Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Tesla Price Bump, Sub-Prime Loans On the Rise, Auto Advertising Down
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Tuesday, May 19th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. This is Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:06Today we're talking about Tesla's price bump, subprime loans on the rise, and auto advertising is down overall from automakers. If we aren't cool- What does that mean for dealers?
- 0:16The people really wanna know who I be and who I be. We're gonna talk about- Trust I stay with me, see me. If it's said it once, no need to repeat. Run up on me, watch you fall on me...
- 0:17what that means for the, the networks. I mean- 'Cause we spendy over here. We definitely- You know... spend. We could-- I think automotive, uh, uh, combined could take Google down. Could literally- [laughs]...
- 0:29tank Google. If everybody was like, "You know what? Bump that," you know. Little show, little show of force. Literally. We're gonna stop spending- Yeah... for today. Yeah. [laughs] Zuckerberg. Yeah.
- 0:38Oh, yeah, just like a one-day freeze. Yeah. Everyone in auto, one-day freeze- Yeah... on Meta and Google. Yeah. Oh my. [laughs] It's, it's over. It's over. Sounds like union work to me. Yeah. [laughs] Oh.
- 0:52Oh, we had so much fun- That's great... we had so much fun just, uh, reconnecting with a lot of you yesterday. If you went to ASOTU CON, we released the full photo set of everything we took. Um, now you can have it.
- 1:03Go find yourself and your friends. Share them, post them, tag them, keep them, show them to your mom. Look how cool I look. You know, aren't you proud? Show them to your mom. Show them to your mom.
- 1:11[laughs] That's what you should do. What else is going on this week? This is that little after ASOTU CON lull, right?
- 1:17Oh, one of the things that's going on is, uh, our, our primary keynote from autoindustry.ai with-- that featured Zach Shefska deploying 100 AI agents to mystery shop 100 dealers. Yes.
- 1:28It's kind of doing a thing on YouTube right now, and that conversation is ramping up really quickly. Um, if you're don't subscribe to it, you should subscribe to, uh, the newsletter. Go to autoindustry.ai.
- 1:38A great one got released today. Um, if you just want a, just a little drip feed once a week on how to apply AI to retail auto, see what some other people are doing, that is the place for you to be.
- 1:48That's the one, for sure. The, the, the newsletter today is dialed in, and we gave you, we gave you some, some freebies in there.
- 1:54So, uh, go check it out, or you can go to autoindustry.ai, and it's the first article on there. So, uh, that, that's the one. Yes. All right, let's talk about some news.
- 2:03Tesla just bumped prices on several higher trim Model Y variants for the first time in two years, signaling that confidence, uh, in EV demand may be heating back up.
- 2:12Meanwhile, Wall Street is still trying to decide whether or not Tesla's stock is going ahead or if it's stuck.
- 2:18Tesla raised prices by $1,000 on the Model Y premium rear wheel drive and all-wheel drive trims, while the performance trim climbed by $500.
- 2:25The entry-level Model Y version stayed unchanged, saying they're trying to protect their affordability and testing some premium, uh, pricing options.
- 2:33Analysts point to rising gas prices and battery material costs as possible drivers behind the move.
- 2:39Despite the pricing confidence, Tesla's stock did slide 4% on Friday and dipped again on Monday as investors weigh slowing momentum and, uh, technical buy points. Yeah, I mean,
- 2:52I think the, the one thing that this article missed is that that legal battle with OpenAI and, and Elon, like, even though it is completely separate from Tesla, anytime- When you lose, you lose, right?
- 3:02You lose, you lose- Confidence slips... when your brand, when your brand's persona is a person- Yeah... and not just a brand. Elon versus Altman. Like, you lose overall. Yeah. Yeah.
- 3:09Yeah, so I, I think that's, that's part and parcel to it. The, the, the raise on pricing, they haven't raised prices on the Model Y for two years. That's, that's unheard of- Yep... in, in any retail auto.
- 3:22So I don't think it's gonna, gonna sway buyers at all. Um, I'm honestly surprised that some of those upper trims haven't seen more of a price hike.
- 3:29The Model Y is still, you know, considered, I, I, I think should be considered in, in an affordability matrix based on the features available, right? It's the best-selling car in America.
- 3:39Maybe not everyone will buy it, but- Right? Yeah. Yep. Do you think that might give you a little, little leeway on the higher trims if it's the best-selling car in America? Yeah. I think it does. Why not?
- 3:46I think it does. Speaking of the dollars- Stop... and the cents- Segway. Time.
- 3:52[upbeat music] Auto lenders diving deeper into subprime financing as affordability pressures are pushing buyers back into the market, and lenders are getting more aggressive chasing deals, meaning more approvals but also higher payments and longer loan terms.
- 4:07Subprime and deep subprime borrowers made up 15.4% of all auto loans and leases in Q4 last year, the highest share since 2021. Average interest rates, 13.2% for subprime, 22% for deep subprime.
- 4:23Dealers are saying lenders are digging a little deeper rather than dramatically lowering their standards, helped by better data and digital document verification. So a little safer there.
- 4:32They can be more flexible on lending. Experience Melinda Zabriskie summed it up saying, quote, "As affordability remains top of mind, both lenders and consumers are adapting."
- 4:42Yeah, I mean, we, we saw this early actually with, uh, w- with a company like-- companies like Upstart- Mm-hmm...
- 4:48that, uh, changed their, their matrix on how they bought into subprime with a lot less than just a credit score.
- 4:55You know, uh, the fact that you can validate offli- uh, you know, offline elements a lot quicker, you can get some documentation digitally, connect payments up.
- 5:05You know, it, it gives some of these lenders the ability to buy a bit deeper in subprime, and that's gonna have to happen if we're gonna wanna continue to not just have a single side of market- marketplace.
- 5:16So I, I, you know, I haven't talked to any dealers about what that subprime lending looks like, but this is a, this is a highlight into, "Hey, look, you know, we, we've gotta serve this market," and, and thankfully the lenders are, are playing ball.
- 5:30You know, there's a graph in this story that I don't think we have, but it shows the curve of the percentage of subprime borrowers, and it was still, I would say, 30% higher pre-COVID. Yep.
- 5:43So it's like the smiley face where-- the smiley face is, you know, the other side is catching up now, and we're getting back there.
- 5:49But still, we're not where we were pre-COVID, so I think that's, like, a good measure to point, seems like- And most of that is just because they can't afford the payments. Exactly.
- 5:56Not, not that the lenders aren't willing to, to, to, to lend. It's just- Exactly... you know. But now all the flexible stuff, the longer loan terms, so, um-It's a little-- It's where we're heading.
- 6:05Speaking of where we're heading- Stop. Sigway Turn. It was a train. This smile isn't going up for the re-advertisers. Not at all. So for decades, automotive advertising practically was the ad industry.
- 6:15But now shrinking OEM budgets, EV uncertainty, and Tesla-style marketing strategies are changing the game, and auto share of ad spend is slipping below a historic benchmark.
- 6:24Automotive advertising, this includes, uh, the, the tier one, is projected to float-- fall below 10% of total ad category spend for the first time ever as tracked by guideline.
- 6:35The category shrank roughly 7% in 2025, with spending pressure continuing into 2026. Analysts point to weaker EV momentum and automakers are scaling back electric initiatives as major contributors to their ad spend. Hmm.
- 6:48Newer brands are ditching traditional, quote, "big splash" campaigns. We saw that at, at the Super Bowl this year in favor of leaner marketing approaches following Tesla's no advertising playbook.
- 6:59Uh, well, I mean, I think a lot of this pullback is from the automakers, not necessarily from tier three.
- 7:04Um, but it makes sense that we're seeing the pullback because the EV thing alone, just how many advertisements do, do we see for EV? Big production, small production, $7,500 off, all at the tier one level.
- 7:15What this really means, if they're pulling back that much, is that this was a big, like, top-of-funnel approach that dealers counted on the OEMs to spend.
- 7:25Um, there's really no recourse there, and I think this is just more of an incentive and, uh, an imperative really for dealers to invest in brand-building activity.
- 7:35Because when you invest in brand-building activity, it doesn't matter what the automaker's doing locally or regionally, people still decide to buy from you regardless of what kind of car they're buying, especially if you have a group and you have multiple ads.
- 7:46So, uh, can't rely on them to do it. They're not gonna do it. Can't- They're not doing it... can't rely on those OEMs. They're cut. They're- Build brand, build community. Yeah. OEMs will do the thing.
- 7:55They have a lot of trouble. They have a lot of things to deal with right now. They do. Let's give them, let's give them that. I tell you what. Those OEMs, I, I just-- I, I would not wanna be in their shoes.
- 8:02They're dealing with such a complexity thing. Obviously watching all the things, how are we gonna invest more in R&D and try to make our cars more affordable so that we compete with the walls that are closing in. Mm.
- 8:12Yeah. Not an easy job. Some serious walls. But look- So many walls... we're sure that you don't have an easy job, too. If you're watching this show, you probably don't have an easy job.
- 8:19But that doesn't mean you don't have a really fulfilling job. So we hope we made it a little more fulfilling for you today, so you can go out there, do that for other people. We'll see you here first thing tomorrow.
- 8:27[upbeat music]