Latest / The Clio Dialogues: Conversations About History / Never Say Inevitable: Rethinking the Road to 1776 | Peter C. Mancall | Contested Continent
Transcript
- 0:01Jennifer Robin Terry: Hello and welcome to the Clio Dialogues, the podcast that links history with the present to help us better understand the world we live in today.
- 0:09Jennifer Robin Terry: I am your host, Jennifer Robin Terry.
- 0:13Jennifer Robin Terry: What if your history class didn't tell you the entire story?
- 0:17Jennifer Robin Terry: Like how, before America was a nation, it was anyone's game.
- 0:22Jennifer Robin Terry: My guest today is Peter C.
- 0:23Jennifer Robin Terry: Mancall, distinguished professor at the University of Southern California, where he is the Andrew W.
- 0:28Jennifer Robin Terry: Mellon Professor of the Humanities and the Linda and Harlan Martins Director of the U.S.C.
- 0:34Jennifer Robin Terry: Huntington Early Modern Studies Institute.
- 0:37Jennifer Robin Terry: He is the author of Contested Continent: The Struggle for North America 1000 to 1680, which is volume one of the Oxford History of the United States, published by Oxford University Press.
- 0:49Jennifer Robin Terry: Welcome, Peter.
- 0:51Jennifer Robin Terry: I am thrilled to talk to you about your book.
- 0:53Jennifer Robin Terry: I am so glad you could join me here on the Clio Dialogues.
- 0:56Peter Mancall: Well, Jennifer, thank you for having me.
- 0:57Peter Mancall: I'm really looking forward to our conversation.
- 0:59Jennifer Robin Terry: We're having this conversation as the United States marks the 250th year since the Declaration of Independence.
- 1:07Jennifer Robin Terry: There's a lot of talk about it, looking backward at American history, and it seems like the march towards nationhood was inevitable the way a lot of history is told.
- 1:17Jennifer Robin Terry: I'm wondering if you could just speak a little bit about how knowing the end or the so-called end can really skew Americans' understanding of the history of North America.
- 1:30Peter Mancall: That is such a great question, especially to start our conversation.
- 1:33Peter Mancall: I think that so many books about early America, the period that is before, say, 1800, take as their logical endpoint the revolution and really their logical, logical endpoint, the Constitution.
- 1:47Peter Mancall: And so this year, the 250th of 1776, there's been a lot of discussion about the Declaration of Independence.
- 1:53Peter Mancall: And unless I miss my mark, in 11 years, there's gonna be a lot of discussion about how we got to the Constitution.
- 1:58Peter Mancall: And so when I talk to a lot of people, you know, in this country and other places, they talk about 1776 as the obvious beginning of the nation, and don't really think like we had to have gotten there, or they had to have gotten to that point, right?
- 2:11Peter Mancall: It was inevitable, it was inexorable.
- 2:13Peter Mancall: And there are certain grand narratives which point in that direction.
- 2:16Peter Mancall: My point is in fact that 1776 is a very distant endpoint from the people who I write about in Contested Continent.
- 2:25Peter Mancall: I end my book almost a hundred years before 1776.
- 2:29Peter Mancall: And I end my book really talking about what a divided place North America was.
- 2:35Peter Mancall: Part of what we do when we collapse the pre-1776 period into the inexorable march towards independence, is we'd miss not only the drama of things, but we miss the many ways it could have gone in different directions.
- 2:50Peter Mancall: We miss the many peoples who contributed to the American experience who sort of got shunted to the side after independence or because of independence or however you want to interpret that.
- 3:00Peter Mancall: So if my book works as a work of narrative history, if you've followed me from the year 1000 to the year 1680, if you get to the end, you're shaking your head thinking, wait, how do we get to a revolution?
- 3:13Peter Mancall: Like this guy has not set that up at all.
- 3:15Peter Mancall: Well, on some deep level, I do set up what happens and what would eventually become the United States.
- 3:21Peter Mancall: But I don't in any way set up what's going to happen over that almost 100 years from the Pueblo revolt to Philadelphia in 76.
- 3:28Jennifer Robin Terry: That's an excellent point.
- 3:29Jennifer Robin Terry: And I do want to tell our listeners, this is a hefty book.
- 3:33Jennifer Robin Terry: This is nearly 700 pages of text.
- 3:36Jennifer Robin Terry: And then there's the bibliography and notes and all that goes with it.
- 3:40Jennifer Robin Terry: But it is so good.
- 3:41Jennifer Robin Terry: It reads so well.
- 3:44Jennifer Robin Terry: And for those who may not be inclined to pick up a book and read 700 or so pages, this book is going to be issued as an audiobook in, is it October?
- 3:53Peter Mancall: It's coming out in October.
- 3:54Peter Mancall: It's my understanding.
- 3:55Jennifer Robin Terry: Wonderful.
- 3:56Jennifer Robin Terry: So I think some people will really enjoy listening to this as well as an audiobook.
- 4:00Jennifer Robin Terry: I'm curious, how much do you think the way US history is taught in school and specifically in college courses, the traditional survey courses, how much does that kind of skew our perspective on pre-revolutionary history?
- 4:15Jennifer Robin Terry: It's a lot of time to cover in 10 to 15 weeks.
- 4:19Peter Mancall: Yes, I think that's true.
- 4:20Peter Mancall: And I I think a one-semester survey of the United States, the period that I work on is probably like two lectures, right?
- 4:26Peter Mancall: I mean, it's sort of dispatched really way too quickly.
- 4:29Peter Mancall: There's the sort of standard, here's what America looked like, and this is how Native peoples lived.
- 4:34Peter Mancall: Here are European explorers, here's the European Reformation, here's the slave trade.
- 4:39Peter Mancall: Boom, we're off to the revolution.
- 4:41Peter Mancall: I spend a lot of my time talking to K-12 teachers.
- 4:45Peter Mancall: There's this wonderful Gilder Lemon Institute in New York, which brings faculty together with K-12 teachers.
- 4:50Peter Mancall: Their textbooks really have almost nothing about the early colonial period in it at all, because the school district's decision is they have to get to the revolution as quickly as possible.
- 5:00Peter Mancall: If you look at a lot of textbooks for the majority of American history being written, it's really about the modern period.
- 5:05Peter Mancall: It's really about the post-1900 period.
- 5:07Peter Mancall: The Civil War is always going to get a lot of attention.
- 5:09Peter Mancall: It's the great national crisis.
- 5:11Peter Mancall: The revolution is always going to be there because it gives us both these heroes that everyone's supposed to know about, they're on our currency and things like that, and it gives us the foundations of a government.
- 5:21Peter Mancall: So those things have to be there.
- 5:23Peter Mancall: The rest, in whoever puts together these things, doesn't seem that important.
- 5:27Peter Mancall: Once upon a time, students would learn a lot about what used to be called the age of discovery or the age of exploration.
- 5:35Peter Mancall: And then that really sort of fell out of favor.
- 5:37Peter Mancall: It fell out of favor for a lot of really good reasons.
- 5:40Peter Mancall: But in falling out of favor, it also kind of disappeared.
- 5:42Peter Mancall: We don't want those heroic narratives about what a great guy Columbus was or Magellan was.
- 5:49Peter Mancall: You know, we pushed that aside.
- 5:50Peter Mancall: We also pushed to the side everyone who was there at the time, including the people who are interacting with those explorers, and who really decide which colonies are going to survive and which colonies are going to fail, especially in North America.
- 6:02Peter Mancall: And so when our trends push us towards the modern period, we lose a lot of the sort of day-to-day, the reality that I think we really need.
- 6:11Peter Mancall: I think all of us need when we write and read about history.
- 6:14Peter Mancall: We need the real people behind it, not just the results of what came from their struggles.
- 6:19Jennifer Robin Terry: I think that's such an excellent point.
- 6:21Jennifer Robin Terry: That's one of the things I find so fascinating about your book, is it is like a really good backstory that is challenging what has now become a familiar narrative.
- 6:30Jennifer Robin Terry: And it is saying, look, this is not a story where Europeans are the protagonists.
- 6:35Jennifer Robin Terry: This is actually an ensemble cast with a whole bunch of people that you have not heard of or thought of in relation to the history of the North American continent.
- 6:45Jennifer Robin Terry: This is a history of struggle, it's a history of failure, of big ideas, and of decisions, but of a whole lot more people than we're typically used to hearing from.
- 6:56Jennifer Robin Terry: And so I wonder when you think about all these decisions and the things that had to happen and the interactions between people, are there some pivotal decisions that really stand out to you that changed the course of history?
- 7:11Peter Mancall: That's a fascinating question.
- 7:13Peter Mancall: A really great question.
- 7:14Peter Mancall: There are a number of times when I try to really understand certain decisions that people made.
- 7:20Peter Mancall: One of the most unlikely decisions was the English decision to invest in Jamestown.
- 7:26Peter Mancall: The English had failed constantly in trying to create colonies in the Americas, including in South America, not just in North America.
- 7:34Peter Mancall: They tried and they had various reasons, and they were in competition with these Iberians, and they wanted to get there, and they saw a lot of their domestic problems being solved by creating colonies, and it made all sorts of logical sense, and yet they keep failing and failing and failing, most famously at Roanoke, but there are other colonies, other places that disappeared also.
- 7:54Peter Mancall: But here's the thing Jamestown is a complete disaster for the English.
- 7:58Peter Mancall: Because of strategic reasons, they decide to put Jamestown sort of beyond a little crook in what is now the James River, a place that was just an ecological disaster zone.
- 8:09Peter Mancall: Like we would call it a super fund site on some level, right?
- 8:13Peter Mancall: Because the water levels in the James in those days sank really low, and yet they continued to get their drinking water running.
- 8:21Peter Mancall: They kept doing that for years.
- 8:23Peter Mancall: And every now and then they decide, okay, we got to get out of Jamestown and expand our territory.
- 8:28Peter Mancall: Some new governor would come in and say, nope, let's go back to Jamestown again.
- 8:31Peter Mancall: So what's amazing to me in terms of these fateful decisions, because this leads to two monumental developments.
- 8:37Peter Mancall: What's amazing to me is that they didn't give up and go someplace else.
- 8:43Peter Mancall: But here's why this is consequential.
- 8:45Peter Mancall: This is the place where we see the development of enslavement in the mainland colonies.
- 8:52Peter Mancall: And this is the place where the English, in their political system, pioneer colonial self-government.
- 8:58Peter Mancall: These two things are foundational to the American experience.
- 9:02Peter Mancall: And those developments about enslavement and self-government both happened 12 years after the English get to Jamestown.
- 9:09Peter Mancall: A lot has happened in those 12 years, and none of it is very good for the English.
- 9:14Peter Mancall: One other thing that emerges from that decision to stay.
- 9:18Peter Mancall: What the English saw in front of them was how to govern this particular place.
- 9:24Peter Mancall: But the person doing that governing was Wahunsunacock, the man who the English Powhatan, and who's most famous because he's Pocahontas' father, and so he has a role in the Disney movie.
- 9:34Peter Mancall: Everybody knows him because of that.
- 9:36Peter Mancall: He was the most powerful politician in this place and in this time.
- 9:40Peter Mancall: And in fact, when he dies is what leads to a really catastrophic war between colonists and the palatins.
- 9:47Peter Mancall: The English are understanding that it is possible to organize this place, to organize resources, to organize people to do things.
- 9:55Peter Mancall: And they're also realizing how important it is for them, the people who newly arrived, how important it is for them to get along with native peoples.
- 10:03Peter Mancall: Not in general, they talked about that in theory, but specific people to form alliances, to go back to one of your earlier questions about how textbooks think about things.
- 10:12Peter Mancall: One of the things that we do is we presume that Europeans are going to succeed in the Americas.
- 10:18Peter Mancall: So we presume the Europeans, in this case the English, are going to triumph over these local conditions in Jamestown.
- 10:24Peter Mancall: And we don't just presume that, we have a very sophisticated modern model, which environmental historian Alfred Crosby came up with called the Columbian Exchange, which emphasizes Europeans extracting resources, which is what they're doing in early Jamestown, and Europeans unwittingly transporting infectious diseases to the Western hemisphere.
- 10:42Peter Mancall: And so we have a model which almost de-emphasizes the importance of individual relations.
- 10:48Peter Mancall: And in my book, what I'm trying to say is, yes, infectious diseases really mattered.
- 10:53Peter Mancall: They were devastating, and I describe some of them in the book in really kind of graphic terms.
- 10:59Peter Mancall: But they weren't everywhere, and they weren't all the time.
- 11:02Peter Mancall: What we need to do as historians is to try to give this early past more complexity.
- 11:07Peter Mancall: That's not just about the Columbian Exchange.
- 11:09Peter Mancall: It's the Columbian Exchange, very useful device for us.
- 11:12Peter Mancall: More useful than, say, the concept of manifest destiny, the 19th century concept.
- 11:16Peter Mancall: It's maybe more useful to us than what Columbus and his followers thought, which is this is all God's plan, not a national plan, but a God's plan.
- 11:24Peter Mancall: Yes, the Columbian Exchange is a modern thing.
- 11:26Peter Mancall: But in pushing for those abstract forces, we risk falling into the trap of inevitability.
- 11:32Peter Mancall: And that strikes me as a very dangerous if we really want to understand any period of history.
- 11:39Peter Mancall: We have to battle the sense of inevitability in order to show why things mattered and why things developed the way that they did.
- 11:46Jennifer Robin Terry: Right.
- 11:46Jennifer Robin Terry: I think one of the ways that we do that is by acknowledging a certain sense of agency.
- 11:52Jennifer Robin Terry: And you do that really well by pointing out that indigenous Americans were not just victims.
- 11:58Jennifer Robin Terry: They were not just recipients of the things that Europeans brought, but they were agents in their own right.
- 12:04Jennifer Robin Terry: You have really de-centered Europeans as the main protagonists.
- 12:08Jennifer Robin Terry: So can you tell us a little more about the indigenous Americans and uh their role in this?
- 12:13Peter Mancall: I really appreciate what you said that I decentered Europeans as the stars of the story.
- 12:18Peter Mancall: They are in the story.
- 12:18Peter Mancall: I want them on the stage, but they're not the only people on the stage.
- 12:21Peter Mancall: And in the entire time period that I write about, ending in 1680, there are more Native peoples in North America than there are Europeans or Africans.
- 12:29Peter Mancall: The demographic transition, which would eventually come much later, a hundred years or so later, and that's in eastern North America.
- 12:35Peter Mancall: You have to go into the 19th century to really have a demographic transition where native peoples become a statistical minority compared to the descendants of Europeans.
- 12:42Peter Mancall: So by decentering Europeans, I'm really trying to say, let's look who actually is walking on this historical state.
- 12:47Peter Mancall: In the early period, they're overwhelmingly native, and even late into the period, they're still mostly Native peoples.
- 12:52Peter Mancall: One of the crucial things to understand is that Europeans have certain ideas about what various parts of the Americas are going to be like based on other Europeans' views.
- 13:03Peter Mancall: And some of those ideas are native peoples are simple, we can take advantage of them, we can kidnap them because they're not very militarily superior.
- 13:11Peter Mancall: Native peoples live in this bounteous environment which has everything we could possibly want, and we're going to extract all this wealth, and that really accelerates once Spaniards get to Mexico.
- 13:21Peter Mancall: These ideas get set in Europeans and start reading other Europeans, missing the point that most knowledge about North America is indigenous knowledge about North America.
- 13:30Peter Mancall: And oftentimes when Europeans try to go someplace and they don't succeed, they blame it on sort of inadequacies.
- 13:37Peter Mancall: This is really true in the North, in the Arctic.
- 13:40Peter Mancall: They say this place is uninhabitable.
- 13:42Peter Mancall: We can't go there, missing the fact that it is inhabited, that people that people are living there, and that those people are determining if the visitors are going to live or die by taking care of them or ignoring them or attacking them.
- 13:54Peter Mancall: So I think a reader of my book will assume at the point of contact, native peoples have a lot to say.
- 14:01Peter Mancall: When you get to the latter chapters, I have two chapters near the end, which I make the point that sort of answered the spirit of your question.
- 14:08Peter Mancall: One is a chapter that looks at the Mississippi Valley at the end of my time period, that is the 1660s, 1670s.
- 14:16Peter Mancall: And it's basically making the point this place has not radically changed.
- 14:19Peter Mancall: This is Indian country.
- 14:20Peter Mancall: It's still Indian country.
- 14:22Peter Mancall: Yes, there are Europeans traveling through, and the Europeans know that they are completely at the mercy of whatever native group they are near.
- 14:30Peter Mancall: But part of why I have that chapter near the end of my book is to say that almost 200 years after Columbus, most of North America is unchanged by the arrival of Europeans.
- 14:40Peter Mancall: Then the last major chapter of my book, I talk about a series of very bloody encounters.
- 14:46Peter Mancall: Bacon's Rebellion is famous for pitting colonists against colonists.
- 14:49Peter Mancall: It's the subject, among other things, of one of the great books of early American history, which is Edmund Morgan's American Slavery and American Freedom, in which Bacon's rebellion plays a crucial role in why white Virginians turn towards enslavement much more eagerly after 1676.
- 15:04Peter Mancall: The other two conflicts, though, Medicoms, which is across southern New England into Coastal Maine, and the other one, the Pueblo Revolt, which is in New Mexico, these are conflicts of native peoples against colonizers, and these are native peoples who were saying enough.
- 15:18Peter Mancall: In New England, what that would mean is territorial expansion.
- 15:22Peter Mancall: In New Mexico, what that tended to mean is the demands that both troops and priests were putting on indigenous peoples reached a point that it was too much.
- 15:32Peter Mancall: And in both those cases, there are these very powerful indigenous rebellions.
- 15:36Peter Mancall: These were catastrophic to Europeans, and one could imagine a scenario that had Europeans already not been established in these areas, especially in New England, they might have said, no, this is not our time to colonize.
- 15:49Peter Mancall: The Spanish actually do leave New Mexico.
- 15:52Peter Mancall: They're out of New Mexico for 12 years.
- 15:54Peter Mancall: I mean it's the most successful native revolt in American history.
- 15:56Peter Mancall: It's also a revolt which is uncomfortable to many modern Americans, because it's fairly clear from the documents that it's not just a revolt against people trying to take our land or even enslave us.
- 16:10Peter Mancall: It is a revolt against the religion of the Europeans, which in that case is the Catholic Church, and the systematic assaults on the church, which come through in testimony from colonial and native observers, really are shocking to modern readers.
- 16:24Peter Mancall: I emphasize them to say not everything boils down to a competition for what would be the word worldly resources, that some people are very, very upset at the presumption that your faith is greater than my faith, that you can make me believe something that I'm not inclined to believe, and that the way you're forcing me to do that I find unacceptable.
- 16:46Peter Mancall: It really tells us something more, or maybe different, than our typical way of looking at rebellions, which is you're taxing us too much.
- 16:55Peter Mancall: This is we are trying to eradicate something which isn't visible.
- 17:00Peter Mancall: Tells us a lot about interaction.
- 17:02Peter Mancall: I think it tells us a lot in our Spain, Europeans and Native peoples over the course of that colonial period.
- 17:07Jennifer Robin Terry: Yeah, I agree.
- 17:08Jennifer Robin Terry: Don Luis, Opecancanough, was an indigenous man who ends up interacting with the guys in Jamestown.
- 17:15Jennifer Robin Terry: Tell me the story.
- 17:17Peter Mancall: The story is somewhat involved, but I'll give you the short version of the story.
- 17:20Jennifer Robin Terry: Okay.
- 17:21Peter Mancall: Um Spanish explorers, Spanish colonizers either adopted or kidnapped this young, young guy who spends some time in Cuba, goes to Spain, and comes back.
- 17:30Peter Mancall: And as far as the Spanish are concerned, he is converted.
- 17:34Peter Mancall: He is like one of them, and he can be very useful in their in their plans.
- 17:39Peter Mancall: And one of the plans that some Spanish missionaries come up with is we're going to plant a mission near Chesapeake Bay.
- 17:45Peter Mancall: So they take this young guy along.
- 17:48Peter Mancall: The Spanish are now calling him Don Luis.
- 17:50Peter Mancall: There's a wonderful biography of him by a grave server named James Horn.
- 17:54Peter Mancall: Now he's not from this region originally, as far as we know.
- 17:57Peter Mancall: He's from somewhere else.
- 17:58Peter Mancall: And so he goes with a small number of missionaries setting up a small establishment.
- 18:04Peter Mancall: For people who know their film history, I sort of say if you remember the movie Black Robe, there were very good visualizations in Black Robe about what these early mission camps were like.
- 18:15Peter Mancall: Well, something happens, and this young man, Don Luis, allies himself with local people, and they rise up and they kill the missionaries.
- 18:24Peter Mancall: This young guy, and he's still relatively young-ish, he's maybe in his twenties, maybe he's 30.
- 18:31Peter Mancall: He disappears from the record because there aren't Europeans out there keeping records.
- 18:34Peter Mancall: He then re-emerges as an ally of Wahun Seneca, of Palatin, now known as Opichen Kanoo.
- 18:42Peter Mancall: This guy now, as an adult in the 16 teams, becomes sort of a war captain for Wahunsenacock, for the Palatins who are meeting the English.
- 18:52Peter Mancall: After Wahun Seneca's death and Pocahontas' death, which are almost at the same time, he emerges as this powerful military figure, and then he leads a rebellion in 1622, which the English refer to as a barbarous massacre.
- 19:09Peter Mancall: And then he would survive that, and he would live into what is becomes the third Anglo-Palatin War in the 1640s, where he is captured and shot.
- 19:20Peter Mancall: Now, why this guy who's not from the area did that, the missionaries never recorded, and to my knowledge, there's no recorded oral history that survives to explain why what happened in 1571 happened.
- 19:30Peter Mancall: But he becomes a hugely consequential figure.
- 19:33Peter Mancall: He plays a starring role in what becomes a turning point in English colonial history.
- 19:39Peter Mancall: After Opichenkano leads that rebellion in 1622, the English are just enraged by this.
- 19:46Peter Mancall: So the English launched this huge assault.
- 19:48Peter Mancall: In the spring of 1623, in an effort to kill Opichenkano and his followers, a group of English soldiers sail up the York, sail them to Pamunkey territory, which is where Opichenkano was living, and they distribute a poison to 200 people.
- 20:05Peter Mancall: But this kind of stuck with me.
- 20:07Peter Mancall: I'm thinking, wait, I don't think I've ever seen that before.
- 20:11Peter Mancall: So I then start digging back into the English conquest of Ireland, which I thought would give me some examples.
- 20:17Peter Mancall: I go back to other times when the English are doing violent things to other people.
- 20:22Peter Mancall: There are no instances of mass poison.
- 20:24Peter Mancall: At the moment that this happens in 1623 is just when the English are codifying their understanding of the laws of war and peace.
- 20:32Peter Mancall: And they go out of their way to say you can't use poison in war.
- 20:36Peter Mancall: And so now let's go back to the Chesapeake in 1623.
- 20:42Peter Mancall: What is going on here?
- 20:43Peter Mancall: Why do they decide to do it?
- 20:46Peter Mancall: The people that do it first claim they didn't do it.
- 20:48Peter Mancall: Then they sort of back up and they more or less admit that they did, but they also knew it was wrong.
- 20:53Peter Mancall: Poison is not a casual act.
- 20:55Peter Mancall: To poison 200 people means you need to prepare a lot of poison.
- 21:00Peter Mancall: They are doing something that they know is wrong.
- 21:02Peter Mancall: Though there's violence before this, including in this area in what's called the First Anglo-Palatin War, which what's from 169 to 1640?
- 21:10Peter Mancall: It's hard to put these things in a relative scale.
- 21:12Peter Mancall: The violence that comes after this is much more devastating and dramatic and much more organized, not just attacking colonists, colonists attacking native communities.
- 21:22Peter Mancall: And then that would reach a culmination in part in the most infamous incident in early New England history, which is during the Anglo-Pequot War, the burning of a Pequot village on the banks of the Mystic River.
- 21:34Peter Mancall: I don't really imagine that happening 50 years earlier.
- 21:37Peter Mancall: And so part of what I tried to do in Contested Continent is say what's going on, which is changing how people see each other.
- 21:44Jennifer Robin Terry: You can definitely see there's this turning point where the violence, it's not self-defense, it's not misunderstanding.
- 21:50Jennifer Robin Terry: It is actually premeditated and calculated and on a larger scale of wiping out people rather than defending against.
- 21:59Jennifer Robin Terry: A perceived threat.
- 22:01Peter Mancall: Exactly.
- 22:02Peter Mancall: That's exactly right.
- 22:02Peter Mancall: And these things are happening at the same time.
- 22:04Peter Mancall: The English are expanding the number of enslaved Africans they're bringing.
- 22:08Peter Mancall: So a different form of violence and destruction of communities is happening at the same time.
- 22:12Jennifer Robin Terry: One of the points of your book is that institutions are not inevitable.
- 22:17Jennifer Robin Terry: And we need to understand that institutions are a result of concerted decisions and actions.
- 22:23Jennifer Robin Terry: What struck me was when I was reading about the Spanish, and the Spanish are having a hard time forcing indigenous people to work, so let's turn to Africa and import people.
- 22:34Jennifer Robin Terry: But the English seemed to think that wasn't the way they were going to go about things until maybe 1619.
- 22:40Jennifer Robin Terry: And then they decided this is the way that we are going to proceed.
- 22:43Jennifer Robin Terry: It was a concerted decision.
- 22:45Jennifer Robin Terry: Can you tell us about that?
- 22:48Peter Mancall: When the English are first thinking about colonizing North America, they're doing it after the Reformation has already happened, right?
- 22:54Peter Mancall: And so they are basically saying we are going to change this place and make it not just part of Europe, but part of Protestant Europe.
- 23:02Peter Mancall: And it's going to make sure we're not like the Spanish or the Portuguese.
- 23:05Peter Mancall: We're not going to be like these people who, among other things, enslaved indigenous and participated in the slave trade.
- 23:11Peter Mancall: We're going to be different.
- 23:12Peter Mancall: And in fact, when Elizabeth is the queen, they make an explicit point that we don't need to ever enslave people.
- 23:17Peter Mancall: We wouldn't do that.
- 23:18Peter Mancall: Iberians would do that, not us.
- 23:20Peter Mancall: And in fact, one of the reasons for going to North America is to get rid of all this, as the English promoters would think of it, surplus people, people who can't find work, especially young men, they may be dangerous at home.
- 23:30Peter Mancall: Let's get rid of them.
- 23:31Peter Mancall: We'll never need enslaved people because we're going to solve our domestic problem, overpopulation, as they thought of it, by providing a labor source to extract resources, which is what they wanted.
- 23:41Peter Mancall: So at the very beginning, there's even a proclamation from Elizabeth herself, the English are not intending to enslave people.
- 23:49Peter Mancall: They, in fact, criticized the Spanish for having done so.
- 23:52Peter Mancall: In those early years of the 17th century, Elizabeth is now gone.
- 23:56Peter Mancall: In an effort to establish a viable extraction economy in Bermuda, the English acquire some enslaved Africans.
- 24:04Peter Mancall: In 1619, the English capture a ship and the first enslaved Africans come to the mainland English colonies.
- 24:11Peter Mancall: The 1619 project and the big debate about the 1619 project really made it sound like that is the great turning point in American history.
- 24:19Peter Mancall: That that was it.
- 24:19Peter Mancall: Well, it was important, but it's very important for us to understand that the laws are not entirely clear about the legal status of these individuals.
- 24:29Peter Mancall: They are presumptively enslaved in the colonies.
- 24:31Peter Mancall: They're certainly treated like they're enslaved in the colonies, but the laws are ambiguous, and the laws remain ambiguous through the middle decades of the seventeenth century.
- 24:40Peter Mancall: The majority of laborers going to the Chesapeake in the middle decades of the 17th century are English.
- 24:45Peter Mancall: Sometimes they're Irish, but basically they're organized by the English.
- 24:48Peter Mancall: The English, in their official rhetoric, really don't want to embrace the idea of enslaved Africans in their American colonies.
- 24:56Peter Mancall: By the middle of the century, things begin to change, in part because of the great expansion of the tobacco economy and the expansion in the islands, especially of the sugar economy, which is really where the English got involved most heavily in the transatlantic slave trade.
- 25:11Peter Mancall: But in the mainland, there is growing demand for labor.
- 25:14Peter Mancall: And though the English still seemingly prefer other English to do their labor, that's to be indentured servants, other developments change the calculus.
- 25:23Peter Mancall: And the most important in that are these two disasters that hit England in the middle of the 1660s plague and the Great Fire of London.
- 25:32Peter Mancall: Those two things together all of a sudden create enormous job opportunities for anyone who's unemployed or underemployed in England.
- 25:39Peter Mancall: No need to cross the ocean, no need to sign up your labor for five years.
- 25:42Peter Mancall: By the way, we heard it's terrible over there.
- 25:44Peter Mancall: They're going to stay home.
- 25:45Peter Mancall: At the same time, the sugar economy is booming and the tobacco economy is booming, and there's constant need for labor.
- 25:51Peter Mancall: And eventually, by the early 1670s, this need for labor reaches the highest levels of English society.
- 25:57Peter Mancall: And we see the creation of the Royal African Company, in which the royal family decide, okay, we're going to get involved in this business.
- 26:04Peter Mancall: That is a radical shift from what Queen Elizabeth had in mind three generations earlier.
- 26:09Peter Mancall: So the English within a relatively short amount of time really make a substantial conversion and embrace.
- 26:15Peter Mancall: So 1619 is absolutely important as a date.
- 26:19Peter Mancall: But what I hope I do in contested content is say, yes, but let's see how these things emerge kind of in as much as possible real time from 1619 through the 1670s.
- 26:31Peter Mancall: I think that Professor Morgan was right in American slavery, American Freedom.
- 26:35Peter Mancall: I do think it's the debate that happens as a result of Bacon's rebellion.
- 26:39Peter Mancall: We see this in the laws, much more eagerly embraced the idea of enslavement and keeping people, not only for their entire lives, but one of the crucial things about slavery as it was in the law in America is the children of enslaved women became the property of the person who claimed ownership of her.
- 26:56Peter Mancall: That was a very important step towards establishing a form of enslavement that did not exist earlier.
- 27:04Peter Mancall: Certain foundational things about modern life emerged in this period.
- 27:08Peter Mancall: One, the idea that nature exists to be harvested, that we human beings can extract whatever we want from the natural world regardless of the consequences.
- 27:18Peter Mancall: That idea did not exist before this time period.
- 27:20Peter Mancall: This is the origins of our modern ecological crisis.
- 27:23Peter Mancall: Yes, the Industrial Revolution mattered, but the origins of our modern ecological crisis were this idea.
- 27:28Peter Mancall: And this idea really developed in the Americas more than anywhere else in the world in the early modern period.
- 27:33Peter Mancall: And it developed because of an idea that Europeans could simply extract what they want.
- 27:37Peter Mancall: That is foundational.
- 27:38Peter Mancall: Second of these kind of larger takeaway points.
- 27:41Peter Mancall: The development of enslavement as it happened in this earlier period led to the acceptance of a society of gross inequality.
- 27:50Peter Mancall: The greatest inequality was between the free and the enslaved.
- 27:54Peter Mancall: But over time, inequality became foundational to America.
- 27:58Peter Mancall: A third takeaway.
- 27:59Peter Mancall: The United States, in the process of creating that nation, it displaced hundreds of indigenous communities.
- 28:06Peter Mancall: Native peoples didn't disappear.
- 28:07Peter Mancall: Native peoples are shaping everyday life throughout this entire time period.
- 28:11Peter Mancall: And finally, it is in the early American period when certain ideas about what we think of as religious freedom did spread across the continent.
- 28:19Peter Mancall: That meant different things in different places.
- 28:21Peter Mancall: The American stereotype is pilgrims and puritans, religious dissenters who leave the Church of England and endure these hardships.
- 28:28Peter Mancall: But that same idea about religious freedom applies to Pope and his followers, who are basically saying to the Catholic Church, our native faith matters.
- 28:37Peter Mancall: This is what we want.
- 28:38Peter Mancall: We have the freedom to establish that.
- 28:40Peter Mancall: Our only way to understand history is to understand the things that individuals struggled with.
- 28:45Peter Mancall: So I tried to demonstrate agency, the people have it.
- 28:48Peter Mancall: Tried to stress the importance of contingency, the decisions people make on one day change what happens on the next day.
- 28:56Peter Mancall: I think it's very important, even when we talk about big picture history on contestant continent is a big picture history to bring it down to the level of the individual and the individual story.
- 29:07Peter Mancall: There's a famous line by Joan Didding who tells stories to make sense of the world.
- 29:11Peter Mancall: I'm telling stories which kept it proud of the archives sometimes.
- 29:15Peter Mancall: And the tellers may be imperfect tellers, but there's still a lot of stories there and they're worth listening to.
- 29:20Peter Mancall: And I hope I've brought some of the humanity of a whole bunch of people back into our present discussion.
- 29:28Jennifer Robin Terry: This has been the Clio Dialogues.
- 29:31Jennifer Robin Terry: Please like, follow, and subscribe.
- 29:33Jennifer Robin Terry: And join me again next time because history isn't finished with us.