Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Beyond Store of Value: Bitcoin and Lightning Are the Real FinTech Opportunity
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51All righty, welcome back to Final Settlement.
- 0:54Today is Tuesday, April 8th, 2025.
- 0:58Super excited for today's Rep. We've got a great episode for
- 1:02you guys. 2 special guests today.
- 1:04So alongside me as my Co host, Liam Nelson and our two guests
- 1:10today, Pierre Corbin, founder and CEO of Flash Payments and
- 1:16Graham Kresic, founder and CEO of Voltage Payments.
- 1:19So you know, lots to talk about today that the high level theme
- 1:23is going to be really, you know, what we've talked about a lot on
- 1:26this show historically is Bitcoin is more than just a
- 1:29store of value. It's more than digital gold.
- 1:32I think that's, you know, the the primary thesis that a lot of
- 1:35allocators are wrapping their heads around today.
- 1:38Even if you think about something like, you know, the
- 1:40United States adopting Bitcoin in some sense and creating a
- 1:44strategic Bitcoin reserve, that's very much the store of
- 1:47value use case. That's how they're thinking
- 1:49about it. That's how most allocators are
- 1:50thinking about it. But the reality is that, you
- 1:54know, digital gold doesn't really do Bitcoin justice.
- 1:57It can be much more than that and propelling forward that sort
- 2:01of next leg of the thesis, if you is, if you will, is, you
- 2:05know, things like the lightning network, other protocols that
- 2:08are interoperable with bitcoins base layer that are getting
- 2:11enable all these different payments, use cases, micro
- 2:15payments, things that you know, Pierre and Flash are doing with
- 2:19Nostril wallet connect are fascinating.
- 2:21And Graham and his team also just put out a report with
- 2:25Fidelity around the Lightning Network.
- 2:27So we'll we'll get into that as well and some some announcements
- 2:30from the voltage team in addition to that.
- 2:33So very excited to have you both on the show today.
- 2:36How are we doing, fellas? Doing great, Yeah, excited to be
- 2:41here. I think that I love the topic
- 2:43because this is something that we talked quite a bit about of
- 2:45just if Bitcoin is only a store of value, then, you know, we
- 2:48kind of lost, lost some of the point.
- 2:50So yeah, excited to dive in. Yeah, that's it was actually, I
- 2:54think there was a clip or a quote from from Jack Dorsey
- 2:57going around the past week or so that said something to the
- 2:59effect of that. Like, you know, if it's just a
- 3:01store of value, Bitcoin has failed.
- 3:04Would would you guys agree? Let's just maybe start there.
- 3:06Would you guys agree with that that sentiment from from Jack a
- 3:09week or so ago I. Mean I think generally speaking,
- 3:15I guess not I mean the story of value is still people using it
- 3:18right? I think it it will mean, you
- 3:20know, Bitcoins full potential won't have been reached I think,
- 3:24but but yeah, I think you know, there's still 1st just as a, you
- 3:29know, hedge against his faith and store of value number go up.
- 3:33I think there's already like a lot of value in Bitcoin just
- 3:36just with that. But but yeah, 100% I mean that's
- 3:39why we're working on at flash as well.
- 3:40It's, you know, Bitcoin, you know, before being peer-to-peer,
- 3:44sorry, before being sort of value.
- 3:46I mean, the title of the the white paper is that it's, you
- 3:49know, peer-to-peer electronic calf, right?
- 3:51So that's, it's supposed to be the first use case before store
- 3:55of value. Store of value is just a result
- 3:58of all of the fundamental mechanisms that were built into
- 4:02Bitcoin. So yeah, but I don't think it
- 4:06would have failed, right? People would still use it, even
- 4:08if it's just to stay in their hand.
- 4:11Graham, do you agree with that or different?
- 4:14I mean like like, yes, I think that ultimately if Bitcoin is
- 4:17only a store value as it failed, like I think failed is like a
- 4:20strong word there. I do think that it has not
- 4:22reached its full potential that it could.
- 4:24And I completely agree on, you know, the Satoshi's I think
- 4:26original vision for it is for a payments mechanism.
- 4:29I mean he put that in the paper of like here's how you can, you
- 4:32know, send these electronic, you know, digital cash payments.
- 4:35So I think there is a huge amount of potential inside of
- 4:39Bitcoin for the payments use case.
- 4:40I think that's been one of the challenges that we've seen at
- 4:43the start of this year is, you know, everyone's excited or was
- 4:46excited about all the things going on in the federal
- 4:49government in the United States of like the whole like the
- 4:51Bitcoin bill and like the crypto stockpile, like all those things
- 4:55that were kind of happening at the administration level.
- 4:57The thing is all those things were for a store of value use
- 5:00case. They're all talking about the
- 5:01government's going to hold this like all those things.
- 5:03I'm not saying that those are all bad things necessarily.
- 5:05We can, you know, debate all those different things
- 5:07independently, but like overall, I think the focus has been on
- 5:10the store value for so long that people really lost sight of the
- 5:14payment side of it. And so that's what I think, you
- 5:16know, but both of our companies are really trying to, to, to
- 5:19bring up is just more of, you know, it is not only, not only
- 5:22can Bitcoin do payments and it can do payments well, but it is
- 5:26actually the most superior way of doing payments in the entire
- 5:29crypto ecosystem. That's what we kind of
- 5:30highlighted in our report with Fidelity is it's not only like,
- 5:33oh, Bitcoin can also do this thing too.
- 5:35It's like, no, it can actually do it and it can do it much
- 5:37better than other systems that have been created to try and
- 5:40solve that problem too. So I think that it it doesn't,
- 5:43you know, it doesn't fail if it's only a store value, but it
- 5:46definitely doesn't reach it's full potential.
- 5:49Yeah, I think that's, that's very well said by both of you.
- 5:51And I I sort of land in a a similar camp of yeah, it's, it's
- 5:55sort of like the next extension of the thesis And it's, you
- 6:00know, it's full potential is being, you know, serving all the
- 6:04needs of a of a form of money, right, which would include a
- 6:07medium of exchange type use case.
- 6:09And it's also just fascinating because like you pointed out,
- 6:13you know, the white paper obviously calls it peer-to-peer
- 6:15cash. And then like, you know, it, the
- 6:17first real usage of Bitcoin, you know, whether you're talking
- 6:20about Silk Road or otherwise, like that was medium exchange.
- 6:22So it's like we've seen this evolution from that to then
- 6:25digital gold. And now it's like, well, you
- 6:27know, into the future will probably be some combination of
- 6:29both of those things. And the other thing that comes
- 6:33to mind is we had Bitstein on the show many months ago and he
- 6:39had a, an interesting way of thinking about, you know, all of
- 6:42this in the sense that I think a lot of people get there, you
- 6:45know, get stuck in the mode of thinking like, well, it needs to
- 6:47be a store of value 1st. And then then it becomes a
- 6:50medium of exchange. And he had a very interesting
- 6:52insight around that in the sense that he was like, it's kind of
- 6:55everything all at once. It's just, you know, you're
- 6:57delaying the spend, right? Like if you as a person who
- 7:01understands the value profit Bitcoin, you understand that
- 7:04you're in a, you know, very small minority that actually
- 7:06understands what it is, then the price is going to go up over
- 7:09time, probably pretty aggressively over the next like
- 7:12decade or two. So you're not incentivized to
- 7:14spend your Bitcoin. And so that's just a reality.
- 7:16But at the same time, money is, is money for a reason, right?
- 7:20Like you're eventually going to use it for something.
- 7:23And so even if you're delaying that eventual meeting of
- 7:27exchange use case, like, one, we still need to like plan for it.
- 7:31And two, there are going to be people around the world who have
- 7:33different use cases and different needs at different
- 7:35times. And so, yeah, I think that's,
- 7:37that's well said. I, I certainly wouldn't say it's
- 7:39failed if, you know, if we don't succeed, you know, to the full
- 7:44extent on the median exchange side.
- 7:46But I think it's just going to be, I think we're early days and
- 7:48I think it's going to be a process.
- 7:49And different people have different needs at different
- 7:52times for, for money, generally speaking.
- 7:56But I did want to maybe just taking a step step back a bit.
- 8:01Pierre, you've been on the show before.
- 8:03People are somewhat familiar with Flash, a portfolio company
- 8:06of of early riders. But maybe each of you could give
- 8:09sort of just a high level brief background on yourselves how you
- 8:12got into Bitcoin and and what each of your companies does.
- 8:17Well, so I can go first, it'll be further.
- 8:19So I'm Pierre Corbin and CEO and Co founder of Flash and yeah,
- 8:23it's nice to be provides software solutions for
- 8:27businesses that want to be able to monetize in Bitcoin and soft
- 8:31custody. No intermediaries, just
- 8:34unlocking peer-to-peer payments for businesses.
- 8:39Awesome. Yes, My name is Graham.
- 8:40I'm, so I'm founder and CEO of Voltage and I got into Bitcoin
- 8:44about 2012, very fascinated about it from like the tech
- 8:47perspective of man. How can you create this like
- 8:50globally decentralized, like payment network that no one can
- 8:52like, you know, stop payments and like all the things that
- 8:56kind of go along inside of Bitcoin from the tech
- 8:58perspective. And then, you know, kept it as a
- 9:01hobby for a long time and worked in software and then ultimately
- 9:04started Voltage basically to solve my own problem of as you,
- 9:07as I was building things inside of Bitcoin, it was just really
- 9:09starting from scratch over and over and over again.
- 9:11And everyone was like building everything from scratch, like
- 9:14from, from, you know, for every single project, building Bitcoin
- 9:17core from source, like all these different things, there's like,
- 9:19man, there's got to be a better way.
- 9:20And so that's why I created voltage.
- 9:22And what it ultimately is today is a, a method of just being
- 9:25able to integrate Bitcoin in the lightning Network is what we do
- 9:28the majority of our business to make it much easier, faster to
- 9:32integrate the technology into your business.
- 9:35And so instead of hiring out a team of, you know, four or five
- 9:37people and again, starting it all from scratch, you can really
- 9:40just kind of hit our AP is and plug in to be able to process
- 9:44payments or, you know, both Bitcoin and then stable coins
- 9:47are coming soon, which we'll probably touch on soon.
- 9:50And being able to do that much easier and faster than you would
- 9:53kind of starting it all from zero.
- 9:55Yeah, that's, that's a super helpful overview.
- 9:57Maybe like Graham on your side, it'd be helpful to walk through
- 10:02maybe like a few examples that are like tangible of like how,
- 10:06you know, either projects or, you know, different use cases
- 10:08are using voltage today. You know, we, we mentioned, we
- 10:12are, we alluded to the, the partnership with Bitco on the
- 10:14stablecoin side, but maybe even before stablecoins like just on
- 10:17the sort of Bitcoin native side some can you walk through some
- 10:20sort of tangible, tangible examples of of how voltage helps
- 10:23companies? Yeah, definitely.
- 10:25I mean, so we so some examples of customers that we work with,
- 10:28they're like exchanges. So if they want to, if an
- 10:30exchange wants to add in Lightning to do, you know,
- 10:32deposits and withdrawals inside of their platform, they're able
- 10:35to hook into voltage really quickly and easily and add in
- 10:37that capability without having to again, hire a team and, and
- 10:40do a lot of the complexity themselves.
- 10:42We also work with like payment processors.
- 10:44So people that are doing historically has been very much
- 10:47like if anyone is moving any kind of Bitcoin on chain, you
- 10:51can do it faster and cheaper via lightning.
- 10:52So that's a better user experience and that's saving
- 10:55potentially millions of dollars a year, depending on your
- 10:57volumes of on chain fees that you can save into moving into
- 11:01lightning. And so we work with a lot of
- 11:02like crypto or Bitcoin specific on payment processors and being
- 11:06able to move, create better, better cogs as well as faster,
- 11:10you know, better experiences by moving that volume into
- 11:13lightning. And then we're also working on,
- 11:15you know, some newer use cases of, you know, getting more
- 11:18traditional finance into into Bitcoin and being able to have
- 11:21kind of like the the dollars to Bitcoin kind of solve for them
- 11:24and, and all those different things.
- 11:25So ultimately we really Lightning is made to be a
- 11:29faster, cheaper way of moving Bitcoin and that's basically
- 11:32what we enable for people like exchanges, payment processors,
- 11:35neo banks, wallets, any of those kinds of folks.
- 11:38Got you. And maybe we can, we can touch
- 11:42on the, the partnership with Bitco now, because I found it
- 11:46very interesting just in the sense that, you know, I think to
- 11:50announce and launch something like this, I'll pull up the, the
- 11:55presser now. But you know, to, to go about
- 11:57this, I would imagine that there was, you know, a significant
- 12:01demand, like there were people, you know, institutions in
- 12:03particular asking for this type of thing.
- 12:08And, and I'm curious 1 is that true?
- 12:11And was that sort of the impetus for doing this that there was,
- 12:14you know, clear demand from institutional folks that wanted
- 12:17to, you know, move dollars in a more efficient way effectively?
- 12:21And then beyond that, I guess, you know, secondary question in
- 12:25in your mind at this stage is that where the majority of
- 12:29demand is for using something like Lightning is moving dollars
- 12:32as opposed to, you know, institutions moving around
- 12:34Bitcoin on Lightning? Yeah.
- 12:36So like with so with this integration with Bitco, we're
- 12:38doing it. I mean we're starting off with
- 12:40doing Bitcoin payments over Lightning.
- 12:43And so stablecoins are kind of a coming soon thing as soon as
- 12:45like Tappered assets is has launched and we have people like
- 12:48Tether that have publicly announced that they're going to
- 12:50support in the coming months. So the stablecoins over
- 12:53Lightning is a coming soon thing in which we do see a huge amount
- 12:56of demand for with this as well for specifically on this Titco
- 12:59integration. Yes, I mean, there has been a
- 13:02lot of folks that we talked to that are very interested in
- 13:05Lightning. They want to enable it for all
- 13:07of the the benefits that I've kind of mentioned before.
- 13:10But they already use people like a bit Go or some kind of a
- 13:13custodian to, to manage all of their other asset movements,
- 13:16asset management. And so instead of having kind of
- 13:19a, an additional provider that would be like voltage, if they
- 13:23work directly, we're able to hook into the bit Go network and
- 13:26they're ultimately customers are able to kind of hit a single
- 13:29source that they've already integrated their business and be
- 13:32able to get the benefits of lightning.
- 13:33So ultimately it makes it much a better user experience for these
- 13:37companies that are wanting to integrate Lightning because they
- 13:40still use the same kind of provider, the same interface
- 13:42that they always have been, but can really enable it much
- 13:45quicker and faster than they would have previously.
- 13:47So ultimately this should we're anticipating having a big jump
- 13:51in adoption by leveraging the Bitco network.
- 13:54They're they're fairly large set of customers and being able to
- 13:57bring Lightning into that, that group.
- 13:59So we are really excited about what this is going to, how this
- 14:03is going to catapult adoption over this coming year.
- 14:06Nice. That's, that's super helpful and
- 14:09really fascinating. I guess before we go into the
- 14:12stable coin side of this a little bit further, I just, you
- 14:16know, reread the Voltage and Fidelity report from earlier
- 14:20this year. And one of the things that
- 14:22really stuck out to me was the average channel capacity really
- 14:27growing significantly, whereas the average number of channels
- 14:32per node has has not really grown quite as much.
- 14:36And you mentioned a ton of integration with, you know,
- 14:39custodians, neo banks. We're seeing a ton of demand
- 14:43from, you know, peer-to-peer custodians in terms of, you
- 14:47know, ways to settle balances that are exchanged between the
- 14:51two custodians. I guess where, where do you see
- 14:55most of the demand for Lightning at least in your seat and based
- 14:59on kind of the public data that you have could be interesting
- 15:02just to see if this is kind of match what you thought voltage
- 15:05was, was going to be in, in the Lightning network exactly when
- 15:08you launched or or where we are today.
- 15:10Yeah. I mean, I guess like touching on
- 15:12the the kind of the the the way that I was thinking about when I
- 15:15started the company versus today, like touching on that
- 15:18first. I mean, when I definitely
- 15:20started voltage, it was very much like consumer like retail
- 15:23focus, like, you know, everyone in the world is going to have a
- 15:25node and everyone is going to need like really easy access and
- 15:28all those things. I think that's definitely
- 15:29shifted as we've seen the Lightning network mature over
- 15:33the years where it's definitely less, less people operating like
- 15:36a, a, a node in like the full-fledged node.
- 15:38We've seen a lot of advancements in things like LDK that help
- 15:41make it much more like you can still do self custodial
- 15:44lightning without like the full on node that we think about in
- 15:47like the start nines or umbrellas or like a full node on
- 15:49voltage. And so we've seen much more of
- 15:52like these kinds of, you know, people like us moving much more
- 15:54onto the business end of things where we work with again, like
- 15:57exchanges, payment processors, all those things that I
- 15:59mentioned and being able to really optimize on creating
- 16:02better experiences for them and then ultimately their users as
- 16:04well. And so in that shift, you know,
- 16:06we in that shift of at least us focusing a lot more on the
- 16:10business side of things, we've seen the metrics inside of
- 16:13Lightning kind of shift towards that as well.
- 16:14As we've highlighted the average channel is getting much, much
- 16:17larger. That's because, you know,
- 16:19businesses are just doing more than, you know, they're trying
- 16:21to facilitate, you know, thousands of payments across
- 16:24their, their customer base, not just like, hey, a couple
- 16:27payments a day maybe for an individual.
- 16:29So that requires more capacity. And it's just that the, the
- 16:32mature, the maturation of the network itself to realize that,
- 16:36OK, it's better to have like 5 really large channels than have
- 16:40like 100 small channels for both from like, from a management
- 16:43perspective, from like your, the, the, the effectiveness of
- 16:46payments going through the likelihood of success, all those
- 16:49things. And so the, this data, as we've
- 16:51kind of highlighted in the report, really show that this
- 16:53is, this is maturity in the network as we've learned what is
- 16:57working and not working. And so that's kind of like what
- 16:59we the the public data is kind of validating what we're seeing
- 17:04on the business side. Yeah, that makes, that makes a
- 17:07ton of sense. I think, you know, just just
- 17:11thinking about the past few years in terms of the Lightning
- 17:15Network, it's adoption, it's growth, it's development, I
- 17:17think, you know, generally speaking, people are just way
- 17:21too impatient. Like, I think there's, you know,
- 17:23been a lot of rhetoric and, and talk on Bitcoin Twitter,
- 17:25etcetera, you know, in terms of just the frictions of lightning
- 17:30which do exist and the ways in which it needs to improve.
- 17:34I'm curious from both of you, you know, how would you sort of
- 17:37handicap the past, call it 12 to 24 months of lightning
- 17:43development and how it's gotten better, more efficient, more
- 17:46usable with, you know, and, and maybe that's even related to
- 17:50like folks like Light Spark and David Marcus entering the fray.
- 17:54How does that sort of relate to again, just this ongoing
- 17:58development that's just going to take time and, and again, I
- 18:00think people are just very impatient and, and, you know,
- 18:03wanting things to just work seamlessly and perfectly
- 18:06overnight. And that's just not the reality
- 18:08of building on an open protocol. But curious any of your either
- 18:11of your thoughts on that? Yeah.
- 18:15So I think, you know, The thing is, it's kind of general
- 18:18question. We could go all over the place,
- 18:21but yeah, I'll start somewhere and we'll see.
- 18:23We'll see where you can go. So generally speaking, when it
- 18:26comes to already building beyond just user experience, but
- 18:30already the building experience, the developer experience, it's
- 18:34pretty tricky to build on Lightning.
- 18:37And it's kind of like what Graham said earlier, you want to
- 18:40start a Bitcoin business, you have to start from scratch.
- 18:43You have to you have a use case. Well, you first have to like
- 18:47build a wallet as anything which which is complicated.
- 18:50That's you know what we stumbled upon a flash that you know,
- 18:54thought. But this is where there's a big
- 18:56differences with nostril wallet connect and the fact that, you
- 18:58know, you can just connect to a share with library of APIs and
- 19:03any wallet can become compatible and all of a sudden you're in
- 19:06confusion can work for all of these wallets right now.
- 19:08That's that's how we developed flaff in the 1st place.
- 19:11We then, of course, created our own wallet generated to be able
- 19:13to just scale this right. But even when it comes to
- 19:16building the wallet itself, you know, how do you make Bitcoin
- 19:21easy over the lighting network? Is not is is not a simple answer
- 19:26because you know, if you want to start lightning wallet in self
- 19:31custody, well, then well, you need to download the wallet and
- 19:35then you need to fund the wallet because you need to open
- 19:39channels, you need to add liquidity to this channel.
- 19:43And so it's kind of, you know, if you're a first time user that
- 19:46is just curious and just wants to try this out and start in our
- 19:51case, accepting Bitcoin payments.
- 19:54Well then to do this in full self custody, which is of course
- 19:56what we recommend to get to get started.
- 20:00Well then in in that case you need to pretty much do.
- 20:04Three payments 4 payments before you can actually get there
- 20:07because you need to buy Bitcoin or to be able to like do this
- 20:09stuff. So for for a new person, it's
- 20:11it's impossible. And now there are other tools
- 20:14out there that exist, but it's not exactly lightning in that
- 20:17case, just like, but but the last two things much more just
- 20:22faster while doing compatible with lightning network, which is
- 20:25how we built our wallets, which is using the liquid network,
- 20:28right. So the funds are liquid and you
- 20:30can do automatic swaps that that just allowed to do, yeah, a
- 20:35bunch of things, right. And so of course it is self
- 20:37custodial because you own your keys.
- 20:39But you do rely on the liquid network, which is less sovereign
- 20:42perhaps compared to Bitcoin or even the lighting network in
- 20:48self custody. So it's, it's a matter of
- 20:50trade-offs, right? But then we managed to make user
- 20:53experience of Flash that if you're a business that is just
- 20:56furious about accepting Bitcoin payments, well then you can get
- 20:59set up in literally just a couple minutes because you
- 21:02download the wallet, it's got a balance of 0 and you don't need
- 21:05any balance to start accepting Bitcoin.
- 21:07So it's automatically connected to Flash and you can accept
- 21:09those payments. So it's very easy and it
- 21:12simplifies such things where where the Lightning Network
- 21:17makes this more more complicated and then involve different use
- 21:20cases that the Lightning Network makes also a bit more
- 21:22complicated like offline payments and stuff like that.
- 21:26You know, we manage to solve with Liquid, but you get into
- 21:29that later. But also one of the great things
- 21:32with the Lightning network that other networks don't have,
- 21:35including the Liquid network is micro payments that are, you
- 21:39know, instant currently. You know, with the fat wallets,
- 21:43there's a limit minimum amount of 1000 set of things because
- 21:47that's the requirement that both swaps have 1000 satoshi
- 21:52transaction now. I mean, word on the street is
- 21:54that they're going to lower it to the minimum amount that they
- 21:57have for the amount of fees that they want, which would be about
- 21:59I think 43 satoshi. So you know, we're already
- 22:02getting into the micro transaction territory, but but
- 22:06still still not quite the price between going up.
- 22:08I think, you know, because this number will have to to be
- 22:12revised. And so, yeah, so that's just
- 22:15some some general thoughts. Yeah.
- 22:18And Graham, on your side, I'm curious as well.
- 22:20Just, you know, I think that was, correct me if I'm wrong,
- 22:23like a lot of the impetus of UN Fidelity putting out that report
- 22:25was just to say like, hey, here's the state of things,
- 22:28here's how things are progressing, here's how
- 22:30development is moving forward. So curious your thoughts on like
- 22:33where are we today relative to a year or two years ago and how do
- 22:37you see this playing out? Yeah.
- 22:39I mean, definitely that was one of the reasons why we put out
- 22:41the report is, I mean, it's one of the really challenging parts
- 22:43about Lightning is that it's, it's inherently a very private
- 22:46network. And given it's peer-to-peer, you
- 22:47can't, you don't have the same metrics that you do with other
- 22:51chains, Bitcoin or Ethereum or slot.
- 22:53When you name the chain, almost all, any kind of public
- 22:55blockchain, you can see exactly how much is being transacted,
- 22:58how frequently the fee rates, all those things.
- 23:00With lightning, it's all private because it's peer-to-peer.
- 23:02So it's, it's easy. That's one of the reasons why
- 23:04you see so much like FUD and light in like on Twitter and
- 23:07things like that for lighting is there is no public data that you
- 23:10can point to. So that's kind of one of the
- 23:12reasons why we want to do a report with Fidelity is to
- 23:14highlight, OK, here's like really what's happening behind
- 23:17the scenes that you can only really get by being in the and
- 23:20being able to facilitate transactions and those kinds of
- 23:22things. And so that was one of the
- 23:24reasons almost everyone that is kind of throwing shade at
- 23:27lighting usually has some kind of motive of their own.
- 23:30It's like they're trying to push side chains or their other layer
- 23:33two or something else that is kind of competing.
- 23:36And so it's something that should basically just be ignored
- 23:40for like from those kinds of folks.
- 23:42And then there's also like inside of crypto in general,
- 23:44there's always like the the desire to have these these
- 23:48solutions very, very quickly. Well, to your point, like
- 23:50building an open protocol and doing it in a correct way where
- 23:53people actually get self custody the entire time is a very
- 23:56challenging thing. And that's a very hard thing to
- 23:58do. Other chains are able to move
- 24:00faster because they're sacrificing on a lot of those
- 24:02things. And so sure, if lighting wanted
- 24:04to sacrifice on all of like the properties that like the Bitcoin
- 24:07started with, yeah, we could move a lot faster, We could make
- 24:09things a lot easier in a UX or whatever.
- 24:11But we would be sacrificing on the whole reason why Bitcoin was
- 24:14created in the 1st place. And obviously the community
- 24:16doesn't want to do that. And so we're very intentional
- 24:19with the way that the lighting has been built out.
- 24:21But then going into more of like from what we see it like, you
- 24:24know, from a couple years ago today to today, vastly different
- 24:27in terms of like what it takes like get started and get, you
- 24:30know, ramped up and lightning. You know what we, our product
- 24:32has come a huge, a very long way in that, that time.
- 24:35We also have a new product that we're releasing in, in next week
- 24:38that should do a lot in terms of boosting that even to another
- 24:41level. And so ultimately the experience
- 24:44has been, it is definitely started challenging and it's
- 24:47been gradually being reduced over over time to the point
- 24:51where you know, it's, it's really as simple as any other
- 24:54payment scheme or blockchain or whatever you want to whatever
- 24:56you want to equate it to via people like, you know, like a
- 25:00voltage or a flash or something. If you're going to try and start
- 25:02and like do it all yourself, like again from scratch, then
- 25:05like there's definitely still some edge cases there.
- 25:07There's still some things that you know, some gotchas that you
- 25:09can run into. But if you're working with a
- 25:11provider that has basically run into every single one of those
- 25:14gotchas and figured out a way to solve for it, it makes the
- 25:17experience far, far better. So we've come a huge way in the
- 25:19last couple of years of accessible and not only
- 25:22accessible, but being able to, to, to process payments quick,
- 25:27faster and cheaper than any other blockchain out in the
- 25:30crypto ecosystem. And that was something else that
- 25:32we highlighted in the Fidelity report is, you know, comparing
- 25:34it to the global like crypto networks, there's nothing that
- 25:38can beat it in terms of speed and reliability and, and cost.
- 25:42Then, then, then what, then what you can do on Lightning.
- 25:44So that was another thing that we wanted to highlight and show
- 25:46that, you know, it's not only working, but it's working
- 25:48really, really well. Yeah, I'm, I'm, I'm glad you,
- 25:52you pointed out a few really important points there.
- 25:55One just being the distinct difference in architectures of,
- 26:00you know, the broader crypto space and, and people building
- 26:03on Bitcoin. I think, you know, there's
- 26:05obviously trade-offs associated, but to your point, like they
- 26:09are, they are sacrificing on certain things in order to move
- 26:12fast and and not really care about some of these fundamental
- 26:15things that are important to Bitcoin.
- 26:18The other component there I think is, you know, I'm curious
- 26:21your views on, well, you know, if I'm being generous about it,
- 26:25I think like the broader crypto space has found some product
- 26:29market fit in stable coins generally.
- 26:32So if you just look at stable coin volumes, vast, vast
- 26:35majority of them are not on Bitcoin, right.
- 26:38But as you are alluding to, you know, they they should be on
- 26:42Bitcoin because, you know, it's cheaper faster than these block
- 26:45chains. But I guess why, why the
- 26:47disconnect up until now? Is it just because the
- 26:50development on Bitcoin tends to move slower almost purposefully
- 26:54so than these other block chains and that's why they've gotten
- 26:56sort of the initial adoption of stablecoins?
- 26:59And do you do you think sort of medium to long term that
- 27:03percentage split shifts over time, so where you know more
- 27:06stablecoin volumes are happening on Lightning or other Bitcoin
- 27:10adjacent? Protocols, yeah.
- 27:14I mean, I think, I think like, like, yes, I think that the the
- 27:17percentages shift overtime. I think why like, you know why
- 27:19it's taking a little bit longer on Bitcoin is 1.
- 27:21I mean, the the protocol for actually being able to like
- 27:24issue a stable point on lightning didn't exist until the
- 27:26recent like, I don't know, a year and a half two years ago or
- 27:29something. And then even then it takes a
- 27:30while to build it out and have it like, you know, very, very
- 27:33reliable. You compare it to people like
- 27:34like the Solana Foundation or something that raises like
- 27:37hundreds of millions of dollars to go and like just throw at the
- 27:39problem. You know, we don't really have
- 27:41that inside of Bitcoin like Lightning Labs is kind of the
- 27:43lead developer on like the Tappert s s protocol, which
- 27:46enables stable coins to be issued on Lightning, But that's
- 27:49there still have like no near the funding of like the Solana
- 27:52Foundation or anything like that.
- 27:53And so it's kind of like, you know, the other other folks
- 27:57solve it by just throwing a bunch of money at the problem,
- 27:59which like is Bitcoin and Lightning is just so grassroots
- 28:01that we don't have that same ability.
- 28:04And I think that that leads us to build it in a much, much
- 28:06better way ultimately. But I do think that we're,
- 28:09we're, we're kind of at the point where that is like now
- 28:12possible. And we're looking, we're seeing
- 28:13people like Tether publicly announced they are going to be
- 28:16issuing on top of lightning. And so I think that once you
- 28:18create like combine that, there's, there's no denying that
- 28:21stablecoins generally have a product market fit inside of the
- 28:24crypto ecosystem. It's what's the majority of
- 28:26crypto in general is used for is stablecoin movement.
- 28:30And so when you couple that the a strong use case with Bitcoin
- 28:34and Lightning being the best way of moving value, I think that's
- 28:37a big recipe success. And that's going to overtime
- 28:40really take a lot of market share from these other chains,
- 28:43especially like, you know, Tron was one of the most popular ways
- 28:46of moving Tether. It still still probably is, but
- 28:49their fee rates are gradually going up.
- 28:51And so I think that as like these ones that really started
- 28:55in a value prop of moving it fast and cheap are starting to
- 28:57lose that value. And so it's only natural that it
- 29:00starts to move into the, the better way of, of transacting,
- 29:03which is Lightning. And so we're very excited for,
- 29:06you know, the stablecoin movement to come to to come to
- 29:08lightning. We think it'll have a a really
- 29:10big impact. Yeah.
- 29:12Two things that I wanted to hit on there.
- 29:13One that really gets under looked is Bitcoin being in
- 29:19Lightning Network, being able to be the fastest, cheapest way in
- 29:22order to transact across all of crypto, but also having the
- 29:26value accrual narrative behind it of it being a store of value.
- 29:29Because if there is no reason to have a store of value, then you
- 29:33know, paying out of that. It's, it's essentially you need
- 29:38it as a savings technology in order to also use it and want to
- 29:42keep it in as a payments technology, right?
- 29:45Like, you know, I'm sure everybody's seen Jesse Myers
- 29:48chart previously of like where all the assets sit and it's, you
- 29:52know, 110 or $130 trillion with money.
- 29:56And then there's about a $500 trillion use case for storing
- 30:00value over time. And so with Bitcoin, it's kind
- 30:04of just both of it actually can both compete with the money
- 30:08aspect as well as actually saving value.
- 30:12And so, you know, just kind of to solidify it.
- 30:15It doesn't make sense to, you know, really focus on having the
- 30:20best payments technology if there isn't any actual real way
- 30:23to store value in the asset. And then additionally, yeah, I
- 30:28was was curious how you see demand for the stable coins kind
- 30:32of rolling out here in the future.
- 30:35Are you going to be kind of going after the same market as
- 30:38the the tethers of the world? Is it going to be a little bit
- 30:41different in terms of, you know, where voltage kind of plays and
- 30:46it's collaboration with Bitco? I was just kind of curious
- 30:48about, you know, how, how you see that playing out.
- 30:52Yeah. I mean, ultimately I think for
- 30:53for us it's definitely, definitely some overlap in the
- 30:56existing, you know, stable coin world just because of you know,
- 31:00it's a lot of these. I think that overtime like as
- 31:03you look at the inefficiencies that you people are seeing
- 31:06inside of these chains for moving stable coins for us to
- 31:10come in and say, hey, you can do the same thing on Lightning and
- 31:12you can save you again a couple $1,000,000 a year on your
- 31:15transaction fees. Like that's kind of a know
- 31:17brainer. So I think that there is going
- 31:18to be there's a lot of overlap naturally just because it's
- 31:21still stable coin movement. It's just kind of a different
- 31:23chain, so to speak. But it's one that actually it's
- 31:26not just another chain for the sake of, you know, more users or
- 31:29anything like that. It's just a far faster, cheaper,
- 31:33better way of moving value. And so I think that there is a
- 31:35lot of overlap that we'll see between the two.
- 31:39Yeah. And I think also it might.
- 31:41I mean, I'm curious to see how long it'll take to transition
- 31:45because of course, USDT on Tron, on Solana, whatever isn't
- 31:50compatible with USDT on Lightning directly, right?
- 31:53Or on liquid or whatever. They, they're on their chain.
- 31:57So you need to have like some kind of swap solutions there or
- 31:59through exchanges and, and, and all that.
- 32:01So, I mean, you know, I wonder how quickly some of the the the
- 32:07stable coins that are exchanged and these are their blockchains
- 32:09are going to start being transitioning to yeah, to, to
- 32:15Bitcoin to Lightning, I guess is the better way to say, because
- 32:18it's not actually Bitcoin, right?
- 32:19It's just the Lightning network itself that I'm making the
- 32:21payments. So it's the payment network of
- 32:23it that is, that is strong. It's just we're using the best
- 32:27payment network for Bitcoin and found a way to actually reuse it
- 32:31for stable coins as well. I think it's just about the
- 32:36efficiency of the payment network itself.
- 32:38And so I think this this transition might take a bit of
- 32:40time and, and I look forward to the day where it won't be messy
- 32:43when you're trying to send USDT to someone where, you know, it's
- 32:46just a OK, so where do you want this USDT?
- 32:48What chain? What's like, Yeah, none of them
- 32:50are compatible. And yeah, the rise of other, I
- 32:53think atomic swap services would also be maybe very useful for
- 32:57such things supposed to rely on custodium, start us to just, you
- 33:02know, do this swap and hold the city of funds momentarily like
- 33:07like the market is today. Yeah, absolutely.
- 33:11Maybe maybe it's worth taking a bit of a, a step back and just
- 33:14thinking about sort of, you know, the interoperability of
- 33:18open protocols. I think is, is something that's
- 33:21really fascinating to me and, and particularly Pierre on your
- 33:24side, what you guys have done leveraging Noster Wallet
- 33:27Connect. If you could talk a little bit
- 33:29about that and, and sort of just what's that, what that has
- 33:31unlocked for you in terms of, you know, making Bitcoin
- 33:35payments better and more efficient by combining various
- 33:38open protocols? Because I think that's again,
- 33:42it's sort of this, this other side of the spectrum.
- 33:45When you think about the Super centralized Solana foundation
- 33:49building XYZ thing, it's like we'll know we're going to take
- 33:52this different approach. One, it's going to be slower a
- 33:54little bit, you know, more purposeful and in certain in
- 34:00terms of how slow it moves, but also like it's not just going to
- 34:03be this, this centralized monolithic, monolithic thing.
- 34:06There's going to be various open protocols that work together to
- 34:09enable all different types of things.
- 34:11So we'd love to to hear a little bit of that what you guys are
- 34:13doing at Flash and then if that that resonates with anything you
- 34:16guys are working on at Voltage, Graham, that'd be interesting as
- 34:18well. Yeah.
- 34:21So essentially we're using of course multiple technologies,
- 34:25but I think in that sense the one that is the most important
- 34:28one and really the one that we started with because before
- 34:31reaching life, we built a bunch of things with my Co founder and
- 34:34just trying to figure out what's the best way to build things.
- 34:38How do we avoid holding custody of user funds?
- 34:41Because the point is to avoid regulate them as much as
- 34:44possible and solve problems in a bit of a different way.
- 34:48And essentially in doing all this, we found Nostra Walk
- 34:51Connect and we realized that it's the best way for us to
- 34:54build in an interoperable environment without having to
- 34:59build a wallet of our own. And the reason for it is because
- 35:03essentially you can using Nostra Walk Connect, you can connect
- 35:06your wallet to flat and then flash can just use this wallet.
- 35:11So we can, we can figure payments, we can also make
- 35:13payments requests. And, and what's very interesting
- 35:16and all of that is that when I say we can trigger payments,
- 35:20Flash isn't really doing anything.
- 35:21We're just sending a message to your wallet and your wallet will
- 35:25receive this message and can then make the payment, but the
- 35:28wallet can still block that payment, right?
- 35:30Like everything is under the user's control.
- 35:33And you know, if I think today of the the best wallets that
- 35:37work with Flash, we've got so ABI Hub, which is self
- 35:42custodial, but you have to pay for it unless you go the more
- 35:47technical route. But I'm thinking like very
- 35:49simple users, so self custodial, but you have to pay for it.
- 35:52There's a coin OS that is free but custodial.
- 35:55And then there's Flash that is self custodial and free, right.
- 35:58So the point that I'm trying to make here is that there's
- 36:01different wallets with different features, whether it's custodial
- 36:06and S custodial that can, you know, help users manage their
- 36:11funds in whatever way they prefer that these same users can
- 36:14connect their wallet to class. And for them we solve the
- 36:18peer-to-peer payment side of things.
- 36:20So we're solving the payment problem, we're not solving the
- 36:22custody problem. Like that's an entirely
- 36:26different topic. The point is more that the Flash
- 36:29can interact with wallets and automate certain actions on
- 36:34these wallets using this technology.
- 36:36And any wallet that adds nostril WAD connects support to it.
- 36:40All of their users are automatically compatible with
- 36:44Flash. But of course, it's not only
- 36:45Flash, it's with the whole ecosystem of nothing WAD connect
- 36:48that is growing and every new wallet that you see coming out
- 36:53like in the past few months, most of them have support for an
- 36:55Oster walk in it because of the use cases that it allows users,
- 36:59users to build. And I can give you, I think one
- 37:03of these example use cases that that I think is, is pretty mind
- 37:07blowing is how we manage our fees at class.
- 37:11So the way Flash works is that it's free to get started, you
- 37:17know, free to use. You can create a store, you can
- 37:20create a point of sale, whatever you want inside of Flash free.
- 37:23And then the moment you receive a payment as a merchant, well
- 37:26then of course, this this happens through our software.
- 37:29So we know when the wallet, the wallet can confirm to us when
- 37:31he's received the payment. And so then we can trigger a
- 37:34payment from the merchant's wallet two hours.
- 37:36So it'll be like, yeah, a micro transaction 1 1/2 percent fee
- 37:40that, that we take. And we know what wallet is
- 37:45connected to flash and we can we have access to methods that
- 37:49allow us to get the information about that wallet.
- 37:52And as part of this response, we can see what network the wallet
- 37:56has access to. So by default, master wallet
- 37:58connect was created only for Lightning and, and a lot of
- 38:02these cases were built with that when we created the platform, as
- 38:05I said earlier, you know, we wanted to go the, the easier
- 38:08route, easier UX to get started, but also easier for us to build.
- 38:12So we went through the Breeze Notice SDK which uses the Liquid
- 38:16network, which which means that essentially for it to be
- 38:19compatible properly with Flash, we added Liquid to an Oster Wall
- 38:22connect. And I know that now on chain is
- 38:25being added to an Oster Wall connector.
- 38:26And so essentially what we can do is when the moment we have to
- 38:30pay the fee to the Flash wallet from the merchants wallet, we
- 38:34can see what networks this user has available.
- 38:37And as I mentioned earlier, the liquid network, in order to do
- 38:40swaps with the Lightning, there's a limit of 1000
- 38:43Satoshi's. So instead of doing the swap, if
- 38:46the user has a liquid wallet, well then we're going to pay
- 38:49ourselves in liquids. But if he does have Lightning,
- 38:52well then we're going to do the payments as well and Lightning
- 38:54to our Lightning wallet. And so in this interoperable way
- 38:58where we know nothing about the user because we don't need to do
- 39:00any kind of KYC or anything. So we don't know the user.
- 39:02The only thing we have is a connection string from his
- 39:05wallet. With this we can know exactly
- 39:07what networks he has and we can generate back end payments using
- 39:12the network that works the best between the paying and the
- 39:16merchant, right? So this is how it works with our
- 39:18subscriptions as well, where I gave the example of the fees.
- 39:21But subscriptions the same thing.
- 39:23We know the pay your wallet what networks he has.
- 39:25We know the merchant wallet what network he has.
- 39:28If they both have liquid right now, it means they both have a
- 39:32flat wallet. We can make them use liquid
- 39:34instead of use like because they're going to be able to do
- 39:40well, smaller transactions and smaller fees because, you know,
- 39:44liquid to liquid is cheaper than having to do the swaps with
- 39:46bolts and breezed and take their own their own.
- 39:49So so we can we can choose the network based on that.
- 39:52And and I think that's like one of the true powerful things that
- 39:57exists in off the wall. Connect that.
- 39:59Yeah, that just keep discovering, you know, with
- 40:01time. Yeah, no, that's, that's
- 40:03amazing. I think, you know, a goal for
- 40:07all of this is like to make it so the end users, whether it's
- 40:10the payer or the merchant isn't, you know, isn't Privy to like
- 40:14what all, everything you just described in terms of what's
- 40:16going on behind the scenes, which networks each each party A
- 40:20or B is, is operating on. And it can just be as easy as
- 40:23possible for them to click a couple buttons and, you know,
- 40:26send or receive their payment. Like that's where we need to get
- 40:28to. And I think like you know what
- 40:30you guys are building is, is really accelerating that that
- 40:33progression to get there. Yeah.
- 40:35So I think just just to follow up on that, that's that's 100%
- 40:38how we're thinking about this in long term.
- 40:40Imagine just a network of payment, imagine PayPal where
- 40:46you know, you can connect your bank account or something,
- 40:48something like that and hold these funds in PayPal and you
- 40:49can send them between these users.
- 40:51PayPal holds custody of these funds.
- 40:53And of course, the the payments that happen in PayPal happen in
- 40:55the PayPal network, right? But the way we're thinking about
- 40:59this is being able to be a pay ourselves or the network itself.
- 41:03Yeah, that's what Master Wallet Connect is.
- 41:05It's not necessarily what is meant to be, but you know, it's
- 41:09a network where people can just hold their funds in, in whatever
- 41:12it is. You know, as soon as we have
- 41:14stable coin support, we will add stable coins to Master Wallet
- 41:18Connect, right. So whatever kind of funds are as
- 41:21part of Master Wallet Connect and the user's wallet, well, one
- 41:24user should be able to send money to another user, not
- 41:28having to wonder what network it is, right?
- 41:30As long as they have one network that matches whether it's
- 41:33lightning liquid on chain stable coin, whichever one it is that
- 41:38they have in common. This is how the payment should
- 41:40go, right? And the users wouldn't even need
- 41:42to like, yeah, choose which I think is, yeah, pretty, pretty
- 41:46exciting and all in, you know, from from Flash's perspective,
- 41:50non custody, I guess, because the wallets might be self
- 41:53custodial or custodial. From Flash's perspective, it
- 41:56doesn't matter, right? Because we're anyway
- 41:57facilitating in this. Yeah.
- 42:00I mean, I think, I think overall like I think that the nostril
- 42:03wall connect is like, you know, very interesting for the fact of
- 42:05like trying to obfuscate as much of like the complexity of of the
- 42:09the experience that we can. I think that that's something
- 42:12that is going to be very important as we look at more
- 42:15like of the kind of like merchant level, like point of
- 42:18sale type experiences. Because I think that's something
- 42:20like, you know, we remember Strike announcing like
- 42:23integration with like NCR and all those things which like
- 42:25ended up like kind of not panning out.
- 42:27But I think that that was, I don't know all the details of
- 42:29that specifically, but I think that was one of the challenges
- 42:31of the experience was like the, the complexity that exists
- 42:36inside of actually like paying at that time with Bitcoin and
- 42:39kind of a point of sale method. I think if there's a lot more
- 42:43that has been solved today versus that, then and then also
- 42:46more that can be solved to really just make it a very, very
- 42:48seamless experience. And just that's one thing that I
- 42:51will admit is one of the great things about credit cards is
- 42:54it's a pretty easy experience to pay.
- 42:55I can even just like tap my phone and it just works.
- 42:57And so we need that's, that's what that's our competition.
- 43:00That's what we need to be striving for and so that's what
- 43:03we need to be, you know, building towards.
- 43:05I think that, you know, nostril wall connect is one of those
- 43:06things that kind of is helping us get there. 100% agreed.
- 43:11And one of the things that you mentioned, Pierre, I think you
- 43:15listed off like 5 or 6 interoperable open networks
- 43:20during that, including nostril wall connect, you know, liquid
- 43:25lightning, Bitcoin on chain, then, you know, being able to
- 43:29use old swaps and can freeze SDK.
- 43:32It's just really amazing the progress.
- 43:35It's kind of happening behind the scenes at the moment.
- 43:38And I guess in person too. But you know, at least, you
- 43:41know, you're obfuscating that for the consumer.
- 43:44So it's just the easiest process it can be. 111 thing you guys
- 43:50didn't mention, I'm just curious to get your thoughts on is the
- 43:53world of of E cash curious, you know, what are your thoughts on
- 43:57on, you know, the development there?
- 43:58I know there's a few different efforts, whether it's Fetty or
- 44:02cashew that are, are sort of pushing that forward, but where
- 44:05do you see that sort of sort of fitting into the landscape of
- 44:09Bitcoin payments generally speaking?
- 44:11Is it just another sort of cog in this, this overall system?
- 44:15And, and you know, the other, the other sort of component of
- 44:18all of this is like, you know, I don't necessarily view lightning
- 44:23as like winner take all. Like I, I think over the medium
- 44:25to long term, there's going to be many different layers on top
- 44:28of Bitcoin. And so, you know, maybe you
- 44:31have, you know, various different sort of things that
- 44:35are progressing simultaneously and and sort of interop as well,
- 44:39but curious if you guys have any thoughts on E cash in
- 44:41particular. Go ahead, Pierre.
- 44:45Yeah, sure. So so I have some I think you
- 44:49know, and I'm planning to dig a bit deeper because the E cash
- 44:52community they are embracing Austin Wall Connect.
- 44:55So, you know, that's that's why I'm to follow this much cost
- 44:59line on the and so on. I think the developer community
- 45:03there and how it's growing is super impressive.
- 45:06And I think that some of the use cases that they've been locked
- 45:08are Yeah, very, just really, really good to see.
- 45:12I remember the one thing that made me, I think start to kind
- 45:17of looked a bit more discovered E cash a bit more was when
- 45:20Doctor Kelly on Twitter shared a video of him making an E cash
- 45:26transaction on an airplane without Internet access, which
- 45:30like, because that's, I think, you know, that's one big
- 45:33difficulty. I think that exists in
- 45:35lightning, in self custodial lightning, which is that the
- 45:41lightning node needs to be, well, it needs to be online, but
- 45:44it also needs to be reachable, right.
- 45:45So, you know, if you think of mobile lightning wallets, well,
- 45:50the node is in the cloud, but you access the nodes from the
- 45:54device. And that's kind of how we were
- 45:56working with flash originally. And that's how we work it.
- 45:58In fact, just with not the word connect typically, but we've
- 46:02added extra features through the flash wallet that allows us to
- 46:06create offline, so create lightning invoices while the
- 46:12phone is offline. And that's because we can
- 46:14leverage the liquid network for that.
- 46:16And so, you know, we can know if if a wallet is offline, we can't
- 46:20wake it up with a notification, Well, then we're going to use
- 46:23the the liquid address that we saved and we're going to do a
- 46:26swap directly this way. And and I think that's one of
- 46:30the things that, and it would be very interesting to see how E
- 46:34cash can kind of scale this, make this more more usable and
- 46:38how, how we could also try and implement something like that.
- 46:40So the merchants would be able to accept offline payments
- 46:44completely. I don't market at this stage, to
- 46:49be honest, how we could potentially integrate, but I
- 46:51think it's pretty good. I do also have some not
- 46:55necessarily doubts, but it is a mint that needs to be created.
- 47:02There is a certain Gray area when it comes to the custody of
- 47:06it, just like there is with the liquid network.
- 47:08I'm not saying right? Yep, But I think that's just
- 47:11when it comes to regulate and that's that's where, you know, I
- 47:16like, I think I have because it's from the perspective of
- 47:20flaff. Again, we want to be always non
- 47:22custodial. So we've got to be able to like
- 47:24figure out what technology is, what technology do we exactly
- 47:28provide to our users to avoid the situation where, you know,
- 47:32six months down the road, all of a sudden we get a, you know, a
- 47:37warning and we have to start KYC and all of our users because
- 47:41we're again, we're, we're fixing the the payment side of things
- 47:43and it's like it's just peer-to-peer comments.
- 47:45There's no need for KYC knowing who our users are.
- 47:48None of that then you know, that's really, if you manage to
- 47:51solve this properly, well, we will never need to KYC our users
- 47:55for, for this. And that's, that's what we'd
- 47:57want to yeah, keep us just a direction for flash.
- 48:03So, so you know, that's that's where I still don't exactly
- 48:06grasp what would be implications when it comes to to regulations
- 48:10there. Just my $0.02.
- 48:15Yeah, I think that's that's super fair, Graham.
- 48:18Yeah. I mean, I think it's
- 48:20interesting. I think that it'll be, it'll be
- 48:22interesting to see how it kind of continues to play out.
- 48:24I think that it it makes sense. It's just like I agree with a
- 48:29Pierce kind of evaluation of like it's, it's similar to a
- 48:31liquid or any of these other side chains.
- 48:35And so I think that they all have unique trade-offs for what
- 48:39they, you know, you kind of have some, some things you give up
- 48:42while you're using it, but then you also gain some some other
- 48:44things. And so it'll just be, I think
- 48:46interesting just to see where the adoption lands.
- 48:49I do think that, you know, lightning is obviously still the
- 48:51most prominent L2 or site like what just not a side chain, but
- 48:56it's the most prominent off chain scaling mechanism that has
- 48:59existed inside of Bitcoin. And that's still like from like,
- 49:02you know, you think about the exchanges that have adopted
- 49:04lightning over the last year, there's been a lot, there's been
- 49:08far less adopting liquid or E cash or fetti mint or whatever
- 49:11it is. And so I think it's still,
- 49:13that's why we focus so hard on lightning is because we still
- 49:16see it as not only what's in demand today, but also where
- 49:19will be the ultimate biggest value accrual inside of Bitcoin
- 49:23scaling in the long term. But it will be interesting to
- 49:26see how some of these newer protocols and and, you know,
- 49:30methods like this play out and see where the adoption
- 49:32ultimately lands. Absolutely.
- 49:37Maybe we could turn to, you know what both of you are excited for
- 49:42for the rest of the year here. Maybe talk a little bit about
- 49:44the road map at each of your, your companies, what's what
- 49:47your, what your heads down focused on right now in terms of
- 49:50building out and offering to your customers.
- 49:56I think. Yeah, I mean we, yeah, we got
- 50:00quite a few things in the works. You know, we'll have a new
- 50:02product out, you know, in the next week or two that we're
- 50:04really excited about. That I think is probably just
- 50:06best to read all the announcements when that happens.
- 50:08But really just simplifying the experience of integrating and
- 50:11using Lightning and just continuing to push the envelope
- 50:14and how how simple we can make it and how quick and easy it can
- 50:17be. So we're doing a lot with that.
- 50:19But then also the big thing that I'm excited for in this year is
- 50:22the stable coins on Lightning. So, you know, we've talked about
- 50:24it for a while and now that we're, it seems like it's, you
- 50:27know, possible, it's here, people are doing it.
- 50:29And so it's really still yet to be seen.
- 50:32What impact does that have on the network and adoption and all
- 50:36those things. So I think that it'll be a
- 50:38pretty big deal both from, you know, the efficiencies that the
- 50:41companies gain from doing stable coins on lightning like we
- 50:44talked about, but also the the boost in the network itself of,
- 50:47you know, more liquidity in the network or whatever it is.
- 50:50And so I think that it'll help both the users of stablecoins,
- 50:53but then also the just the general Bitcoin Lightning
- 50:55network in itself. So we're really excited.
- 50:58We're working on the products in that realm too.
- 51:00So we're excited to see that be finally possible.
- 51:04And then, you know, look, working with customers to enable
- 51:06that inside of their application.
- 51:07So we think that'll be a big a big opportunity this year.
- 51:13Yeah, but also on on fashion side where it's we're, we're
- 51:16about to release the new version of our web application that has
- 51:21much nicer user interface, but also this user experience.
- 51:26You know, we gathered a lot of feedback from the users in the
- 51:29past six months. And so we're, yeah, hoping this
- 51:32version will be when that's puts all of this feedback together.
- 51:37And after watching how users use flats, the first things they do
- 51:41when they get on the application, what kind of issues
- 51:44they they they see the, the Bitcoin of crowd there.
- 51:47They can be a bit, a bit difficult when it comes to, to
- 51:49some things like, you know, in our onboarding currently, when
- 51:53you, when you create the account, you have to provide
- 51:58some, I mean, you can provide some information if as a
- 52:00business, you want to be able to receive invoices in order to
- 52:04justify, well, the expenses that you had, which are the flash
- 52:08fees that we take. It's completely optional.
- 52:11You can click on the little skip button, but the skip button is
- 52:13too small. And Bitcoin is considered this
- 52:15KYC process, even though it can be like fake information.
- 52:20So you know, that's the kind of like stuff that's a, but the,
- 52:23the, the, the, the answer here. And I think it's, it's, it's
- 52:26true for every product that, that you build is how quickly
- 52:30can you get the user to actually using your, your platform and
- 52:34like actually having something that allows them to.
- 52:37And so that that's, you know, what, what we were trying to, to
- 52:39work on on this new, new version.
- 52:41So we're also going to be releasing our, our wallet that
- 52:43is currently on test flight. We're going to be releasing it
- 52:46in app stores and with, yeah, packed up functionalities,
- 52:51including subscription management directly.
- 52:55So you'll be able to manage all of your flash subscriptions from
- 52:57the wallet, but also we'll be adding the possibility of having
- 53:01these offline payments, as I mentioned, and it'll be offline
- 53:04payments in any kind of network. You know, what we want to do is
- 53:07every single one of our checkouts by default will show
- 53:10the lightning network and show a lightning invoice.
- 53:13But you can pay otherwise you can pay in liquids, you can pay
- 53:17on chain USDT. So, you know, kind of pack all
- 53:19of these payment solutions using lightning as the default, but
- 53:23you know, giving more options when, when paying, which of
- 53:26course will make it easier for for merchants that want to get
- 53:29into because we get, we get this, it's about, first of all,
- 53:33most people, they don't understand, you know, Bitcoin
- 53:36versus crypto. And so oftentimes is, oh, you
- 53:39only have Bitcoin now, OK, and, and I understand then, right.
- 53:45So then, of course, you know, the majority of anyway, the,
- 53:48the, the conversations I have like this are education and
- 53:50explaining kind of why we, we make this difference.
- 53:53But also being able to add USDT and just stable coins in general
- 53:58is the kind of thing that will make this, it'll make it easier
- 54:03to answer when someone has these kind of remarks.
- 54:11But then, you know, the next thing that we want to be able to
- 54:13do is of course, scale all of this, make sure everything works
- 54:17nicely. But then adding your self
- 54:19custodial lightning is kind of, you know, a priority for us here
- 54:23because, you know, first of all, I think self custodial lightning
- 54:27is kind of the way to go and it's become so much easier than
- 54:30what it used to be. So I think there's just, yeah,
- 54:33depending on some use case, you know, of course we're looking at
- 54:35voltage about we've of course had many conversation with
- 54:38Graham as well and his team simply because of the, you know,
- 54:41the quality of their product, the of course, the reputation
- 54:45that it has and just how easy it is to get started on that.
- 54:48Right. So because one thing we need to
- 54:50be able to do is, you know, building the flat vault is one
- 54:53thing and it's it's great because we can unlock use cases
- 54:55and we didn't throw them. But in the end, our business
- 54:58model comes from our business tools.
- 55:01Therefore, we need to be able to make sure that we bring more
- 55:05people over. So other wallets that already
- 55:08have a user base help them get onto Noster Wallet Connect.
- 55:11And so we're going to be open sourcing a bunch of our work as
- 55:15well to make it easier for them to be able to reach out and say,
- 55:19look, here it is. It's the exact same technology
- 55:22you're using the exact same wallet Olympics to be able to
- 55:26simplify that, then grow this network because we will grow
- 55:30with it. Brilliant.
- 55:33Very exciting boys. Maybe before we wrap here, I
- 55:39started the the convo by mentioning a report that that
- 55:43Liam had written called Bitcoin is the true fintech.
- 55:46And I think we've enumerated a lot of reasons why that is.
- 55:49And, and, you know, part of that report and part of what Liam put
- 55:54out there was like, if you think about quote, UN quote fintech,
- 55:57what that really has looked like over the past couple decades,
- 56:00It's really like, you know, lipstick on a pig of the
- 56:03traditional finance system, all these slow, old archaic rails,
- 56:06the SWIFT system, what have you. And it's, you know, it's not
- 56:12something fundamentally different and new and better and
- 56:14more efficient. Whereas if you look at
- 56:16everything that you can enable via Bitcoin and all these
- 56:19interoperable, interoperable protocols that work together
- 56:22like that is that is really financial technology, IE Fintech
- 56:26more so than just, you know, mapping sort of like, you know,
- 56:31Venmo on top of these old slow rails where like the payment
- 56:35isn't actually settling, IE, you know, name of the show final
- 56:37settlement. Like these are better native
- 56:42sort of infrastructure for everything you could possibly do
- 56:44in in finance. So Liam, I don't know if you had
- 56:46anything else to share on that or just generally on on what
- 56:50we've talked about today. I yeah, no, just would recommend
- 56:54anybody check out the piece if they haven't already.
- 56:56I mean, we touched on most of it, but a lot of there are three
- 56:59main pillars of why Bitcoin is the real Fintech, I would say,
- 57:02which is, you know, it's elite savings technology just being
- 57:06completely finite. It is, you know, the custodial
- 57:10properties that are built into it, whether it's self custody,
- 57:13multi sig or collaborative custody.
- 57:16It just allows for better escrow payments, you know, holding
- 57:21Bitcoin and more self sovereign ways in in ways where there's
- 57:26reduced custodial risk. And then the last one is
- 57:30primarily talking about how it's interoperable nature is just
- 57:35allows it to be the best fintech ever, you know, allowing for,
- 57:39you know, everything like consumer rewards, payroll
- 57:43payments, different escrow natures.
- 57:46It's just significantly better than the existing systems.
- 57:50So I and I think just based on the conversation today, you guys
- 57:55are, are really pushing the ball forward on, you know, really
- 57:59bringing this, especially on the payment side just to to the
- 58:03broader audience. But it would, yeah, I mean,
- 58:06unless yeah, that's, I would just recommend everybody check
- 58:10out the report if they haven't already.
- 58:11Yeah, we'll, we'll put that in the show notes.
- 58:13We'll also put Voltage and Fidelity's recent report in the
- 58:18show notes as well. And Pierre and Graham, where
- 58:21can, where can folks learn more about flash and voltage and, and
- 58:25yourselves as well? Yeah.
- 58:27So you can just go on pay with flash.com.
- 58:30That's our website directly that we redid recently, actually last
- 58:35year. So go go check it out.
- 58:37We also have, of course on X. You can find me Kirk organ.
- 58:42So for me you'll find me and you can find all the information
- 58:44about about flash directly. And you know all the other stuff
- 58:48that I do if I can plug actually, if ever there's anyone
- 58:51in Europe next month, May 23rd to 25th, there's the Bitcoin
- 58:55film fest happening in Warsaw. I'm the Co founder of that.
- 58:58I I'm not so much involved in the organization, but anymore
- 59:01because I just don't have much time, but it is happening.
- 59:04It's going to be a blast. So it's just a small so you can
- 59:06also find that on on my ex. Beautiful, Awesome.
- 59:11Yeah, you can find voltage at our websites. voltage.cloud.
- 59:15Yeah, hit us up, send us an e-mail.
- 59:17My name, my e-mail is graham@voltage.cloud.
- 59:20You can also find me on like Twitter at at GKRIZEK.
- 59:24Yeah, definitely. Hit us up if you're interested
- 59:26in Lightning payments. Beautiful, well really
- 59:29appreciate the time follows. This is a great combo and look
- 59:33forward to speaking again soon. Thanks a lot there boys.
- 59:38Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 59:40If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 59:42episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 59:45app. All the links we discussed in
- 59:47today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 59:50Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Rat Media is
- 59:52for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 59:55nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 59:58Regardless of where you are in your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:00:01to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:00:04to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:00:07advisors.