Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Where Would You Hide the Body? Exploring our Dark Side
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking feels so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. So my wife
- 1:00Life has been telling her friends in conversations they're talking about something else or texting
- 1:06about something else, and she'll just sort of smirk at me and then interject
- 1:11this. She'll say, Hey, by the way, if anything sketchy ever
- 1:15happens to me, I disappear mysteriously or they find my body in a ditch,
- 1:22I want you to tell the police that the first person they should look
- 1:26at is my husband, because I'm a little nervous about the man. And
- 1:34here's where that comes from. I'm a true crime addict. I know a
- 1:41lot of it is trash television I know that sometimes they embellish or fill in
- 1:47blanks with fiction, or ramp up the drama unnecessarily. I know that sometimes
- 1:52true crime is not always true. I'm also fully aware of the CSI effect,
- 2:00and this deals with our expectations the general public. Weaned on crime television,
- 2:07we have this sort of mental picture of how the process is supposed to
- 2:09go. Now, if you don't know what the CSI effect is, CSI
- 2:15is a television crime show that released in October of two thousand on CBS.
- 2:21This show blasted out of the ratings gate and dominated television. Everybody was watching
- 2:27it, everybody was talking about it, and it's the type of TV forensic
- 2:31cop crime show that you would expect week after week. Suspiciously attractive investigators are
- 2:38using fancy forensic techniques to solve mostly murder cases. What happens in TV crime
- 2:46The investigators outsmart that criminals and things are usually solved in short order. The
- 2:53public perception, then, is that forensics is swift and clean and wan and
- 2:59done, and there's always going to be a smoking gun. Forensics itself is
- 3:06nothing new. We like to think that forensic examinations are novel and recent,
- 3:09But I mean as long as there have been crime scenes, people have investigated
- 3:15crime scenes. I'm reminded of this famous story. Forgive the digression, but
- 3:20it's interesting. The story from like two thousand years ago about the Greek tyrant
- 3:25of Syracuse, a guy named Hero the Second. He was not a good
- 3:30guy. He was very vain, and he wanted a gold crown made for
- 3:36himself, and so he hired a goldsmith. He gave him the raw material,
- 3:40the pure gold, and he said, fashion me an amazing, beautiful
- 3:45holy crown. And when the goldsmith delivered it, Hero the Second looked at
- 3:52it and he was suspicious, and he thought, hey, wait a minute,
- 3:55what are the chances that this guy took some of the goal for himself
- 4:00secretly? And then he blended some other metals not as valuable into the crown,
- 4:08easily disguised. It was still gold in color, It still looked like
- 4:13gold, but not one hundred percent. And then the goldsmith just sort of
- 4:17filled his own pocket, hoping nobody would notice. How was Hero the Second
- 4:24gonna know the difference? Well, he brought in the famous Greek mathematician and
- 4:30physicist Archimedes, and he said, I want you to figure this out.
- 4:34Is it pure gold? Or is the guy ripping me off? Archimedes was
- 4:40not allowed to take the crown apart, or damage it, or even scratch
- 4:44it. Right, this was a holy object that had been dedicated to the
- 4:47gods. How does he examine it without disturbing it? And according to our
- 4:54history books, one day he was sitting in the bathtub and he noticed that
- 4:59the more his body sank in the tub, the more water spilled out over
- 5:04the edges. And he apparently had an epiphany in that moment, and he
- 5:10jumped up stark naked, and he yelled eureka, eureka, And he ran
- 5:15out and put together this experiment. He had the crown, and then he
- 5:19had two masses of metal that were the very same weight. He had the
- 5:25crown, then gold, a mass of gold, then a mass of silver,
- 5:30and he took a large vessel filled it up to right at the brim
- 5:34with water. He took the massive silver and he dropped it into the water,
- 5:41and then he measured how much water spilled out. Then he filled it
- 5:45back up and he grabbed the mass of gold. He dropped the gold in,
- 5:49but not as much water spilled out, because gold is more dense than
- 5:56silver. Meaning that even if it weighs the same, it will take up
- 6:00less volume. After that, he grabbed the crown. He dropped it into
- 6:05the full vessel of water, and he measured and low, and behold,
- 6:11more water than should have been displaced by gold. Pure gold spilled out.
- 6:16He had proven that the goldsmith had snuck in some cheaper metals into the crown
- 6:24and apparently kept some of the gold for himself. Well, what is that
- 6:28if not forensics fascinating story. The Chin dynasty, China, more than two
- 6:34thousand years ago, they were filing autopsy reports, and the reason we know
- 6:41this is because archaeologists have discovered them worldwide. By the early part of the
- 6:47nineteenth century, police started to examine hair and fingerprints and blood more closely.
- 6:55Guns were becoming more popular, and so ballistics forensics sort of the involved with
- 7:00them. The twentieth century saw us unlocking the mysteries of the human genome.
- 7:05Before you know it, we've got computers getting into the game. The first
- 7:11court case, a murder case involving DNA evidence, happened in nineteen eighty seven.
- 7:16There was a guy accused of killing somebody else. They put him on
- 7:19trial. They took a DNA sample and they compared it with the DNA of
- 7:25five thousand other people, and this guy was cleared, the accused was exonerated,
- 7:32and beyond that, the DNA evidence implicated and ultimately convicted somebody else.
- 7:42The FBI would have a full DNA database starting in nineteen ninety eight. And
- 7:46of course we talk about genetic testing all the time today. Crime scene investigation
- 7:53the CSI effect. We think we expect, hey, somebody sweep up the
- 7:59fibers and check the fabrics and look for the prints and test the secretions and
- 8:03whatever, and you will find the killer. And if you don't, it's
- 8:07your fault. But of course this is not how things go down in the
- 8:11real world. I'm not saying that there aren't mistakes and efficiencies, bureaucracy,
- 8:18laziness, oversights, corruption, or just incompetence. I'm not saying that we
- 8:24won't find examples of people being like this, because you'll find it in any
- 8:30situation where human beings are involved. But even when the pros are professional and
- 8:35the process is working as it should, our expectations can be really unrealistic.
- 8:41We're thinking we're going to get CSI, CSI Vegas, CSI New York CSI,
- 8:48Miami or whatever fast and flashy crime drama we've been binging for the last
- 8:56two weeks. And this is the case even with true crime shows like The
- 9:01First forty eight and the idea there is that most cases are blown wide open
- 9:05and the killers are discovered and arrested within the first forty eight hours. You
- 9:11got two days, and after that then things go cold and most criminals will
- 9:16get away with it. So whatever you're going to find, whoever you're going
- 9:20to find, you got to do it in the first forty eight hours or
- 9:24you're host. So now you've got the general public developing unrealistic expectations while they've
- 9:31been watching the real I have a confession. I'm a sucker for a show
- 9:37on h l N called Forensic Files. This is an older show. It
- 9:43started back in the nineteen nineties, narrated by one of my favorite voices in
- 9:48all of broadcasting, a guy named Peter Thomas. He passed away some years
- 9:52ago, but I just love his voice, so authoritative and professional and compelling.
- 9:56I'd watch Forensic Files just to listen to Peter Thomas. But I will
- 10:03sit in front of the television for show after show. Each episode is about
- 10:07twenty three minutes, and they just loop on hl N. I will be
- 10:13at a convention. After a long day at the event, I will go
- 10:18back and decompress in the hotel room, binging forensic files until I finally fall
- 10:26asleep. And of course I watched this show at home. So Natalie and
- 10:31I are sitting there and she's passively listening to whatever crime is being portrayed on
- 10:37screen's I don't know, she's reading, or she's scrolling her phone, or
- 10:41just kind of resting with the dogs, and I am locked onto the murder
- 10:46mystery. The forensic evidence discovered and examined. You know, the imprint of
- 10:54the killer's shoe. It was a size eleven and a half combat boot a
- 10:58specific man, not very many of those in the United States. I wonder
- 11:05where this was purchased. There's a fingerprint belonging to somebody who did not live
- 11:11in that house. They scrape out some skin cells from underneath the step mother's
- 11:18fingernails. There's blood spatter in the back of the creepy white serial killer Van
- 11:28Arson. Investigators find out that there was accelerant next to the victim who burned
- 11:33to death in what was supposed to be an electrical fire. This is the
- 11:39whole vibe of forensic files. And I'm sitting there watching, and as I'm
- 11:43watching, the gears in my head are turning. The criminals are getting caught
- 11:50because they made mistakes, or they had a bad method, or they just
- 11:54left a trail unnecessarily. So as I'm watching, I'm thinking, well,
- 12:00I could do that better. I wouldn't make that mistake. Here's my method,
- 12:03Here's how I would get away with it. And then I articulate these
- 12:09thoughts to my wife, and Natalie says, who thinks like that? Is
- 12:16there something you want to tell me? Have you been living a double life?
- 12:20Are you secretly a serial killer? Because that's information that I would sure
- 12:26like to have. And I always smile and go, baby, you're safe.
- 12:33I'm good. I know. I'm a lover. I'm not a fighter.
- 12:35I'd never hurt anybody. I'm just saying, if I was a criminal,
- 12:41I could do a hell of a lot better than old Buster butt Scratch,
- 12:46who lives in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, who buried the murder weapon out
- 12:52in his yard next to the hot tub. That's all I'm saying. Okay,
- 12:56I could do better. Natalie says, all right, fine, if
- 13:03you were going to murder me, how would you get away with it?
- 13:07Now, I'm not taking this bait. Yeah, I've not taken that bait.
- 13:15I'm smarter than that. I said, baby, I'd never murder you.
- 13:18I am safe people. And then she says, okay, fine,
- 13:24it's not me. If you murdered somebody else, how would you get away
- 13:28with it? And I'm still qualifying, right, well, this is just
- 13:33hypothetical. We're just talking. This is I mean, nothing here has anything
- 13:37to do with who I am as a human being. I am an agent
- 13:41of healing, not harm. I'm just overcompensating. Having said that, here
- 13:48are a few things I would do to get away with murder. And as
- 13:52her face remains totally blank, I start to lay out my evil plan and
- 14:00I say, first of all, fibers. Fibers are always a problem at
- 14:05crime scenes. Clothing. You know, you got your shirt, in your
- 14:07pants, your socks, whatever, it's always fibers falling out. Then there
- 14:11are skin cells which might be shed somewhere that's potential d in a evidence,
- 14:18hair falling out of my head that may incriminate me, fingerprints I inadvertently leave
- 14:26on a doorknob, or a shell, or a table, or even the
- 14:30victim. That's a problem. So here's how I would create a protective shield
- 14:35to keep any of me from remaining at the scene. I would encase myself
- 14:43in saran wrap, and then I would dig out eye holes and put on
- 14:48goggles, and maybe put on some kind of a mask, a gas mask
- 14:52or one of those N ninety five masks, medical masks for breathing. So
- 14:56I'm not exhaling any implyting genetic evidence onto the scene. I'm totally covered up,
- 15:03and I'm moving fast so I don't have to worry about overheating. But
- 15:07I am totally wrapped in plastic wrap. Natalie is processing that visual. She's
- 15:16envisioning her husband totally saran wrapped, about to enter the crime scene. But
- 15:22she is still listening. And then I say, this, shoe prints.
- 15:26How many times has a killer left imprints even on concrete or tile. Certainly
- 15:35if they go out and step in the dirt or mud, that's just dumb.
- 15:39I would invent a solution for that. Now I wear a size fourteen
- 15:45shoe. I would mount a shoe underneath the shoe. Not stilts, but
- 15:52just a few inches under my size fourteen sole would be a smaller soul that
- 15:58would eliminate me as a suspect. And I would practice walking around in these
- 16:03sort of manufactured shoes over shoes. I would get really good at my movement
- 16:10so that I wouldn't tip over and give myself away. Now the cops are
- 16:15looking for a size ten and not a size fourteen. I think that's clever.
- 16:22My wife is getting increasingly uncomfortable. If I had better judgment, I
- 16:27might listen to it, but I continue anyway. I'm right handed. I
- 16:33would practice doing everything left handed so it looks totally organic and natural. Then
- 16:41they might be looking for a left hander. That seems prudent. If I
- 16:48was doing a tandem crime with somebody else, we would speak in a different
- 16:53language, something other than English, because I only speak English. So if
- 16:59they're looking for someone who speaks a different language, that might rule me out
- 17:06as well. And this is something we could practice certain words that we harvested
- 17:10and had ready. Of course, my first thought was, well, what's
- 17:12the second most popular language in the United States. It's going to be Spanish.
- 17:18And I thought at first, well, that would you know, that
- 17:21would really increase the suspect pool beyond me or make it harder to pin me
- 17:26down. Natalie brought up this since she's absolutely right. She's like, oh,
- 17:30great, you will potentially implicate someone else, and you will add to
- 17:34the stereotype of the immigrant criminal in the United States. And I had to
- 17:42give her that one. And then I thought, well, wait a minute,
- 17:45I'm already a killer. I have no moral center anyway. What do
- 17:49I care what stereotype I perpetrate? But I okay, fine, I take
- 17:53her point. And then I think, well, how about a different,
- 17:56more obscure language from a cross the ocean. The man caught on security video
- 18:03was speaking Belarusian. Do I think that detectives are going to hop on a
- 18:10plane, go to Belarus and start knocking on doors to ask questions? I
- 18:15do knot. Another language seems prudent. I would not keep certainly, I
- 18:23wouldn't park in my driveway the evil scary Painter's white nineteen seventy seven serial killer
- 18:32van. How many people keep driving around with the car they used to perpetrate
- 18:38the crimes. I would paint it and sell it. I would maybe dig
- 18:45a huge hole in a field and just bury the whole thing. I certainly
- 18:48wouldn't be driving around town where a cop could pull me over for a routine
- 18:53stop. You got an expired tag or a tailed is out by the way,
- 18:57Can you open the back doors at the van and let me take an
- 19:02inspection? Holly? Yet, why do you have a human body sized freezer
- 19:08that has bloodstains on it? Now? This seems easily avoided, I'm just
- 19:12saying. And then I finish with an idea that I admit is totally dark,
- 19:19but it has always bugged me. Why do killers leave the body where
- 19:25it is quickly and easily discovered. I think the whole point is as little
- 19:30evidence as possible. Why drop it in the river so it washes up on
- 19:36shore. Why just stick it under a few leaves and branches. It'll be
- 19:38found immediately if you bury it. Why only bury it eighteen inches? You're
- 19:44at the mercy of the next big rain. No what I would do,
- 19:48And I got this idea from somebody on my own Facebook page, so I'm
- 19:52not the only one who thinks like this. I would use a post hole
- 19:57digger, something that vertically and I would dig way down to about fifteen feet
- 20:04and I would bury the body vertically. I would fill the hole up to
- 20:11a certain height, and then I would add some rock near where the natural
- 20:15rock table would be, and then I don't know, a couple of feet
- 20:18under the surface, I would put roadkill, probably a dog. I'm not
- 20:25going to kill a dog. I'm not a monster, right, I'm not
- 20:29going to kill a dog. But unfortunately in our world there are dogs who
- 20:33are hit by cars and whatever. So I would find one and I would
- 20:37bury it maybe two feet under the actual surface of the ground. So the
- 20:45surge parties out. Everybody's doing the grid. They've got the cadaver dogs.
- 20:49Hey, they get a hit, the ground is doug up, there's a
- 20:55dog that has been decomposing. False positive. They check that spot off their
- 21:02list and they go away. I've been working it out in my brain.
- 21:08That seems like it might work now. Since that day, since that conversation,
- 21:15my wife has not looked at me the same way. She's like,
- 21:22you have a dark side? Something wrong with you? Who thinks like this?
- 21:30And I told her, Honey, I don't care how sweet and kind,
- 21:36cherub faced and wonderful you are, you have a dark side. I'm
- 21:41convinced every human being has a dark dungeon in the back of their skull somewhere.
- 21:48I don't care who you are. I don't care how many protests you
- 21:52hear from people who say their thoughts only consist of happy, happy, joy
- 21:56joy, lifetime movie harps and confetti and gold light. You know, I
- 22:00don't care how many people tell you that they're lying. I'm convinced everybody has
- 22:07a dark side, and I have been reading some research on this that having
- 22:14a dark side is not necessarily a bad thing. In fact, it might
- 22:19be healthy. Oh, we got to talk about this. I'm going to
- 22:23share more about what I have been reading on humanity's dark side. Next,
- 22:34we're talking about the dark side, the dark shade of human nature. Do
- 22:41we all have that dark side? I'll make a confession, since I've been
- 22:45talking about my own thoughts, mostly because I want you to feel safe to
- 22:49have those thoughts as well, or at least to entertain what they are,
- 22:53to understand why they exist, and so fine, I'll put myself out there
- 22:59and will share a specific from my past. It was one of my first
- 23:03radio jobs. I was in my early twenties. Granted, I was kind
- 23:08of a hot, tempered, piss and vinegar young twenty something, so I
- 23:12was pretty ramped up, but I had a boss at a Christian station.
- 23:19The owner of that business one of the worst people I have ever met.
- 23:29It is rare in my life that I use the word hate. I mean,
- 23:33I talk all the time about how we want to defeat hate on this
- 23:37planet. Maybe you are like me, desperate to find some redemption, some
- 23:41redeeming quality in everybody, or almost everybody. I am telling you this guy
- 23:51was just poison, insecure, temperamental, demeaning. He would just walk in.
- 23:57He's one of those guys when he would walk in the room, and
- 24:00when he walked in the building, the temperature cooled. Everybody got tense,
- 24:07speaking voices turned into whispers, and everybody was like, is he here?
- 24:12Is he still here? Has he left? Does anybody know when he's gonna
- 24:17leave? Because we couldn't wait for him to leave. His presence meant that
- 24:21at any moment he might turn the corner, walk into your room and make
- 24:26you feel like shit, just destroy you verbally, and then remind you that
- 24:33because he wrote the checks and he determined who got hired and fired, he
- 24:37essentially held your destiny, your job, maybe even your career and future in
- 24:44his hands and having made that proclamation and firmly put you in your place.
- 24:48He would turn and waltz out the door, conscience free. I hated that
- 24:56man, and I fantasized one day he'd walk in the room, dress me
- 25:02down, make me feel like shit, just go off, and I'd let
- 25:06him finish, and then I would throw him through plate glass. I think
- 25:12we've all had those moments where we say, it's a good thing for you.
- 25:18I'm civilized. A man named doctor Leon Seltzer. He has a doctor
- 25:25in both English and psychology. Former professor at Queen's College in Cleveland, State.
- 25:32He's written several books on psychology, and he writes the Evolution of the
- 25:37Self blog, and he has this article just how dark is your dark side?
- 25:45Doctor Seltzer says this, when we talk about having a dark side,
- 25:49where're generally calling attention to our most aggressive or lustful anti social instincts, or
- 25:57the mean spirited, blood thirsty belligerents presumably lurking deep within us, or our
- 26:04acting out impulses that would disrupt others' lives, if not outright decimate them,
- 26:11rape, mutilation, murder, unconscionable acts of thievery, betrayal, treachery,
- 26:18sadism, massochism, unbounded greed, incest, and so on. But what
- 26:25I'd like to suggest here is that perhaps your darkest fantasies shouldn't be understood as
- 26:30all that demonic, or at least they can be much more compassionately appreciated as
- 26:37audacious, disinhibited, primitive, grandiose, or hedonistic, as opposed to say,
- 26:45degrading, disgraceful, or nefarious. Freud, in his classic Civilization and
- 26:52its Discontents nineteen twenty nine, postulated that being part of a civilized society safeguards
- 26:59us from personal chaos, from being dominated by our moral id So, as
- 27:04civilized beings, we appoint communal authorities like police to protect us not simply from
- 27:11others' baser impulses, but also our own. Yet, to Freud, this
- 27:17necessary protection also culminates in our discontent, for we're thereby required to subdue our
- 27:25pleasure seeking instinctual drives. To live harmoniously with others, we must subdue our
- 27:33otherwise impetuous desires. I believe most people would agree that, although it's somewhat
- 27:40reductive, there's something profoundly true in Freud's assumptions about the human psyche. At
- 27:45the same time, I think that while we may be wired to at least
- 27:51imagine what it might be like to boldly and unabashedly follow our inborn predilections and
- 27:59without the slightest regard for how they might affect others, just envisioning ourselves engaging
- 28:06in such behaviors hardly means that finally we'd choose to enact them. After all,
- 28:12in so many ways, we need literally to rely on others for survival.
- 28:18Additionally, we're a gregarious species, and so wouldn't want to do things
- 28:23that might offend others and alienate them from us. Though we might not be
- 28:29able to resist fantasizing various acts that might enable us to freely pursue our altogether
- 28:36personal pleasure principle, the overwhelming majority of us are strongly motivated to restrain ourselves
- 28:44from actually carrying out such clearly sociopathic behaviors. Given these natural internal constraints,
- 28:52we need to question whether our dark side is ultimately all that dark. That
- 28:59is, we're generally cognizant that whatever fantasies we may have of power, revenge,
- 29:04conquest, or reckless expression of libido are just that fantasies, but by
- 29:11permitting ourselves to at least daydream about them, we can afford ourselves some kind
- 29:18of compensatory gratification. At a safe remove from reality. We can offer ourselves
- 29:25the alternative of imagining what in actuality we wouldn't really choose to do, or,
- 29:32for that matter, be, And in that sense, our dark side
- 29:36can be seen as well rather innocent. Permitting it to surface in day dreams
- 29:42represents a measured indulgence, offering us an escape from the pro social behavior that
- 29:49almost all of us regularly elect to participate in. For we do want and
- 29:55need to keep our social ties safe and secure. Though we may have a
- 30:00competitive streak in is, we also place a high value on interpersonal cooperation.
- 30:07So voluntarily we monitor our impulses and we take care to keep them in check.
- 30:15And as a respite from all our self discipline and forbearance, we periodically
- 30:22permit ourselves to fabricate a world than which our desires, however outrageous or antisocial,
- 30:29might nonetheless reign supreme. Given that our dark side embodies are more primitive
- 30:37pleasure or power seeking instincts, must we zealously avoid disclosing it or reject it
- 30:45as despicable, something other than respectably human, and therefore to be shunned and
- 30:51repudiated. In the end, such dark predictions really can't be seen as intrinsically
- 30:57culpable, and that most of them merely represent appetites or urges innates in all
- 31:04of us. So might we finally honor them, appreciating our most aggressive or
- 31:11erotic fantasies day dreams and many night dreams too, as a psychological safety valve.
- 31:21To me, unsatisfactory alternative is to view them shamefully, as depicting a
- 31:26part of us so abhorrent that it must be hidden from others and, if
- 31:30possible, from ourselves as well. Many psychology researchers have written about the practical
- 31:37utility of day dreams, for as already suggested, they can function positively as
- 31:45a much needed outlet for our frustrations, enabling us to give at least covert
- 31:51expression to impulses and inclinations we know would be foolhardy or hazardous to act out,
- 31:59and so are simply entertaining such fantasies doesn't really reflect any disastrous potential that
- 32:06must thereby be viewed as dark or depraved. The reason that horror movies are
- 32:13perennially popular, especially among the young, is that they too enable us to
- 32:17experience a safe release from or vicarious expression of our most primitive anti social instincts,
- 32:28and the same is true for many TV shows like Dexter. We are
- 32:35finally all animals, and what helps us to transcend the raw instincts of our
- 32:42more primitive, less evolved ancestors is that, in our highly developed interest in
- 32:49pro social behavior, almost all of us freely consent to forego id related pleasures,
- 32:57the pursuit of which we realize would hurt others and almost certainly come back
- 33:02to haunt us for both inner and outer balance. We have a fundamental need
- 33:08to express, however indirectly, our whole being, and we hardly need deny
- 33:15our forbidden thoughts, for they're only a relatively small segment of what's naturally inside
- 33:22us. Fully accepting our basic humanity actually necessitates that we acknowledge and make peace
- 33:29with our so called dark side, which finally is far less dark when we
- 33:36see it for what it is. As Carl Jung said, everyone carries a
- 33:40shadow, and the less it is embodied in the individual's conscious life, the
- 33:45blacker and denser. It is moreover, young believe that, in spite of
- 33:52its function as a reservoir for human darkness, or perhaps because of this,
- 33:59the shadow is the seat of creativity. And it makes perfect sense that if
- 34:05creativity entails a certain freedom from our customary constraints and thought and feeling, then
- 34:10giving ourselves the license to create also involves granting ourselves the privilege to inwardly explore
- 34:20and outwardly express the darker side of our latent tendencies and impulses. It may
- 34:27well be that what makes a work of our great in the first place is
- 34:30its universality, And what makes it universal is that it addresses so much of
- 34:36what resides deep inside us, the unprincipled and ignominious, as well as the
- 34:43wholesome, praiseworthy, and noble. I'll close with a set of four brief
- 34:47quotes, all of them suggest in just a few words much of what I've
- 34:52labored to express in so many more. And the quotes he includes are the
- 35:00This Anthony Hopkins, the actor who made so famous the character of Hannibal Lecter.
- 35:05Hopkins, the actor said, I think the healthy way to live is
- 35:09to make friends with the beast inside oneself, and that means not the beast,
- 35:15but the shadow, the dark side of one's nature. So have fun
- 35:20with it and accept everything about yourself. Self help author John Bradshaw said this
- 35:28evil is a source of moral intelligence, in the sense that we need to
- 35:32learn from our shadow, from our dark side, in order to be good.
- 35:38Sue Grafton, who is the author of so many detective novels, wrote
- 35:43this. She said, we all need to look into the dark side of
- 35:46our nature. That's where the energy is, the passion. People are afraid
- 35:52of that because it holds pieces of us we are busy denying. And the
- 35:58article finishes with a quote from film and stage actor Sheryl Lee, who said
- 36:02this, the more we deny that we have a dark side, the more
- 36:07power it has over us. I have calls with callers who apparently have a
- 36:15dark side lurking just beneath the skin, and let's find out what they have
- 36:22to say after this. I am about two and a half weeks out from
- 36:31speaking in Orlando, Florida. That's going to be March seventeenth. I've also
- 36:37got a whole bunch of dates, not just my speaking events, but conventions
- 36:40American Atheist and Freedom from Religion Foundation, Secular Student Alliance anyway, all of
- 36:46these events Los Angeles, Little Rock, Kansas City, Saint Louis, Denver,
- 36:52and more. Just scroll and find the city near you the Thinkingatheist dot
- 36:58com slash events. We continue talking about our dark side, the uncivilized primate
- 37:09lurking just beneath the skin of the civilized primate. Three one seven is it?
- 37:15Josh? Can you hear me? Uh? Yeah? What do you
- 37:20think about this? My father was put on drugs when he was a baby,
- 37:25and when he met my mother, he overdosed a lot, was taken
- 37:30to a hospital, was taken off the drugs, but because he had such
- 37:34a history with drugs, he hallucinated an angel and thought God was talking to
- 37:37him. And so with this new found faith, he then indoctrinated all of
- 37:44my siblings, which are five of us, into his faith. And when
- 37:47I was a kid growing up, I was never taught critical thinking. I
- 37:52was never taught like who I am. Truly, when I was about eleven,
- 37:58my parents both heavy evangelicals. My world was that house. My world
- 38:04was that perception of what my father taught us, and so I never knew
- 38:08anything outside of it. And we were homeschooled, living in the country,
- 38:14and so as a kid growing up, I thought that getting beat with a
- 38:19mighty might attachment was normal. I thought when my dad would use a pig
- 38:24whip on us, that was normal. I thought when he screamed and yelled
- 38:30and did terrible things, that was normal, because that was my world.
- 38:34But as I got older, it was harder and harder for him to keep
- 38:37that world together. And eventually I started asking questions and he started putting me
- 38:44under more dogma, making me feel bad, trying to destroy my sense of
- 38:47self, trying to put me back under that perception of what he wants me
- 38:51to be. He stopped schooling me and my twin brother because, according to
- 38:55my parents, what would you do with an education. When I was about
- 39:00twenty five or twenty six, that's when the brainwashing pretty much totally broke.
- 39:06I was suicidal and I didn't know myself. I remember when I was leaving
- 39:12the house, I went up to the train tracks and started crying because I
- 39:16had no education. I didn't even know how to fill out a check.
- 39:21I realized that I didn't matter. They were just using the Bible in order
- 39:28to abuse all my siblings and me and they just didn't care. Do you
- 39:35ever find yourself having dark thoughts about all of this? Well, the way
- 39:40that I've gotten over dark thoughts, especially in the early days of this,
- 39:45was pretty much trying to gain as much knowledge as humanly possible. My thing
- 39:50is trying to use logic and reason and trying to learn who my father really
- 39:54is and my mother. It's what kept the bad thoughts away. I mean,
- 40:00with what you said, you wanted to take that guy who's a dick
- 40:04to you and throw them out a window. Yeah, I've had those thoughts.
- 40:07I think everybody at some point has had those thoughts when it comes to
- 40:10fantasizing and having a dark side. Now that I can think critically and logically,
- 40:16oh hell yeah, there's many times I wanted to go over to their
- 40:21house, kick the door in, run up to this guy and just pick
- 40:24him off the ground and make him realize, oh shit, he's going to
- 40:29kick my hat. But the thing is, I think I've come to the
- 40:34point now where I don't even feel sorry anymore. I just look at him
- 40:38and I'm like, what hell did you go through to make you into such
- 40:43a lunatic? That's actually an important point. Many of the abusers have been
- 40:47abused, many of the victimizers are in some ways victims. It sounds like
- 40:53that we're excusing the behavior. The fact that you have that perspective is just,
- 41:00I think, real maturity. So thank you for being a part of
- 41:04the conversation. This is actually a little more sort of sobering than I had
- 41:07started. I feel like, I hope I'm doing your call justice after I
- 41:10do a whole twenty minute ranch full of I'm cracking jokes about crime scenes,
- 41:15you know. But no, no, you're good, Josh, Breathe the
- 41:20free air, my friend, and thanks for being a part of today's broadcast.
- 41:23It's been great talking with you, you two, sir, all right,
- 41:27take care David at nine one nine, are you there? Nice?
- 41:34That's dark side, I definitely have one. Never had a hard life.
- 41:39I grew up in a not very rich household at all. My father was
- 41:44a Baptist minister in the North American Baptist so wealth was the only privilege I
- 41:51wasn't born with. And haven't had any major blows in my life. I'm
- 41:55sixty eight almost and you know, a couple medical things, but nothing really
- 42:00big, So no life experience to make me have dark thoughts, especially towards
- 42:08myself, but I have them. I'm a huge fan of Dexter, and
- 42:15you know, I watched that show, and I think of how I might
- 42:16want to dispose of somebody so I couldn't get caught. And there's a certain
- 42:22public figure whom I would love to see a particular brand of great harm come
- 42:29to. And I won't go into details, stopping there for a second because
- 42:32I think you and I might be in the zip code. But I try
- 42:35to frame it like this. I would never want external harm to come,
- 42:39but if they had a sudden aneurism, I would not be all that grieved.
- 42:45Is that a terrible thing to say? I wish I could see me
- 42:47nodding, and yes, that's exactly where I'm at. And I'd wish a
- 42:52certain particular outcomes of that said aneurysm. That's a hard thing to say.
- 42:59Yeah, And like, we have someone down the street from me who flew
- 43:04a Trump flag constantly. Now he fled I live in Virginia. Now he
- 43:07flies underneath the American flag. He's got a youngin flag. And I drive
- 43:14fast at and I think of like parking in the high school parking lot across
- 43:17from that during school with binoculars to check out the flag pole, and then
- 43:22coming by at night and parking around a corner dressed all in black, and
- 43:25I'm gonna cut that frickin' youngkin flag down. And it's just a I think
- 43:31it's literally it's a it's a healthy release, assuming you don't act on it,
- 43:37of course, but just entertaining these thoughts is sort of the same as
- 43:42watching the true crime shows and things like that. Thanks for calling, and
- 43:46thanks for the kind words. I enjoyed. I enjoy your I appreciate you
- 43:51so very much. Thanks man. Take care. Jenny at two zero nine,
- 43:59thanks for waiting. Are you there, Yes, I'm here. Recently
- 44:04I've been holding back my dark side, but I've come to a conclusion that
- 44:08with all these attacks on women's healthcare and now they're going after ibs, which
- 44:15that is the only way I got one of my grandsons, it makes them
- 44:20so angry. These people don't even have a medical degree and they make decisions
- 44:25on women. So now, you know, I try to channel it.
- 44:30You know, it's like, should we start protesting churches? Should we do
- 44:34stuff? No, I think we need to start a movement to take away
- 44:37their Dackstreet exemption. Jenny, let me give some quick context to people who
- 44:42aren't in the know, especially that we have an international audience. The Alabama
- 44:46Supreme Court just ruled that frozen embryos are human beings and if anyone destroys an
- 44:57embryo, that's essentially murder, kind of murder. And now there are organizations
- 45:02who are shutting down. They're in vitro fertilization programs because you essentially, they
- 45:09don't want to be prosecuted for murder. And there's all these other things going
- 45:13on. The couples who are going through IVF treatments are horrified. It is
- 45:17just traumatizing and an assault on human rights, and it's just stupid. I
- 45:22saw somebody and they showed they had a dozen eggs in the passenger seat of
- 45:27their car, and they said, now I'm going to drive in the hov
- 45:30lane because now I have thirteen people in the car according to the Alabama Supreme
- 45:36Court. And you're right, they don't have medical degrees. They're spouting the
- 45:38name of God every ten seconds. Zalots. The Christian nationalists, they are
- 45:44using xelotry and ideology to make law, and they're forcing their limited value system
- 45:50down everybody else's throats and it makes us enraged. And I think your anger
- 45:53is absolutely understandable. Jenny, Yeah. I mean I listen to people all
- 45:58the time, and older people who are really heartbroken that their kids aren't even
- 46:04going to give them grandchildren because of the way the situations are going. They
- 46:08don't feel safe, and I don't blame them. My two daughters went through
- 46:13pregnancy during COVID and one had to do IVF, and she went through so
- 46:20much to have my grandson that you know, I was just heart wrenching to
- 46:25me because I couldn't be so close to her and everything. But I do
- 46:30you know, at one point my girls had said maybe we're not going to
- 46:32have kids, you know, And I couldn't hold it against them, But
- 46:37I do know more and more women are deciding either to have their tips tied
- 46:42or whatever because they don't want to be put in bad situations and looked on
- 46:45as a second class citizen. Doesn't the dark part of us occasionally admit to
- 46:51saying, wouldn't it be nice to take all of the Alabama Supreme Court who
- 46:55voted for this and put them in a van and them to an island surrounded
- 47:01by sharks and alligators and radio. It's just an island that they cannot leave,
- 47:08and you know, give them and then the rest of us go and
- 47:14evolve society. You know, you go over here and you be small and
- 47:17restrictive and paranoid and fearful and controlling. Have a nice day, you guys
- 47:22ruin each other's lives. We're going to go over here and evolve as a
- 47:25species. I do fantasize about that, yeah, I mean, the one
- 47:29of the Supreme Court judges down there talks about how there's some sort of seven
- 47:36pillar Christian thing that they're trying to rule all parts of government, and I'm
- 47:42like, are you freaking kidding me? You know, what happens in Alabama
- 47:47is really a reflection of what's happening in Bible Belt states, key parts of
- 47:52the United States. You know, they don't just want to do this in
- 47:55one part of the country. They have a mission to overtake the colorlture.
- 48:00They want Gilead. Your anger is understandable, and I think it's understandable if
- 48:05you and I occasionally go back into our dark closet and say, what if
- 48:08something happened to those guys and we didn't have to worry about him anymore.
- 48:14We don't want harm to come to them. I'm just saying, if the
- 48:15aliens came, you know, if you're going to probe anybody, can you
- 48:21probe the people on the Alabama Supreme Court and keep them all night? You
- 48:23know, they don't have to be anywhere. I'm just saying, Jenny,
- 48:27thanks for calling this show, and hang in there. Okay, okay,
- 48:30all later. She is referring to what's called the Seven Mountains mandate. There
- 48:37are seven aspects of society that hardline Christianity wants to overtake. Family, religion,
- 48:45education, media, entertainment, business, and government. If you conquer
- 48:51all seven of those mandates, you have conquered the culture. And that is
- 48:55what is being invoked at the level of the Alabama Supreme Court. So I'm
- 49:00going to quickly try to squeeze in two more A zero one? Is it?
- 49:07Mark? What do you have? I'm an AI optimist, but I
- 49:12naively hold the idea that the solution to evil AI is more AI. However,
- 49:20this new creature AI is watching us, and the training data that it's
- 49:28getting is not necessarily showing humanity in the most flattering way. So I mean
- 49:35there's a lot of ways that AI could be good, but there are so
- 49:38many ways that it could go bad. So I've kind of come to the
- 49:43conclusion that it may start looking at the rotten things we do and come to
- 49:51a conclusion that that's how we prefer to be treated. So are we talking
- 49:55sky in that here? Oh? I think it's far worse in that.
- 50:00You know, some cultures they have demons in their mythology called thought form,
- 50:06where literally the demon itself is a is an incantate, a result of an
- 50:12incantation or the imagination of the sorcerer or the whoever. And I think that's
- 50:19kind of what we're making. This is an interesting angle. So let's say
- 50:22that artificial intelligence becomes sentient. It is conscious, It is a conscious mind,
- 50:30and it sees the darkness that infects the human race and the horrible things
- 50:37we do to each other, right, the inhumanity of humanity, And even
- 50:43if it thinks it's acting in a benevolent way, it's saying, oh,
- 50:46they must really like that, and then it begins to build societal models based
- 50:53on darkness, pain, and cruelty. You've cut My hypothesis is exactly spot
- 50:59on. That's freaking scary. Uh oh, they will like, oh,
- 51:02how many people murder each other? They must love murder? Well AAI AI.
- 51:09I mean there are lots of different flavors of AI, but generally speaking,
- 51:15AI is optimized for certain objectives. And if it comes to the conclusion
- 51:22and see, we're we're not telling you we're not. Yeah, we have
- 51:24some guardrails that we put up, but more and more as cognitive powers become
- 51:30super intelligent, which is soon, frighteningly soon, it's going to come up
- 51:36with its own moral imperative that human beings scarcely have the capacity to under even
- 51:42begin to understand, even conceptually, let alone practically. Well, let me
- 51:47ask you this. The vast majority of us do not act in anti social
- 51:52ways. We are pro social creatures. So I believe there is more kindness,
- 52:00there is more benevolence, there's more charity, there's more good, And
- 52:06so wouldn't an artificial consciousness see that? And then way it's actions based on
- 52:14how much good and how much evil there is in our society. Well,
- 52:17I think the word if is doing a whole lot of heavy lifting. I
- 52:22can't help when I think about this scenario. I can't help to think about
- 52:24the old Santa Claus is coming to town lyrics. It sees you when you're
- 52:30sleeping, it sees you when you're awake. It knows if you've been bad
- 52:35or good, so be good for goodness sake. And I think that's important
- 52:39to remember because it is watching it and being good and benevolent to one another
- 52:46might not just be a good thing to do in and of itself, but
- 52:50it might be a survival strategy for us as humans. Interesting I've spoke to
- 52:55Professor Nita Farahani, who is an expert in AI and is a big proponent
- 53:01of cognitive liberty. As more and more in the neuralink age, you know,
- 53:06people are talking about how what's happening under the skull can be scanned and
- 53:10read at least to a degree. What if AI could see our dark sides,
- 53:15the stuff we don't show everybody and somehow measure that and think, Oh,
- 53:22they enjoy that. They got a you know, they got an endorphin
- 53:24rush from Seth fantasizing about throwing his evil boss through the window. Maybe will
- 53:31weigh society in that way? Oh yeah, yeah, that's horrifying. Mark,
- 53:36thanks for that. Think, Hey, I'm going to have a question
- 53:38quickly. And since you're an AI guy, I don't want to sound like
- 53:43the guy resistant to new technologies. I don't want to be the person who's
- 53:45like, wow, these kids today, you know and back when I was.
- 53:51I know, you're just a lud eyed as the next genera. I
- 53:53know someone call me a lud eye the other day, and I'm like,
- 53:55no, no, no. I think raising legitimate concerns about new technicies that
- 54:00may start thinking for themselves. And more than that, I'm a little bit
- 54:05nervous about the replacing of human creators. I love the idea of technology lightening
- 54:12the service load of humanity, a lot of the menial load, making our
- 54:17lives easier and less laborious in that way. I like the idea of tools
- 54:24for creation human creation. What's starting to bother me is this idea that people
- 54:30now who are painters and who are animators, and they make art and music
- 54:37and all these things, they are now in competition with machines or software that
- 54:44can do it for nothing, sometimes meaning that they've lost their livelihood or in
- 54:50some ways might be replaced by the machines. I don't think that's hyperbole,
- 54:53and it kind of grieves me. I'm working on a project right now,
- 54:58Mark, I'm trying to do a visual life version of the story of us,
- 55:01the story of you, And so I'm using images of the universe.
- 55:06And there were supernova's and the Big Bang and planet Earth and whatnot. And
- 55:09for half a second I thought, Wow, I could use AI images for
- 55:14this, and I could probably do it pretty cheaply. And then I thought
- 55:16about all of the people who create these animations and shoot these videos of the
- 55:22night sky and the faces and the breeze and the close ups of the eyes.
- 55:27You know, they lit the scene and frame the camera and they put
- 55:30it together. And I think I'm replacing them. What does that do to
- 55:35their lives? What statement am I making about humanity? If I rest so
- 55:38much on the machines for the creative part of expression. That grieves me.
- 55:44Do you have an opinion? Mark? Am I wrong there? I do
- 55:46both academic and real. I'm a first time novelist, and I will not
- 55:51plug my own book. But I realized during the editing process and when I
- 55:55was having it converted to an audiobook, that I like would be one of
- 56:00the last human authors ever, which is little consolation to the reality that authors
- 56:08and musicians and entertainers and surgeons and CPAs and the list goes on and on
- 56:17are being replaced by a machine. And that you're right, It isn't hyperbole.
- 56:22It's absolutely real, and it's happening in front of our very eyes,
- 56:27and it's happening across all domains, all of it. Mark, When I
- 56:31was in a video as a video producer, and back then, we would
- 56:36spend you know, ten grand for an HD video camera. Oh, it's
- 56:40a big deal. You know, it shoots ten adp wow, And it
- 56:44was a lot of money. And now you can shoot four K or higher
- 56:46on a cell phone and everybody's got one. So the industry changed and we
- 56:52saw a lot of video houses closed and everybody had to adapt. I think
- 56:55that's different. You know, technology evolves, we as a society have to
- 57:00evolve with it. I think the creation of thinking machines that might replace the
- 57:07creator, the human creator, I think that's a different conversation. That doesn't
- 57:12make us lattites, does it, Mark, No, Seth. This creature
- 57:16is trespassing on what has normally been a very selfish realm of humanity. Our
- 57:23ability to think, our ability to create, is there anything more. You
- 57:31know, I'm really kind of a loss for words because I can't think of
- 57:36an allegory that's worse than the reality. I don't know. There are some
- 57:39I've seen who are like, well, that's going to happen anyway, so
- 57:43let's find a way to go with it. What's that line, I'd rather
- 57:45be a pet than cattle. You know, if it's going to take over,
- 57:50at least I'm going to be involved in the process some way. But
- 57:52I feel like, at some point, don't we as a society, as
- 57:55a species, consciously say we're going to partition this out. As flawed as
- 58:00it is and sometimes as slow and imperfect as it is, but this is
- 58:04a human thing where humans do this and the machines will do that. I
- 58:08don't think it's ever going to happen, but I am watching closely. And
- 58:12you know, if AI can ever read the human dark side and interprets that
- 58:15dark side in the wrong way, then maybe it is Skynet or worse.
- 58:21I don't know. Build a bunker. Let's build a bunker. Mark,
- 58:24Yeah, yeah, all right, thank you, sir. I appreciate your
- 58:28man hanging there. We may have to do a whole broadcast on AI.
- 58:31I think everybody. Most people have an opinion, and they're polarized opinions.
- 58:36I've talked to some people who were like, you know, it is what
- 58:38it is. You're just resisting change. Just sound like your parents. And
- 58:44there are other people who are saying this is foreign territory. The technology is
- 58:50developing faster than our development of the understanding of the consequences. We got to
- 58:55slow down. I think that's the message everybody, to slow down. Because
- 59:00we can do it, doesn't mean we should because it becomes exponential. Maybe
- 59:04that's a whole show. Would you welcome a show like that? Would you
- 59:07want to have those discussions and depth for zero four? You've been so patient,
- 59:12Thanks for waiting. What's your name for Darth? We're talking about the
- 59:15dark side. What do you have for us? Okay? Well, I
- 59:17was thinking about the Crench gets route of star Ture where Kirk the transport being
- 59:23split him in two and one was the very kind, u civil but weak
- 59:30indecistient. He's very indecisive Kirk, and the other was strong and there is
- 59:35such a work, very animalstic and spock headswich thing to him that's inside of
- 59:38you. It's part of what makes you such a magnificent starship captain. Without
- 59:44that, you are not Kirk. So it is in us. It's what
- 59:47Mark Twain said that most of us are like the shining bright moon, you
- 59:53know, in the darkest night. But each of us has a dark side
- 59:57that you should ever suit. And my uncle said that coming back from war,
- 1:00:00and he learned that you could cradle a child and embrace a woman and
- 1:00:05also kill a man to defend it. So it's that part is in us.
- 1:00:10It's part of the reason why the book jack O and Hyde was written
- 1:00:15because he was fascinated how each human has both of those in us. It's
- 1:00:20in us, you know, and one, as Kirk discovered, one controls
- 1:00:24the other. But without that, we're not who we think we are.
- 1:00:29We're something all together different. It's in you. It's part of what makes
- 1:00:34you such a magnificent starship captain. But that controls that side of you.
- 1:00:39The nice Kirk was indecisive, he was weak, he couldn't lead, and
- 1:00:44he said, no, we've got we've got to find a way to put
- 1:00:45you back together again so that you can be the Kirk that is this magnificent
- 1:00:51commander. I will say that Evil Spock was a badass. Evil Spock with
- 1:00:58the goat wasn't He was just a badass. He was a bad He was
- 1:01:01a badass, badass. Bernard, you're awesome. Thanks for capping the show
- 1:01:07and hang in there. Okay, thank you, sir. All right,
- 1:01:09So I want to I want to tell you the other day. I'll look,
- 1:01:12you got the picture, but I saw a man at the gas pump
- 1:01:15a few days ago and he could be your brother. I mean, I
- 1:01:20said, you need you need to behave yourself because you have a doctor.
- 1:01:24There's somebody out there that looks you want to mistake I don't. I don't
- 1:01:28want him to be mistaken for you. You behave yourself. All right,
- 1:01:34Thanks, I'll send the picture, all right. Appreciate you. Brother.
- 1:01:40That's Garry. Is somebody out there, some poor sap looks like me.
- 1:01:46I am so very sorry. I don't think my parents have anything to tell
- 1:01:51me. Speaking of Dexter, I fantasized about consequences for the people who wrote
- 1:01:58season eight and the finale of Dexter, because I think there might have to
- 1:02:02be consequences. I just had to throw that out there. As we finish
- 1:02:08our conversation today about the dark Side. I appreciate you listening, thanks for
- 1:02:15putting up with your host. I'll see you back here next time. Follow
- 1:02:19the Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos,
- 1:02:24products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to
- 1:02:29atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions.
- 1:02:34Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.