Latest / Conversations for Equal Pay / #6, Interview with Karla Pineda, Executive Director at LCLAA
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Across the board, women continue to earn less than men.
- 0:05White women make about eighty cents to a man's dollar,
- 0:10Black women earned sixty six cents, Native women and Latinas
- 0:17just fifty eight cents, and Asian American women, though often
- 0:24reported higher earnings, still face wide pay gaps depending on
- 0:30ethnicity and industry. The numbers tell a story about the
- 0:38urging need for change. I'm Juline Allen, and this is
- 0:43Conversations or Equal Pay, where we talk with leaders, innovators,
- 0:51and change makers about closing the gap and uplifting women
- 0:55of color in the workplace. Conversations for equal we're talking
- 1:08to Carla Panita today, the executive director of the Labor
- 1:12Council for Latin American Advancement or LACLAW. Carla is a
- 1:18powerful voice for LATINX workers and their families, leading efforts
- 1:23to advance economic justice, labor rights, and equity in the workplace.
- 1:29Her work continues lackless mission to ensure that the voices
- 1:34of LATINX workers are heard and that their contributions are
- 1:38recognized across every sector of our economy. Carla, thank you
- 1:43for joining us today.
- 1:45Speaker 2: Now, thank you for the invitation.
- 1:48Speaker 1: So Carla, there is a wage gap for Latinas across
- 1:51all sorts of sectors. What are the biggest systemic reasons
- 1:56that keep Latina workers from earning equal pay?
- 2:00Speaker 3: So you know, when we talk about the wage gap,
- 2:04it's not about individual choices that you know, Latina especially make.
- 2:11There's a lot of barriers that that shape where and
- 2:15how Latinas work.
- 2:17Speaker 2: Right.
- 2:17Speaker 3: So some of those issues could be occupational segregation. Right,
- 2:21Latinas are constant concentrated in industries that are either low
- 2:27wage by like the hospitality industry, domestic work, agricultural too
- 2:34by and these are jobs that are essential, but you know,
- 2:40unfortunately they're undervalue.
- 2:42Speaker 2: Right.
- 2:42Speaker 3: So other other issues that influence the gap for Latinas
- 2:49is also access to education, right, So we lack access
- 2:53to education mentorship. But we also understand that having a
- 2:59degree or so doesn't mean that you're gonna make more money,
- 3:03right because we're still even when you have a degree,
- 3:06you still find yourself in that in that situation, other
- 3:11issues could be discrimination discrimination to either you know, get
- 3:15promoted or even get higher. A lot of discrimination can
- 3:20be based on race, gender, your ethnicity, your age. Immigration
- 3:27is another status, immigration, status and language barrier.
- 3:31Speaker 2: It's another issue, right, we know.
- 3:32Speaker 3: That undocumented women, documented Latinas are more vulnerable to harassment
- 3:39to wage staff and they don't find sometimes they don't
- 3:44have a way to deal with most things, right, but
- 3:47they need to they need to prove make money, they
- 3:50need to take care of their families, so they just
- 3:54you know, accept those conditions sometimes. Another issue that we
- 4:00have seen this lack of family friendly policy, I.
- 4:04Speaker 2: Like pay leave.
- 4:07Speaker 3: You know, when when we're mothers and we have to
- 4:09take care of our children and we don't have access
- 4:11to pay leave, sometimes we have to choose between taking
- 4:14care of a family having a job, and sometimes we
- 4:16call that the motherhood penalty, right, or we we sometimes
- 4:24we're also skipped for being mothers on promotions or opportunities
- 4:28for training. If you have to travel, sometimes they assume that, well,
- 4:33you have a child or you have kids, so you know,
- 4:35we're just going to send someone who doesn't. And typically
- 4:40sometimes those are men, right, even though they also have children.
- 4:44Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 4:45Speaker 3: Yeah, So so those are some of the issues, right
- 4:48that we have seen, and.
- 4:50Speaker 1: We know that when you do everything right, Latinas still
- 4:54face a pay gap. The they they when you control
- 4:59for education, they face discrimination in the workplace. They also
- 5:04face something called the broken wrong in which sometimes they're
- 5:10not sought out for leadership or management opportunities, which prevents
- 5:15them from securing higher paying roles.
- 5:20Speaker 2: Correct.
- 5:20Speaker 3: Correct, you know we've seen this right like I said,
- 5:26Like I mentioned the education piece, right now, we see
- 5:28that women that being us with a master's degree are
- 5:32still earning the same as men of white men with
- 5:35an associate degree. So that's challenging because we're also trying
- 5:40to invest in our education. We put the time, but
- 5:44we're still not being considered. We're being skipped the promotions
- 5:48like I said, and trainings and opportunities to advance in
- 5:52the workplace. Yeah.
- 5:56Speaker 1: So moving on to my next question, the Latin of
- 5:59pay gap. It's often stated as Latina is earning around
- 6:02fifty four cents for every dollar earned by white non
- 6:06Hispanic by white non Hispanic men. Can you translate this
- 6:11staggering disparity into real life economic consequences for Latin X
- 6:18families in the broader community, especially concerning wealth building, education,
- 6:23and health equity.
- 6:25Speaker 3: Yes, so we see that, you know, as you said,
- 6:28it's fifty percents.
- 6:29Speaker 2: For some women.
- 6:30Speaker 3: Also, depending where what country you come from, that could
- 6:35be even even lower. We have seen some women I believe,
- 6:39if you're from Watemana and you work in a rural area,
- 6:42these women are only earning about twenty nine cents to
- 6:45the dollar. So we you know, based on the fifty
- 6:49four cents right now, we're looking about over a million dollars.
- 6:53It's about one point two million dollars in a forty
- 6:55year career, and that tends to change depending on what
- 6:58the number will be next. Here we're not looking to earn,
- 7:02you know, to get pay equity until over in one
- 7:06hundred and fifty years from now. Yeahs so you and
- 7:11I are never going to get to see this, which
- 7:15is in saying yes so, And what does this mean
- 7:17for us as women? I think you know this can
- 7:20impact a lot of things. Being able to afford a home,
- 7:25pay your rent, pay your bills. Sometimes we have to
- 7:29choose between paying for health care versus feeding our family.
- 7:35Speaker 2: This can be you.
- 7:36Speaker 3: You can miss out on having a savings account for
- 7:39an emergency. A lot of us can can afford to
- 7:43put money aside buying groceries, paying for child care if
- 7:49you have children, you can afford daycare or quality daycare
- 7:53sometimes for your kids. For young Latina, it's like you
- 7:57can't afford to go to college sometimes, right, based on
- 8:01how much money you're earning. So those are real life,
- 8:04you know, cases like we all need to survive, we
- 8:09all need to live. And the gap that's really hurting,
- 8:13you know, the most vulnerable women.
- 8:17Speaker 1: It leaves to. So basically over a forty year career,
- 8:22they lose one million dollars actually over one million over
- 8:27over and that leads to multi generational insecurity.
- 8:32Speaker 2: Exactly, exactly.
- 8:34Speaker 3: Yeah, and you know, if we can I have a
- 8:36daughter myself, and you know, if we can afford a
- 8:39lot of times, especially in Latino families, you know, you
- 8:42buy a home and that's your children's home, or you know,
- 8:46you can invest in your retirement also, right, and that's
- 8:50money that you can leave for your kids or pay
- 8:53for their education. And we cannot do that right now.
- 8:59Speaker 1: So LACK works closely with the labor movement. How does
- 9:03unions and collective bargaining serve as a powerful tool for
- 9:07addressing the systemic issues in the Latina pay gap?
- 9:12Speaker 3: Yeah, So we always say, you know, for us, one
- 9:14of the roles that LACLA has taken on and in
- 9:17this campaign for the last you know, I know we
- 9:20just celebrated ten years, but we've actually been doing this
- 9:22a little bit longer since twenty twelve. About is promoting unionization,
- 9:28we say unions are a powerful tool that we need
- 9:32to learn about. We need to know how to organize
- 9:34in the workplace.
- 9:37Speaker 2: Unions.
- 9:37Speaker 3: If you have a collective bargaining agreement with a contract, right,
- 9:43the pay discrimination doesn't exist. You will get paid the
- 9:47same amount, no matter you know if you're doing it,
- 9:51if you're a woman or if you're a Latina, that
- 9:54doesn't influence how much money you make. As long as
- 9:57you know you're you're still within the same job as men.
- 10:01So that eliment is that Also, we also understand that
- 10:05women in unions earn about twenty two percent more. Salaries
- 10:09are about twenty two percent higher for all women, and
- 10:13for Latinas it's about forty percent. Right, Latinas can earn
- 10:17up to forty percent more if you if you have
- 10:19if you're in a union a union job.
- 10:23Speaker 2: Unions also give you a lot of those.
- 10:25Speaker 3: Other things we talked about, which is not a coal insurance.
- 10:29You have benefits, you have until you have paid leave,
- 10:33you have vacations. You also have something that's very important.
- 10:38It's a pension, a retirement one right that that helps you,
- 10:45you know, invest in your future. So so unions should
- 10:50be seeing right now, we see unions as the one
- 10:54of the only solutions that we have until we can
- 10:58change the system. You know, they also ensure Another thing
- 11:02that unions will do for you is is besides all
- 11:05the benefits, it's also making sure that we have good
- 11:08working conditions, right, which is important that that you're in.
- 11:11Speaker 2: A safe job.
- 11:13Speaker 3: Collective Buyings agreement also include causes against discrimination and against
- 11:18sexual harassment, which is another issue that we face as women.
- 11:22Speaker 1: Yeah, you're really showing why unions remain one of the
- 11:26most effective equalizers in the workplace. So Lacola is involved
- 11:35in advocacy at all levels. What are one or two
- 11:39key policy measures, whether state level pay transparency laws or
- 11:44federal bills like the Paycheck Fairness Act, that you believe
- 11:48will have the most immediate and significant impact on closing
- 11:52the wage gap for women of color.
- 11:55Speaker 3: So besides the Paycheck Fairness Act, I think we need
- 12:00to go back to having a conversation about the race
- 12:05the way to act. Right. We believe that, you know,
- 12:09if we can get that pass, even though some states have,
- 12:13you know, their own state policies, but I think at
- 12:15the federal level that would really impact a lot of
- 12:20women that are in those those industries that I mentioned, right,
- 12:24especially women in the service industry, domestic workers. The Race
- 12:31to Waye Act would increase that that hourly pay to
- 12:35about seventeen dollars across war. There's about sixty percent of
- 12:42women that will benefit from this because these are industries
- 12:45that are where women are overrepresented. And out of that
- 12:49sixty one in three women are women of color, right,
- 12:54So so this this would be a big change for them.
- 12:59It would create economic security and when you know that
- 13:03you're gonna earn more, there's it brings stability. You will
- 13:08also reduce some of the harassment and the wage stuff
- 13:11problems that we see. So I think that's one. The
- 13:15other one that I would probably mention is the Family Act. Yeah,
- 13:22you know, we just it was just introduced. We supported,
- 13:25you know, the Family Act, and this with this movie,
- 13:30the women will get pay leave, right, pay leave to
- 13:34take care of their families. Right, So these are benefits
- 13:37that not everybody has. When you're pregnant, you have a child,
- 13:41the most women don't don't have maternity.
- 13:45Speaker 2: Leaf that's part of their work contract.
- 13:48Speaker 3: So you know, women would get twelve weeks of of
- 13:52leave and it would be paid all right. So so
- 13:55I think that that can help also another.
- 13:57Speaker 2: Big group of women.
- 14:00Speaker 3: It also makes ensures that companies are covering this no
- 14:04matter the site. A lot of times we say, well
- 14:06it's only big companies that cover this pay leave. Well,
- 14:09now it's it would create across the board, like no
- 14:11matter the site of the company that you work for,
- 14:13they would have to give you that. So, like I said,
- 14:18you know, those are howly through of the things that
- 14:20would help kind of normalize wages and support women.
- 14:26Speaker 1: And a lot of people don't really know that the
- 14:29federal minimum wage is seven dollars and ninety five cents
- 14:32an hour. And really the federal minimum wage just does
- 14:37not just impact one group of people.
- 14:39Speaker 3: It impacts everyone, everyone, everyone exactly. And then you know,
- 14:45like with the pay lead too, there's about sixty I
- 14:47believe with the Latina is about sixty nine percent of
- 14:50Latinas don't have pay leaf. Yeah, so and and there's
- 14:57a lot you know, I think in the U Black
- 15:00workers is about sixty fix perfect all right, So so
- 15:04it's it's very huge you know, like we're not just
- 15:06talking about Latinas, but it's all workers of color that
- 15:09would benefit from this.
- 15:13Speaker 1: So, given the significant challenges women of color face and
- 15:17the hiring process and workplace, what is the most important
- 15:22practical advice you would give to a Latina or woman
- 15:25of color about negotiating her salary or promotion.
- 15:31Speaker 3: So for me, I work with a lot of interns
- 15:36at Laclaw and a lot of students, a lot of
- 15:39them are women, young Latinas, and one of the advices
- 15:42I give them when you know, when you graduate college
- 15:45and you go get your first job, negotiate that salary.
- 15:48Your first salary is extremely important. I think that you know,
- 15:53I was young myself too, no training, didn't know how
- 15:56to ask for more money, and and you can see
- 16:00right where you start that. I think that first salary
- 16:03really creates that that foundation is you're just gonna go
- 16:07up from there.
- 16:08Speaker 2: And when you when you.
- 16:09Speaker 3: Take a lower salary, you're you're really creating that like
- 16:13you're you're ready below right, whether it's one percent, two percent.
- 16:18So one is negotiate your first salary. A lot of
- 16:22times we don't know, we don't know how to do that.
- 16:25Speaker 2: So you know.
- 16:26Speaker 3: I say, when you go to an interview or you're
- 16:28you're you're whether you're negotiating a race or your job.
- 16:33Speaker 2: Know your worth. Know your worth.
- 16:35Speaker 3: I think that you know, there's a study from.
- 16:40Speaker 2: That's as you know, women that ask.
- 16:43Speaker 3: For for a salary increase more than twice are most
- 16:47likely to get it.
- 16:49Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 16:50Speaker 2: So so so what you can do is ask. And
- 16:54but also when you ask, like I said, know your.
- 16:55Speaker 3: Worth, know your rights, No, know what you're asking for,
- 17:00talk about your wins and what you bringing to the table.
- 17:02Speaker 2: I think that's really important.
- 17:05Speaker 3: And how the company that you work with for will
- 17:08benefit from from giving you this promotion or from hiring you.
- 17:15You know, I think negotiating it's not about being difficult.
- 17:19Speaker 2: It's about asking for what you deserve.
- 17:23Speaker 1: Right and anchor your salary on market data. The data
- 17:28is out there, not based on your needs or your
- 17:33past salary history. And then also take account of your
- 17:39accomplishments as well.
- 17:42Speaker 2: Yes, yes, no, your wins, know how to speak for it.
- 17:44I think.
- 17:46Speaker 3: Transparency has helped right because now we can do research,
- 17:49we can go I always tell women go.
- 17:52Speaker 2: Go research the market, like you're saying, see what other
- 17:55jobs are out there? And how much they're pain so
- 17:57that you understand where you like and as well. Yes, absolutely.
- 18:05Speaker 3: So.
- 18:05Speaker 1: For some Latina workers, issues like immigration status or language.
- 18:10Language barriers make the pay gap even worse. How does
- 18:15LACKLA make sure it's work and solutions help the most
- 18:19vulnerable women like migrant or undocumented workers.
- 18:24Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 18:25Speaker 3: So, you know, one of the things that we do
- 18:28is everything is bilingual. Because we know a language, it
- 18:32is a barrier for a lot of women. So our work,
- 18:38everything that we're doing that we know that it's educational,
- 18:41has to be in Spanish. That's that's key for us.
- 18:46Another thing is we we produce a lot of educational
- 18:50pieces about no you're rights.
- 18:54Speaker 2: Under the current administration.
- 18:56Speaker 3: You know, there's so many things happening that it's really
- 18:59hard to keep up with, right, So we take a
- 19:04lot of this information. We do a lot of explainers,
- 19:06a lot of one pagers, again bilinguals, so that workers
- 19:10understand what are the changes that are happening, if it's
- 19:13whether it's good or bad. Even like I said, the
- 19:15Family Act, right, a lot of them don't understand what
- 19:18that means.
- 19:18Speaker 2: So we summarize that, we put in one page. We
- 19:21do it in Spanish.
- 19:23Speaker 3: We do workshops, webinars, we'll talk to workers about it
- 19:28and why they need to support this legislation. With women,
- 19:33we understand that for example, you know, farm workers are
- 19:36not able to organize, right they're excluded from joining a union,
- 19:40but we still provide the same information. I think that
- 19:45whether you're in a union or not, there's still ways
- 19:47that we can still create those policies, whether it's through
- 19:52like collective action or working with farm worker organizations to
- 19:57bring the resources and lack of producers to them. And
- 20:01and I think that's a way for them to also,
- 20:05you know, have that support system that they need in
- 20:10the workplace, whether they're unionized or not.
- 20:14Speaker 1: Yeah, and that's such an important reminder at that advocacy
- 20:19should include every type of worker, not just people with
- 20:23privilege and access and our command lack of love for
- 20:27its legislative presence.
- 20:29Speaker 2: Thank you, thank you.
- 20:31Speaker 3: Yes, And it's extremely important I think that you know,
- 20:34fifty three years ago, we were created to to support
- 20:38workers within the labor movement, within the unions, but we've
- 20:42moved beyond just unionized workers because we understand that organizations
- 20:46I LACKLA are the ones that are going to bridge
- 20:48that gap between our communities and labor.
- 20:52Speaker 2: A lot of.
- 20:52Speaker 3: Times workers don't understand how unions do, or they say, well,
- 20:56unions just come and take my money.
- 20:58Speaker 2: And you know I can't pay that, but why am
- 21:01I paying?
- 21:01Speaker 3: So we do a lot of that education, a lot
- 21:03of it in Spanish, so that they understand the value
- 21:08right where your money is going. If you are in
- 21:10a union, what are the benefits that you're going to
- 21:14receive based on your contributions. So and we also talk
- 21:20to the labor movement in our unions and we say,
- 21:22you know, the unions also need workers of color, they
- 21:25need Latinos, they need black viation to survive, and if
- 21:30we want to survive and want to grow, we need
- 21:31to talk to them as well.
- 21:33Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 21:34Speaker 1: Absolutely, So my last question, many corporations publicly commit diversity
- 21:41and inclusion. In your view, what is the most single
- 21:46most important action employers must take to move beyond symbolic
- 21:51gestures and institute genuine, measurable accountability for achieving pay equity
- 21:58for their Latina employees.
- 22:02Speaker 2: One.
- 22:02Speaker 3: I think corporations really need to understand the value that
- 22:08latin Us bring to their companies.
- 22:11Speaker 2: You know, a lot of times we're we're you know.
- 22:13Speaker 3: We're the bilingual employees, right we speak two languages, and
- 22:19sometimes we don't get paid for it, right, we we
- 22:21only get paid for one, but we're really doing double work.
- 22:25So they need to value that. They need to value
- 22:27our language and our you know, are what we bring
- 22:31to the table. I also think corporations need to start investing.
- 22:35It's not like you're saying, it's not just saying they
- 22:37support us, but start investing in our communities. Do outreach
- 22:43to our communities high school, you know, college students, they
- 22:47need to be present, and then they need you need
- 22:49to really talk to the especially new generations that are
- 22:53going to enter the workforce, you know, do more recruitment
- 22:57in our communities. Another thing that you know I talk
- 23:02about is.
- 23:03Speaker 2: Training, right, create those opportunities.
- 23:06Speaker 3: Don't say, well, we have Latinas in our in our corporations,
- 23:10in our companies, but what else are you doing for them?
- 23:13Once they're in your company and they are doing great jobs?
- 23:16Are you creating more opportunities? Are you opening those doors
- 23:21in those spaces so that they can move up in
- 23:25your companies? I think that's extremely important. And another one
- 23:30is I think with you know, the elimination with d
- 23:33I we need to ask corporations. I think they need to.
- 23:38They need to continue to promote you know, diversity, equity,
- 23:42and inclusion. Just because these policies have been.
- 23:47Speaker 2: Eliminated, we don't have they don't have to.
- 23:49Speaker 3: They can continue to promote that within their corporations. And
- 23:55I think that would really speak to to the work
- 23:58that you're doing to your your company, and it gives
- 24:01you a different brand. I think like that's also a
- 24:04lot of corporations care about their brand and if you
- 24:07continue to promote this, then you really show it like
- 24:10it's gonna build a different brand for you for you, right.
- 24:15Speaker 1: In speaking of branding, it's not just about branding, it's
- 24:18about outcomes and the fact that when you are more
- 24:24inclusive to latinas, it also impacts the welfare of your
- 24:31fellow employees, of your other employees exactly exactly.
- 24:37Speaker 3: And we know that when you have a team that
- 24:39it's diverse, that you know, maybe we speak multiple languages,
- 24:43we understand different communities, different cultures. That's just really more
- 24:48value to you, right so, you know, and again within
- 24:54that industry, I think they need to they need to
- 24:56see that and they need to show it by having
- 24:59more more workers of color.
- 25:01Speaker 1: Absolutely, diversity is important. Yes, good for the bottom line.
- 25:09So Carlin, that's all the questions I have for now.
- 25:12Thank you for joining me today. It's been an honor.
- 25:16Speaker 3: No, of course, thank you, and I'm happy to speak
- 25:19a little bit more about this. I think you're doing
- 25:21a great job with this podcast, and we.
- 25:24Speaker 2: Look forward to the next one.
- 25:25Speaker 1: Hopefully that's it for this episode of Conversations for Equal Pay.
- 25:32To tune into more episodes, welcome to our website at
- 25:36conversations for equalpay dot org. You're listening to Conversations for
- 25:44Equal Pay