of an Amazon, they have people that optimize everything. And I want,
- 28:42and we'll talk about some of the tricks and tips to optimize, but that you learn at that level.
- 28:47But I've worked in startups, I've worked with startups. I don't see people. Some great founders,
- 28:54probably the successful ones look into it, but I see a lot of people that don't look into this.
- 28:57Don't figure out how to optimize their meeting companies in the 10 to 20 to 30 to 50 million
- 29:03dollar range that don't train anybody on me. So I think it's more common than not to have horrible
- 29:08meetings and to probably not include other organizational psychology insights into your company.
- 29:14So I'm curious if it's new, if it's ignored, if it's something that people don't quite understand,
- 29:19the concept of until then you write a book about it, very tangible, very tactical. What do you think?
- 29:27So the field is, I mean, it's around 100 years old. So it's not new. In fact, I think it was
- 29:34around three years ago, it was identified as the number one fastest growing profession.
- 29:41So the number of graduate programs is just increasing incredibly. So I think the word is out.
- 29:48And I think organizations are more and more realizing that having an organizational
- 29:53psychologist on staff or as a consultant is an incredible opportunity to make sure you're
- 29:58getting the most out of your talent and not hemorrhaging your key talent and building teens and
- 30:04building leaders. So yeah, there's momentum. Obviously, there's a little bit of a war on science
- 30:13these days, but we're not seeing it in the organizational work arena. I think it actually
- 30:21provides great clarity. When I think about the success of my past book and I think what's been
- 30:27appealing about my new book coming out, it is because it just says, here's a set of practices
- 30:33that here's the data. It's new ways of thinking about things, try it, try new experiments. And the
- 30:41beauty of our science is that it's customizable. So like, especially in the one-on-one book,
- 30:50the glad we met, the art and science of one-on-one meetings, I threw in the word art and science of
- 30:55one of meetings very intentionally because the science, in all cases, it definitely provides insights
- 31:02but we still have to make it fit for you and make it fit for your situation. So what's unique about
- 31:08my content, I think, is I don't take the similar tack of meeting suck, meetings suck, hate meetings,
- 31:16meetings hell. Instead, I say, you know, these things are really important. They can be potentially
- 31:21transformative. Here's a menu of choices. Go through this menu. It's founded in science and make
- 31:31choices that fit who you are. But that notion of making choices is where we need people to evolve to.
- 31:40And another good example is setting meeting times, right? So most meetings are an hour. Why do you
- 31:47think that is? Because somebody has that in their calendar. Exactly. That's the most
- 31:54uninspired reason to have a meeting that's an hour, especially given something called Parkinson's
- 32:00Law. And Parkinson's Law is the idea that work expands to fill whatever time is allotted to it.
- 32:05So if a meeting is scheduled for an hour, magically it will take one hour. But we can actually use
- 32:11Parkinson's Law to our advantage. If we schedule our meeting for 42 minutes, 25 minutes,
- 32:18we will get it done. Going back to our football analogy, there's a tight clock on those huddles.
- 32:26They can't run over. No, they have their time. That's it. And they get it done. Yeah.
- 32:31Actually, you know what? Just a nod to your understanding of how to influence people with data.
- 32:39I think that the way that you structure your arguments and the way that you write your books,
- 32:44I think it's actually very, it's a very important way to communicate data and facts,
- 32:50because when you give people autonomy to sort of choose how to implement into the organization,
- 32:56I think that's probably why your message is so successful. Because you show people, like listen,
- 33:01this is the facts. We're going to tailor it to your circumstance. And I think that, you know,
- 33:06people are so funny. You mentioned there's a war on science. People always push back when they
- 33:10feel like they don't have a choice. And this is where dogma extends far beyond this conversation.
- 33:16And we won't go there. But the point is, people always need to feel like they have autonomy in
- 33:22their decision making. And, you know, in business, it's no different. So I think the way you
- 33:26communicate is probably why you're so successful at what you do. And it's very kind of you. And
- 33:32I appreciate it. And I sucked at it in the beginning. But I work really hard.
- 33:37Well, you know why it's because you know, you know, you know, you know, and you just want to like
- 33:41shape them. And why don't you get it? But yeah, I digress. You can't do that. So you just say,
- 33:48I'll also, I'll also add, it's tied to even how you started your interview with me offline. When you
- 33:54told me, assume our listeners are really smart. Yeah. That's what I assume. When I write,
- 34:00you know, when I write, I assume that people are looking for the facts, looking for evidence.
- 34:07And that when presented with choices, you know, they can make good, reasonable choices.
- 34:13Doesn't mean they won't make mistakes. But mistakes don't bother me, right? I mean,
- 34:17mistakes are just the opportunity to learn. Yeah. And without mistakes, it'd be a really boring
- 34:22world. Of course. And so it's just helping people think about a common problem differently.
- 34:28Which again, was why I was so excited about the one-on-one meeting. I know we'll talk about that
- 34:32later because there was nothing on that. Like you go, you know, when I wrote my first book,
- 34:38you know, surprising science and meetings, there was a lot of traffic in that space, you know,
- 34:43which is why I didn't necessarily think it was going to get the traction and it did. But when you
- 34:47look at the one-on-one meeting space, there's no traffic. It's wide open. And yet there's around
- 34:56200 plus million of these things a day around the globe. And so that's a lot. That's in the
- 35:03use. I'm really hoping that, you know, the one-on-one content can truly take organizations to a whole
- 35:09new level. But I know we'll hit that way. Yeah. We can go into that pretty soon. I just have one more
- 35:15question because it's the one thing that you were asked to probably go on CNN or Fox Business or MSNBC
- 35:22to speak about that thing that Shopify did. I thought was very interesting. What is your
- 35:27opinion on that? Is that positive? Is that potentially encouraging the wrong behavior, the right
- 35:33behavior? What do you think? And we can describe what it is. It's basically like, maybe you can
- 35:39describe it because I don't want to misspeak. Yeah. I mean, in the simplest, when it first came
- 35:46out, there's really basically a ban on meetings that everyone was asked to remove all meetings from
- 35:51their calendar of three and more people for at least, I think it was a couple of weeks or so.
- 35:56And so it was this massive just cleaning the slate and elimination of meetings and putting a
- 36:03lot of pressure on people not to have meetings anymore. And so I don't know where they're at right
- 36:13now. You know, I talked to some Shopify folks and they appreciate the efforts, but they, I mean,
- 36:23I've heard people meeting in secret. Oh, that's really what that's the ridiculous thing.
- 36:27Another calendar. That's so ridiculous. So my issue with Shopify was, so first of all, I was
- 36:36really appreciative that they're an organization that wanted to try to do something about the meeting
- 36:42issue. So really kudos to them. I think that's fabulous that they made this a priority.
- 36:50But this idea of just eliminating meetings is like trying to get healthy and saying, okay,
- 36:58I'm no longer going to eat any processed food and sugar. You could say that, but that's a diet
- 37:06that's going to be hard to maintain. We know from health that the best thing you can do to become
- 37:12healthy is to take a system's perspective, right? To start engaging in better healthy and lifestyle
- 37:19choices. It's not just about depriving yourself of something. And that usually when people just
- 37:25deprive themselves of something, they're just drawn to it even more. So what I think, if an, you know,
- 37:34what Spotify should have done is not take such a strong top down perspective. Every function
- 37:41in an organization has different meeting needs, right? Those in marketing are going to have
- 37:47different needs from those in sales, from those in IT. So this idea of saying that this is the
- 37:54corporate policy, everyone needs to just doesn't make sense. You could really hurt certain functions.
- 37:59So what I would have done if I was doing Shopify and I wanted to get my meeting number under control
- 38:04is I'd actually do a bottoms up process, not a top down process. I would charge each of my managers
- 38:10to meet with their teams, do an audit, start talking about meetings and what can be eliminated,
- 38:16what can be short and what can be shrunk, and let each team take this challenge because meetings
- 38:23are a collective experience. So I love the idea of taking all this incredible negative energy around
- 38:29meetings and harvesting it for good. And people are prime. So some of my engagements I do with
- 38:34the organizations, I do that activity. And people are fantastic. They are so hungry for it. I can't
- 38:41get them to stop, but they're able to re-engineer their meetings, shorten meetings, fix meetings.
- 38:47So I like this bottoms up approach. But at the same time, I like when an organization
- 38:54also A, make sure that they've leveled up people's skills. So go to the training thing we talked
- 39:01about earlier. B, that they make sure that their engagement surveys include content around meetings
- 39:06because we need to create that feedback loop. C, that they've assigned someone on their leadership
- 39:11team ownership of meetings. We need someone to own it. Meetings are bigger investment than IT.
- 39:20Bigger. And yet we couldn't imagine not having someone own IT for an organization.
- 39:25Of course. Someone needs to own meetings as a critical work process where they say,
- 39:29yep, I'm going to monitor. I'm going to make sure we have a good return on investment.
- 39:33So that's that's the C. And then there's a host of other, you know, interesting practices,
- 39:38you know, that can be done to change that ecosystem. But so what I advocate for is taking a systemic
- 39:46approach to changing meeting culture so that you get the positives without the negatives.
- 39:52I felt like Shopify's approach was just about demonizing meetings. And as a result,
- 39:58it could have some unintended consequences. So I love their passion, but I would have chosen
- 40:03approach. I think that mitigated some of those unintended consequences. I'm just going to take
- 40:07a quick break. Thank the longtime friend and sponsor of the show, the HubSpot podcast network.
- 40:11They have incredible podcasts. One of my favorites, one that you have to check out this month
- 40:15is Nudge hosted by Phil Agnew. Now, if you've ever noticed, the smallest changes always seem
- 40:21to have the biggest impact on Nudge. You learn simple evidence back tips to help you kick
- 40:27bad habits, get a raise, grow a business. The point is every bite size 20-minute show comes packed
- 40:33with practical advice from these incredible entrepreneurs, behavioral scientists, and everybody
- 40:39in between. Nudge is fast paced, but very insightful and a must listen if you're a podcast fan.
- 40:45Make sure you listen to Nudge wherever you love to get your podcasts. So let's talk about,
- 40:50let's talk about and thank you, but let's talk about one on ones because I want to give a significant
- 40:54amount of time to that. So one on ones in my back, in my experience, it's always been, again,
- 41:03that one example that I gave you was like the best possible one-on-one experience that I've
- 41:08ever had in any job that I've held. Outside of that, because my background's in sales, it was
- 41:16either for pipeline or for quarterly or annual or semi-annual performance review, and that was
- 41:23like the only one-on-one instance. And I think that also, I've seen that in other departments where
- 41:28it's just performance review is the only one-on-one engagement that somebody would have.
- 41:35Is that correct? Is that incorrect? Do organizations use one-on-ones differently? Do organizations
- 41:40not use one-on-ones at all? It may be, give me a rundown of all the different things you see,
- 41:45what's common practice, what's not. It's all over the board. It's all over the board,
- 41:52but I'll tell you this. It's not all over the board when it comes to our best leaders.
- 41:59They absolutely leverage one-on-ones. They recognize that one-on-ones are the display stage
- 42:06for their leadership. In many regards, this where leadership happens. So when you look at the less
- 42:11effective leaders, yeah, I mean, they're not having them, or if they do have them, they're just
- 42:18treating as a micromanaging session. They're just getting up all in the grill of the employee,
- 42:25but the best managers aren't like your example. The best managers recognize that they're orchestrating
- 42:33the meeting, but the meeting's not for them. The meetings for their direct. The best managers
- 42:39realize that this is an investment, and it's an investment that pays dividends. In fact,
- 42:45when I was thinking about a title for the new book, the glad we met, and I was talking to Adam
- 42:53Grant, who's another organizational psychologist, and we're brainstorming top titles. The alternative
- 43:00title, which we didn't use, but I was really tempted to use, but it didn't really fit my brand
- 43:05very well, is basically the one meeting that shouldn't be an email. I like that, which I don't hate that.
- 43:12I don't hate it either, but I generally take a positive spin on all these things, so I don't
- 43:17think it fit as well, but I think that sentiment is perfect. It is the one meeting that should not
- 43:24be an email. It is about connection. It's about me learning what's on your mind and how I can best
- 43:32support you. And the fact is, each of these meetings winds up saving me time, because now by
- 43:41dedicating this time to you, I'm addressing your issues, we're actually eliminating a lot of
- 43:45spontaneous encounters, because I'm giving you what you need. In fact, you often will save your
- 43:50issues for these one-on-ones. So there turns out there's less interruptions. So not only
- 43:57are we giving time to the manager, because we are, we're elevating you as the team member, the
- 44:04direct, because you're getting what you need. You're feeling heard, right? You're feeling elevated.
- 44:09You're feeling supported. You're feeling aligned. But the twist is that it's
- 44:16positively affecting the leader's performance. Leaders are judged by the success or lack thereof
- 44:24of their directs. So the better your directs do, the better you are as a leader. So these one-on-ones
- 44:32hit all those elements. But similar to what we talked about earlier,
- 44:38that blind spot I mentioned still exists. And that we have seen in the work that leaders think
- 44:47their one-on-ones are better than the team members. The team members often leave the one-on-one
- 44:53not feeling satisfied. And I'll share one little finding and then I'll pause and let you do your
- 44:59one-on-one. I have a lot to. I know. It's such a great topic. There's so much here.
- 45:07The best predictor of one-on-one success is the direct doing the majority of the talking.
- 45:17Therefore, the best predictor of the ineffectiveness is the leader doing the majority of the talking.
- 45:23I think that's really telling. And it could apply to your world, right? If you have a podcast
- 45:29and you were talking more than your guest, you probably wouldn't have this fantastic audience
- 45:34that you have. No, that would be a big issue. I've seen podcasts or it's like that, but
- 45:40yeah, I've been on podcasts like that. Oh my goodness. That's so funny. Okay, so in this one-on-one
- 45:47interaction, somebody who's listening to this, they understand that we have to have them.
- 45:54I want to pull out. It's like a mini therapy session to a degree. How would you best describe
- 46:03the end result, the best possible end result, outside of just the person speaking more than you?
- 46:08I'm the leader. You're the direct. You're coming in. I want you to be speaking, telling me all your
- 46:12worries and your problems. But I'm trying to tie this back to like, okay, where does this go in
- 46:17terms of business context? I'm talking about their girlfriend, their boyfriend, their spouse,
- 46:22their dog that had to be taken to the vet. Am I talking about the fact that I don't know,
- 46:30they're not performing at work. They're stressed. Is it everything outside of work and inside?
- 46:36It's mostly inside of work. It can touch upon outside of work, depending on your relationship
- 46:42with the person, because clearly what's happening outside of work typically gets brought into work.
- 46:49So it could be some of that. But in general, it's work-related topics tied into the direct reports,
- 46:57well-being, motivation, productivity, priorities, clarity of assignments, alignment,
- 47:03but also bigger, longer horizon, their career development, their sense of place in the organization.
- 47:10So it's about the day-to-day experience, but also the longer horizon experience.
- 47:18If I had to sum it up and I love this expression, you hear this. You're seeing it a lot more on
- 47:23television these days. This notion of seeing someone. I see you. One of them ones are your way
- 47:29of seeing someone. The one-on-one is the opportunity to have that connection where the direct says,
- 47:36okay, here's what's going on. Here's why I need some help. The leader through excellent questioning
- 47:46and excellent listening is really able to fully engage and be present in those moments.
- 47:53The desired state is not the leader feeling happy at the end of the meeting. It's not necessarily
- 47:58even the direct feeling happy, but the direct feeling heard and seen and supported and appreciated,
- 48:07and those things can happen even if you have to deliver some negative feedback. Because when
- 48:11it's done well, that actually can elevate a relationship too. So the one-on-ones are just
- 48:19the high-touch mechanism for truly enabling and supporting and elevating your team.
- 48:32What would be your recommendation to create a psychologically safe environment that allows the
- 48:39person, the direct, to feel comfortable speaking about some of this stuff? Like their career
- 48:45aspect. So I love this and I love that bringing this up because I'm a big believer in
- 48:51helping somebody get to where they need to be inside or outside of the company that I'm working in,
- 48:56but it's a lot for somebody to take in. If I was hired by an individual, I'm very apprehensive
- 49:04about being honest about where I want to go. Yep. So first of all, it really is how we roll this out
- 49:11or reboot our efforts. What I advocate for in the book is tying this initiative to organizational
- 49:21values and your own personal values. You know, people don't like flavor of the month initiatives.
- 49:28We're very cynical. But if you actually look at your organizational values and scan your personal
- 49:33values, one-on-ones actually align perfectly with it. You typically see people's personal values
- 49:43are helping others, caring. One-on-ones are that mechanism. So when you communicate this thing,
- 49:51tie it to these broader values, then frame it. Frame it such that people know that you're doing
- 49:59this not to micromanage. You're doing this so that you can be the best manager to them that
- 50:05you possibly can be. So set the stage, set why you're doing it, tell them that every few months,
- 50:13you'll collect some evaluation data from them just to see if it's working for them.
- 50:19Also, when you have these meetings, start them well. Start them with positive energy, connect
- 50:26to some past one-on-one so they see you're actually listening and making connections.
- 50:32Be appropriately vulnerable. If you want someone to disclose to you, look for opportunities
- 50:38to disclose to them. We know from the research that the days of leaders coming across like they
- 50:45have no problems are done. We know we're all humans. We all have problems. We could be making
- 50:54$10 million a year or $10,000 a year. We all have problems. And when we're appropriately vulnerable
- 51:03to people, it just opens the door. And then as soon as someone does share, now the pressure is on
- 51:10you to honor that sharing. Listen, appreciate, empathize, reinforce. So we can start to build the
- 51:18psychological safety in these one-on-ones over time. And it doesn't take much time. But we do need
- 51:25to do it. And when people see that you are committed to them, that the agenda of the one-on-one is
- 51:32their agenda, they'll start truly enjoying these things. And we have a little theme here. I make
- 51:40a comment and then I share some research. So let me tell you. So I did in one of my studies,
- 51:48and I talk about this in the book because I think it's a kick is that I ask people would they want
- 51:54more one-on-ones with their bosses, less one-on-ones with their bosses. And I assumed that people would want
- 52:02less one-on-ones with their bosses, basically if their days are just filled with meetings. They're like,
- 52:08I can't do another meeting. I can't do another meeting. I need less of these. I need to get this
- 52:13under control. But we actually found that when a leader does these one-on-ones, well, no matter
- 52:21how busy the person is, they want more. Really? And I love that. People want real human connection
- 52:29in their work. They want real human connection. And all right, here's a bonus research insight.
- 52:34And I think this one is such a kick. When we started to ask people what's their desired
- 52:39cadences for how many of these happened, we assumed that the most junior people would be like,
- 52:46I need these as much as possible. I'm new. I need this weekly. What we found was the opposite.
- 52:53The more senior you are, the more you want these. Right? Because you know at that point that
- 53:02really effective one-on-ones elevate you, make you more successful. And that contact with your leader
- 53:09is so critical. So they wanted absolutely weekly one-on-ones. But interestingly, most senior
- 53:16employees don't get weekly one-on-ones. Often the cadence is slower.
- 53:20What is the, like, so you would say ideal is one-on-one. That's what the employee wants. That's
- 53:26what the leader wants. And the goal is also, there's a lot of pieces that will allow this to come
- 53:32together properly. So you shouldn't be overloading your leaders with too many direct reports that they
- 53:36can't do this. That's very important as well. I mean, the leader also has to be open to
- 53:43the concept of being vulnerable and making something not about them, not purely not, I don't
- 53:50want to say it's not about performance. But it's all these adjacent factors that will lead to
- 53:55performance. So it's like you're looking, you're actually one-on-one in the leading indicator,
- 53:59not the lagging indicator basically. Yes. Yes. I mean, it's investment. Yeah. It's all it is.
- 54:07You're just investing in your people. But it's one of those, one of the few investments that you
- 54:14will get a tremendous return on. And if you keep your top talent, they don't leave. That saves you
- 54:19huge amounts of time. If people are more aligned, it saves you huge amounts of time. So it actually
- 54:25is an investment that you get that return on. So to go back to the first part of your question,
- 54:34the research generally supports weekly or every other week. Cadence says, those were the best.
- 54:41And I best is being defined as the employee feels much more engaged. They feel that they can
- 54:49be much more productive and aligned having those regular points of contact. Those can be 30 minutes
- 54:55or 25 minutes. Easy. Then you could have some other fillers in between. So some leaders do some
- 55:01async. So they track like basically their one-on-one notes are put into a Google Doc and then people can
- 55:06provide async updates. And they can ask questions and the leader can respond. Beautiful. Love it.
- 55:13Once you start going beyond two weeks, you get these massive recency effects. So if you and I
- 55:19are doing our one-on-ones once a month, the things that we will talk about are basically the things
- 55:25that just happened the last week. And that lack of full expression limits. So there's a
- 55:36recency bias in the media. And there's just no momentum that builds. So a monthly one-on-one is
- 55:44still better than no one-on-ones. But basically, the gains associated with that weekly or biweekly
- 55:49are just so much higher. And it just starts to decrease when you have monthly. It's still better
- 55:54than zero. But we just don't have the same utility. So I would much rather have people do the weekly
- 56:02or the biweekly for less time than saving to the monthly with more time. And I'm just now just
- 56:12thinking about all these edge cases, or not edge cases, or just like different things that could
- 56:16impact this. Zoom versus in person, I would assume in person. Well, we collect a date on that.
- 56:24I'm sure you did. That's fine. So I have a chapter in the book that talks about where to have
- 56:30these one-on-one is. Because it's kind of interesting. And so the place that we found was the
- 56:37least desirable was the directs office. Oh, interesting. That was kind of neat. Yeah.
- 56:43Most desirable was actually the manager's office or a conference room. Then there was this
- 56:50almost a bimodal where half loved the idea of meeting off-site or taking a walk. And the other
- 56:58half hated that idea. So, you know, where you come with this is that because this is a meeting
- 57:05orchestrated by you before the direct, you just ask them, you know, where do you want to have these
- 57:09things? Happy to do it anywhere that would be helpful to you. That's a nice message, right? And
- 57:15that kind of reinforces. Now, as it relates to virtual, there was a slight preference for face to
- 57:21face over virtual, but it wasn't huge. You know, people generally found the virtual worked for them.
- 57:30But early on, when they didn't really know the manager as well, they just felt there was
- 57:35a little bit of a missed opportunity. And they didn't feel as comfortable disclosing. Now,
- 57:40interestingly though, the walking meeting is really one of the best choices if everyone's
- 57:47game for it. What the research shows is that when two humans walk next to each other,
- 57:53they're actually much more comfortable sharing. There's just something about not staring at
- 57:59that person. There's something about being in a different setting, you know, ideally, you know,
- 58:03nature. That seems to evoke greater safety, greater willingness to share, and more creativity,
- 58:11by the way. So I think that's part of this intentionality equation. And so while I just shared
- 58:19the science, I just want the manager to decide, you know, talk to the people and figure it out,
- 58:25and use it as the opportunity to keep convincing them that this is their meeting.
- 58:30What about some other behaviors that I've seen that I think are in my personal opinion,
- 58:37they're not great, but it seems to be things that people do to do instead of a strong one-on-one
- 58:45designated time. So I'm seeing managers texting back and forth async, sending five-minute long
- 58:51voice notes, having super casual conversations on WhatsApp. What are these things play into?
- 58:57Again, it's all about leader-direct relationship. Are these things damaging? Can they help a degree
- 59:04at all? I appreciate that leaders recognize that there's lots of different ways of communicating with
- 59:12their people, and they can leverage so many different techniques. But those types of communications
- 59:19by the very nature just tend to be very tactical, right? They're just about moving the ball down the
- 59:28field. They just lack the substance. Oh, sorry, you're good. My dog has saw another dog outside and
- 59:37is going bonkers. No, you're fine. And she's a tiny little pug, but they always are.
- 59:43She thinks there's no dog that she couldn't defeat in a fight, and she needs them all to know that
- 59:48she is the toughest dog in the neighborhood. Listen, you're hopefully safe at home if somebody
- 59:53tries to break in. At least, at least she'll sound vicious. That's all the matter. She will stay
- 59:57ambitious. So basically, those other forms of communication can complement the one-on-one,
- 1:00:07but they don't replace it. And I put in the book, this quiz basically that says, okay, if you're
- 1:00:16doing this, this, and this, and this, do you still need to do one-on-ones? And I go through it,
- 1:00:21so you're, you see the person casually. Your door is always open. You text them, but it's a
- 1:00:30fake quiz, because anytime that you, if you say, no, I don't need to meet with the one-on-one,
- 1:00:37you're wrong. Because one-on-ones are different. One-on-ones are about that genuine connection,
- 1:00:44and helping someone to feel truly seen at home. No, I think that I believe that what happens is
- 1:00:53people always look for shortcuts and hacks and everything they do. And unfortunately, communicating
- 1:00:59with people is no different. I mean, that's why people send voice notes even instead of sending
- 1:01:05attacks or an email. It's just trying to hack it, basically, and expedite it. And again,
- 1:01:13I mean, that can work, but if you're truly trying to build a relationship,
- 1:01:21you're truly trying to help someone, you need more than that. And I just can't emphasize enough
- 1:01:29that while we could, you know, maybe a listener can come away saying, oh, you know what? I don't
- 1:01:35want to cuddle my people. You know, I don't want to spend the time. They know what to do.
- 1:01:41But the fact is, these one-on-ones truly, truly help you as a leader too.
- 1:01:47And I mean, it's just like that often gets lost on leaders. This makes you better.
- 1:01:54And think about how much time it takes to replace your good talent. This makes you time.
- 1:02:02So it makes you better. It makes you time. In fact, there's even some research that was where
- 1:02:07employees were surveyed saying, how do one-on-ones affect their team performance? The vast majority
- 1:02:12said it improved team performance. Well, they feel, okay, so if somebody feels
- 1:02:18seen and listened to and cared about an organization, they're not, it's not like they're
- 1:02:23not going to eventually move on to something else. Everybody has their own career objectives,
- 1:02:27but a couple things. You're going to know what those career objectives are because you're
- 1:02:32speaking to them all the time and you're okay with at some point in their career moving to another
- 1:02:36company. If that's what they want, you're not going to stop them, but at least you can know
- 1:02:40when it's happening and you can help them get there. And one of my favorite things as a leader
- 1:02:44is to make like a verbal contract with somebody like, listen, we're going to work together for
- 1:02:49two years. And then after that two-year period, I'm going to help you get to where you want to go,
- 1:02:53but give me like two of your best years basically. But you know what's going on. Yeah.
- 1:02:59And I love that by the way. And so often employees leave just because they don't think they have
- 1:03:07a future. And they're in their own heads. So these conversations, once you hear it,
- 1:03:15there might be paths that the employee didn't think about at all, right? We have people who leave us
- 1:03:23who were surprised, right? Where we say, if you just would have told me, we could have figured
- 1:03:28something out. Yeah. And the employees say, you never asked. And the fact is, is that the one
- 1:03:36of ones provide that mechanism to keep figuring it out and exploring new opportunities. And that's
- 1:03:45exciting. That's why I go back to how we started that some leader could listen to this podcast
- 1:03:54and say, oh yeah, okay. So one of ones are an option for me. No, they're not an option. It's a
- 1:04:02requirement. If you're not doing them, you need to start. If you are doing them, you need to make
- 1:04:08sure that you're doing them well. Otherwise, you're not reaping the benefits. But this is the
- 1:04:15foundation of leadership, especially in hybrid workplaces. Yeah. Can you actually on that point?
- 1:04:24So somebody's listening to this and they understand the benefit, they're bought in. They can figure
- 1:04:31it out themselves to a degree, but just even go a step further tactically. How do you start it?
- 1:04:37Cades of questions that are sort of agnostic of the individual that's in that meeting.
- 1:04:42Good questions to ask. And then how do you end it? So that's you're basically,
- 1:04:48that's a question asking me to describe my entire book. Oh, I'm sorry. Okay.
- 1:04:52No, you have to apologize. It's a perfect question. So again, I mean, that's what the book does
- 1:04:58is it literally walks from start to finish. I'll give you not everything. You don't want to give away
- 1:05:04the far. So, but I'm going to give it a few examples. By the way, just a side point, you're
- 1:05:13very good on stage. I was again, I'm just referencing the things that I saw when I was prepping for
- 1:05:16this. And you said like the six pillars of good meetings. And then you were teaching it over,
- 1:05:22I think, to a Google talk. And then you were saying how I guess your editor or your publicist or
- 1:05:27something says, don't tell them the six pillars or six pillars are not going to read the book.
- 1:05:31And then you said, well, these are just six of 250 million that I put in the book. And I was
- 1:05:35laughing because that's the best way. But you know, in all seriousness, when somebody listens to
- 1:05:41something like this, it's so interesting. They're going to listen to it. They will still get the
- 1:05:46book. And then there's actually another level of, I guess, commitment that they have to have,
- 1:05:50which is holding themselves accountable to doing anything. Because you can consume all the
- 1:05:54information you want. And people have this actually a really nasty habit of just consuming,
- 1:05:59consuming, consuming, and not actioning. So they'll listen to this. They'll read the book. They'll
- 1:06:04get it on audible. They'll go find you on social. And they probably still then will not do anything
- 1:06:09until they, you know, maybe six months later, they're like, yeah, maybe I should try something
- 1:06:13out in my company. But I know. I hope they think more seriously. Well, thank you. I appreciate that.
- 1:06:18Yeah. All right. So I'll give you one that I think is really fun and interesting.
- 1:06:26I'll give you two at least two. Okay. I have a feeling I'm going to leave you more than two. But
- 1:06:32I want to bookend the start and the end. All right. So a question that doesn't work
- 1:06:37is asking, how are you? When you ask someone, how are you? They tend to go into autopilot. Right?
- 1:06:45They go good. You basically didn't learn anything of value. But you can ask the question differently.
- 1:06:52If you ask someone, how are you? But actually, I want you to respond on a one to 10 scale with 10
- 1:07:00being great and one being horrible. How are you? Now you're going to get responses like vibes,
- 1:07:07sixes, sevens, eights. And now you can talk about it. So that's a simple example.
- 1:07:16Asking a good, how are you? In that manner, elicits a real and genuine conversation.
- 1:07:23So that's one tip. I love that. Another tip is in the beginning, and I think I may have shared this is
- 1:07:34after you refresh on what you hope to achieve in the one-on-one. And by the way, one-on-one should
- 1:07:42have a plan of action. A lot of leaders think that you don't need an agenda for these things.
- 1:07:47You actually do. It just doesn't need to be a big, heavy, formal agenda. But the research
- 1:07:53was generally showing that people need some plan of action in the beginning where we've
- 1:08:00clearly identified the critical priorities to discuss. And the most important element of creating
- 1:08:07that agenda is the direct doing it or the direct collaborating with you. So when you're creating
- 1:08:15that plan of action, the direct's voice should be dominating it. So you refresh on that plan of
- 1:08:21action. So you're making reference to other things, you're facilitating, you're listening.
- 1:08:30Another key piece, and I'm trying to give you different little tips at different stages,
- 1:08:35is around solutioning. It's critical, obviously, to ask your directs their ideas on how to solve
- 1:08:41the problem. Because that's good. You don't need to be the sage on the stage. Let it be someone
- 1:08:47else too. But here's the thing that leaders often get wrong, is that if the direct solution does not
- 1:08:53align perfectly with yours, you think they have to go with yours. And that's wrong. If the direct
- 1:08:59solution maybe in your mind is lesser, but the gap is not meaningful, let it go. Yeah. Let it go.
- 1:09:09Go with their idea. You don't know for fact your idea is better. If the gap is big and it's
- 1:09:16meaningful, sure, share your perspective. But no one to let things go. So often we ask people their
- 1:09:24opinion, but we're just using it to tee up our own opinion. And so much good can come from one-on-ones
- 1:09:31by showing and demonstrating that you trust them. You can ask them good questions to help them
- 1:09:37keep shaping their initial thoughts. But don't intervene unless you truly have to let it go.
- 1:09:45By doing that, you're building all this commitment. People are going to feel much more supported
- 1:09:49and heard and listened to. So that's another common issue that common problem that leaders have is
- 1:09:55they don't know when to let things go. You know, I'll go ahead. Are you going to say something?
- 1:09:59Sorry. I have so much to say. So you go. No, I don't want to take it away from this.
- 1:10:05Keep going. And then I'll bring up something after. Keep going. Sorry.
- 1:10:08All right. Another thing is recognizing that as you're doing these one-on-ones,
- 1:10:13there are these two constellation of needs that you need to meet. You need to meet the
- 1:10:17employee's tactical needs. You know, but you also need to address the more personal needs.
- 1:10:23This is a now-legate like to go into a restaurant. You could get great food, but if the service is
- 1:10:28terrible, that experience wasn't good. If you get great service and the food is terrible,
- 1:10:34the experience was bad. So the leader just has to be dialed in that they need a process that
- 1:10:40addresses both the tactical and the personal needs. And I have a model I provide along with
- 1:10:46behaviors that do both. The other thing, and I'll just two more quick things. One is,
- 1:10:54to your point earlier about people read and hear these things, but don't necessarily do something
- 1:10:59with it. That really haunted me as I wrote this book. So this book is really different from me
- 1:11:04because I filled it with self-assessments. And they're really hard. Like they really make you think
- 1:11:10and challenge some of your assumptions. So I'm hoping through those self-assessments that people
- 1:11:15realize here are their blind spots and here are set of things to do. All right. One last thing,
- 1:11:21and I'm going to stop. The end. All right. There's a research finding and I love this and it ties
- 1:11:26to one-on-ones. Basically, they did an experiment. They brought people into a lab. They were randomly
- 1:11:32assigned to one of two conditions. One condition is they basically stuck their hand into ice cold
- 1:11:38water. That hurts, right? They did it for a minute, felt lots of pain. The second condition,
- 1:11:44they put their hands in the same ice cold water, but then for 60 seconds, but then they were told,
- 1:11:50we're going to do it for 30 more seconds. We're going to put it back in this glass. The water
- 1:11:56was slightly, slightly warmer, still freezing and painful, but slightly more, slightly better
- 1:12:03than the initial glass. And what they found is that those people who ended on that more positive note
- 1:12:10actually said, yeah, I'd be willing to do this experiment again. Oh, wow, that's funny. So they
- 1:12:14were miserable for actually longer than the first group, but because it had more of a positive ending,
- 1:12:22their experience was different. And that same applies with a one-on-one. That no matter what you
- 1:12:28talked about, how difficult it was that even if you had to give negative feedback, we can figure out
- 1:12:35a way of trying to end on a more uplifting note where the person doesn't feel be down.
- 1:12:43The person realizes that you still believe in them, that you're there for them, so that they
- 1:12:49leave feeling energized as opposed to deflated. So what I wanted to say, and I didn't want to stop
- 1:12:57you because this is just, I know you're going to have a thought on this as well, and I didn't want
- 1:13:01to take you away from this because it was amazing, but there's so many parallels in just
- 1:13:07relationship, communication, your spouse, your partner, your kid. This is, I know this is going to
- 1:13:18be for business leaders, but as I'm hearing this, I'm like, oh my goodness, this is just a masterclass
- 1:13:23in communication. Oh my gosh, I love that you brought that up. Because you're absolutely right. I mean,
- 1:13:32so one of the things I talk about is we should be having one-on-ones with our kids.
- 1:13:40They need to be seen and heard, and too often we just get into these rhythms with our kids that
- 1:13:46our conversations are just impassing. And kids, children need connection. This opportunity where
- 1:13:56you're just purely dialed into their needs, listening, asking questions, reflecting, even focusing
- 1:14:02on the short term and the big picture. So what subjects are you really loving at school that
- 1:14:08maybe you want to do more of? That's a long term, that's like career advancement question.
- 1:14:14So there's layers to this, and you're so right, like these one-on-ones and what comes from the
- 1:14:24science applies in so many different relationships. And if we take some of these same skills and act
- 1:14:31intentionally and empathetically and benefits all the relationships in our lives. And I just can't
- 1:14:39stress enough that this investment promotes so much harmony, so much creativity and innovation,
- 1:14:53so much effectiveness and productivity, so much resilience, so much more grit,
- 1:14:58and all these things, right, help individuals, teams, organizations, and families thrive.
- 1:15:07Yeah, at the end of the day, it's just this purposeful time dedicated to communicating.
- 1:15:13And you know what? I don't have kids yet, that's that's soon, but not yet, but I have so many
- 1:15:19friends with kids, and even the way I was raised, I love my parents, they raised me very, very well,
- 1:15:23but a lot of it is just casual in passing. And I'm thinking about the times even growing up
- 1:15:30that I think are not a thing with parents raising kids now, like that time at the dinner table
- 1:15:35when there was no distractions, when you could in theory have these quasi-one-on-ones.
- 1:15:40I don't think people even have those anymore, because everybody's on an iPad or an iPhone or
- 1:15:44an iPhone TV. I agree. I mean, I think our world is becoming more and more disconnected.
- 1:15:50Yeah. And we see it in all contexts, right, so people basically socialize with people who have
- 1:15:56the same worldviews. Yeah. And it just creates more and more polarization. I think we'll look,
- 1:16:02you know, I can see right now in the world what it's causing. I testified to Congress this past summer
- 1:16:11on some work psychology-related issues. And some of the things they were telling me,
- 1:16:19it's crazy. So they have a lounge, you know, where people could go. But it's not, there's a
- 1:16:26Republican lounge and a Democrat lounge. The Democrat lounge has CNN, the Republican lounge,
- 1:16:33headfox. People can't even hang out together. When they get on buses to go to various locations,
- 1:16:42they're not on the same bus. They're two separate buses. There's a Republican bus and a Democrat bus.
- 1:16:48I mean, this is horrible. So without these points of contact, this meaningful interaction and
- 1:16:54conversation, it's just hard for us to break down barriers. I firmly believe that as a country,
- 1:17:03that people have so much more in common than you would ever know by looking at our politics.
- 1:17:08Yeah, I agree with that completely. I think politics is the worst representation of the average
- 1:17:13individual. I agree. Yeah, I agree. I'm actually, it's funny because I notice it more. I'm Canadian.
- 1:17:20Hey, so my wife and kids are Canadian. Okay, so they must notice it that there's such a huge divide
- 1:17:28in the U.S. compared to Canada. People are not, people are political. They're not as political
- 1:17:34as they are in the U.S. People are, they are very, yeah. And there was this research study that I saw
- 1:17:41that when I was growing up, what they found was the biggest thing a parent wanted for their kid
- 1:17:47was to marry someone in the same religion. Now, the biggest thing that a parent wants from their
- 1:17:52kid is to marry someone within the same political party. Wow, that's super telling. And that's
- 1:17:58actually really, that seems very bad. Actually, there's not an eloquently to say, it just seems like
- 1:18:05it's not a good thing. And it's like social, social encourages us. The echo chambers on social
- 1:18:12and algorithms on social definitely don't help and COVID didn't help and being locked down and
- 1:18:17not talking to people didn't help. Nope. And a broken educational system, right?
- 1:18:22Absolutely. And the notion of, you know, confirmation bias, right? People seek out information that
- 1:18:28they already know and or they think they know as opposed to seeking out information that questions
- 1:18:33what they know. And maybe this is a nice tie back, you know, where I feel like what's neat about
- 1:18:40glad we met is, is it brings, you know, this knowledge, this science, this evidence.
- 1:18:50And I feel that through research and data, you're able to penetrate better, right? Into someone's
- 1:18:57mind. So they might say, Hey, I do this all the time. It's working for me. But now when they read
- 1:19:02about the science, it gives them a little bit more pause. Yeah. And they're willing to, I think,
- 1:19:06break that confirmation bias a little bit more. And so that's why I'm just, I'm such a big fan of
- 1:19:12making science work for people, you know, communicating science in a way that reaches people.
- 1:19:19And, you know, all these things work together that, again, if we can make our one-on-ones and we
- 1:19:26can make our regular meetings, 25% better. The gains are tremendous. That's huge.
- 1:19:33All right. Okay. We've gone through a lot. What, what did we not, what did we not go through?
- 1:19:37Is there anything else that we wanted to go into that you want to go into rather? Excuse me.
- 1:19:41I'd love to tell people, check out my website. Yeah. Where do they go? Where do they go? Sorry,
- 1:19:46socials, website, all that. Yeah. So I have a strong presence on LinkedIn. Okay. So definitely check
- 1:19:52me out on LinkedIn. That's my main, that's my main thrust. And then my website is stevenroglberg.com.
- 1:20:00Okay. Stevenroglberg.com. And I have so many resources there for people. I also have a page
- 1:20:06that I just created around one-on-ones. I've had two articles I just published in Harbor Business
- 1:20:10Review that have links there for people to read again about one-on-ones. One of the things we didn't
- 1:20:16talk about, but maybe we could do this at a future podcast is skip levels, right? Because skip
- 1:20:21levels are really interesting. But I have, I have that in my book and I have some content on the
- 1:20:26webpage. I don't know what a skip level is. What's the definition? That's when basically leader meets
- 1:20:33with the directs of their directs. Oh, that's interesting. Yeah, but okay. Got it by the book. Yeah.
- 1:20:42So you definitely check it out the resources. Feel free to reach out to me. My email's on there.
- 1:20:47I have no problem with people reaching out and talking to me. And and then obviously please
- 1:20:53buy the book. Because you know, you write these things. You just want people to buy it. Oh my
- 1:20:56goodness. And by the way, I don't, I actually am donating all my earnings. Everything goes to
- 1:21:04American Cancer Society. So buy the book. If you're interested in one-on-ones or buy the book,
- 1:21:09you want to support the American Cancer Society. I love that. Good. Well, let me know the links you
- 1:21:13want in the show notes. I'll put them all down there. Okay. So just a couple questions to end this
- 1:21:18out just to pull it some last bits of wisdom. If I had an incredible career at this stage and you
- 1:21:24look back, you would tell your 20-year-old self one thing what would it be? My 20-year-old self wouldn't
- 1:21:32even listen to me. That's fair. It wouldn't really matter. But you know, what I would tell my kids is
- 1:21:40you know, strive to have a meaningful life. And there's not one particular path to that,
- 1:21:47but strive for meaningfulness. This world has meaningful problems and you need to be part of that
- 1:21:53solution. And I'm a huge believer that very difficult problems can be solved with each and every
- 1:21:59person doing something. So pick a life, pick a career that allows you to do something and to
- 1:22:07reinforce that meaningfulness. I love that. And last thing at this point in your life, what does
- 1:22:12success mean to you? Helping as many people as I can. I love that. It's very simple. I'm very
- 1:22:22clear on that. And that actually happened after my first, I think after I did CBS this morning,
- 1:22:30and I started getting hit up to just kind of be a general workplace commentator on TV.
- 1:22:35And I got tempted because it's very addictive. Knowing you're talking to a couple million
- 1:22:40people is really addictive. No kidding. Yeah, it's fun. Especially if you have a good message,
- 1:22:45too, and you can help. Exactly. But I really decided that I didn't want to do that. That I want to
- 1:22:51stay true to what I do. My science, as opposed to just being a generalist. But it ties to just my
- 1:23:00hope of what success looks for me now is just doing meaningful work, helping as much as I can,
- 1:23:05especially shedding light on problems at work that are just draining and hurting people.