Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EFWD Offshore Europe Special
Transcript
- 0:09The energy industry is at a crossroads, but what might the
- 0:11future look like? I'm Ed Reed, the editor of E
- 0:14Forward, and I caught up with a number of E Forward members at
- 0:16the recent Offshore Europe show in Aberdeen to get a bit of a
- 0:19steer the industry's working out how to come to terms with the
- 0:23transition as the government and politicians more broadly
- 0:26consider how growing the energy sector can align with its
- 0:29efforts to tackle emissions. It's hard to escape mention of
- 0:32the windfall tax, but it's becoming increasingly clear that
- 0:35as a means to raise revenue, it's woefully underperformed.
- 0:39What it has delivered is a choke point for investment in the
- 0:41North Sea, complicated by other areas such as the new licence
- 0:45ban and the various court cases around emissions.
- 0:48It was actually remarkable that given these challenges, how
- 0:50optimistic people we spoke to were part of this is a
- 0:54necessity. It's ultimately an indulgence to
- 0:56simply complain about what's wrong with the world or the
- 0:58government. Industry needs to look forward
- 1:01and focus on how to try and find solutions.
- 1:04I was enjoying my time in Aberdeen and offshore Europe was
- 1:07no different. Part of the fascination for me
- 1:09is the importance of energy to the city.
- 1:12In other parts of the country, the energy industry can
- 1:14sometimes feel a bit abstract. In Aberdeen though, everyone
- 1:17knows people in the industry and everyone has an opinion.
- 1:19We will continue to need oil and gas right up until 2050 and
- 1:22beyond, even while staying on track for net zero.
- 1:25And we're going to need the skills and the people for our
- 1:28existing hydrocarbon supply system while layering on low
- 1:31emission technologies. As the energy transition takes
- 1:34shape, workers will be crucial to keeping the lights on and the
- 1:37economy running. It often feels like oil and gas
- 1:40workers, especially in the offshore, were taken for granted
- 1:43and that's at odds with those workers in other more onshore
- 1:45areas. And there are certainly risks to
- 1:48the workforce that go right to the top of how we as a country
- 1:51are planning for the energy sector, Michael Love from Apito
- 1:53explained. So we have done a lot of work
- 1:56recently with our partners, the likes of the Chamber of Commerce
- 2:00over UK to really try and understand and link people,
- 2:05place industry, business, all these core pillars to the
- 2:08industrial strategy and make sure that before that was
- 2:11published, it reflected a lot, a lot of what we feel needed to be
- 2:14included. We are concerned, I think Ed, in
- 2:18an honest terms that you know, we risk offshoring our
- 2:20workforce, our supply chain. And that sense of industrial
- 2:23clarity also came through in conversations with Paula
- 2:26Patterson at Fidez Oak. We look around us and it's very,
- 2:30very mechanical, right at the heart of what we do is people,
- 2:33you know, and there's that uncertainty has an impact on
- 2:36people. So there's conversations about
- 2:39the decline in the oil and gas industry and the move into
- 2:42renewable energies and the transition into that, but
- 2:45there's no sense of what plan is.
- 2:47There's no sense of when one turns off and one turns on, or
- 2:50what that transition really looks like.
- 2:52So if I'm a person working in oil and gas currently, I'm
- 2:56wondering what's next for me and where my skills get to be used.
- 3:00Part of that answer has to come from executives, but this can be
- 3:03a challenge, Jill Hughes from Affinity explained.
- 3:06Those who have become CEOs or CFOs or other acronyms beginning
- 3:09with C may not always be the best at transmitting a message
- 3:12with workers, she said. The leaders need to be able to
- 3:15think about their people, what their people will connect with
- 3:18and and use the right language that's going to help people to
- 3:21understand what it is that they're really trying to achieve
- 3:23in the big picture of change. We've got people in
- 3:25organizations that are CFO's or CEO's.
- 3:28They're absolutely amazing at what they do, but they're not
- 3:32always amazing at getting the messages quite right or talking
- 3:35to their people in that direct way.
- 3:36That's going to make a big difference.
- 3:39They need to just remember that the people are what will make
- 3:42the change happen and what will make the change stick, so don't
- 3:45forget about them in the grand scheme of things.
- 3:47But the energy industry is unlike many other industries in
- 3:50the sense that it's not always straightforward.
- 3:52Contractors need to be able to make choices about the future
- 3:54and in terms of things like paying for training courses
- 3:57while not maybe being Privy to the top line direction that
- 4:00those C sweeters have. Ian Taylor from Chorus.
- 4:03So the challenge for the workforce lies in trying to find
- 4:05a way through the thicket of regulations and opportunities.
- 4:08We're quite interested in the infrastructure that happens in
- 4:10between all of the above and I think that's where the workforce
- 4:14challenges will happen specifically.
- 4:15I don't think it will be in anyone bucket specifically, I
- 4:19think the the workforce of the future, I think the workforce
- 4:22tend not to look at themselves in the categories which they are
- 4:25signed from a view from above. I think people tend to base
- 4:30their skill set based on their vocation, so I think we'll see a
- 4:32lot more transitional workers. I think there be a lot more
- 4:35requirement for people to look objectively about the skills
- 4:38they have in their workforce and how ready they are to adapt to
- 4:40quite a changing energy environment.
- 4:42As always, it's hard to escape from the discussion of AI, and
- 4:45to all extent, workers are ready for this change.
- 4:48Jill Hughes went on to say AI was going to play a big role in
- 4:51digital transformation and call for people to show flexibility
- 4:55in how to deliver it. I think the the level of change
- 4:58that's happening in that area is so significant.
- 5:01The pace is so great at the moment.
- 5:03Being able to put a road map in place that's going to help you
- 5:06to adapt. But it needs to be that agile
- 5:08road map. So don't think about things that
- 5:10are five years away. Think about things that are 5
- 5:12months away and being able to be a evolving constantly with that
- 5:18change because the change is happening.
- 5:20It's such a pace around us right now.
- 5:22That pace of change clearly varies.
- 5:23Some are moving fast, but as Ian Taylor explained, some are not.
- 5:28Digital awareness and adopting adopt, willingness to adopt,
- 5:32it's still quite low. I think we spoke last night
- 5:34about a scenario where I've just been asked to print off an Excel
- 5:38sheet and sign it and then scan it back in and send it.
- 5:41So digitization is still not fully fledged because partly
- 5:45because what they did a requirements a lot of high
- 5:47hazard industries have are there's no margin for error, you
- 5:52physically can't get it wrong. So adoption is slower.
- 5:55I think there is an appetite to do it, but I think the pace of
- 5:58change in technology really mandates that we need to look at
- 6:01subjectively. And the challenges that industry
- 6:04faces our customers face are one that can't be solved quickly or
- 6:07without the use of supporting technologies like AI.
- 6:10It is a challenge for workers to position themselves
- 6:12individually, but to be fair, the wide industry is also coming
- 6:16to grips with how it needs to tackle a more complicated
- 6:18transition. In 2020 and 2021, the oil
- 6:21industry was on its knees and it really seemed like it could be
- 6:23the end of hydrocarbons. All that was needed, the
- 6:25thinking was at the time, was for a light push and the edifice
- 6:28of oil and gas would crumble. Looking back now, that says
- 6:32massively simplify the challenge that it was ahead for society.
- 6:35Sometimes, though, it feels like the Department for Energy
- 6:37Security in net zero is stuck with that same thinking.
- 6:40The industry has moved on to try and find a way to reconcile
- 6:43meeting current and future oil and gas demand with this major
- 6:46shift into solar, wind, CCS, hydrogen and all these other
- 6:49parts of an integrated energy system with which we must
- 6:52grapple. Steve Swindell, the outgoing
- 6:54head of excess, highlighted that need to make the case to
- 6:57politicians. It's about the necessity of oil
- 6:59and gas to deliver on the energy transition goals, he said.
- 7:03The thing that I picked up on most was it's about and it's oil
- 7:07and gas and wind and hydrogen and storage.
- 7:11That that's what that's what we're talking about here.
- 7:14And everybody's agreeing and everybody's saying we shouldn't
- 7:17be having a the polarized debate is not helping.
- 7:19The interesting thing about the politicians and the politics,
- 7:23they're actually making it a polarized debate when I don't
- 7:25think it needs to be. You can achieve the climate
- 7:28goals. We can achieve clean energy by
- 7:3020-30 and still produce oil and gas to do that.
- 7:33In fact, it's necessary to produce oil and gas to achieve
- 7:36those goals. And you turn that into a
- 7:38positive rather than it's this is bad.
- 7:40And that's that's good. I think that's that's the
- 7:42challenge that the politicians have.
- 7:45And there are some signs of progress from government,
- 7:47particularly around supporting CCS clusters.
- 7:49Desnos has signed up to support 2IN the Northeast and Northwest
- 7:52with £21.7 billion worth of funding.
- 7:55Going a step further, the National Wealth Fund has stepped
- 7:58in to provide earlier stage funding for the peak cluster,
- 8:01Gavin Roberts of Spirit Energy explained.
- 8:03And listen, that's fantastic recognition, I'll say.
- 8:05So the National Wealth Fund, previously the UK Investment
- 8:07bank, National Wealth Fund recently announced A commitment
- 8:11to invest in the peak cluster side of it, so the pipeline side
- 8:13of it and something the region around 30 million.
- 8:16The interesting thing there is that makes the our project the
- 8:19only project in the UK that has government investment going into
- 8:26it in that kind. Again, this isn't a grant, this
- 8:28isn't a subsidy investment. The National Wealth Fund expects
- 8:31to get payback from this and how will the public benefit will
- 8:35benefit from it as well. So that's a really important
- 8:38step and we would invite and encourage and look forward to
- 8:42further similar announcements of investment into those sorts of
- 8:44projects. I think that's how we help help
- 8:47make people understand how important these projects are and
- 8:51that they can be a value creator.
- 8:53There's a, there's a general conception that CCS is just
- 8:55cost, that all CCS projects will require enormous amounts of, of,
- 9:00of public subsidy. Now the reality is when we have
- 9:02a, a newer industry such as CCS because the technology is not
- 9:06new, but what we want to do is scale, yes, that's, that's new.
- 9:09That's going to be challenging and all, all such new industries
- 9:12require support from government to an extent, but not all CCS
- 9:15projects require the same sort of support.
- 9:17Certainly our our project doesn't.
- 9:19Gavin went on to say Morecambe Netzero would pay on around £7
- 9:22billion over its project life to the Treasury, and while there's
- 9:26a clear benefit to the Government from those revenues,
- 9:28there are also the more diffuse benefits.
- 9:30The plan aims to capitalize on private investment of around £5
- 9:33billion for the project, which should unlock around £10 billion
- 9:37of inward investment. And that plan's also going to
- 9:40help safeguard existing traditional jobs in areas such
- 9:43as cement production that would otherwise struggle with carbon
- 9:46emissions. Spirit expects that around
- 9:4813,000 jobs will benefit as a result of its project, with more
- 9:52in the supply chain. And jobs are front and Center
- 9:55for Proserve also, both in existing industries and new
- 9:58opportunities, Dan Fernley told me.
- 10:00We're keeping our conventional, you know, heritage, our
- 10:02commercial energy heritage because there's still a lot to
- 10:05do in that space. You know, the life extension,
- 10:08even the decommissioning. We play in all facets of that
- 10:11energy space. So we continue to do that, but
- 10:13our globalization is a big part of that as well.
- 10:15Aberdeen is an amazing skill set and people and heritage and
- 10:19industry and the capabilities, especially in the supply chain.
- 10:22It's been here for a long time. My family came from this
- 10:25industry, I'm this industry. So it's quite personal to me.
- 10:27And what we do is, is we, we push that expertise out to the
- 10:31world. You know, we have people in
- 10:32Aberdeen going out to West Africa.
- 10:34We have them supporting some of our more technical problems in
- 10:37Southeast Asia. And it, it works well for us
- 10:39now. But it's, you know, servicing
- 10:42the world from UK becomes more and more expensive.
- 10:45So it's a, it's a consideration that we continue to follow,
- 10:48adapt and and we'll see where we are in the next 5 to 10 years
- 10:52as, as everyone's looking at. There's a complexity to the
- 10:55energy industry that is easy to overlook.
- 10:57Speaking to people around Aberdeen, the intermingling of
- 11:00supply chains between the offshore wind and oil and gas
- 11:03and CCS industries is abundantly clear.
- 11:06The message comes through again and again about how damaging the
- 11:10oil industry has a knock on impact on plans to ramp up our
- 11:13low carbon plants. It's also clear the industry is
- 11:17facing up to its responsibilities.
- 11:18It's trying to find a way through the challenges of
- 11:20operating in the UK alongside those commercial and practical
- 11:24needs. The way forwards is integration,
- 11:27but where there is integration, there is a need to recognize
- 11:30complexity. Aberdeen's moved on from the
- 11:32notion of a clean break with hydrocarbons.
- 11:35New energies are simply not delivering at the speed
- 11:37required, and headwinds facing these new industries, such as
- 11:40high interest rates, equipment bottlenecks and deglobalization,
- 11:43are slowing these developments down.
- 11:46No one I spoke to denied the need to tackle the UK's
- 11:49emissions problem, but there's a clear sense we cannot tackle net
- 11:52zero on its own. We must also think of how to
- 11:55deliver for society. People may struggle to see the
- 11:58immediate impact of climate change, but we'll be well aware
- 12:01of inflation and job losses. For E Forward members, this
- 12:05presents both a challenge. And for E Forward members, this
- 12:09presents both a challenge and an opportunity.
- 12:12The industry needs to maintain its technical leadership while
- 12:15developing new capabilities. Companies that can successfully
- 12:18integrate existing expertise with emerging technologies while
- 12:22keeping their workforce engaged and skilled will be best
- 12:25positioned to thrive. But this requires a long term
- 12:28view and investment in both infrastructure and people,
- 12:31something that our members with a deep understanding of the
- 12:33energy sectors complexities are uniquely positioned to deliver.
- 12:37And if you want to hear more, you can listen and watch the
- 12:39full interviews from all of our members on the E Forward YouTube
- 12:42channel. I've been Ed Reed, Editor Review
- 12:44forward, where we're always pushing the conversation
- 12:47forward.