Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 7 Episode 18: How the Hague Convention Can Trap Abuse Survivors
Transcript
- 0:17R: And we're back.
- 0:18David Mandel: We're back.
- 0:19David Mandel: Hey.
- 0:20David Mandel: Hey there.
- 0:21R: How's it going?
- 0:23David Mandel: I am a little bit jet lagged and dislocated for a lot of reasons, but very happy to be doing this show today.
- 0:34David Mandel: And but I think that the headline is well, first, who are you?
- 0:38David Mandel: Who are you?
- 0:39R: Who am I?
- 0:40R: I'm Matwinondo, and I'm with the Safe and Together Institute, and you're co-founder with Safety Nexus.
- 0:46R: Who are you?
- 0:47David Mandel: Okay.
- 0:48David Mandel: I'm David Mandel, CEO, founder of the Safe and Together Institute, and co-founder with U of Safety Nexus, which is very exciting.
- 0:54David Mandel: And we're we just came back from a trip where we were all over Australia, but particularly launching a beta pilot of our AI-powered Safe and Together Digital Coach and Insight Engine, which you'll be hearing more about in future episodes.
- 1:08David Mandel: So but but the headset, I would like the headline.
- 1:12David Mandel: I would like to acknowledge.
- 1:14R: Yeah, please.
- 1:15R: I am in my hometown of Santa Rosa, California, and I would like to acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land, the Pomo and the Coast Miwok people.
- 1:27R: And really exciting, you know, we're going to be spending some time this weekend with the Intertribal Council here that has a land-based teaching and learning center up in Napa, California.
- 1:40R: And very, very, very excited to be home, really, and had a wonderful night last night watching election results.
- 1:49R: So it has been a beautiful 24 hours.
- 1:54R: And you know, this is a really important podcast.
- 2:00R: I really felt very strongly about making sure that we gave platform to our guests to have this conversation about international custody and access issues.
- 2:18R: You know, we work in court contexts across the world, mostly family court systems, obviously criminal and remand and juvenile court systems as well.
- 2:31R: But there is just something so broken and so devastating about the family court systems across the world, where where survivors, victims, and women are really being stripped of their rights and of their resources, quite frankly, by perpetrators who use the court systems, manipulate those court systems, not in the short term, but over many years often, and really harm the connection and contact and custody of survivor, adult survivors with their children.
- 3:14R: And and I don't know if you want to give any more of a little bit of introduction for that, David, before we introduce our guests.
- 3:20David Mandel: Sure, sure.
- 3:21David Mandel: I I think there's two things I want to set up for our audience before we introduce our guests.
- 3:27David Mandel: One is that central to this discussion is really the concept of course control, really understanding that patterns of course control often involve so many behaviors that are not physical, but are about controlling resources, controlling children, controlling access, controlling movement of people, and that that this is very much gonna sit within that that space, that that concept of course control.
- 3:57David Mandel: And and the the other thing is really that you know it's gonna sit at the the intersection of migration, uh nationality, people having access to other countries and resources, and and and really how systems understand parental alienation.
- 4:19David Mandel: And usually wrongly understand it and wrongly label protective behaviors as being alienating.
- 4:25David Mandel: You know, so so uh, you know, people familiar, uh one of the chapters of my book is the myth of parental alienation, and and how that is not something that is really a term that is applicable when there's even the possibility of domestic abuse, course of control being present.
- 4:43David Mandel: So I think these are the themes that are going to come up, you know, course of control, parental alienation, the idea of kids as weapons and as tools and as uh and then what does protection really mean and look like?
- 4:55David Mandel: And it doesn't look like what a lot of people think it looks like.
- 4:59David Mandel: So, anyway, so with that, Ruth, I'll kind of kick it back to you to introduce our guests.
- 5:03R: I would love to introduce Hague moms, and I know that this does not represent all of you, but you know, there's Ruth Denine and we have Leslie Johansson who's with us as well.
- 5:15R: And I'm just really grateful you both joined us.
- 5:17R: And I'd love for you all to introduce yourself and give a little bit of your bio, and then we can launch into what is the Hague Convention and how does it impact people in international custody and access cases.
- 5:30R: So, Ruth, would you love to introduce yourself, please?
- 5:33SPEAKER_04: Oh, sure.
- 5:34SPEAKER_04: So I'm with Danine and I'm the international coordinator for something called Filial Hague Mothers that was set up four years ago, and we're working to try and ensure that victim survivors of domestic abuse, coercive control, both mothers and their children, are not further abused by the legal system, in this case by the Hague Abduction Convention.
- 5:55SPEAKER_04: So that's who I am, and that's what I do.
- 5:57SPEAKER_04: And Leslie isn't part of Hague Mothers, she's just a wonderful partner and friend.
- 6:02SPEAKER_00: Wonderful, Leslie.
- 6:04SPEAKER_00: Hi, thank you, Ruth.
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: My name's Leslie Johansson, and I work at the Narquis Golan International Child Abduction Initiative at Sanctuary for Families.
- 6:13SPEAKER_00: Sanctuary is a nonprofit that is based in New York, and we serve survivors of domestic violence, sex trafficking, and other forms of gender-based violence.
- 6:24SPEAKER_00: And the initiative that I work for as an attorney assists survivors when they're facing Hague abduction convention litigation and related issues across the United States.
- 6:36SPEAKER_00: So we provide legal consultation.
- 6:38SPEAKER_00: Sometimes we provide representation, including with pro bono partners across the United States.
- 6:44SPEAKER_00: And then we also focus on education to the bench, attorneys, advocates, and clients about the convention and related issues.
- 6:53R: You know, we're gonna start off by defining what the Hague Convention is.
- 6:58R: And I just want to say, where you both comment on, you know, what that particular law is, how it impacts survivors, and that there are so many well-intended laws and international agreements on paper.
- 7:14R: And the fact is, is that in the court system as it exists, they often are used in ways that strip particularly women of their rights.
- 7:29R: And so can you explain to our listeners what the Hague Convention is, what it was intended to do, and what its actual impact is currently in reality?
- 7:41SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.
- 7:42SPEAKER_00: And you you kind of pin the nail right on the head, that is exactly what's going on here with the Hague Obduction Convention.
- 7:48SPEAKER_00: And I'll say too, I'm gonna just call it the Hague Hague Convention.
- 7:53SPEAKER_00: There are several different Hague conventions, but this is the only one that I'm talking about.
- 7:57SPEAKER_00: Um, and I'm just using that just for you know brevity's sake.
- 8:01SPEAKER_00: But the Hague Convention here was adopted in October 1980.
- 8:06SPEAKER_00: And what it is, is it's a framework for treaty partner countries to work together in specific ways to resolve when there's an allegation of an international child abduction.
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: So there is over 200 different, I'm sorry, 100 different countries who have signed on to the Hague Convention.
- 8:24SPEAKER_00: And two countries must have signed on and they must have accepted each other's accession in order for the Hague Convention to apply.
- 8:32SPEAKER_00: So, a good example that we often use in the United States is the US and Russia have both signed on to the Hague Convention, but we have not accepted Russia's accession.
- 8:43SPEAKER_00: So if there's a parent in Russia who is seeking the return of a child in the US, they cannot file under the Hague Convention.
- 8:50SPEAKER_00: They'd have to file under in state court under state-specific family laws.
- 8:56SPEAKER_00: The Hague Convention has two main objectives to one, ensure the prompt return of children who are alleged to have been wrongfully removed or illegally retained in another country, and then also to ensure that the rights of custody and access under the laws of one state are effectively respected in the other states.
- 9:18SPEAKER_00: And by state here I mean the two different countries.
- 9:23SPEAKER_00: Sorry, Ruth, go ahead.
- 9:25SPEAKER_00: No, no, I'm just configured.
- 9:26SPEAKER_00: Sorry.
- 9:27SPEAKER_00: So the the treaty is really only supposed to determine where the child will ultimately reside.
- 9:33SPEAKER_00: And it is specifically not supposed to be used to resolve custody cases or any substantive issues involving the best interests of the child.
- 9:43SPEAKER_00: At least that's the way the United States interprets it.
- 9:47SPEAKER_00: We'll talk a little more about that later, I think.
- 9:49SPEAKER_00: But it's really meant to provide for the prompt return of that child back to the originating country so that the court in that country can make those ultimate custody decisions.
- 10:01SPEAKER_00: You know, if a parent is seeking their child's return under the Hague Convention, they have to file a petition in the jurisdiction where the child is currently located.
- 10:12SPEAKER_00: And that parent's initial case is really pretty easy to prove.
- 10:16SPEAKER_00: And if they've proven it, then the burden switches to that taking parent who's seen as the abductor.
- 10:23SPEAKER_00: We call them the respondent in court.
- 10:25SPEAKER_00: And there are really very limited defenses that that respondent can raise to defeat that presumption of return.
- 10:34SPEAKER_00: And one thing to keep in mind is so when it was originally drafted, like you alluded to, Ruth, the drafters had this idea that the people that they were dealing with here would be non-custodial, non-primary caretaking parents.
- 10:49SPEAKER_00: Usually, just statistically, that's the father, that's who they were thinking of, looking for, you know, a friendlier jurisdiction to try to obtain custody of the kids.
- 10:59SPEAKER_00: So the intention in The Hague was to create a presumption of return back to that another, back to that original country, so that these parents could not obtain a favorable custody decision due to their forum shopping.
- 11:15SPEAKER_00: But what we have found out, just you know, through time and statistics, is that the majority of these taking parents are actually primary caretaking mothers.
- 11:26SPEAKER_00: And many, many of them are alleging that they've left that other country for a safety reason.
- 11:35SPEAKER_00: And so because these drafters didn't really contemplate this scenario, there's no mention of domestic violence in the Hague convention.
- 11:44SPEAKER_00: And so there's really not a true consideration of the harmful effects that domestic violence have on the mother, particularly on the children.
- 11:56SPEAKER_00: And it's never been updated to kind of address that.
- 12:00SPEAKER_00: So we often see mothers who are raising domestic violence allegations under this Article 13B defense, which is it states that if the child was to return to the prior country, that they would be at grave risk of being exposed to physical or psychological harm or some other intolerable situation.
- 12:22SPEAKER_00: But this defense doesn't mention domestic violence.
- 12:25SPEAKER_00: It has a really high burden of proof in the United States.
- 12:28SPEAKER_00: It's known as the clear and convincing standard.
- 12:31SPEAKER_00: And as you can see in many court decisions, it's treated really, really narrowly.
- 12:37SPEAKER_00: So it requires a lot of proof of sustained violence.
- 12:41SPEAKER_00: And as we all know, it's really difficult because in many acts of domestic violence, they occur behind closed doors.
- 12:48SPEAKER_00: There might not be witnesses, there might not be documents.
- 12:51R: Right, right, right.
- 12:53R: You know, so so just for our listeners, you know, to be clear, there's there's a lot of issues and vulnerabilities created via migration.
- 13:04R: So some of the instances of the use of this law that I'm aware of are women who were actually returning to their country of origin with their children, but their children had been born in places like the United States or the UK, and they had experienced tremendous coercive control and domestic violence and needed their familial support systems in order for them to not be destitute and even more vulnerable.
- 13:35R: So and even if there were court cases in that country which showed that there was coercive control or showed that there had been domestic violence protection orders, that this Hague convention was actually used in those instances to accuse that survivor of kidnapping those children.
- 14:00R: And once you're involved in that litigation in that cycle, it is just so difficult to navigate custody and access.
- 14:11R: David, I don't know if you wanted to to to add or Ruth to this framing of the situation.
- 14:20David Mandel: I'll turn it off to Ruth first and then I'll comment.
- 14:23David Mandel: Yeah.
- 14:24SPEAKER_04: One thing I I would add, which is sort of implicit in what Leslie has said, but I think it's worth drawing out a little further, is that this original idea that the abductor or the kidnapper would be the father and it would be a foreign father, there was there was a strong sense that that act would be an abusive act.
- 14:42SPEAKER_04: So it wouldn't seem to be taking a child across a border.
- 14:45SPEAKER_04: It would be taking a child across the border out of vindictiveness at the end of a relationship, or for FGM, or for child marriage, or to bring a child up in a patriarchal religion.
- 14:55SPEAKER_04: So it was a really serious and dangerous case.
- 14:58SPEAKER_04: And so the abductor was seen as a danger to the child.
- 15:01SPEAKER_04: It was seen as a form of child abuse.
- 15:03SPEAKER_04: And the whole idea of bringing that child back as quickly as you possibly could to its habitual residence and its primary career mother made perfect sense in that scenario.
- 15:13SPEAKER_04: But of course, now all those attitudes about this is a form of child abuse and the abductor is a danger to the child are now placed at the door of the at the feet of the mother who is actually trying to protect the child.
- 15:27David Mandel: Yeah.
- 15:28David Mandel: It's interesting to me that implicit in the original framing and intent of the convention was coercive control, but not, it was never named.
- 15:41David Mandel: You know, that those scenarios that you're describing are are highly likely to be coercive control.
- 15:48David Mandel: And and and I think this speaks to, and this is I, you know, this idea of family, a family court on steroids, or or this challenge across not only the family law system, but the child protection system, where we continue to operate within structures, policies, frameworks, where we think of child maltreatment, child and child abduction, child sexual abuse as being, you know, subset of those, and domestic abuse as separate issues.
- 16:16David Mandel: And, you know, and and one of the major intents of the Saving Together model in the approach is to, and what we do operationally by kind of saying you need to look at patterns of course control and actions taken to harm the children.
- 16:30David Mandel: That's the foundation of our pattern-based approach.
- 16:33David Mandel: That a lot of these problems arise because there's this distinction made between somehow looking at, and I want to say I was about to say the treatment of the adult and the treatment of the top, but really what I say is somehow chopping up the behavior of the person using violence and saying it's oh, they're uh they're violent to an adult, they're violent, maybe they're violent to a kid, maybe they're violent to a stranger, or maybe they're violent to the workplace.
- 17:00David Mandel: And somehow we we like have not yet really kind of said we need to assess violent people comprehensively, abuse comprehensively in the in the in the nature of the person, and see the way it impacts and ripples out throughout the family unit, to extended family, to kin, to the workplace.
- 17:21David Mandel: And we have this very like, oh, there's intimate partner violence, and that's adult to adult.
- 17:25David Mandel: So does do, you know, Ruth and Leslie, what is how does this land, this assessment land for both of you and your experience with these Hague convention cases?
- 17:35SPEAKER_04: I think you absolutely hit the nail on the head there.
- 17:39SPEAKER_04: And I also think that aspects of post-separation abuse or the disinclination to believe it exists fit into that model.
- 17:48SPEAKER_04: So there's this idea that that happened there and that happened there, but you don't join these things together.
- 17:53SPEAKER_04: And so the relationship has ended.
- 17:55SPEAKER_04: So that's the end of the abuse.
- 17:56SPEAKER_04: We we don't have a problem anymore.
- 17:58SPEAKER_04: So all of those myths feed into this problem, I think.
- 18:02SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.
- 18:03SPEAKER_00: And I mean, we even see cases where there will be two subject children, and there's a recent case that just came down in the United States where the children were separated.
- 18:13SPEAKER_00: They found grave risk of exposure to harm to the older child based on the father's physical abuse of her, and did not find it for the younger child.
- 18:25SPEAKER_00: So they split them up, which I mean, you know, there's a whole host of problems.
- 18:29SPEAKER_00: But but the thought of not looking at the physical abuse of one child and that impact on the other, even if that child was not directly physically abused, is a problem in my mind.
- 18:43R: This is where the the incident focus of the court system decontextualizes the pattern.
- 18:50R: And and you know, I it is a fixture of judicial systems.
- 18:57R: It is the judicial focus, and working with that globally is absolutely a challenge, you know.
- 19:06R: So I know that you all refer to the the the Hague cases as family court on, you know, on speed or something, you know, like like it's just it's the vulnerabilities exacerbated are exacerbated tremendously.
- 19:24R: And then you have the international context.
- 19:26R: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 19:30R: What are the factors that are exacerbating the lack of context, the danger, the financial control?
- 19:39R: You know, tell me more about that.
- 19:43SPEAKER_04: Yeah, I as you say they're all interconnected, and it's this great morus of horror, really.
- 19:48SPEAKER_04: So even before the Hague case, many of the mothers that we work with will already have been traumatized in the family court system.
- 19:56SPEAKER_04: They'll have gone to the family court to get safeguarding and to help them be protected and their child to be protected, and they'll have been betrayed entirely by that system.
- 20:05SPEAKER_04: So they already understand they'll not be protected by the systems that are meant to be there to do just that.
- 20:11SPEAKER_04: So their starting point is one of exhaustion, often financial exhaustion as well, and considerable vulnerability and high levels of fear.
- 20:20SPEAKER_04: I mean, mothers don't take their children and go across international borders on a whim.
- 20:24SPEAKER_04: You know, this is this is a serious move that they make.
- 20:28SPEAKER_04: Also, a heck of a lot of mothers don't know about the convention.
- 20:32SPEAKER_04: They don't even know they're doing something unlawful.
- 20:35SPEAKER_04: They think they're doing the right thing, they're protecting themselves and their children.
- 20:38SPEAKER_04: Well, they are doing the right thing in protecting themselves and their children.
- 20:41SPEAKER_04: But it's not until they they are home in their home country, in the safety of their home country, taking a deep breath, and suddenly they're served with a petition.
- 20:49SPEAKER_04: So they won't understand at all.
- 20:51SPEAKER_04: We we get mothers coming to us in a state of complete bewilderment, literally bewilderment.
- 20:56SPEAKER_04: They cannot believe this can be happening to them.
- 20:59SPEAKER_04: So that's an additional layer that that that creates a sort of a paranoia and a fear, which makes it really hard to think this thing through carefully.
- 21:10SPEAKER_04: Also, with rare exceptions, they'll not be eligible for legal aid.
- 21:14SPEAKER_04: So some will have to self-litigate.
- 21:16SPEAKER_04: And these are life-changing hearings and potentially quite complex.
- 21:21SPEAKER_04: So even if they're able to pay for a lawyer, what we find is it's not easy to find one that's got both Hague expertise and domestic violence and trauma expertise.
- 21:30SPEAKER_04: So when we found Sanctuary for Families, you know, it was a manner from heaven, really.
- 21:34SPEAKER_04: But that's quite a rare combination in lawyers, as far as we're concerned.
- 21:38SPEAKER_04: There are lots of lawyers, back to the coerce of control, post separation abuse.
- 21:43SPEAKER_04: There are lots of lawyers who take a very black and white view of what domestic violence is, and they think if it's not physical, then again, it doesn't count.
- 21:51SPEAKER_04: But either way, they're already the abductor.
- 21:55SPEAKER_04: It's back to this default where they're the abductor and taking the child.
- 22:00SPEAKER_04: Is the the problem and returning the child is the solution.
- 22:04SPEAKER_04: So that's the context they're already in.
- 22:06SPEAKER_04: And so they're already in the wrong, and the the scales are already balanced against them, even before they open their mouths, really, at the court hearing.
- 22:14SPEAKER_04: And also, as as I think Leslie mentioned, hay cases are summary.
- 22:19SPEAKER_04: So the idea is to get everything done and dusted in six weeks.
- 22:22SPEAKER_04: So the courts don't necessarily undertake any fact-finding or source police or social services evidence.
- 22:30SPEAKER_04: That's down to the mother to find all that evidence from the country she's just fled in a state of fear and terror.
- 22:36SPEAKER_04: Perhaps to get it translated if they because you know the court won't supply that translation service for work.
- 22:41SPEAKER_04: So all of this comes upon her as a credible state of knots when she's already vulnerable, when she's already been a victim of domestic abuse, when she's already been betrayed by the state.
- 22:53SPEAKER_04: Yes, and plus in the background, you have all the things that happen in family courts, victim blaming, minimization of domestic abuse and the impact of it, dismissing people's test mothers' testimonies, parental alienation, all that panoply.
- 23:07SPEAKER_04: So, yes, it's it's an absolutely horrific situation.
- 23:11SPEAKER_04: And I mean, our our role is is as advocates, we we do support mothers, but that's not our primary role.
- 23:17SPEAKER_04: We're trying to change the convention.
- 23:19SPEAKER_04: And so we can do so little to help these mothers, and they come to us in a state of complete despair.
- 23:26SPEAKER_04: And I'm left feeling despair too, because all I can say to them is, well, I'm sorry.
- 23:32R: That's often all I can do.
- 23:35R: Yeah, Leslie, do you have some some examples of of cases that that that would convey the danger and the and the just resource stripping of these of these motions for for survivors?
- 23:52SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.
- 23:53SPEAKER_00: You know, Ruth talked about how the convention contemplates that these cases from start to finish will be completed in six weeks.
- 24:01SPEAKER_00: And that is one of the biggest problems.
- 24:03SPEAKER_00: You know, if we don't connect with a client quickly, almost really before the petition is filed, it is so difficult to get them competent representation in this period of time.
- 24:17SPEAKER_00: And so we know that it's just a contemplation in the convention that it's not, it's not mandatory to have this six-week from start to finish in a case.
- 24:28SPEAKER_00: But a petitioner's counsel is often putting a lot of pressure on the courts to make this very quick.
- 24:35SPEAKER_00: And it is seen as expedited litigation.
- 24:38SPEAKER_00: So if we get to the case to, you know, if if we just don't connect with the client until the case has already begun, that's really difficult.
- 24:47SPEAKER_00: It's really hard to slow it down once it is already sped up.
- 24:52SPEAKER_00: You know, a lot of times our clients need foreign evidence, witnesses.
- 24:57SPEAKER_00: They might need document translation.
- 24:59SPEAKER_00: If there's not enough time to do that, if these discovery periods of time aren't slowed down, they just can't get that.
- 25:07SPEAKER_00: And some of that is vital often to really educating the court about the seriousness of the domestic violence that took place and explaining it in ways that say, hey, you might not be able to see this violence in the way it might not have been an assault.
- 25:22SPEAKER_00: It might have been sustained psychological violence over a long period of time.
- 25:28SPEAKER_00: It might have been financial control, isolation, all the things that we know about, but that a judge might not see on a daily basis.
- 25:34SPEAKER_00: And so if they can't get that evidence, or that expert, or that expert talking about course of control, or that expert talking about why it's futile to go and make an allegation against an abuser in that particular country, because even though there's great laws on the books, in reality, they're not prosecuted or they're encouraged to settle it as a family matter, things like that.
- 26:01SPEAKER_00: You know, if we can't put that all into play, then these respondents who already have to sustain this these really high burdens of proof, they're at such a disadvantage.
- 26:11SPEAKER_00: We have never, I'm I'm yet to see a case where a respondent mother lost her Hague convention case and then won her custody case thereafter.
- 26:21SPEAKER_00: That's how significant this this these Hague cases are.
- 26:26SPEAKER_04: And further to that, there are a number of countries where the mother can then be criminalized for kidnapping.
- 26:37SPEAKER_04: And so she goes back with the child to try and protect the child and ends up in prison.
- 26:42SPEAKER_04: So obviously, custody is is off the books at that point.
- 26:45SPEAKER_04: So yes, it's uh she's once she's in the wrong, she's thoroughly in the wrong.
- 26:52R: Wow.
- 26:53R: David, I saw you wanted to comment.
- 26:56David Mandel: Yeah, I I want to go back to one of Leslie's points and and you're just appreciating just the the painfulness of the entire thing.
- 27:05David Mandel: Leslie used the phrase competent counsel, competent representation.
- 27:10David Mandel: You know, and I was thinking about a training I did in Australia a couple years ago for for about 200 family law lawyers.
- 27:21David Mandel: And some of them were Hague lawyers, and they I was presenting them about our perpetrator pattern-based approach and the multiple pathways to harm, and and they said this was new to them and very useful information, right?
- 27:33David Mandel: So they their feedback was this was this was valuable.
- 27:36David Mandel: But can you describe either what you've seen or what you think the standard of competent representation?
- 27:45David Mandel: And I'm not talking about the the need for logistical translation, so on and so forth, but that the the understanding of both the domestic abuse issues but the legal issues that you'd want to see in a competent Hague attorney representing a domestic violence survivor and their children.
- 28:05SPEAKER_00: Yeah, absolutely.
- 28:06SPEAKER_00: I mean, and we say we come, we work with lawyers all the time, just so that I'm clear, who have no background in domestic violence and or hague abduction convention related cases, but we we train them and we work alongside of them and and we guide them and make them into the experts.
- 28:25SPEAKER_00: And I absolutely believe that that can be done.
- 28:29SPEAKER_00: But you, you know, the I think a lawyer who is representing a survivor in these cases, yes, absolutely has to learn the Hague convention, but also needs to be trauma informed and needs to understand the ways in which their client might not present evidence in a cohesive way, particularly when they first meet and why that might be.
- 28:53SPEAKER_00: And you need to meet your client where they are.
- 28:56SPEAKER_00: And that I think is the biggest block.
- 29:00SPEAKER_00: I've seen so many cases where the, you know, our clients get to us after the Hague, unfortunately, is done and the appeal period is done, and there's not much we can do for them.
- 29:12SPEAKER_00: Where they had attorneys where it was clear maybe they thought it was like, you know, an extension of a custody case or didn't fully appreciate the domestic violence because it was non-physical, things like that.
- 29:26SPEAKER_00: So that's really important to us, and that's what we train on to.
- 29:30R: I, you know, I'm just gonna, I'm gonna encourage our readers, our listeners who are advocates and who are working in policy and law to really lean into the gaps around legal representation for survivors and victims of domestic abuse and coercive control.
- 29:51R: And the fact of the matter is, and I'm just gonna call out the the legal community for failing to appropriately train lawyers in how to deal with domestic abuse and coercive control and child abuse in the context of custody and access.
- 30:11R: Massive failures.
- 30:13R: And in the United States, this is exacerbated by the fact that there's so many different ways that custody and access as court systems exist within the many different regions of the United States, right?
- 30:28R: And and children and victims are being victimized, harmed, and children are being abused and dying because of this gap.
- 30:43R: And and and you know, I I sometimes wonder why when lawyers seem so incredibly motivated to win cases, they do not seem incredibly motivated to win cases around coercive control and domestic abuse in this context.
- 31:02R: And so people really need to do better.
- 31:05R: And there's lots of training around this that exists.
- 31:10R: You know, you're training, we're training, but the lack of engagement indicates some massive blind spots, passivities, victim blaming that just exists widely in the legal setting.
- 31:27R: And we need to reform those attitudes if we're gonna actually reform the court systems themselves and the way that they're interpreting the law and the way they're doing business.
- 31:43R: So just a shout out to the people who are doing that work, but also really saying we need more of it.
- 31:51R: We need more engaged lawyers, we need more lawyers trained and more lawyers concerned about this con this specific types of cases, which I would argue are probably about 60% of custody and access cases that go to go to you know legal representation and negotiation, high conflict cases.
- 32:15R: So I think too, it would be really beneficial for our listeners to hear about how the decontextualization of domestic abuse, of perpetrators' patterns, of the actions that they take to harm their relationships, to harm the adult survivor, and to harm children, how that's playing out in the context of the the Hague Convention and these custody and access cases.
- 32:47R: Really?
- 32:47R: So let's let's dive into the decontextualization issue, both around the safety and well-being of the child and the adult impact on them.
- 33:01SPEAKER_00: Do you want to kick off Leslie?
- 33:03SPEAKER_00: Sure.
- 33:04SPEAKER_00: I mean, one thing that I think about a lot is I used to work for the court system prior to my current role.
- 33:12SPEAKER_00: And so I think a lot about courts' credibility determinations because sometimes, particularly in domestic violence cases, you might that might be all you have.
- 33:22SPEAKER_00: You might just have testimony.
- 33:24SPEAKER_00: And so if you have a client who comes in, you know, I'm thinking, you know, back to one client we had who came in.
- 33:33SPEAKER_00: She had a very, very long history, of course, of control.
- 33:37SPEAKER_00: But the facts were a little bit, you know, different than what we normally would see.
- 33:43SPEAKER_00: And we knew that a court would have a lot of difficulty kind of understanding it.
- 33:48SPEAKER_00: And to compound that, she didn't remember full details.
- 33:53SPEAKER_00: She there were pivotal moments that she it was almost like it was a black hole.
- 33:59SPEAKER_00: She couldn't remember some kind of specific event.
- 34:03SPEAKER_00: She could not tell her story really in chronological order.
- 34:08SPEAKER_00: Sometimes we would ask her a question and she'd respond talking about something really quite different.
- 34:15SPEAKER_00: And these are all, we know that these are all responses to the trauma that she endured for decades.
- 34:24SPEAKER_00: But thinking about it, what how is a judge going to respond to that when that person is testifying?
- 34:33SPEAKER_00: That's a really difficult problem.
- 34:36SPEAKER_00: And so, you know, we work with our clients, obviously, and our partners do too, to help prepare them for testimony, to prepare them for cross-examination, which can be horrifying and re-traumatizing in and of itself.
- 34:49SPEAKER_00: But when you're not thinking with this framework that a survivor is different than your normal quote unquote abducting parent, you're doing them such a disservice.
- 35:01SPEAKER_00: And they're really set up to lose in that framework.
- 35:05R: Yeah.
- 35:06R: Right.
- 35:07R: Ruth, did you want to add to that around decontextualization?
- 35:11SPEAKER_04: Yes, I think that's so right.
- 35:13SPEAKER_04: And you have, on the other hand, the father who, if he's a perpetrator father, he's not actually emotionally involved in the thought he might lose his child.
- 35:22SPEAKER_04: He's just involved in the idea of getting control back.
- 35:25SPEAKER_04: So he journey presents really well.
- 35:27SPEAKER_04: He often is the richer of the pair, and often the the mother has left the relationship and is in poverty.
- 35:33SPEAKER_04: And so he's wearing the right suit, he's he's speaking in modulated tones, he remembers everything, he's made notes because you know he's he's prepared himself for this.
- 35:42SPEAKER_04: So the the difference in those two, in the way those two testimonies are received is really quite stark, and it's it still surprises me that judges don't uh remain unaware of that context of those two witnesses, but consistently blame the mother for not remembering things for maybe getting it wrong or maybe saying an answer one moment and then sort of seems to contradict her answer the next minute.
- 36:10SPEAKER_04: And the number of mothers who've had responses from judges about how they're not believable and they're not credible, and look how good and thoughtful the father is.
- 36:20SPEAKER_04: It is the norm, it's absolutely the norm.
- 36:23SPEAKER_04: And I think as well that back to this old thing that plays back into this, because the perpetrator is the left-behind father, he's the victim, he's being supported by the state, so he can afford to bring these cases forward, and the mother is not.
- 36:39SPEAKER_04: He's the victim, and she is the offender, and taking the sending the child back is the best interest of the child.
- 36:47SPEAKER_04: So we have all that set up there.
- 36:49SPEAKER_04: That is, it's not decontextualized, it's just a new context.
- 36:53SPEAKER_04: It's the context of Davo.
- 36:55SPEAKER_04: So deny, deny, attack, reverse victim and offender.
- 37:00SPEAKER_04: That's exactly what the context is.
- 37:02SPEAKER_04: And it doesn't matter how good your lawyer is and how well your mum gives the testimony, that context is mitigating against her really quite severely.
- 37:13SPEAKER_04: One example, I mean, lots of really horrific examples of injustice that have occurred because of this, you know, Darvo approach.
- 37:23SPEAKER_04: So a student from Eastern European country went to Britain to study, and she was raped and became pregnant and tried to continue with her studies but wasn't able to.
- 37:36SPEAKER_04: So went home to get the support of her family to bring up the child.
- 37:40SPEAKER_04: A hericase was brought against her.
- 37:42SPEAKER_04: It was not considered that she would be at grave risk coming back to the UK because the UK is considered to be such a safe place for mothers and children.
- 37:50SPEAKER_04: So she was sent back.
- 37:52SPEAKER_04: She was sent back on a visitor's visa, she didn't have a permanent visa, student visa, so she can't work.
- 37:57SPEAKER_04: And she's been living in abject poverty ever since.
- 38:01SPEAKER_04: And she's going to be stuck here until the child is 16 and able to do anything, basically, and just hoping that she can keep getting her visa renewed.
- 38:10SPEAKER_04: And that sort of injustice is so bewildering, so mind-boggling.
- 38:17SPEAKER_04: It can only happen because of that Darvo context, which has placed her in the wrong.
- 38:23SPEAKER_04: And so everything else follows from that.
- 38:25SPEAKER_04: Right.
- 38:26R: My goodness.
- 38:27R: That's such a terrible story, Ruth.
- 38:31David Mandel: I, you know, I have two thoughts off of this, and then one and one that I'll do the latter one that came in as I was listening to the conversation.
- 38:40David Mandel: The image of sort of uh mostly fathers filing these international cases and showing up in this other country, you know, following, following, kind of and engaging the resources.
- 38:53David Mandel: Talk about family court on steroids.
- 38:58David Mandel: I I I can't imagine they're not also leveraging gender bias on steroids.
- 39:04David Mandel: And what I mean by that is, you know, for 30 years I've been hearing about how fathers who show up and say abusive fathers, coercively controlling fathers, who show up to court in a white shirt in a suit, crying, saying how much they love their children, how much leverage that gives them emotionally in these situations.
- 39:27David Mandel: And now we're adding sort of cross-border efforts.
- 39:32David Mandel: I am willing to travel to the ends of the earth to make sure I have contact with my kids.
- 39:40David Mandel: That I can't believe that there isn't an emotional resonance that's there that plays a role unconsciously, I'm assuming.
- 39:49David Mandel: That's one thing.
- 39:51David Mandel: That was just a statement.
- 39:52David Mandel: The question is, you know, in local jurisdictions, so not international jurisdictions, I've seen the value of putting a perpetrator pattern in front of a judge.
- 40:08David Mandel: And with that information, a reasonable jurist would say, did say, I'm taking a particular case, would say, that a mom fleeing from one US state, so this is internal, to another state was a reasonable protective effort.
- 40:23David Mandel: So once they were given that information about the perpetrator's pattern, they saw the fleeing contextualized to, oh, that's protection.
- 40:33David Mandel: That's what protection looks like.
- 40:35David Mandel: Removing your children from a violent situation is protection.
- 40:39David Mandel: That's what we'd expect.
- 40:40David Mandel: In fact, you're required to, like I really want to say this.
- 40:43David Mandel: That's what we require parents to do, to provide for the children's basic safety, their basic needs.
- 40:49David Mandel: It's a requirement legally.
- 40:51David Mandel: Like I just I want to I just want to keep going back to this.
- 40:54David Mandel: This is not a nice to have, but sort of, you know, it's and so jurists who are presented in that context with that information, I've seen them come to a good decision, you know, a good understanding.
- 41:08David Mandel: Does that information matter in Hague conventions, given what you're saying, the legal standard and the focus?
- 41:15David Mandel: Where or where have you seen it matter when that information is brought forward and is brought forward well?
- 41:23SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, I think it definitely matters.
- 41:25SPEAKER_00: I I think it's hard to bring it forward because there's this understanding that an abduction took place right from the get-go.
- 41:35SPEAKER_00: Like it's so, it almost doesn't get flipped until the end of a Hague litigation.
- 41:41SPEAKER_00: And one of the problems is so much, you know, a lot of the information about whatever kind of abuse occurred doesn't come out until there's a fact finding.
- 41:52SPEAKER_00: So there's just this sense push it along, push it along.
- 41:55SPEAKER_00: This this child has been taken from their home country and needs to get back there very quickly.
- 42:01SPEAKER_00: And then only in the rarest occasions does a court find, okay, you know, this this violence was so significant that you can't safely go back there.
- 42:16David Mandel: So I've I've described parental, so I'm gonna keep going back to your metaphor of steroids, because that was your metaphor in the notes.
- 42:24David Mandel: But so this is parental alienation on steroids.
- 42:28David Mandel: This is a sword and a shield, right?
- 42:30David Mandel: It's it's it's a sword to attack and it's a shield to deflect from the domestic abuse perpetration that's likely to have gone on.
- 42:38David Mandel: So is that is that a fair accurate accurate like this is point of play?
- 42:42David Mandel: You just described like you you so the a protective parent who's fled is immediately suspect, immediately the problem, immediately has to defend themselves.
- 42:53David Mandel: And you're saying the amount of effort it takes to get the court to say, to flip the script and say, wow, there's and even and and what I'm saying here is even on terrorists, even if you were in danger, we're not sure the child was in danger.
- 43:10David Mandel: So you've got to make a case.
- 43:11David Mandel: Not only did domestic violence happen, but it's relevant to the child's condition, right?
- 43:16David Mandel: Is that is that might be really understanding of the legal barriers or arguments that need to be made?
- 43:22SPEAKER_04: Absolutely.
- 43:23SPEAKER_04: And there's a there's a further tripwire, and that is that there's something called protective orders or or mediating measures.
- 43:32SPEAKER_04: Uh, and so you can prove grave risk, and the judge can still decide to send you back with these so-called protective orders, which are no use at all.
- 43:41SPEAKER_04: I mean, we know domestically that protection orders frequently fail.
- 43:45SPEAKER_04: And so across international borders, with no follow-up, with no knowledge of whether the woman has the courage to actually take her partner back to court again for breaking a non molestation order, for example.
- 44:00SPEAKER_04: So, with no knowledge at all of all the evidence against them, judges will nonetheless ignore the grave risk and send the child back with a protection order.
- 44:10SPEAKER_04: It's yes, it's it's I think part of the issue is that there's a real feeling that the convention is a success story.
- 44:20SPEAKER_04: And in terms of its original purpose and how efficiently it brings children back, it really is a success story.
- 44:27SPEAKER_04: In terms of the number of countries that signed up to it, it's a success story.
- 44:31SPEAKER_04: So it's international cooperation, you know, all sorts of levels.
- 44:35SPEAKER_04: It's a brilliant piece of work, really.
- 44:37SPEAKER_04: And so people are very proud of it and they don't want it undermined.
- 44:40SPEAKER_04: And if the exceptions, and they're called exceptions because they're meant to be exceptional, we're not meant to use them a lot, if the exceptions can constantly be used in cases of domestic violence to say grave risk, no return, then the entire convention starts to crumble.
- 44:57SPEAKER_04: And those administering the convention have spoken to that effect that at all costs the convention must be protected.
- 45:04SPEAKER_04: So there's also this sort of administrative desire to not make any changes, because once one domino falls, then the rest will start crumbling.
- 45:16David Mandel: And is that really related to the the other Hague convention?
- 45:20David Mandel: Is the other it's it's about the investment in the wider framework, or is it about particularly this particular convention related to to children and in and and abduction?
- 45:32SPEAKER_04: That's an interesting question.
- 45:33SPEAKER_04: I I don't know the answer.
- 45:35SPEAKER_04: I know this is one of the conventions that they are particularly proud of, but yes, I guess the the whole standing of The Hague is interrelated, isn't it?
- 45:44R: I'm gonna ask this question, and I I think probably I know the answer to it.
- 45:49R: But have the people who say that this is a success tracked the well-being and safety of the children who were returned to the domestic violence perpetrator.
- 46:00R: No.
- 46:01R: Okay.
- 46:02R: So so they don't actually know.
- 46:04R: This is this is the internal navel gazing of a law where it's like, no, it's a success because look at the interesting thing, I think, is no, it's um yeah, really, yeah.
- 46:18SPEAKER_04: They do now know.
- 46:19SPEAKER_04: That's the interesting thing.
- 46:21SPEAKER_04: So I I I'm not a lawyer, so I started this in a state of total ignorance.
- 46:26SPEAKER_04: This is probably just as well.
- 46:27SPEAKER_04: Otherwise, I possibly wouldn't have taken it on.
- 46:30SPEAKER_04: But with working with our partners, including Sanctuary for Families, Narcus Goland, we managed to get the Hague Bureau or this Secretary General to agree that there would be a domestic violence in the Hague Forum in South Africa in 2024, and then there was a follow-up one in Brazil 2025.
- 46:48SPEAKER_04: And the one in South Africa was extraordinary, really, and it was to give credit to the Secretary General, he took a risk by putting the words domestic violence and the Hague Convention together as a forum title.
- 47:02SPEAKER_04: There was an audience of a hundred judges, government representatives, senior legal officials, etc., and I think 300 online.
- 47:11SPEAKER_04: And we went out to South Africa, a bundle of us, and we managed to get a survivors panel.
- 47:18SPEAKER_04: There was a fight because there was some concern that we wanted to keep it objective.
- 47:23SPEAKER_04: But we got a survivors panel, and it was absolutely extraordinary.
- 47:28SPEAKER_04: I will never forget it.
- 47:30SPEAKER_04: It was one of the most moving things, most powerful things I've ever seen in my life, seen or heard in my life.
- 47:36SPEAKER_04: We had we had mums speaking on video, we had uh their testimonies spoken by others, but then two mothers, one from Australia and one from New Zealand, who've both set up support organizations, some others, came and told their stories.
- 47:51SPEAKER_04: And it you could have heard a pin drop.
- 47:54SPEAKER_04: And I think that would have been the first time for many of those in that hall that they had ever, ever heard the extraordinary brutality and cruelty that arises from this convention.
- 48:09SPEAKER_04: And it did create it did change some hearts and minds.
- 48:15SPEAKER_04: But then I think in the intervening period, uh lots of fathers' rights activists have really there's been a backlash, and so the The Hague have sort of doubled down, and then so we found Brazil was much less open to any ideas of change.
- 48:32SPEAKER_04: And I think we're going to come on to talk about Brazil briefly, but the Brazil Supreme Court have done some brilliant work on changing the implementation of The Hague, and that was really dismissed by Hague officials during the Brazil Forum.
- 48:47SPEAKER_04: So they do know, and I had thought once they knew they would change.
- 48:52SPEAKER_04: So that's been an eye-opener for me.
- 48:55SPEAKER_04: Yeah.
- 48:56R: I I you know, I one of the things I I know we're we're we're we're good on time, and there's a lot of things to ask, and I wish I could cover everything.
- 49:09R: I know that the in the context of these disputes, that that's that countries have very different understandings.
- 49:18R: The signatories have very different understandings of domestic abuse, of coercive control, and that that is absolutely impacting the way that these cases are seen.
- 49:32R: And and you know, that's not surprising because even within countries, right, in Australia, there's different understandings of domestic abuse.
- 49:41R: Some have coercive control laws, some don't, in the United States as well.
- 49:46R: But that can you talk a little bit about how those differing understandings between the signatories are impacting victims and children and outcomes for them?
- 50:01SPEAKER_00: Yeah, absolutely.
- 50:02SPEAKER_00: So Ruth talked a little bit about ameliorative measures, and this is where it really comes down to it.
- 50:07SPEAKER_00: So I told we talked about the Article 13B defense.
- 50:11SPEAKER_00: That's where you can allege domestic violence.
- 50:15SPEAKER_00: And if the court, like Ruth said, finds that the respondent parent has sustained that burden, the court then still can consider if there's these ameliorative measures that's like a safeguard that can be put into place in order to lessen that risk to the child and still return the child back to that country of habitual residence.
- 50:35SPEAKER_00: So we argue that these don't work because different countries have very different legal systems.
- 50:43SPEAKER_00: So let's say a court in the US finds grave risk but still returns the child and adds all these ameliorative measures in.
- 50:51SPEAKER_00: So, like the abuser maybe agrees to a protective order that he won't harass the survivor.
- 50:57SPEAKER_00: The abuser pays for the survivor's housing.
- 50:59SPEAKER_00: We see things like this all the time.
- 51:02SPEAKER_00: And they might be well-intentioned, but these measures may not take effect automatically.
- 51:09SPEAKER_00: The abuser may have full control over whether they do take effect or not.
- 51:14SPEAKER_00: And an abuser can really use this to their advantage.
- 51:17SPEAKER_00: So we see these ameliorative measures actually often heightening the power and control dynamic between parties because it can invite this dependency again, the survivor has on the abuser.
- 51:31SPEAKER_00: And we have even seen a case in the United States where this is so sad to me, a respondent mother, you know, they found grave risk, but said that there were ameliorative measures that could be put into place.
- 51:44SPEAKER_00: The child was returned back to the country of habitual residence.
- 51:47SPEAKER_00: The mother returned with the child, and there were all of these ameliorative measures that were put into place.
- 51:52SPEAKER_00: She then alleged that none of them actually happened once she got back to that other country.
- 51:58SPEAKER_00: And she petitioned that original court in the US for a finding of violation, saying, you know, please help me.
- 52:04SPEAKER_00: You put this into place.
- 52:05SPEAKER_00: It's not working.
- 52:06SPEAKER_00: And the court said to her, the child was returned.
- 52:09SPEAKER_00: We no longer have jurisdiction.
- 52:11SPEAKER_00: The end.
- 52:12SPEAKER_00: Go take it up in the new country.
- 52:14SPEAKER_00: You give the abuser all the power there, you know, however well-intentioned that original decision might have been.
- 52:20R: Yeah.
- 52:20R: And those came about in order to try to solve this problem, which shows that the drafters of those measures had no knowledge of course of control and ongoing domestic abuse.
- 52:31R: This is part of the problem.
- 52:33R: I mean, beginning with the inception of the 1980, you know, agreement, where the very drafter of this, who was a woman, said that she didn't even consider gender-based violence because it wasn't a consideration in her mind.
- 52:49R: Well, we're just scaling all over the place, people.
- 52:53R: You know, I am horrified at the thoughts of a court system saying, oh, well, the perpetrator is going to pay for your housing.
- 53:02R: Therefore, everything is good.
- 53:06R: What a bunch of blowing.
- 53:08R: David, did you want to comment on that?
- 53:10R: Because that's just crazy.
- 53:12David Mandel: You know, I think you've really covered it in terms of the coercive control and the dynamic.
- 53:18David Mandel: And I did appreciate the context of the the sort of pay for housing.
- 53:22David Mandel: And we see this in child safety cases, you know, where sort of you you sort of you try to fix it, you try to kind of compensate, but you have to be really careful that you're not creating more conditions of control and more avenues.
- 53:36David Mandel: And and this is why the understanding of course control is so important across the board for everybody to really understand.
- 53:43David Mandel: And again, I keep going back to the failure of systems, whether it's the training of lawyers, whether it's the legal framework, to really understand a perpetrator pattern-based approach and this continued chopping up.
- 53:57David Mandel: And I and I think I don't want to make them too responsible because these are advocacy issues that have developed separately.
- 54:03David Mandel: These are research fields that are still siloed.
- 54:06David Mandel: You know, the people who handle like child spanking and corporal punishment are different from the child maltreatment people, who are different from the child safety people, who are different from the child sexual abuse people, that the professionals need to take responsibility for working in silos and say, no, we need to say, be able to create the picture of how somebody who's using violence, course control, how they're impacting the entire family.
- 54:30David Mandel: And this idea that you can abuse one child and start impacting the other one is just is sort of absurd.
- 54:38David Mandel: So I think I'm just going back to basics, Ruth, right now, which is sort of like we we need that fundamental shift in the way we all look at and talk about these issues.
- 54:48SPEAKER_04: I mean, one tiny glimmer of hope, uh, which actually came out of the South Africa Forum or was was encouraged by the South Africa Forum.
- 54:56SPEAKER_04: So one of our senior judges in the UK, who is now actually uh the senior judge in the UK, uh, was at the South Africa Forum and was very, very moved by the presentations from the survivors and spoke at length to one of them subsequently and promised to put training in place for Hague judges, which I spoke to him at the Brazil conference, and he had done that.
- 55:20SPEAKER_04: But also he was he was on a on a Hague case relatively recently, and he made a no-return decision based on the acknowledgement that the sustained coercive control that the woman had undergone had impacted her mental health severely, and she was in a state of absolute fear and terror of the abuser.
- 55:44SPEAKER_04: And the decision was made that, well, not the decision was made, but it was clear that this was impacting her capability of being a parent, and that more so if she was returned and she would go back with the child to try and protect the child, that the impact would be such that she would probably have a breakdown.
- 56:03SPEAKER_04: And what was discussed, because uh often I'm sure we've all seen in courts that the mother's state of mental health, which has been damaged by the perpetrator, is often used against her.
- 56:14SPEAKER_04: And so she loses custody because she's crazy or you know, she can't cope.
- 56:18SPEAKER_04: So it was quite interesting that in this case it was considered that the perpetrator's behavior had caused this, and that her fear may or may not be appropriate.
- 56:30SPEAKER_04: You know, we couldn't tell because she wasn't sent back, but they wouldn't send her back because her parenting would be even yes, would be indelibly damaged, or ability to parent would be.
- 56:42SPEAKER_04: So that was a case where I mean I've no idea how much the South Africa experience impacted as a judge, how much the training impacted the judge, how much reading around the subject impacted.
- 56:54SPEAKER_04: But what was interesting to me was that a lot of judges know about this stuff, but they don't have the right attitude.
- 57:01SPEAKER_04: They don't care, basically.
- 57:03SPEAKER_04: And so I think what I saw, what I hope we saw in that judgment, was somebody who cared, somebody who actually wanted to be sure that the mother and child were safe.
- 57:13SPEAKER_04: And it's I think David mentioned it earlier, it's that hearts and minds thing.
- 57:17SPEAKER_04: That's what's so difficult when we live in a society which is drenched in misogyny and sexism and so on.
- 57:24R: Yeah.
- 57:25R: Well, I want to transition to some places that may be getting it right.
- 57:33R: And I'm gonna say this poorly in Portuguese.
- 57:35R: A lot of people don't know.
- 57:37R: I am a Latin American and Azorian woman, and I have to learn Portuguese.
- 57:41R: So this is my shout out to O Brasil está na vanguarda.
- 57:47R: They're leading the way, the woman is leading the way in in reform.
- 57:53R: So could you speak a little bit about how Brazil has contextualized the the failures of this agreement and tried to make sure that they are not doing further harm when they apply it?
- 58:13SPEAKER_04: Yeah, sure.
- 58:14SPEAKER_04: So Brazil's Supreme Court looked at the convention in relation to the Brazilian constitution.
- 58:22SPEAKER_04: Uh, and they came up with a judgment in August 2025, I think it was.
- 58:27SPEAKER_04: And essentially the overarching approach was to consider that the effectiveness of the convention shouldn't be measured on the basis of the speed of return, which is sort of how it tends to operate, but by its capability of reconciling international cooperation and genuine protection for women and children.
- 58:51SPEAKER_04: So that's the balance they wanted to get rather than simply the default send the child back.
- 58:56SPEAKER_04: So the discussions that were had, and there were lots of really superb women's organizations and feminist organizations, domestic violence professionals working with the judiciary on this.
- 59:07SPEAKER_04: And it was a really, really impressive approach, I think.
- 59:10SPEAKER_04: So the discussions included an appreciation of the gender inequalities that we've mentioned before that absolutely underpin all these cases, and a decision that they needed to be central to any evaluation of whether there should be a return or not.
- 59:25SPEAKER_04: So not just an assumption that mothers and fathers were equal in terms of power and resources, and particularly an understanding that migrant women had further detriments to them that had to be considered.
- 59:38SPEAKER_04: So what they were looking for was the idea of a contextual assessment, so exactly what we've been talking about earlier.
- 59:46SPEAKER_04: They also appreciated that this is a human rights issue for mothers and their children.
- 59:51SPEAKER_04: Again, yes, yes, please.
- 59:54SPEAKER_04: And that the difficulties the mother would have in building their evidence base were really undermining her opportunities to get justice.
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_04: So they lowered the standard of proof, they appreciated the difficulties of getting the evidence and getting the evidence in the right language, they appreciated the inequality of armours in terms of support that's not given to mothers but given to fathers very often.
- 1:00:19SPEAKER_04: And they decided that courts must apply a gender-based perspective and give decisive weight with their words to victims' testimonies.
- 1:00:29SPEAKER_04: So rather than the victim blaming and disbelief, the victims' testimonies were taken at face value.
- 1:00:36SPEAKER_04: Yeah, this is this is the truth, this is what happened to this woman.
- 1:00:40SPEAKER_04: And plus, they wanted to ensure the child's perspective was taken into account.
- 1:00:45SPEAKER_04: So as a as a context for those initial discussions, uh, you couldn't want for more really.
- 1:00:52SPEAKER_04: So the key elements of the decision included the fact that all judgments must be made using the gender-based perspective, taking into account the best interests of the child, and must be contextualized around that gender-based perspective.
- 1:01:08SPEAKER_04: And that the judges are having training in domestic abuse, trauma, and gender bias, which is that's such a key one, I think, for me.
- 1:01:16SPEAKER_04: The domestic violence, whether it's direct or indirect in terms of the child, is at grave risk.
- 1:01:22SPEAKER_04: So if you prove it, that's a grave risk, end of that problem.
- 1:01:26SPEAKER_04: The evidence threshold has been lowered.
- 1:01:28SPEAKER_04: If you've proven grave risk, there can be no return.
- 1:01:31SPEAKER_04: You can't use protection orders to ensure a return.
- 1:01:34SPEAKER_04: Again, yes, of course.
- 1:01:36SPEAKER_04: It makes absolute sense, doesn't it?
- 1:01:39SPEAKER_04: Interestingly, they decided that in order to make a fully contextualized decision, they might might need more time.
- 1:01:48SPEAKER_04: They might need more time to get the evidence.
- 1:01:49SPEAKER_04: So they've given themselves an extended period of up to one year for the judgment to be made in contested cases, as opposed to six weeks.
- 1:01:59SPEAKER_04: And it's quite interesting.
- 1:02:00SPEAKER_04: A senior judge spoke about this at the Brazil Forum, and the Hague Secretary-General was really just he wasn't the only one, was really disturbed by the idea that a year might be taken to get it right, as opposed to getting it wrong quickly.
- 1:02:13SPEAKER_04: I was just very interesting.
- 1:02:15SPEAKER_04: And also they have, I don't know if it's in place yet, but they decided they would put in place a protocol for Brazilian consulates to assist women and children who are victims of domestic violence and who therefore might fall foul of the Hague itself.
- 1:02:30SPEAKER_04: And there's a quote here, which I I love, so I keep reminding myself of it.
- 1:02:36SPEAKER_04: The exception of grave risk to the child must be interpreted in a manner consistent with the principles of the best interests of the child and under a gender-based perspective, so as to allow its application when there are concrete indications of domestic violence, even if the child is not a direct victim.
- 1:02:53SPEAKER_04: So that sort of encapsulates really.
- 1:02:55SPEAKER_04: So that's what they've done, and you know, good for them, really.
- 1:02:59SPEAKER_04: And what I had hoped was that other countries would take it up.
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_04: But there's a lot of politics at play here, and the north-south divide, etc.
- 1:03:08SPEAKER_04: So as yet they haven't, but we we live in hope.
- 1:03:12R: That's that those are those are great the things to hear that those considerations and amendments have been inserted.
- 1:03:21R: Now, you know, the gender-based lens and the power and control lens is one that all court systems struggle with.
- 1:03:32R: They say that they're neutral, but in all effect, are not indeed neutral.
- 1:03:39R: They prioritize the person who has the most resources and who often brought the claim, which is, you know, we hear that presumption in this in this instance as well, that the presumption is that there was an abduction and that there was a there was a crime committed across international borders.
- 1:04:01R: Uh, Leslie, did you want to add anything around those additional considerations that Brazil is inserting?
- 1:04:09SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you know, just briefly, I mean, the evaluation under the best interests of the child, that's huge.
- 1:04:16SPEAKER_00: We absolutely, we expressly do not do that in the United States.
- 1:04:20SPEAKER_00: And when you think about the severity of the consequences, it's it's it's really troubling that we we don't have that kind of analysis.
- 1:04:31SPEAKER_00: And then also this idea, this understanding that the child may not be the direct victim, is so important because we see these court decisions all the time where it references, oh, well, the child was outside of the room of the domestic violence, or the child didn't see this specific occurrence.
- 1:04:51SPEAKER_00: And I think that is such a, you know, we're not really understanding domestic violence then.
- 1:04:56SPEAKER_00: Domestic violence doesn't happen in this one little instance and then it's it's gone and there, it's not, you know, it's pervasive over a relationship.
- 1:05:04SPEAKER_00: And obviously, we know it it it impacts children in so many different ways.
- 1:05:09SPEAKER_00: So the fact that the court's acknowledging that and saying they're going to consider that is huge to me and makes me optimistic too.
- 1:05:16R: I mean, we didn't even sign the rights of the child convention, okay?
- 1:05:19R: Let's just write double set here.
- 1:05:22R: Um yeah.
- 1:05:23David Mandel: So it the out of you piece, as I'm listening, less it's you talking about that, you know, again, it's such a common framework.
- 1:05:33David Mandel: It's a sort of suggests that the nexus between domestic abuse and children is seeing and hearing, right?
- 1:05:39David Mandel: And I always, you know, kind of again in in my book, kind of have a whole chapter on the myth of the the child witness, you know, this idea that the nexus is only that versus all these other things.
- 1:05:50David Mandel: And and right now, what's coming to me is sort of really just to to the continuum.
- 1:05:56David Mandel: So would we hold that standard, and I hate to be extreme.
- 1:06:00David Mandel: If the murder happened of them outside the view of the child, that the child wasn't impacted.
- 1:06:05SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 1:06:06David Mandel: If if the mom was put in a coma, okay, for a week, was would that child not be impacted?
- 1:06:11David Mandel: If the mom had a leg broken, or you know, you start working back from the extreme and go, so so what does it really take?
- 1:06:20David Mandel: Well, like what what are really is our thesis or hypothesis there that says it's it's somehow something because there's a wooden door between the child and does the door have to be soundproof?
- 1:06:32David Mandel: Do we really I mean, because we don't even really go into that, like like even in these arguments, people just assume they have the most superficial understanding.
- 1:06:40David Mandel: They want to separate it, they want to see it separated in many cases, and they don't want, and this is what we again we do through the model, which is like, wait a second, let's draw a connection between those behaviors and how the family's functioning differently or how the child's life is different because of this.
- 1:06:57David Mandel: I always use the example when a perpetrator forces, and this is this is again on steroids, when a perpetrator forces a mom and kids to leave and go to refuge or to shelter, the kids may never have seen anything, but that forced choice to prioritize safety of a child's parent, let's just use that, disrupts the in child's child, the entire child's life, where they're sleeping, where they're walking out the door the next day, their toys, their contact, their school, their medical, you know, could disrupt everything, their entire ecosystem.
- 1:07:38David Mandel: Because a parent makes a choice, well, I deserve to be safe, and they deserve not to have a who's dead or in danger.
- 1:07:44David Mandel: So this is again this choice on steroids, and we somehow are like nope, not connected, not relevant, not part of the conversation, nope, nothing to see here.
- 1:07:56David Mandel: And it's it's an there's a there's a I want to call, I feel like I'm you know been spending so much time with Ruth that that sort of I I've my filter is is going away.
- 1:08:07David Mandel: But it's the the the illogic of it in a system that prides itself on reason and argumentation.
- 1:08:20David Mandel: And and and again, so I'm gonna again I'm gonna kind of channel Ruth here for a second.
- 1:08:24David Mandel: For people for for lawyers who are defending or representing, and not defending it's not a criminal case, but you know, representing domestic violence victim, this is to to challenge the illogic of those arguments, to challenge the idea that you need to have in your argumentation arsenal, this is not historic, this is not irrelevant, and this is not disconnected from the child's best interests.
- 1:08:53David Mandel: Like if you are somebody who is representing, whether it's in a in a in a state, in a in a local jurisdiction, family law case, or a hate case, if this is not part of your argumentation armory, and I'm using it really specifically, I'm using that kind of war battle language.
- 1:09:10David Mandel: If it is not, then you are not prepared to defend in a full-throated defense your client.
- 1:09:17David Mandel: And let's call that what it is, which is a gap in legal capacity training and skill.
- 1:09:23David Mandel: Yeah.
- 1:09:24David Mandel: Did I, Ruth?
- 1:09:25David Mandel: Did I do you justice?
- 1:09:27R: You got there.
- 1:09:27R: You almost got there.
- 1:09:28R: You weren't quite no, but it's sort of I just call that naming what's real because it is.
- 1:09:36David Mandel: Yeah, but it's but it is it, but it's just sort of magical thinking.
- 1:09:40David Mandel: Sorry that I'm kind of on a little bit of rant, but just magical thinking that uh that a a a piece of plastic, a door, or wooden or piece of wood, somehow is this magical shield that that bubble that that kind of prevents anything from impacting the child.
- 1:09:58David Mandel: Uh is is it's crazy.
- 1:10:01R: And it's just a layer of insanity once you get to play dislocated services, like, oh yeah, that child's not at all impacted by being forced into refuge.
- 1:10:11R: Let me force you into refuge for two weeks and see how you do, buddy.
- 1:10:15David Mandel: Or to or to make that argument, again, I'm going back to the lawyers who are again the capacity of those lawyers who are representing moms in these cases, which is the actual, you know, I know there's lots of barriers and evidence and things, but the but really to start with the argument that the forcing somebody to leave their own country leave a country and uproot is a cardinal harm created by the the user of violence, user of course control.
- 1:10:52David Mandel: It is it's a choice that wouldn't be made without the presence of violence.
- 1:10:57David Mandel: And I and going back, I think, Ruth, to to your comment, which is sort of like hearts and minds.
- 1:11:03R: We have to at least there may be legal barriers, maybe evidence barriers, but do I have that concept in my view, in my legal brain, as I consider what's in front of me, and and I hear that Brazil is has done a lot of this, which is really part of this is an implicit belief that children are bouncy, that they're not gonna experience the long-term impact of dislocation, of threats, of anxiety, of physical injury, even, and that is not real.
- 1:11:40R: And that presumption has to go away because it's harming children and their well-being.
- 1:11:47R: And on the other side of that presumption is that we need to give a large amount of grace, particularly to men as parents, not necessarily women as parents, around their parenting, and around their violence and control in the home.
- 1:12:07R: And that is a horrible presumption.
- 1:12:09R: And again, it is not a neutral presumption, it is not gender neutral, it's extremely gender specific.
- 1:12:16R: And those those presumptions and those allowances we can show very well across the board globally, are given to men as parents, not to women as parents.
- 1:12:32R: So there is gender bias in our legal system, it's just not explicit necessarily, it's implicit, right?
- 1:12:41R: And it's hidden behind the motions and the language, and but it comes out very clearly in the judgments, it's very clear as a pattern.
- 1:12:51R: So I think really pushing back on the court's own claim that it is neutral and showing the court where they're not at all actually neutral and they're not considering the rights of children, they're not considering the well-being of children.
- 1:13:08R: And they're doing active harm to the rights and the access and the custody of women as parents, particularly in the context of domestic abuse, is really, really important.
- 1:13:19R: So everybody just needs to keep pushing and being very clear about the outcomes.
- 1:13:25R: I want to start moving to hearing about what Hague Moms is doing now and how you all see changing this reality and what you're doing right now to do that.
- 1:13:38R: So let I would love our listeners to hear about that.
- 1:13:42unknown: Okay.
- 1:13:43SPEAKER_04: Well, there were three aspects, I guess, to what we're doing, all of them focused on the safety and well-being of mothers and children, which is our obviously our ultimate aim.
- 1:13:52SPEAKER_04: And it's all it's all contained within the fact that essentially, other than this one part-time member of staff, we are just a voluntary global network.
- 1:14:01SPEAKER_04: So we can only do what we can do.
- 1:14:03SPEAKER_04: So sometimes things grow more slowly than others.
- 1:14:07SPEAKER_04: But the the baseline is the grassroots building the movement.
- 1:14:12SPEAKER_04: So we want to keep expanding our membership and our partnerships in terms of expertise and location so that we're truly global.
- 1:14:19SPEAKER_04: At the moment, we've got about 120 members and advisors across the world and about 35 partners, ranging from really small survivor-led support groups to really quite big global organizations.
- 1:14:34SPEAKER_04: At the same time, or as part of that, we're trying to raise awareness of the problem at all levels, so government level, Hague level, and with survivors and the those that demographic that might become Hague victims, really.
- 1:14:48SPEAKER_04: So, for example, we with when I say we, I absolutely always mean we.
- 1:14:53SPEAKER_04: It's always the members and the partners rather than Hague mothers, which is sort of the at the hub of the network, really.
- 1:14:59SPEAKER_04: So with our partners, we got together 38,000 signature petition, which was handed into The Hague asking for change.
- 1:15:07SPEAKER_04: There was a letter writing campaign by mothers.
- 1:15:09SPEAKER_04: We produced the Mothers' Voices booklets and a video.
- 1:15:12SPEAKER_04: There've been various things done, training that we've done for domestic violence organizations, and uh Leslie's organization does superb training uh for lawyers, but also for lay people like myself, other organisations do.
- 1:15:26SPEAKER_04: Creating resources for domestic violence uh organizations, for mothers, for lawyers.
- 1:15:32SPEAKER_04: And recently we're terribly proud of this.
- 1:15:35SPEAKER_04: Several of our mothers, one of whom is also trained as a lawyer and a lawyer in Canada, produced a court support guide for Canada, which is absolutely superb.
- 1:15:45SPEAKER_04: And it's the first ever of its kind, as far as I'm aware, in that it explains to the mother what she can do, what's going to happen, and how, if at all, she can get out of the situation she's in.
- 1:15:58SPEAKER_04: So we're hoping to now to replicate that across other countries.
- 1:16:02SPEAKER_04: So those are sort of the grassroots things in the part of building the movement is trying to find funding, which as I'm sure you know, for domestic violence in women's organizations, it's really problematic right now.
- 1:16:14SPEAKER_04: And this is such a niche area, it's even more problematic for us, I think.
- 1:16:18SPEAKER_04: But so that's the grassroots.
- 1:16:20SPEAKER_04: And then in terms of legislation, we've got a sort of twofold approach.
- 1:16:24SPEAKER_04: One is domestic, and one is the bigger human rights approach that we're taking.
- 1:16:28SPEAKER_04: So it's probably very clear, changing the convention itself is currently not an option.
- 1:16:34SPEAKER_04: That's what I thought I was going to do when I started this.
- 1:16:37SPEAKER_04: I'll explain and they'll change the convention, I thought.
- 1:16:40SPEAKER_04: But you have to get all 103 signatories to agree even to one word being changed.
- 1:16:44SPEAKER_04: So that's clearly not going to happen, at least not right now.
- 1:16:47SPEAKER_04: But as Brazil has shown, it is possible to make changes at the domestic level of implementation that could really make a difference.
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_04: And if more and more countries start to do that, then the convention centrally will change by default.
- 1:17:02SPEAKER_04: It'd just be used in a different way.
- 1:17:04SPEAKER_04: So we're we're working at the moment with UK government and Australian governments in particular, just because those are two countries that are open to discussion and open to engagement with us.
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_04: So we recently met with the Australian General, sorry, Attorney General's legal team in Australia, and we were talking about the possible implementation of recommendations from a family court report, sorry, family council report from 2024 about The Hague and about safeguarding mothers in The Hague.
- 1:17:37SPEAKER_04: And so there are a number of implements implementable, sorry, that's not really a word, there's a number of recommendations that could be implemented, and they're quite keen to make progress on this and have spoken to us about it.
- 1:17:49SPEAKER_04: So, for example, that baseline of acknowledging children are victims in their own right is in there as a recommendation.
- 1:17:56SPEAKER_04: And also quite an interesting one, I think, is to for the courts to be aware that if the primary carer mother can't return with her child through fear or poverty or visa issues, then that could constitute a grave risk to the child, which is an interesting.
- 1:18:12SPEAKER_04: I mean, again, of course it could, but I've not seen other courts consider that.
- 1:18:17SPEAKER_04: They're also looking at possibly mandated training in domestic abuse and the whole dynamics of domestic violence, as they put it.
- 1:18:25SPEAKER_04: So there are a number of really good recommendations there, some of which we'd like to see strengthened, but it is a starting point.
- 1:18:31SPEAKER_04: And in the UK, we've always worked closely with the Ministry of Justice here.
- 1:18:36SPEAKER_04: And at the moment, they've committed to undertaking a really in-depth piece of research into the Hague Convention cases and the outcomes and the gender bias.
- 1:18:45SPEAKER_04: And so they're really looking at it carefully in terms of all the things that we know are important and all the things we know are problems with the Hague.
- 1:18:53SPEAKER_04: So that evidence will be superb to give us a baseline for making change, because we can prove things.
- 1:19:01SPEAKER_04: And we're working with various UK partners and with MPs and peers on a series of initiatives about private law, so family courts and the Hague Court.
- 1:19:11SPEAKER_04: So with the understanding this is a you know a spectrum.
- 1:19:14SPEAKER_04: So that's the domestic, and then really quickly, human rights.
- 1:19:19SPEAKER_04: This is the Achilles heel of the convention, as far as I'm concerned, because states have an absolute obligation, bottom line, obligation to protect their citizens from violence and other things, and to uphold the human rights of their citizens.
- 1:19:35SPEAKER_04: And by giving the pri the convention precedence, they are violating those human rights of their citizens over and over again, in the most egregious manner.
- 1:19:46SPEAKER_04: Because clearly, returning a protective mother and child to the country of their abuser is so obviously undermining their right to live free from violence.
- 1:19:55SPEAKER_04: It's straightforward, really, isn't it?
- 1:19:57SPEAKER_04: So we feel that that's that's the way that we can start to challenge the convention.
- 1:20:04SPEAKER_04: And it's quite interesting that Brazil took a human rights approach when they looked at the constitutionality of it.
- 1:20:10SPEAKER_04: So we might bring a case to the European Court of Human Rights.
- 1:20:13SPEAKER_04: Uh, we've had an interesting conversation at a hearing with the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, and we've given them some recommendations which which include what they were so to issue a restorative interpretation that harmonic harmonizes the convention with the Bellum de Parra Convention and the American Convention on Human Rights, affirming that all provisions of the Convention must be read through the lens of women's rights to be free from violence and her right to physical and mental integrity.
- 1:20:42SPEAKER_04: So it's that sort of really fundamental approach to this treaty that could make such a difference.
- 1:20:51SPEAKER_04: We're looking at the possibility of strategic litigation in national courts or amicus briefs.
- 1:20:56SPEAKER_04: Also, could we support the better use of Article 20, which is the human rights exceptional defence within the convention?
- 1:21:03SPEAKER_04: Could we involve the Commission on Rights of the Child or CEDAW or other similar human rights organizations to produce a joint statement which would give a sort of a moral statement?
- 1:21:15SPEAKER_04: We're already working very closely with the UN special reporter on violence against women and girls, Remal Salam, who is a strong supporter of change in this dimension.
- 1:21:25SPEAKER_04: So those are sort of the various things we're doing.
- 1:21:28SPEAKER_04: And as an offshoot of that, if you like, uh one of the wonderful women who's been working on this for at least 20 years, Professor Mill Viner from Oregon, has produced a convention on safety for survivors of family violence involved in international custody disputes.
- 1:21:45SPEAKER_04: It's the new treaty, which would fix the domestic violence problem.
- 1:21:48SPEAKER_04: And essentially, all the signatories to the convention could simply also sign up to this and it would it would obligate a different approach.
- 1:21:58SPEAKER_04: So the sort of things that Brazil was talking about in its discussions would become part of this convention.
- 1:22:03SPEAKER_04: Yeah.
- 1:22:04SPEAKER_04: So lots of things happening.
- 1:22:06SPEAKER_04: And as I say, the the difficulty we have is simply that that we're at our heart, we're really small.
- 1:22:14SPEAKER_04: We're big globally, but everybody has other jobs and things they do, you know.
- 1:22:18SPEAKER_04: So so I'm constantly bothering Leslie with irritating questions and and tasks that I would like to do.
- 1:22:24SPEAKER_04: And she does her best, obviously, but she has another job to work with.
- 1:22:28SPEAKER_04: So we'll get there eventually.
- 1:22:30R: Well, I'm really encouraged to hear all of those different pathways to potential reform.
- 1:22:37R: And I really hope that our listeners consider them and and have a think on whether they can contribute to assisting in making this happen.
- 1:22:48R: You know, we have a lot of a lot of listeners around the world in different sectors, including law and judicial and the courts.
- 1:22:57R: So those those recommendations are very concrete, and and I hope, I hope that that we can move forward.
- 1:23:05R: But I would love to start moving to wrapping up.
- 1:23:09R: And I would love to hear from both of you, really, about what you would want to say to both survivors and also to professionals, to lawyers who are who are representing them or defending them, or lawyers and court professionals who are trying to amend and these processes to work at that policy level to do so.
- 1:23:39R: So so give us your best around encouragement for survivors as well as for professionals.
- 1:23:49SPEAKER_00: Sure.
- 1:23:49SPEAKER_00: I would I would say, you know, these issues have really been hidden from the mainstream for way too long.
- 1:23:58SPEAKER_00: And the more people who learn about them, I really have to believe that the closer we are to bringing about some meaningful change.
- 1:24:07SPEAKER_00: So we get litigators from all over the country who have never done this before.
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_00: They become very committed to taking these cases.
- 1:24:16SPEAKER_00: So many wonderful stories of repeat partners from law firms who are taking them over and over again.
- 1:24:23SPEAKER_00: And the more time, the more litigators that we can get committed to taking these cases, the more we can chip away at this antiquated case law and get more victories for our clients.
- 1:24:34SPEAKER_00: And so I really do believe the change is possible.
- 1:24:37SPEAKER_00: And we see it, even when it's incremental, we see it every day.
- 1:24:40R: Yeah.
- 1:24:40R: Yeah, that's what about you, Ruth?
- 1:24:43R: What would you say also to survivors and as well to their lawyers?
- 1:24:47SPEAKER_04: I mean, absolutely to survivors, please get in touch.
- 1:24:50SPEAKER_04: We promise we will do our absolute best to find you the right support.
- 1:24:54SPEAKER_04: However rare it is to find it, we will move heaven and earth to try and support you.
- 1:25:00SPEAKER_04: And there can also be really lovely things that happen with survivors.
- 1:25:04SPEAKER_04: So recently I was put back in touch with a survivor who some years ago I'd put in touch with Leslie and I'd not heard from her.
- 1:25:14SPEAKER_04: And then she she has, with Leslie's help, or she had won her case and is now an advocate, and she's come back and joined us as a member, and she's part of our mother's expert group, which helps us that strategy.
- 1:25:26SPEAKER_04: So survivors can come to us in a state of despair.
- 1:25:30SPEAKER_04: We can find them the right help, hopefully, but certainly we'll give them that support.
- 1:25:34SPEAKER_04: And then they often come back and work with us.
- 1:25:36SPEAKER_04: And a lot of survivors, in spite of the trauma, in spite of all the that they've been through, find that being active as part of this huge network can really help with healing.
- 1:25:49SPEAKER_04: I think it can make things feel a little bit better that you're fighting for other mothers.
- 1:25:54SPEAKER_04: So, yes, survivors, please come.
- 1:25:57SPEAKER_04: And and in general, as you said, you know, if people want to join us in any capacity as occasional advisors, as active members, academics, lawyers, DV professionals, human rights activists, survivors.
- 1:26:10SPEAKER_04: We've got grandmothers of the hay group, in fact, which is rather wonderful.
- 1:26:13SPEAKER_04: So, yes, please get in touch and please shout as loudly as you can about this problem because the more light that's shone on it, the more likely we are to change.
- 1:26:27SPEAKER_04: I wanted just to say one of our mums, well our mums, that's inappropriate use of words, but one of the mums that we're in contact with lives in Ireland, she's Ukrainian-Irish, her children are in Germany, and she's only allowed to see them.
- 1:26:42SPEAKER_04: I think it's about four hours a month or something, and she can't talk to them in her mother tongue because they're with their father who abused her.
- 1:26:52SPEAKER_04: And she's very, very eloquent and very, very heartbroken.
- 1:26:57SPEAKER_04: And she said this at a webinar we had recently, and I would like to share it.
- 1:27:02SPEAKER_04: Please understand this the Hague Convention, when applied without nuance, without compassion, and without trauma-informed practices, destroys lives.
- 1:27:12SPEAKER_04: It does not serve justice, it serves power, and it empowers those who seek to continue controlling, harming, and breaking the very people it was meant to protect.
- 1:27:24SPEAKER_03: Wow.
- 1:27:28David Mandel: Hearing that is reaffirms, you know, again, this metaphor about family law on steroids.
- 1:27:35David Mandel: The some of the most anguished survivors have ever been around are those where courts have ordered the return, giving children, ordered giving children to dangerous people.
- 1:27:50David Mandel: And then the being labeled as being alienated and and and this is that on steroids.
- 1:27:56David Mandel: And I it really I've learned so much listening because this is an example of well-intentioned legislation that ultimately puts process over people to the detriment of women and children, particularly.
- 1:28:12David Mandel: So thank you for the work you do, and thank you for bringing attention to this.
- 1:28:17David Mandel: And we're we're happy to be able to platform you so hopefully more people learn and reach out and and and have information because as I've traveled through the professional world, often people are not aware or or appropriately trained or or prepared to enter into this Hague arena.
- 1:28:37David Mandel: So thank you for the work you do.
- 1:28:39R: Well, thank you for the work you do.
- 1:28:41R: Absolutely.
- 1:28:42R: Ruth and Leslie, this has really been an honor.
- 1:28:45R: I know we've gone a little bit longer than normal, but this is a very incredibly important conversation for us to have and and our listeners to be aware of.
- 1:28:57R: And you've been listening to partnered with the survivor.
- 1:29:01R: I am still Ruth Raimundo and with the Safe and Together Institute and Safety Nexus.
- 1:29:08R: And David, I don't know if you wanted to add any additional, you know, cranky survivor-esque.
- 1:29:16David Mandel: No, I just want to just thank our guests and just say that, you know, we'll be putting this show up.
- 1:29:22David Mandel: You'll be you obviously listen to those show notes, we'll have links.
- 1:29:25David Mandel: If you want to learn more about the institute, you know, go to safety of the institute.com.
- 1:29:30David Mandel: If you want to learn more about our digital coach, which is going to be emergent next year, which we're piloting right now, that's a safety nexus.ai.
- 1:29:38David Mandel: There's learning opportunities.
- 1:29:40David Mandel: There's a conference in Australia.
- 1:29:42David Mandel: But just this is uh we're really committed to a global community of professional survivors working together to transform systems.
- 1:29:50David Mandel: And this podcast is part of it.
- 1:29:53David Mandel: And I think with that, we are we are out of the