Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 72: The Stories that Shaped France in 2020 with guests Lauren Collins and Aida Alami
Transcript
- 0:07You listening to the New Paris, I'm your host Lindsay tributo.
- 0:12This is the final episode of this Trainwreck year but to
- 0:17recap in a way that goes beyond, the specifically wrenching
- 0:20horror of covid, I'm joined by my friends and regular guests,
- 0:23Lauren Collins and Ida, Ida me. We're going to chat about some
- 0:26of the other big stories that shaped France in 2012.
- 0:30Auntie. All right, ladies, let's get
- 0:32right to it. If I may, I'll mention the pre
- 0:35covid municipal election drama. For those who don't remember,
- 0:39Benjamin Coffeyville who was Mac Halls candidate was forced to
- 0:44drop out of the race for a video sexting Scandal and was replaced
- 0:48by the then Health Minister and his bosom.
- 0:51But for me the Scandal here is is really twofold.
- 0:53And his booze on says she knew of the scale of the coronavirus
- 0:56threat back. In January alerted, the
- 0:59president and the Prime Minister but Find any way to run for
- 1:02mayor. Knowing what we would know by
- 1:05March, this is obviously a very bad look.
- 1:08I know there's some thinking that she was sort of stuck
- 1:12between a rock and a hard place. She didn't really have a choice.
- 1:14She was thrown in as I done. And I were talking about just
- 1:18before this recording about how she was sort of a, the
- 1:24scapegoat, any other thoughts on this particular start of the
- 1:27year, because now we're not hearing anything about annulus
- 1:29bosom, but she was really in the Media of quite a bit in the
- 1:32beginning but we are not hearing about Ana's Vision but I'm
- 1:36actually thinking about Anna's boozing in that France started
- 1:40vaccinating last week. So far the rollout has been
- 1:44conspicuously slow. I think we evacuated 70 people.
- 1:50Anyway, know it's funny, I was just thinking about this this
- 1:52morning because I was reading something where the health
- 1:56Minister was saying, it's not that we don't have the vaccines,
- 1:59we're just taking a progressive approach and immediately it was
- 2:03like flies flashback masks. It's not that we don't have the
- 2:07masks, which we now know they didn't.
- 2:09That is a legacy of Enya Suzanne for me was just you know and
- 2:15erosion of trust in government figures that you really want to
- 2:18be trusting right now. So I guess that's yes that's her
- 2:21big Legacy. Is that the the the source of
- 2:25Trust can be traced back to her and then everybody who came just
- 2:30after her, I mean frankly the only one but when I'm here I
- 2:34mean we're taking a chronological approach and it's
- 2:38like as we all know, whatever january/february 2020 seems so
- 2:43long ago but you say ideas but then I say lied to us about
- 2:49masks is kind of what remains here for me.
- 2:52And you know these final days of December.
- 2:55T20. Okay, well, so that that's two
- 3:00links, a little bit to to covid something that doesn't link to
- 3:03covid. Is the the fact that France was
- 3:06also rocked by a literary pedophilia scandal with a very
- 3:11thorough New York Times report about Gabriella, met Sniff and
- 3:14the elites who protected him. What do you make about this?
- 3:16I know both of you are big fans of Novi.
- 3:19Who led the the report for the New York Times and like found
- 3:24Gabrielle met Sniff and Italy it Like, you know, his like go to
- 3:27hotel and and and it's interesting to me is that this
- 3:32story highlights the the radical different, like, the radical
- 3:37difference in treatment of this issue from The French Press
- 3:41because no one went so far as to track him down in the French
- 3:45media. But anyway, what what give us
- 3:47like, give us one of you give us a recap of sort of like why this
- 3:51was such a big deal. I think this was a big deal for
- 3:53many reasons, one of them Um, is that the year started with the,
- 3:57this is a ceremony with Polanski getting getting an award and the
- 4:04French media, and I was talking about it and so on.
- 4:06And then the New York Times who visits the story that no one
- 4:10bothered to look into. And I mean, there's so many
- 4:14prominent men in France or just protected by Everyone by
- 4:18politicians by the media, by intellectual by artists, and
- 4:23it's just part of a larger Or system and I'm sure there are
- 4:27more stories that could be done, more things to talk about.
- 4:31And what I find interesting is that it kind of started, this
- 4:34huge feud between France and the New York Times earlier this
- 4:38year. Yeah, this is because I think
- 4:41they're they're just not used to the 22.
- 4:46Let me just sometimes looking into things that way they're
- 4:50used to foreign correspondence writing more soft stories or
- 4:54stories that kind of enjoy it. Celebrate the the French culture
- 4:59and and I thought that was a very interesting start of the
- 5:03year in terms of covering France and how it evolved throughout
- 5:05the year. Well, so I think like where the
- 5:09the the role of a journalist is to challenge and to go deeper,
- 5:13right? And it doesn't seem like the
- 5:14French or willing to do that. At.
- 5:18No, I think we should when you pay that.
- 5:20I mean, the story was ripe for the picking the kind of
- 5:26re-examination of the case was spurred by Vanessa Springer has
- 5:31Memoir, right? So, I mean, she had the, you
- 5:37know, she had the courage and the wherewithal to write this
- 5:42book saying, hey, all this start horrible stuff, happened every
- 5:47adult, both in my, you know, in my personal life and in public
- 5:54institutions, in in school, my doctor in the literary estate,
- 6:00just basically everyone who should have protected me didn't,
- 6:04and she kind of like, laid a lot of it out and, you know, nor I
- 6:11had the, the kind of wisdom to go and Connect the dots and take
- 6:19the story further and anyway, it was just, it was surprising that
- 6:27nobody else. I mean, myself included, I was
- 6:29like, well, I should have gone in tract, Matt, snuff down, and
- 6:33but it was like all there and it has been for a number of years.
- 6:38Although the, you know, the publication of Vanessa's finger
- 6:41has book really added a lot of evidence, but it, but anyway,
- 6:45which is, which is just to say, like, I think itís right to say
- 6:51that you know a lot of people could have done this story and
- 6:54for one reason or another didn't.
- 6:56Hmm. It's very it's obviously very
- 7:00disconcerting because there are other figures like him who are
- 7:02still sort of going around on with without consequences for
- 7:09their actions. And you know, he's certainly not
- 7:11the only one, obviously we talked a lot about Roman
- 7:13Polanski. Woody, Allen is very much
- 7:15protected here, While being a quite a polarizing figure or
- 7:21perhaps more and more polarizing figure in the u.s., what do we
- 7:24think is this is this the end to sort of, you know, the
- 7:28protection of such Elites or do? We really still need to thank,
- 7:31you know, until someone big in cinema really Falls that the
- 7:35French, you know? I mean, look at, look at look
- 7:37what happened later in the year in food, there were accusations
- 7:41building around a French, or sorry, a Japanese Chef in
- 7:45France, in Paris. About, you know, women coming
- 7:49forward who had very uncomfortable or abusive
- 7:53experiences with him and eventually, an Ori also covered
- 7:57this story he ended up committed committing suicide and in the
- 8:02end you know it's terrible for him and his family.
- 8:04It's terrible for the women who will never get any kind of
- 8:06closure. But what it did highlight to me
- 8:09is that women are not believed because women felt that they
- 8:13were too many boundaries in place for them to actually go to
- 8:16court or worse. Art of make a formal complaint
- 8:19with the police. And so I feel like that's the
- 8:23big theme running through this year with a many of these
- 8:26examples of abusive abusive power or male sexual harassment.
- 8:31Is women are still not believe when they do speak up there just
- 8:35to complicate the issue a little bit.
- 8:36I mean, the next big, you know, figure to fall on.
- 8:41This was another. Another Nori onishi story was
- 8:43Kristoff's, your ha who was the kind of cultural attache.
- 8:48And City Hall for many many years.
- 8:49That that's an interesting story because it wasn't a question of
- 8:53whether or not women were believed.
- 8:56It was a man who I say accused but also backed up with like
- 9:07reams of documentary evidence, you know, I don't remember the
- 9:14exact details, but I think it's fair to characterize it as An
- 9:18exploitative. If not abusive relationship, I
- 9:20can't does anyone remember did he accuse him of rape or was it
- 9:25a sexual relationship? They had when the man was
- 9:27underage? I can't be quite the second one.
- 9:30I can't quite retrieve the details.
- 9:33So I'll petiole is the Michelle know anyone who's listening to,
- 9:35this will have to go look it up, but it was just interesting
- 9:39because this was another person who had come out of a highly
- 9:44refined, you know. Be milieu in Paris, he came.
- 9:49He came out of the fashion world and I think he was a longtime
- 9:53assistant to. I want to say, did he come out?
- 10:00He came out of the kind of Yves Saint Laurent home.
- 10:02Yes, history, right, yeah. So have a Banshee.
- 10:05Yeah anyway, so just to say it, just too complicated even more.
- 10:12I mean, it was also a question of someone who just Don't really
- 10:18have the power to go there until this year.
- 10:21And finally, felt finally felt that the moment was right, and
- 10:25that he had a chance to put his story out there and see someone
- 10:30face consequences, which he did. So what I'm eager to see is the
- 10:34same thing happen in film and in in the food world because
- 10:37there's a lot of unchecked and and, and sort of Examples of
- 10:43such abuses, running rampant. And it's, I mean, it's building
- 10:47there was a big piece in media pack, to just, I want to say
- 10:50last week for, you know, related to the food world.
- 10:54But it really is something that has been brewing and I'm sure,
- 10:57you know, covid obviously halted some of this but not, not all of
- 11:01it. So I hope that 2021 brings extra
- 11:05closure for the people who have been, you know, victims of this.
- 11:09But anyway, so good point, forgot that there was that
- 11:12sense. An element to that story.
- 11:14What else do we want to say? I mean, we'll of course, you
- 11:16mentioned, the lies about the necessity of masks and that's
- 11:19still still carrying on. I don't how you don't prepare
- 11:23for a pandemic in one month. I mean, you know, no matter what
- 11:28they say, I really didn't have anything.
- 11:30Like I don't know how they can justify, you know, no mask.
- 11:34So not enough ICU beds. I mean, what could have, you
- 11:39know, there was nothing they could have done, you know, and
- 11:42then in In addition to that they live.
- 11:43So it was pretty, pretty terrible management of
- 11:47everything. I got to try to find there was
- 11:49some video that came out over the summer, I think, which
- 11:52highlighted like a sequence of different interviews, radio, and
- 11:56TV interviews from different people or featuring different
- 12:00people from the government who kept going, on the air and
- 12:03saying, like, no, we didn't have an issue with with the number of
- 12:07masks. No, it wasn't this, you know,
- 12:09and just sort of like the fact that they will any of them
- 12:12really The consequences for this, I'm like, more or less,
- 12:16you know, like used to being lied to, by politicians.
- 12:22But this is just has such like lasting corrosive effects
- 12:29because now, everyone thinks they're lying about the vaccine,
- 12:33and I'll just offense public confidence in them, and then
- 12:38bismal and France, and I can't help but see A very direct
- 12:43connection between the two because, yeah, like I know that
- 12:49even. Yeah, as I said before, I like
- 12:51even I someone not given to conspiratorial thinking and who
- 12:57surely will have the vaccine and wanted I mean it's just like the
- 13:01second, you hear this kind of denial assist language about
- 13:09supplies and preparation you just you don't Leave it.
- 13:13Yeah well and certainly you know they're going for the trifecta
- 13:18now with you know not even just the mask issue but also the way
- 13:23they were testing and then you know, poor communication all
- 13:27throughout and now the vaccine. So it's sort of like, okay, what
- 13:30are we what are we gearing up for in early 2021 to be to be
- 13:36continued? Obviously we need a sort of
- 13:37damning report like the one that Lawrence Wright.
- 13:40Just you know wrote for the New Yorker about Out the u.s.
- 13:44failures, I'm sure it will take, I will say in comparison to the
- 13:49u.s. situation. I mean, one counterweight and
- 13:52all that, it cancels out all the lives.
- 13:53As I do think the confinements have been managed relatively
- 13:57well relatively. Well in France, I mean, at least
- 14:00if known what was open, what wasn't where we can go, where we
- 14:06can't, rather than, like this kind of, you know, individuals
- 14:09like each each person to his own mentality where it's Just like,
- 14:13well, do whatever you want to, but like, if you get a virus,
- 14:17you know, you're bad. Yeah, I mean, there's proud of
- 14:21forget something for people who are not in France and I see it
- 14:25from a Moroccan point of view, in terms of economic fall outs.
- 14:31I mean, I think from an outsider's point of view, it
- 14:35seems that people in France are really taken care of by the
- 14:38government, which is not the case in most of the world.
- 14:40And I think that's something we need to also talk about about
- 14:45people getting help and been this business is getting
- 14:47helpless, not enough, of course. It can never be enough but it's
- 14:52nowhere near the disaster that we see in other countries, where
- 14:55people having a little piece that stuck out for me.
- 15:04So much was like Trump getting on the phone with Governors and
- 15:09being like, yeah, but like get your, you know, hope you can
- 15:13like round up some ventilators and the government's for like
- 15:17Governors, like what are you talking about?
- 15:19And Trump is just like good luck.
- 15:21Dudes is basically all. And then the, for the governor
- 15:24goes, we need Tom Brady, not a backup.
- 15:26And I was just like, better protection of sports metaphors,
- 15:31like machismo. Kind of like I have you to kiss
- 15:36up to Trump states rights being a cover for just abusive
- 15:41practices. Like everything was converging
- 15:44there for me in a really like it really just Infuriating way.
- 15:52Yeah, I mean these are these are systems that are very hard to
- 15:54compare, right? Obviously there has been a form
- 15:56of leadership National leadership here.
- 15:59And certainly mayor Hidalgo has worked to make sure that there
- 16:04were things put into place for a Parisian businesses.
- 16:07You know, the part the sort of free-for-all with the with the
- 16:12Terraces that spills into the street.
- 16:14I mean, all of that? Yes, of course.
- 16:16It feeds her plan for for, you know, getting rid of cars but It
- 16:20was a, it was a prompt reaction and did a lot of good for, for
- 16:24especially restaurants who needed to figure out a way to
- 16:27survive. So, in that respect you're
- 16:29right, I mean, there there's the US.
- 16:32Sort of will always be the worst example in this.
- 16:38So, beyond that we start moving toward, I don't know.
- 16:42Let's say spring June, we have George Floyd.
- 16:47And, and the reverberations that that carried in Or nationally
- 16:50and, you know, with the with a sort of satellite black lives
- 16:55matter movement in France, LED in part by assets holiday, who,
- 16:59as we have talked about this with Ida on the show, I've
- 17:02talked about it with you, Lauren and Lauren, you ended up doing a
- 17:04profile of her this summer. What do we make of how quickly
- 17:09that took off in France? So I did and I went to the June
- 17:17protest together. We were there It was huge, it
- 17:21was like, so I mean, I don't you think there was like, yeah, I've
- 17:27been robbed. It was what it was.
- 17:34It was I mean it's just worth remembering to I mean, I think
- 17:39we've now seen scientific evidence emerging that outdoor
- 17:42kind of like moving protests. Don't pose a huge risk like
- 17:47that. There hasn't been increased
- 17:49transmission. From the kinds of protests that
- 17:51we saw this summer, but we didn't know that at the time and
- 17:53it was like, kind of scary to just step out in a crowd and
- 17:58then like so many people did it anyway.
- 18:02And We didn't stay the whole time.
- 18:06I mean, we were there early. It was like, you know, very
- 18:12chill. Later on, we saw, but oida, we
- 18:17went to both protest together once wife.
- 18:20Yeah, and both times the police were, like, shooting off tear
- 18:27gas, when there was absolutely, no reason that we could see for
- 18:33that to be happening. and and then of course, you know, you
- 18:38would see like the kind of You know, less call kind of like
- 18:44whatever the many for equivalent is of like late night at the bar
- 18:48photos. But you know, from everything we
- 18:50saw like these protests were like great and then the police
- 18:54started shooting serious. But anyway, exactly happened.
- 18:59How it happened. Where where I'm going with that
- 19:03is just having seen, how much like will and energy and public.
- 19:10Like just, you know, Volante there is on this issue, is
- 19:17especially disappointing. When macron, maybe this was in
- 19:21July, you know, finally made what was billed as his big
- 19:25speech issue. Didn't mention any victim of
- 19:32police violence, has name that I can recall.
- 19:35I know, he didn't, I know he didn't say George Floyd, and I
- 19:38know he didn't say out of a tree or a witch witch.
- 19:40Is I think, you know, pretty conscious Choice given that
- 19:43Angela Merkel even had sat down a couple of days earlier and
- 19:46said George Floyd and then gone on to specific German examples
- 19:50and he said, you know, no no statues going to be taken off
- 19:55his pedestal and France. It was just such a missed
- 20:00opportunity. Like I just really look back at
- 20:03that. Moment for France would like a
- 20:05lot of frustration and sadness I would say because you know, it's
- 20:11just like so many people who got off their asses went and stood
- 20:16out in the street to say this matters to me and there was just
- 20:20such a, you know, Blind Eye and and deaf ear from the powers
- 20:27that be Well, there's also the funding either.
- 20:31Go ahead. Yeah, sorry, no, it's just that,
- 20:34you know, someone, I saw someone wrote something on Twitter
- 20:37yesterday that I thought was applies to so many things.
- 20:41He's someone tweeted, something, like, you can never understand
- 20:45the vulnerable. If you never been vulnerable
- 20:46yourself yourself, and I think it rarely applies more to me
- 20:50than when I see how the French establishment speaks about
- 20:55police violence. Because they just don't get it.
- 21:00And even a lot of my friends in Paris and stuff, they just don't
- 21:05understand it because we come from the social class and
- 21:09erased, it never has to ever deal with the police.
- 21:13And I've been following these movements that try to talk about
- 21:18these issues and talk about race for years.
- 21:21And I have to say that this is the first year that I see these
- 21:25people that never wanted to hear it have been so tone deaf about
- 21:29this issue. Finally, paying a little bit of
- 21:32attention, but I mean, there's still like so much work and so
- 21:35much, you know, explaining to do about, you know, how these
- 21:39things are all connected, and how it's about race, and it's
- 21:42about many things. But I think, when that music
- 21:45producer was beaten up by the police and it was on the front
- 21:49page of the Bastion, this is the first time that I saw people who
- 21:53always refused to pay attention to this.
- 21:56Finally, kind of understand that there's a Correlation between
- 22:00violence and race. Yeah, but again it's also about
- 22:04social class because at that Mark, although it was someone
- 22:08who had been in jail and had a troubled past and things like
- 22:11that when the victim is not perfectly like refuse to to see
- 22:15it any other way. So it's it's really complicated
- 22:18issue to talk about in France and I find that the
- 22:22establishment media access from India, Pakistan and other news
- 22:27outlets they just Really fail at explaining things.
- 22:31They always criminalize the victim and and so it's hard to
- 22:37reach the larger public and and Michael definitely has been
- 22:40extremely tone-deaf about this. And and and his new interior
- 22:43Ministry Domina is just going after minorities and it seems to
- 22:50have a complete license to do so.
- 22:53I mean it seems you know that seems to be his mission.
- 22:58Exclusive Mission as far as I can tell.
- 23:02I mean and spending not music not to scramble our chronology
- 23:06too much but the thing just that we have to talk about to and we
- 23:11talked about the Michelle Ziegler case is just this Global
- 23:15Security Law that contained a provision which would have made
- 23:23it illegal for people to film the police.
- 23:26The caveat like in the original version of the bill was in a
- 23:30manner that was intended to cause mental or physical harm to
- 23:34the person films. So, I mean, that could have
- 23:36meant anything and this was another moment this year where
- 23:39people were just like this is too much like, yeah, it might be
- 23:44covid, but like that, a lot of people were out in the street
- 23:47for that too. And what happened was the vote
- 23:49on the bill happened? I mean, this was just luck, is
- 23:53not the word, but Chance happened to coincide with The,
- 23:59with the Michelle's Eckler beating and that's something
- 24:04that's, you know, had already voted the bill, I believe is
- 24:07what happened past it and then the secular tape came out and
- 24:13people were like, yeah, this is like what we're talking about.
- 24:18And then, you know, they had to retire the law and for what,
- 24:23they promise, a promise that they'll completely rewrite
- 24:26article 24, which was the one that said, You know, you can't
- 24:30film the police unless we say you can basically.
- 24:33So I mean fortunately you know that law was like a travesty and
- 24:40it came really, really close to getting past and and right now
- 24:46is in limbo, ironically only because of the very sort of
- 24:49video that it was trying to ban. So and you know, for a lot of
- 24:53people who don't know, the French police do not wear body
- 24:56cams. So the filming This beating
- 24:59happened because the Michelle has is a record producer and has
- 25:05an office in the 1700 of these smaller Studio that has cameras
- 25:09security cameras. And then you also got different
- 25:12angles on the events from Neighbors who were filming.
- 25:15And so, you know, obviously if you remove the right of people
- 25:19to do that, then we have a severe problem.
- 25:21Also, what I thought was astounding in the writing of the
- 25:23original bill, was the people who are then meant to do,
- 25:28Determine whether the filming of a police officer was intended to
- 25:33bring harm on that police officer or the police
- 25:36themselves. So there's no way for this to be
- 25:41sort of a rule that is unbiased in anyway.
- 25:46And you know, so the parallels I think between some of the vial
- 25:49of a lot of the violence we've seen erupt in the u.s. in within
- 25:52this year and in France seem to be struggling with a lot of this
- 25:57same issues, which is sort of this like Refusal to accept and
- 26:00to, to Really face the racial implications of police violence
- 26:09and you hear the same kind of excuses idea.
- 26:11You were mentioning how, you know, a lot of the elite here
- 26:15will refuse not even just the elite.
- 26:17I mean just people in general who aren't confronted with these
- 26:20realities refuse to or will make excuses, you know, for
- 26:24individuals who have had trouble with the law or who are from a
- 26:27different social class. As somehow being deserving of,
- 26:31you know, excessive violence on from the police and and those
- 26:36are similar things you here in the States.
- 26:37You know, even with George Floyd, it was like, oh well, he
- 26:39had been accused of this or he had been, you know, in trouble
- 26:42with the law for this. And, you know, we're not talking
- 26:44about individual sort of, you know, whether you're on the
- 26:52naughty or the the nice list. It's about, you know, being
- 26:55humans, who are not meant to Be subjected to such violence
- 27:00anyway. It just it just seems like there
- 27:02are a lot more parallels between the u.s. and France.
- 27:04Then either country really wants to live.
- 27:08Exactly. There was a cartoon that I saw
- 27:11that will stick with me this year that which was like, I
- 27:14think I saw it. I don't remember where I saw it,
- 27:17but it was like a french guy like reading the paper reading
- 27:22like a story about George Floyd and the newspaper.
- 27:25And then there's just like this guy like Getting a beat-down,
- 27:29like, right next to him, and he doesn't even see it because his
- 27:32energies are like focused abroad, you know, and I thought
- 27:36that was pretty apt. But I mean, as as we've said,
- 27:41like the conversation has changed a little bit this year,
- 27:44the conversation has progressed a little bit this year.
- 27:48So, you know, I know we just thought I think that cartoon was
- 27:53like, before the big demonstrations in France.
- 27:57I do, I do I may have been around the same time once the in
- 28:02any case it was definitely over the summer and you know, we
- 28:07we've had so many protests this summer, you know, since since D
- 28:10confinement it's like trying to retrace all the steps.
- 28:13But even though we've jumped ahead a bit, we've covered some
- 28:16of the things that I wanted to definitely highlight which was
- 28:18the security bill, which is just absolutely an Abomination.
- 28:23I don't know if you both saw, but it's, it's been Knock down.
- 28:30I don't know if this is part of the bill or if this was
- 28:32separate, but the use of drones to film protesters that's been
- 28:38made, that's been prohibited. So, that's one thing we get into
- 28:43the fall. People are, you know, trying to
- 28:47imagine what the the seasons going to look like after
- 28:49vacations and sort of pretending like covid-19.
- 28:57Exactly. Well must have been close to an
- 29:00anniversary but we had the knife attack at Charlie hebdo's former
- 29:03offices and that sent people sort of into a tizzy shortly
- 29:09thereafter. And and this is just to show the
- 29:12how on nerve on edge. People were a fighter jet, broke
- 29:16the barrier of sound, flying over Paris, which is, you know,
- 29:19usually not something that ever is allowed to happen.
- 29:22But it was for a particular reason and it sounded like an
- 29:25explosion right outside my building.
- 29:27Everyone on Twitter in Paris sitting at my desk in total
- 29:34silence. You didn't hear it.
- 29:39I thought there was like Lauren missed the sonic.
- 29:43Boom, I am Sonic behave. I mean, what I will.
- 29:49What I will say is that, you know, and and the reason it
- 29:52highlights something for me is just how freaked out I got.
- 29:57Because it Was just after I think the the knife attack and
- 30:01that's also very close to where I live.
- 30:03And and so, it was just like, oh my God, what is going on?
- 30:06In this long, this city, I mean, has not only on the part of like
- 30:11the general population, but also on the part of whatever
- 30:15Authority controls the air space, because then, when they
- 30:17later told us what happened, it was like, Well, actually had a
- 30:21plan broach, the like forbidden airspace by accident and then
- 30:26they sent a fighter jet, is that what happened?
- 30:27Or I think, if I think they had a, there was a plane that they
- 30:31had lost communication with or something.
- 30:33There was something about you can pin a few Yeah.
- 30:37Yeah. And then it was just like, okay,
- 30:38we're going in like, I mean, I was just every on every level
- 30:42like my anxiety. Yeah.
- 30:45So so that and then, unfortunately, and again, we
- 30:48will have less horrific things to discuss in a minute.
- 30:52But Samuel Patty, the beheading of the teacher just outside of
- 30:56Paris, you know, and that raised yet, again, all sorts of issues.
- 31:02And led the, in fact to this these these sort of A, how do we
- 31:10say sort of the Pinnacle of the tensions between the, the French
- 31:14government sort of, the French neoconservatives, and the
- 31:17American Media. And either we, you know, you
- 31:20mentioned this earlier. But just to the extent that the
- 31:25French refused to believe that, you know, anyone from outside of
- 31:31France, can have an informed opinion about issues of Say and
- 31:37how an abuse is of lice, eat a and how that does or doesn't
- 31:40impact some of the things that have happened.
- 31:43These these Horrors within the country, I just Lauren.
- 31:47I remember you reacting, very, very viscerally to that news.
- 31:50And so I wanted to leave it open to both of you to comment and I
- 31:56just think I had a lot of and ya know, you you I want to hear
- 32:00what you have to say. I do you go.
- 32:04Well, of course, the The beheading was absolutely
- 32:08horrific. I feel like you have to say that
- 32:10before you say anything else because people can easily jump
- 32:14out your throat and anything you say, then they said that you
- 32:17support any kind of horrific thing that happens.
- 32:21But what I'm noticing again in France that I find extremely
- 32:25upsetting, is that there's such a lack of nuance.
- 32:31There's such a like, of diversity in the voices that are
- 32:35present in the In the intellectuals that we here and
- 32:39again, mid Depok carries like such a huge burden to Nuance to
- 32:44the narrative and talk about a lot of different things and talk
- 32:47about abuses of power and talk about also in this case about
- 32:52how the terrorists was known by the services, and there was
- 32:57again, an intelligence failure, as there are so many in these
- 33:02cases, but we always direct the conversation in a different
- 33:05direction in France. It becomes about Muslim ngos and
- 33:10in this specific case the c f which is an NGO that gives legal
- 33:16counsel to victims of islamophobia and they become
- 33:20kind of the target of the media. The target of politicians and
- 33:22the entire conversation changes. We don't talk about the
- 33:27responsibilities of the state who don't talk about the
- 33:30failures of the intelligence Services.
- 33:32We don't talk about any of that. We just start talking again
- 33:35about the same people. And then you have this kind of
- 33:37Hysteria that starts and then they take advantage of moments
- 33:42like that to kind of talk about other things.
- 33:45We don't talk about Max anymore, we don't talk about depends emic
- 33:48anymore. We just talked about some Muslim
- 33:51organizations and some individuals and and I find it
- 33:55really shocking in a place like France.
- 33:57It should in my opinion, have very powerful and strong media,
- 34:03that kind of challenges what the government says.
- 34:06As but again as we have seen in the last couple of decades
- 34:09whenever it's about islamist terrorism, the media kind of
- 34:14loses its ability to challenge what the governance say I think
- 34:20I mean it's certainly not only the French media we saw that in
- 34:24America after right, 911. I mean in just prior flagrant
- 34:29examples that are all kind of we all agree upon now.
- 34:35And I think That. I don't know, I think that's
- 34:42part of why. American reporters.
- 34:47At least some have tried to be more aggressive on these
- 34:54stories. Just like knowing that there's
- 34:57this kind of period of. I don't know what the word for.
- 35:04It is like period, where dissent is not welcome.
- 35:09I mean you can look at that as Unity or you can just look at it
- 35:13as I don't know. I think it's like, really,
- 35:16really tricky in the, in the aftermath of these kind of
- 35:20events and Yeah, I don't know. I think I think you're you're
- 35:30getting to something which is sort of our we don't have the
- 35:34right words to talk about all of this because it just keeps
- 35:37happening. And like I just said I mean
- 35:40there's you know it's no one is no, one is disagreeing with the
- 35:47horror of the act itself. It's about everything was sort
- 35:50of the context around it and and what else can be at play besides
- 35:54just pointing the finger at organization, how do you go
- 36:00from? A teacher like, you know, a
- 36:05pretty fantastic teacher by all accounts being beheaded after
- 36:10school. By let's point out.
- 36:15Not a French, was he a French citizen?
- 36:18I don't think so, right. I think he's, he was, he came in
- 36:24too fast as a refugee at a very young age and then I'm not sure
- 36:28I ever became French. I'd say that he wasn't from the
- 36:36school and he was from, you know, elsewhere in I want to say
- 36:41it was a Muslim Russian Refugee of Chechen ethnicity.
- 36:47So we've got that and somehow we go from that.
- 36:52To again, the minister of the Interior, like saying he's
- 36:58shocked by seeing halal foods and supermarkets, right?
- 37:01Right now, this is where the conversation goes and just like,
- 37:06yeah, I think what we're talking about is how we go from that.
- 37:09A to that be Well, it's not even a, to be at that point, it's,
- 37:15you know, a 2f and, you know, with all sorts of detours in
- 37:19between and and, and like you said that, you know, some of our
- 37:24fellow writers and correspondents who write for the
- 37:28Washington Post or who write for the New York Times and Al
- 37:32Jazeera and the guardian have have really tried to do fair and
- 37:38balanced informative. You know, reporting on this and
- 37:41it is, they're not there. Not saying that it's like it's
- 37:46like they're they're not supposed to anger the president
- 37:52and that's what this has come to look at or look like you know
- 37:55actually went back home then picks up the phone and you know
- 37:59wants to speak to the ft and the media guy at the New York Times.
- 38:03It's just sort of like, I think I don't think that, I think it's
- 38:06a little bit. Unfair to say that that is what
- 38:10happened, but I think it's on that I'm summarizing, right?
- 38:13But I know, I know, but, but that became a point of
- 38:15contention. And I just think it's
- 38:16interesting to point out because, yes, like, I think it's
- 38:22unclear exactly what happened with the Ft bit.
- 38:25Like, with the New York Times thing.
- 38:27We know that, like, basically Ben Smith asked for an
- 38:29interview, and macron said, yes. And then Ben Smith wrote it
- 38:34like, hey, macaron picked up the phone and called me the other
- 38:36day, which I think is like, Perfectly like admissible.
- 38:40But like other people thought was like, you know, a distortion
- 38:45of like an important, an important like use it as a way
- 38:51to say that the American Media lies and that was like what the
- 38:54debate degenerated into. I just felt like it was people
- 38:59missing the forest for the trees like somehow, right this right,
- 39:04you know, the conversation became about like did Ben Smith
- 39:07lie, when he said Ed macron, all the home and it's just like that
- 39:11that was not the important that was right?
- 39:15Except I did not think that was a substantive, conversation will
- 39:19know. And if you saw what happened on
- 39:22Twitter and how the you know the media, the French media Elites
- 39:28in the neoconservatives that we all try to avoid how they jumped
- 39:33on. It was, you know, they pick that
- 39:35apart and the rest of the issue became.
- 39:38Significant and nor did they find it, you know, to be
- 39:41problematic that he's, you know, giving interviews in that way or
- 39:46saying yes to that. But, you know, won't speak to.
- 39:49I don't know someone at the Washington Post, for example,
- 39:52who lives here. I don't know, it's just the
- 39:54choice and I get, that's not even the real issue, right?
- 39:57I mean, he, the president can say yes and no to whoever he
- 39:59wants, but it's the, it's the level of effort and energy spent
- 40:06criticizing. What is very qualified
- 40:11reporting? That's being done.
- 40:12Yeah, I think the issue is that you don't understand.
- 40:17You're a foreigner there for. You don't understand.
- 40:20Least you today is used as a smokescreen for.
- 40:22I just agree with your conclusions, exactly.
- 40:27But someone said, someone answered them on Twitter who
- 40:30said didn't know, we understand my city.
- 40:32We just reject your white supremacist version of it,
- 40:36right? So that was it.
- 40:38Brilliant answer. I mean and that's something that
- 40:41France really has to not even just get better at.
- 40:45They need to really properly handle this sort of recycled
- 40:50response to every every element of criticism.
- 40:54There's no internet connection at all.
- 40:57Anyway, exactly just to keep things moving because we know
- 41:00the vaccine is still a hot mess. So we don't need to go into sort
- 41:04of current, current dramas, but I did want to end with one.
- 41:09One less Gastly story that put France in everyone's mind and
- 41:14that was Emily and Paris. And as much as I do, then it as
- 41:19much as I love it, it gave us all something else to discuss
- 41:23for the majority of my God, I can't believe you're letting
- 41:25heavily have the last word or isn't did anything else happy?
- 41:29Like I think there's no better way to end the conversation.
- 41:39Are you guys? We have to be positive.
- 41:43We are not like, yeah, it's acted.
- 41:46I love my gosh. Oh, I did.
- 41:51I did. I'm busy.
- 41:52I've been simple thing. You're such a provocateur Ida.
- 42:01What are you doing over there? Come on Billy.
- 42:04Look. What else happens.
- 42:05Please. Okay.
- 42:08Okay. Rousing defensive Emily of
- 42:12Paris. I thought it was endearing.
- 42:16I thought it was I spent the whole evening watching it, not
- 42:20doing anything else. It allowed me to think about it.
- 42:23Where do I do have to say? It was really weird, that no one
- 42:33looking like me. It was in that show, I don't
- 42:37know in what part of Paris they were Filming.
- 42:40But I just decided to kind of enjoy it and not see all the
- 42:46issues with it but I completely understand why you both hate it.
- 42:51Here's what I will say. I will say that at the very
- 42:53least as soon as people can travel Paris will be among, you
- 42:58know, the first place until return.
- 43:00And so for our terrorism, I gotta thank God.
- 43:02Emily came to Paris. If people want to come here, you
- 43:08know what I mean? Like after It's seeing Paris.
- 43:10So empty in the, you know, over the last 11 months, it's a bit
- 43:15creepy. Like, it's were nearing that
- 43:16like Erie, is this going to be forever feeling?
- 43:20And so I wouldn't mind if we had a little bit more movement, but
- 43:24that's that's really the only positive, I'll, I'll see
- 43:29station. So, okay, so that we're not
- 43:33finishing on Emily and Paris. Let me ask you this.
- 43:36What do you hope? And obviously, this is not tied
- 43:39to the news or anything. What would you like to see
- 43:42happen for France in 2021? I would like to see a candidate
- 43:50emerge for the 2022 elections. That's not mine were banned and
- 43:55it's not a man you're my queen. That's what I'm hoping for this.
- 43:59Well, might be Anne Hidalgo. Right?
- 44:03She actually said the other day that she was going to run or
- 44:07strongly hinted at it, didn't she?
- 44:08Yeah, I think I think that's a really great answer.
- 44:11I think there's just like a whole giant unreserved run under
- 44:18spoken for constituency to the left of macron and to the right
- 44:25of melon Xiang and it would be really great to see a credible
- 44:31credible. Gyor.
- 44:34Speak for what I think. I mean you know what I think is
- 44:39a big chunk of people Absolutely, no I don't know.
- 44:44Sure, I don't have a better answer than that.
- 44:47That's fine. That's fine.
- 44:48I think that's going to anyway, be the topic of conversation
- 44:52through a lot of 2021. So you know by summer I'm sure
- 44:56we'll know exactly who the who the options are or maybe shortly
- 44:59thereafter because at least Francis doesn't pull a, you
- 45:03know, 24 month, campaign schedule, like you're right.
- 45:08Thank God. And then I had no won't be
- 45:10spending all of her nights watching the Is watching
- 45:13election coverage. When we say, thank you for being
- 45:17part of what has been a very challenging strange and
- 45:23emotional 2020. And I can't wait to keep talking
- 45:25about France with you in the new year.
- 45:29Thanks, you guys. Happy New Year.
- 45:32Happy Mother. That's the show for today.
- 45:38As always. Thank you for listening
- 45:40subscribing and sharing with Friends, you can find all
- 45:43previous episodes of the new Paris podcast wherever you
- 45:46stream your podcasts and on world radio Paris.
- 45:49If you're enjoying these conversations, please consider
- 45:51picking up a copy of the New Paris book or my recent release
- 45:55for new proposition from your local book sellers.
- 45:58Until next time I Bianco